Numerical resolution of an unbalanced mass transport problem
26
0
0
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Numerical resolution of an unbalanced mass transport problem J.-D. Benamou. N° 4786 mars 2003. ISSN 0249-6399. ISRN INRIA/RR--4786--FR+ENG. THÈME 4. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4)
(5) !" #$% !&'&( *)+& ) (,
(6) - . /10324/6587:9<;>=@?BA CDFEHGJI,K!a LN I_Xb^f6MP_cOQg`V`G YiE
(7) hcGJRFISUVkIHTW_VXjkOZd
(8) Y\CY\[ GJClIj]FV-SZY:Ie^]^IHVXOZ_ GJOZ_`TWV`OQY:[ m-Ti]n]oY:gpV a I,g`IHdqDFIHg`dqDnIr[>sKPtiu\vLwGxTigq_y\z\z:{,L|y:}]oTi~\I_. (H
(9) WFi: CDFOU_]oTi]>I
(10) g]Fg`Y\]>Y:_XIkT GJY a OodHTWV`OQY:[YiVXDFI,Y:[F~\I,Ti[V`Y\g`YWOQV`dqDJ]Fg`Y\nSQIHGYi&I
(11) e^]oY:[FI
(12) [V-y GJDFIV`OUdqDFDxY aT\d
(13) OQd
(14) [Y\V`GJgXY Y a a RnTWd
(15) V`I IHa _(OZ[F[Y:[J vWonOUTi_#SUTiT [na d
(16) T\I ]^a VXI OZ[Fa OV`VXOZYT\SoV`DFT\OU[ _a [FnI [nTi S RFa [PI
(17) n[oT\_pSZOQT\VXOZ[nIHd_HI aC Dn]FI-gXY:TiFRFSZ~:I
(18) G8GIH[4VXI IlaJOZ SZSQTiRn~\_pVXgqgqTiTW[nV`~\I-OUTiV`[!DFIl[PRFRnGJ_`TiIHngXOQOUSZd
(19) OVcT\b S Yi VXDnOZ_GJIV`DFY a Y\[Ti[T\dHT a IHG8OUdkI
(20) g`gXY:gI_cV`OQGxTiVXOZY\[ ]FgXY:FSZI
(21) GOZ[G8I
(22) VXIHY\g`Y\SZY\~\b: B¡X¢!£ W¤: Y\[F~:I6,Ti[VXY:gXYWPOQV`dqDk]FgXY:FSZI
(23) G¥H¦T\_`_XI
(24) gXVXI
(25) OZ[ a OU_cVqTi[nd
(26) I\¥W§-Rn~\GJI
(27) [VXI a, T\~\gqTi[F~:OZT\[¨GJIV`DFY a. Unité de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 Le Chesnay Cedex (France) Téléphone : +33 1 39 63 55 11 — Télécopie : +33 1 39 63 53 30.
(28) J ( J" $c N) - $ & !"&)+,$" & J 3 PG
(29) OVq dqV`DDFY aa II
(30) eP[P]>RFY:G _` Ti
(31) Y:[g`RnOV _!RFy]nI gX Y:a RF]oI O-Y]> _pY:I
(32) T\g`[n~\G8_gqTiI
(33) a [FV T\~:[naOQIH_JI[+dVXT\I"gqRFTiVXOQ~\VXgqGJIHT gWI
(34) Ti[a OZV SIHx _ RFOQ[Fa[IIHVXg`[nGJY _XaOYV RFH a OQ_JOQVXoI OZd
(35) [FTia OV`VXTiOZOZ[nT\Y\_SQ[ I_x av #RTi[ IH]Fa_pVg`Y\nT F[oa SZTiE
(36) TiSZGJ]^IHV _JI
(37) I"[Fa Y:I ! [ d
(38) IY\: [FRn[F~:OQY\SZI"RnOQn\,g IHH T\TiIHR+[_HV`]nY\gXg` Y#YT Fa)SZ E
(39) IHGJ_pVXOZI Gx [nTWVXY\OZ[$Y\%[ & a)RF I
(40) OZSQg`OZgXFIHg RF g I
(41) [ Y\G Rn_ V OZ
(42) SQSZY\Rng`_pY\VXSZg`Y\Y\~:[nOQI:_ SU T¨]>I
(43) gXVXOZ[FIH[ndI a IdI
(44) VpV`IG'
(45) VXDFY a I_XRFg(RF[J]Fg`Y\FSZE
(46) GJIT\d
(47) T a
(48) GJO( RFI * £ H ¡ ,+ ]FgXY:FSZE
(49) GJI a I,Y\[F~:I\¥ a OU_pV`Ti[odI a I¦T\_`_pIHgpV`I
(50) OZ[*¥^G VXDnY a I a I T\~\gqTi[F~:OQIH[§-RF~:GJI
(51) [V .
(52) {.
(53) !
(54) !. &(x$" "Fg`Y\GY\[F~:I _V`DFI
(55) Y:gXb a I_ a
(56) FSUTiOU_#IV a IH_g`I
(57) G FSUTiOU_ OZ[V`DFISZTiVXI#%$ &('8dI
(58) [V`RFgXb {:} VXYJ]Fg`IH_XI
(59) [V a T bP_H¥PT d y\Y:y[n#_XO
(60) a-.,IHg`T\/F-ySZI#Ti
(61) -GJz Y\Rn {[:tV(YiQ Z1 03Y:g§-)k]nOQT\[8gpGxVl T\gX_`Y:_*G V`g`OQT\V`[n_-_XRo]o_pY:I,gpVOZ[ VXDFa IHO
(62) Y\2>g`IHbkgXIHDo[:T\Vl_VXoDFIHIHI
(63) Y\[8g`I~:VXTWOUV`d
(64) DFT\I
(65) S&g`_pI VXa+R a * OZyWIHKW_ * /{\-Hv { # {\
(66) -H{ KW {\ yzW#
(67) -3{ -3, /yi-u} GJY {\a uI_V` QI
(68) OZZ_&Y\1 0g`VXY\DF]>SZIHYiY\gXV`~:I
(69) I
(70) bx [Y\VXIg`OUIVqTidiTiS ZSZQ g` OZIH[ *T a ay Rnb¨-
(71) _pVXTig` [!y\OZT\v OZS _` _pRnTi,W]FI<]n Y\y\SQOUg{ d
(72) TiVXDFVX y OZI#Y\, [nTi#]F_< ]n{4T\SQ-3SZOZ_XI Ya {:I
(73) Gxy GJTiI
(74) VX{\g`DF~\KWIHI:GJ¥WZZTiY\0VXg<#OUdOZC[nOUTi_pDF[nV`I Ti_ [oa* d/IH-I_XBOQOZ~: [8{i[>GJYiKiI<Ba I6 OZv5dH Tid SFtHOZI
(75) OZBGx[ uWV-TiB~:[P
(76) OQRF-W[FGJtH~o>¥\I
(77) g`yiT\OUvW_pd
(78) VX>Tig`S&Y\y:[nG8tHBY\I
(79) G!ZVXQD$1b:03 ¥ VXSZI
(80) Do9 TG WV § 8#a GxI
(81) CnTWDF[FhcIIY:_Xg6V`Y\DFY\SZI-R^oV`_c¦OQVqY:T\T\[d_`SZI_pYiIH(VXg`YVX_pDFVXVXIHI DFOQ[ IlaT:d3OU_cV`f VqRnTiTi]F[nSog`d
(82) RnYWI _p&IlO a OUYi_<IB_V`VXDFTiDFI[I¨VXY\Y\]FV`Y\T\VX[FSFOZGJ~:GxIT\T\ S ,_`VX_<TigqnTi[Ti[oVXY:SU_cTigXIH[oYWg-dPI-OQGxV`ddqTiY:D ][nGJ_p>VXT:Igq_XTiV _<OZ[:VXI
(83) V<gqI
(84) TiY:[[n[ V_pV`I
(85) DFYg6I ]n* a OZgX[FTiY:OQV`FVXTOUSQTiIHY\GS >TiV`[* DFa I-]Fng`[o7f Y\Ti0 :S 0 ]FT8g`VXIHgq_`Tid[og`OQ_c> IHI g-a Gxa I
(86) Ti[n]n_X_lOQVc]Fb"gXI _pRnIH[ngXd3PV`OZOQ[FY:~8[n_ VXDF IOQVXVXD+YiVqOTia S*I
(87) Gx[VXT:OUd
(88) _XT\_H<S ;>j¨=[nI,[FY:g`T\gXGgXIH@SQb? [ T\dYiIV`_DFI
(89) ggXI TiS Y: g an_T\SZVXT\Dn[nI dI da SUT\a_`_XTWOZV`dHTnTi¥FSV` DFI
(90) g`If Y:]FgXg`IYWRnP_XO aOQ[nI~ _ VXB¨DnCO I82BI
(91) g`I
(92) [V!f [FY\Y:[gXGxRF[PT\nSQ/O T\AHTiSZT\VX[nOZY\d[nI _,aDoa T TW\VqIxT>IHOI
(93) V`I
(94) DF[¦I
(95) gkV`IHgX_pIVXI RFa OQg`OQIH[ _¨_p {iY:KiGJ#ITi[ [FaY\g`OGxVJTi_pSZIH
(96) O AI
(97) TWGxV`_OQY:VX[DoY\TWV8g¨T_XRnGJdqD Y a TOo]FdHg`TWY^V`dOQY:I_X[_,YiRn<[nV`T DF\I8Y:O a T\Ff SZb GJPbxY a[FOY\ OUb _XIlVXDnY\I-g#GxYiV`T\DF_`I
(98) _ g#a [FOZY:_pVX[g`OZ_pFOZR^~\[nVXOZOY\o[dHTiT\[[ Va ]nVXDFDFI
(99) IH[FgXY:I
(100) GJY\g`I
(101) I#[nTnVXDF¥PIT!V`[Fg`Y\T\g`[nGx_p TiI
(102) SZg<
(103) O AGxTWV`TiOQ]xY:[OQV`Yi_XI
(104) SQV`cDFDI ? oa V`TWDFV`I-T8nd
(105) T\T\SZ[T\[n_XdI
(106) I g`OQaY:I
