Generating interoperability test cases from conformance test case generation tools

(1)

HAL Id: hal-00408505

https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00408505

Submitted on 30 Jul 2009

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Generating interoperability test cases from conformance test case generation tools

Ismail Berrada, Richard Castanet, Patrick Felix

To cite this version:

Ismail Berrada, Richard Castanet, Patrick Felix. Generating interoperability test cases from con-

formance test case generation tools. 24th IFIP International Conference on Formal Techniques for

Networked and Distributed Systems (FORTE’04), Sep 2004, Madrid, Spain. �hal-00408505�

(2)

&'(-.+/01!#$%&'$23"!#4$

576984:<;>=@?BACDCD:FEG:GHJI;LKMN:<CEPOB:Q6SRD:<TNARU:<TNEV.:-RDC9;LKWYXZ=>;\[

] ^`_acbd efBaBgdhijalknmno`oh0prqts*uDv7wxqzy7{_|vS}Fu~^FY

nn

o*k^\uDpruUu~}QuDGFFvS^npFu

uDvxvS^n}r^

|~^wyS^npru9y

|utqzJnB\^

v7q

v

,Jn` Fqtw J^uDv

|-rwxuw.|npwy7J}FqtpFu9qtup-y wx|n\Qy7qt|`prw

|nv}QuDv7qts<q\pF

|nv7§^

vS^n§uD£|nv7¤

|vUq\p-y7uDv7|nuDvS^

qt\qzy¨ Yy7uDwy7q\pF

^nwxu~}Y|`p¢^J^vS^n§uDyxv7qt©u}Y£.v7qzy7qtpr

|

y7Fuªqtp-y7uDv7|`u9vS^ qttqzy¡ «v7uD¬^y7qt|`prw cp®^nrQv7|*^9Y^npr}4^nwxwx|-q\^y7u~}^\n|nv7qzy7r§

qtwBy7Fup4qtp<yxv7|<}Qru}

|nvy7Fqtw

vS^§uD£ |v7¤N0w^|nprwxu~¯-FuprunG^`}F^nFyS^y7qt|`pY|

|nFvUv7uwxrzy7wy7|«|np

|nv7§^npFuy7uwy7qtpr«y7|-|ntw

|nv`upFuDvS^y7qtpF4q\p-y7uDv7|nuDvS^ qt\qzy¨

y7uwy7w°qtw

F\z ª^nQy7|`§^y7q\n*_ Uy7Fu£.^ -£ u.wxF|£±y7r^y%y7ruFv7|`|nwxu~}^rFv7|`^nS

^rrtqtuw

|vcy7uDwy7q\pFqtp«|np<y7u9Qy~

² ³r´cµ¶G·¸ª¹º»µG¼7·c´

VC9½QR9½K½F=N69¾ A`K;¬¿ K:<R9;>½QTN6:QC9AÀ 6SA`EjR9½,EAnÁQAn=¬½F¾j¾NC9½EÀNKRD6:QTNE469ACDÁr;LKA`6ÂFÃ@½AnTN6SÀNC9AUK½QC9Ä

C9A`K~R9TNAn6D6°½<ÅN69ÀNKM¾NC9½EÀNKRD6nHRDAn6SR9;>TGÆNHnR9MNAc¾GCD½KAn6D6°½QÅNKMGAnKWJ;>TGÆRDMN:-R :69ÇJ6SR9An8È¾ ½r6969An6D6SA`6

:P6SAR,½<ÅUEA`6S;>C9A`EÉ¾GC9½F¾ AnCSRD;¬A`6:<T E Ê*½FCË AnMN:*ÁJ;¬½FCD6nH%;>6R9MGAY½QTGA®½QÅR9MGA®À 6SA`E#Á*:Q=¬;LEG:<R9;>½QT

R9AnKMNTG;>ÌrÀGA`6ÂFÍ:<CD;¬½FÀN6.RDAn6SR9;>TGÆ,8«AR9MG½E½F=¬½FÆQ;>An6.MN:*ÁFAUË»AATY¾GC9½F¾ ½r6SA`E«:<TNE®:Q¾G¾G=>;¬A`E%ÂJÎªTNA

:<¾G¾GCD½F:FKMY;L6K½FTÅÏ½QCD84:<TNKAªRDAn6SR9;>TGÆNHN;¬T¢ÐMG;LKM:469;>TGÆQ=>A;¬8«¾G=>A8«ATrR:-R9;>½QT¢;L6K½F8j¾ :<CDAnE

R9½#R9MNAÑ67R:<TNEN:<CEÒRD½ÓË AÑ69ÀGCDA¢R9MN:<R4R9MGAÑ;¬8«¾G=>A8«ATrR:-R9;>½QTÔE½JA`64ÐMN:-R4RDMGAÑ6SRD:QTNEG:<CE

6S¾»AnK;\¿NA`6Õ R9MNA,RDMGA½FC9ÇË AnMG;>TNEK½QTÅÏ½FC984:QTNKARDAn6SR9;>TGÆ;L6R9MN:<R¦:<=>= K½QTGÅÏ½QCD8Ö;>8«¾G=>A8«ATÄ

RD:-RD;¬½FTN6R9½®RDMGA«:<ËN6SR9C:QKRª67R:<TNEN:<CEP6SMG½FÀG=LEP;¬TrRDACD½Q¾»AC:-R9A,Ð;\RDMÑAn:FKMP½<RDMGAC`H»:Q=\RDMG½QÀNÆQM

;¬T¢¾GC:QKR9;LKA¦R9MG;L6U;L6TG½QRUTGAnKAn6D69:QC9;>=>Ç«R9MGAKn:Q69AQÂGÃMGA½QR9MGAnC:<¾G¾NC9½r:QKMY;L6;>TrR9ACD½Q¾»AC:<ËN;¬=¬Ä

;\R7Ç#RDAn6SR9;>TGÆNH ;>T×ÐMG;LKMÒR7ÐB½Ñ½FC8«½QCDAY;>8«¾G=>A8«ATrRD:<R9;>½QTN6«:QC9A4RDAn6SR9A`EØE;>CDAnK~RD=¬ÇÓ:QÆF:<;>TN6SR

An:QKM½<RDMGAC`H%Ð;\RDMÑRDMGA467R:<TNEN:<CE±ÀN69AnEÉ:Q6:¾GCD;¬84:<CD;>=¬Ç±:F6¦:CDAÅÏACDAT KAR9½P:QE*Ù7À E;>Kn:-RDA

¾GC9½FËG=>A846:<TNE;>TNK½F8j¾ :-R9;>ËG;>=¬;¬R9;>An6nH°:<T E69AnK½QTNEG:QC9;>=>Ç±:Q6:ÆQÀG;LEAjR9½RDMGA«ÅÏÀGTNKR9;>½QTN6¦RD½

Ë ARDAn6SR9AnE¢:QTNE®RDMGAÆQAnTGAC:<=Ë»AMN:*ÁJ;>½QCBR9½4Ë»AA[¾»AnKR9AnE°Â

O0½QTÅÏ½FC984:<T KABR9A`67RD;¬TGÆ;>TN69¾G;>C9A`6.=¬;¬RSRD=¬A¦K½FT¿ EAnTNKA;>T«R9MGAÀN6SAnCcK½F8«8,ÀGTG;¬R7ÇQÂQ5xT®K½QTGÄ

R9C:Q6SRnHK½QTÅÏ½FC984:<T KAR9A`67RD;¬TGÆ¾ ½QR9ATrRD;>:Q=¬=>Ç¾GCD½-ÁJ;>EGAn6Ë»ATGA¿GRD6°R9½U:<T;>8«¾G=¬An8«ATrR9½FCEÀGCD;>TGÆ

