a p p o r t
d e r e c h e r c h e
ISRNINRIA/RR--6115--FR+ENG
Thème COG
INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE
Some applications of l ∞ -constraints in image processing
Pierre Weiss — Gilles Aubert — Laure Blanc-Féraud
N° 6115
November 2006
l
∞ !" #$"%'&)(+*,*!(.-/(0&21,1.3546&)727)(0189:;(0*=<>35?A@B9*,(.CD7)@FEGIHJLK+*M@F9N
OQPSR=TVUW$XY[Z]\_^a`cbdR!TVU!`fe=gihijlkmbnkmop`
q;rdgistUbn`$uArdkwvIjBv
xAvIySyFgirdbfz_U'rdU,e{PSU=r{e{PSU|j~}SiMZAg iU!TFU=rAI+i'Z]iDylvihiU!`
!=Sii Xlr$hig+vikjbnPSk`fylvIyFU=rfkw`Qbnghik iU'vIhig+rdkbdPST`#ogirATDkjSkTVk!kjShh+U=jSU!rdkweLrdU!hiSwvIrnk=kjSh
oljlebnkg+jlvIw`Sjlz_U!r;v
l∞eg+jl`tbnrnvikj0b, Uf`dPSg¡¢bdPlvIb5TVvija^ewvi`n`ckwe=viaTDg_z_U!`5l`ckjShLbdgibnvi_ Mvirdkwvbnkg+j e!vIjBU`tb{vbdU,zljlz_U=rfbdPSkw`QogirnTvIk`dT5ufTVgijlhgIbdPlU=r{`$vIrnUAbnPSUx$lzSkj
XL`dPSU=r
¤£
vbnU=TVk~TDg_z_U!2¥lbdPSU
BV −l1 TDg_z_U!2¥bnPSU
BV −l∞ TVg_z_U=vIjlz§¦6U!^iU!r!¨`e=vircbngagijF©AbnUªabdSrnUz_U!e=giTVyFg+`dkmbnkg+j«TVg_z_U!2
OQPlU=j¡#U'z_U,`de=rdkBU'vhiU!jSU=r{vIeg+ja iU=rnhiU!j0bvIhig+rdkbdPlT¬bdg`cg+ +U`dle{PySrdg+SU=T`=OQPSkw`$vIhig+rdkbdPlT®k`
bnPSULySrdgistU!ebdU!z`cSlhir{viz_kU=j0bzSU!`neU=j0b,«U¯ljlvI^hik iUAjaSTVU!rdkwe=viBrnU!`dSbn`;bdPlvIbQ`dPSg¡°bdPlUL±0lvikbdkU!`
vijlzDkTVkmb{`5gio~g+Sr5TVg_z_U=w`!¥0vijlzD¡#UQb{vie{²aUQbnPSUA±0SU,`tbnkg+jgIoFbdPSUl`cU$gio~bdPSU$bngIb{vIS vIrnkwvbdkgijDbngbdrnU!vb
Fgiljlz_U!zjSg+k`dU!`Q`dle{P6vi`$±0lvij+bnk,vbnkg+jjSg+k`dUi
³6´0µ~¶n·¸ ¹i
l∞jlgirnT¥IbdgIb{vIS virdkwvbnkg+jTVkjSkTVk!vIbdkgij¥+Bg+Sjlz_U,zVjSgikw`cU,`=¥+z_lvIkbt^i¥+±0lvij0bdk!vbnkg+j jlgikw`cU+¥SegiTVySrnU!`n`dkg+jjSg+k`dUi¥_ySrngIstU,ebnU!z`cSlhir{viz_kU=j0b$z_U!`neU!j+b,
º®»$¼V»$½' =#¿¾$½#=$
l
∞$À{f$
¾ÂÁt="$
ÃÄ !ÅÆ Ä AÇ vijl`5e=U$rnviySyBg+rcbz_U$rnU!e{PSU!rne{PlUi¥IjSg+l`ySrnÈ!`dU=j0bdg+jl`ySl`dkU!Srn`TVg_z_R!U,`5z_U$rnU!`cbnvIlrnvIbdkgij
g+ÉzSUzSÈ!eg+TVyBg0`ckbdkgij°z¨kTvIh+U!`±0Sk$g+j+bwvÂylvIrdbdkwelvirdkbdÈz_UopvIkrdU6viySylvIr{vMÊwbdrnUSjSU6eg+j+bnrnvikj0bnU
l∞.fg+l`TVg+j+bnrdg+jl`±0SUËyll`dkU=Sr{`TVg_z_R=U!`Dewvi`n`dk±0SU,`'_bdkk`nvIj0bwv6 vIrnkvIbdkgijÂbngIbnviUyBU!S iU!j+b
`!¨Uª_ySrnkTVU=r`cg+l`eU=bcbnUogirnTVUiqvIrnTDkz¨vI_bnrdU,`=¥jSgiB`'rdU=bdrngiS +gijl`UËTVg_z_R=Uz_Ux$lz_kj
XL`cPSU!r
£
vbnU=TVk2¥;U,`TVg_z_R!U,`
BV −L1 Ub BV −L∞¥#vIkjl`ckQ±0SUUTVgazSR=Uz_Uz_È,egiTVyFg+`dkmbnkg+jÌz¨SjSU kTvIh+UU=jÌhiÈ!giTVÈbnrdkUU=bbnUªabdSrnUzSUÍD5¦6U=^+U=r,«Agil`DTVkjlkTVkw`cg+jl`DSjSUogijlebdkgijSjSU!Uegija +Uª_U
zSUrnÈ=h+SwvIrnk`nvbnkg+j¥;`dgil`e=gij0bdr{vIkj0bdU!`
l∞ÎAgil`ËTDg+j0bdrngijl`V±0¨SjSU.z_U,`de=U=j0bdU6z_U6`dgil`
h+rnv+z_kU=j0b
ylrdgistUbdÈyFU=rnTVUbz_UrdÈ,`cg+lz_rnUe=U'ySrngiSR=TVUz_U'TvIjlkR!rdUe=gija iU!rdh+U=j0bdU+5fgiB`fz_gijljSgijl`$¯ljlvIU=TVU!j+b
yll`dkU=Sr{`rdÈ,`cSbnvIbn`jaSTVÈ=rnk±0SU,`±+lk_TDg+j0bdrnU=j0b±0SU!±0SU,`±0lvIkmbnÈ!`UbkTVkbdU,`z_U!`TVg_z_R=U!`È=bdlzSkÈ,`=
Agil`#¯ljlk`n`cg+jl`#ylvIrQTVgij0bdrnU=rQ±0SULv vIrnkvIbdkgijbngIbnviULj¨U!`cbyBvi`#bdg+stgiSr{`vogijBebdkgijljSU=ULwvySl`
v+zSvIySbdÈ=UÏVwvVrnÈ=hilvirdkw`dvIbdkgijz¨kTvIh+U!`$U!j+b{Ðie{PSÈ!U!`$z_USrdlkmb{`$Bg+rdjlÈ!`ÑpSrdlkmb{`Az_Ue=giTVySrnU!`n`ckgijBÒ¥SUb
±0SU'z_U,`QogijBebdkgijljSU=U,`Qkw`n`dvij+bnU!`yFU=S +U=j0bAz_gijljSU=rfz_U,`QrdÈ,`clmb{vbn`Qyll`A`dvIbdkw`topvik`nvIj0bn`!
