• Aucun résultat trouvé

Clause pénale et dommages-intérêts incitatifs Une analyse économique

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "Clause pénale et dommages-intérêts incitatifs Une analyse économique"

Copied!
14
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

HAL Id: hal-00128518

https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00128518

Preprint submitted on 1 Feb 2007

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Clause pénale et dommages-intérêts incitatifs Une analyse économique

Saïd Souam

To cite this version:

Saïd Souam. Clause pénale et dommages-intérêts incitatifs Une analyse économique. 2007. �hal-

00128518�

(2)

/

&&)012*&3145!64

7897;: /=<>

/ ;!#?1@%"!)$(ABC%D!$ FEG4%DIH.KJLABE=MBNPOJ(71QR,SLJLT

< %"UF.%"VCRWV*)$&*"!4YX=%"!+2JP*&31Z!)VH,S\[X=]M

SV^$!W1_2*$!3`B^)4a*&4.%"b3`5%"$&%.cZ!d2%.^4`&=*44,%.*.4,feg_*$&%f3h$!Wi!W

C4.%.U.g5&%F,j3kk635ea4&%f14%fF2l$%D2YmC%..!$n*&$%"poqSRj%p&%.C.!$3r

%p&s34Gt1C%.fu49C3.!4,%D'"vm!#=`*CG ,!Wt-"!)&*!)w&%"x?1&%" Cxey)x?!*,!W&v

*249l!F2z;!W1!634R{^)2%F"!*W }|~ 4\4*C!+?!FFo

€‚&ƒ„…†f†‡@ˆm&ƒV‰mŠ)‹;‰)Œ& Ž‰#ƒ„ƒ(‡1gsŒ‡‹1&Š&ƒs…3‹N‰#‘B‹ˆmŒC‹Œ&‡’W‘„=’+‡“P&}‰)Y”K•ŠF’ ‡L–&‡Š.‰—Y‰„1Iˆm‡Š)‹

„1…4‹;‰4ŠF’4‡GŒ‰#ŒB“KsŠW˜2Œ@‘ƒs‡.–=’WCƒ(s™4C.“‰)ŠW…‹ƒ(@‰3†=…4„Š–Š‡B‰)Š…3‹ƒ\&ŠFšF‡}“L ›ƒ}œ

:g2%"F=4I*)1d12F= !BFC%.,!FCf34ž&FZ'&(%"?4Z4;IŸC*"!3Z3%R!W1_;C*,!Wg4

*234.%.C{oS\( DY14‚,$&-,m!v *C)I%.?!+¡WlW!‚ R!ž&3$4,fC^W?;w%p4P_1*3C!W-,f

&%"!F !%"v*&¢4&% Z'l ^4-"-D!*)Z44.4Nz"!—Fo

€‚…Dƒ”4f’)‡…4‹1˜&‹;‰WŠ…3‹\“L…‰)”4V&&’Šm”Š†f‡‹”&Ÿ‡=„’s•™Œ‰)C“¡‡}£ &Ÿ‡l3‹V&CC‰¤‡ Š—‹ƒs…4†f†I¥

‰Š$‰W `„x„…4†f†V‡ˆBƒCš.Š‹‰WŒC Ž@‰+ƒ ‘=Š$’d‹1Z“P&‰fŽ‰) `‡ ’’…4Œ`¥¦’s•‡‰Z“¡‡‰Š)§4‹kƒs…4†f†G“(’)4ƒ–…4C‰)‘f‹Š

†=…Š#‹„ œ

¨

Œ‡‹†f…Š#‹ƒ ‘1’©32ˆmN“PC ‰#‘†=Ž†ª„R•…"––4Š)2‘†f…„Œ&3L…Y‡ˆm†ª‹;‰#&\’+‡P“KCŠ+‹”Š4‡˜‡Š.‰Œ4‰—Œf…‹˜‹‘4ƒ}Š

’’«ƒ‰l†‡‹Š–&&ƒC‰)†ª‹;‰I™4C@ƒƒCŠ)˜2t…¬„ŒC Šƒ…Š&œ5­…4‰)tƒ}‰WŠ“K’)‡;‰WŠ…4‹®&…3‹‰WD‡ Š tƒs&Ÿ‡®sŒ.“K‰)ŒC¯‹…4‹

Œ2& Š,‰+2œ4

H < %Fi!F*&$ &°± v44o2!+?M

o S\&L2F!)$&²C!4"%p',K -,4%{Z&

\³&gq^)2h4%pkmC%I4s&%)k6Ÿ,!3´`{^!4"%"'dmC52F!#,&o\( "*!fª+1 !%"

-"4*,!3R63Vi^$3G*)C !)w&%"*)!)64*&4IZD;!po

µ

41*"!3´4n! Ÿ2 !¶²R!$z24C%F&g&14$j&*414Z!W6&j ^$-.%p&!W14%Dn)k$!fHi1xC

_1&*3i%4n*&4.%"b4g*2I ^&D;w*C&M"vK.^$3h s*,!W-V$&4\ ^$!W-")*2%fg*C4I4%i,&4

4L4,o

µ

41*"!3G4%DCmC%{"!4g²C%DC&%"&%BF&LC&R*CCP&4_GF%p&L* "m%"L4IC%D*C¢ o

µ

41*"!3j=4!+i!)3·²m4;!)% &-.C,!F-"=H.F&=!)*!#.C%KeY2d%pC*3!m!#?C%(f9-.4.%\3a

-"&!%"§&c_1&Ij4%ZFC¶F%p&¶C$ MDoKX=&a*n*@2 vV4¯?kC«&)e§4§n!WI

%p&%.,!FI4l43&1*&Cs

œ

o SRm%"4h"!631m(h

S\2P1&$!+$R44.!$!Ws&C(4K&(s!+i!)4L.%"w&‚?&%"!$&L63!34$44,&R*&4IZ(!#;*C9G4

-"2!+R64G*%..2!W1&2*"!#?;!#,&1%,4¡mC_$&%.mC$!i C4i!?4%\Ws*&!,&v $%p!+?%{2!W14

¸&4,%"&R*$&4%D!&R4VW4W"!3lHi1F)4,!WIVF¸!)%pv4_*CwL4b?;!#iv3-.%.&-"!*v1ooM o

¹žºK»\¼»\½{¾&¿CÀC½‚Á—ÂBÃD¼¾Ä$Å{Æ,½{¾ÃD½}ÇÈÂ"É#À(È2ÊqËR¹‚Ì´Å{¿Â"Í#¿Î&Æ.¼Ä½sÏ"ÏF½zºCÆÐ ÁÑÒº¾CÍÒÓC½DÆ.Ï"ͤ¿Å À&½BÔ4¼ºÆ"ÏDÕ

(3)

„ Š#ƒƒs4‡ƒŠ…3‹ ‘

&*&!$ !3aq^C-F%p&!W1%"g5m!RHFI&=_2*4,%( *$%"b4 13.%"Z*@C%"5 ^&)0CMj

Š)ƒ}”44Cƒ

N4C

Œ‹Œ)–Š)&ƒ

64!C3;F!)&o

!4,14Z ¸!F4¸&Ÿ2K*C4,4_lD%F?;&!F%¡*&4$%DC%L*C_6!m-.%"!W4N(! v!$Ks%D4

i313%pŸ!#?;!)f?2*Y41Ym%,4hh!$!+$I&&YeIgž!)&%.žlC4I&&Ij*&4¡_,%{1I

$%§*i!#?;!,3o ¸ ) %p!)*&!) *&&s !631 W ,_; 1!W44?!$13o < !W!vc&¦!)!)?!3t;

¸@&&%"44B4C(*&&(*"!¤?;!#,&(64f! %žh1&-.!F*2d%"!+?1=&zB;#(4%"C5641Y$f*q_$&%F;f63¸!F

C4C4%p"o63!Ÿ;-"-.!$**&4I1!)3N4b?14"^*4145!D.4;!) 6B^F!$30IV*%p,!$3(?2F%Do

SV^C%ii!W*Y!31!F%RfI2!)ICŸ¡*&&)! 4

C*%\H

C~

MR64!BI*)!)%p4žZ! ?1)%\&

C  4_a*&*&%"R)IZ!Fs94?%"4f)!)oTpqŸ-"-.!)Rfc-"-"P9!)-"%p%pv &*%.-.4i{!

