BOCR framework for decision analysis

(1)

OATAO is an open access repository that collects the work of Toulouse researchers and makes it freely available over the web where possible

Any correspondence concerning this service should be sent

to the repository administrator: [email protected] This is an author’s version published in: http://oatao.univ-toulouse.fr/23636

To cite this version:

Tchangani, Ayeley and Pérès, François BOCR framework for decision analysis. (2010) In: IFAC LSS 2010, 12 July 2010 - 14 July 2010 (Villeneuve d'Ascq, France).

Official URL: https://doi.org/10.3182/20100712-3-FR-2020.00083

(2)

! "# $ % %& ' ( ) &* +&

! "# $ * &, ) &* +

!

" #

$ %&' "

(

! )

* * ! "

* * "

- %. $+ % , - , -% , -%

. %&' / ! 0

1 2. +3 2 .

% -

" -

#

, )

#

, )

, ") -

-

"

3 ) # -

! -

) -

- 4

- 156 56 7"

%&' 18"

!

9

#

86 1:6 11" "

" ;6 <6 1=6 >?""

# -

2

@ #

! "

# )

! (

-

(3)

> ( %,AB C ( +A 2/2 . %.%DE/2/

+ ! "

/ ( ( "

# !

$ %

"

6

! %

! )

# 6

@ 6

6

! !

# ( 1

O_axis

A_axis

a_axis

a-A plane a-O plane

A-O plane

How well does alternative A satisfy objective O?

What is the value of attribute a of alternative A? Whatrelationshipbetween

Attributesandobjectives ? O_axis

A_axis

a_axis

a-A plane a-O plane

A-O plane

How well does alternative A satisfy objective O?

What is the value of attribute a of alternative A? Whatrelationshipbetween

Attributesandobjectives ?

( 1 +

( 1

-

# 2

-

!

4

%

!

0 1 & % -

"

" -

.

18" !

- A

! F "

F "

F " F " -

! ! -

0 1 2& ! F "

F " -

%

"

F "

"

0 %&'

-

( >

Objective (o)

B_attributes O_attributes C_attributes R_attributes

Alternative (A)

… … … …

.. .

Supporting attributes Rejecting attributes

measurable attributes measurable attributes

Objective (o)

B_attributes O_attributes C_attributes R_attributes

Alternative (A)

… … … …

.. .

Supporting attributes Rejecting attributes

measurable attributes measurable attributes

( > -

B

!

! B

2& 3 1 4 #

% !

!

@

(4)

*

" G !

-

@ ! "

%&' .

# %&'

# !

#

2&2 5 6 7,, % #

! -

-

!

8 1

#

( -

"

@ "

# (

!

0 1 9& -

"

! ) -

! "

" # 6

-

" "

-

# "

(

"

! " @ 1" - >"

1"

>"

4 6 4

" .

!

5 6 ,, % # %

# "

#

2 " -

@

B G

G" 2 !

" 4 # 6

B G

G")

% @

"

#

% @ -

-

@

"

" 2

-

!

4 )

9 $

6 B

) !

@ ! @

-

: 1 !

)

!

$

! @ -

$

H.' ( . (; < I6

- 6

!

@ H.' * * '

# % , * # ( "

; #, # . ' ( ' "

/ <I6

- 6

! @

" !

@ H( ' *

' .' . ' ,, ' /

' * * , < I

(5)

@ @

"

8 1 $ # "# % &

@

) -

@ -

" 6

@ -

A J

( ? !

S-S graph

A-A graph

C-C graph S-C graph

A-C graph S-S graph

A-A graph

C-C graph S-C graph

A-C graph

( ? , - J

! " # $ " %) !

J

@ 6

@ *' . .

<*

& " #&$& " % -

J !

6 @

'! " # $ " % ! -

@ -

@ J

@

& $ '! " #&$ " %)

J -

@

! $ '! " #($ " %

! J @

- ( ;

-

$ 2

$ -

-

%&'

A-A graph

intermediary attributes primary attributes

R(o,A) A_O(o,A)

S-S graph

primary state variables

intermediary state variables

R(o,A) SO(o,A)

C-C graph ultimate consequences intermediary consequences

R(o,A) CO(o,A) A-A graph

R(o,A) A_O(o,A) A-A graph

R(o,A) A_O(o,A)

S-S graph

R(o,A) SO(o,A) S-S graph

R(o,A) SO(o,A)

C-C graph ultimate consequences intermediary consequences

R(o,A) CO(o,A) C-C graph

ultimate consequences intermediary consequences

R(o,A) CO(o,A)

( ; , - $

2&2& & & = 3 % . 6 + !

