HAL Id: halshs-00143793
https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-00143793
Submitted on 27 Apr 2008
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Sacrifice ratio dispersion within the Euro Zone:What can be learned about implementing a Single Monetary
Policy?
Marilyne Huchet, Jean-Jacques Durand, Julien Licheron
To cite this version:
Marilyne Huchet, Jean-Jacques Durand, Julien Licheron. Sacrifice ratio dispersion within the Euro Zone:What can be learned about implementing a Single Monetary Policy?. International Review of Applied Economics, Taylor & Francis (Routledge), 2008, 22 (5), pp.601-621. �halshs-00143793�
2
#%34576981756,*:;<=84;>4:?@!A%?8)BC%DEAGFIHJ8KLF:M
NOEPRQTSUNTPRVEWTXLOEY5Z,[,\']:^,Z:_G`aPbcedgfTQTOhi[:jhlk%m1SUnop[,\,Zqop^sr&NXTdtceOEQluvj'hik\qop^
]:wY"xbyPRVxz,{|}e~yU}t$ e9"T~$~+R|L9ERp yK}e~R@~y"}tU}y9KU}t~~$@}L}t$URJUR~UU "E
}e~"T~}tRJ:}U|}tpU|L: KlE"pRL|L}eRGR ¡ T¢¢£T¤G¥~UU}gpU$~R¦| :~E$K}tU}ey,KU}t§T$U}tL$i~
| JL:T tU}g ER$~UyK}e~}t¨9UR©TKpy E,}tLU U}eR9K$yTU}eR §E"ªy«E}g $+~}¬¨~UU UE
®,¯,°.i$ e~$¤y°%$~" K~5U"R<~"«¡±TK}eqyE t² ~}e~5~³:$ t R~UT¡±² y¡±T"}eqK ± }¬¨i´~K}tp"$~A eEK:
p}¬yRE g~}tR ~$¤Lµ}t~U t²¶p }tK}±$E }±EiG}¬~ t$² ~,lKEEA}tL$K~p}ti| p$L"$¨ i~y$K}tU}tEp"U}t§
,| }t·|¸$·<«Ts e}¬¹ $ºKº| º~}tpT $ $y~@$$~º}g>U| &$ K·¨ s}¬ U tU}e¸"UR»:| }e~. ¨U}tT
K tU}±R ~|}gº«Uq$¼| @}t }U}tE J eL$ ªG¶}tLU U}eRº$ @U|LE~U9R9}e~}¬ U tU}e7$ys«Ta~$½R~)
¾
~UU}t"}$U}eRi"R¦|L,$| G}y,·ª}t" U}tRªy«
¾
$U}tL,E eL~AKp ¿ÀUR| ,¥LKyyªÁ=EU"E TÂA$G¹Ã¥Á1ÂAÄ
K| =|$9i$U¨ RTKK= "}yª~U$« }t e}²G§ $"·}y e t²+ K²9Ry3y¨}t¨¤Å ER G t² §:l$yGÆ= Ky }eL
}eGy!R¶·²7"$ETU}e½}gº¥ KyTy>~E$"}U}±E"}esG}¬~~}±R §q,| }t·|7qET eº~"¨¨ $~UJ|J|
Ri}¬y yy K¨Ly:U"}t¨R¨ $« ²ª| pÇ)E~UK}t|E{5K²¶}eR Æ=}tL t ppU p$ELU}eR9R%~UU "E
}tUKEE~$¤Èe:}e~l t}t¹ $ t²9K«+ Ky« eÉ}t9| ¶~U$ y¶Rq~}t¨ eiR UyU²) e}t$² §=~}tE¶~UU UE
}tUKEE~5}tq ¬²3R~"²piU"}"´~"TR ~´~5RKR }eRE TERLRi}e$~U%| %~yi=iR UyU²p}tp e~¤
Ê:ËUÌLÍÎRÏÐRÑ$ÒÅy"}tU}eE=K}LÓRiRLUyU²q t}e·²Ó$ U¨ TEyÓ¥$R i}e$:Ç)R UE²3Ô' }eRiÃ¥ÇÔÕÄ
ÖÖÖGÖÖÖÖÖGÖÖÖÖÖGÖÖÖÖRÖÖÖGÖÖÖÖÖGÖÖÖRÖÖÖÖGÖÖÖÖÖ
×eØÙÚÛ×eÙKÜUÝÞØUßRàGÞáÙÚâãäLÚ忨±áeßåçtèLâØLéRØÚÚØUßLêLØçyëRéì$í¶îgä íAé=ëyïéðñò$êêeógãôÙKܱÞõçtèLâØUßðÜåØeÚÜUØUßRìEÜö"Úö"÷åÝUÞØUßtãø4ùõÙUÜUØLú öÜûØãëðü"ñýêþã
ÿýñýLéRØeÚÚØUßEÜUØâØKãôáÙÚÜUØ"ìEÛ÷ÙUåõ±ØÙUÚÛeÙ"ÜUÝUÞØUßâÞáÙÚâ 5ÞÚåæÛá¬Ø±ÚÚØUßêá
í5ÙáåõKÚØ úGÞÜûØçtÛöÞáâö"ÚãUáeöÜÙ÷4ùKÞßyéØÚKÚØUßRØeç$ëRéì$í+îgäí5éëEïTéðñò$êêógãàLè±ùÙáçØ÷ØÚçyâìEÜUö"Úö"÷åØLéEÞátÙUõØTØtçEâØTØUßçtåö"ÚîàTì$é ótãñý
áÞØâ"Ø ðUçyátåØeÞÜãëðü"þò´êUý"ãKÿýþòT騱ÚKÚØUßyÜUØUâØãKôátÙUÚÜUØKìyÛ÷ÙUåõ÷Ùátåõ"ÚØûKÞÜûØçtÛöÞáâöUÚ AÙ"áöÜÙU÷TùKÞßeÛáeØÚKÚØUßgá