ÓÔ¸ , ¶ iÕÄ Ö jSg+rdTVU
l∞¥ATVkjSkTDkw`nvbdkgijÖz_U wv× virdkwvbnkg+jØbdgibnvIUi¥ASrdlkmb{`FgirnjSÈ,`=¥flrdSkbn`z_U e=giTVySrnU!`n`ckgij¥0lrdSkbn`$zSU±+BvIj0bdk¯Be=vIbdkgij¥SzSlvIkmbnÈi¥Sz_U,`de=U=j0bdU'z_U`dgiB`
hir{viz_kU=j0bySrdgistUbnÈ
ÙÚÛÜÝ{ÞiÞ~ßáàpâ{Ýã)àpÚäSåVÚtæ
l∞çâ{ÚIäSåã2ènÝàéälã2åàéä>àéÛÝ=ê0ÜQÞ~èdÚ!â{Üå{å{àéäaê
ëÔ$
ìîíï
! ¸ ¹ÅI,ð¸ ï ñ
òôó ¸ !_,ð¸ ï V ï ¹Ø¹ ´+õ ï ð!ð¸ ï ö
Sô\_yBU,ek¯BejSgIb{vbnkg+jl`Ë'''''L''''''L'''''''L'
S÷xfU!e=viw`QgIoeg+ja iUªvijlvI^_`ckw`ø''L''''''L'''''''L' ù
S Ç
kw`de=rdU=bdk!vbnkg+jgiobnPSU'z_kúFU!rdU!j+bnkvigiyFU=r{vbngir{`û'''L'''''''L' ü
ýÿþ
ðp! ´ ï ´ ï
¹ÎÅ
ï
ðÅ ´ ï ´ , ¸ ´ ¸ ÕpÅ!ð¸ ï ¸ ¸ Õ´ Æ
ìpì
l5ªakw`cbdU=jBeU'gIovV`cg+Sbdkgij®'''L''''''L'''''''L'
l÷AgijSjSkw±0SU=jlU!`n`QgIobnPSU`dgi_bdkgijl`.L''''''L'''''''L'
ô ð´0· ¸ ´ ¸,´ I ´ ¹Î!ÅlS¹ð´ ï
¹ ´ , ´ ï
ì
OQPlU'ySrdkjle=kySUgIobdPSUvih+girnkmbnPSTø'L''''''L'''''''L' +
Ag¡ÎbngËe{PSg+`dUAbnPSU`dU!±0SU=jBeU
{tk}! ''''''L'''''''L' +
÷q;rdg+hir{vITVTVkjShVvi`dyFU!eb{`$vIjlzeg+TVyS_bdkjShVbnkTVU6'''L'''''''L' M
ñ ï ´+· ¸ ÕpÅ!ð¸ ï ¸§Ó|´0µF´ "D+_M ¸¸ ï$# ´ ,Å ´ ¹ ´ ¸ Æ ;¸ !ðp!ð¸ ï ¸ Õ´ Æ ìaý
S u[lrdkUoySrnU!`dU=j0bnvIbdkgijgiobnPSU'TVg_z_U=Ë''''''L'''''''L' ,
S W#lrdrnU=j0b$jaSTVU=rnke!vIvIylySrdg0vie{PSU,`D'L''''''L'''''''L'
S÷q;rdkjlekySUvIjlzkTDylU!TDU!j0bnvbnkg+jgIog+Sr$TVUbnPSg_z ''L'''''''L' M
S ASTVU=rnke!vIkTVySU!TVU=j0bnvIbdkgij°''L''''''L'''''''L' ,
S÷xfU!`dSmb{`Q'L'''''''L''''''L'''''''L' ù
ö&%!ð
ï
¹ÅlÕpð
µ ¸ ¸ Õ
B´ lp ¸ Õ´ Æ× ì'
l OQPlU
BV −lp TVg_z_U=~''''L''''''L'''''''L' ,ü
l÷OQPlU
BV −l1 TVg_z_U=''''L''''''L'''''''L' +
(*) ðp+ 𸠤¸ Ë ¸ Å ï ¹ ´ ¹ ï ¸ ð2 ´ -,
ò.
ù_*/AjSkw±+lU=jSU,`d`$giobnPSU`cg+Sbdkgij[''L''''''L'''''''L'
ù_ /AjSkogirnT¿¡$PSkbdU'jSg+k`dU10bdPSU32QvM^+U!`dkvij'stl`cbdk¯Be=vIbdkgij°'L'''''''L' +
ù_ 4BvIj0bdk!vIbdkgijjlgikw`cUrnU=TVg vIø''L''''''L'''''''L' +
ù_ ASTVU=rnke!vIz_U=bnvikw`.'''''L''''''L'''''''L' +
' 5 ¸ ï +ÕpÅ!ð¸ ï ý
6 ;´ ï ¹ð ýì
A
çJLK
ÙÚÛÜÝ{ÞiÞ~ßáàpâ{Ýã)àpÚäSåVÚtæ
l∞çâ{ÚIäSåã2ènÝàéälã2åàéä>àéÛÝ=ê0ÜQÞ~èdÚ!â{Üå{å{àéäaê
T U
¾»;
V jÂbnPSkw`ylviyBU!r¡UvIrnUkj0bnU=rnU!`cbdU!z«kj¢v6ewvi`n`'gioQkTvIh+UËrdU,`tbngir{vbnkg+j«vijlz§z_U!e=giTVyFg+`dkmbnkg+j«TVg_z_U!`
bnPlvbAe!vIjBU'¡$rnkbcbdU!jljlz_U=rfbdPSU'h+U=jSU!rnviBog+rdTW0
uinf∈KJ(u) Ñci,Ò
¡$kbdP
K z_U¯BjSU!zvi`X0
K={u∈Z,||u−f||∞≤α} ÑciiÒ
AU=rnU
f kw`vh+k +U=jDgil`dU=rn iU,zzSvIbnvl
Ze=vijrnU=ylrdU,`cU!j+b5vij0^'gioBbnPSUQbt¡gzSk`nernUbnUQ`dylv+eU!`L0
X =Y n
g+r Y =X×X X kw`bdPSU'z_kw`de=rdU=bdU`cyBvieULgIokTvihiU!`Ñpkj¡$PSkwe{Pe!vi`dU
n=nxny
kw`#bdPSUjaSTFU=r$gio
ylkmª_U=w`{Ò
Y kw`QvzSk`nernUbnU`dylvie=Ugio
2−D +U!ebdgir#¯lU!zS`Ñbt^0ylke!vI^Vhir{vizSkU!j+b{`nÒ
£
kjlvI^i¥
J :Z→ Y
kw`$vVeg+j0 +UªoSjBebdkgij
V j>bdPSUD vi`cbkmbdbdU=r{vbnSrnUz_U! igIbnU!zbngz_U!jSgikw`dkjShbdU,e{PSjSkw±+lU!`0^g+y_bdkTVk,vbdkgij¥BoU!¡|TVg_z_U=w`Akj
e=girnyBg+rnvIbdU
l∞ jSgirnT`=#XjlU'gIobdPSU'rnU!v+`cg+jl`k`QbnPlvbAbdPSU
l∞ jSg+rdT¿k`$jlgIbAz_kúFU!rdU!j0bdkwvISUi¥lvijlzbdPal`
zSk[ZËelmb$bngDPBvIjlz_UBgibdPjaSTVU=rnke!vI^ËvijlzbdPSU!girnUbdkwe=vi^i«U'¡$k`dPSg¡ØbdPlrdg+ShiPSg+_bQbdPSkw`QylviyBU!r!¥
bnPlvb$g+SrQogirnTSwvbnkg+jv+ebdBvI^Ëe=g iU=r{`v¡$kwz_Ur{vIjSh+Ugiol`dUoSvIySySkwe=vbnkg+jl`!E\Ubfl`Qh+k +ULvDSrnkU=o
g +U=rn akU!¡'
£
krn`cb!¥I¡$PlU=jVz_U!vikjShL¡$kmbnPjSg+k`dU!`gioBFgiSjlzSU!zDvITVySkmbnlz_Ui¥IbdPSUf¦.vIª_kTST|vAqg0`tbnU=rnkg+rdk~Ñp¦.uAq#Ò
ylrdkjlekySU6jlvbnSr{vI^×U!v+zS`Dbdg§g+y_bdkTVk,vbnkg+jÉylrdg+SU!T`V¡$kmbnP
l∞ egijB`tbnrnvikj0bn`!Î\ale{P°jSg+k`dU!`DornU
±0SU!j0bd^ËvIySyFU!virQvIoébdU!rQe=giTVySrnU!`n`ckgij
£
girQkjB`tb{vIjle=ULkj0bdU!jl`ckbt^girQ¡QvM iU!U=begaU]Ze=kU!j0b$±0lvij0bdk!vbnkg+j
U!v+zËbng`cle{PFgiSjBz_U!zjSg+k`dU!`!OQPSk`Q¡$kBUbnPSUbdg+ySkwegio`dU!ebdkgijÂÑ
7Ò
OQPSUTVgazSU=Ñti!Ò5kjle=Bz_U!`vIjSgibdPSU!r#e=v+`d`giovIySylkwe=vIbdkgijl`giohirnU!vIb;kj0bnU=rnU!`cb;kjkTvIh+UfySrng_eU!`n`
kjShB5¦.vIja^TVg_z_U!`Ql`dUbdPlUbdgIb{vI virdkwvbnkg+jv+`$vVySrdkgirQg+jbnPSU'kTVvihiU,`=5OQPSkw`f±0lvij+bnkmbt^`cg+TDU!PSg¡
TVU,vi`dSrdU,`bnPSU$g+`nekvIbdkgijl`gIo~vIjDkTvIh+Ui6V¤b¡Qvi`kj0bdrngazSleU,za^x$lzSkj¥_XL`cPlU=rvIjlz
£
vIbdU!TDkÑ2xfX
£ Ò
kj_^i+`v+`$vVrdU!hiSwvIrnk!kjlhDe=rdkbdU!rdkgijogirfkTvIhiU'z_U!jSgikw`dkjShBaV¤bn`$Tvikjkj+bnU=rnU!`cb$kU!`$kjbdPSUopvieb$bnPlvb