R9MGAA`:<CD=¬Ç67R:<ÆFAn6½<ÅEAnÁQAn=¬½F¾G8«ATrR:Q6U:469;>8j¾N=¬A,KMNAnKWÂNÚÛ=>;¬8«;¬RD:<R9;>½QTP½<Å.K½FTÅÏ½QCD84:<TNKA

R9An6SR9;>TGÆÉË A`K½F8jAYÅÏC9½F8ÜR9MGAÆQAnTGAC:<=>;\R7ÇÉ½<ÅR9MGA¾GCD½<R9½K½Q=L6Ë»A;>TGÆÑRDAn6SR9A`E%H ¾N:<C9R9;LKÀG=L:<CD=>Ç

:-RR9MNAÎÝJ5ª8«½EAn=c:<¾G¾N=¬;LK:<R9;>½QTN6=L:*ÇQAnCnH%¾GCD½<RD½K½Q=L6:<CDAjR7Çr¾N;>Kn:<=>=¬ÇÁQACDÇÑK½Q8«¾G=>A[:QTNE

ÆQATNAC:<=¡Hr½QÞ»AnC9;>TGÆ«84:<TJÇ®½F¾R9;>½QTN6:QTNEKMG½Q;LKA`6Â

5xTl½FCDEGACjR9½ÒEA`K;LEA¢R9MNAÑK½FC9CDAnKR9TGA`696j½<Å:<Tß;>8«¾G=¬An8«ATrRD:<R9;>½QT°Hc:#K=¬A`:<C®KCD;¬R9ACD;>½QT

;>6¦TGAnAnEA`E%Â5xT±R9MNAjK½QTrR9A[rR¦½<Å0K½QTÅÏ½FC984:QTNKARDAn6SR9;>TGÆNH84:<TJÇ¢¾GCD½Q¾»½F6D:<=L6ÅÏ½FC¦69ÀNKMÑK½QC9Ä

C9A`K~R9TNAn6D6Y;>TàRDMGAÑÅÏ½FC98á½QÅ;¬8«¾G=>A8«AnTFR:-RD;¬½FTâCDA=L:-R9;>½QT 6YMN:*ÁFA±Ë»AATã84:QEAlä¬åFHDæ-ç¡ÂèUTÄ

ÅÏ½QC9R9ÀGTN:<R9An=¬ÇFH@;>TFRDACD½Q¾»AC:<ËG;>=>;\R7ÇR9A`67RD;¬TGÆÉE;LEÓTG½<RWrTN½-Ðé69ÀNKMÓÅÏ½FC984:Q=¬;>ên:<R9;>½QT°Â@ÚTG½<RDMGAC

(3)

E;>6DKÀ 6969AnEË An=¬=>½-ÐÂ

!#"ÔMN;¬=>A:¾GCDAnK;>69AªEA¿NTG;¬R9;>½QT®½QÅ@;>TFRDACD½Q¾»AC:<ËG;>=>;\R7Çj;>6

6S½F8jAnÐMN:-R.An=¬ÀN69;>ÁQAQH`ÅÏÀGT K~R9;>½QT :<=>=¬Ç,R9MGA8«An:QTG;>TGÆª;L6K=¬A`:<C%$*K½Q8«¾»½QTGAnTFR6.K½F8j8ÀGTG;LK:<R9;>TGÆ

Ð;\RDMj½FTGAU:<TN½<R9MNAC.K½FC9CDAnKR9=>Ç:<TNEj¾GCD½-ÁJ;>E;>TGÆªR9MGAA[¾ A`K~R9A`E«6SAnC9ÁJ;LKAn6nÂ<ÝJ½Q8«AUEA¿NTG;¬R9;>½QTN6

½<Å@;>TrR9ACD½Q¾»AC:<ËN;¬=>;\R7Ç«:<CDA&$JÃMGA:<ËG;>=>;\R7Ç«½<Å@R7Ð0½½QCB8j½FC9A¦6SÇ6SR9An8«6cR9½jA[GKMN:QTGÆQA;¬TÅÏ½FC984:<Ä

R9;>½QTP:<TNE8,ÀGR9ÀN:Q=¬=>Ç®ÀN69A¦R9MGA;>TÅÏ½QCD84:-RD;¬½FTYRDMN:-RUMN:F6Ë AnAT¢A[GKMN:QTGÆQA`E±ä'<çÂGÃMGA:<ËG;>=>;\R7Ç

½<ÅU:PE;L67RDC9;>ËGÀRDAnEÓ69ÇJ6SR9An8 RD½P;¬TrRDACKMN:<TGÆFA«V)(ªèª6,ÁJ;L:R9MGAK½F8j8ÀGTG;LK:<R9;>TGÆ¢¾G=>:<RSÅÏ½FC98

ä*-ç¡ÂÃMJÀN6nHFRDMGA:QK~RD;¬ÁJ;¬R7Ç«½<Å@;>TrR9ACD½Q¾»AC:<ËN;¬=>;\R7ÇjRDAn6SR9;>TGÆjK½QTN69;L67R6c;>TKMGA`KWJ;¬TGÆjK½FC9CDAnKR0½Q¾GÄ

AC:-R9;>½QT 6.½<Å°:69ÇJ6SR9An8 ½QÅ°K½Q8«¾»½QTGAnTrRD6nÂFÚKK½QCE;>TGÆ¦R9½®äzæåç¡H-RDMG;L60:FK~R9;>ÁJ;\R7Çj6SMN½QÀG=LE4KMGAnKW

½QTG=>Ç,A[rRDACDTN:<=8«A`696D:<ÆFAn6R9MN:<Rc=>An:QERD½;¬TrR9AnCSÄxK½F8«¾ ½FTGATrRK½F8j8ÀGTG;LK:<R9;>½QT°Â<ÃMG;L6.;L6.TG½QR

R9MGAYKn:Q69A«½<Åä+<çc;¬T#ÐMG;LKMÉR9MG;L6,:FK~RD;¬ÁJ;¬R7ÇÑ6SMN½QÀG=LE#KMGAnKWÑ:QT#;¬TrR9AnC9½F¾ AnCD:QËG;>=¬;¬R7Ç±CDA=L:-R9;>½QT@Â

ÃMGAj:QÀR9MN½QC6Ær:*ÁQA,TN;¬TGAj;>TFRDACD½Q¾»AC:<ËG;>=>;\R7Ç¢CDA=L:-R9;>½QT 6ªEAn¾ AnTNE;>TGÆ½QT±RDMGA«:<CKMG;\RDAnKR9ÀGCDA

ÀN6SA`E%Â

-,./1023/4%563 !YÃMGAYEAnÆQCDAA«½<Å½FËN6SAnC9Á-:QËG;¬=>;¬R7ÇÑ:<TNE#K½QTrR9CD½Q=>=>:<Ä

ËG;¬=>;¬R7ÇQH-:<TNER9MGAK½FT¿NÆFÀGCD:<R9;>½QT½QÅGR9MGAK½Q8«8,ÀGTN;>Kn:-R9;>TGÆ¦6SÇ6SR9A846MN:*ÁQAB:UÆFC9A`:-R;>T7NÀNATNKA

½QTR9MGA;>TFRDACD½Q¾»AC:<ËG;>=>;\R7Ç:<CKMG;¬R9A`K~R9ÀNC9A0R9½:QE½F¾RnÂ<ÃMNAÚª67RDC9;LEA:<CKMG;¬R9A`K~R9ÀNC9A0½<Åä98`çÀN69An6

