Visual quality assessment for motion vectors watermarking in the MPEG‑4 AVC domain

HAL Id: hal-00848611

https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00848611

Submitted on 26 Jul 2013

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access

archive for the deposit and dissemination of

sci-entific research documents, whether they are

pub-lished or not. The documents may come from

teaching and research institutions in France or

abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est

destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents

scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,

émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de

recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires

publics ou privés.

Visual quality assessment for motion vectors

watermarking in the MPEG‑4 AVC domain

Marwen Hasnaoui, Mihai Mitrea, Maher Belhaj, Francoise Preteux

To cite this version:

Marwen Hasnaoui, Mihai Mitrea, Maher Belhaj, Francoise Preteux. Visual quality assessment for

mo-tion vectors watermarking in the MPEG‑4 AVC domain. Internamo-tional Workshop on Video Processing

and Quality Metrics, Jan 2010, Scottsdale, United States. pp.1-6. �hal-00848611�

1

1

2345671856739A1644B44CBD91EF1CF93FD12B9F1

69BC63D13D19B1CB1621FC63D1

1 2314567589AB12312ACDE5B1231FE5B157131DCE91 76CA9C9C18118195DA6B1 !21"E#5DCE7C1 $B1D9E1%5DE6189DAEDB1$&'&&1!(D)1*1D57E1 +5D,E73567589AB1A5A3ACDE5B15ED3-E5.5-55B1/D578A6E3#DECE90AC169#5DA63E921 1 1 61

38,55)6B1 C81 ADEC)1 ,5CED5D41 51 8#DE66E1 (AE81 6CDE51 -E8E61 51 5E75A751 DE6E5D1 C8#A61 8,1 8#EAC)B1CAE165(A751571A7CED8#ED5-AAC)15DE1CE1CDEE1 5A71 5(57C55E61 8/1 691 571 5##D8531 E1 #DE6E7C1 #5#ED1 E561,AC1CE12!71819%18CA871(EC8D1,5CED5D4A751 571 #DE6E7C61 CE1 /AD6C1 DE/EDE7E1 566E66E7C1 /8D1 CE1 (A6A-AAC)1 8/1 CE1 DE5CE1 5DCE/5C631 E1 E#EDAE7C61 /88,1 CE1 86C1 #8#95D1 C)#E61 8/1 :95AC)1 ECDA61 A71 (AE81 #D8E66A7561 123456 7288494AB4CDEF471 ;#E541 6A5751 C81 78A6E1 D5CA8B15-689CE15(ED55E1A//EDE7EB1#E541E5716:95DE1EDD8DB1 571A55E1/AEAC)<B1 B9945E2A6DEF471;6CD9C9D5187CE7CB1 78D5A=E1D86618DDE5CA87B18DDE5CA871:95AC)B16CD9C9D51 6AA5DAC)1 ECDA<B1 571 1FBC2FE51 ;A5AC51 (AE81 :95AC)<31E179EDA51DE69C618DDE6#871C81518D#9618/1>1 (AE816E:9E7E618/15-89C1?'1A79CE61E531

46 97F61 2!7181 9%B1 1 /D5E6B1 8CA871 (EC8D6B1 ,5CED5D4A75B1CD576#5DE7)B1:95AC)1ECDA631

1

3 13!"#$%"!1 1

71 8DED1 C81 E75C1 #AD5)1 897CEDA751 ,AE1 4EE#A751 51 A-EDCAE61/8D151DA5C/9196EDB1,5CED5D4A751689CA8761571-E1 876AEDE61 571 A#EDE#CA-E1 ;CD576#5DE7C<1 CD54A751 E6655E1 A61 A76EDCE1 A7C81 CE1 EA51 C81 -E1 #D8CECE1 @&1?A31 891CE1ECECA8718/1CA61E6655E1-E1D8-96C1C819757E1 #D8E66A7515715AA89615CC546B1CE1#AD5CE1571-E1CD54E1 8,71C81CE156C1E551-9)ED31

B7E18/1CE178,55)61(AE81,5CED5D4A751A65(57C55E1A61 DE#DE6E7CE1 -)1 AC61 6#EE31 B71 CE1 87E1 57B1 A5)1 #ED/8DA751 ,5CED5D4A751 558DAC61 DE:9ADE1 8#E1 CD576/8D5CA8761 871 978#DE66E1 EA5B1 C961 -E8A751 8#9C5CA875)1 8#E1 571 /8D-AA751 DE51 CAE1 5##A5CA87631 B71 CE1 8CED1 57B1 6ED(AE61 A4E1 (AE81 871 E571E#E71871DE51CAE1#D8E66A751C961A#86A751CA61 6E(EDE1876CD5A7C1871CE1DE5CE1,5CED5D4A7516)6CE61@8A31 1 689CA871 C81 CA61 E5841 5)1 -E1 DE#DE6E7CE1 -)1 8#DE66E1 85A71 ,5CED5D4A751 6)6CE631 EAD1 5A71 5(57C55E1A61DE5CE1C81CEAD15-AAC)1C81A76EDC1CE15D41,AC1 A7A51E8A7518/1CE18#DE66E16CDE531

