• Aucun résultat trouvé

Dispositifs et pratiques d'interdisciplinarités SPI/SHS en école d'ingénieur.

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "Dispositifs et pratiques d'interdisciplinarités SPI/SHS en école d'ingénieur."

Copied!
8
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

HAL Id: hal-00232689

https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00232689

Submitted on 1 Feb 2008

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Dispositifs et pratiques d’interdisciplinarités SPI/SHS en école d’ingénieur.

Dominique Vinck

To cite this version:

Dominique Vinck. Dispositifs et pratiques d’interdisciplinarités SPI/SHS en école d’ingénieur..

M.Faucheux, J.Forest. Les recherches en sciences humaines et sociales dans les écoles d’ingénieurs., Petra, Paris., pp.143-154, 2007. �hal-00232689�

(2)

Slightly revised for: M.Faucheux, J.Forest, (2007), Les recherches en sciences humaines et sociales dans les écoles d’ingénieurs, Petra, Paris. pp. 143-154 Prononcé à l’INSA-Lyon, 29-30 juin 2006

Dispositifs et pratiques d'interdisciplinarités SPI/SHS en école d'ingénieur

!"$#&%')(+*-,/.102$43506%/$ 387 ":9<;>=@?<$BA1C,63D&%'EGF$GHG,DCIIJ1#

KML

N6OQPDR2S$TVUVWCPDXYS$O[ZVR2\$XY]^S$OV]`_2PaT@Xbcb'XYWdUfePDgM]`TV_ehiXOfP8_jRCTVX]6WjXYkQeXYOV\1RCXPDg

lnm0Co$oQj#pF$3qF$EjrjF$s1,^3tou1J1#rI3vs%wo$,DBA1Eu3xo1u1,t 38yF ECAz#{o$o1yF$ #0|,Djrj}$2,Drj}1

%'C,8F3Drjo1#Y10j~,838€}$s1,i%'€0s$p,DE6%/rdzIrM3‚F$I3ƒrC}$2,Drj}$s1,^3…„†l3‚F‡c‡/rs#&%'Eu3ˆ3D$%‰Cpz‡'‡/s%

$1JI,DsV38I3-Šo$,DuJ1#‹j>M3nFQmY%'C,Drd :o$,DEj}$j13D Œ#YEu3:#0:F$BAC,^3D&%'EF$3#0j$.10C.1387@F$u3‡i$,Du3F1

,D0jY38$Izj%Žs%aF$:3c%'02$F10C,DF 3F$†3Drjj%'‡/rz%'E’‘co102,s1jo1#Yd7f#†38IrjVF$#Y0:1F$Ej#Y3D06%/$Œj“;u

A12,^3c3F$”#0[F$u3Dr2,•–ou%/$—rjB,5rj$ 3c%'02$rjE[F$0CQ3rdC,c%i0j$u3,DdrC}1C,DrC}1M3zˆ;u˜+;$™›šF‡i‡/E2,Dj$rM3F1

o$,D$,/&%'E3œ38rjYjM%/‡iYu3`šF${A2,/.1C1rj3žF$0z13Ÿ#YM3€1$,/M3Ÿs%ˆo$,D1rjEjF1,83 FQmECA10j#B0s%'š¡rju¢$%

FQm0Co$o$,Dj%i3^3502.1j7"s%'ru„ lnmYuAI3i%i3^3Djj%nF$0j13)›%i,80sA10jY#a%'C,8F3Drjo1#Y10jB,5>j%i,D“;u£¤…%¤;u˜Œ;[M3c%

%iu2¥Du1,^3G,/38EŒ0z#{,^3-›#0>,Djrd$10j3^350j$rd>o$,D‡iu353D $$j##YŒVm3c%no1030M363c1,DEj¦„@D#a3i%GFQm0s$%'0CM%

o1#&V3:,D3DE“§#›%i,D0sA0j~#%8C,DF$3Drjo #10j,D”3c1o$o1Q3D“FVmYuAzM%'C,<F$3:0j$‹C,Du3<FVmYC$o$,DC,>38I3

o$,DuJ1#Ej0s%/{3D7GEs%i}$1F$3+s%,DE3iQ#%'0s%D3D7GFQm0jrjrj$,DF$C,+F$3%'z<o1,D02#~%'EI3+F$”%i,D0sA0j~#G¨Œ©`ª…«Y¬$ª6«o1s

rj$:o10s%'BJ1#Yu387 #¤%4I¦%aF$0C13Ž1rj$%'6u%'Gu­Œ#3F$3Drjo #~1M3`jo$,DE38j$rM-Vm$%"o10M3®#{’¯zGo1{Ff3š

#u3G;u˜Œ;“Es%'02%3Du$A12%0C,/.110z#387@1~Q3o1s1o1#YEdI3n6%ao$#&V3F$3Do1C,^3DEdI3F$0j 3#s1,630Co$o$,8 rC}I36„1

rjj#0§3…mY0/¥Du$%'j7£#0†o$,DM3^3D °†ou1J1#C,GF$0jQ3¤F$3,8sAufu3G0j#Y‡/0j%'M3D7"F$$z%#0>#Y3c%'Œ3D,D3c%i,8C%n0s$

9¤®’p‘i,DsAuu3nF$rC±G1,nF$†#0F$438rj~o1#Y1C™…„lnmY%'2,DF35rjBo1#Y10C,D&%'E$A0:o103nF$>3D „$lrz}IC,Drj}$61,

3Durjs1“F$†380:rj0C,',•‹C,8:F$%a‡i0z,DGQ+F$I$J1#:uA3c%i363Djj%'7VF$0C13#cmu3/o10jrdM%'C,DF$438rj~o1#Y10j,D:s%

0s+rC±G1,aF$’3D0GFuY38rj~o1#Y1u„

D#)²ƒ0³o1I1,%'0C%F$§J1$$13,D0j3D 13Œ‘i:$rC´17µ1¶$¶$¶u™ŒF$·32mYj¦.10C.Q2,>F$0j13Œ#imY%'C,DF$3Drjo #10C,D&%'Eu„’¸^¹

C,c%'0CQ3¤IJ2¥8s%D3²°~uA&%'j%5„ lnmEs%F$FŒ%i,D0sA10j#"}Œ0j$7"F$M3G’$%'0s%i$Q3G$FV3i%i,Dj#Y#3D7"#0†o$,DY38>

rj$:ou%':F$3nrdM%i,D0C%'3juA1~,8$Izj%'0j#u387@6%'ru„1s1.1zM%"%²¦o jzM%`#:rdIrjI1,53F$’o1#B£3Ds1,^3

F$Y35rjBo #1I3…„§l0º1EjrdI353D&%'E»FQm0C,c%'rs#C, F$M3€350CA1$B,63¼F‡i‡/EC,8zM%D3€3i1,½1x¯j»uJ2¥5s%ˆu%iBA

#imY%8C,DF$Y35rjo #10C,D&%'Ej7$o10C,DrjGG#o$,DuJ1#Y‹jGrC,D1Y35’F$M3arj0s3D0j#&%8E3a#&%'o #3a‘$.10C%'7"¸2¾$¾ ¿M™6„jl3

rj$>0jIF&%'0j,D3nF$:,Ddrz}IC,Drj}$F$j0j$F$j%F$3nrj$u10j3^380zIrM3nQ#s1,o1C,Ds%%'CM%F$r213c%i,c1B,8

1$½A13D1€.1#J0z#Às%[%'EC.$,8EjÁFÂo$,'uJ1#‹j>¦„*’,D7>#30Co$o$,D1rC}II3s%[,8E3c1#&%'06%D3Ã38rz{zM%/‡iI3

‡,D0C.1j%'E3[Iƒ#s1,[‡i0jrj#Y&%'j%“o10M3[#0‰%'ÄjrC}Iu„GD#Y3[YuA1&%'jM%°ÅF$Ejrj# Y38$IC,[#3[0Co$o$,8 rC}Iu3[s%°

%i,D0sA0j~##C,`rd6¥D1~M%'jj%`3i1,`#3u3c%'$ 3£3DGoQQ3D2%5„Q;10C13Ž1j‡i‡i,c%ŽF$’F$Edrz#{ Y3D$$$jj%ŽF$

#0³o10C,c%F$3rC}$2,Drj}$s1,^387#u3rj$u10j3^3D0j1rjM3,D3c%'2%3Du$A1CM%:o1s—u%i#4350CJ1#3o1u1,#cm0jrs%'$Q„"lI3

F$Y35rjBo #1I3 3Drjj%'~‡'YM3 3D$% Fu3DrC,8‹s%'3 ‘i$Æ¥D %iBA3 $ j %'C,D0drs%/{¦™6„Æ/# ‡/0s$%

rj$ 3i%i,c1B,DG#imY0C,i%/r6Q#0s%'$F$‹3a#0-‡i$,D#0s%i$F13"o$,DuJ1#‹zu3as% 3i%i$Q3a0s$%'0CM%"m0s+${Ad0s+F$I3

