• Aucun résultat trouvé

Une approche pour des capteurs d'alarmes intelligents dans les réseaux

N/A
N/A
Info
Télécharger
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "Une approche pour des capteurs d'alarmes intelligents dans les réseaux"

Copied!
20
0
0

Chargement.... (Voir le texte intégral maintenant)

Texte intégral

(1)Une approche pour des capteurs d’alarmes intelligents dans les réseaux Renée Boubour, Claude Jard. To cite this version: Renée Boubour, Claude Jard. Une approche pour des capteurs d’alarmes intelligents dans les réseaux. [Rapport de recherche] RR-2982, INRIA. 1996. �inria-00073716�. HAL Id: inria-00073716 https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00073716 Submitted on 24 May 2006. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés..

(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Une approche pour des capteurs d’alarmes intelligents dans les r´eseaux Ren´ee Boubour et Claude Jard. N ˚ 2982 Septembre 1996 ` THEME 1. ISSN 0249-6399. apport de recherche.

(3)

(4)  

(5) 

(6)      !" #$%&'(!)!"%"*+'  +,!"(- /(. +0 12436275 298+:<;=:>;? 27@ ABDCE; FG2/HICE?JF KLIN"M ON+PQS ^_ `WR a N"N"T [ U NW^ VJVbXZOY c>N"V[(U \4U][ N)M ON"U R(VbcZc `d_ [eZN _ N"f L N _ f L NhgijlkdmljQSn4N)cZ[]N"O o _ NPpklklqrQsPWqtc>VbulN"U vxw w _ ` _ ` ` g‚DŽ `` y{XZoZz)UU |N _c} ‹l_]Vb`y[]c † ~(`` Ug€` N)gZVb[UgZ‚UXEV‚ƒgZ‹N„N/N T fW_ VJVb†’‘<cEe fWc VJN_][ ` †eEf` NL gN9‚ e>V g Vbud`gZN"XZUU]‹l‚ƒ[ N(N)† ‚Œe‚ƒg/Nl` ‰O“eEXEN"Vb[]U†ƒ†ƒ‚ƒgZ‡ˆ†ŒVbUNVJXZeEg4[]N"N"[+UUteZU e>\4N"VJU U]gZ[ `N)MUOXZ‚ƒ[]N"N"†ƒU ‚ƒU U_ N"N"N"TT U]c>[NpV VJOx_ XZ[]N"Y†ƒT UW[ LZ”4eZ`• NeZ` [ZN)XZN)UT U‚WN)TeXZf N"[T ‹d†ŒO ‚ƒN"†ƒU‚ O` ` cZgZXZcUgZN"†ƒTg fWU` VJ[–c[ Vb† ` OX gŠ_ — ‰ O c>VbN"gZg4gZ[N"‚ƒUN"U N"[(_ N"TVJU]‚NWV Vb_ XZOY N)UWeZ”dN • ^ ` N"XE[ U_ †ŠN"N"Y4[c ‚ƒ` N"U U ` gE`d_U(e g _ `N"U([ _ c>NV e_ N)[ T †ŒO“N)‚ŒV U_ cf L ` NX _ N"[N"Y4ec NT _‘>†ƒgEO†ŒU N U _ ` ‚ƒgZN"U(UXZfWVJg XEO U–VJ` ‚ƒ†ƒe [ZN"N)M T ‚ƒUN(N"eZY4N†ŒU c[–Vb_ g7` c>[ N"VbU(u7N)VJg7[ † [ ` _ gN eZN)U(c>VbgZgZN"UN"[eZN"UVJ‚V _ ON"Up” ˜š_™<› zœžbŸ y _ w ~ _ N"T U]NpVJXZY ^ eZN_ [ZN"T ‚pN"T f ` OOXEgZ†ƒfWVJ[ † ` gŠ‰"udN"U][ † ` geEN"U‡DVJXZ[ N"UW‰df `l_ _ N"T ‚Vb[]† ` g eŠŽ VJ‚V _ ON"Up‰ `d_ e _ N"U c>V [ †ŒN)‚ŒUp‰ N"T U]NWVbXZY eZN N"[ †ˆ”. °<±²®³©´µ´"¶ ·W´¸I± ¹ º»±D¹ ¼l½ ¶ˆ±I¹ ¾J¿(À©Á"¿J²®¶ ± º¾J±ÂJ³®´"ºJ½ ±ŠÃ± ¹ ·ˆ±]¹ ½]Á)Ä(Å"°<ƊÇ<ÃÈ. ¡ƒ¢£¥¤D¦Œ§©¨"ªD¦ƒ«4¬J¦®­©¯. Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rennes IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex (France) T´el´ephone : (33) 99 84 71 00 – T´el´ecopie : (33) 99 84 71 71.

(7) 

(8)   “h%p(!"!"%)*„r

(9)   %& 

(10)    z ›

(11) ž › ~ KL †ƒUc>Vbc>N _ c _ N"U N"g4[]UVgZN VJcZc _]` Vbf L [ ` ‡ˆVbXZ‚ƒ[O“Vbg>VJudN"ON"g4[G†Œg []N"‚ƒN"f ` OOXEgZ†ƒfWVJ[ † ` g gZVb‚ N)V [_ O `d_U c UW_]”` c>D[VJu4†ƒUVJ[ o<† ` VJgŠU]N)‰4e XZU ` †ŒgEgu„eEc>†ŒUV [ _ _ [ †Œ† oEVbXZ‚ []`lN"_ eeZN U _ \4UU][]VJN)gZOe ^ N"Y4N"c>[ _ N †Š_ †ƒgEN"N"gZ[]f"UpNd” ”NeZN‘<gZN“V O ` eZN"‚ ` ‡‡ˆVbXZ‚ƒ[]UVJgEe `d _ yeZ<N _ œ UW ‰ ™ ^ N" [ _ zJ†Š~gZN)[][]N"U ‚ƒN"f ` OOXEgZ†ƒfWVJ[ † ` ggZN"[ `l_  ‰ ‡ˆVJXZ‚ƒ[ O“VJg<VJulN)ON"g4[W‰Vb‚V _ Of `d_]_ N)‚ Vb[]† ` gG‰c>V _ []†VJ‚.

(12)  

(13) 

(14)     "! $#% '&('*)+'#+#,).- /0 #% '1 '$2. 3. Š 

(15)  '%"

(16)  6 V f _ ` †ƒU]UVJgZf)NVJf"[ XZN"‚ƒ‚ƒNl‰IN"g[–Vb†Œ‚ƒ‚ƒNN"[tN"gf ` O cZ‚ƒN"Y4†ƒ[ZNlT ‰EeZN"U _ N"T U]NWVbXZYeZN[ZN"T ‚pN"T f ` OOXEgZ†ƒfWVJ[ † ` gN"Yd— cZeŠ‚ƒŽ †,XZ74gXZN U \4‚DU]Ž [†ƒg4N)M O[ZN T _NN"8 [eENu _ ulVJN"gEU eZ[]† †ƒ` U]gŠU–Vb‰Gg4g [` XZc U` X c _ `l_‚ƒN"[ `U9gZ77U+XEXZN"U]gZ[ N† ` VbgZ[]U[ N"eEg4N9[]† ` ulgN"U []c>† V ` _ gG[ ”†Œf)^ XZ‚ƒV † _NM O_ N †VM ‚ŒN)U‚ V9eZ74†;:XZN"N T U_ []N"†g4` [ gN"U eE‡N` gZulf)N)[]U]†[]` † ` gZg U eZfWVbN)XZU(U–VJVb‚‚ƒV †Œ[Z_ N„OT N)N"[UN)eE[(N„VJf X`d_]eE_ † N"T Vb‚VJul[]g † `` U]g/[ †ŒeŠfŽ eEVbN"‚ V U_ c>O VJN"gEUWgZ‰4N"e>UWVb<‰ gZ74UXZXZ†»gZVbcZNc>VJV f"_ f)V N"8= cZ[[]XZ† ` gZg/N‚eZV N"_ UulNlcZ‰<‚ƒXZ\ Uae` N"XZT ‚ƒN"†ƒfWg4VJ[[ N"XZUWg ” 6_$` 8N"‚ƒUNg f"` N)[]g7† [` _ gZVbU‚eZN"N[ UeZ` X g4[fWV Vb_ f"VJ[]f"XE[ N"NM ‚ƒ_ ‚ŒN N)O_ N"T N"c>g4V [_ []Vb†Io eZ`dN)_ UeN"cT N)L UN"T U g ` ` XZO UN"M eZgZ†ƒ‹lN"UpN ‰l_ U g `VbXZgZUul‚ƒc N"_]Up` $” c >(` X U ` ‹4gZXUeZ†ƒf"N(†<‚DXZŽ †ƒg ON"Tc f"`l‚VJ_ [† _ VJVJgZulf)NNg eŠ` Ž XZXZgZ‹dNNWVJc XŠ_ ‰ †ƒU]VM N[ N"_ gVp‹lf N ` _ OUeZcZN"[ NU ` M XZ[]†ƒ‚ƒUN"_ [Ox_ N)T [ LZ` eZ6 N"`Uea N"T ‹lN"‚ ` cZcN"T Uc ` X _ ‚DŽ ` oE_ U]N _ ‹lVJ[]` † ` gN"[‚Vt` ‹N T _ † ‘>` fWVb[]† ` g e>VbgZU` ‚ƒNe ` O“_ Vb†ƒgZNeZN"UU \7_U¥— [eŠN"Ž OVb‚ VN"U_ O N"TN"c>UWV ” [ †ŒUp” Ž o N"f)[]† ‡»‹4†ƒUZNT N)U][‚ VeZ†ƒU [ †ƒoZXE[]† g+eZN‚V ‡ gZf)[]† g+eZNeZ†VJudg U []†ƒfU]X ‚ƒN"U fWVJcZ[ N"X U D‚JUpŽ VJul†ƒ[IN"U U]N"g4[ †ŒN)‚Œ‚ƒN"O N"g4[Ie>VJgEUŠf"N"[V _ []†ƒf"‚ƒNeŠŽ N"Y4c ` U]N _ XZgZN e N"T O“V _ f L Nl‰ `d_ †ƒul†ƒg>Vb‚ƒN VM g ` [ _ N f ` gZg<VJ†ƒUD— UUVJVJgZgZf"UNdVp‰J‹ c>` V † _ _ ‚ƒNV M [ O“_ VJVb†ƒ[]gZN"†ƒO cZXZN"‚ƒg4N [Š_ eZN)N)Y7U cEVb‚Œ†ƒU]f"c<†ƒ[ N"N"f"O[ UN"eZg4\4[g>XEVJg O []†,77N)OXEN"cZU>U‚ƒ†pN"udT U ‚ ` VM o>‚DVbŽ `‚'f)c f"L X \4_]U_ %†N"74gZXZf"NdN” eE6 N"N"UUc>VJVJgZ‚ƒu gE`dN"_ U†ƒ[ N"L [OeZN"N"UUVJN"[„‚V _N)OY7cN"NUpT — ‰ _ †Œ` N)gZf"N"U eŠŽ XZ[ †Œ‚ƒ†ƒU–Vb[]† `` g U ` g7[_ N)gxf ` X _ U eŠŽ]N"T []XEeZN9N"[ gZN9_ U ` g4[c>VJU e N"T f _ †Œ[ U †Œf)†ˆ”• ` XZ_ U c _ N)T U]`dN"_]g4_ [ ` gZU ` ‚ƒN feŠŽ Vbg4‚ []V N"_ Y4O []NN"UWeZ” N9?N)ud‚ N"VtU][ c<† N _gxO eZN"N[W‰de>N"T VJU gENWVJUXZ‚ƒN(Yc<N"V [ _ VbXZu g,_ VJN"Tc [L VJN[ U]eZXZN9†ƒ‹l‚DVbŽ g7V [p[‰leEN)N(U]U]U]N)†ƒg7[ XZ[ †ƒN N"_ ‚ƒ‚Œ‚ƒN)N(O[ N"_ g4Vp[‹lVJVJ†ƒ‚ZYN)N9T [U eZX N(c ‚_VN"T U]f N)g7[ N N"T _ ‚VJ‚D[]Ž VJ† c{g — c _ ` f L Nf LZ` †ƒU]†ƒNl” @g4‘<gŠ‰4g ` XEUN"Y4c ` U ` gEU‚ŒN)UO ` eN"T ‚ƒ†ŒUVJ[ † ` gZUc _ ` c ` UZN"T N"UN"[‚ƒN"UU ` ‚ƒXZ[]† ` gZUN"g4‹4†ƒU–VJuN"T N"Up” A B