¸ %"%Z6kWr!fŸ=h!¬C$!)6421oRABm%Z*Ck-F!)%p§&gsg4h$!)64&j=%"!+?&a 3

1&*&& 2!W%"oRTpI-.&4%{2!+l4Cc*C§*2c*¢!!W%Z)kg2!FF%"§*&3Gh!+@!Ws3«F%p§)§2W3*.!4«)

1!+,&-"!)!Ÿ2%B$R!W-.%"&*"!F‚ef$!f.&C4*&4G4.V4&R!W-.-"C%D$R*&4,o

SV^Cm2+01 Z

C*%%{l\5%.134%"eg*&$$64&Ÿ,!)4a5!w%DZ !)I$3oB(!)C%D3%

*2&W24$1$%D2?;!)FeW?;!WV4g%D!$633o < -p!Wa4G!FŸ24%\I!w%pI3,!)92FC4,

*249lF$%pY&2*,&(4!!#h;) v!F -.C 4%.!#ž41d;4!+iI)f —2W?;fs!#hIHi_!92ML.44q

4i!F!ŸC4`%"3hCh!F!+,``,*,!3 Wc;#¶-$!)hxs!#h4o(`%"&Ÿ#.="!)4G«-.&!)6n*3¸3D

&Ÿ%"C*&V4!+,

™f‡‹;‰)

H.@&CI%"3!#Bf)%"3hh !F!#,f4V,*,!3IC%‚2F!)$&Mž63

m!#\0%4`&1\63;!KZm!)DC4g*&4.%"5cl@-$!#Dož7 !R{^$!) !i!)4` ^419!#,5z

Cg*24V3%GW`s*&!,c&$4%D64`c,&*$!t&Ÿª*C4,s&v(!FV^?;wC%D`631¶4%="2!+14%D`

!)?1@´4c!+,c&D;%p&v!F&Ÿ=3i!W&V4`).%"nWc%p3hCh!F!+Wxc)5-.&!hF¶ !)hc=)

1!+,V+;#;L&?;(1m!#h;)4o

14,vI*&t%p&Ÿ1+.g%p3%pte«{^C#0 «C*&31Z!)641«4 )«!$Ÿ« 4?%ptC¯!§H

’+‡

C‹"–3…&C†f‹;‰

Mf&{ª!#§g*&4%{%"D414%D5ea)g%DC!+,3o XGg+vL!(2zV-.gŸ%§*&C%F.!)`Ih%.

^¢4013$¢w&¶34lWn%"@l!Wsk *1 c;%{lG ^F F!)Z!+,%Z)k4%.$3oKTp=_!Fz,k2!)!+1 !%"

!#$,!3;4CY&64&$W24Ym2F!Ò"I_;!))Iž^&z¡m213*C&s &!%"4PW&!$F)%p+4i!3 o

!).I632W6&Y&I63;!(4424C&IejY.%"?&4_rC*&31Z!)641oBTp(^$?w@%"g!); !R64j !($

1!+,&g4=*C4. C53%GW *&!,&v("^)&%.h;!,%{2`*&!F"4CD5Z"!3 g‚^2zf)19.%p!?;!)Fo‚S\

%p!Ft®*CI4,y¯*Ck!-.-"%DC$n*&4ix1·Ÿ¯$%"&4!%.¯&%j41¯C!+$¯14¦_!92¯e

"^"!)Igo3XGf)vFf-.!#Lf3?1!W%R!Ÿ,!)3C%R4.%"I&&4,1%{l¡ ^)3-.-"!%R{^C#0 G2¡

%p14 4"!))5s%"&!)R4Im2F!#,!W-"-.&%"&*&!$&c$f*@fL¶),3C 4%"f4I@)!+,

_!)9@W4o&Až)!%D(*C44.%"!h44i!W34N5!$( s3%L*Cª$0 fd%p#.¡²47¢?3BH

2~

Mž4CW=*C

g{^$!4i!W-.!$*,!F`4YC4"= )4n)2Y42!W1I64B^!FY%",!W%"4\g.^F!—m-.%"&*,!FcejW·m! Až!)30

71¢m?13$ H 2~4~ Mž4CWf*C&( ^C4iKeY%"!*¢ C!-.-"%DC*3!&&N-"!)9ANm!)30Zž74¢C?) H C~~± M

4C=F5*C&=4g.^$!W4,!W-"!*&i!4c&f&1$= &3n%!F1*4omSR%p!F5Cc*&4G4.Z4g"^)?&%"!)4

?!FFeW?!$(4%D!$642bC4,K&%.ZBC&B ^)244F!%L)f%p+$ž!)!+W!W2 4

&*&%DoAž4$!# 40

g7¢?&IH 2~~ MZ54.%p4l64B^!FG&ŸI1&*&C !)%D§4&1`*§*@c l43;)&%g&j!).C`Z&

%p3hh!F!#"Ccn,*,!3 o

/

§4.%pk!#$,!3«4C`C63&$)kk1&$!#.§_!W2W`B^F2Ÿ=&

,!92k*C4*&&%$kWnsŸ!)h!$F!#,k4§D%F?;C*2xB^)t%p! 63`B^&%.%Dm%l«{^$3t1G*C44&I1%

6&63ž^)4y)%"g63ž^!F&Ÿd!+*C"o

/

´4h  s&*i!W-f3,,!&&5W%"!).2 Ÿ!F*&!&!%.913%.%{2!+d'.%p

^$CŸ01&%RIF!)Z!+,%RCg9C_!WG *CI%"!Fs634oR¢4;v=j=m·H

±

M(Z33,%"4L@!# !B64I-F!#

Il2=!+-"$!)%(4I1&$!#._;!))IeZ646‚^)j641!‚5C-.%"3!)4b)5!B3%V)I%DC5!w%p9-,m!

(4)

%p&*!)!)?4o

JR-.!v3,64B^$g"!w%pI4I!$Ÿs!Wj¡I%.D3 h;!F!#,&vB !B*&&)!B64!B-.%"!)4\+lW!B&DR %

^$',%Dc*23 !%"n*4`%DCŸ13;ŸCh&v(4´4&4I&&4G&42y%D" Ÿ1!*n3tC ,4%.G*C

H

‡ †

MGCŸfD-.-"! =ª&424ª&-.-"!*&&*g64a*cs!+ª ,%"&Z4g!+?&4_r5m%"&*C4,!3y4

^2*2,!)?!+,3o QL34$&-,m!vk4C®*&%.F@!+C s!+i!)4 i^$!)4!#"!)4 &44&1" 4!)"!)-p

H

“K3‹;Š‰ŠW˜2 „‡†‡ˆ ƒ

M§3%.%"&!)y^?&%"&%§$!$I²g*&&)!c6 !`®*@s $%Fn4rC*¢&%§e )

%p&3;Ÿh;!F!#, ªFk%p{ !*C¯&Ds3.&D"!) f$&¶2!Wc44Z*&!&C4Z!FF!*3!#,&fs!I4t?4

!*!#,%($mC%..!$eI1*!$%RL%p&$! &%R4&(.%" C*,!3V4I%p*¢)%" 6*&&ICŸžs !)h9HFC%

_;o&!-.%{@*"!4=ef)f&!W"!4ID%ž3R4%"!+,L%"3%p!F,!)4,)FC*&$)&MDo

o± SV^14%i;f)(.¢1&4%D!&L*&4.%.,

JRg$¢&4%"!$I4V*44,%.,v L;#1%"2FC4LCcC*414Z!W9"^!W-"4%"i!W4v;FC;$!¤"C‚ s3;

g%Y-"414&$;g,!FwC%"I ^F!—*&!+$,!3ge=m%"C4%pI)fh144 Z*!)!3o1($,dh%"1*¢=

"^)&2+01f&*&!)64fCŸBZ-"-.Bh@ŸC=Ÿ%Lf&*;!ŸZh&$4ZNY)f*&C%D3$$fCWgC64B!

-"C%.!#G!)*!¤"C%FC 24.5e`%p4%p`3h3&g4&*2!F !gH{k*C%p3F$&MY,44d¯!—$Cª4

1!+,I4C*2%i,&!)V.,fIW=%"H{$Yh,mMDo / a_1I;)*3)2 !)641I&DR*C3)!B3j*234.%"R

,%.?@!WB&g2F=Z4%{2‚4;)263B{^&I301I-.&!)¡3-"-.%F"V*&4,4_·3%R!q&!$63!q1%"F,4

^C5!4%DC%R)&!)Z4={^&I30C%Do&)!$.*!m4-"-{%"l*&3$%{B64!&%.h;!#.%"=.%"=W&%F.Cf3Z%D!s63

H"¶ 2W2!W%"5g!+\&Y$%p3`14%pg3`%"D Ò..MfV!)*!#.,!3GH{$g &&!%DZ4!+b63`'&

C4%p3G%DCŸ)FCFMo

XGC4_¦h%.&1*¢&n4«Wy¢4%p!¯2k*C3F%""k*C._!Ÿ,4P²f3`*&4.%"i`*&4I;).n·FCk*&4.%.,

!*&4GW.o

/

´*C44.%.dŸd!+ª*4G )d^$!W%"C§t*CG4.g.44,&g39?1&%"!WCh&564!V 4f4y64!(14?4

?C!W%(1%ii!#;4,Cf4%{C4\3a2_*C4.!4 oSV^Cm2+014Z+l10&Z!)6419&=*4.%.,=*&4I,dl

C_1&%.4_=4,!3L-.4&Z4.)2²CD^@&Z4;;%"C@*3!),!3Bo

SV^$ml;41G4;#; !%DK-.2*,%"f²&*4%p!)D"!#$4"!3&44%"!¤BC(*C3$%{"*&%"3!)h!$)!+,

dC4,IH.%"4."!3M ¡_!Fzi*C5 ^2*2,!-"I3aY"!#.%p&=49%.m%"!$,5&d?1%V 4¢4%D=4g)

%p&i!W4 *&34,%.*$ H{6 !§3%"%.!4 ',%" 4"!$)!Fs& *&4IZ &=3.C& 4M ` @W!#i 631!