,DE3iQ#%'0s%D36„$lnmY0Co$o1j#†#imYM%'C,DF$438rj~o1#Y10C,D&%'E3i%®1I:o$,D%'3%'0…%i{ŒA1Ej}$Ejj%'F$†#{0o102,c%F$M3n0jr…%'61,^3D7

mY#V3D &% F$EjrjF$61,®$F3c%i,'j#Qu“3/o #Grj&%'²Ij$71rju%i,8)1>3D0sA B,ajY6%%'‘/*®’7£¸2¾$Çuµ$™^„

µu¹³l0œ3/o1Ejrj0j#Y350s%'$ÂF35rjBo1#Y10j,D€rdIFQ&%ÁQ1Áo12,c%' Fw3DjQ3—F$€#0Á,D3'o1Q380CJ1Y#Y%'E F$I3

rC}IC,Drj}$s1,53o10C,`,D0Co$o1$,%’#s1,uJ2¥Ds%F$’,Ddrz}IC,Drj}$<s%0s$“f3i%/$ 3G38I#CA1EdI3o10C,#0+38 rjE6%'Eu„ul

$,Drjj#Y#jj%ÈF 3D0CA B,t}$0j$F$rj0Coy#Y0ÉrjQ3i%i,4r6%i F@mB$|A13^1 ‘co10C,vdj†o1#yF1I3

o$,DuJ1#Ej0s%/{3G1FV3c%i,/j##I3'™#s1,oC,Ds%%'0CM%F$:u3c1,DC,n#3Gj6¥5s1°s%#3n,D4383G#YEM3G0s!‡i0jB%

F$:o$,D{A1#EC. C,`³0M3/o1Mrs%o10C,c%irs#C,6„ D#3n$%1~Q3¤rj$ 38rzj$rd>F$3no1f3i%1#0s%D3ns%o$,DE3i1o$o1f38E3nF1

(3)

o$,D1Fr…%i{„z+rjI1o17$#3`rdM%i,/BJuj% )11G‡i,DGF1,DEC.$,DM3^3D F$Ez rC,80s%/{GF$0zQ3a#0jj#Y#G#I3

o$,DuJ1#‹j3F$CA1j$$j%38rzj%i‡/u36%£%'jrC}¦$I3EjrC}10Co$o1jM%0s°F$EsJ106%5„lnmY0CJ3Dj1rj:FQmBQI’A143D{f

.1#IJ0j#YÁ,80z38$1Ej #0j43638ž#BJ$,5 rju1,^3— F$3—0jI0z#²Q353—#1rj0j#u3¡o10C,Drjj##Y0j,D3…„>s%%'€3D%0s%i$$7

o$,DuJ1#Ej0s%/{o1I1,#u3aF$EjrjF$s1,^3as%oII1,#0’3D1rjEs%'EM7M%'C,/o1j##YG#u3"o$,D06%iu3aF$3arC}12,DrC}1s1,^3…„

¹Ql0GFu²$10j38rzj%'‡cfo1Äs%i&% 0sV353DQF+rj# 3D$$$jj%5„jlnmY}$3c%'$B,DGF$335rzj$rdI3a$%i,8G

#u3[F$438rj~o1#Y13“%i,Du$A1CM%°0sV3^3D#Y61,”‡'Ejrj$$F$&%'EÅ#$,^3Dmj#Y#u3³o$,D1rj‹jF$2%°ÅF$3°,D0Co$o$,D1rC}Izj%D3

10s%%'CIFV3s%¤ŒF$u3j†o$,iQM%D3ŒF@m0s$%i,DM3F38rzo1#Y1u36„QM3:$$uA0s%i$Q3%i}$Ed,Du308¥5s1,8335

‡i M%"F$02 3a#I3a%'2,^3c%'rju3£%'0CIF3aG#im0CA10j$rMEjGF$M3)35rjjIrM3)38Ž¥8IGj:o10C,i%/G06 0C,/.1u3as% F$0CQ3

#0Œrj$%'3i%'0…%i$[F$3<3D0CA1 –,^3Es%'0sJ1#3s%`%i,D02 3D>3Go102,G#YM3G,Duu%i$u3Go1EjF$02.1.$f3…„£",D0sA0z##Y2,0dAMr

F$3 rz}IC,Drj}$61,s3 F@m0s$%i,DM3[F$438rj~o1#Y13!M3c%°0j#$,^3§€²1j F$ˆF$ECo10M363DC,[#0½‡'C,Ds%1,Dˆ3c1,§V

o10C,D0dFB.1s%`o12,•s%F$>38o1Q3D2,F$u3n3i%/{Q3nrC,DB%i33c1,G380†o$,D$o$,DFu3Drjo #1>‘‰f38rjuA1Yrj7

¸2¾$¾ ¿M™6„

l3 J1$$$u3 ,D0j3D$Q3 FQmYj¦.Q0C.12, %i,D0sA0j~#Æ%'C,8FY38rj~o1#Y10j,D ‘/rC,DEd0s%/BA1&%'E 38rzj%'‡/j7

,DCII$Aj#Y#j>jM%"o$,'IJ1#Ej0s%'j7Q%'EC.$,80s%i$>F$#Y0rM¦$0j363D0j$rMj7$%,D0sA0j~#f0s +‡,D$%'‹C,D3F°3D0CA1 –,

ut0Co$o$,8EC}$CQ3D{ . #{J10j#C™ÁuA1&%'jM%ˆ0j#$,^3À»32mY%'2,c,'.12,ž3i1,ˆ#YM3ÀrjIF%/1 3¼rjIrC,D‹s%'M3ÀF$

#im0C,c%i{rsQ#0s%'$F$3aF$3Drjo #1I387 FQm0s$%'0CM%o$#&V3aG#Y0GF$Ej02,Drj}$G$)A0o103aF$’38„

l¡rj03›F ¡#0·,DjrC}1C,8rC}1Ã3c1,“#3³3/²Q3i%'‹j>M3“F ·o$,8$Frs%i$ˆ‘/$o%i>350s%i$Às%,D0^%iI0j#Y350s%i$ˆF1

#im0jrs%'BA1&%'E 1FV3c%i,'Yj##j7Å$$A0s%/{qs%ž0jrs%iBA1&%'EwF wrj$$rjCou%'$$7Ã.1M3c%'qF$ #0 o$,D1Frs%i$$7

$o%i>3D06%/$ˆF$¡#0¡rz}I041¡#$. 3i%/d7’%'EC.$,D06%iÀF$·II$Az##3“rj$%i,D0j%'M3“F$¡0j#~%'E¡s%+F$

F$EsAz#{o$o1jj%F1,80sJ1#j7®.13i%/$!F$§#imY ‡i$,D0s%/{!s%-F$›#0“rj$$$0j363D0j1rjj7s%'ru„™3c%%²¦o1Y“F1

rjs%%'‰3D&%06%i‚FQm0Co$oQj#·#imY%'2,DF38rzo1#Y10C,D&%'E!s%F$·F$‡c‡'Yr6Q#&%'Eu3+rj$$rC,D‹6%'3>,8zIrj$%i,DEjM3>o10C,Œ#{I3

rC}IC,Drj}$s1,536„Ž0j 3# o$,8E3Dj%G%'6u%'j7`$uV3$uV30Co$ouC,D$ 3Œ3i1,>#u3Œ3D&%06%/$ 3³IIV30sAQ3

r%4I²IEju3F$0j13#Y<rj0jFu,D:F$:#imBrj1#0s%/{I0z#>;u1o1EC,'Y61,D:F$:HEj$Y/$F3c%i,/{z#:HG,Dj$uJ1#:s%F$3

Fu²$$0jYu3nF$:,Djrj}IC,Drj}$"#cm zM%'II,DCM%5„Q`,DEjEjC¡¸2¾$¾$¶$7j#Y#:,DE3c#&%'F$†#0†A#$%'Erj$6¥D M%'

FQmY1FV3c%i,'Yj#3D7¡FQmjQ3Dj. I0j%D3¼=Árj}$C,8rz}Is1,^3¼j ;rz{zIrM3½ u1, #m•¦.1Ej$Y61, s%À2 ;1rjz1rdI3

rjIf3ns%¤;1 r20j#Yu3…„ D#"36m0C.13^350j&%F$†6%%i,DsŒ±G AI,D’QI†‡i$,D0s%'Œo1#B1,DF35rjo #10j,Ds%