ÀG¾G¾»ACRDAn6SR9AC6:<T E:RDAn6SRK½J½QCE;>TN:-RD;¬½FTY¾GCD½KAnEGÀGC9AFÂGÃMGAÚ.Ã;:1XG½FC9ÀG8 ä<<ç°¾GCD½Q¾»½F69AnE

:YRDAn6SRK½QTG¿NÆQÀGC:-RD;¬½FTK½QTGTGA`K~RD;¬TGÆR9A`67RDAC6¦R9½R9MNA«EG;\ÞACDATrR5x8«¾G=¬An8«ATrRD:<R9;>½QTN6èTNEAC

Ã@A`67R.=Ï57èªÃ6>~H°:QTNE±¾N=>:FKAn6¦V ½Q;>TrRD6½QÅc½QËN69ACDÁ-:-RD;¬½FT?=ÏVBÎ@>:QTNE±V ½F;¬TrRD6¦½QÅO0½QTrRDC9½F=:QTNE

ÎªËN6SAnC9Á-:<R9;>½QT?=VBOÎ@>¦Ë AR7Ð0AnAT57èÃ6:<TNEË AR7Ð0AnATÑR9An6SR9AnCD6:QTNEÑ57èªÃ6nÂ.äA-ç.¾GCD½Q¾»½F69AnE

:,ÆFATGAnC9;LKª:QCDKMN;\RDAnK~RDÀGCDA¦EA`6S;>ÆQTNAnEY:F60R9½J½Q=>Ë ½*[®ÐMN½F69A¦K½Q8«¾ ½FTGATrR6K:<TË AK½QT¿NÆFÀGCDAnE

:Q6TGAnAnEA`E%Â

CB3 2D2!ÃMGAªC9A`KATrRBC9A`6SA`:<CKMjÐB½QCDW6½FT®;¬TrRDACD½Q¾»AC:<ËG;>=¬;¬R7ÇR9An6SRSÄ

;¬TGÆ:<CDAC9An=>:<R9AnEjRD½,69ÇJ6SR9An84:-R9;LKRDAn6SR06SÀN;\RDAÆQAnTGAC:-RD;¬½FT°ÂGä98`ç»ÐB:F6.½QTGA½<ÅR9MGA¿NC67Rc¾ :<¾»AC6

;¬TYR9MGAª¿NA=LE%ÂÃMGA:<¾G¾NC9½r:QKM4:QE½F¾R9A`E®;L6cË :Q69AnE4½FT®C9A`:QKMN:QËG;>=¬;¬R7Çj:QTN:<=>Ç6S;L6nÂE:QTGÆNHE;¬8

AR0:Q=¨Â<M :*ÁQA¾GCD½Q¾»½F69AnEj:ÐMG½Q=>A½<ÅÐ0½FC9W6 CDA=L:-RD;¬TGÆ¦RD½;¬TrR9AnC9½F¾ AnCD:QËG;>=¬;¬R7ÇR9A`67RD;¬TNÆ4ä¬å%F1GæGåçÂ

ä¬å%FGHå'NHnå18`ç¾GC9½F¾ ½r6SA`EP:®RDAn6SR¦ÆFATGAnCD:<R9;>½QT¢RDAnKMGTG;LÌrÀGAÅÏ½QC6SÇJ8«8«AR9CD;LK¾GCD½<RD½JK½Q=L6Ë :Q69AnE

½QTY69Ç67RDA8)K½F8j¾»½F69;¬R9;>½QT°Â»äæGåç%EAn:Q= Ð;¬R9MEACD;¬Á-:<R9;>½QT®½QÅ@;¬TrRDACD½Q¾»AC:<ËG;>=¬;¬R7ÇRDAn6SRD60ÅÏ½QC0R9MNA

K½QTrRDC9½F=:<T EPR9MNAjEG:<RD:Y¾N:<C9Rª½QÅ¾GC9½QR9½K½F=>6nÂÚ'69WQA=>ARD½QTPRDAn6SR69ÀG;¬R9AÅÏ½QCK½FTFRDC9½F=@¾N:QCSR¦;>6

EACD;¬ÁFAnE%Â2Hc:QKMÒR9An6SRjKn:Q69AY;L6RDMGAT×¾N:<C:<8«ARDACD;¬ênAnE%ÂÃMGA®RDAn6SRj69ÀG;¬R9AY;L6jK½Q8«¾G=>ARDAnEÓËJÇ

:Q6D6S;>ÆQTG;>TGÆÁ-:<=>ÀGAn6¦RD½¾ :<C:<8«ARDAC6Â%ÃMGA4:<¾N¾GC9½r:QKMÉ:QE½F¾R9A`EÑËJÇÒäzæQæ-ç;>669½PK:<=>=>AnEJIKML

NPONQ

KSRUTV ;¬TÐMG;LKMÑ:Y69;¬TNÆQ=>A,ATrRD;\R7Ç¢;>TFRDACD½Q¾»AC:-RDAn6UÐ;¬R9MÑR9MGAjCDAn6SRª½<Å.RDMGAj;¬TrR9AnÆQC:-RDAnE

K½Q8«8ÀGTG;LK:-RD;¬TNÆj69Ç67RDA846ÂGÃMNA:Q¾G¾GCD½F:FKM4;>6BRDMGAT¢CDA¾»½QC9R9AnEY½QTR9MGAÍ.½F5xVl69Ç67RDA8¢Â5xT

½QCEACRD½:*ÁF½Q;LEÑRDMGA6SRD:<R9A6S¾N:FKA®A[¾G=¬½r6S;>½QT@HäF<çB¾NC9½F¾ ½r6SA`EÉ:±R9A`67Rj¾GÀGCD¾ ½r6SA®½FC9;>ATrRDAnE

8jAR9MG½E%ÂÃMNA¾NC9;>TNK;>¾G=>AÐ:Q6RDMGAEGA¿NTG;¬R9;>½QTl½<Å6SÇJTNKMNC9½FTG;¬ê`:-RD;¬½FTÓC9ÀG=>An6ÅÏ½FCj¾ :<C:<=>=¬An=

K½Q8«¾»½F69;\RD;¬½FT°ÂcÃC9AR984:<T 64AR:Q=¨Âªäæ&F-çª69MG½-ÐBAnE×R9MN:<RnH0ÀGTNEAnC69½Q8«A±:Q6D6SÀN8j¾GR9;>½QTN6nH.R9MNA

W/ GÄ¡R9A`67RR9MNA½QCDÇ«ÅÏ½QCUK½QTÅÏ½FC984:QTNKA;L66SÀG;¬RD:QËG=>AªÅÏ½FCUK½F8j¾»½F69;¬R9;>½QTN:Q=°6SÇ6SR9A846nÂ

X 52?,.2 MS/10)!ÃMG;>6«¾ :<¾»AC«¾GCD½Q¾»½F69An6j:±ÅÏC:<8«AÐB½QCDWÅÏ½QCjR9A`67RD;¬TGÆ#;>TrR9ACD½Q¾»AC:<ËN;¬=¬Ä

;\R7ÇÉ;¬T 6S¾G;>CDAnEÉËJÇÑÐB½QCDWÑ½<Åä+-çÂÝJ½F8jA4¾ :<C:<8«ARDACD;¬ênAnEC9An=>:<R9;>½QTN6nH%RD:QWJ;¬TGÆP;>TrR9½±:FKK½FÀGTrR

(4)

:<T¢:<¾G¾GCD½F:FKM®:<TNE:Q6D69½JK;>:<R9A`E®:<=>ÆQ½FC9;¬R9MG8éÅÏ½FCKMGAnKWJ;>TGÆ,RDMGAK½FC9CDAnKR9TGA`6960½<Å K½Q8«8ÀGTG;¬Ä

