A Convergent Algorithm for the Multimodal Traffic Equilibrium Problem
26
0
0
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. A convergent algorithm for the multimodal traffic equilibrium problem Laura Wynter. N° 4125 February 2001. ISSN 0249-6399. ISRN INRIA/RR--4125--FR+ENG. THÈME 4. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4)
(5) .
(6) !"#$&%"'( )*+,!"- ! .
(7) -"/ 0/132
(8) 4517698(:<;5=>45?. @ ACBEDFGIHKJMLNDIOCPRQTSULRVXW"FS/V>YMSULRDZLR[\Q S\LNV>W ] F[U^M[_S\B#DZFE[`#VXDZYCPRFaMFE[ bdcUVXe_FS/fhgd@
(9) ikjil m/QTYCY3VXcUS ] FncUFo`ACF#c`ACFpWrqGtsou>vwHyxCFEzCc\OtQTc\^{uT|>|CskHyuXuIYtQT}>FE[. ~{
(10) E# CXX @ ACFDIOCPNSULRDV ] QXPS\c\QT&`FEOCLRPNLRzCc\LNOCDYCc\VXzCPRF#DL[ ] Fo[U`#cULRzF ] LNWw}XF#WtF#cQTP<z^ WtVXWMDZVXWCVXSUVXWtFX Q>[^DZDZFS\cUL`T3 QTc\LRQTSULRVXWtQXP(LRWCFEOtQXPNLNS_^YCcUV>zCPRF#Dk'F[UACV SUAQ SnLNW'[YCLNSUFIVTS\ACF WtVXWMDZVXWCVXSUVXWtLR`#LS_^"VTS\ACF `#V>[SVXY3F#cQ SUV>cES\ACFYCc\VXzCPRF#DD&Q5^{Q ] DZLNSkQ ] LN3FEcUFEW>S/FEQXXFEcYtcUV>YFEcS_^>MACLR`A ] Fo[U`#cULRz3FE[ S\ACFACLRF#cQTc`ACLR`EQTP WQ SUOtcUFVT<SUAtFkS\c\Q5>F#P`#V>[SLRWSUF#cQX`SULRVXWt[E@ ACLR[YCc\VXY3F#cUS_^IY3F#c\DZLS[ QWtQTSUOCcQTP ] FE`#VXDZYV[LNSULRVXW QTYCYCc\V>Q>`AXWtVTS VXSUACFEcUL[UFnQ5 QXLNPQTzCPRFXtACLR`AhQ ] DZLS[/YCc\V QTzCPR^{`V>WXF#c\}XFEWS QXPN}>VXc\LS\ACD&[#FYtcUFo[FEW>S/V>WCF[UOt`AhQTPR}XVXc\LNSUACD FoQX[ULNPR^wLRDZYCPRF#DZF#WS\QXzCPRF&Ot[LRWC} Q [UVXPRXFEc¡¢VXcS\ACF{[ULNWt}XPRF£`PQX[\[kS\c\QT¤`ZFEOCLRPNLRzCc\LNOCD¥YCc\VXzCPRF#D
(11) QTW ] Qh`#VXWXFEc }>F#Wt`#F&YCc\VVX_ @ ACL[c\F#YtcUFo[FEW>S[¡SUACF¤¦tc\[SYCc\V QTzCPR^w`V>WXF#c\}XFEWSnDZF#SUACV ] ¢VXcI[V>PNLRWC}"SUACF¤WtVXWMDZVXWCVXSUVXWtFX Q>[^DZDZFS\cUL`TS\c\QT&`¡Fo>OtLNPRLNztcULROCD YCc\VXztPNFED" §h¨©rª\« ¬
(12) X QX[U^DZDZFS\cUL`D OCPNSUL`PQX[\[SUcQ ¤`nQX[\[LR}XWtDFEWSEMWCFo[_S\F ] DV>WCVTS\VXWCL`LNS_^X ] FE[\`F#WSDZFS\ACV ]. ®¯3°±³²o´µ ¶(·5¸ ¹º_»½¼½¸ ¾À¿Á5ºÂº_»½¼ÀøÅÄÅÄź¼µ ÷5Á±¢Æ
(13) °±ÈÇ. Unité de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 Le Chesnay Cedex (France) Téléphone : +33 1 39 63 55 11 — Télécopie : +33 1 39 63 53 30.
(14) . # $¥ I . !{ # . -/$+%_dn !"( %"!K( .
(15) jFwYCcUV>zCPRB#DZF ] Q rFE`S\Q S\LNV>W D OtPS\LR`#PRQ>[U[UF ] O S\c\QT¦`w[ FaMYCc\LNDZF FEW }EW#cQTPk`#VXDZDZFwOCWtFwLRWM
(16) oOtQ S\LNV>W QTc\LRQTSULRVXWCFEPNPRF¤WCV>WMÀDZV>WCVTS\VXWCF>Q5XFo`¤OCW VXY#cQ S\F#OCcQX[U^D#SUc\LROCF>kVXOt[IDZVXWSUc\VXWt[OCF{D&QXPN}>c PQ WCVXWMDZVXWCVXSUV>WCLNF ] FZP V>YEc\QTSUF#OtcErOCWCF&QXOMSUc\FIYtcUV>YCcUL S XrDZVXLRWt[nc\FE[SUc\LR`SULRXFXrY3F#OMS #SUc\FZ[\Q S\LR[³QTLNSUF> FSS\F YtcUV>YCcU L S ] o`c\LSdPQWQ SUOtcUF/AtL!Ec\QXc\`ACLOCF ] Fo[dLRWSUF#cQX`SULRVXWt[dF#WSUc\Fk`#PRQ>[U[UFE[ ] F/S\c\QT¦`T>gPNPRFkY3F#c\DZLS"#}QTPRF#DZF#WS OtWCF ] o`VXDZY3V>[ULS\LNV>WhWtQ S\OCc\F#PRPNF ] F P V>Y Ec\QTSUF#Otc/YtQTc¡`PQX[\[F>CFSnQ5XFo``FSUSUF ] E`V>DZYV[LNSULRVXW ] Fo[kQXPN}>VXc\LS\ACDZFE[ `#VXWXFEcU}>FEQXW>S[# /VXO[kYC c E[UF#WS\VXWt[OCW S\F#PQTPR}XV>cULNSUAtDF>3OCLFo[_SnYtQTcnQTLRPRPNFEOCc\[k³QX`#LNPR F #¤LRDYt!P EDFEWSUF#. c # YtQTcUSULRc ] OCWh[UVXPRXFEOCc YV>OCcPNFYtcUV>zCPNBEDZF $] QT3Fo` S\QTSULRVXW"OCWCLN`#PRQ>[U[UFXF#Sk[UQYCc\F#OC>F ] F`VXW>F#c\}XF#W`FX $ . %. ¬ o ª &
(17) Q rFE`S\QTSULRVXWQX[U^DZDZFS\cULOCF ] O SUcQ ¦`XMDV>WCVTS\VXWCLRFnF#Wz3V('S#F>CDS\ACV ] F ] F ] FE[\`FEWSUF.
(18)
(19) ! #"$ % '. (. &. I( &%"! d. @ AtFDIOCPNSULRDV ] QX*P )¢V>c
(20) DIOCPNSUL`PQX[\[,+SUcQ ¤`FEOCLRPNLRzCc\LNOtD YCcUV>zCPRF#DpL[QWQ SUOtc\QXPQXW ] LRDZYV>cSQTWS}XFEWCF#cQTPRL%-oQ S\LNV>W VXtS\ACF/`PQX[\[L`dSUcQ ¤`FEOCLRPNLRzCc\LNOCD YCcUV>zCPRF#D( ACLRPRF SUACFPQ SUSUF#c`EQTWIzFF#aYtcUFo[U[UF ] QX[Qn`V>W>FaVXYCSULRDL.-EQTSULRVXW YtcUV>}XcQTD OtW ] F#cdSUACF¡c\F#PQ SULRXFEPN^IDZLNP ] Q>[U[UOCDZYMSULRVXW&VX([_S\cUL` S\PN^LRWt`c\FEQ>[LRWC}S\c\Q5>F#Pt`#V>[Sd¢OCWt`SULRVXWt[ESUACFk¢VXc\DZF#c Q ] DZLS[kWtV [UOt`Ah¢VXc\D OtPRQTSULRVXW3LNWw}XF#WtF#cQTPÀ0 /£Wt[SUFoQ ] SUACFD OtPS\LNDZV ] QTP
(21) YCc\VXzCPRF#D L[kF#aMYCcUFo[U[UF ] D&QTSUACFEDZQTSULN `EQTPRPN^ Q>[nQ{ QTc\LQ SULRVXWQTP
(22) LNWCFoOtQTPRLS_^wYCcUV>zCPRF#DQX[¡LRW>S\cUV ] O`F ] z^JDZLS\ A )s 1321+4 /£W ] F#F ] LNWSUAtFZ`EQX[UFIVXQ DIOCPNSULRDV ] QXP<FEOCLRPNLRzCc\LNOtD YCc\VXzCPRF#DSUAtF`V>[SVXY3F#cQ S\VXc¢VXcFEQ>`A `#PRQ>[U[ ] FEYFEW ] [V>W{S\AC6 F 5tV VXXFEACL`PRFE[ VT DZV>cUFSUAQTWZVXWCF`#PRQ>[U[EXQTW ] TLRWYQTcUSUL`OCPQTco SUAtFE[UF ] F#Y3F#W ] FEWt`LRFE[dQTc\F}>F#WCFEc\QXPNPR^WCVXSd[^DZDZFSUc\L`Tik[Q¡c\FE[UOCPSo S\ACFneQX`#VXzCLQTWD&Q SUc\LNawVTSUACF&V >F#cQTPRP
(23) `#V>[SVXY3F#cQ S\VXc¡LR[LNS\[UF#PNQX[U^DZDZFS\cUL`TZ ACFEW'SUACL[VM`#`#OCc\[E<S\ACFneQX`#VT ztLRQXW"D&QTSUc\LaLR[/WCVTS ] LRQX}XVXWQTPRLR[\QTzCPR8F 7S\ACL[kLRDZYCPNLRFE[SUAtQTSkSUAtF QTc\LRQTSULRVXWtQXP<LNWCFoOtQTPRLS_^ ] F¦WCLNWt}&SUACF 'QXc ] c\VXY FoOCLNPRLRzCcULROCD `#VXW ] LNSULRVXW[nLR[¡WCVXS¡S\ACFZVXYMS\LND&QXPNLNS_^ `V>W ] LNSULRVXWwVXQ YtQTcUSUL`OtPRQXcV>YMSULRDZ%L -oQ SULRVXWYCc\VXzCPRF#DI@ AQ S L[ES\ACFV XF#cQTPRP`#V>[SV>YFEc\QTSUVXcLR[WCVXSS\ACFI}>c\Q ] LRF#WSVXdQTWCVXSUACFEck¢OCW` SULRVXW ] F¦WCF ] V XF#ckSUACFF#WS\LNc\F¢FoQX[ULNzCPRF c\F#}>LNV>WTQTW ] SUAtF#c\FL[WCVnQTWtQXPNV>}XV>Ot$[ 9:FE`D&QTWCWSUcQTWt[¢VXc\D&Q SULRVXW ;dLNWSUVQXW FEOCLR QTPRF#WS`V>W>FaVXYCSULRD.L -EQTSULRVXW YtcUV>zCPNFED ACLRPRFSUACFkD OCPNSULRDZV ] QTPMS\c\QT&` FoOCLNPRLRzCcULROCD9YCcUV>zCPRF#DXz^ ] F¦tWCLNSULRVXW(TSUAtF#W ] VFE[WtVTSY3F#c\DLNSS\ACF/QTYCYtPNLN `EQ S\LNV>WhVTSUAtF³Q5XV>cULNSUFQXPN}>VXc\LS\ACD&[ ¢VXckSUACF[FEYtQTcQTztPNF>[ULNWC}>PNF#`#PRQ>[U[S\c\QT¤` QX[\[ULN}>WCDZF#WS/YCc\VXzCPRF#D3F¤`LRF#WS QXPN}>VXc\LS\ACDZLR`QXYCYCc\V>QX`AtFE[E`#QXW LNW YCc\LNW`LRYCPNF> zFwQXYCYCPRLNF ] f FSUAtV ] [&¢VXc [V>PNLRWC}7DV>WCVTS\VXWCFh QXcULQ S\LNV>WtQTP LRWCFo>OQTPRLS_^ZYCc\VXzCPRF#D&[QTc\F/SUAtF/¢VM`Ot[VX(QPQTc\}XF/z3V ] ^&VTc\FE[UFEQXc\`A&LRW&SUAtFWCV>WCPRLNWCFoQTcYCcUV>}XcQTDZDZLNWt} `V>DDIOM WtLS_^>@ AtFLRWSUF#c\FE[SUF ] cUFoQ ] FEcdL[cUF#¢F#c\cUF ] SUV bQTSUc\LNM[\[V>< W )_s 1181=+