C7/8DC975CE)B1 ,5CED5D4A751 571 8#DE66A871 5DE1 C,81 57C5587A6CA1E6AED5C531%8#DE66A871EAA75CE61CE1(A6951

DE9757)1 A71 CE1 (AE81 6E:9E7E61 561 51 AACB1 E(E71 CE1 6A5CE6C1 5CED5CA871 8/1 51 8#DE66E1 6CDE51 ,891 E51 C81 (A6951 5DCE/5C631 71 AC61 C9D7B1 ,5CED5D4A751 E#8AC61 CE1 (A6951DE9757)1A718DED1C81AE1CE15D431

E1 #DE6E7C1 6C9)1 8-ECA(E)1 E6C5-A6E61 ,ECED1 571 5C1 ,5C1ECE7C1CE1CD576#5DE7C15ACA(E1,5CED5D4A751571-E1 5AE(E1 /8D1 CE1 1 /D5E1 8CA871 (EC8D61 8/1 CE1 2!7181 9%1 6CDE531 D81 CE1 ,5CED5D4A751 #8A7C1 8/1 (AE,B1 CE1 6C9)1 A61 5E7ED561 781 #5DCA95D1 E6192921 DE6CDACA8761 5##)1 /8D1 CE1 A76EDCA871 D9E1 8D1 /8D1 CE1 6CD5CE5)1 /88,E1 ,E71 6EECA751CE18CA871(EC8D61C81-E15D4E31

E1 #5#ED1 561 CE1 /88,A751 6CD9C9DE31 ECA8711 89CA7E61 68E1-56A16)7C51EEE7C61/8D1CE12!71819%16CDE531 ECA8711 #DE6E7C61 CE1 (A6951 :95AC)1 ECDA61 876AEDE1 A71 CE1 #DE6E7C1 6C9)31 E1 (AE81 8D#961 571 CE1 E#EDAE7C51,8D415DE1E6DA-E1A71ECA871931ECA87191 -DA7561A7C81A5C1CE1A7/9E7E18/1CE18#DE66A871D5CE1571 8/1 CE1 (AE81 87CE7C1 871 CE1 5DCE/5C1 (A6A-AAC)1 ,AE1 ECA87191879E61CE1#5#ED31

1

33 1CB1621%1&!'1()(*(!1 1

E1 2!7181 9%1 8#DE66A871 6C575DB1 5343531 43DE8B1 571 DE9E1 CE1 DE9757)1 EA6CA751 A71 CE1 75C9D51 (AE81 /D5E61-8C1A71CE1CE#8D515716#5CA5185A761@>1FA31 71CE1CE#8D5185A7B1CE1DE9757)15875169E66A(E1 /D5E61A61DE9E1-)18CA8718#E765CA8731718DED1C8181 CA6B1 CE1 (AE81 A61 A(AE1 A71 7861 ;7D89#1 8/1 AC9DE6<31 !51 781 87C5A761 5C1 E56C1 87E1 6 /D5EB1 571 51 (5DA5-E1 79-ED1 ;E(E71 '<1 8/1 1 571 1 /D5E631 E1 1 /D5E61 5DE1 E78E1 -)1 CE6E(E6B1 96A751 A55E1 8#DE66A871 CE7A:9E631 E1 1 /D5E61 5DE1 8CA871#DEACE1 /D81 #DE(A8961/D5E631E11/D5E615DE18CA871#DEACE1/D81 -8C1 #DE(A8961 571 69-6E:9E7C1 /D5E631 E1 1 571 1 #DEACA871DEAE6187)187115711/D5E61A71CE165E17831 8D1 CE1 A7CED1 #DEACA87B1 A//EDE7C1 6A=E1 -8461 5DE1 /AD6C1 E/A7E1 871 CE1 /D5EB1 58DA751 C81 AC61 87CE7C1 ;8CA87B1 E(E1 8/1 EC5AB1 4B3<31 E1 -841 6A=E6B1 A71 #AE6B1 571 -E1

&E

&E × B1_{&E × B1}G _{G ×}&EB1_{G × B1}G _{G × B1}8 _{8 × B1571}G 8 × 3118 65ED1-84615DE18-C5A7E1-)16#ACCA751 51#5DE7C1-841A71 C,81 E:951 5DE51 -84631 %876E:9E7C)B1 51 -8461 5DE1 69-#5DC61 8/1 &E ×&E1EB9D5BFB1 ,A1 5DE1 CE1 -56A1

A61E/A7EB1E51-841A61566A57E151DE/EDE7E1/D5E157151 8CA871(EC8D15A(A75151#D8(E7AE7E18//6EC1A71CE1DE/EDE7E1 /D5E31E1A//EDE7E1-EC,EE71CE1#AE618/1CE1-841571 CE1#AE618#AE1/D81CE185CA871#8A7CE1-)1CE18CA871 (EC8D1 A71 CE1 DE/EDE7E1 /D5E1 A61 CE71 CD576/8DE1 -)1 571 A7CE5ED1 "%B1 :957CA=EB1 571 E7CD8#)1 8E31 E1 6EC1 8/1 8CA8761 (EC8D6B1 DE/EDE7E1 /D5E6B1 571 CD576/8D1 :957CA=E1A//EDE7E61571-E196E1C81DE-9A1CE1/D5E31 E1 6C9)1 DE#8DCE1 A71 CE1 #DE6E7C1 #5#ED1 E(595CE61 CE1 (A6951 5DCE/5C61 A79E1 A71 CE1 8DA5A751 ;978#DE66E<1 (AE81 -)1 ,5CED5D4A751 CE1 8CA871 (EC8D61 8/1 CE1 1 /D5E631 71 8CED1 ,8D6B1 ,E1 651 E(595CE1 -)1 E5761 8/1 68E1 #8#95D1 :95AC)1 ECDA61 CE1 A//EDE7E61 -EC,EE71 CE1 8DA5A751 ;978#DE66E<1 (AE81 571 CE1 E8#DE66E1 (AE81 8-C5A7E1 5/CED1 68E1 #DEE/A7E1 5CED5CA8761 8/1 CE1 A7CED18CA871(EC8D1(59E631