(17) ' 0' . 'r  !d]  4. 5. CEDGF 6. HJI"K LM NPORQSI"KUTWVOSOWI"KXIYLZV[ V\]^I"K. ` g/eEN _ N"T U]NWVbXZYN"_U][„Vbf"[]XEN"‚ƒ‚ŒN)_ON"g4[VJeZO ` †ƒU]Nf ` O` O N9N"T [VJg4[_]` ‡ ` gZ_ f"[]† ` gZgZN"‚ƒ‚ƒN"ON)g7[8 †ƒgZeN"T c>N)g4— V. d u " N ] U [ † ` e>c<VbN"XZg4[+[]NXZN"[][†ƒ‚ƒ†ƒ‚ U]N ul_ †,74‚ƒXZN"UN"OO N)N"8 g7O[ N)UZUN"T c>_ V N"U N"U T `N+X eZ_ Nf"N"‚U Vtc [ L VJ\4gZU]U†,74OXZ†ƒN"U]UWU ”_† ?g†Œg<eZ7/N)U(VJe † _ N)gZUg‡ N"T` N"gEUf"c []† ` gEc gZN)N"O‚ƒ‚ƒN"N"Ug4eZ[NeZ†ƒul[]N"NdU ‰Z[]O† ` N)gOU N` g4U][†GN"e‚ƒN‚ƒT N— ‘>c<gEN _ †Œ‡N)`laU _ ` O VM VJgZU–Vpf)N"‹ UW` ‰E† _ N"[‚ VeZNudN"‚VtU][ f† `` gxO cZeZ[–N)VbUoZ‡ˆ†ƒVb‚Œ†ƒXZ[ZNl[]T N"”JUc• ` b ` XZXxUg c>` VJXZgEU(gZN"†ƒg4Ued)[ZN‰T _ eZN"U]N9U ` ‚gZVUUZ†ƒN"T f"f)† X V+M_ †ƒ[Z‚VNdT ‰udeEN"U]N"[ U † ` f g ` g4eZ‘<N"ulU(X c<_ VJVJgZ[]†gZ` N)gZUWUW” ‰ eZN"U ?Ž N"U [„XEgZf N 74XZN"U []† ` gf ` OcE‚ŒN)Y7Nd” 6 Ž VbU]c<N"f"[+†ƒg7[ _ †ƒgZU N'M 74XZN"ON)g7[ _ N"T c>V _ [ †ˆ‰ V M ‚ V“‡ ` †ƒUe>VbgZU‚DŽ N"U]c<VJf"N N"eZ[N)U(e>cVJgE_ ` UoZ‚Œ‚NN"M O [ N"N"OUW”cZ^Up‰4V eZ_ N"VbU†ƒ‚ŒO“‚ƒN"VJX gE_ UW†’‡©‰dN"†ƒU]‚<[‡ˆVJVJ[]XE† ` [gZc U_ eEN"gZNe c<_ VJN„gZN)gZg“N)U(f ` e>OVbgZcEU[]N(‚ƒN"eEU N"_ U(N"T U]c NWL VbN"TXZg YI` ‰>O VbN"MXZgZulN"O UN"eEg4N[]N(eN‚T V+‡ `lf_ `O“OVboZ[]† †ƒ` g>gZVJU [ ` eZ† N"_ UN c>VbgZ6 gZN"N"UU[‚ `l_ Vp_ U‹lVJeEXZN"YUVbU]†ƒf"ul[]g<XEVJN"‚ƒ‚ƒ†ƒU(U–VJU][X † _ ` gZ‚ƒN(Up” U X a N"[ ‡ ` g4[VJcZc>V _ V 8= [ _ NcZ‚ƒXZU †ŒN)X _ Uc _ N T ` f"f)XZc>VJ[ † ` gZUp”>€+Ž VJo `l_ eG‰4‚ˆŽ †ƒO— c‚ƒN"`lO _ [–N"VJg4gE[f"†ŒNgEeeZN"N+T c<[]N"N"gZgZe>† _Vbg7f [ ` N"OUcZN"g4[ N„[ _ eZN„N)N"U‚ƒ‚ƒfpN"VJUpUg” @eZgZNU c>XZVb†ƒ[]gZNlgZ‰<N"‚ƒUNuo<N)N"T g U `N T _†ƒg9Vbg4eZ[NeZO N"U VJgZ` f"†ƒcZf"XZX ‚_ Vb_ N"[]†gE` f"gN"UeZX eŠŽ [VJN"‚OV _ cZOUpN)‰ZUU ` c XZ` U []N"‡ g4`l[]_ †ƒON"‚ N— eZeZNt†ƒU [ e>_ VJ†ƒoZ[ N"XEU(N _ eŠ‚Ž `Vf"udf"N"X U]_][ _ † N)` gZg f"N"_ UpN"‹4‰Š†ŒeŠN)Žg7†ƒg4[([]VbN XZ_ ‹lU]UVJ†I‚ƒ‚ƒU N"` U XZ` ‹lX N"g4eZ[pN‰4e c X _8 N"T VtfIM N"T ‚eEVN"gZ[–Vbf"†ŒN‚ƒ‚ƒNe>VbeZgZNU(cZXE‚ƒXZg“U[ N"N"g OcZcE‚ƒUXZ‚U` uul_,† 74VbXZgZNleZ”N6 eZNN"U o>_N)N)U T U]` NW†ƒg VbXZeZYIN ‰ Vb†ŒgEU]Y† 74XŠŽ V+M ‚V‹lV _ †WN"T [ZNT u _ VJgEeZ†ƒU]U–Vbg4[]NeZN"U ‡ ` gZf)[]† ` gZUp”. ,º. h_h jiWkl'mk.

(18) W

(19) e

(20)    

(21)   CED C. NP\\ I" [GV_LMGNjO Q V[GVa\<] I"K.  L_ _  ` 4XZXZgEN"NO gEu NN"_ Vbg4c>gZ[WVJ‰peZgZcZNWgE‚ƒXZ74NUX>†ŒN"VbN)U]g4X [[]_ †ƒUU [ZXZNc T U]_ eŠf)` N"Ž oZVJcZ‚‚[]N"MV †ƒO _oZO‚ƒN"N UŠN"UpeZc<” NN"6 XZeN‹dN"TN"u f"g4_‚ƒN"[ VbgEgZVbf ecZc>N‹ V ` _ ‚ƒVXZXZ8= gZO [ N_ NNfWeZU]Vb†ƒNU]OfWe VbXZ` eZ‚ƒgE[–NVbg g eGN"T N"N"T Ž OVbUp‚‰ZVN)‚ƒg7N"O X[<_e>N"VbUW‡ _ ”gZNT UŠƒ77P XZXEg N"gZU_ f"N)T NU]XZNW‚ƒeEVb†ƒulN(XŠgZ‰Jf (N `N"gZgZ74udU]XZXZN"NlgZ‚ƒ‰G[e VJ[D_ []\4VJ† cZ` g4†g [ — N"Vb[‚ V ‚_ VO f N"` UWO” cZ‚ƒN"Y4†ƒ[ZNT eZN"U _ N"T U]NWVbXZY O ` eZN _ gZN"U _ N"gZe9eZ†f"†ƒ‚ƒN(‚ƒN[ _ VJ†ƒ[]N)ON"g4[NfWVJf)NN"[(VJeN'T 74X>VJ[eZNtf"N"U ` _ _ _ _ _ _ ` _ _  ` e‚ ` NM fW_ VJfN >‚ƒ†ƒ74†ƒU–gZVbXZU][]N†D† ‰d` ‚DcgŽ N"gZN"X U[N"OeZ‚ƒN"N oZX ‚ƒ‚ƒNN"[X eZ_+VJN)†ƒU„` []f)N)VJf"O‚X V N"_]_ g4_ON"[WgZN"‰dUf"†ƒ‚INuN"N"Te>U]g[VbN T gZ†ƒ_ g4U„N"T [ZN)N ‚ƒTUNN"N"U[ U]U–N"[VJOg4‡ cZ` [gZUpeZ‰'f"N [ Vb† †ƒ` gZN"gT U]eZ† XEeZ74†NXZN‚NV‚ƒN(eZg<N g VJ[]‚XOV _ oNf ` eZNg4N"‘>eŠUtudŽ VJcX ‚_]_ V `VboZ[]O† ‚ ` N"MN"gOUp”eZN"ƒUpPX ‰IeZ_ N"fNT U NW‚ƒgZN"VJU]XXG† _— ” `6 oZVU]Nf _`d‹_]N"_ T N)N"T ‚ UW_ Vb‰G[]N"† `U [„gVJeŠ‚ `lŽ VJ_ ‚U(V _ f O` gZN)U]UW†ƒ‰e74N T XZ_ N"†T Nc>fN ` _ OON)O [(NeZXEN+gZU]N [ _ ` XZcf"N[ T X_ VJ_ []N † _ ` g9e>Vbc gZ_ UN)T ‚Œ‚ƒ†ƒNO []†ŒN"g<O VJ† cZ_ NU(‚VM V ‚Vf ` e ‚ƒ‚ƒN"N"T []f"N)[ f"† `[]† g9` geZN"eZUN+Vbc>‚ V VJ_ gEO gZN"N"UU e>VbgZ€UN"‚ƒN"UtU []N"N"fT U]L NpgZVJ†,XZ74YIXZ” N"U+eZ†ƒ‹lN _ U]N)U„U ` g4[VJ‚ `l_ UN"g4‹4†ŒUVJuN"T N"UU X _ ‚ƒN+[ LIN)M ON+eZN‚V f `l_ _ N"T ‚Vb[]† ` geŠŽ VJ‚V _ ON"Up‰ †ƒbU] Uk XZ d"N"‰4UpeZ‰ZNN"g4O“[ _ VbNgZVJ†ƒcZXZXZ[ _ ‚N"VJUp[ ‰Z† ` eZgZNUO“eZNVJgEu †Œ_ cEVbXZc ‚L VJN"[](U † ` bgZƒUŠPWj eZ Nd)‰4o>eZVJNU N"fWUVJ‚ƒeZf"NXZ‚ƒe U` eZgZNgN"c T N"_ U ` o>bƒVbP oZ †ƒ ‚ƒd"†Œ[Z‰dN"eZT *U Nb‚DƒŽPl†ƒg4P []d N)‚Œ` ‚ƒ†ƒXulN)eEgZNf"N‚DŽ XZV [_ †Œ[ ‚ƒ† †ƒ‘>U–Vbf"†ƒ[]N"† ‚ƒ` ‚ƒg N eZN _ N"T U NWVJXZY eZN ^ N"[ _ †EbZ‰Zm  d)” 7. . %p%"  !l  