kb5rnU=hilvirdk=U,`bnPSU$kTVvihiU,`¡$kmbnPSgi_b5lSrnrnkjShLbnPSU$U!z_h+U!`!E/`ckjShLbdPlUQbdPSU!girn^gIoz_lvikbt^b^!+`¤¥i¡U$e=vij
`dPSg¡ bdPBvbTVkjSkTDk=kjShbdPSUbdgibnvI vIrnkvIbdkgij6SjBz_U=rv
lpegijB`tbnrnvikj0b!¥Fe=vij.BUrdU=ogirnTSwvbnU!zSjBz_U=r og+rdTÑti!Ò;OQPSkw`QyBg+kj0bfkw`$z_Ub{vIkU!zkj`dU!ebdkgijÂÑ
6Ò
ÍD¦6U!^iU=r'kjc^!ü+`;kjl`dySkrdkjShorngiT bnPSUËTVg_z_U=;gIofx$lz_kj¥5XL`cPlU=rvIjBz
£
vbnU=TVkd^I+`¤¥ySrdg+yBg0`cU,z
vVjlU=¡[TVgazSU=bngz_U,egiTVyFg+`dUbdPSUkTvihiU!`Qkj0bdgËylkU,eU=¡$kw`dU`cTVgagIbnPoSjlebnkg+jl`ÑbdPSUDe=vircbng0g+jgIobdPSU
kTvIh+U!`{Òvijlz«g+`nekwvbnkjlholjlebnkg+jl`ËÑébnPSUbnUªabdSrnUgir'jlgikw`cUMÒË«U¡$k;`dPSg¡ kj§`dU!ebnkg+jÉÑ
5ÒLbnPlvb
bnPSkw`$TVgazSU=e=vijvi`dgVBU'rnUog+rdTSwvbdU,zËSjBz_U=r$og+rdTÑti!Ò
\ag+ akjShËySrngilU!T Ñci!Ò$jaSTVU!rdkwe=vi^kw`jSgIbvIj6U!v+`c^bnv+`c²~AOQPlUz_g+TVvikj
K Plvi`jSg+j.`cTVgagIbnP
FgiljlzSvIrn^.vIjBz>¡UVTVvi²iUVjSg6vi`n`dSTVy_bdkgijl`Lgioz_kúFU!rdU!j0bdkwvISkkbt^.g+j
JËOQPSUVySrngIstU,ebdU,z `dSSh+rnv+z_k
U!j0bz_U!`neU!j+bTDU=bdPSg_ze^i`k`v6yBg¡U=rdoSbng0g+5bng.`cg+ +UË`cle{PÂh+U=jSU!rdkweVySrngiSU=T`!«UËrdU! akU!¡/kbn`
ylrdg+yBU!rcbnkU,`gIoeg+j0 +U=rnhiU!jleUQvIjlzVg+y_bdkTvIkmbt^DvIjlz`dPSg¡ÉPSg¡ÌbdgvIylyS^Dkb5bdg'bnPSUAviBg +UTVU!j+bnkg+jSjSU,z
ylrdg+SU!T`=
A
çJLK
¦.vija^§gIoAbnPSUkzSU!vi`Vylrdg+yBg0`cU,z§kjÌbdPlk`yBvIyFU=rvIrnUjlgIbjSU=¡'ÉOQPSgilhiP¢¡U6ewvIkT bdPlvIb`cg+TVU
g+rdkhikjlvie=gij0bdrnkl_bdkgijl`virdUDySrnU!`dU=j0b'kj bdPSkw`'ylviyBU!r!1/A`dkjShvySrngIstU,ebnU!z>`dSSh+rnv+z_kU=j0bzSU!`neU=j0bbdg
g+y_bdkTVk!UjSgijBz_kmú~U=rnU=j0bnkviSUoljlebnkg+jlvIw`gio0kTvIhiUylrdg_eU,`d`dkjShQ¡v+`jSgIb{vIS^Aylrdg+yBg0`cU,zAkjf^,_¥iù0¥!-`)
XlrËTvIkj eg+j+bnrdkS_bnkg+j°PSU=rnU.TVkh+P0bFU>vIjÎU,vi`dk^¢kTVySU=TVU=j0bnviSU z_U=¯ljSkbdkgijØgIo'bnPSU>z_kw`nernUbdU
`dSSh+rnv+z_kU=j0bn`!¥_vIjlzvDrdU,vIk`cbdkweLrdU! 0kU=¡ÖgIobdPSU±0lvikbdkU!`$vijlzkTVkmb{`$gIobdPSkw`$TVUbnPSg_z
uW#PlvITBg+UkjÉylviyBU!rg^ù+`)¥Q`cg+ +U!z×bdPSU6ySrngilU!T gIo'x$X
£
l`ckjSh§z_lvikbt^iefkw`jaSTVU=rnkwe=vI
TVU=bdPSg_zÉk``dPSg¡$jÌbdgÂFU.egija +U=rnhiU=j0b,¥;vIjlzÌ¡girn²a`DkjÉviTVg0`tbrnU!vIQbnkTVUh^ü+`¤ \akjBeUbdPlU=jØ`cg+TVU
U=úFg+rcb{`$¡U=rnULTv+z_U'bdgB`cUzSlvIkmbt^kj6TVg+rdU'h+U=jSU!rnviySrdg+SU=T`=ufTVgijlhgIbdPlU=rf¡girn²_`=¥_UbAB`AekbdU
bnPSUfylviyBU!r;a^1ilj2U,eb#vijlzvI)^+`F¡$PSU=rnU$bnPSUAvISbdPSg+rn`h+U=jSU!rnvik=UQbnPSUAvih+girnkmbnPSTÔgiou_W#PBvITFgiU
og+rv§¡$kwz_U«ewvi`n`gIo
l1 ylrdg+SU!T`Ëkjlelz_kjSh¢z_U,eg+j0 +gi_bdkgij¥g+rFU!`cblv+`ckw`ySlrn`dSkb!ÔuAjSgIbnPSU=r h+U=jSU!rnvik!vIbdkgij¡Qvi`fh+k +U=j6a^6O
£
W#PlvIj>Ub!vI)fkjk^+`¤¥F¡U=rnU'bnPSUDvi_bdPlgir{`fl`dUz_lvikbt^bdg`cg+ +U
`dgiTVUySrdg+SU=T`Akja ig+ akjSh`dU!eg+jlz6g+rnz_U!rArnU=h+Svirdk=kjSholjlebnkg+jlvIw`=XV j.FgIbnP>¡girn²_`$bdPlgiSh+P¥~bdPSU
vi_bdPlgir{`vIrnUfegijB`tbnrnvikjSU,zbngl`dU
l2zSvIbnvL¯BzSU=kmbt^bdU!rdT`!XSr#egij0bnrdkS_bnkg+jDPlU=rnUi¥ikw`bnPlvb#¡#Uf`dPSg¡
Plg¡ÎbdgviySyS^z_lvikbt^Ëog+rfvIja^
lpjlgirnT
x$U,eU!j+bn^Ì`cg+TDU6vih+girnkmbnPST`B`ckjSh«bdgibnvI$ virdkwvbnkg+j¢¡U=rnUySrngiyFg+`dU!z×bdgÂrnU!z_le=UbdPSU.vircbnkmopv+ebn`
rnU!`dSbdkjShÂorngiT bnPSU>e=giTVySrnU!`n`ckgij°vIhig+rdkbdPST`!Ö\~Or{vITVkjSkfUb, vi2 kjl^IüS¥m-`)¥$ySrngiyFg+`dU!z¢bdg
TVkjSkTDk=U.bdPSUbngIbnvif vIrnkvIbdkgijÉSjlz_U!rv
l∞eg+jl`cbdr{vIkj+bVbng§rdU,z_leUbnPSU.vIrdbdkopviebn`gioXi+qn#Y'ii+
e=giTVySrnU!`n`ckgij
£
~ufbdU!rU=b!Avi2fkjo^`ySrdg+yBg0`cU,zbdgËTVkjSkTDk=UbdPSUbdgibnvI vIrnkvIbdkgijbdgrdU,z_leUbdPSU
zSk`cbdg+rcbnkg+jl`gIobnPSU3i+qn#Y/egiTVySrnU!`n`dkg+j«U±0SU!`cbdkgijbdPlU'l`cUgiobdPlUbdgIb{vI vIrnkwvbdkgij¥Svi`QvDySrdkgir
¡$PlU=j°z_U!vikjSh«¡$kmbnP°zSk`cbdg+rcbnkg+jl`DgIoFgiljlz_U!zÉvITVySkbdlz_U+¥vijlzÉ`cPSg¡½bdPlvIbËU!vi`dkU=rVz_kmú~U=rnU=j0bnkviSU
ylrdkgir{`Q`cg+TDU=bdkTVU!`QU!vizbdgFUbdbdU!rfrdU,`clmb{`=
V¤bkw`jlgIbbnPSU¯lr{`tbDvbcbnU=TVy_bbng>`dgi iUVͦ6U=^+U=r,¨`'zSU!eg+TVyBg0`ckbdkgij§ySrngilU!Tu$e{²ajSg¡$U!z_h+U!z
`dgi_bnkg+jl`e=vijÌFUogiSjBzÌkjp^ ¥#a¥A `¤ÎOgÂg+Sr²ajSg¡$U,z_hiU+¥;g+SrVogirnTSwvbnkg+jÌgioAÍD;¦6U=^+U=r,¨`
zSU!eg+TVyBg0`ckbdkgijTVgazSU=kw`$jSU=¡'¥S`dkTDylU+¥lvIjlze=giSwzU!v+zËbngVbdPSUzSU!`dkh+jgioopvi`cbAvIhig+rdkbdPlTV`!