&*C4%{C&%.!4N&PC%i,!&(%DI%D4!$W.C%{2Fl4BV*44,%."o&TpmzN!WG%F.C; F!31&%qeª*&

!)?1@l646m1I!F4ž^#0GCKm2F!#,&v)V*&34,%{ 4;',%"%"4IIeB^$!)I%F"6 Cl4Do2

6 !Cw?(,3$ !)h!$W!)$B^&@l4po

SR !)h!W!)$5%"C4*2!W"!3`H.$&f%.,!W2I34L,44,&f ^W2*&*C%"g4%bF9-$!)%DCMm2f*&34,%."=?!),

k!#-"-.!$**&!),&

s™c“L…4ƒ2‰

92!k*%pC¯Ck!)&-.-p!*@2*!#.2

s™¬‡‹B‰#

!W3,%"3! C4Z&`*44$%"&!4,

4 Z3.2!W%p&o5JR 1%"2Fvc"^4&14`,3$&nH

–4’$’xC…4†f†=Š.‰)†f‹;‰

h3i!+`e &!F$)%"

%p&+$,o

(5)

-"4%"&$!I3V!#4;!#"!3I.^$*&Z!)Y2*24"d.%.& C*"!31H"(4vu!FF!)&Z3MV²4$&&1$

s34´4%..4!D.2 &!®34y4 %{"!4!)$ F!#Z!).2 n !)4?2z,!F C54, 44uD*!)-"!61

H.4!)h!F$!#.

…m’—„ š.s“

4a_m%,4%D!),!$3MoA¡)!%DfC%{m4"f44R?1*&&C%FC=&*413Z!FD,

14%L Ÿ.!-.!$%I)g.¢1%"!Fg&G*&3$%{"Z!#*4G )$f²L*C3,!)*&&Z!)I%D?42vL*4,q^2*%D!#$%p¶

*234.%.C.v*&4"L!Fs 4?%.V&L*&34,%{"o

SR%p*&!i!)4c&Y!)I$!*i!3f!+-"-.&%"&4,&f63jW2f*&3$%{"f44\!)*&4GW"²m2FFI1%{Z

24_cC%ii!&Y5%"C!+%eZ5*C43i!#*Z!WI%p?@oJ\F$l1\',%"5 *!+@)&4\4,!F5R&%.Ue

"^63!F!#h%"4o

Tz(&Ÿ\4"!Fg4gs3$!W&%4n%"3D;¤.%p!)64ggW5$¢&4%p!gG*44,%.,9!)1*&4I"=63;!K%"!¶

4%p!# 4 %"4%p!)$v§.^F_%.4%p!+C.!$3 4 .!4?13{i!Ws@lt&"4,!FCF®4 %D2W"!)4

*234.%.@*$Wo !)%"3%9-$!)%Dc*&24%" !W1F4=6&qj*¢,%b2R¶?%

4i!F!4V§*}i!)-I*&4I§3%=m%,44!%"c=^$C*¢m%=kh;!) ožS\&5_§C%i,!$3Z!)3?;CŸ.!s ,v

"^)m1d14%L&4l4,%RWf?%R5h;!)jC*¢=ž"^WC4.%pY13%‚h2!F s%\W=*&4Ld%p4*"!4 o3JR

*234.%.CV!W1*I"vLg%"!+bg*&3$% Fg%"& !m 41 k% 4F5$%DwC!WI14%i,4poL7B^$!F(&Ÿb "xC%

"^)m14%."! vž{^4.%"‚^!)4?2z"!)Lf5 !)w&%"Z3$!W2F3ož7!KCY4_a&%F"!&= I%.$&4P*&

4%p!#"vY2F4%p`4¦h13,!+Ze +y!W%"´!$,!3 ²f$&k_ mC%i,!$§s3.!4?CŸ,!F 4ZmC%¶%"C4%iZe

"^"!)Igo

<

m%"w2f*=4$4%L%"!$4Y!4,!FID%Ri^$!W4W@%"'žb12F!+W3¡"^WC44%.žId¢C4%p!F=4&*&$%"i v

14f%D4.%p31f=l?!W-\3`  DoAB4%\5%(eh;!)g3,%"9%p-"2_!3`%WZ*CWC I1&$\

C4s{!)4,%"', !)*&!)."!)-" v§.%"!W !W! -.4254.2 &%.44 ) %."!*$!)w&%"&4

2&)0C -"4%"5C%D4 CFC4 *%"!+,w%p& m% *&4I&%"&% W 4C%"!F4%p!+$ ^) %"w&1F 4

&4I&&4‚C%L%"4%.žefY$%p3oTpq&^)2!+P4(5%.&Z!)&%‚.&I1m=d1m&%R)=64Ÿi!)4

5"^F-"-.!$**&!)$5)I%"44$%pI3a*44,%.\H

––4Š&Š‹N‰

‡1

MoX=Cf631W&V*!+%p*C4z$&*C&svq!$‚{R

"^!W4i%"'\*&9G4amC&%F"!$feZ*64B^$!q0j!#(1l%"4$%"9*234.%.CGX=24a4_1!FwI,I v

14 C)0&%"4 i^$-"-.!$**&!). 4 .^$!+4?1zi!)&4´&*!)-"!F6 4 ) %"&),!W *4F%"2*2$CF

H

)–$–3Š$&Š‹N‰ 3’Š#‡‹ C

v

…m’—„š.“

MDo4JR-"!) v44V!)4"%D&s %p3Z&%F.CIg%"!F 6IVW=%D2W"!4

*234.%.@*$Wo

AqW!%D«&*C!FC -"3C5FC4_ F.C4`4$%D #0s4o9Tpn^!#k,4§ ^Ch4%" 4

"^)&%.h;!,%.& -,14&$Z4,%" t%D!!$!+$t4% i^$mZjg,4j*&t64!4j&%.&4i!+% Ÿ

*&%"&!—h !F!#,cH"4%"*&¶C5!)1*3!#,i!WIe`{^_1&*4"!3y&*&34,%{"M=2ª)c-"_!)h!F!).g3%="^F!)*C%."!#.1

!4¢1@%"C4.`en*3Cj!$,!3j*&4.%"&*$13CcHiZ&!$WC4%"k%"!Fk«*&4I4,nk.^W2FC§63!14%.%{2!+l

,%.4!W%"%¡)3G@%Fi!)*& ^)I!)4;?41*C34Z!63Vf.^F_*C4"!)4G&R*&34,%{"MŸo&Tp^!#

^4`&%.h!).%.&1914%f{^2*45!${"5&!$Y6!P%{%"2!+VC^W?;%"&%,%"w&d%"4h"!63153%ªW 15

%""!F64oSRZ44_;!)w&IZ&*C!Ÿ-"4Z$‚%"s!W=9-F@!+b645Z4&49&l4L;4

'$%pd4i!W$!Ÿ=*&4Yg4hz,!)F4žC4_j*C44$%{"*&4I1Fw,l4¡ŸC*!)-"!F&4CY*C&4%pY ^C#0 f)

%p!$z,f·W2(*&3.%"iKf 4BC(*&4GW"oJ¡-"!Wv43,3LZ4%"!%‚Z&*C!ŸZV63;!m*C4*%.1Y

-"2!+N63;)%pw&*¢1! ! !#-.*CfWV&*&! !3l%.4F%"vW!+?1&4f"^F!—?1&Ÿ,!4;&*&!-.!$64

;m-,!W%.$&V4I%"!F644RW%")"!I*&$%"&*2F)4o

EG4$%D %p3 C^WC%i,!$*; %p*2!Ws¬ &3 &¦.%"!W *%p!,w%p& *&!${D Z3i!)313oxEG

*249l³C3;PC%L-"!W!%ž*&641f{^4I&&F%"44$%p-"-.!$**&VmV*$%"q l44F%p3R*C4

(6)

%p&i!?;a ^)4c%pwcc4244&4V%=%{C44%.Ve`{^$_1&*,!3y-.%"*a3§*234.%.C{oLX=C9

4_;!)w&,&Isv4 R*IC%D(K%"w&\f4C49Cl4B6mG!F40I=\!W4?Czi!F C,

*!)-"!F6o&XGC(9$%"!F!$w.CI v4C415%p?1f4CK*&&%..%"w(s!WI=FC(%Dw1&

549C&$I&f #G!+G%F.C$=34`g*%D!)$w&%"5cmC%.F2g3`%p! 6315IWZ%D2W"!)4

*234.%.@*$Wo / c4C%{!w%pc 2*"!)4§%pCŸ`&5%"4Z4,g)9)g!I4%.$&4,5?1&*2Z4&g)

$!#F"C%{$%DC*4145!69j-F?@%\3aj-.?;C%()*)sY2W*C3IC%{"!#?;C4LeZWI%"w&1F

f44&C.!W"%"'"o&J¡-"!) v4R*&3*&—3R9C;!)w&%".%"w&Kh%pw?D%L% Wf Ÿ="!w%p

*234.%.@*$Wef)Z!)w&%"2Lm!)-"-.&%"&4"L%"4C4"L;@03R_4s&o

± o SR%{%"@-.-"!*&2*3V3G*44,%.¡²&49C&"!)4,@%,';3_1*C4"!)4I-,%"*C

< -p!)n9h;!)n*4Gm%,4%p¶&I C4_n ^)49,&$W5C#0s&vR!WL-.C 4%"&!)*C41*3C%2%f9&%f)