(22) . ! DGF. "$#WT NL%'I"& KI"KcQWI L\V)(jVaMG[. ` ` ` _ L ` M _ _ `d_]_ ‚eZVJX [ • † `U]\4gXZU][UeGN"M gŽ OVb‚NVXE_ U'N)O g/U †ƒN"[]fWUWX Vb” U(6 gZNeZUN+cc _ O“†ƒ†ŒgZgEVbf"f"XZ†ƒ†ƒc>c>‹lNVJVJ†ƒ‚ƒuUN"O N"‡T g` N"NgZT g4_ f"[IVJ[ ‚Š†e>` eEVJgZgZNgZUN)eE‚O† VVbN"ulc g4g [W` Vb”U]U]D[ N‚†ŒfeZUpNŽVJVbe eul` †ƒN"T[cZ[ N"[ZeZNf"T N []N"† _ U N"[(gf eZ` eZgZNN"g>UO V c>8= ` Vb[ e_gZN+N"gZT ‚ƒN"†Œc>U U V N _V_ O‚Œ[ N)†IU Vp‚ƒ‹lN"` NU(oZUUUN†ƒ[]‚_ VX>‹lVbVbf [][]†† `` gZgZNT UU— ` ` oZU]N _ ‹N"T N"`UW‰Ef"_ N"‚ƒ‚ƒ_ N"U 77XE_ †>f `d_]_ N"` U]c ` gZeEN"g4[ VM _ eZN"UU]†ƒ[]X<_ VJ[]† ` gZU _ N)T c>N _ [ `d_ `d†WN"_ T N"Up” 6 Ž N"Y4c _ ` N"U]U † ` ge ` †ƒ[ N"8 [ _ N` VJU U]+N _ * U‹lVbXZ[]†cZ` ‚ƒgg Nd)c ” X c N)gZe NN"g f OcZ[ NeZ†ƒ‹lN U]N"U†ƒgZf)N [ †Œ[ XZeZN"U b []N"O c N"‚ƒ‚ƒN"Up‰4eZN(f gZg>Vb†ŒU U–VbgZf"Nl‰EeŠŽ oZU N — _ _ ` _ _ _ XZf"†pgENlT N ” €6_ N"VbNc gZ_c UŠN"T_ ‚ƒU]†ƒNN)gZg7oZf)[†ŒXZc<VJ[†eŠ` eZŽ gVJNtg>eZeZVbX †‚ƒVJ\7_ ulU N"TgN U]`NpVJU]‚ƒN"[ XU†ƒf/eEVJN)N‚T V[–[ZVJN"Og4T ‚p[N"TN"f UG` ` oZN"O[U]N OeZ_ N‹lXZVJeEgE[ † †Œ† fpVb` VJulgZ[]g gZ† ` N"U]g‚D[‰E%†VJg74†ƒ`XZgZXZNU †U 74‚ƒ‡ˆN"XZVJUN†ƒU c>`f"VbN"gZgZ‚ƒU‚ƒgZNXZN"eZUpg X‰JO †ƒ‚4_ N"N"†ŒT gEU]U]NW[†ŒOVbgXXEN"T f"eZO N"NU eŠU–ulVJN)Ž L † U]\4[]N(† c ` eZ` gN[ LIVJ‘>N"U]M Y4UU N`N"U— Uc X _ _N"T f"‚ƒ†ƒN"U]UN)U0VJU]74c<XZN"Nf"[ c U` ‡ U ` U]gZ†ƒoZf"‚ƒ[ N† ` eZgZN"gZUN)‚Œg U` eZ[]X† ` gZ_ N"UT U]NpeZVJNXŠc>”dVJ• gE` gZXZN"UU(g N)`[(XZVJU‚V VJ_ [ O[–VbN"f ULEN"` [gZUeZN"e<UVp‹l‚ƒ†ŒVJN)g4gZ[–UVbN"ulY4N †ƒU]V(M [–eEVbg4N"U[eN"g4NT ‘<[ _ gZNt†ƒ[]N"† `‚ƒ‚ŒgZN)UWU” VJXZU U]†  g _ N"T U]NpVJXN)U][f ` gZU]†ƒeN T _ N(T f ` OO NXZgN"gEU]N"OoZ‚ƒNeZNf ` Oc ` U–Vbg4[]UO“Vb[ZN T _ †ŒN)‚ŒUN"[ ‚ ` ul†ƒf"†ƒN"‚ƒU†ƒg7[ N _ f ` g4— gZe N)` f"g4[Z[N"T Up‚ŒN)‰ŠUVJgcE2c>N"XZ‚peZN"T UU(eZU ` Nrg4‡ˆ[V-f‚ƒ, N"` Ug f u` N"OT gcN T _ ` †,U–74VbXZg4N/[]U. +N"N"T[(‚pN"T‚ƒO N"U(N"V g4_ []f"UUeZ‚ŒNN)X _ _ N"T UU]Np†ƒg4VJXZ[]N Y1_ f 0 ©` ” gEDgZ‚ŠN"N)Y4U]†[ ` gZ_ N"Upc ” _ N"T U]N"g4[ZNT c>V _ XZg9u _ VJc L N ` XZU+` ‡DVJ†ƒU ` gZU„‚DŽ L \4` c ` [ LIN"M U _ N 77XGŽ N)Y7†ƒU []N XZgN"`gZU N"OoZ‚ƒN _ eZN O ` \lN)gZUW‰G_ e>VJgEU‚ŒN _ N"T U]NWVbXxeZ`lN _ ulN)_ U][]† ` g • eZc N)L UVJU][ZNN"T ‚peZN"T f†ƒU][ O_ †ƒoZOXXZN"T gEN †Œd"fp”dVJ• []† ` XEgZUUW‰pVJc<cZNc<N"O ‚ ` N"gE[]3U [VJ. Zg4fW[Vb‚cZV[]N)udXN"U]_ [ 0† 4XZggf"N"VJg4ud[N"g4VJ[‚ƒ†ƒeZUZXN)T N_ eEN)T U]N"NWU(VbVJX‚V eZNOudN"N"U U][ b©† Vp` ‹lg VJg4bf[4‡ eŠƒŽ P VJ od"‰ 74XZeZ† N _ N fXZ, ` gZ†ƒN[ Æ. 5 _h576.

(23)  

(24) 

(25)     "! $#% '&('*)+'#+#,).- /0 #% '1 '$2. S c4. . S : superviseur (central) c5. Réseau de gestion. ci : hiérarchie de capteurs c1. c3. c2. : remontée d’alarme(s) e2. Réseau à surveiller. e1. e3. e4. e5. ei : éléments de réseaux : sites. P ‚ƒeZN"NUudg N"` U][][ † † ‘>` fWgŠVb”p[]• † ` ` gZ[ UI_ NeGŽOxVb‚N"VT fW_ VbO gZN"†ƒU]UWO ‰f)N'NjeE74NXZ†4f `lc>_ N _ _ N"OT ‚VJN"[ [I† ` eEgNVU [ g>` Vbf [] X N __ N"eZ‚ƒ‚ŒN"N)UOVJN"‚Vg4_ [OU–VN"UIcZe<‚VJVJf)gZNUGe>‚ŒN)VbUŠgZo>UVb‚ƒN"U]N"UUeZeŠ†ƒU]Ž †ƒf g4_ ‡†ŒO `d_ †ƒO“g>VJVb[ []N"† `X gZ_ UU eZN"U N [_ XZN)[[]_†ƒ‚ƒVb†ƒgZUZN"U]T NO c †ƒU]` U]X † ` _ g‚VteŠŽ]‡ N"T` ‹gEN"T f"gZ[]N"† `O g N"g4eZ[]NUGU]eZ†ƒNudg>‚V VJ‚ƒ‡ †ƒ` U–gZVb[]f"†[ ` † `g geŠeZŽ VJN‚udV N"_ OU][ †N"` U*gbeZ j N) U d"”E_ VJ• cZ` c XE`lUr_ []VbUcZeŠc<Ž N"N"T ‚ ‹` N"gZT gZU N)O. ŠUN"XZg4c>[]U N _ b‹4 3 †ƒU] d)N"‰'X 74_ XZ0 † XZg ud6 N"N U][ _ † N"` T U]gZNWg>VbVbX † _ eZNN fWVJulc>N"UVb[]oZ† ‚ƒ` Ng eZN"NU][[ _ VJVJ‚†ƒ`d[]N _ _U+‚Œ‹7N)XUU †ƒ`lf"†_ []f†ƒN"` UOeZON"U(NteEXZ†Œg U f _N"†ƒgEO U]N"†Œg<OVJoZ[]N)‚ƒNX _ eZUN eZfWX VJcE_ N"[]T U N"NWX VJ_ X UeZeŠNŽ Vbul‚ V N"_U O []† ` N"gŠU(” N"[+eZN ffWLVbcZN"O []N)†ƒX gZ_ U„UeEc>NN)XZ_ ‹lN"N"O g4[` g4N)8 [Z[ N"_ T NN"UeEN"eEUN"U[]†ƒO VJ‚NV _ _ UpO‰"eZN"UtN"U N"fg4` [ O _ N cZf"[]N)N"UX _ fWUVbeŠcZŽ []` N"f"X f"_ X U_ _ N)N"[gZf)‹lN"N U _ U74XZXZ†4gc `U]XZU]†ƒc<[]N† ` _ ‹4gE†ƒgZU]N"N)g4X [_ eZf"N"N)Ug7VJ[ _[ Vb[ _ ‚ˆ†ƒ” oZ6 XEN"[]UU e>eZN)VbU(gZUO‚N)V U]U–o>VbVJulU N"NUeŠU]†ƒŽ ul†ƒg4g<‡ VJ`l‚_ VJO“g4[Vb[]‚Œ†N)` U(gZVJU‚VeZ_ NOudN"N"UpU]‰4[ †N"` g4gŠ[ _"” Nt?N"N"XZUtY fW`VJcZX [ V+N"M X XZ_ g U„c<U]XEN"c>XZN‹d_ N"‹4g4†Œ[„U N"VJX XZ_ U ”IU]•†N"` g4XZ‹ U` f \d` N gE_ U]U]†ƒec N `T _ g4` [–gZVbUg N"f T O` gZN)g4g7X [ XZN"U g[N)VbgZU]UU]`N"Of"†pNoET ‚ŒVtMN+XZeZgN+U fW†ŒVJ[ cEEN []`dN"XZX g _ U„U]†ƒN)[][N ‚ƒ_ N"N"X c _ _ N"cZT U ‚N"VJg4f"[–N)VJOg4[N"g4XZ[(gxU XN"T ‚W_ N"T O‚ƒN N"_g4N"T[U NWeZVJN X _ N"eZT U N„NWVJ[ X _ V&` ‘>X“fXEeZgNu e _ ` ` gZXZgc<N"TNN"UpeŠ” Ž]N" T ‚WN"gT OfpN)VJg7cZ[ [ UN"eZX N_ _ N"T U]NW6 VbXZY c _]` _ f L N"Uc ` L \4U],† 74XZN"O N"g4[W” `c6 †ƒg4[]V †ƒ‚ƒ‚W‘>N"T U(udX eN)N9T ‚Œ†ƒO P†Œe [ _N"gZg4[gZN ‚ƒNXZgZg†ƒ` ‹lN"NWY4VbN"X9O eZcZN+‚ƒN[ __ eZ`VJNgZU f O` g{†ƒU]‘>U ul† M `X g _ VJeZ[ †N„` ge ` eZgZNg` N)UT N"†ƒ[]UN"U+N"[N"f"[+N"` eZ‚ƒXZ_ N†fWeZVJ` N+cE[]‚VN"X ud_ N"UWU]” [ †6_ ` N"g98= U _ eZ_ N"X f)[–_ VJN"T gEU NWulVJ‚ƒXGN"U ” f ` N"gZU U]†ƒN)T e‚WN)NT T O_ N"T N"Upg4” []6 UN"eZUN fpVJcZN"T U][ NpN"VJX X _ UU U ` g4g4[[g4g4XZXZOxOxN TN T _ ` [Z[ZN"T N"TUUNleEP NV flP N  VtM N"f[t+‚ŒN"N)[(U ‚ƒN‹lU]VJXE‚ƒc>N"UN _ g ‹4†ŒU † N"UX _ ‡ N"g4U][[VJe cZN"T gc<`V [ZNV T c>[ V N+_ ‚ƒnIN"U” U †Œ[ N"U   2&g#%(