×tÞõåØÚ$åܱûØeáeöUÚã"äLÚ忨eáeßtåçtèâØéرÚÚØUßLêØtç$ëRéìyíîäTí5éëyïéLðñò$êêóãôÙUܱÞõçgèâØUßðÜåØÚÜUØUßEìEÜö"ÚöK÷åÝÞØUßãøDùõÙKÜØúTöKÜûØãëLð¦ü"ñýêeþãÿýñý
éRØÚKÚØUßEÜUØUâ"ØKãôátÙUÚÜØ"ìyÛ÷ÙUåõtÞõåØÚõåÜûØeáeöUÚ 5ÞÚåæÛáeØÚKÚØUßUêá
{|}e~}tK t}eR9 ±}y}e$~p}tpT ei"$|KyL¨| y| R¢~q$!G¢~q|$L e$9py²y«~" ~ÕU
:RLJ·« y:| +UU )E~UK§'}t""i~+iE ,yU}t }²G§'K$~" U}¬¨IU"R ~}g¨ }tK}t$yEi· TKp$L·
K$y }eRR,}t U tU}eR¤4{| J}e~~"TJR| pU"$ ~}UR"²ER$~UR~~RE}t$+:}U|9K$~UU"}tK}tLii UE²
t}e·²¶KpR}t ~,· e$~~q« UiypR¨ER i}¬~K~$¤T°=y·5| $RU}e$y ~UL}e$~q|$ lKR~$¶ªU|T
¹ ²>K"i}t$EK~)R9}e~}tK tU}eRºE~UK~$»=| @ tE$¹ºR9EEUKy p« ·R¹7$K$G}«L}e e}² §i~ ±R y
¾
~Ui·"~G
}tK tU}tRUU}ey ~:"·|$¨ E~l}t iRLUE² t}e·² §A}tqK"$q}tKR"3U}eR §A·,y¨ $~l$ K}tEE~
~UU}t·¹}¬ ´~~§4$$E t eEp"l| }t¨|E
¾
~UiA$~U"~y K}tG¨¶iR}e~}tK tU}tRJ KREE~~$¤L{|}e~=:y eT tE}ti|T
« $U}lRiR LU}g¨| ´~~"| RK¡tKUCy~UK~p|"EL¨|| 9´~K}tp}eRaRp~E$"}"}tE+K}§5²R}t$E ± t²
$U}tL$p~| ,L:T tU}tL,y t~~§Li~"LK$p~1,Ky·5R5R $¡² E5KE ,"~~,iE~UK}t! 4Ky
Ã!! 4ÄK§$"}e~}g¨3U"R7ÕR $¡±Ky·E¨L´¡±T}tE4 "3· EK$y }eRp}t'| }tK tU}±R3"UR¤y¥:L}"}e$E LK$~" K~
UK½| i t}"" ":yRK}t"½|~E$K}tU}tEp"U}t~'3y²¶}±UK,}eG$ t²¶UK R pyy EU² "J$ $| %ÃKR=
¨ }tLI$y T tU}tR!i| @$ @R pU| ~$i}tĤ'Å EK}tU}tE)KU}t~+$·| KR+«) }±:$aR~
}t R}e$UR~5R~UU UE LR}U" y´~«T:$iEyLEUK}e$~$¤
{|+LK$~Eq ·i}¬ $~UU}t¨"$~p| }e~p"y}t9KRq| :$ t 9yEG·K}e$~l«T$ eR¨ }¬¨K9| ¶¥5$R i}e9y
Ç EU²9Ô }±EÃ¥Ç Ô,Ĥ4{|J~}t¨ ±ii EU²+ ±}·² e$« ²| l¥ KyTyÁAEU"E 5ÂA$¹Ã¥ÁAÂAÄ·
ERy"$i}t |~5«L$i~~}¬¨ $,| }¬<R53y}tEUE}tL}t¨p "}y,~UU$«L}e t}²iq}|}t:| , "pEKU$¹ iR~
Õ,| R epÃ}¤¤3R}tEUy}L}t¨:| ,$¨G¨¨,}tK t}eRiKU=«$ ±R7 ¿Ä¤" qR| ,$|L}e5Ey" ~= e}e$~=}t:U|T
$UK$"~AR~" ·|i,TR e}t$²JRi}eRE 4$$R Ri}eE~·¤RÈe$$J$~}t t²p«T= L~UUG,|}t~E$K}t"}y,KU}t~5:
U@}tUKl« KREG t²ayiR¨a¥ÇÔ ip«T~UU$~§A| yRpiR!iR EU².R e}t$²!qEL e| aLKy R
~²piK}eqU"$K~AiU}±RE TyRK~$¤LÅL|i~"²pi"K}t$~1:y epyRq e}t$UAU| AUR~"¹ªR| ¥ÁAÂ,¤#:R~
| ) i}tE pEyL"¨ E "$ET}t$a"$$ R}eR"yy EU"}e´~J". EU}t$}LU }t| "a "K ²7ÃR~
URKy$q«²:| yR "¨ E$K}""}qK}tL$p}t'| J pÇEE~"}t|·{5K²Ä4UK·G~ U$p}tEUp:~UU "E
$RL"¨ E|A$y eJK$yTE| $~q~²iiU"}e$~%,¯,+$E g² ~}e~,R~y$K}tU}tEqKU}tR²y3}±E~=:}U|}ti|
KqE":~|yT eÕ| $ gi$ ~q| ´~&$yTE~UU}eG~·¤
$y EU"}e$~~·}L}t$UR"R%~UUL UE $RR "¨ y¤"= 1$ }e~A|L"$KRKq t"$pUp| :RU¹ ~UKG
¯, G~Ir!R~$|LÃGRÄK§,ÂAGR r Ç ¾ ysÃEÄi· aÁ³EGar ,Ky$}à ¢G¢£RÄK§=«RJEL
$REU"}«GU}eRº}e~:RK eT¤µ4}~UU g² §q:.KR~)Rs¥Ç ÔCyyEUK}e$~)$ U²a"!~~´~~| @ g}eR7G
~UU UE }e~"~}eR¶ eGR¹ }t¨+5| i²Ei}tE~qR%~E$K}t"}yi"U}t~,G}¬~~}±R«T´|¶y$K~~ÕEyEUK}±´~Õy
R AU}tiR¤T{| pyy t² ~}e~qRJ eR¨K}eG£G¡ ¢¢£ i|Lp~iR" ¡² E" t e}¬¨/$~UU}¬3K$~:~| yT e
$ eE" t²> "EL}es~Ris}t ~}t¨|EK~$¤Å Ey t² §lq@~! ~UU LUE J®,¯,° i| R eR¨G²<}t ~"T}"$>UK
