Which predictor is the best to predict inflation in Europe: the real money-gap or a nominal money based indicator?

(1)

HAL Id: hal-00207497

https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00207497

Preprint submitted on 17 Jan 2008

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Which predictor is the best to predict inflation in Europe: the real money-gap or a nominal money based

indicator?

Gilles Dufrénot, Roseline Joyeux, Anne Peguin-Feissolle

To cite this version:

Gilles Dufrénot, Roseline Joyeux, Anne Peguin-Feissolle. Which predictor is the best to predict inflation in Europe: the real money-gap or a nominal money based indicator?. 2008. �hal-00207497�

(2)

2()&435/$7698:;( <=(>$?3@$4(&3A)$4!6(;BC$D(/EFG

HJILKMKONQPRTSDUWVYX[Z!\!]_^_`Qab\DP+NcKed!ZNf\"d!NgShi*jW`kTZZNlEXcm7SILZnpo;NIWP'P+\KqKONr

^Ms9autJRwv+xs4`!twZIeyNcV*P+Iz]XlE{cV+IMP | {cZ}~HausuJk,`7o/V+{ZBN

i{QS{cV+ILNctZIeyNcVP+Iz]_d!`!RNc{cV_]_NZB];\"UDs?\Z\IOQPY`)d!}"Z!Nd!`kS;P]_VY{cKLIM{

rHbaus?Jk,na`7,{cV*P+NILKMKON`7o/V+{ZN

)++c

vZ]_NKMIz]NcVY{g]WSV+N`]Ww\IL\V]{cZB]>yILN=P\"Z!NcV+ZILZm]_!N\Z}QSg]\"U~\ZNg]{cV_d\KLIO[d{cV+N

\ZP_]_VSN}DT ¡Z!NCyIMN IWP2]_{g]=]_!N@NcZB]_V+{K¢"{Z7£/P¤=~\ZNg]{cVdA\KLIOcdS;P]=¢"N@cV+N}"Ie¢KMN@IOU¥]_N

{gS]_!\"VI¦]_IMNBP{ZQ]T]_\<gSV¢ILZUKO{g]I§\"Zk¨P+NB\Z}yIONc©IOP]_!{g]ªNcZB]_V+{cK¢"{[Z«£)PP+N]J]_!N[I¬V=~\ZN]{cVd

\KqIOcd=¢d=S/P+ILZm2{KLKD]!NIqZU_\Vª{g]_I§\"Z=V+NKONcy{ZQ]4U_\VILZUKO{g]IL\Z={Z}=\7S]_7S7]9V\®+NBg]_IL\ZDPvZs9SV+\"N`){

\ZQ]_V\!y"NcV'Pd¯{7PuNªNcVmN}{c¢\7S]]_!NJV+\KLN\U9~\Z!Ng]{VYd¯{cmmVYNcm{g]NQP?{!P9S/P*NUMSDK;IqZ}IOB{g]_\V'Pu\U9UMS]WSV+N

ILZU_KO{g]IL\"Z{Z!}=\!S]_7S«]+ ¡Z¯\"Z!N{Z}`/NcyIO}N[Z!BNILZU{cy"\!SVu\U]_NS/P*N[UMSKLZN7P'Pu\U°±7²³L°´µ¶~\ZN]{cVd

{cmmV+Nm{g]NQP{QP¯m\\}@7VYN}7IOg]_\V'P=IWP=V+\7yIL}N}@¢d@]_NKqI¦]NcV+{g]WSV+N« Z]_!N\Q]_NcV=!{Z}`TN[wILV+IO{K

NgyIO}NZBN·ILZU{cy\7SV \U¹¸ºc´µ~\Z!NcdILZ}IM{g]\"V*P IpP»U_\!SZ!}Dx¶N@7SV\DP+N<\"U=]_IWP>{NcV>IWP2]\

\ZQ]_VIe¢«S]Nw]p\¥]_N~\Z7m\ILZ7m }Nc¢{]N\Z]_NVY\"KLNª\"Uu¯\"Z!Nd¼{mmV+Ncm{g]NQPbIqZ=]_N=P+Ng]W]_ILZ«m \"Uu~\ZN]{cVd

\KqIOcd½x!NQSN7P]IL\"Z,~N{cVYNILZQ]NV+NQP]N}·ILZ<IpPª~Ng]_!NcV]_N>VYN{K~\Z!Nd¾m{cA\"ZB]{IqZDP~\V+N

ILZU_\V+~{g]IL\Z>{c¢"\!S]bUMS]WSV+N¥ILZU_KO{g]I§\"Z¿IqZ sSVY\"N`]_{Z>{Z¿IqZ}IO{g]\V¢{QPYN}>\Z2]_N=mV+\7J]_ V+{']N=\"U

Z\ILZ{K¶~\ZNcdDÀ¾NJS/P*N~{{Z!N[K;}{g]{UWV+{ªNg~\V£ILZP]N{}¹\U¶]_NJS/PS{K)]ILªN¯PYNcV+IONQPªNg]_!\}P#\Z

{cmmV+Nm{g]N?s9SV\~}{g]{B

ÁÂgÃÄÅ cÆ/ÇD\"Z!Ng]{cVd\KLIO[d!`ILZUKO{g]IL\"Z!`"{ZNKD}{]{

ÈÉuÊ ËM'*ÌMÍÌO7+ÌÅÎ Çs4Ï | `Qs#Ð | `Qs#ÐÑB` |Ò `Ð Ò

ÓÔªÕ)Ö¬×Ø+ÙcÚ9Û~ÜeÝ×Ø'Õ+ÞÛ~ÝßÕ+ÙcÙØ+ÙàOáâÕ+ãcÝ+Õ+ÞeÞeÕ+ÙÖBâWÕ*äpÕ+Ø+âWÝ×ØåääWÜLäMÖeØ+ÙÖOäM×ÜzæçgæØ+âLÖLÝèÞeØ+âOÞêéàWáâ×Ü§ä"×ÕÞzæÜ¦ÙÜ¦ÙcæèÖeÖeÜ¦Ùë¶Öe×ÕìØÖ¬Øí

î7ï

áâOâWÕ'äMæáÙìcÜ¦Ùë¶Ø+ècÖ¬×á'âí+ð9ÕæØ+âMÖ¬ñuÕÙcÖBá'à«òDÝ+áÙáñuÜeÝ*ä_çgÛ~Ø'Ý+óèØ+âLÜeÕ/ô¶ÙÜêõÕ+â_äWÜzÖ¦éçQö*écìÙÕé÷uöÔùø!úYûücçýèBäqÖ¬âWØ+ÞeÜzØåçgþÕ+ÞMÿ

úDøuüû çBØ'ã«ÿ

úDøüû

çÕ+ñuØÜ¬ÞMÿâ_á*éÕYèãÕàäYíñuóQíÕ+ìgè«íØèBí

(3)

Î

+

Å

Æ)+Ì

ÅÎ

vZC]_!NKLIz]NV+{g]WSV+N`]Ww\<IL\V]{cZB]~yILNgªP\ZNcVZILZm¾]_!N\Z}QSg]ª\U\ZNg]{VYd\KqIOcd {cV+N

\ZP_]_VSN}D

ZN¹yIONg IWPJ]_!{g]]_!N2NcZB]_V+{K¢{Z7£/P¤#~\ZN]{cVd>\7KOIOd,TSP_]¢N2cVYN}"Ie¢KON2ILU¡]_!N2{gS]_\VIz]ILN7P

{cZQ]/]_\ªgSV¢~ILZUKO{g]IL\ZDBk@~IWP*}\{cVm7SªN[ZB];IpP;]_{g];V+N}I§¢IOKMIz]_d~IWP9m{IqZN}w]_«V+\7Sm~}"I¬V+Ng]EIqZU_KO{g]IL\Z

]{cVmN']_ILZ7m pRvYx«x¶IMP4{cV+\{cIWP4}NUNZ!}N}ILZ]_N\"V+N]_IL{K/{Z}ªN[~IeV+IOQ{K~\V£DPå;x¶NJ~\ZN]{cVd

{gS]_!\"VI¦]_IMNBP=P+Ng]]_!N ILZB]NcV+NQP_]TV+{å]NBPP+\ ]_!{g]TILZUKO{g]IL\"Z,{Z}\7S]_7S7]w}7\Z\Q]w}NyIL{g]N¥]\\JSUWV+\

]{cVmN']¶y{KzSN7På"v+KMIOIz]¶]p\]_IpP?{cV+\{c=IWP]_Nw{QPPS~7]IL\Z]_!{g]4~\"Z!Ng]{cVdª\KLIOd¥{ZZ\7]9V+NcKed\Z

ILZQ]NcV+ªN}IO{g]N~\"Z!Ng]{cVd¯{cmmV+Ncm{]NQP¢N{gSPYN~\ZNcd¼}N~{Z}=UWSDZ!g]I§\"ZP#{cV+NZ\Q]uP_]{g¢KLN77Rwv+xCIMP#{Z

{cV+\7VIM{]N U_\V+ \"U\ZNg]{VYd»\KLIOdNZ,}"IWP+ILZUKO{g]I§\"Z,IWP]_N2V+Iqª{cVd,m\{K\UP_]{g¢IMKOIpPY{g]IL\Z

\KqIOcd!`~IO=IWP]_N{!PYNIqZs9SV+\N7w\!Ngy"NcV+`/{UIL]9\URv+x,~\}NKWP¼U_\VILZDP_]{cZBN¡]_«V+\!Sm~]_N