(24) ¢VXc Q [UOCDZD&QTc\^VXDZFSUAtV ] [d¢V>cDZV>WCVTS\VXWCF QXcULQ S\LNV>WtQTPrLRWCFEOtQXPNLNS_^¤YCc\VXzCPRF#D&[E ikWCVTS\ACF#cZY3VXYCOCPQTcZc\FE[UVXPROMSULRVXW [_S\c\QTSUF#}>^'¢VXcSUACFQX[U^DZDF#SUc\LR`{SUcQ ¤` QX[\[LR}XWCDZFEW>SYCc\VXzCPRF#D L[ISUACFh[UVT `EQTPRPNF ] > ?= @A%BC @D
(25) EF TztQ>[F ] VXW'SUACF&L ] FoQVTSUACFHGQX`#VXzCLV>cnSUACFJInQXOt[U[_JF#L ] F#P ] FE`#VXDZYV[LNSULRVXW QXYCYCc\V>Q>`ACFE[Ot[UF ] ¢VXc/[UVXPRLNWC}Z[U^[SUFED&[ VTWCVXWCPRLRWCFEQXcFoOtQ S\LNV>Wt[# @ ACF&L ] FoQ z3F#AtLNW ] S\ACF&DZFS\ACV ] L[nS\V¦Ca SUAtF&VT3 ] LQT}>VXWtQXP½(VXc`c\V>[\[¡SUFEcUD&[EVTSUACF&DIOCPNSULR5QXcULQ S\F&`V>[S ¢OtWt` S\LNV>Wt[QTW ] S\VSUACFEW [V>PN>FZQ[UFEOCFEWt`F&VX ] LQT}>VXWtQXPK)³QTW ] S\AOt[[UF#YtQXc\QXzCPNFL+/YtcUV>zCPNFED&[#
(26) /£W7S\ACF¤`#Q>[FZVT S\ACF¡SUcQ ¤`¡QX[\[LR}XWCDZFEW>S YCc\VXzCPRF#DSUAtF ] LRQX}XV>WtQTPRLR[UF ] [ULNWt}XPRF£`PQX[\[Q>[U[ULN}>WCDZF#WS\[`#QXW{z3F[V>PN>F ] ¢V>PNPRV LNWt}IQ [ULRDYtPNF SUcQTWt[¢VXc\D&Q SULRVXW(tz^5QXcULRVXO[/DZFS\ACV ] [/¢V>c`#VXWXF#a"YCc\VX}>c\QXDZDLRWC}NMWCF VXSUACFDZV>[SkL ] F#PR^>Ot[UF ] LRWSUACL[`#Q>[FLR[¡S\ACFZYV>YCOCPQTcxtc\QXWCÀ'VXPN¢FX<V>cn`#VXWXF#a `VXDIzCLRWtQ S\LNV>Wt[#<DZF#SUACV ] &@ ACL[QTYCYtcUVQX`A PRFEQ ] [SUV [UVXPRLNWt}QZ[UFEOCF#W`FnVTYCc\VXzCPRF#D&[ VTSUACFn¢V>cUD. RCZ[S OR S TP.Q U V Y d hji[k i WLT8X \ ]!^`_$ab=c_$a c e ee c,f g8ce e e c_$a ^lf!g. )sC+. AtF#c\FHm LR[nS\ACF{[UFS VX QXc\`E[nLNW7S\ACF¤WCF#S_V>cUr(SUACF&S\c\Q5>F#P`#V>[S¢OCWt` S\LNV>W LR[
(27) QXW ] SUACF{DV ] FEP LRWt`#PNO ] FE[vu Ot[UF#c`PQX[\[UFE[E VXcDZV ] FE[E@ ACF LNSUF#cQ S\LNV>WIWOCDIzFEcLR[c\F¢FEcUc\F ] SUVQX[x]owrn4@ prAOtqst [#Tp [ULRWt`FQ SFoQX`A LRWCWCFEc LNSUFEc\QTSULRVXWIVTCS\ACF ] FE`#VXDZYV[LNSULRVXWQTPR}XV>cULNSUACDoSUAtFYtcUV>zCPNFED SUVnz3F[UVXPRXF ] L[
(28) Q¡[ULNWC}>PNF#`#PRQ>[U[(SUcQ ¤`FEOCLRPNLRzCc\LNOtD YtcUV>zCPNFEDSUACFn³Q5>VXc\LS\F¡QXPN}>VXc\LS\ACD&[`EQTW"zFO[F ] LRWQ&[Fo>OtF#WSULQTxP )¢V>cF#>F#W"YtQTcQTPRPNFEPy+D&QTWtWCF#co. zkV FEXF#co S\ACLR[ ] FE`#VXDZY3V>[ULS\LNV>WDZF#SUACV ] QX[L[S\ACFk`#Q>[F ¢V>cSUAtFkQTPR}XV>cULNSUACD&[
(29) ¢V>c QTc\LRQTSULRVXWtQXPMLNWCFoOtQTPRLS\LNFo[ XQ PNPRO ] F ] SUV QXzV >FXTL[YtcUV QTztPN^`VXW>F#c\}XF#WSVXWCPR^OCW ] FEcdc\F#PQ SULRXFEPN^[_S\cULRWC}>F#WSd`V>W ] LNSULRVXWt[dVXWSUACFkSUcQ5XFEPC`V>[S V>YFEc\QTSUV>cE@ ACFo[F`VXW ] LS\LNV>Wt[SQT>FSUACF ¢VXc\DVXPNV F#c[FEDLN£`VXWS\LNWOCLNS_^"QXW ] [UVXDZF¢V>cUDVTDZVXWtVTSUV>WCL`LNS_^X ] F#Y3F#W ] LRWC}7VXW SUAtF"YQTcUSUL`OCPQTcZQTPR}XV>cULNSUACD O[F ] @ AtF DZV>[S¤[_S\c\QXLN}>AS¢VXc\ QTc ] QTPR}XVXc\LNSUACD&[IcUFo>OtLNc\F"[SUc\L` S DZV>WCVTS\VXWCL`LNS_^X QTW ] QTc\LQTWS\[&F#aMLR[S¤ACL`A QXPNPRV SUACF FoOCLNPRLRzCcULROCD YCcUV>zCPRF#D S\V zF ] F¦tWtF ] LRW SUF#c\D&[&VT DZV>WCVTS\VXWCFVXY3F#cQ S\VXc[#D /£W S\ACF `#Q>[FhVXS\ACF ] LQT}>VXWtQXPN.L -EQTSULRVXW DF#SUACV ] QTz3V XF>ikACW QTW ] zkVX}QT{ W )_s 1|>u + °°·}~L!.
(30) @F . G. x
(31) PRVXc\LRQXWQXW ] JYCLRFE[\[K)_sC18|u8+ > QTW ] bQTWt}nQXW ] AtQXW )s1|>u8+ )½[FEF/QTP[VOCYCOCL[dQXW ] QXcU>FEQTO"s1| =+(}>LN>F PNVM`#QXP `#VXWXFEcU}>F#Wt`#Fkc\FE[UOCPNS\[ ztQ>[F ] CO Y3VXW"S_VQ>[U[UOCDZYMS\LNV>Wt[ VXW SUACFnS\c\Q5>F#P<`V[_S¢OtWt` S\LNV>Wt[
(32) @ ACFn`V>[S¢OCW` US LRVXW[QXcUFo)³xCc\FE`AtFS + ] LN3FEcUFEW>S\LRQXzCPRFkLRW¤SUAtFkWCFELN}>Az3VXc\ACVV ] VTS\ACFkFoOCLNPRLRzCcULROCD [UVXPROMSULRVXW _ d! i b d d#"%$ ]!^ _ i b ]!^ _. AtF#c\F c\F¢F#c[nS\V SUAtF ] LQT}>VXWtQXPYtQTcUSIVX SUACF DZQTSUc\La< i L[S\ACF¤S\c\Q5>F#PS\LNDZF¤¢OtWt` S\LNV>W F# QXPNOtQTSUF ] Q S QXW7FEOCLRPNLRzCc\LNOCD¥[V>PNOCSULRVXW T '& () ]!^ _QXW ] + c\F#YtcUFo[FEW>S[¡SUACF{DZQTSUc\LaWCVXc\D{@ ACFE[UF S_V `#VXW ] LS\LNV>Wt[kFEWt[UOCcUF SUAt_ QTSkS\ACF ] LRQX}X]!VX^`W_ QTPRi LR[\Q S\LNV>W QT]!PR^ }X_ VXc\i*LNSUACD `V>W>F#c\}XFo[ SUV"Q{PRVM`#QTPRPR^ OCWtLROCFZ[V>PNOCSULRVXW )½x
(33) PNV>cULQTWwQXW ] JYCLRFE[\[ICs 18|8u + j I¡PRVXztQXP`VXW>F#c\}XF#W`Fc\FEOCLRcUFo[Q"[SUc\LR`S¡DZVXWtVTSUV>WCL`LNS_^Q>[U[UOCDZYMS\LNV>WwV XFEc/S\_ACF FEWSULRcUF¡¢FEQ>[LRzCPRFncUFE}XLRVXW @ ACFn[UFE`V>W ] `#VXW ] LNSULRVXW LNDZYCPRLRFE[dSUAtQTS L[YV[LNSULRXF ] F¦WCLS\F)½i/ACWs1321+XS\ACVXOt}XA&S\ACF¡`#VXWXFEc\[UF/L[ L[kz3VTS\Awc\V QTW ] WtVTSWtFE`Fo[U[\QTc\LRPN^ SUc\OCFXni [OM¤`#LNFEW>Sn`V>W ] LNSU]!LRVX^ _ Wh¢i V>cLNSS\V{ACV>P ] 3AtV FEXF#cotL[kSUAtQTS ]!^ _ i `#VXPROCDZW ] LRQX}XVXWQTPRPN^ ] V>DZLNWtQXWSESUAQ S/L[#CPRFSUSULRWC}-, & i . ,0/1/ .32 5 O 47698. /£W"VTS\ACF#c VXc ] LRWSUFEc\Q>` SULRVXW[#. V. /;< :. g. . ,=/ .. V. g c /;< :. ]!^ _ g. g. . , / .?>. @-A. cB. &C$. . D5.. c ee e c e. )Àu8+. [E>S\ACFLRW>S\F#cQX`SULRVXWt[ ] OCFnS\VIDZF#DIzFEc\[ VXV>WCF [ V W"`#PRQ>[U[ QTc\F¡D Ot`A"}Xc\FEQTSUF#cSUAQTW SUACF`c\V>[\[. /SL[`PRFEQTcS\AtQ SLN
(34) QIDV ] FEP<LNW`PRO ] FE[`#V>[S¢OtWt` S\LNV>Wt[SUAtQTSLNWt`#VXc\YV>c\QTSUFDV>cUFSUAQTW"VXWCFn`PQX[\[VTS\c\QT&`X D V ] F>VXco5tV VXW DZV>cUF{SUAtQXW VXWtF QTc`TS\ACF#W SUACFo[F LNWS\F#cQX` S\LNV>Wt[LRPRPWtVTSZzFQTPRPWtF#}XPRLR}XFEQXzCPRFX )McoLNW Z S\AtQ S`#QX[UFXQ[FEYtQTcQTztPNFQTYtYCcUV5aMLRD&Q SULRVXWVTrS\ACF/D OtPS\LNDZV ] QTPDZV ] F#PtVXOtP ] AtQ5>FzFEF#W¤[UOM¤`LRF#WSdLRWZSUACF/¦tc\[S YtPRQ>`CF + /OCDZF#c\L`#QTPFaMY3F#c\LNDZFEW>S[AtQ5XF{`#VXWM¦cUDZF ] SUACF"WCV>WMÀDZV>WCVTS\VXWCL`LNS_^VX/SUAtF{S\c\Q5>F#P`#V>[SV>YFEc\QTSUV>cE LRW YCc\Q>` S\LR`#FX /£W ] F#F ] dLNSZAQX[zFEF#W VXzt[UF#c\XF ] WOCDZF#c\VXOt[IS\LNDZFE [ )½[FEF"@VXLRWS¤QTW ] ^WSUFEcEs 181E C¢V>cV>WCF [UOt`A'FaCQTDZYCPRCF +kS\AtQ SS\ACF¤`V[_SVXY3F#cQ S\VXcnLRW'QDIOCPS\LNDZV ] QXPSUcQ ¤`FEOCLRPNLRzCc\LNOCD+YCc\VXzCPRF#D L[QTPRDZV>[SWCF#>F#c DZV>WCVTS\VXWCF> /£W S\ACLR[`#VXWSUF#aSokS\ACF'DZQTe_VXc\LS_^ VXIQTPR}XV>cULNSUACD&[ Ot[UF ] SUV [V>PN>FwD OtPS\LNDZV ] QTPnYCc\VXztPNFEDZ[QXcUF WtVhPNV>WC}XFEcYCcUV QXzCPN^'`V>W>F#c\}XFEW>So(QTW ] LRW ] FEF ] LNSI`#QXW7zF{[UACV W'SUAQ SI[UOt`A QTPR}XV>cULNSUACD&[nD&Q5^ ¢c\FEOCFEWSUPR^ `#VXWXFEcU}>F/S\VY3VXLRWS\[AtLR`AQTc\FnWCVTSFEOCLRPRLNzCc\LQQTSkQTPRP½ /£W7S\ACLR[ YtQTY3F#co