(26) 

(27) "-  G)+

(28)  (')+'* (  . ! DC. I" ] V\%SI. 6 ` _ LZ` _ ` ` be>V cZVbcZgZ‚ƒUŽ †ƒ†ƒfWef"VJN"N"T [N[(† ` eZV gZ_N[U o>†Œf)_ VbN"‚ŒT NdU]c<N‰V 77N"_ U][XE[†ƒNN"eŠUW‚ƒ‰dNŽ N"cZY4fWXZVJcZ†ƒU‚UeeZ†ƒ[]N)NT N []N‚ƒN"_ eZUON)N"UT †ƒ[]gZOxN"†ƒgEU]N"[eT [ Nl_ ”N?VpeZ‹lŽ N"N"N"UU]f[eeZN"g T [N)` NU[–VbOxO ON"†ƒT gZO[ LZ†ƒU]N)` []g7eZN)[GUN)e>U'eVJc N"T gE‹d_]U` N"o<‚ ‚ŒNVJcZoZfWc†ƒVJ‚ƒN)Te†ƒN"U]_U[]NN)e>UWeZVb”JNgZ• U‚D` Ž ‚ƒ` XZNoZUe U]gEN _NO“‹l[ VJVb_ [ Vb†ƒ†gZ†ƒ` [Ng` eZgEeZN"UWNU ‰ f` ` g7O[N"cT [Z`lNT _ []N"N"Y4O cZ‚ N"`lg4_ []N)T UN"UWN"”[@eZ‚ƒ‚ƒNN"U‚V` :‹N_ T _N)†g7‘>[fWeZVJ[N"† U` g9O `eZ\dNtN"cgZ_]UG` eZc N(_ †pO N"T [Z` N"T eU(N"TeŠ‚ƒ†ŒŽ UN"N Y_ N"T f)eZXZN"[]U† `f `gEOU _c N)T`lc>_ V []_N"[]O †ƒN"N"U*g474[]U XZ_NN)T c>f"N"V U_ [][ †ƒN"UWf ‰ L VM gZ‚D†,Ž 74VJXZ†ƒeZN"NU eŠeZN)Ž `dU _ e` oE_ N"U]U„N _ c<‹lVJV _[][† ` †ƒN"gZ‚ƒUUW‰I4N"[t‰ŠP eŠ Ž  N” :»N)f"[]XZN _ eZN"U[ _ VJ†ƒ[ N"ON"g4[ U„VJ‚ƒu `d_ †ƒ[ L O†,7lXZN)U(eZ†ƒU][ _ †ƒoZXN)T UN"[ V M ‚V ‹ ` ‚WN"T N„U X _. ,º. h_h jiWkl'mk.

(29) q. W

(30) e

(31)    

(32)  . `U g4[6 _ N"eZUNVJeZcZN"c XZ`lY M _ []`lU__ e N"_U N"c Up_N T ” _ N)KT U(` cXE`[` X eŠ_ `Ž Vb‚ƒoN(`deE_ † eŠVb‰4ulXZg `gEU]N[ †Œc f_ †ƒeEU]NNc<N"g VJgZf gZ` N)OUcZe>[ VbN(gZUeZ_ N‚ƒN"‚DU Ž VJ_ U]N"T c<U NWN"VJf"[XZY †ƒg4eZ[ _ N†ƒgZ[ZUN"T N'M‚pN"74T f _XZ` N)OOON"g4XE[ gZ_†ƒfWN"` T VJc>[ V M † _ ` [ g † eZVbXN)U ‚ƒ†ŒN)N"T XU]NWeZVbX XZY_ N"T VrU]XZ[ ‚ƒ[VpVJ‹d[N eŠUŽ XZ‚gVNg :IN"[ [† eZgNeZo N`d_fWeŠVb‰pXZe U–VbX 8 ‚Œ†ƒVM [ZNleZT ”N"?U N)_ ‚ŒN"‚ƒ‚NVJ—D[]f"† †<` ‹lgZVUŠ[‡ˆVbN"O† Nc N)`lY7_ N"cE‚ƒ‚Œ‚Œ†ƒN)f"UŠ†ƒ[ N"N"Y4Oc N"_ †Œg4Ox[N"c<T N"V UGe>[ †ƒVJNgZeZUGXXZgO [ N"e ON"‚ƒcZNlU ‰ cN"Y4L †ƒ\4U]U][ †,N74XZeZNN)Uud[]‚ `N"fo>L VJgE‚D‰E%† 74f XZ` N)O U„Oc<NN _ flO Ž N"N"U][][+[VJug4N)T [g N eZT _ NVb‚ƒeZN"O†ƒU][ N"_ g4†ƒoZ[XZ‚ƒNN„_ fp‚VJV+U‡ e>` VbgZgZf"U[ † `‚ƒN"gU„eZVJXcEc U]_]XZ` c<f NL _ N"‹7U†ƒU VJN"f"X [ _ XZN"U]‚ƒX ‚ƒN"_ UW‚ƒ”_N"@UgZfWU]VJXEcZ†Œ[ [ N"NlX ‰G_ †ŒU ‚ _ N"T c>V _ []†ƒ_ U `lf"N)_ XZYd—ˆf"†IU N(f _ `4`d_ e ` ` gZgZN"` g4[c ` X _ N"T O N"[][ _ N(XEgeZ†VJulg ` U][ †ƒ` fl” 6 Ž `†ƒg4[ZN T _N"8 [eZN‚V` eN"T f"N)g7[ _ Vb‚Œ†ƒUVJM []† ` g N"?U Ž[N"UeZ[(N f"*N N"gZ74e XZNNg ‚V` XZU]XZUc<N"N Y4c ‹4_ †ƒ†ŒU]O † `g„gZO Uc>†ƒV gZ_ U<‚Œe NN"T []c<N N"_ gZOe>'N Vbg7. G[ NfWVJeZcZN[ N"‚DŽ]X N"T _[–U(Vb[Š†ƒg4eZ[]N N"‚ƒ‡ ‚ƒ†ƒgZulN"f)g4[]† [] U gZ0 gE” N"ON"g4[Iud‚ o>VJ‚deZXU \7U [ N"O Nl” @g9cE‚ŒXEUeZN‚V+g ` [ † ` g eZNfWVbXZU–Vb‚ƒ†Œ[ZNlT ‰Zg ` XZUc _ N"g ` gZUN"Y4cZ‚ƒ†Œf)†Œ[ N"ON)g7[N)g9f ` O cZ[]N‚ƒN"U N"T ‹dN"g4[]X>Vb‚ƒ†Œ[ZN"T U eZN"g N f c>` VbO gZgZcZN"[]U+NeŠOŽ N"XZO‚ƒ[]†ƒoZcZ‚p‚ƒN"TN"NU ‚DVMŽ VbU][ c<_ VpN"‹lf"[N _ `lU_ e ‚ V _ Nf `c>gZV f)_ [X †Œ_]N)_ ‚ŠN"U]gZX f"_ Nl”‚ƒN"€U(NVJ‚OV _ N"8OON)NdUW‰I‰ 74†ƒ‚XZU† N"_ ON oZN"M ‚ƒ[NN„†ƒg7†ƒf"[Z†GN T _‚VN)U]gU–Vb` g4[]†[` g eZNeZNc _ c N"_ gZN"T e fI_NT N— eZ`d_N)e gZ_ f"N"NUe>c<VbV gZ_ [U†ƒN"XZ‚ƒg9U„N)[T []N",† O74XZcZN"U[ZN)‚T `UW”ul†,74gZXZNNl”Zc • _ ` ` o>XZVbUoZg†ƒ‚ƒ` †ŒUXEVJU[ † ‡ ` ` ggZeeZ`X+gEO U`c e` N"XM ‚ƒ_ Nf"c<N)N ‚ _ V OU]N"X [_ eGeZŽ N"V U _ gZN)T N U]_NWVb‚VXZY9O eZ` NeN"T^ ‚ƒ†ŒN"U[ VJ_ [ †† ` N"g[eZeZN"N"UU c L N"T •g ` ` O XZUtN"M gZU N"` UX LN"[VJ†ƒeZ[ `NgZc U+_ N"e gZN"T e ‹l_N)N„‚ ` N"cZg c<N f _ ` OXEgZcZN[ N(e‚ƒN)N"T []UN"f"VJ[ U]† c<` N"g f"[ V MUVb‚V ‚WNpT VJ‹ [` ` ‚WN"† T _NlN"‰GUpc>” V _ ‚V _ N"f ` gZg>VJ†ƒU U–VJgEf"N †ŒgEf _ N"T O N"g4— [eVJN)T ‚ƒ[]N„N"f"eE[ N„† ` Og ` U []X † _‡®U(‚ŒN)VbUcZc>fWVVJ_cE[][]N)N"g>X VJ_ g4U[ eZVM X XZ_ gEN)T NU]NW‡ˆVbVbX OeZ†ƒ‚ƒN‚ƒN(udeŠN"U]Ž `l[ †_ ` e g_ N)N"UU]e<[+VJN"gZgZUU XZ‚D†ƒŽ `[]N oZU N"N g4_ ‹l‹7Vb†ƒU[]VJ† `ugŠN)T Nl” a” 6 ?V N)eZU„†ƒU]fW[ Vb_ cZ†ƒoZ[]N)XZX []†_ ` U+g/U]N eZ_ N+` g4‚V[ VeZb†Œ†gEVbU]ul†g fW` VJU][]c<†ƒVJfoZeZ‚ƒN"NUpc>‰>VbN)gZg/gZf N"`4Up` ” c N T _ Vbg4[W‰IeZN _ NpT VJ‚ƒ†ƒU]N _ XZgZN+c>V _ []†ƒN+eZX9c _ ` f"N"U]U XZU+eŠŽ VJg>Vb‚Œ\4U NeŠŽ VJ‚V _ ON"UN"[eZN 6 N"U†ŒgEf"N _ [ †ƒ[]XZeZN)U‚ŒN)UcZ‚ƒXZU†ƒOc `l_ [–VJg4[ N"UW‰ Vt M ‚V ‡ ` †ƒ_UN"g [ N _ O ` NeZN‡ _ 'N T 74XZ` N"gZf)N` N"[eŠŽ †ŒO c>VJf)`l[W‰p_ U]X _ ‚ƒN"U ` _ c>N"g4Vb‹4gZ†ƒgZU–N"VbUuNTU ‚ƒNg4[eE‚ƒ† †WVbN)T ulN"g U` VbU]XZ[ †ŒYfd‰lO g VJ` U[–74VbX>OVbOulN"N)Ug7[N)[(Vp‹dc<N"N f[ ‚ˆN"Ž UXZ[ eŠ†ƒ‚ŒŽ †ƒVJU‚VJV []† O` g„N"UpeŠ”4Ž Vb• ‚Œu XE`l_U†Œ[ †ŒgEL eZO,† 77N)UX c gZ_]`Uo>U VJoEXZ†ŒSU ‚ƒ†ƒ77U][ XEN"N"U‚ƒ‚Œo>NrVJ‡ UZN"T U(OU XN(_ N)U]‚ƒN[ O ` e N"M ‚ƒNl”  %)%"

