A Practical Approach of Diffusion Load Balancing Algorithms

HAL Id: inria-00071394

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00071394

Submitted on 23 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub-

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,

A Practical Approach of Diffusion Load Balancing Algorithms

Emmanuel Jeannot, Flavien Vernier

To cite this version:

Emmanuel Jeannot, Flavien Vernier. A Practical Approach of Diffusion Load Balancing Algorithms.

[Research Report] RR-5875, INRIA. 2006. �inria-00071394�

ISRN INRIA/RR--5875--FR+ENG

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

Thème NUM

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

A Practical Approach of Diffusion Load Balancing Algorithms.

Emmanuel Jeannot — Flavien Vernier

N° 5875

Mars 2006

*)+,-(.

/0103254768:9<;58:2544=?>

∗

^{@ A} 9B2DC EF8G4H8:IJ4EF8:I

†

KMLONQPSRTVUXWZY\[D]_^a`bNQPSRc^edDfOPSgchjilk:fORc^

m hbnpoaRQ`b^eq<rtsunvhbiwrxrwR

y<zp{O{5nvhj`<|_R}hbRc~+LORchb~+LORd€ƒ‚p„D…p‚†Y\W†zvhb^<‡vˆvˆv‰}YŠ‡pˆ‹{ŒzpGRc^

Ž‘c’Q“•”O–v’v— ˜ d™`bLOil^{Œzv{?RchcšXz{Oh+zv~`jil~QzprXzp{O{OhbnGzG~+Lnp›|_ixœ5f?^iwnvdžrwnGzG|™ŸŒzvrwzvdŒ~iwdOzprwvnGhjix`jLŒPS^

zvdŒ|™ix`b^iwP‹{ŒrxRcP‹Rcd:`bz•`bixnGd zvhjR¡^`jf?|_ixRJ|£¢¤KMLOhbRQR{OhjnGŸOrwRQP¥^zvhjR¡ixdD¦vRJ^a`bix:z•`bRc|£¢§KMLOR¨Œhb^`il^`jLOR

|OR`jRchjPSiwdŒz•`bixnGdnv› `bLOR©rxn:zv|ŸŒzprlzpdŒ~QixdŒª{ŒzvhbzvPSR`jRchb^(«eix`jLOnGf_`<zpdD]¬GrxnGŸŒzpr­DdOn•«erwRc|_GRv¢KMLOR^RJ~nGdŒ|

{ŒhjnGŸOrxRcPŠ~QnvdŒ^jiw^`b^©iwd®Rc^`jiwP¥z•`bixdO¯`bLOR~QnG^`zpdŒ|`jLŒR¬Ÿ?RcdOR¨Œ`np›ez¯rxn:zv|°R±O~+LŒzvdOvRG¢KMLOR¥rlzv^`nvdOR

^`jf?|_ixRJ^©`jLŒR~nGd:¦GRQhbvRcdŒ~RS|_R`bRc~`jiwnvd#np›M`jLŒR¥rxn:zv|°ŸŒzprlzpd?~iwdO²zprwvnvhbix`jLOP¯¢³Œnvh}`bLOiw^rwzG^a`{5nviwd:`«R

Gix¦GRªzvdzprwvnGhjix`jLŒPŸ?zv^jRc|†nGd^jixPªfOrlz•`jRJ|¡zvdOdORczvrxiwdO`jnhjRJ|_fŒ~QR`bLOR‹~QnvdD¦vRchjGRQdŒ~QR}`jn•«Mzph+|O^uzrwnGzG|

hbRQ{?zphj`jix`jiwnvdiwdª^`jRc{Œ^´`jLŒzp`ƒ~czpdªŸ?RM|_nvdŒR«eix`jLS|_il^j~QhjRQ`jR(rxn:zv|O^c¢´[DRc¦vRQh+zprD^jixPªfOrwzp`jiwnvdŒ^~Qrxn:^Rµ`jLOil^{Œzp{5RQh

zvdŒ|ixrwrxf?^a`bhbzp`jRu`jLOR}iwPS{Œzv~`<np›´`jLOR}¦•zphbiwnvfŒ^MPSR`bLOn_|O^ezpd?|zvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP¥^(ixd:`jhbn_|_fŒ~QRc|£¢

·²¸:¹ºb»¼ “•½‘v— rwnGzG|†ŸŒzvrwzvdŒ~iwdOŒš i¶`bRQh+z•`jiw¦vR¥zvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP¯š7|_i¶œfŒ^jixnGd7š {?zph+zpPSR`bRQh}|_R¨?dOi¶`bixnGd7š´^jiwPf_¾

rlz•`bRc|zpdOdŒRczprwiwdOŒšO~QnvdD¦vRchjGRQdŒ~QRX|_RQ`jRc~`jiwnvd7¢

∗

¿ÁÀÂ7¿tÃÄ©Å_Æ ¿tõÄuǝÈ+ÉeÊÌËÌ͆ÍÎǝÏÑÐaÒÓFÏÔÌÕcËÌÐÖĐףØÚÙÖÛÖÜJĐÝ+ÞÝÖßÖà3á5È+ÒÌâÌãQÐaËJäcåÎÐæÑÐaÍ¡ÀÈ+ÒÌÇèçĬé•åFÈ+ÒJǝÐÖêëÐaÉ<È+ÏÑælì НÉ<È+ÒQËÌÐaælêíîÐjÈ+ÒJÒÌã+ÓèïæÑãÖåîÏðÈJêñxå

†

^òó ،ôÁÀ´È+ÒÌÇèç¯õÖÄ£ÅOÆÂ7¿tÃÄ?ǝÈ+ÉeÊÌËÌÍMÍÎǝÏÑÐaÒÓFÏÔÌÕcËÌÐÖÄ ×£Ø®ÙÖÛÖÜJÄ Ý+ÞÝÖßÖàáÈ+ÒÌâJãcÐaËJäcåÎÐæÑÐaÍ<ÀÈ+ÒJÇaçÄ£é•åÎÈ+ÒÌÇaÐÖê²ÐaÉ<È+ÏÑælì

ö

ȝäcÏÑÐaÒ:êäÐaåÎÒÌÏÑÐaåFïæÑãÖåÎÏðÈJêñxå

}) $ZS $ !#.

‘ — R`‹zphj`jil~rwR¬{Ohbgc^jRQd:`jR¥fOdŒRzp{Œ{Ohjn_~+LOR¥{Œhbzp`jilkGfŒR¬|_Rc^ªzprwvnvhbix`jLOPSRc^|gJk:fOixrwiwŸOhbzvvR¬|_R

~+L?zphbvR©|_R©`a]D{?R}|_ixœ5f?^iwnvd¯R`V|OR}rxRcfOh<iwP‹{ŒrwzvdG`+z•`bixnGd7¢ƒK hbnvil^M{OhbnvŸOrwNQPSRc^e^jnvd:`<zpŸ5nvh+|_gJ^Q¢7R}{ŒhjRcP‹iwRQh

~QnvdŒ~QRQhbdORVrlz‹|_g`bRQhbP‹iwdŒzp`jiwnvd|ORc^({Œzph+zpPSNQ`jhbRc^(|_RXrzprwvnvhbix`jLOPSRX^bzpd?^(zvfŒ~fŒdORu~QnvdOd?zpil^j^bzpdŒ~QR<vrwnvŸ?zprwR

|Of3^j]D^`jNcPSRv¢7R^jRc~QnvdŒ|1^z•`j`bzv~+LŒR†rRc^`jiwPSzp`jiwnvd1|Of3~n! _`SR`‹|Of1Ÿ5gQdOgQ¨?~RRQdOGRQdŒ|OhjgJ^{ŒzvhªrwRc^

gJ~+LŒzpdŒvRc^ª|_R¯~+LŒzphbvRG¢ R|_RchjdŒixRchª{OhbnvŸŒrxNcP‹Rg`bfŒ|_iwgRJ^a`¥~RcrxfOie|_Rrlz|_gQ`jRJ~Ö`jiwnvd |_R~QnvdD¦vRchjGRQdŒ~QR

|ORrzvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOPSR|gck:fOiwrxiwŸOh+zpGRv¢#mnvfOhS~R¯|_RQhbdOiwRQhª{?nGixd:`cšdOnvf?^{Ohbnv{5nG^jnvd?^fOd zprwvnvhbix`jLOPSRŸ?zv^jg

^jfOherwR©hjRJ~fOix`<^iwPfOrwg©{?nGfOhehbgc|_fOiwhbRufŒdOR}~nvdD¦GRQhbvRQd?~RVRcdP¥zvhb~+LORJ^M|RJ^j~czprwixRchekGfŒi7{?Rcf_`Vzp{Œ{Œzph+z#"l`jhbR

z̦GRc~e|_RJ^µ~+LŒzvhjGRc^ƒ|_il^b~hbN`jRJ^Q¢m rwfŒ^jixRcfOhb^µ^iwPfOrlz•`bixnGdŒ^ƒ`bRQhbPSixdORcd:`~RQ`zphj`jil~rwR<R`ixrwrxf?^a`bhjRcdG`r$RœR`M|_Rc^

PSgQ`jLOn_|_RJ^MR`VzprwvnGhjix`jLŒP‹RJ^({OhjnG{?n:^gJ^Q¢

% ¼ ’J‘ º –'& ‘S— gJkGfŒixrwixŸŒhbzvvRV|_Ru~+LŒzphbvRGšGzvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOPSR<i¶`bgQh+z•`bi¶›aš_|_ixœ5f?^iwnvd7š_|_gQ¨ŒdOix`jiwnvd|_RV{ŒzvhbzvPSN`jhbRvš

hbRc~QfOix`e^jiwPfOrwgvšŒ|Og`jRJ~Ö`bixnGd|_R~QnvdD¦vRchjGRQdŒ~QRv¢

9 :

!ª ¥$µ´!

; dŒR²np›u`jLOR†PSn:^a`¬iwPS{?nGh`+zpd:`¬{OhbnvŸOrwRQP¥^¥iwd™|_iw^`jhbiwŸOf_`jRJ|{OhbnD~QRc^b^iwdO®~nGdŒ^jiw^`b^¥iwdŸŒzprlzpd?~iwdO#`jLOR

«(nvhb­¬rwnGzG|²zpPSnvdO¥zvrxr´{Ohjn_~QRc^b^nGhb^c¢KMLOR{OfOhb{?n:^R}nv›rwnGzG|=<Á«(nvhb­?>(Ÿ?zprlzpdŒ~QixdO¥il^e`bnzv~+LŒixRc¦vR}Ÿ5R``bRQh

{5RQhj›ÁnvhbP¥zpdŒ~QRc^´np›?|Oiw^`jhbixŸŒf_`jRJ|ª~QnvPS{Of_`+z•`jiwnvd?^Qš•ŸD]}iwP‹{Œhjn•¦DiwdOVrwnGzG|zprwrxn_~cz•`jiwnvd ¢´KMLOR(rxn:zv|ŸŒzprlzpdŒ~QixdŒ

{ŒhjnGŸOrxRcP¤«Mzv^e^`jfŒ|_iwRc|¯ŸD]^jRQ¦GRQh+zpr7zvf_`jLOnGhb^›ÁhbnvP|_i¶œRQhbRQd:`<{5nviwd:`b^env›¦DiwRQ«A@-Bpš‡Dš 8 šDCOš5‚_šŒ‰Oš5…)EF¢ ˜d

P¥zvd:]¬zv{O{Orwiw~cz•`bixnGdŒ^M^fŒ~+Lzv^M|_RcdŒ^R©rwixdŒRczphezvrxGRQŸOh+zOš:i¶`<il^({?n:^j^jiwŸOrxRu`bnS^`bzp`jil~Qzvrxrw]¬~nGP‹{Œf_`jRX`jLOR}rwnGzG|

zvdŒ|²|_il^a`bhjiwŸOf_`bRix`XRc¦vRQdŒrx]¯zpPSnvdŒS`jLORª{Ohjn_~QRc^b^nGhb^c¢ F<n•«(RQ¦vRchcšŒnp›t`jRcd†ix`Xil^<dOnv`X{5nG^b^iwŸOrwR}`jn­:dŒn•«

#%#

`jLŒR}rxn:zv|np›`jLOR©{OhbnvŸOrwRQP zpdŒ|`jLŒRQhbR›ÁnvhbR©z¥|_]DdŒzpPSil~XrwnGzG|Ÿ?zprlzpdŒ~QixdOS^b~+LORQPSR©iw^<hjRJkGfŒixhbRc|£¢

˜ d `jLOil^{Œzp{5RQh¯«(R†›Án_~f?^nGdž`bLOR#i¶`bRQh+z•`jiw¦vRrxn:zv|™Ÿ?zprlzpdŒ~QixdO zprwvnGhjix`jLOP¥^ixd:`bhjn_|_fŒ~QRc| ixdG@-BEF¢

KMLŒRc^jR†zprwvnvhbix`jLOP¥^¥zv^b^jfOPSR¯`jLŒzp`z#dOn_|_R†P¥zpd?zpvRJ^Si¶`+^¬rwnGzG|3nGdOrw]1«eix`jL™ix`b^¬dŒRczphbRc^`¥dORQiwvLDŸ5nvh+^Q¢

KMLŒRQ]†zphbRGRQdORchjil~zvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP¥^QšfŒ^jR›ÁfŒrƒ«eLORQd¡`jLOR¥^j]D^`jRcP iw^©|_RJ~RcdG`bhbzvrxiIHQRJ|†nGhX«eLORcd^jnvPSR‹dOn_|_Rc^

~czpdOdŒnp`|OixhbRc~`jrw]~nvPSPªfOdOil~Qz•`bR«eix`jL‹zprwr:`jLOR(np`bLORQhdOn_|_RJ^Q¢JF<n•«(RQ¦vRch7`bLORc^jR(zvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP¥^7›îzG~RM^Rc¦vRchbzvr

{ŒhjnGŸOrxRcP¥^Q¢

³iwhb^`jrw]všƒ`bLORPSzpoanvhbi¶`a]°np›u^a`bfŒ|_iwRc^SzpŸ5nvf_`‹`jLŒRc^jRzprwvnGhjix`jLŒPS^ªfŒ^jRGrxnGŸŒzpr(­DdOn•«erxRJ|_vRGšrxiw­vR`jLOR

dŒR`a«(nvhb­#`jnv{5nvrwnvG]®nvhSdOn_|_R²{Ohbnv{5RQhj`jiwRc^cš `bn®|_R`bRQhbP‹iwdOR¯`bLOR¯rxn:zv|3ŸŒzprlzpdŒ~QixdŒ°{?zph+zpPSR`bRQh+^Q¢ ˜ `¬iw^

^jfOix`bzvŸOrxRª`jnviw¦vRª`jLOR‹nv{O`jiwPSzvr{Œzph+zpPSR`bRQh+^<ix› `jLŒR‹dŒR`a«(nvhb­zvdŒ|²`bLORªdŒnD|ORc^u{Ohbnv{5RQhj`jiwRc^uzphbRª^`bz•`biw~

zvdŒ|ix›}`jLOil^­DdOn•«erwRc|OvR²il^dOnv`¬`jnDn3R±_{?RcdŒ^jix¦GR†ixd`bRQhbP¥^nv›©{Œhjn_~RJ^j^jiwdO#`jiwPSRv¢GFVn•«Rc¦vRchcšM^f?~+L

GrxnGŸŒzpr_­DdOn•«erwRc|OvReil^ƒdOnp`(zprw«(zÌ]_^ƒz̦•zpiwrwzvŸOrwRMzvdŒ|¥|_RQ`jRQhbPSixdŒixdO©`bLOR<{ŒzvhbzvPSR`jRchb^`bLORQd¥PªfŒ^`µŸ?RX|_nvdOR

«eix`jLŒnvf_`e`bLOiw^<­:dŒn•«erxRJ|_vRG¢

[DRJ~nGdŒ|_rw]vš£PSnG^`unv›µ`bLORc^jR‹zvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP¥^XzG^j^jfOPSR`bLŒz•`}ŸŒzvrwzvdŒ~iwdO`jLORSrwnGzv|†iw^}zvrx«MzÌ]_^<Ÿ5RQdORQ¨?~ilzpr

zvdŒ|‹rxRJzv|O^ƒ`jnz©hbRc|_f?~Ö`jiwnvdSnv›?`bLOR<R±_RJ~f_`bixnGdS`jiwP‹RG¢KF<n•«(RQ¦vRchcšÌ`bLOil^ il^ƒdOnp`µ`jhbfORv¢ƒ[DiwdŒ~RGšv`bhbzvdŒ^a›ÁRchjhbiwdO

^jnvPSRªrxn:zv|›ÁhbnvP*nvdORª{OhbnD~QRc^b^nGhe`jn¯zpd¡np`jLŒRQhVhbRck:fOiwhbRc^V^jnvPSR‹~nvPSPªfOdOil~Qz•`bixnGd7¢ ˜ ›ƒ`jLOR‹dOR`a«(nvhb­iw^