6&Ÿ$!3j?!W%R*CI64Y?144%"&!$LlF$%"Ig —*&I&V44_·&%F"!&V*&34,%.*.$&o4X=5!)4¡4

?15&YC*C44Z!FD.Cv‚!)4R4C%ib*C4 !$Ÿ$Ieg!%D63B^$&$)&=4?%"&!$4\C¶%p!)*&!)5s9.%p

^2*&*%"

 ™g‡‹;‰+

13%*¢!!W%9%pZw&96 !‚_!)Z!F&%.&!)\WI?@W&%  }!)3"c*C44$%{(13%&$)o

:a&%"Fg4CI*C5*&2Y ^$-"-"!*@2*&!)"5nI9AB&%"imomAN4%h!W`%D31%"5e·*,g63Czi!WvL!K&D

1&*&& 2!W%"Z2 p!W*2!W4_a!FD.!—m&%$%"5*&4F%"\mY.%"C 2*2,!3j4%"R*C3— !ž4=6&q

!4?13{i!F lžD*!)-"!64m!#ž',%"d%p!

oX=*CF,f 2*"!)4v31bC2+013)%"&5!@%B0f

*234.%.C{o

Aq4%‚*2-F!%D&v*23; !4&%. L4$%";ŸC*,!3Z!)I;)4,%"2*¢,m%žN4I?1%ž(&6&Ff)

h!GeY%,3!W%p=HF4Zf %.?!$*e=-"4%.!W%.MRqW%"%D!$,ed$%" -"%p%‚1?14B'.%p3h4,(Ÿ%B

&%"*C¢4%"4C!Ws3o

S\¯?114%g?414%{2!+·%D4I%"´W«*C43$%" *@C%a!Fl0 t4´!+1*&%.,!+.14

s™`“L…ƒ}‰

%c3n*Wk

%p441*"!kH.*234$%{b5%.31*.!mMV3 z%V{^_;!Ÿ,*&Z ^W54-"-"%"g ^Wx23$%D52*¢12W%V63;!LŸ&%.!#

)1(!)$&%"&sŸC4,b14%BW!H"*&4.%.;(.%" -,@%FN(%Dm%"!$,Mo

EG4\z4K14%L!)I;W!-.!$%R.^WCm2+01sf64B^F! B^_!$z,( ^$!)*C%ii!$1YD%R)?&$%Rh!FZ4

gW%"3%"!F.m%V.^W2*¢12,%Dož\&)!F.*&!‚B^g3*9C=9?13$55%.4m%"4oX==*Z*24%D&v

*234.%.Cf*C4s!FŸ$j!)I&4kkF%p!) 263;!(D*&!-"!cFg%"31!+ªH{y)gm%"4%"!,@M"vR k%p!#_y

?4,&vžd%"C5wCf5*C(4f%.44$%p4;!W.C%{2Ff5*234.%"Do&JR-"!Wv4(41 31(64=&(&$

1km%,Ÿ$4=j ^W?&%"!)4t?!W.eW?;!j4t%D!$63;@oRX=&c*C§*&sv$&¶4_«&%Fi!&¶*¢!!W%,44

%pZwC63!4_;!)5!$W(?1@%N&D %"2q s!)4.2v3*23-p4%{ZC4I%p!#;*!)*&!${& DL54"!43o

± o S\*&3$%{;b%p4*"!4

\4 !4&%"4j4C54t%pZ!%I"I1 ´*&4.%"l!+Gx%"44*.!«63c3a!F))Ÿ$%"3; C%

_1I;)%p!W64o

SR?&$%%f.^W2*&¢,%Vn*2I ^_&*4"!3``*&4.%.b&Ÿbz&g)5e bW5%p!#_n

?4,

=

oBS\c*4 %p441*"!3n4ª',%"¶s!+V-.2!WhFjH"&(e

± 4C

~

&*MDvR !#

%p3¢;!#h!#"!-LH.&42qe ± MR4C &*o 713f)f%pwYY9CC.!W4,%p', v )f?%(?%.!#

C0&% H

| MDo

½(Á)½pß¿—½DºÆL;&¿—ÅDÆ$½Ï"ÏFÅKÎÂ.ÆBÁ#½}ÏN¾C¼»CÆ.½"ºªÀÅzÓC½sÁ#¼ ÎÎ@½{»(½D¾¿+ÏLÂ{º¿¼ ºÆNÀ½Rýz¿—¿½ºC½sÏW¿)͗¼ ¾=½sÏ,¿Æ.½D¾ÓC¼ÅÐ(ÁÑÂiÆF¿ÍÒÃsÁ#½\À½È2ÂpÓC½sÁ#Á

!.Õ

(7)

™\“K…3ƒ‰

±

Z*2K%{4$%D3o&J¡%"2?11*¢2v4!F*C4;&^)?w%DV&F?&v!F4%"@-,w&%"@%.V &R_1&*4,%¡*&4.%"¡²

C0&% ?4 Z!4_G63%p4%" H ± |

MDo

TzR^?;w%p52!Ws!K6g9?1C%(B^F_C*$g5*C44.%.b!) !#i!+@L635s!L\ 1F\ !()9?1%%

"^)*¢12,%Z3D=)¶%.&14n63;xs3 *C4G4x%"441*"! o*2!Y&DG&-.-D!*&&*2k*&%Z*&2Wc;%"G

_!)5!$ %NW(?&%BD&%"&B !#$4o2:Y%pR*&*CL4%{%p&-.-"!*&&*23l*44,%."o

(44$%{Nb%p441*"!IN_*,!3G-"4%D*&2

< m2+01s1592!)4,4ª*3a63! ¶@Ÿscg`*g ^—c_*4,!3y-"4%p*&c?1C*¶y*&4.%"ª

%p441*"! o SV^)!W6g!-{-,@%"&1*&5?C*jWgs!+$"!3`%p*C&4C4.5%pC!WZ4&)g-.2!+V6¶)5?%

%p44!#,3 s3%"PZ'Z4;K&R*2K!F%"2!+;-"-"!F*&2*Vb1&R-F!%"fH{*2 ± m?1)%B%

"^)*¢12,% M !63;*4^F2Ÿ;W%"w&F ^$_1&*4"!3=-"4%D*2&64!4m%"?"o

JR-.2!+iv!WBC^W?;w%"I6fFC(4_%.,!FC\?31%,44 ;#1N*¢!Ws!W%¡+f%pw)ff4I&2 "!+$&%"'$(

*25*&ComJ¡kC-{-"ivqC%i,4b ^)`*C3$%{HFA | vž_*4"!3`-,%"*&2MDvž*¢4C%%`*$%"bHFA | v

C4s{!)4,%"',ŸM5*¢C45%p!c13%.^&*&¢,m%VHW?2F% M92!F=Z!W4%pg)g!#$,!3n4

?%om7g42!)g&&%"=4?!¡2me H o~ H| ± M o H. M.ML%"64B^$!W ž^)$!#¡63= ±

H o~ H| ± M o H| ± M{MDo 7! $&(4_C%i,!&dF,4q ^W2**24%DIm%žh!)&%L%"!+_Z | e

° vLCF&Y0`&414bŸF%p!*$&VHW?2F% !)n&&%" MŸo XZ^$§.^$!)4"%,'2bI4$P13%f)

%pw1F49&&.!)4,%p',o

AqW!%D54,%D25%"mZ3"4?14ª',%Da!+4?46g§-.?;%=`*C %"2z;#.ª1gW`*24%"cB^#

*234.%.C;4%"31*.!qo

Ažs!#h!F!+W 1*3!),!3

 ™´“P…ƒ2‰

²*C*3!g¦*¢&

‡u“K Š…sŠ

%D!$ 13%§W®%"w&¦

4 "!)4.C%"'2, &!$ C&$!W4%p%.!) {^&-.-"!$*&*!#, "^F_2*4i!W -"4%p*&& H{!t-.C%.!#

"4,-"!F‚%p4%pG*&4I4,$R*&4,R4*&!W"!)4l;3‚1 s!+h!$F!¤iR%B*¢C*Mo

XG1;3 %p?,!+?1&¦63; 3%"%.!#«&&% F ?;1m%t14% ?!+i% ) C4?!$

*&4"!#*&2²23$R ;*&!&$Z;!)C-{-"!*&&*23o

Tp9!#"!3a ^)4c%p!631l.%"4 !#I4%.F24\Ÿ%$l?1%4CYI*&2fc*2&)!F.*!B%D&s$4

{^)C?%p!3Y?;!FeW?;!KI%"!F64o

(4iK!)I4%.$&4,KZ! 4?1%D ^4h$!W4"!IeV_;*C4$&%Do

± o± (44,%.;b,%.& -,@%F;%"%D!$,

<

m2+01s1Ke%"&;44_;!)w&0V4=*4F%"ž!#B.%.& -,%iN%p3%p!).f4\W263!F_;!Ÿ,

H.c-"!$¶)`*&4.%.G!3;M=4¶!+h!$!+,cB^#`4-{-.%pk_3i%.nHien.^4`Cg44_yC%."!&ŸM=)

!4%..4"65)I?%R3%"^W2*¢,m%DoSª^&-{-"!*&*&!).I$WZ63IC-"!+;! s63B^e%D&s4b!)I!63

Y.%"C -.&%FB(%p3%"!F "(4;!)6414;(*C*CL4-"!W4%p3o

Aq4%(!$W)Ÿ,%.%*2}$.!)C&v %"%D4fI*C&&%"!W6ICc!#$%D4!) C4L4j!)*C&%F"!++4Dm%\FC4-"-.%D2

_.C%.&o4SRY?1%K%("^W2*¢,m%\PFY%p!#_a9*C&s !3a 4L$4 s3%pf)'fH

vA

|

MDoCSV^-.-"%p_"%"3D&4@W(e

4;

~

2K*2R

±

\)

%D2p,&4$o

S\2I4_n%,w@1&I44K,$I3=_ -.-p!F*2*&&I(C*5Z44Z!)