]NQPW]_ILZ7m,\Ux9{cdKL\"VTVSKONQPwnJKON{cyN7Pw{[ZIL~\V]{cZQ]bNcVNcZQ]{mN¹\U]_N¥y"{cV+IO{[Z!N\U]_!N ILZB]NcV+NQP_]V+{g]N

c!{[Z«mDNBPSDZ!NchKM{ILZNB}Dx¶IWP¼\!SK§}5N{[Z,]_{g]`JILZ<V+{]_ILN`]_IWP\"7]_I§\"Z<IWPV+Ng]{ILZN}@¢dù{UNg

s9SV\N{cZ~NcZQ]_V+{K¢{Z7£DPå

kP+N\"Z!}¯yIONg IWP]_!{g]9NZB]_V+{cKD¢{Z7£DP#P+Ng];]_NIeV\ZNc]{cVd\KLIMcdª¢dS/P+ILZm{KqK]!NJILZU_\V+~{g]IL\Z

V+NKLNcy{ZB]U_\VuIqZU_KO{g]IL\"Z{Z!}=\!S]_7S«]9V\®+Ng]IL\ZPå"v+Z~sSV+\Nc`/{\ZQ]_V\7yNcV'Pd¯{QP#NªNcVmN}={c¢\7S]]_!N

V+\KLN\U~\Z!Ng]{cVd¿{cmmV+Nm{g]NQPw{7P¡S/PYNUpSKuIqZ}IO{g]\V'Pw\"UUWS]WSV+N=ILZUKO{g]I§\"Z¿{Z}\7S]W7S«]*¶ ¡Z2]_!N¹\ZN

{Z!}`NcyIO}NZBN¡ILZªU{cy\7SV9\U]_!NS/P*NUMSDKLZN7P'P4\U°±²w³q°´µ/~\ZNg]{cVd{cmmV+Ncm{]NQP9{7P¶m\\}V+N}7I§g]\"V*P

IWPuV+\7yIL}N}¥¢dª]_NKMIz]NV+{g]WSV+Nå Z]_!N\7]_NcV!{Z}`/NIeV+IOB{[K;NcyIO}NZBNIqZU{y"\!SV?\"U¸åºc´µ\"ZNd

ILZ}"IO{]\"V'P#IWPU_\7SZ}/x1!N7SV\DP+Nª\"U9]_IpP#{cNcVIWPu]\ c\ZQ]_VIe¢«S]N]_\=]_N\Z7m\ILZ7m }Nc¢"{g]N\Z¥]_!N

V+\KLNT\"U¶~\ZNcd¯{cmmV+Ncm{g]NBPILZ]_NP+Ng]W]_ILZ7m¯\"U¶\ZNg]{Vdª\KLIMcdªx1!NJQSN7P]IL\Z~NT{cV+NJILZB]NcV+NQP_]N}ILZ

IWPJ~!Ng]_NV¡]_!N¥V+N{[Ku~\ZNcdm{c»\ZQ]{ILZDP~\V+N¹ILZU+\V~{g]_I§\"Z»{¢"\!S]bUMS]WSV+N¹ILZU_KM{]IL\Z>ILZ sSV+\N`

]_{Z{Z~ILZ}"IO{]\"V¢"{QP+N}~\Z]_NmV+\7J]_wV+{g]N\U¶Z\~IMZ!{[K~\ZNcdQÀANS;P+N{{[Z!NKD}{g]{UWV+{N~\V£

ILZDP]N{}=\"U¶]_N¡S/P_S/{KD]_ILªN¯PYNcV+ION!PuªNg]_!\}P?\"Z¯{cmmV+Nm{g]N¡s9SV\¹}{']{7x¶NJVYN{QP+\ZDPuU_\VS/P+ILZm={[Z!NK

}{g]{ù{cVYN·]Ww\nU_\KL}Do;IqV*P]K§d"`¯]_!N PY\n{cKLKONQ}gs9SV+\n{V+N{}{g]{ù{V+Nù\ZP]_V_Sg]N} S/PILZ7m P+NcyNV+{QK

{cmmV+Nm{g]_IL\ZVY\N}QSV+NQPBR~NcNZ}IqZ«mS\Z]_NT\"ZByNcZQ]IL\ZP¶S/P*N}`"]_!NJ}{']{~{cd=}IWPKO{d¯}ILUUNV+NZQ]

c!{cV+{g]NVIOP]IL7P+`!]_!NcV+Ng¢d¯IM~KqdILZm=Z\V+\7¢7S/P_]9\"Z!KzSP+I§\"ZDPå7kJZ!\!]_!NcV9V+N{QPY\"Z~7d~N¡V+NUNcV9{[Z!NQK

}{g]{IMP#]_{g]`9\!y"NcV]_!NNcV+IL\}¼SZ!}NcVTNch{ILZ{g]IL\Z

n

|

ÏY`)]_Ns9SV\N{cZ \!SZB]_VILNQPT{[Z2¢N

!öÕ+Õ'çØñuáÙë9á'Ö¬×Õ+â_äWç#"/Õ+âMÙØ+ÙcÚÕ$&%(')Lí+*ú+ücü#,Oç

ï

ÞzØ+âWÜeìØ-$.%('/)Mí+*ú+üücç«úüüü#,Wí

0DöÕ+Õ'çò/äMÖeâWÕ+Þ¦ÞeØØ+ÙìÛwÜLäM×cÚÜzÙ1*úücü,MçBö'õÕ+ÙBä_äWáÙ2*_ú+ücüü/,MçBö'ÖLáÝÚuØ+Ùì9ÔØÖOäWáÙ2*_ú+ücüü/,pí

3

öÕ+Õ'ç÷9ÕÞ§äpáÙ4*qøûûû,OçþâWÕ+Ý+áÝ+ÜQØ+Ùì65¶Õ+ëcØ6*eøûcûû,Mç87ÕâWÞzØ*Ý×Ø+Ùìö*õÕ+ÙBä_äáÙ4*qøûû(9/,Oçg÷9ÕèñØ+ÙÙØ+Ùcì:7)âWÕ+Ü<;Õ+â *qøûcû,í

=

(4)

\ZP+IO}NcV+N}{7P!{yILZm¯}"IeyNcVmNZB]9N\Z\IOP_]_VS']WSVNQP*lE{cZ!N[K}{g]{J~\}NKpPu!NKq~]\={cB]WSV+NP_Sc

N]NcV+\mNcZNIz]ILN7P9{cVY\P*P)]_!N\!SZB]_VILNQPå

x9\¯¢!VILZ7m¼NyIO}NZBNJVYNcm{cV+}ILZ7m=]_NJV+N7PNg]I§y"NJV+N}IOc]_I§y"NJ\7~NcV?\"U¶]_NJVYN{K~\ZNcd¯m{c2{Z!}¹{

Z\ILZ{KT~\"ZNcd,mV+\7T]_CILZ}IOB{g]\7VU_\VUMS]WSV+N ILZUKO{c]_IL\Z`N>U_\"KLKL\7 ]W~\<{cV\{cNQPåÀ<N>U_ILV'P]

\ZP+IO}NcVb{[Z¼IqZUKM{]IL\Z¼NQS/{]_IL\"Z \"ZB]{IqZILZm¹]_!NV+N{[K4~\"Z!Ncd2m{c¿{QP¡{ ~\ZN]{cVd ILZ}IOB{g]\7V+`¶{cKL\Z7m

~Iz]_T]W~\\Q]_!NcV9~{cV+\N\Z\~IOby"{cV+IM{c¢KONQP]_!{g];\Q]NgZB]I§{[KOKqdªILZUKeSNZNUpS]WSVYNIqZUKM{]IL\Z]_N\7S7]_7S7]n

m{c {Z}{5\w\"Z!N[ZB]2VYN[U_KONg]ILZ7mù]_N5ILZUKO{g]IL\"Z NchN]{g]_IL\ZDPx9\ ~\}NK]_!N¾V+Iey{g]N5P+Ng]\"V

ILZU_KO{g]IL\"ZNch!NQ]{g]_IL\ZP+`D~N~{QP*PSªNw]_!{g]¶]_N~{cmNZQ]+P#{KLIqmZ]_NIeV#ILZUKO{g]I§\"ZU_\"VYN{QP_]+P#\"Z]_!NNcZQ]_V+{K

¢{Z«£¤WP IM~KMIOIz]2ILZUKO{g]IL\Zù\7¢®*Ng]I§y"N7Tx1!NZ`J]_IMP ~\}NKIWP \{cV+N}·]\ù{Z\Q]_NV \"Z!NwNcV+N`

ILZDP]N{}2\"U9]_NVYN{K¶~\"Z!Ncd2m{c`)N\"ZP+IL}NV]_N~mV\7]_\U]_N~Z\~ILZ{K~\ZNcd¼{7P{~\ZN]{cVd

ILZ}"IO{]\"V*

x¶NV+NQP_]b\"Uu]_N={cNcVTIpPw\Vm{cZIBN}¿{QPTU_\KMK§\!ªP9NQ]_IL\"Z | ¢V+ION[U_Kqd»}NKMILZN{]NQP]_NN~IeV+IO{BK

~\Z!Ncd¿}N{Z!} NQS{g]I§\"Z¹]_!{g]#IMPTNQP_]ILª{g]N} ILZ \"VY}NgVu]_\ \!¢«]{cILZ {¹P+NVI§N!P¡\"U]_NVYN{K~\ZNcdnm{/