^jrwn•«™`jLOR~QnvPSPfŒdOiw~cz•`bixnGd~QnG^`e~czpdŸ?R}LŒixGLORQhM`bLŒzpd`jLŒR}R±_Rc~Qf_`jiwnvd`jiwPSR}Gzpiwd7¢

KMLOiwh+|_rx]Gš£^iwdŒ~Rª`jLŒRªrwnGzG|²iw^XdOnv`uiwd_¨ŒdOix`jRcrx]†|Oix¦Dil^iwŸOrwRvš5`jLORª¨ŒdŒzvr´rwnGzG|²ŸŒzvrwzvdŒ~iwdO<Îz•›t`bRQh©~nvdD¦GRQhj¾

GRQdŒ~QRVnv›7`jLOR©zprwvnGhjix`jLŒPL>µ~Qzvd¥›îzv~QRuz

!M ONO

{OhbnvŸŒrxRcP¢ƒKMLOil^({OhbnvŸOrwRQP§LŒzv{O{?RcdŒ^(«eLORQd`jLOR©|_ixœ5RchjRcdŒ~R

nv›´rwnGzG|¬Ÿ5R`a«(RQRQdRczG~+LdOn_|_R©il^MnvdOrw]¥nvdORG¢ ˜›aš_›ÁnvhMiwdŒ^a`+zpdŒ~QRvš_«(RXL?z̦vR©zª~+LŒzvixdnp›

n

{Ohbn_~Rc^b^jnvh+^QšG`jLOR rwnGzG|~czpd°Ÿ?R¥|_il^`jhbixŸOfO`jRc|#zG^

{n, n − 1, . . . , 2, 1, }

zpdŒ|¡`jLOR¬|Oi¶œfŒ^jixnGd°rwnGzG|¡Ÿ?zprlzpdŒ~QixdO¯zprwvnGhjix`jLŒP

~czpdŸ?R}rwn_~+­vRJ|ŸD]¥`bLOiw^V~nvdO¨ŒvfOh+z•`bixnGd7¢

˜ d`jLOil^({Œzp{5RQhJšD«Ru{Ohbnv{5nG^jRXzª{Oh+zv~Ö`biw~czprzp{O{Œhjn:zv~+L¥np›´rxn:zv|¬Ÿ?zprlzpdŒ~QixdO`jLŒzp`M^jnvrw¦vRJ^ `bLOR 8 zvŸ?n•¦GR

{ŒhjnGŸOrxRcP¥^Q¢K´n`bLOR‹Ÿ?RJ^a`}np›nvfOh©­DdOn•«erwRc|_GRdOnrxn:zv|†Ÿ?zprlzpdŒ~QixdOzprwvnGhjix`jLOP*nv› `jLORSrwi¶`bRQh+z•`bfOhjR‹~Qzvd

|ORczpre«eix`jL `bLORc^jR 8 il^b^fORJ^¥z•`S`jLŒR†^jzvP‹R`bixPSRv¢QP°R²viw¦vRPSR`bLOn_|O^S`jn®|_RQ`jRchjPSiwdOR¯`jLOR†|Oi¶œfŒ^jixnGd

{?zph+zpPSR`bRQh+^´«eix`jLŒnvf_`zvdD]vrwnvŸ?zpr_­DdOn•«erwRc|_GRv¢(P°R<{Ohbnv{5nG^jRezpd¥zpd?zprw]D^jil^np›`jLORX~nG^`µzpd?|ªŸ5RQdŒR¨O`µnv›

rwnGzG|©R±O~+LŒzvdOvRƒiwdnvh+|_Rch7`jnu|_R`bRQhbPSixdOR«eLORQdi¶`iw^´«nGh`bL}R±O~+LŒzvdOviwdO<^jnvPSR rwnGzv|7¢´KMLORµ~QnvdD¦vRchjGRQdŒ~QR

nv›V`bLOR†rwnGzv|3ŸŒzvrwzvdŒ~iwdO#zprwvnvhbix`jLOP¥^S«eix`jLdOn#ixdO¨ŒdOix`jRQrw]|_ix¦Dil^iwŸOrwR¯rxn:zv|O^Sil^¬zprl^jn°^`jfŒ|OixRJ|ixd `jLŒiw^

{?zp{5RQhJ¢ ; fŒhuzv{O{OhbnGzv~+L²il^©^{Œrxix`uiwd:`jn`a«n?¢}KMLOR›ÁnGhjPSRchVviw¦vRJ^XzvdzvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP Ÿ?zv^jRc|†nGd¡^jixPªfOrwzp`jRJ|

zvdOdORJzprwixdO`jnªhjRJ|_fŒ~Runvh(RQrwiwP‹iwdŒzp`jRX`jLOR©^a`bRQ{Œ^`bLŒz•`e~Qzvd¬Ÿ?R©GRQdORchbzp`jRc|SŸD]S`bLORu|Oiw^b~hbR`bRXrwnGzG|¬z•`(`jLOR

~QnvdD¦vRchjGRQdŒ~QRXnv›rwnGzG|Ÿ?zprlzpdŒ~QixdO¬zvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP¥^Q¢ KMLŒR}rwzp``jRch<il^M`jLORª|_R`bRc~Ö`bixnGd¯np›`jLOR~QnvdD¦vRchjGRQdŒ~QRXnv›

rwnGzG|†ŸŒzvrwzvdŒ~iwdOzprwvnvhbix`jLOP¥^X`jn¯^a`bnv{°i¶`}iwd°^`bzp`jil~rwnGzG|¡~Qnvd:`jRQ±:`Jš7nvhu`bnP¥zpd?zpvRª`jLŒRª›ÁhbRck:fORcdŒ~]²nv›

rwnGzG|¬ŸŒzvrwzvdŒ~iwdOS^a`bRQ{¯iwd|_]DdŒzvPSiw~urwnGzv|~nGdG`bR±D`c¢ KMLŒRunGŸ_oaRc~`jiw¦vRJ^(zvhjRX`jn¥^`jnG{`bLOR}rxn:zv|ŸŒzprlzpdŒ~QixdŒ

zvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP¤«eLORcd¯i¶`<LŒzG^e~nGd:¦GRQhbvRJ|zpd?|`bn¥dOnp`<rwnG^jRu`jiwPSR©`jn¥R±O~+LŒzvdOvR©iwd_›ÁnvhbP¥z•`bixnGd›ÁnGhM`jLORrwnGzG|

Ÿ?zprlzpdŒ~QixdOSzprwvnGhjix`jLŒP¢ƒ³iwdŒzprwrx]GšD`jLOR}Gix¦GRQdPSR`jLŒnD|Œ^<zphbRXRR¬~iwRQd:`VzpdŒ|RJzv^j]S`jn¥iwP‹{ŒrxRcP‹Rcd:`c¢

˜ `uiw^eiwPS{?nGh`+zpd:`<`bn¬dOnp`bR}`jL?z•`cš?ixd¯`bLOil^V«(nvhb­šO«R}P¥zv­vR}¦vRchj]›ÁRQ«zv^b^jfOPS{_`jiwnvdŒ^c¢PR‹~Qzpd²|_RJzpr

«eix`jLRQix`jLORch(^`bzp`jil~<nvh(|_]DdŒzpPSil~<rwnGzG|£¢KMLŒRVdORQ`a«nGhj­`jnv{5nvrwnvG]‹~czpd¥Ÿ5RXnv› zpdD]ª`a]:{5RXzG^ rwnvdOªzv^i¶`(iw^

~QnvdOdŒRc~Ö`bRc|£¢T<n_|_Rc^VzpdŒ|dORQ`a«nGhj­_^e~Qzvd¯Ÿ?R}LOnGPSnvvRcdORQnGfŒ^(nvh<LŒR`jRchjnGvRcdORQnGfŒ^Q¢ƒKMLORdOnp`bixnGdnv›rwnGzG|

il^ƒ¦GRQhb]zpŸŒ^`jh+zv~`cšpix`~czpd‹Ÿ?RVzvdD]G`bLOiwdOu`jLŒzp`7oafŒ^`µhjRJk:fOixhbRc^ƒ^jnvPSR(`jiwPSRe`jn}Ÿ5R<{Ohbn_~RJ^j^jRc| <î|Ozp`bzŒšpR`+~p¢>Ö¢

KMLŒR{Ohbnv{5nG^jRc|²PSRQ`jLOn_|O^©|_RJzpr«ei¶`bL^`bz•`biw~ªdORQ`a«nGhj­_^<ŸŒf_`X`bLORSzv|Ozv{_`bzp`jiwnvd²`bn|_]DdŒzvP‹il~ªdOR`a«(nvhb­_^

il^V^`jh+zpiwvL:`M›Ánvhb«Mzph+|£¢³iwdŒzprwrx]Gš?dŒn¥vrwnvŸŒzvr7­DdOn•«erxRJ|_vR}il^ehbRck:fOiwhjRJ|`jn¬{Ohbn_~RJ^j^M`bLORzvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP¯¢(KMLOR

­DdOn•«erwRc|OvRil^©rwixPSix`jRc|`bn`bLOR¥~nGP‹{Œf_`bzp`jiwnvd#^{5RQRJ|¡nv›µ`jLŒR‹dŒRQiwvLDŸ?nGhcš`bn`jLORSrwixdO­~+LŒzph+zv~`jRQhbil^a`biw~c^

Ÿ5R`a«(RQRcdzSdŒnD|ORzpdŒ|i¶`+^edORcixGL:Ÿ5nvhJšD`jnS`bLOR}rwnGzv|np›dORcixGL:Ÿ5nvh+^MzpdŒ|`bnS`jLOR~QnvPS{Of_`+z•`jiwnvd`jiwPSR©›Ánvh

nGdOR©fOdOix`<np›rxn:zv|£¢ƒqVrxr£`bLORc^jR©ixdO›ÁnvhbPSzp`jiwnvd¯zphbR}^fO{Œ{?n:^RJ|¬`bn¥Ÿ?R}Gix¦GRQd7š_~Qzvrw~QfOrlz•`jRJ|nGheRc^`jiwP¥z•`jRJ|£¢

P°ReLŒz̦vR(iwP‹{ŒrxRcP‹Rcd:`jRc|SzvdŒ|`bRc^`jRJ|`bLORM{Ohbnv{5nG^jRc|}›ÁRJz•`bfOhjRJ^ixdSnGhb|_Rch`jn©RQ¦•zprwfŒzp`jR(`jLORcixhƒiwPS{Œzv~`c¢

y<Rc^jfOr¶`+^µ^jLOn•« `jLŒzp`µiwd¥`jLORX«nGhb^`µ~QzG^R6<î|_Rc{?RcdŒ|_iwdOnGdS`jLORXdOR`a«(nvhb­ª^j{?RcRc|¥zvdŒ|‹`jnv`bzpr5rwnGzv| >֚v«(RV|_n

dŒnp`(›îzv~R}zvd:]¬|ORQvh+zv|Œz•`jiwnvd¥nv›´{5RQhj›ÁnvhbP¥zpdŒ~QRu~QnvPS{ŒzphbRc|¥`jn‹{OhjRc¦DixnGfŒ^Mzprwvnvhbix`jLOP¥^np› `bLOR©rxix`jRchbzp`jfOhbRv¢

˜ d`jLŒR}Ÿ?RJ^a`V~czv^jRX`bLOR©{?Rch›ÁnGhjP¥zvdŒ~R©Gzvixdiw^<P‹nGhjRX`jL?zpd=BcˆGˆ¢qVd¯np`jLŒRQheiwdG`bRQhbRc^`jiwdO‹{OLORQdŒnvPSRQdŒz

«(R(LŒz̦vRnvŸŒ^jRQhb¦vRJ|©R±_{?RchjiwPSRQd:`bzvrxrw]}il^ `bLŒz•`ƒ|_Rc{?RcdŒ|_iwdO©nvd`bLORMrxn:zv|£šJ`bLORe^{5RQRJ|nv›O`jLOR(dORQ`a«nGhj­}zpd?|

`bLOR~QnvPS{Of_`+z•`jiwnvd?zpr rwnGzG|£šO`bLORrwnGzG|¯ŸŒzprlzpdŒ~QixdŒ¬zprwvnvhbix`jLOP|_nDRc^<dŒnp`Xzvrx«MzÌ]_^efŒ^jRzprwr7`bLORz̦•zpiwrwzvŸOrwR

hbRc^jnvfŒhb~QRc^ ix`<iw^<zvŸOrwRX`bnS¨ŒdŒ|`jLŒR}hjiwvL:`ezpPSnvfOd:`enp›hbRc^jnvfOh+~RJ^ `bLŒz•`<Gix¦GRc^ez‹vnDn_|^j{5RQRc|_¾FfO{ ¢

KMLOil^X{Œzp{5RQhuiw^VnvhbGzvdOi-HcRc|¯zv^V›Ánvrwrwn•«<^Q¢V[DRJ~Ö`bixnGd‡¥{OhbRc^jRQd:`+^e`jLŒRhbRQrlz•`jRJ|¯«nGhj­_^cšŒ«(RhbRQ¦DixRc«`jLOR

|Oi¶œfŒ^jixnGd‹nGd¥zpdD]^`bz•`biw~MdŒR`a«(nvhb­5¢ ˜ d¬[DRc~`jiwnvd 8 ¢IBpšv«(R<^`jfŒ|_]`jLORV{OhjnGŸOrwRQP nv›?`bLORV~nGdOdORJ~Ö`jiwnvd‹rwixdO­_^

LŒR`jRchjnGvRcdORQix`a]v¢ƒKMLOil^eil^eRck:fOiw¦•zprwRQd:`e`jn¥^`jfŒ|_]DiwdOS`jLŒR~nG^`Vzpd?|`bLOR}Ÿ5RQdORQ¨O`Vnp›`jLŒR}rxn:zv|ŸŒzprlzpdŒ~QixdŒ

zvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP¯¢§[_Rc~Ö`bixnGd 8 ¢‡{OhjRJ^Rcd:`b^z1|_RJ~RQd:`bhbzvrxiIHQRJ|™PSR`jLŒnD|ž`jn~nGP‹{Œf_`jR`jLOR°rwnGzv|žŸŒzprlzpdŒ~QixdŒ

{?zph+zpPSR`bRQh+^Q¢KMLORc^jRV{ŒzvhbzvPSR`jRchb^µixd?~rwfŒ|_RX`jLORuhbzp`jiwnnp›´rxn:zv|¥RQ±_~+L?zpdOGRVzpdŒ|¥`jLOR©|_ixœ5RchjRcdŒ~RXnp› dOn_|_R

^j{5RQRc|Œ^Q¢e[DRc~`jiwnvd 8 ¢8

il^V|_RJ|_il~Qz•`bRc|`bnS`jLORªdOnp`<iwd_¨ŒdOix`jRcrx]²|_iw¦Diw^jiwŸOrxRrxn:zv|O^ezvdŒ|`jn¥`bLOR|_RQ`jRJ~Ö`jiwnvd²nv›

`bLORM~nvdD¦GRQhbvRQd?~R nv›O`jLORMrwnGzG|}ŸŒzprlzpd?~iwdOXzvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP¯¢ ˜d‹[_Rc~Ö`bixnGdCu«R({OhbRc^jRQd:` `bLORMixPS{OrwRQPSRcdG`+z•`bixnGd

nv› `bLOR}rxn:zv|ŸŒzprlzpd?~iwdO¥zprwvnvhbix`jLOP zvdŒ|ixrwrxf?^a`bhbzp`jRu`jLOR}Ÿ5RQL?z̦:iwnvhenv› `bLOR}rxn:zv|zprwvnGhjix`jLOP zv~Q~Qnvh+|_iwdO

`bn‹`jLOR}PSR`bLOn_|O^M`bLŒz•`<«(R©viw¦vR©ŸD]^nGPSRuRQ±_{?RchjiwPSRQd:`bzp`jiwnvd¯zpdŒ|¯[DRc~`jiwnvd†‚‹~nGdŒ~rwfŒ|_RJ^MnvfOhM«(nvhb­5¢

eQ© e$ ¥

KMLŒRXix`jRchbzp`jiw¦vRVrwnGzG|¥ŸŒzvrwzvdŒ~iwdOªzvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP¥^µzvhjRXvRQdŒRQh+zprwrx]¥|_RJ|_iw~cz•`bRc|¥`bnª^`bzp`jil~VdORQ`a«nGhj­_^c¢q ^`bz•`biw~

dŒR`a«(nvhb­`bnv{5nvrwnvG]il^¥~rlzv^b^il~Qzvrxrw]°hjRc{OhjRJ^Rcd:`jRc|Ÿ:]z°^jixPS{OrwRfŒdŒ|_iwhjRJ~Ö`jRJ|1~QnvdOdORJ~Ö`bRc|Ghbzv{OL

G = (V, E)