‡l“K Š…4sŠ

i^C3.%p`²B+5?2F%

 }!)4.VW%"3%p!F,VŸ;I&-.-"N)Z'&Z4RFCK4_*&2KH 4 ° | Mo

(8)

2%.454,(64={^3%"%{2!+B%"?1@%¡63!B!)%{2!FB4C*CY o

 ŠW†ª…

v!F &^)C?w&%"f4\*&f*(6=&

*24"gxZ!)sk 4?%"c&%5F%p!#h4_u44f)g-.&!hF&5! 63`*&Cj4&%F;!)&%" ž^)44ª5e

*C¢%p*¢C%LeI&D"!)&%‚g?1;;&4Do

23‹4„…

v! .%p!+h 4.2Ÿ.!)Z=Wf?)C%R4

"^_C*4"!)4ym%Z.^&*¢.%"v!F0´` !)=4¶;%.$k ^$-"-"!W*&2*&!+,&vV !)f41x&%FG4 f ,& y&D

,%.& -.&%"&=eIdi!)&%"*&YC%ii!1o;743;(%_C9I6I$d.%"!h4m2m;d?24%D!$ŸG63ž^)e )Yh!

14% .^W2*¢,%Do§X=& *& *&2 v« ?1% ^$_;*$&%.  &2!F $ *&3.%"®C%p* 631

&4I&&4BCŸ-.!)h VH

±° °

| MDo

Aq4%K%p&Ÿl%Dv;3g4R!W%"G6441f*G*@C4%pI ^2+01 f492C.!W3i%p'}i^?;w%D4R'.%"Y

Z!F)C%L%DZw&Y4CC*&34,%{"V4f%D4*i!WgCF4%p63G{^$_1&*,!3g-"4%p*&G&zB;#4‚l&!F%"

4C=WC=*&34,%{"fI.%.CŸ-"%.\Im%"4%"!$}i3omXGI)sv‚f4_a%."!3%p-"w%"&4Pc%"&L6415

*C¢!+_·f-.&s

™Y‡‹;‰)

vm&-ž4&$*&Cg)(*C$dZ! f ?%"f=44 C(h !gD2*&!W-,!F&

}™d‡4‹;‰)

o

o

*¢C4VW%"!F l*4I$.^F!4?1&zi!)@l*&!-"!61

X=2fFI*2%.5)I$¢C%"!$I4f*C3F%""f!)*I1F " vBY14Ih%"&f*44,%"!Wh3"!44RC&)0Z)

!#$,!3y*C44.%.*F1&Fj4 Z)&6&Fc.^4j4&4_k2%F"!F25HF?!W%"aWC54_M=4!)?1¶%DC!F&%=4&

!4?13{i!F l,&*2!W-.!$64&(-"!j631IY*C44.%.¡fm2 fh!WBo3SR=!*!3g64!;Ÿ!+q&Ÿ h@Ÿ2ID%

"^)&%F"!$*&FV4(JRW!) OfC!F*¢)Ÿ,&!)H 2~~ MŸo

S\f*&C%"f ^WC&)0f2z¡)=Ÿ!+?14po

/

5C*¢1"%L ‚9?11%LsdF$4qq^)*C*C%,5Ÿ%žZ*$%"že

%p!+_r-"!+_x1c63C4"!Ò"¶e`C*¢%Ÿo

/

¶-"!Fg)a*&34,%{=s!WcdWCg!)4?13{i!F l,5-.&!).v\

%p44!#;4Z)&f6! !#3!) 1&%"!4fd%"1&4*!#,!F5C4.%"f&Rm4_IC%i,!FCH.f6&4,!i&-.-p!W*&2*&

}™I“K…4ƒ2‰

CŸfy4C%"&Vm!)-"-.&%"&4,c4`)c64,!+,jŸ2*&!W-,!F&cC§&%F.Mo‚X=%"4d*&FW¶%p!W&v(&

2%F"!FCsY ¡)G64Ÿi!)4ZI.^F_;C*4,!3·4j4=W=%.m4%"=4j*$%"¡¡*&&FYYY1&4*2!W"!)4

%BF&%F.CDm%$ —

™ž“K…4ƒ}‰

o

id&)01YId&%"!).=B^!+4,%"&%R4_4¢C4Zw1!)I4%.$&4,63GW=F!#$.C%..%"=&*C44Z!63=

s3$!WI\64!Rk*23z,!)F1V.^%"h!+,%.&g5h&4o T"^C!+ ^W5%.`4¢4w;mg41

!4?13{i!F lR6 !Ba4C%"&R!FcCg*&&fB^)_4%p4%p!W"!)4`H

…’#„as“

MŸoX=Cf**svBWI&%Fi!96!

!4?13{i!+;-F!)‚-$*&ef1._f

…’)„Z“

oXZ^4,%D%."v)=W!)"%",%DfC*&5!64Z$%p63ž^*C&

^4,!F!F,!3jB^)49%,w&FG44&4924C4"vB!$q0jI)43¡4aŸ%p.!W4?D"!Fso;&*&!q?!R4

-"2!+R6I631m!;63;I.^Fj!+4?1z,! sYGz2*&!W-"!63H.! *^FCŸ¡3h &%F?hIL?1%p!)-"!WChFMpv 4jCzP %\4

%p&*&%"&%2F4%pI631g41I*%.F@!#&I*C44"!#*C&I.^$!)?Ÿ,!4bn6313{i!)4`B^)g&*54i!F!+,

s*&!W23oX=C;L*V*@2 v3G?%"2!+;441&% 4Vzh4?1"!4=ef) I_1&*"!)4*C43.%.C{o

&I4,m%"I4.%"424%DG63&v‚30b4CI*¢!)_nC6m,

 ™¶‡‹B‰—

`%D!#_nb6324.!#,&vL$

4_%pw&&(CK)L4"!F! 2(HFe=Ÿ?;4!%‚"^_C*4"!)4-,4%D*&2ž&K4924s{!#4i&%.'i MqCh3"! 4e

I !)$,!3j-"-.!$**&=64g.^F!)?1Ÿi!)@l4¡&D‚!F),%"&BH.Z!W=5h1*&YC4263iYV*@CV

!$30IV h4?4i!WIef%.4F%"f*&4_l!W40=1b$_4

…4’)„z“

MŸo

¼ÍÒÆÅÂÁÒ½D»½D¾¿BÆ$¼º2Ï"ÏF½Â.º(½D¿Â.Æ.½Ï!&Î&¼ ºCÆÀ½zÏ3Æ.ÅsÏWº&ÁÒ¿+Âp¿+ÏÏiÍ#»\Í)Á—ÂÍÆ.½sÏzÕ

¼ÍÒƾ&¼ ¿+Âi»(»½"¾&¿&Á—½ÏÂ{Æ.¿—Í)ÃÁ#½sÏ4ÀC½PÈ2Â{ÓC½ Á—Á !½{¿N¼½{ÆiÏi¼ ¾ !.Õ

(9)

!4?13{i!F l,5&-.-"!*@2*g`Wj%.=&5_n%i,!$&oR($, %"w&1Wj*&%"&`yC-{-,2d&5!)1*3!#,i!W

*234.%.@!+%p&Y%f$I_c%.,!F&=mC%D*Cg63ž^)F5$%{2!#"Z !w%p 2Ÿ05.%p!)64g*#;!R63!(%.4Ib

*2&)!63;!ftCŸf?!$*}i!+l1o < «*&34$%"&!%D2v"^_&*4,!)4y-"4%p*&&`&^)?w&%"`',%Dc&-.-"!$*&*nŸg*&%..2!)&

*23!#"!)41o

&#0s&34V$ C%D!#"j4j34$%p%=64gZ'gmC%.Z!)94,m%"1{_135!(_!WD,¶&

&-.&%Dn4«.^F_;*4W!W -"4%p*&&´4k*C3$%{"n3C n*%..2!W1§*2k4¦4g64B^«^?;w%p

Z!F)C%D`63B^41x%pw)`4`&4I&C54=s&3«&g*C%D!#"wC%"&g64c4g?3g,!31j*&!