(107) Rn _pTiSZb8RFSQOQV6GJOU_]nd
(108) T\T\OQg#RnVX_XDnI a I g`I
(109) SZI
(110) WTi[nd
(111) IYi&V`DFIf _XY\SZR^VXOZY\[* OU~\_gqTiI&[n4~\RFIJOUOZTiW[VXTiDFSZV`I
(112) IHIH[gXdqI
(113) V,DF Y\[nVXYg`O I VXRFDFIY^Id
(114) YiRn(]>_,I
(115) v [oY\FTi[4VXSZY
(116) O V`ADFV`TWDFIVXOZIY\_pVX[¦IOZdGJY:V`IH[Idq a DFa [nI
(117) Y\]>O ]^I
(118) V`RF[ OQY:Ia [4Ti]n[gXT\VI[ _pTia IH[ [:]Fa V`gXI ]>Y:a I
(119) ]o[nOZY[ T\_pSQIxO/ A
(120) tHT I a GJ+Y\Y g`a I"G!O>DFRFd
(121) I
(122) SUTWg`TWV`IV`OQOQY:Y:T [¦[!a TiYiYi]^#>V,VXVXDnDFV`DFI-IxI"V`DFT\IRFf~\GJTiI
(123) [ [fa V`IY\ a¦^DFVq TiOUdqOZT[D T8gXY:FRn_pV[RnG8IHgXOUd
(124) T\S GJIVXDnY a Y:gRF[PnTiSUTi[nd
(125) I a a TWVqTF GJIH_pIVXOZV`GxMPDFIY TWd3aV`VXOQOZ Y:Y\["E[ +]F-Ig`Y\]FOZnSQg`SZSQIHRnIH_X_pGJI
(126) VX[gq_TWV`OZ_V`[IVXGJDFVXDnI II VXGxIHGJY\TWg`V`I
(127) Y\DFVXSZDFI
(128) Y\GxY ~:a b\TW V`OZOZ[ dHTi_XSIHdG8VXOZY Y\a [ IHS {¥_pY\I[ d3VXTOZY\[@]oTiygXVXVXOUdDFRFISUTiTig8Rn~\TiGJ]F]FI
(129) SZ[OUd
(130) VXTWI aV`OQY: [T\~\g`I
(131) gqTiSUTW[FVX~:I OZa T\[4V`Y+[PRFTiGJ[ IHI
(132) gXg`OUgXd
(133) Y:T\g S F RTSUR. G. Hx$JILKNMO & * QP !" #. VXWZY\[^]`_bacY\dEeT_7f]cg]ihkjlfm4W. * I
(134) VRnf7_J0 8 og`_pVgXId
(135) T\SQSV`DFIGJY\[FY# ]nDnT\_XOZd dSUT\_`_pOUd
(136) T\S Y\g`G!RFSUTWV`OQY:[ Y\¨V`DFI Y:[F~\I ,T\[VXY\g`YWPOVqdqD]Fg`Y\FSZI
(137) G n OZ\I
(138) [8V YoY:RF[ a I a ¥:[nY\[$ [FI
(139) ~TWV`OQ:I#GJIT\_XRFg`T\FSZI Rn[nd3V`OQY:[n_Toqp-Ti[ a oqr OQVXD_`TiGJIGxT\_`_(OQ[JV`DFIVXY:gXRo_ sutwvTxy zx¥\n[ a Ti[xT\]F]FSZOZdHTWVXOZY\[{ OZdqDJg`IHT\SQO/A
(140) I_ VXDFIV`g`T\[n_X]oY:gpV( g`Y\G|oqpV`Y}oNrOZ[JVXDnI Y\SZSQY OZ[F~_XI
(141) [n_XI 8c"FY:g-TiSZS oY:gXIHS*_pI
(142) bV ~¥ { _XTiVXOU_coIH_ Ti[ a T:dqDFOQIH\I_V`DFI,GJOQ[nOQGxTiSdY:_pV. +N oqp 3t q No r`( 3. * -0. {( oqp ( 3. * 30. RTS. eTqNYg43fYjU_¡ wj3fqeT_mY. ««¬ ®. K^tWu:v. y. 4Tig`IkIl~\g`IHOZ\d
(143) I
(144) T\[SQSoVDFI
(145) g`Y I-a V`IHDF[nI-_pOQV`VcOQbxGJI RF a[oIHd3VX]oOZIHY\[ [oa _>IHo [:p V#(Y\>g`G!£¥Rn¤8SZTiTiVX[ OZY\a [xo Yi ( V`DF¦Ik£§4¤!T:Y\_X_XiI
(146) ©gXVX¨©IHOQ[ sa ¥FOUT _pV`oTiY:[oRFdI[ a * I Y\a g Y:a ]oIIHVq["TiOZSZ_X_#IV_pIHOZI![ª vv ¢x 03<<44II RFgXVXDFIHg-T\_`_pRnG8IkV`DnTWVV`DFI
(147) b Tig`I¨>Y\RF[ a I a Ti[ a [nY\g`GJ= T\SQ/O A
(148) I a I OQSZS&_`T b oTiSUTi[nd
(149) I a 8 oqp l ©t o l ©t\#3 * N{ 0 =.
(150) K. . ! . 4a IHIJ[n_pFOQVce+bT"I
(151) V-VXOZ\GJI
(152) SZIxY^dOQ[OQVcVXbxIHgXnWIHT\S S a _H ¤4¥ o
(153) U*
(154) ¦£§t ¤F#x¥OQ[¦ TiU SZS(¦VX¨©DnIvT_pxnI¥o:_XRnTiI
(155) VXS:OU0_c TibP[OZ[Fa ~8dVXY:DF[nI_pOd
(156) a Y\IH[gVXOZT\[PSQRFS<O]>VcbY:_`I&_XOQFRnSZTWI8V`OQVXY:OZGJ[ I a I
(157) ]>I
(158) [ a I
(159) [VH¥ o
(160) oct ¤4 tE¤ s * qK 0 & TiY\[ 7g a ¤"OU_-!#d$Y:[n!%_XI
(161)
(162) g`\TiI [ a a ©¨©s&¥ OU_(VXDnIY\R^V Tig a [nY\g`GJT\SPVXY s(CDFIGxT\_`_6d
(163) T\[F[FY\(V 'oY Y:R^V6Yi>VXDFI a Y\GxTiOZ[ ? [FOQVXOUTiS*T\[ a n[nTiS*d
(164) Y\[ a OV`OQY:[n_ * 3} 0 o¤%1TtwoNp Lo
(165) b! Tt o = Ti,g`TiI[]nV`Y\gXg`IYW_Xd
(166) gXOQV`OZodqDI a a OZ _pY:V`g T\[nId:I RoTWVX_XOZI
(167) Y\Ix[ / -%* qK , 03 @ Y:Cg-DFTJIHgX[*IH¥6PV`OQI DFI0_ OU_Rn~\T\OZgX\I"IH["YilPV`bDFI vW 4T:_X_XI
(168) gq_cV`I
(169) OZ[ a OU_cVqTi[nd
(170) I * TiSU_pY¦d
(171) T\SQSZI a ; r * Nv 0 )+*-,.o p Uo = t/.102
(172) # o9 U 9 U 3b;:3 p 354 687 TiGJY:[F~8T\SQDS o<#_`TWV`OZ_p bPOQ[F~ * qK 0#Ti[ Xa * 3} 036CDFIGJOQ[nOQGJ/O AHTWV`OQY:["]ngXY:FSQIHG * Nv 0dHTi[ oI,_XDFY [V`YJoId
(173) Y\[P\I
(174) e OQVXDSQOZ[FITig-dY:[n_pVXgqTiOZ[:Vq_#OQ[ VXDnI, T\gXOUTinSQI (o =two>3T? [ a I
(175) I a Rn_pOZ[F~8VXDnIH_XI,[FI T\gXOUTin SQI_8 r = # *t 0 3bBC: )+*-, (oqp o = t?.102
(176) p Ko 354 @A7 Ti[ La * NK 0VXgqTi[o_c Y:gXGx_#OQ[ oD% /=ctE¤E=F tw¤G s * Nu 0 & _X vWY\ SZR^ CY\VXOZgDFY\Ix[OQV`_ldOUY:_kd[PY\RF\GJ[FIO(e^]FOQRFRFVcV`b I8TWV`T\OQ[ Y:OV`a[*D4 T\g`[ IHa _X]>T\IH[+d3VTiV`RnXY ~\GJoI
(177) <[=©VXI laY\T\VXDn~\gqIxTiOQ[F[~:VXOZIHT\~\[gqTi[[ Rna G8OQIH[ gXOUd
(178) * t T\0¨S&V` Y\IHSZdqSQDFY [n O _¨RF g`I8Y\DnG T\_¨ Y:>gXI
(179) G I
(180) RF[+SUT ]Fg`* Y\yi]>3v Y:0_X8I aCDnOZ[ I OU_X_,RF]FOVq]>
(181) _Y\ _XgXG8VXI YPaFY\I OZVXHK[ DF[FJMvTIL9x"Jx_X_ Ti [ §la OQVX_ D¦Y\TiFSZg`V`gXIHTiI_XTOZ]o[Fa II bkd3a V,GJ V`g`I
(182) Y"Y\[uG VXV`OZg`Y\oqT\[n[npkI _XaVXSZDnTiOZVXgX[OZY:Y\V`RF[nDF~\_HOZD_ ]FT g`IVXI
(183) gqVPTiOZRoY\[n_Rn_XSZ_&TiT\]nVX_`OZ_pTiY\Rn]>O[ G8I
(184) gNQI8¥WP Tl Y:_pg,VXg`OQ
(185) O[n)P_pOZV`[FT\~l[n]FdIJg`Y\V`]>DnI
(186) TWgXV Vcbko Yi= ^OUVX_DnOZd_ Y:aG8OU_c]oVqT\Tid3[nV`d
(187) SQb I o = ctwoNp (SRi. Y\gRX¨©vTxn6CDnI
(188) [OVldHTi[ oIdqDnIHd)\I a V`DnTWVV`DFI a I
(189) [o_pOQVcbOU_Ti[nT\SQbV`OZdHTiSZSQbx~:OQ:I
(190) [ b. * ,N0. Hz VXTiY8[ a V`DFVXIDFIVXgqY\Ti]^[nV`_XOQSUGJTWVXO/AHOZY\TW[^V`OQY:8[]Fg`Y\FSZI
(191) G * Kq0*_XOQGJ]FSZbkbOZI
(192) S a _ T RnT a g`TiVXOUd a I
(193) ]>I
(194) [ a I
(195) [nd
(196) IYi^V`DFI a OZ_pV`T\[ndI OQVXD!gXI_p]>IHdV o9 U ct oqp . . )+*Q,.