1

333 19!+(!&1,$)%&1*(%1 1

E55DE661CE12!71816CDE518A/A5CA8716CD5CE5)B1CE1 9571 8-6ED(ED1 ,A1 5,5)61 ,5C1 51 (AE81 87CE7C1 A6#5)E1 ;5/CED1 E8A75<1 871 68E1 E(AE1 ;8#9CED1 6DEE7B1916ECB1(AE81#D8EC8D1H<31

E1 2!7181 9%1 876AED61 /D5E61 DE#DE6E7CE1 A71 CE1 I%-%D186D6'1/8D5C3148,E(EDB1CE15DCE/5C1E//EC615DE1EDE1

A7(E6CA55CE1 87)1 A71 CE1 I1 ;9A757E<1 8#87E7CB1 -)1 876AEDA751 6E(ED51 8-ECA(E1 E569DE61 @G1$A1 CE6E1 E569DE615DE1A(AE1A7C81CDEE15CE58DAE61@&'A611

•1 123456 7288494AB4CDEF476 4EF94F1 ;#E541 6A5751 C81 78A6E1 D5CA81113 B15-689CE15(ED55E1A//EDE7E111"B1#E541 E5716:95DE1EDD8D1112!B1571A55E1/AEAC)111<1 •1 B9945E2A6 DEF476 4EF94F1 ;6CD9C9D51 87CE7C111%B1

78D5A=E1 D8661 8DDE5CA871113%%B1 8DDE5CA871 :95AC)111%JB15716CD9C9D516AA5DAC)1ECDA1112<1 •1 1FBC2FE564EF94F1;A5AC51(AE81:95AC)111"9J<31 38CE1C5CB1EE#C1/8D1CE1"9J1@&&AB151CE18CED1E569DE61 ,EDE1 55#CE1 /D81 A55E1 :95AC)1 566E66E7CB1 -)1 8#9CA7515715(ED55E18(ED151(AE81/D5E631

E1 #AE1 A//EDE7E1 -56E1 E569DE61 6EE41 51 #ED/EC1 E:95AC)1 -EC,EE71 CE1 CE6CE1 571 CE1 DE/EDE7E1 (AE81 6E:9E7E631 5C1 A6B1 E(E71 A/1 CE1 A//EDE7E61 5DE1 78C1 (ED)1 A51;/8D1E5#EB168E1,ACE178A6E15E1871CE1#AE6<1 CE)1 ,A1 -E1 68,71 -)1 CE6E1 E569DE631 48,E(EDB1 CE6E1 E569DE61 5778C1 A6DAA75CE1 -EC,EE71 6#5D6E1 571 #8,ED/91A6C8DCA8761;,A15DE1(A6A-E<1571/DE:9E7C1651 A6C8DCA8761 ;,A1 5DE1 A7(A6A-E<31 E1 8DDE5CA871 -56E1 E569DE61 6EE41 51 6C5CA6CA51 /AC1 8/1 CE1 CE6CE1 (AE81 871 CE1 DE/EDE7E31 5C1 A6B1 A/1 CE1 CE6CE1 6A5751 DE6E-E61 CE1 8DA5A75B1 E(E71 ,AC1 68E1 78A6EB1 CE1 8DDE5CA871 -56E1 E569DE61 ,A1 DE/EC1 CA61 DE6E-57E31 E1 "9J1 A61 51 68#A6CA5CE1 E569DEB1 C54A751 A7C81 5897C1 -8C1 CE1 /ACEDA751 571 CE1 564A751 #D8#EDCAE61 8/1 CE1 9571 (A6951 6)6CE31AD6CB1-8C1CE1DE/EDE7E1571CE1CE6CE1(AE8615DE1 6#5CA5)1571CE#8D5)1/ACEDE31E7B1CEAD1 A//EDE7E1A61

6E871 /ACED1 A71 8DED1 C81 8-C5A71 CE1 85CA8761 ,EDE1 CE1 5DCE/5C61 ,891 -E1 564E1 -)1 CE1 8DA5A751 5C51 CE6E(E631 71CE1#DE6E7C16C9)B151CE6E1E569DE15(E1E#8)E1CE1 #5D5ECED61571CE1,8D4A751577ED1EC5AE1A71@&DA31 1 32 1B'+(%*(!)1($+1 1 32 - 12%#("1"+$1

E1 DE69C61 DE#8DCE1 A71 CA61 6C9)1 5(E1 -EE71 8-C5A7E1 -)1 #D8E66A751 51 8D#961 8/1 >1 (AE81 6E:9E7E61 8/1 5-89C1 ?'1 A79CE61E531