š_«eLORchjR

V

iw^(`bLOR}^RQ`enp›´¦GRQhj`jRQ±zpdŒ|

E

il^(`jLOR}^jR`enp›Rc|_GRvš

E ⊆ V × V

¢zv~+L{Œhjn_~RJ^j^jnvh(il^

z¬¦vRQhj`jRQ±nv›ƒ`jLORªvh+zp{OL²zpd?|²RczG~+L¯~QnvPSPfŒdOiw~cz•`bixnGd²rxiwdO­¯Ÿ?RQ`a«RcRQd¯`a«(n¬{Ohbn_~Rc^b^jnvh+^

i, j

il^V`jLORRJ|_vR

(i, j) ∈ E

Ÿ?RQ`a«RcRQd`jLOR(`a«(nX¦GRQhj`jR±_RJ^

i

^zpd?|

j

^<

i, j ∈ V

>Ö¢ƒRQhj`jRQ±_Rc^zphbRµrlzpŸ5RQrwRc|›ÁhjnGP

1

^`bn

n

^«eLORQhbR

n

il^`jLORudDfOPŸ5RQhMnv›7{Ohjn_~QRc^b^nGhb^cšvLORcdŒ~R

|V | = n

^{¢ R`}

m

Ÿ5RX`jLORudDfOPŸ5RQhMnp› ~QnvPSPfŒdOiw~cz•`bixnGd¬rxiwdO­_^

<

|E| = m

^{>Ö¢ 7RQ`}

F

Ÿ5R‹`jLOR¥¦GRc~Ö`bnvhunp›MRc|_GR¾B«RcixGL:`b^uzpdŒ|rxRQ`}fŒ^}|_RQdŒnp`jR

f i,j

`jLOR¥«(RQiwvL:`©np›RJ|_vR

(i, j)

^<

f i,j = F k |E k = (i, j))

^{¢ 7R`}

C n

Ÿ5R©`jLOR}¦GRc~`jnvhenv›dŒnD|OR¾B«RcixGLG`+^M^fŒ~+L`bLŒz•`e`bLORz̦vRchbzvvRVnv›

C n i

il^edOnvhbP¥zprwi-HcRc|

P

i C _ni

n = 1

^¢

˜ d @-BEFš

]:Ÿ5RQdŒ­vn¯ixd:`bhjn_|_fŒ~QRc|z|Oiw^`jhbixŸŒf_`jRJ|¡rwnGzG|¡ŸŒzvrwzvdŒ~iwdO < >©zvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP*›Ánvh}^`bz•`biw~‹dORQ`¾

«(nvhb­_^´~czprwrxRJ|`bLOR<|_ixœ5f?^iwnvd¥zprwvnGhjix`jLŒPnvh ³ ; [ <î³iwhb^` ; hb|ORQh [_~+LORcP‹R >Ö¢ ˜ `µzv^b^fŒP‹RJ^`jLŒzp` zX{Œhjn_~RJ^j^

i

Ÿ?zprlzpdŒ~QRc^(i¶`+^erwnGzv|^iwPfŒr¶`+zpdORcnvfŒ^jrx]¥«eix`jL¯zprwr£ix`b^MdORcixGL:Ÿ5nvh+^c¢K´nSŸŒzprlzpdŒ~QRV`bLOR©rxn:zv|£šOzªh+z•`jiwn

α ij

nv›

`bLORrwnGzG|²|_ixœ5RchjRcdŒ~RŸ5R`a«(RQRcd²`jLŒR{Ohbn_~Rc^b^

i

^zpdŒ|

j

il^X^j«Mzp{O{5Rc|¯Ÿ5R`a«(RQRcd

i

^zvdŒ|

j

¢V³OnGhXz¥{Ohbn_~RJ^j^

i

š?`jLOR‹rwnGzv|¯Ÿ?zprlzpdŒ~QixdO^a`bRQ{¡«eix`jLzprwr´ix`b^XdORQiwvLDŸ5nvh+^<il^VGix¦GRQd†ŸD] µk:fŒz•`bixnGd < B><«eLŒRQhbR

w _i ^(t)

^{iw^V`jLOR}

«(nvhb­¥rwnGzv||_nGdOR©Ÿ:]{Ohjn_~QRc^b^

i

z•`M`jiwPSR

t

^¢

w ^(t+1) _i = w ^(t) _i + P

j α ij .

w ^(t) _j − w ^(t) _i

<B)>

kGf?z•`jiwnvd=<B >(iw^MrwiwdORczvh<zpdŒ|`jLDfŒ^Mix`V~QzvdŸ5R}hbR¾B«ehjix`jR©iwdP¥zp`jhbi¶±¬›ÁnGhjP

W ^(t+1) = M W ^(t) .

^<·>

FVRQhbR

W ^(t)

il^(`jLŒR}¦vRc~`jnGh

(w ^(t) _i )

^zvdŒ|

M

il^M`jLOR}|_ixœfŒ^iwnvd¯P¥z•`bhjix±|_RQ¨ŒdORJ|ŸD]

m ^(t) _ij =





 α ij

ix›

(i, j) ∈ E ∧ i 6= j, 1 − P

k α ik ∀k|(i, k) ∈ E ∧ i = j,

0 otherwise.

KMLŒiw^¬zvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP L?zv^¥nv›t`jRQdŸ5RQRcdž^a`bfŒ|_iwRc|™zpd?|™|_RQhbix¦GRc|£¢

˜ d @-BGš(‡Dš(„ EV`bLOR¡zpfO`jLOnGhb^Siwd:`jhbnD|OfŒ~RJ|

`bLORViwPSRQdŒ^jixnGd ƒ±O~+LŒzvdOvR < >©zpd?|²`jLŒRSsuRcdORQh+zprwi-HcRc|XiwP‹RcdŒ^jixnGd ƒ±O~+LŒzvdOvR <Îs >Ö¢

˜

d¡`jLORJ^R

zvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP¥^ªz{Ohbn_~Rc^b^jnvh‹ŸŒzprlzpdŒ~QRc^ªi¶`+^Srxn:zv|1«ei¶`bL3nGdOrx]1nvdORnp›ui¶`+^SdORQiwvLDŸ5nvh+^ªzp`SRJzv~+L1^`jRc{7¢

˜d

@_š CEƒ`jLOR¬[DRJ~nvd?| ; h+|_RQh[_~+LŒRQPSR'<Î[ ; [D>uzvdŒ|†`bLOR LORQŸD]_^jLORQ¦²PSR`bLOn_|#zphbRªiwd:`jhbnD|OfŒ~RJ|£¢ªKMLORJ^R

zvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP¥^¬hbRQPSRQPªŸ?Rchb^`jLŒRrlzv^`rwnGzG|™R±O~+LŒzvdOvR¡`jn3^j{5RQRc| fO{ž`bLOR#~fOhbhjRcd:`R±O~+LŒzvdOvRG¢ W†nvhbR

hbRc~QRQd:`jrw]vš?`jLŒR‹zG|Ozp{_`+z•`bixnGd²np›µzprwr´`jLORJ^R‹zprwvnvhbix`jLOP¥^<nGd¡|_]DdŒzvP‹il~dŒR`a«(nvhb­D^<LŒz̦vRŸ5RQRcd^`jfŒ|OixRJ|†iwd

@IBcˆOš BBpš Ḃ)EB¢

˜ d`jLOil^M{Œzv{?RchcšD«(RV›Án_~f?^MnvfOhe^`jfŒ|_]¥nGd`bLOR©|_R`bRQhbP‹iwdŒzp`jiwnvdnp›7`bLOR}³ ; [¥{?zph+zpPSR`bRQh+^µnGd^`bz•`biw~

zvdŒ|²LORQ`jRchjnGvRQdŒRQnvf?^edOR`a«(nvhb­_^Q¢ 7R`ufŒ^udOnp`bR`bLŒz•`unvfOh©^a`bfŒ|_]²~Qzvd†Ÿ5Rªzp{Œ{OrxiwRc|†`jn`jLORªrwzvhjGRQh<{Œzvh`

nv› `jLŒR‹zvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP¥^X|_Rchjiw¦vRJ|¯›ÁhbnvP`jLOR¥³ ; [¯nvd°^a`+z•`jil~ªnvh©|_]DdŒzpPSil~dORQ`a«nGhj­_^c¢©KMLŒRªGRQdORchbzvr7›ÁnvhbP

nv›³ ; [nGd^`bzp`jil~©zpdŒ|LORQ`jRQhbnvGRQdORcnvfŒ^dORQ`a«nGhj­_^(iw^MGix¦GRQdŸD]

w _i ^(t+1) = w ^(t) _i − X

j

α i,j .f i,j . w ^(t) _i C n _i

− w ^(t) _j C n _j

!

<8 >

˜ d`bLOiw^e~czv^jRu`jLOR|_ixœfŒ^iwnvd¯Ÿ5Rc~QnvPSRc^

m ^(t) _ij =



 

 

α _ij f _i,j C _nj

ix›

(i, j) ∈ E ∧ i 6= j, 1 − P

k m ik ∀k|(i, k) ∈ E ∧ i = j,

0 otherwise,

zvdŒ|`jLOR}P¥z•`bhjix±¬›ÁnGhjP <F‡>(Ÿ5Rc~QnvPSRc^

W ^(t+1) = M ^T W ^(t)

˜

d`jLOR©rwi¶`bRQh+z•`bfOhjRGšD¦Ìzvhjiwnvf?^PSRQ`jLOn_|O^M~QzvdŸ5Ru›ÁnvfOd?|¬`bLŒz•`<|_RQ`jRQhbPSixdŒRV`bLORc^jR©{Œzph+zpPSR`bRQh+^

α i,j

nvh

f i,j

¢KMLŒRQhbRªzphbRª`jLOhbRQRS~rlzv^b^il~Qzvr´PSRQ`jLOn_|O^X`jn¯~nGPS{Of_`jR

α

]DŸ5RQdO­Gn LOnGiw~QR @IB#EBš(nviwrxrlz•` LOnvil~R

@т)E(nvh}nv{O`jiwPSzvr LOnvil~R'@IB 8 EF¢KMLŒR¬nv{_`bixP¥zvr LOnvil~R¥dORcRc|O^zGrxnGŸŒzprƒ­DdOn•«erwRc|OvRSnp›(`jLOR¥dŒR`a«(nvhb­5¢

KMLŒR ]DŸ?RcdO­vn LOnGiw~QR<dORcRc|O^z©­:dŒn•«erxRJ|_vRenv›5`bLOR<Ghbzv{OL¥|_RQGhjRcR

D(G)

zvdŒ|Sviw¦vRJ^

α ij = _D(G)+1 ¹

^š

zvdŒ|`jLOR (nviwrwrwzp` LŒnvil~R©nvdOrw]¬dORcRc|O^Vzª­DdOn•«erwRc|OvRunp›dORQiwvLDŸ5nvh+^(|ORQvhbRQRX`jn¬|OR`jRchjPSiwdOR

α

α ij = 1

max(d(i), d(j)) + 1 ,

«eLŒRQhbR

d(i)

il^`jLŒR°|_RcvhbRQRnp›ªdŒnD|OR

i

^zp``bixPSR

t

^¢ KMLOR#{ŒzvhbzvP‹RQ`jRch

f i,j

PªfŒ^`Ÿ5R®|_R`bRQhbP‹iwdORJ|

zG~Q~Qnvh+|_ixdŒ¬`jn`jLŒR¬~nvd?^a`bhbzvixd:`b^Xnp›`jLOR¥|_ixœfŒ^iwnvd°P¥z•`bhjix±

M

^š

M

Pf?^a`}Ÿ5R¬^a`bnD~+L?zv^`jil~pš£iwhjhbRc|_f?~iwŸOrxR zvdŒ|zp{5RQhbixn_|_il~,@-BEF¢

e e!ª e$ µ´(}

!"#$%&('

R`<fŒ^V^a`+zphj`MŸD]|_R¨ŒdŒixdO‹`bLOR~n:^a`<zvdŒ|`jLOR}Ÿ5RQdORQ¨O`Vnv›z‹rwnGzv|ŸŒzvrwzvdŒ~iwdO¥zprwvnGhjix`jLOP¯¢ KMLOR~QnG^`eiw^

`bLOR`bixPSRªrxn:^a`uŸ:]R±O~+LŒzvdOviwdOS`bLORrwnGzG|£š?ix`Xil^XvRQdŒRQh+zprwrx]|_fOR`bn~QnvPSPfOdŒiw~cz•`jiwnvd ¢VKMLORŸ5RQdORQ¨O`©iw^

`bLOR`bixPSRªGzpiwdORJ|¯Ÿ:]R±O~+LŒzvdOviwdOS`bLORrwnGzG|£šŒix`Xil^V|_fŒR`jnz¥Ÿ5R``bRQhuŸŒzprlzpd?~Rv¢ ˜ d kGf?z•`jiwnvd <8 >e`jLOR

{?zph+zpPSR`bRQh

f i,j

~QnvhbhjRJ^{5nvd?|O^X`jn¯`jLŒR¥«RcixGLG`nv›(RJ|_vR

(i, j)

¢KMLŒiw^}{?zph+zpPSR`bRQhu›îz̦vnGhb^X`jLŒR¥›îzv^`jRJ^a`

RJ|_vRJ^Q¢ ˜dnp`jLŒRQh©«nGhb|Œ^Qš?`jLOil^©{ŒzvhbzvP‹RQ`jRchVP¥zpdŒzvvRJ^<`bLOR‹~QnG^`Xnv› `jLOR zprwvnvhbix`jLOP¯¢©KMLOR‹~QnG^`unv›

`bLOR ™zprwvnGhjix`jLŒP il^(P¥zpiwdOrx]¬|OfORu`jnª`jLOR©R±O~+LŒzvdOvRVnp› rwnGzG|£¢KF<RQd?~RvšD`bLORu{Œzph+zpPSR`bRQh

f i,j

PfŒ^`eŸ?R

|OR`jRchjPSiwdORc|°^jfŒ~+L°`jLŒzp`u`bLOR¬~n:^a`}nv›`bLOR zvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP il^}rxn•«(RQhu`bLŒzpd`jLOR¥Ÿ5RQdŒR¨O`Gix¦GRQdŸ:]¡`jLOR

RQ±O~+LŒzpdOGR©np›ƒrxn:zv|£¢ ˜ d¯nvfOhV{OhbzG~Ö`biw~czpr zv{O{OhbnGzv~+L š

f i,j

il^<iwd

{0, 1}

^{¢ ˜}›`bLORª~QnG^`<np›`jLŒRR±O~+LŒzvdOvR©np›

L ^(t) _ij

Ÿ?RQ`a«RcRQd

i

^zvdŒ|

j

iw^vhbRczp`jRQh `jLŒzvd¬i¶`+^µŸ5RQdŒR¨O`JšG`bLORQd

f i,j

il^(^RQ`µ`jn

0

zpd?|S`jLORchjRViw^dOnRQ±_~+L?zpdOGR

Ÿ5R`a«(RQRcd

i

^zpdŒ|

j

šnp`bLORQhb«eil^R

f i,j

il^X^jR`X`jn

1

zpdŒ|¯`bLORrwnGzG|

L ^(t) _ij

il^XR±O~+LŒzpdŒvRc|¯Ÿ5R`a«(RQRcd

i

^zpdŒ|

j

^¢

˜`V~czpdŸ?R}dŒnp`jRJ|`jLŒzp`<Ÿ:]`jLOil^<|_RQ¨ŒdOix`jiwnvd`jL?z•`

f i,j

|ORQ{5RQdŒ|O^<nvd`jLOR©`bixPSRvš?LORQd?~R}ix`<Ÿ?RJ~nvPSRJ^

f _i,j ^(t)

zvdŒ|i¶`+^<~nGhjhbRc^j{?nGdŒ|_iwdO¦GRc~`jnvh

F

Ÿ?RJ~nGP‹RJ^

F ^(t)

^¢

KMLOR#~n:^a`¯zpdŒ|ž`jLOR°Ÿ5RQdORQ¨O`nv›ªzpd R±O~+LŒzpdŒvR¡|_Rc{?RcdŒ|O^nvd `jLOR#^ji-HcR¡np›`jLOil^R±O~+LŒzpdŒvRv¢ K n

|OR`jRchjPSiwdORu`jLOR~QnG^`enp›ƒzpdR±O~+LŒzpdŒvRu«R©viw¦vRu`bLOR©›Ánvrwrxn•«eiwdO‹Rck:fŒzp`jiwnvd7š

n:^a`

(L ^(t) _ij ) =

^{m hbR ƒ±O~ nG^`}

(|L ^(t) _ij |) +

^{ıO~ n:^a`}

(|L ^(t) _ij |) +

^{mn:^a` ıO~ n:^a`}

(|L ^(t) _ij |).