ÁAE|LeU}ÃGÄAELÁ=$$| e"}r °}t·|à L¢¢Ä"J$ t· tUp~E$"}tK}tEqKU}t~§¦~}t E|}e~'iU|LR eR¨²+}¬~
~" }U·« e=U}tEKU}y yRp yK}e~R ~$¤
{|Jp}g GpR|}¬~3 $T:}e~i~UU "$9~ U t eR:~$¤{|J :~$U}eKR~´~lR¶| JERy,Õ
~y$K}tU}tE9KU}tT¤ÅT"}eRI£ "´~EK~+y p }tK}±$E Õi $ ± }¬¨I· "y| §$&Å $U}e!}e~~~$~i|
U}¬ EK$~" K~$¤GÅ K}tRÕ "EL}e$~A~RiERy TR}t¨pKpE¹G~·¤
{|q~E$"}U}ty,KU}ti$$p«Tq$U}t $l~| ,Lp tU}tL:y$~K$~"T U}t¨JUKR<R¡Uy TKEEU·¨ E¡±T}¬·
K$y }eRª}¬:U| Õ}tK tU}±RiKU¤R{|}e~G$U}t }K}tRR| ,~R$K}tU}ey%"U}tlp$²i«T,}e t g~UK$i~}tpT t²¤Rµ}g¨R ª
~"| Õ~R ~~}g«T e) |I"ERJ· !}tK t}eR!K t eRq}t¨!U}t¨|E" }t¨s}¬!iR UE²aT t}e$²|
U}tp"$ t² eRq~| :}¬" tU}eyKU«²RLKyEUy¨ ,L}g·¤{| :~y$K}tK}tEÕK}J}e~$y y ":| :~"L¸G
yRA¨$T~:Ã}¤R¤| p¨$T~«T:$¶y y $ $"·"}tE 5yÄ% "´~~$R~,lT"EE=&! ¤T{|}¬~
~">}e~5$y}¬y eETU| y t~~5}t,| ~"|R$:yK ¤
¡4µ}g¨R Kl¡
{|J~E$"}tK}tElK}9}e~Õ :}e$ t²+~$9}¬|L$K}t$y A~Õ,$ e 5~qp }tK}±$E 5$E t² ~´~qG%"y 5iR UE²
t}e·²iU"$K~$¤yÈe$Ly~4U,«L~T yRE$· $«L R~²RE| ´~}E}tG¨3yRp eJyR Ri}e=|L Ri
}tEU ~}t¨ eE¡}t¨}i}¬"RKp}t 9E~U i~" "¤¯: |LEL¨|| /~E$K}t"}y9KU}t}e~J~}¬p e9yy EK§=}~
$~UK}¬3U}eR) KRL´~| R:Lp:T$| iR¶}t"U}e pT"E}e~R¤Èeq$y }t´~ «T´|}eEU}e²L}t¨$|$G¨ ´~}t
}tK tU}tR Ä,· y g U}g¨9| $}tp}tq E"~iyR,$L}tK tU}eR¤5Å L"E Ai| ~ |$ E tyR²9«$·
"EL~$q$ q$L }±$¤
¥yK g²/qT}"}e$E 5~U }±´~pÃ"'¹R §GEÄyKq« R~$+R| J´~U}t3K}±R/R D| }e e t}g~q i$ ~§4,| }ty|
´~~qK tU}eG~|}g«T:$U| JyG¨$·9}tK tU}tR9yK}tU}tR Õ eR¨"}ti~K}e$~$¤"¹RL
K R"~+$!EL"$¨ ~E$"}"}tE KU}t!.¢¿ KRi| Ô }"$sÅRU´~$¤=ÈUs$|L:R~§| "}t ~JU|J
"3· EiRL´¡±T"EEU·¨ E¡±G}tEpKyU}±R}t}t U tU}±RK/~"|yT e)«+~~$}tK$):}|)q t}T
¢¿ ±~~5}t3E ,~~p}y 4Ky à Ĥ:R"Rir:}¬¨ ÃE Ä"}t "¹RLGÆ~5$ "RE|iñ~}¬¨
« $|ªKER}U}ey ELJ®,¯,°&i$ e~Ķy«Uy}g¶E~UU}tp"$~,RÔp¤gŦ¤T~y$K}tU}tEp"U}t~A|1K$R¨ pU"R ¢p" §
:}|+iyR,$«LER ¿ ÃU e$~~,|·|E ±, "'¹RÆ~3 E g $ĤÁ³ Er ,Ky$}t/à ¢G¢£RÄ,y ¬~+~J
T|}e ± }g~Õ piG$ e e}g¨ªU+$~UU}tp"i}g }¬ }ey E · EpiR/~y$K}tK}tEp"U}t~"=¥Ç Ô>$y EU"}e$~,RL
| =T}eR)¢¡ L¢¢E¤R{|,E gT´~=R| q´~U"}tp"$i~E$"}tK}tE,"U}t~A"$R¨ ,U"R¸¢T¤ l}t 4R¨y U)E¤
}tpµ}t ty T¤E{|²3y e~K$~UT|L|G²L´| $~}e~|E t ¥ÇÔ@$y EU"}e$~5UEE5U|L%~yi%~E$K}tU}ey"U}tq$ qK¾ $
|}e~ |²RT$U| $~}¬~ R | ,| elT"}eT¤4µ}tE t t² §4U|L²~| R>U|,~E$"}U}tyª"U}t~U·¹ J| }g¨| Õy g$~l}t
~"«T¡± "}e~RA eR>}t" U}eRJKU´~§~"¨G¨ ´~U}t¨pU||L T|}e e t}g~ q}¬~= y¡ e}t EAG U}eRRAE E
}tK tU}tR¤{| ) ·+UKR Á5 Esr ÕKE$}t!à ¢¢£ÄJ:}e t :| KR) KRL}e L"²7}¬·"K$~UK}¬¨
$Rp yK}e~R+:}|9y K$~" K~ÕKRA:~R ~$¤Dµ}t~U ² §4qp:}e ± «p·« e,"Ep E",| i"´~ K~ÕKE| y
~}g¨pUqiE "U}tL,i| e¨ }e$~$»E| $}t~1« R~JRp| ! D| }e e t}g~= :· iy ~1« ~$lRªi~UU "E
®,¯,°:¤Å ER G t² §l:!q} ± J K }e!y}U}eRy }t ~}¬¨|EK~"¨yKR}t¨7| & gU}e<~E$K}tU}tE!"U}t ~