F$3o$,D$.$,D0Cu3nF$:,Djrj}$C,8rz}Ij7£"0drjrj$,DF$C%a1$#0C,/.1:o #0jrd>0s1[3Drjj1rj33D1rz{0z#u3D7F$0CQ3`1

o1C,^3'o1jrs%iBA’.1#uJ10j#:F :0~%i,D3D<F$#im$$A0s%'Œ1FV3i%i,/j#Y#u„1:I1A1jj%3…mY3i%0sV3^3DQ%i,D0dF1&%

o10C,n#0rC,DEj0s%'$“F@mB$>3c%i,cr6%1,D:‡iEjF$EC,D0s%iBAF$:,Djrj}$j,Dr2}$‘c/Q3i%/&%¦%F$:#0’,D Fr^%i$ŒD$FV3c%i,Dj##Y2™

s% FQmB1$xEdrj #xF$1rs%4u,D0C# o1#&1,DYF$3Drjo #10z,Dȑ/H’E2$Yx1FV3c%i,Dj#7ˆEMrj$$$Yx1F3c%i,/j##YÈs%

;1 r2 #$. {-$F3c%i,'j#Y#C™6„

1L

S$O@TVXPDXYS$OV]`kVSuUVReY\“X]^_G_jO“kQe\$Wj_GT£hiUVO@_GR2_jWV_MR2WV_GXOfP8_jRCTVX]^WjXkfeXO@\$XR2_

;1Ir2s1ÆFVmz¦.10C.1C, Qx%i,D06A10jY#ˆF$ ,Djrj}IC,Drj}$x%'C,8FY38rj~o1#Y10j,Dwz‡i‡'r6%/‡i7ÅY#ˆrduA1j%žF$

36m~M%'C,/,D$.1C,3c1,"#3rj$$F$&%'Q3F$:3D0’35z±G$A$,D$„lGo$,'IJ1#‹j3c% o10C,c%irs#Y‹C,8zj%ŽEC1zM%

F$0CQ3a#Grj0dFu,DGF$,DjrC}IC,Drj}$u3ard6¥D1~M%'3aCM%i,D:;u˜Œ;^%a;u£'7$¯j>’3…mYY#QmI3i%o103`3/o1Edrz‡/u„

1LKML

n\k@R2XYS1R2X~PDgGO£hi_j]DPakV\$]`\$UŒWj\$TVRC\$_Ggdk@X]•PDg§S$eS$XVUV_

3Ÿrj$##Y‹j.u387ƒ38Irj6 qF$»,DB.u61,œ3DrjzM%/‡/fj7¡$u1,/,/Y3ŸF$»o$}$#@38o$}$ F$3œ38rjYj1rjM3D7

3Du1#. IzM%p#cm~o1$,c%'0CIrj F$3po$,DEj0j#0CJ1#u3 E2o 3c%'E2 #$. 3…„½GA10jM%pFQmY2u.10C.C,º1Æ%i,D0sA0jY#

%'C,8F3Drjo1#Y10j~,8j7Q~#V‡'0sFu,D0j&%32mY0jrdrj,8F$C,)3i1,`#Go$,DuJ1#Y‹j:Es%FuC,D7QF$Ej‡i$~,"$-A135Ejrj :QIj7

Ej#0CJ1$,DC,¤F$3GrdIrjCou%D3¤s%`1[#0z¦.10C.1†o102,c%'0C.1E387"dIo #rz%'C,G#3}u²$o1%i}$‹M3Du3GF$†J0M3DŒs%nrd13c%i,c1B,8

1:,DEj‡iEC,8zM%/{z#rj$Q„

—0j#}1s1,D6V3DjzM%'7#u3o$,DEj0j#0CJ1#Yu3ECo13c%'Ej #{.1V3“3D$%~M%'C,/10CJ1#Yu3+s%#u30Co$o$,8 rC}Iu3F$I3

1 3s% F$3Ž0s$%i,D3a$rj1†j 3i1,D0CJ1#36„lnm0Mrjrj$,DF>3c1,"#u3arj$$rj2ou%D3as%a3c1,a#3"o$,D1rjo1I3Ž3c% FQm0s$%'0C%

o1#&V3nF‡/‡'Yrj#Y:,DEj0j#35C,nmY#"u3c%F$Ejr2¦1jrs%'EF$13i%i$Q3ns%FQmuJ2¥Ds%D3nrj$$rC,8s%D36„ul3nrC}IC,Drj}$61,s3

0sAICM%0j#$,^3ŒmY#‡/0s$%<1‰%'C<o@3+rj$ 3DF$EC,D0CJ1#j7J1j0sfrju1oˆFQmz‡i‡i$,c%^%F$”o10^%ij%'!0dA0j%F$

rj$>jIr2,·Á38½rd:o$,8zIFu,DˆFQm{$ˆF$3Drjo #~1ˆÁ#m0s$%i,D¦„0C% 0s$ rj$$rj2ou%D3!…%°1F$‹z#{I3

(4)

rC}IC,Drj}$s1,53®#u3"o1#&V3"A1 #{M%'0z–,D36„jl3a%'C,D10CJ1#Yu3"o10j#0CJI,Du3aF$’3D0Grj$ 3i%i,cr^%i#3aE2ouQ3DjM%5„

C,c%'0CII3¤‡/0d13GF1†o$,D1rjEjF$2,D7£o$#&V3G1F$u3c%'387"0sJ1u$%iY3638zM%nrjCo12$F10zM%n>F$:J1$ 3n,DEu3c#&%'0s%D3nŠQo10C,

szo1#j7`#Y“‡/0j&%-FQmC$o1#,8C,:2Q3Dj:JQ#§#3FI²I10z3<F$Œ,Djrj}$2,Drj}$“F$I3G 3s%F$3<0s$%i,836„£'#

36m0C.1&%<0j#$,^3FVmYCIo #Yrj&%'2,†#{I3<,D0j3D$ 3F1³rj}$0drsQF$·36mz¦.10C.C,F$0CQ3#im0dAjM%1,D³r26¥D1~M%'³s%<F$

36m~M%'C,/,D$.1C,Œ3c1,<#u31Ejrj363D&%'EM3>%'2,/130s1‚F38rzo1#Y1387j¡o10C,c%ir6Q#Y2,>#im{$%i#&%'E[ ,8zs%%i,D[C

rj0sV38GF$3a1F$‹z#387 Es%i}I F$M3as% rC$uI0j436380j$rM3aF$’350o$,'o$,8GFuY3Drjo #1u„

1L1L

Ghi\$kVkVRC_jOQPDX]^]5\$_GT@_d]`TVX~b/b'gMRC_jOVWM_j]

l3ÈF$~‡'‡/EC,8zIrju3ÈC%i,D F$Y3Drjo #1I3t38M% $$:J$,5sV3836„½lu3w$C,w&%w|#{0|rj1$o1EC,D0^%i

%'C,8F3Drjo1#Y10j~,8u„’prdM%i,D0CB,Dd7>#Y61,·F$j%'‡/rj0s%'Ÿ0jF$ˆ#Yu3!1FBAYFV3!Ã%i,D06A10jY##Y2,·F$0j13·#

,D3'o1jrs% ’$%j#7QrjQVmYC1rj#B$%"o10M3`#3%'C,/o1j##Y06%/$ 3"A1.1I1,D6V3D3…„l30j#YY‡irM0s%/‡D3F$F1,

s%:u¡38›,DECA‹z#j%-0j#,53%i,/$:o1s1,536„@l3<rj}1C,Dr2}$s1,^3<F$EMrju$A$,D2%F$M3†3DY#Y%F$I3<#§u­¡#c3

36m0s%%'CIF$0jYjM%¡ F$M3—Fu‡c‡'EC,Dj1rj3—1rj j 3i1,D0CJ1#3…„l0Á.1Ej$.$,D0Co$}${ F$I3o$,DI1&%'E3—s%F$3

F$Y3c%'0C1rd3zM%i,DFY35rjBo1#Y1u33DG,Djrj$Q3c%i,i1&%a0s$%4I1,F$GrC,D&%'‹C,83rj’#0G,•.us1,F$’#0F$3DrC,Dou%'

rjB,Drj$ 3i%'0C1rjEjj7³#imY%'EC,D¯6%—F ,8jrju1,^3‚€#0€Es%i}$1F$€CIo1EC,D~j%'0j#j7³#0€0jM%/‡iYrM0s%'$ps%—#0

0j#Y‡iYrM0s%'$ F$3Âo1}$Ej$ ‹j$M3ps%Â# %i²uo1tF1 1F$Ez#3D06%/$Q„¡E2o10I353D0j%#u3pF‡/‡'EC,Dj$rdI3

o$,DE3i1o$o1f38Ej387#3arj$Q3c%i,c138zM% F$3aF$Ej0C,Drj}I3aF$)%i,D0^A10jY#rj$6¥D %o1#&V3",DEd0z#3c%'M36„

l3¤F‡/‡'EC,DjIrju3o1$,4%'2%‡i$0j#zj%o1s¡3c1,n#0§3Drjj%'‡crj&%'Ej7"#imY}0z$%'E>u[#imYu$A1C,i%1,D>FQm3/o$,D&%

F$31Q3G6%nF$3¤0su%i,DM36„##I3¤rj$$rj2,/$j%'7Q%iuu%nFQm0sJ$,DFu7£#{3Gj6¥5s1[Q3c%'&%$%i$u1j#3GF$0j13G#3Dj#c3