(33)   (h +   !"r # ( .  . . DGF. . [GVa\<] I"K. _ O N8 e_ N"T U]†ƒulgEN` XZg9U]\4M O cZ[ ` 8 ON_ eZN+eZ\4UD‡ ` gZf"[]† ` gZgZN"O N"g4[ ` X eZNeN"T ‹4†VJ[ † ` gŠ‰ZN)‚Œ‚ƒN+N"U][ ` oZU]N _ — g E 6 N b V ‚ V ‹lVboZ6‚ƒNN"UN)[Vbc>‚V N"_ XEO [ N"N"U[ c<N„N"XZVbU]‹lU N)g7f"[†pN"TU]N N+V+c _]cZ` ‚ƒc>XZVJU]†ƒudN"N X _ ”YU?c>Ž VJN"gEU [DgZ— N"VpM UW—D”eZ† _ N 74XŠŽ XZgZNU †Œudg>VJ‚ƒ†ƒU–Vb[]† ` g ‡ˆVJ†ƒ[ Nc>V _ XZg N"T ‚WN"T ON)g7[ eZeZNNc<_ N)VJT U]gZNWgZVbNXU ‹l` V+XZUDe — a N"T Vbf"f"‚ƒN"N"gZg4f[L U]N N_ c c _]`` c<[]N"VJg4ul[ Nd†ŒN)”J‚Œ• ‚ƒN"` O XZUN"g4XZ[([]†ƒeŠ‚ƒ†ƒŽ U Vb` XZgE[ U _ N"VbU‚ `lU]_ †ƒUGulg>‚ƒNVb‚ƒ[ †ŒN U_ VJO [ † N` gZeZUWN‰ eVM N"T cZc>‚ƒN)XZgZUe>‡VJ`lgE_ f"[ N"N U_ N"Vbg4†ƒU[ `_ Ng VJU]‚†V _‚DOŽ]N)T [–N"VJUp[ ” M ‚DŽ Vb†ƒeZNeZN"UtfWVJcZ[ N"X _ U ?N"U+eN"T c<N"gZe<VJgZf"N)UU ` g4[†ƒg4[]N _ f"N"cZ[ZN"T N"UVJXgE†Œ‹dNWVJXeZXU]\4U][ N"M ONeENulN"U []† ` gŠ‰ V _ _ cZ‚Vbf» N"T U(gU N"X gZU]N)‚ƒON oZN"T‚ƒUNNWeŠVJŽ XŠVJ” ‚V _ ON"UEN"[‚ŒN)X _ UGe N"T c<N"gZe>VbgZf"N"UU ` g4[ _ N)c _ N"T U N"g4[ZN"T NpU VM ‚ˆŽ Vb†ŒeENŠeŠŽ XZgeŠŽ `l_ e _ N c>V _ []†ƒN"‚ N"T [ ,† 776 XEVN"[Z‘<NT ulU X X _ _ Nr‚ƒjtN"U(e Vb` ‚gZV gZ_ O NN"U]†ƒUWY‰dU N"` Y4†ƒN"[O XZcZ1g ‚ƒN". IUO eEN` []O † ‡Š` eŠ[ Ž †’VJ‡©U‚V eŠ_ OŽ VJ‚N"V 3U _ O0 ” N"Up”  g O ` []† ‡Ic>N)XZ[f ` g4[ N"gZ† _ eZN"U(Vb‚ V _ O N"U [ ` XZ[ N"U†ŒgEe N"T c<N"gZe>Vbg7[ N"Ufb f ` O ON $d"‰ ` X“eN"T c>N)gZe>VJg4[ N"Ufbf ` OO N d)‰ ` X N"8 [ _ N„‹4†ƒeZNfb f ` O ON d .  . . 

(34). Æ. 5 _h576.

(35)  

(36) 

(37)     "! $#% '&('*)+'#+#,).- /0 #% '1 '$2. T4 : A4. T5 : A5. a1. T8 : A8. a3. a6. a2. a5 T2 : A2. T1 : A1. . a7. a8. T3 : A3 a4. a9. a1. a2. j  ).292&  #% (&

(38)  )  _! $#, '&( g`  [Zd)NT” VJ‚ `l_ UG”I€(N)XZY9O ` []† ‡®Uc>N)XZ‹lN"g4[N"T u4VJ‚ƒN"ON)g7[Vp‹ ` † _ eEN"UVJ‚V _ ON"UN"gf ` OOXZgcbf ` OON +N"[ DC VOWOWI_K 9  gENc>VJgZgEN„eN)T U]†ƒulgZNXEg/eZ\4U¥‡ ` gZf)[]† ` gZgEN"ON"g4[ ` XXZgZN+eN"T ‹4†VJ[ † ` geZN„o ` g ‡ ` gZf"[]† ` gZgZN"O N"g4[W‰<N"‚ƒ‚ƒN gŠeZ†ƒŽ N"U c>U [N _ c>UZVJN"T UN)U` oZe>U]VJN gE_ U‹lVJ‚ŒN oE‚Œ_ NN"T U]eZNW† Vb_ XŠN"f"” []N)ON"g4[O“Vb†ƒUc>N)XZ[c _]` ‹ ` 77XEN _ cZ‚ƒXZU]†ƒN"X _ U b‹ ` † _ No>NpVJXZf ` XZgc d eŠŽ VJ‚V _ ON"U 6 N"Uc>VbgZgZN"Utc>N"XE‹lN"g4[U Nc _]` c>VJudN _ "” ?Ž N"U [D— VpM —DeZ† _  N 74XŠŽ XZg9eE\7U¥‡ ` gEf"[]† ` gEgZN"ON)g7[U X _ XZg N"T ‚WN"T ON)g7[ _ ` _ ` ` eZf ` N gZgZN)T N"U]Y4NWN"VbU X/c e ` X gZ_ gNTXEgZc<NN"XZ_ [Vb†ƒfWU VJ` XEg U]N 74XZXEN"g“‚ƒf ` eEg\774U¥‡XZNZgEf"b a[]N"† XgEgZeZN"N9OcZN)†ƒg7‚ƒN [eZU]X N _ c eZ_]N"` U[ ` N"T f‚pN"` T O ‚ŒN)UWN"g4‰[]c U_]eZ` f"N N)_U]N"U]T UXENWU“VJcX c<VJ74† XZ_ ‰ †Š_‚ƒXZN"‚†GVJU[]`† ` g7g [ eZf ` N+gZf U]`†ƒeg7N [T _]N"` g>gEVbU„gZN)f"T u7NVJc>‚ƒN"V O _ N"N)g4Y7Y[ N)O74XŠcZŽ ‚ƒ†ŒN‚Jd)c<”ZN"•XZ[G` XZN"Y4U†ƒU]XZ[][]N †ƒ_ ‚ƒ†ƒXZU ` gZgZNU(fWVJVb‚XZ`lU–_ VbU(‚Œ†ƒ‚ƒ[ZN+N'T []N)N g7_ [ O_ NNeZeZN"N+XZYfWVbc>XZVbU–gZVbgZ‚Œ†ƒN"[ZUGNT U–N"Vbg4gZ[ "U _ 74NXZc>NVJeEgZN"gEU'N"VbUW‚ ”IV • _ O ` XZN"UU gŠŽ VbcZ6 c>N"V U _ VJ_ N"†ƒT U]U U NWN"VJg4XZ[Y N"g4eZ[N _ N^ N"N"‚ƒ[ ‚ƒ_ N"†UW” c>N _ ON"[ []N"g4[eŠŽ N"Y4c _ †ƒON _ eEN"U„‚ƒ†ƒN"gZU+eZN fWVJXZUVJ‚ƒ†ƒ[ZN T eZN g>VJ[ X _ N"UeE†Œ‹dN _ U N"U N". g4_[ N)_ T U]N9NWVb‚ƒN"X U+eZc>NVJgEc>gZVbN"gZU gZN"6 U/V 0 _ ” N)6 ‚ VbN)[]U„† ` f g ` g4eZ‘>NudXfpVJ_ VbXZ[]U† VJ` ‚ƒgZ†ƒ[ZUN T N"T N"‚pN"g4T O [ _ N"N“g4c<[–VbVJ† gZ_ N"gZUN)UeZNN"U]‚ƒ[†ƒN"VbgZ‚ Ut`d_ eZU N_ fWN"VJc XE_ N"U–T UVJN"‚ƒg4†ƒ[Z[ZN+TN"T N c ` V9M U]U ‚D†ƒŽ oZVJ‚ƒ†ƒN"eZU„NN)eGg7Ž [ XE_ g N c>‚ƒN"VbUgZ[ gZ_ N"VbUgZU]U †ƒ` [ g4† ` [ gZ_ UN"T c>N"g4N _[ [_ `dNt_ c>†pN"TVJN"gZU+gEe>N"U(VbgZc>U(V _‚VteZ‘>N"udU X _ _N"N f"[3 VJ‰gZ`»udX9‚ƒM N"U ‚ƒN"Uc>VJgZgEN"UU ` g4[ _ N"c _ N"T U]N)g7[ZN"T NpU„c>V _ ‚ƒN"Uf"N _ f)‚ŒN)UN"[ 6 V ‘>udX _ N e ` gZgZNXZgN)Y7N)OcZ‚ƒNeZN _ N"T U NWVJX eZNc>VbgZgZN"Up” 6 Vc _ N"T U N"gZf"NeZNf"\4f"‚ƒN"U e>VJgZU ‚ŒN _ N"T U]NpVJXeZN c>g `dVb_gZO gZN"VJU ‚ƒNl_ ” N"c _ N)T U]N"g4[]N ‚ƒN _ N"[ ` X _ U]c ` g4[–Vbg N„T eEX _ N"T U NWVJXeZN+[ZN"T ‚pN"T f ` OOXEgZ†ƒfWVJ[ † ` g VM XZgZNU †Œ[ X>VJ[ † ` g9cZ‚ƒXZU 6 _ ` ` _ ^ _ `l_ _ M _ gŠb eZŽ \ NN)VO U c>` Vb[]N"T† UU ‡®NWUeZVJeGNXEŽ Y/Vbc ‚` VeZgZ_ NeO Nc<T N"_ VJeU VbgZd)[]”gZ† ` N)g UeZU Ng7‚[tVe eN"T gZc>f+N)gZeZe>N"VJU gEf"N)NlT U]‰<NWN"Vb[ XZY/N"T [ †%eE74N XZN)[ZN)N"T [ U† U]X ‘>_ gZ‚Œ†ƒN)UpU‰ [ _ VbeZgZ†ƒg>U]†ƒVJ[ † † ` N)gZUWU‰<flc>Ž V N"_U][¥XZ— V&g9—ˆeEVJ† ‚ƒc N L 74VbXŠo>N"Ž †Œ[ ‚ •c>V _ `XEXZgU+N"gZf ` U N"gZOU †ƒeoZN‚ƒT N(_]` eGgZŽ (UVb‚77V _XGO Ž XEN"gU ‚ŒbJ†ƒN"TN"‹dgN"g4eE[]NXZN)fW‚ŒVb‚ƒN"XZO U–VbN"‚Œg4†ƒ[Z[NT ‹4N"†ƒeZg4N[ _d N N"[ c>VJ74gEXZgZNN"f"UWN"‰[U N"` gZ†ƒ[U N"XZOgEoZN‚ƒN([ _ N)VJU]gZ[U U]†ƒ[][ †_ ` XZgŠf)‰G[]X N"_ U N[„T N"†ƒeZ[ N"‡ g4`l[_ †’O‘(NN T . . . . ,º. h_h jiWkl'mk.