?"" 1?") !

" !

2&2& & & & > + ! -

- 6

( ; - 6

J

! " -

" 2

#

"

6

2&2& & &2& # !

# -

(

4

@

16 1<" " - 1<"" -

@ @ -

1>"" %&' 1;""

"

="" &

(6)

%&' - 6

/

J >"" -

@ ?"

?"

;"

J

A -

- J

%&'

%&' 18"" (

@ <"- 8"

<"

="

9 -

8"

@ 5"

5"

!

@ 7"

7"

A J

4

% ! )

18""

4 ( <" 2

Pa(X)

Goal: to measure the strength of the influence of each parent node Y Pa(X) on the node X

( <

@ 1:"

@

6

%&' @

H' . . ' ? * , ,

' , ' '

, <I !

#

! @ 1:"

18"

1:"

4

J 4

5 # 6 & B

-

% !

#

% !

!

? %00 A0% 2 .

0 ! -

"

! >:6 >16 >>"

9& > 1 ( ( #

2 17" " -

! !

0 1 & % !

! !

" 6

! !

! 6

(7)

!

@ ! -

!

0 1 & !

" !

@ 11"

! "! 11"

"

) "

"

" " "

! "

! 6

@ 1>"

" !

! " !

! 1>"

!

' "6

! @

@ 1?

1?"

# ( (' -

" 1;"

1;"

.

# @

9&2 (( ( , 1 ( ( # * # . 6

! -

! " 6

!

!-

!

! -

! !

@ 1<"- 1="

# # $

1<"

# % # &

1="

$ % &

6

-

@ 18"-

15"

' ( # ' ( #

18"

' ( # ' ( #

15"

(

6 ' '

!

' '

! !

!

0 1 & !

!

@ 17"

! ! 17"

; . D3/2 .

% -

- -

! "

)

#

@

A(A A. A/

K1L M D % 1775" A )

4 @ (% >

)$$ $ >$ 1$ >"

K>L % >:::" ' 8 A = $

5 , * ' 0% # B . 6

= 6 4' ' + , 2 -

K?L 18=?" / '

+ 3 # ;=" >7?->75

17<5 18=?"

K;L M ' , ' N 175="

' ,A &AA) %

7, 5 '5;

;88-;7:

K<L M ' , ' N 175=" &

) ' ,A &AA

@ , C * 7, 5 '

>; >>5->?5

(8)

K=L D B 1777"

5 6 % N 17 158->:;

K8L 0 + # 17=?" , ( ## ( "

' 3 '

K5L M ' 2 # 178=" , ( ## (

D

K7L / , D 178>" , ( ## ( *

% % '

K1:L + 0 D 175;" B "

( ## ( > % B

K11L M M , O / M B 177?" 7, # > * "

. ( % , 1; /2%,

K1>L + # # , M 0 D 177<" A -

)

@ @ (

* ' @ ' 4 * % 1"

8 ( 1;1-1;5

K1?L ( N M >::1" 3 % B . 6 0

,' D /

K1;L / , 0 >:::" +

8@@@

- . ( 0 @ ( (

1>" ; ;77-<:5 K1<L / >::1" '

) 2 ' - . ( @ ( "

( 5 . 1=" ? ><<->=7

K1=L + 17=?" =

0 $ = ' 4 A A

K18L / >::<" ' % ,, * ' "

% B . 6 $ 0 = 6 ( . ' 3 1

7,, 4 5 6 B/ '

K15L A / 175=" = 7, # $ ' "

% 4 #, ,, B

K17L B / >::?" > 1 ( # 0

= 6 ($ E ' ,, @ ( ( 4 #"

, > 3 '

K>:L % ' >::=" % / ! 0

% 0 A ' 3

0 > ,, >% # ;> 885-855

K>1L % ' >::7" A , ,

% - , % + , ) / ! -

0 % 8 C * 8 * "

# ' (% 0 = 6 ( N 5 .

1 8? - 71

K>>L % ' >::7" , /

% # , % -

, C *

8 * # 4 #, ( > N ; . 1

?-1=

K>?L ' N 1757" #

A P3 D