P™LŒRQhbRS`jLOR~nG^`np›<z²rwnGzG|°R±O~+LŒzpdŒvR

L ^(t) _ij

il^©`jLŒR¬`jiwPSR¥`jn¡{OhjRc{ŒzphbR‹`jLOil^ªrxn:zv|›Ánvh}`bLOR¬RQ±_~+L?zpdOGR

<îm hbR ƒ±O~ n:^a`

(|L ^(t) _ij |)

>š£{OrwfŒ^X`jLORª`jiwPSRªnv› `jLOR‹R±O~+LŒzvdOvR <ƒ±O~ nG^`

(|L ^(t) _ij |)

>֚£{OrwfŒ^X`jLORª`jiwPSR`bniwd_¾

`bRQGhbzp`jRix`}nvd¡`jLORShbRc~Rcix¦GRQh,<ÁmnG^` ƒ±O~ nG^`

(|L ^(t) _ij |)

>Ö¢mµhjRƒ±O~ nG^`}zpdŒ|¡mn:^a` ƒ±O~ n:^a`}~nGP‹{ŒrxRQ`jRQrw]

|ORQ{5RQdŒ|nvd`jLORzv{O{Orwiw~cz•`bixnGd7¢ ƒ±O~ nG^`MnvdOrw]|_Rc{?RcdŒ|O^Mnvd`jLŒRurwnGzG|

L ^(t) _ij

zvdŒ|¬nGd`bLOR}Rc|OvR

(i, j)

^šOz

GnDnD|Rc^`jiwP¥z•`bixnGdnv› `jLŒiw^<~QnG^`<~Qzpd¯Ÿ5R

ıO~

nG^`

(|L ^(t) _ij |) =

^zp`

ij + |L ^(t) _ij |

(«

ij

,

«eLŒRQhbR ´z•`

ij

zpdŒ| («

ij

zphbRuhjRJ^{5Rc~`jiw¦vRQrw]¥`bLOR}rwzp`jRcdŒ~]zvdŒ|`jLOR©ŸŒzvdŒ|_«eil|D`jL²nv›´RJ|_vR

(i, j)

^¢

KMLORŸ?RcdOR¨Œ`‹Gix¦GRQd#ŸD]`bLORRQ±O~+LŒzpdOGR¥np›

L ^(t) _ij

~Qzpd1Ÿ?RRc^`jiwPSzp`jRJ|®ŸD]¡`bLOR~QnvPS{Of_`+z•`jiwnvd#`bixPSR nGd

i

^zpdŒ|

j

«eix`jLOnGf_`}R±O~+LŒzvdOvR‹PSixdDfŒ^u`bLOR¬~nGP‹{Œf_`bzp`jiwnvd`jiwP‹R¥nGd

i

^zvdŒ|

j

z•›t`bRQh©`bLOiw^©RQ±O~+LŒzpdOGRv¢

˜d:`bfOi¶`bix¦GRQrw]©`jLOR(Ÿ5RQdORQ¨O` np›?zXrwnGzv|R±O~+LŒzpdŒvRµPªfŒ^`Ÿ5RM{?n:^ix`jiw¦vRi¶›?`jLORe~nGPS{Of_`bzp`jiwnvd`jiwP‹R(il^´hbRc|OfŒ~RJ|

ŸD]‹`jLŒiw^R±O~+LŒzvdOvR<zvdŒ|¥dORcGz•`bix¦GR<iwd¥`jLORunp`bLORQh(~QzG^RG¢ R`f?^µhbRc~czprwrO`jL?z•`(`jLORu~nvPS{OfO`bz•`bixnGd¥`jiwPSRVnGd

i

^zpdŒ|

j

iw^eGix¦GRQdŸD]¬`jLŒR}PSzp±_ixPªfOP Ÿ5R`a«(RQRcd`bLOR~nGPS{Of_`bzp`jiwnvd`jiwPSR}nvd

i

zvdŒ|`jLOR~QnvPS{Of_`+z•`jiwnvd

`bixPSRªnvd

j

¢©KMLOR›ÁnGrxrwn•«eiwdO¬Rck:fŒzp`jiwnvd²Gix¦GRc^e`bLOR‹Ÿ?RcdOR¨O`u›ÁnvhX`jLŒRª~QzG^RJ^e¾

L ^(t) _ij > 0

^zvdŒ|

L ^(t) _ij < 0

^¾

hbRc^j{5Rc~Ö`bix¦GRQrw]¥nvd

i

^zvdŒ|

j

^i¶›

i

viw¦vRJ^Mrxn:zv|¬`jn

j

^¢

(RQdORQ¨O`

(L ^(t) _ij ) =



 

 

 

 

max(

^PS{

(w ^(t) _i , i),

^PS{

(w _j ^(t) , j))

− max(

^P‹{

(w _i ^(t) − L ^(t) _ij , i),

^PS{

(w ^(t) _j + L ^(t) _ij , j))

^i¶›

L ^(t) _ij > 0, max(

^PS{

(w ^(t) _i , i),

^PS{

(w _j ^(t) , j))

− max(

^P‹{

(w _i ^(t) + L ^(t) _ij , i),

^PS{

(w ^(t) _j − L ^(t) _ij , j))

^i¶›

L ^(t) _ij < 0,

«eLŒRQhbR PS{

(w ^(t) _i , i)

iw^ƒ`jLOR<~QnvPS{Of_`+z•`jiwnvd‹`bixPSRenp›

w ^(t) _i

^nGd

i

^¢ 7RQ`µfŒ^ƒdOnv`jRM`bLŒz•` iwd¬³ ; [š•ix›

L ^(t) _ij > 0

`bLORQd PS{

(w ^(t) _i , i) >

^PS{

(w _j ^(t) , j)

^{zvdŒ|ªi¶›}

L ^(t) _ij < 0

^{`bLORQd PS{}

(w _i ^(t) , i) <

^PS{

(w ^(t) _j , j)

švLŒRQdŒ~QRM`jLOR RJ^a`bixP¥zp`jiwnvdnp›Ÿ?RcdOR¨O`V~czpdŸ?R}hbRQ«ehbix``jRcdzG^(›Ánvrwrxn•«<^

(RQdŒR¨O`

(L ^(t) _ij ) = (

PS{

(w _i ^(t) , i) − max(

^PS{

(w ^(t) _i − L ^(t) _ij , i),

^PS{

(w _j ^(t) + L ^(t) _ij , j))

^ix›

L ^(t) _ij > 0,

PS{

(w _j ^(t) , j) − max(

^PS{

(w ^(t) _i + L ^(t) _ij , i),

^PS{

(w ^(t) _j − L ^(t) _ij , j))

^ix›

L ^(t) _ij < 0.

<4C3>

˜ dS`bLORei¶`bRQh+z•`bix¦GR 1zvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP¥^Qš•`bLOR<Ÿ5RQdORQ¨O`µnv›zvd‹RQ±O~+LŒzpdOGRnv›5rwnGzG|Sz•`µz©viw¦vRcdªix`jRchbzp`jiwnvdS~Qzvd

iwdŒ~QhjRJzv^jRª«eix`jL°`jLŒR¬dOR±D`ix`jRchbzp`jiwnvdŒ^c¢¥KMLOR¥Rc^`jiwP¥z•`jiwnvd°np›(`jLŒR¥Ÿ?RcdOR¨O``jLŒzp`«RSviw¦vRSiwd µk:fŒz•`bixnGd

<C3><iw^XRQ¦•zprwfŒzp`jRc|†nvd²nvdŒrx]¯nvdŒRix`jRQh+z•`bixnGd7¢FVRQdŒ~QRvš£z¬{ŒzvhbzvPSR`jRch

k

il^Viwd:`jhbnD|OfŒ~RJ|¯`jnRc^`jiwPSzp`jR`jLOR

Ÿ5RQdŒR¨O`nGd#`jLOR

k

^fŒ~c~RJ^j^jix¦GRSi¶`bRQh+z•`jiwnvd?^z•›t`bRQhªzvd#R±O~+LŒzpdŒvRv¢ ˜dŒ|_RcRc|£š

f _i,j ^(t)

il^}Rck:fŒzvr `jn

1

i¶›<zpd?|

nGdOrw]ix› n:^a`

(L ^(t) _ij ) < k∗

^(RQdORQ¨O`

(L ^(t) _ij )

¢KMLOR}{?zph+zpPSR`bRQh

k

~Qzpd¯Ÿ5R~nGdŒ^`bzpd:`envhedŒnp`<Áiwd¡[DRJ~Ö`jiwnvd C

`bLOR}iwP‹{?zv~Ö`env›Ÿ5np`bL¯~czv^jRc^MzphbR}~nGP‹{?zphbRc| >¢

; dORerwiwP‹ix`µnv›?`bLOiw^µ~nG^`•Ÿ?RcdOR¨Œ`µ^]_^`jRQP zp{O{5Rczvhb^ƒzp`ƒ`jLOR<~QnvdD¦vRchjGRQdŒ~QRnv›?`bLOR<zprwvnGhjix`jLŒP¢ P™LORQd

`bLOR#|_i¶œRQhbRQd?~R#np›rwnGzG|žŸ5R`a«(RQRcd ‡1LOnvPSnvGRQdORcnvfŒ^dORQiwvLDŸ5nvh+^il^ B¡`bLOil^²^]_^`jRQP ^`jnG{Œ^`jLOR°R±D¾

~+L?zpdOGRc^c¢7RQ`‹f?^ª~QnvdŒ^jiw|ORQhª`jLOR›Ánvrwrxn•«eiwdO†RQ±OzpPS{OrwRvš zrxiwdOR«eix`jL3`jLŒRrwnGzv|hjRc{Œzphj`jix`jiwnvd

W ^(t) = [11, 10, 9, 8, . . .]

¢´q<d}RQ±O~+LŒzpdOGR`jLŒzp` viw¦vRJ^5`jLOR›ÁnGrxrwn•«eixdŒerxn:zv|XhjRc{Œzphj`jix`jiwnvd

W ^(t) = [10, 11, 9, 8, . . .]

L?zv^Vz~nG^`XzvdŒ|†z¥dDfOrwr´Ÿ5RQdŒR¨O`Jš?`bLORQhbR›ÁnGhjR©`bLORS~nG^`•Ÿ?RcdOR¨Œ`X^]_^`jRcP ›ÁnGhjŸOil|O^<`jLOil^VRQ±O~+LŒzpdOGRv¢<KMLOR

rwnGzG|¯hjRc{Œzphj`jix`jiwnvd²iwd¡^`jRc{†iw^uz¬~QrwzG^j^jiw~czpr´{OhjnGŸOrwRQP«eLORQd²`bLOR‹rxn:zv|¯il^VdOnv`Xiwd_¨ŒdOix`jRcrx]²|_iw¦Diw^jiwŸOrxRGši¶`uiw^

iwdŒ~QhjRJzv^jRc|¬«eix`jL`bLOR~n:^a`̟5RQdORQ¨O`<^]_^`jRQPD`jLOil^e{OhbnvŸŒrxRcP¤iw^V^a`bfŒ|_iwRc|ixd†[DRJ~Ö`bixnGd 8 ¢8 ¢

$ %#

³ŒhjnGP`jLORSvRcdORQh+zpr´Rck:fŒzp`jiwnvd¡nv›³ ; [²«R‹LŒz̦vR‹|_R`bRQhbPSixdORJ|²`bLORª{?zph+zpPSR`bRQh

f _i,j ^(t)

ixd`jLŒRª{OhbRQ¦DiwnvfŒ^

^jRc~`jiwnvd7¢ T<n•«}š rwR`¥fŒ^¥^`jf?|_]®`jLŒR{?zph+zpPSR`bRQh+^

α i,j

zpdŒ|

C n _i

¢ ˜ d™[DRJ~Ö`jiwnvd™‡Dš¦Ìzvhjiwnvf?^ªPSRQ`jLOn_|O^

zvhjRSGix¦GRQd°`jn†|_RQ`jRchjPSiwdOR

α i,j

zpdŒ|

C n i

¢ (f_`nvdŒrx]¡`jLOR (nGixrwrwzp` LOnvil~R¬|_nDRJ^}dOnp`ªdORQRJ|°z¯GrxnGŸŒzpr

­DdOn•«erwRc|OvRX`jn¥~nGP‹{Œf_`jR

α i,j

¢ KMLŒR}np`jLŒRQhePSR`bLOn_|O^M›Ánvh

α i,j

zvdŒ|

C n i

dORcRc|¯z‹vrwnvŸŒzvr£­:dŒn•«erxRJ|_vRG¢

˜ d#`bLOiw^^RJ~Ö`jiwnvd šzPSR`bLOn_|°`jLŒzp`nvdOrw]†dORcRc|O^z¯rxn_~Qzvr ­DdOn•«erwRc|_GR‹il^}Gix¦GRQd`jn†|_RQ`jRQhbPSixdŒR¥`jLOR

hbRQrlz•`bixnGd

α i,j

C _ni

¢ 7R`<f?^<|_RQdŒnp`jR

C

`jLŒR}¦vRc~`jnGhenp›`jLOR}{Ohbn_~RJ^j^jnvh+^^j{5RQRc|Œ^Q¢ R`

C r

Ÿ5R©`jLORP¥zp`jhbi¶±nv›

hbRQrlz•`bix¦GRu^j{5RQRc|Œ^<|_R¨?dORc|ŸD]

C r _i,j

š_`bLOR}hbRQrlz•`jiw¦vR©^j{?RcRc|np›

j

~nGPS{ŒzphbRc|¬`jn

i

C r _i,j =

( _C

j

C i +C j (i, j) ∈ E, j 6= i,

0 otherwise.

KMLDfŒ^ `jLŒRµfOdOix`np›

C

il^ dŒnp`´iwPS{?nGh`+zpd:`cš•ix`~czpdŸ5RMW F HGšpWŒnv{?^ nGh´zpdD]unp`bLORQhJ¢(P™ix`jL`jLOil^|_R¨ŒdŒi¶`bixnGd nv›zhjRcrwzp`jiw¦vRe^{5RQRJ|SP¥z•`jhbix±š:z}|_ixœ5fŒ^jiwnvd¥P¥z•`bhjix±`bLŒz•`µ«(R<|_RcdOnp`bR

M r

~QzvdSŸ?R<Gix¦GRQd7¢

M r

il^µ|_RQ¨ŒdORJ|

^jfŒ~+L`jLŒzp`

M r _ij =

min(δ i C r _i,j , δ j C r _i,j ) j 6= i, 1 − P

j(j6=i) M r _ij j = i,

«eix`jL

δ i = P ¹

j(j6=i) C _ri,j

¢ ]¬~QnvdŒ^`jhbfŒ~`jiwnvd7šDix`Mil^MRczG^]‹`bnS^jLOn•«™`bLŒz•`

M r _ij ≥ 0

^zvdŒ|

P

j M r _ij = 1

^š

iwd¯np`bLORQhe«(nvh+|O^`jLOR}P¥zp`jhbi¶±

M r

il^e^`jn_~+LŒzv^`jil~p¢

¸D¼ “ ¸

N * "!#%$&(+ %03%#/ 4"5 K/ /

M r

%! * "!#%$ 5L% # M%$ N03N#!, %*'

I*L*%!# #? %$'N-% %N 6 4DN $)*N ! NMNM* %$* %$ 6

M r

!/#NM*% .IN %$*L N.#)*% 7/N7

4DN 0

G

5,"!# MN6M%$ $NM NM*1$* $%$. %# / ON7

“ ¼7¼

M r

! !# OMD%!# K/#NM*% .-N%$* MDN#* 4DN N.#$ !MN$ /"! 4DNMN.5 M$"MN

MNM*# 7/N)7

∃µ

^$

µ

!6&%'"N* D/$ ( NM *) !M M 4D

M r ^T µ = µ

^{7 ++ M%$ !# # $}

M r

/ !

NM%!, !D 4D

µ = hC

^DNN

h

^{! !# M / %}

P

i w ⁽⁰⁾ _i = h P

i C i

7 ""!.%, 0 N$

W ⁽⁰⁾

4DN/$%%#$ *%!# #.? %$

µ

^{! %# %$%J}

C

⁷

qX^e^LOn•«edŸD]¬KMLORQnGhjRcP BpšD`jLOR žzprwvnGhjix`jLOPÚ~QnvdD¦vRchjGRc^ ix› `bLOR©dOR`a«(nvhb­

G

il^e~nGdOdORc~`jRJ|zpd?|

dŒnvd_¾BŸOiw{Œzphj`jix`jRG¢KMLORX~nvdŒdORc~`jiw¦:ix`a]‹np›`jLORXdOR`a«(nvhb­ª|ORQ{5RQdŒ|O^nvdS`bLORV^jR`

E

zpdŒ|‹`bLORVdORQ`a«nGhj­ªiw^µdOnp`

ŸŒix{Œzvh`bi¶`bR}i¶›

M r

il^e«Rcrxr7~QnvdŒ^`jhbfŒ~`jRc|7¢µKMLOR}{OhbRQ¦DiwnvfŒ^(PSR`bLOn_|²|_nDRc^MdOnv`<RQdŒ^jfOhbRX`bLŒz•`e`bLOR}dORQ`a«nGhj­

il^MdOnv`<ŸOix{?zphj`jix`jRvšD`bn¥RQdŒ^jfOhbRu`jLŒzp`<«R}~Qzvdf?^Ru`jLŒR©›Ánvrwrxn•«eiwdO¥|_R¨?dOi¶`bixnGd

C r i,j =



 

 

C _j

C _i +C j (i, j) ∈ E, j 6= i,

C _i

2C i j = i,

0 otherwise.