}e~"T~}tR>R ª}tiT~}t¨a"¡±² E+K ± }¬¨>´~U}t3KE~§Õ,|}e$|&:}e t p "R }eG.~T :"$~U"J| $}t
|²RT´| ´~}e~5R ¡U t}t EEGK¡}t" U}eR,UUy´¡RU¤
#:Rq §=ÂAE e ,Ã ÄqR}tEK~yi~L"E ,~|LU$Ri}tG¨G~R,| D| }e t e}g~J 9$G KRE|»| 9y"¡
}tK tU}tR:UKy$¡URK5}e~A~~"i$:ppR}tiEG~U$E|"y ¨|LER| '«~}tL´~~1$² $ ±:ÃU}U¤R¤R~~i$,Kq«TAU|T
~·i%y "}t¨i}e~}¬" tU}e3· :y$E$ eKU}g¨i}tK tU}eRi}e~$~Ĥy{|}e~5$LKRE|pE e~pEy ~UUKy}g·"~U| yG
$~U+R¶"}t¨|EU}t¨º}tK t}eyI"@«| a~yi"+E t l}~}g U t}eR ~)ELK}t¨s@¨L}t a"}tia~"}e´~·¤{| $~
~~"qU}eR ~5yKA$EG~}¬~KE4:}|3"y·T| $RU}e$y · pq}tK}t$y L3y$K$yR Ri}t,}t ~}¬¨|EK~¤
}eEU}±U}e$U}tRiRG}¬~}t U tU}±RiT}e~RE~§y«Uy}g $q«²i eR$$U}g¨ UT·¹ ~· UKyL¨| ~}t,| }LU U}eR,U"
Ã$"}L$<R~º$EUK$ }tL´¡$ELE i}¬¨<y K$¨LsRy E }t U tU}±RĤ #3| $E tT U$~|
L:T tU}g pyG5 e~~Ã}¤¤yU| q~" AyG¨·~Ä5R E·|i "$$K}tL$ªT}¬~$§T· Jy«UE}g ~}tpU|L}¬~
pEG A·´~U}t3Kq| p~E$"}tU}y:"U}tlKRE|}e~}tLU U}eR¤G{|$~p$~UU}tp"$~"$R¨ qUKR «T$ eR½¢q"
$«LER£T¤¿§,}U|i·i$ K·¨ E e~³"9E¤ ¿ÀÃ}¤R¤Rq·|i eR:|$p }ey~=´~U}tp"´~ĤRÂAE t eÆ~A· "y|
U9yR ~UUULU}tR¨~y$K}tU}eyª"U}t~ |~ ¨ KU$9py²$U}t ªEK~ y 9$L }±$U}tR ~§«R|}e~l }e~GE¡
~" E}t"}'iU| G§G e}t¹L%E" g²i´~U"}tp"´~«L~$pR T|L} ± e}g~5 UL´~§G}e~ $L}eq e}ti}U}eR ~$¤RÁA$$| e"}r
°}t·|ªÃ ¢¢Ä5$K}U}ty}y:ÂAy t Æ~A· "y|iKR5~~"Gi}t¨ªE·|ª}e~}¬ U tU}eª}e~AKq«TÕ¨ K$iR ¬²p« ²i
iR EU²l e}t·²~| }te· JKR5 ¨ ±$U}t¨i| p}¬: yAR~"L t²~| R$¹ ~=$ J$| =pELª~| R$¹ ~,ÃU~" ·|
~ªiR ²aiya~|$¹ ~lU}e~$E :~| $¹ ~ÄlRU|L«T|E}ey JRi}¬" tU}tRa· yGpy K}¬¨U| $~
}e~}t" U}eR L}¬~$~$¤{|~E$K}tU}eyJK}9$~U"}tp"´~ $R e|R~3« l« }t~$§5}¤R¤T| ²yET e9$R ~U"}UJ
}e~"²pi$R~" "%RT| "KK~ARiRLUyU²pEREU"EU}tR¤yµT |"iR´§LÁAE|LeU}Trº°}t$|ià ¢¢ÄTU$¹ }e~~"T
:}| "'¹R Æ~&ÃEÄ.$ qRKR r ,}tG¨GÆ~sÃy ÄiG$ e e}tG¨©$ "RE|©UR| $}ta}t$· E$}²<"
}e~UU}¬¨R }e~|q«:$:U|L~=iR UyU²qR e}t·²i}tpT ¬~$~5KE~" U}¬¨3U"R>U ,~"| }te}tqT e}t$²p$ ,| ~A|
~}tqT t²ªK e5$¶ GR¨ y~=K$~"TR ~=Kl$|$¨LE~}¬ | :$yR Ri}±3~}LU}eD¤G{|}e~=¹}t J« "y¹ RRq
« Uq$aTR¨ LET~liR UyU²)R e}e²a~| R$¹ ~l$ . R¨ LET~i·| R"}²EU}±R ~J}e~l² p´~~E"}y }t
RKUq$RK"$U t²iE g U|Ly TU"$K~5R}e~}t" U}tR¤
{|A}e~=|²¶Á=$·| ±K}r °=}t$|¶Ã ¢¢ÄK§" ¬² }t¨¶y¶Á=$$$| eU}5ÃÄK§4$R ~UU ~EK}tU}tEqK}´~U"}tp"´~
« R~ºR>~UU Ky p®¯,°Éi$ e~$»=U|}e~)$LKRE|&Ui}K~+| @K}tU}eRº¶!R}e~UU}¬"}eR&« U:$·
~UU UE 5~" g²/~| R$¹ ~,· ¶~UU "E RpEL¶~"| ¹ ~y¤L¯« R py e e§}·« e$~|Li$UK$"~,R=iR UE²
t}e·²',«T=« KR¹LiR,i}tEUq:~² ~UUp"}ÕERq E$q:~UUG|R~UU}t,yR:TR E¤y{| ""i$$q«
$R ~}e9~ KE}eRL}eR¶|,$~$"}«T$~,| J$~"G~$~iR| JiR EU²9L t}e$²·|RK}K}±´~ÕU
U g U}eR ~ }t~iE"}t$« e$~§³,|}e ei|L¶ t±UqE·E}t ~pyU}eR ~ U | yEUKy 5« $¹¶|Õ$$ Æ«T
ty}t $)« ² | 9yU}eRLK}e.Ã}U¤¤³iR UE²T t}e·².~| R$¹ ~Ĥ5{| 9E}¬ | !}¬~ Ua$~UU}¬3K|T