(197). . Ri. (oqp Uo = t R i oqp q3 /A.
(198) F IH/JTL1U@ mIHGJT\g)©-:
(199) -,dHTi[ oI,~:I
(200) [FIHg`T\SQO
(201) I a VXY a OQSUTWV`I a Ti[ a VXgqTi[o_pSUTWV`I aa I
(202) [n_XOV`OQI_}8. Y\g V£. * - -0. y. o = ctGV x o p WV+SRiU. * - 30. oqp3(l t\#3 4oqp3(l tw¤4 qo p 3t # . * - N0. >¥FT\[ a o p UO _[FY T:_X_XRFGJI a VXYx_`TWV`OZ_p b. ¤RX¨vTx. * - N0. H{. XZY<«+X\[.
(203) }.
(204) !
(205) !. CDFI a IH[n_XOVcbOU_[FY Ti[nT\SQbVXOUd
(206) T\SQSZb~:OQ:I
(207) [Pb o9 U`t #Z * N0 > )+*-,(o p o. #. r & +. Ti[ a V`DFI,Y\]^V`OQGJO/AHTiVXOZY\[]Fg`Y\FSZI
(208) G K #_XOQGJ]FSZbbPOZI
(209) S a _. r & R x o p &r U #b r & + & r.
(210) K. * - q0. } a IH]o
(211) IH[ a I
(212) [FV I H/Y:gXJTG L@RFSZTiVX OZY\I[*V(Rn4_]>I,Y\OQOZ[ [a VI
(213) VXI Dna Tig`VI
(214) OGxVT\OU_g)J]oYV`Dn_X_XTWOQV nSQIkVXYJI
(215) eP]ngXI_X_VXDnI a OZ_pV`T\[ndIRn_XOZ[F~xT _XOQGJOZSZT\gVXOZGJI = t\U#Z V = . . R ; . r oNp U o = t/.102
(216) # & o U 3 bC:3 p 354 687 * 0 +* N0 /A * 0
(217) A. * - 30. Hv Ti[POQVXbPDªGJ(Y\o g` I!&Y:[KT\~: T\OQT\[![ _Xa RF^d
(218) hcY\I[nd3_pV VXVXgqY¨TiOZVX[DFV Id
(219) y Y\k[nOU_p_#VXgqhcTiRnOZ_p[VV`_GJIHy [: V`TiOQY:[ [Fa I a { 3DF(IHgXCIJDFPI#b Y\]^TiV`[oOQGJTiSZY\O H~\TWb V`OQY:[!OQVX]FD g`Y\MPnIHdSQIHVXG OZY\[¥a Y-\I/_ -\8[FYi+V Ixa I
(220) T\]>~:I
(221) Ti[ OZa[ Dn_XO T a :IIY\VX Y* -dY:-0([n_Xd
(222) O T\a [8IHgl>ITxa dO
(223) Y:2>[PIH\gXIIHe"[VXG8OUTWOZVX[FI OZa GJ<O CTWDFVXIOZY\Y\[]F]nVXOZgXGJY:FT\SQSQIHOQVcGb #d
(224) Y\C[ DFa I OV`dOQY:Y:[J_pV_XOZRFG8[n]ndSQVXb8OZY\I[e^]FT\g`]FIH]o_`I_ TiVXg`DnOQ[nTiV<~xVXY\DF[ IlVXY\DF]^I!V`OQgXGxOZ~\TiD4S V-oDn9 T\U[ a _`TWVXOU_pnIH_ * {30#Ti[ a o tE¤ *-t 0 &:& Ti[ a OU_VXDnI
(225) g`I Y\g`I_pOZGJ]FSQb"~\OZ\IH["PbxV`DFIVXOZGJI,OQ[VXIHgX]>Y\SUTWV`OQY:[ Y:gXG RFSUT * -HNu 0 o U ct o = (D
(226) Lo p + o p ( mIH]FSZT:dOZ[F~ & oOQ[ * -3-.0¥ Ikn[nT\SQSZbY:^V`T\OQ[ VXDnIdSUTiOZG8I a ; a OZ_pV`T\[ndI 8 * - N0. (oqp o = t o = (TLoqp . RTS. [ j
(227) >Y¡gYle
(228) kY¡ wj feT_bmY * /- :0. X>_ VY\IGJOZT_I d~:T\SZYPIH]FY T\]Fa g SZOZdqdH_XDFTWI
(229) Y:VXI OZOZY\d
(230) [oI\tH_
(231) ¥>- {iVXYDnKW-I8I
(232) dqH:DFvWI
(233) Y:g#-OZd
(234) VXVXI!DFDnIY\Ti6d
(235) VY\VXVX[nDFDF_pI I8VXgqa oTiOUIHOZ_p[DnV`V#TiT [oPY\dOQY:I Gxg T T\ _`_XOQ_I
(236) VX[nD+n_XT\OgXV`SZIT\OQ_p:[n]>I!dIHI OUd_XV¨_X* RF-V`0#YI8OZTiV`_g`[ gqT\a Ti[ng`_XVXI
(237) SZDFSZTibI8VXOZ_`Y\4TW[ VXT:OUT\_X_p_Xn[ I
(238) Ia gqa _paVX I
(239) OZSUOZTW[ VXOZa Y\OU[+_pV`GxTi[oT d)\I8I_
(240) GJ¥BT OZ[b OZYi[xY\VX4DF]^IV`IlOQ_pGxI:]F¥BTig` Y\SoY\]>dgY\Y:OQ[_X[oIV`_cagXVqY:TiOZSP[[n d
(241) Y\ Itg BaVXTDnIITi]oSZIHOQo[n[n[n~ TiTiSZS<
(242) O AdOQTWVXY:V`DJ[ OQY:aV [J OQVXY,OZY\Y\]>g`[G!Y\oOZRF[:SUV
(243) bTW*V`!OZOQ [FY:ZO[JV`t|OZT\Y\oSngTiRn[ Ti[a [ oanTi[nSUI
(244) TiTi[^[nS:0 d
(245) Y:I >g`a d
(246) Y\I!RFGx[ OQT\Va _`TiVX_ DFg`a b g`TiY\dV`RFY:Tn~:[ D a § OQT"VXOZdY\]oSU[nT\IH_`_6[n_pTiOZOU_(d
(247) SZO
(248) T\V`AS^Y,TWVXV`gXIOQIHY:dqSZ[DFTi[Fe!VXO(IH:Y\gXRn[nG II T ana I a VXYJV`DFIdY_cV RF[ndVXOZY\[nT\S 6Y\g`I¨]Fg`IHd
(249) OZ_XI
(250) SZbOZ[n_pVXIHT a = Y\ * 3v 0¥ IRn_XI a VXDnI,gXIHSZTiePI a f ?. * (o p o = t. .102
(251) @#7. r = B & o9
(252) ZU <Lo &: = p Ko K bo /A ¥* 30 Lo9
(253) ZU * N0 o = . * -%,N0. OU_DFTIHgX_cI VqTW V`IxOZ_¨ TJT\gX]oOUTiYn_pOQSQVXI OZ\a II
(254) n]>[FI
(255) I[oa TiSQVcPbb]no T\p g`T\TiG8[ a I
(256) VXIHugH"CY\VXDFI,IJV`nDn[oTWTiV S "a OZIH_-[n[F_XOYiVcV¨b T\[PbGJY:kgXIOZ_TJ[FGJIHd
(257) OZ[FIHOQ_`GJ_XT\O gXHOZTiSQbVXOZY\o[TiSUWTiTi[ng`d
(258) OZIT\a FSZI\ ¦OV`? D V oqpoId
(259) TiRo_pIOQV-OZ_-TJ_XY\SZR^VXOZY\["VXY8V`DFIdY:[n_pIHgXWTiVXOZY\[SUT K #FRFV-[FYiV OQVXD <e^OU_cV`I
(260) [nd
(261) ITi[ a RF[FO(RFI
(262) [FI_X_ YiGJ#ITV`DF_XY Y\a SZR^<VXCOZY\DF[OZ_ Y:[Pg¨RFGJ]ngXI
(263) Y:g`FOZdHSQIHTiGSnGJ* I
(264) -%VX,NDF0 Y a T\VX_lRngX [nY\g`_GxY\R^TiSZVSQbVXYIH>_pV`I¨T\F_XI
(265) SZOZ[n_X_XDFOQIVXOZa \IOQ[ VXY t VX DFI¨DFOQGJIHgX]FI SZOZ d
(266) OI8VdRnY:_X[nI _cT"V`g`dT\Y\OQ[[iVchcRFo~:£¥TiVXI!¤ ~:g`DFT OUa dqOZDxI
(267) [OZ_V [FOU_#IVXdYxIH_`T_`Tia g`T\b]^VVXYVXDFVXIDFI8GJdY\Y:g`[Ik:gXIY:eFRndqDn_pVTigqT\T\~\dGJVXI
(268) I
(269) g`[/O AHV`TWI aV`OQY:SUTi["~:Y\g`T\<[FVX~\DFOUI Ti[OQ[G8V`I
(270) I
(271) ~\VXgqDFTiY[ a a Yi* #Y\ g`viG! RnVXYxSZT TJ* _pyiSZNv OQ~:0U03DF,SZb j¨a [FCO I2BI
(272) ~:g`Y:I
(273) Ti[SVYiGJ(Y VXDna OZO >_kd
(274) ]nTWT\V`]oOQY:IH[ g Yi VXDnI f OZ[P\Y:SQPOZ[F~!V`DFI ; a OZ_pV`T\[ndI: ««¬ ®. K^tWu:v.