E1 8DDE6#87A751 (AE81 87CE7C1 A61 ECED85E7E896B1 8-A7A751 75C9D51 571 6)7CECA1 6E7E6B1 8(AE6B1 7E,6B1 571 6#8DC61 @8A1 E5#E61 8/1 8DA5A751 571 5D4E1 /D5E61 5DE1#DE6E7CE1A71A59DE1&31 1 11 1 1 11 1 1 E%. 1- 1BDA5A751;E/C<15715D4E1;DA5C<1/D5E631 1

E1 /D5E1 6A=E1 A61 ?>DDGG1 #AE631 E6E1 6E:9E7E61 ,EDE1 8E15C1CDEE1A//EDE7C1D5CE6611

•1 E81 4-ACK61 ;8,1 :95AC)1 (AE8B1 58DA751 C81 CE1 8-AE1 7EC,8D419655E6<1

•1 >&D14-ACK61;EA91:95AC)1(AE8B18DDE6#87A751C81CE1 7CED7EC1E575E6<1

•1 &'D814-ACK61;A51:95AC)1(AE8<31

E1 6E:9E7E61 ,EDE1 8E1 58DA751 C81 CE1 DEF452A41 #D8/AE1;7811/D5E6<B1,AC1D'1/D5E61#ED1781E7EB1CE1 7816CD9C9DE1A61H311

71CE1E#EDAE7C6B187)18CA871(EC8D618DDE6#87A751C81 1 /D5E61 ;A7CED1 /D5E1 #DEACA87<1 ,EDE1 876AEDE31 %876E:9E7C)B1 CE6E1 (EC8D61 5DE1 8#9CE1 -)1 51 EA571 #DEAC8D1@>1FA31

E1 E#EDAE7C61 6C5DCE1 -)1 #D8E66A751 51 #5DCA95D1 (AE81 6E:9E7E1 8E1 5C1 EA91 :95AC)1 ;5-E61&18<1 571 /88,E1-)1E6C5-A6A751CE15E7ED5AC)18/1CE1DE69C61,AC1 DE6#EC1 C81 CE1 8#DE66A871 D5CE1 ;8,1 571 A51 :95AC)1 (AE81 DE69C61 5DE1 A96CD5CE1 A71 A561D1><1 571 C81 CE1 (AE81 87CE7C1 ;CE1 DE6C1 8/1 CE1 6E:9E7E61 5DE1 876AEDE1 A71 CE1 E#EDAE7C61DE#8DCE1A71A5631E1$<31

32 / 18$!%%0(1($)1

E16C9)1/896E61871CE15DCE/5C1(A6A-AAC)18DDE6#87A751 C81 57)1 5ACA(E1 ,5CED5D4A751 6EE631 71 8CED1 ,8D6B1AC1 A615669E1C5C151D5781(59E1;CE15D4<1A615E1C81571 5D-ACD5DA)1 86E71 79-ED1 8/1 8CA871 (EC8D61 8DDE6#87A751C81511/D5E31381E6192921DE6CDACA8715##AE61 C81CE1,5CED5D4E1(EC8D1#86ACA871A71CE11/D5E18D1C81CE1 876AEDE11 /D5E1 8DED1 A71 CE1 7831 %876E:9E7C)B1 CE1 (A6A-AAC)18/1CE15DCE/5C61A6151/97CA8718/16E(ED51(5DA5-E6611 •1 CE15#AC9E18/1CE18A/A5CA87B1B8315-E1&1

•1 CE1 79-EDK#86ACA8718/1CE1 8A/AE1 5D8-8461A7C81 571A7A(A9511/D5EB1B8315-E61D1571?1 •1 CE1#86ACA8718/1CE11/D5E1A71CE178B1B8315-E18311 &31 46E948EB62F2D2526EF6E68AB2A686467282BE2A6 E152741;2!4!1CE15D41(59E<1 FE1CEDE15715D-ACD5DA)186E711/D5E1#86ACA871A71CE1781 ;CE18C11/D5E1A71CE179EDA51A96CD5CA876<1571516A75E1 ,5CED5D4E1 8CA871 (EC8DB1 8DDE6#87A751 C81 CE1 5D8-841 85CE1 A71 CE1 E7CDE1 8/1 CA61 /D5E31 E1 8CA871(EC8D1(59E1,5615CEDE1-)15ACA871,AC151-A75D)1 D5781 5E7ED5CE1 6E:9E7EB1 ,AC1 A//EDE7C1 5#AC9E661 +1&B1&2B1+1DB1D2B1+1?B1?2B1+18B182B1+1>B1>231

D31 46 E948EB6 2F2D2526 EF6 E6 8AB2A6 86 46 AD496 86 7282476EB9D5BF12A6E6689E41

FE1CEDE15715D-ACD5DA)186E711/D5E1#86ACA871A71CE1781 ;CE1 8C1 1 /D5E1 A71 CE1 79EDA51 A96CD5CA876<1 571 876AED1 51 /AE1 +1DB1 D21 5#AC9E1 8A/A5CA871 8/1 51 (5DA5-E1 79-ED1 8/1 8CA871 (EC8D631 DEE1 56E61 5DE1 A96CD5CE1 A71 5-E1D61 ;5<1 51 6A75E1 8CA871 (EC8DB1 8DDE6#87A751 C81 CE1 E7CD51 5D8-841 ;-<1 C,81 8CA871 (EC8D6B18DDE6#87A751C81CE19##ED1E/C18D7ED1571E7CD51 5D8-8461 ;<1 CDEE1 8CA871 (EC8D6B1 8DDE6#87A751 C81 CE19##ED1E/CB1-8CC81E/C1571E7CD515D8-84631 ?31 46E948EB62F2D2526EF6E68AB2A686461F22A68646 "E49E947#6EB9D5B62A64689E41 FE1CEDE1511/D5E1#86ACA8715D-ACD5DA)186E71;A715-E1?B1 CE18C11/D5E1A71CE178<15715669E1518A/A5CA8718/1 /AE15#AC9E1+1DB1D21A615##AE1C81516A75E15D8-8431 E1 A#5C1 8/1 CE1 #86ACA871 8/1 CA61 5D8-841 A71 CE1 5DCE/5C61A61E(595CE1/8D1>156E6B175E)1CE15D8-8461 8DDE6#87A751C81CE1/89D18D7ED61571C81CE1E7CDE31 831 46E948EB62F2D2526EF6E68AB2A686461F22A68646 E49E947689E462A646$1