(39) m. W

(40) e

(41)    

(42)   P1. T1. P2. P1. T0. T1. P1. P1 T1 Panne rémanente. Causalité simple T1. P2. T2. 3 . Panne résorbée. T1. T1. P3. Causalité exclusive. P1. P2 P1. P1. Panne spontanée. P1 T1. P3 P2. P3. Causalité simultanée. T2. P3. P2. Causalité OU. Causalité ET. j

(43)  "- G)+

(44)  1 #1 & )+ G'   #,)+0( '$#,)+1. XZVb†Œg ‚ƒ‚ƒN". X _O UW‰J` g []† ` ‡XZeŠUGŽ ‡ˆVJVb‚V†ŒU _ ` OgZN)UU‚DŽ 0L ”I\7•c ` ` [ XZLIUtN"M U g N ` 77[ `XGgZŽ XEU g„N"(‚gEU]ƒNN"OO oZ` ‚ƒN[]† eŠ‡Ž eŠVJŽ ‚VJV ‚_ V O_ ON"UGN"e U` VJgEU g U `N T f"_ †WN"NT T c<V NM _ [‚V `l_ [†ƒN(_ Vb‚ƒgZN"UU]†ƒc[ † L ` N"gT g `O "” N"M ^ gZVN"_U ` oZU]N _ ‹lVJoZ‚ƒN"U‚ `l_ UeGŽ XEgZN[ _ VbgZU]†ƒ[ † ` gN"g4[ _ Nc>VbgZgZN"Up” D! I"\LI_KUIYLZ] VKWV EI_KUQ V[GVa\<] I"K 9 _ ` _ 8 _ ` _ L 8 _ M ‡f ` ` †ƒO€UcVJc gZ`` UUX VJ_ XZg4g‚D[Ž]N"T[ f ` N)T` OU]XZNW‚ƒo<VbN"XNON"gN"g g4[g/c>VJeZUZgEX9N"T gZf"[XNl_ ‰4Vp†Œ†ƒ‘<UZ‚INlTfN"‰U]N"‚ƒ[[(N"UU c XZO` U]Xf)N"N"_ O cZ‚[]N"V†ƒUoZud‚ƒN"NN"U]U]eE[ U † N` Xg9oE‚ f"eZ` N"X74UXZ_ cN N"T _ U]NW\4‚VbV U]XŠ†,_74”ŠN"XZO €N"UVJ` gEg4c<U[ZN"N"TXZXZN‹dg9eZN"Ng4[]N)[ c>‚ N"V$_ [74N)T U]XZNNWN"Vb[XZXŠU[ ‰<†ƒeŠ‚Œ‚†ƒŽ `dUZVJN"_ T‚N"UGV 77U _ XGOV Ž XEN"‚Upg V ‰ c74XZ_ ` †G‹ c ` _]74` X>‹ VJ` g474[(XZNVb†Œ‚ƒgEN(U]†ŠO eEVJN"GU 'U 77X<. ŠVJO ulNdVJ” U ?74X>N"‚VbV+ulN"c U`leG_ []Ž NVb‚eŠV _Ž VJO XZN"[UVJg40 [g” ?cZ‚ƒŽ XZN"UU [(V+M ‚ƒNf ` O gEUZ` 'N TeZ74NXZeZN"gENrf"‡ N ` gZ74f)XZ[]Nt† ` ‚ŒgZN gE_ N"N"T OU NWN"VJg4X[eZeZNX ul_ N)N"TU]U []NW† VJ` Xg N"U [ `d_ u7VbgZ†ƒUZNT eZN‡ˆV)f , ` g L †pN T _ V _ f L †,74XZNN"[S77XEN‚VtulN"U []† ` g N"U [(f"N)g7[ _ Vb‚Œ†ƒUZN"T Nl” @gfWVbU„eENU–VJ[ X _ Vb[]† ` geEX _ N"T U NWVJX eZN[ZN"T ‚WN"T f ` O OXZgZ†ƒfWVb[]† ` U g b‹ ` † _ NeEX _ N"T U NWVJX eZNulN"U []† ` g d"‰GeZN"U ` ] _ ` ` _ _ _ [VJOc gEU„cZ‚ƒN"†ƒgZU c>N)XZ‹lN"g4[ c ‹ 74XZN eZN"Uc<N []N"U eŠŽ VJ‚V ON)UW”?N"‚VUWŽ N"Y4cZ‚ƒ†,77XEN“g ` [–VbOO N"g4[c>V _ . . T0’. P4 T1. T0. P2. T3. P1 T2. P3. P5. T5. P6. T6. P7. T7. T4. T8.     2&  #%(( 1     <'. Æ. 5 _h576.

(45) k.  

(46) 

(47)     "! $#% '&('*)+'#+#,).- /0 #% '1 '$2. T4 a7. a8 T8. P6. P3. a3. A4 ; A8 a1. T4 a2. T8.  ‚ƒeZN+N‡ˆeVb`†Œ[*gZ74gXZN)T N"NUW”"‚ƒN"?UN)†ƒUg4‡ c>`lN _ _O []N)VJU[ † eŠ` gZŽ VJU‚V eZ_ NOudN"N"UU]†ƒ[ gZ† ` eZg XZ†ƒ`U]N)g4g7[[ueZN"T N"gU/N T _ . Vb‚Œ[ N)_ O` XZN"g4U'[0 GXZe>gZVJNgZUc _ ‚ƒ†N"`lU _ †ƒ` [ZoENT U]ON _ ‹l` VJ†ƒgZ[]e† ` _ gZNUWU” X 6 _ N)U‚ƒN+c>[ N _ _ Vp[]‘>N)fU eŠ_ N"Ž ‹lVbVJ‚ V gZ_ f O L NtN"Ug>UVJ` [ g4X [„_ N"f‚ƒ‚ƒ` N"gZO U]†ƒN"eg4N T[_ N"eT N"N)TU c>N"f gE` e>O VJOg4[]NN)UN)T [–eEVJNg4[‚DŽ N"T†ƒ[gZVJe[N)T c>eZN"NgE‡ e>` VJgZg4f"[][]N)† ` UgZ‚ŒgZN)N"U„O XZN"gEg4N"[UeZeZX N"U_ N"T VbU]NWXZVb[ XŠ_ N"” UWj” @‚ƒ‚ƒN"U+U ` g7[+N"g %"!"%"%"

(48)    . (+S  + (  . '%  9 . 6 N _ N"T U]NWVbX9eZNc<VJgZgZN)U _ N"c _ N"T U]N)g7[ N‚ƒN"UfWVJXEU–VJ‚ƒ†ƒ[ZN)T UN"g4[ _ Nt‚ŒN)Uc>VJgZgEN"U(U XZU]f"N)cZ[]†ƒoZ‚ƒN"UeZNU]Nc _ ` eZXZ† _ N e>_ N"TVbU]gZNWUVbX/‚ŒN eE_ NN"T U]c<NpVJVJgZX gZeZN)N(U [Z_ N"N)T ‚Wc N"T _f N"`T U ON"g4O[]N"XZg4gZ[†ƒfW‚ƒVbN"U[]† `U \4gGO” 6 cZN)[ U` 8 OO N)` U []† Vb‡®U[][]eŠN)Ž gZVbeZ‚ V XZ_ UpO ‰>VpN"‹lU"N)74fXZ‚ƒ†(N"N"XT []_ †,U74XZeN"N"T [ c>[]N)N"gZg4e>[VJ‚ƒN"gEUf"N"[ U_ VbN"gZ[U]†ƒ†ƒ[]gZ† e` gZN"T c>UN)eEg4X — e>VbgZf"N"Up”     . j

(49) 1 <)+

(50) ((&

(51)  ) 0"! $#% '&('. . EDGF. #WOWV] M SI IYLZK3I" ] VOPLM WI Q  \ I_ KI_V RQSI TSVaOSOWI_K. _ _ ^ _ _ ` egZN)†ƒT fWf@Vb_ g[]†ƒ‹† ` ` VJgGgZcZ”UcZ‚ƒ‚ƒ,† N"74U X>`VJoEg4[U]N ‚_ V ‹lVJeE[]\7† ` g<gZVJUOVb†,[]74[]XZN)NgZeZU XZ[–VJN"UpgE‰Še>‚V `d_ e U(eZeEN"N„U eZ\4N"T U¥U]‡ Np` VJgZXZf)Y []† ` eZgZN gEN"ON)[ N"g4†[ VJUX eEX N"T _U]N"NWT UVbNWXxVJXeZN eEN„c>VJ[ZgZN"T ‚WgEN"T N"f UW` ‰ O g OXZX4U — 6 L 8= _ ` ` L 8= eZO N)` U[]† VJ‡®Ž ‚UN"V gZf_ f O` gZN"V f"UN gZ_ e>N)gVbON"T gZUpN"U” g46 ‚ƒ[IN V6eZ_N‘>N"T c>ulU NWVJX VJgE_ XN/gZN"eZUŠN ee<`VJulgZgZN"UgZU[]NXZ† ` g XZgGg”aN"T ?N"U]NpY4N"VJ[ ‚X+_V VJeZ†ƒ†ƒ[(gZNeEeE[ZXZN"X T ‚W†ƒN"[T _ f N"TeEU ON"NWU„VJOXeXZN"eZT c>gZN+†ƒN)fWgZc>Vbe>VJ[]VJgE† gEgZgf"N"N"U†ƒO UN"cZ[N)g7‚ƒ‚†%[ V+74_ XZN f NG` ‚Œ‚DgZN)Ž U6N)fpgZVJVb[Zf ‚ N)T V g>V _ VJO gZ[ † N"N"` O Ug9eZN"eZg4N"NU[ eZU NN)XZeYN"T f"O ‚ƒN"`gE[]f † L ‡®U N _b‚ŒN"N)g UO UZ'N T ` 74[]XZ† ‡®N"U gEf"Nl ” N"[ (VJU]U ` f"†WN"T U _ N"U]c<N"f"[ †ƒ‹lN"O N"g4[ VbXZY[ _ VJgZU †ƒ[]† ` gZU  N"[ 74XZ†Ec>N"XE‹lN"g4[ 6 V g ` [ † ` geZNUZN)T O“VJg4[ %† 74XZN eZN _ N"T U]NpVJXf ` gZU]†ƒeN T _ N"T N†ƒf"†ZN"U [f"N"‚ƒ‚ƒNeZNUZN)T O“VJg4[ %† 74XZN f ` O c `d_ []N)ON"g4[–Vb‚ƒNl‰ fl6 Ž N„N"U U [DN"— gZVpM —DUeZe† _ ` *N gZ74gXŠN„T Ž N"Vb‚ƒX ‚ƒN_ U]N"TN(U]NpeVJNT X‘>gZeZ†ƒN„[c>c<VVJ_gZgZXZN)gZU/NN)TeZ[]N"†,74U fXZ_ N"†ƒ[ZcZNT[ † N)` U]g[eEVJN"‚ `lU_ N"U(YeN"T f"NT XZ‘>[gZ† †` gZc>UV _ 74XZ‚VtN‡ˆc>VbN"OXE[†ƒ‚ƒ‚ŒN N:IeŠN"f"Ž `l[ XZ_ e N __ N"‚ŒUN c>_ VN"T U_ NW[ †ŒVJN)XG‚ŒU ” U X _ • ‚ƒN"` U(XZVbU+‚ V Vp_ ‹ O ` gEN"EUU74o>XŠN)ŽU †ƒ` ‚<†ƒe gN"T feŠ_ Ž †ŒN"[pY4‰Zc N"_ ‚ƒ†ƒ‚ƒONN"N U]_ [N"g Y4` cZ[Z‚ƒN"†ƒT f"N †ƒ[]N"O 4” N"g4[‚V f ` gZf)X _]_ N"gZf"N9N)g7[ _ N c>VJgZgEN"UW” ^G` X _ eNT ‘>gE† _ ‚c>VV _ UZ[ N"T †ŒO“N)‚ŒU Vbg4eZ[]†,N"74U XZ_NN)T eZU]NWN VbXZ_ N)YxT U]NWeZVbNX^eZNN"[ c>_ †ˆVb‰gZN"gZ[ N"Upg ‰I` g g ` XEU]U(X _ g ` ‚ƒN"XZUUUZVbN"TcZO“cZXZVbg4\ []` ,† gZ74UXZN"e U` gZeGf+Ž N)U]g7X [ __ N"‚ƒ‚N"VbUf"N"UZON"T O N)g7VJ[g4U[]†,74uN"XZT gN"NUT _ eGVJ‚ƒŽ `dN"O_ e N)_ g7N"U[ f ` gZU]†ƒeN T _ N"T N"Up” 6 Vr‘>ulX _ Nqt†ƒ‚Œ‚ƒXZU [ _ Nf"N"‚Vc<V _ ‚ˆŽ N"Y4N"O cZ‚ƒNeZN(eEN"XZY _ N"T U]NpVJXZY eZN ^ N"[ _ Y† 74XZ†IU ` g4['N T 74XZ†ƒ‹lV&— . . .  .