(275) v. . RTS. VXWZY j
(276) kY bjU3feT_bmY ) 8 o = ; .102 )+*-, ,.(o p o = 3 7. ! . [a OU_cVqV`TiDF[nOU_d
(277) I]nTiOZ[]>I
(278) VXg DFI! I Y\SZ]FSQYg`Y\]>OZ[FY:_X~I_XV`I
(279) Y [n_X I Y\g ~:OQY\:[+I
(280) [ RFV [PnYTiSU]oTi[nY_Xd
(281) _XI OZaFSQab"TWRFV`T"[PnPTibSUTid[oY:d[nI _paO a a IHI
(282) gX[nOZ[F_XO~V`OQV`IDF_ZI8oqG8pTiOQe^[ I a a o 4¥nT:n_X_X[ I
(283) a gq_po VXI
(284) OZ[ VX; DnI dd
(285) SZT\Y:["_XIH>_pIV a Y\I
(286) g`[oG!_pOQRnVcSZbTiVXV`I Y a T\ _ OZ[VXDnI _XI
(287) [n_XI DFOUdqDG8OZ[FOZGJO
(288) AHIH_V`DFI,¦T\_`_pIHg`_pVXIHOQ[ a OU_cVqTi[nd
(289) I )+= *-, , (oqp =o = q7? V * yiNz 0 o = Uo = :3 K DFIHgXI OU_-T8]oY_pOQVXOZ\I]nT\g`T\G8I
(290) VXIHg#oTiSUTi[nd
(291) OQ[F~8V`DFIkV Y a OU_cVqTi[nd
(292) IH_H GJOQ[nmOQGJIHGJ/O AHTWT\V`g OQ)+Y:[ VXDo TWOV8V`D VXDFg`OUIH_8_X]>]FIHgXd3Y:VFSZV`I
(293) Y G V`DFOUI_ d
(294) Y\DF[nY:d
(295) SQI
(296) }I ]^oJV`RnnTiIHSZSSQab¦T :? I
(297) Vlg`b¦d
(298) Ti[ d
(299) SQY>_pI,IgXVXI
(300) Y Y\*g`-.G!,3RF0,SUTWIHV`\I IHa [ T\VX_ DFY:RF~\D I"DFI
(301) g`+I ):I
(302) IH]VXDnI r * y -0 @ (o p o = t .02
(303) = o 3b o = ( DXo = ( 3 : p K K 354 @A4 3 7 OQVXD VXDFIT aFa OQVXOZY\[nT\S*dY:[n_cV`g`T\OQ[V * y\3y 0 o
(304) Z%1Tt o = VX_`Y:TWVX~\OUI
(305) _pVXnDFI IHa g OQVXD V`DFIRn_XRnT\S#d
(306) Y\[n_pVXgqTiOZ[V o9
(307) Z! t o p T\[ a VXDnI d
(308) Y\[VXOZ[PRFOVcb4I&RnTiVXOZY\[ * 3u 0 DnOZdqDG Rn_pV >I j¨[FIldHTi[Y:n_XI
(309) g`\IVXDoTWVdY\[o_cV`g`T\OQ[V * y:y 0 hcRn_cVOZ[ a OUd
(310) TWV`IH_VXDnTiVV`DFIlGJOZ[FOQGJ/O AHTiVXOZY\[WTig`OUTiFSZIH`_ o9
(311) Z! <T\[ a o = DoT \I-V`Y >IkVXDFI_`TiGJI\ 6SZOQGJOZ[nTWV`OQ[n~ o = gXI a Rnd
(312) IH_ * y -0<V`Y * -%,N0<V`DnTWV T\__pY:SQ:I a OZ[ 1t <4I¨DFIHgXI¨ Y^dRn_ Y\[" Y\g`G!RnSZTiVXOZY\[ * y-0#Ti[ a _pY:SQ:IOV-PbT a Ti]^V`OQ[n~ V`DFI§-Rn~\GJI
(313) [VXI a Ti~:g`T\[F~\OUTi[xGJI
(314) VXDFY a Yi vW ?. . . . . . . . . .
(315) . >SUR. ! $ ¦ ,( J
(316) # x$ . . . . . VXWZY eDacgeT_ba`jleT_. CDFI d Y:G8 ]nOZ_#R^V`V`DFTiIVXOZY\_X]n[nTWT\V`SoOZ>T\SY\RF~\[gqT a a I OZa"I
(317) [a VY\OQGx[©Tiv OZ[x OU_ a I
(318) [FY\VXI a s¨vTxJT\[ a V`DFIl Y:SQSZY OZ[F~[FY\V`TWV`OQY:[n_ OQSZSBoIkRn_XI a 8 & 4 t 7 & C :,OZ_V`DFIVXOZGJI _p]oT\dIk~\gqT a OQIH[:VOZ[©vDx = & 4 t & OU_V`DFIVXOZGJI _p]nT:dI T\]FSUT\dOUTi[& Y\g6V Y!:IHdVXY\gq_6OZ[+v vDx>¥ -Ti[ a ¥ 7 :3 7 : Z:t a I
(319) [nYiVXI_6V`DFIkOQ[F[nI
(320) g#]FgXY a Rod3VH T\~\CCgqTiDFDF[FII ~:IlT\G ~\RFgqfrTiSV`[FOQdH]n~:TiOZSQ[¦T\OZI
(321) [g oOUI i_9 ~\ OZUg`\OQI
(322) Vp#VX[ IH Y\[Pg-b T\d_,8 Y:[nT_pVX_`gqT TiaFOZa[:SQVqI _ ]>* KNY\0OZ[T\V[ ]naXgXY:* } F0SQIH G Pb OZ[VXg`Y a RndOZ[F~T_X]nT\d
(323) I VXOZG8I a IH]oIH[ a IH[:V . . . . "!. $# "!#. "!. $# "!%#. & $# '! (!#. *). ;Z+)o<=L o = ct. r = )4o ,)i =ª3b & o p )i¤!K o p -)i
(324) Z%1 o = o = Xo = 3 K * N0. yi{. * N0. XV OZY\DF[oIHgX_ I* }V`DFcy\Iy3VX03IH gXGx_OZ[P\Y\SZPOQ[n~ +dY:G8Ik g`Y\G VXDFIOZ[VXIH~\gqTWVXOZY\["Pb]nT\gpV-Y\ K Ti[ a Ro_pOZ[F~JoY:RF[ a T\gXb dY:[ a O n OZ\I
(325) [8OZ[FOV`OZT\SoT\[ a n[nTiS a I
(326) [n_XOQVXOZIH_ToqpTi[ a o = ¥:VXDFI- f OZ_<IRFOQWT\SQIH[:V(V`YVXDFIl_`T ana SQI ]>Y\OZ[V<]FgXY:FSZI
(327) G 8 ;b iUo = * yWqK 0 .02 354 @A4 3 .). . /1032. 5). 4. XZY<«+X\[.
(328) t.
(329) !
(330) !. CDFI * Y\g`GJT\S0Y:]^VXOZGxTiSZOVcbd
(331) Y\[ a OV`OQY:[n_# Y\gV`DFOZ_-]FgXY:FSZI
(332) G T\gXI8 = = oK t 4¤ o t o =t 4 ¤ o & ¤4! Tt oqp o
(333) Z%1Tt o = )i
(334) b! ct (o o = =. . &). ) & . . y\}. * 30.