FE1 CEDE1 51 8A/A5CA871 8/1 /AE1 5#AC9E1 +1DB1 D21 571 5669E1 CA61 8A/A5CA871 A61 87E1 871 CE1 5D8-841 85CE1A71CE1E7CDE18/1CE1/D5E31E1E#E7E7)18/1CE1 5DCE/5C61,AC1CE1/D5E11#86ACA871A71CE1781A61A96CD5CE1 /8D1/A(E1#86ACA876B175E)1CE1/AD6CB1CE18CB1CE1$CB1CE1&8CB1 571CE156C1;CE1&$C<31

1

LE71 A76#ECA751 CE1 79EDA51 (59E61 DE#8DCE1 A71 5-E61&18B1AC1571-E178CAE1C5C61

•1 51 CE1 876AEDE1 ,5CED5D4A751 6E75DA861 ;51 5D41 5#AC9E6B1 51 79-ED6K#86ACA8761 8/1 ,5CED5D4E1 5D8-8461 571 511 /D5E61 #86ACA8761 A71 CE1 78<1

DE69CE1A71CD576#5DE7C15DCE/5C6B1DE55DE661CE1C)#E18/1 :95AC)1ECDA1

•1 CE1 #AE1 A//EDE7E1-56E1 E569DE61 68,E1 CE6E(E61 8DE1 A6DAA75CA(E1 C571 CE1 8DDE5CA871-56E1 E569DE61 ;,A1 ,EDE1 :9ACE1 A7(5DA57C<1 CA61 A61 51 876E:9E7E1 8/1 CE1 /5C1 C5C1 CE1 8CA871 (EC8D1 8A/A5CA8761 E51 C81 651 571 6#DE51 EDD8D61A71CE1E8E1(AE81

•1 561 E#ECEB1 CE1 86C1 6E76ACA(E1 :95AC)1 ECDA1 A61 CE1 "9J61 561 CE1 5DCE/5C61 A71 CE1 1 8CA871(EC8D1 ,5CED5D4A751 5DE1 A79E1 -)1 CE1 8CA871 87CE7C1 5CED5CA87B1 CE)1 5DE1 8DE1 A4E)1 C81 -E1 6#8CCE1 89C1 -)1 E569DE61 A79A751 CE#8D51 /ACEDA751 C571 -)1 M6C5CAN1 E569DE6311 1 2 191(1.(!()%&1"211(1($)1 1 61515E7ED518796A871871CE179EDA51(59E61#DE6E7CE1 A71CE1#DE(A89616ECA87B1AC1571-E165A1C5C1E51571E(ED)1 CAE1,5CED5D4A751A61#866A-E6151CE18-ECA(E1E569DE61 5(E1(59E618DDE6#87A751C81CD576#5DE7)31

71 CE1 6E:9EB1 CE1 5E7ED5AC)1 8/1 CE6E1 DE69C61 ,A1 -E1 A7(E6CA55CE1 ,AC1 DE6#EC1 C81 CE1 8#DE66A871 D5CE1 571 C81 CE1 (AE81 87CE7CB1B831A5631D1$31 C95)B1 CE1 81 5-8(E1 #DE6E7CE1E#EDAE7C61,A1-E1DE69E1871A//EDE7C1(AE81 6E:9E7E61 ;2!4!1 51A//EDE7C1 8#DE66A871D5CE1 8D1 51 A//EDE7C1 (A695187CE7C<1571CE1DE5CA(E1(5DA5CA8761;E78CE1-)1 ε <1 ,AC1 DE6#EC1 C81 CE1 DE/EDE7E1 (59E61 #DE6E7CE1 A71 5-E61&181,A1-E18#9CE158DA751C8611

948494AB4 4F

948494AB4 %& %&

%& ₋ =

ε B1

,EDE1%&_948494AB41 DE#DE6E7C61 CE1 (59E1 /8D1 57)1 8/1 CE1 A7(E6CA55CE1 :95AC)1 ECDA61 DE#8DCE1 A71 5-E61&181 ,AE1

4F

%& 1 6C5761 /8D1 CE1 8DDE6#87A751 (59E1 8#9CE1 871 CE17E,1(AE816E:9E7E31

&31 46E948EB62F2D25267414A74AB62646B194FF2A6 9E46'(2)F!6C*+1

E1 E#EDAE7C61 &181 5DE1 DE69E1 /8D1 CE1 65E1 (A6951 87CE7CB1 CA61 CAE1 8E1 5C1 A51 ;9_&=&'D8D2KF<1 571 8,1 :95ACAE61 ;9_D=E8D2KF<31 E1 8DDE6#87A751 ε 1 (5DA5CA8761 5DE1 A96CD5CE1 A71 A5631D1>31 38CE1 C5C1 561 CE1 DE5CA(E1 (5DA5CA8761 8/1 CE1 8DDE5CA871-56E1 E569DE61 571 8/1CE155E1AEAC)1,EDE1E51571E(ED)1CAE18,ED1C571 &OB1CE)1,EDE178C1A6#5)E1A71CE6E1/A59DE631