˜

d`bLOiw^e~czv^jRvšD`bLOR}hjRcrwzp`jiw¦vR©|_ixœ5fŒ^jiwnvd¯P¥z•`jhbix±

M r

il^<|_R¨?dORc|ŸD]

M r _ij =

min(δ i C r i,j , δ j C r i,j ) j 6= i 1 − P

j(j6=i) M r ij j = i

«eix`jL

δ i = P ¹

j C _ri,j

¢žKMLOil^¥PSR`bLOn_| «(zvhjh+zpd:`b^`jL?z•`¥`jLŒR²dOR`a«(nvhb­®iw^SdŒnp`¬ŸOiw{Œzphj`jix`jR¯Ÿ5Rc~czpfŒ^jR²i¶`

«Mzphbh+zpd:`b^©`bLŒz•`ª`jLOR¯|_ilzpGnvdŒzvr np›

M r

iw^ªdOnv`‹dDfOrwr΢=F<RcdŒ~RGšƒ«ei¶`bL`bLOiw^ªPSR`bLOn_|®`jLŒR|_ixœfŒ^iwnvd

zvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP ~QnvdD¦vRchjGRc^ªi¶›zpd?|3nGdOrw]1ix›u`bLOR²dORQ`a«nGhj­il^¬~QnvdOdORJ~Ö`bRc| <Á«eLOil~+Lž^jRQRQP¥^S`bLOR²PSixdŒixPªfOP

hbRck:fOiwhbRQPSRQd:`M>¢

K´n¡ŸOfŒixrl|®`bLOR|Oi¶œfŒ^jixnGdP¥z•`jhbix±

M

«eix`jL1nvdORnp›e`jLŒRc^jR`a«(n†PSR`bLOn_|O^SzpdŒ|#`bLOR~QnG^`•Ÿ?RcdOR¨O`

|OR¨ŒdORJ|}iwdª[DRc~`jiwnvd 8 ¢-BpšÌ`bLORµ¦GRc~`jnvh

L ^(t) r

nv›DrwnGzG|©R±O~+LŒzvdOvRƒ{OhbRc|Oiw~`jiwnvdPªfŒ^a`´Ÿ?R(|_R¨ŒdŒRc|©`bnX~nGPS{Of_`jR

f _ij ^(t)

^¢

L ^(t) r

iw^MGix¦GRQdŸ:]

L ^(t) r _ij = M r ij w _i ^(t) − M r ji w _j ^(t)

P™ix`jL

F ^(t)

^zpd?|

M r

|_RQ¨ŒdORJ|£š_`jLŒR|_i¶œfŒ^jixnGd¯PSzp`jhbi¶±

M ^(t)

il^eviw¦vRcdŸD]

m ^(t) _ij =

( f _ij ^(t) M r _ij j 6= i, 1 − P

k(k6=i) f _ik ^(t) M r _ik j = i,

zvdŒ|`jLOR^j]_^a`bRQP¤rwnGzG|Ÿ5RQLŒz̦DiwnvhMil^<~rlzv^b^il~Qzvrxrw]¬|_RQ¨ŒdORc|ŸD]

W ^(t+1) = M ^{(t) T} W ^(t) .

' $ ( $ % % "%# %

KMLŒRXrlzv^`M^`jRc{¬`bLŒz•`e«(Ru^`jfŒ|O]¥ixd`jLOil^({Œzp{5RQhMil^`jLORu`jRchjPSiwdŒz•`bixnGdnv›7`jLOR ™zvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP¯¢ƒKMLOiw^M^`jRc{

~QnvdŒ^jil^a`+^Mixd²|_RQ`jRc~`jiwdO¥`bLOR}RQdŒ|¯nv›´`bLOR zprwvnGhjix`jLOP¤`jn¬^`jnv{¯ix`Xzpd?|z̦Gnvil|¥`bLOR~n:^a`env›RQ±_~+L?zpdOGR

nv›Viwd_›ÁnvhbP¥z•`jiwnvd |_nvdŒRŸD]#`jLŒRÚzprwvnvhbix`jLOP¯¢KMLOil^S~nG^`¥~Qzpd3Ÿ?R¯iwPS{?nGh`+zpd:`‹ix›V`bLORdOR`a«(nvhb­#iw^

^jrwn•« nGhe`jLORd:fŒPŸ5RQh<nv›dŒRQiwvLDŸ?nGhb^<iw^eLŒixGL7¢ ˜›`bLORrwnGzG|¯nvhM`jLŒRdORQ`a«nGhj­zvhjR|O]:d?zpPSiw~všŒix`X~Qzvd²Ÿ?R

iwd:`jRchjRJ^a`bixdO¬`jn|_RQ`jRJ~Ö`u`jLOR‹~nvdD¦GRQhbvRQd?~Ru`jnhjRJ|_fŒ~R`jLOR›ÁhjRJkGfŒRQdŒ~Q]nv› rxn:zv|¯ŸŒzvrwzvdŒ~iwdO^`jRc{Œ^<nGh<`jn

iwdŒ~QhjRJzv^jRXix`<i¶›`jLŒR}fOdDŸŒzprlzpdŒ~QR©ixdŒ~QhjRJzv^jRc^c¢

KMLORVPSzvixdS{OhbnvŸŒrxRcP `jnª|_R`bRc~Ö`µ~QnvdD¦vRchjGRQdŒ~QRil^ƒ`bLŒz•`µ`jLORerwnGzG|ªil^ dŒnp` iwd_¨ŒdOix`jRcrx]S|_iw¦:il^jixŸOrwRe›ÁnGhƒ`jLOR

hbRczvrzv{O{Orwiw~cz•`bixnGdŒ^Q¢}KMLOil^uixPS{OrwiwRc^X`jLŒzp`X`bLOR zprwvnGhjix`jLŒP*~czpdOdŒnp`}zprw«(zÌ]_^<hbRczG~+L†zfŒdOi¶›ÁnGhjP rwnGzG|

|Oiw^`jhbixŸŒf_`jiwnvd7š?LORQd?~Rix`X|_nDRc^<dOnp`Xzvrx«MzÌ]_^MhjRJzv~+L`jLORª~nvdD¦GRQhbvRQd?~Ru{?nGixd:`c¢<[DnGPSR^a`bRQ{Œ^Vnp›rxn:zv|¯~Qzvd

zv{O{5RczphµixdS`bLORV^j]D^`jRcP `bLŒz•`(~QzpdSŸOrwn_~+­`bLOR 3zvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP¯¢´K]:{Œiw~czprwrx]GšGz}rwixdŒR<np› C}{Ohbn_~Rc^b^jnvh+^´«eix`jL

`bLORrwnGzG||Oiw^`jhbixŸŒf_`jiwnvd

{3, 2, 1, 0}

~czpdOdŒnp`<hbRczv~+L²z¥fŒdOi¶›ÁnGhjPrwnGzv|¯|_il^`jhbixŸOfO`jiwnvd²«eix`jL¯`jLŒR~rlzv^b^il~Qzvr

|Oi¶œfŒ^jixnGdSzvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP¯¢W†nvhbRQn•¦vRchcšJ`bLOiw^µ{OhbnvŸOrwRQP zp{O{5RczvhƒP‹nGhjRenv›t`jRcd‹«eix`jLS`bLORV~QnG^`̟5RQdŒR¨O`µ^j]_^a`bRQP

{ŒhjRJ^RcdG`bRc|ixd†[DRJ~Ö`bixnGd 8 ¢-Bp¢

¸ Á’¥‘ ¸ ’ ¼5¸ ´‘“ ¼  &¸

R`(fŒ^M^a`+zphj`ŸD]SRQrwixPSiwdŒz•`bixdOª`jLŒiw^(|_il^j~QhjRQ`jil^jzp`jiwnvd¬{OhbnvŸŒrxRcP¢ ˜d¬`bLORurxix`jRchbzp`jfOhbRvšG`jLORurwnGzv|¬ŸŒzprlzpdŒ~QixdŒ

{ŒhjnGŸOrxRcP¤np›iwdŒ|_iw¦:il^jixŸOrwR}fOdOix`¾è^ji-HcR©`jnv­GRQdŒ^Mil^e^`jfŒ|_iwRc|¯iwd=@%E «eLORQhbR©`jLŒRzpf_`bLOnvh+^Mixd:`bhjn_|_fŒ~QRc|`jLOR ˜

;

«(R nGf <˜ ;

U2>µfOdOix`(nGd¬RczG~+L¬Rc|_GRvšDzpdŒ|¬ixd@-BC%E5«eLŒRQhbR<`jLŒRuzvf_`jLOnGhb^µixd:`bhjn_|_fŒ~QRc|¬zhbzvdŒ|_nGP‹iIHQRJ|

zvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP`bLŒz•`|ORczprl^ƒ«eix`jL¬LŒR`jRchjnGvRcdORQnGfŒ^dOR`a«(nvhb­_^Q¢

˜

dS`jLOil^µ^jRc~`jiwnvd7š:z}dORQ«zp{Œ{Ohjn:zv~+L‹ŸŒzv^jRc|‹nGd

^jiwPfOrlz•`bRc|SzpdOdŒRczprwiwdO}zprwvnvhbix`jLOP¥^il^ƒfŒ^jRc|£¢KMLORenvŸOoaRc~Ö`bix¦GReiw^ƒ`jn}{5RQhj`jfOhbŸ?RM`bLORV^j]_^a`bRQP`bnPSn•¦vR(`jLOR

rwnGzG|nv›O`jLORePSn:^a`rxn:zv|_RJ|dOn_|_RJ^`jn•«Mzph+|©`jLŒR(rwRczG^a`rwnGzv|ORc|dŒnD|ORc^«eLORQdª`jLŒRM~QrwzG^j^jil~Qzpr ®zprwvnvhbix`jLOP

il^MŸOrwn_~+­vRc|7¢ FVRQdŒ~QRvšD`bLORzprwvnGhjix`jLOPÚnG{?Rchbzp`jRJ^(zG^(›Ánvrwrxn•«<^i¶›z‹dOn_|_R

i

il^MfOdDŸŒzprlzpdŒ~QRc|«ei¶`bLhbRc^j{5Rc~Ö`

`bn©i¶`+^ƒdORQiwvLDŸ5nvh

j

zvdŒ|ªdOn©rxn:zv|ªiw^ƒRQ±O~+LŒzpdOGRc|Ÿ?RQ`a«RcRQdª`jLORJ^RM`a«(n©dOn_|_Rc^cšvzuhbzvdŒ|_nGP ¦•zprwfORe|_RQdOnv`jRJ|

zprwRcz Diw^<|OhbzÌ«edŸ?RQ`a«RcRQd¯ˆSzpdŒ| B

(0 <

^zprwRcz

< 1)

^{šOzpdŒ|ix›}

zprwRcz

< e ^{(−κ∗U ij )} ,

z‹{Œzvh`<nv›´rwnGzG|il^eR±O~+LŒzvdOvRJ|£¢

U ij

|_RQdOnv`jRJ^(`jLOR}dDfOPªŸ?Rch<np›ƒ^f?~Q~RJ^j^jiw¦vRurxn:zv|ŸŒzprlzpdŒ~QixdŒ‹ix`jRchbzp`jiwnvdŒ^

|OfOhjiwdO«eLOil~+L†`jLŒRªdORcixGLDŸ?nGhb^XdOn_|_Rc^

i

^zvdŒ|

j

zvhjRªfOdDŸŒzprlzpd?~Rc|zpdŒ||_ndOnp`©R±O~+LŒzvdOvRªrxn:zv|£¢KMLOR {?zph+zpPSR`bRQh

κ

|_R¨?dORc^`jLOR°{OhbnvŸŒzvŸOiwrxix`a]1`bnR±O~+LŒzvdOvR¡rxn:zv|™zpd?|ž~QzvdžŸ?R°|_R¨?dORc| Ÿ:]

κ = ^ln(p) _τ

«eLŒRQhbR

p

il^u`jLORS{OhbnvŸŒzvŸOiwrxix`a]¯`jn¯R±O~+LŒzvdOvR‹rwnGzv|z•`©`jLŒR‹ix`jRchbzp`jiwnvd

τ

^np›

U ij

¢S³Onvh}RQ±OzpPS{OrwRªix›

50%

nv›{OhbnvŸ?zpŸOiwrxix`a]`jn¯R±O~+LŒzvdOvRªiw^©«Mzpd:`bRc|¡zp`©`jLOR¥^jRc~nGdŒ|†ix`jRchbzp`jiwnvd

κ = ^ln(0.5) ₂

^¢ 7RQ`©f?^©dOnp`bRª`bLŒz•`

`bLOil^}PSR`jLŒnD|#|_nDRJ^©dOnp`RcdŒ^fŒhjR‹`jn¯hbRczG~+L¡`bLOR¥fOdOix›ÁnvhbPrwnGzv|°|_il^a`bhjiwŸOf_`bixnGd#ŸOf_`ix`~Qzpd°hbRc|_fŒ~QRS`jLOR

fŒd:Ÿ?zprlzpdŒ~QRv¢

¼ ¸ “ ¸ – ¸ ½ ¸ ’ ¸ –v’ ¼ “ ¼  &¸

R`f?^hbRc~Qzvrxr`bLŒz•`ª`jLOR¬¨Œhb^`{OhbnvŸOrwRQP {OhbRc^jRQd:`jRJ|°ixd#`bLOiw^ª^RJ~Ö`bixnGd®iw^©`bLOR~QnvdD¦vRchjGRQdŒ~QR‹|OR`jRJ~Ö`bixnGd

nv›M`jLOR zprwvnvhbix`jLOP¯¢'F<RcdŒ~RGš«(R¬PªfŒ^a`S|_R`bRc~``jLŒzp`ªdOn¡P‹nGhjRrxn:zv|°iw^ªR±O~+LŒzvdOvRJ|°ixd#`bLORdORQ`¾

«(nvhb­¢

˜

d@-B̂)E`jLOR}zvf_`jLOnGhb^viw¦vRuz|_RJ~RcdG`bhbzvrxiIHQRJ|¬~nGdD¦vRQhbvRcdŒ~RX|_R`bRc~Ö`bixnGdzvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOPÚ|_Rc|_il~Qzp`jRJ|¥`jn

{?zph+zprwrxRcrix`jRchbzp`jiw¦vR¥zv^j]DdŒ~+LOhbnvdOnGfŒ^uzprwvnvhbix`jLOP¥^c¢SKMLŒiw^}zvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOPil^©ŸŒzv^jRc|nvd`jLOR¥rwRczG|_RQh}RcrxRJ~Ö`bixnGd

nGd†`bLOR ˜ ƒ¾MB 8 C=<î³ixhbRP™iwhbR)>V{Ohjnv`jn_~nGrΚ7zvdŒ|²`bLOil^©ŸŒzv^jR‹~czpdŸ?RSfŒ^jRc|†`jn²|_R`bRc~`}zvrwnvŸ?zpr^a`+z•`jR

iwd†^j]:d?~+LOhjnGdOnvf?^ezprwvnvhbix`jLOP¥^M«eix`jLOnGf_`XzpdD]~RQd:`bhbzvrxiIHczp`jiwnvd7¢(KMLORc^jRzprwvnGhjix`jLOP¥^enG{?Rchbzp`jR©nvd†z‹`bhjRcRvš

LŒRQdŒ~QRuz‹^{?zpdOdOiwdOª`jhbRQRunp›´`jLOR©dORQ`a«nGhj­SPf?^a`MŸ?R}|_RQ¨ŒdORJ|£¢ zphbixnGfŒ^(zprwvnvhbix`jLOP¥^(R±_il^a`(`jn‹vRcdORQh+z•`bR

z¯^j{ŒzpdŒdOixdŒ`bhjRcRvš ›ÁhjnGP `jLOR^iwPS{OrxRS`bnv­GRQd(<Î^>uzprwvnGhjix`jLŒP `jn`jLŒR¥P‹nGhjR¥^jnv{OLŒiw^`jil~Qzp`jRc|°zprwvnGhjix`jLŒPS^

`bLŒz•`Xviw¦vRz¥PSiwdOixPªfOP‹¾F«(RQiwvL:`V^j{ŒzpdŒdOixdŒ¥`jhbRQR1@IBc‰Oš(B̅Dš(Bc„Oš(B %EF¢<KMLORvnGzvr7np›`bLORzprwvnGhjix`jLŒP il^e`jn

|OR`jRJ~Ö`Vz‹ŸOiwdŒzphb]^`bzp`jR `bLOR zprwvnvhbix`jLOPÚLŒzG^e~nGd:¦GRQhbvRJ|¥nvhedOnv`c¢

