Vers la certification du compilateur v5 d'Esterel dans Coq
47
0
0
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Vers la certification du compilateur v5 d’Esterel dans Coq Delphine Kaplan - Terrasse. No 4092 Décembre 2000. ISSN 0249-6399. ISRN INRIA/RR--4092--FR. ` THEME 1. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6) "!# $&% '(*),+-. # #0/&21 $3 465879:<;4>=@?A75B?A;DCFE46G GH?JII4 KLNMPORQTSVUXWYPZ[Q\^]6_ QP`aZ[b6Zc`cMORQPZ dfe `Pgihkj@Klcmn Wa\poAoJhkqc`arsQfq[Q e LAQPq e LNQtj uwvkxzyVU|{Y e QPOR}Aq[Qfyzvkvkv~UuwToJ\^kQZ s Tf.Q e hkORoNg\p`cQP]AqJAr.Zc`[QPqcQAQPZc`}\^Z[YZc]Nq]Ajq\ RjAQORQPj6`.ZcYO#\^j6`[gz]AQr6Q\ e \p]AZ\pgi`[Y e hzqcq[QPZcoJhkjrN\^j6`R\^]6_@ e giq e ]Agi`[Z e hkjNZc`cq[] e `[g<ZBrN\^jAZiQRr6hzO#\pgjNQr6]O \^`[YPqcgiQPB .\ Z[YPO#\pj6`cgz]AQFQZc` oAq[YPZcQjw`[YPQ>o\^qT]Aj¡QjAZcQPO2}NQ r6Q qcMPziQPZr¢ gij6<YPqcQPj e Q@rA\^jAZ2iQ$Zc`Bb6iQ#r6Q \ ZcYO#\^j6`[gz]AQ2jJ\^`c]NqcQPiiQk £¤hk]AZ \ khkjNZ2oAqchz]AkY$8hzqcORQiQPO$QPj6`\ e hkqcq[Q e `[ghzj¥r6Q@\>`[q\krs] e `cgihzj¦r¢ ]NjAQ o\^q[`cgiQ@ZcgizjAg¨§ e \^`[gikQ r6]©\pjAw\pkQQPj e gq e ]Agi`cZ\p]@ORh^bzQPj#r6]©Zcb6Zc`[MPORQFrsQoAqcQ]AkQPZm
(7) hA$QP`frsQFZ[hkj@gij6`cQPq,ª\ e Q]A`cgiigiZ\p`cQP]Aq r6giZ[ohzjAgi}AiQ~rN\^jAZam
(8) QPj6`\^]Aq \ jAhz]AkQPiiQ2ZcYO#\^j6`[gz]AQ e hkjAZ[`cqc] e `cgikQ@r.Z[`cQPq[QPa\@r.\p}hzqrY`cYRY e qcgi`cQ QPj«K b6oJhkB¬r6hzjAj\pjw` r. ]AjNQo\^q[`a]Aj©gj6`[QPqcoAq[MP`cQTQPj®¯qchkihz2QP`r.\^]A`[qcQo\pqc`V]AjAQZ[oY e g§ e \^`[ghzj@QPj®m
(9) hAJ \2`[q\krs] e `cgihzj QPj e giq e ]Ng`°V\}\^Z[Qfr6] e hkORoNg\p`cQP]AqZ[`cQPq[QP.A\YP`[Yfr6giq[Q e `cQORQPj6`
(10) ZcoJY e g¨§YPQQPjRm
(11) hA QPjR]A`[gigiZ\^j6` B hkqr6qcQ@Z[]AoJYPqcgiQP]Aq .Q@oAq[gij e gio\^V`cq\ k\^gia\ e hkjNZcgiZc`[Y®° e Qqc`cg¨§Qq#iQ e hzORoAgi\^`[QP]AqTs>Qj¥m
(12) hAQPj q\^giZchzjAj\^j6`Z[]Aq e QPZVZcoJY e g¨§ e \p`cgihkjAZ ±³²J´H µ¶p·8>"\^jNw\^zQPZ
(13) o\^q\^iiMPiQPZZcb6j e LAq[hkjAQPZ ¬Z[`cQPq[QPAA¬Aq[QP]AkQZ8hzqcORQiQPZ ¬wm
(14) hAJ¬A¸6oJY e g¨§ e \H¹ `[ghzj@r6Q e giq e ]Agi`[Z¬m
(15) Qqc`cg¨§ e \^`cgihzjrsQ e hkORoNg\p`cQP]Aq . ÆkÇBÈÉÈÊË^ǪÌ[ÈËÊÍ<ÌÈÎÏcÐÎ^ÇBÍ.Ñ6Ò Î^ÓkÔ.ÕiÐÇ8ÖaÈ×ÊÐÓÙØwÐPÍ<×ÚÑ^Ð Ïc×<ÐÇBÈË Ô.Ñ^ÔJÛ<ÈÓHÉÊÔBÇJÈÛÎ^ÊËËÔc×.ÜÝPÝÞ^ß. º»¼,½B¾¿<ÀPÁB¾iÂAà ¾8Ä<Å. Unit´e de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis 2004 route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 SOPHIA-ANTIPOLIS Cedex (France) T´el´ephone : 04 93 65 77 77 - International : +33 4 93 65 77 77 T´el´ecopie : 04 93 65 77 65 - International : +33 4 93 65 77 65.
(16) @. ¢ ! ! 2 - Ù % ' +-¢ > "! / 21 ¯ ´
(17) ¶^´zKLAQA e hzORoAgiiQPq.hp¢Z[`cQPq[QPJgZ}\^Z[QrThkjT\aq[Q§jAQORQPj6`h^ e \^]AZ\^igi`Bbf`[L\^` e hzqcq[QPZcoJhkjrsZ `[h@`cLAQ e hzjAZc`[qc] e `[gikQ e gq e ]Agi`cZ,gijL\pqr \^q[Qk 2KLAQ e hkjAZ[`cqc] e `cgikQ$ZcQPO \^j6`cg e ZgiZFr6Q §jAQr>}6b\RZ[QP` hpfgij68QPq[QPj e Q q[]AiQPZ2ig zQ2gij £a\p`c]Aq\^¸6QPO \^j6`cg e Z Q$L\ kQT<hkqcO \^ig PQr\pjr>oAqch^zQr e hkq[qcQ e `2`cLAQ `[q\^jNZc\^`[ghzjh^ \
(18) Z[gzjAg¨§ e \pjw`.oJ\^qc`h^ ¯Zc`cQqcQPAgij6`ch e hkjAZ[`cqc] e `cgikQ e giq e ]Agi`cZ¬ g`[LAgij`cLAQoNqch6h^ \pZcZ[gZ[`\pjw` m
(19) hAJ KLNQ e hzjAZc`[qc] e `[gikQ@Z[QPO#\pjw`[g e ZFhp~Z[`cQPq[QPL\^Z §q[Zc`2}JQPQPj q[g`[`cQPj gij¡K
(20) b6ohz gij«`cLAQ@m
(21) QPj6`\p]Aq QPj66giqchzjAORQPj6` ¬^b6gQrsgjNf}Jhk`[L#\q[hkihkZ[oQ e g¨§ e \^`[gihkj <Q_AQ e ]A`\^}AiQ
(22) \^jJr2\m
(23) hAZ[oQ e g§ e \^`[ghzj KLAQ `[q\^jNZc\^`[ghzj®hp¤¯Zc`cQqcQPoAq[hkzq\^O$Zgj6`[h e gq e ]Agi`cZ L\^Z}JQPQPj¡rsgq[Q e `[b>giORoAiQPO$QPj6`cQr$gij¡m
(24) hAJ¬.]AZcgijA LAgizLAQPqRhzqr6Qq -KLNQ@oAqch6hp~hp e hzqcq[Q e `cjNQPZcZ@LJ\^ZR`[LAQPj }JQPQPj³oQPq,8hkq[ORQr¢¬qcQ \^ZchzjAgijA¡\^}Jhk]N`2`cLAQPZ[Q Z[oQ e g§ e \^`[ghzjAZ .!µ ²" $# ^ ¸6b6j e LAqchzjAhk]AZ\pjAw\pkQPZ ¬Z[`cQPq[QPsN¬q[h6h^`cLAQhkqcb6¬m
(25) hAJ¬Am
(26) giq e ]Ng`[ZaZ[oQ e g§ e \^`[ghzj¬ m
(27) QPq[`cg¨§ e \p`cgihkj hp e hkORoNgiQPq[Z .
(28) T 2# Ù £¤hk]AZarsY e qcgizhkjAZarA\pjAZ e Qq\^oAoJhkq[`]AjAQoAq[QPORgiMPq[QfY`\^oJQohzZcZ[g}NQzQPqcZV\ e QPq[`cg¨§ e \p`cgihkj QPj@m
(29) hA r6] e hzORoAgi\^`[QP]AqARr¢ ¯Zc`cQqcQPB .£hz]AZ e hkjAZ[gr6YPqchzjAZ\T`cq\zr6] e `[gihkjr6QPZoAqchzkq\^ORO$QPZr6]@jAh^b6\^] r.Z[`cQPq[QP ª¯Zc`cQqcQP]Aq ÙQPj e giq e ]Agi`cZ ¬k`[QPiQaz] QPiiQQPZ[` oAq[YPZcQjw`[YPQrA\^jNZ y c km
(30) QP`[`cQajNhk]AzQPiQ
(31) `cq\kr6] e ¹ `[ghzj QPZc`}\pZcYPQTZc]AqV]Aj@q\ RjAQPO$QPj6` Z[YPO#\pj6`cgz]AQr6Q\ e \^]NZ\^igi`cYz¬z]Ag e hkqcq[QPZcoJhkjJr®°\TjNhk`cgihzj#r6Q rN\^jAZiQrshkO#\pgijAQr6]®O \^`[YPqcgiQPB .£hz]AZ\ khkjNZa]A`[gigiZcYTiQFZ[b6Zc`cMORQ2r6Q2oAqcQ]AkQ gij6 `c QPq
(32) \ e `[g¨¤m
(33) hA © ohz ]A q r6YPkQhzoAoJQPq]AjAQ2oNqcQPO$gMqcQ2\^oAoAq[h _AgO \^`[ghzj@r6QF\$oAq[QP]AkQRrsQ e hkq[qcQ e `[gihkj¡r6Q \`[q\krs] e `cgihzj wm
(34) hA~8hk]NqcjAgi`]Aj$QPj66gq[hkjAjNQPORQPj6` rsQL\^]A`
(35) jAgikQ \^]¬ e hkj68hzqc`\^}AiQaoJhk]Nqq\pgZ[hkjAjNQPq Z[]Aq r6QZahk } QP`cZr6Y§jAgiZo\pq e h Bgijr6] e `cgihkj jToAq[hkkq\^O$ORQ¯Zc`cQqcQP.QPZ[`]A! j " #%$ e hkO$ohzZcYr. ]Aj $&$ (' #%$)" $*",+-#%. . / Q`¯r¢ ]Nj 102 \ 5hkjNZfrA\pjAZaiQ e \zr6qcQ2r.Z[`cQPq[QP ]AqV h 6@Z[QP]AiZ $3/+ , 4. ' #%$ 8gijAZc`[qc] e `cgihkj@oNqcgij e gio\p Q P .£hz]AZajAhz]AZaoN, iQPZ
(36) ZcgikjJ\^]6_Rr. QPj6`cq[YP&Q 7^Z[hkq[`cgiQZchkj6` rsY e \^q[YPZQP`
(37) ZcQP]AiQPZ
(38) iQPZ
(39) gjNZc`cq[] e `[ghzjAZ
(40) oAqcgiORgi`[gzQPZrsQ e hzjw`[ q 8zQVZchzjw` e hzjAZcgr6YqcYPQPZ <QZagijAZc`[qc] e `cgihkjAZars)Q 9hk`[Zar6Qr6hkjNjAYPQPZVjAQZchkj6`o\pZoAqcgiZ[QPZaQPj e hkO$oA`cQ £¤hk]AZ Zc]AoAoJhkZ[QPqchzjAZ2o\pq\ Zc]Agi`[QRr6giZcoJhkZcQqr. ]AjNQRgij6§jAgi`[YRr6Q2ZcgikjJ\^]6_¡r6hkj6`]NjAQRo\pqc`[gQT§JjAgiQ Z[QPq\ ]N`cgiigZ[YPQTo\^qVQZfoNqchkzq\pORORQZ Am