(52) . ,º. h_h jiWkl'mk.  .

(53) P. W

(54) e

(55)    

(56)   T1. T2. T1. T2. Deux ordres partiels (sans motifs concurrents) : T1 T2. . P1. T1. P2. T2. P. P. q  #/#% ' G)+

(57)  T2. T1. Un ordre partiel (motifs concurrents) : T1. . T2.   '). a1 &(< )  _!

(58)  G G'  ')+#.W '1 '$29. P5. T5 a6 A5 // A8. a7. T8. a8. a5 P6.  #+#,'   )+

(59) .   . T5. T8. . #e!  #%& j  &(

(60) ) *"!  #% '& . T0 T2 T4 T0’ T8 T1 T5 T3 T7 T0 T0’. T2. T4. T8 T5. T1 T3. m  1    G')+)+

(61) 0E

(62)  G  ')+#"$'

(63) )1 ‚ƒc>N"V g4_ [][ U†ŒN)eZ‚ŒUXU cX `_ †ƒ‚ƒg4N"[(UeZ[ _N+Vb‹4gZXZU]†ƒN„[]† eE` N"gZUU UZ74NTXŠ77Ž XE†Œ‚ƒN"UgZVJf"eZN"U+O eZN"[]N+[ N"[ g4_ VJ[WgZ” U †Œ[ † ` gZUp‰>O VJ†ƒU 74XZ†U ` g7[eZ†ƒU][ †ŒgEulXN"T Uc>V _ ‚ŒN)U `d_ e _ N"U 6 V f ` gEf"X _]_ N"gZf"N eZN9c>VbgZgZN"U U †ŒudgZ† ‘>N 74XZN9‚ƒN"U9Vb‚ V _ O N"UeZN"U O ` []† ‡®U+f ` gEf"N _ gN"T U9U]Nc _ ` eEXZ†ƒU]N"g4[ eZudXN _ ‡ˆN V-f ,` gc _ †ƒN"gZT U eN"g4N"T c<[]NN"gZXZe<gVJg4N"[]Y4Nl[ ” _ 6VJ†ƒN"[U+eZO X ` [_ †N"T ‡®U]U(NpVJf Xx` gZeZf"XN _ _c>N"VJg4gZ[ gEUN"U]UN _]N"` [ g4‚[+Ve f ` ` gEO f c ` ` oZU]U †ƒN[]_† `‹gN"T U c<. V_ N"Vbg4‚ƒ‚[ N)M_ ‚ŒN"N ‚VJ_ fIN"N)T c U _ N)0T U]” N"6g4[–V Vbg4‘Z[— ‚DU Ž†ŒN"Og4XE[ _ ‚ŒN"[‚VJVJgf"N)TN"OO N"N"g4g4[[e>eZVbN„gZUeEN"‚ƒNXZY9_ N"T O U NW` VJ[]XŠ† ‡®” UeGŽ Vb‚V _ O N"U(VJU U ` f"†pN"T U VM eZN"U[ _ VbgZU]†ƒ[]† ` gZ*U 77XE†'c<N"XZ‹dN"g4[ N"8 [ _ N[]† _ N"T N"U _ N"T U]6 NWVbV X9‡ˆVbeZON_ †ƒ^ ‚ƒ‚ŒN"N [ _ †D‰74XZN"U]†I[ c _VJN"‚ `lgZ_e9UN"e g N"T ff _ _` †ŒO[ N9cZu[ N($_ VJ8 N"f"Y4N cZ^ ‚ƒVM †ƒf"XZ†ƒ[]_ gxN)OVbN"‚Œug4`l[_ ‚ †ŒVt[ L U]O[ _ NXZf)eE[]N“X _ f N„` eZgZXU [ __ XEN"T U]f"NW[]Vb† ` XŠg ” K eŠ_ g9Ž N"YVJN"_TU f"U XZ` [f"† †ƒ` NgZ^Gc U`` eZX N__ f"f"N)N‚ V[D\4Vbc<X N„eEN"NT U]NW_ VbN"T XxU]NWVbeZXZN YIc>‰ŠVb‚V+gZgZf N"` U gZU]XZ[ gXZf"[ N"† T ` U]gNWVbeŠXxŽ N"eZYN N"T f"XZN"[ [† ` †9gZU'N T 74N"XZU [†ƒ‹lfVb` ‚ŒN)gEg7g7([ XEN„74XZN"†[N"c U _ [` XZU–Vb‹X4N"T ‡NN)f [ `l_]_ N"— f"[N"NU][ bN" †ƒg4d"[WY” ” ?N"[ X []N f ` gZU]6 [ V_ XZ‘<f)ul[]†X ` _ g/N„VbmU]eU ` ` f)gZ†ŒgZN NV+M XZXZg gZN"NY4UZN"N'TO 74XZcZN)‚ƒNgZf"eZN+NeZUZN'N T 74[ XZ_ VbN"gEgZf"U]†ƒN„[ † N)` [gZ‚ˆUŽ `dXZ_ g e _ `lN_ e c<_ V Nt_ [ c>†ƒN"V ‚'_ []Vb†ƒU]N"U ‚I` U]f"X †pNl_ T ” f"N"U[ _ VJgZU †Œ[ † ` gZUp” T7.   .

(64) . Æ. 5 _h576.

(65) PlP.  

(66) 

(67)     "! $#% '&('*)+'#+#,).- /0 #% '1 '$2. A1 :. a6. A5 :. a9. A8 : a7. a5. a8 a9. S : a6. Q: T1 T5. a5. T8. k  2&  #%  ''')+)+

(68)  ( G')+)+

(69) j *#, *&(

(70) ) * "!  #% &  6 `d_ _ _ _ _ ` M ` ` _ UeZ†ŒN[ † ` Ž gZU_ eN)c>U]c<V N(_ N"c>f"‚ƒV[]N"†ƒU‹d[]N"O†ƒN"O‚I` N"U[]g4X† ‡®[Uc>‚ƒeŠN"VŽ UVJ_ ‚VJV ‚ƒ‚N"_ V UOO`dN)_ UWN"e ” U_ 6 N"VbVU(U]U ‘>c>ulV f)X_†WN[ T_ †ŒNN)Vt‚ŒkU XZgZ†ƒ‚ƒN‚ƒXZN"U]Y[ _N"T Nf" XE‚ Vr[]† U]XZcg oZ` N"XU U []_([ †ƒ[]` XEoEoZ[][]†[ `N"N"g gZg4† X _eZN"N" U g ” N"TU]‚pXEN"T O oZU]N"[ g4†Œ[ []X>U VJg4[‚ƒ N"UN)[ [VJ g4— 6 N O ` e N"M ‚ƒNVJ†ƒgZU]† N)T [–VJoE‚Œ†c<N _ ON"[eZN U \7g4[ L N"T []†ƒU N _ ‚DŽ N"gZU N"OoZ‚ƒNeZN"U U]cN"T f)†’‘<fWVJ[ † ` gZUe ` gZgN"T N"U c>V _ ‚DfWŽ VbXZXZ[]U–†ƒ‚ƒVb†ƒU–‚ƒ†ŒVb[Z[]NlT N"‰ X VtM _ "” [ _ ?Vp‹dŽ N"N U]_ [¥U— V&M ‚ƒ—ˆN"eEU† _cEN ‚ Vb74f"XŠN"UŽ †Œ‚N"[f ` [ _g4Vb[]gZ†ƒN"U]g4†ƒ[][ † ` VM gZU"‚ V `dN"‡ `[†ƒ‚ƒUN"U‚DŽ N"O gZ`U N"[]†O‡®UoZeŠ‚ƒN+Ž VJeZ‚V N"_ U+Oc>N"VJUpgZ‰lgEVpN"‹lUWN)‰GfN"‚ƒ[+N"X ‚Œ_N)UX _eN"_T c<N)‚ N"VbgZ[]e<† ` VJggZf"eZN)NU N"[†ƒgZ?eN)N"[„T c<N"N"Y4gZN"e>O VbgZcZf"‚ƒN+N"Up‡ˆ‰<VJU]†ƒX[_ VJ‚ŒcEN)c>UV [ _ _ V Vb8= gZ[ _U]Nx†ƒ[ † N"`T u4gZVJUW‚ƒ” N"ON)g7[eZX g ` g{—ˆeN)T []N _ O†ƒgZ†ƒU]O N„N"g4[ _ NeEN"U N"T ‹ ` ‚ƒXZ[]† ` gEUc ` UD— UO†ŒoEXZ‚Œ‚ƒN)[ U †ŒcEVM ‚ŒN)c>UWV‰d_ f []` † O _ eŠOŽ XZ N g O N"N"8 O [ N JN"T ” [–Vb[eENc<VJgZgZNd‰lc>V _ N)Y7N)OcZ‚ƒN(c ` X _ ‚Vc>VbgZgZN

(71) N"[‚ƒN"UfWVJUeZNc>VJgEgZN"U ED C \M KI I"O YNj] TLI QSI"KX] VK SV EI"KcQVa[GV\] I"K 6 _ ` _ ` M _]` ` N"?g+N"‚\VV †ƒc<g7c N[ZN"_ †ƒT UO u N_ N"VJN"[Wg4g+‰ [ŠVMf eEc>N"O VU„_cZN"T[ []‹ † N_` ‚ŒeZeŠXEN"Ž []XZU† g` O gZN"TVJUI[ U VJeE74[X X>eZVb_ NN"ulT U N"c>NWUGVbVJU]gZXNgZN)‡DNgVJe†ƒ‡[Š`` eZgZgE† gf"[]N"NlT † f"‰J` []eŠgtN)Ž ON"eZY4NN"c g4U]_ ['N)†ŒUO VbOXN _ gZ` cE†ƒeZ‹l‚ŒN"NpXEUIVJU]eEX†ƒN"NXeZ‡ _Xt` U gZO ` f"oZ[ †U e ` N N"gZ_ ‚ƒ‹lgZNVbN"eZ[]O †N` N"cgEg4U [IVbcc>[]`VJ[ U]u4N"U gZVJ†Œ[]eZoE† XZ‚ŒN)N)gŠUWU ”‰ Uc<N"N ‚ _ ` O (g N"77[XEeZNN(eZeZN"U†ƒU O f _ †ƒVJO U 74†ƒgZX>NVb_ul‰JN"‚UG`lc>_ UN)XZeZ‹lNN"‚ g4Vr[e U]NN"T []c N)_]f"`[]† eZ` XZg † _ eZN N(` c<XVJg gZ` gZgŠN)UW” ‰46 N"V g4c[ _ _]N(` o>‚ƒN"VJUoEN"†ŒT ‚ƒ‹ †ƒU–` Vb‚ƒXZ[]† []` † `ggEeZUX c _ ` N)T U]U]U NW†ŒVboEX‚ŒN)UeZNU N"c>‚ `VJggEgZ‚ƒN"N"UU Vb‚ V _ O N"U ` oZU]N _ ‹N"T N"Up” a7. a8.   . . . .  . .  . ('%)

