Tracing the Origins of Verification Conditions
9
0
0
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Tracing the Origins of Verification Conditions Ranan Fraer. N˚ 2840 March 1996 THE`ME 2. ISSN 0249-6399. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6) !"# $% '&( )*! $
(7) + ,.-/,.-10/23,.452 6 798;:%<=>@?BA;C9DE<GFIHKJ5DILDE< F < MNLOPFQLRSFUTWV9:XYHKFIDQZ[RS< \^]_HP`a< Mcb]WH[OKd ecO5dSdYH5]_MgfS<]W<;L!79< ]hL!79<iCj[=PkPl[mG>@noOK]hL!7op;qKqKr>sp3t%dSOKJK<;T. u vxw y z3{S|KyK} 6 79<BM~V9d9DIL OPFdS]_HKJ5]hOK:K<;]WDEYL OPMWDIH5CT_V9TWM_< :DQTO%XSOPMhL!7MWH H5FYMh7SOPMgOKL L$< dSM_TOKTDICSdR9MO d]WH5J5]hOK:O5CSC9H5M_OPM_< f DIM_7FEHV9f cH[OK]_<OKThTW<;]WM_DEH[CSTdY< ]WH5]h:TBTWV9C[M_O5L$M_DIL%OKCSfoT_< :O5C5M_DIL%OKCSOKFEV9T_DIT H[CDIMgOKCfJ5< C9<;]_OKMW< TOFIDIT_MHPK< ]_DEYLOKMWDIH5CLH5CSfSDEM_DEH[CSTM_7SOKMDITThRSXST_< Z R9<;C[MWFIVT_RXS:DEM_MW< f M_HO Mh79<H[]W<;:d]WH5< ] 79<;CO5< ]_DYL OPM_DEH[CLH5CSfSDEM_DEH[CLOKCC9HKMXY<d]WH5< f M_79DQT:O3VX<*fSR9<MWHO5C <;]_]_H5]UDICM_79<dS]WH5J5]hOK:¡H5]xOKCGDQCSL$H[CST_DIT_MW<;CSL$V#DQCGM_79<gOKCC9HKMhOPMWDIH5CTU¢C H5]_M_RCSOPM_<FIVKDIMxDQT£5< ]_VfSD¤¥LRSFEM M_Ho]W< FIOKMW<O*¦OPDIFIDIC9Jod]WH HPgOPM_MW< :d9MMWHoO"dSOK]_MWDQLRSFIO5]Gd9DE<;L$<HKgLH fS<H5]GOKThT_< ]_MWDIH5C <
(8) dS]_H5dYH5T_<O T_HKFQR9M_DEH[C
(9) M_HMh79DQTNdS]_H5X9FI< :RTWDQC9JM_79<GM_< L!7SCSDIZ R9<GHKxH5]_DIJKDQC
(10) Mh]_O5L!§5DQC9JY ¨"©[ª«h¬ z3®wK} d]WH5J5]hOK:K<;]WDEYL OPMWDIH5CU[H[]WDIJKDQC¥Mh]_O5L!§[DIC9JY9dS]WH5J5]hOK::DICSJ%<;C5 DQ]WH[CS:< C[M. ¯±°U²W³´ µ ²g¶·I³¸¹$º ·ÐWÑ ·QÓIÔ Ô ÐaÑÈÐ ÐcÔ ÐhÛaÑ Ó ÐW·EÝ3ÔWÞ$Ô Ô Þ#àKÔ ·Qá ѽРâ Ð Ø Ý »½Ï ¼#Ô ¾ÀÕ Ô ¿3Ú$¿PßÁW¾ÀÙÄÂÄÜcÃÆÅGÙ à»ÈÇ3â9Á ãP¿;ä ½¿3¼Â¦ÉaÃÆÅ3ÁWÁaË!Ê3ÁaÂÃÆÅ;åQæ.Ë!ÌÁa¦¼Àçè¾ÀÍËc»½Ç3é[ÁBÁaÉaÎÈ»½Ï ê3¦Á^ÏKëxÒ ¼À»½ÁWÌxÏKÒ!ÃÆÅ#ÕxÖì¼!Ï_í × ¿3ê »ÈÏKÁaØ ä ÉaÃÆÏ%ÁaÅ3ÙÉaÁÕ Ú ãKî ê;Ò Å3Ø ÃÆÉÜÇ ãï ê;ç ðñWÕ ò!Ú!ò!ß%ó;ô Ò!Ï × Ò õ ¾ÀžÀÅ[ô ö3½¾ÀÁaÂ÷̽¼!¿3Ç3Ãè¾;ô ÃÆÅ3¦Ãè¾;ô ÍIÂ. Unite´ de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis 2004 route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 SOPHIA-ANTIPOLIS Cedex (France) Te´le´phone : (33) 93 65 77 77 – Te´le´copie : (33) 93 65 77 65.