K:-RD;¬TNÆY6SÇ6SR9An8«6nÂÃMGA:Q¾G¾GCD½F:QKM¢;L6Ë :Q69AnE¢½QT:4=>:QêÇPK½F8«¾ ½r6S;¬R9;>½QTP;>T±½QCEAnCUR9½:*ÁQ½F;>E

R9MGA®6SRD:<R9A®69¾N:QKA4A[¾G=>½F69;¬½FT°Â°ÃMGA4½QCD;>ÆQ;>TN:<=>;\R7ÇP½QÅB½FÀGC:<¾N¾GC9½r:QKM;>6RDMGA®¾»½F6D6S;>ËG;>=¬;¬R7ÇPRD½

;¬TrR9AnCSÅ:FKA69½Q8«AK½QTGÅÏ½QCD8«:QTNKAªR9A`67RRD½J½Q=L6BÅÏ½QCÆQAnTGAC:-RD;¬TNÆ;>TrR9ACD½Q¾»AC:<ËN;¬=>;\R7Ç«RDAn6SRD6nÂ

ÃMGA4C9An84:<;>TNEAC,½<ÅBR9MGA®¾ :<¾»AC;L6½FC9Ær:<TG;>êA`E:F6ÅÏ½Q=>=¬½-ÐU6$@ÝJA`K~R9;>½QT×æ¾NC9A`6SAnTFR6R9MNA

ÅÏ½QCD8«:Q=8«½EA=B:<TNE#TG½QRD:<R9;>½QTN6À 6SA`E%ÂÝJA`K~R9;>½QTF±;¬TrR9CD½EÀNKAn6:QTNEÉA[¾G=L:<;>TN669½Q8«A®¾N:<Ä

CD:Q8jAR9AnC9;>êA`EY;>TrR9ACD½Q¾»AC:<ËN;¬=>;\R7Ç4CDA=L:-RD;¬½FTN6nÂG?B:F6SA`EY½FTR9MGACDAn69ÀG=¬RD6½<Å.69AnK~RD;¬½FT FGHG69AnK~RD;¬½FT

'69MG½-ÐU6.¿NC6SRnHrMG½-ÐßR9½ÆQATNAC:-R9A;¬TrR9AnC9½F¾ AnCD:QËG;>=¬;¬R7Ç,RDAn6SRD6cÅÏ½QC0R9MG;L6cÅÏCD:Q8jAnÐ0½FC9Wj:<TNE®R9MGAnT

MG½-ÐÔ½QÀGC:<¾N¾GC9½r:QKM®Kn:<T®Ë»AªÀ 6SA`E4R9½jÆQAnTGAC:-RDAU;>TFRDACD½Q¾»AC:<ËG;>=>;\R7ÇR9A`67R6cÅÏCD½Q8 69½Q8«A¦K½QTGÄ

ÅÏ½QCD8«:QTNKAªR9A`67RRD½J½Q=L6Â O0½FTNK=>ÀN69;¬½FTY;L6;¬TP69AnK~RD;¬½FT*GHG:<TNE6S½F8«A¦A`ÌrÀG;¬Á-:Q=¬AnTNKA¾GCD½J½<Å6:<CDA

¾GC9A`6SAnTrR9AnE;>T¢69AnKR9;>½QT +GÂ

·¸S¼9´ Ø¼xµ ³

ÃMGAcË»AMN:*ÁJ;>½QC°½QÅGK½Q8«8ÀGTG;LK:-RD;¬TNÆK½F8j¾»½QTNATrRD6K:<TË»A0EGAn6DKCD;¬Ë»AnEËJÇ¦8«An:<T 6°½<ÅÅÏ½FC984:Q=

8j½EAn=>6ª6SÀ KM±:Q6U5xTN¾GÀRÎªÀGR9¾GÀR@:QË An=¬A`EPÃ@C:<TN69;¬R9;>½QT±ÝJÇ67RDA8 =Ï59ÎÃUÝ>~Â Úª6À 6SÀN:Q=@;>T

R9MGABR9A`67RD;¬TNÆªRDMGA½FC9ÇFH*Ð0ATGAnAnERD½8j½EAn=;¬8«¾G=>A8«AnTFR:-RD;¬½FTN6H-AnÁQAnT,;¬ÅNR9MNA;>C.Ë AnMN:*ÁJ;¬½FCD6:<CDA

ÀGTGWJTG½-ÐT°ÂÚUT57èÃàÐ;¬=>=°:<=L6S½Ë ACDA¾GCDAn69ATrRDAnE4ËJÇ®:<T59ÎÃUÝÂGÝJAnKR9;>½QT¢æÂ>åª;>TrR9CD½JEGÀNKA`6

R9MGA459ÎÃUÝ8«½EA=c:QTNE#6S½F8«A4TG½<RD;¬½FTN6ÀN69AnEÉ;¬T#RDMGA4CDAn6SR½<ÅBR9MGA4¾N:Q¾ AnCnÂÝJAnKR9;>½QTÒæÂzæ

EA¿NTNAn6RDMGA59ÎÃUÝYK½Q8«¾»½F69;\RD;¬½FT°Â

! X B "!3

°AR S Ë A:,6SÇ6SR9A8éK½F8«¾ ½r6SA`E½QÅ°:6SARc½<Å°K½F8«8,ÀGTG;LK:<R9;>TGÆK½F8«¾ ½FTGATrRD6

(Mi)^ÂHÁQAnC9Ç

K½Q8«¾»½QTGAnTrR

Mi

EA¿ TGAn6B:,69AR½<Å@:FK~R9;>½QT 6 =AÁQAnTrRD6>

A^Mⁱ ¾»AC9ÅÏ½QCD8«AnE4ËJÇ

Mi

HJ:QTNE®:6SAR

½<Å;¬TrR9AnCD:FK~RD;¬½FTN6 ¾ ½F;¬TrR6;=Ï¾»½QC9RD6.½FC.;¬TrR9AnCSÅ:FKA`6 >

P^Mⁱ RDMGCD½QÀGÆFMÐMG;LKM

Mi

K½F8«8,ÀGTG;LK:<R9A`6

Ð;\RDM®R9MNAª½QR9MGAnCBK½Q8«¾ ½FTGATrR60:QTNE4Ð;¬R9MY;¬RD6BAnTrÁJ;>C9½FTG8«ATrRnÂrÃ@½jEA¿ TGAÅÏ½FC984:Q=¬=>Ç4:,K½F8jÄ

¾ ½FTGATrR

Mi

HNÐBAÐ;>=¬=ÀN69AR9MGA8«½JEGA=½<Å.5xTG¾GÀRÎªÀR9¾NÀR:<Ë»A=>=¬A`EPÃ@C:<TN69;¬R9;>½QT±ÝJÇ67RDA8

=Ï59ÎÃUÝS>ªÐMG;LKM;L6:<T#:QEN:<¾R:-R9;>½QT½<Å0R9MGA«ÀN69ÀN:<=#ÃUÝÑ8«½EA=¡Â°5xTR9MG;L68«½JEGA=¡H%AÁQAnC9Ç

:QK~RD;¬½FT±;L6:Q6D69½JK;>:<R9A`ER9½:QT±;>TFRDAC9Å:QKAR9MGCD½QÀNÆQMPÐMG;LKMPR9MNAj69Ç67RDA83C9A`KAn;¬ÁFAn6½FCª69ATNEG6

R9MGAAnÁQATrR`Â

2 M$!&% K('*),+#-".

QR N T/1032L

M= (Q^M⁴Σ^M⁴→M⁴ q^M₀ ) ⁵⁷⁶ ^L98 ^L1:

; Q^M ^Q^R ^N RPLT;I=< RUT N TLUR

N

K3>

q^M₀ ∈Q^M ^Q^R ^T⁶ ^L ^Q^K ^Q^T^QN ^26RT ^N ^T^L1?