(35) F¤F#aCQTDZLNWtFZSUACF¤WQ SUOtcUF¤VX SUACF{`#V>[SVXY3F#cQ S\VXcLRW QhD OCPNSULRDZV ] QTPdSUcQ ¤`ZFEOCLRPNLRzCc\LNOtD tY cUV>zCPNFED 'F [ACV LRW [Fo` SULRVXW uCS\ACF z3F#AtQ5LRVXcZS\AtQ S `EQTW z3FhFaMACLRzCLS\F ] z^ S\ACFE[UFwQXPN}>VXc\LS\ACD&[ZACF#W S\ACF/DZVXWtVTSUV>WCL`LNS_^ c\FEOCLRcUFEDFEWSdLR[dWCVTSDF#SE>SUAtQTSdL[#>SUAtQTSdLNSUACV>OMSdS\ACF/WCFo`FE[\[\QTc\^ DZVXWCVXSUV>WCLR`#LS_^IYCc\VXY3F#cUS_^X QXPN}>VXc\LS\ACD&[
(36) DZQ5^I`VXW>F#c\}XFS\VWCVXWCÀFo>OtLNPRLNztcULROCDpY3VXLRWS\[E kFaSE>F/[UACV S\AtQ SdQ ] LNrF#c\F#WSYCc\VXY3F#cUS_^XT[SUc\LR`SUPR^ FEQXXFEcdS\AtQTWDZVXWCVXSUV>WCLR`#LS_^> ] VFE[ ACV>P ] LRW"QZD&QTW^¤`EQX[UFE[ECQTW ] YCc\V L ] Fo[Q>F#c\^&F#PRF#}>QXWS LRWSUFEcUYCc\FSQ S\LNV>W{VT S\ACFnLNWS\F#cQX` S\LNV>Wt[ QX`#cUV[U[d5QXcULQTztPNFo[LRW SUACFnD OtPS\LN QTc\LQ SUF¡S\c\Q5>F#Pr`V>[S¢OCWt` S\LNV>Wt[Ei `AtQTcQX`SUF#c\.L -EQ S\LNV>W&VTSUACL[ YtcUV>YFEcS_^ZL[YtcUV L ] F ] LRW [UFE`SULRVXW &C Mk[ULN}>WCL¦3`#QTWSLNDZY3VXcUS\QTW`F¡LR[SUAQ SSUACL[ YCc\VXY3F#cUS_^AQX[zFEF#W[ACV W¤SUV Q ] DZLSYCc\V QTzCPR^w`#VXWXFEcU}>F#WS¡QXPN}>VXc\LS\ACD&[#Z@ ACL[`PQX[\[nVTQXPN}>VXc\LS\ACD&[¡LR[ ] FE[\`c\LNz3F ] LNW [UFE`SULRVXW'Gt¤JFE`SULRVXW v7`#VXWt`#PNO ] FE[&LNSUA Q ] LR[\`Ot[\[ULNV>W VXS\ACFw`#VXWt[UFEOCFEWt`Fo[ZVTnSUACL[¤c\FE[UOCPNS&¢VXc¤z3VTS\A SUACF SUcQ ¤`FEOCLRPNLRzCc\LNOtD YtcUV>zCPNFEDCQTW ] SUACFDZV>cUFn}XFEWCF#cQTPrV>YMSULRD&QTP<YCc\LR`#LNWt}ZQXW ] WCFS_VXc\ ] Fo[LR}XW"YCc\VXzCPRF#D&[E. ±¢Æ°(±ÈÇ.
(37)
(38) ! #"$ % v 1. 2. s iS_VT£QTc`/WtFS_VXc\. !{
(39)
(40)
(41) "
(42) )*! . ,Z!
(43) " $"n . j(FS/Ot[kzFE}XLRWz^ cUFo`#QXPNPRLNWt}IS\ACFztQ>[L` ] F#¦tWCLNSULRVXWhVT
(44) SUcQ ¤`nFo>OtLNPRLNztcULROCD I¡LRXFEWhQZWCFS_VXc\ ] F#¦tWCF ] V >F#cQ D z3F#LRWC}&QI[UFSVXWCV ] Fo[# D Q[F#SVT
(45) QXc\`E[#MQXW ] Q[UFSVT
(46) VXc\LN}>LNWM ] Fo[_S\LNWtQTSULRVXW YtQTLRc\[E }>c\QXYCA & FoQX`H A M YtQT^LRcLc[[UQXi L ] SUVAtQ5>FQ>[U[UVM`LQ S\F ] LNSUAZLNSdQ ] F#D&QTW ] k S\AtQ SDIOt[_Sz3F/[\Q SUL[¦tF ] ik[LRWZDZV>[SVXSUACFEc WtFS_VXc\o 5V YCc\VXzCPRF#D&[E>S\ACFQTc`#[AtQ5>F¡Q>[U[UVM`LQ SUF ] LNSUA"SUACFED `V[_S¢OCWt`SULRVXWt[E W i CSUAtQTS LRWt`#cUFoQX[UFkLNSUA S\ACK F 5V VXW&S\AtQ 6 S )³QTW ] Y3V>[\[LRzCPR^QXWCVTS\ACF#!c +QXc\`X ikW{Fo>OtLNPRLNztcULROCD LR[c\FEQX`AtF ] VX] W¤^`SU_ ACFWCFS_VXc\IAtF#W&S\ACF 5V ] LR[SUc\OCzCOCSUFE[LNS\[UF#PNLRW [UOt`A QI Q5^Z[UVS\AtQ S/QX_ PNW P ] FEDZQXW ] [ QTc\F[\Q S\LR[¦tF ] MQTW ] WCV[ULRWC}XPRFkOt[UF#c`EQTW¤c\F ] O`F AtLR[S\c\Q5>F#P<`V[_S/z^{`AtQXWC}XLRWC}YtQ S\A @ ACFkD OCPNSUL`PQX[\[S\c\QT&`Q>[U[ULR}XWCDZF#WSYCc\VXztPNFED AtQ>[SUACF¡Q ]C] F ] `V>DYtPNF#aLNS_^S\AtQ S ] F#D&QXW ] [F#aL[SdzF#S_FEF#W FoQX`A M9YtQTLRc¢VXcDZVXc\FSUAtQXWhVXWCFI`PQX[\[VTx5tV 73QX[[Ot`A(tS\ACF 5tV /[QTc\FXFE`SUV>c/ QTPROCF ] /f VXc\FYCc\FE`L[UF#PR^X FoQX`AM YQTLRc ] F#D&QTW ] k QTW ] FEQX`A"QTc`K5V QTc\LRQXzCPNF W LR[ L ] F#WS\L¦tF ] z^ZS_VILRW ] L`Fo[#S\AtQ SL[# k / QTW ] / AtF#c\F A L[SUACFn`PQX[\[dLRW ] F#a<JMLNDZLRPRQXcUPR^XSUAtFS\c\Q5>F#P3`V>_ [S\[V>W&SUACFnWCF#S_V>cUPRLNWCM[ QTc\F/¢OtWt` S\LNV>Wt[ VT(DZV>cUF S\_ AtW QTW VXWCF QTc\LRQXzCPNF>XS\AtQ S L[# W i & W ¢VXc [UVXDZFkWOCDIzFEc VT(`#PRQ>[U[UFE[E
(47) @ AtLR[YCc\VXzCPRF#D L[ d c\F¢FEcUc\F ] S\VQ>N [
(48) ! ] AC^ F#_ W{SUACF¡] F^ r_ FEb `cS_ VXce VXe WCeF¡c_` PQXi [\[dV>W{QTWtVTSUAtF#cLR[WCVTSSUAtF¡[\QTDZFQ>[dL`F#À>F#c[UFQ 7TSUAQ S L[E /b i"! b & # b i$! /b ¢V>c/QTPRP(`PQX[\[UFE[ A & # VXW SUAtF}XcQTYCA% ] ^ _ _ g ] g ^ _ _ B @ ACFS\c\QT¤`hQX[\[LR}XWCDZFEW>S&YCc\VXztPNFED L[&VTnYCcQX` S\LR`EQTPLRWSUF#c\FE[SZ¢VXc¤YtcUF ] LR`SULRWC}7SUAtFhPNLRXFEPN^ VXOMS`VXDZFVTQ `AQTWC}>FLNWWtFS_VXc\kLRWM¢c\Q>[_S\cUO` SUOtcUFV>c[UF#c\L`Fo[#@ ACFD OtPS\LNDZV ] QTP>SUcQ ¤`Q>[U[ULR}XWCDZF#WSYCc\VXztPNFED AtQ>[c\FE`#F#LRXF ] YQTcUSUL`OCPQTc(QTSS\F#WSULRVXWTQ>[WOCDZF#c\VXO[YCPQTWCWtLNWC}¡[U`#F#WtQXcULRV>[cUFo>OtLNc\FD&QTLRWC}SUAtF ] L[SULRWt` S\LNV>WzF#S_FEF#W ] LrF#c\F#WS 5V S_^YFo[ZVXW SUACFhWtFS_VXc\3[O`A Q>[ZzCOt[UFE[ZXFEc\[UOt[&`EQTc[#AtFEQ5^ XFEc\[UOt[PRLN}>A>S&>F#ACL`PRFE[E}>OCL ] F ] XFEc\[UOt[ OtWC}XOCL ] F ] XFEACL`PRFE[ECQX[FEPNPQ>[OtcUztQXW{WCF#S_V>cUZDZV ] F#P[LNW"ACL`A{S\ACN F 5tV /[VXW{LRWSUFEc\[UFE`SULRWC}IPRLRWCM[ LNWSUFEc\Q>` S S\ACc\VXOC}>A{S\ACF#LRc SUcQ5XFEPr`#V>[S ¢OCWt` S\LNV>Wt[E kFaSEMFkF#aMQXDZLNWCF¡QTWtQXPN^S\LR`EQTPRPN^ZQ [ULNDZYCPRF¡FaCQTDZYCPRF/S\AtQ SLNPRPNO[_S\c\QTSUFE[dSUAtFYCc\FE[UF#W`FkVXD OCPNSULRYCPRFFoOCLNPRLRzM c\LQC>[S\QXzCPRFkQTW ] OCWt[S\QTztPNF> V>Wt[L ] FEcSUAtF/S_VT£QTc`WtFS_VXc\ VT(x
(49) LR}XOCc\Fs/LNSUA{PNLRWCFEQXc`#V>[S¢OCWt`SULRVXWt[d¢VXcdS_V `#PRQ>[U[UFE[ QXW ] V>cULR}XLRWM ] FE[SULRWtQTSULRVXW ] F#D&QTW ] Q>[ }XLRXF#W zFEPNV & $ / /(' /('*),+ )`&+ ] db / ^ _ i & $ e )>& _ b /('*>&- _ d d /('/-10 ] ^ _ i & $ e _ b e 8. _ k F. c"2 / ] / AtF#c\F LR[S\ACF"SUcQ5XFEPdS\LNDZFhQTW SUACF 5tV )³VXcSUAtF"WOCDIzFEcZVT>F#ACL`PRFE [ + VT¡`#PRQ>[U[ w VXW QXc\` A A & $ -M] aQX^ _W ]i _ ] ] L[nSUACF F#D&QTW ¢V>c`PQXa [\j [ wr{@ ACFEWSUACFZ¢FoQX[ULNzCPRF ] V>DZQXLNW `V>Wt[ULR[S\[nVXS\ACV>[UF / ¢V>c k & $ & $ A c p / ] / ] < / ; AtLR`A43 / T65 d"9 a QXW 3 / T65 d"9 d QTW +¢VXcQXPNP - /SL[`#PNFoQTc
(50) SUAtQTSSUACFY_ gQTcUSULQTP b g _ . _ 2 _ c > B = 8 b 7 : b 7 ] F#c\LN Q S\LN>FX<V>c GQX`#VXzCLQTWrD&Q S\cULNa VTdS\ACFE[UF&`V[_S¡¢OCWt`SULRVXWt[nL[¡WCVTSY3c V>[ULS\LN>F ] F#¦tWCLNSUF>(QTW ] SUAOt[S\ACF i ;# + @ ¢OtWt` S\LNV>Wt[QTc\FWtVTSDZVXWCVXSUVXWtLR`X@ AQ S]!^ LR_ [E@? i VXW[Fo>OtF#WSUPR^XMF¡`EQTWCWtVTS ]!^ _ ]!^BA i c ^ _ ADC _c$AE= p. °°·}~L!.