³Œnvhu`jLOR‹rwnGzv|†ŸŒzprlzpdŒ~QixdŒzprwvnGhjix`jLŒPšzpd°zv|Ozv{_`bzp`jiwnvd²nv› `jLORSzprwvnGhjix`jLŒPGix¦GRQd†iwd @IBJ‚ Eil^ufŒ^jRc|£¢

KMLŒiw^}zG|Ozp{_`+z•`bixnGdil^^j]:d?~+LOhjnGdOnvf?^XzvdŒ|#|_Rc|_il~Qzp`jRJ|†`bn²ŸOixd?zphb]¡^a`+z•`bRS|OR`jRJ~Ö`bixnGd7¢¬KMLOR¥il|_Rcznp›(`jLŒiw^

zvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP iw^Mzv^µ›Ánvrwrwn•«<^2<Î^RcRX³ixGfOhbRB)> Rczv~+LdOn_|_R

i

|_RQ¨ŒdORJ^

k

~+LŒzpdOdŒRQrl^µ«eLORchjR

k

il^ `bLORud:fŒPŸ5RQh nv›ŒdORcixGL:Ÿ5nvh+^7nv›

i

^{¢ ˜} d`jLOR(¨Œh+^a`^a`+zpGRµnp›Œ`jLORMzprwvnGhjix`jLOP¯šÌix›5z<dŒnD|ORLŒzG^nvdOrw]©nvdORM~+LŒzpdŒdORQrG`jLŒzp`il^dOnp`

zG^j^jn_~ilz•`bRc|`jn¬zSdORcixGL:Ÿ5nvhJš_ix`Xzv^b^n_~Qiwzp`jRc^`bLOiw^X~+LŒzpdŒdORQr`bn¬i¶`+^edORcixGL:Ÿ5nvhM`bLŒz•`XLŒzv^MdOn¬~+L?zpdOdORcr zpd?|

|OR¨ŒdORJ^(`jLOil^edORcixGLDŸ?nGhMzG^(i¶`+^M›îz•`bLORQh<zvdŒ|^jRQd?|O^(`jnSix`b^M›îzp`jLORchM`jLOR}^`bz•`bR}np›i¶`+^e^fOŸO¾Î`bhjRcRv¢ ˜›z‹dOn_|_R

hbRc~QRQiw¦vRJ^ƒ`jLŒRu^`bzp`jRVnv›´z^jfOŸ_¾F`jhbRQRV›ÁhjnGPÚzdORcixGL:Ÿ5nvhJš:i¶`ezv^b^n_~Qiwzp`jRc^z~+LŒzvdOdORcrŒ`bn`bLOiw^(dORcixGLDŸ?nGhzpd?|

|OR¨ŒdORJ^`jLOil^(dORQiwvLDŸ5nvhMzv^nvdORunp› ix`b^M~+LOiwrl|_hjRcd7¢

˜

`(il^(nvŸD¦DixnGfŒ^ƒ`bLŒz•`(`jLŒRurwRczp› dOn_|_RJ^µnv›7`jLOR}^j{ŒzpdŒdOixdŒ

`bhjRcRLŒz̦GR¬R±OzG~Ö`jrw]#nvdOR^f?~+L1~+LŒzpdŒdORQrMz•`‹`jLOR¯^`bzphj`nv›<`jLOR{Ohbnp`bnD~QnvrF¢FVRQdŒ~QRvšƒ`bLORzvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP iw^

^`bzvh`bRc|Ÿ:]¬`jLOR©rwRcz̦vRJ^`jLŒzp`e^jRQd?|¬`bLORQiwh<^a`+z•`bRX`bn‹`jLORcixhM›îzp`jLORchc¢ƒTVzp`jfOh+zprwrw]všD`jLŒR©^`bzp`jR©np›zS^fOŸO¾Î`bhjRcR

nv›(dŒnD|OR

i

il^|_R¨?dORc|#ŸD]

V

j S t j , j ∈ {i} ∪ ∆ i

š«eLORQhbR

S t j

iw^©`bLOR^`bzp`jR¥np›

j

^zvdŒ|

∆ i

iw^}`jLOR^jR`

nv›u~+LOiwrl|_hjRcd3nv›

i

^{¢ ;} ŸŒ^Rchj¦GR`bLŒz•`S`bLOR†^a`+z•`bRnv›uz#~+LOiwrw|

j

il^‹`jLOR†^`bzp`jR¯np›ui¶`+^¥^fŒŸ_¾Î`bhjRcR²zpdŒ|1`jLOR

~QnvdD¦vRchjGRQdŒ~QR(^`bzp`jR<nv›7z}dOn_|_R

i

iw^ `jhbfOR<ix›7i¶`(LŒzv^ dOnp`µRQ±O~+LŒzpdOGRc|‹rwnGzv|S«eix`jL¥ix`b^dORcixGL:Ÿ5nvhJšvzvdŒ|‹›îzprl^R nv`jLORchj«eil^jRv¢ ˜ d`bLOR}^RJ~nGdŒ|zvdŒ|¬rlzv^`<^a`+zpGRXnv› `jLŒRzprwvnvhbix`jLOP¯šD«eLORQd¯zªdOn_|_R

i

LŒzv^ezvrxr£ix`b^e~+L?zpdOdORcrw^

zG^j^jn_~ilz•`bRc|`jnzprwr´ix`b^udORcixGLDŸ?nGhb^<zvdŒ|²`bLŒz•`©zprwr´ix`b^udORcixGLDŸ?nGhb^XzphbRi¶`+^©~+LOixrl|_hbRQd7š?`jLŒiw^udOn_|_R

i

^{il^X`jLOR}

hbnDnp`Mnp›7`bLORu`jhbRQRG¢ FVRQdŒ~QRvšD`bLOR}^a`+z•`jRunp›i¶`+^e^fŒŸ_¾Î`bhjRcRXil^`jLOR}^`bzp`jRunp› `bLORu`jhbRQRGš:iwdnp`jLŒRQhM«nGhb|Œ^Qš:`jLŒiw^

dŒnD|OR¬|_R`bRc~Ö`+^©`jLŒR¬vrwnvŸŒzvr ^a`+z•`bR¥np›(`jLOR¬^j]_^a`bRQP¯¢ ˜ `^jRQdŒ|Œ^©`jLOil^}GrxnGŸŒzpr`bn²i¶`+^~+LOiwrw|OhjRcd°^`bzp`jR¬zpd?|

`bLORQ]S|_n}rwix­GRQ«eil^Re«eix`jL¬`jLORcixhµ~+LŒixrl|_hbRQd¬zpd?|‹^jnnGd7¢KMLDfŒ^ƒ`jLORXixd_›ÁnGhjP¥zp`jiwnvdSnp›5`jLORXvrwnvŸŒzvrO^a`+z•`bR<vnDRc^

`bLOhbnvfOGL¡zprwr`jLORSdORQ`a«nGhj­¢ P™i¶`bL¡`bLOil^}zprwvnvhbix`jLOP¯š5`a«nhjnDnv`udOn_|_RJ^©~QzpdŸ?RS|_RQ¨ŒdORc|7š£`jLŒzp`uPSRJzpdŒ^

1 2 3

4 5 6

ÈVà ÊpãÖÍFÍFÏJæÑАÍîÓBÈbÓÎЬã+ñXÓÌÐ

ԕåîÍÎÓ5ÍÎÓFÈÖÐã+ñvÓ JдÇaãÖÒäНåÖÐaÒÌÇaÐ

âÌÐèÓÎÐaÇaÓÎÏÑãÖÒ©È+æÖãÖåîÏÓÌÉ©êÌÐÈ+åÁô

åîã ͵ǝãÖåîåîНÍÎÊpãÖÒÌâ¥ÓFã©ÓÌÐ<ÍFËcô

ÓÎåÎÐaЁÍîÓBÈbÓÎУÍFÐaÒÓ_ñwåîãÖÉ¡È´ÒÌãQâÌÐ5ÓÎã

ÏÓÎÍ£ñlÈbÓÌÐaåê

1 2 3

4 5 6

root root

ÃÊpãÖÍFÍÎÏÌæÑЃÍÎÓFÈbÓÎÐã+ñOÓÌÐÍÎÐaǝãÖÒJâ

ÍÎÓFÈÖÐã+ñ:Ó ÌÐǝãÖÒäÐaåÖÐaÒÌÇaÐ âÌÐèÓÎНÇèÓÎÏÑãÖÒ

È+æÖãÖåîÏÓ ÌÉ ÏӐÙåîãQã+ÓFÍÖÐaÒÌÐaåÎÈbÓFÐaâ

çÓÌÐÔÌåÎÍîÓSÍÎÓFÈÖÐÖêÌАâ•È+ÍÌÐaâ

È+åîåÎã´Í¥ÇaãÖåîåÎÐaÍÎÊvãÖÒJâ3ÓÎã¡ÓÌÐÖæÑãÌÈ+æ

ÍÎÓFÈbÓÎÐ(ÍFÐaÒÓñxåÎãÖɞÈeÒÌãQâÌеÓFã<ÏÓÎÍÇÌÏÑæô

âÌåîÐaÒ:ê

³iwvfOhbR,B ƒKMLORc^jRX¨ŒvfOhbRc^(iwrxrwfŒ^`jh+z•`bRV`a«(nª{5nG^b^jixŸOrwR©^a`+z•`jRJ^(np› `bLOR}^a`+zpGRc^np› `bLOR}~nGd:¦GRQhbvRcdŒ~RV|OR`jRJ~Ö¾

`bixnGdzvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP¯¢ƒKMLORQ]zvrw^jnSixrwrwfŒ^a`bhbzp`jRu`jLŒR}vRQdŒRQh+z•`jiwnvdnp›`a«n‹hbn:nv`b^Miwd`jLOR©`bhjRcRv¢

`bLORc^jR}`a«(n¬dOn_|_RJ^<LŒz̦GR|_R`bRc~Ö`bRc|¯`bLORGrxnGŸŒzpr^a`+z•`bRŸOf_`ui¶`uiw^VdOnp`©z¥{OhbnvŸOrwRQP ›ÁnvhV`jLOR~QnvdD¦vRchjGRQdŒ~QR

|OR`jRJ~Ö`bixnGd7¢

K´nV¨?dOiw^jL‹«ei¶`bL7špix›Œ`jLŒR(~QnvdD¦vRchjGRQdŒ~QR iw^|_RQ`jRJ~Ö`jRJ|£š•`bLOR®zprwvnGhjix`jLŒP~czpdªŸ?Re^`jnv{Œ{?RJ|ix›Œ`jLŒR(rwnGzG|

il^e^`bz•`biw~v¢ ˜d`bLOR}np`bLORQhe~czv^jRX¾µ|O]:d?zpPSiw~urwnGzG|£š_|_]DdŒzpPSil~XdŒR`a«(nvhb­D^(nGh(nv`jLORch}¢x¢w¢¾ƒ`jLŒR©~QnvdD¦vRchjGRQdŒ~QR

|OR`jRJ~Ö`bixnGd†zprwvnvhbix`jLOP~Qzpd²Ÿ5Rf?^RJ|`jn¬hbRc|_f?~R}`bLOR›ÁhbRck:fORcdŒ~]np› ^`jRQ{?^<ix›`bLORª^j]_^a`bRQPŸ?RJ~QzvP‹R

^`bzvŸOrwRunGheixd?~hbRczv^jRui¶`<ix›ix`<Ÿ5Rc~QzvPSRufŒd:Ÿ?zprlzpdŒ~QRc|£¢

: , ¯<,e!ª´©!&!$SQ, }´!

"# %#

R`f?^^a`+zphj`}`jn†iwd:`jhbn_|_fŒ~R¬z¡~rlzv^b^il~Qzvr ^a`bhjfŒ~`jfOhbR¥np›<zvd#zv{O{Orwiw~cz•`bixnGd°iwdŒ~QrxfŒ|OixdOzpd#i¶`bRQh+z•`bix¦GR

zvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP¯¢KMLŒiw^<^`jhbfŒ~`jfOhbR©iw^MGix¦GRQdŸ:]q<rwvnvhbix`jLOP BG¢

K´«n®^`jRc{Œ^¥zp{O{5RczvhSixd `jLŒiw^¥zvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP¯š `jLŒR¨?hb^`¥nvdOR¯il^‹`jLOR²iwdOix`jilzprwi-HJz•`jiwnvdzpd?|`bLOR†^RJ~nGdŒ|

nGdORuiw^(`bLOR}~nvPS{OfO`bz•`bixnGd7¢ ˜d`bLOR©›ÁnvhbPSRQhJš:`jLOR}|_RQ`jRc~`jiwnvdnp›~nvdD¦GRQhbvRQd?~RVzvdŒ|¬`bLOR©rxn:zv|ŸŒzprlzpdŒ~QixdŒ

zvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOPzphbR ixdŒi¶`biwzvrxiIHQRJ|£¢´KMLORixdŒi¶`biwzvrxiIHczp`jiwnvdnv›_`jLORM~nGd:¦GRQhbvRcdŒ~Rƒ|_RQ`jRc~`jiwnvd¾?iwdOi¶` XR`jRJ~ nGd:¦u¾

~QnvdŒ^jil^a`+^ixdSvRcdORQh+z•`bixdŒ©z}^j{ŒzvdOdOiwdOu`jhbRQRenp›5`jLŒR<dOR`a«(nvhb­}fŒ^jRc|‹ŸD]`bLORVzp{Œ{Orxil~Qzp`jiwnvdSzpdŒ|‹iwdOix`jilzprwi-HcixdO

`bLOR¯{Œzph+zpPSRQ`jRQh+^‹zpdŒ|`jLOR¯dORcixGL:Ÿ5nvhbLOnDn_|nv›V`jLŒR¯~QnvdD¦vRchjGRQdŒ~QR|_RQ`jRc~`jiwnvdzprwvnGhjix`jLOP¯¢1KMLŒRrwnGzG|

Ÿ?zprlzpdŒ~QixdO©iwdOix`jilzprwi-HJz•`jiwnvdª¾7iwdOi¶` 1¾ ~nGdŒ^il^`b^iwd‹GR`j`jiwdO^a`+z•`biw~(iwd_›ÁnvhbP¥z•`jiwnvdª¾´|_RcvhbRQRMnp›5dORQiwvLDŸ5nvh+^Qš

{5n•«(RQhenp›ƒdORcixGLDŸ?nGhb^<zvdŒ|`jLOR

α ij

~nGP‹{Œf_`jRJ|¾µ›ÁhbnvP¤`bLORdORcixGLDŸ?nGhb^M`bn¬iwdOi¶`biwzvrxiIHQR`jLOR{?zph+zpPSR`bRQh+^

nv›X`bLOR zprwvnGhjix`jLOP¯¢ KMLŒiw^¥iwdOix`jilzprwi-HJz•`bixnGd ~QnvhbhjRJ^{5nvdŒ|Œ^`bn1[DRc~`jiwnvd 8 ¢‡D¢ ˜d3`bLOR†rlz•`j`jRQh¬¾`jLOR

~QnvPS{Of_`+z•`bixnGd°^`jRc{¡¾<ix›`bLOR¬^`jRQ{#il^©rxn:zv|¡ŸŒzprlzpdŒ~QixdŒŒš£`bLOR¬zprwvnGhjix`jLOP^`bzvh`+^X`jn†^jRQdŒ|i¶`+^k:fŒzpd:`bi¶`a]

nv›rwnGzG|¯zpdŒ|¯hbRc~QRQiw¦vRu`jLORdORQiwvLDŸ5nvh+^ekGf?zpd:`jix`a]nv›rwnGzG|«ei¶`bL ֍vRQ`P#o p¢(TVnp`jR©`bLŒz•`Xixd vR`P#o u«R

Ž& ¼ “ î’

KMLORc^jRªzvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP¥^V|_RJ^j~QhjiwŸ5R}`jLORS~rlzv^b^jiw~czpr ^`jhbfŒ~Ö`bfOhbRnp› {ŒhjnGŒ¢<«eix`jLi¶`bRQh+z•`jiw¦vR

zvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP <Ánvd `jLOR°rwR›t`M>zvdŒ|`jLŒR¡›ÁfOd?~Ö`jiwnvd `jLŒzp`¯|OR`jRchjPSiwdOR`jLOR

α

{Œzph+zpPSR`bRQh+^¬«eix`jL z1rwn_~Qzpr

­DdOn•«erwRc|OvRufŒ^RJ|iwd²^a`bRQ{¯iwdOi¶` G<Ánvd`jLŒR}hjiwvL:`M>¢

~QrwzG^j^jil~Qzpr^`jhbfŒ~Ö`bfOhjR©nv›{Ohbnv?¢

«eix`jLix`jRQh+z•`bix¦GR žzvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP

iwdOi¶`+q<{O{

iwdOi¶` XR`jRJ~ nGd:¦

iwdOi¶`

»