Ng]_IL\Z

Ò

VYNQP*NZQ]+P~\7SV~NQPW]_ILª{g]NQP\U]_N2ILZUKO{g]IL\"Z,~\}NKWuNg]I§\"Z¿Ï,\{cVYNQPJ]_N¹VYN}"IOg]_IeyN

\7~NcV\"U]_N2V+N{KT~\Z!Nd,m{<{Z},{ Z\ILZ{K=\ZNcd»mV+\!T]_,IqZ!}"IOB{g]p\"VS/P+ILZ7m\!S]pn\U_nPY{[~KWN

U_\V+N{QP_]+PNg]_IL\ZÐw\ZKzS}NQP]_!N{cNcV

Î=Â ÌMÌM"Ë ¹Å Æ Â Ë Å Í Â Â "Ë ÅÎ)ÂÃ Æ Â Î Æ

Â¹Å Æ Â Ë

SV¶KL\"Z«mnVSZ~NQS{g]I§\"ZVYNcV+NQPYN[ZB]+P9{JP]{Z}{cV+}~\}NK\"UD]_!N}N[{[Z!}U_\V¶V+N{K~\"Z!Ncd

ε π α + + + + + + + = −

^!^"^#^$^%^& ^`

wNcV+N '(

)

IWP·]_!NZ\ILZ{K~\Z!Ncd¨P_]_\c£` *+

,

IWP·]_!N V+ION KMNcyNKL` . -

/ 0

−

=

¹² ¹²

12 3 3

π

^IpP@]_!N

{cZZBS{[KOIWP*N}ILZUKO{g]I§\"ZVY{g]N¡ILZ~QS{cV]NV)]` 45

6

IWP¶]_NV+N{[KH¡RTlE` 7

89

: IWP]_N¡K§\Z7mnV_SZILZB]NcV+N7P];V+{g]N` ;

89 : IWP

]_N=P!\"V]nWVSZ2ILZB]NcV+NQP_]uV+{']N`=<><@?AIWPu]_N~V+N{K9NUUNg]IeyNNch"[{Z«mNV+{g]N`CB

DE

F IWP]_!NU_\"V+NILmZ2ILZQ]NcV+NBP]

V+{g]N={Z} GH

ε

IWPT{=}IpP_]WSV¢{Z!N]NcV+=;x1!N¥ILZ}NchJI4V+NU_NcV'P]p\>{¹PN[ILU_IO=\!SZB]_Vd`wIMKON]_N=ILZ}NchLK V+NcUNcV'P;]\{QS{Vp]NcVåkJKLK]_Ny{cV+IO{c¢KMN7PwV+Iz]W]NcZ~ILZ~KL\!NcV+{QPYN{cV+NILZK§\"m{cV+Iz]_~`7~IMKON]_!NV+N{ILZIqZm

\Q]_NV'P¿{cV+N<IqZKONcyNKNM GH

ε

IOP>ILZ}NcNZ}NZQ]Ked {[Z!} IL}NZQ]_IO{KMKLd }"IWP]_V+Ie¢7S]N} {~\Z7m \7SZQ]_VILN7P¿{Z}

QS{cV]NV'P

OQPRTSUVXWYZU\[^]`__bacNadeaXf]d\aegVZdVZhi]je@fkScWelSWmcNafQnacNapogSSaqd^WmogSja[r]TdrSjUa\st^tZuwvjfyxZzSUa|{agacQ{mcNaf}f~WmcNaphpaelUod^]fhf

oZfkScN]eqU^SSjcNaloZfkSTz|oXd[SjUaZSolx]RT]`STzoeSwod[SUao[^VX{mS]VZd|VX_SUafN]`dYZRjaQelWmckcNade}z|]d\stmt^t^

(5)

x¶N\V+N']_IM{[KLKLd`ªN2NchNg]]_N2\NU_UIOQIONZQ]+PT]_\{cyN¹]_!N U_\KqK§\!~ILZm<P+ILmZP9x1N2ILZUKeSN[Z!N2\U

ILZU_KO{g]IL\"ZS;P]¢"N P+ILmZ!N}Z!Ncm{g]IeyNKqd

<

+`PIqZ!N {ZIqZ!cV+N{7PYN ILZ,ILZUKO{g]I§\"ZªN{ZDP~{2IemNcV

V+Ng]WS!VZ \Z2\KL}ILZm)PT\UuV+N{K9{7P'PYNg]+P;x1IWPTIWPTKqIL£NKqd¼]\ ILZ!}QS/N={¹P_S¢P]Iz]WS]_IL\Z¹¢N]W~NNZ ~\ZNcd¿{Z}

m\\}P«x1!N¡ILZQ]NV+NQP];V+{]Ny{cV+IL{c¢KON7P9{c7]WSV+N]_!N¡IO~{Q];\"U;UILZ{ZIO{[K{QPP+Ng]9P_S¢P]Iz]WS]_IL\ZDQÀ¾NNchNg]

]_NTKL\"Z«mnVSZ=ILZQ]NV+NQP]EV+{g]N]p\={cVVd¯{JZ!Ncm{g]IeyNP+ILmZ

<

{Z}]_!NP+\V]pnVSZ~V+{g]N]p\¢N\P+Iz]IeyN

>

kVIWP+N~ILZ¥]_!NKL\Z«mnVSZILZQ]NcV+NBP]4V+{g]NJILKOK¶KMN{}¯]\{~}NcV+N{QP+N~\U¶]_N~}Nª{[Z!}¹U_\V~\ZNcd

p]p\¡]{c£N{}Qy"{[ZB]{cmN\UIemNcV¶V+Ng]WSVZP9\ZJ¢\Z}P+`7IOKMN{Z~ILZcV+N{BP*N¡ILZJ]_!NP+!\"VW]D]NcVILZQ]NcVYNQP];V+{']N

~ILKMK;V+NQP_SDKz]?IqZ¼{ILm!NcV#}N{Z!}¹U_\"V#~\ZNd kV+IWP+IMZ7m¼U_\"V+NILmZ¹ILZQ]NV+NQP]4V+{g]NIWP#KqIL£NKqd=]\]WV+{cZP+KO{g]N

ILZQ]\={T}NcV+N{QP+NJILZ]_NT~\"Z!Ncd=}Nª{Z}

<

Y`D{gS/PYN}¢d¥{¡V\"NZP+Iz]_d]\¹PS¢P]_Iz]WS]NT{g{gdªUWV+\

}\~N7P]_IL~\Z!NdÀ¾N>Nch!DN]]_N¿\NUUIOIONZQ]ª\UV*N{KTHbRTlù]\C¢N \P+Iz]_IeyNKedùP+ILmZ!N}

>

o;ILZ{[KOKqd!`~{Zù{cV+N[IO{g]IL\Zù\U]_NCVYN{K~NUUNBg]_IeyN@Nghc!{[Z«mDN,V+{g]NV+NQPSKz]+P ILZù{ZùILZV+N{7P+N@ILZ·]_N

}N~{Z}U_\V}\~NQP]ILSVV+NcZ!d"`)P+\]_!{g]NTNghNBg]/]W!N\NcU_UIO[IONZQ]

]_\¢N\DP+Iz]Iey"N ¢N{gS;P+NT{QZ

{cV+N[I§{g]I§\"Zª\U/]_NT}\~N7P]ILTgSVV+NZcd¯IpP4V+NUKON]N}¢d¯{[Z=ILZcVYN{QP+NILZ 2P+NNb]_!NJ}N7P+VI¬7]IL\Z

\U]_!N}{g]{?¢"NKL\!

!

À¾N SPYNQS{cV]NcVKed<{Z!N[Kw}{g]{CP{cZZILZm5UWV+\ ]_\

|

Ï ux1!NNI¬VIOB{KT{Z{KqdP'IWP

U_\gS/P+N7P¿\Z5]_N·U_\KqK§\!~ILZmmV+\7S\"U=]_NCs9SV\N{cZ\7SZQ]_VIMNBPmkS/P]_V+IL{`#"NKLmIzSDª`R~NZª{cV£`

o;ILZKO{Z}`Do/V+{ZBN`;HJNcV+ª{Z7d!`¶H¡V+NNN`/v]{K§d!`D]_N¡ªNg]_!NcV+KM{Z!}P+`ª\V~{cd!`lE\V]WSm{cKL`9{[ILZ!`7~N}NZ

{cZ!}]_Nt~ZIz]N}%$ILZm}\=!x1!NJ}{g]{T{cV+NTUWV+\" P+NcyNcV*{K/P+\7SV+NQP «]_!N¡vZQ]NcVZ!{g]IL\"Z!{K,\ZNg]{cVd~oDSZ}

vo9»}{g]{g¢{BP+N`1]_!N¥Z!{g]IL\"Z!{KuNZQ]_V+{K¶¢{Z7£/P¤P]{]_IMP]IL7P+`]_N bs?R½{[ILZILZ}IM{g]\7V'Pw{cZ}2sSV\DP]{']

}{g]{g¢"{QP+N«7x¶NJPYNcV+IMNBP9{cV+NJPYN{QP+\Z{KLKqdª{}®S/P]N}D

x¶NZ!\~ILZ{[K¶\ZNcd¿P]\c£`'&`)IMPb\w7S]N}¹{BP]_NKL\m{cV+Iz]_ \U1 Ò Dx!NV+IONKONcyNKL`)(#`IWP