; Σ^M ⊆ P^M × A^M ⁵⁷⁶ ^L@8^L P^M ^Q^R ^NBA ^K ^Q^T^LRPLT ^IC< ^Q^KT ^L98D< ^NFE LRHGI0I*8UTRKJ T6 8 I*/

O 6

576 QLE

6 M Ê ÎNMOM/K ^QLEN ^T^LR ⁵ ^Q^T⁶ ^Q^TR ^LPKQP ^Q⁸ ÎKRM ^LPKT ^N ^KS> A^M ^Q^R ^T⁶ ^L ^N ²⁰ ⁶ ^NFT^LPTIC<

NUE TQ

I4KSR LWV

E 6 N K O LX>

T9Y M ^T⁶ ⁸Î*/ Ô ⁶ P^M^?Q'UT ^Q^RZ0 ^N ^8UT ^Q^T^QÎKLX> ^Q^KTÎ ^T⁶ ⁸ ^LL ^RPLTR@: Σ^M = Σ_i^M ∪ Σ_o^M ∪ I^M^:3<I*8 (p, a) ∈ Σ^M⁴ ^T⁶ ^LPK (p, a) ∈ Σ^M_i ^Q^< a ^Q^R ^Q^K*03/T ^NFE ^T^QÎK ⁴ (p, a) ∈ Σ_o^M ^Q^< a ^Q^R ^N ^K ÎN/T[03/T ^NFE ^T^QÎK ⁴ ^N ^KS> (p, a) ∈ I^M ^Q^< a ^Q^R ^N ^K ^Q^KT^L@8UK ^N ²

NUE TQ

I4K IC<

M^?

; →M ⊆Q^M × Σ^M × Q^M ^Q^R ^T⁶ ^L ^T\8 ^N ^KR ^Q^T^Q^I4K]8 ^L92^N ^T^Q^{IKS?O^} ^L ^KMIT^L q ^α→M q⁰ ^<IN8 (q, α, q⁰)∈→M

N

K3>

q→^αM

<I*8

∃q⁰:q→^αM q⁰^?

V LWV&T

4 IOLT S ⁵ ^Q2_2`>&LPKMI4TL T6 L RLPT#IC<

Q

K*03/T#IN/T[03/T,2

NFT L@2LX> T8

N

KSR

QTQ IK R Y

RUT L@M R9?

(5)

V ITLU?

p?α67R:<TNEG6ÅÏ½FC

(p, α)∈Σ_i^M ^{:<T E} p!α^ÅÏ½FC (p, α)∈Σ_o^M^Â µ¯=p!α^;¬Å µ=p?α

:<TNE

¯

µ=p?α^;¬Å µ=p!α^Â

V N

M0S2LU?ªÝJ¾»AnK;¬¿ Kn:-R9;>½QT

M1

½QÅR9MNAX;¬Æ ÂåjK½Q8«8ÀGTG;LK:-RDAn6ªÐ;\RDM69¾ A`K;¬¿ K:<R9;>½QT

M2

R9MGCD½QÀGÆFM±;>TFRDAC9Å :QKAn6

C1^:<TNE C2 :<T E±Ð;¬R9MÑ;¬RD6¦AnTrÁJ;>C9½FTG8«ATrRRDMGCD½QÀGÆFMP;¬TrR9AnCSÅ:FKA`6

C3

:<TNE

C4ÂBÝJ¾ A`K;¬¿ K:<R9;>½QT

M2

K½F8j8ÀGTG;LK:<R9An6®Ð;\RDMÔ;\R6®ATJÁJ;>C9½FTG8«ATrR4R9MGCD½QÀNÆQMß;¬TrRDAC9Ä

Å:QKA

C5^ÂGXG½QC M1

$ P^M¹ ={C1, C2, C3, C4}^H A^M¹ ={!start,?ack,!init,?status}^H Σ_o^M¹ ={C1!start, C4!init}^H:<TNE Σ_i^M¹ ={C2?ack, C3?status}^Â

Canal3

1

3 2

1

2 3

Canal1 Canal2

C1!start

C1?start

C2?ack

C2!ack C3?status

Canal5

Canal4 C4!init

C5!ready M1

M2

C1?start C2?ack

r e|n§§¦Fprqt~^y7qtpFªwxuDqt¥r~^y7qt|nprw

"AÀN69A¦R9MGAÅÏ½F=¬=>½-Ð;>TGÆ467R:<TNEG:QCDEYTG½<R:-RD;¬½FT½QÅ59ÎÃUÝÂ

% $ +6LPT

M ∈ IOLT S⁴ µ(i) ∈Σ^M⁴ α(i) ∈ Σ^M \I^M⁴ τ(i) ∈ I^M⁴ σ ∈ (Σ^M \I^M)^∗⁴ S ⊆Σ^M⁴ P ⊆Q^M⁴ ^N ^K3> q, q⁰, qi∈Q^M^?

; q^µ¹^...µⁿ−→ M q⁰ =∆ ∃q0=q, q1..., qn=q⁰,∀i∈[1, n], qi−1 µi

→M qi

?

; out(q) =∆ {α∈Σ^M_o | ∃q⁰ ^N ^K3> q ^α→M q⁰}^?

; out(P) =∆ {out(q)|q∈P}^?

- 6 LOP

QR QLT

2L T L 6 N P Q IN8 IC<

M ^QR&>LUR E 8

QLT LW>

5 QT6 ⇒

; q ⇒M q⁰ =∆ q=q⁰ ^IN8 q^τ...τ−→M q⁰^?

; q ^α⇒M q⁰ =∆ ∃q1, q2, q ⇒M q1

→αM q2

⇒M q⁰^?

; q ^σ⇒M q⁰ =∆ ∃q0=q, q1. . . , qn =q⁰,∀i∈[1, n], qi−1 µi

⇒M qi, σ=µ1· · ·µn

?

; q ^σ⇒M =∆ ∃q⁰, q ^σ⇒M q⁰^?

; q af ter σ =∆ {q⁰∈Q^M |q ^σ⇒M q⁰}^? M af ter σ =∆ q^M₀ af ter σ^?

; Out(M, σ) =∆ out(M af ter σ)^? OutS(M, σ) =∆ Out(M, σ)∩S^?

; T races(q) =∆ {σ∈(Σ^M \I^M)^∗|q af ter σ6=∅}^? T races(M) =∆

T races(q^M₀ )^?

V ITL ?UXN½QC

M ∈ IOLT S^H X ⊆ P^M^H S ⊆ Σ^M^H µ ∈ Σ^M^Hª:QTNE (σ, σ⁰) ∈ T races(M)^$

(6)

; σ.σ⁰ Ð;¬=>=@EAnTG½<RDAR9MGAK½QTNKn:-RDATN:<R9;>½QTY½QÅ@RDMGAR7Ð0½jRDCD:FKAn6nÂ

; σ/S

Ð;>=>=EATN½<R9A¢RDMGA±¾GCD½<Ù7A`K~RD;¬½FTØ½QÅ

σ ^½QT S EA¿ TGAnElËJÇ$

/S = ,(α.σ)/S = σ/S if α6∈S^HG:<TNE (α.σ)/S =α.(σ/S)if α∈S^Â

; Σ^M/X = {(p, a) ∈ Σ^M|p ∈ X} Ð;>=¬=EAnTG½<RDAYRDMGA¢¾GCD½<Ù7AnKR9;>½QTÒ½QÅ

Σ^M ^½FTÒR9MNA

;¬TrRDAC9Å:QKA69AR

X^Â

; PM(σ, X) ={σ⁰ ∈T races(M)|σ_/Σ^M/X =σ⁰_/ΣM/X

Ð;>=¬=.EAnTG½<RDAR9MNAj69AR¦½<Å

R9C:QKAn6½<Å

M RDMN:-RK½QCDC9A`6S¾»½QTNEYÐ;\RDM

σ ^½FT X^Â

; card(S) Ð;¬=>=@EAnTG½<RDAªRDMGATJÀG8,Ë»AC½QÅAn=¬An8«ATrRD6½QÅ

S^Â

ÚUT¢59ÎÃUÝ

M ;L6;¬TG¾NÀRK½F8j¾N=¬AR9A;¬Å;¬RU;>6K½Q8«¾G=>ARDA=>Ç69¾ A`K;¬¿NAnEYÅÏ½QC;>TG¾GÀR¦:QK~RD;¬½FTN6nÂ

2 M

!&+2LT

M ^T ^L ^N ^K '*),+#-".3?