Ÿo;C*!¡?!Rej.^F*$%p5 ^415*&%.$!)9%"&s4.,!)4n4!$*¢11$4Z!)641g34`W26313g4CI

X=%p!+\*2!+?!L"^2_1&*C3"!4c-.%"*&&ZŸ&%.!#\9%pw1F924%Df65)%DwC449CC "!W4,%p'}if44Z!)&%.!#

4C

…4†f†f…4‹Z€q‡

oXGY) v;4V+=%.,!F63Gi^$_&*4,!3j-"4%p*&&=&zP)m!—j ^F' .%p+G%"w)I'

4CRW2P0R4(X=%D!);*&!+?!F{o / V*&%F.2!W1*&4?%"C*C&‚!)4,Kb?;&Ih3* s!)hWo

| o XG&49&Z;&%F,V3I%p!63

\4 !4&%"4I %p&W"!y4$%p k?14%=bk2*¢,%=45)6)$c) ?1%f%"lV4

%p44!%.¶kh;!)`01¶e`"^)?2*&4oBT"_!FD"g&%f2!FFm%"I¶Ÿ!)h!$W!),¶ ^mC%p!i!4§ ^)§4.%p

@*¢,%=3,4,!444=gm%"4hh;!F!)$c ^$4*&*%{%p1*&c=¶44,4=-.-"%.= 44d*&3Z&5_

2%F"!FCo=(4G&%"4k&!)4,C4j&x,%"4!$x)§!914%i$&"Ck%DwC&§Ÿ1*!)-"!F25  6B^Wey%"&4L²

C4s{!)4,%"', v_C*4"!)4G-.%"*3C*&W;4H

€LŠ$”4Š)„4‡N‰#„I‡†V‡ˆmƒ

MDo

X=2c)§*&&j§Wn%DwCk§49CC "!W4,%p', vV{^)*¢1.%g2zl!+1!W-"-.&%"&4F%p§.^F_*4,!W

"^!W_1*C4"!)4a3a*4.%.R! 63B^$!K%"Z4&4924Ie¢C4.%Z+l!+-"-"&%"&*&4.%"5I?)C%(4

h!·ž*&=64B^F!‚=03o4X=&1*&I*CCv

Y Š)ƒs”4ª

h1-"!F641Id?4%"YeG4f"!)&%"*&Y2%F"!Y%p

C4"!)w&%"&IC4f%=F ?1%DoBXIr*&3 vR!C4%"U$ª*&W2!W%"&4=6j*&W,¶%pw1Wj&$)4c¶!$w%"

,!92f%"!F 6V64)?1%¡&Ÿ4,%"?1!FFeW?!$K4I%p!F64Vž.^W2*¢1,%B?;%p?;!Fe4W?!FR4

%p!6311o JRn-"-"ivL4&*g*@9.^2+01g&*C43Z!63g%.2!+V6g{^$34,!W2F!#, %"631!F%.V6¶.^4

14.%"k?!FeW?!$c3«%p! 63k@Ÿ%"§*&4Iw,C4*C# !=63!f%.4,k§{^?&%"!)4¯?;!FeW?;!¶4

%p!6311o

SV^$_;C*,!35-"4%p*&&R 4f4g% YD0$%D!$631d%L%"C4%.‚eGW=%"w&=Y49C&s{!)$&%"',o3TpBC^WC!+

C5-F@!qq^)f%DwCYfCZ4ž·Wf2!WZ4N3DžmeGW=4Yf)(-"4%i,I6;4

4-"-"%"!W%`)¯i!W&%"*¯%.,!3oI7;!{^$4-{-.%pt¯,&%"!W2F!$ŸvI.^&*&¢1"m%jC9C«{^_1*4i!)4¦-"4%p*&&¯%

%p?%"c h;!) oBS\¶%p! 63aDf*&c*@9D4%."5%="^)*¢i%oqXGa*c-.2!+,vK$Wj&$F31c

&!w@%"f44i!)9@)Yf%D!s63f64CZª?%LCŸB ?;%pª?;!FeW?!$(45%"!$Ÿ641f¡.^W2*¢.%‚C4.%"f

%p!6311o

SRª*+2 12W14N'$%D?f*45*C4I%"3Z!F\4.%"f&Rm4_%pw&&K%"&*C&4,o&JRF$-F!#

44%i,&%(Y%p!F6 Y4_ 4_·mC%..!$Vj'Y,I1o4XGI*Cl-.2!+iv !FBC%"U$R63ž^W=&$WYZ!_

65)f4_c$%DCf%Dw1&Y%D! 664c)2f_j%."!&%pC 4,P45"^)?C%Ds!W¶?;!)FeW?;!f4

%p!6311o

Á$їÂ{ÆW¿+Í#ÃÁ)½žÀ½

Âp¾CÀ¼½D¿ ž¼CÏ.½!4Î&¼ ºCÆÁ) »(ÍÏ.½L½{¾‚ºÓÆ.½qÎ2Æ.Â{¿ÍºC½‚ÀC½‚ýD¿)¿—½‚Æ Á½LÂiº\Âi¾2½D»Â{Æ2ÇC½z¾\¹LÁ)Á—½D»Â Ÿ¾½ž½Ÿ¿

½D¾ &ÆiÂi¾ÃD½Õ

½"¿)¿)½žÏ.½ÃŸ¿—Í—¼ ¾½ÏF¿@ÂÏiÅD½žÏFºÆÁÑ)ÂiÆ.¿Í—ßÁ½ À½ ¼Á—ͤ¾2Ï !.Õ

(10)

° o W;)*4oXG4&& "!)$&%"'$

i5*}i!)4v‚44,%"gW5-$!#6B^$&F)5%pCŸg&=;&!Wl4,I4&= 2*,!Wd%"&*C&4$I34`

,%"m!R*&%"!+"wC%"&K*C¢! !$ v4%"1I*I4,fW)4%Fq4&L%"4Z4,K?C*&CP%ž4*44$%p"^),!F! "!)4

f)*)&1 12WV=.;63ž^!+Ÿ$%.C  %p!)m!64C-{-,!F**2(&R*44$%"io

Tz*&44?!;3,%žI%p!$%žF!G4!-.-"%p*&

‡K“PŠ)… Š

!)I%F.CW4,%"fW

…4†f†=…3‹=€q‡

B

X=%p!+b*C!+?!$Fo SR

“L‹4‡’,‰£ „…‰WŠ—‹

C4_L,i

/

!Ff%3Z{^$!#.&%,m!)*,!3`h;Ÿ— CY*)sfC&$

6m&$)&(44;4!).!)?1&oX=1(*&01svmI&%"Ff

‰)Š“P’—‡B‰)„ Y‡†V‡ˆBƒ

6m1&KC4s

!4,%D'.f44¡Ÿ1*!)-"!F2f41fW2*&4.%"io / I!D"!#*i!)4a!+G4%F..G&z¡-.&!)"4,%D)

€LŠ”4Š)„4‡;‰)„

I‡†‡@ˆm&ƒ

H"&Ÿ$!i!W %"2!F 4h ?%"2!FC &%F"C M"v`F&

‹4„s’FŠ”4Š+„‡;‰W„ =‡†‡ˆƒ

H{4s

*24I,!3M(¡-"!)aF&

‹4‡;’‰£ ’+‡14ƒƒ

H{m%""*C4I ,!3j&%K%.2%FL&4_ 49C3%"2&ŸM

6 !414(!)4,%D2 4;+1(%.,!F*)!$w%"ZDo / Z44_!WwCf*&31Ÿ$B&^!4s3oT" _!$z,4lmCŸ2*&*&4%"

!4%..4a4,%"¬C*&5!Ÿ.2§ ^)®*3"t 4,%D¶ s%D!Ÿ,&§ .^WCF%p3ofX=&§*C«63;!5Ÿ!),vl

%p%p(&LC%{5C3"L2P(&L4,%"&KC-"!+lq^&*2W2!W%"&%B)f641&zi!)4!#;!#"!)o

< %{Z4,K*C44$%DVWV*&Ws(H"4

‰)Š“Lm’—‡;‰+C„ I‡†V‡ˆ ƒ

M

S\&

‰)Š“P’#‡N‰#„ I‡†‡ˆƒ

&4, &t*&4.´4 F%"C C*2,!3

 ™ ‡‹B‰—3œ

T"¶0 )

^$!W-"4%.,!F

™=“P…ƒ2‰

D%V*Z63;!KC^FCŸR56B^

s™ ‡‹;‰)

%V*3Z63!‚?g?14$1&FC4\

C%Ÿo

S\j 31

š

C4&

™=“L…4ƒC‰

!41!+VI%"4m%"2I!W1@-.-"!$*2*3CI4n*&4.%"@W4%pI6‚^)

Ÿ%p.&49&&4

™Z“L…3ƒ2‰

!#!+ª4g_1&*,!3g!)1@-.-"!$*2*3253´*&4.%."oKJ\$¶&%F.C

"4,-"!Ft*C.«m%,4%D!$¦?* $44, %"w 6!¶&^)C?&%"%"&!)

 ™y“L…4ƒC‰

Ÿ%""*&4IŸ$%p!*&&v

4$&;)L1& "!)4,@%,'.\};"^2_&*4"!3I-"%"*&C4o

J\F$1;'.%pf)V 3%p*Cf ^)h2%.%D!$w%De=.^$$%"&4o / ,&F%"w&3%.%"&!)B'$%D4,!F!$&eª

-p!+;(D.%.,&!63CK14%qh63&%ži^$$%pf%qC%D*¢fB^#Z*C3*%{%p4N5'Cf !*#;!{*2!3D

)(C-{-,!F**2Do2&%.mZ4m?14;&&C43%ž&PC4.%pCP%pw$&R4&492&4Do

S\&f*C4$f.^F%"%p%  1m!)*!)!)%p944ž;#f!)94%F,4Wd13%&

‹‡’,‰£ I‡m†V‡ˆm&ƒ

63=3%

F2

€RŠ)”Š)„4‡‰W„Y‡†‡@ˆ ƒ

o

S\&

‹‡’,‰£ ’)‡ƒ Cƒ

!#*&!+W4RY?!$*}i!+lY3"3i!FCF)YeZ!)4!%"YI%.4$%pI4I*C44.%.C{o2*&!