(335) I SZGJY\VXOQOU[odI,TWVXV`I Dna TWV ¥BIO ~\=I
(336) V-TOZ_l I
(337) dSZSUOQT\GJ_`_XOZOZ[ndHTWTiV`S Ika a ¥ OZgX II!d3V gXiIT da YWhc\Y:IHOQg[VVXDFY\I ]^V`I&OQGxRnT\TiSQVXOQOZVcY\b[n_X_lbPYi_pVX6IHTxG ]Fg`* OQIH[ _`_pVXRnDngXI,IHSQY\I]^_X_V`OQ]>GxYiTiV`S*I
(338) [d
(339) VXY\OU[TiVXS g`'nY\S>Y V`DFkI
(340) Y:? gXbo 03= OZ_ . . >S. . _bY. . eDacgeT_ba`jleT_. 4DFI OUdqdDY:[V`VXDFOZIl[RnGJIIVXV`Y"DFY T a a _#TiYi]FV- VXyiDFzWI dH§-TiRF[~:>G8IIH[Ti]FVXI ]Fa SZOZI a Ti ~:g`T\I
(341) [FV#~\RoOUTi_6[ ngq_c_pV`V#g`TiY:VXnIH_p~\IHbgX:Y\IVX viDo(TWVHT\¥[ a Y:gF]>RFY:OZS _Xa OV`TJOQ:Ib[FI o * DnTiOZ~\dqgqD"Ti[no~\IOUdTiY\[GJY:I[ _ Ti[ a OZGJ]FSQOUdOQV¨d
(342) Y\[n_pVXgqTiOZ[V 03¥ I,DnT \I:¥P]oY:OQ[V OU_pIOZ["V`OQGJIT\[ a _X]nT:dI\¥ =L9 U * yiNv 0 t *. o9 U& =X U K o9 U 4
(343) DFIHgXI x * y:t 0 t : v s v v 3 ¤M :N K 77 Y\VXOU dT\I[FVXOUDn_pDFTiIV _
(344) V`LDFI"? V8SZIOU_8 V TiDoSU_pTiY+[ a OQGJ_p]>O a Y\IgXV`Y\Ti[V * y\VX3v Y 0[noYiIVXdOUY\dIGJVXIDn_!TiOZV [^nV`DF[FI OQVXI Y\]^ V`DFOQGxIH[FTiI
(345) S :I
(346) g * t o4W@ T\[F0OZ_XTiDF>IYW_!\IY:g Dno¦T\_!OZ_8VXY¦]>Y:_XTi_XVXOV`OUOQ_c: b I Ti[ a = 3 [ V`Y tw¤ s oId
(347) T\Rn_pIY\V`DFI,oY:RF[ a T\gXb"dY\[ a OV`OQY:[n_Y\[ =4<+IdHTi["VXDPRn_TiSU_XY8g`IH_pVXgqTiOZ! t I:" v s v ªvTx# B $ $ ¤% & * yiNu 0 7B7 tw¤ s :N >]Fg`IxY Y\a'l]^Rn_XV`dOZOQ[FI,GJ~T O/A
(348) [FY:I agXI G RFSQOQSZOZVXT[FD I* Tig`y\gIH3v _Xd0]oY:V`I[nDFd3_cI8VV`g`VX[FT\YY\OQ[[$V`V#DFSZVXIxOQ[FDn[FITiTiIV-g¨ d
(349) OQTi[W[VXTiIHg`T ~\OUa Tigq TiFT\[SZI[a V` Tid
(350) ~:Ti I
(351) [ !Y:3RFoSZI8_XCbJgXDFIHoOU]F_I SUT\VXdIHTiI gXRFaG ~:GJP bI
(352) OQ[SZTS6VXI I
(353) SZaOQ:[F I
(354) I[T\TiVX_#g¨Ro]FTiRFg`SZSQ[nY\b]>dVXY:>OZ_XY\II [a dY:V`OQDnG![4TWFVyiOZ[FzDnI T:a _-* _pV`V`IHYYI >I
(355) SZY 03 ( Y\[o_pI:RnI
(356) [VXSZb OQVOZ_[nTWV`RFgqTiSFV`Y T a Y\]^VVXDFI_`TiGJIl_pVXgqTWVXIH~\b8Y\[xV`DFIk[FY\[$ SZOQ[FITi¦ g ; [nY\g`G']>I
(357) [oTiSZ
(358) O ATWVXOZY\[& 4I,Rn_pIkV`DFI IH~\I
(359) [ a gXIkV`g`T\[n_c Y:gXG Y\< ! V`Y a RnTiSZ
(360) O AHIVXDFI,]>I
(361) [oTiSZ
(362) O ATWVXOZY\["VXIHgXG 8 o Xo * = = t * y ,N0. * o = Xo = < K K ) DFIHgX+I *kOZ_T RF[od3VXOZY\[Y:[ s Ti[ Xa * y ,N0DnY\S a _]oY:OQ[V OU_pI: 4I¨ Y:SQSZY V`DFIVXIHgXGJOZ[FY\SZY\~:bxYi vWTi[ a Rn_XIVXDFI Y:SQSZY OZ[F~ WT\gXOUTiFSZIH_T\[ a [FYiVqTWVXOZY\[o_8 r * {\Nz 0 Rt o =K:-,t I:N !%RT., £t RT ,q p 7 7 /"032. "!. . . !. . !. . !. !. . !. . . . . !. "!. . /"032. . "!. /0,. ««¬ ®. K^tWu:v. 8OQ1,. ctw¤. ¨2. +3. IHSZ_XI\¥54. 5) `t )i¤%1oNp . {. * -0.
(363) u. ! . . 4ITiSU_pY8[FI
(364) I a VXDFI,[FI Rn[nd3V`OQY:[nTiST8. . :{ y Ti[ a Y:g-dSUTig`OVcb OZSZS&_pI
(365) V t i
(366) b! #T g`I a RF[ a T\[:V[FY\V`TiVXOZY\[" Y\gVXDnI Ti~:g`T\[F~\I¨G!RFSQVXOZ]FSZOQIHglTWVV`OQGJI
(367) g`I §g`OV` V`IkI
(368) gJ]ngX_pY:Y:FGJSQIHIG d
(369) T\* yiSZd
(370) KNRF0#SZTiT\VX_OZY\8 [n_ Ti[ a dqDnTi[F~:OQ[n~VXDFI OQ[F W_XRF]@_`T aFa SZI]>Y\OZ[V8]Fg`Y\nSQIHGOZ[VXY+T\[_pRn] OZ[^c¥ I .02 / , %4 & *%< !RT + , £ o S *%W.3© * {\N{ 0 &4 = P 4 3 4 4 ;4 ) GJ_XDFI
(371) Y\[RF VXS IY\a aVX>OU dIlI"OZ[@SZVXOQ[FDnV`ITiDFTiV Ig R [F* SZIO
(372) Ti):eP[ IVxa 4}_pIo 0 d3= V` OQY:OT\V[*gXI OU _6[FDFCY IHY4 gXI-d
(373) [nY\GJY\Ti~\[]FgqSZSZTiOQb¦[n[n~\IH RFTiIxgSZSQG!b * FRnRFSV`VOQOQVX]F[FD SZOUOZdI
(374) VXIHgqDnSQ_JbI"YiDPlRnbPSZT]oOQ[na Y\IHg`VXTiDFTiVXgxIOU_pd%d
(375) OU03_8Y\([nYi§-_p8VXSUgq_X Tiy\YnOZz¥:[ VXV`¥DF_ VXIlDF IRFOZdq[nOZD [d3V`VX OQI
(376) Y:~:OQ[ SZg`ST\/ o[ aI _pDn Y\Y\TiRFRFS~#a >]FgqI"T\ddYPVXOUIHdg`Id
(377) OQ_p:RnIJdqDT\[ T a G8OU_Y a [FOQY\oVHdH©TWVX? OZ[Y\[ vWa YP¥ IH _#Ix[FY\RnV-_XI _pa IHI
(378) TGd
(379) [FYPII
(380) dgqId_XOZ\_`TiI g`bx ]oTi[IHgpa V`RF[FgXI oTWVXVXOZDFY\IH[¦Y\g`Y\I V`OZ/ dHTiS 8 a / I
(381) : I
(382) , SZY\]Ft GJIH/ [:Vq
(383) _k y: ,}* n© T\d? [) VXDnOZ_Y:n_XI
(384) g` TiVXOZY\[* *.Tt * o =. *. . K. * 30. 3. ). 5. /"032 . . +). . ). 4. . >S. VXWZY e Za Y_7fY. . eDacg4eD_ba`jleT_ S. §l_T\GJ_#IHVX[:DnV`I OQY: [FTi[F~:I g`a T\[FTi~\>I¨YW\G!I:RF¥PSQOQVX["OZ]FVXSZDFOQIHIg`[F_I Y\ (d
(385) _`Y\T [naF_pa VXSZgqITi OZ]>[Y\V`OZ_[:T\Vd]FVXg`OZ[FY\~JFSZY\I
(386) G[ * \{¥ {N,P0 ¥ I,* td
(387) Ti["i[F
(388) ZY % 1U0d
(389) Y\Ti[n[ _Xa O a *WI
(390) ¥Fg$[oR©TiGJt I
(391) 7SZb o =K:kT\[ a * {iqK 0 & 4 ,}t ¤K *Ztw¤ CDPRn_H¥P Y\SZSQY OZ[F~ y\z I a In[FIV`DFI TiRF~:G8IH[VXI aPk T\~\gqTi[F~:OZT\[8. o=. ). ). ). ; 5)i ,q.* RT o = Tt. / , + 4. 5) 0*% o K *%W.3 !#RT & 4 )+ , £E = = !/ & 4 ) ,q & 4 )+, £ . S *% K K. {:}. * 30. 4DFI,IHgXgXIId
(392) Ti= SZSB VX DoTWTiVg`I- ]oOZY_l_pOQT8VXOZ_X\DFIlY:]ngpTiV`DngqTiTiGJ[ a IV`[FI
(393) Yigq_VqTW V`OQDFY:OU[dqD Y:Tig g`IlT,9
(394) Z]F!g` OZqY\g`COndqDFDFI,Y:d_XI
(395) Y\[xg`g`OIHa _XIH]o[:Y:V`[ OZdHa TiOZ[FSo~8OQ[x_`V`T DFanI¨a SQ_XI I& ]>RFY\IHOZ[SnVY\ ]FVXgXDFY:OUF_SZI
(396) ]oG Ti]>I
(397) g .102 ; i ,q.* RT o * {\Nv 0 = P 4 3 4 C4 ) dSZIHT\gXSZbxDnT:_#VXDFI_`TiGJI,_pY:SQRFVXOZY\[T\_ * yiNK 0 ). /"032 . >S. . 5). 4. VXWZY elac]cgjfW S. nR§ _XI _pa OZGJVX]FY¦SZ.I ,_pY:T\SQ :SQ*~:IY\<g`VXRODnV`I"DFG ]Fo g`Y\Yi n!SQIHI
(398) yiePG zW]> IH¥#dd
(399) 4VXTiI SZI a SZI ~\V`a YIVx§ dY\T [Pn V`:DFyFI
(400) g`g`¥I
(401) ~\nII-T:V`_c_pY8V`I I
(402) a VX]@DFY\IOQVX[ IH_`g`T gXTiaFIHVXSZa OZTi\SQeFI I"TW]>VXG8OZY\Y\OZI
(403) [o[VXVH_!DF Y Y\a -VX DFDFI OUdq'bD AHTdY: [nT _pVXTig`SZRn~\d3Y:VqgX_ OQVXT4DnG _pIOU_JRFI
(404) [F[nY d
(405) I = U = , = <R o = #T\gXIk~\OZ\IH[* MVXIH]§ 84" OQ[ a _pRodqDV`DnTWV 8 * {t 0 ; ., = * = <R o = ; i , = .* = R o = ! i CDFI
(406) [_pI
(407) V . 5). . 5). ). 5). . +). t. ). . ).