(41) Q e gÙjAhk]AZoJQPqcO$QP`c`[q\ r. gr6QPj6`cg¨§Qqf]Nj®oAq[hkzq\^O$ORQ\ kQ e Zchzj e hzqcoAZVQPj Zc]AoNoAqcgiO#\pj6` \ o\^q[`cgiQr6Y e \^q\^`[ghzj giORoN\pj6`\^`[ghzjrsQPZFoNqchkzq\pORORQZfZ[`cQPq[QPf]NqFo\pqFr6QPZ e giq e ]Agi`cZTZcYz]AQPj6`[gQZ ¬\^Z[Zch e giQRiQPZTQPj6¹ `[qcYPQPZ 7^Z[hkqc`[giQPZar. ]AjoAq[hkzq\^O$ORQ\ kQ e iQPZQPj6`cq[YPQPZ 7^Zchzqc`[gQZar6] e gq e ]Agi` zm
(42) L\kz]AQ
(43) gijAZc`\^j6`r.\ e `[gk\p`cgihkj e hzqcq[QPZcoJhkjr>° ]Aj e b e iQFr. LAhkq[ihkkQr6] e giq e ]Ng` ¤j@YP`\^`frs] e gq e ]Agi`cZ Br6hkjAjNYo\^qVB QjAZcQPO2}NQr6QPZqcQkgiZc`[qcQPZ e hkqcq[QPZcoJhkjJr>ohz]AqjAhk]NZf°2]Nj@QPj6¹ Z[QPO2}AiQar6QoJhkgij6` r.\^q[ q :P`r6]2oAq[hkkq\^O$ORQ e hArA\pkQV}Agij\^giqcQar¢ ]NjFYP`\^`r6QaB\^]N`chkO \^`[Q¯rsQ e hzjw`[ q 8z Q P d&e L\kz]AQ e b e iQfr. LAhzqcihkzQk¬^iQ e giq e ]Ng` e \p e ]AiQ]AjRjAhz]AkQYP`\^`Q` r6QVjAhk]NkQPiiQPZ
(44) Zchkq[`cgiQPZ
(45) QPj2<hkj e `[gihkj r6Q ª YP`\^` e hk]Nq\^j6`QP`r6QPZQPj6`[qcYPQPZ hk]Aq
(46) kYqcg¨§QPq\ e hkq[qcQ e `[gihkj@r6Q\`cq\kr6] e `cgihkj¬6giJª\p]A`zYPqcg¨§QPqaz]AQoJhk]Aq]NjRoAq[hkkq\^O$ORQr6hkjAjNY QP` ]Aj®YkYPjAQORQPj6`r. QPj6`cq[YPQRr6hkjNjAYk¬.\2q[Y\ e `cgihkj e \^ e ]NYQ2o\^q\ &+ ./ 1;- $/ <$ QPZ[`\ O=:PORQRz]AQ e QPiQ e \p e ]AiYPQ@o\pq2iQ e gq e ]Agi` e hkqcq[QPZcoJhkjJrA\^j6` £¤hk]AZ2oJhk]AzhkjAZ2YjAhkj e QPq#r6Q©O#\^jNgMqcQ gij68hzqcO$QPiQ e QP`c`[QoAqchzoAqcgiYP`[Y e hzORORQZ[]Agi&` > j©oAqchzkq\pORO$QaQPZ[` o\^q]Aj e gq e ]Agi` ªr6hzj6`aiQPZqcQPzgiZc`cq[QPZZ[hkj6`gjNg`[g\^iQ¹ O$QPj6` ° PYqch ¬AZ[goJhk]Aq`[hk]A` $YPz $YPjAQP$O$ ?QPj6 `ar.0@#%QP.j6`c q[+ YPQhkj@2\ > Sk
(47) B YkYPjAQORQPj6`rsQ Z[hkqc`[giQ e \^ e ]AiY
(48) o\^q\Z[YPO#\pj6`cgz]AQ e hzjAZc`[qc] e `[gikQQPZ[`gr6Qjw`[gk]NQ ° e QPi]AgJr6hkjAjNY o\^qiQ e giq e ]Agi`¬ yA
(49) iQoAqchzkq\^ORO$Qar6YPq[gzYFhz}A`cQjw]©QPZc` $ $ $ ? 0A#B.C 4+ oJ\^qaiQ e gq e ]Agi`frN\^jAZVZchkj©jAhk]AzQP YP`\p`ar6Qq[QPkgiZc`[qcQk \Z[oY e g§ e \^`[ghzj rsQ®\>oAq[hkoAq[gY`cY¡r6Q e hkq[qcQ e `cgihkj&r6Q>\ `cq\kr6] e `cgihkj¥rshkgi`R`[QPjAgiq e hkO$oA`cQ®rs] e \pq\ e `cMPq[Qagij6§jNgwr6] e hkO$ohzqc`[QPORQPj6`.r. ]AjoAq[hkzq\^O$ORQqcY\ e `cg¨.QP`r6] e giq e ]Agi` e hkqcq[QPZcoJhkjJrA\^j6` ªr6hzjAjAY o\pq]AjAQZ[]Agi`cQgij6§jAgiQr6QqcY \ e `[ghzjAZ . 0Ó?F-GPÝH. DED.
(50) u £hz]AZjAhz]AZaigiORgi`cQqchkjNZ¬krA\pjAZaiQ e \zr6qcQFrsQ e Qq\poAohzqc` ¬°T\oNqcQP]AzQFr6Q`[q\zr6] e `[ghzj@r6Q\ToJ\^qc`[giQ e hzO2}Agij\^`[hkgiqcQarsQPZaoAq[hkzq\^O$ORQPZ
(51) Zc`[QPqcQP]Nq8oJhkgij6`Sfr6Q \Tr6Y§JjAgi`cgihkj e g¨¹,r6QZcZc]NZ P hz]AqYP`\^}Aigiq\ e hkq[qcQ e `[gihkj#rsQa\V`cq\zr6] e `[gihkj¬zjAhk]NZ \ khzjAZ e LNhkgiZcg.r6QajNhk]AZ}J\^ZcQq Z[]Aq\kQqcZcgihzj r6QT\$ZcYPO \^j6`cgz]AQ e hzjAZc`[qc] e `cgikQRr6Y e qcgi`cQRrN\^jAZiQ e L\poAgi`cq[Q r6Q y, .m
(52) QP`[`cQ2Z[Y¹ O \^j60`cgz ]A 4$ ?Q ' $-* . #%$$ 0 jAhk]AZo\pq\ `o\pqc`[g e ]AigMqcQPO$QPj6`}AgiQPjR\zrA\^oA`[YPQa\^]s_FoAqcQ]AkQPZ
(53) r6Q e hkq[qcQ e `cgihkj 6hk]Aq 8hzqcO \^igiZcQPq\`cq\kr6] e `cgihkj$jAhk]NZ \ khzjAZ]A`[gigiZcQq \q[QPoAqcYZcQPj6`\p`cgihkj zq\^oNLAgk]NQar6QaB giORoA\^j6`\ `cgihkjQPj e giq e ]Agi`cZr6Y e qcgi`cQ2rA\^jNZaiQ e L\^oNg`[qcQ SkSz \Tq[QPoAq[YPZcQPj6`\^`cgihzjkq\poALAgz]AQr. ]Aj e giq e ]Agi`aZ[Yz]AQPj6`cgiQPQZc` r6hzjAjAYPQVo\^qÙ]Aj2QPjAZ[QPO2}AiQar6QoJhkqc`[QPZihkzgz]AQZQ` r6Qaq[QPkgiZ[`cqcQZ q[QPigYZ o\pq r6QPZÙ§iZ ziQjNhk]AZ \~o\^q[] \ oAi]AZa\kr6Y k]J\^`cQ ohz]Aq]AjAQV8hzqcO#\pigZ\^`[ghzjrN\^jAZam
(54) hAJ m
(55) Q q\poAohzqc` e hzORoJhkq[`cQRu>o\pqc`cgiQPZ \@oAq[QPORgiMPq[Q o\^q[`cgiQR`[q\^gi`[QrsQ#\8hkq[O#\pgiZ\^`cgihzj®r6Q \@Z[Y¹ O \^j6`cgz]AQ e hkjAZ[`cq[] e `cgizQk¬r¢ ]NjAQRo\pqc`FrN\^jAZiQ2zYPjAYPq\^`cQ]Aqr¢ Qjw6giqchzjAjAQPO$QPj6`r6QRoAq[hkzq\^O$O#\ `[ghzj m
(56) QPj6`\^]Aq ¬r.\^]A`[qcQ2o\pqc`2rA\^jAZ ª\pZcZcgiZ[`\^j6`F°\$oAq[QP]AzQ#m
(57) hAJ £¤hk]AZ2\ khzjAZ\^gijAZcg
(58) hk}N`cQPj6]¡rA\pjAZF]Nj oAq[QPORgiQPq`[QPORoAZÙ]AjFQjw6giqchzjAjAQPO$QPj6`r6QoAqchzkq\^ORO \^`[gh^j¬z]Ag e hzORoAq[QPjr ]Aj2\^j\pb6Z[QP]AqZ[bwj6`\ _Agk]NQ QP` ]Ajgijw`[QPqcoN q :P`[QRoJhk]AqF¯Zc`cQqcQPa]Nq e hkjNZc`cq[] e `[g ]NgZ jAhk]AZ\ zhkjAZV8hzqcO#\pigZ[Y e QP`[`cQ$ZcYPO \^j6`cgz]AQ rA\pjAZam
(59) hAJ¬AQPj hkO$QP`c`\^j6`rA\^jAZ]NjAQoAqcQPO$giMPqcQ\^oNoAqch _AgiO#\p`cgihkjTiQPZgijAZc`[qc] e `[gihkjAZZ[]Agik\^j6`cQPZ > B gijAZ[`cq[] e `cgihzj#r6Q}Jhk] e iQ icih6hkos Ùohz]AqYP6gi`cQPqViQPZoAqchz}AiMPORQZ r6QZ e LNg hkoALAq[YPjAgiQk¬ iZcQP]AZ qVgijA\Z[`coq[\p] qce `[`cggiQ hzjAe hzZ O2r¢}A\pgi`cj`[\^QP`[j6hk`cgiQ qcQaicrsoJQP\^Z ]AeZ[Qgiq e
(60) ]NQg``[Zr6 QVZc]AZ[oQjAZcgihkj icZ[]AZcoJQPjrz! P¬6oJhk]Nq jAhz]AZ e hkj e QPj6`cqcQq \r6QP]s_sgiMPO$Qo\^q[`cgiQfrsgZ e ]A`[QfiQPZr6 g .YPqcQPj6`[QPZa\^oAoNqch e LAQPZoJhkZcZ[gi}AiQPZaz]AQajAhz]AZ\ khkjNZQPj66gZ\^zYPQPZ oJhk]Aqq[QPoAq[YPZcQPj6`[QPqQZ e giq e ]Agi`cZarA\pjAZm
(61) hsTQ`8hzqcO \^igiZcQPq\`cq\kr6] e `cgihkj A£hk]NZ Q_AoAigz]AhkjNZ g e gJjAhk`[qcQ e LAhzg_ rsQR<hkqcO \^igiZ\p`cgihkj .{\^jNZF]AjNQ#`[qchzgZ[giMPORQ2o\pqc`[gQ jAhz]AZ2\^}JhkqrshkjAZ2\©oAqcQP]NkQ@r6Q e hkq[qcQ e `cgihkj oAq[hkoAq[QPORQjw`r6gi`cQz w£¤hk]AZr6hkjNjAhkjAZ
(62) QPj \^jAjAQ _s Q «\~ZcoJY e g¨§ e \p`cgihkj e hkO$oAiMP`cQar6QV\`cq\kr6] e `cgihkj rA\^jAZ m
(63) hAR\pgijAZcgz]AQ e QP`c`[QoAqcQ]AkQFrsQ e hkq[qcQ e `cgihkj Jj6§j¬rA\pjAZ]AjAQFrsQPqcjAgiMPq[Qo\pqc`cgiQk¬NjAhk]NZoAqcY e gZ[hkjAZViQ `[q\ k\^gi.z] gNqcQPZ[`cQ°B\^giqcQoJhk]Aq e hzORoAiMP`[QPq\oAq[QP]AkQQP`
(64) jAhz]AZ YkhAz]AhkjAZ e QPq[`\pgjNQPZf\poAoAqch e LAQPZz]Ag jAhz]AZo\pq\^giZ[ZcQPj6`f\poAoAq[hkoAq[gYQPZ !