£
kjlvI^+¥SvIjlzbdPlvIbTVkhiP0bFUbdPSUTvIkjeg+j0bdrnkSSbdkgijgiobdPSkw`QylviyBU!r!¥0¡#ULhik iULvh+U=jSU!rnvilor{vITVU
¡girn²VogirQbnPSU'ySrngiSU=T`Qgiobt^ayBUËÑci!Ò
q r
'®¾ ¾s{
tvu@w xy{z}|~X|$da 6.~@d
\Ub$l`fzSU!`nernkFULbdPSU'jSgibnvIbdkgijl`Q¡Ul`cULbnPSrdg+ShiPlgi_bQbdPlk`$yBvIyFU=r,
«U¯lr{`tbfrnU=TVkjlzËbnPlvb
X=Y n¥ Y =X×X vIjlz Z e=vijFUvIja^ËgiobnPSg+`dULbt¡#g`dylvie=U!`!
uAlbdPSUQbnPSU=g+rd^Dz_U= +U=giyFU!zkjDbdPlk`;ylvIyFU=r5viySySkU,`bdge=gigirkTVvihiU,`=Og`dkTVySko^bdPlUfjSgIb{vbnkg+jl`=¥
¡ULog_el`$g+jh+rnvM^_`ne=viUkTvIh+U!`!
f ∈Z kw`$vDhik iU!jzSvIbnvl¥SvIjlz
J :Z→Y k`AvDe=gija iU=ª¥0ylrdg+yBU!rQoSjlebnkg+j
£
gir u∈X¥ ui∈Y z_U=jSgibdU,`bdPSU'k
bnP6egiTVyFgijSU!j0bQgio
u
£
gir
g∈Y¥_bnPSU=j gi∈ Y 2 zSU=jSgibdU!`$bdPSU
i−theg+TVyBg+jSU=j0b$gIo
g¥Svijlz gi= (gi,1, gi,2)
ÙÚÛÜÝ{ÞiÞ~ßáàpâ{Ýã)àpÚäSåVÚtæ
l∞çâ{ÚIäSåã2ènÝàéälã2åàéä>àéÛÝ=ê0ÜQÞ~èdÚ!â{Üå{å{àéäaê
ù
<·,·>X
z_U!jSgIbnU!`QbnPSU'l`dlvI`ne=vivirylrdg_z_leb$gij
X £ g+r u, v∈X ¡#UPlvM +U0
< u, v >X:=
n
X
i=1
uivi
Ñ2_+Ò
<·,·>Y
z_U!jSgIbnU!`bdPlU'l`cBvI`ne=vIwvIrQySrng_z_lebQg+j
Y £ g+r g, h∈Y 0
< g, h >Y:=
n
X
i=1 2
X
j=1
gi,jhi,j
Ñ2_
Ò
| · |p¥ p∈[1,∞[ k`bnPSU lp jSgirnT½g+j
X 0
|u|p:= (
n
X
i=1
|ui|p)1/p Ñ2_iÒ
| · |∞
kw`QbdPSU
l∞ jlgirnT®gij
X 0
|u|∞= max
i∈{1,2,...,n}|ui| Ñ2_+Ò
|| · ||p
¥Sogir
p∈[1,∞[kw`fvDjSgirnT½g+j
Y z_U=¯ljSU!za^0
||g||p:= (
n
X
i=1
|gi|p2)1/p Ñ2_áùIÒ
uAjlz¯ljlvI^0
||g||∞:= max
i∈{1,2,...,n}|gi|2
Ñ2_ü+Ò
K kw`fveg+ja iUª`cU=bÑpvVlvikj.ve=U=rdbnvIkjTDU=bdrnke,ÒØPSU=j
Z=X¥ K k`stl`tbLvIjPa^0yFU=r{elBU'gio
¡$kwzabnP
2α¥le=U=j0bdU!rdU,zg+j
f
£
kjlvI^
bac¥_kw`QbdPlU'kj0bdU!hiU!ryBvIrdbQgio
a∈Y
tvut ez}| a@_nb|z a av~
´+õ ï ð!ð
¸ ï ò2ì ^q5rngiyFU=roSjlebnkg+j`ØuÔeg+ja iUªoSjlebdkgij
J g+j Z kw`Aylrdg+yBU!rfkmovIjlz6g+jS^ko
J k`jSgIb
kwz_U!j+bnke!vI^U!±0lvI~bng
+∞ vIjlzbdPlvIbfkmbAzSg0U,`QjSgIb$b{vI²+UbnPSU vISU
−∞gij Z
´+õ ï ð!ð
¸ ïØòQwòQ ^áW#gaU=r{ek 0kbt^`«u oSjBebdkgij
J :Z→Y kw`f`dvikzbdgVFUegaU=r{ek iUkoL0
||u||2→ ∞ ⇒J(u)→ ∞ Ñ)_+Ò
ü A
çJLK
´+õ
ï
ð!ð ¸
ï°òwýQ
^V jlz_kwe=vIbdg+r;oSjBebdkgij.`\U=b
K∈Z FUvjSg+jËU=TVy_bt^Ëe=g0`cU,ze=gija iU=ªV`dSl`dUbQgIo
Z
OQPlULkjlz_kwe=vIbdg+rQoSjlebnkg+jgIo
K¥Sz_U!jSgIbnU!z
χK
¥Skw`fz_U¯BjSU!za^0
χK(x) =
0 ko x∈K
∞ gibdPSU!rd¡$kw`dU
Ñ)_!0Ò
ko
K kw`$vVeg+TDyBviebf`dUb,¥_bdPSU!j
χK
kw`fegaU!rne=k +Ui
´+õ
ï
ð!ð ¸
ïÎòQ6
^\alFz_kú~U=rnU=j0bdkwvIvIjlz`dSShir{vizSkU!j+b`×OQPSU`clFz_kú~U=rnU=j0bdkwvIgIo
J vIbfyBg+kj0b
u∈Z¥
kw`$z_U=¯ljSU!za^0
∂J(u) ={η∈Z, J(u)+< η,(x−u)>Z≤J(x),∀x∈Z} Ñ2S+,Ò
η∈∂J(u)kw`fe!vIU,zvV`dSShir{vizSkU!j+b,
OQPSU`dS~z_kúFU!rdU!j+bnkvie=vijFUbdPlgiSh+P+b$giov+`bdPSU`dUb$gIoPa^ayBU!rdySwvIjlU!`ylvi`n`dkjShDbnPSrdg+ShiPyFgikj+b
u
¡$Plke{PËljlz_U=rnU!`cbdkTvbnUfbdPlUAoSjBebdkgij
J5XjyBg+kj0bn`#¡$PSU!rdU
J k`z_kúFU!rdU!j+bnkviSUi¥+bdPSU`clFz_kú~U=rnU=j0bdkwvI
rnU!zSleU,`bdgvV`ckjShiUbngij0bdPSUe=v+`d`dkwe=vI~h+rnv+z_kU!j0b!
´+õ ï ð!ð ¸ ïØòQwñQ ^\U!hiU=jBz_rdU
¤£
U=jle{PlU=W#gijstlh+vbnU`
\Ub GFUve=gija iU=ªVylrdg+yBU!rviySySke!vbdkgijordg+T
Z bng Y ∪ {∞}OQPSUeg+jstSh0vbdUoSjlebdkgijgIo
G
kw`$z_U=¯ljSU!za^0
G∗(u) = sup
x∈Z
(< x, u >Z−G(x)) Ñ2SMiÒ
G∗ kw`fvVeg+ja iUªËylrdg+yBU!rQoSjlebnkg+j5¦6g+rdU!g iU=r,¥0¡#UPlvM +U0
G∗∗=G
tvu $~@|.z.~ E.~ n¡.¢dzl£~¤3zQ.z6.~@ ny{zQ< 6n
Og`ckTVySkmo^bdPSU'jSgibnvIbdkgijl`!¥_¡#U'z_U!jSgIbnU
u(i, j)bnPSU' vISUgIo
ugijySkªaU!