}tq EJRqU| $~9iR EU²!~"| ·¹G~R«T$U|!yRi· a}¬" tU}tR¤AÈI$RpGU}t¨!L:T tU}tL}tqT ¬~
K$~" G~LK}eG~ KRq+¨}¬ /U}¬i| R}ERñ K$~"Lª$+U9«TK}¬ J² E~ÄK§AÁA$$·| ±U}%r °}e|à ¢¢Ä
E" ²¢¿9¤R{| $}t$~UU}tp"$~~$7Kq«T=| }t¨|L t²ª~ ~}U}¬ AK,|L®,¯,°@i$ ~"T$$}eU}e$U}tR §L:$y g~}tG
|4p$G²3$| 5~U R}e$~~}tG¨'|L%~UU Uy ®Õ¯'°i$ e t}t¨p$G KRE|q|$ ~}¬yyRK}t"i$¤
Èay l$~/~"T$$}eU}e$y t t² §| }e~i| $U| $~+y ie·"}eRa~}¬ EJU|L9E}t ,| }e~l · ª}e~p"RK·
$Rp yK}e~R ~«T$|iE$"~~5Ey EU"}e$~5$ pRL"}tiR¤RÈe ·« t´~³~A$~"Ty}tE e t²,"p$E t tUR e e}tG¨i´~U"}tp"´~
RT| %~E$K}t"}y"U}tq}t3R"4U,«TeKE g U| t}iT|L}¬~5}¬ R}e$UR¤
{'Õ "E$y "´~5"5$~UU}tp"}t¨,| ,~y$K}tU}eE=KU}t:·E4U,|· :RpU$LELKEE" t²¦»RR,| , =|· §
| iU|LR eR¨²!}tEU"y E$.« ²@ÂA t pÃGÄK§,|}e·|IEUy}e e~$y e t}t¨| yl$~UJRJK}t¨|EU}¬¨
}tK tU}tRaR " }ey~ t² ¡}eEK}t"}e$ }e~}t" U}tRa}e~E~Ó=$ R| 9$U|L |· §5| 9~UUUL Ky =®%¯,°
i$ ± e}t¨p$LKRE|p}g:~%~}tE%Á=E| ±U}ÃĤ
{|9·| R}eE«T:$| $~JUq iU|L~T ~R | UL~9R:|L~U R²¤5ÂAE ± ¬Æ~Ji| R e¨²
$ e}¬ ~i~}¬:T eJ$ i· }t¨T $~UU}tp"$~iR| ~E$"}eU}tEJKU}t§5· "ELK}tUl,|L}¬~ t}G¨}tK tU}tR
$pyGy²Ei}tE~1ELK}tR¨i~"$$}±U}e$p}e~}t U tU}eRi}e~G´~5· q,| p$y t² ~}t¨,| K"i}t$EK~1T|T
yR$~U1A}¬" tU}tR$$~$~$¤ l |L$ e´~~§T}AR t²l K }e$~1R}tEA$~U"}t3K$~=| p~E$"}U}ty:"U}t§
$E t tK$ KR yU}t ty· $ELEUU² ¡U~"T$E}t"} }e~}tK t}G~§i|L« ² py¹ }t¨ }}tUK}± 9K RK·
$R $ g~}eR ~U"R ~y$K}tU}eEqKU}tR²yi}tE~,R=UKR©}tE"$U}y ERp yK}e~R ~ÕR$~UK}¬3K$~$¤LÇR §
ÂAE t Æ~5iU|G eR¨²p$~ Æ4TKp}T| $UK$"~5iR UE²: R e}t·² ~"|L$¹ ~UÕ« }e~ tU$T¤
Å }gEp| JE}t =U|}e~q · :}e~,~U R²~E$K}tU}tEJ"U}t ~ E²Gyi}tE~ ,}| }t¶| K9yK¶RL| l R~U
|}t²p²Ly~5$Lp yi}tLÕ| | | ¨KyELE LEy ~"R,EK~5,yRpiRliR UyU²q e}t$²p|R~UK}g¨¨ $
"R$´~~1ERG ¨ y%}¬:| $~KU}t~§ Á1$$$| e"}eÆ~AôGÄ~UU Ky ®,¯,°.i$ e ±}t¨p$ "RE|p:yT e
~$<"l« iq$LKy K}tU´§~}¬yi}5 "R}e$~,· UL }tE""U$~UK}¬3KpR| i~E$"}tU}eEqKU}t¤L{|
$"·}y p}t ~UU·« }e t}U²sJ$~" K~9GT }tG¨sR!i$ J~" E}tK}t$}eR ~ÃR~+KR$!}t!3y²spT}tK}t$R
«²p$| G~}t¨,U| ~yi=i$ ~"Ty}tK}t$U}±R3"Ry$|pEyL·U²p:}| }¬'|L,LKER R¤ "= ·y g²G~}e~|R~A t}eE~
E tRG¨ª| J~$il e}t $~,R~,"yEp }tK}e$y ~U G}e´~ÕUK Á1y| eU}5ÃÄK§ÁA$$$|Le}rÀ°}t$|/à L¢¢ÄK§R
ÂARL%rºÇ) ¾ y ÃEĤ
&%~UU$T,}|'|LKG ±R:}t¨q« }tyK}tU1´~UK}tK$Õ®:$UR¯:°¨K$~~} î,¯,°ÄiG$ K»
+
∆ Φ +
∆ Φ
=
∆
+
∆ Φ +
∆ Φ
=
∆
= − = −
= − = −
µ π π
µ
π
= ÃÄ
,|
}e~| = eR¨p!! U}gi5K§
π | }tLU U}eRpKUA«L:$,K}ti5K¡A$L%U}¬i³ $~~$:Rpy
$RR y « ~}¬~§$ µ =[µµ ]′ | KRR}tLRU}eG~§4,|}e$|+$REUE}t ~=| i~"|L$¹ ~=|=EUU|T
$URRLR¨ y~yK}t$« ±´~
[∆ ∆ ]′
=
! π" TU}gi5¤
ÈeA}e~R~~"i$p| #
$
%
&
Σ
≈()(+* '
,µ §D| - ñE"}t$E$¡UyREK}t·yq3UK}¶R|Lp}t RU}tR $UR"Ä }e~5,R}t$¨ Ry L3UK}¦¤
ÈI|}e~9LK$~UU"}"$s"L$~·U}tR §,| a}¬ R}G~ .