(65) P@
(66) " "T 12 0 ¢ P%F
(67) \2`[q\krs] e `cgihzj*r.Z[`cQPq[QP]AqQPj e giq e ]Agi`[Z e hkj e QPqcjNQ2QZfgijAZ[`cq[] e `cgihzjAZoAq[gO$gi`cgikQPZarsQ e hzj6`c q 8ziQ r.Z[`cQPq[QPr6hkj6`zhkg e g.\igiZc`[Q >. ED.
(68) . !#"$% &('( ) - - . )/"$01 2 "768' % ;< ="$ ) "A@ @;' C EDF #"G ) ML 1D 8%V$ ="$).
(69) . *",+' 435" "96:' "?> "B@ ' H"JI K " N OPQ R(N2SUT "XW. £hz]AZ\ khkjNZgijr6gz]AYa°Frsqchkgi`[Q\~Zcb6j6`\ _AQVLAYPqcgi`[YPQr6] e \p e ]A.r6QaoAq[h e QPZcZ[]AZfz]AgJQPZ[`]A`cgiigiZcYPQrA\^jAZ y ohz]Aqr6Y e q[giqcQ2\TZcYPO \^j6`cgz]AQ e hkjAZ[`cqc] e `cgikQz m
(70) QPZgijAZc`[qc] e `[gihkjAZZchzj6`fgiO$oYPq\^`[gzQPZQP`iQP]Aq e hkO¹ oJhkq[`cQPO$QPj6`gij6`c]Ng`[g¨QPZc`ÙQ_AoAigz]AYarN\^jAZiQ e L yr6Q yc ^£hk]NZq\poAoQhzjAZZ[gO$oAiQPORQjw`JiQPZoAq[gij e gio\^iQPZ r6 g .YPqcQj e QPZ\ kQ e \Z[bwj6`\ _AQr. hkqcgizgjNQfr6] jAh^b6\^] > ¹ B gijAZc`[qc] e `[gihkj2 Y.Z[ \<P¬ z]AgjAQ`[QPqcO$gjNQ P\^O \^giZ¬zQPZ[`aqcQORoA\ 5 YPQo\pqaB gjNZc`cq[] e `[ghzj2]Z^ _`[z]AgZcQ `cQPq[ORgijAQ°Tª gijAZ[`\^j6`
(71) Zc]Agik\pjw` &YZ[ \bac[ d;d8]/].Z^_:`(`.e.f$¬ ¹fB gjNZc`cq[] e `[ghzj# fd "7g Z\&hY.i ej*¸w]A`[gigiZ[YPQ2ohz]Aqgij6`cQPq[qchzORoAq[QF]AjNQRgijAZc`[qc] e `cgihkj " °$o\pqc`[gqTr6QPZ gijAZc`\^j6`cZk]Ng^Zc]AgikQjw`iQoNqcQPO$gQq.gjNZc`\pj6`¬PZ\^jAZ.B Q_AY e ]N`cQPq 8oNqcYPQPO$oA`cgihzja<hkqc`[Q P¬QPZc`qcQPO$oA \ 5YQ o\^qB gijAZc`[qc] e `cgihkjT _-^ _-]`.e.f "Gg Y.`.e¸w ¬Az]Ag.Z[]AZcoJQPjr©B gijAZ[`cq[] e `cgihzj " ¬ ¹iQ@Z[gzj\^ \&i hkk¬
(72) `[hk&] hz]AqcZ$oAqcYZcQPj6`¬VoJQP]A!` :P`cq[Q®gij6`cq[hAr6]Agi`Ro\pqR]Aj³Zcgizj\^Vh e \pB¬QPj³Q_AY e ]A`\^j6` B gijAZ[`cq[] e `cgihzjRZc]Ngk\pj6`cQQPj o\^q\^iiMPiQ > . % ;8 ( Bl:mon NJ6 & )Jp . Ù hkoJYPq\p`cQP]AqJ K 8Z[LAg¨8` JQPZ[`]A`[gigiZ[Y rA\^jNZ.\rsY§jAgi`cgihzj~rsQPZgijAZ[`cqc] e `cgihkjNZr6YPq[gikYPQr.Zc`[QPqcQª¬ oJhk]Aq 6r Y e \^iQPqiQ e hAr6Q2r6Q`[QPqcO$gjJ\^giZchzj#r. ]AjAQ Zchk]NZB¹BgjNZc`cq[] e `[ghzj®QjAkihk}JYPQoJ\^qa]NjR\qrZ] .\^qVQ_AQPORoAiQk¬ B gijAZc`[qc] e `[gihkj¡fd "sg Z\&hYi e j-¸z@QPZc` e hAr6YQo\^q> Atu" a H;vwF3 K ",6Tx @ v6 *T<+:
(73) x>I £¤hk]AZ ]A`[gigiZ[hkjAZ\
(74) Z[b6jw`\ _AQ e \^ e ]NsrsQoAqch e QZcZc]NZBfrA\pjAZ e Qz]AgkZ[]Agi`o\pqZ[hk] e giZr6Q e hkj e giZ[ghzj \pqQ _sQORoAiQ iQoAqchzkq\^ORO$ Q > C (Dy .& @ @ L 1z ). 0Ó?F-GPÝH. DED.
(75) e hkq[qcQPZ[ohzjr6QPj6`2°2B gjs¹ Z[QPq\$jAhz`cYT`chz]A`ZcgiORoAiQPO$QPj6` ¢QPZ e hAr6QPZFr6QT`cQqcORgij\pgiZchkj 6r g e QRrsQR{aQ q[]Ag j B\^]AzORQPj6`[Yr6QRH; y @ T;I \^ZcZ[h e giYR°RB gij6`cqchAr6] e `cgihkj>r6QPZN Q_ S e QoAT `cgihkjNZ {f\pjAZB Q _sQORoAiQ oAq[Y e YrN\^j6`¬Ùª gijr6g e QTQPZ[` T
(76) FT P¬oA]AgiZk] giZ[QRq[Y8MPq[Q°©\$oAqcQPO$giMPqcQ 8QP`T]AjAgz]AQRrA\pjAZ e Q e \pZ Q_ e QoA`cgihkj©qcQPj e hkj6`cq[YPQFQj#q[QPORhzj6`\^j6`rA\^jNZQoAq[hkzq\^O$ORQk \~ZcYPO \^j6`cgz]AQ e hzjAZc`[qc] e `[gikQfr¢ ¯Zc`cQqcQPQPZc`r6hkjNjAYPQrA\^jNZ y.Zchk]NZ iQPZ`[qchzgZÙ8hzqcORQZL\^}Ng`[]AQPiiQPZ&> \$ZcYPO \^j6`cgz]AQ e hkjNZc`cq[] e `[gzQ e hzORoJhkq[`cQPO$QPj6`\^iQk¬N\RZ[YPO#\pj6`cgz]AQ e hzjAZc`[qc] e `[gikQRhzoYq\^`[gihkjAjAQiQTQP` \ ZcYPO \^j6`cgz]AQ e hzjAZc`[qc] e `[gikQo\^q
(77) YP`\^`cZ
(78) ¹hz]F[QPjAZcQO2}AiQar6Qohzgj6`[Z r.\pqc q :`BP w£¤hk]AZar6Y`\^giiihkjAZ
(79) rA\^jAZ e Q@z]AgZ[]Agi`F\$ZcoJY e g¨§ e \^`cgihzj r6]«\pjAw\pkQ2Zc`[QPqcQfrA\pjAZFm
(80) QPj6`\p]Aq¬oN]AgiZZ\ Z[oY e g¨§ e \^`[gihkj rN\^jAZTiQ Z[bwZ[`cMPO$Q#m
(81) hAJ m
(82) QPZ2r6QP]6_¡Z[oY e g¨§ e \^`[gihkjAZTjAhk]NZ e hzjr6]Agiq[hkjAZFr¢ ]NjAQ2o\^q[`°]AjQPj66gq[hkjAjNQPORQPj6`r6Q oAq[hkzq\^O$O#\p`cgihkjhzoYq\^`[gihkjAjAQª¬Jr.\^]A`[qcQo\pqc`a° ]Aj QPj6wgiq[hkjAjAQORQPj6`ar6QoAq[QP]AkQz .
(83) "!$#% & '. £¤hk]AZ\ khzjAZar6Y e q[gi`aiQjAh^b6\^]@r.Zc`[QPqcQ rA\^jNZfm
(84) QPj6`\p]AqaQj@]A`cgiigiZ\pjw`\TZ[YPO#\pjw`[gk]NQ e hkjAZ[`cqc] e ¹ `[gzQ e hzORoJhkqc`[QPORQjw`\^iQo\^qVYP`\p` m
(85) Q`c`cQTZcYO#\^j6`[gz]AQ]A`[gigiZ[Q]AjAQ2r6Y§jNg`[gihkj@YP`[QPjr6]NQRr6QPZ`cQPq[ORQPZ <`cQPq[ORQPZr6Y e hzqcYPZ, Vz]Ag.oAqcQjr QPj e hzORoA`[Qa\jAhz`cgihkj r6Qohzgj6`[Z r.\pqcq :`cZ¬NoQqcORQ`c`\pj6`a\^gijAZcgJiQ e h^¹ rA\pkQFrsQPZaYP`\^`[ZaZc]NqaiQoAqchzkq\pORO$QgjNg`[g\^B d ]A`cq[QPORQjw`r6gi`¬ e QPZ[`a]AjNQZcYPO \^j6`cgz]AQo\pqQPjAZcQO2}AiQ r6Q oJhkgij6`cZ2r.\^q[ q :P`2z]AgoQqcORQ`r6Q$6gZ[]\^igiZcQqF\ oAq[hkzqcQPZ[Zcgihkj-r6QPZ2Y`\^`[Z2Zc]Aq2iQ$oAqchzkq\pORO$QgijAg¨¹ `[g\pB {\^jAZVZ\$kQqcZcgihzj e hkO$ohzqc`[QPORQPj6`\^iQk¬ e QP`c`[Q2ZcYPO \^j6`cgz]AQZcQToA q :`cQ2o\pqc`cg e ]NgiMPq[QPORQjw`V}AgiQPj®\p] Z[]Agiwgr6Q Zc&] Q`~rsgZ[ohzjAgi}AiQQPj®Z[YPO#\pj6`cgz]AQj\^`[]AqcQPiiQk Jm
(86) Q e goJQPqcO$QP`aQjw`[qcQ2\^]A`[qcQFrsQF6giZc]\pigZ[QPqaiQPZ gijAZ[`cqc] e `cgihkjNZf\ e `cgikYPQZfrA\pjAZB gijAZ[`\pjw`ÙQP`fr6Qq[YPohzjr6q[Q°Tr6QPZV}QPZ[hkgijAZar6QTr6QP}A]AJ Ù QPj6wgiq[hkjAjAQORQPj6`frsYPkQPihzoAoYRrN\^jAZm
(87) QPj6`\p]AqoAq[hkoJhkZ[QRr6Q e L\^q[kQPq]NjoAqchzkq\pORO$Q~rsY e hkq[Y2QP` r6Q ]Ng\^oNoAigz]AQq]AjAQ`cq\^jAZ[g`[gihkj ohz]Aqa]Nj#YkYPjAQORQPj6`fr¢ Qjw`[qcYPQTr6hkjAjNYk ..QjAhk]NkQ\p]@oAqchzkq\^ORO2Q r6Y e hkq[Y\poAo\pq\ i`F\pihkqcZ2° \ oA\ e Q#r6Q$B \pj e giQPj QPj66giqchkjNjAQPORQjw`Tk]N?Q Q$wgiQPjNZr. YPzhAk]NQPqFQZc` hzoYPq\^`[ghzjAjAQPB NlB.w\^zjAQPq\^gi` `[hk]A`[Q8hzgZa° :`cqcQ e hkO$oAiYP`cYr6Q\~ª,\ 5hkj Zc]Ngk\pj6`c Q > ¹ r6QPZ e qcgioA`[ghzj@r6Q\Z[YPO#\pj6`cgz]AQ e hzjAZc`[qc] e `cgikQ e hkORoJhkq[`cQPO$QPj6`\pQQj#Z[YPO#\pj6`cgz]AQaj\p`c]Aq[QPiiQk¬ ¹`cq\zr6] e `[gihkjF\p]A`chzO#\^`[gk]NQ¯rsQPZr6QP]6_FZ[oY e g¨§ e \^`[gihkjAZ e hkORoJhkq[`cQPO$QPj6`\pQZ ª\ kQ e QP`Z\^jAZY`\^` rA\^jAZ m
(88) hA¬ ¹ oAqcQ]AkQFrsQfB Yz]Agik\^iQPj e Qfr6Q e QZ~rsQP]6_#Z[oY e g¨§ e \^`[gihkjAZrA\^jAZam
(89) hAJ lB6qcQZc`cQVYPw\piQPORQPj6`r6QZQ .hkqc`[Z °
(90) B\^giqcQ \p]FjNgzQ\^]Tr6]o\pqcZcQq 8Z[QP]AA\Z[b6jw`\ _AQ e \p e ]AAr6Q
(91) oAqch e QPZ[Zc]AZ, QPZ[`r6Y e q[g`[Q P¬\^gijAZcgz]\^]@jAgizQ\^]@r6QB Q_A`cQjAZcgihkj>r6QFB QPj66giqchkjNjAQPORQjw` ¬koJhk]NqfoNqcQPjrsqcQTQPj e hkORoN`cQ iQPZVgjNZc`cq[] e `[ghzjAZ 9hz`cZar6QFrshkjAjAYQPZaQP`iQPZgijAZ[`cq[] e `cgihzjAZfr6YqcgikYPQZ m
(92) hkO$ORQ$jAhk]AZ \^iihkjAZ2iQ>khzgq2O \^gij6`cQPjJ\^j6`¬jAhz]AZ@\ khzjAZR]A`[gigiZ[Y@\>ZcYPO \^j6`cgz]AQ e hzjAZc`[qc] e `cgikQ e hzORoJhkq[`cQPO$QPj6`\^iQoJhk]Aq
(93) ZcoJY e g¨§Qqa\`cq\kr6] e `cgihkj r6QPZoAq[hkzq\^O$ORQPZZ[`cQPq[QPQj e gq e ]Agi`cZrA\pjAZam
(94) hA . ED.