; M ^Q^R ^Q^K*0S/T Ê Î*M0S2^LPT^L ^Q^< ∀q∈Q^M⁴ ∀a∈Σ^M_i ⁴ q â⇒M

?

; M ^Q^R2^Q^KL ^N ⁸ ^Q^< ∀q ∈ Q^M⁴ card(out(q)) ≤1^?#'K ^T⁶ ^Q^R ÊN ^RL ⁴ ^T⁶ ^L ⁰³⁸ ÎPL Ê ^T^QÎ4K Î=<

M ^IK S ⊆ Σ^M ^Q^R ^T⁶ ^L ²^Q^KML ^N ⁸ 'N),+#-". KMI4T LX>

T9Y M/S

8 LRT\8

QLE T LX>CTI

S ^G^T⁶ ^/3R T races(M/S) ={σ/S |σ∈T races(M)}^JU?

!

WW2/1021 M 5 ) %% M XB BO

O0½Q8«8,ÀGTN;>Kn:-R9;>½QT8«AnKMN:QTG;L6S8 ½QÅ@R7ÐB½«59ÎÃUÝYKn:<TË A8«½EA=>AnEËJÇY:QT59ÎÃUÝ%Â

2 M W!&+2LT

M1

N

KS>

M2

T L T5 I '*),+#-". RX/

E 6 T6 N T

Σ_i^M¹ ∩Σ_i^M² =Σ^M_o ¹∩ Σ_o^M² = ∅^?- ⁶ ^L ^R ^Y ^K Ê ⁶ ⁸ ÎKI*/3R Ê Î*M0SIR ^Q^T^QÎ4K ÎC< M1

N

K3>

M2

QR T6 L 'N)#+,- .

M = (Q^M, Σ^M,→M, q^M₀ ) ^KIT^LW> M1kM2⁴

>L

A

KMLX>

T@Y

:

; I*8UTR I=<

M ^Q^R ^T⁶ ^L ^/K ^QÎK Î=< ^0I*8UTR Î=< M1

N

KS>

M2

:

P^M =P^M¹∪P^M²^?

; Σ^M_o =Σ^M¹_o ∩Σ^M²_o ^?

; Σ^M_i = (Σ^M¹_i \Σ^M²_o )∪(Σ^M²_i \Σ^M¹_o )^?

; I^M =I^M¹∪I^M²^?

; q^M₀ = (q^M¹₀ , q^M²₀ )^?

; Q^M ={q1kq2|q1∈Q^M¹, q2∈Q^M²}^?

; →M

QR T6 L RXM

N

2_2LURUT 8 L92

N TQ IK >L

A

KMLX>

T@Y T6

L<I*2_2I 5 QK O 8 /2LRBG

µ∈Σ^M^JU:

F?

q1

→µM1 q₁⁰⁴ µ6∈Σ^M²\I^M² ⇒ q1kq2

→µM q⁰₁kq2

?

q2

→µM2 q₂⁰⁴ µ6∈Σ^M¹\I^M¹ ⇒ q1kq2

→µM q1kq⁰₂

?

q1

→µM1 q₁⁰⁴ q2

→µM2q₂⁰⁴ µ6∈I^M ⇒ q1kq2

→µM q⁰₁kq₂⁰

5xT;>TrR9ACD½Q¾»AC:<ËN;¬=>;\R7Ç«RDAn6SR9;>TGÆNHÐBAÀN69ÀN:<=>=¬ÇYTGAA`E®RD½4½QËN69ACDÁQAª½QTG=>ÇY69½Q8«A¦69¾»AnK;¬¿ KAnÁQATrR6

:<8«½QTGÆª:<=>=r¾»½F6D69;¬ËG=>AcAnÁQAnTFR6Â*ÃMN:<R;L6H*ÐBA0EA¿NTGA

MvisibleXÂ*ÃMGA0½FËN69ACDÁ*:QËG=>AAÁFATrRD6

½<Å

MvisibleX :QC9AjRDMG½F69A®A[GKMN:QTGÆQA`EÑ½-ÁFAC

XÂ@ÃMNA®½<RDMGACAnÁQAnTFR6:<CDA4K½FTN6S;LEAnC9A`E

;¬TrR9AnC9T :<=°:QKR9;>½QTN6

τ^Â

2 M6!&+2LT

M ^T ^L ^N K&'*),+#-".

N

KS>

X ⊆P^M ^N RPLTWI=<

Q

KT L98D<

NFE LUR@?

MvisibleX

Q

R'N),+#-". >&L

A

KLW>

T9Y

:

; Q^M^visible^X =Q^M⁴ ^N ^K3> q^M^visible^X0 =q^M0

?

; Σ^M^visible^X =Σ^M/X∪ {τ}^?

; →MvisibleX

QR T6 L R M N

2_2LURUT 8 L@2

N TQ IKR >&L

A

KMLX>

T9Y

G

µ∈Σ^M^JU:

F? q→^µM q⁰⁴ µ6∈Σ^M/X ⇒ q→^τMvisibleXq⁰

?

q→^µM q⁰⁴ µ∈Σ^M/X ⇒ q→^µMvisibleXq⁰

V ITL

?@AR

M^H M1

Hn:QTNE

M2

Ë»A.R9MGCDAA.59ÎÃUÝ%Â"ÔMGAT

X=P^M ^R9MNAT MvisibleX =

M^Â M1kXM2

!23 %

M1kM2visible X^Â

(7)

µG¼S·c´

Ú6SÇ6SR9A8 ½<ÅK½Q8«8ÀGTG;LK:-RD;¬TNÆ#K½Q8«¾»½QTGAnTFR64EA¿ TGAnEß:#6SAR®½<Å:*Á-:<;>=>:QËG=¬A;>TFRDAC9Å:QKAn6nÂ

HÁQAnTFR6 A[GKMN:QTGÆQA`E½-ÁQAnCR9MG;L669AR:<CDA½QËN69ACDÁ-:<ËG=>AB:QTNE,R9MGAnTRDAn6SRD:QËG=¬AFÂ<5xTrR9AnC9½F¾ AnCD:QËG;¬=>;¬R7Ç

C9An=>:<R9;>½QTN6®ÅÏ½QC69ÀNKMà69Ç67RDA846®8ÀN67RRD:QWQAÑ:FKK½FÀGTrR®R9MNAn69A:*Á-:<;>=>:QËG=>AP;¬TrR9AnCSÅ:FKA`6ÂBÃMG;>6

6SA`K~R9;>½QT;>TFRDC9½EÀ KAn6:QTNEK½Q8«¾N:QC9A`66S½F8jA¾N:QCD:Q8«AR9AnC9;>êA`E®;>TrR9ACD½Q¾»AC:<ËN;¬=>;\R7Ç4CDA=L:-RD;¬½FTN6nÂ

W! @3?3

ÎªTGA½<Å.RDMGA,À 6SA`EPK½QTGÅÏ½QCD8«:QTNKA,C9An=>:<R9;>½QTN6;L6R9MGAC9An=>:<R9;>½QT

ioconfÂ 5R¦6SRD:<R9An6UR9MN:<R¦:QT

;¬8«¾G=>A8«ATrR:-R9;>½QT

I ;L64K½FTÅÏ½QCD84:<TrR«R9½Ó;¬RD6®69¾»AnK;¬¿ Kn:-R9;>½QT

M ;¬Å:-ÅR9AnC®:ÉR9C:QKA½QÅ

M^H

½QÀRD¾GÀRD6«½QÅ

I :<CDAÅÏ½QCDAn69AAT×;¬T

M^ÂÃMG;L6jC9An=>:<R9;>½QTl:<=>=¬½-ÐU6¾N:<C9R9;L:<=69¾ A`K;¬¿ K:<R9;>½QTN6«:<T E :<=>=¬½-ÐU6B;>8j¾N=¬An8jAnTrRD:-RD;¬½FTN6BR9½®:FEGEYR9MGAÀGT EAC6S¾»AnK;\¿»K:-RD;¬½FT°Â

2 M !&+2LT

M ^N ^KS> I ^T ^L ^T⁵ ^I 'N),+#-".3?