(i, j)
Ogz_k`nernUbnk!ULbdPSU'h+rnv+z_kU!j0bQ¡Ul`dUbnPSUewvi`n`dke!vIF¯lr{`tb$gir{z_U!rQ`ne{PSU!TDUFgirnrdg¡U!zËordg+T¥^áù`¤
£
gir
u∈X 0
(∇u)(i, j) = ((∂1u)(i, j),(∂2u)(i, j)) Ñ)_!+Ò
∇ukw`$vIjU=U=TVU=j0bfgio
Y
(∂1u)(i, j) =
u(i+ 1, j)−u(i, j) ko i < nx
0 kmo i=nx
Ñ)_ Ò
(∂2u)(i, j) =
u(i, j+ 1)−u(i, j) ko j < ny
0 kmo j=ny
Ñ)_,+Ò
OQPSkw`fz_U=¯ljSkbdkgij6vIg¡f`;bngz_U¯ljlUbdPSUz_k iU!rdh+U=jle=Uylrdg+yBU!rd^Ëa^z_lvikbt^i¥_kTVyBg0`ckjSh0
<∇u, p >Y=−< u, div(p)>X
Ñ)_!0Ò
ÙÚÛÜÝ{ÞiÞ~ßáàpâ{Ýã)àpÚäSåVÚtæ
l∞çâ{ÚIäSåã2ènÝàéälã2åàéä>àéÛÝ=ê0ÜQÞ~èdÚ!â{Üå{å{àéäaê
«U¡$k~`dU=UbdPBvbQPlvM akjSh`cle{PvrnU=wvbnkg+jËk`#jSU,eU!`n`nvIrn^bngDe=giTVyS_bnUfbdPlUU=ª_v+eb$`clShir{viz_kU=j0b;gio
bnPSUz_kw`de=rdU=bdULoSjlebdkgijlvi2;\_kTVySUvIhiU!Srnvhik iU,`X0
(div(p))(i, j) =
p1(i, j)−p1(i−1, j) kmo 1< i < nx
p1(i, j) ko i= 1
−p1(i−1, j) kmo i=nx
+
p2(i, j)−p2(i, j−1) ko 1< j < ny
p2(i, j) ko j= 1
−p2(i, j−1) ko j=ny
Ñ)_MùiÒ
ØkbdPbnPSk`Az_k`nernUbnk,vbnkg+j¥a¡#U'e=vij6z_U¯ljlUbnPSUbdgibnvi vIrnkvIbdkgijv+`X0
J1(u) :=
n
X
i=1
|(∇u)i|2
Ñ)_!ü0Ò
uAjSgIbnPSU=rA±0lvij0bdkbt^ËgIokj0bdU!rdU,`tb$kjbdPSkw`$ylviyBU!r$k`QbnPSU'z_kw`de=rdU=bdk=U!zPa^ayBU!rn`dSrdopvie=Ugio
u 0 J2(u) :=
n
X
i=1
q
|(∇u)i|22+ 1 Ñ)_¦+Ò
OQPSg0`cULbt¡gDoSjlebnkg+jl`fvirdUeg+j0 +Uª
§ ¨e© $ ¾ »¼V»$$ [6ª =»Ë= | {«f
¬
T3¦T®
vu@w ¯°~@z}|z$n± ²@³.~
xfU=¡$rnkmbnkjShVySrngilU!T Ñt+!Òljlz_U=rfbdPSUog+rdT¥0
uinf∈Z{J(u) +χK(u)} Ñ2SI+Ò
¡$PSU!rdU
χK
k`5bdPSUkjBz_ke!vbngiroSjBebdkgijgIo
K¥+kmbk`#eU!vir5bdPBvb#ylrdg+SU!TÑ2SIiÒ5k`#egija +Uª¥iySrngiyFU=r vijlzegaU=r{ek iULgij
ZOQPal`!¥_¡U'U!vi`dk^h+Ub$bdPlU'Uª_k`cbdU!jleUgiovVTVkjlkTVk=U=r,
vut ´µ¶³d~@·³z6z}¸nf.¢zp@³~@d
ØPlU=j
J kw``cbdrnkwebd^ e=gija iU=ª¥¡UPlvM iUVSjSkw±0SU=jlU!`n`'gIofvTVkjlkTVk=U=r,¥S_bkjÂbdPSUh+U=jSU!rnvi5eg+j0 +Uª e!vi`dUi¥0¡#UhiU=bvDegija +Uª`cU=b#gIo`cg+_bnkg+jl`!«Ukl`cbdr{vbnUAkb#bnPSrngiSh+PvIjËU=ªSvITVySUAkj
1−DbnPlvb¡#U
`cbdBz_^ËwvbdU!r$kj
2−D Ub{vI²+U
Z=X¥ nx=n¥ ny= 1 vIjlz`dUb30
J(u) =
n−1
X
i=1
|ui+1−ui| Ñ2S_MÒ
, A
çJLK
OvI²+U
fi=i/(n−1)¥_¡$kbdP i∈ {0,2, ..., n−1}vIjlz α <0.5
OQPSUkj+bnU=rnySrnUbnvIbdkgij×gio$bdPSkw`DTVgazSU=Qk`bnPSUog+g¡$kjShk0Ë¡UvirdUgag+²0kjSh6og+rDbdPSUoSjlebdkgij¢gio
TVkjSkTVviz_kw`de=rdU=bdULbdgibnvi Mvirdkwvbnkg+j¥_eg+j+b{vIkjSU!zkjbnPSU'rnU!zbdSFUz_r{vM¡$jg+j
£
khiSrnUÑt,Ò
W#U!vird^i¥avIBTVg+jSgIbngijSg+l`kjlernU!v+`ckjSh`dU!±0SU!jleU,`;`nvbdkw`co^0kjSh'bnPSUegijB`tbnrnvikj0b!¥+hig+kjShordg+T
αvIjBz
virdrnk 0kjSh'bng
1−αPlvM iUAbdPSU'`nvITVUfbngIbnvi~ Mvirdkwvbnkg+j>Ñ
1−2αÒ¥SvIjBzvIrnU`dgi_bnkg+jl`;gioySrngilU!T
(+ )
£
khiSrnUj0YLrnU=U=j¹0zSvIbnvbdU!rdT
x$U!z¹0'SySyFU=rvijlz«g¡U=r'e=gijl`cbdr{vIkj0bn`
2SUËvijlz Sv+e{²o0bt¡g
yFg+`n`dkSU'`cg+Sbdkgijl`
º » ¼½ Ì6ª d¾$;$¾ »±«"¾$¾$$
«Uh+gËlvie{²bdgbnPSUh+U=jSU!rnviySrngiSU=T Ñt+!Ò
J kw`AvËhiU=jlU=r{vIySrngiyFU=regija +UªËoSjBebdkgij>gij
Z¥BvIjBz K kw`Qhik iU!ja^>ÑciiÒ
V jbdPlULyBvi`cboU!¡Ö^+U!virn`!¥+Tvij0^Uú~girdbn`QPlvM +UFU=U!jz_U,z_kwe=vbnU!zbdgDbnPSU'z_U!`dkh+jgioopv+`tbfvIhig+rdkbdPlTV`
bng`dgi iUQkTvihikjSh'ySrngiSU=T`!xfX
£
ylrdg+SU!TÔog+r5kjl`tb{vIjle=Ufe=vijjSg¡ÌFUA`dgi iU,zkjËvITVg+`cb;rnU!vIabnkTVU
^ü_¥+I¥M`)
/Aj_ogirdbdSjBvbdU!^+¥a¡#ULe=vIjljSgIbPSgiyFUL`dgi akjlhÑt+MÒ¡$kbdPvPSkhiPËr{vbnUAgioegija +U=rnhiU=jBeUfvi`#¡UATviz_U
jlgvi`n`dSTVy_bdkgijl`g+j
J UªSeU!y_b$egija +Uª_kmbt^+6V TvihikjSUfbnPlvb$¡UAPlvM +UvIjvIhig+rdkbdPST bnPlvbQhiU!jSU=r{vbnU!`;v
`dU!±0SU!jleU
{uk}bdPBvbfkw`$`cSylyBg0`cU,zËbngËvIySySrng+v+e{Pv`dgi_bdkgijgIoQÑti,Ò
u ewvi`n`dke!vI;rnU!`dSbDgioeg+ja iUªÂgiySbdkTDk!vIbdkgijµ^i+`QbdU=w`B`bnPlvbVjSg«kmbnU=r{vbnk +UTVUbnPSg_z
gijS^
B`ckjSh.bnPSU`cU,±+lU=jle=U!`
J(uk) vIjBz ∂J(uk) e=vij¢vie{PSkU= +Uv.FUbdbdU!rDr{vbnUËbnPlvIj O(1) 2
¥ogirDhiU!jSU=r{vI
e=gija iU=ªËTVkjSkTVk,vbnkg+jySrngilU!T Ñ
k`QbnPSUz_U,`ckrdU,zylrdU,ekw`ckgijBÒ
V¤o¡#UjSgIbnU
J¯bnPSUTVkjSkTST®gio#Ñt+!Ò¥SvIjlz
J¯k= mini∈{1,2,...,k}(J(ui))¥_kbQTDU,vIjl`;bdPBvbbdgDhiUb vySrnU!e=k`dkg+j
|J¯k−J¯| ≤¥vIja^6vIhigirnkbdPST ¡$krnU!±0SkrdU
k bngFUDgIo#g+rnzSU=r
bO(1)2 c Ñ2`cU!U±^I+`og+rLv TVg+rdUySrnU!e=k`dUL`cbnvIbdU!TDU!j0b{Ò
«UVySrdg+yBg0`cUkj>bdPSkw`ylviyBU!rbngB`cUbdPSUDySrngIstU,ebdU,z>`dSSh+rnv+z_kU!j0bTVUbnPSg_z6ogir¡$PSkwe{P.bnPSUeg+T
ylU=ªakbt^¢kw`Ë`dPSg¡$jÌbdg×FU O(1) 2
[\agÂbdPBvb!¥QjSg§TVU=bdPSg_zØe=vijÉzSg§BU=bcbdU!rËbnPlvIj°kbËogirËg+SrhiU!jSU=r{vI
ÙÚÛÜÝ{ÞiÞ~ßáàpâ{Ýã)àpÚäSåVÚtæ
l∞çâ{ÚIäSåã2ènÝàéälã2åàéä>àéÛÝ=ê0ÜQÞ~èdÚ!â{Üå{å{àéäaê
+
ylrdg+SU!T¥+SyËbdgvTSbdkySke!vbdk iUAopviebdgir,Ogl`cUAbdPSkw`;bdU!e{PljSk±0SU¡#UAjSU=U,zVbdgBULvISUfbngeg+TVyS_bdU
vÂ`dSSh+rnv+z_kU!j0bVvijlzÌbdPSUg5Bekz_U,vIj°ySrngIstU,ebdg+rVgij