(95) .
(96) "!$. ¢QPZgijAZ[`cqc] e `cgihkjNZ r.Z[`cQPq[QP]Aq
(97) Zchzj6` r6Y e q[gi`cQPZarA\pjAZ m
(98) hA o\^qB QPjAZ[QPO2}AiQgijr6] e `cg¨. k£¤hk]AZ \ zhkjAZ e hAr6Y QZZcgikj\p]6_#oJ\^qiQPZQPj6`cgiQPq[Z¬.r. h 6 B\^q[k]AO$QPj6`QPj6`cgiQPqk]Ng\^oAo\pq\`rA\pjAZaiQPZgijAZ[`cqc] e ¹ `[ghzjAZar. YPO$gZ[Zcgihkj2Q`fr6QoAq[YPZcQPj e Qk
(99)
(100) !"# %$&"& ')(* ,+
(101)
(102) -.
(103) ,/ 0*. 12 )0* 34 5')( .
(104) $/*.6,4 7')( .
(105) $81
(106) 9
(107) : *
(108) ,; <')(=.
(109) >')(?.
(110) 5')( .
(111) $/: @,/.
(112) 5')(!.
(113) 5')( .
(114) $819
(115) 2 2 2"A.
(116) 5')(!.
(117) 5')( .
(118) $/2 0 2"4 7')(?.
(119) >')( .
(120) $# 9
(121) *1#.
(122) 7')( .
(123) $/:*B6C ,#.
(124) 5')( .
(125) ,+. £¤hk]AZ
(126) \ khkjNZhkO$gZkhzhzj6`\^giq[QPORQPj6`ª gijAZ[`cqc] e `cgihkjRrsQ}hz] e iQ [ d d<] z]AgJQPZ[` °B hkq[gikgijAQ r6QZ oAq[h^¹ }AiMPO$QPZ r6QVZ e LAgPhzoALAqcYjAgiQfr6Y e qcgi`cZarA\pjAZiQ e L iS yfrsQ yc w£¤hk]AZjNQa`cq\^gi`chzjAZ r6hzj e oJ\^Z\`[q\krs] e `cgihzj r6QZ}hz] e iQPZ
(127) QPjRoAq[QPORgiMPq[Qf\poAoAqch _AgiO#\p`cgihkj £hz]AZ \ zhkjAZYw\^iQPO$QPj6`hkO$giZB gijAZc`[qc] e `cgihkjRr6QVZc]AZ[oQj6¹ Z[ghzj w_-^ _-]`.e.f$ k]NgjAQoNqcYPZ[QPj6`cQ2o\pZfr. gij6`cYPq :P`f\p]#oNqcQPO$gQqgjNZc`\pj6` £¤hk]AZVjAhk]NZaoA\ 5 hkjAZVQPj@Q .QP` rA\pjAZiQoAqcQPO$giQPqgijAZc`\^j6`¬6,h 6#Z[QP]AiQ\o\pqc`[gQ e hzO2}Agij\^`[hkgiqcQarsQPZ e giq e ]Agi`cZVZcYz]AQPj6`[gQZVgijw`[QPqc6giQPj6` £hz]AZa\^iihkjNZ r6hzjAjAQPqO \^gij6`cQPjJ\^j6`\<hkqcO \^igiZ\p`cgihkj2r6Q\Z[YPO#\pjw`[gk]NQ e hzjAZc`[qc] e `[gikQ e hkO$ohzqc`cQ ¹ O$QPj6`\^iQrA\^jAZam
(128) hAJ m
(129) hzORO$Q2jAhk]AZ$B \ zhkjAZ2r6Y °>w]¬ iQPZ2Z[gikj\p]6_-Zchkj6` e hAr6YZ#oJ\^qRiQPZ$QPj6`cgiQPq[Z hk]Aq$ZcgiORoAig¨§QPq ¬ jAhz]AZf\ zhkjAZr6Y e gr6Qq~rsQ e hAr6QPqiQPZaZ[`\p`c]A`[Z~\pZcZ[h e gYZ~\p]6_@ZcgikjJ\^]6_ o\^qVQZa}JhwhziYPQPjAZr6Q¸ e hk`[`" DVj jAhz`cQPqF\ E;G7H H
(130) IE+ JX+KXI iQFr6hzO#\^gijAQr6QF¸ e hk`c` {\^jNZ e Q e hkj6`[Q_A`cQk¬JB YPiYPORQPj6` J rsYPjAhk`[QB\^}AZ[QPj e Q r. ]Aj Z[gzj\^B¬.B YPiYPO$QPj6` r6YPjNhk`cQ \©oAqcYPZ[QPj e Qr. ]Aj«Zcgikj\p Q`2ª YPiYPO$QPj6` rsYPjAhk`[Q ]AjAQ k\^iQP]Aq gijr6Y`cQPq[ORgijAYPQoJhk]AqÙ]Aj2ZcgiK kjJ\^B ^.Qar6hzO#\^gijALQ EMG@QZc`
(131) ZcoJY e g¨§YfrN\^jAZ m
(132) hA o\^qÙ]AI jFQjAZcQPO2}NQgijrs] e `cg¨ >
(133)
(134) - 0 N
(135) 0 0 2"A O P 9
(136) 0"/ 0 N
(137) 0 0 2 $/0* "/ 0 N
(138) 0 0 2 $8Q0
(139) 0*.# 0 N
(140) 0 0 2R+. £¤hk]AZr6Y §jAgiZcZ[hkjAZQjAZc]Agi`[Q2]Aj®YkYPjAQORQPj6` e hzORO$Qf]NjAQ<hkj e `[gihkjr6QPZQPj6`[gQqcZ <Zcgikj\p]6_ rA\^jAZ iQPZ}Jh6hkiYPQPjNZ~rsQ¸ e hk`c` 8Zc`\^`[]A`cZ P ¢QPZ}JhwhziYPQPjAZFrsQ¸ e hk`c`jAhz]AZoQqcORQ`c`cq[hkj6`r6Q2qcQoAqcYPZ[QPj6`cQPq2iQPZ YPzYPjAQPO$QPj6`cZVo\^q[`cgiQPiZ¬Az]Ag\^oAo\pq\pgZ[ZcQPj6`ihkq[Z rs]#`[q\pg`[QPORQjw`arsQPZZcgikjJ\^]6_ h e \p]6_ £hz]AZ@\ khzjAZ#r6Y §jAgiQP!Z S o\^q@\pj\^ihkzgiQ\ zQ e Q7Z U ¬ e hkO$ORQ YP`\^j6`@r6QPZ Z[]Agi`cQPZgij6§JjAgiQPZr6Q2}h6hzYQPjAZr6QR 1 ¸ T. e hz"`c1` ;- $. QPVZ S 1 WT.,"; $ oJQP]AzQPj6` T:P.,`[qc"Q2;Zc oJ$Y e g¨§YZrA\pjAZm
(141) hA o\^q iQPZ¤8hkj e `cgihkjAZr6QPZVQPj6`cgiQPq[ZfrA\pjAZiQPZ}h6hzYQPjAZfrsQ~¸ e hk`[&` > X
(142) C 6)0* ? 0 Y )"A Z [ 5')( 0 N
(143) 0 0 2\+. 0Ó?F-GPÝH. DED.
(144) m
(145) Q `Bb6oJQrsQrshkjAjAYQ#jNhk]AZ2Z[QPq\>YP6\^iQPO$QPj6`F`[qcYPZ$]A`cgiiQRoJhk]AqRrsY e qcgiq[Q@iQPZ e giq e ]Ng`[Z2QP`2jAhz]AZ2iQ 6r Y`\^giiihkjAZ
(146) iQPZfrN\^jAZ e Qz]AgZc]Agi` £¤hk]AZ$jAhk`[hkjAZJ`.q d iQ@¸ e hk`[`B¹c\kr6gz]AQ@oJ\^qc`[g e ]AigiQPq#z]AgVQPZc`$jw]Nao\pqc`chz]A`F a ¢QPZ hzoYPq\^`[QP]AqcZ qª¬
(147) 1efQP` ,d\Zc]Aq
(148) iQPZ ¸ e hk`c`,¹,\zr6gz]AQPZ
(149) Zchkj6`iQPZ
(150) Q_A`cQjAZcgihkjNZ j\p`c]Aq[QPiiQP Z rsQPZ hzoYp Jq\^`[QP]Aq[Z ¬ TQ ` -l r6Y §jAgiZaZ[]AqiQ~rshkO#\pgijAQar6Q¸ e hz`cA` E G §J iS or. 0. 1. and. 0. 1. 0. 0. 1. 0. 0. 0. 1. 1. 1. 1. 0. 1. 1. 0. 1. not. .S . 0. 0. 1. 1. 0. S. 0+ . $- - #B$ ' #B+$ " $. 1. ¸shkgiQPj6` r6QP]6_ ¸ e hk`c`,¹,\zr6gz]AQPZQP`#«]Ajj\p`c]Aq[QPB¬.iQPZFr6g .YPqcQPj6`[Z2hkoJYPq\p`cQP]Aq[ZFZ[hkj6`YP`[QPjr6]NZ e hzORO$QZc]Agi`&> +"! %$ &! *) )+! - . ' p v x (!/v x a' p v x , !/v a' p - l v x a. x. £hz]AZrshkjAjAhzjAZYPw\piQPORQPj6`.\r6Y§JjAgi`cgihkjFrsQPZhkoJYPq\p`cQP]Aq[Z r6Qr6Y e \p\^kQZQP`r6Q
(151) O#\H_sgiOT]AO@¬BYP`[QPjr6]NZ \p]6_¸ e hk`c`,¹,\zr6gz]AQPZ&> 02 vo
(152) x 1 . sa/ p v x v s x. vwTx. 354 H 354 H 354 S
(153). T. ED.