(51) @F . t 21 = t 22. x 22. t 11 = t 12. 4. 3 t 11 < t 12 t 21 < t 22. 2 t 11 > t 12 t 21 > t 22 1 x 11. 16. @@ "u @ ACc\F#FnFEOCLRPNLRzCc\LNOtD [V>PNOCSULRVXWt[ z3F`FEcSQTLRW{S\AtQ S S\ACF[V>PNOCSULRVXW SUVZSUAtF¡DIOCPNSULRDV ] QXP<SUcQ ¤`¡FEOCLRPRLNzCc\LROCD YCc\VXztPNFED ] F¦WCF ] z^ /£W"³Q>` SEMLNSSUOtcUWt[/VXOMS SUAQ SSUAtF#c\FnQXcUF¡S\ACcUFEFnFEOCLRPNLRzCc\LNOCD[V>PNOCSULRVXWt[EC[AtV W LRW"x
(52) LR}XOCc\FuM. ) &=+LR[OtWCLROCF>. @ ACFZS\ACc\F#F&[V>PNOCSULRVXWt[n`V>cUc\FE[UY3VXW ] \S V"SUACFZ¢V>PNPRV LNWt}J5tV /[EACFEcUFISUAtFZ¦tc\[ScUV }XLRXFE[S\ACF&QTDZVXOCWSVT S\ACFn¦tc[_S/`#PRQ>[U[ V>W"QXc\`E[sQXW ] uMCQTW ] S\CA F[Fo`V>W ] c\V S\ACFQTDZV>OCWS VX(S\ACF[Fo`V>W ] `#PRQ>[U[ 1.33. 14.67. 1.. 8. 8. 2. 4. 14.67. 1.33. 0. 4. 52. 52. 47. 40. 3.. 0. 2. 2. 52. 52. kFSUSUF# c )_Cs 1=2Tu +LNPRPROt[_S\c\QTSUF ] Q¤[LRDZLNPQTcFaCQTDZYCPRFX3QTP[V{ztQX[UF ] VXW Q&S_VXQXc\`¡WCF#S_V>cU LS\A PNLRWCFoQTc`#V>[S/¢OCWt` S\LNV>Wt[E @ ACF¤QXcS\LR`#PNF&L[LRDY3VXcUS\QXWSLNW'SUAQ S LNS QX[¡SUAtF&¦tc[_SS\VhAtQ5XF ] L[U`#Ot[\[F ] S\ACF¤YCc\FE[UF#W`FZVT D OCPNSULRYCPRF FoOCLNPRLRzCcULQC¤xtOCcUSUACFEcUDZVXc\FX /FSUSUFEcLNW ] LR`EQ S\F ] SUAtQTSSUACF{DL ]C] PRF¤[UVXPROMSULRVXWACL`A7`#VXc\cUFo[Y3VXW ] [SUV"SUACF¤S_V `#PRQ>[U[UFE[ [UAtQTc\LRWC} ¢OtPNPR^¤S\ACFnS_V&QXc\`E[# QX[ 9OCWt[S\QTztPN F ;. @ ACF`#V>[S\[¢V>cFEQX`A"VTSUACFnS\ACc\F#F[V>PNOCSULRVXWt[QXcUFE 52. 52. 1.. 2. 40. 47. 3. 44. 44. AtF#c\F¤QT}>QXLNW(SUAtF&¦tc[_Sc\V }>LN>FE[¡SUAtF&SUcQ5XFEPSULRDFo[¢V>c QXFEACLR`#PNF&VX/`PQX[\[Zs&VXW QTc`#[Zs¤QXW ] uMQTW ] S\ACF [UFE`#VXW ] }XLRXFo[SUACFnS\c\Q5>F#P3SULRDZFE[ ¢V>c/`PQX[\[/uM JV>PNOCSULRVXW u¡L[d}>LN>F#WZz^QXW&FEOtQXP[UYCPNLNSVXrSUACFkS_V `#PRQ>[U[UFE[VXWZSUAtF/S_VQTc`#[E
(53) ikPS\ACVXOC}>AZSUACFFEOCLRPNLRzCc\LNOtD `#VXW ] LS\LNV>W¤LR[[\Q SUL[¦tF ] QTSdS\ACLR[Y3VXLRW>SoLS LR[QTW{OCWt[S\QTztPNF¡[V>PNOMS\LNV>W&LNW{SUAtQTSQXPS\F#c\LNWC} F#XFEW{[UPNLR}XASUPR^SUACF05tV VT `#PRQ>[U[uV>WIS\ACF/WCF#S_V>cULRPRPCcUFo[OtPSLRWZXF#AtLR`#PNFo[VT3SUAtQTSd`PQX[\[[FEF#LRWC}Q ] LrF#c\F#WSoXPRV FEc`#V>[SE85tV YtQTSS\F#c\W. ±¢Æ°(±ÈÇ.
(54)
(55) ! #"$ % . 2. 4. 3.5. 3. Solution 1 Solution 2 Solution 3. 2.5 x22. Non solution 2. 1.5. 1. 0.5. 0 0. @@. &. 5. 10 x11. 15. 20. @ ACF`V>W>F#c\}XFEWt`FkSUV ] LN3FEcUFEW>Sk[UVXPROMS\LNV>Wt[QX`E`VXc ] LRWC}ISUVSUACFQXPN}>VXc\LS\ACD [S\QTcUSULRWC}ZY3VXLRW>S. V>Wt[UFEOCF#WS\PN^>XXFEACL`PRFE[VX<zVXSUA{`#PRQ>[U[UFE[LRPRPtc\FFEOCLRPNLRzCcQ SUFLRWSUV QWCF#[_SQTzCPRF/Fo>OtLNPRLNztcULROCDQXW ] [UVXPROMSULRVXW uIL[Q5tV S\AtQ S/VXOCP ] YCcUV>ztQTztPN^¤WtF#XFEc zFV>zt[FEcU>F ] MQ>`#`V>c ] LNWC}ISUVS\ACF`V[_S¢OCW` SULRVXWOt[UF ] . /£W x
(56) LR}XOCc\JF &C
(57) F&LNPRPNO[_S\c\QTSUFZSUAtF [UVXPROMSULRVXWt[¢VXOCW ] z^wSUACF ] LRQX}XV>WtQTPRLR[\Q S\LNV>WwDZFS\ACV ] QX`E`V>c ] LRWC}"SUV s5uMs ] L rF#c\F#WS¡[S\QXcS\LNWt}¤YV>LNWS[/LRWhSUACFI¢FEQ>[LRzCPRFc\F#}XLRVXW(j)³xCV>cF#aCQTDZYCPRFXr[_SQTcUSULRWC}¤Y3VXLRW>S ) & +{QTW ] dd & ++ & +t & & $ & _ & bb QXW ] _ & +C[V `#VXc\cUFo[Y3VXW ] [SUVw[S\QXcS\LNWC}S\ACF¤QTPR}XV>cULNSUAtD+Q S b QXW ] QXPN_ P<b VXd SUAtFnk b `#PRQ>[U[ju. 5t_ V d b V>W k QTdc`s> +2 @ ACFn`_ V>d,Wd XF#c\}XFEWt`F S\AtQ S/QXPNPrVT(SUACF`PQX[\[¡0 s 5V LR[LRWCLNSULQTPRPN^¤V>W QXc\_ `nbu `#cULNSUFEcULRVXWVXS\ACFIQXPN}>VXc\LS\ACD L[ ] F#¦tWCF ] Q>[S\ACF QT}>}Xc\F#}Q SUN F 5tV ] LN3FEcUFEWt`Fo[/z3FS_F#F#Wh[UOt`#`#FE[\[LRXFLNSUFEc\QTSULRVXWt[E QXW ] LR[/[UFS S\V $ + )³VXc/QZD&Q aMLRD OCD VTso|X| ] LQT}>VXWtQXPNL[UQTSULRVXW¤LNSUFEc\QTSULRVXWt [ + /S LR[`PRFEQXcSUAQ SSUACF¡[V>PNOMS\LNV>W¤`ACV>[UF#W ] LrF#c[Q>`#`#VXc ] LNWt}nSUVS\ACFn[_SQTcUSULRWC}Y3VXLRW>SVT<S\ACFQXPN}>VXc\LS\ACD
(58) i[L ] F ¢c\VXD SUACFV>cULR}XLRWACL`A"L[QZ[Y3FE`#LRQXP`#Q>[F>C[_SQTcUSULRWC}SUACFQTPR}XV>cULNSUAtD VXWQYV>LNWSkQTPRVXWt} S\ACFn¦tc[_S SUAtcUFEF¡c\V /[ `EQTOt[UFE[ LNS/S\V{`V>W>F#c\}XFSUV{JV>PNOCSULRVXW sXQTW ] [ULNDZLRPRQXcUPR^&¢V>cSUACF PRQ>[_S/S\ACc\F#Fc\V /[QTW ] JV>PNOMS\LNV>< W &C ACF#WS\ACF QXPN}>VXc\LS\ACD L[[_SQTcUSUF ] QXPNV>WC}SUACFPRLRWCF d,d & -MtQXW ] Q SS\ACFVXc\LN}>LNW(MLS`#VXWXFEcU}>FE[dSUVZS\ACFOCWt[S\QXzCPNF[UVXPROMS\LNV>W xtOCcUSUACFEcUDZVXc\FX3ACFEWhSUACFZQTPR}XV>cULNSUAtDL_ [[S\QXcS\F ] QXcUV>OCW ] S\ACFIPRLRWCF dd & -MrLNSn[SUV>Yt[kQTSnQ&WtVXWMFEOCLRPNLRzCc\LNOtD _ 5V [UVXPROMSULRVXW @ ACFIYCc\FE`F ] LRWC}{F#aMQXDZYCPNFI[ACV /[`PRFEQXcUPR^{S\AtQ SQTPR}XV>cULNSUAtDZ[¢VXc¡DV>WCVTS\VXWCF 5QXcULQ S\LNV>WtQTPLNWtFEOtQTPRLNSULRFE[k`EQTW ³QXLNP(SUV{`#VXWXFEcU}>FXVXckDZQ5^"F#>F#Wh`V>WXF#c\}XF¡S\V¤Q&WCVXWCÀFo>OtLNPRLNztcULROCD QXPNOCF>tACFEW QTYCYtPNLRF ] S\V&SUACF Ot[OQTPÀtWCV>WM DZV>WCVTS\VXWCFISUcQ ¤`FEOCLRPNLRzCc\LNOtD YCc\VXzCPRF#D&[EIxCOtcS\ACF#c\DZVXc\FXx
(59) LN}>OCc\F &"}>LN>FE[¡QTW7QTPR}XVXc\LNSUACDZL` LRWSUF#c\YCc\FSQ SULRVXW S\VhSUAto F 9_OtWt[_SQTzCLRPRLS_^ ;¤VT SUAtF JVXPROMS\LNV>W u ISUACF¤>FE`SUVXc¦tF#P ] J [ )³ACF#c\FX}>LN>F#W7z^wS\ACF{xCcQTWt>'VXPN¢F ] LNc\FE`SULRVXW >FE`SUVX!c +dYV>LNWSSUV QTc ] [JV>PNOMS\LNV>WuIV>WCPN^ QTPRVXWC}SUAtFPNLRWCF d,d & -M. _. °°·}~L!.