KcV jÉbdPSU6jlUªab`cU,ebnkg+jl`V¡#U6`dPSg¡¿Plg¡½bdg e=giTVyS_bnU'`cSlhir{viz_kU=j0bn`!¦6girnU=g +U=r,¥IbnPSU{5le=kwz_U!vijySrdgistU!ebdgirQg+j
K e=vijFUeg+TVyS_bdU,zU!vi`dk^+EV¤b e!vIjBU`dPSg¡$jbdPlvIb30
(ΠK(u))i = ui
kmo |ui−fi|2≤α fi+α|uui−fi
i−fi|2
gIbdPlU=rn¡$k`dU
Ñ i+Ò
OQPSkw`vIhig+rdkbdPSTøkw`¡U=²0jlg¡$j.kj.bdPSUDgiy_bnkTVk!vIbdkgij e=giTVTljSkmbt^§Ñ2`cU!UogirLkjl`tb{vIjle=Ub^i`Ò{V¤b
¡Qvi`#ySrngiyFg+`dU!zrnU!e=U=j0bd^kjkTVvihiULySrngae=U!`n`ckjShkj`cg+TDULylviyBU!rn`¿^a¥Mù0¥~,+`)«U'z_U!`nernkBULkmbQSrnkU]Àl^
FU=g¡'
Ádu@w ¢zpy<~@|~y@zÃnf.¢dzl a@Änn<~¢Å
¯
ukw`$v`cg+SbdkgijgIoÑci!Ò¥SkmokbA`dvIbdkw`t¯BU!`#ogirfvij0^
t >0 0
¯
u= ΠK(¯u−tη) Ñ i+Ò
ΠK(·)z_U=jSgibdU,`bdPSU{5Bekz_U,vIjySrngIstU,ebdg+rQgij
K¥SvIjlz η kw`fvij0^U=U=TVU=j0b$gIo
∂J(¯u)
OgËeg+TDyl_bdU
¯
u¥_¡U'l`dULbdPSU'ySrngIstU,ebnU!z`cSlhir{viz_kU=j0b$vIhigirnkbdPST½z_U=¯ljSU,za^0
( u0∈K
uk+1= ΠK(uk−tk ηk
||ηk||2)
Ñ Ò
AU=rnUi¥
tk>0og+rfvIja^
kvIjlz ηk k`fvija^U=U=TVU=j0bfgIo
∂J(uk)
Ádut Ƶ6ÇÈÉ|<¢zµ.¢zÊz}·³z}|z
{ t
k}
ËOQPlUQe=gija iU!rdh+U=jle=U5gIoBbdPSkw`kbdU=r{vbnk +U`ne{PSU!TDUQz_U!yBU!jlzS`g+jbdPlUFU=PBvM 0kgilrgiolbnPSU$`cU,±+lU=jle=U
tk
\U=b
U
FUQbdPlUf`cU=b5gIo`cg+_bnkg+jl`gIoÑt+,ÒOQPSUQogig¡$kjShLbnPSU=g+rdU!T|ySrng iU!`bnPlvbog+r5v¡#U!le{Plg+`dU=jV`cU,±+lU=jle=U
tk
¥_¡#U'PlvM +ULe=gija iU!rdh+U=jle=UÌ^i`0
Í ´a¸ ´ Æ
6pì*Î
æ limk→∞tk= 0 ÝäM P∞
k=0tk =∞B;ãPÏSÜ=ä limk→∞J(uk) = infu∈KJ(u) ÝäM limk→∞d(uk, U) = 0
Ð
ÏlÜèdÜ
d(·,·) àwå'ãSÏlÜ¿ÑFlâßáàHM+Ü{ÝähMàwåã¤ÝIäFâ{Ü#æ{èdÚÛ ÝÞlÚàéäBã#ãÚËÝåÜ=ãÒ
¦.vija^`cU,±+lU=jle=U!``dvIbdkw`to^bnPSUQPa^0yFgIbnPSU!`dkw`giolbnPSk`bnPSU=g+rdU!T
£
g+rkjl`cbnvijleU
tk =(k+1)1 p
¡$kbdP
p∈ ]0,1]gir tk =(k+1) log((k+1))1
OQPSk`¡$kwz_UQe{PSgikweU#TVvi²iU,`bnPSU#bdPSU!girnU=T|z_kZËeSbbngl`cU;ogirySr{viebdkwe=vI
e=giTVyS_b{vbnkg+jl`¡0vITVg+jSh.vI;yFg+`n`ckSU`dU!±0SU=jBeU!`!¥TvIja^«e=giSwzÂU!viz«bng> +U=rn^ `dg¡¬eg+j0 +U=rnhiU!jleU+
\_giTVUfkwz_U!v+`5¡U=rnU$ySrdg+yBg0`cU,zDbdg'b{vie{²aU$bdPSkw`5ylrdg+SU!T vijlzDbdPlUfbdPlU=girn^Dk`;jSg¡°¡#U!BU!`cbnvIlkw`cPlU!z6Ñp`dU=U
^,_¥Mù¦`og+rf`cg+TVULrnUoU!rdU!jleU,`nÒ
M A
çJLK
V¤o J kw`v\kyl`ne{PSkmbneg+j+bnkjlgil`¡$kbdP\kyl`ne{PSkbd'eg+jl`tb{vIj0b
Lk2Uiv0
|J(u)−J(v)| ≤L||u−v||2
Ñ i+Ò
¡Ue=vij¯ljBzvDylvirnviTVUbdU!rdU!`n`#giy_bnkTvI`cU,±+lU=jle=UVÑ2eotv^+ù¦`Ò¿0
Í ´a¸ ´ Æ 6wòQ
Ó
ÏSÜfÞ~èdÚÔ=Ü{â=ã¤ÜCMËåCF<G¤êièdÝjMIàpÜäBãM+Üå=â{Ü=älã
Ð
àéãPÏåãܤÞoÕ
tk = D
√k
Ñ I0Ò
Ü=äSå>F_èdÜåLãPÏSÝIãÕ
k= ¯Jk−J¯≤O(1)LD
√k
Ñ +ùiÒ
Ð
ÏlÜèdÜ
D àwåãPÏSÜ¿ÑLFlâßmàHMiÜ{ÝähMàpÝIÛVÜ=ã¤Ü=èÚcæ'ãSÏlÜå=Ü=ã
KÒ
OQPSkw`kw`vijU!vi`d^e{PlgikweUbdgAU=jl`dSrnU5v$higag_zLrnvIbdUgIoSe=gija iU!rdh+U=jle=Ui¦6girnU5`dgiySPSkw`cbdkwe=vbnU!zbdU,e{PSjSkw±0SU!`
e!vIjBU'z_U,`ckhijSU,zËlv+`cU,zËg+jkbdU=r{vbnk +UU,`tbnkTvIbdU!`gio
J¯Ñp`dU=UÖ^!+`og+rkjl`cbnvijleUMÒOgVg+Sr#²ajSg¡$U!zShiUi¥
bngrnU!vi^h0vIkjËUZËekU=jBe^D¡$kmbnPËbdPlg+`dU$bdU,e{PSjSkw±+lU!`!¥+g+jSUAgioébdU=jjSU=U,zS`;U=ªabdr{v'kjSogirnTVvIbdkgijl`#vIFgi_b#bdPSU
`dgi_bnkg+j¥Sk²+UbdPSUviySySrngMª_kTvbnU'z_k`cbnvijleUorngiT
uk bngVbdPSU`cU=bAgIo`cg+Sbdkgijl`!V¤be!vIjbdPal`ABU,eg+TDU rnU!vi^Ëz_kZËeSbfbdgviySyS^ËkjySr{viebdkweU+
£
kjlvI^+¥l¡U'rdU,e=vi~bnPlvbAko
J kw`Ae=gija iU=ª~¥SzSkmú~U=rnU=j0bdkwvIlU+¥S¡$kmbnP\kyl`ne{PSkmbn'hir{viz_kU=j0b,¥abdPSU!j6¡#Uz_g jlgIb$jSU=U,zbdgVjSgirnTvIk!ULbdPSU'h+rnv+z_kU!j0b!¥_vIjlzvVeg+jl`cbnvIj0b$`tbnU=y6`dk!ULU!jl`dSrdU,`$eg+j0 +U=rnhiU!jleU0
Í ´a¸ ´ Æ 6ý}*Îæ3Õ
||∇J(u)− ∇J(v)||2≤L0||u−v||2
Ñ Iü0Ò
ãPÏSÜ=ä>ãPÏSÜ$ÞFèdÚÔ=Ü{âã ÜCMêièdÝjMIàpÜäBãM+Üå=â{Ü=älãLÕ
u0∈K
uk+1= ΠK(uk−t∇J(uk))
Ñ m0Ò
Ð
àéãPÏ>â{ÚIäSåã¤ÝIälã;å{ã ÜÞ
t=L20 ÜälåCF_ènÜåãSÏlÝãÕ
d(uk, U)→0 Ñ i+Ò
Ádu ×.nÄn< ÅÉÅÉ~@dÄØ ay{z}|.o ad£¥|Ųy¿³v.~@dÄØ.~@ÅÙz
V¤o¡#UySrdg_e=U=U!zË¡$kmbnPe!vIrnUi¥+bdPSULTVU=TVgirn^VrdU,±+lkrnU=TVU=j0b{`5gIobdPSkw`QvIhigirnkbdPST¬vIrnUAjSgTVgirnUfbdPBvIjËbt¡$kweU
bnPSU`ck=UgIobdPlUkTvIhiULvIjlzËbdPSULU=jShibdPl`#gIog+Sr
ce=gazSU!`z_gjSgibU=ªSeU=U,z
300kjSU!`!;XjSUAkTVyBg+rcb{vIj0b v+z_ vIj0bnvihiUQgIoFbdPlU!`dUfvIhigirnkbdPST`kw`bdPal`5bdgvIg¡×opvi`cb;kTVySU!TVU=j0bnvIbdkgijVgIovTVgazSU=)OQPlU$Skh'kw`n`cSU
kw`bdPBvbAeg+TVyS_bdkjShDbdkTVU!`fe!vIjBU'wvIrnhiU+
ÙÚÛÜÝ{ÞiÞ~ßáàpâ{Ýã)àpÚäSåVÚtæ
l∞çâ{ÚIäSåã2ènÝàéälã2åàéä>àéÛÝ=ê0ÜQÞ~èdÚ!â{Üå{å{àéäaê
,
«UAe=vijD`dU=UQkb;¡$PSU!jbnrd^akjShLbdg¯ljBzDv`cbdg+ySySkjShernkmbnU=rnkg+j}V¤b5¡gilzBUAjSgijl`dU=jB`cUbdg'v+`d`dU!`n`bdPSU
e=gijlzSkmbnkg+j
0∈∂J(uk)nV jlzSU=U!z¥
J TVkhiP0b$BU'jSg+j
`cTVgagIbnP`dgDbdPlvIb$bdPSU'jSg+rdT¿gIobdPSU`dSSh+rnv+z_kU!j0b
TVkhiP0bfFUvirdh+U'U= +U=j iU!rd^e=g0`cUbngbdPlU`cg+Sbdkgij§Ñpe=gijl`dkzSU=r
J(x) =||x||2
og+rfkjl`tb{vIjle=U,ÒOQPal`fv
`dkTDylU'e{PSg+ke=ULkw`QbngV`dUb$bnPSU'jaSTFU=r$giokbdU!rnvIbdkgijl`!