3D$%o$,/Y3n#u3n~IFBAF£3nŠQ26¥^6 °F$rj0C,',•{‹C,Dj7V F$0j#~%'EM3nF$#mYECA0j#B0s%/{I7£F$:#0:,Djrj$$$0j363D0jIrjs%

F$œ#0€o$,D$u%i$ 3Dj#1 #Yu3ƒF3Drjo1#Y136„[;1uV3D=/3i%i>2,ˆrj3ƒrjM%i,D0j%'3ƒQ³o1‹M3Dj%ˆ3i1,½#{I3

rC}IC,Drj}$s1,53œrdIFQ&%¼wrC,DEj2,ŸF$I3Ÿ1rj <o$,DEj}$j 3D 13Ÿs%¼F$3Ÿ‡c,iV3c%i,D0s%i{136„³ ¯zj7‚F$I3

F$~‡i‡'EC,Dj$rM3<rj$$rMC,/Ij%#0Œo1f3D%/$[,Dj#0s%/BA§F$u3<rj}1C,DrC}Is1,^3<0sˆ3Dj¡F$“#Y61,’o$,D$o$,D“FuY3Drjo1#Y1u„

;1j#!§#s1,3/oEjrj0j#Y&%'E“u3c%rdC%i,D02#Y“u—0C,/.110z#j70zIrjYj$I§u¡II$Aj##j7`#Yu3<j6¥5s s%#{I3

,DY3Du3ajIrjI1,iV3`3D$% F$~‡i‡'EC,Dj%D3…„Co1,%'C,`3'$0s%Y%'2%'3i1,®#3aF$Y‡i‡'EC,Dj$rM3aF$#Y0j¦.10C.1j71F$

rj$$rj2ou%D3a…% F$E6%i}$1F$3D71rC$$F&% GF$#imY%'C,8F3Drjo1#Y10C,D&%'E’3D1rj0j#zj%B,',DEj0j#Y3c%'¦„

l3¤F‡/‡'EC,DjIrju3o1,c%'2%0sV3^3Da3c1,#0†A13DEd›3Drjj%'‡/F$3Q13G6%F$3n06$%i,D36„1D#®32m0C. %0j#$,^3¤F$

rj$:o$,Dj$Fu,8†rd >jM%#u3nrj}1C,DrC}1s1,53nzŒo$,8EI38j$rjŒF$Ej‡i~1363Dj%rjmY#"rj$uA1zM%F$‡/0j,Ds%#{I3

1F$‹j#Yu3s%ŽI¦%i~#3"$%'~#u3’s%%i,DC±-$AI,Du„Q;10j 3rj}$C,Drj}IC,`Go1$,c%'C,F$Ž¥c1.1jj%Ž0zM%arj

3D2,D0j&%#0›J1$$$”38rjYjIrjj7`Y#u3i%$%i#§FQmCIo #rj&%D2,:rM3<F$~‡'‡/EC,8zIrju3<s%F$³3D0j3^–,†#0§#{.1§s%#{I3

rj$%i,D02~M%'3"o$,D$ou,83aF$GrC}I0jo1C,63/o1jr6%/BA1¦„zl3Žrz}1j,Dr2}$s1,^3ŽF$Ejrju$A$,Dj% 0j#$,^3ao1u$,arj2,4%'0CII3

F$Y35rjBo #1I387-1ˆo$,DC¥D6%ŒQmu3c%°3Drjj%'‡/ÃÅ32mY#o103^38‰o10C,°#Y0¡,DEj0j#350s%'ÀFQmBQˆo$,D1F&%“‘41

1F$‹j#Yd7†Q F$Ej 3i%i,D0s%'sI,/™¡1+0CJQ3D$,cJÁ#cm0s%%'C%i$œ6%[#mEj$2,/. u„’ u$,s$17§380½,DEj0j#350s%'

rj$$rC,8‹s%'€r2$ 3c%'&%j7°C 3D$7›ºo$,8.$,D‹M36„†u$,‚F m0s$%i,DM3D7§#0 ,D.us1,½38rjYjM%/‡/ o10363Dj7°0s

rj$%i,D02B,Dj7`o10C,’$°EdA0j#&f0s%i$—rC,D&%'[F$³#Y0³o1C,i%i~Ij$rM³F$u3:o$,DuJ1#‹j>M3D7F$u3u3c%i$Q36%<F$I3

3D$#&$%'$Q36„uD#Y3F$$IzM%a#imY†o$,8I353D FVmY¯s%i,8’F$3n3Drj2o%iM3`o$,D$‡iu3^3D $Ij#43…„%'j#~#u3F‡/‡'EC,DjIrju3D7

3Dj#Y#u3·I¼38M%³o10M3!dIo #rz%'zj% †38I3!j o10j,D$#ˆs% F$EsJ10s%%M3!F$0C 3!#ƒ,83/o1Mrs%°’$%j#7

,Djrd¦u3ns%.1EC,DEj3n2>%'0C%Fu~‡i‡'EC,Dj1rj3nrj$Q3c%iB%¦%i{A3D7"3D$%#{0+38I1,8rjF$¥5s1°FQm0jrMrsV3D0s%'

s%ŽF$Grj¦‡c#&%D3Q>jI0rdzM%"#imYF$j%'&%'EGo$,/$‡i363D $Ij#Y#’F$rj}$0jr6Qs% #03i1,/A1Y¯j>FVm{:%i,D0sA10j#

%'C,8F3Drjo1#Y10j~,8u„

»>¯jj7¡rj2,c%'0C13¼F‡c‡'EC,Dj1rj387·o1,%'0CM% 3c1, #3¼C1~.1jIrju3D7¡#Y»#0ju.102.1 s%À#%i²¦o1»F1

‡i$,•0z#350s%/{I7Ž3c1,n#3nEs%i}$1F$3ns%n3c1,n#0F$Ez0C,8rz}1d7Ž3D$%‡i0jrjY#jj%F$jM%i~‡'YEdI387£0j3GFQm0s$%i,D3

3c1o$o1Q3D2%1Àd0j>jˆ06%%'C%i‡D„)0j 3“#Ãrj0u3“Fˆ%²Io1¡F ·,D02o$o1,%+0sˆ%'C,c,80C$7F$I3›rz}IC,Drj}$61,s3

s%%'CM%!0s o$$~M%!F$3¡ F$‹j#387§3c1,¡#0½J0u3DÁF$ÀF$¦$Eju3¡‡irs%'{Au3¡0sA0jM%'7ŒC€‡iœF1½o$,8s¥D6%'7

FQmz‡i‡'r6%C,®1$<zI¯s%':#EC.1‹C,D’o1u1,’%'M3c%'6,)#{QF$‹j#I7@#imY#Y#BV3c%i,D2,s% :#’,DjIFu,D’A1{A0jM%„ul

%'C,i,D0C$7<F$0zQ3°rj—rj0u3D7<3c%›0C$$C1¦„zl$,^3Dm~#3i%Œo$,DY3“o1#{V3 0sœ38EC,Ds 7:~#F$dA1j%1Á#Y6ŸF1

rj$ 3i%i,cr…%i{ F$u3wo$,DIJ1#Ej0s%'3t6%»1 #C F$ A0j#F$0s%' F1|1F$‹j#YM3xu #C

FQmdIo1EC,D>jM%'0s%i$$7”#jj#—3c1o$o1Q3Dœ#0Ârj$ 3c%i,irs%i FQm{ F$3/o1Q3D&%/‡‚F$œ>3Dœ#imYECo$,8s Au„

(5)

F$3,DE3c#&%'0s%D3F$M%rjC,%'0CQ33i1o$o1f38zM%"1$†3i%i,Drs%'’o1#0C$Y‡/rj06%/$Q„ul3nF$EdrjI1o102.13®%'j:o1$,DC#338M%

o10C,/‡i143no1s!rd :o10s%'BJ1#YM36„ 3Grj}1C,8rC}1s1,^3G¦.QEj$s,^3o16$A1j%'7£o10C,¤s1j:o1#j7"F$Ejrju1o1C,1§o1#0z

F$·,Djr2}$C,Drj}I¡zƒEs%'0Co13“F$$%#m4363i¡F$¡rj}$0Mrs$—3c%0C,8Ej·o10C,>1$·o$,8 Frs%i{ˆrdIrC,D‹s%'

rj0Co1&%'0j#350dJ1#u„ul0:Fu²$I0j>:3i%rsQQ#0s%'BA1:s%a–,/,DEsAC,^3DBJQ#u„V;u1,`#:¯j:IJ2¥5s%'7F$3rC}IC,Drj}$61,s3

C·38 rj1#.1†AM%'7£o10C,Grj$%,Dj7£o10353DC,1§%'j:oQ3¤r$ 3D{F EC,80sJ1#Œ>C$o1#$,DC,G#%'C,',D0j~I7">0CA10jIrjj,