$&¸¥qV{O{²~nvd?|_i¶`bixnGd ½ ¼

©il^ e[:`bRQ{ ’ ¸

GR`P#o

~QnvPS{Of_`bR7io

^jRQdŒ|ŒyeRc~Q¦ nGzG|

XR`bRc~ nvdD¦

¸ ½

q<{Œ{ GnvŸ

¸ ´½ » &¸

|Oiw^`jhbixŸŒf_`jRJ|~QnvPS{Of_`+z•`jiwnvdnp›

α

B¼ “

i = 0

^`bn

myDegree

^{½ ¼}

^RcdŒ|Pª]rwnGzG|¥`jn¥dŒRQiwvLDŸ?nGh@

i

^E

¸ ´½ B¼ “

B¼ “

i = 0

^`bn

myDegree

^{½ ¼}

hjRJ~RQiw¦vRurwnGzv|›ÁhbnvP¤dORcixGLDŸ?nGh@

i

^E

¸ ´½ B¼ “

~nGPS{Of_`jR

M r ij M r ji

B¼ “

i = 0

^`bn

myDegree

^{½ ¼}

^RcdŒ|

M r ij

`jn¥dŒRQiwvLDŸ?nGh@

i

^E

¸ ´½ B¼ “

B¼ “

i = 0

^`bn

myDegree

^{½ ¼}

hjRJ~RQiw¦vR

RM r ji

›ÁhbnvP dORQiwvLDŸ5nvh)@

i

^E

¸ ´½ B¼ “

RM r ji < M r ji

’ ¸

M r ij = RM r ji ∗ M r ij /M r ji

M r ji = RM r ji

¸ ´½

oaf?^a`VRQ±O~+LŒzpdOGR}zSd:fŒPŸ5RQhe`bLŒz•`X|ORc^b~hbixŸ5Rc^M`bLORk:fŒzvdG`bi¶`a]np›rxn:zv|¯zpd?|dŒnp`Xz hjRJzpr<rwnGzG|£¢TVR±D`cš5i¶`

~QnvPS{Of_`bRc^<`jLORªrxn:zv|`jLŒzp`Xix`VPf?^a`©^RcdŒ|`jn¬RJzv~+L²dORcixGLDŸ?nGhVzv~c~nvh+|_iwdOS`jn¬`jLOR~QnvdŒ|Oi¶`bixnGdŒ^<Gix¦GRQd²iwd

[_Rc~Ö`bixnGdŒ^ 8 ¢-BXzpdŒ| 8 ¢‡D¢ ˜ ›7ix`(zv{O{?RJzph+^ƒ`bLŒz•``a«ndŒRQiwvLDŸ?nGhb^µzphbR<dOnp`ŸŒzprlzpdŒ~QRc|¥zvdŒ|¥|_ndŒnp`µRQ±_~+L?zpdOGR

rwnGzG|£šO`bLORS^LŒzv­vRchV^]_^`jRcP~czpd²›ÁnGhb~QRzpd²RQ±_~+L?zpdOGR}np› rwnGzv|7¢VKMLOil^V^`jRQ{¡iw^u|_nvdŒRiwd ~QnvPS{Of_`bR7io •¢

P™LŒRQd†`bLOR‹rxn:zv|¯`bLŒz•`}Pf?^a`uŸ?RSR±O~+LŒzvdOvRJ|¯iw^©~QnvPS{Of_`bRc|£š£RJzv~+L†dOn_|_RS^jRQdŒ|O^uzpd?| ÌnGhVhbRc~Rcix¦GRc^V`jLOR

RQ±O~+LŒzpdOGRc^uiwd ^jRQdŒ|Oy<Rc~¦ nGzv|•¢¬³ixd?zprwrx]Gš `bLOR~nGdD¦vRQhbvRcdŒ~RS|_RQ`jRc~`jiwnvd®zprwvnGhjix`jLŒPZ~+LORc~+­_^}ix›M`jLOR

rwnGzG|²ŸŒzvrwzvdŒ~iwdOzvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOPLŒzv^u~nGd:¦GRQhbvRJ|`jn^`jnG{¡ix`c¢ixdOix`bqV{O{pš Qq<{O{°~nGdŒ|_ix`jiwnvdzpdŒ| q<{Œ{

GnvŸV~QnvhbhjRJ^{5nvdŒ|¬`jnS`bLOR}zp{O{Orwil~Qz•`bixnGd`bLŒz•`<PªfŒ^`<Ÿ?R}ŸŒzvrwzvdŒ~RJ|£¢

% "# %#

KMLŒR›ÁnGrxrwn•«eixdŒ^jixPªfOrwzp`jiwnvdŒ^‹zphbRhbRczvrxiIHQRJ|®«eix`jL™[DixP¬suhbiw|7¢1[DixP¬suhbiw|3il^‹z†`jnDnvrw­Di¶`‹`jL?z•`S{Ohjn•¦Dil|_Rc^

~QnvhbR(›ÁfOdŒ~Ö`bixnGdŒzprwix`a]›ÁnGhƒ`jLORX^iwPfOrlz•`bixnGdSnp›£|_iw^`jhbiwŸOf_`jRJ|¥zp{O{Œrxil~Qzp`jiwnvdŒ^ƒiwd¥LORQ`jRQhbnvGRQdORcnvfŒ^ƒ|Oiw^`jhbixŸŒf_`jRJ|

RcdD¦:iwhbnvdOPSRQd:`+^ @чpˆ EB¢KMLORSzp{O{Œrxil~Qzp`jiwnvd²`bLŒz•`©iw^uŸŒzvrwzvdŒ~RJ|²il^XhbRQ{ŒhjRJ^RcdG`bRc|²ŸD]²zpdixd:`bRQvRchV`bLŒz•`}~nGh¾

hbRc^j{5nvdŒ|O^`jn²`bLORrwnGzG|#np›e`bLORzv{O{Orwiw~cz•`jiwnvd ¢ 7R`‹fŒ^ªhjRJ~Qzprwr `bLŒz•``jLORrxn:zv|#il^^`bzp`jil~¥¾V`bLORGrxnGŸŒzpr

rwnGzG|¯np›ƒ`bLORª^j]_^a`bRQPiw^V`jLOR‹^jzvPSRª|_fOhbiwdO¥`jLŒRª~nGPS{Of_`bzp`jiwnvd

P

i w ⁽⁰⁾ _i = P

i w ^(t) _i

›ÁnGhXzvrxr

t

^¾(LORcdŒ~R

dŒn‹rwnGzG|~czpd¯Ÿ5Rzv|O|_RJ|nvhehbR`jhbiwRQ¦vRJ|¬iwd¯`jLOR^j]_^a`bRQP¯¢ q ^`bzp`jil~XrwnGzG|il^oafŒ^`VfŒ^jRc|`jn¥iwrwrxfŒ^`jh+z•`bR©`jLOR

~QnvdD¦vRchjGRQdŒ~QRXnv›´`bLORzprwvnGhjix`jLŒPšŒŸOf_`<`bLOR zprwvnvhbix`jLOP ~czpd²|_RJzpr7«eix`jL†|_]DdŒzvPSiw~©rwnGzG|£¢µKMLORrwnGzG|

il^<zvrw^jn¥~nvd?^il|_RQhbRc|LOnGP‹nGvRcdORQnGfŒ^QšD`bLOR}`bixPSR}`bn¬~nvPS{OfO`jRzSviw¦vRcd¯rxn:zv||_nDRc^edOnv`X|_Rc{?RcdŒ|¯nvd`jLŒiw^

rwnGzG|£šOix`<nvdOrw]|ORQ{5RQdŒ|O^Vnvd`jLŒRk:fŒzpd:`jix`a]nv›rwnGzG|¯zpdŒ|nvd`bLOR^j{?RcRc|np›`jLŒR}{Ohjn_~QRc^b^nGheixd¯«eLOil~+L²i¶`

il^e~nGPS{Of_`jRJ|£¢

˜ d#z¨Œhb^`©{Œzphj`cš£`bLORSŸ?RcLŒz̦DixnGh©np›µ`bLOR¥³

;

[¡zprwvnvhbix`jLOP il^}^a`bfŒ|_iwRc|nvd`jLORS«(nvh+^R‹~QzG^RS~nGd_¨Œp¾

fŒhbzp`jiwnvd }zrxiwdORS`bnv{5nvrwnvv]²«eix`jL®‰CLŒnvPSnvGRQdORcnvfŒ^udOn_|_RJ^}^fŒ~+L`jL?z•`zprwrƒ`bLOR¥rxn:zv|¡iw^}nGd¡`bLORS¨Œh+^a`

dŒnD|ORv¢¡KMLOR{Ohbnvvh+zpPZ`jLŒzp`ªil^Ÿ?zprlzpdŒ~QRc|®~Qzvd®Ÿ?R¦DixRc«RJ|®zv^ªz†{ŒzvhbzvrxrwRQrµzvdŒ|®ix`jRchbzp`jiw¦vR¬dDfOPSRQhbil~Qzpr

^jnvrw¦vRch `bLŒz•`e~nGP‹{Œf_`jRJ^2BJˆvˆGˆix`jRQh+z•`bixnGdŒ^«eLORQhbR<`bLORu`jnv{5nvrwnvG]ªil^(¦Dixhj`jfŒzvr£zpdŒ||_RQ{5RQdŒ|Œ^nGd¬`bLORu|Œz•`bz

|ORQ{5RQdŒ|_RcdŒ~]G¢XKMLOil^u^a`bfŒ|_]¯iw^XhbRczprwiIHQRc|›ÁnGh<`a«(n~QzG^RJ^Qš?¨Œh+^a`uz qXT dORQ`a«nGhj­¯zpd?|£š5^jRc~QnvdŒ|7š5z ©[

dŒR`a«(nvhb­5¢

”O‘c’ ¸ ’ »¼ “

˜d†`jLORª›ÁnvhbPSRQhJšzŸŒzpd?|_«eiw|_`jL†nv›BcˆGˆvW²Ÿ p^eil^Xf?^RJ|²«ei¶`bLˆŒ¢-B̂•P¥^<nv›µrwzp`jRcdŒ~]¯nvd¡Rczv~+L²RJ|_vRG¢u³iwp¾

fŒhjR‡†^LOn•«<^}`jLOR¬:zpiwd®viw¦vRcd°ŸD]`jLOR³

;

[#zvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOPZ«eix`jL®`bLOR~QnG^`̟5RQdŒR¨O`ª^j]_^a`bRQP zpdŒ|#«eix`jL

~QnvdD¦vRchjGRQdŒ~QRe|_R`bRc~Ö`bixnGd<

Algo2

> ~QnvPS{ŒzvhjRJ|`bn`bLORX³

;

[¥zprwvnGhjix`jLŒP'«eix`jLOnGf_`(~QnG^`•Ÿ?RcdOR¨O`M^]_^`jRcP

zvdŒ|«ei¶`bLOnvfO`V~nvdD¦GRQhbvRQd?~RX|OR`jRJ~Ö`bixnGd=<

Algo1

^>¢ 7RQ`<fŒ^edOnv`jR©`jL?z•`<iwd

Algo2

`jLOR~QnG^`̟5RQdŒR¨O`<{Œzp¾ h+zpPSRQ`jRQh

k

il^µGix¦GRQd¬ŸD]

k ^(t+1) = k ^(t) − 1

^«ei¶`bL

k ⁽⁰⁾ = 1000

¢´KMLORuGzvixd¬il^viw¦vRQdŸ:]

T1−T2 T1

š_«eLŒRQhbR

T 1

^zpdŒ|

T 2

zphbRe`bLORu~QnvPS{Of_`+z•`bixnGd¥`jiwPSRXnv›

Algo1

^zpd?|

Algo2

š:hbRc^j{?RJ~Ö`jiw¦vRcrx]G¢JFVRQdŒ~QRvšDix›7`jLORuGzvixdiw^

dŒRQGzp`jiw¦vRGšD`jLOR

Algo2

^jrxn•«<^e|On•«ed`bLORR±_RJ~f_`bixnGdnv›´`bLOR}{OhbnvGhbzvP¤zpdŒ|¯zSGzvixd¯nv›ˆŒ¢‚ªPSRczvdŒ^M`jL?z•`

`bLOR~QnvPS{Of_`+z•`jiwnvd°`bixPSR¬nv›(`bLOR¬{OhbnvGhbzvP iw^ª|_iw¦:il|_RJ|#Ÿ:]¡`a«n?¢ ˜ d#`bLOiw^¨ŒvfŒhjRGš `bLOR¬Gzvixd®|_Rc{?RcdŒ|O^

nGd²`jLŒR‹rwnGzG|†z̦vRchbzvvR

w ^∗

¾M`bLORªGrxnGŸŒzprrwnGzv|†iw^uviw¦vRcd¡ŸD]

64 × w ^∗

¾<zpdŒ|¡nvd†`bLOR‹d:fŒPŸ5RQh©np›µrwnGzG|

Ÿ?zprlzpdŒ~QixdO^`jRc{Œ^c¢ ˜›£`bLORVrwnGzG|SŸŒzprlzpd?~iwdO^`jRQ{iw^BvšG`jLORXrxn:zv|SŸŒzvrwzvdŒ~iwdOzvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP il^zv{O{OrwixRJ|SnvdOrw]

nGdOR<`bixPSR©z•`(`jLORX¨Œh+^a`(i¶`bRQh+z•`bixnGd¬np›£`bLORX{ŒhjnGvh+zpP¯¢´KMLORuhbRc^jfOr¶`+^µnGd³ixGfOhbRu‡ª^LOn•« `bLŒz•`(`jLORuGzvixdiw^

^jiwvdOix¨?~Qzvd:`M«eLŒRQd

w ^∗

il^erwn•« zpd?|zvrw^jn¥^LŒn•«™`jLŒzp`<`jLŒR}Gzpiwdiw^edDfOrwr£«eLORcd

w ^∗

il^eLOiwvL7¢ KMLOil^eil^<|_fOR

`bn}`jLŒRX~n:^a`(np›`jLŒRVrwnGzv|SŸ?zprlzpdŒ~QixdOªzprwvnvhbix`jLOP'i¶`+^Rcr¶›«eLORcd¬i¶`(LŒzv^~nGd:¦GRQhbvRJ|£špix`b^(~nG^`µil^~QnvdŒ^`bzvd:`

1

10

100

1000 0 200

400 600

800 1000 0

0.5 1

Gain

w*

Lb Ite Gain

³iwvfOhbR‡ ®s©zvixd viw¦vRQd™«eix`jLž`jLOR#~n:^a`̟5RQdORQ¨O`{ŒzvhbzvP‹RQ`jRch

k ^(t+1) = k ^(t) − 1

zvdŒ|™«eix`jL `jLOR

~QnvdD¦vRchjGRQdŒ~QRX|_RQ`jRJ~Ö`jiwnvd¯zprwvnGhjix`jLŒP¤nvd¯z qVTdŒR`a«(nvhb­5¢

zvdŒ|¬ix`envdOrw]¬|_Rc{?RcdŒ|O^Mnp› `jLOR©dORQ`a«nGhj­¢ F<RQd?~Rvš_«eLŒRQd`jLOR}~nGPS{Of_`bzp`jiwnvd`jiwP‹R©il^(rxn•«™¾ƒ«eLORcd

w ^∗

^{iw^}

rwn•« ¾ `jLORª~nG^`Vnv›rwnGzG|Ÿ?zprlzpdŒ~QixdO¥il^<hbRQrlz•`bix¦GRQrw]¬LOiwvL†zvdŒ|«eLORQd¯`bLOR~nGPS{Of_`bzp`jiwnvd¯`bixPSRil^<LOiwvL¾

«eLŒRQd

w ^∗

iw^(LOiwvL¾ix`eiw^(dORcvrwixGixŸŒrxRG¢ ˜ ›´`jLOR}~n:^a`(np› rwnGzG|¬ŸŒzvrwzvdŒ~iwdOªiw^(dORcvrwixGixŸOrwRvš:`bLORu~QnG^`•Ÿ?RcdOR¨O`

^j]_^a`bRQP*zpdŒ|`bLORª~QnvdD¦vRchjGRQdŒ~QR}|_R`bRc~Ö`bixnGd†zphbR}dOnp`ufŒ^jR›ÁfOrŸOf_`ui¶`X~czpd²Ÿ5RdOnv`jRJ|`jLŒzp`V`jLŒRQ]²zphbR}dOnp`

RQ±_{?RcdŒ^iw¦vR©«eix`jL²z qXTdOR`a«(nvhb­ `bLOR}Gzvixdnvd¯³ixGfOhjR‡‹il^MdORQ¦GRQhedORcGzp`jiw¦vRu«eLORQd

w ^∗

il^eLOiwvL ¢

&¼D» ¸ ’ »¼ “

˜ d `bLOR†rlz•``bRQhJš(`jLOR¡^bzpPSR²{OhbnvŸŒrxRcP il^¬|_RQ{Œrxn•]GRc| nvd™z ©[ dORQ`a«nGhj­«eLŒRQhbR¯`jLOR†Ÿ?zpdŒ|_«eil|D`bL™iw^