(154) x K. 02 v x 1 sa/ p J v . x. 354 H
(155) H 354 H T 354 T. . £hz]AZq\^oAoJQPihkjAZTk]NQFiQ2O#\H_AgOT]AO rsQRr6QP]6_QPjAZ[QPO2}AiQPZFr6Q2jJ\^`c]NqcQPiZ e hzjAZcgiZ[`cQ2QPjiQP]Aq ]AjAgihkj¬ °T\kz]AQiQVhkj qcQP`[q\pj e LAQB QPjAZcQO2}AiQfr6QPZjJ\^`c]NqcQPiZfz]Ag.Z[hkj6`Zc`[qcg e `[QPORQPj6`gij68YqcgiQP]Aq[Za\^] O#\H_sgiOT]AO r6QZfr6QP]s_#ORgijAgiO2]AOTZ hz]Aq e \^ e ]AiQPqiQaO \ _AgiOF]NOr6Qfr6Q]6_¸ e hk`c`,¹,\zr6gz]AQP Z ³QP` ¬6giZ[]6R`ar6Qr6YPo\pZcZcQqaiQaoAq[QPORgiQPq j\p`c]Aq[QP z]Ag\$ohz]Aqk\^iQP]Aq K rN\^jAZ F¬.\pgjNZcgz]AQFiQToAqcQORgiQPqajJ! \^`c]NqcQP z]Ag\ohz]Aqk\^iQP]Aq K rA\^jAZ ¬oN]AgiZFr.\ khzgq\$k\^iQP]Aq K Zchzgi`FrA\^jNZ Z[hkgi`FrA\pjAZ ! m
(156) Q e gjNhk]AZFrshkjAjAQ$\2<hkqcO2]NQToJhkZcZ[gi}AiQ Z[! ]Agik\^j6`c Q > . -L v. + 4! x a. vw
(157) x v& x ppp v x , v x !2v x p , ! vw
(158) x (/! v x ppp !/v x 2. Khk]A` e QPZThkoJYPq\p`cQP]Aq[Z2Zc]AqTiQPZF¸ e hk`c`,¹,\zr6gz]AQPZThkj6`]AjAQ$ZcoJY e g¨§ e \p`cgihkj«`cq[MPZFjJ\^`c]NqcQPiiQ#rA\pjAZFm
(159) hA z]AQjNhk]AZar6hzjAjAhzjAZQPj@\^jAjNQ_AQ V jNQ\p]A`cq[Q hkoJYPq\p`cgihkj«gO$ohzqc`\^j6`cQ2QPZ[`R\©ORgiZcQR° hk]Nqr6QZ#¸ e hz`c`,¹,\zr6gk]NQPZ2ihkqcZz]AQRB hkj«kQP]A` e L\pjAkQPq \Tk\piQP]Aq\ .Q e `[YPQR°$]Aj@QPj6`cgiQPqTr6hkjAjNYk .m
(160) QPiQ ¹ e gZ[QT8QPq\$zq\ e Q°\8hkj e `cgihkj$£¤Q
(161) z]Ag oAq[QPjr QPjF\pqck]NORQPj6`J]AjF¸ e hz`c`,¹,\zr6gk]N Q 2¬P]Njj\^`[]AqcQ 2\^gijAZ[gwz] ]Aj}JhwhziYPQPjFr6Q
(162) ¸ e hk`[
(163) ` QP`qcQ`chk]NqcjAQ iQjAhk]NkQ\p]¸ e hk`[`B¹c\kr6gz]AQ 8jAhz`c Y
(164) ohz]AqiQz]AQP ©QPZc`\^ZcZ[h e giYF° p a. p v . x. H 354 53 4 H . £¤hk]AZ
(165) \ khkjNZ}QZchkgij¬zoJhk]Aqr6Y§jNgq e QP`[`cQV8hzj e `cgihzjRr6QORgiZcQa° hk]Aq ¬wr¢ ]Nj2oQP`[gi`iQPORO$Q \^q[g`[LAORY ¹ `[gz]AQ.QPO$j\^`,fz]Ag.oQqcORQ`ar6QFr6Y e grsQPqfr6QB YPw\pig`[Yfr6Qr6Q]6_#j\p`c]Aq[QPiZ *. . *. ,!
(166) " . $#&%*
(167) .('*)%,+/
(168) .('"+ X
(169) C 6)0*
(170) - /,. / 0 Y ) ')( 5')(! 0 N
(171) 0 0 2 ')(! 0 Y )7 0 C, 0 Y
(172) )/1 0 R 1 032 0 )N
(173) 0 02/1 0 1 54 0 N
(174) 0 0)2 (6 :75 *. V # 0C 038
(175) 91 2:038 +V
(176) 91; C <# *
(177) $#6+. 0Ó?F-GPÝH. DED.
(178) S v . QZYPkYPjNQPORQPj6`[Zakhzj6` oJhk]Azhkgiq :P`cq[QFq[QPoAqcYZcQPj6`cYZfoJ\^qar6QPZVYPiYPORQjw`[Zar6] `Bb6oQ/
(179) A £¤hk]AZ
(180) r6hkjAjNhkjAZ°oAq[YPZcQPj6`\Z[oY e g§ e \^`[ghzj#r6QV\ZcYPO \^j6`cgz]AQ e hkjNZc`cq[] e `[gzQ e hkO$ohzqc`cQORQPj6`\piQk £¤hk]AZ2\ khzjAZYkMPq[QPORQPj6`O$hAr6g¨§Y\ r6Y§jAgi`[ghzj¡r6QPZoNqcYr6g e \p`cZ QP`
(181) ./ e L @r6Q y oJhk]Aq iQPZQjAkihk}JQPqrA\pjAZ\$r6Y§jNg`[gihkjr. ]Aj@]AjAgz]AQToAqcY r6g e \^`
(182) .m
(183) QRr6QPq[jAgiQPqQPZc` o\^q\^ORY`cqcYTo\pqf]Nj }Jh6hkiYPQPj®rsQ¸ e hk`c` z]A
(184) g hk]AQ]Nj@ q 8zQr6Q e hzjw`[ q 8zQz¬ e hzORORQ e QZc`iQ e \^ZVohz]AqaiQoAq[Yr6g e \^`
(185) ./ QP`VZchzj , " $ ¢QoAqcYrsg e \^`
(186) *\T\~8hkq[ORQZ[]Agik\^j6`c Q > v ",+. H. x. + . H. v ",+ . x-+. v ",+. x . h 6 QPZ[`R]Aj ¸ e hk`[`B¹c\kr6gz]AQ@z]Agar6YPjNhk`cQ©]Aj YPkYPjNQPORQPj6`2o\pqc`[gQQP` ]Aj-¸ e hz`c`,¹,\zr6gk]NQ#z]Ag , 6r YjAhk`[QF]Aj©QPjAZcQO2}AiQ~rsQ e hAr6QPZr6Q e hkORoNY`cgihkj A¢Q e hzjw`[q 8zQ!QPZ[`~° J Zc ghkj A$ 0C$ , 0C. oJ\^ZcZ[QPq o\pq B gijAZc`[qc] e `cgihkj " ¬kgiAQPZ[`a° K Z[ghzj ",% bFo\pZcZ[QPqQP`° I Zcg.hzj 0C$ , b2o\pZcZcQqO#\^giZk] hzj @$ ",% 0. QVª\pgiqcQagiO$oYPq\^`[gzQPORQjw` k¸6g.iQ e hkj6`[q 8kiQQPZ[`f° K ¬6hzjRqcY e ]AoJMPqcQ2iQPZZ[gzj\^]s_27 e hAr6Qfz]Ag ", <$ :P`[qcQ$YPORgiZ 7pqcQP`[hk]Aq[jA Y 8Zc`\^`[]A` K aQ`iQPZZcgizj\^]6_@7 e hAr6QPZz]Ag @$ 0$- <$- 0C. :`cqcQ2YORgiZ7pqcQP`[hk]Aq[jAYPZ <Zc`\p`c]A` J P¬ÙQZRZcgizj\^]6@_ 7 e hAr6QPZ#z]Ag\poAo\^q[`cgiQPjAjNQPj6`#\^]s_ e hzORoAiYPO$QPj6`\^giq[QPZ\ b6\^j6`2iQ@Zc`\^`[]A` I ¸6gViQ e hkj6`cq 8kiQ@QPZ[`#° I ¬hzj q[Y e ]AoJMPq[QZcQP]AiQPO$QPj6`2iQPZ2ZcgikjJ\^]6@_ 7 e hsrsQPZ#z]Ag @$=0$
(187) <$ ?0. :P`[qcQ YPO$giZ 7^q[QP`chz]AqcjNYPZ <k\^iQP]Aq J P¬NQZZcgikj\p]6@_ 7 e hAr6QZfz]Ag\poAo\pqc`cgiQPjNjAQPj6`a\^]6_ e hkO$oAiYPORQjw`\^giqcQZ \ b6\^j6` iQZc`\^`c]N` I .Q
(188) oAq[Yr6g e \^"`
(189) RoJQP]A` :P`[qcQhz}A`cQPj6]2°Vo\^q[`cgiqr. ]Aj e hArA\pkQr6#Q , QP`
(190) . z]AQ jNhk]AZr6Y§JjAgiZcZchzjAZ gij68hzqcO$QPiQORQPj6`o\^q > . $ v "9+. x H% . J+. . . . 0. ('(). l v ",+ x 1 2 354 cZ g& H J v "9+ x H p J+354 **' ' ,) v "9+ x , v "9+ x I 34 l v ",+ x,+ DVj oJQP]A`aYw\^iQPO$QPj6`6giZc]\pgiZ[QPq e Q e hArA\pkQo\pqQZ[LAYPO#\Tr6Q\§Jk]Aq[Q~yN . . Must 1. Ay . Can 0.
(191) &",. $ ",$ 0@ +"/. 1 *$
(192) . 0C./?#%$ ' #B+$ " $. S. 1. £¤hk]AZÙohz]AkhzjAZ r6hzjAjAQPq
(193) O#\pgj6`[QPj\^j6`\ r6Y§jAgi`[ghzj<hkqcO$QPiiQ r6Q
(194) oJhk]Aq- H ¬kz]AgJQPZ[` r6Y §jAg gijr6] e `cgikQORQPj6`Zc]Aq QZgijAZc`[qc] e `[gihkjAZ m
(195) hzORORQjAhz]AZB\ khzjAZfr6Y1 P° Zchz]AigikjAYk¬¢jAhk]AJZo\pqc`[hkjAZ2r6Q2\ r6Y §jAgi`cgihkj@r6!Q , QP`.
(196) ./ r6hkjAjNYPQrA\^jAZiQ e L 2r6Q y, ED.