(11) $ % )* &( )*! $%
(12) )* !"G $ w
(13) } <
(14) TWV9T_MW8;:%<
(15) M~V dSDIZ R9<
(16) fS<
(17) KA;]WDEYL OPMWDIH5Cf9<dS]WH5J5]hOK::< T#<;TWMRSCH5RSMWDIFdY< RDQC[MWA ]hOKLMWDE Z R9D.OKL L$< dSMW< < C<;C5Mh]WA <NRSCdS]_HKJ[]_O5::< OKCC9HKM_ANO3K< Lgf9<;T^O5T_T_< ]_MWDIH5CSTFIHV9f ÈBH5O5]W<5POKCSOKFEV9T_<gL<cdS]_H J[]_O5::%<gT_V C[MhO 9DIZ R9<;:< C[M<MÄT_A :OKC[MWDQZ R9< :<;C5M P<M/J5A C98;]W< RSCS< FEDQTWM_<Nf9< L$H[CSf9DIMWDIH5CSTÄfS<5A ]_D.LOPM_DEH[C Z R9D< T_Mc<;CSThR9DEM_<%T_H5RS:DQTW<
(18) RSCofSA :H5CST_M_]hOPM_< RS]Bf9<Mh79AH[]W8;:< T [DRSC9<L$H5Cf9DEM_DEH[Cf9<5A ]_D.LOPM_DEH[C CS<dY< RSMdSOKT Mh]W<dS]_H5RSKA<5 L$< LDÄd<;R9M Mh]W<f *RSC9<< ]h]W<;RS]#fSOKCTBFI<dS]_HKJ5]hOK::<KH[R "RSC9<DQC LH5CST_DQTWMhOKCSL<¥fSOKCSTFE<;T%O5CSC9H5M_OPM_DEH[CST "nOPFQ79< RS]_< RTW<;:%<;C[MDEF< T_MMh]W8;Tf9DE¤¥L$DIFE<*f9<]_<FIDE<;]RSCA;L!79< L fOKCSTFQO%dS]_< RSK < %RSC< CfS]WH5DEMgfSO5CSTFE<GdS]_HKJ[]_O5::<NH[RfOKCSTFI< TgOKThTW<;]WM_DEH[CST BH5RSTgdS]_H5dYH5T_H5CSTRSC9< T_HKFQR9M_DEH[ C L$<GdS]_H5XSFE8;:%<#<;C*RSMWDIFEDQT_O5C[M FIOMW<;L!7SC9DQZ R9<GfSR"T_R9DI D£f9<;TgH5]_DEJ5DIC9<;T i y;w « "| ! } 5A ]_DYL OPM_DEH[C
(19) f9<d]WH5J5]hOK::< T ThR9DI D£f9< TNH5]_DEJ5DIC9<;T9<;C[[DQ]_H5CSC9<;:< C[M f9<dS]_HKJ[]_O5::O M_DEH[C.
(20)
(21)
(22) ! "#$% &'% )(* ,+ ' . -. x)10
(23) ^ $% DICSL<NM_7S<NFIOKMW<cT_D M_DE<;T[N79<;CFIHV9fOKCSfBH5OK]_<2 FIH5r5r9KBH5O5rKq43.T_<MRSdM_7S<cXSOKT_DQT/HPUO:<Mh79H9fH5] d]WH DQC9Jd]WH5J5]hOK:TLH5]h]W<;L$M STW< K< ]hOPF dS]_HKJ[]_O5:K<;]WDEYLOKMWDIH5CTWV9T_MW< :T 7SO35<GOKdSdY< O5]W<;f ¢BThRSOPFIFEVM_79< :OKDIC*L$H[:dYH5CS< C[MHKThRSL!7
(24) OT_V9TWM_< :DQT O%5< ]_D.LOPM_DEH[C¥L$H[CSf9DIMWDIH5C
(25) JK< CS< ]hOPMWH[6] 57Bb 9? 8M_7SOKMgM_OK§K< TgOKT DQCSdSRSM^OKCDQ:dY< ]hOPM_DE5<NdS]_HKJ5]hOK: O5CSfOGT_dY< LD.LOPM_DEH[:C 5½RSCSfS< ]ÄMh79<gH5]h:iHKUdS]W%< ;dYH5T_Ma~L$H[CSf9DIMWDIH5CSTOKCf FIH H5d%DIC[OK]_DQOKC[M_T 8UO5CSfH5R9MhdSR9MhTÄOFEDQTWM/HK.FIHKJ5DIL OPF9L$H[CSf9DIMWDIH5CST 6 79< T_< L$H5Cf9DEM_DEH[CST/OK]_< T_RdSdH[TW<;fM_HX< d]WH5< f:O5C RSOPFIFEVBH5]U:<;L!7SOKC9DQLOKFEFIV 5ÈRSTWDQC9JcOgMh79<H[]W<;:1dS]_HK<;$] 8! O5CSfM_79< DI]xT_OKMWDQTaYO5X9DIFEDIM~Vc<;CST_R]W<;T M_79< LH5]h]W<;L$MhC9< ThTUHKM_79< dS]_HKJ[]_O5:*= <cT< SO5:dSFE<;TxHKMWH H5FITM_7OPMH[]_§BM_7SDITgO3V#<gLO5CL$DIMW<gMh79< M_OKC9H5]hf \/O5T_L OPF 7/<;]WDE< >] 2 ? At @43ÈS?BV9dST_:V 2Æ?BH H5k @B3ÈD CE76C 2 FG\ HGq5B= 3.H[]/\< C9< FEH[dI< 2 ?n\qK%m 3J 7/< ]_D.LOPM_DEH[C LH5CSfSDEM_DEH[C JK< CS< ]hOPMWH[]_T