ªN{7PSV+N}{7P¶]_NJKL\m{cV+Iz] \U/]_N\ZP_SDªNcV9V+IONIqZ!}Nch/x!NJILZUKM{]IL\Z~V+{g]N`

π

`IWP4\w7S]N}{7P

]_Nw{[ZZBS{KMIWP+N}IqZUKM{]IL\Z W]_{g]4IWP + *

, -

−

=

^.^/ ^.^/

./ 00

π

x1!NKL\Z7mn_VSZ=ILZ"]NcVYNQPW]9V+{å]N` 2 1 `/IWPu\DP+NZ {QPª\ZN \U¡]_!N U_\KLKL\7~ILZm]W\>y{cV+IL{c¢KON7P }NcNZ}ILZmS\Z,}{g]{2{gy"{IMKO{c¢IMKLIz]_dm1]_!N HT\7yNcVZªNZQ]

¢\Z}=dIMNKO}\"V]_!NJ¢IMKMK/V+{]N7"o;\V]_!N¯P\V]nWVSZ¹ILZB]NcV+NQP_]V+{']N`D~NJS/P+N]_N\"Z!Nd¼ª{cV£Ng]4V+{']N~{QP#{

V+\7hd!`\V=]_N@\ªNcVY[IO{K¢{Z«£DP }Nc\P+I¦]V+{g]NwNZ5]_N@~\ZNcdª{cV£Ng]V+{]N·P+NcV+ILN7P IWP¿Z\7]

{gy"{[IOKO{¢KON7/x9NVYN{K9HbRTlE`43;`1IOP]_NKL\m{cV+Iz]_ \U9]_NHRJl{g] Ð=VILN7P!5DkPb{VY\!hd U_\V]_!N

U_\V+NIemZ=ILZB]NcV+NQP_]¶V+{g]N`"NJ!\\DP+N]_!Nbt¯¢\Z}dIONKM}/Qo;ILZ{KqKLd`"]_!NJV+N{K/NU_UNBg]_IeyNTNch{Z7mNV+{g]NJIWP

(6)

ªN{7PSV+N}C{QP]_!N¹]_V+{}N¥NIemB]N},{gyNcVY{cmN \"U]_N2V+N{K#Nch{Z«mDN2V+{g]N¹¢"{QP+N},\Z>¢IqKO{g]NV+{K?]_VY{}N

P{V+NQP¯{[Z!}@Nch\Vp]¯PILIOKM{VI¦]dkTZ@ILZcV+N{7P+N>ILZ ] V+NcU_KONg]+P¯{cZ@{V+NIO{g]I§\"Z\"UT]_N>}\~N7P]IL

gSVVYNcZcd

kTKMK]_N ~\}NKMPª{cV+N NQP_]ILª{g]N},\7yNcVJ]_!N2NcV+IL\}UWV+\7

]\

Ñ Ï/À<N¹S/PYN¼]_!N }{g]{

P{ZZILZmUWVY\"

]p\

|

Ï ]p\\7S]N\!S«]_n_\"UnPY{[wKONU_\"V+N{QP]+På

;)J

x9\2{gy\IL}¥]_!NV+\7¢KLN \UP7SV+IL\!S/P#V+NcmVYNQP'P+IL\ZP+`)N¢NmILZ¼\!SVbN[wIeV+IOB{K¶IqZ7yN7P_]_IemD{]_IL\"Z=~Iz]

{cZ¿{Z{KqdP+IWP\U]_NSDZI¦]VY\\Q]V\NcVp]_I§NQPT\U]_N=ILZ}"ILyIO}QS{[K#P+NcV+ILN7P;x9\¼]_IOPNU_UNBg]`N={cKed2]W\

]NQPW]+P¢"{QP*N}=\Z=\I

|

Ïu{cZ!}l¶IOKMKMILDP?{[Z!}27SDK

| Ò

!x1!Nd¯{cyNPY\~N{}7y{ZB]{cmNQPu\7yNV]_N

\ZQy"N[ZB]I§\"Z!{[Kªv+`lENQP*{cV+{Z{Z} ILZ | Ò 2]NQP] vl4P+IqZ!NC]_Ncd {[KOKL\7 U_\V¿cV+\DP'PYnP+N]IL\Z

}NcNcZ!}NZ!N7Dx¶NV+NBPSKz]+PILZx9{c¢KMN ILZ!}"IO{g]NJ]_!{g]¶~N~\UM]NcZ\ZKeS}NILZU{cy\7SVu\U1]_!NJSZIz]VY\\Q]

7d\7]_NBP+IpPY`NhNc7];U_\V)]_!N¡ILZUKO{g]IL\ZV+{g]N]_{]IOPD

À<!N[Z,NBP]Iqª{g]ILZ7m>]_!N }Nª{Z}CU_\VV+N{[K#~\ZNd!`ªN2\ZP+IO}NcV=P+Ncy"NcV+{K#\¢ILZ{g]I§\"ZDP\U]_N

Ngh!KO{Z{g]\Vdùy"{cV+IM{c¢KONQP»{Z}5]_IpP dIONKM}DP2]_7VYNN·~\}NKWP Y\}NKWP ]_«V+\7Sm Ò `wIM5~IOKMK¢N

{c{cVYNcZQ]TILZ2]{g¢KON7P | {Z} Ò ¢"NKL\! À¾N¹ª{c£N¥S/P+N¼\"UbNQP]IL{]\"V'P#]_{g]¡NghKL\Iz]#]_N¹ILZU_\V+{]IL\Z

{gy"{[IOKO{¢KON<IqZ5]_!N<cV+\DP'P+n+P+Ng]IL\ZDP>ILZ\V+}NcV¹]p\ù\!¢«]{cILZ \"V+N@V+N[IOP+N<N7P]_ILª{g]NQP¿\U¥]_!N·{cy"NcV+{cmN

{cV+{~N]NcV'PILZ~]_N~\}N[Kx\]_IWP4NUUNBg]`"NJ\"ZP+IM}NcV¶]Ww\]Wd«NQPu\U¶{ZNK;NQP]IL{]\7V'Px9{g¢KON | IP

ª{}NSª\"UD]_!NV+NQPSKz]+P9\UKL\Z7mnV_SZ~NQS{g]_IL\ZDPS/P+ILZm{oSDKLKqd~\}7ILUION}~ # poD #9NQP]_ILª{g]\V'

x¶IpP N7P]Iqª{g]\7VY`V\\DP+N}·¢dAl¶N}7V+\"ZI | Y`{KLKL\7P¿U_\V2Ng]NcV\"mNZN\7S/P>P+KL\N7P {V+\P*P¹]_N

\7SZQ]_VI§NQPILZ¿{}}"I¦]IL\Z=]\ \7VV+N']_ILZ7m U_\"VbNZ}\mNcZ\7S/P¢IO{QPb{[Z!}>P+NcV+IO{K9\"VV+NcKO{g]_IL\ZD/x9{c¢KMNBP Ò {]\

Ò {cKWP+\V+Nc\VW]~P\~N¹VYNQPSKz]+P¢{7PYN}\"ZªN{Z¿mV+\QS,NQP]_ILª{g]\V'P~{BPV\"!\PYN} ¢d l¶N7PY{cV+{Z{Z}

~Iz]_

Ðu{Z}lENQPY{cV+{Z! #"$&%('-

åx¶7IWP?{[KOKL\"ªP]p\¥~{£DNNch!KLIOIz]¶]_NPNN}=\U9{}®S/P]~NZQ]

]_\]_NKL\"Z«mnVSZ~NQSDIOKqIe¢V+IeSD¯

o/V+\ x9{g¢KON

|

`¶\!SV~{ILZ UILZ}"ILZmDPT{V+N{7PU_\KOKL\7Påx¶NªN!P_]ILª{g]NQPb{]c¹V+IL\VNch!Ng]{g]_IL\ZDP

UWV+\½]_!N\"Vdx¶NPNIOUIO{g]IL\"ZP¹P+!\! { \DPI¦]IeyN ILZ\~N NKO{!P_]I§[I¦]dKL\DP+N¹]\SZIz]_d!`?~IO,IP

\ZPY\"Z!{[ZB]/~Iz]_J]_!NJQS{ZQ]Iz]{']_IeyN]_N\Vd~7d\7]_NQP+IWPå7kJZ~ILZcV+NB{QPYN¡ILZ~V+NB{KDILZ\~N]_BSPEV+NQPSKz]+P4IqZª{

V+\\7VW]_IL\Z{g]N¹ILZ!cV+N{7P+NIqZ2]_N}N{Z!}>U_\"VTV+N{cK4~\ZNcd¶x1!N¹}Nª{Z}>U_\V~\ZNcdIWPwZNcm{g]_IeyNKMd

V+NKL{g]N}w]p\J]_NV+{g]N\UILZUKO{g]IL\ZD«x1!NJ\V+}NcVE\"U;ª{cmZI¦]S}N\UD]_NP+NIOnNKO{QP]ILIz]_dªIpPuP+ª{KMK {cV+\7SZ}~n