D31 46 E948EB6 2F2D2526 7414A74AB6 26 46 2FE56 BA4A6'(2)F!6,C+1

E1 E#EDAE7C61 &181 5DE1 DE#E5CE1 /8D1 CE1 DE6C1 8/1 81 (AE81 6E:9E7E61 A71 CE1 8D#9631 A5631E1$1 A96CD5CE1 CE1 ε 1 (5DA5CA87618/1CE1(A6951ECDA61,AC1CE1(A695187CE7C1/8D1 C,81 7E,1 (AE81 6E:9E7E61 ;E78CE1 -)1 (&1 571 (DB1 DE6#ECA(E)<B1 8E1 5C1 EA91 :95AC)1 ;>&D14-ACK6<31 4EDE1 555A7B1 CE1 8DDE5CA871-56E1 E569DE61 571 CE1 55E1 AEAC)1 ,EDE1 78C1 A96CD5CE1 561 CE)1 DE69CE1 A71 (59E61 8,ED1C571&O31

9)(1-316(210%%%)%&1112$!%"!1"211(1*"#%2%%"!1*+)%$#(141(1*"#%2%%"!1%1*#(1"!11(1*"%"!1 0("1"(+"!#%!.1"11(1(!)1*")"51%!11(11212*(1%!1"6 1 1 13456 789A6 BBC6 1D3E6 7FA6 6 7FA6 36 7FA6 46 6 33D6 7FA6 C6

7-81-91 EE3>D1 '3'&1 ?3'E1 $$$3$'1 $$$3$&1 '3$$1 FF3&?1 $$$3G$1 ?F3$81

7/81/91 E?3?F1 '3'D1 >3>'1 $$$3$G1 $$$3$G1 '3$$1 FF3&D1 $$$3GE1 8?3D&1

7:81:91 E&3GD1 '3'D1 F3?'1 $$$3G81 &'''3'E1 '3$$1 FF3&D1 $$$3G>1 8F3F?1

78191 E'3F&1 '3'?1 &&3$>1 $$$3G81 $$$3G$1 '3$$1 FF3&D1 $$$3G'1 >D3G>1

7;81;91 >$3GD1 '3'81 &E3F&1 $$$3G?1 $$$3F?1 '3$$1 FF3&D1 $$$3F?1 >D3'&1

1 9)(1/316(210%%%)%&1112$!%"!1"211(1!$*(1"21*"#%2%(#1*")"5141(1*"#%2%%"!1111(1 *+)%$#(17/81/91!#1%1*#(1"!11(1*"%"!10("11(11212*(1%!1"6 1 1 13456 789A6 BBC6 1D3E6 7FA6 6 7FA6 36 7FA6 46 6 33D6 7FA6 C6

-1)"51 E?3?F1 '3'D1 >3>'1 $$$3G$1 $$$3$G1 '3$$1 FF3&D1 $$$3GE1 8?3D&1

/1)"51 >83EG1 '38E1 &&'3>$1 $$$3D>1 $$$3EF1 '3$$1 FF3&>1 $$G3D81 G'3F&1

:1)"51 >?3$D1 '38F1 &&D3E81 $$$3&$1 $$$3>?1 '3$$1 FF3&'1 $$G3&G1 GD3F81

1

9)(1:316(210%%%)%&1112$!%"!1"211(1+"%%"!1"211(1*")"51%!11(12*(141(1*"#%2%%"!1111(1 *+)%$#(17/81/91!#1%1*#(1"!11(11212*(6 1 13456 789A6 BBC6 1D3E6 7FA6 6 7FA6 36 7FA6 46 6 33D6 7FA6 C6

$++()(21 >G3'G1 '3881 &&'3DF1 $$$3&$1 &'''3&'1 '3$$1 FF3'F1 $$G3D81 FF3'>1

""*)(21 E?3?F1 '3'D1 >3>'1 $$$3G$1 $$$3$G1 '3$$1 FF3&D1 $$$3GF1 8?3D&1

(!)1 E>3>'1 '3'D1 &&3>G1 $$$3G>1 $$$3$$1 '3$$1 FF3&D1 $$$3GE1 8>3E$1

$++(%.11 EF38'1 '3''>1 &3''1 $$$3$G1 &'''3''1 '3$$1 FF3&D1 $$$3$D1 ?E3'81

""*%.11 EG3GE1 '3''D1 '3D$1 $$$3$G1 &'''3''1 '3$$1 FF3&?1 $$$3$F1 ?>3&&1

1 9)(1316(210%%%)%&1112$!%"!1"211(1+"%%"!1"211(1112*(1%!11(1"141(1*"#%2%%"!1111(1 *+)%$#(17/81/91!#1%1*#(1"!11(1*"%"!10("1)"(#111(1(!(1"211(12*(6 1 1 13456 789A6 BBC6 1D3E6 7FA6 6 7FA6 36 7FA6 46 6 33D6 7FA6 C6