(60) |. @F . 9 . $"n"(. tA LNPRFDZVXWCVXSUVXWtLR`#LS_^"`#QTW"z3F [AtV W WCVXSSUV&ACV>P ] ¢V>c/DZV>[S/D OCPNSULRDZV ] QTP<S\c\QT&`nFoOCLNPRLRzCcULROCDYCcUV>zCPRF#D&[ z^ `#VXWt[SUc\Ot`SULRVXWoFLNPRP>[UACV 7LRWSUACL[
(61) [Fo` SULRVXWnS\AtQ SSUACFWCVXSULRVXWVTCWtFE[SUF ] DZV>WCVTS\VXWCL`LNS_^X5LRW>S\cUV ] O`F ] LRW V>ACF#W QXW ] AtQXYCPRQXLR4 [ )_s 1|8|=+ CVX3FEc\[/QXWhF#PRF#}QTWS/FaMYCPQTWtQTSULRVXWVTS\ACFYCc\VM`FE[\[VXLRWSUFEc\Q>` SULRVXW[LNWS\ACF DIOCPNSULRDV ] QXP S\c\Q5>F#P`V>[S(¢OtWt` S\LNV>Wt[#xCOtcS\ACF#c\DZVXc\FXESUACL[`PQX[\[(VXM¢OCWt` S\LNV>Wt[`#QXWzF [UACV WSUV¡Q ] DZLNS
(62) YtcUV QTztPN^n`V>W>F#c\}XFEW>S QXPN}>VXc\LS\ACD&[# x
(63) LRc\[S/FnLRWSUc\V ] Ot`FQWOCD z3F#cVX ] F#¦tWCLNSULRVXWt[ECWCVXS\QTSULRVXWCQXW ] Q>[U[UOCDZYMS\LNV>Wt[#.
(64) $EF % x @=?4"$, ,"F ! : o E "$ % ! "#x o 8
(65)
(66) oEF % E. 4 % ,+ , >@$ , -+ @A J @/.L103 $ %AE !F : '&(*) p o @F @FF > !?H 80 @F 8 % @ 2 3 C"" 4 ! E EF EFo " ] n5(*)6 qs7(*)6 p. tA LNPRFhSUAtFhzV>OCW ] F ] WCFE[\[¤VX L[&WCVXS¤WCF#F ] F ] /QTW ] Q `VFEc\`#LNLNS_^ `V>W ] LNSULRVXW V>OCP ] [UOM¤`F>SUACF )¢¦CaMF ] ] F#D&QTW ] +SUcQ ¤`kFEOCLRPNLRzCc\LNOCD p L[dz^&`V>Wt[SUc\Ot` S\LNV>W ] F¦tWtF ] V >F#cQYV>PN^ACF ] c\QXP½`V>WXFa<`VXDZYtQ>` S [F#SE /VXSUF S\AtQ Sotz^{O[LRWC}&VXWtFVTSUACF DZQXW^¤SUcQTW[_¢V>cUD&Q S\LNV>Wt[ Q5 QTLRPRQXzCPNF
(67) )½[FEFXtF> }:9Rs|,; + tSUACF F#PQX[SUL` ] F#D&QTW ] DV ] FEP QXPR[UVI¦CS\[LRWSUVSUAtLR[ ¢cQTDZFEV>cUr @ ACF QXcULQ S\LNV>WtQTPrLRWCFEOtQXPNLNS_^&SUAQ S ] F#¦tWCFE[S\ACFD OtPS\LNDZV ] QTPSUcQ ¤`¡FEOCLRPNLRzCc\LNOCD YCcUV>zCPRF#D L[ }XLRXFEW z^ . < >= ?! @BADC EGF HI FJ1I K>L-FNM
(68) IOL,PRQTS,FNM I JVUW H!K>XNM P Y[Z]\ @$ . ! F,E EF _ =p + @ c %_ =<p e. ; )³G=+ C /£WwSUACFSUcQ ¤` FEOCLRPNLRzCc\LNOCD YtcUV>zCPNFEDS\ACFI¢FEQX[ULRzCPNFZ[UFS L[¡Q `#QXcS\FE[ULRQXW YCc\V ] Ot` SnVT`#VXDZY3VXWCFEW>Sn[OtzM p [UYtQ>`FE[ESUAtQTS/LR[ & )Àv8+ _/ ^ _ / b ce ee c_ ) i =<p ) + _ &= p ^ / )l2>+ /< p p b`_a_ j(Fc S b / & . / . z3FnSUAtF ] LNDZFEWt[LRVXWVX(SUAtFBL de&`#VXDZY3VXWC) FEW>S/[UOCzt[UYtQX`#FXxCOtcS\ACF#c\DZVXc\FXMF¡AQ5XFSUAtQTS n p & )`|+. ?. ]!^`_ i c _ _. ]!^`_ i ^ ] b ^ _ i c ee eCc] ) ^ _ i i e l[LRWC}&S\ACF QTz3V XFWtVTS\QTSULRVXWtSUACF 5QXcULQ S\LNV>WtQTP<LRWCFo>OQTPRLS_^ ¢) G3. + LR[kFEOCLR QTPRF#WSSUV&S\ACF¢V>PNPRV LNWt}¤[^M[SUF#DVT. `#VXOCYtPNF ] QTc\LQ SULRVXWQTPrLNWtFEOtQTPRLNSULRFE[ . < >= ?! @BDCOfK>SNWgM PhijU,ijJjP YkK lnm-F HI FJ1I K>L-FNMoIOL,PRQTS,FNM I J1I PRijZG\ @A ? / . ] ^ _ i c_. / . _. / ; + C. _ =p @ / / c _ = p e. !F,E EF/ > A &C$. ce e e c. bp+. )`1+. ±¢Æ°(±ÈÇ.
(69)
(70) ! #"$ % . 1. < >= ?! @ C NJ H!K>L Y:KTLK JjK>L I I JVURZ N@D ,"F >l > I[_S\cUV>WC}XPR^'DV>WCVTS\VXWCF @ H E 108 ! ] p >@ !l>@F u d 2 + !F E E ; u d d @ ? i )_so|+ ]!^ _ ]!^BA i c_ ADC _ A c _c"AE=pe < >= ? ! @ N@ " >l > /jLRYt[U`AtLS,- @ E 410 4J @D !l>@F , d 2 + F E E> ] p , )_s>sC+ i d _ A c @ _ c"A4=p e ]!^ _ ]!^A i . . . . . .
(71) . . . /£W V>c ] F#c/S\V ] F#¦tWCF WtFE[SUF ] DV>WCVTS\VXWCL`LNS_^X3LNSL[kWCFo`Fo[U[\QTc\^¤S\V&¢OCcUSUACFEc ] Fo`V>DY3V>[UFS\ACF V>YFEc\QTSUVXc ¢FoQX[ULNztPNF[UFS LNW\S VIS\ACFn¢VXPRPRV LNWC}jFS p / & / _ / n & ^`_ /b c e ee c_ b i _ / n & ^`_ ^ c e ee c_ )/ i p n / T65 / 9 p ^ b87 b / / & p n / T65 / 9 p e 7) ikWtQTPRVX}>VXOt[ ] F#¦tWCLNSULRVXWt[ AtVXP ] ¢V>c /QTW ] /U . . ]. QTW ]. )_s5u8+ )_sC&+ )_sEG=+ )_s5v8+. . _. p. . . @ ACFEWSUAtF ] F#¦tWCLNSULRVXW VXkQhWCFo[_S\F ] DZVXWtVTSUV>WCF¤V>YFEc\QTSUVXc cUFEPRQTSULRXF&S\V SUAtF ] Fo`VXDZY3V>[ULS\LNV>W QTz3V XF¤L[QX[. ¢V>PNPRV /[6) V>ACF#WhQTW ] AtQXYCPQTL[#<sC18|8|=+ . < >= ?! @ DC NJ H!K>L L,P i JjPRh Y K>L,K JjK>L I I JVUZ N@ ,"F [SUc\VXWt}XPR^ WCFo[_S\F ] DZV>WCVTS\VXWCF >@ , %>`?. 4l H EFo , > K"F ! @ `"
(72) 4@A J @ ?
(73) E4 ]0% nKxp @=? qs E3p @$ > ` >@ NE >% . . . . p. . . . $ %AE
(74) ,"F . >@=?8?H
(75) @$ >l >@$o @ @ + @F >! o J @ @ AE @>+ @$ j E !] b 0^ _"$b c _ @D b $i $ + E "H @ EF_ b J@Fp b F > @>+*">_
(76) b !%p B b
(77) _ b o @$ >l4 E3 ">
(78) `! @ i ] b _ b ^ _ b 2 %AEj " 8 / / / i / / i > !` >@=?8?j
(79) @A @$ @ / .L /j+ @ ! ?4 @ / -. / 8 E F ] E ^`_ ^ _ EF @ c_ c _ E 1+ @$ 8 0"$ @D $ $ _ +o<@Fp F6"F> ! _ > @ p 8 @$ >l / / i _ ^`_ %AE6 ,"F , ! @3?> >@$ @AK @ >@ AEF @T+ @A 8 E6 ! 0"$ @D _) p) $ $ + E ] ) ^` _ " ) @ ^ _ ) i cE_ ) ji H@F F >` >@ ]) . !. . . ". . . #. . &%. ' (. $. . . . . . . )*. + , (. " . /SLR[FoQX[U^wS\V[UF#F¤S\AtQ S&QTW^7[_S\cUV>WC}XPR^'DV>WCVTS\VXWCF{¢OCWt`SULRVXW. L[[_S\cUV>WC}XPR^WtFE[SUF ] DV>WCVTS\VXWCF>zCOMSSUAtQTS S\ACF `#VXWXFEc\[UF L[nWCVXSSUc\OCFX&i YCc\VVTL[nWCV>WCFS\ACF#PRFE[\[nYCc\V L ] F ] LRW9Åu;&gaCQTDZYCPRFE[nLRW 9 u-;dQTW ] LNW'S\ACFZ¢VXPRPNV LRWC} [UFE`SULRVXW"LNPRPROt[_S\c\QTSUF¡SUAQ SkQZ[_S\cUV>WC}XPR^&WCFo[_S\F ] DZVXWCVXSUVXWtF¢OtWt` S\LNV>W"WtF#F ] WCVXS/F#XFEW z3FDZVXWCVXSUV>WCFX. /£W SUACFWCF#aSZ[UFE`SULRVXWF[AtV SUAtQTSZWtFE[SUF ] DZVXWCVXSUVXWtLR`#LS_^ LRPNP ACV>P ] LRW D&QTW^ `#Q>[Fo[VT/S\ACFD OCPNSULN DZV ] QXP<SUcQ ¤`Fo>OtLNPRLNztcULROCDYCcUV>zCPRF#DQXW ] ¢OCcUSUACFEc/YCc\V L ] Fo[/QTWhFEPNFE}>QTWS/LRWSUF#c\YCc\FSQ SULRVXW"VTS\ACFI`#cUV[U[`#PRQ>[U[ LRWSUFEc\Q>` SULRVXW[#. °°·}~L!.
(80) @F . so|. /£W¢OtPNP}XFEWCF#cQTPRLNS_^XS\ACF ] FE`V>DZYV[LNSULRVXWOt[UF ] LNW ] F¦tWCLRWC}kSUACF`VXOtYCPNF ] [^M[SUFEDVXM5QXcULQ S\LNV>WtQTPXLNWCFoOtQTPRLS\LNFo[ c\F ] Ot`Fo[nFEQX`A [UOCzt[UFS / A $ b S\V QVXWCF# ] LRDZF#Wt[ULRVXWtQXP[OCz[YtQ>`F> @ ACL[D&Q5^wWCVXSE
(81) ACV F#XFEcE(zFZS\ACF p Q ] 5QX= WS\QT}>c F#V>Ot[QXYCYCc\V>Q>`A>FEXFEW LN(S\AtQ S ] Fo`V>DY3V>[ULNSULRVXW Q ] DZLS[SUACF[SUc\VXWt}IWCFo[_S\F ] DZV[_S/`V>DZYCOMS\QTSULRVXWtQXPNPR^¤ DZV>WCVTS\VXWCL`LNS_^ YCc\VXY3F#cUS_A^ 7(LNS `VXc\c\FE[UYV>W ] [E<LNW [UVXDZF&[FEWt[F>S\VQ b PRF#>F#PACLRF#cQTc`ACL`#QTPYCc\VXztPNFED"(ACLR`A7L[ `#PNFoQTc\PN^ ] L¤`#OCPS{SUV D&QTWCLRYCOCPQ S\FX /£W D&QTW^ `#QX[UFE[E Q'[UD&QTPRP/WOCD z3F#c{VT`PQX[\[Fo[ZLR[Z¢V>OCW ] SUV OtW ] F#c\PR^ Q AtLNFEc\QXc\`ACL`#QXPrYCcUV>zCPRF#DQXW ] SUACL[/L[YtQXcS\LR`#OCPQTc\PN^"[VZ¢V>cSUcQ ¤`nWCF#S_V>cUM[E /£W ] FEF ] 3VXWtF`#QTWVXÈSUF#WhL ] FEW>S\L¢^ S_V ] L[_S\LNWt`Sk`PQX[\[Fo[#MQXW ] QZWQ SUOtc\QXP3AtLNFEc\QXc\`A^&z3FS_F#F#W SUAtF#LRck`V[_S ¢OCWt`SULRVXWt[E xtVXcSUACL[cUFoQX[UVXWQX[FEPNP<QX[¢VXc `PQTc\LS_^ZVXFaMYV[LNSULRVXW(F/S\ACF#c\F¢V>cUF[LRDZYCPNLN¢^ZSUAtFDIOCPS\LNDZV ] QXP3FoOCLNPRLRzM c\LROCD YCc\VXzCPRF#D S\VZVXWCF¡AtQ5LNWt} S_VILRWSUFEc\Q>` SULRWC}Z`PQX[\[Fo[#@ ACFEWSUACF ] FE`V>DZYV[LNSULRVXW LR[ LRDZDF ] LQ SUFQXW ] S\ACF ] F¦tWCLNSULRVXWVXWCFo[_S\F ] DZVXWCVXSUVXWtLR`#LS_^¤c\F ] Ot`Fo[dS\VZSUACFn¢V>PNPRV LRWC} . < >= ?! @ C nP i JjPRh%Y:KTLK JjK>L I I JVU K mP HJ 5K i SNXi W,F P i ZAE ,"F @$ !l
(82) @A @$4 j@A ] >@F?