/µ · 01µ $$ Æ« R~$K}g« $&$²>ERLRi}e
}tE" KU}D¤4ÅL}LEU| Õ ~q|Lp}e~AU T e}tE}U t²+y g U| p}tq E=RAii· ~| R·¹¶RJ«$|
}tK tU}tR3· qKE !! ¦§,=p~U t}t¹,| 1 K$~UU"}tK$q®,¯,°.i$ RUq}"~ K t²L}t¨i~UUULUE LU"¤
{|KÆ~l|².:/~$¹U.´~U"}tp"ª| +K t e:}t¨a~UU "E =®¯,°©iG$ e§R~J UKyU$ UKR Á=$$| e"}
à Ļ
22322
45
+
∆ +
∆ +
∆
=
∆
+
∆ +
∆ +
∆
=
∆
6 6
6 6
= − = −
= −7 = −
8 7
8 9
8
9
8
8
9
8
9
9 7
8 7
8 :9
8
9
8
9
8
9
8
9 ;
<
;
<
; ;;
<
;
< = =?>>> =
@
> =
= = =>
@
=>
=)=
A
A
A AAA
επ
π π
ε π
π B
C DEEED
F= Ã Ä
,|
[ ]′
= ε επ
εG GH I G }e~5| Õ KRA}tG yU}eRl KRyE~~§LÕ|}±$|ªyREUE}g~5|L:~"| R$¹ ~5"i$¨G¨"¨":~"L t²
ε $qy¨¨K¨"3y πε ¤${| py p}e~U « $$}e~5~~i$,Uq«TÕiR UE² ~"|L$¹»U| }e~ $EL}"
K$~UU"}tU}t =~~"LqU}eRi}e~|L Ky $yLEKU yeR| | }tE:~}¬:T eA«T}tE"}tU1®,¯,°iG$ T}t ~UKR
R,iRyR:T e}t$$9i$ ~§,| }t$|yKJKyL }gÁ=$$$|Le}r °=}·|à ¢G¢ÄU¨ KUJ "²| }g¨L|
}tq y}e~}tR©}g>U| s~E$K}t"}ys"U}t $~UU}tp"´~¤pÈe}e~@y ¬~<R~~"Li$sU|
Ω
≈
ε §J|
ΩñyK}t$yE¡ERE"}t$E=pU"}iRT| = "}G RU}±R:LUy´~~Ä}e~5,R}t$¨ Ry L3UK}¦¤
ÁAy ~}eK}t¨¶| ¶~UU UE A}e~U U« ·$´~l~l R¨ LET~pyK}t$« ±´~ $ )$ g² }¬¨ &R eÆ~JERpT~}K}±R
| $R"ɲ }e$ e~q| +}tK}tL}"®:"RpÇR}tG¨¯Õ "$¨ +î,Ç)¯'ÄqLK$~EUU}eR %| ¶~UU "E 1i$ e§
,| }t·|9:}e e 5E e ±R<T~pU}t~UA9ERpRUpU| J~² ~U" }tqL e~l$~" G~$~,U~UU LUE A~"| R$¹ ~qy JU|R~"
$~UK}¬3K~E$"}U}tyKU}t~$»
+
=
∆
+
=
∆
∞
=
∞
= −
−
∞
=
∞
= −
−
π π
ε ε
π
ε
ε !
" #%$&$&$'#
(= ÃU£RÄ
ÈRK,U)iR U"R | $y E$)iG$ %UR"É}t÷Ä%¶| +~UUUL UE =K K$~·U}tRà ÄK§A~qR
}eEU}±U}e$U}tR e$~q}e~q$yT}tK$T¤{59K}tL´~U}tp"´~ =| J$UK$K~ R'~UU UE 5}e~U « $$$~ )
*ε · ε+π §,lp~UR~~"iq|A|l KR,R}tLRU}eG~ ,
µ }e~qJ t}t E,$:«T}tU}±ERA| J~}¬:T U$ $y~
~UU UE T~"| R·¹G~
ε ¤EµD|KiR$§E|L'~UU UE T~"|$¹ ~5yKALK$~" i$,"Õ«1 ER"K$ tU$qy q|$ 1 L}
E"}·E$~§G,| }t$|:K$ ~ tU´~1}tEK -
=
Ω §G| . }¬~| ,}±EU}U²l3UK}¦¤R{5p$Rq e"³| }eE"}tK}t$U}±R
R|Li~UUUL UE 4®,¯,°&i$ e§:pq~U1EyAy}"} E ~~"qU}eR ~¨E"R}t¨iU|LpE gTp=¤Ã±¡Ä/
yU$iK~pñ,|Ll}e~| JRL:«TqR, ¨ y~qyK}t$« t$~Ĥ4ÈUy ,$R~´§10 TÓq:|T~q $$9RT
K}eG·"}tU² }¬¨3"´~UK}tU}e §,|}e$|p$$q« $¹ pUKR>$yR Ri}eA|L$²¤
µR e ±R:}tR¨Â t$·|yKJr32= $| Æ~à RÄ5p}tK}t$y q¹~1,$ e R~%Á1$·| eK}r °}t|Æ~à ¢G¢ÄA$~UU}tp"´~
R%~y$K}tK}typK}~§EL%yR}K}tRE 5}eE"}tU² }g¨¶$~UU"}}eR9}¬~=|=$¨R¨¨Kl3y +~"| ·¹G~qà $"$~
ε+π l EU}e D R,Ä5|$ Õ qT"p$ EAK"1EpU|L, e $ "y ! ¦§G ±}t¹ y¨¨K¨Uq~" ¬²~"| G¹G~
Ã4)
*ε ĤyÈUi$| :RK~§y| Lp tU}¬ , eRR¨¡i$UK$R,py 3~| R$¹JRpE !! +}e~5~~ i$,Uq«T