F$3a}u²$o1u%i}$‹M3D3ao$,DuA13D B,83s%,DEsA12,^3DBJQ#u3D71,Djs%%,DGjrd0s£38’#0-‡i$,D’#Y06%/$>$&%'0j#YFo$,DC¥D6%'7

F$3n3i%/{Q3ns%F$3n}u²$o1u%i}$‹3836„$lu3$.1Ej$s1,^3¤z>%'B,DjM%#mY†o$,8363D “FVm{$>3i%'0C.$10s%i$“F #0

,Djr2}$C,Drj}I§0j#$,^3ms11=/¯zu3Go$,D$.$,D353DCM%¤rj$‡i$,/EjzM%¤0s!o #0j!~$%/0j#i„fl3;u˜+;·j§%'B,Dj%

#imYYo$,Du353D “†#3;u‡iIrMzM%`#{0<%'¯6%'<J0jY363DEj>380z13’38:o1f38C,nF$†M3c%i$$7"3D0CQ3G32m0363c1,8C,n

#½o$,DuJ1#‹j>Àu3c%³J1j€o1Q3DE¦„’l3¡F$6 Ÿ%'j:o1,80z#%'E3¡F$ˆ,DjrC}IC,Drj}$ÁI€3D$%[o10M3¡‡i0Mrz#jzM%

rj$$rj#Y0CJ1#I387‰0j3œ3c1,i%iuu%ˆ#0»IÈo$,•38»jxrdou%'»F$prjs%%'pFu~‡i‡'EC,Dj$rM»rdIFQ&%½»F1I3

1rj :o$,8Ez}Ij 3D Q3 o$,D‡i$$F$M3as% GF$3ar2$‡i#Y%D3®M$%/#M3D71Q$o1u1,c,80CzM% ¯…%i,DnEsA1&%'E3…„

3 F‡/‡/E2,Dj$rj387 #{,^38"mj#Y#u3Æ$ 38M%to103 CIo #Yrj&%'EdI3 s%qF$ECJ0s%%3D7 38M%t#0 rj06V35

FQmY1rj <o$,DEC}1j 3D1 3D7F$Ň,cV3i%i,D0s%i$ 3 s%°FQmY0drjrsV3D06%i 3°,DEjrjo$,D13[F$EC.$,D0dF$C%°#0Å0j#&%8E

}0j~1ŒF$u3G,8z#{0s%/{Q3jM%i,DŒrC}$2,DrC}1s1,^3-s%¤1",Dj$‡i,DrdzM%n#u3ju´$²Q3c%'jj%D3F$Y38rzo1#Y10j,D36„Ql

3crdrj‹3<F·%i,D06A10jY#%'C,8FY35rjo1#~10j,D“F$ECo1j$F·0j#$,^3F$§#imYC$o1#$,D0s%i$!s%F$“#0›,8jrj$$$0j363D0j$rj“F1

rj3F$Y‡i‡/E2,Dj1rj36%aF$’#s1,ao$,D438:jrj :ou%'u„M’#0F E2o1C$FŒ0sV363DV#0†3/²I1rz}¦,D$$4380s%'+F$30j‡i‡/ %'EI3

3D1rj0j#3nŠ$rj$Q3c%i,cr^%i$>F$:#0rj$‡'Y0jIrjj7QF$’#0:rduA1A1Y0j#&%'E’6%aFŒ,83/o1jr6%a’$%j#„$M3rj$$F$&%'Q3

rj$$rC,8‹s%'3°F$‰#imYM%'C,DF$438rj~o1#Y10C,D&%'EÅ3D$%+o #V3³Yo1$,c%'0CM%'3°‰#u3°rj0jFu,80C.13°ECo143i%'Ej #$. {I3

o$,DEj0j#0CJ1#u3`šnj#Y#3Œ1‡/#&fj%Œ3i1,>#0!rj0Co10Mrj&%'E·!rj13c%i,cB,D!F$3+IJ2¥5jrs%i‡D3ŒuÀF$3+EMrj0j$43Du3+F$

,DEC.u#0s%'$Q„†lnm0Co$o$,DjM%/Y36380C.1ŸF$I3‚F$‡/‡/E2,Dj$rj3‚‡/0j&%—o102,4%iŸF$3‚0Co$o$,Dj%'Y3^3502.13‚rj ##jrs%'~‡D36„lI3

rj$ 3i%i,cr…%i{Q3aE2o 3c%'Ej$#$. {V3Žrj6¥8 %'3aF$E2o1zIF 2% F$3`3/²I$rj}u,D$$350s%i$Q3aF$j%'&%'0jB,D3…„

1L1L

n_GWj\$TVRC\$_GXOV]•PDXPDUQPDXYS$OVOV_Ce

0CQ3ˆ#3ÀC$o1EC,Dj$rju3ˆF$Ÿ,Djrj}$C,8rz}Iº%'2,DF38rzo1#Y10j,Dj7”#0€o$,8‡iu3^3D{ $$0j#Y%'EœF$Ârz}I0jrsw3c%

%'C,'o1z##Eju„¦)drz3i%£o102,c%irs#Y‹C,Djj%VA$,80z$o1u1,a#3F35rz–o #~1u3aj:o1Q3D&%'$†0C,'. $0j#j71rjGQu3c%

o10C,/‡i143#“rj0u3Go1I1,#u3;u˜+;·0s‚35j~!F$u3Ejrd #u3FVmY$.1Ez$s1,536„@lnmYF$j%'&%'EŒF$3<1FBA1F£3<s%¤F$3

F$Y35rjBo #1I3u3c%Ž0s$%'0CM%"%'C,',/$.1Ej’#u3rj1rdCou%D3s%"#u3 F$‹j#3FQm0C10j#~²3Du„lG,•38’u3c%Ž0sV3635

.$,D0CIF†o1u1,`#u3`1F$BAQFV3Go1u1,`#u3rj1rdCou%D36„l<rj0jFu,D0C.1~Q3i%/%$%i$Ij#Qo$,Dj$FŒ0j#$,^3`rj %'uu%'

3D$†o1$,%'0C$rj¦„

l3F$43'o1f3D%/‡D3`Q3c%'&%u%i{$1j#3a‡/0CA1$,DY3D0jM%"#0,Djrj$$$0j363D0jIrj’F,D3DGo$,D43Žs% F$30Co$o$,Dj%i3^3502.1I3

rj$##Ydrs%/‡D3³os1A1j%[38I¦%'C$B,[#imEjrj}$0ju.1Á38rzj%'‡/V‚z ;u˜Œ;Ÿs%!;u6„lnmY%'C,8Fu438rj~o1#Y10C,D&%'E‚0s

rju1oÁo102,³rju1o $7:06Ÿrj$%i,D02B,Dj7:#0j43638ÃF$u3°‡,c£3i%i,D0s%i$ 3 s%“02.$.$,D0sA1—#Yu3<¥^6 žFQmY0MrjrsV3506%iQ3

,DEjrjBo$,8 3ŽF>.1j¦,DŠ3Drjj$rju3aF1,83c¹i1#Y#3D7}Œ0j$u3c¹i$}MQ0j1I3…„u+rj$%i,D0jB,Dd7 #$,^3DG#I3

M%'0C.13[Q3c%'&%$%i$$$j#3!s%°$,/.10C$3D06%/$$$j#3[o1C,/s%%'2%“#0Å,Dj=/‡i$,D’Q#0s%'$ F$u3[j6¥5s117F1I3

F$~‡i‡/rs#&%'Eu3D71F$3a0jrdQ3as% F$3a‡i10z#&%'Eu3D7 #3a‡/0CA,DY38zM%"#m Ez#0CJ1$,D0^%i$F$-II$Ad0s o1 %D3aF$)A¦Gs%

#0>rj1$o1EC,D0^%iI7®3c1,c%'uu%#,53DmY#3:32mYQ3Dr2,•BAj%)F$0CQ3#0>F1,DEdu„QD#43¤0u3^3i1,Dj%`1I†A143DBJY#&%'EŒs%`1I

‡i$,•:F$-,8jrj$$$0j363D0j$rMF$M%a#u3`rj}IC,Drj}$s1,53$%£JM3D Q„¦•#3$‡c‡,5j%1>rd0jFu,DGo1I1,`#im0j$Y0s%'

‘/EjBo13¼F$ºo$,8s¥5s%'7·#0CJ,D06%i$B,D387‰ 3i%/%$%D3Á‡iEjF$E2,^06%i~‡D3D7·,8E3Dj06 7·o$,D.¦,D0Cu3 uto$#u3¼F$

rj$:o1Es%'&%'{A1%'EC™6„)Œrd0jFu,D0C.1ŒQ3c%'&%$%i$$$j#`u3i%GE2.10z#{zj%¤†o1$,%'0C%no1u$,rjs$”Q`#3-0z$zM%

rj0C,a#s1,auA1u3c%i353DjzM% 3c%a3D1~o1$,c%'0CM%#s1,",Ddrj¦$0j363D0j1rjGF$3Drjo #~10jB,8Gz:A1j%o10C,/‡i1Y3