(83) . . . . . . ! ` >@=?8?K
(84) @A @$ @ >@ +$@ ! ?0 @ d > @ d d i . b ^`_ b c_ d i ] _b p b _ p _ b ^ _ 2 d d i d i ! @3?>?
(85)
(86) @A @Aj @ d .L d ] ^`_ b ^ _ c _ _ p $. !. . + "7 ] b ^ _ b c_ d i p b. @ ACL[ ] Fo`VXDZY3V>[ULS\LNV>W"`#VXc\cUFo[Y3VXW ] [S\V&QIDIOCPNSULRDV ] QXPrSUcQ ¤`¡WCFS_VXc\ZLS\A"S_VSUcQ ¤`¡`PQX[\[Fo[# QTW ] d kVTS\FAtV FEXF#corSUAQ S QTW ] d QXcUF&[SULRPNP>FE`SUVXc¡¢OCW` SULRVXW[#ACF#c\F & b QTW ] d & _ b b d
(87) /£W }>_ F#WCFEc\QXP½ z3VTS\Ab QTW ] b d ] bLNPRPCz3FFE] OtQXPSUV¡SUACFWOCDIzFEcVTrQTc`#[VXtSUAtFWCFS_p VXb c\r5SUACV>OCb }XASUAtLR[p L[WCVXSWCF#F ] F ] ¢V>c SUACFc\FE[UOCPNS\[ V>b cDZF#SUACV ] [YtcUV>YV[F ] LRW{S\ACL[YtQTY3F#co . . %. $"n K !
(88) #$&% '(
(89) )* < .
(90) . V>Wt[UL ] FEcnWCV Q"WCFS_VXc\hLNSUAS_V"SUcQ ¤``PQX[\[Fo[#<F> }N(zCOt[UFE[QTW ] `EQTc[#<V>cACFEQ5^ QTW ] PRLN}>ASn>F#ACL`PRFE[E m/FE`#QXPNPdSUACF¤S_VwQXc\`ZWtFS_VXc\wVT ¦t}>OCc\FhsX/£W7SUAtF¤¢VXPRPRV LNWC}hF#aCQTDZYCPRFE[E
(91) [UOCYCY3V>[UF&SUAQ S S\ACF&S\VTS\QXPdV>cULR}XLRWM ] FE[SULRWtQ S\LNV>W ] FEDZQXW ] ¢cUV>D WCV ] F7s{S\V'WtV ] FuVT¡`PQX[\6 [ 9U ` ;"LR[ZFo>OQTPSUV sE|tdQTW ] uT|w¢VXc&`#PRQ>[U[ 93z ; i/PRP WOCDZFEcUL`#QXP3c\FE[UOCPNS\[ LRW"SUACL[/[UFE` S\LNV>W F#c\FnVXzMSQTLRWCF ] Ot[ULNWt}ZfwQTYCPRFXC>F#c[LRVXW C. j(FSSUAtFD OCPNSULRDZV ] QTP(`#V>[S V>YFEc\QTSUV>c\[zF}>LN>F#W"zFEPNV . & '/- ' $ )_s! + ] db n & ^ _ d b 0! . i
(92) ' ' $ ) e &^ _ d b i )_s2>+ ] n & -^`_ ! i
(93) d '/& - '*- e ) ^ _ i b _ d )_sC|+ ] d b n & ^ _ d b 0! . d i ' '*- - e ^ _ d b b i _ d )_sC1+ ] n ^`_ ! i & e ^ _ i AtF#c\F / }XLRXFE[S\ACFnSUcQ5XFEP3SULRDFVXS\AC0 F 9U`#QTc ;¡`#PRQ>[U[E V>WhQTc` A tQXW ] / }XLRXFE[S\ACFnSUcQ5XFEP3SULRDFVXS\ACF09zCOt[[; `#PRQ>[U[E ] VXWQTc` A JLRDZLNPQTc\PN^> / QTW ] / }XLRXF¡SUAC6 F 5V /[VXS\ACF`#QXcQTW ] ] zCOt[`#PRQ>[U[UFE[ V>W"QXc\` A . _. . _. ±¢Æ°(±ÈÇ.
(94)
(95) ! #"$ % . sXs. Cost function tb2(xc2*(xb2),xb2). Cost function tb1(xc1*(xb1),xb1). 80 80. 70. 60 60. 50. 40 40. 30. 20 20. 0. 2. 4. 6. 8. 10 x1b. 12. 14. 16. 18. 20. 0. 2. 4. 6. 8. 10 x2b. 12. 14. 16. 18. 20.
(96)
(97) "!# "%$&'(*),+'.- ()/&'1032),&'0%!# 4$5& ( )/5+- *( ),5& "0 2),5& 0 76,8:9!;"<= >@?A:BDC >@?E:B!7FG 7 #H " 7<JI1!7K=KMLN<MIO"! <MP
(98) 6Q9IO<M 7 RST 7U1"V74!#WX6Q9 IY<M 7 Z[ \ #Z[1]T!^P7KM 7U!7K=KML_FG 7 7 <MIGI1 ` "!# 7a$Zbdce($+2$&303f gh [1 i[j!7IO U<J!#.FT!#"<dk^l
(99) $m<MnP7<MV71oUpL, rr s;t;u7v (*),+'O0 5 rr w w s7xzy rr rr w 5 w ( / ) + 0 p u # t [ y s { s x u 5 l
(100) q`c r s#t}| )/+' rr w 5 w ( / ) & 1 ' 0 1 { x ; ~ v rr rr w w 5 / ) + ( , ) & 0 1 ; s ; t u { [ { x # v r 5 5. aOFG<M!#:n 76l
(101) $ <Jm1 & x w7w us7s ) +') 5+ ) &' x w7w {7yp~ ) +') 5+ ) 5m& x w w vp~ ~ ) +') 5+ [ (l4$"0c x w7w s s ) +') 5+ ) &'Y) 5n <MI3i 1V;!#KM9!#\!#),+'c |x | 2[),&'`c s|x | 3!#7m4V}!7K=9 w x w ~}v# fp<MFX<MKJ!#"K=L i !;n)/+'c |x | 2p),&'`c w xMs i "Z[11"FG<= !#:<M8 9 !#K/ x w s sv f%1I17i["ZIO :@ "!# 7$ <M #FG 7 7 77f V71ip 7aFT!}L.9 IYn!X!;"9"!7K <M13!#3I3:LG9 [1"K=Lp<MPXZI1 n@"9IO9"7fZ" 7P
(102) @" FG #" 7<JIO<=@Lo @L^<M`IOKM!7KML\!#<J@]_UpL^4]"`I1KM! <MI14! I3IO :@6Q9IY"<= <J<MI1!7<=P.<= "Z!#"P79FX:"m #6<d3 ^I1KM! V;!7<J!#UKM7f% X 1W ;V 13!#KMK,I1 7 ,13!; [ p<M[1^!}V7 "T@" P.FG 7 7 <MI1<d@L_ @L i GF49ZI3I3 1aTI1 7IOKJ!7"`I1 6Q9IY"<= <J <MI1!7<=P T [<MFT!#K !7"!7FGO"<JIX 7KM9["<= S 76 "G]3@4I1KM! Z<MZ9U<=9S6Q aN]"4IOKJ!7" V;!7<J!#UKM7f RSX16Q 7"4 K=V Z"
(103) !#3!#FGO"<JIW""!#TI48:9<MK=<MU"<=9F UKM1F<=GV;!#"<J!#UKM),+ ^ 7U"!#<M_" 7KM9["<= ),+' - ()/&' 032),5+- (*),5& 0"fi oI!#1V;!#KM9!;"^!7 K= 7
(104) "^I1
(105) 6Q9IY"<= X$&' ()/ +' - ()/&' 032),&' 0Z!# $5& ()/5+- (*),5& 0"2),5& 0"fW KM #3 #6a X6Q9IO<M 7!7a " ;Vp<M[N<M_ %<MP79 f ¡ U1"V74!#ZU 76Q9IO<M 7W!7G@"<JIY"K=L_<MI1!7<=P^<M"1<MW ,IO<MV7G!#"P79FG 31f
(106) !;W<J1i/" ;V 13!#KMKIO N 7 ,13!;" 7N[ pT<= [1¢!#<J@6QL£ @L 76WFG #" 7<JIO<=@L7i1V 1¤ 79P ¤<=.<J P K= U!#KMKMLT 7[HFG 7 7 7f ¥ I1 7^1n #6IO 6Q9IO<M 7<JP <=V 1.U,1KM $ +'¦bdc { () +' t}v 0 § { s x y () &'10 ª%ª¬«;®}¯°Y±. >*¨7© B.
(107) @F . s5u. Cost function tb2(xc2*(xb2),xb2). Cost function tb1(xc1*(xb1),xb1). 45. 50. 40 40. 35. 30 30. 25. 20 20. 15. 0. 2. 4. 6. 8. 10 x1b. 12. 14. 16. 18. 20. 0. 2. 4. 6. 8. 10 x2b. 12. 14. 16. 18. 20. [
(108) "!# "%$&'(*),+'.- ()/&'1032),&'0 #6/8:9!#<M 7>D¨#© BC/>D¨ B%!# 4$5& ( )/5+- *( ),5& "0 2),5& 0!7FG 7 #H " 7<JI1!7K=KMLN<MIO"! <MP
(109) 6Q9IO<M 7 $ 5+. (*) 5+ t} 0§ y s x u () 5& 0 >*¨?B 5 $ &' >*¨ ¨7B { () +' t}v 0 { {x u () &' 0 5 $ 5& (*) 5+ t} 0 y {x { () 5& 0 >*¨ B 1""V}!7<J!#UK=!7[1]X!7!7U ;V 7f #m"!;n[</1"1 IOm pIIO93<=
(110) mV;!7K=9 76m1k[ 1: 76 ""1"FG$& i [1 ,1 [1I1n<JKM<=!#<M #6IOKJ!7" }f ¥ U 16Q 7"7i nIO []"F "n [H FG #" 7<JIO<=@L_ #6 G ;V7KMK 7 ,13!;" 7`U:L£"!#p<MPoT[11"FG<= !#:W #6"`j!7I1 7U<J!#S #6m$!# V}!7K=9 !;<MP <=X!#X1V 13!#K1k:"FGN <=:34 76^[1FT!# K=Lp[" 7f_RS. U["!7<= 6Q 4)/+'oc |x | 2[),&'.c s|x | !; 1 (l
(111) $"0c x w ss !7G6Q )/+'c w x=s 2[),&'nc s|x | i !; 1 (l
(112) $"0c x w su7 w
(113) "!;m<Mi: j!7I1 7U<J!#T<J # V7L :<=<MV7W[1]<=7f bdc db c db c. ¡ "T #"1Z !# i NI1!# i%! Z!#U, ;V7 i"!;W"N 7 ,13!;" 7W$a[O] UpL8:9!;"<= 4¨#©;C[¨.<J <M[^@"^FG 7 7 77f ¥ P:!#<Mi 7KMV:<MPX6Q 78:9<=KM<MU<M9F <=^FT 76%"W !7"!7FX1"<MIV;!#"<M!7UKM`)/+(),&O03i !7\9U@"<d"9[<MP.Z [<MFT!#K%V}!7K=9<M: T"4IO :@6Q9IY"<= n$&()/+ - (),&O032),&O0"i 4 7U[3!#<Mo"Z6Q9IY"<= <MKMK=93!;"o<=_ <MP79"[f `"!71mFG!}LG!}V !X[ 79U[! " 4"aFG 7 7 7<MI1<d@LG #66Q9IO<M 7 76% <=P 9[ip!7FXK=LN!#" <M IY"<= ^ , 7<M:"f ¥ p Fe!#" 79 N"W<= IO<M 7_ , 7<M n<Jm1"O6Q 7"a " ;V:<J[.<M_ %<MP79ZAfgh[1 i[" .6Q9IO<M 7!#"`FG #" 7<JI1!7K=KMLT<= IO"!7<MP46Q9IY"<= 1f. #W!#KMKF
(114) 9K=<MFX [!7K3!;NI4I1 6Q9IO<M 7a"!;"<M6QL^<J` @L i/ O 76%6Q9 IY<M 7 1f $ +' bc { () +' t;v 0h§ { s7xzy (*) &' 0 $ 5+ bc () 5+ t} 0§ y s x u () 5& 0 $ &' bc { () +' t;v 0 5 { {[x u (*) &'10 5 $ 5& bc () 5+ t} 0 5 y {x { () 5& 0 5 [O"1"FG<=!7:. #6W"Tj!7I1 7U<J!# 6Q .8 9 !;<M 7 .¨; #C/>*¨ ;BX<JN8 9 !#Kn" )/+' c |x | 2[),&' c s|x | !#G" x w7w :{7{# 1.1V;!#KM9!;"N!#m)/+' c w x=s 2[),&' c I1K=!#"K=LG"1\ [HFX #" 7 f. V7f 7<M1
(115) 6Q 7KMK= M< P >*¨# :B >*¨ 7B >*¨7A B >*¨ ;B Mx svs w y# 1V;!7K=9!#¢!; s|x | f` ;V7"!7K=K 7 ,13!; <J. %ª.