(408) Z%1 . XZY<«+X\[.
(409)
(410) !
(411) !. MVXIH]@8" OZ[ a . MVXIH]. (. _pRodqDV`DnTWV. , *. ,. 8. ; 5) ., * <R o = . ¨YJVXDFI~\gqT a OQIH[:V a I_Xd
(412) I
(413) [V. 84B. . ; 5) ,q.* R o = ! q, .* . {\u. * N0. { VX DFDFI,I
(414) g`~:I\g`¥T Tia ]FOQIH]n[T\VgX_pIHVX[IHVX]nSZb\_ ¥i*V`DFDFIHI¨[nd
(415) dRnI,_pGxVXY\T G bP>OU_<I¨V`V`Y!DFI,Rn_X[FI IHI a VXYJ]FV`DFOUd Il]nRFT\] g`T\a GJO >IVXIHIHgXg6IH[YiV V`DF_I¨ Y\T\gRFVX~\DnGJIIHV [: V`IYxa dd
(416) Y:Y\[n[n_pVX_pgqVXTigqTiOZ[:OZ[Vq_ V`0_< OZ[ n Y8oT\d)xV`YJ_pVXIH]§ ]Fg`Y\FMSZV`I
(417) I
(418) G] 6§ MV`TiI
(419) [ ] a ( OU_T\gXTJIx~\_XgqOQT GJa ]FOQIHSZ[:b+VT _pVXg`I
(420) I
(421) ] SUTW eFY:TWgV`VXOQY:DF[ I GJa RoITiV`SDFY]Fag`Y\FY:SZgI
(422) GVXDF IxGJOZ[FOZG8/O AHTiVXOZY\[4]nTigXV,Yi#VXDFI_`T ana SQI ]>Y\OZ[V >S. = t R W &) , o = , = t o = = & 4 * = )
(423) 2 . R. VXWZYbgeTm fjUme elac]cgjfW. * ,N0. . 4I,[FY a OU_`dRn_`_IHT:dqD"Y\ _pVXI
(424) ]Y\&VXDnITin_pVXgqT\dVT\SQ~:Y\g`OV`DFG Y\gY:RFg]nT\gpV`OZd
(425) RFSZT\g Ti~:g`T\[F~\OUTi[& * CYJ_XY\SZ\IMV`I
(426) ]§¥ I[FIHI a VXY a O
(427) 2>IHgXIH[VXOUTWVXI}; OQVXDg`IH_X]oId3VV`Y Ti[ a ~\I
(428) V Y\g L8 ). 4. +) . . . ). ) £ = !/ & 4 ) , = & 4 )©£ !R & 4 C5 ) 9
(429) Z! * = 1 )i
(430) b! tE¤ )i . XV§Dn OZV`_I
(431) gOU_#OQ[VXDnVXIHI,~\gqTWT\V`gXOQOU[FTWV`~OQY:P[nb!Ti]oS>Ti Y:gXVgXG OQ[xRF_XSZTi]nVXT\OZd
(432) Y\I-[ TiYi[ a VXDFV`OQIGJ_XIl]nT\T\d
(433) [ Ia VXRnOZGJ_XOQ[FI ~ V`TiDF]FI-SUT\Wd
(434) TiIg`OZI&Y\RnRn_<TW>V`OQY\Y:Rn[ [ a Tig`b!d
(435) Y\[ a OQVXOZY\[o_ I¨_pIHIVXDnTiV * K:Nz 0 = & 4 t & 4 /R = , = OQVXDoY:RF[ a T\gXb"dY\[ a OV`OQY:[n_8 * 4K -0 = & ¤! TtwoNp>Xo ¤%1+ = = ¤4! * K3y 0 = &
(436) Z%1+
(437) Z%1Tt = =
(438) Z%1i * = U Ti[ a * K:N{ 0 = ¤4! & t = = ¤%1&M Y\Y\gqdVXOUI dI8o VXDo¤4TW!V T* Kt -.oq0lpiOZ_,T I T ) T bYiIH[^ Y\gqdOZ[F~"VXDFIJOZ[FOQVXOUTiS a IH[n_pOQVcb d
(439) Y\[ a OQVXOZY\[o_
(440) 8CDFIx_cV`gXY:[F~ T bOZ_¨V`Y _XY\SZ\4I¨VXIDFRnOU__XI!]Fg`TxY\]FFRFSZI
(441) nG SQOUdY\SZb[TT nT\[FOQSUOQTiVXnI SQIa
(442) O 2>Y:IHgpgXV`IHg`[nT\[ dI,]o_pT\V`dT\)W~\Ti~\~:IHI gXI a gX~:OQVpgXV`O I
(443) a [ * kM^{ ( m(ZC 0VXDnTiV¨Rn_XIH_-+T "<"(C V`IHdqDF[FO(RFI,V`Y * . 4Id
(444) Ti[n[FYiV a
(445) O 2>IHgXIH[VXOUTWVX}I ; OQVXDg`IH_X]oId3VV`Y ,8Ti[ a ,"OZ_l_pOZGJ]FSQbY\^VqTiOZ[FI a Pb"_XY\SZOZ[F~ . ). ). . ). ). . ,). .102 / , + . . ««¬ ®. K^tWu:v. = K. !#. & 4 ) ,qC & 4 ) . !. , / £ !%R. C & 4 ) , £ .
(446) Hz -. . DFOUdqD"OU_I:RnOQWTiSZI
(447) [VVXY©8 !/ & 4 . ). . . R. ,q & 4 ) =. . R. ! . , £ . =. V[ a OU_IHI OQa GJ¥n]>SQI
(448) Y\V-gXV`RnTi_[V,_pI
(449) V`V Y 8 [nYiVXOUdIJV`DnTWVV`DFOZ_G8OZ[FOZGJO
(450) ATWVXOZY\[ dHTi[4oIx]>I
(451) gX Y\g`GJI a ]oY:OQ[V OU_pIJOZ[¦_X]nT:dIxTi[ a V`OQGJI\ ? ?. CDFIH[2, 9 U ct. 9 U :tG & 4 ) + R 7 = 9 U "! : "!!8 ! ¤: * 4 . 02 7 5 9 U U !7 D K ct. . 7. OU_Y\FV`TiOZ[FI a Pb_XY\SZPOQ[n~ OZ[. CTiSZDFbOUVX_-OUd
(452) OUT\_SQSZVXb"RngXY:[ngl_lRnY\_XR^OZ[FV~ V`Y >I I!VXTxY:[ _pOZ GJ_lGJ]FSZIIV`DFY\[FY Ia a OQCGJDFI
(453) I![o_p]FOZg`Y\Yi[nhcT\IS*d3V`]FOQg`Y:Yi[hcIYid3<VXOZVXY\Dn[I ]Fa g`OUY\_Xd
(454) ngXSQI
(455) IHVXG O/A
(456) I a DFWOUdqTiDg`OZT\d
(457) T\F[ SQI_>I!V`RFd
(458) gXY\[oGJ_l]FY:R^R^V`VlI V`a YTi>[ I [F]FY\g`Y\V-FVXSZDnI
(459) GTiVkOZ_X_OQGJT\[n]FTiSZI!SZbqT:A
(460) _I a VXDnOZI[ a ITiV`T\[ OQa S OZ [¦W y:Ti}g`OUTi FSZIDnT :IVXY>I a I
(461) n[FI a Y\[V Y a O
(462) 2>IHgXIH[:Vk_cVqTi~\~:I
(463) g`I a ~\g`O a CDFOZ_ OZ[FOZG8/O A
(464) OZ[F~ ; OQVXDg`IH_X]oId3VVXY *kOU_IHT\_Xb * :RoT a gqTWV`OZ.d 0T\[ a ~\OZ\IH_#]>Y\OZ[V OZ_XIOQ[_X]nT\d
(465) I o Xo = t #$
(466) A + D? *. = < . pn_ V`[nTiT\~:§-SBI
(467) VXg`~OZgXTiGJI OZa[ ITio[ Y: aRF*[ a a OZ_pT\V`gX T\b[:9
(468) ZVd
(469) Y\!Yi[ *la0-DnOT\d
(470) V`TiOQS&Y:[n[XT[FYiVX8 VlOZG8>IkI _ca V`I
(471) OZ_`] dg`I3V` O HI [a ]FY\gq[T\dV`VXDFOUdI!I _` TiGJIlGxI~:T ):gXO Ila T,]oSZY:OQ[nOQ[IHVqTi_lg#T\Ti_ ]F]no gX= Y e^TiOZGJ[ a TiVX* OZY\B[J-RnC_XDFOQ[nI
(472) b~VXTiDng`II ). . )
(473) Z%1 x & = 9
(474) Z! < * = t # x &. * . MV`I
(475) ] ( UO __XOQGJ]FSZbV`DFI,]oY:OQ[V OU_pIRF] a TiVXI T8~\gqT a OZI
(476) [V-_pVXI
(477) ]" Y\gV`DFI a RnT\S*]Fg`Y\FSZI
(478) Gx_@8 R. = t/R . = W & 4 ) , o ,= = t o = * . D FIH§lgXI_ a OZ_`OZd_RnV`_`DF_XI,I a [PRFOQ[ G!> v I
(479) lgIHY\T: dq~:D@gXO OQa VXIH]>g`TiY\VXOZ[OZY\V`[ _OZYi[ lVXV`OZDFGJOUI_TiTi[SZ~\a Y:gX_pOQ]oVXT\DFdG I: d
(480) Y:_pV`_xT\[ Y:]^VXOZGxTiS
(481) > S . !Y\]>I
(482) gqTWVXOZY\[o_. Z L. L]`_7h`YgacY_mY. U4 £o 4OQVXI
(483) IxgqTWnV`gqOQY:_cV[n_dqDnTiIH[ da )Y\V`nDn_XTWI
(484) Vg`\V`I!DFI" Y\§ RFg n d
(485) gXy OQVXIHOQVXgXIHOUTg`Ti8kVXOZY\V`DF[¦IJ]F4g`YPT:d
(486) _XIH_X_`I
(487) _gq_cdV`Y:I
(488) [POZ[\I
(489) Tig`~\[ Ia _
(490) ; +a IOZ_pSZV`IT\V![nVXdDFIJIdT\Y:SQG8~:Y\]>g`Y\OV`[nDFI
(491) G[V`_kg`RFYi[VXYWDF\IJIHg GJ-HOQePz:Iz\az a OU_cVqTi[nd
(492) I r * K\qK 0 )+*Q, , (oqp o = ( U t = o B oNp3 o = t o = ( DXo = ( 3 p K Toi[ a VXDFI a RnT\SQOQVcbJI
(493) g`gXY:g`_6~\OZ\I
(494) ["T\`_ ; [FY:gXGx_Yi V`DFI¨~:g`T a OZI
(495) [V`_ OV`Dg`IH_X]oId3VV`YV`DFI a RnTiS>WTig`OZT\FSQI_ RT\[ a . . =. . . r & 4 ) , B p . . . * . K}. * 30. XZY<«+X\[.