(26) OK]_<OPFQTWH RSTW<;f DQC H5]h:OPFB:< M_79H9fST*XSOKT_< fH5C T_MW< d[ DQTW<]W<YC9<;:%<;C[M¥FEDQ§P< 7>KL n 2 MKH5CSk54r 3cH5O] NP2 <BXS]_Dq @43gO5T< O5L!7 ]_<$YCS< :< C[M¥T_MW< d 7SO5TMWHXY<oOPFIDIfOPMW<;f X5V dS]WH DQC9JM_79< LH5]h]W<;T_dYH5Cf9DICSJ%T_<M HPK<;]WDEYLOKMWDIH5CL$H5Cf9DEM_DEH[CST BH< K< ] .D^H[C9<5< ]_D.LOPM_DEH[CL$H[CSf9DIMWDIH5CoL OKCSC9H5MXY<dS]WH5< f"Mh79DIT:< O5CSTM_7SOKMc<DIM_7S< ]M_79<dS]_H J[]_O5:fSH[<;T"C9HKM*T_OKMWDQTaV DIM_T*T_dY< LD.LOPM_DEH[C cH[]
(27) Mh79<T_dY< LDYL OPM_DEH[Cf9H < T*C9HKM"T_M_OPM_< LH5]h]W<;L$MWFIV M_79< DQC[MW<;CSf9< f:< O5C9DQC9JGHPM_79<BdS]WH5J5]hOK:*Q ?aCXYHKM_7L OKT_< TMh79<NRST_< ]/DQTÄThRSdSdYH5T_< fMWH:H9f9DEV%Mh79<NdS]_HKJ5]hOK: H[]/M_7S<cT_dY< LD.LOPM_DEH[COKCSfMh79<cT_V T_MW<;:fSH[<;TÄC9H5MÄJKDIK<NO5C5V79DQC5MH5CN79<;]W<NMh79DQT^:H9f9D.LOPM_DEH[CT_79H[R9FQf H9L LRS] 9 CÄK<;CN7S< CoMh]WV DQC9J*MWH"dS]WH5<%OM_]hR9<L$H5Cf9DEM_DEH[C UT_M_OPM_< f OKT#OKCH5]hf9DICOK]_V.]_T_MBH[]_fS< ]BFEH5JKDQL H[]_:%R9FQOSUDIMGDITZ[RSDEM_<¥f9D¤¥L R9FEMMWHoRSCSfS< ]hTWMhOKCSf N7SOPMGH[C9<DQTGM_]_V DIC9J"M_HodS]WH5<KUO5CSfDICN79DQL!7O3V Mh79DQTLH5CSf9DIMWDIH5C¥DIT]W< FIOKMW< f¥MWHO%dH[T_T_DIXSFE<N< 9< LRSMWDIH5CHKUM_79<dS]WH5J5]hOK:*= ?aC¥HKM_7S< ]ÄH5]hfST KMh79<O5XST_< CSL< HK/FEDQCS§ TcXY<M~<<;C"M_79<T_H5R]_L<dS]WH5J5]hOK:O5CSf"M_7S<K<;]WDEYLOKMWDIH5C"L$H[CSf9DIMWDIH5CSTNDITBO¥TW<;]WDIH5RT FIO5L!§¥M_H¥M_79< MhOKTh§HPNH[]_:OPFg5< ]_DYL OPM_DEH[C 6£HL$H5:dY< CSThOPM_<K^RTW<;]_Tf9HTWH[:%<"§[DICfHP:%<;C[M_OPF dS]_H9L$<;T_T_DICSJH5] ]_<Mh]WDI< DQC9J"M_79<
(28) H5]_DEJ5DIC HP MW<;]_:TGMh7SOPM%OKdSdY< O5]#DICOLH5CSf9DIMWDIH5CU
(29) H[]GDQCSTWMhOKCSL<KX[V ]_< L$H5J5C9SD RDQC9J"DQC O
(30) L$H5Cf9DEM_DEH[CM_7S<%C9< J5OPM_DEH[C"HPÄMh79<M_< T_McHP^O5UC T%VT_M_OKMW< :<;C5M YMh79<Vf9<;fSRSL<M_7OPMcMh79DQTLH5CSfSDEM_DEH[C"DIT J5< C9<;]_OKMW<;f
(31) X[V¥M_7SX< W