I ^{6/& M} M=∆∀σ∈T races(M)⇒Out(I, σ)⊆Out(M, σ)^?

Ã@½±K½Q8«¾N:<CDAjËG;¬T :<CDÇ±C9An=>:<R9;>½QTN6nH%ÐBA4ÀN6SA

v ^:<TNE ∼=^Â@AR Rx

:QTNE

Ry

Ë»A4R7ÐB½ËN;¬TN:QC9Ç

C9An=>:<R9;>½QTN6%½-ÁFAC

IOLT S^Â Ry v Rx

;¬ÅÅÏ½QCAÁFACDÇ

(I, M)∈ IOLT S6SÀNKMRDMN:-R

IRxM

R9MGAnT

I Ry M^Â Rx∼=Ry

;¬Å Ry v Rx

:<TNE

Rxv Ry

Â

W!

, ?%1& ! %D6!

ÃMGA467R:<C9R9;>TGÆ¾»½Q;>TrRÅÏ½QC;¬TrRDACD½Q¾»AC:<ËG;>=¬;¬R7ÇR9A`67RD;¬TGÆ¢;L66S½F8«AÆF;¬ÁFAT69¾»AnK;¬¿ Kn:-R9;>½QT 6H;>8Ä

¾G=¬An8«ATrRD:<R9;>½QTN6¦ÅÏ½FCR9MGA`6SA®69¾ A`K;¬¿ K:<R9;>½QTN6EGA¿NTG;>TGÆP69½Q8«A4:*Á*:Q;¬=L:<ËN=¬Aj;¬TrRDAC9Å:QKA`6H°:QTNEÉ:

KCD;\RDACD;¬½FTÓR9MN:<R4;¬8«¾G=>A8«ATrR:-R9;>½QT 6j69MG½FÀG=>EØ69:<R9;L67ÅÏÇFÂ.ÃMrÀ 6H.ÃÐ0½É;¬8«¾G=>A8«AnTFR:-RD;¬½FTN6j;¬TÄ

R9ACD½Q¾»AC:-RDA;¬Å@RDMGAÇ®KMGA`KW«R9MGA¦;>TFRDACD½Q¾»AC:<ËG;>=>;\R7Ç4KCD;¬R9ACD;>½QT°ÂJÃMGAªÅÏCD:Q8jAnÐ0½FC9W«¾GCDAn69ATrRDAnE

MGACDAQHF;>6cËN:Q69AnE«½FT«R9MGA¦K½Q8«¾N:QC9;L69½QTjË AR7Ð0AnAT«R9MNA½QÀGR9¾GÀR6c½QÅR9MGA¦6SÇ6SR9A8 R9½,Ë AR9An6SR9A`E

:<TNEªR9MNA½QÀRD¾GÀR6°½<Å½FTGA6S¾»AnK;\¿»K:-RD;¬½FT°H8«½EÀG=>½69½Q8«A.;¬TrRDAC9Å:QKA.¾NC9½QÙ7AnK~RD;¬½FT°Â9°AR

I(i)

Ë»A

:<Tj;¬8«¾G=>A8«ATrR:-R9;>½QT«½QÅNR9MNAU6S¾»AnK;\¿ Kn:-RD;¬½FT

M(i)

Ð;\RDM

i∈ {1,2}^H*:<TNE X ⊂P^M¹∪P^M²

Ë A:QT;>TrR9AC9Å:QKA6SARnÂS"ÉAC9A`K:Q=¬=»R9M :-R

M1k^XM2

;>6

M1kM²visible X^Â

2 MW!

interopX(I1, I2)⁴=∀σ∈trace(M1kXM2)⁴ ⇒

OutΣ^I1(I1kXI2, σ)⊂ ∪_σ⁰_∈P_M1kM2_(σ,X)Out_Σ^M1/X(M1, σ_/Σ⁰ M1)

ÃMGA¿NC67RCDA=L:-R9;>½QT¢EA¿NTGAnE;L6BR9MGACDA=L:-RD;¬½FT

interopX

ÂG5R6SRD:<R9An6BRDMN:-REGÀGC9;>TGÆjR9MNA;¬TÄ

R9AC:QKR9;>½QTË»AR7ÐBAAnT

I1

:QTNE

I2

H*ÐMGATj:URDCD:FKA

σ^½<Å M1kXM2

;>6;>T-Ù7AnKR9A`ERD½RDMGAB69Ç67RDA8

R9½YË»ARDAn6SR9A`E%H»R9MGA½QËN69ACDÁ-:<ËG=>AË»AMN:*ÁJ;>½QC6½<Å.RDMGA69Ç67RDA83¾GCD½<Ù7AnKR9A`E¢½QTPRDMGA:*Á-:<;>=L:<ËG=>A

;¬TrR9AnCSÅ:FKA`6½<Å

I1

;L6ÅÏ½FC9A`6SAnATÓ;>TÓR9MNAYÀGTG;>½QT×½<ÅU½QË 6SAnC9Á-:<ËN=¬A®Ë»AM :*Ár;>½QC6.=¾GC9½QÙ7AnKR9AnE#½FT

R9MGA4:*Á-:<;>=>:QËG=>A,;>TFRDAC9Å:QKAn6>U½QÅ

M1

HÐMG;>=>A«:Q¾G¾G=>ÇJ;¬TGÆR9MNAj¾NC9½QÙ7AnK~RD;¬½FT°H»½QT±RDMGA4:<=>¾GMN:QË AR

½<Å

M1

HG½QÅA`:QKMR9C:QKA

σ⁰ ∈T races(M1kM2) ⁼σ⁰ K½Q;>TNK;LEA`6Ð;\RDM

σ ½FTRDMGA;>TrR9AC9Å:QKA 6SAR

X^>~Â

°AR Y =P^M¹∩P^M² Ë ARDMGAK½F8j8ÀGT¢;¬TrRDAC9Å:QKA`6B½<Å

M1

:<TNE

M2

Â

2 M !

intercomX(I1, I2)⁴=∀σ∈trace(M1kXM2)⁴ ∀σ⁰ ∈PM1kM2(σ, X)⁴ σ⁰_/Y 6=⇒Out_Σ^I1(I1kXI2, σ)⊂ ∪_σ⁰_∈P_M1kM2_(σ,X)Out_Σ^M1/X(M1, σ⁰_/ΣM1)

(8)

intercomX interopX

K:-RD;¬½FTN6nÂ¦AnTGAC:<=>=>ÇQH*K½Q8«¾»½QTGAnTrRD6 :<CDARDAn6SR9AnER9½K½FTÅÏ½QCD84:<TNKAQH*:<TNER9MJÀN6nH

intercomX

:*ÁQ½Q;LEG60R9MNAK½QTGÅÏ½QCD8«:QTNKAªR9A`67RD;¬TNÆNHËGÀRª½QTG=>Ç4R9A`67R6BR9MGA;>TrR9AnCSÄxK½F8j8ÀGTG;LK:<R9;>½QTY¾ :<C9RnÂ