BJW²Ÿ p^uzvdŒ|¡`jLORSrlz•`jRcdŒ~]²il^ CGˆvP¥^Q¢‹³´iwvfŒhjRJ^

8 š C²zpdŒ|°‚^jLOn•«`bLORS{Ohbnvvh+zpP ~QnvPS{Of_`+z•`jiwnvd`jiwPSRc^

|ORQ{5RQdŒ|_iwdO¯nvd`jLŒR¥rxn:zv|°z̦vRQh+zpGR

w ^∗

zvdŒ|nvd`jLOR¥dDfOPªŸ?Rch}np›rwnGzG|¡Ÿ?zprlzpdŒ~QixdO¯^`jRQ{?^Q¢ ³iwvfOhbR

8

~QnvhbhjRJ^{5nvd?|O^´`jn}`bLOR<{OhbnvGhbzvP«ei¶`bL¬z}~rlzv^b^il~QzvrO³

;

[‹zprwvnGhjix`jLOP'«ei¶`bLOnvfO`~n:^a`̟5RQdORQ¨O`µ^]_^`jRcP'zpd?|

«eix`jLŒnvf_`~nGdD¦vRQhbvRcdŒ~R‹|_R`bRc~`jiwnvd#zprwvnvhbix`jLOP¯¢6FVRQhbRvš£«(R¥~Qzpd#^jRQRª`jLŒzp`}`jLOR‹¨Œh+^a`}ix`jRchbzp`jiwnvdŒ^unp›`jLOR

rwnGzG|²ŸŒzvrwzvdŒ~iwdO¯zprwvnvhbix`jLOP*viw¦vR‹z:zpiwdzvdŒ|²`bLŒz•`z•›t`bRQh}^jnvPSRªix`jRchbzp`jiwnvdŒ^Xnp›(rxn:zv|²Ÿ?zprlzpdŒ~QixdO?š`jLOR

~QnvPS{Of_`+z•`bixnGd`bixPSR¬iwdŒ~QhjRJzv^jRc^zvdŒ|`jLOR¥`bixPSR`jn†~nGPS{Of_`jR¬`jLOR¬{ŒhjnGvh+zpPŸ5Rc~QnvPSRc^}PªfŒ~+L®vhbRczp`jRch

`bLŒzpdz¡^RJkGfŒRQd:`jilzpr(~nvPS{OfO`bz•`bixnGd7¢†KMLOil^{ŒhjnGŸOrxRcPZLŒzG^}`a«(n¡~nGPS{OrxRcPSRQd:`bzvhj]hjRJzv^jnvdŒ^c¢²KMLOR¥¨Œh+^a`

il^u`jL?z•`©`jLOR¬~QrwzG^j^jil~Qzpr³ ; [zprwvnGhjix`jLŒP|_nDRc^©dOnv`©¦GRQhbi¶›Á]²ix›ezrwnGzG|¡RQ±_~+L?zpdOGRil^©P‹nGhjRS~n:^a`brx]†`jLŒzvd

Ÿ5RQdŒR¨?~Qiwzvr΢™KMLOR†^jRc~QnvdŒ|1iw^S`bLŒz•`¥iwd `jLOil^¥iwP‹{ŒrxRcP‹Rcd:`bz•`bixnGd1`bLOR†³ ; [3zprwvnGhjix`jLŒP hjfOd?^SfOd:`jiwre`jLOR

RcdŒ| np›u`jLOR¡{OhjnGvh+zpP¯šzvdŒ| i¶›u`jLŒR†rxn:zv| hbRQ{Œzvh`bi¶`bixnGd3LŒzG^¥~nGd:¦GRQhbvRJ|£š `bLOR†³ ; [ zprwvnGhjix`jLŒP |_nDRc^

dŒnp`VRQ±_~+L?zpdOGRurwnGzG|¯ŸOf_`Vix`XRQ±O~+LŒzpdOGRc^e^jnvPSR}iwd_›ÁnvhbP¥z•`jiwnvd ¢ ˜d†z qVT dOR`a«(nvhb­¬`bLOR~n:^a`Xnp›`jLORJ^R

200 0 600 1000

200 0 600 400

1000 800 0

500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000

Time

w*

Lb Ite Time

³´iwvfŒhjR 8 rlzv^b^jiw~czprrxn:zv|ŸŒzprlzpd?~iwdOŒ¢

RQ±O~+LŒzpdOGRc^zphbRMdORQGrxiwviwŸOrwR(ŸŒf_``jLORc]Ÿ5Rc~nGPSR(¦GRQhb]iwP‹{5nvhj`bzvd:`ix›Œ`bLORedORQ`a«nGhj­}il^ƒ^rwn•«3zG^›Ánvhƒzu[ ¢

FVRQdŒ~QRvšŒ`jLOR~QnG^`•Ÿ?RcdOR¨O`V^j]_^a`bRQP*zpdŒ|`bLOR~nGdD¦vRQhbvRcdŒ~R©|_RQ`jRc~`jiwnvd†zvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP ~Qzvd²Ÿ?Rixd:`jRchjRJ^a`bixdŒ

›ÁnGhezpdD]¬^iIHQRunp›

w ^∗

^{¢ ˜}d³iwvfOhbRC‹`jLŒR©~QnvdD¦vRchjGRQdŒ~QRV|_RQ`jRc~`jiwnvdzprwvnvhbix`jLOPÚil^(ixPS{OrwRQPSRQd:`bRc|zpdŒ|`jLOR

^bzpPSR‹~nG^`•Ÿ?RcdOR¨Œ`©^j]_^a`bRQPzv^uiwd¡`bLOR qVT§~Qnvd_¨ŒGfOh+z•`jiwnvd¡iw^ufŒ^jRc| V`jLORS{ŒzvhbzvPSR`jRch

k

il^}|_RQ¨ŒdORc|

ŸD]

k ^(t+1) = k ^(t) − 1

^¢ P°RX~czpd¬^jRQRe`bLŒz•``jLORXhjRJ^fOrx`µil^ Ÿ5R`j`jRQh`jL?zpd¬iwd³ixGfOhbR 8 ¢ƒKMLORV~QnvPS{Of_`+z•`bixnGd

`bixPSRenv›?`bLORe{OhbnvŸOrwRQP |_nDRc^dOnv` ixdŒ~QhjRJzv^jRMixd_¨?dOi¶`bRQrw]všv`jLOR<~QnG^`̟5RQdŒR¨O`µ^j]_^a`bRQP'|On:RJ^dOnp` RQ±O~+LŒzpdOGR(z

rwnGzG|¬ix›´ix`eRc^`jiwPSzp`jRJ^µ`bLŒz•`M`bLOR}~nG^`Miw^(`bn:n‹ŸOiw¥zpdŒ|¬`jLOR}~nGdD¦vRQhbvRcdŒ~Ru|_R`bRc~`jiwnvdzvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP¤|_RQ`jRc~`b^

`bLŒz•`}`bLORQhbRSiw^dOn¯P‹nGhjRSRQ±_~+L?zpdOGR‹zvdŒ|#^a`bnv{Œ^u`bLOR¬³ ; [zprwvnGhjix`jLOP¯¢ (f_`}`jLŒR¬~nvPS{OfO`bz•`bixnGd¡`bixPSR

zvrx«MzÌ]_^7iwdŒ~hbRczG^RJ^ PªfŒ~+LPSnGhjR`jLŒzvd›ÁnGhz©^jRck:fORcdG`biwzvr:~QnvPS{Of_`+z•`bixnGd7¢KMLŒiw^il^|OfOR(`jnX`jLORMRc^`jiwP¥z•`bixnGd

|OnvdOR©ŸD]¬`bLOR~n:^a`̟5RQdORQ¨O`<^]_^`jRQP `bLOR~n:^a`VzvdŒ|¬`bLOR}Gzvixdnp›ƒzpd¯RQ±_~+L?zpdOGRXil^<~nGPS{Of_`jRJ|rxn_~Qzvrxrw]v¢

˜ dz²|Oiw^`jhbixŸŒf_`jRJ|^]_^`jRcP`jLŒRGzvixd#nv›ezvd#R±O~+LŒzpdŒvR¥il^^jixGdOi¶¨5~Qzpd:`nGdOrx]i¶›<ix`il^hbRczvrxiIHQRJ|ŸD]`jLOR

^jrwn•«RJ^a`({Ohjn_~QRc^b^nGhcš:i¶`<il^(`jLŒiw^M{Ohbn_~RJ^j^jnvh`jLŒzp`<|_nvPSiwdŒz•`bRc^(`jLŒR©~QnvPS{Of_`+z•`bixnGd`bixPSRv¢ FVRQdŒ~QRvšOz‹viw¦vRcd

{Œhjn_~RJ^j^jnvh~QzpdŒdOnp`M~nvPS{OfO`jRXzvd¬R±OzG~Ö`µ:zpiwd¬np› zvd¬R±O~+LŒzvdOvR<«eix`jLŒnvf_`(LŒz̦DixdOªzvrwnvŸ?zprŒ­DdOn•«erwRc|OvRvš

ŸŒf_`ix`M~czpd¬RJ^a`bixP¥zp`jR<`bLORVGrxnGŸŒzpr?ixPS{ŒzG~Ö`(np›£`jLŒRXrwnGzG|SŸŒzprlzpdŒ~QixdŒzprwvnGhjix`jLOP «eix`jL¬`bLORX~QnvPS{Of_`+z•`bixnGd

`bixPSR¯np›uzpd i¶`bRQh+z•`jiwnvd ¢ ˜ d3³iwvfOhbR¯‚†`jLŒR¯^bzpPSR¯^]_^`jRcPS^SzG^ªiwd³´iwvfŒhjR C°zvhjRixPS{OrwRQPSRcdG`bRc|3ŸOf_`

iwd°`jLOil^~czv^jR

k

zvrw^jn²|_RQ{5RQdŒ|Œ^}nvd°`jLŒR¬~nvPS{OfO`bz•`bixnGd°`jiwP‹R¥nv›Mzvdix`jRchbzp`jiwnvd7¢KMLŒR¬~nvPS{OfO`bz•`bixnGdil^

^j]DdŒ~+LOhbnvdOnGfŒ^cšQLORcdŒ~R ix›_`jLŒR~nGPS{Of_`bzp`jiwnvd©`bixPSRµnv›Œzpd}ix`jRchbzp`jiwnvd}nvd©`bLOR^jrwn•«RJ^a`7{Ohbn_~RJ^j^jnvh£iwdŒ~hbRczG^RJ^Qš

`bLOR~nGPS{Of_`bzp`jiwnvd`jiwPSR}np›zvd¯i¶`bRQh+z•`jiwnvdnvd²zpdD]¥nv`jLORche{Ohjn_~QRc^b^nGh(iwdŒ~QhjRJzv^jRc^`jnDnŒ¢ƒKMLORchjRQ›ÁnvhbRvš:›Ánvh<z

Gix¦GRQd‹dOn_|_RvšG«eLORQdS`bLOR<~nGPS{Of_`bzp`jiwnvd‹`jiwPSR<np›ix`b^ƒix`jRchbzp`jiwnvd‹iw^µvhbRcz•`bRQh`jL?zpd‹`jLORX~nvPS{OfO`bz•`bixnGd`bixPSR

nv›7i¶`+^µ{ŒhjRc¦:iwnvf?^ ix`jRQh+z•`bixnGd7š:i¶`e|_iw¦:il|_RJ^µix`b^¦•zprwfORVnv›

k

Ÿ:]¬‡O¢³iwvfOhbRX‚^LŒn•«<^ƒ`jL?z•`«eix`jL`jLOil^(^]_^`jRQP¯š

`bLOR¯rxn:zv|1ŸŒzprlzpdŒ~QixdŒzprwvnGhjix`jLŒP iw^¥^`jnG{O{?RJ|1zp›t`jRQh¬z¡›ÁRQ« i¶`bRQh+z•`bixnGdŒ^‹ixd «eLOil~+L`jLŒR¯~QnvPS{Of_`+z•`bixnGd

200 0 600 1000

200 0 600 400

1000 800 0

500 1000 1500 2000 2500

Time

w*

Lb Ite Time

³iwvfOhbR C nGzv|SŸ?zprlzpdŒ~QixdO}«eix`jL~nGd:¦GRQhbvRcdŒ~Re|_RQ`jRc~`jiwnvdzvdŒ|¥~n:^a`̟5RQdORQ¨O`(^j]_^a`bRQP «ei¶`bL

k ^(t+1) = k ^(t) − 1

^¢

`bixPSR°LŒzv^iwdŒ~hbRczG^RJ|£¢ KMLDfŒ^`jLŒRrwnGzG|™ŸŒzprlzpd?~iwdO3zvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP il^Ÿ?RcdOR¨5~ilzpru`jn1`jLOR°{Ohbnvvh+zpP iwd

zvrxPSn:^a`}zprwr ~nGd_¨ŒvfŒhbzp`jiwnvdŒ^c¢ P™LORcd¡`bLORSvrwnvŸŒzvrrwnGzG|†il^}^P¥zvrxr¾e«eLORcd°z{ŒzvhbzvrxrwRQrƒ~nGPS{Of_`bzp`jiwnvdiw^

PSnGhjRSR±_{5RQdŒ^jiw¦vR‹`jLŒzvd°z¯^jRck:fORcdG`biwzvrƒnvdOR‹¾<`bLOR¥rwnGzv|ŸŒzvrwzvdŒ~iwdO¯zprwvnvhbix`jLOPil^©dOnv`Ÿ?RcdOR¨?~QiwzvrƒŸOf_`

ix`Xil^u^a`bnv{O{5Rc|¯›îzG^a`uRQdOnGfOvL¯›ÁnGhXix`b^u~n:^a`V`jnŸ5R‹dORQGrxiwviwŸOrwRv¢VW²nGhjRcn•¦vRchcšOix`u~czpd†Ÿ5RdŒnp`jRJ|¯`jL?z•`X«eix`jL

`bLOil^eR±D`jhbRQPSR~Qnvd_¨ŒGfOh+z•`jiwnvd`jLORrxn:zv|ŸŒzprlzpdŒ~QixdŒSzvrxGnvhbi¶`bLOP¤«eix`jL¯`bLOiw^X~n:^a`̟5RQdORQ¨O`<^]_^`jRQP|_nDRc^

dŒnp`}fŒ^jR¬zprwr`jLOR¬{Œhjn_~RJ^j^jnvh+^c¢ªKzpŸOrwR'B¥^LOn•«<^u`bLOR¥dDfOPŸ5RQh}nv›({Œhjn_~RJ^j^jnvh+^XfŒ^RJ|#zpdŒ|¡`jLOR¥nG{_`jiwP¥zpr

dDfOPªŸ?RchVnv› {Ohjn_~QRc^b^nGhb^c¢(KMLŒRnv{O`jiwPSzvr ¦•zprwfOR¾nv{O`B¾(iw^V`jLŒRdDfOPŸ5RQhXnp› {Ohbn_~RJ^j^jnvh+^(`jn¬hbRczG~+L¯`jLOR

n w ^∗

! " #

$

% &'(

$

KzpŸŒrxRB KMLŒiw^ª`bzvŸOrwR^jLOn•«<^›ÁnGh¥z†viw¦vRcdrwnGzv|1ixd3rxiwdOR²‡²`bLORd:fŒPŸ5RQhSnp›<dOn_|_RJ^‹fŒ^RJ|«eix`jL3`jLOR

~QnG^`•Ÿ?RcdOR¨O`µ^j]_^a`bRQP¯šviwdSrxiwdORenG{_`c¢IBM`jLORVnv{_`bixP¥zprŒd:fŒPŸ5RQh nv›5dOn_|_RJ^ƒ«eix`jLS`jLŒR<~nG^`•Ÿ?RcdOR¨Œ`µ^]_^`jRQP¯¢

PSiwdOiwPfOP*~nGP‹{Œf_`bzp`jiwnvd¯`jiwPSR«eix`jL¯`jLŒRª~n:^a`̟5RQdORQ¨O`V^j]D^`jRcP¯¢MKMLŒiw^Vnv{_`bixP¥zpr ¦ÌzvrxfŒRiw^X~nGP‹{Œf_`jRJ|

f?^iwdOªzvrwnvŸŒzvrŒ­DdOn•«erwRc|_GRv¢JPR©^RcRe`jL?z•`M«ei¶`bLOnvf_`(vrwnvŸŒzvrŒ­DdOn•«erwRc|_GRvš:«RV¨ŒdŒ|¬zhjRJ^fŒr¶`(¦vRQhb]S~rwnG^jR

`bn‹`jLOR}nG{_`jiwP¥zprF¢