(496)
(497) !
(498) !. -3-. 4 ¨ I q V ):I@sut # %#> N # %#> ¥N t ( = ¦¨ªv ¥
(499) t #\¥ t #Ti[ a = t t\#\<4I a OZ_`dg`IV`O
(500) AHI T VXVXDnDnI,I,VXI
(501) DF\g`Y:I
(502) SQRFI VXaOZY\OQGJ[ IHYi[n&_pV`OZDFY\I[n[n Y\TiRnS&g-_X]ndT:g`OdV`II
(503) g`VXOZOZTJGJTiI >a YWY\\GxI¨T\ Y\OQ[gV Rn_XOZY8[FVX~I_cTVq_K 8 K K ~\g`O a 4I!_XDFY Y:[ n~\RFg`I -!T\[ a y TW}V ¤ qH ¤4JT3L Ti[ Ia Rn_XUI#Zn¤4TiSUTi![nZd
(504) ¤I a ZOZ¢[F 8 OQVX OUTiS^Ti [ a n[nT\S a I
(505) [n _XOQVXOZIH_H¥ V Yk~:T\Rn_X¢_X OUTi [ RF[n dVXOZ Y\[n_<d
(506) I
(507) [VX IHgXI a g`IH_X]oId3VXOZ\IHSQb . . oqp ct. . p p
(508) p
(509) . . . o = ct. 0.08. p p
(510) p
(511) . −0.5 Wasserstein L2. duality error 1 duality error 2 −1. 0.07. −1.5 0.06. Log10(error). distances squared. −2 0.05. 0.04. −2.5. −3. 0.03 −3.5 0.02 −4 0.01. 0. −4.5. 0. 200. 400 600 iterations. 800. −5. 1000. 0. 200. 400 600 iterations. OQ~:RFgXI-38(CIH_pV H U L I,]>I
(512) gXVXRn gX" VXDFI o[n TiS a I
(513) [n _XOVcb"_pY8VXDoTWVVXDnI a TW VqT OZ[ [F Y [FY\V-n TiSUTi[odI a. 800. 1000. ". p . oqp ( ct. p
(514). . . . p
(515). . o = ct. p . 0.08. . p
(516). . . . . p
(517). . 8. ¤4 K p. . . . . −0.5 Wasserstein L2. duality error 1 duality error 2 −1. 0.07. −1.5 0.06. Log10(error). distances squared. −2 0.05. 0.04. −2.5. −3. 0.03 −3.5 0.02 −4 0.01. 0. −4.5. 0. 200. 400 600 iterations. 800. 1000. −5. 0. 200. 400 600 iterations. 800. 1000. OQ~:RFgXIy8(CIH_pV¨y YiY:#YRFigV`D GJOQ* e^nI T\a SZT\[n Rnd[nI ad3V`OQT\Y:[ [Fa [nTiRFS [P nT\ SZT\Yi[nV`IdI VXa Do0kTWVXVI_cT\Vq__OZOZ[ [ a V`OUDFd
(518) ITiVXI]nRFTgXI+d
(519) Y\4[P\T:IH_XgX_X~:IHI
(520) _pVX[nIHd
(521) OQI8[ VXd
(522) DPT\Rn_X_!Id
(523) V`Y\DF[^I ogXa GJI
(524) VXOZIH[FgX~OZY\VXgqDFTWI V`OQY:d[Y:[Yi:,Ie^VXOQDnVcbI ". ««¬ ®. K^tWu:v.
(525) y -. . ! . ZOdG8Y:[P]o\T\I
(526) d3g`V-~\IHY\[n&dV`I DFI g`Ti VX= I8 OQ[ a ]nOZTidHTWgqTiV`IHGJ_,IT V`I
(527) g`gqTi_ VX6DFOQIH[gD]n'oT\TWgpVV`OZdd
(528) YRF_cSZVkT\g RF [nI,dVXTiOZY\S [*T xbP4_VqIJT )\I
(529) IGJ ]F= DntT:_pO/ A
(530) I8 V`DnTWV I a O a [FYiV_pVXR a bVXDnI £ o 4TiI[VDFI
(531) VXg`YIdqOZDF[PI\d IH)B_p¥^VXOZ ~:Y\Tig-VXoIJTiV`SUDFTiI[nd
(532) OZI G8a ]oa T\TWd3VqV8TFYi¥^V`DFVXIDnIIe^]n]>TiIHgqdTiVXGJI a I
(533) VXd
(534) I
(535) Y\g [P \IHY\gX[¦~:I
(536) V`[nDFd
(537) IIlV`]FY g`Y aT\gRna d
(538) _I a g`IH_X_XY\]>SZIHR^d3VXV`OZOQY\:[*I
(539) ªSZbx? VX[DnI]nT\4gpV`T:OZd
(540) _X_XRFI
(541) SUgqTi_pg VXI
(542) OZ[ I Ti[ a ; a OU_pV`Ti[odIH_HCDFIg`IH_XRFSVq_Yi(VqTiFSZI>I
(543) SZY d
(544) Y\[nd
(545) I
(546) g`[ VXDFIoTiSUTi[n d
(547) I aa I
(548) [o_pOQVXOZIH_lYi H J Ti>YW\I,T\[ a Rn_XIkVXDFI_`TiGJI[PRFGJI
(549) g`OZdHTiS ]nT\g`T\G8I
(550) VXIHg`_#IeFd
(551) I
(552) ]^V Y\g VX Y\DngqIld I¦_I
(553) V¨T\VX_`DFRn_pIk_kIHg`n>_p[nVXI IHT\OQGJS*[xdY:TiY:gX[ G8Ia ]n]n;R^gXIVX dI OUd
(554) a"_pY\I aGJIH8 ]o[n Y:_XO[FI VcI
(555) bJY\[nV`VqY8_6_XI
(556) YiGxg`B\TiV`I:V`DF¥odqIlTiD" GJVXVXI
(557) DFOQgePII d~\axY:OZ[P\a \IHOU_c[I
(558) Vqg`Ti~\n[nIH[o[nd
(559) TiI\dS (I,a Y\IH6[nDF_pVXI
(560) OQDnVc[ bI8 Ti§ [ OQ [oa n dg`V`yIHDFT\IT\_XSQ4IH~:_HY\¥iT:g`V`_XODFV`_XI
(561) DFbI gXGVX; IH¥n OQ[ V`]>DFdI
(562) I8Y\[nGJ T\T\SQ]>/O SQAHRnY\TiIH[FVX_¨IHOZY\[Yi[ V YiCDnV`T\DF[ I )^_(a VXOZ_pYV`T\V`DF[nIdI OQGJ* _p]>IY:d_XY:I [ a a >SQY\OZ[FRFI"[ a OQ[Tig`b!V`DFdIY:[ VqTia FOQVXSZOZ.I Y\0![nTi_H¥\]FY:]nRFgXYg(T\VXdqIDF_cV#I_kdY\VXg`DFg`I IH_Xd]oY\Y:g`[ g`IHa d3_V VXY T\V`SQDFRnIIVXYigq-Ti[o¦_pSUT\TW_`V`_pOQY:IHg`[ _pVXY\IHBOQ[T n a OUT\_pRnV`Ti_X[o_XOUdTiI\[ OZ[T\SQS*_X]nT:dIk Y\g DFOUdqD I,DnT :I * _pIHI * - -0k0 . (oqp o = t R No p ( ? R t K U #3 t K. )+*-,. ~\OZDF\IHIgX_I R oNp OZ_k(V``DFtIJVX¤gq/Ti#%[n¤ _XK SUTWVXOZY\ [ K ka OU_X_cY8VqTiVX[nDnd
(563) TiI\Vl T 4[`g I
(564) SZY\OUTiRFFgSZIdHT\IH_X_pI VXOZGJTiVXIYi VXDnI,4T:_X_XI
(565) gq_cV`I
(566) TiOZ[ [ a a T OU_pV`TiRn[oT da I,g`TiOU_ VXRFg`I Y\g`G!RFSUT . )+*-,. (oqp o = w t ¤ 3¤ K . DFOUdqD"OU_OZ[~\YPY a T:d
(567) dY:g a Ti[nd
(568) I OQVXD VXDFI,WT\SQRFI,Y:^V`T\OQ[nI a Y\g t #%¤ ¤ OZ["V`DFIV`T\FSZI\ aa IOU_cdVqg` TiIH[nT\DFd
(569) _XIHIIH[ _H*(VX DnCOQDFag aI¨IdOZSZg`[FOZIH[FOQT\VXIJOU_XTiIHOQS[+_H¥ a VXIHVXDF[nDFI8_XIOVqVcOZTibJGJFV`]nSZI
(570) I.T\[ 0¨da VJ~\YPVXY\YJI-_lg`VXI
(571) V`DnY GxI TiVX]>DFOZ[nI
(572) I _#[o; Ti_cVqSZ O
(573) TWAVX[FTWOZY:VXY\OZgX[nY\G [n[ TiY\g`OZ_bxV` TiDF[ IHI Ta )\a VXI
(574) OCDF2BgJIHI
(575) gXTig`I
(576) [I
(577) [oaY\dg`IJIlVXDnV`oI DFI
(578) I}VGx; T:IH_XI
(579) _![+dY\VXOQgqGJ[FTiOQ[n]>VXOU_pY\Ti [FI