(32) YZAWXS]hOKCSL!7HPM_79DQTNT_M_OKMW< :<;C5M 6 79DQTGdSO5d<;]BdS]_H5dYH5T_< TOO3V"HP:%<;L!7SOKCS[D R DIC9J*M_7SDIT#dS]_H9L$< ThT#X[VDICST_M_]hRS:< C[M_DIC9J"O¥5< ]_D.LOPM_DEH[C LH5CSfSDEM_DEH[C J5< C9<;]_OKMWH[]# DEMh7H5]_DEJ5DICM_]hOKL!§[DQC9J*¦OKLDEFIDEM_DE<;T"6 79DQTM_< L!7SC9DQZ R9<KdS]_H5dYH5T_< fX[\V Ng<;]WM_HKMGDQC 2 Ng< ]hqSp] Ng< ]hq5=[= Ng<;]_q -43ÈÄ7SO5TXY<<<;CDQC9DEM_DIOKFEFIVOKdSd9FIDI< fDQCDI:d9FI< :<;C5M_DICSJ T_H5RS]hL$<ÈFI<5<FÄf9<;XSR9JKJ5DICSJ HKNdS]WH5J5]hOK::DICSJ*FQOKCSJ5RSOKJK< TGX[V< T_M_O5X9FEDQTh79DICSJOo]_<FQOPMWDIH5CXY<M~<<;CM_79<*LRS]h]W<;C[MGDICST_M_]hRSLMWDIH5COKCf O"dYH5T_DEM_DEH[CDICMh79<¥TWH[RS]hL$<dS]_HKJ5]hOK:*
(33) ?BDIK< CO"CSOKM_RS]hOPF^T_< :O5C5M_DIL TGf9< ThL]_DQd9MWDIH5C HPgM_79<
(34) FIO5C9J5RSOKJK<5 DIMDITdH[T_T_DQX9FE<%MWH*DIC[M_<J5]hOPM_<M_7SDIT#]_<FQOPMWDIH5C"DQCoMh79<TW<;:O5C[MWDQLTOKCSfMh79<DIC[MW< J5]hOPM_DEH[C"DITT_7SHNCMWH"X< T_V9TWM_< :OPM_DILO5CSfTW<;:D~OKR9M_H5:OPM_[D R;OKX9FI<K
(35) eN<FQOPM_< fH5]h§H5CH5]_DIJKDQC Mh]_O5L!§[DIC9J"DQCM_79<¦]hOK:< H[]_§HK OKFEJ5< XS]hOPDQLcThdY< L$DEYL OPMWDIH5CTgDITN]_< dYH5]_MW<;fX[V 7ÄO5C K< R]_T_< C FGFEDQC[MgO5CSf"6gDIdDQ^C 2 K_F6 Aq -B3 <BTH[]WDIJKDQCMh]_O5L!§5DQC9J7SOKTX< < C*dS]_HK< fRTW<¦R9F.H5]DIC[M_< ]hdS]W< MW<;]_T 5DIMDITgT_< CST_DIXSFE<MWHOKdSdSFEVDIMM_H%5< ]_DEYLOKMWDIH5CL$H[CSf9DIMWDIH5CST^JK< CS< ]hOPMWH[]_T Q ?aCSfS<< fU[XYHKMh7¥§[DICSfTÄHP M_H[H5FITOK]_<NTWDQ:DEFQOK]^DICMh7SOPMM_79< Vd<;]aH[]_: T_V9C[M_OKLMWDQLGOKCSfT_< :O5C5M_DILGO5CSOPFIV9TWDQTgH5C"Mh79<DQCSdSR9MdS]_HKJ5]hOK:OKCSf*JK<;C9< ]hOPM_<TWH[:<GH5R9MhdSR9MXY<DEMBM_79< L RS]h]W<;C5MTWMhOPM_<BHKxOKC
(36) < 9< L R9MWDIH5C:O5L!79DQC9<K H5]K<;]WDEYL OPMWDIH5C
(37) L$H5Cf9DEM_DEH[CST ` ?f9< XSRSJKJKDQC9J%DITgL$H[CST_DIf9<;]W<;f <;T_T_< C[M_DIOKFxDQC RCSf9< ]hT_M_OKCf9DICSJ*dS]_HKJ[]_O5: < 9< L R9MWDIH5C Mh79< ]_<DITGC9H"L$H[RSC[MW<;]_dSO5]WMBDICdS]_HKJ[]_O5: 5< ]_D.LO M_DEH[CT_V9TWM_< :TM_7SOKM L$H5RSFIf79<FQdRCSf9< ]hT_M_OKCf9DICSJ%5< ]_DYL OPM_DEH[C
(38) L$H[CSf9DIMWDIH5CST b aRS]H[]_§]_< dS]_< T_< C[MhTO5C OKMWM_< :d9M MWHdS]_HKJ[]W<;T_TDQC
(39) Mh79DQTNOK]_< O <7SO35<oOKdSd9FIDI< f M_79<;TW<DIf9<;OKTDQC OK<;]WDEYL OPMWDIH5C L$H[CSf9DIMWDIH5C J5< C9<;]_OKMWH5]XSRSDEFIM
(40) DIM_7 Mh79<dS]_H J[]_O5::%DQC9J < C[ DI]_H5CS:<;C5M%JK<;C9< ]hOPM_H5]b<;C[M_OKR:] 2 M5OKLqKBl 3È <7SO35<XY< C9<MW<;fHKBMh79<*¦OKL$DIFIDEM_DE<;T%HK :O5C9DIdR9FIOKMWDQC9J¥T_V C[MhOKL$M_DILGT_M_]hRSLM_RS]_< T O5CSf*HP/M_79<%XSR9DIFEMWÈDQC":%<;L!7SOKCSDITh:T HP/TW< FE<;L$M_DEH[C*O5CSf79DIJ579FIDIJ57 .. /. õxõ Å*c4d$e$fg.