¯s%i,D,DC35GCrj06£38u„

l[rj0jFu,D02.1”$,/.10C$380s%/{$Iz#{7)o10C,C1jo #[#Y0[rj$ 3/%i%$%i—FQm3'oQ0jrd3F@m0j$Y0s%'$‘/rj$&%'E3F1

o1~#{I%'0C.1d7›3DEj10j~,8I387†.$,Du1o13!F$Ã%i,D0sA0j~#7¥Du1,/1EM3!FVmYE6%F$j7†,D6Au387>C$o1EC,Dj$rjÀrj$6¥D %'C™87

‡'0dA,'438>#imY0Co$o$,8zM%/353D0C.1rj ##jrs%'~‡D„QD#"#Y>%'>#Y0o1C,c%'~$‡i$,D0s%'$$$j#Y#GF!‡i0j&%nF[o10353D0C.>FQmB1

F$Y35rjBo #1½Å#im0s$%i,8‰(Ÿo103[#‰%'j:oQ3!F$Ã,DCAz$,!0s$À%'su%'3 ,DB.110s1Ÿ$>FVm0Co$o$,D$‡iIF,[#I3

0jIrM36„Ql3‡c1u363D3-F$3%i}$Ed,D387®Es%i}$1F$36%nFu$uIEju3Ejrj}$0Co$o1jM%GFQm0s$%'0CM%no$#&V3 mY$³o10C,c%

F$30jj#3ns%F$’o$,DEM3Dj%'0s%i{Q3n3/²$%'}$E6%/u3…„Il0rj$#~#0CJ1$,D0s%i{³3i1,)#0:# ¦.u:F1,DEj:o1C,D6%F$

(6)

s%#3aF1j%i&%'EM3"o$,D$‡i363D $Iz##36„

$‡c17 #u3",8‹C. #3ŽFG¥5s Šuj##YM3arj$%i,DBJuj% Grj$ 3i%i,4B,DGF$3ŽI3'o10jrju3aF$)%i,D06A10j#Q%'C,DF$3Drjo #10–,Du„

D#)32m0C.1&%FVmYQ3c%'&%C,<#0§rd$‡/0j$rM!Š£o10jrs%'“F$§$$$=/0j.$,DM3^3D !§#imjIrjM%i,D“F$3o1C,^3D$$13s%F$3

F$Y35rjBo #1I3ƒs%¡A11#M%'Eœ0j‡c‡'Yrj}IEjœF$œ,DCIFu,D€o1Q3^3D~J1#œ#0Ârj$‡,8M%'0s%i$ F$3ˆo1$%D3ˆF$€A¦š

,Djrd¦$0j363D0j$rMŒC$o1#Yrj&%'ŒF¡‡'0j&%¤m0srs$ŒF$3Drjo #1›Vm0›#Œ Io1$#ŒFVm{[uJ2¥^6%GFQmEs%F$Œs%

mY#C143i%'$¡o1#{1,80z#&%'E—F$Ão1 %D3°F$‰A¦Ås%“FQmC$o$,DM363D„lI3“,D‹2. #3 F—¥^6 0zF$j%“#{I3

rC}IC,Drj}$s1,53`G0drjrMCou%'C,aF$’3Du1s%%i,8’3D3"o$,8o¦,D3£A¦V3Ž-#0GF$435r6V363Ds% F$o10C,i%'0C.1C,"#’38Irj1f

rjs%%'Œ0sA1jM%1,D†J1ECIEj‡/rjŒŒrj}10jrsQ„V•#`3…m0C.1&%¤FQmYQ3c%'0s1,8C,1$ŒEs%i}${ŒF¡F$0j#.uŒ6%GF!,DM3/o1jrs%

F$3<F$~‡'‡/EC,8zIrM3D7Ž$“#.1³F$§#imEjrj}I0z¦.1u„"n+%i²$o1“F$›,8‹C. #“F“¥5d‰3c%¤o #BV3<‡/EjrdIF¡§#I3

rj0jFu,80C.13aECo13c%'Ej #{.13"o$,8Ej0j#Y0CJ1#3…„

1L

GhiXYOV]DPDRCU ³_dOfP8\uPDXYS$O“TV_)ehigjWV\$O $_GXYOQPD_dRCTVXY]5WjXYkQeXYOV\$XR2_

D#rj$uA1zM%>%4I¦%'C‡i Y3 F ÅF$E2o10363DC,[#imdIo #{,D06%/$ŸF$3 F‡/‡'EC,Dj$rdI387†#0‚rjQ3i%i,cr^%i¼F$ÅrM0jFu,D3

ECo13c%'EC1#.1u3ns%13c%'&%$%i$$$j#36„l0rj$ 3c%i,irs%i$³35rzj%i‡/rj$6¥D %':o10u3^350sV363DVo0C,#{I3

o$,D0s%i{3F35rs1,53D{Au3s%0j$~ou#0s%'$B,D3+F$”0s%'EC,D0s$7F$§%i,D0jrjM3.$,D0Co1}$Yu3s%F$[rj$%'CMV36„

j% 3c1o$o1$,4%'2, rd3 o$,D0s%iu3 F$ >0j$ ‹C,D %'C## mz##I3 ‡'0jrjY#&%8zM%y# %i,D0sA0jY#

%'C,8F3Drjo1#Y10j~,8»s%ˆ#0prj$‡,8M%'0s%i$xF$3Ào1 %D3¼F$A¦Â‘c<~1r2´17·µ1¶$¶$¶u™ÅIV3¼F$sA1$ 3

o1u1,^3c1BA$,8”#0³,DEj‡/#d1{ —jÃo1$,4%'02%<#cm0s%%'CM%i$½3i1,>#imYQ3c%i,cj%'06%i—F$[rMs%%'”‡i$,/[F@m0Mrs%i

rj$##Ydrs%/BAu„$ ’$uV3`#im0dAQ3uJQ35C,iA1EF 0j 3#’rM0jFu,DF$Go$,Ds¥8s%D3F$-,Ddrz}IC,Drj}$rj$6¥D %D3j%i,8

3D1rj$#.uM3s%:Ejrj0j$rzjQ3‘'0zI0j#~²Q35°F$I3<o$,D1rj3^3/V3F$[rjIrjCou%'$u™D7#0[0z#&%'E³F$u3Edrz}10j¦.1I3

F$ECo1CIFF$I3 IJ2¥5s%D3 ~M%'C,DEjF$0z,DM3 <o$,D F1%D3as%VuJ1~#3DEu3aF$0CQ3a#imY%'C,80jrs%'„

lnmErj}I0z¦.1œo10I353Dj7[o10C,ÀC1jo #j7[o10C,Á#0º35Âjwrj :QwF$€%'s¦%'3Àrj$Q3DF E2,DE3Àrj +

Yo1$,4%'02%D3o10C,Œ#im{$!F 3+F$435rjo1#Y13“j—o$,DE35j$rj$„®3%'su%'387-#£3+s%F$ECJ106%%V3ŒC‚rj :$7

rj$ 3i%i&%C%F$M3uJ2¥Ds%D3%'C,DEdF0jB,53F$0j13#Y0<FI²I10z:rj ##jrs%'BA1u„1`}$ 3D3`o102,®1$:F$3Drjo #1

Á#mYM%'zM%/{ F$u3¡rj}$2,Drj}$s1,^3!o10C,c%'2$0jB,Du3D7Œ#3Œ¥DuVCM%³1Ÿ, #{ÁF$½,8Co$,DE38zM%'0s%i$œFVmBQ IJ2¥8s%

3Drjj%i‡/jzM%rj$ 3c%i,i1&%'7VFQm{Œrj$$rdCou%I°FQmB11:Es%i}$1F$†3c1,#jj#£#"32mY0C.1,D0j&%F$-%i,D06A10jY##Y2,

CQ38z:J#u„l’%'s¦%',8Cou,DEM3DCM%'†06V3^3D@“uJ2¥Ds%rj:“z“F$6Az$–,6„ D#rj$%i,/BJu‡/0jB,DC13c%'C,87

F$0CQ3#YG.$,Du1o1j71uJ2¥Ds%a%'C,8Fu438rj~o1#Y10j,Du„uD#1,DCo$,DEM3Dj%'rjs$+@#’s%%'2%`3i1,®#{0¤%'0sJ1#:š1~#3i%

#s1,"o1$,4%'j=io10s,'#Gs%f,DCo$,DE38C%'G#s1,"o1$% F$)AuG‘'0Co$o$,D1rC}$j71r2IrjCou%D3D7%²¦o1GF$GF$$u1EjGuJ1Y#438Ej7

3c%²I#GF$Grj13c%i,cr6%i<10C,/,D0s%iBAj7 6%'ru„™6„j/#1rdM%i,/BJuGrj13c%i,c1–,D’3DY:#&%'0j$EjzM%V1$Grj$uI0z36380z1rd

F$G#mYuJ2¥5s% s%F$#0G‡i0 j$F$-# mY0CJ1$,DF$C,…„

lnmErj}I0z¦.1o10u3^3DG06£353D o10C,a#)%i,D0sA0z#@3i1,aF$3auJ2¥5s%D3"%'0Cu.1BJ1#YM3£%'j#43Žm{F$43Do1Q3D&%'‡"C$o1EC,Dj%'0j#7

1·o1#0j¡u‚F$3:o$‹drju3>Edrj0j$YM3u¡1¡rj$:ou%'j=c,8C$F‚FQmIJ3DC,/A0s%/{„ l³‡i0j&%<F$”38§,DCIFu,5

CQ38z:J#›3c1,n#<%'2,/,D0C°s%FQm²Œ%i,D0sA10j#Y#C,¤3c%0sV353D£1“F3Do1Q3D&%/‡`o$,DBA1Y#EC.1E:o1I1,n#cm0Co$o$,DjM%/Y36380C.