«U¡$k`cU!UkjbnPSUvIySySkwe=vbnkg+jl`#bdPlvIb#bnPSUrdU!vIbdkgij
k ≤O(1)LD√ k
vig¡f`;bdg¯ljlzbdPSULjaSTFU=r
giokbdU!rnvIbdkgijl`QjSU!U!z_U,zbdgVhiU=b$vzSU!`dkrnU!zvie=e=Sr{vie^+
£
girQkjB`tb{vIjle=U¡UAh+Ub¨yFU=r{eU!y_bdlvi^Ë`cbnvIlU+¨a`dgi_bnkg+jl`;ylrdU=bcbt^Vopvi`cbogirbdPSU
BV −L∞ySrngiSU=T Ñ `cU,eg+jlzS`ogir¡\U=jlv0Ò¥;l_bogirDbdPlU6TDg+rdUeg+TVySU=ª¢ySrngiSU=T gioAÍD;¦6U=^+U=r,¥5¡UjlU=U!zÉvIrngiljlz
5TVkj0SbdU!`'ogirÌ2QvIrnlvirnvkTvIh+UiË«UVbdPlkjS² bdPBvb'bdPlk`'h+U=jSU!rdkweVvIhig+rdkbdPST`cPSg+Swz>FUËl`dU!z«¡$PSU!j
¡$kkjShbdg>hiUbDv6±+lke{² g iU=rn akU!¡ÔgiobnPSUviSkkbdkU!`'gio$vTVg_z_U!26OQPSU!j§TDg+rdUrnU¯BjSU!z bdU,e{PSjSkw±0SU!`
Bvi`dU!zgijvIjvIjlvi^_`dk`QgiobdPlU`tbnrdlebdSrnUgIo
J `dPSgiSwzBULbnPSgiSh+P0bfgIot
uATDg+jSh'bnPSUAeg+jlelrdrnU=j0b;vIhig+rdkbdPlTV`!¥IUbl`5TVU=j0bnkg+jSSjlz_UfTVUbnPSg_zS`^M`)¥0¡$PSkwe{PËvIrnU$²ajSg¡$j
bnge=gija iU!rdh+U'opvi`cbdU!r!¥~S_b'vIrnUTVgirnUzSk[ZËelmbbdgkTVySU=TVU!j+b'kj>ySr{viebdkweU+¥BrnU!±0SkrdUPSkhiPSU!rTVU=TVg+rd^
`dylv+eUi¥QvIjBz¢PlvM +UbdPSU.`nvITVUbdPSU!girnUbnke!vIfeg+ja iU=rnhiU!jleUr{vbdU+Îx$U!e=U=j0bd^i¥#Í5SrnkkfU!`cbdU!rdg ¢kjp^_>`
ylrdg+yBg0`cU,zvDjSU=¡ TVUbnPSg_z¡$kbdP6vVeg+TDylU=ªakbt^Ëgio
O(1)
5OQPSk`QTVU=bdPSg_zvIySylkU!`bngVvV`dTvIU!rf`cU=bQgio
ylrdg+SU!T`=¥~S_bkb'`dU=U!T`fbnPlvbkmb'TVkhiP0bLFUVvIySySkU!z6bngbnPSUDySrdg+SU=T`A¡UDySrdU,`cU!j0bkj.bdPlk`LylviyBU!r!
V¤bf¡$kBUbnPSU'ySSrnyBg0`cUgioo_bnSrnU'kja iU,`tbnkh0vbnkg+jl`=
Ú Û
½ =»Ë= ÝÜ÷ÞQQÁc # ß
©
»¾$
{ {«f
àvu@w á*âd<~@zQ¡y.z}z} 6.~@9nf.¢zÊÅÙv£z}
OQPlk`#ylvIr{vIh+rnviySPvIjlzËbdPSkw`ylvIr{vIh+rnviySPVgijS^Vk`#ySrnU!`dU=j0bdU,zkjËbdPlULe=gij0bdkjaSgil`#`cU=bcbnkjShB
Ωz_U=jlgIbdU,`#v
Fgiljlz_U!zgiyFU=j6`dUb$gIo
Y
2 U'rnU!e!vIFbdPlvIb$bdPSU`dylvie=UgiooSjBebdkgijB`$gIoBg+Sjlz_U,z virdkwvbnkg+j Ñp`dU=U1^-`
og+rfvVegiTVySUbnUrdU=oU=rnU=jle=U,Ò#k`Az_U¯ljlU!za^0
BV(Ω) ={u∈L1(Ω), sup
{ξ∈Cc1(Ω;ã 2),kξkL∞(Ω)≤1}
Z
Ω
u(x)div(ξ(x))dx <∞} Ñ)_SMÒ
V jo^!ü-`)¥FÍ~¦6U!^iU=rL`tbnlz_kU!z.bdPSU!girnUbdkwe=vi^ËbnPSUVx$lz_kj
XL`cPSU!r
£
vIbdU!TDkTDg_z_U!2¥vijlz¯lh+SrdU,zgi_b
kbn`kTVkbnvbnkg+j.bngz_kw`de=rdkTVkjBvbdU¡#U!ve!vIrdbdgagij6kj vjSgikw`cUgirvVbdU=ª0bnSrnUiXfUDgil`dU=rn iU,zbnPlvbLbdPlk`
kTDkbnvIbdkgij×e=giSwz§FUg iU!rdyBvi`n`cU,z.l`dkjlh v.z_kú~U=rnU=j0bzSvIbnvbnU=rnTbnPlvIjÂbnPSUr{vbnPSU=rSjSkj_ogirnTvbnk +U
L2z_kw`tb{vIjle=UAbngVbdPSUzSvIbnvl
AUz_U¯ljlU!zvDjSgirnT¥0
||v||G= inf
g {||g||∞, div(g) =v, g= (g1, g2),|g|=q
g21+g22} Ñ)_++Ò
vV`dylvie=UÖ0
G={v,||v||G <∞}¥
A
çJLK
vijlz°ySrngiyFg+`dU!zÌbdg×z_U,eg+TDyFg+`dU.vIjØkTvIh+U
f kj0bdg×v×e!vIrdbdgagij
u vIjBzÉv§bdUªabnSrdU
v l`dkjSh×bdPSU og+g¡$kjShTVg_z_U!n0
u∈BV(Ω),vinf∈G,f=u+v{ Z
Ω|Du|+λ||v||G} Ñ)_i0Ò
OQPSU
GjSgirnTûgIoBvijg0`de=kvIbdkjShfoljlebnkg+jrnU=TvIkjl``cTvi)¥I`cgAbdPlvIbbdPSkw`TDg_z_U!0yFU=rnTVkmb{`bdgLBU=bcbnU=r U=ªabdr{viebQg+`nekvIbdkjShyBvbcbnU=rnjl`gIobdPSUkTVvihiU,`=u[higag_zËU=ª_viTVySUbdgVkl`cbdr{vbnUAbnPSk`Qylrdg+yBU!rcbt^kw`bdPSU
og+g¡$kjSh±0
ä ||sin(nx)||L2([0,2π])=π ∀n∈å
ä ||sin(nx)||G([0,2π])= 1/n ∀n∈å
àvut æ_³..z6¹L³ÅÙzQ<~@| aÌ Eyyd. |¢z}
ÍD#¦6U!^iU!rËz_kz°jlgIbySrngiyFg+`dU.vIja^×jaSTVU!rdkwe=vifTVUbdPlgazÉbng¢`dgi iUPSkw`ËTVg_z_U=) OQPlU6¯lr{`tbvi_bdPSg+rn`
¡$Plg bnrdkU!zÌbng×egiTVySSbdU.v§`dgi_bdkgijÉ¡#U!rdUg\;nçU!`dU.vIjlzØ\~QXL`cPSU!rkjÊ^ `) OQPlU=^ÌviySySrngMª_kTvbnU
bnPSU
L∞jSg+rdT kjÂbnPSU GjSgirnT¥a^ v
LpjSgirnT bng6ySrnU!`dU=rn iUz_kúFU!rdU!j+bnkviSkkbt^i¥vIjlz«kTVyBg0`cUbnPlvb