%p&Ÿ$b?%.@!44%m"4.%DwCFVŸ%""*I1;Ÿ$%p!*&3o

S\&*C3F%""zi!+

‹‡ ’$‰£ ’)‡4ƒCƒ

g \&Y,3C 4%p

ƒ 2’–4š.C‹"–3… &Š—‹ˆ¯s™I“L…4ƒC‰

^$=9%"!$64 ^Cm$,!3&‚%"4*2w&oEd3. ‚"4,-"!F(% Wl4%"i%ž631‚  f)

s!#h;!W!).%"w@1Fleª{^)&Z!)&hFo

ËL¾C½BÏ }¾2¿sÏ.½ À½BÃs½ÏmÂ{Æ º»(½D¾C¿ÏÏi½ ¿—Æ.¼ ºÓ2½ ÀÂi¾2Ï \½q½s½Ï,¿2½Ÿ¿Iº¿$Ï !4½{¿\Âi¿Í+Ï !.Õ

¼ÍÒÆÁFÑÂiÆ.¿—Í)ÃÁ#½BÀ½ ¹ C͗¼ ¾½{¿ B¼Á—¿)¼ ¾ !.Õ

(11)

<

SRG*3)Csd1&$f&f2bC%."!&&F& .Z'(63!B*C32!ŸBZ!F4_gm%Rs!+$"!3·63

F2x.%"!Wh44_;vY3,C4jWy?&m%aŸh 2*"!#?´64B^3$)&k2**24%"Ze t%p! i!)4®4

*&4.%."o(S\&g&%F"!$aWk-"44=C%D*C§63`*^zGc$%!W4,%p'pof^FCŸli^C%{5C4G!+G4

%"i!W2F!#,1o

S\= 3s{4C ž'$%D?g*&45&%F,=3Z%D! 6=4.%,Y$%.,!F&C^F!m0

l*¢C@Z3N4\WCR*&31m!#"!4Rq^_1*C4"!)4*C44.%.NHFmC%ž_ o&24Z."!3l3*&4

4t%p441*,!WMc%"§63t$¬D%p{4Cgj' .%"t&%"³®*&4y4¯%p!W

^&D%.&*C4o

J\F$d-$*&!$W!)"=Y*&2F*q%D!$63&(!63ž^3=&F!!)I!#*C%."!#$&g*&2B^!)_C*4i!)4

3l*&3$%{Do

J\F$I4C*&%{CWG*&4I%F"C4¡314%i,4!z,II*2&)!‚64!BI%p45!f\&%"&14*&!i!W

4!-"!*@"!41K!&-.-"!*@2*R3l*&34,%{Do

J\F$Y%"&!+RCf*&"V4Y.%.&1 C*"!

 ™“K…4ƒ‰

D%."3R4;&V*jFC(I 4

I-F@*&!F&(?1%p!F-.!h;&HF%Dh w@lg CŸ%pg&IC4s{!)4,%"', vL*&4"I§F!#i!+1&v

*&4"fCZ!#;!)Ÿ$%{"!-"v‚*C\4g"^)&%.%DCm%B D!*&!&!%"5!qc?@!)Y*&2*R3a44&Z!)3;!#

4l*&4I4%F,4;!&-.-"!F*C&*&vrMDo

J\F$f !IF!)-"!I)f%{4$%"=-"-.!F*&2*&f4g*C34$%"¡q@G'C*¢YC(%{4F%pC!&-.-"!F*C&*C(4g*C3$%{

*& CdC%&=?2+C.!ID4hC &*i!?=*&&*¢C3fY%{C42Y641g)9%"!+_ zi!+54CI)

*&4.%."o

J\F$5!4j)K s41&}!+_&%"!,&Y%p4-"&!342FYe5,%{C F$%Dg¶"^!W-"4%"i!W4nD%

F%%p!F4_ c4-.-"%DC4R%D!5Gm%"!F649_`*CF!4,²;Fgs!WLCŸ\41Y*C5*&2Y4!)

*&4._ o

Aq4%‚"%"Z!#%pvm54L*2W2ŸC%()*&Cb$g4_j*&,14%"!FCo3Tp 0ZI ^dC%.L*CW26!

s34·&-.-"!*@2*&x®sn®CF&nŸ&%F?;4Z 4h z&*"!-g*C43Z!63;3o=: 4gF$%Dy4Cx*2F$

*&,%"!$¶.^&sz%.&1*&5eg!)%"5-{%.@!WvLjŸhz"!#$4,!Fk`6355%"4."!3vLg5!)1!+Z!$ i!)4

5*C4.¶F%";ŸC*,!W v\+`-.2*!W$!+$,!Fy4`{^)@W*@"!4y3y%"!F64c$%px&9C%ii!3!)s!64`

*24I,!3Z&?2+C.!b%p!#?C&(%.,!&(*&4.%"&*,4W3o4T"m0ZGq^)&4,%"mC%.L*C)FC64={^4

14%{%.@! 642F!W-,!F%n ^$!)-{-,!F*@*&&§ WCt44a !#·%DlaD&*;),!+?1&sv5 !#a

&9;42P1&$!+$L%{2!F4ho

(4*)!)4

S\`%Dm%"n4§"^)&&)01kC*&31!6§Dk%.&%"&C4Y,%.&*¢1%ZmC-"!+!)"!#?C4=4n64CŸ,!W

%"2!F 4aCdIh%D4_a&%.h !#,%.&f63!ž_!FD,R4CfW%"$!#"3oS\9%"4h"!6319&2+01sZ!F*&!‚B^&D

@Yk%pŸW1o < mC%i,!%f3`4l4\c;# !m%"YC%.&Zw,%"3G44!)?4\'$%p9%p!WGn*4I$v‚c?!#

(12)

C ¦C-{-,2·¬0§¯*C44$%{·H,,%.&Ÿ*.!4v=!W4?1z,!F54Z*C441%{"!F-·3 &vf,*3ooÒM"vY

"^hs C*"!-e¶F,!#4%"5!I&4@l4b&I!)-{-,@%"&"&I2+,%."!+?G-.-"%.,lC4_`%.,!FCoL7)4`$

*&%"!).w&%"&`6§4x?`&)01 &`*&!$.Dv=Wy*)C k)§B^WC&%.UFZc%."!*!w&%.&4

!&4$3oCJf^?;wC%Df'fD&%"!%pf_ZF%pCb%pw)R4f&44&C53N3%L*Cf63;!ŸN4

2%F.CY5%p!Ws631Y R4f%D&i!3g*C44.%.@*}$&Ff61g4C4_52%F"!FC 4L?&%"s&K?;!WeW?;!W4

%p!6311oXGYZ'&&vh*C3gC2%.4,?1*Cj =-.?;%\3ž2FC4q?1)h&(%

$&C4.%,%"w&Co4OV2Ÿ$Y641Y4C(g*2H.C4s{!#$&%"'$ MR*4^$&z¡$K D4=63;! &*&!4=3g44,4

&44&C4"24%D6 =4 V.^WC4$%DI*CIs34R3(C%ii!&6!‚Y-"44PHFZ'@lI!q$K d;4

!4,%i?;!)%B3% Z4&%"@%N3I&4,%B$$&;zi!+MDo

QL%"!Fk1!)4.§-.424,_ !)?1j',%" 4F!)&ke *t!+?12 odSPt%DZ!%c!—a*C3*C&%.

"^!W-"4%"i!W %p&W"!)?1 4_ 243&14,oIJPŸ,{*C¦63¦"^!WŸ,!)F4i!)4« 4!$*&!)!)%D¦H"Fk 1

2%F"!F*F!%"M !Ws ^)4; h144 HF?!)%D ^)4 &!$F)%pM *&&!$ *C 4 !+?1&

&4I&&4 S\t%p ts%"&!)j4!),!+?1«3&§&n*@2§4 !i!W D.1C%D %`& 6)

"^!WŸ,!+$"!)4V D!)*!W2!W%"ª{ eYC*C*IfŸ-"-"!F&Z4N ^_4C%"!F1*&4o&X=(*(*C&svWf*2WCŸ

ZW2K49&&.!)4,%p'"L?1%{2!F4;'.%"%p&i!+?14%.*¢&L4;!) 6(.4,-F³&4Z)‚ 1&DB#e

14%y-"!)«`*&4I3i`4441&%) =h441 yzi!#,!Ftt&3&&4DoLX=C¶3g*C&g

"^_&%"!$*Ck§{^!W1Ÿ,!+$4"!)4a Ÿ1!*3!)!)%"§CzG-.&!hF&v(?!%"k64C!=!#_!$Ÿ$4,&vVWn!+C"!)4´pG)

*24IF!)641&3oRS\&¶4CC.!W4,%p',¶`4?3l'.%px%pC3C44&%"!$%"c63n!f*x$0k

!#$,!3C%{$42*Cef%p144?13%"vs!)4Z.^F!#?1&Ÿ,! C53N3\ Ÿ12;4_C%i,!Fs1 C%{2!F4

6¶*$&o

/

1c !Icm2+01c*&4".h-"!*3j*&*&)%.!+ª4;5*Cc*29e`cDC%D!$4%D!#"j4`)

*)CŸ2Wo

S\V4_;!w@l!#4;-.4&l4,*41*&%.f)-.2*!F!+,Vf+VZ!Wf 4?%"f)V!)Ÿ,!+1*.!4.%,f&

*)CŸ2 ) e -"!&$!+, &*C44Z!63 H.@-.-"!$*&&*C M 4 *& %DC4 Ÿ13*W,!+?