Ò

Bx¶NNchKO{[Z!{g]IL\"Z~U_\V]_IMP9IWP1]_!{g]¶K§\!ILZU_KM{]IL\Z~IMZJ]_!NsSVY\{cV+N{V+NgyNZB]+PP]_V\"Z«m=PS¢DP]Iz]WS]_IL\Z

NUUNg]+PuUWVY\ ~\ZN]{cVd={7P*P+Ng]+P9]\¥V+N{cK;{QPP+Ng]+P?\"V4U_\"V+NIqmZ=SVV+NZION7Px1!N}N[ª{Z}=U_\VV+N{K\ZNd

IWP\DP+Iz]IeyN[KLd {U_UNg]N}¹¢d¹]_!N¥P+!\"V]pn]NV ILZQ]NcV+NBP]uV+{]N{cZ!}¹ZNcm{g]_IeyNKqd \VV+NcKL{]N}¥~Iz]_=]_NK§\Z7mn

]NcV ILZQ]NcVYNQP]#V+{']NQ w\7~Ngy"NcV+`)]_!N¹P+N~IMnN[KO{7P]ILIz]_d U_\Vu]_N=U_\"VNcVJIWPTZ\Q]TPW]{']_IpP_]I§{KMKqd»P+IqmZILUIO{ZQ]*

(7)

{QP*P+Ng]9PS¢DP_]I¦]WS]_IL\"ZQÀ¾NJ{KWP+\ª\!¢P+NcVyN]_!{g]/]_N\NUU_IOQIONZQ]E\U]_!Nbt¯¢"\"Z!}dIONKM}IWP9Z\7]9P]{']_IMP]IL{KOKqd

P+IemZIMUIO{ZB]*x1!NCNhKM{Z!{g]I§\"ZA\U]_IWP¼{Z¾¢N,U_\!SZ}5ILZ@]_NU{g]~]_{g]`\7yNcV=]_NNcVI§\}@SZ}NcV

Ngh"{[ªILZ{g]I§\"Z!`E]_!Nt=>ILZB]NcV+NQP_]VY{å]NQPb{cyN=}7V+IeyNZ¹]_NsSV\N{cZ2V+{]NQPTIqZ {=\"ZB]Ngh7]b\U#{

Ò nd"N{cV

]_V+NcZ!}\UILZcVYNQ{BP+IqZmªILZQ]NcmV+{]_IL\"Z{cV+\DP'P9~{cV£Ng]+P«x¶QS/P+`ILZJ]_NVYNcmV+NQP*P+IL\Z`7]_N]W~\V+{']NQP9{V+NKLIL£NKqd

]_\¢Nw\"KLKOIqZN{cV7sy"NZQ]WS{KLKqd`NUILZ}]_N~NchNg]N}\DPIz]IeyNP+ILmZ=U_\V]_NTV+N{K/NUUNBg]I§y"NNch{Z«mDN

V+{g]Nª{cZ}=]_IpPwPSmmNQP_]+P{ZNcm{]IeyNIO~{g]#\Z2~\ZNcd }Nª{Z}2\"U#{ª}NcV+NIO{g]IqZ«m¿gSVV+NcZ!cd//xIWP

KL{cdDP9ILZU{cy\7SV¶\UD]_NgSVVYNcZcd=P_S¢P]Iz]WS]_IL\Z7d\7]_NQP+IWPå

k~PP+\7Z5¢dù]_!N¾{ZN[Kª\IqZB]NcmV+{g]_I§\"Z5]NQP_]+P+`~{<c\ILZQ]NcmVY{g]_IL\ZùV+NKL{g]IL\"ZP+IL ¢Ng]WNNcZùVYN{QK

~\Z!Ncd{[Z!}»]_!N>NchKO{Z{g]\Vdy{VIO{c¢KONQPªIpP¯{\!SZB]N}CU_\VvZ!}NN}>]_N

υ

P]{]_IMP]IL IWP~~NKWK {g¢"\!y"N Ï{cZ}>]_N \Q]_!NcV=P+I§h<P_]{g]_IMP_]IL7PªKLIMN¹SZ}NcV Ï/w\7NgyNcVY`NQS{']_IL\Z ª{QP'P_SD~N7Pª{Z

ILZDP]{cZB]{cZN\7S/P9{}®S;P]~NZQ]E\"UD]_!NV+N{KD~\ZNcd~¢{KO{ZBN]_\~Iz]+P9}N7P+IeV+N}KMNcy"N[KD7S[{[Z~ILZDP]{ZB]{cZN\7S/P

NQSILKMIe¢V+IeSD P]{']N¢"Ng]WNNcZ=]_NVYN{K¶~\ZNcdP_SKed¿{Z}¥]_!NV+N{K9}Nª{Z}2U_\"V\"Z!Nd¼IWPSZKqIL£NKqd

mI§y"NZJ]_NTNchIpP_]NcZNJ\UD]_V+{cZDP+{g]I§\"Z~\P_]+PÀ<N]_BS/PZNN}J]p\ª{c£N{}IpP_]ILZg]_I§\"Z~¢Ng]WNNcZJ]_!NJKL\Z7mn

{cZ!}¹P+\Vp]nV_SZ¢"N{cyIL\7SVILZ]_NT~\ZNcd=ª{cV£N]¢dP+NILUdILZm={Z=NcVV+\"V4\"V_V+Ng]_I§\"ZªN[!{ZIpP+ \U

{g]WS{KJV+N{[K{QP+·¢"{KM{Z!QNBP¥]\7{cV+}]_!N[I¬V2}NQP+ILV+N} KL\Z7mnVSZ 2KONcyNKWvZ@]_IWP¹yIONg`x9{g¢KONQP

Ò

{

]_7VY\!Sm

Ò

ªV+Nc\7VW]=P+\~N>N7P_]ILª{g]IL\"ZP¢{QPYN}@\ZC]_NªN{ZCmV+\7S pHbs ={Z}C\\"K§N}·ªN{Z

mV+\7S pl/,Hs69NQPW]_ILª{g]\"V*PBx¶N?]_«V+NN]{g¢K§N!P1\"VV+NQP!\"Z!}¡]_\J]_!N~\}NKWP ]_7V\7Sm

Ò

V+NQPNg]_IeyNKqd

x¶N l/Hbs~Ng]_\}CV+NBP]WVILg]+P~]_N>KL\Z7mnV_SZ@\NUUIWILNZQ]+P~]_\C¢N¿NQS{K{V+\P*P]_!N>\7SZQ]_VILNQP

p]_!Nd{cV+Nù\\KLN}+`=IOKMN5]_N P+\Vp]nV_SZ\NcU_U_IMINcZQ]+P{cV+NNQP_]ILª{g]N}ILZ}IeyDIO}QS{KMKLd{[Z!} ]_!NQZ

{gy"NcV+{cmN}DExN2NBP]Iqª{g]NBP{V+N¹¢{QPYN}\"Z2]_!N2{cKMIO{c]_IL\Z>\U]_N2ª{chIMS KOIL£N[KOIL\\}¿{cV+\{c

{cZ!}{ªNgT]\"Z!npab{cPY\"Z{[KLm\VIz]_ù]\¡]_NU_\KqK§\!~ILZm=PN[ILUIOB{g]_IL\Z

( ) ( )

⁻

( )

=

−

= −

−

− + + ∆ − + ∆ + +

=

−

∆

ε η µ λ β φ

^` ^|

U_\V=N{<\!SZB]_VdW`~!NcV+N

ε

IWP]_N¿}"IWP_]WSV¢{ZBN2]NcV {Z} }NQP+IemZ{]NQP]_!N yNg]\7Vª\UJ]_N Ngh!KO{Z{g]\Vd~y{VIO{c¢KONQP«vU)]_!N¡V+\\Q]+P1\"U/]_IpP4NQS{]IL\Z~KMIONT\!S«]+P+IL}Nb]_!NbSZI¦]9ILV+KMN`"]_NcZ]_!NJ~\}N[KIP

NcVV\V+n\"V_V+Ng]_I¬Z7m

<

!

φ

?{[Z!}]_NcVYNNchIpP_]+Pu{~KL\Z7mn_VSZV+NKO{c]_IL\ZP+IL¥¢N]W~NNZ]_N~}Nª{Z}=U_\"VVYN{QK

~\Z!Ncdª{Z}I¦]+P9}Ng]NcV~ILZ{ZQ]+P9}NU_ILZN}J¢d

(

^" ^"

)

^"^# ^"^#

"#

"# $

%

&

ν φ

β

+

−

=

− ⁽^' ^Ò

)+*-,/.0.2143416587+149;:=<>.?<34@BA+CD7FEG8<1HC36,/5=3614.?5<>58IJ7FK1LCNM8534KO.2,H5<>PH@7Q<>,/5R,BS+7QK1UTWVX@B58GY7FK1[Z E8.2,B:=14@65R<>5/7Q1.21HCN7\.2@]7^1BC`_aCb141

@H9[9d14.`C2A>@45GWeDf8g/g8hOij@65=Gk K8<l5O5@45G+*m.2@45/n14AjefOg8go/i2p

(8)

x¶N¨KL\Z7mnV_SDZ \N[U_U_IMIONZQ]+P{cV+N NQS{K·]\

(

)

φ β

α

=− M@]_!N¨KL\"Z«mnVSZ !\~\mNcZNIz]d

7d\7]_NBP+IpPuIWP9]_QS/Pu!{cV+{g]NVIjBN}¢d

α

α =

U_\"V?NgyNcVd¯\7SZQ]_VdkT}}Iz]I§\"Z!{[KOKqd!`~Nw{KMcSKO{g]Nb]_!N

ªN{Z2mV+\7S¿NQP]_ILª{g]\VIL IWPw{[Z {y"NcV+{cmN\U¢\7]W]_N2P+\Vp]n{cZ!} KL\Z7mn_VSZ¿\NUUIOIONZQ]+PDÀAN