(116)
(117) ! #"$ % . s&. Cost function tb2(xc2*(xb2),xb2). Cost function tb1(xc1*(xb1),xb1). 27.2. 27. 27. 26.5. 26.8. 26. 26.6. 25.5. 10. 10.2. 10.4. x1b. 10.6. 10.8. 11. 8. 8.2. 8.4. 8.6. 8.8. 9 x2b. 9.2. 9.4. 9.6. 9.8. 10. \A ¥ p 7F !#" 79.W<= IY"<= o , 7<M:" 76"W^ 7 ,13!; " #68:9!#<M 7W>D¨#©:BDC/>D¨:B. Cost function tb1(xc1*(xb1),xb1). Cost function tb2(xc2*(xb2),xb2). 20. 18. 18. 16. 14. 16. 12 14 0. 0.2. 0.4. 0.6. 0.8. 1 x1b. 1.2. 1.4. 1.6. 1.8. 2. 0. 0.2. 0.4. 0.6. 0.8. 1 x2b. 1.2. 1.4. 1.6. 1.8. 2. : X@" 7 ,13!; "$&'(*),+'N- ()/&'032),&'0!#$5& *( ),5+- ( )/5& 30 2),5& 0n #68:9!;"<=
(118) >D¨; pBDC/>D¨ #Bn!#"4 # FG #" 7<JI1!7K=KMLT<= IO"!7<MP46Q9IY"<= a KM #3 #6.6Q9IO<M 7 U["!7<=.6Q F WLpFe!#U, ;V7`!#" ;Vp<J[T<M\ %<MP79 : i a! p 7F ! U 1\9o G<MK=KM93!;"aW , 7<M 7^ #6%W GIO9"V7m!#n<M 7nFG 7 7 7<MI!#KMK=LT<MIO"! <MP >U 1 1_©G!#\¨7BOf. 4
(119) W % / !"! !$#%&('*)+-,/.10324.657,8592 :5<; ,=.65$>?2A@B.C,1@ 24.5 DE,;6+2 :592F0 G ,/+B,/57,/+ H$I H5JDLKMH5NH%:6+2FIF2:F:4O/.DLK H+8@.H+I4H @PQ2KR57,*:4,=PTSL2 ; ,=.U5$>?2A@ O/.CO G 245J.H$I*21V4W?HPTH$X4.HW G :4,/PTW?5JH$,/+-,;U5Y>2 Z .F:5[I PQOL:F:FK[H+\572 . G :*,];^5Y>2_:42FI1,=+0/K`O/+B0a5$>?24+b2CcO G H+2d5Y>2IF,L:5e;FW?+BI 5JH$,/+f,;_5$>?2^:42FIF,/+0gI PhO/:F:1KiOL:dO ;FW?+BI 5JH$,/+j,;*5$>kH%:l@ O/.CO G 245J.H$I8: ,=PTW?5JH$,/+mon<Ph2FO=.PTDLKU,/S/2 .8OgPhO=. pq24r9:4IFO/Ph28+245Jse,/.1tLKl:W I>\OE:F5JW 0/DEH%:_>HupL>PTD H G @.1O3I45 H$IFO/PTKvH ;`+,=5H G @ ,L:F:H$X4Ph2wm6)Y;1Kx>,/se24SL24.FKv5$>?2UIF,/:F5";FW?+I45 H$,=+:`,=+2FO3I>aO/.1IUO/.12`:5 .W I45JW?.CO/PPTD6:H G HPQO/.FK Wy@d57,iO30q0/H5JHSL2lO/+B0FzB,=. G W?PT5JH @PuH$I1O=5 HS/2AIF,=+:59O=+ 5 :FK{5$>?24+dOl592 :5; ,/. 5Y>2N+2 :592F0 G ,/+,=59,=+ H$I4H5 Dv@.1,1@ 2 .5JD|,/S/2 . O: G O/PP}:W X +B2 5Jse,/.1tLK :FW I>OL:M@ ,L:F:H$X4PTDa,=+2dO=.CI*,;65$>?2^+245Jse,/.1tLKRO/:UH+~5Y>2:42*21cO G @Ph2 :FK[,v24.F:_O_pk,w,y0 OF@3@B.C,4cqH G O/572A572 :F57m. ª%ª¬«;®}¯°Y±.
(120) @F . sEG .
(121) ". " !
(122) #$&% ,!"- !. . -/. /£WS\ACL[k[UFE` S\LNV>WtF. ] Fo[U`#cULRzFQ{`VXW>F#c\}XF#WSQTPR}XV>cULNSUACD ¢VXcS\ACFDIOCPS\LNDZV ] QXPSUcQ ¤`FoOCLNPRLRzCcULROCDYCcUV>zCPRF#D @ AtLR[LR[LRDY3VXcUS\QXWSLRWhSUAtQTSkS\ACFIDIOCPNSULRDV ] QXPFoOCLNPRLRzCcULROCD YCc\VXzCPRF#D AtQ>[#SUV ] Q S\FXrz3F#F#W`VXW[L ] F#c\F ] S\V{z3F Qh¢OCW ] QXDFEWS\QTPRPR^WCV>WMDV>WCVTS\VXWCF& QXcULQ S\LNV>WtQTPLRWCFEOtQXPNLNS_^'YCcUV>zCPRF#D
(123) QXW ] SUAtF#c\F¢VXc\F&S\Vw[UQTSUL[_¢^'WCV WCV W `#VXW ] LS\LNV>Wt[¢V>c&QTPR}XVXc\LNSUACDZL`¤`V>W>F#c\}XFEWt`F>'F AQ5XF [UACV WLRW S\ACFYCc\F#LNV>Ot[ [UFE`SULRVXWSUAtQTSEACLRPRF{S\ACF YtcUV>zCPNFED LR[LRW ] F#F ] WCV>WMDV>WCVTS\VXWCF>LNW }XFEWCF#cQTPÀLS&`#QXW QTS SUAtF[\QTDZF{SULRDFh[\Q S\LR[¢^ Q ] LNrF#c\F#WSEFEQXXFEcE YtcUV>YFEcS_^>('FYCcUV L ] FQTPR}XV>cULNSUACDZL`dc\FE[UOCPNS\[
(124) ¢V>cD OCPNSULRDZV ] QTPCFo>OtLNPRLNztcULROCD YtcUV>zCPNFED&[[UQTSUL[_¢^LRWC}¡SUACL[FEQT>F#c YtcUV>YFEcS_^&VX[SUc\VXWC}WCFo[_S\F ] DZVXWCVXSUVXWtLR`#LS_^> kVTSUF SUAtQTSn`#PRQ>[U[kLNW ] LR`#FE[ QTW ] LNPRPQ SkS\LNDZFo[/S\ACcUV>OC}XAtVXOMS/S\ACL[¡[UFE`SULRVXWhz3F F#aYtcUFo[U[UF ] n Q>[k[UOCzt[\`c\LNYMS[ . )³c\QTSUACFEc SUAtQXW"[UOCY3F#c[U`#cULRYMS[,+dSUV&Y3F#c\DZLSS\ACFOt[UFnVTLNSUFEc\QTSULRVXW`V>OCWSUF#c/[UOCY3F#c[U`#cULRYMS[# @ ACFn¢V>PNPRV LRWC}Q>[U[UOCDZYMS\LNV>Wt[ LNPRPz3FcUFoOCLNc\F ] LNW"S\ACLR[k[Fo` SULRVXW(.
(125) >4 _ c_ =p. 8 !. . 0 EFv En % x @=?6" ?. , >@ ! @F . , 2 + 1 08 !
(126) 6 . . _ c_ . . ] `^ _ ] ^`_ ] ^`_ ] ^`_ . . . . . c_ c _ c _ c _. i ] ^ _ i ] ^ _ i ] ^ _ i ] ^ _ . . . . . c_ i c_ i c_ i c_ i. . . . . , d , d _ , d _ , d _. _. . . . . . . _ c _ c _ c _ c. . . . . =. p. @A . )½u8|+ )½u81+ ) >& |+ ) t& sC+. /£WhS\ACFPNLR}XASkVXSUACFo[FQX[\[OCDZYMS\LNV>Wt[EFAtQ5>FSUACF ¢VXPRPNV LRWC}¤YtcUV>YFEcS_^"VTS\ACF V>YMSULRD&QTP
(127) 5QXPNOtF¢OCWt`SULRVXW i _ ^`_ >: A
(128) @$ 8 8 0"$ D@ 2 " g$ "+ EF !` >@=?8? @$ N >@$ @AK ,"F EF EF % x @=? ] x (" E3 BK"$ " !` , R ) & u8+ i i _ ^ _ _ ^ _ _ _ c , d ) &&+ ] ^`_ ^ _ i c_ i ] ^ _ ^ _ i c _ i _ _ c. . . . . . . . . . . @ ACF[_S\cUV>WC}DZVXWCVXSUVXWtLR`#LS_^IVT QTW ] i ¢V>PNPRV ¢cUV>D S\ACF ] F#¦tWCLNSULRVXW&VX<Q [_S\cUV>WC}XPR^. WtFE[SUF ] Z D VXWCVXSUV>WCFnVXY3F#cQ SUV>cE@ ACFEW S\AC] F^.c\cFE_ [UOCi PS ¢V>PNPRV ] /^ _ [ ¢cU^`_V>D i cj _ FEDZ DZQ&vCNsnVT9 u-;À . 'FLNPRPD&QT>FnOt[FnVXS\ACFn¢VXPRPNV LRWC}PNFEDZDZQt. >: . . !
(129) . E>. @$ ] = b / ] ^ _ Cc_ $i ! _ g . . . . &. /. ] g ^`_ c_ $i ! _. . . . ) &XG=+. ±¢Æ°(±ÈÇ.
(130)
(131) ! #"$ % . sov. > > A AE @>+j j "F 8 ! % > . + b @A > % -x @3?cB = @T.10 c "$ o%BC @ "A 8_ % = p . . . . !F . _ ^ _ i. l. OPyQ Y . & 4. . !.
(132) .C @=? EF ^ ] c,p i . . ) &v8+. ] ^`_c_ a [i k _. ) &E +. _ = p e . . xtVXc ¦CaMF ] z^ ) &TG3+ <S\ACF&D&QTYCYtLNWC} LR[[U^DDZF#SUc\LR`ZQTW ] S\ACF#c\F¢V>cUF ] LQT}XV>WtQTPRL[UQXzCPNF>I@ ACFEW<S\ACF D&QXYCYCLRWC}LR[SU_ ACF ] F#c\LN Q S\LN>F VT<QnYVXSUF#WS\LRQXPCVXY3F#c] Q S\VXcoTACL`AL[}>LN>F#WZLNW)`&>v8+ :^ SUACFk[SUc\VXWt}¡DZV>WCVTS\VXWCL`LNS_^ VX MSUAtFDLRWCLRD OCDVT ) &>v+LR[/QTSSQTLRWCF ] Q SkQOCWCLOCFY3VXLRW>So i . ] b ^.c_. > @
(133) 'AE6 , .L0% o
(134) ! : E EFN v ,"F , o
(135) ! @F @J E0 l"F @$ 8 @$
(136) C "F @ . 8 .! 8 % `+o@$ @$ > x E `"F - .L>! 8 %: ] @D E ,:
(137) AEF `+ [
(138) ! " @ l @D 0 !8 .L E3 % >@
(139) EF > >K >@F?n % 8 AE 4x E
(140) % 8 ?= @$ *,+ >6 ,>@@$ > `+ N@A @$ E %: 8 j,""$ 8 %o H%?4@F
(141) 6 j o `
(142) [ 4 !