(41) l. >% , =A!. M_DICSJE<NFIMW<;]_COPMWDIK<GO5dSdS]_H5OKL!7S< TL$H5RSFIf*RST_<GHKM_7S< ] dS]_HKJ[]_O5::DQC9J<;C[[DQ]_H5CS:< C[MJK<;C9< ]hOPM_H5]hT^FIDI§K<GM_79< V C[Mh79< T_[D R < ]c?B<;C9< ]hOPM_H5] 2 e/6 k5Bk 3È9H[] <[ DK 2 FGFIDIq -43È 6 79<#dSO5d<;]DQTH5]_J5O5C9[D R < fO5T^H5FEFIHNT [<;L$M_DEH[C=d]W<;TW<;C5MhTM_79<#OPFIJKH[]WDIM_7S:HK£K<;]WDEYLOKMWDIH5CLH5CSf9D M_DEH[CoJ5< C9<;]_OKMWDIH5C _ ?aCMh79<TW<;L$MWDIH5\C -¥<%< 9< :d9FIDVMh79<d]WH[X9FE<;: MWH"TWH5FE5<H[CoOThdY< L$DEYLdS]_HKJ5]hOK: O5CSf*DEMhTcLH5CSf9DIMWDIH5CT [< LMWDIH5CST l¥O5CS f @DIC[Mh]WH9fSRSL<GH5]_DEJ5DIC¦RSCL$MWDIH5CTNOKTNOfOPM_OT_M_]hRSLM_RS]_<G< FEFxT_R9D M_< fMWH]_< dS]_< T_< C[MfS< ThL$< CfSOKCSL<BDQC H[]_:OPM_DEH[C J ?aCT_< LMWDIH5Cr%<#f9< ThL]_DIXY<#M_79<#DQC[MW<J[]_OKMWDIH5CHKxH[]WDIJKDQC ¦RCSL$M_DEH[CST/DQCM_79<N5< ]_D.LOPM_DEH[C%LH5CSfSDEM_DEH[CST/JK<;C9< ]hOPM_H5]OKCf%Mh79<cLH5:d9FI< 9DEM~VHP M_79<NCS< OPFIJKH[]WDIM_7S:iDIT O5CSOPFI
(42) V R<;fDIC*T_< L$M_DEH[C*t9 < L$M_DEH[C
(43) k%< Sd9FQOPDQCSTM_79<GdSO5]WM_DIL R9FQOK]_DEM_DE<;T^HKxM_7S<Gb<;C5MhOKRS]DQ:d9FE<;:< C[M_OKMWDIH5C < L$M_DEH[CqT_M_Rf9DE<;TM_79<*< 9MW<;CST_DIX9DIFIDEM~VHPNMh79DQT%H5]h§ MWH]W<;OPFd]WH5J5]hOK:K< ]_DEYLOKMWDIH5CT_V T_MW<;:T < LH5CSLFIRf9<#DIC"T_< L$M_DEH[Cp;mX5VTWH[:%<G]_< :OK]h§ TH5CM_79<LH5CSC9<;L$M_DEH[CSTg DEMh7"dS]WH5J5]hOK:T_FEDQL$DQC9J !"# $% %
(44) )"À N # x < DIFEFxL$H5CL$< C[Mh]_OKMW<#H5C"OTh:OKFEF£DI:dY< ]hOPMWDIK<d]WH5J5]hOK::DIC9JFQOKC9J[RSOPJ5< DIM_7O5T_T_DIJ5CS:< C[MhTSLH5CSf9D M_DEH[CSOPFQTOKCf FIH H5dST \^]_HKJ[]_O5:TO5]W<O5CSC9HKMhOPM_< f DEMh7 FEH H5d DQC5O5]WDQOKC[M_TO5CSf H5d9M_DEH[CSOPFNO5T_T_< ]_MWDIH5CT L OKCXY<%d9FQOKL< foXY<$H[]W<DICST_M_]hRSLMWDIH5CST 6 < N B T_V9C[M_O "HPÄMh79<FQOKCSJ5RSOKJK<GDQTcJ5DE5< CXY<FIHG 7ÄOK]_DIO5X9FI< fS< L$FQOK]hOPM_DEH[CST [< SdS]W<;T_T_DIH5CSTOKCSfY]hT_MaH5]hf9< ]OKThTW<;]WM_DEH[CSTgOK]_<Gf9<$YCS< fDIC*M_7S<RST_ROPF gO3VK :
(45) HWY f9< LFIT T OKThTW<;]WM DICTWM O5T_T_< ]_M d]WH5J5]hOK . DQCST_M
(46) Z T DIf "!$# < Sd%& O5CSC9H5M' DQCSTWM)( O5CSC9HKM' DICTWM T%V < 9d +*-,W. O5CSC9HKM' DICTWM WHYHZAW O5CSC9HKM' DICTWM / , TAYW < Sd% T102 O5T_T_< ]_M314 O5CSC9H5M' DQCSTWM O5CSC9H5M ' DQCSTWM 5 6