]NQPW]wU_\"V~KL\Z7mnV_SZC!\~\mNcZNIz]_dS/P+ILZm@{~®+\ILZQ] ~{S/P+{Z>]NQP_]¢{QPYN},\"Z>]_!N ZBSDKOK7d\7]_NQP+IWPª\U

NQSIey{KON[ZN ¢Ng]WNNZ]_!N l/,Hs {Z},Hs NQP]IMª{g]\7V'=vU>]_NKL\Z7mnV_SZ \NUU_IO[IONZQ]+P¾{cV+N

\~\"mNZ\7S/P+`"]_!NcZ]_!N¡,HsNQP]ILª{g]NQP4{cV+N\"ZP+IpP_]NZQ]9{Z}=NUUIMIONZQ] np]NBP]9ILZ]_N¡]{g¢KONQP 7vZ~]_N

]{g¢KLN7PY`]_!N¡y{KeSNQP?\U]_N {c¢\7yNÐ ILZ}IO{g]N{Nc7]{cZ!N\U]_!NJZQSKMK;\U¶\\KL{c¢IMKOIz]_dU_\"V]_!N

KL\Z«mnVSZ \NU_UIOIMNZB]+PÀ<N{Z·]_NV+NU_\"V+N\"ZP+IO}N[V=]_{]]_NV+N@{cV+N,Z\P+IemZILUIOB{ZQ] P_]{å]_IMP_]I§{K

}IqU_UNcV+NZBNQP9¢Ng]W~NNcZ]_N¡]W\=NQPW]_IL{]\"V'Påx¶NT\"ZKedNhBNc7]_IL\Z=IWP1]_!N\NUU_IO[IONZQ]1\"U]_!N¡VYN{K/HbRwl

ILZ\}NK Ò ¶U_\VIOJ]_NZBSDKLK\U;NQSI§y"{KMNZB]¶\NcU_U_IWILNZQ]+P9{cV+\DP'P/]_N\7SZQ]_VI§NQP9IpPEV+N®'Ng]N}D

vZ¿{KMK¶]_N=V+NcmV+NBPP+IL\ZPY`1]_NNcVVY\"Vn\7VVYNå]_I§\"Z¿\NUU_IOQIONZQ]+Pw{cV+NyNcVd»KL\DP*N¯]p\ SZIz]d!`IL~KLdIqZm

]_{]]_!N¥P+\V]pn{cZ!} K§\Z7mnV_SZ \NcUUIMIONZQ]+Pb{cV+NZ!NQ{VKed NQS{[K/xIWPPSmmN7P]+Pu]_{]]_!NV+NQPP_SV+N\Z

~\Z!Ncd }N{Z!}¥]\2V+Nå]WSVZ¥]p\ I¦]+PKL\Z«mnVSZ NQSILKMIe¢V+IqS IWPV+{g]_!NcVJP_]_V+\"Z«m {cZ!}¼]_!{g]]_!N{}®S/P]~NZQ]

]_ILªN¾ª{cd5¢"N@IqZDP_]{ZQ]{cZ!N\!S/PåTx1!N·P!\"V]nM]NV IqZB]NV+NQP]VY{å]N`JILù!{QP Z\ IL~{g]=wNZ<~N

\ZP+IO}NcV4{gyNV+{cmNn¢{7PYN}KL\Z7mnVSZª\NcUUIMIONZQ]+P p]_!NboD #=\V1HbsNQP]_ILª{g]\7V Y`}«\NQP4{cU_UNg]]_!N

}N~{Z}½U_\V5V+N{K,~\Z!Nd IqZ ]_N\\"KLN}n¢"{QP+N} V+NcmVYNQP'P+IL\ZDP pl/,Hs x¶N \VV+NQP\"Z!}"ILZ7m

\NcU_UIO[IONZQ];IWPP_]{g]_IMP]ILB{KLKqdP+IemZIMUIO{ZQ]ENIz]_!NcV9{g]D]_!N \V9{å]D]_!NJÐ KLNcyNK\U¶P+IqmZILUIO{ZN~Iz]~{

P+N~IOnNKO{!P_]I§[I¦]d¥\NU_UIOIONZQ]¶y{cVdILZm=¢Ng]WNNZ

{cZ!}

Ò

x¶Nt==¢\Z}dIMNKO}V+Nª{IqZDPuZ!\Z

P+IemZIMUIO{ZB]*7kPU_\V]_NT\Q]_NcV¶y{VI§{¢KON7P+`~NUILZ}]_{g];]_NV+N{cKHbRTl \DP+Iz]I§y"NKqd¯{UUNg]+P9V+N{KD\ZNd

}N~{Z}`"IMKON¡¢\7]_]_NJILZUKO{g]IL\Z={Z}]_NKL\Z7mnV_SDZªIqZB]NcV+NQP_]¶V+{]N¡!{y"N{JZ!Ncm{g]I§y"NJILZUK§SNZ!N e®S;P]

{QP2~I¦]5]_!N¾o/, # NQP]ILª{g]\7V ª"I¬mZILUIO{ZQ] IqZUKqSNcZ!QNBP¿\U¥]_!N5KO{g]M]NcV¿{cVYN·U_\7SZ}5~NZù~N

\ZP+IO}NcV]_!Nl)HbsNQPW]_IL{]\"V*

"!$#&%(')&*+,-*+.0/#

{gyILZmNQP_]ILª{g]N}ù\7SV KL\Z7mnVSZAV+N{K=~\Z!Ncd}N[ª{Z}`JN·Z!Nh«] P]WS}7d<~Ng]_NV¹]_NCVYN{K

~\Z!Ncdnm{c \"ZB]{cILZDPILZU_\"V+ª{g]_IL\Z¼{¢"\!S]4UMS]WSV+N~IqZUKW{g]_IL\Z=¢d>PNQILUdILZm {ZIqZUKO{g]_IL\Z2~\}NKWDÀ<N

{QP*PSNJ]_!{g]`)ILZ{}}Iz]IL\"Z]\]_NV+N{cK~\ZNcdm{c`ILZUKO{g]IL\"ZIMP#{KWP+\2ILZUKeSNZN}=¢d=]_N~\!S«]_7S7]nm{

{cZ!}ILZUKO{g]IL\"ZNh!Ng]{g]_I§\"ZPm

(

¹² ¹²

)

¹³ ² ² ¹²

142 12

12

µ π µ ε µ

5 5

µ π ω

π

= ₋ + ₋ + − + ₋ +

6

7

8

9

:

6

;

6

6 < ` Ï

(9)

wNcV+N

−

π

IpP]_!N~Nh!Ng]{g]_I§\"ZILZ2QS{cV_]NcV]n \UILZUKO{g]IL\"ZILZ2QS{V]NcV]9¢d]_NV+Iey{g]NP+Ng]\"VuILZ

\7SZQ]_Vd`

(

⁻

)

IOP]_N2\7S7]_7S«]nm{c`

−

ε

IpPT]_N2N7P_]ILª{g]N}>V+NBP+IL}QS/{KuU_V+\ NQS{]IL\Z ~{cZ}

ω

IWP9{}IWP]WSV¢"{[Z!N]NcV¯

À¾NZNN}=]\¹~{c£N=P+\~N7d!\!]_!NQP+NBP{c¢\7S]¶]_NJ{cd2ILZUKO{g]I§\"Z¼NchNg]{]_IL\"ZP{V+NU_\V+N}DÀ<N

{QP*PSN¿{ ¢{Bc£7{cV+}nKL\\"£ILZ«m·ªN!{[ZIWP+ {Z}@{KWP+\<\ZP+IL}NcV~]_{g]T]_Ncd{cV+N>ILZUKeSNZN}C¢d,]_N

IM~KMIOIz]¶ILZU_KO{g]I§\"Z~\7¢®*Ng]IeyNJP+N])¢dT]_N~\Z!Ng]{cVd{gS]W!\"V+Iz]Wd

≤

− +

= ₋ ₋ ₋

−

π π π

π

^` ^Ð

wNcV+N

π

IpP]_!NIOKMIOIz]u\ZNg]{Vd¼{gS]_\VIz]ILN7P¤¶ILZUKO{g]IO\Z]{cVmN']+kP#{V+\7hd\U¶]_IWP]{cVmNg]`D~N

\ZP+IO}NcV¶]_N «P]{g¢KON~\\ZNZQ]1\"U;{!P_]9ILZUKO{g]IL\Z\"w7S]N}¢d¥{[Z Jl¿U_IMKz]NV7vZ~]_NPYNQSNKL`~N

{KLK]_IWPy"{cV+IM{c¢KON]_NT\"VYN¡ILZU_KM{]IL\Z`{cZ}]_NT}"ILUUNcV+NZN ! !