(143) C 8
(144) . . > @
(145) A E : !! @
(146) 0"F ] FE[\`F#WSDZFS\ACV ] + EFo10 " @ jj> > . . o
(147) x
(148) -., N @J> ? >! E 2 +* E kFo`VXDZY3V>[UF ] E> >j @/.L > ., ? >! E >@$ @T. `? @$ "$ C j . V>Wt[L ] FEcWCFaSS\ACFYtQXLNcVX<}>QTY¢OCW` SULRVXW[¢VXcS\ACFk[U^M[_S\F#D VTr5QXcULQ S\LNV>WtQTPMLRWCFo>OQTPRLS_^IYCcUV>zCPRF#D&[# ] F¦WCF ] z^&S\ACFWCFo[_S\F ]] FE`#VXDZY3V>[ULS\LNV>W V >F#cS_V&`V>DZYV>WCF#WS/[Otzt[YQX`Fo[#j(FS & O 476 ' ? ) &32>+ = ^ `_ c_ i n LTU ^`_ i ] ^ _ c_ i ^`_ i c_ ADC ^BA i c AtF#c\F LR[[_S\cUV>WC}XPR^I`#VXWXF#aQXW ] `V>W>S\LNWOCV>Ot[UPN^ ] LrF#c\F#WS\LRQXzCPNF>
(149) j(FS z3F/SUAtFkOCWCLOCF. A ^`_ c_ i [UVXPROMS\LNV>W{ S\V n](*)`&=) 28+ qs7(. 'F ] F¦WCFQTWtQXPNV>}XV>Ot[PR^SUACF}QTY ¢OCWt`SULRVXW"¢VXc S\ACF0/£b0) + QX[ ] c,p i i & O 4 6 i ' ? i i = . ) &|+ ^`_ i c_ ^ _ `^ _ c_ n TU ^`_ ] ^ _ ^`_ c_ ADC ^A i c AtF#c\F L[[_S\cUV>WC}XPR^ `V>WXFa QXW ] `#VXWSULRWOCVXO[PR^ ] LrF#c\F#WS\LRQXzCPNF>j(FS zFS\ACF A ^ _ ^`_ i c_ i OtWCLROCF [UVXPROMn S\(*LNV>) W{S\qs V )`&8( |=+ & M WCF&LRWSUFEcUFo[_S\LNWC} [UY3FE`LQTP`#QX[UFZVTSUACF{}>QTY'¢OCW` SULRVXW[H) &32>+nQTW ] )`&8|=+¡LR[AtF#W d AtF#c\F dL[QTW&Q¡YCcULRVXc\L ] F¦WCF ] [U^DZDZFS\cUL`YV[LNSULRXF ] F#¦tWCLNSUFD&Q S\cULNa<XQTW ] ^ _[ULNDZi LRPRn QXcUPR^Xdb _ i & ^`_ n db _ d = C(*LN) SUA ) = (*) ) l[LRWC}¤S\ACL[/YtQXcS\LR`#OCPRQXck`ACV>LR`#FVTdQXOMaMLNPRLRQXcU^{¢OCWt`SULRVXW PRFEQ ] [SUV¤SUACF ¢VXPRPNV LRWC}&}>QXY¢OCWt`SULRVXWh¢V>c`PQX[\[ A CQ>[ LNW 9R2 ;* $ & OPyQ ? / / ' ? / / / ) &1+ / ^ _ c_ i n LT U ] ^`_ c_ i c"A _ C - A _ c ^BA _ i C c . . . . . . °°·}~L!. . . .
(150) @F . s! AtLR`A`#QXW{S\ACF#Wz3FFaMYCc\FE[\[F ] Q>[
(151) . & o )¢G|+ O PyQ / / b / d ^ _ c_ i n LT U A ^ _ ] ^`_ c_ ii e @ ACF ] LrF#c\F#WSULQTztPNF>(WCV>Wt`V>W>FawV>YMSULRDZL%-oQ S\LNV>WYCc\VXztPNFEDZ[Q>[U[UVM`LQ S\F ] LS\A )`&=28+nQTW ] ) &|+(VXcH)`&81=+¡VXc )³G>|=+QXcUFn}>LN>F#W{z^ )¢GsC+ R O TPyUQ ^ _ c_ i c QXW ] )¢Gu8+ R O TPyUQ ^`_ ^ _ i c_ i e /. . . . . . . dg [\[UF#WSULQTPYtcUV>YFEcS\LNFo[VT
(152) SUACF }>QTY"¢OCW` SULRVXW[kQTc\Fn}XLRXFEW"z3F#PRV l[LRWC}¤j(F#DZD&Q¤vMÅuMMS\ACFYCc\VVT³[D&Q5^¤z3F V>zMS\QXLNWtF ] Q>[ ] LNc\FE`S¡F#aSUF#W[LRVXWt[¡VXSUACV[FI¢VXOtW ] <¢V>c¡F#aCQTDZYCPRFX<LRW 9Rsou;(@ ACFEVXc\F#D&[¡uC u QTW ] Gt GQTW ] AtQ5XF S\ACF#c\F¢V>cUF¡z3F#F#WV>DLNSS\F ] . @ T @ T
(153) @$ 8 E 8 ! K"A` >@ 4 j 2 " g$ " @A 2 + EF] > % -x @3?4"$ " ! : o EF "$ o%BC>` >@H"A 8 % J" @$ "EF %. . . . . *. . & + o>@$ @F J ; +
(154) +/ >> >@$ $ %AE ?=," @$ ` >@ i i ^ _ c_ _ ^`_ i = p . : j E "F> `! ^ _ c_ " _ = p i ] ^ _ c_ c p + @A i i & + H@A 2 3 %! ,+ Eo? " @A @ i i ; + >J ^ _ ^ _ c_ i i " _ =p ^ _ ^`_ c_ @ ?H . 6 E _ = p ] ` ^ _ ^ _ c _ , c p \ ! E !
(155) + #x "( E3 BH @ x E , >@ ! @F, " u ' u d + E @ i i ! @$> H"F @ ^ o_ jj "$, 8 % ! $ ",4+ p E @ i ?>% K ,"A`
(156) ` >@ j ! $ ",_ +o^`_ @A EF , > > . : j E ">
(157) ! L. >! @A @$_ F^ _> * i c,p " ] ` ^ _ c _ 93 %! , + -x "( E3 B >@ x ED @D @ , " u ' u d +4 EF @ < i !l>` >@$ H" > @F ^ j_ "$ % ? 2 ",6 + EF @ p ?>% ,"$
(158) > @D j ? 2 ",+ >@$ EF_ , . : j E . ! @A @$ F * _ i i " . . , (. . . & !. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . !. . . . . . !. ] ^`_ ^ _ c_ c,p. . @ T @ T
(159) j< / @ @?=o= > ! @=
(160) @A 8 8 ! 0"$ @ [ 2 " g$ "6>@$ d @ $EF @T+ Eo 0"$ ? " E 2 + C"" 4 ! E j E> >@$ J EFo> 0 @$ ` >@ b ] = = @A @ J% C ?x "( ,E B @F @FF > x E=x "( E3 B< @D @ , p >@$ ,, @$> ? 8N @. . 8 %!. . . @ ACFnQX[\[UOCDZYMSULRVXWt[QTW ] QTW ] _ qs _ ^ _ i _ qs. YtLNWC}[. . . . SUACF¡jFEDD&QZvMÅun}XOQTcQTWSUFEFSUACFnjLRYt[\`ACLNS-`#VXWSULRWOCLNS_^VX<SUACF¡LRDYtPNL`LNSD&QXYM @ ACF#WCSUACFc\FE[UOCPNS¢V>PNPRV /[¢c\VXDMFX }tR 9Ns>s ;. A ^ _ i. 'F ] F¦WCFQ ] FE[\`FEW>S ] LRc\FE` S\LNV>W"¢VXc SUAtFYCcUV>zCPRF#D ³) Gu8+MztQX[UF ] OCY3VXW"SUAtF[V>PNOMS\LNV>W{S\V) &8|=+ j(FS k n & A ^`_ ^ _ i c_ i _ . )¢G=&+ ±¢Æ°(±ÈÇ.
(161)
(162) ! #"$ % . sL2. z3FnSUAtF ] FE[\`FEW>S ] LRc\FE` S\LNV>W{¢V>c SUACF}QTY ¢OCWt`SULRVXW. . . & b V>Wt[L ] FEcWCV \S ACF[Y3FE`#LRQXP`#Q>[F¡VTQTOMaMLRPNLQTc\^Z¢OCWt`SULRVXW d tACLR`A"PRFEQ ] [SUVZSUAtF}>QTY ¢OtWt` \S LNV>W"VX )`&81+ :F ¢VXc\F[AtV LNWC}ISUAQ S k LR[Q ] FE[\`F#WS ] LRcU Fo` S\^`_ LNV>i Wn CQId SUFE`At_ WCR LR`EQTP ] F#¦tWCLNSULRVXWL[WCF#F ] F ] . < > = ?! @ 2 AE&}>c\QXYCACL`#QXP ] F#c\LR5QTSULRXF j "8"$ @3? >
(163) 6 E4
(164) ,"8"A @=? $@ J
(165) = ^`_ i ]n (*) qs7(*) . .
(166). 04"F @ . 8 >. ^ i )¢G>G=+ @3?>..F J> + E> _. n[(*) qs (*). . . _. =. . . `^ _ i ^ ki s ^ k c i = ? "FE ^ _c i c EF , ?!"E E6 @3? @F , >@$jl EN?> "E j EF
(167) ,""$ @=?
(168) EF @ i & 8 > +x E @ E @A @ ! 0"$ J i ki `^ _ ^ _ ^ > @
(169) o
(170) E +0@A 8 E 3 E ,"F E ! j ! @3?@$ !l
(171) @A @ *,+N EH "8"$ @3? @A 6 @A 8 ! @=?8% .F E @ EF6% 6, + @o"F! %>` + i i N@ F ?
(172) 8 l ! o ] @A
(173) ] E !`, @=?H >@$ >l >@F 6 EFj 0"$ @$ @ i A i ^ _ ^`_ c_ ] ^ _ ^ _ c_ @ ACF'S\FaS 9ÅuT|-;YCcUV L ] FE[{YCc\VXY3F#cUSULRFE[QTW ] LNPRPROt[_S\c\QTSULRVXWt[ VTI}XcQTYCACL`#QXP ] F#c\LN Q S\LN>FE[E/ACL`A }>F#WCFEc\QXPNL.#- F . =. . . . . . . . . . .
(174). . . . . . . . [UOCzC}>c\Q ] LRF#WS\[/QXW ] ] LRc\FE` S\LNV>WtQTP ] F#c\LR5QTSULRXFo[ SUV{SUACF`#QX[UFVXXFE`SUV>c¢OCWt`SULRVXWt[nQTW ] D OCPNSULR QTPROCF ] D&QXYCYCLRWC}>[E 'FQTc\Fn`VXW`F#c\WCF ] LNSUAVXWtF¡YQTcUSUL`OCPQTc YCc\VXY3F#cUS_^¤VT
(175) }XcQTYCAtLR`EQTP ] F#c\LR5QTSULRXFo[#MYCc\FE[UF#WS\F ] z3F#PRV . >@ ! 8 oH R 08
(176) >@$ @Aj
(177) ,""$ @3? + >@ F" @F 8 > + 2 > @$ i AEF @T+ @A 8
Documents relatifs
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des
[…] Chez nous, le parterre […] est composé communément des citoyens les moins riches, les moins maniérés, les moins raffinés dans leurs mœurs ; de ceux
But on another hand, increasing q at constant operative pressure results in decreasing the equilibrium pressure, by decreasing the operative temperature (Figure 9), and finally, it
R´ esum´ e : On pr´esente des r´esultats autour du probl`eme suivant: pour un point mat´eriel dont l’acc´el´eration est born´ee par une constante donn´ee, et pour un
Ensuite, pour déterminer lesquelles des voix créées pouvaient être qualifiées d’« androgynes », nous avons fait un test de perception dans lequel nous avons demandé
Toutefois, des améliorations sont à prévoir car bien que la protection induite par ces glycoconjugués soit significative, elle n’est cependant pas optimale pour mettre
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des
Venant compléter les nombreux guides spécialisés qui informent le touriste gay sur les différents lieux et structures qu’il pourra fréquenter s’il recherche son