(47) 7 OKThT_< ]_M DQCST_M7 DICST_M. 6 79<NOKFEJ5H5]_DEMh7S: MWH#J5< C9<;]_OKMW<K< ]_DEYLOKMWDIH5CLH5CSf9DIMWDIH5CT¦]WH[:iOKCOKCSCSHKM_OKMW<;fdS]_HKJ[]_O5:¡DQTÄXSO5TW<;fH[C D `W§[T_M_]hO98 T<;OK§K< T_Ma~dS]W<;L$H[CSf9DIMWDIH5C¥L OPFQLR9FQRST92 KBD `htr3È < M;:< =?>A@CBED^f9<;C9HKM_<Mh79<GFIHJLKMHONP%QSROHTVU WYX[Z]\ P^Z_ULW`P^aJPbNcaSU1d e?Xgf-HhNCJ9P^Z5NjiAHXgfMHOk^ULRCHlHCmHnTd9P^Z_ULWU ko>pYk^U RqP?aAHrQsULNPtTOULWYX.ZuPvZvU W2B)PwUxfMHGP^Rd[HJLk$PuHOR HCmAHTdPvZvU WU ky>.g6 7S<OPFIJKH[]WDIM_7S:d<;]aH[]_:TNO¥XOKL!§[O5]_fTMh]_O35< ]hT_OKFHP/M_79<DICST_M_]hRSLMWDIH5Cx>T_M_O5]WM_DICSJ ¦]_H5:Mh79<dYH5T_M_L$H[CSf9DIMWDIH5C BSOKCSf*L$H[:dSR9MW<;TgM_79<G:DQT_T_DICSJO5T_T_< ]_MWDIH5CTOKM<;OKL!7
(48) DIC[MW<;]_:<;f9DIO5]WV¥dYHKDQC[M 7S< C
(49) ]_< O5L!79DQC9JORST_< ]dS]_H DIf9<;fOKThTW<;]WM_DEH[{C z DEMJK<;C9< ]hOPM_< TÄOK< ]_DEYLOKMWDIH5CL$H[CSf9DIMWDIH5CHK£M_7S<NH5]h: z}|~:<s=^>S@jBEDhOKCf
(50) DIMN]W<;TWMhOK]_M_Tg DIM_x 7 z(O5TgM_79<CS< dH[TWMhL$H5Cf9DEM_DEH[C <NDQC5Mh]WH9fSRL$<NMh79<c]_<FQOPMWDIH5SC zlLI>E z -@jn Mc DIM_7Mh79<c:< O5C9DQC9J P^aAHQoU NP$TVU WYX[ZwP^Z_ULW K. zlLhZ]NP?Rd[HJLk$PwHVRJPuHORjEZ5WJPvZ]WM`HCmHnTd9P^Z_ULWU klP?aAHGZ]W9NP^RdMTP^Z_ULW`> Z]klP^aAHEQSROHTOULWYX.ZuPvZvU W`z Z5N P?Rd-H{f-HVk^U ROHHCmHnTd9P^Z5W1>psJ.WYXZ]k;P^aAHle Z]NPU k HORcZ5iYTOJ9P^Z_ULWgTVU WYX[ZwP^Z_ULW9N3n MTOULWSPwJ Z]W9NhULW1e`VJ e5Z?X k^ULRcd e_JL N G <]_< T_M_]_DILMBH[RS]#dS]W<;TW<;C[M_OPM_DEH[CMWHdSO5]WM_DIOKFLH5]h]W<;L$MhC9< ThT XSRSMMh79<T_O5:<LH5CST_DIfS< ]hOPMWDIH5CT O5dSd9FIV
(51) M_HMWHKMhOPF£LH5]h]W<;L$MhC9< ThTgOKT <FIF½#?aC"N7SOPMgH5FEFIHNT 9<RST_< x MWH¥fS< C9H5MW<GM_7S<< :d9M~V*FEDQT_Mo S@jj H[]GO"FEDQT_M DEMh7M~H< FE<;:%<;C[M_Tq OKCSf3 OKCSf` H5]#Mh79<
(52) L$H[CSLOKMW<;CSOPM_DEH[CHKFIDIT_M_T OKCf P ¡j¢ ¢ ÃÆÃÆÅ3Å3¿3¿3ê;ê;»»½Ì£Ç3»½ÍEÁÁa¼!½¦ÉWíí¼!ÅV¿3$£»½Â¦Ç3ÁaÁaÅÁÄÉa»½ÁWÁ$ÃÆÊ;¼!!£ ÁWÅ%¾ÀÊçÆêÍE¼!¥¾hçÆð#»½çÆÃƼc¼!¾N¤ Å#ÁW»½ÊGÉaê3¼!¦Ç;ÅÅ3ÁW»½Ì½Á$¦»± «Ágð »WçÆÃÆÁô ̦j»½© ¼cĨ ÌÈÃÆÁaÌ/¿¾À¾À½çÆÌȾh¼N»ÈÁ Ê3ÃÆÃÆ̦Å3»È¿;ÃÆÅ3ê;Ë!»ÈÌÄê;ÃƾÀÌÈÅ;Ç3Ê%Áaʼ!¾Àê;Ì»½¿3»½ê;Ç3»½Á Ìij¼À´3Í.Û5ªW»½Ç3Ð Ø Ág· ¦¼ÀÁaÍYçè¾h»È»ÈÇ;ÃÆÁ¼!Åq¦ÁW$¥ çè¾hð»½ÃƾÀ¼!Å%Å ã ¾Àx¤Â¦Â¦Ç;¼c¤ ÃÆçÆÁ^¦j»½§EÇ3Á¨ ô ¼À»½Ç3Ç;ÁaÁ ¬ ë õ ¬_.