(197) SkS ¢QPZhkoJYPq\^`cQ]AqcZZc]NqaiQPZa¸ e hz`c`,¹,\zr6gk]NQPZaZ[QPqchzjw`VgiORoAig e gi`cQPO2Qjw`ÙZc]Aq e LJ\^qczYPZohz]AqoJhk]Azhkgiq Z \^o6¹ oAigz]AQPqa°T]AjNQfoJ\^giqcQr6Q¸ e hz`c`,¹,\zr6gk]NQPZ {\^jAZ Q e \^Z2r. ]Aj e hAr6Q@r6Q e hkO$oAiYP`cgihzj ¬\^] e ]AjZcgizj\^ YPO$gZ QP`FiQPZ e hAr6QPZ2r6Q e hzORoAiYP`[gihkj N H N @$ 0C$ < $ 0C. jNhkj@oAi]AN Z :P`cq[QR\^`[`cQPgij6` N@ $ ' 0$- ,, vw NJ$ + x oJhk]Aq N H N P .¢Q e hAr6Q " /% :P`cq[Q\p`c`[QPgijw`
(198) ZcgjAhk]NZar6QPkhzjAZo\pZcZcQqao\pq e QP`c`[QFgijAZ[`cq[] e `cgihzj e hkj6`[ q 8kiQ ?H K 6lB 0$- , :P`[qcQ\^`c`[QPgij6`O \^giZ A$?",% 0. B :P`[qcQZcgNjAhk]AZÙjAQZchzORORQZ.o\^Zhz}AigikYPZr. bo\^Z[ZcQPq e hkj6`cq 8kiQ !H I P £¤hk]AZ\ khkjNZ r6hzj e o\^qarsY§jAgi`cgihzj > vwN?+. x H% . . J+. ; . N. ¯j#q\^giZchzjAj\pjw`r6QB\ 5hzjRZcgiO$g\pgq[Q oJhk]NqQZaYPO$gZ[ZcgihkjNZ r6QZ[gzj\^]s_RjAhk]AZhz}A`cQjAhkjAZ> v& +. x H% . +
(199). . . ; . ¢ Q Z[QP]A e hAr6Qar6Q`[QPqcO$gjJ\^giZchzjFz]AgAoJQP]A` :P`[qcQa\p`c`cQgj6`QZc`
(200) e \pq]AjAQYPO$giZcZcgihzj`cQPq[ORgijAQ`[hk]& hk]Aq[Z hk]Aq
(201) iQ`cQPZ[`ar6QaoNqcYPZ[QPj e Qk¬JiQPZ e \^Z
(202) h 62iQVZcgikj\pQZc`
(203) oAqcYPZ[QPj6`hk] \^}AZ[QPj6` Z[hkj6` Z[giORoAiQPZ>^giZ[]6R` r6Q q\^oAoJQPiiQPqiQoAqcY r6g e \^`qcY e ]AqcZ[gikQPO$QPj6` ¢hkqk]NQiQZ[gikj\p^QPZc`gijr6YP`[QPqcO$gijAYk¬P\^] e ]AjZ[gzj\^^jNQ r6hkgi` :P`[qcQ YPO$giZQP` \p] e ]Aj e hsrsQar6Q`cQPq[ORgij\pgZ[hkjjAQar6hzgi` :P`[qcQf\p`c`[QPgijw` ^lB6jAhk]NZª\^]N`¯rshkj e giORoJhkZcQq]Aj e hzj6`c q 8ziQ !H I Zc]AqÙ`chk]N`¯\poAoJQPAqcY e ]AqcZ[g¨ w¢QPZZcgikjJ\^]6@ _ 7 e hsrsQPZ z]Ag6jAQoJQP]AkQjw`Ùo\^Z :P`[qcQYPO$gZ 7^q[QP`chz]AqcjAYZZchzjw` rA\pjAZB gij6`cQPq[ZcQ e `[gihkjFr6Q e QP]6_z]AgzjAQoJQP]AzQPj6`oJ\^ZB :P`[qcQoJhk]AqiQPZZ[hk]AZ,¹ªgijAZ[`cqc] e `cgihkjNZ ^m
(204) Q e g6ZcQ
(205) `cq\kr6]Ng` ª\ e giiQPORQPj6`.zq\ e Qa°B hkoJYPq\p`cQP]Aq qwZ[]AqQZ¯¸ e hk`[`B¹c\kr6gz]AQPZ 8QjFQ .QP` MH J H J8Q H J P £¤hk]AZ\ khkjNZ r6hzj e > vw*",+'/+. 0. x H 12. v ",+ x wv ';+ x G v ",+ x . 34 354 $ . wv x vo x. . H K HG J. vo';+. x 53 4 . vwx. H I. hk]Aq \$Z[Yz]AQPj e Qz¬`cqchzgiZ e \^Z2r6hzgzQPj6`YPw\pQORQPj6`):P`cq[QRQPj66giZ\pkYPZZ[QPihkj\$k\^iQP]AqTr6] e hAr6QRr6Q `[QPqcO$gjJ\^giZchzj*r6Q$\ oAqcQORgiMPqcQ2gijAZ[`cq[] e `cgihzj¡o\pZcZcY$QPj e hkj6`cq 8kiQR°@\ r6QP]s_sgiMPO$Q2gijAZc`[qc] e `[gihkj lB QZc` giORoJhkq[`\pjw` ¬rA\pjAZiQ e \^Z,h 6 e Q`c`cQ2k\piQP]AqaQZc` I ¬Jr6QTq\^oNoQPiQPq qcY e ]NqcZcgizQPORQPj6`!
(206) \ zQ e I Z[]Aq\ r6Q]6_AgMORQgijAZc`[qc] e `[gihkj 0. v ",6'G+. . x H 12 . . x $ x
(207) J &$ v ",+ x $ G v ",+ x v "9+ x
(208) J &$ v ",+ v9 " +. vo';+ x + ov ';+. x . x + G vw';+ x . vw';+ . 34 34. v ",+ v ",+ . x-vw
(209) x x-vw
(210) x. H K H J. 34. v ",+. x-vw
(211) x. H I. hz]Aqª gijAZ[`cqc] e `cgihkj>o\pq\^iiMPiQk¬.hzj®]N`cgiigZ[QF`[hk]A` ZcgiORoAiQPO$QPj6`B \poAoJQPqcY e ]AqcZ[g¨fr6]oAqcY r6g e \^`Z[]Aq iQPZr6QP]6_ Zchk]NZB¹BgjNZc`cq[] e `[ghzjAZ¬Jz]AQB hkj e hzO2}AgijAQf\ zQ e QZhkoJYPq\p`cQP]Aq[Z q.QP` Z C> v " @ '/+. 0Ó?F-GPÝH. DED. x H% . v "9+. x $. . ov ';+ . x +. . -L v. v "9+. x +. vw';+. x&x. .
(212) S y \FrsY§jAgi`cgihzjrs]#oNqcYr6g e \p`ohz]AqiQPZgijAZc`[qc] e `cgihkjAZr. Q_ e QPoA`[gihkj QP`ar6QZ[LAg¨8`
(213) QPZc`V`cqcgi6g\^iQ > v H:"?I!+. x %H . v ",+ . v K 7 " +. x H%. v ",+ . .. x=+ x +. K. v ",+. x . v ",+. x . hz]Aq\arsY e \^q\^`cgihzjFr. ]AjZ[gzj\^6ih e \^B¬`cqchzgiZ e \^Zr6hkgizQPj6` :P`[qcQ
(214) YP`c]rsgQqZcQPihzjF]Aj oAqcQPO$giQPq e \p e ]A 6r Q
(215) ¡\ kQ e ]Aj@Zcgizj\^ gijr6Y`cQPq[ORgijAYk J.QToAqcQPO$giQPq e \^Zgij6`cQPq[6gQjw`VihkqcZz]AQB hkj " /% oJ\^ZcZ[QPqo\^q B gijAZc`[qc] e `[gihkj¡Q`z]AQ iQRZ[gzj\^ " /% :P`cq[Q#YORgiZ&>hkj \^oAoJQPiiQ#\^ihzqcZq[Y e ]Aq[ZcgikQPO$QPj6`
(216) ¥\ kQ e iQ Z[`\^`[]A`r6QoAqcYZcQPj e Q~\pZcZ[h e gY° 6.Qar6Q]6_AgMORQ e \^Z\^oAoJ\^q\pgi`ihzqcZz]AQiQZ[gzj\^Ar6Y e \^qcY @$ 0C$ , 0. :P`[qcQYPO$giZrA\^jAZB gijAZc`[qc] e `[gihkj¬ k]NQPk]NQ Z[hkgi`\
(217) k\^iQP]Nqr6] e hkj6`[q 8kiQ > hzjF\^oAoJQPiiQ \^ihzqcZq[Y e ]Aq[ZcgikQORQPj6`.
(218) \ zQ e iQTZc`\p`c]A`r.\^}AZ[QPj e QR\pZcZ[h e gY2° .j6§j¬.ZcgiQZc`\^`[]A`r6Q q[QPZc`[Q2gijr6YP`[QPqcO$gjNYF\^oAq[YPZiQ e \p e ]ArsQ
(219) ¬NhkjR6\^qr6Q e QFr6QPq[jAgiQPqf\poAoJQP q[Y e ]Aq[Zcg¨R DVj oJQP]A`aq[YPZc]NOR QPq e QZa`cq[hkgiZ e \pZf\^gijAZ[g > ¹ hkj$oAqchzo\^zQfiQPZ
(220) cO2]NZc`B
(221) ihkqk]NQfB hkj r6hkgi`
(222) o\^Z[ZcQPqVo\^qB gijAZc`[qc] e `cgihkj e hzjw`[ q 8zQT° P¬ ¹ hkj$oAqchzo\^zQfiQPZ
(223) R O "
(224) ihkqz]AQB hkj$oQP]N`o\^Z[ZcQPqVo\^qB gijAZc`[qc] e `[gihkj e hzj6`c q 8ziQ~° Rhz] I P¬ ¹ hkj$jAQoAq[hko\pkQqcgiQPj ZcgijAhzj . . . v "XW/+. . 0. x H 12. . v "9+ v ",+ v ",+ . K x J x I x. 354 [H /K Q v "9+ 354 v "9+ I x vo x 354 v "9+ I x vo x. I x vo x H K. H J H I. £¤hk`[hkjAZRz]AQ@iQ e \pZR h 6 H QP` \^Z[Zch e giY*° «QPZc`$gO$ohzZcZ[g}NQz Daj oJhk]Aq[q\ kYPq[g§JQPqRoAi]AZ zYPjAYPq\^iQPORQjw`az]AQiQoAqcY r6g e \^`% I
(225) ©jAQ oJQP]A`QPjAzQPjr6q[QPqr6Q RZcg&?H I w
(226) J .Q e hArA\^zQFr6Q Q`
(227) z]AgoQPq[ORQP`ar¢ hz}A`cQjAgiq
(228) O$YPqcgi`[QPq\pg`r. :P`[qcQ8hzqcO \ ¹. igiZcYPQ oAi]AZ oNqcY e giZ[YPORQPj6` \ToNqcQP]A ,zQF r6Q . G v ",+ x v x H K ohz]Aqcq\^gi` :P`cq[Qª\pg`[QfrA\pjAZfm
(229) hAJ \¤ZcoJY e g¨§ e \p`cgihkjRrs]oAqcY r6g e \^-`
(230) RrA\pjAZm
(231) hAQPZc`hz}A`cQPj6]AQarsgq[Q e `[QPORQPj6`°oJ\^qc`[giq¯rsQ \arsY§jAgi`cgihzj 6]AQoNqcY e Y r6QPORO$QPj6` 6lB.Z \pkgi`r. ]Aj oAqcYrsg e \^`ar6Y§JjAggijr6] e `cgikQORQPj6`r6hkj6`khzg e giQr6YP}N]A&` >.
(232) . .
(233)
(234) (6" 0 N
(235) 0 0 2 ')(=.
(236) 5')(! 0 Y ) ')(! 0 Y ?')(! 0 Y ?')( 9
(237) 0*1Z (6 2*1 B ", 0 Y )# 1 .
(238) $# (6 P 9
(239) 0-1 9
(240) 0 9
(241) 0 # $ (6 0*. 12" 2*1 B" 0* N
(242) 0 0)2 #,, *$ # ,W 0* Y) #+? 2*1 B P 9
(243) 0!')( (6[ 2*1 B 0*. 12 )0 $# 9
(244) 0 -
(245) / . 9
(246) 0 5 2*1 B ## $ (6*1
(247) 9
(248) : * 6 2*1 B" 0* N
(249) 0 0)2 #, :
(250) $ #, 1 " @, . $ #, " "! "#, )0 Y ) # +? 2*1 B P 9
(251) 0!'): ( : #-
(252) 0* !')( (6? 2*1 B- 1 "!$#$#?')( (6[ 2*1 B 1
(253) 9
(254) : *
(255) ?:F17$ @ #"!$#$# . ED.
(256) S \TqcQP\p`cgihkj@r6Q`[q\pjAZcgi`cgihzj " " r6hzjAjAYPQFrN\^jAZVQ e L 2r6Q yQPZc`VYPw\pQORQPj6`ZcoJY e g¨§YQRrA\^jAZ m
(257) r6hzhAjA jAhzojA\pqaZi]AQPj©ZoAoAqcqcQYORrsg gie MP\^qc`QZar6Yigi§kjNjAgQPZgij> r6] e `[gikQPO$QPj6`QP`jAQFoJhkZ[QFoJ\^Zr6QoAq[hk}AiMPO$Qo\pqc`cg e ]NgiQPq .£hk]NZaQPj
(258)
(259) Y-
(260) )/-,A 0 Y ) ')(!.
(261) 5')(!.
(262) 5')(? 0 Y )[')(- <')( 9
(263) 0*1Z 9
(264) * : 0*. 1 2" , 0 Y #,, *$ # Y -
(265)
(266) )/- 0*. 12 )0 $# 0*. 12 )0 = # 9
(267) 0 $# $# 9
(268) * : *.6 , :R $ # " 0) Y ) #
(269) Y -
(270) )*- *.6?: # 0*. 12 0* ? #7 -
(271) /. 9
(272) 0?: 0* #- # $# 9
(273)
(274) *1
(275) 9
(276) :)*
(277) " :R $ # 1
(278) "#@, .