E%1 ED3EF1 '3'D1 >38&1 $$$3GG1 $$$3GG1 &3''1 FF3&?1 $$$3GG1 8&3?&1

11 E?3?F1 '3'D1 >3>'1 $$$3$G1 $$$3$G1 '3$$1 FF3&D1 $$$3GE1 8?3D&1

<11 E83G'1 '3'D1 E3'?1 $$$3F1 $$$3F$1 '3$$1 FF3&D1 $$$3GF1 ?G3>&1

-11 EF3D>1 '3'&1 D3>E1 &'''3'&1 &'''3'&1 '3$$1 FF3&D1 $$$3$&1 ?E3ED1

-<11 E$38?1 '3''&1 '38?1 &'''3'&1 &'''3'&1 '3$$1 FF3&?1 $$$3$E1 ?83$E1

1

E1(59E61DE#DE6E7CE1A71A5631D1$168,1C5C61 •1 CE15DCE/5C1CD576#5DE7)1,561E51571E(ED)1CAE1

(5A5CE1

•1 CE1(A6951:95AC)1ECDA615DE18DE16E76ACA(E1C81CE1 (A6951 87CE7C1 C571 C81 CE1 8#DE66A871 D5CE1 CA61 -E5(A89D1 ,891 6955E6C1 C5C1 CE1 #D5CA51 ,5CED5D4A751EC8615)1,8D41E:95)15881/8D1 57)1 8#DE66A871 D5CE1 -9C1 68E1 #5D5ECED61 ,891 -E1 DE:9ADE1 C81 -E1 6EC1 58DA751 C81 CE1 (A6951 87CE7C1C)#E1

•1 CE1#86ACA8718/1 CE1 8A/AE15D81-8461A7C81 571 A7A(A951 1 /D5E1 E51 C81 5DCE/5C61 8DE1 97#DEAC5-E1 C571 CE1 8A/A5CA871 8/1 CE1 5D41 5#AC9E15718D1CE1#86ACA8718/1CE11/D5E1A71CE1 781 /8D1 #D5CA51 ,5CED5D4A751 6EE6B1 CE6E1 DE69C61 #8A7C1 C81 CE1 /5C1 C5C1 CE11 /D5E1 #86ACA871 571CE15D415#AC9E1571-E1D578)16EECE1 ,AE1 68E1 DE6CDACA8761 5##)1 C81 CE1 #86ACA8761 8/1 CE1,5CED5D4E15D8-8461A7169E66A(E178631

23 1"!)$%"!1 1

A61#5#ED1#DE6E7C61515E7ED51 6C9)1;(595-E1/8D1 57)1 5ACA(E1,5CED5D4A751CE7A:9E<1E6C5-A6A751C5C1CE1 8CA871 (EC8D1 ,5CED5D4A751 A71 2!7181 9%1 A61 #866A-EB15C1E56C1/D81CE1CD576#5DE7)1#8A7C18/1(AE,31 E6E1 DE69C61 5DE1 8-C5A7E1 871 51 5D5E1 571 ECED85E7E8961 (AE81 8D#961 571 5DE1 (5A5CE1 /8D1 CDEE1 DE#DE6E7C5CA(E1 8#DE66A871 D5CE61 ;E84-ACK6B1 >&D4-ACK61571&'D84-ACK6<311

E1 E(595CA871 ,561 -56E1 871 7A7E1 A7CE76A(E)1 876AEDE1 8-ECA(E1 E569DE61 ;3 B1 "B1 2!B1 B1%JB1 %B13%%B1 2B1"9J<1 571 876AEDE1 /89D1 8A/A5CA8716CD5CE5AE631

E6E1DE69C61571-E1876AEDE156151/AD6C16CE#1C8,5D61 51 #D88/1 8/1 87E#C61 /8D1 8CA871 (EC8D1 -56E1 ,5CED5D4A7561 AC1 #D8(E1 C5C1 A71 E51 571 E(ED)1 A7(E6CA55CE1 56E1 CE1CD576#5DE7)1A6169##8DCE1-)1 51 CE1 876AEDE1 E569DE631 48,E(EDB1 CE1 DE69C1 #DE6E7CE1 A71 CA61 #5#ED1 6891 -E1 /88,E1 -)1 571 A7(E6CA55CA871871CE1D8-96C7E6631 1 2 234 5 534 6 634 7 734 8 9AB CDE 5 9AB CDE 6 FF DE5 FF DE6 9 ADE 5 9 ADE 6  DE5  DE6 D44 D88 D77 D66 D55 1 2 236 238 23 23 5 536 9AB CDE5 9AB CDE6 FF DE5 FF DE6 9 ADE 5 9 ADE 6  DE5  DE6 71 61 51 1 E%. 1/ 16(210%%%)%&10%%"!1112$!%"!1"211(1 *"#%2%%"!1*+)%$#(12"110%#("1(,$(!(1"*+((#1 1#%22((!1( 1 E%. 1: 16(210%%%)%&10%%"!1112$!%"!1"211(1 !$*(1"21*"#%2%(#1*")"512"110%#("1(,$(!(1 "*+((#11#%22((!1( 1 2 5 6 7 8 4  9AB CDE5 9AB CDE6 FF DE5 FF DE6 9 AD5 9 AD6  D5  D6  DE!"# $%%&EDE!"# &'E(  D&) $%%&ED&) 1 2 234 5 534 6 634 7 9AB CDE5 9AB CDE6 FF DE5 FF DE6 9 ADE 5 9 ADE 6  DE5  DE6 5* 58 * 8 5 1 E%. 1 1(210%%%)%&10%%"!1112$!%"!1"211(1 +"%%"!1"211(1*")"51%!11(12*(12"110%#("1 (,$(!(1"*+((#11#%22((!1( 1 E%. 1; 16(210%%%)%&10%%"!1112$!%"!1"211(1 +"%%"!1"211(112*(1%!11(1"12"110%#("1(,$(!(1 "*+((#11#%22((!1( 1 1