(53)
(54)
(55) ! "#$% &'% )(* ,+ ' . @. 6 7S<#OKFEJ5H5]_DEMh7S: DQT f9< ThL]_DQX<;fRST_DQC9JDIC9< ]_< CSL<#]hR9FI< T. B { BG@ @ B} B
(56) B} } B @n B}>3 zo.@jn M zy > z @Cn - B > > z @jn M n - B > z @Cn - B > z @jn M B} > !" E >3 =# |z D%$g='&(| zo.Dc@Cn - L n M >-*)G,+` z@jn M B}.-* /0 !12>[*)4365879+ >[*)S@ >[*)6$.&|z@ >-*):$,&(| Bh n -. B ;+` z@jn M. B}2<63+ =<q@n < | zh n - 6 7S<"]_<FQOPM_DEH[C @> B B T_M_O5CSfSTH5]B B ? NN79< ]_<"M_79<oThRSXST_MWDIM_RSMWDIH5C B ? NDIT H[]_:OKFEDSR<;f DQCMh79<RSThRSOKF^gO3VO35HKDQf9DICSJ*Mh79<L OKd9MhRS]_<¥HP ¦]_<<¥O5]WDQOKX9FI< TDICZ RSO5C[MWDEYLOKMWDIH5CST < d]W<;TW<;C5M XY<FIH1M~HM~V dSDIL OPFUThRSXST_MWDIM_R9M_DEH[C*]hR9FI< T @ z} z @ @ A@ 5WpB8 @> zB$.@ z $9@ 5È=8 @ =. DQCSOPFIFEV5<gC9< < fOB]_RSFE<^H5]L$H[:dR9MWDQC9JcMh79<gL$H5Cf9DEM_DEH[CSTxH5]xM_79<N79H5FE<dS]WH5J5]hOK:*£6 79<gC9H5M_OPM_DEH[C. z CE n -TWMhOKCSfSTH[] n MGDQTgM_7S<TW< M HPK< ]_DEYLOKMWDIH5C
(57) LH5CSfSDEM_DEH[CSTgJK<;C9< ]hOPM_< f¦]_H5:M_79< O5CSC9H5M_OPM_< f*dS]_HKJ5]hOK:7z .C B >E z @jn M 5-D8 958 DE/FGIH?JK L2z/3>2nBJ3r z}|z n - M N P¥O RQTS <BT^O5C< SOK:d9FI<K[L$H5CTWDQf9< ]ÄM_79< H5FEFIH DQC9JdS]_HKJ5]hOK:(L$H5:dSRSMWDQC9JM_7S<cZ R9HKM_DE<;C5MV U O5CSfM_7S<c]W<;:OPDQCSf9< ] HK^M_7S<%DQC[MW<J5< ]f9DI[DQT_DEH[CHP X[V;.W #<7O3K<%dRS]_dYH5T_< fSFEV"DQC5Mh]WH9fSRL$< fO
(58) XSR9J*DQCoM_7S<dS]_HKJ[]_O5: Mh79<MW< T_MHP^Mh79<%FIH H5dDQTh9XYW DQCSTWM_< O5fHP,ZY.W 6 7SDITBO3V5D DQTO5Co< 9O5L$M:R9FIMWDQd9FI<%HK[W M_79< d]WH5J5]hOK:TWM_H5dSTg DIM_7 < Z RSOKF MWHJW O5CSfCSHKM MWH]\ ?aCMh79<NJ[RS]_<Gp M_79<dS]WH5J5]hOK: DQT^Th79HNCH5CMh79<NFI<$Ma~7SO5CSfTWDQf9<cO5CSfM_7S<NK<;]WDEYLOKMWDIH5CL$H[CSf9DIMWDIH5CST H[C
(59) Mh79<]_DEJ[75MW7OKCSfTWDQf9<K/6 79<GMh7S]_<<GL$H[CSf9DIMWDIH5CST T_M_OKMW<#DICH5]hf9<;]Mh7SOPM Mh79<GDQC5O5]WDQOKC[MDIT ThOPM_DITW< f*OPM. õxõ Å*c4d$e$fg.
(60) r. >% , =A!. H WY 0 @>WY@>UM@ M DIC[M_<JK<;] T 2 Z \"3 U \ ( ( / , TAYDW X W T10;2 , U VW $ Z \!3 14 U U (
(61) W ( 2 9 U VW $/Z \ $ W%3. Z q\ | 9 \VW $ Z \ 9 U VW ${/Z \ $X {W | ; = U LDVW W $ W9Z \. . 9 U VW ${/Z \ $ & /X W | 9 UVW $Z \ $ W . Ä< 9DIT_MWDQC9JMW<;]_: DEMh7"C9H:%H9f9DE<;f*ThRSX9M_< ]h:T C9< FEV
(62) L ]W<;OPM_< fMW< ]h:* ^< 9DQTWM_DICSJM_< ]h: DIM_7":H fSD<;f"T_RSXSMW< ]h:T. DIJ5RS]_<p. *<cC*DQC5M_<J5< ] f9DI DIT_DEH[Cd]WH5J5]hOK:OKCSf*DIM_Tg5< ]_DYL OPM_DEH[CLH5CSf9DIMWDIH5CT Mh79<g< C[M_]_VHKYM_7S<FIH H5d KM_79<gDQC5O5]WDQOKC[MDIT/dS]_< T_< ]_K<;fX[VG< O5L!7FIH H5dDEM_< ]hOPMWDIH5CUKOKCSf%M_7S<gdYH5T_M_LH5CSfSDEM_DEH[C DQT ThOPMWDQTW< f*OPMgM_7S<G< 9DEM HKxMh79<GFEH H[d /6 79<G< ]h]WH[]O5dSdY< OK]hTDIC*Mh79<GFIO5TWMg5< ]_DYL OPM_DEH[C¥L$H[CSf9DIMWDIH5C SMh7SOPM L OKCSCSHKMNXY<%ThOPMWDQTW< fT_DICL$/< &=?.X WSDf9H < TBC9HKMNDQ:d9FIV W <iT_V9TWM_< : XSOKT_< f"H[C*M_79<%MW< L!7C9DIZ R9< d]WH[dH[TW<;f"DICMh79DQTBdSO5d<;]BO5R9MWH[:OPMWDQLOKFEFIV"79DEJ[79FIDEJ[75MhTNMh79<%H[]WDIJKDQC"HPb 9X W*DICM_79<TWH[RS]hL$<dS]_HKJ[]_O5:* N7S< CM_79<RST_< ] T_<FI< LM_T Mh79DQTg< SdS]_< ThTWDIH5C
(63) DIC*M_7S<GK< ]_DEYLOKMWDIH5C