(279) $ # " " 69
(280) #
(281) Y X 1 $#[')(
(282) Y X @ # ')(
(283) Y X 1
(284) 9
(285) : *
(286) :-15@$# 0 " 0 N
(287) 0 0)/2 1 0 , 0 Y) )* 1 4 0 Y ; "A 0 Y ) ( 9 : *
(288) 5: ##$## : *
(289) * 0 5: ### $###$" 9 *
(290) *
(291) 5: ##$## *
(292) *
(293) * 0 5: ### $##### . Khz]A`cQ\¤ZcoJY e g¨§ e \p`cgihkjRrA\pjAZm
(294) hArsQ \Z[YPO#\pj6`cgz]AQ e hzjAZc`[qc] e `[gikQ e hzORoJhkqc`[QPORQjw`\^iQr.Zc`[QPqcQ ]Nq8Z\^jAZ$}hz] e iQ@QP`2Z\^jAZ$Zc]AZ[oQjAZcgihkj"RQZc`#rshkjAjAYQ@QPj-\^jAjNQ_AQ a
(295) \>q[QP\^`cgihzj¦rsQ#`[q\pjAZcgi`cgihzj jAQ>jAhz]AZRZ[QPqc6giq\«o\pZRoJhk]Aq$\ oAqcQ]AkQr6Q e hzqcq[Q e `cgihzj¬az]AQ>jAhk]AZ \ khzjAZRq[QPZc`[qcQPgij6`cQ¡°>\oJ\^qc`[giQ e hzO2}Agij\^`[hkgiqcQarsQf\ `cq\kr6] e `cgihkj QPj e giq e ]Agi` ¯iQVjAhk]AZZ[QPq\T]N`cgiiQfoJhk]NqYPkhAz]AQPqB Q_A`cQPjNZcgihkj@r6Q\ oAq[QP]AzQF°T\o\pqc`[gQq[QPkgiZc`[qcQ <oAqcgiZ[QQPj e hkO$oA`cQr6QB \p`c`[QPj6`cQQP`frsQf\ Zc]AZ[oQjAZcgihk"j arA\pjAZiQ e L N !
(296) P@
(297) " /&21 £¤hk]AZ2\^iihkjNZf`[hk]A`2r.\^}Jhkqr>}AqcgiYPzQPORQjw` q\^oNoQPiQPq2iQPZ2r6 g .YPqcQPj6`[QPZ2Zchz]N`cgihkjAZ2z]AQRjNhk]AZF\ zhkjAZ YP`[]r6giYPQPZ ¬A\ k\^j6`rsQ e LAhkgiZ[gq e QiQaz]AgAjNhk]AZ \Vo\pqc]2\O$QPgiiQ]AqcQ
(298) ohz]Aq]AjAQVgO$oA\^j6`\p`cgih^jrA\^jNZ m
(299) hA ¤jAQaoNqcQPO$gMqcQf\poAoAq[h e LAQz]Ag.6gQjw`
(300) °B QPZcoNqcgi`o\pqc`r6Q\~`cq\zr6] e `[gihkj2<hkqcO \^igiZcYPQrA\pjAZ iQ e L S r6Q y , m
(301) QP`c`[Q#`[q\zr6] e `[ghzjQPZc`2r6Y§JjAgiQ2qcY e ]NqcZcgizQPORQPj6`TZc]AqTiQPZoAq[hkzq\^O$ORQPZVQP`2\^ZcZ[h e giQ#° e L\kz]AQ oAq[hkzq\^O$ORQ e hkjNZc`cq[] e `[g]Aj$QPjAZ[QPO2}AiQar. Yz]\^`[gihkjR}Jh6hkiYPQPjNjAQPZ A¸N\8hzqcO \^igiZ\^`[gihkjQPZ[``cq[YPZoAqch e LAQ r6Q ª gij6`cQPq[oA q :`cQgiORoN\pj6`cYQPj®m A¯iQjAY e QPZcZ[g`[Q2]AjAQzQPZc`[gihkj Q_AoAig e gi`cQr6QPZVjAhkO$Z r6Q~§iZ¬Agij e ]J\^j6` iQPZVoAqchz}AiMPORQPZr6QqcQjAhkO$O#\^zQk¬^Z[]A}AZc`[gi`c]A`[ghzj¬AQ` e £¤hk]AZ\ zhkjAZoAqcY<YPqcYjAhz]AZr6giqcgikQqkQqcZ]AjNQ \poAoAqch e LAQoAi]AZ\^}AZ[`cq\^gi`cQk¬p h 6iQPZ§iZZchzjw`q[QPoAqcYZcQPj6¹ `[YPZo\^qar6QZf\^}NZc`cq\ e `[gihkjAZ ¯j#]N`cgiigZ\^j6`B hkqrsqcQZc]AoJYPq[gQ]Aqr6giZcoJhkjAgi}AiQfrN\^jAZm
(302) hsJ¬NjAhk]AZoJhk]NqcqchzjAZ 0Ó?F-GPÝH. DED.
(303) Su \pgjNZcg}JYPjAY § e giQPqr6QPZVhkoJYPq\p`cgihkjAZarsQfq[QPjAhzORO#\pkQQP`VZc]A}NZc`cgi`[]A`cgihkj¬6kYPq[YPQPZ]AjAQ<hkgiZ oJhk]Nqa`chz]A`cQ\p] jAgizQ\^] ORY`\A {VQP]s_®Zchz]N`cgihkjAZhzjw`YP`[YRQPj66giZ\pkYPQPZ ZcQPihkj e QP`[`cQ r6QP]6_AgiMPORQ2\^oNoAqch e LAQk¬z]AgZ gijAZ[oAgiqcQPj6``chz]A`cQ r6Q]6_®r6Q\ qcQoAqcYPZ[QPj6`\p`cgihkj@zq\poALAgz]AQr6QPZ e gq e ]Agi`cZarshkjAjAYQFrA\^jNZQ e L iSkSz \ToAqcQORgiMPqcQ QPZc`\^izYP}Aqcgz]A Q >NQPiiQFr6Y e q[gi`a]Aj e gq e ]Agi` e hkORO$Qa]AjNQFZ[`cqc] e `c]Aq[Q2qcY e ]AqcZ[gzQrsYPoQj6¹ rA\pj6`Fr6QRr6QP]s_¡QPj6`cgiQPqcZ ¢Q2oAqcQORgiQPqqcQPoNqcYPZ[QPj6`cQ@iQ2jAhzO2}Aqc#Q ¡r6Q§iZQPj6`cq\pj6`FQP` QRrsQP]6_AgiMPORQTiQ jAhzO2}AqcQ r6Q§iZZ[hkq[`\^j6` w\ZcYPO \^j6`cgz]AQ\^Z[Zch e giYPQ°]Aj e giq e ]Agi` QZc`\^ihkq[Z r6Y§jNgQq[Y e ]Aq[ZcgikQORQPj6` Z[]AqiQPZ e gq e ]Agi`cZ ¬6QP`qcQ`chk]NqcjAQ]AjAQ¤8hkj e `cgihkjRrsQ k\^iQP]Aq[Z}h6hzYQPjAjAQPZzQPqcZ k\^iQP]NqcZ
(304) }h6hkiYPQjAjAQPZ \ar6Q]6_AgMORQZ[hki]A`cgihzjQPZc`r6YjAhk`\^`cgihzjAjAQPii Q > QPiiQ r6Y e qcgi`]Aj e giq e ]Agi` e hzORORQ]AjAQÙ8hkj e `cgihkj H£¤hk]AZ Z[]AoAoJhkZcQqchkjNZ]AjAQ
(305) gij6§jAgi`cYr6Q§JZQPj6`[q\^j6`[ZQ`Z[hkq[`\^j6`[Z ^m
(306) QP`c`[Qar6QPq[jAgiMPqcQZ[hki]A`cgihzj~\¤ZcQPq[6gr6Q
(307) }\^Z[Q \p] r6YkQPihkoNoQPO$QPj6` r6Q
(308) \aoNqcQP]AzQfr6Q`[q\zr6] e `[ghzjrN\^jAZ m
(309) hAJ¬kz]AQ
(310) jAhk]NZoAqcYZcQPj6`cQqchkjNZarA\^jAZÙQ
(311) oAq[h e L\pgij e L\poAgi`cqcQz ¤j e giq e ]Agi`az]Ag.giORoN\pj6`cQ]Aj oAq[hkkq\^O$ORQZc`[QPqcQP\TiQZcLAYO#\ Zc]Agik\^j6 `>. GO. E. E’. SEL. RES. K0. SUSP. K1. KILL. K2 ...... 6 S +. ." .
(312) &+; $-C $# . . 0A#B.C 4./ =0@ .. $ $- $# . ED.
(313) S {\pjAZiQ e \kr6q[Qar6Q e Q`cq\ k\^gikjAhz]AZjAQ
(314) `cq\pgi`chkjNZoJ\^ZiQPZgjNZc`cq[] e `[ghzjAZ r.\p`c`cQjw`[Q Q`¯rsQZc]AZ[oQPjNZcgihkj z ]AgZcQ`cq\kr6]AgiZ[QPj6`ao\pq r6QZ e giq e ]Agi`cZf\ zQ e q[QPkgiZ[`cqcQZ .m
(315) Q e g\ §j@r6QoJhk]Azhkgiq jNhk]AZ e hzj e QPj6`[qcQPqZc]Nqa\ o\pqc`[gQ e hzO2}Agij\^`[hkgiqcQarsQ\`[q\krs] e `cgihzj#Qj e gq e ]Agi`cZ £¤hk]AZohz]AkhzjAZr6hzj e hkO$QP`c`[qcQg e gziQPZ.§iZWV¸.¬¸2 a¸A¬^nVlcTQP`¸AÙ £¤hk]AZq\poAoQhzjAZ`[hk]A`[Q8hzgZ iQP]Aq[Zaq 8kiQPZqcQZcoJQ e `cg¨8Z > ¹ iQa§JWa¸ 8q[QPZc]NORQ e hzj6`c q 8ziQfB\ e `cgik\^`[ghzj\p] e hk]Aq[Zfr6QZgjNZc`\pj6`cZZc]Ngk\pj6` iQoAqcQORgiQPqgijAZc`\^j6`¬ ¹ iQa§J¸ a¸A«zMPiQfB YP`\^`ar6QPZq[QPkgiZ[`cqcQZ¬JjAhk`[hkjAZaz]AQTWa¸QPZc`\^ihkq[Z r6Y \ e `[gzY ªWV¸ ¸ V¸A ¬ ¹ iQa§Jnalc>qcQPO$QP`iQPZqcQkgiZc`[qcQPZ° PYPqch$ihkqcZr. ]AjAQiQPzYPQFr. Q_ e QPoN`cgihkj¬ ¹ iQa§J¸A>QPZ[`a\Frsg%Z hkj e `cgihkj r6QPZVqcQPzgZ[`cq[QPZ ¢QPZ
(316) §iZaz]AQjAhk]NZqcQP`[QPjAhkjNZfQj#oNqcQPO$gMqcQ\^oAoNqch _AgiO#\^`[gihkjTZchkj6`iQPZZ[]Agik\^j6`cZ> ¹ iQa§J /Dz]Ag e hzj6`c q 8ziQfB\ e `cgik\^`[ghzj2gijAgi`cg\^iQ 8gi.Z[QPq\gO$oA\^j6`cY
(317) oAi]AZ`\^qr$o\pq]Aj qcQPzgiZc`cq[Q P¬ ¹ iQPZ
(318) §iZ e hkq[qcQPZ[ohzjrA\pjw`\^]6_ ZcgikjJ\^]6_#r. QPj6`[qcYPQ B P¬ ¹FiQPZ§JZ e hkqcq[QPZcoJhkjJrA\^j6`#\p]6_¡Zcgi6\^]6_ r6Q Z[hkqc`[giQ B TQP`2iQPZT§iZ e hkq[qcQPZ[ohzjrA\^j6` \^]6_ e hAr6QPZRr6Q `cQPq[ORgij\pgZ[hkj BnfvN¬nFSz¬nfyN¬ QP` e {T h 6$iQaZcLNYPO#\ ZcgiORoNg¨§YarshkjAjAYQPj§k]Aq[QuRk]NQfjNhk]AZa\ zhkjAZ
(319) ]A`cgiigiZcYk £¤hk]AZVkQPq[qchzjAZo\^q\TZc]Agi`[Qz] giZ[QPq\ª\ e giQTr. YP`cQPjJr6qcQ2iQPZ e giq e ]Agi`[Z~\ zQ e QZa§JZVO#\pjz]\^j6`cZ £¤hk]AZr6hkjNjAhkjAZrA\pjAZ \V§J iQPZ e giq e ]Agi`[Zak]NggiORoN\pj6`cQPj6`iQPZ gijAZ[`cq[] e `cgihzjAZaZc`[QPqcQoJQPqcO$gZ[QPZrA\^jAZ iQ e \kr6q[Q#r6Q$jAhk`[qcQ YP`c]Jr6Qk £hz]AZTjAhk`[hkjAZFn ihkq[Zz]AQRjNhk]AZTkhz]AihkjAZgiZchzQqF]Aj §B¬\^]Jk]NQP e \^Z2n q[QPoAqcYZcQPj6`cQ2iQPZan ToJhk]Aq H& gB . .