FÆ%i,D0sA0j~#À%'C,DF$3Drjo #10z–,^¦„l0Èrj ='rj13c%i,cr^%i$ÆF$x#imY$J2¥^6% F$v#{0v,8jrj}$C,Drj}Ixs% F$x#0

o$,DuJ1#Ej0s%/{ 35§‡'0j&%rd6¥D1~M%'j>jM%C¡¯j+%'CoQ3§#0§F1Ejrju$A1C,i%'§Fo1%-F$›Au“F1

rC}I0r6Q!‘/Es%i}$1F$3D7F‡i‡/rsQ#%'EI3<F$§35§j[±-1A$,8”6%G,DE3iQ#%'0…%D3'™6„@l“F0j#$.u³3i%FQm0s$%'0CM%Go1#&£3

‡'0jrjY#³f³rj}10jrs·A1 &%'7F$³0j$Y‹2,D³rj$$rC,8‹s%'³s%G%40Cu.1BJQ#j7rj j%<#3rj}$Q3D3Œ38 o10M363Dj%<s%

rj$>jM%a#u3rj}$C,8rz}Is1,^30C.1363Dj%5„uD#Y3n3D$%Ž0z#{,^3# >F13F1EdJ0s%D3ECo143i%'Ej #$. {3jŒrj}I0z:JI,Du„

Drj7#0·35rjj$rj·35[rj$ 3c%i,iQ&%F$0C13>#0”0~%i,D3D[F$3+F$Es%'0C#3Œ6%:#¡3DEC,Ds1‚F$[rz}I0jrs·%/{zM%[F$3

C¦.10C.Qjj%D3V%'0Cu.1BJ1#I3…„

+mY0s$%i,83 0jrs%iBA1&%'E3 rj$6¥D %'u3 ‘/Ejr2,•%1,Dj7—u,/.10C$350s%i$qFQm{qrj ##1 u FQmB1Æ3DEj>10j,Dj7

rj$$rj2ou%is%,DEj0C#350s%'FQm{j 38z.1$jj% I†rj$=c2$rM0jFu,Djj% FQmEs%F$0j%i™a0CF$jM%"Gr2$ 3c%i,i1B,5

s%:s%Y%i,8†:#mECo$,D6 A†#0rj$‡i0j1rjs%`#{0†rd$I0z36350CIrM†’$%j##u„##3nrj$$F35j%-%,D06A10jY##j,

#u3 1F$0z#&%'Eu3¼FQmEjrC,D&%1,83 6%ÀF$º‡i$,D0j#Y350s%i$tF$3Ÿ3D0CA11B,^3D7¡pu3^3D0C²C, F$u3¼rj13c%i,cr6%iQ3

%'C,8F3Drjo1#Y10j~,83<s%§#{I3<s%%i,D“Œ#cmECo$,D6 Au„`;13<rj1=/rC$ 3i%i,cr^%iQ3<rj06%'0z#B²35zM%G#0“Fu²$10j>f

%'C,8F3Drjo1#Y10j~,8u„

l·%c²¦o1ÅFQmIJ2¥5s%“M%'C,DEjF$Y0j,DÃ1‡/#B½3c1,°#Y0—Fu²$0zu„)9¤uJu3c%'—s%“u$A12,4%'7’#Œ3c1o$o1$,%'Ã#0

(7)

¸2¾$¾$¾$0C™as%@0s$rj$$rj2ou%'s1,^3a‘c$rC´17"¸2¾$¾$¾J$™aF$Grd13c%i,cB,DGF$3 o$,•3Du3`3D. $‡/0j%'M3aFo1% F$)A¦

F$rz}I0jrsŒs%ŽF$’EjF$Y06%/Y38C,`#C1,`CIo$,D363D$Q„13uJ2¥5s%D3D7rj =io$,/1F1&%D3D71}u²uJ1,DF$3D7Q0dF›}I rj7I$AI,DC%

#u3"o1f353DBJ1Y#Y%'EI3ŽF@mBQ0Co$o$,Dj%'Y363D02.1’rj$6¥D M%5„zl)%i,D06A10jY#rj$6¥D %3c1,aF$3ECJ10srj}II3ŽF$¤%'s¦%'3D7$o10C,

szo1#j7[I3i%¡1 j%‚F$œ#imYEdrC,D&%1,Dœu­ÈF$3ˆF$BA1C,'.1zIrju3ˆrj$$rMCou%j##3 3c1,'. 3^38j%5„jl0

,DEjF$0drs%i$ FVm{$Ã,8ECo113Dˆrj$1ō‰ 02o$o1z#+FQmY$‡i‡c,Dd7†FQmBÁ,D0Co$o1$,%“~M%'C,DEjF$0z,Dd7†FQmB1

ou$J1#Yrj06%/$—s%FQm{1I[rj :Q$rj0s%'$Å3D$%0su%'02%<FQm rjrd03D 13FQmY0Co$o$,8 ‡iIF–,>#imEjrj}$0j¦.1”6%F$

>s1w3DŸrj$$$0~%i,Du„D#ŒoQ6$%¡06V3^3D·3…m0C.1B,ÅFQmB»o$,D%4%²uo1 F$Ÿ#.1rjYj#7°F 35rdEzI0C,D»FVmBQI

F$Ej$Q3c%i,D0^%i$$7>FQmB$½0j6%%'ƒMQEC,DYd7>FQmBQŸo #{0zŸF$ˆrju1,^387>^%'ru„"IV3!rjM3³J$,DuQ## Q3

3c1o$o1$,%'C%°#0Árd13c%i,crs%i{Ÿ%'C,DF$Y35rjo #10j,Du„:p‡Y1,!s%[ˆ3i1,DˆF ˆ#Y61,·35½06œo1 M%'7

rjB,Drs#0s%'s% F3Dr6V363D $71~#3rC,DEdzM% F$-#imY,/,DECAC,^3DBJQ#Y&%'EGF$0jQ3a#0’Fu²$10jVGrd ##Ydrs%/BAj7I%'02%a3c1,a#

o1#0j F$Å#0Ão$,D1Frs%i$€3Drjj%'‡/ÅÅF$Å#0Ã,DM=/rj$ 3i%i,cr…%i{ F$j%'&%'0jB,Du„G/#3!3c1o$o1$,c%'C%“#{0

rj$ 3i%i,cr…%i{F$3rj1:o$,D 3s%<F$M30/¥cV3c%'jj%D3<#Y1rj0s$‰s%3D2,cA1CM%<F$›J10M35³³#0³rj$Q3c%i,cr^%i

FQmBQI,DCo$,DE38j%'0s%i$:o10C,i%'0C.1Eju„

$L

S$O@W2eYUV]5XYS$O

l0·,Djrj}IC,Drj}$Å;u˜+;ÁF$0j 3“#3“EMrj1#3“FVmY$.1Ej$Y61,^3°3c%1ˆsjo1#Y”%²¦o1¡F 3°3D&%0s%'Q3›F$

%i,D0sA0j~#"M%'C,DF$Y35rj~o1#10z,Du­·38rsQ:#zM%`#{I3nF$‡/‡'EC,5C$rM3nF$#Y0j¦.10C.1j7£F$Es%i}$1F$j7£F$:,D02o$o$$,4%

#0€%'z<o1,D02#~%'Ej7·F$œo$,DuJ1#Ej0s%/{j7·F$œo1Q3D&%i$ 38 rj0j#Âs%ˆF$œ#E2. &%'Y&%'Eu„Œl0o1#&1o10C,i%ˆF$3

o$,DuJ1#‹j3[,DC1rj$%i,8E3[F$0CQ3[#3!Edrz}I0ju.3[j%i,8Ão$}u²Q3DrjzQ3!6%ŒJ1 #$. 3i%'3D7:o10C,[6zo1#j7>35

,Ds%,/u$A1jM%£{rzC10jrdC,/J1Eu36„¦"I¦%'C‡i Y387f3i1,®#{-‡i$$F$7 #{I3ao$,/Irzo10j#u3aF‡/‡irCQ#&%'EM3`3D$% F$¯j-I0s%1,D

s%3c1o$o1Q3DCM%aF$Go$$,4%'C,a#m0s%%'CM%i“3c1,`#{I3¯z3FjQ3D$Q3`F$#cm0jrs%'rj1#~#jr6%/BA1Š$#’rj0dFu,D0C.