ÚUTG½QR9MGAnCBKC9;¬R9AnC9;>½QT«;L6RD½EA¿NTGAª:,6SAR

A⊆Σ^M¹∪Σ^M² RD½,Ë»AªK½-ÁQACDAnE°Â

intercoverX

K½-ÁQAnCD6:<=>=JR9C:<T 6S;¬R9;>½QTN6ÐMG;LKMj¾N:Q6D6 ËJÇ,:¦ÆQ;>ÁQATAÁFATrR.½<Å

A^Â intercover⁰X

K½-ÁQAnCD669½Q8«A

R9C:<TN69;\RD;¬½FTN6 ÐMG;LKM¾ :Q6D6 ËrÇj:¦ÆQ;>ÁQATjAÁFATrR.½<Å

AÂQÃMGARDCD:FKA`6R9MN:<R.R9MGA`6SACDA=L:-R9;>½QT 6.K½QTGÄ 6S;LEACUKn:<TË A6984:<=>=¬AnCUK½F8j¾ :<CD;¬TGÆR9½

intercomX

:QTNE

interopX

Â

2 MW!

intercoverX(I1, I2) ⁴= ∀a ∈ A⁴ ∀σ ∈ trace(M1kXM2)⁴ ∀σ⁰ ∈ PM1kM2(σ, X)⁴ σ⁰_/a6=⇒

OutΣ^I1(I1kXI2, σ)⊂ ∪_σ⁰_∈P_M1kM2_(σ,X)Out_Σ^M1/X(M1, σ_/Σ⁰ M1)

2 MW!

intercover⁰X(I1, I2) ⁴= ∀a ∈ A⁴ ∃σ ∈ trace(M1kXM2)⁴ ∀σ⁰ ∈ PM1kM2(σ, X)⁴ σ⁰_/a6=⇒

OutΣ^I1(I1kXI2, σ)⊂ ∪σ⁰∈PM1kM2(σ,X)OutΣ_M1/X(M1, σ_/Σ⁰ M1)

ÃMGAUÅÏ½FÀGC0CDA=L:-RD;¬½FTN6EA¿NTGA`E®MGAnC9A:QC9Aª6SÀG;¬RD:QËG=>AUÅÏ½QC:<TJÇR9A`67R:<CKMG;\RDAnKR9ÀGCDAQÂrÃMGAªKMG½F;>KA

½<Å.:CDA=L:-RD;¬½FTEGA¾»ATNEG6U½QTR9MGAK½QT¿ EGATNKAªRDMN:-RUÐBAMN:*ÁFAª;>TP:<T¢;¬8«¾G=>A8«AnTFR:-RD;¬½FT:QTNE

:<=L6S½«½QTR9MNA6S;>êA½<Å.K½F8«¾ ½FTGATrRD60RD½4Ë A;>TJÁQ½QWFAnE%Â

Ú6%CDAn69ÀG=¬RnHRDMGA.TGA[rR@R9MGAn½QCDA8ã69MG½-ÐU6»RDMGAAnÌrÀG;>Á-:<=>ATNKA Ë AR7Ð0AnAT

interopX

:QTNE

ioconf^$

B 023

!&+6LPT

M1⁴ M2⁴ I1

N

KS>

I2

T

L<I*/8'N)#+,- . ?^ L N

RR /M L T6 N T

M1⁴ M2⁴

I1

N

K3>

I2

N 8 L Q KN0S/T

E

INM032LT L 4

Σ_o^M¹∩Σ_o^M² =∅⁴ Σ_o^M¹∩Σ_o^I² =∅⁴ Σ_o^I¹∩Σ_o^M² =∅⁴

N

KS>

Σ_o^I¹∩Σ_o^I² =∅^?- ⁶ ^LPKS:

interopX(I1, I2)∧interopX(I2, I1) ∼= I1kXI2 ioconf M1kXM2

ÚUT;¬TrR9AnC9A`67RD;¬TNÆK:F6SAª;>6BÐMGAnTYRDMGA¦ÐMG½Q=>Aª;>TrR9AnCSÅ:FKAn6B:<CDAª:*Á-:Q;¬=L:<ËG=>A&$

X =P^M¹∪P^M²^Â

5xT±R9MN;>6Kn:Q69AQH ÅÏ½QC

σ ∈ M1kM2

HÐ0AMN:*ÁQA

P_M1kM2(σ, P^M¹∪P^M²) ={σ}Â%ÃMGAnC9AÅÏ½QCDAQH R9MGAªC9An=>:<R9;>½QTN6

interopX

:<T E

intercomX

K:QT4Ë AªÐC9;¬RSRDAT®:F6.ÅÏ½Q=>=>½-ÐU6 =RDMGAª69ÀGËN6DKCD;¬¾GR

X

Ð;¬=>=°Ë»A½Q8«;¬RSR9A`E>U$

interop(I1, I2)=⁴∀σ∈trace(M1kM2)⇒Out_ΣI1(I1kI2, σ)⊂Out(M1, σ_/ΣM1)^Â

intercom(I1, I2)⁴=∀σ∈trace(M1kM2)σ_/Y 6=⇒Out_ΣI1(I1kI2, σ)⊂Out(M1, σ_/ΣM1)

ÃMGA0¾ :<¾»ACBä+<çEGA¿NTGA`ETG;>TGAB;¬TrRDACD½Q¾»AC:<ËG;>=¬;¬R7Ç¦C9An=>:<R9;>½QTN6ËN:Q69AnE½QT:=>:*ÇFAC:<CKMG;\RDAnKR9ÀGCDA

ÅÏ½QC.:Q69ÇJTNKMGCD½QTG½FÀN6°AnTrÁJ;>C9½FTG8«ATrRnÂ*ÃMGA`6SABC9An=>:<R9;>½QTN6:<CDA0EGAnK½F8«¾ ½r6SA`E;>TFRD½RDMGCDAAK=L:Q6D6SA`6

EA¾»ATNEG;¬TGÆ,½QT4ÐMG;LKM«;¬TrR9AnCSÅ:FKA`6.½<ÅR9MNAU;¬8«¾G=>A8«AnTFR:-RD;¬½FTN6.RDMGAÇ,ÅÏ½JKÀN6½FT°ÂFÃMNAn69AC9An=>:<Ä

R9;>½QTN6BK:QT®Ë Aª½QËR:<;>TGAnE4ÅÏC9½F8

interopX

ËJÇ«EA¿NTN;¬TGÆ«:69ÀG;¬RD:<ËN=¬Aª;¬TrR9AnCSÅ:FKA¦6SAR

X^ÂJXG½FC

A[G:<8«¾G=>AQH»R9MNACDA=L:-RD;¬½FT

interop K½QCDC9A`6S¾»½QT EG6RD½èTG;¬=L:-RDAC:<=.Ã½<RD:Q= 5xTFRDACD½Q¾»AC:<ËG;>=>;\R7Ç IA=L:-RD;¬½FTEA¿NTGA`E;>T#ä+<ç¡Â

Ã@½4K½FTNK=>ÀNEAFHNK½F8«¾N:<CD;>69½QTYË AR7Ð0AnAT¢C9An=>:<R9;>½QTN6B;L6ÆQ;>ÁQAnTYË»A=>=¬½-Ð $

interopX(I1, I2)∧interopX(I2, I1)∼=I1kXI2 ioconf M1kXM2

intercomX(I1, I2)vinteropX(I1, I2)^Â

intercover⁰X(I1, I2)vintercoverX(I1, I2)vinteropX(I1, I2)^Â