(320) ' #. £¤hk]AZr6hzjAjAhzjAZa]AjNgz]AQORQPj6`a]Nj*\poQPq5]¡r6Q e QP`[`cQR\^oNoAqch e LAQRz]Ag\$]AjAQ 8hkq[O#\^igiZ\p`cgihkj2oN]N` 8k` ihk]Nqr6QrA\pjAZam
(321) hA ¤j e giq e ]Agi`QPZ[`qcQPoNqcYPZ[QPj6`cY2g e g.o\pq]AjAQZc`[qc] e `[]AqcQTqcY e ]AqcZ[gikQFr6QoJhkq[`cQPZ ¤jAQohzqc`[Q~rsYPoQjr@r6Q r6Q]6_#j\p`c]Aq[QP <jAhkO2}Aq[Qar. QPj6`cq[YPQPZ ¤QP` 8jAhzO2}AqcQar6QZ[hkqc`[giQPZ jAQoJhkqc`[QoQP]N` :P`cq[Qf]NjR}A] .QPq ¬ ]AjNQRoJhkqc`[Q D) ¬]AjAQRoJhkq[`cQRK¬]AjAQ2oJhkq[`cQ A£ DVK¬.]AjAQ e hkO$ohzZcgi`cgihzj®r6Q2oJhkqc`[QPZ¬]NjoAqchAr6]Agi`r6Q oJhkq[`cQPZ ¬AQP` e A¸6hkgi ` ! 8q[QPZco$ " ' Ù]AjAQaoJhkq[`cQ° <qcQPZ[o " §JZÙQPj6`cq\pj6`cZQP ` 8q[QPZco ¤jAQoJhkqc`[QQPZc` e hkjAZ[`cq[]Agi`cQF°To\pqc`[gqarsQPZhkoJYPq\p`cQP]NqcZYPiYPORQjw`\^giqcQZ Z[]Agik\^j6`cZ > ' Ù§iZZ[hkqc`\^j6`cZ @. 0Ó?F-GPÝH. DED.
(322) S. E. E’ K0. GO. K1 K2 ...... zu S +. . .!" $ - - % 1)./ $ % $. ED.
(323) S E. E k =/= 1. 0. 0. E’. GO. Kk 0. E. E’ E’s. s! GO. K. E s. p\s. E GO. E’ E GO. GO K. K. K. K0. p;q E GO. E’. Q. E GO. K. E. E’ GO. E GO. K. K0. E’. E L. GO. M A X. p|q E GO. K. {p}. GO. E’. K0. K0. P K1. K1. K2. R. E’. Q. Ki. K. L1. L2. L0 K0. K1. R0 R1. N . K K0. E’. P. M A X. E’. Q. E. 0Ó?F-GPÝH. E’. P. K. s?p,q. DED. K. K. E. E’. P. P. K. E’. GO. GO. GO. K0 0. E’ E s s’ E’. R2.
(324) % 1? 0@#%. . #B$ 1 " $- $#A ./% +$. K2. K i-1.
(325) S h hzj oJhkq[`cQ D) oJhkq[`cQFK oJhkq[`cQF£8DaK gr6QPj6`[g`[Y r6]NoAig e \^`cgihzj 6 e hzORoJhkZ[g`[hkj @ oAq[hAr6]Agi` > q[Y 9Q_Agihkj oJQPqcO2]N`\^`[gihkj \ ZcYO#\^j6`[gz]AQRr¢ ]Nj e giq e ]Agi`TZcQPq\®\pihkqcZ2r6hzjAjAYPQ$o\^qT]AjAQ8hkj e `cgihkj¡rA\pjAZ E E £¤hk]AZ \p]AqchzjAZa}JQPZchzgij®rA\^jNZa]Aj oAq[QPORgiQPq`[QPORoAZarsQZcoJY e g¨§QPqiQoAq[hAr6]Agi` e \^q[`cYPZ[giQPj*rsQ}h6G hzYQPj®r6G QF¸ e hk`[` £¤hk]AZr6hkjAjNhkjAZ\ÙZcoJY e g¨§ e \^`cgihzjrA\pjAZm
(326) hAar6QZ e gq e ]Agi`cZQP`rsQ\
(327) `cq\zr6] e `[gihkjZc]Agik\pjw` e QP`c`[Q \poAoAqch e LAQ QPj@\pjAjAQ_AQ d Am
(328) QP`[`cQV8hzqcO#\pigZ\^`[ghzjj QPZ[` o\pZ e hkO$oAiMP`cQjNhk`\pORQPj6`Qj e Q~z]Ag e hzj e QPq[jAQiQ e hArA\^zQ r6Q \ qcY9Q_Agihkj e \p e ]ArsQfoJhkgij6`
(329) §A_AQ
(330). . . . ' #. {\pjAZ e QP`[`cQ¡\^oNoAqch e LAQk¬
(331) iQPZ$§iZ2Zchzjw` gij6`cQPq[oAqcY`cYPZ@rA\pjAZ Q e oJh-r6QPZ }JhwhziYPQPjAZ r6Q*¸ e hk`[` E;G ¢QPZT§iZ e hkqcq[QPZcoJhkjJrA\^j6`R\^]s_¡Zcgikj\p]6_¡r. QPj6`cqcYQ ª ¬\^]6_Zcgizj\^]6_ rsQRZchzqc`[gQ B QP`2\^]s_ e hAr6QPZ r6Q2`[QPqcO$gij\^giZchzj ªn¬Z[hkj6`qcQPoAq[YPZcQjw`[YPZRoJ\^qFr6QZF¸ e hz`c`B¹c\krsgz]AQZ m
(332) Q e g jAhz]AZoJQPqcO$QP`r.\ khzgqV]AjAQ Y e qcgi`c]Aq[Q2]AjAg¨8hzqcORQoJhk]Aqr6YPjAhz`cQPq°\8hkgiZ]Aj©QPjAZcQO2}AiQFr6Q §iZ¬J]Aj@YPzYPjAQPO$QPj6`aQP`]Aj©QPjAZcQO2}AiQ r6Q e hAr6QPZfrsQf`[QPqcO$gij\^giZchzj ¤j e giq e ]Agi`aQPZ[`aqcQoAqcYPZ[QPj6`cY$o\^q]AjNQ8hzj e `[ghzj@k]NgoAq[QPjr QPj\^q[k]AO$QPj6`cZ
(333) ]Aj@}Jh6hkiYPQPj®rsQF¸ e hz`c` /DP¬A]Nj¸ e hk`[`B¹c\kr6gz]AQ ª ¬AQP`q[QP`chz]AqcjNQ]AjAQoJ\^giqcQr6Q¸ e hz`c`,¹,\zr6gk]NQP Z ªi¬n P \Z[oY e g¨§ e \^`[gihkj®r6QZ e giq e ]Agi`[ZfrA\pjAZam
(334) hA2ZcQq\2r6hzj e > X
(335) C 6)0* 69
(336) "/ Z 5 0 N
(337) 0 0 2 ')(! 0 Y ) ')(! 0 Y )
(338) ! 0 Y )"+. £¤hk]AZa\pihzjAZr6hkjAjNQPqf°ToAq[YPZcQjw`iQPZq[MPkiQPZr6Q\`[q\zr6] e `[ghzj®z]AgrsY e hk]NQjw`arsQB giO$oA\^j6`\ `[ghzj 6r QZoAqchzkq\pORO$QPZQPj e giq e ]Agi`cZr6hkjNjAYPQrA\^jNZ \V§J A k£¤hk]AZr6hkjNjAhkjAZ e QPZq[MPkiQPZarN\^jAZ
(339) iQZc`Bb6iQfr6Q\ Z[YPO#\pjw`[gk]NQaj\p`c]Aq[QPiQz¬Ao\pqZchk] e giZar6Q e \^qcQ`cYk ¢QPZZcb6O2}JhkiQPZ QP` r6YPjNhk`cQjw`Tr6QPZoAq[hkzq\^O$ORQPZa¯Zc`cQqcQPB¬ QP`0r6QPZ e gq e ]Agi`cZ ¬.QP` QP` r6YjAhk`[QPj6`aqcQZcoJQ e `cgiz" QPORQPj6' `V]Aj }h6hkiYPQjrsQF¸ e hz`c`QP`]Aj@¸ e hk`c`,¹,\zr6gz]AQk ¸sg QZc`\2oJ\^giqcQ % + ! ¬.hkj>jAhz`cQ TZchkj>oAq[QPORgiQPqYPiYPO$QPj6` Q` TZ[hkjr6QP]6_AgiMPO$Q YPiYPO$QPj6` ! ¯j6§j hkj jAhz`cQ + QP` QZhkoJYPq\p`cQP]Aq[Z + , QP` -l Zc]NqQZ}h6hkiYPQjAZfr6Q¸ e hk`c` . ED.
(340) Sx. `cq\zr e hkO$oA . N. ; p . `cq\zrQPORgi` . . ; p . `cq\zroAqcQZcQPj6` . `cq\zrZcQ. *"9+:'. `cq\zro\^q\^iiQP. . ",6'. . `cq\zrih e \^ . `cq\zr`cq\^o . `cq\zrZcLAg¨8` . . p. p. . . ;p < ;p p. 0Ó?F-GPÝH. .
(341). + . 7. . p. ". v. . v. v. . . . v ". p ".
(342). . . . x. v. vv. . vv. $. x $ x $. vwx vwx&x. . . '. v. . . . v v . v&v. x. . . '. "B@ '. ;p . "XW. " ; p p v v I x vwx x. H"JI. ; p . K ". ;p . p. ". p. p . . x. .. . . K v. . . " $ #B. . "/ . $. v . v x ". +. +. v. x. . - - %. -L v&v. . x. . vwx vwx&x. x + x . x
(343) x x + x vw
(344) x 3 4 H
(345) vv x
Documents relatifs
Dans chaque ville et pour toutes les lignes de tramway considérées, il faudrait disposer des trafics avant et après ouverture d’une ligne et de plusieurs projections d’évolution
Le fait d’écrire à partir d’une oeuvre d’art visuelle ressemble à une forme de contrainte; nous croyons par ailleurs que cette pratique a eu un effet durable sur l’écriture
variables d'ordre psychologique: soit f.amiliale ou personnelle, soit so- ciale, soit professionnelle, soit une combinaison de ces facteurs. Ce patient a récupéré
For the two coolest objects in Figure 3.6, HD 4539 and PG 1716+426, both at Ta < 27, 000 K, there is a good match between the predicted synthetic spectra and the FUSE data: the
lui inculquer le registre li'lquistioue, les l1abitudes alimen- taires et vestimentaires ainsi que le comportement des bour- geois de Québec. Pierrette Paul doit
La conciliation emploi-famille : des mesures à développer dans les milieux de travail Tableau 4 : Les dispositions favorisant la conciliation travailfamille dans les
Figure 2.4 Predicted (continuous lines) and observed values (filled circles: stands aged from trees with root collar; open circles: stands aged from trees without root collar)
Cette posture permet de dégager deux idées centrales : le poids des milieux professionnels locaux dans l’intermédiation et le transit des idées, modèles et pratiques