}eEU}±U²}t¨pK$~UU"}"}tRp$$,| q«=,K}e"3R~$»
=
∞
=
ÃÄ
&iE"iy,E":| eR¨ ¡9 UKy t}²R,i ²}e~q $ET$~UU}eR·« eJ|²RT$| $~}e~y»¦~ KE | $RU}e$y R~
:$ e R~,p }t"}e$E 4 ·~UG~}t¨+Rª| lLKyKp|y i~"| RÕ¶K$y· t²ª|1iR UyU²JG }±$²¶~|LEL e
|$ p·¶KK=RJ$"·}y yRyT%" K|² ~U"$~}e~ %$U"$K~ ¤ {|A}e~=|²:pE e~3U²$E "U}tT
}eEU}±U²}t¨iR~~"qU}e:UiR}e~U"}t¨R }e~|q«T:$:| ,~" ¬²3· ipy p~| R·¹G~y»y:~~"iAU|i$T
~"| R·¹G~l) $Õ|$ E }t ~UU··$ $y~JUK$qR }t U t}eR §5 e}¬¹ ¶~"G t²~| R$¹ ~$¤È´| :RK~§|
$RE"pRK· ET~ "K+!py 7~"|L¹>R7}t" eU}tRº}e~9~~" i$@U!«T y"¤{|}e~~| RK¡
}eEU}±U²}t¨pK$~UU"}"}tR,UK·G~ U$~5}tEKT»
=
ÃRÄ
Ô G5| pÃ$y}":"´~UK}t"}t ÄA~~"LqU}eRi|| q$¨¨¨UpG3y ~| R$¹ ~}eE"}tK}e$}¬ | 3~UU UE
®,¯,°ºERK"´~RLiU9~"| }teK~q}tª| ª~U$EJR=iR UyU² G }±$² §$9$~UU}tp"i5U|Li~E$"}"}tEpKU}t¶$·«
y«Uy}t $"|,R~}e t²~}t¨JU| ®,ǯ $~EUU}tR/ÃK£Ä¤ÁARq}t¨ª| i}¬:T e~p$~"TR ~pLK}eG~
² }e$ ±~1´~K}tp"$~AR yU$iK~
§
§
·
¤y{|$~y$UK}tE}±·"~5:}e t Ty e tR!~"p$E t tUA|
~y$K}tU}tE"U}t
τ
!
y ¨}t ,U}ti=| R"}$R#"¤
{|LRi}t"RTU|}e~5KU}tp}e~| Lp tU}¬ K}tE T$"KR,i UE²:L e}t$²i~|L·¹ ε$π $¹
A}ipÕR| J}tK tU}eyKUi eL$ AAU}tip&%'"´§,|}e ep|LiRLi$KUR,R³| ~y$K}tU}tEJKU}t+:y e«
$U}tL$:R~| qT U}t yG t~~«Uq$:U}tiE~$L%&%'"K t e:}t¨,| ,~·iiR UE² ~| $¹ ε$π »
}}e~5L´
¾
~U| pT tU}g ,$U"$4| }e~A}e~U U« ·$,R:| E !! + e $ TU}¬i³(%)"´§G«R|,~"L<R
}K~q$UK$"~|Ky ¨G||LiK}t~U*"p K}e~qR~Õ:$ e U¤{|ª~y$K}tU}tElK}9$·|T~Õ K}tp"$ t²+«l,K}e/R~q
"}eRpT|L"}ti=| RK}ER#"´§G$qERq"$:R~5UR e eR3~·»
=
= =
+
= +
=
= τ
τ
τ π
τ π
δε δπ
δε δ
τ
ÃRÄ
{|}e~,~UU}e~U}$y K}tL}}eRJK"$U t²p$| $~| i t}KKy R q¨L}t J }ty~ ¬²¦»R| i~y$K}tU}eEqKU}t$$+}t
UE« ~$s~| L:T tU}g }¬: yR ! < ± $ pUKR @iy UyU²! R e}t·²7~"| ·¹a|J,yT e
E y e t²pK$y y%}¬" tU}tRq«²iR 1KyEU$¨ 1 }tE4« :$'"}ti$~$&%)"¤
!"$#%'&)($*,+-%/.0*
1325432687:9$;=<?>@<=ABC7DFEGBHBJI)A-B;DLK:</K
{|1 ~RTU| }e~ · }e~Kp$~UU}tp"q~E$"}U}±E"U}tpUR5y|iT| A:$ tL%¥ÇÔ!EyLEUK}e$~5R |
K}eG!R »¡ L¢¢£4»L§,| }t$|):y e9E ± eR ~ÕUE ¬ Up|L¨$R:~UU Uy A}e~"T~}eEi¨
| $~9Ey EU"}e$~$¤ s+~ $y EUK g²IRURE ,K~~ ,RiE~K}t "y JÃ!! Äp· }tLU U}eR"U$§
$U}tL$i~5|L,$R y 4¨"RU|JKU,R¦| :Á=R ~"Li K}ty,ÈU G¶ÃUÁ 4ÈUĤ! 9Uq|$«T$$R "$
}tEUq eR¨E"}|ª~AÃ$L:L´"$M!! 4Ĥ$¯T R}i¯A$~$"}«T$~| $~=U,}gp |LGUy}t ¬~·¤
¯º K$ ±}ti}tE²~UU}tRyK}²$E ¬²G~}¬~ÕRU|L3~"}e$~,ÃERK"$ eR¨K· ~§T¯L¨iEK$ ,}e$¹L²G¡µD e e%ï!,µÄA·
T|}e ± }g~¡ ¦K"RiK$~UK~Ä~"¨¨ $~UK~1U|1KE !! )$ }¬" tU}tRKUqEKÕ«T´|ÈÃÄ5LKREE~~$~,ÃU}U¤R¤LKE !!