f =u+v a^vyFU=jlvik!vIbdkgijËTVU=bdPSg_z;\aBe{PvIjvIySySrngMª_kTvIbdkgijkTDylkU!`Q`dgiTVUAjaSTVU=rnkwe=vIFkw`d`dSU!`!¥
vijlzegijB`tbnrnvikjl`#bngl`cU vISU,`QgIo
pvirdg+Sjlz
2
iB
£
ufIstgiUb!vI)Akjk^ `ySrngiyFg+`dUvFUbdbdU=r'viySySrngMªakTvbnkg+jgiobdPSUDTVg_z_U=)OQPSU!^6`cPSg¡[bnPlvb
bnPSU$z_kw`de=rdU=bdU
G `dU=TVk jSg+rdT[kw`bdPSU$z_BvI_gIolbdPSU
T V oSjlebnkg+jlvISvijlz'bnPlvbkb5e=vIjBUfe=giTVyS_bnU!zl`ckjSh uFW#PlviTFgiU'vIhig+rdkbdPlT¥^ù`);AU= +U=rdbdPSU!U,`d`#bdPlU=^vi`dgVkTVyFg+`dUbdPlvIb
f =u+v 0^yBU!jlvIk,vbnkg+j
OQPlU=krfz_k`nernUbnU'vIySySrngMª_kTvIbdkgij¡$rnkbdU!`X0
infu,v{T V(u) +µX
i,j
|f−u−v|2i,j+T V∗(v γ)}
OQPSU!^VySrdg+yBg0`cULveg+ja iU=rnhiU!j0b;vIhigirnkbdPST bdgD`cg+ +Ufkb¿^ `~bdPlvIb#¡Qvi`#hiU!jSU=r{vIk!U!zDa^WSW#PBvI_ªUb
vi2kj_^,+`)
u®jlU=¡¬vIySySrng+v+e{P>Plv+`rdU,eU!j+bn^ BU!U=j§z_U! iU=giylyBU,z a^ Ç YLg+z_opvIrn«U=b!vi2kjc^ `¤Og6giSr
²ajSg¡$U!zShiUËbnPSkw`kw`elrdrnU=j0bd^«bdPSUFU!`cbj0lTDU!rdkwe=viviySySrngMª_kTvbnkg+jÂbdg«Í¦6U!^iU!r!¨`DySrdg+SU=T¥;vi`
jlgÂviySySrngMª_kTvbnkg+j×kw`VjSU=U,z_U!z¢bdgÂkTDyFg+`dU
f = u+vÉOQPlUvi_bdPlgir{`D`dgi iUkbËl`ckjSh§vÂ\aU!e=gijlz Xr{z_U!rËW#g+jSUq5rngihir{vITVTVkjShÉÑ)\lX'W#q#ÒVviySySrng+vie{PÉOQPSkw`vIhig+rdkbdPlT k`Ëvi`dg«²0jlg¡$j¢bngÂe=gija iU!rdh+U
kj«yBg+^ajSg+TDkwvIbnkTVUiOQPSUVTvIkj«k`n`clUrnU=TvIkjSkjShTDkhiP0b'FUVbdPSUeg+TVySU=ª_kmbt^6gio;bdPlUËeg_z_U!`VÑbdPSU
vi_bdPlgir{`Al`dUDbdPSU¦ X\è½klrnvird^SÒfvijlz>bdPSUeg+TVyS_bdkjShbdkTVUiÖV j¸^
`¤¥bnPSU=^.kjlz_kwe=vIbdUDbdPBvbbdPSU
q Ç °vIySylrdg0vie{PVbdgD`cg+ +Ux$Bz_kj
XL`dPSU=r
£
vbnU=TVklylrdg+SU!T¬k`QvIrngiljlzDbt¡$ke=UAopv+`tbnU=r#bdPlvijËbnPSU\BX'W#q
viySySrng+v+e{P
ÙÚÛÜÝ{ÞiÞ~ßáàpâ{Ýã)àpÚäSåVÚtæ
l∞çâ{ÚIäSåã2ènÝàéälã2åàéä>àéÛÝ=ê0ÜQÞ~èdÚ!â{Üå{å{àéäaê
M
àvu ×<~@|~y¿zc ad£¥~ÅÙyz6Ųz6 E.~én¡³deÅÙz.¢d£
V jbdPlUvIySySrng+v+e{PSU!`;ySrngiyFg+`dU!zËkj_^ ¥ `bnPSUl`dU=r$Plv+`;bngVhik iUvIjUªabdr{vyBvIr{vITVUbnU=r,¥av+`
f =u+v
kw`kTVyFg+`dU!za^yBU!jlvIk,vbnkg+jOvi²0kjShDkmbQbng0gDwvIrnhiUAU!v+zS`#bdgDPSkhiPegiTVySSbdkjShbnkTVU+¥SvIjlzbnvi²0kjShDkmb
bngag`dTvIz_gaU,`jlgIbU=jl`dSrnUbnPlvbLbdPSUe=gijl`cbdr{vIkj0bAk`b{vI²iU!j>¡U=kj0bdgvie!eg+Sj0b!XVj>bnPSUogig¡$kjShl¥
¡UySrnU!`dU=j0bfvTVU=bdPSg_zbdPlvIbfyBU!rdTVkbn`QbngvM igikwzbnPSkw`$yBU!jlvIk!vbnkg+j
ÍDl¦6U=^+U=r,¨`$zSk`nernUbnk!U!zySrdg+SU=T½¡$rnkmbnU!`X0
uinf∈X{J1(u) +λ inf
g∈Y,div(g)=f−u{||g||∞)}} Ñ)_ Ò
ØPSU!rdU
J1
k`$z_U=¯ljSU,zkj§Ñ2S,üiÒ«U'PlvM iUbdPlUogig¡$kjShVrdU,`clmb{0
ê ¸< #¸ ,ð,ð ¸
ï°ñQpì
ë ènÚjG=ßÜÛíìîjÒðï¦ñòâ{Ýä_G{ÜèdÜ2æÚèÛÖF_ßÝIã¤ÜCMÝå5æÚßéßÚ
Ð
åÖÕ
g∈Y,||infg||∞≤α{J1(f −div(g))} Ñ2_++Ò
ê ¸¸ OQPSU¯lr{`tb$kwz_U!vDkw`QbdPlvIbf¡#U'e!vIjl`cULbnPSUe{PlvIjlhiUgIo MvirdkwvIlU10
u=f−div(g) Ñ2S++Ò
bng>hiU=bDvij×giy_bnkTVk!vIbdkgij§ySrngiSU=T bnPlvbVz_U=yFU=jlzl`g+jS^ÂgiofgijSU MvirdkwvIlU
g>OQPSkw`k`yBg0`d`dkSU
FU!e!vIl`dULbdPSU'g+yBU!rnvIbdg+r
div k`f`dSr2stU!ebdk iULordg+T
Y bdg X
uinf∈X{J1(u) +λ inf
g∈Y,div(g)=f−u{||g||∞}}= inf
g∈Y{J1(f−div(g)) +λ||g||∞} Ñ)_0ùiÒ
OQPSkw`fylrdg+SU!Te=giSwzBU`dgi iU,zl`ckjShËv`dSSh+rnv+z_kU!j0b$zSU!`neU=j0b,OSrnjSkjlhVbdPSUwvIh+rnvijShiULTlmbnk
ylkU=r
λkj0bdgLvAeg+jl`cbdr{vIkj+b,¥!¡U;h+UbbnPSU#ogig¡$kjShfTVkjSkTVk!vIbdkgijySrngilU!T Ñp¡#U#rdU=oU=rbdg$bnPSUviySyFU=jlz_kª og+rQbdPSU'kjS²ËFUbt¡U=U=jbnPSUbt¡#gVTVg_z_U=w`{Òd0
g∈Y,||infg||∞≤α{J1(f −div(g))} Ñ2_iü0Ò
AgIbdkweUbnPlvbko¡UrnU=ySwvie=UbnPSU
L∞ jSgirnT a^×v L2 jSgirnT kj Ñ)_ Ò¥;¡Uh+UbDbdPSUTVg_z_U=$gio XL`dPSU!r
\agiÈ
çU!`dUÌ^I-`)