Q3c%'&%$%i$$$j#7 #im0drjrj$,DF>3c1,aF$3",8‹C. #3ŽFG¥5s+s%"#mY@3i%i,c1j%'0s%i{F$G#0Grj$$‡,DM%'0s%i$F$u3"o1 %D3

F$-A¦u„0z13rj2,c%'0j~13rj0M3D7Q#I3rj}$2,Drj}$s1,6335-,8s%i,/uuAj%a06$%iu1,`FQmB1F3Do1Q3D&%/‡aC$o1E2,•zM%'0j#Qu

3c1,£1¯z)%'C,',D0j~„u)%i²¦o1GF@mIJ2¥5s% %'C,DEjF$0j~,8’‡i0jrjY#&%'-#imCIo$,D363D F$I3 o1 %D3aF$AuGs% #0

rj$ 3i%i,cr…%i{rj$6¥D %'F$3ao$,DuJ1#Ej0s%/{I3s%ŽF$3"Es%i}I F$3…„u1,®#{3rz}IC,Drj}$61,^3n;I˜+;ŒCEjrd #

FQmY$.1Ej$s1,^3D7#rduA1j%<FQmYuAzM%'C,F$3<uJ2¥Ds%D3u%'C,/EjF0jB,53Q`ou363Dj%3i1o$o1,%'6,F$+%'2#43

EjrC}10j¦.13D7£o10C,¤C1jo #>#imEs%'0sJ1#3635jzM%nFQmB1³rj1:o%'d=4,D2$F!FQmIJV38C,cA0s%i{I7"F$>rj0u3%c²¦o1YM3Gu

F$:3DrjEj$02,•{f3£3DC,/AzM%aF$J10u3D0s%i,D0sA10j#Vrj$6¥D %8„$3IJ2¥8s%D3D7Q0M3^3D1rjEu3’#0’#jrs%1,Drj$6¥D %'

F$>ou1J1#~rM0s%'$ 3<C1jo #0jB,Du3F1›#0ŒF$35rzo1#Y1j7arj$%i,DBJuj%¤Œ‡i0z,D“C13c%'C,D7aF$0C13:#§rd##Mrs%i‡GF1

,Djr2}$C,Drj}Ij7ÃQ IJ2¥5s%Ÿ%'2,DF35rz–o #~10j,Du„¡D#3Ârj$%i,DBJujM% xrj$ 3c%i,i1B,D 3D#&%'0j$Ejj% 1I

rj$uI0z36380z1rdŒF$›#imJ2¥5s%¤s%¤F$>#0›‡'0j$[F1›#im0CJ1$,DF$C,6„Ql†%i,D0sA0z#rj$6¥D %3c1,F$u3ECJ0srj}13F1

%'s¦%'3I½F$ F$‹j#·3i%:1Å1j%o$,/BA1#Ej. Ej7G#·u­Á3…mYC$o$,DC,D$%#{I3+F${AC,/.1j$rM3+s%#{I3

o1Q3^3DBJ1Y#&%8E3FVm0C,c%irs#Y06%i“rdIrC,D‹s%'3…„$³‡1,s%:3c1,8:F$:#Y61,)35:0s°o1$~M%'7@#3rC,D3c%'0j##Y35j%

#u3n0Co$o$,Dj%'Y363D02.1I3nrd6¥D1~M%D3G6%`o$,D1F1Y38zM%#0>‡i 3nF$I3,8E3c#&%'0s%D33Drjj%'~‡iu3nrj ='rj13c%i,c1%D3ns%

F$3rz}IC,Drj}$61,^3`o1#B£30Cou%'3<F$II$Aj#Y#u30CA1j%1,83F$’,8jrj}$C,Drj}IM%'C,DF$438rj~o1#Y10j,D3…„0CA1$,/3D2,

#u3[0Co$o$,DjM%i4353D0C.3 rj6¥8 %D3!3i%“o$,DIJ0sJ1#j>jM%³#0ˆjY##Y61,DÅ>0j$‹C,D‚F@m0363c1,8C,[F$Å0j$‹C,5

F1,D0sJ1#G#imY0C,i%/r6Q#0s%'$F$-#{0,DjrC}1C,8rC}1:;u˜Œ;CEjrd#FQmYu.1Ej$s1,^3…„

$L

GXQeYXS$RC\$k VXY_

.10CI7 ƒ„&7‘C¸2¾$¾ ¿M™'7fl0’%i}$‹38F$†#%'C,DF$3Drjo #10C,D&%'EF$0CQ3#33Drjj$rM33D1rj0j#YM36„ lrC,D 3DjzM%

F$3`3'o1Ejrj0z#&%'E387 1¬ ! …¬"j«$#%#M7$‘&¦¶u™'7o$o„µ$µI=cµ1ÇQ„

'6d0zM%'s%i7$„7$‘C¸2¾$¾ ¿M™'7Il3 uJ2¥^6%D3aF$0C 3a#0Grj$$rj2ou%i„z#Ej>jM%D3"o1II,£1$’38 rC{ #$. GF$M3"o$,D1rj3^3i£3

F$Grj$$rj2ou%iI7(1¬"d«Y¬"Y¬*)V« {ª^¨+2¨1«$7$‘ u™£o$oV„jµ1¾£¸2=V¸-,Q„

—Q3DrdIA1rj7V;@„71‘C¸2¾$¾ ¿M™5„&7.EjrdIF&%'EM3D7 #Y&%'3s% EjrC}IMr3aF$G#Y0o$,80s%/{-%'2,DF38rzo1#Y10j,Dj7* /)-$ª

.¨1«071‘ ™D7uo$oV„Q¸*&¦= $¶ „

*7 ‘C¸2¾$Çuµ¦™D7!«%1 2j«©«0$¨$ª6«30#*45`ª6¬6.7 8 j«9):- 1 ª ;Cª<-M7 *®’7u"02,/36„

"}$~##7`H†„ s%˃0C,/,D0jM%'7=a„7`‘C¸2¾$¾ ¿M™'7 5¨1«1¬?>2ª®©¬"uª .1«$+ 6«@%# Ad«@~¬?> " ª B©¬.^¨16. 27

,D353D3£?${A2,^3D&%'0jB,53aF$`0j’1,6„

(8)

M%i,/BJu$%'$“†#0†o$,D3Dz“rd :ou%'F$3¤IJ2¥5s%D3nF$0CQ3¤#u3nFI²I10zI33D1rj0j#3D7" *+; ª^¨"C¨1«

1¬"j«¬"Y¬*)V«z7GD‘iµ$™/7$o$oQ„ ¿"&M="¸V„

:$r2´17<7‘C¸2¾$¾$¾J$™87 ) #1«*uª ·¨"$¬« -4 9"1¬*)Qª5¨D©/1« ¨ ~«$+d«@0# j¬. «Y¬.

8«0"1¬"+C¨1«Y¬.71H,DC$uJ1#j7u@?H„

:$r2´17 +„7"‘cµ1¶$¶$¶u™D7 5`ª^¨1«" A?«01 2j«©«0$¨$ª…«@0#;4 B¨1B«Y¬. 2j« A?«0 {ª6«

? j«9): 17 HG,DCIIJ1#d7IV?H†„

Références

Documents relatifs

To test whether the vesicular pool of Atat1 promotes the acetyl- ation of -tubulin in MTs, we isolated subcellular fractions from newborn mouse cortices and then assessed

Néanmoins, la dualité des acides (Lewis et Bronsted) est un système dispendieux, dont le recyclage est une opération complexe et par conséquent difficilement applicable à

Cette mutation familiale du gène MME est une substitution d’une base guanine par une base adenine sur le chromosome 3q25.2, ce qui induit un remplacement d’un acide aminé cystéine

En ouvrant cette page avec Netscape composer, vous verrez que le cadre prévu pour accueillir le panoramique a une taille déterminée, choisie par les concepteurs des hyperpaysages

Chaque séance durera deux heures, mais dans la seconde, seule la première heure sera consacrée à l'expérimentation décrite ici ; durant la seconde, les élèves travailleront sur

A time-varying respiratory elastance model is developed with a negative elastic component (E demand ), to describe the driving pressure generated during a patient initiated

The aim of this study was to assess, in three experimental fields representative of the various topoclimatological zones of Luxembourg, the impact of timing of fungicide

Attention to a relation ontology [...] refocuses security discourses to better reflect and appreciate three forms of interconnection that are not sufficiently attended to