(64) LH5CSfSDEM_DEH[C BHKMW<#OPFQT_HM_7OPM^Mh79<#H5]_DEJ5DICHKs RX WDQT^< 9O5L$M_FEVM_7S<ThOK:<c< SdS]W<;T_T_DIH5CDQC¥M_7S<dS]_HKJ[]_O5:*x6 79DQTDIT CSHKM OPFIO3V9TM_7S<LOKT_<K<f9DQTWM_DIC9J[R9DQT_7M~HH5M_79<;] LOKT_< T < & =?X WSDMh7SOPM 7SO35<BC9H%H5]_DEJ5DIC 9OKFEMh79H5R9J[7¥T_H5:<BHK£M_7S<DQ]ThRSXY< M_79<;]W<#OK]_<c< SdS]W<;T_T_DIH5CSTFEDQ§P
(65) dS]_< ThTWDIH5CST:DEJ[75M7SO3K<BOKCH[]WDIJKDQC 6 79<V]_< dS]_< T_< C[M^C9< MW<;]_:TM_7SOKM7SO35<cXY<< CL$H[CSTWMh]_RL$MW<;f ¦]WH[:OPFQ]_< OKfSV¥< 9DQTWM_DIC9J< 9d]W<;T_T_DEH[CSTfSRS]_DIC9JMh79<GJK<;C9< ]hOPM_DEH[C
(66) dS]_H9L$< ThT :H5]_<gThRSX9M_FEV5[O5C< SdS]W<;T_T_DIH5C%FEDQ§P< , = U LD!%W"# /W%7SOKT/DIM_TÄH5]_DEJ5DIC%DICMh79<NT_RX< 9d]W<;T_T_DEH[C , U"(WgGHPUM_7S<cFIH[H[dDQC5O5]WDQOKC[M XSR9MgT_H5:<NHPxDEMhTThRSXY< SdS]_< ThTWDIH5CST KFIDQ§P< U"$ cO5CS{f ;W. 7SO3K<#Mh79<DQ]gH5]_DEJ5DICTDQC*M_79<]_DIJ57[Ma~7SOKCf
(67) T_DIf9<;T HPM_79<O5T_T_DIJ5CS:< C[MhTDQC*M_79<GFIH H5d*XH9f9V5 < DIFIFdS]_H5dYH5T_<O¥]_< dS]_< T_< C[MhOPMWDIH5C*HKÄH5]_DEJ5DIC*DQC H5]h:OPMWDIH5CTNM_7OPMcMhOK§K< TNDQC[MWH
(68) O5LLH5RSC[MNMh79< T_<%f9&D %< ]_< CL$< T/X[VO3KHKDQf9DQC9JMWHT_MWH5]_<gM_79<cH5]_DEJ5DICSTHKOKFEFYT_RSXSMW< ]h:T/HP O#MW<;]_:(M_7SOKM/O5T/C9HKMÄL!7OKC9J5< ffSRS]_DIC9J Mh79<L$H[CSf9DIMWDIH5CJK<;C9< ]hOPM_DEH[C 0* Ä ?aC
(69) H5]hf9< ]^MWHRSCSf9<;]_T_M_O5CSf
(70) 7SHdSOK]_M_THP£Mh79<GTWH[RS]hL$<cdS]_HKJ[]_O5:O5dSdY< OK]OPMgf9D&%.<;]W<;C[MdYH5T_DEM_DEH[CSTDICM_79< 5< ]_D.LOPM_DEH[CL$H[CSf9DIMWDIH5CST FI<M/RST/L$H[CST_DIf9<;]Oc5< ]_VTWDQ:d9FE<gdS]_HKJ[]_O5Y : 5! DE F K ]2z/3 ; 2 X \"3 '. ¬ ë õ ¬_.
(71)
Documents relatifs
To test whether the vesicular pool of Atat1 promotes the acetyl- ation of -tubulin in MTs, we isolated subcellular fractions from newborn mouse cortices and then assessed
Néanmoins, la dualité des acides (Lewis et Bronsted) est un système dispendieux, dont le recyclage est une opération complexe et par conséquent difficilement applicable à
Cette mutation familiale du gène MME est une substitution d’une base guanine par une base adenine sur le chromosome 3q25.2, ce qui induit un remplacement d’un acide aminé cystéine
En ouvrant cette page avec Netscape composer, vous verrez que le cadre prévu pour accueillir le panoramique a une taille déterminée, choisie par les concepteurs des hyperpaysages
Chaque séance durera deux heures, mais dans la seconde, seule la première heure sera consacrée à l'expérimentation décrite ici ; durant la seconde, les élèves travailleront sur
A time-varying respiratory elastance model is developed with a negative elastic component (E demand ), to describe the driving pressure generated during a patient initiated
The aim of this study was to assess, in three experimental fields representative of the various topoclimatological zones of Luxembourg, the impact of timing of fungicide
Attention to a relation ontology [...] refocuses security discourses to better reflect and appreciate three forms of interconnection that are not sufficiently attended to