&%.! 3Ch&(H.!)&-.-"!F*2* MDo&SV^)CWi,!3f.^$!+D,!+,!W( !$*!!)%DV4?%.!#B14%i,%žR**2KD%žW

1&%F"!W1*Cf&*C34Z!631f(&%.$(?;*2K%R&R&%F"!&(6m4Ne=i^$!)W@%"'BYf*&1

C ,b63ž^!)z$%"b ^)49h4g&Ÿ,!W`&I%"CW"!4I*C44.%.@*$&$W2o

/

g!—h !!Fi!Wk_

2%.454,Y*C35!6&Y?2W4&=*!{D=&ŸR&*2sŸ!)%pg}R%{%"&!)(2!FC%f&K D&feg!F_

24%p¢%N*3C%i$!)CK!#$,!3R*m-,F!F*F2W$o

S\G%{!%R!#¡63;YfŸ¢&!),3%p&?%\*31*&%"FI-F@!P61FIC*!)!3%"!F&C%( 

14?4V&4@)&4!W-"W1%f %ªFj*4G4%i$&4V&=mC%F"!$ožC*3!\Ÿbnn-.&!)f64g&=mC%i,!$&

*234.%.@*.$¶4Gz-.-"! Z=%.,!F&$W2oPJ¡¯C4"!$*!)C4G)x%p*"!)4´4¶ 1&v3&514?4

h!!)%R=*¢!)_ZI)=%DwY=4&49CC4ž·%L-.?&%Ÿo1*!m14ž'$%Df&%F"!*F!w%p¡

*&2I4CF!#i!WH"63153=‚^)?3YCIC#0s&I!*&!WMªn{^)1g4f%."!&I!$Dg9,3)

144?1m!)%R&4*!),!Wg,3F=Ÿ%F"=63=.^WCF%pf4&%Fi!WG&zž#3gl!+1G4h!+C Z=!W&%R)

*)CŸI)4oX=f*C*&Cvm4I*%.$!)! *&%.,!3`&!C9Cf Ÿ1I3%.%"&!)\'.%p-{-,!F*@*&Ic

§¶! &%"&!)f*C&IC%ii!WIg%"%"¶5,&F&I!$Ÿ14!#"!31oL\&64CŸ"!)l13;Ÿ&Ih4

-"4C$)RB^)44R$G64Y.%"wC%i,!Wl4L&2+01C&fcC*&31Z!)4oT"LC^WC!)L?;%p!,h;)&Z

^4Z*¢,!%‚$%DwCK%"F$%ž=.^WC#0sf&*414!F6f4ž&(F!)*&"!)4P?144BCZ4&)e=5%"!#

H.!+,!63&v&Z&C*!#&v nMo

(13)

<

¢!4v3AKoqA¡o

#,3gH

C~

MR²I4.%.*,(2fh4C%"%"!F%L,54,%F0 1v

<

Z%p!*@C9JP*&31Z!)*OV?! v

GFo H M"v o |q o

&* 4&%"vV[YoVH 2~ Mj² =%"!5`&§A !$z¢l4²R&¯JR*C44Z!* < %D42*¢ v]3%.&f4-YA¡$!,!*&&

J\*23I01v GFo v o ~ ±q o

%p31Ÿ&;vqJož

> o µ C%p&H

±

MK² fOfw&1W2Ig%"!¤VV!)1_;*$!3§4 *&34,%{Do SV^4%.V¶)

,¢&4%"!$IC*&34Z!)641I4&V*44,%.,j4%"!¤P*4IC%D vOf?I ^#Jb*3Z!FfAB$!i!63v dio ± H M"v

o

||

o

R¢v¶Gv = vc7 o·}nQ(o fC H± MR² Až!z¢;!# OªCr:-.-"4%p > %, 7?1%p&+0 v

T"4i%"i!W3OV?! 4-SR &dJR*23Z!)*&sv Gio

±

H Mpv& o

| o

XG=[CŸ,v[lo

µ o t40iH C~~~

MR² fAž&)0ZW;ŸKCYSb!)64!),ClX=&C3 v

‹D£&’…“K„Š)‡5….–

€ž‡k‡‹4„ &…‹…†=Š)ƒ

v¢4Fž².s&%"om4"oÒh1 @&Cz | N hoÒ-{o

J\!)v < oZ§7BoIOª&!$*¢13Ÿ.2!+ H C~~ MK² GF31v 7$&42%" %"2*¢ Oª&!)&sv5 :$!W2

T"4?z.l v < 5C%D!*&=JR*&5!*bOV?! v GFo H Mpv& o | ° o

=C!v < o1H± =?;!)I.¢=*&f15&"!#Z!¤ "q²-"-D!*!4;#F0Z*2W;ŸC!)·(43Z

!)?!F*234.%.@*}N) v3T"4,&%.i!)4&4OV?;! -SR &dJP*&31Z!)*sv GFo

±±

v3 o

m

|

o

SR24v oo(Oª4yH

±4|

Mc² G:¬+¢ `-"4%p*&C44-Z 2*&!W-,!F*kC%D-.%.&*§!) !#?;!WSR

*234$%D!& v1T,,&%.,!3&3Oª?! 4-mSR dJ\*C44Z!*Cv G.o ±| v@Bo | o

Aqm!)0v > oH 2~ MV² Of!$ c7¢C%D!#gQ‚¢%"4¢ %"&&*¢g-R3$%{2* Oª&!C vm]s4%"&B-‚S\&

7.!)&sv G.o

v& o

|4±

|4|

o

Aqm!)0v > oI`7 o7¢C?&FvH @~~ Mn² GQP¢«:,!W25QK%.24C-.-ch & ¢;´Až%,4hh !F!)0®

> !#4-

µ

!W& v < Z%p!F*CYJ\*C34Z!*bOV?;! v Gio m~ v&Bo ~N o

Aqm!)0v > oLf7 o(7¢C?&$WvRH 2~4~ < EG4.g§:4,!W2

µ

!#; ´¢ u#$¢ =C%D!$& < Z3

T"!)?!32F 4v

<

Z%"!F*&CYJ\*414Z!W*(OV?! v G,o

m

H Mpv@ o

q

±B

o

Aqm!)0v

>

oI`7 o7¢C?2FFvH

2~~3±

MK² JR-"4%D*2Z4 (mD,k1 ¢«:,!W&

>

&!#¬

AN%DhmCh!F!#F0G4-

µ

!); v]4%"&4-SR fJR*&3Z!*& v Gio

°

H Mpv@ o

| o

Aqm!)0v > o(7 o7¢?;&FfH 2~~ Mg² AB!+i!#?¶X=C& 4vQL¢ Ed AB2W%{?;¶XG!F*i!W&%F0´4-

J\*23!*&Lf¢bSR o

O1%D4v oH

~&|

M\²dJ\-"-.!F*2!F4 O&F!)C*&fIXf&C

>

&2Ÿ%"f-.%

%"&&*C¢54-ž43$%"&* v4OV

]}3%"4-J*&3Z!*&v Gio

°

H Mpv&qo

~ ° o

71¢m?13$v7BoH

~

MR²YX=C9C

>

2Ÿ%p-.%

%D2*¢4-N(44.%.* v

]sm%$m2-J\*4145!*Cv dmFo

H± MDv&Bo | ~ o

(14)

C~ <

J\*23!*bOª?! v G.o

H |

MDv& o

°2|

~4±

o

71¢m?13$vb7Bo¡H± ° MR² 7;*2!W-"!* AN@%.-"4%"*5?1%DIX=&1-"4% %p2*¢r4-f(44,%.* 1v =?&%p

]}3¢ > o2:=W!(W@%B-,%mSR vJ\*31!*&LC s!)v2XG!$ *1 !)4=AB1%mE ° ± vEG3?Ih&%Do

Références

Documents relatifs

To test whether the vesicular pool of Atat1 promotes the acetyl- ation of -tubulin in MTs, we isolated subcellular fractions from newborn mouse cortices and then assessed

Néanmoins, la dualité des acides (Lewis et Bronsted) est un système dispendieux, dont le recyclage est une opération complexe et par conséquent difficilement applicable à

Cette mutation familiale du gène MME est une substitution d’une base guanine par une base adenine sur le chromosome 3q25.2, ce qui induit un remplacement d’un acide aminé cystéine

En ouvrant cette page avec Netscape composer, vous verrez que le cadre prévu pour accueillir le panoramique a une taille déterminée, choisie par les concepteurs des hyperpaysages

Chaque séance durera deux heures, mais dans la seconde, seule la première heure sera consacrée à l'expérimentation décrite ici ; durant la seconde, les élèves travailleront sur

A time-varying respiratory elastance model is developed with a negative elastic component (E demand ), to describe the driving pressure generated during a patient initiated

The aim of this study was to assess, in three experimental fields representative of the various topoclimatological zones of Luxembourg, the impact of timing of fungicide

Attention to a relation ontology [...] refocuses security discourses to better reflect and appreciate three forms of interconnection that are not sufficiently attended to