π

π − ]_NILZUKO{g]I§\"Z~m{c=ILZªQS{cV]NcV]EU_\"V

\7SZQ]_Vd#"

À¾N{[KWPY\\ZP+IL}NcV]_!{g]]_!N\!S«]_7S7]pnm{c~IMP9NZ}\mNcZ!\!S/P+Kedª}Ng]NV~ILZN}~{QP9U_\KLKL\7P

(

^$% ^$%

) (

^$%^& ^$%

)

^$%

$%

$% '

(

)

) +−+−=− ₋₋₋₋

*

+ *

*

+ ,

-

π υ

υ

^`

wNcV+N / . IWP]_!NNZB]_V+{cK "b{Z7£;¤pP9ILZQ]NcVYNQP];V+{']NI§[~IWPP*Ng]]_7V\!Sm~{x9{gd!KL\"V¶V_SDKLN

( ) (

² ²

)

¹ ⁰

3 465

7

485

485 465

465

9

485

= α

^;

π − π + α

^:

− +

kTUM]NcV,{5V+Nn{V+{~Ng]_VI«{g]_I§\"Z!`¯]_!Nù\¢ILZ{g]I§\"Z \U _Ï ]_7V\7Sm >dIONKO}P¿]_NùU_\KLKL\!IqZm

ILZU_KO{g]IL\"ZNQS{g]IL\"Z

( ) ( )

( )

^<= ^<= ^<= ^<= ^<= ^<= ^<=

<=

<= > >

η π β ε

β

π π β β

π β π

+ +

+

− +

=

−

− ^?

@

?

A ??

B

C ?

?

D

?

? E

Ñ

wNcV+N FG

η

IWPu{}IWP]WSV¢"{[Z!N]NcV+=x¶IpP?NQS{g]IL\Z=\¢ILZNQP¶]W\={QPN]+P\U¶~\Z!Ng]{cVd~\KLIOcdªVSDKON7P U_\VILZUKO{g]IL\Z]{cVmNg]_ILZ7mD{¡]{cVmNg]_ILZ7m=VSKON{Z}{[Z=ILZDP_]VS~NZQ]nW¢{QPYN}VSKMN«!RNcyIO{g]I§\"ZDP?\U]_N~{g]WS{K

V+N{KD\"ZNcdP]\c£~UWV+\I¦]+PKL\Z7mnV_SZ]{VmNg] HI

ε

^J uP+IemZ{KP4{]_7V+N{]D]_\ 7VILNP]{g¢ILKOIz]d7kTZ\7¢DP*NVyN}

y{KeSN {c¢\7yN¹]_N¹]{cVmN']Ty{KzSN {dIM~Kqd,ILmNcVªIqZUKM{]IL\Z`ILKON¹]_N \\PIz]N>P+Iz]WS{g]_IL\ZC{[d

dIONKM}={w}NNKONcV+{g]IL\Z=\UILZUKO{g]I§\"Zx¶NwNZB]_V+{cK "b{[Z£S/PYNQP]_!NIqZU_\V+ª{g]_IL\Z=\ZQ]NZQ]1\"U]N\V+{cV_d

}IMP*NQSIqKOIe¢VIO{T{Z}VYN{Bg]+P>¢d¯{[Z«mILZ«m¹Iz]+P4ILZQ]NcV+NBP]¶VY{g]N`mIeyNZªIz]+PIOKMIOIz]9ILZUKO{g]IL\Z\7¢®*NBg]_IeyNJ{Z}

]_Nª\!S«]_7S7]pnm{c/"s?QS{g]_IL\Z ÑIWPbNQP]IL{]N}2{QPU_\KqK§\"På/x¶\ }N{K)~Iz]_=]_NªNZ}\mN[Z!NIz]dVY\!¢KONª`

N¡S/P+NILZDP]_VS~NZQ]+P?{Z}={cKqd¼{H N7P_]_Iqª{g]\V1 WILZDP]N{}=\U4{P]{Z}{V+}vLK NQP]IL{]\"V ]_\=m{cILZ

NUU_IOIMNZcd2¢d NchKL\Iz]ILZm {}}Iz]I§\Z{K9~\ªNZQ]+P#V+NQP]_VIM]IL\ZPå/xN]nP]{']_IMP_]IL7Pb{cV+Nª\7S]N}=S/P+IqZm

N]NcV+\DP+N}{BP]_ILn4{[Z!}¥P*NcV+IL{K;\VV+NcK§{g]I§\"Z!n\ZDP+IpP_]NcZQ]4P]{cZ}{V+}NcVV+\7V'P!x¶\=}N{K~Iz]_~]_NV+\!¢KON \U

(10)

P{]_IM{K\VV+NKL{]IL\Z`VIL\V]_\]_NNQP_]ILª{g]_IL\Z`7~NU_IqV*P];V+NcmV+NBP'P]_!N¡ILZ}IeyDIO}QS{K/P+NcV+IONQP9\Z d"N{cV+Ked]IqªN

}QSªIONQP~{Z}2~\V£ Iz]_2]_!N¥V+N7P+IL}QS{KWP\U]_NBP+N=V+NmV+NQP'P+I§\ZPå¶x1!N7P+N}QSDªIONQP~{V+N¹ILZQ]NcZ!}N} ]_\

{c7]WSVYNP\c£DP¶]_{g]1{gV+NP!{cV+N}ª{cV+\DP'P¶]_!NJ}ILUUNV+NZQ];ªN[¢NcV*P\U)]_N{ZNK/{Z}]_QS/P¶]\VYNc~\7yN{

\Q]NcZB]_IL{K\~~\Z=U{g]\7V7o/ILZ{KLKqd`]\{gy\IL}=\KqILZN{V+Iz]WdªV+\7¢KON[=PY`N\ZDP+IO}NcVuKL{cmmN}=IqZUKM{]IL\Z

{cZ!}>\V+N=IqZU_KO{g]IL\"ZPYNcD{V+{g]NcKedILZ2]_N=V+NcmVYNQP'PY\"V'P YILZDP_]N{} \"U]_!N¹ILZUKO{g]I§\"Z!nm{c;x1!N¥VYNQPSKz]+Pw{cV+N

P!\!Z¹ILZ¼x{c¢KONÏ ILZ¥]_!Nx9{g¢KON`]_!NV+N{[K¶\ZNcdn_mD{c¼IpP]_!NNQP_]ILª{g]N}=V+NQP+IO}QS{KWPU_V+\ NQS{]IL\Z

*

k~P IpP¿P+NNZ!`w]_!N@\NUU_IO[IONZQ]¼\U]_N@KL{mmDN}5VYN{KLn~\ZNcd m{c IWP¼\P+Iz]IeyN@{Z!} P_]{å]_IWP]IL{KOKMd

P+IemZIMUIO{ZB]*À<Nª{cZ2ILZQ]NVV+Ng]9]_7IWPU_ILZ}"ILZm {QPb{Z2ILZ}"I§{g]IL\"Z¼\U]_N~V+N}ILg]I§y"N\7~NV\U]_!NV+N{K

~\Z!Ncdnm{cªU_\"V9UMS]WSV+NILZUKO{g]IL\ZDQÀ¾N¡Z!\!]N]_{g]/]_!N\NUU_IO[IONZQ]E\UD]_NT\!S«]_7S7]nm{c~IWPP+ILmZIMUIO{ZQ] {]

]_N ½KLNcyNK;\"UuP+IemZIMUIO{Z!QNu{cZ}]_!{g]]_!N\V+NJILZUKO{g]IL\Z=IMPu{KWP+\2P+ILmZILUIO{ZQ]4{]]_N~Ð½KLNcyNK/\U

P+IemZIMUIO{Z!QN«

kTZ ILZB]NcV+N7P]_ILZ7m¿QSNQP]IL\Z IpP~!Ng]_NV]_NV+N{K\ZNcdn_m{c>IWP\"V+N=ILZU_\"V+ª{g]_IeyN={c¢\7S]#UMS]WSV+N

ILZU_KO{g]IL\"Z]_!{Z{[ZILZ}IO{g]\V¢{QPYN}\"Z=Z!\~IqZ{K;~\ZNcd!nmV+\7]_DDx¶\{}}7V+NBP'P]_IMP#QSNQP_]I§\"Z!`NVYNn

NQP_]_Iqª{g]NNQS{g]I§\"Z +Ñ¥¢dùP_S¢/P_]_Iz]WS]_ILZ7mA{CZ!\~IqZ{K~~\ZNcd<mV+\7T]_@m{c5ILZ}IO{g]\7V=U_\V]_N>V+N{K

~\Z!Ncd=m{c/7,\V+NPNILUIO{KMKqd!`ªNJVYNcK§{BN

−

ε

^¢d

∆

− ∆

^`T!NcV+N

∆

IWP?}N[UIqZN}={QP]_N {cZZBS{[KOIWP*N} Z!\~IqZ{K ~\Z!NdmV+\!T]_ P+ILªIqKO{cV+KLd]\J]_N}NUILZIz]IL\"Z\UD]_N{ZZQS{KMIWP*N}~ILZUKO{g]I§\"ZVY{g]Nm

(

)

−

=

∆

x¶N]{cVmNg];y{KzSNJ\U/]_NZ\ILZ{K/~\Z!NdªmV+\7T]_`

∆

`IWP4\w7S]N}{QP9]_N UIz]W]N}wy"{KzSN7P6 P]{']_ILU_\"VYN{QP_]+P 9\U]_!NU_\KLKL\7~ILZmNQS{g]_IL\Z

(

)

+−+=

∆

δ

π

₋

δ

₋ ₋

NQS{g]_I§\"ZDPY`Z{ªNKqd¯{Z £7SZKO{g NQS{g]_IL\Z`D{l¶ILKOKMIL)P4gSV_yNT{[Z!}={Z{mmV+Ncm{g]NT}N~{Z}NQS{g]I§\"Z

HJIeyNZILZUKO{g]IL\Z`;{ILmNcV#\7S]_7S7]nm{=V+NQPSKz]+P#UWV+\{cZNch{[ZP+IL\Z!{cVd2~\ZNg]{cVd¯\KLIMcd

>

δ

"bNQP+IO}N7P+`]_\{cIONcyN{KL\7NcVuIqZUKO{g]_IL\Z`]_!NJV+{g]N\U9Z\"~ILZ{K~\Z!Ncd=mV+\7J]_ªZNN}P9]\¯¢"N{}®SP_]N}

}\7ZB~{cVY} !