$J}t U tU}eRJK,« $|EREUy}qL}1K$UÄA}tE·|¶RAEL:$ t p$yLEUK}e$~$¤GÈU¶$| Aq~§D}5·E~
| $}U|LAR| qª~"}e´~=}e~~UU}±EyU²¤R{|}e~=K}g }¬¨i "y }e$~~" RKR| ,G$K}t}K}±RªRA~E$"}U}tR
K}@~q$ e :R~+URy iG$ 3~E}tK}t$U}eR¤={| LRi}tUR+R3| ~E$"}U}±E"U}t!G´~}sUy
$RK"´~"TR ,",| ,L:T tU}tL,$UK$5RqiR EU²ª~| ¹y3| q}tK tU}eyª"UR»}tRKGUi· }tiE
i}tUR§=}t}eR ~J}t| 9}¬" tU}tRKU+UKRÉ}K~}g }U}ty , e $ q~U3« TKp$L·lÃU}U¤R¤$ ¾ ~U
UU·G~}"²Ä¤ÇRR §5y q eR¨ ¡UG}eEU}±U²}t¨$~UUK}tU}tR$EL}$~ y¡U~UUU}tREK}² RU|Lª"R !
~K}e$~§L~}¬y:E"R~~"L3}tG¨:|T| ·¨¨¨U,~" ¬²ª~"| R$¹JTK~5T3y E}t:LE'| ,yG
|¤$M¦R~UU g² §LKE ! ¶·p}¬" tU}tRiyK~~i$,KpyREUE}¬i,}"R´,}U|L}tiy ³~ $$}eU}e$U}tRiiG$ Ó
|}e~5~~:RK}eyqK"" t²i~" }K~5y RU¤
{|KÆ~|²py ~UU Ky ®¯,°.i$ e~5E"$R ~UU "q:}|q«T´|,| $y EU" g²i|y¨L}t,U|L eR¨iRKR
K%ÃU}t~UR}eU"ER$R y }¬" tU}tRpKU´§G$K$ qÈpµÄ¤
132 2 B 7:<L< 9 BH=< CK >-H=BH< A K BA6 9!7:< JI AB;DLK:9 K
{|J"}~U:~U }gy q´~U}t3U}eR9LKRE$y EUy} e~ $| ~}¬¨¶| y"}tpE = ·¨ e¨E|}tE|yELEUU² Æ~
®,¯,° i$ Ó| }e~p t$¨ e¨E|)p~U«L~ UK}tE}±·=U9¨L "UJ KRqÕ| }KE¡±L}e~}¬LRU}eG~§²
p~U³ $5«,"J|L}t¨|:}|+K$~"$Ky ~$qT ep e¨E|/ÃR t² $y yU~}¬/E·|yy EU²Ä¤Lµ45U|}~
| }ty´§:l3y¹ qT~lA«T$|/}¬"RKp}eR¶$"}"}tñ¯,¹ y}g¹ i· 9Å ·|,E i$K}UK}tyÄ$L¶ e}¬¹ $ e}g| K}e
U$~UK~,ÃU~UEU}g¨:}U|l3 }tpL©p ty¨ ~$L3| i"E~UU}g¨,|L| %R1 $U|Lp R~UA t$¨+}¬~Õ~}t¨ }t"}$·EUĤ
{|E"}y~l$"}"K}t~"¨¨L´~U|:Uy p t·¨G~lyKiU«lU$¹"Rpy$|R%|LiUq$ t +$ELEUK}±´~§³,| }ty|
:yT e~$ K~R·« e¨}¬ ¶U|L~EqT e e¨E|$ )RU+UK$y ·²¤{|}e~p"´~"L ÕE e~9$Ty~ÕU+«
$R ~}¬~KE4:}|,| 5U| $RU}t$E T t$¨ ~5}t,| =}t U gLERi UE²:L ±}·²3iER·Õ "}y´~K¤
¯, $| iLK e}ti}tE²a3yU¹@:T~Up«T"RU,E"$ «T"KLU}t¨!y JeUEK}±RU| )$E t tU}tRIG
~y$K}tU}tE,"U}t~$»}¬ªRUqU$¹ Õ}tEKpy$Ey E4| q$UK$K~1 q"p$ª"L }tK}t$U}eR §LqELpp²JEK}t·« e,}~
}tEU"yTE$}¬| :"3ya~²G~U RLqU| T"}eº´GE»¡E»¤ s+|$L9E e~ y$@TR¨ y~
E"}·« e$~}t¶R"5UpU$¹Li}gEKJE$yy E|Lp}t U gLEpR|Lp"Ky }tKiE¤LÇR, E}e~$ ² §4p
~=U:J y¨ LR~1EK}t·« e$~$»E| ,·|·¨ q}t3| pÔp¤Å¤R t tE5 "}t$:RA}t y:| ,·|$¨ q}tpU| Õ Ri}¬y
·|·¨ KU ~~| G e tE9䨤}t!| µ4K$|º®,¯,° iG$ ¬§3:.|· ~$| UK· / e ty
·|·¨ =KAEU}e 5G§R$| K /UR e tE $|·¨ KU~}tE5| Ĥ
{|q~$yR ª~K}tEL$~UU}tp"}tRi RE$y ,yR ~}e~UK~RAyR:GU}t¨pU|L:}tpG e~qK$~"TR ~,LK}±R ~R
| ,~"² ~U"sKq«L´|ip~" g²ª~"|L·¹i$ pqpyi~| R$¹¤E{|,}tq e~K$~"G~ U}±R ~AKE·| $q~}¬¨
| = eR¨ ¡3}±EK}tU²L}t¨pK$~UUK}tU}±R3yK=K R"$:}tq¯T }p¯, ¤
¯,¨¨¨K,~"G t²ª~| R$¹ ~A$yK²:| ,~K}±´~=R ! ¨"R%|i· i}g U t}eRiyK}tU}tRJ}tiyT~}KÕ}tK}eG~
R |L%~| RUGD¤yÇR"$R §y| Lp t}t }tp e~K$~"G~L U}±R ~A~"| RU|T| $UK$~"L$|p
~"| R·¹aRy ,yl}e~lT"p$ EK§=Õ| }e eJU|LKKlRU| 9}¬" tU}e"U+yK}e$~GT }tG¨aRU|T
$y EU²¦»yKR~RiÕEy EU"}e$~Aï~UU"}t§GµTK$$$§qKp$G²§ÕK$E$§3M p«Ty U¨p$ | iU|L" · ~ÄTU|T