2 234 5 534 6 634 7 9AB CD+ 5 9AB CD+ 6 FF D+ 5 FF D+ 6 9 AD+ 5 9 AD+ 6  D+5  D+6 D44 D88 D77 D66 D55 1 2 234 5 534 6 634 7 734 9AB CD+ 5 9AB CD+ 6 FF D+5 FF D+6 9 AD +5 9 AD +6  D+5  D+6 71 61 51 1 E%. 1= 16(210%%%)%&10%%"!1112$!%"!1"211(1 *"#%2%%"!1*+)%$#(12"1#%22((!10%$)1"!(! 1 E%. 1> 16(210%%%)%&10%%"!1112$!%"!1"211(1 !$*(1"21*"#%2%(#1*")"512"1#%22((!10%$)1 "!(! 1 1 2 5 6 7 8 4  , 9AB CD+ 5 9AB CD+ 6 FF D+5 FF D+6 9 AD+ 5 9 AD+ 6  D+5  D+6  DE!"# $%%&EDE!"# &'E(  D&) $%%&ED&) 1 2 234 5 534 6 634 7 734 9AB CD+ 5 9AB CD+ 6 FF D+5 FF D+6 9 AD+ 5 9 AD+ 6  D+5  D+6 5* 58 * 8 5 1 E%. 1? 1(210%%%)%&10%%"!1112$!%"!1"211(1 +"%%"!1"211(1*")"51%!11(12*(12"1#%22((!1 0%$)1"!(! 1 E%. 1< 16(210%%%)%&10%%"!1112$!%"!1"211(1 +"%%"!1"211(112*(1%!11(1"12"1#%22((!10%"$)1 "!(! 1 1 1 65!"@)(#.*(!1 1

A61 6C9)1 ,561 69##8DCE1 -)1 CE1 2!"!9P1 #D8EC1;-E9.E)4646/D9255E)461965E6088F2A6 46 54F6 /BEA)4F6 %271F6 46 272F6 31)E52F1F6 46 41B92F1F<1 5D57CE1 -)1 CE1 DE71 35CA8751 E6E5D1 5E7)1;3 <31

1

(2((!(1

@&A1 31 %8B1 231 2AEDB1 Q31 F88B1 02)2E56 5E49E92A)B15EA1DE66B1D''?31

@DA1 231 D78B1 231 94EDB1 31 L8C96E7B1 4BA2.4F6EA7621152BE2AF68602)2E565E49E92A)6 EA766A4A694B2AB1DCE14896EB1D''?31

@?A1 31 "5(8A7EB1 31 5CE9B1 EE)46 746 7B4AF6 E722F45F6A192.4FB1P5(8A6AEDB1D''831

@8A1 DE71 35CA8751 D8EC1 2!"!9PB1 CC#6KK,,,3EAE(5638D5K1

@>A1C1 1F3E'&11

@EA1BK!%1&88$E1&'1;D''><1

@FA1 31 LAE557B1 73Q31 9A(57B1 731 F87CE555DB1 31 P9CD5B1 MB(ED(AE,1 8/1 CE1 43DE8K9%1 9AE81 %8A751 C575DNB1 !!!1 D57631 871 %AD9AC61 571 )6CE61 /8D1 9AE81E7885)B1&?;F<B1>E'1>FEB1D''?31

@GA1 Q31 R575B1 431 25ACDEB1 ML5CED5D4A751 A71 CE1 2!7&1D1 (AE81 6E:9E7E6NB1 E6E5D1 DE#8DC1 7831 D''&"''EB1!315DA6B1D''&31

@$A1 R31 L575B1 3%31 F8(A4B1 43 31 EA41 571 !331 A87EAB1 M55E1 :95AC)1 566E66E7C61 D81 EDD8D1 (A6A-AAC)1 C81 6CD9C9D51 6AA5DAC)NB1 !!!1 D5765CA8761 87155E1D8E66A75B1&?;8<B1E''1E&DB1D''831

@&'A1 31(A-56B1 55E1 J95AC)1 C5CA6CA61 571 EAD1 C6E1 A71 CE5575)6A61 571 %8#DE66A87B1 "1 CE6A6B1 F855=AA1C7A(ED6AC)B1D''&31

@&&A1 3F31 L5C687B1 Q31 49B1 Q331 278,57B1 M"A5AC51 9AE81 J95AC)1 2ECDA1 F56E1 871 49571 9A6A87NB1 Q89D7518/1!ECD87A155A75B1&';&<B1D'1D$B1D''&31 @&DA131"9C5B12312ACDE5B131DCE9B1231FE5B1ME1 2!7181 9%1 85A71 ,5CED5D4A751 CD576#5DE7)N1 D831!1E$GDB1#31E$GD'B1D''G31

1 1