"

<

δ

uÀ<N,NQP]ILª{g]N ]_IWP2NQS{g]I§\"Z@S/P+ILZ7m N!P_]_IL{]\"V'P PIqªIMKO{cV=]_\@]_\DP+N>S/P+N}C]_\

NQP_]_Iqª{g]N ]_!N>V+N{K~\ZNcdA}Nª{[Z!}<{[Z!}·UILZ}C]W\·NBP]_ILª{g]N}<\N[U_U_IMIONZQ]+P]_!{g]¯{cV+NCP_]{å]_IWP]IL{KOKMd

P+IemZIMUIO{ZB])Iz]_ #%$

&

#

'(

−

δ

= ^{Z}

δ

^.^/ =^- ^,^)+* « ¡Z!N]_IpP9IWP4}\"Z!N`7~N\"S]N]_NJP_]{g]_ILU_\"V+N{7P]+P {cZ!}NBP]Iqª{g]N]_!NU_\KLKL\7~ILZmNQS{g]_IL\Z¢dH¡¿

( ) ( )

(

³

)

² ¹ ⁰

4 115

3 1

1

6

1

1 78787878 7878787878

78 99 ::

η π β β

π π β β

π β π

+ +

∆

−

∆ +

− +

=

−

x¶N>V+NQP_SDK¦]+P{cV+NCP+!\!wZ<IqZ¾x{g¢KON>Ï/ÀANCP+NN ]_{g]]_!N\NcUUIMIONZQ]¯\U]_!N>Z\~IqZ{K\ZNcd

(11)

]_Ny{KMIO}Iz]d¥\U]_NILZDP]_V_SD~NZB]+PS/P+N}¥ILZ]_NwH¡>V'NmV+NQP'P+I§\ZPå"o;\VuN{=Nch\mNcZ\7S/Py{VIO{c¢KONIMZ

]_NILZUKO{g]IL\Z~NQS{g]IL\Z`7~NU_ILV'P]]NQP]/U_\V)]_!N1®Y\ILZQ]9PW]{å]IpP_]I§Q{KDP+ILmZIMUIO{ZN\UD]_NIqZP]_VSªNZQ]+PåQkP9IWP

P+NN[ZILZ»x{c¢KON¹Ï`uNghBNc7]TU_\V]_N2ILZUKO{g]IL\Z ]{cVmN]_`1]N2ILZDP]_VS~NZQ]+P{cZ>¢N¼\"ZDP+IO}NcVYN}{QPm\\}

V+N}ILg]\7V*P\U)]_!NNch\mNcZ\7S/Py"{cV+IO{¢KONQPå7v+Z}NN}`"]_Nnpy"{[KeSNQP?\"U]_!N¡o;IWP+NcV1]NBP]9{V+NJKLNQPP¶]_!{[ZÐ

{cZ!}]_IWPILZ}QSNQP¶]_!N¡V+N®*Ng]IL\Zª\"U/]_NZQSKMKD7d!\!]_!NQP+IP4\UZ\=\"V_V+NcKO{g]_IL\Z¢"Ng]WNNZ]_!NJNhKM{Z!{g]\"V_d

y{VIO{c¢KONQP {[Z!}]_!NILZDP]_VSªNZQ]+På¥oDSV]_!NcV+`2~N {cKed ]_!N {cVm{cZ ]NQP_]]_\ PYNN ~Ng]_!NcV@]_N

ILZDP]_VS~NZQ]+P?{Z¢N\"ZP+IM}NV+N}={7PuNch\mNcZ!\!S/På"kP9]_NJny"{[KeSNQP?\U]_N]NQP]+P?{cV+NJILmNcV]_!{cZ¹Ð `

N\"Z!KzS}N]_{g]]_NIqZP]_VS~NZQ]+P1{cV+NILZ}NcNZ!}NZQ])\"UD]_NNVV\VD]NcVILZJ]_NILZUKO{g]I§\"Z~NQS{g]_IL\ZDP

!"

À¾NZ\7 Ngh"{ILZNJ~IO[\U1]_!Nw]Ww\=y{cV+IL{c¢KON7P4 p]_NZ\ILZ{K\ZNcdn_mV+\!T]_=V+{']N\V]_NV+N{K

~\Z!Ncdnm{cTIWP]_N=~\DP]#ILZU_\"V+~{]IeyN={c¢"\!S]uUMS]WSVYNILZU_KO{g]IL\"Z)vZ¹]_IWP¡yIONg`~NNcVU_\"V+ \7S7]n_\"U_n

P+{~KMNV+N}IOg]IL\"ZP7À¾NU_{BN~P+\NT}IqUUIOgSDK¦]IONQPuILZ=}\IqZ«m2PSª{Z=NchNcVY[IWPYNU_\V¶]_N~\K§NP+{~KON

P+ILZN`U_\"VPY\"N\!SZB]_VILN7P+`7]_NV+N{cV+NZ!\}{']{U_\V)]_N\ZNcdª{cmmVYNcm{g]N

Ò

UWV+\5]_NNcVI§\}~\U]_!N

ILZQ]_V+\}QS']_IL\"Zª\U)]_!NsSV+\/o;\"V/]_IMP9V+N{QPY\"Z!`\7S]n_\"U_nPY{KON¡U_\V+N{!P_]+P9{cV+N\7S]N}~U_\"V9{JPYN[KON]IL\Z

\U=\7SZQ]_VI§N!P kSP_]_VIL{`¡RNZª{cV£`¡o/VY{cZN`Jv]{cKed`]WN ªNg]_NcV+KO{Z}PY`\V{cd`ª!N}NcZA{Z}@]_N

twZIz]N} $wILZm}\=À<N\ZP+IO}NcV]Ww\J]Wd«NQP9\U)!\"V+I«\ZP¶VYN[K§Ny"{ZQ];U_\"V¶\"ZNg]{Vd\KqIOcdP+\Vp]nM]NcV

{cZ!} KL\Z«mnp]NcV \VIB\ZPåkPT{Z IMKLKeSP_]_V+{g]_IL\Z \U¡P+!\"V_]_nVSZ¼V+N}7IOg]_IL\ZDP+`~N=\"7S]N=\ZNnQS{cV]NcV

{c!NQ{}5U_\"V+N{QP]+Påo;\7V]_!NKL\Z7mNV¥]_ILªNC\V+IB\ZPY`¡~N,\ZP+IL}NcV¼\"Z!Nnd!N{cV¼{cZ}@]W~\npd"N{cV¼{cNB{}

V+N}ILg]IL\ZP#9x¶N¹U_\V+N{QP]+P{cV+N2\7S]N}¿\!y"NcV]_N2NcVIL\}UWV+\" ]_7VY\!Sm | Ï )À¾N

{QP*P+N7P'P]_!N P]{g¢IOKMIz]_d,\U]_N2V+NKO{g]_IL\ZDP+IqDPwV+Ncy{IMKOILZm>SZB]ILK Ñ Ï,U_\"VT]_N¹NcV+IL\}{[UM]NV

kT\V+}ILZ7mKqd!`]_NU_\"VYN{7P]+P?{cV+N¡¢"{!PYN}=\Z]_NwN!P_]_IL{c]NQP4V+NQPYNcZQ]N}=ILZ]_!NJV+NN}"ILZm P+Ng]IL\ZP?{[Z}

\ZJ]_NT{g]WS{Ky{KeSN!P4\U)]_!NJNchKO{Z{g]\7Vd~y"{cV+IM{c¢KONQPå!\"VYNPNIqU_IOB{[KLKLd`"]_!NJU_\"VYN{QP_]+P{V+N\!¢«]{cILZN}

UWV+\5]_!NNQP]ILª{g]I§\"Z~\UD]_NU_\KLKL\7~ILZmªNQS{g]IL\ZPm

( ) ( )

( )

^$% ^$%^& ^$% ^$'%^& ^& ^$% ^$% ^& ^$'% ^&

&

$%

$% ( (

η π β ε

β

π π β β

π β π

+ +

+

− +

=

−

− −

−

)

* +

,

-

.

- / 021143

52687

( ) ( )

(

^; ^9': ^; ^9: ^; ^9: ^;^9':

)

^; ^9: ^;^9: ^; ^9: ^9: ^;

9:

<

< ==

η π β β

π π β β

π β π

+ +

∆

−

∆ +

− +

=

−

− ^>

?

@ A

?

B

C

0214D3

EGFH2IH J

K

L M

N

O

=

^P FHQHSRUTUVXW 5 TH 7 H!YSZ 5 TUVX[ 6 R 01143

5267

0214D3

5 IH]\IHSRH 6 TH 7 V6 P

5_^a`Hcbad

e fhgjiklimnmg!oqprqskl!imnmt!imuowvnxioyz{pXysg}|zm"gg!sp~!is~2p'myg!ionxs4i_mpXysug |mg!oxz"s4g}|i4!ig4pXl!4pt!iu|xi