(580) SIHgxTi[[ T:V#ad3Y\VX&OZnPVX[nODnVcTib I S ]Fg`IH_`dg`OQ>I a a IH[n_pOQVXOZIH_HT ? [ Y\RFg H J d
(581) T:_pI o <Xoqp ( 3ªtE¤/#%¤ =. DFOUdqD"GxTiV`dqDFI_#VXDFI ; d Y\GJ]>Y\[FIH[VY\V`DFIGJOe^I aa OU_pV`Ti[odIk Y\g tw¤ ¤#\ zF z - zF/ -z -Hz\z r @ p $ $ 3bB -: t zt Kn1t z} zF z\z\v:z zF {ti}iK zF K:z3, , o = <X3 o = ( 3 zF/ -Hz\Ky zn 3z ,:y\} zF z\v:y , zF z\z\4z - y^ y z\u YiTi<[ a V`§-DF I [nY\g¨Yia VXI
(582) VXDn[nDnI
(583) _XI g OVcV b T Yo bxUI
(584) /VXUePYx VXg`qRnI
(585) [ GJ" a II
(586) OZ~\gqW_pRFT\V`g`TiSQIHRF[ _ Ia _l* N{ V`Y\0-DF I Ti[ ,a a * I
(587) 3} ]>DF0I
(588) I
(589) [_p[ Dna Y T\ [ntudV`I,DF#%Y\I8¤ ¤SQIHV`DF\VXDFI
(590) IS I ]Fdng`RFY\[ng`nT\\SQS IIH_Ga I
(591) Yi[ncOU__Xo OQVXVcYb SZOZYP_¨Y )Y\Y\gqTig dVI a a VXOCDF2BVXII
(592) Y g`VXI
(593) GxOZ[G8V¨TWI!VqVXdqOZI
(594) DG8\Y:I8o SQRF_cV`VXT\I
(595) OZ[Y\]n[a _ VXVXDnDnI
(596) I,[~:TiVXDnRoI,_X_XGJOZT\T:[_XOU__VX]FgqTig`Y\[nn_X]oT\FY:gpSQbVGJdHTiOZRn[F_XOQIGJa /O A
(597) PIb_ VXVXDnDFIkI!GJ4OUT:_X_X_XOZ_X[FI
(598) ~Jgq_cV`GJI
(599) OZT:[ _X_ d
(600) gX<OQVXV`IHDFgXIOZY\OQ[[nO* V`VXOZgqT\TiS&[oTi_p[SUTWa V`OQnY:[n[ T\036S ~:CT\DFRnI,_X_XIHOUSQTiSZOZ[n]^_VXOUTid
(601) g`T\IkS&]n_pDoTiTigX= VX]>OUI,TiSZYiSQb _XRF]Ft]>Y\¤4gX VX¤4I #Ja VXY\DFR^ªI Vq_p; O a IkdVXY\DnGJI ]>a Y\Y\[FGxIH[TiV!OZ[*OZ _ [FY\Y\VXV OUd_pI Y * OQnGJ~:]>RFY\gXIkgXV`KNTi0[VV`DnT\TW[ V#a VXDFV`I,DFI
(602) d
(603) [ Y\[P\IIHgXGJ~:I
(604) OZ[n[Fd
(605) OQGJI-OZ/O _A
(606) I _XSZYT ¦IHg6T\ _`Y\_pgIHg`SU_pTiVXg`IH~\OQI[ d<g`OQVXI
(607) g`DFOZY\IH[[ VXgqTi[n_p I
(608) g#GxT\_`_#TiV-TiSZS*Ti[ a _pGxTiSZS [FY:OZ_XI OQVXD [FYJOQGJ]>Y:_XI a n[nTiS a IH[n_XOVcb:6CDFIY\]^V`OQGxTiS _XY\SZR^VXOZY\[ a YPIH_[FY\V Ti]n]oITigq_ * n~\RngXI * }30U0k . XZY<«+X\[.
(609) {.
(610) !
(611) ! -. timestep 1. timestep 3. timestep 5. timestep 7. timestep 9. timestep 11. timestep 13. timestep 15. timestep 17. timestep 19. timestep 21. timestep 23. timestep 25. timestep 27. timestep 29. timestep 31. OZ~\RFg`I,{8 I
(612) \IHS dRFg`\I_Yiio Y\g ". 0.5. t\#%¤ ¤. 0 Wasserstein L2. duality error 1 duality error 2 −1. 0.4. 0.3. Log10(error). distances squared. −2. −3. −4. 0.2. −5 0.1 −6. 0. 0. 1000. 2000 3000 iterations. 4000. K^tWu:v. −7. 0. OQ~:RFg`IkK8<dY\[P:I
(613) g`~\I
(614) [odI ". ««¬ ®. 5000. 1000. 2000 3000 iterations. 4000. 5000.
(615)
(616) K -. . timestep 1. timestep 3. timestep 5. timestep 7. timestep 9. timestep 11. timestep 13. timestep 15. timestep 17. timestep 19. timestep 21. timestep 23. timestep 25. timestep 27. timestep 29. timestep 31. ! . OZ~\RFg`I}8 IH\IHS*dRFg`\I_Y\<o Y\g tE¤ ¤# ) )
(617) , P ( (,( +# 8 ! $ )+ +$ $ ". . >SUR. [^]Tfjlh<e<fjl]`_. P [b IHTWV`V`DFDFOUO
(618) _kI
(619) ):g!I _XIH (dY\VXg`RFOZIHY\SZdHSZ[ I
(620) T\[ _p V I* _pIHIOQI"e^VXD ]oTiIHSUV`gX_XDFOZYGJI
(621) I
(622) -T:[ud3VV`RnY\
(623) Ti-RFS#v g:Y\0TinLSZ_X~\I
(624) ? Y:Vxg`gX\OQdVXI Y:DFa [nG dIHOZIgX[ TW[oV`_,PDFOZVXI
(625) I Dng IOQ[ Y\]Fg`Y\TOZFI ]nSZI
(626) T\G gpY\V`¨OZY\d
(627) T\RF_`SUVX_XTiDFIHg¨_`I _pV`OZTi[Fg`Rn~~\TiI
(628) VX[VkDnVXT\OQI V`]FTi]FVXRnOZSZ\OZT\dHISQTWOQVcVXd
(629) b¦OZY\Y\GJ[+Yi]n_pT\VXRFDngX~:OUI~\_pY:I [¦_cY:V`gXI YiI a d
(630) T:_cV`OQ[n~!V`IHdqDF[FO(RFI\< CDFOU_]Fg`Y\FSZI
(631) G OU_#VXDnI
(632) g`I Y\g`I¨ Vcb]nOZdHTiSZSQbJV`DFI,d Y\GJ]FRFV`TWV`OQY:["Y\T a OU_cVqTi[nd
(633) I¨>IV I
Documents relatifs
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des
[…] Chez nous, le parterre […] est composé communément des citoyens les moins riches, les moins maniérés, les moins raffinés dans leurs mœurs ; de ceux
But on another hand, increasing q at constant operative pressure results in decreasing the equilibrium pressure, by decreasing the operative temperature (Figure 9), and finally, it
R´ esum´ e : On pr´esente des r´esultats autour du probl`eme suivant: pour un point mat´eriel dont l’acc´el´eration est born´ee par une constante donn´ee, et pour un
Ensuite, pour déterminer lesquelles des voix créées pouvaient être qualifiées d’« androgynes », nous avons fait un test de perception dans lequel nous avons demandé
Toutefois, des améliorations sont à prévoir car bien que la protection induite par ces glycoconjugués soit significative, elle n’est cependant pas optimale pour mettre
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des
Venant compléter les nombreux guides spécialisés qui informent le touriste gay sur les différents lieux et structures qu’il pourra fréquenter s’il recherche son