(72) S  +   6 _ _ _ _ _ `l_ ` ` _]_ eŠeZN)Ž VbU(‚ N+V eZ_ †cO VJudN"†Œg gEU` f"N"U†ƒ[c>[]†ƒNeZf"UN"N"UUeZ[eNN"eZTc>c<N+VbN"gZcZgZgZ‚e<VJN"VJf"UpgZN ” f"N)N)Uegd"‰ N"` g4oZ[ [ N"N)T g4NXZeZN"UX/c>U V XZ_ c<NeZN"‹4U(†ƒU]fpN"VJX cZ[ N"eZX N)_ UU†ƒcZg4‚‡ VJfIN)O“T UVbU][]X † _ gZ‚ƒN U*_ bN"†ƒT f"U †NWVJeZXGN"‰ZU c ` f"X f"_X ‡ ` N)X gZ_ f"gEN"† U_ `c ` XZ@ ‹ L `ggZXZU []N"†ƒ‚ƒg4†ƒU–‹7VJ†ƒUg4VJ[` uleEN _N"U‚V([ _ N"fpf VJL cZgZ[ ,† X 74_ XZNN"UeŠŽe†Œg{N)T` ‡‹l`lN"_ ‚ O“` cEVJc [ N"†T `N"UgZ` UIe>eZVbNgZUc ‚Œ_ NN"T fIfpN)TVJeZe N"_ gZN(f"eŠNtŽ fWN"_ YVJXZN"T f"U` XEVJ‚ƒ[]Nl† ` ‰dgZc>U V _ _ N"TN"c>U][V _VJ_ []O†ƒN"cEU†Œ‚ƒ ‚qZVJ‰<ud_ PN3 e> ‰dVbggZ`UXZ‚VU f XZf NeZNulN"U []† g+c>V N)Y7N)OcZ‚ƒNl”p• XZUN"Y4f"‚ƒX gEU'eGŽ N)OoZ‚WN"T N‚DŽ †Œg4[ XZU † ge>VJgZU‚ƒN[ V&‘>feZX N"T U]NpVJXeZN . . ,º. h_h jiWkl'mk.

(73) Ppj. W

(74) e

(75)    

(76)   a1. S c5. a3 a2 a5. a6. a7. a8. c4 c3 c2. a8. a5. a7. a3. c1 e1. a5. a1. a1 e2. p3. a2. a8. e3. a6. a2 c1. c2. c3. a3 p4 p5 e4.  [ZU N"X T ‚W_ N"T f ‚ƒ`N"UO †ƒOg4‡ XZ`dgZ_ O †ƒfWVbVJ[][]†† `` gŠgZU‰bc 77`XEX N_ c>eZN)N"XZU [(_ VJVJcZ†ƒUc ` `lgZ_ U[]N eZ_ N‚Vf `"f XZ8` [_XZ`Zf LflNŽ N"U eZ[(Ntc ul` N"X U _[]77† ` X gŠ` ” †Šg ` XZUg ` XZUo>VbU ` gEU(XZgZ†,74XZN"O N"g4[ a6 p6 a7. P.      2 &g#, _!

(77) ' )+

(78)  '

(79)  '<)+  #%0Y  . . DGF. (jV_LMGNjOWK. SKI_\. G^ _(` `X _ f L_ V$74XZNU]†ƒ[]N _ bXEg N"T_ ‚p` N"T O N"g4[eZN6 _ N"T U NWVJX ` _XxXZgx_ ` u _]` XEc>NeŠL Ž]N"T ‚WN"T ON)g7[ U`deZ_ N _ _ N)T U]NW` VbXgd XZg fpVJc4— [VbN"‚ VX _ O N"oZUU]N c _ ‹l` NeE‚ƒXZN"†ƒU([]N"VbU‚ V U X O _ N"‚ƒN(UcU]†ƒ[ NeEVJXZU †ƒU []` N"f"Up†p” NlT ” N)?UŽ N)fWU]VJ[cZf"[ N"N"X[N"U(gZcU N"OeEoZXZ‚ƒN(†ƒU]N"eGg4Ž `d[_ fe _ VJN"Uf)XZ74g XZ†<XZN"g U][‡ e` X Nl_ ‰ZgEf†IN"g4g[]N"N"g>g4Vb[ _g4N"T[NeZeEN"X U U XZc>N6 _ V ‹4†ƒ‘<U]N"ulX X _ _ ”IN • P ` 9XZUc _ g N"T ` U [N"`g4gE[]NU XZg _ N"T U XZ‚ƒ[–VJ[‚DŽ N"c gZ` U U N"U]O†ƒoZoZ‚ƒ‚ƒN N(eŠeZŽN)` U oZ`lU N_ _e ‹l_ VbN"[]U † ` ‡ ` g X _c>gZV †ƒ_ U‚ƒc>N"V U_ fp‚ƒVJN"cZU[ fpN"VJX cZ_ [U N"X fl_PlUp‰ ” fWj N"[f 3 eZLZN`d_ ‚† V6* ` ‘>g7ul[XVJ‚ƒ_ N"N“Up” Pd6” N"6 U N"U_]` N)T gZ‚WN)eZT OU+N"g g4` []† U_ UeZN‘>ul_ X N)T _U]N"NWg4VbXZ[Y eZN)b U6NlP Vb‚ VM V _ N O dN"UN"[c _]‚ƒN„` eZU XZXZ†ƒc<[ N"N UW_ ‹4” †ƒ6 U]N"N"X U _ _]` b®ngEdeZU„U ` u g4_ [†ƒUZ‘>N)T UulX ‘>_ udN"T XU_ c>N)g7V [t_ eZeZN"N"UU c>N"T ‚pVbN"T gZO gZN"N"g4Up[]‰Ug eZ` Ng _ ` N"T oZU NWU VJN _XG‹l” VboZ‚ƒg N"UWV ” 6 N"U N"M f L N) U ` oZ ‚ƒ†,74 4XZ”ZN"U• ‘>` XZudXU_ ‡ˆN)Vbg7†Œ[U ` eEgZN"UU ‚DŽ N)LT f \4L c VJ` gZ[ udLIN"N"M UU](N eZN 74XZON„N"‚ƒUN"U–UVbVbul‚ N"V U+_ O N"g4N"[ U_ N“U ` ‚ƒg7N"U[ ` oZU]N ` _ ‹N"T N"U_]`c>V _ ‚ƒN"UfWVJcE_ []N"X L _ U(flPd‰ZfWj+N)[(f 3 e>VbgZUXZg _ `l_ e _ Ntf `lL N T _ N"M g4[Vp‹dN"f‚DŽ `l_ e ` _ Ne>VJgZU_ ‚ƒ'N 74XZN"‚ŠN)‚Œ‚ƒN"U UU N` g4U [g4N"gZ[U cXZ†ƒ[]NeZXE[ _ †Œ[VJN"gEUU]OU X †ƒU N"fU(VJV$X 74XZU]N XEc>U]N †ƒ[]_ Nd‹4”Š†ŒU €N"X VJ_ gZUn‚ƒc<N+V fW_ VJ‚De Ž †Œg4N[ N eG_ ŽOxXEg/N"T eZU †\7VJU† _[ NN"O eEN"NU(eZfWNVbcZul[]N)N)U]X []†_ Ugf f"N"N"g4[([ f VJZ‚ƒ” †ƒUZN"T Nl‰N)‚Œ‚ƒN"U `d_ e n _ ` N"XZU U ` ‚ˆoZŽ LU N\4_ c ‹` N"T [ ULIN)N)M `U]U]N[+†Œ74gEXZf"_]N‚ƒ` XZ‚ƒUN"U e>VbfWgZVJU„cZ[ ‚DN"Ž `lX _ _ e U _ N `l_ 74e XZ` † gZfgE`` N"g4g4[][“†ƒN"f g4`l[+_]_ [ N"` f"XZ[ _ []N"N"OU+N"‚ƒg4N"[ U+e‚ƒN"N"TU9c<N"_ VJgZ‚V e>_ VbOgZf"N"N"UpU‰‚DN"Ž g4N"gZ[ _ U N9N"OVJoZ‚V ‚ƒ_N OeZN"N"UpU ‰ [e>N"Vb‚ƒgZ‚ŒN)f"U N"Ut77XGN"Žg4N)[ ‚Œ_‚ƒN"N UVJU]‚NV _U Og4N"[Uc U NceZ_]XE` †Œ[eZN"XEUW†Œ”U?VJg4N)[[][]U]NtX †Œ_ gEeZf"‚ƒ;† XZ:U]N T† _ N"gg4[]N)UU][U †ƒu[]N)N"T g UN T eEVbX ‚ƒN"_ ON"T U]N"NWg4Vb[XU]eZ[ N+†ƒf"[Z[]N"NdT ‚p‰>N"T fcE` XZO†ƒU O74XZXZN(gE‚ƒ†ŒN"fpUVJ[]e† `N"T c>gN)gZg4N — c<N"XZ‹dN"g4[(c>VbU _ VJ†ƒU ` gZg>VboZ‚ƒN"ON)g7[ N"8 [ _ N ` oZU]N _ ‹N"T N"Uc>V _ ‚ƒN"UfpVJcZ[ N"X _ UeZX _ N"T U NWVJX eZNulN)U][]† ` gŠ”  

(80) . 

(81). 

(82) 

(83) 

(84). . Æ. 5 _h576.

(85)  

(86) 

(87)     "! $#% '&('*)+'#+#,).- /0 #% '1 '$2 DC 6. . I YNjOWOSVaMGKKVOYI. P3. _ _ ` ` M _ _ ` _ ` _ eZVb‚ N V _ ‚ƒN O N"X cN"_ UU†ƒegZeNf)T N)‘>T†Œc>c<gEN"N † gEb UeeZe>d N VJgZc>‚f)VV N"_ U ‚ŒN"N _f N"T_ ‹ gZN"T N"MU g>‚ƒNWN"VbVJg4†ƒXU][U–VbeZ‚DgZŽN` f"f)c>N9f"VbX fgZ_]gZ_ gZN"N"UgZUp†Œ‰f"U N[]VM N eŠ[ _V Ž VpXZ‹leg N N"T _ [ b UN` X‚ŒO N)U(eZ†ƒgZON N `cZ[]‚ƒU]XZ† ‡®†UU†ƒ‚ƒN"eGN"XU Ž Vb_ U‚VdoE_ U]O `lN _ N"e ‹lUW_VJ”ZN"[]U €† Vbc>gZgZVU„U(_ eG[]‚ƒ†ƒNŽN"Vb‚ƒfW‚UV VJU]UO X eŠ_ N"Ž UXZeZgEN"N"N[U U_ cN"T U]N"T NWf"Vb† ‘>X/fWeEVb[]N† ` c<g VJgZc>gZV N)_ U(‡ˆVJN"†ƒ[[]N ‚ˆŽ N"N"gE[U]N"eGOŽ XEoZgZ‚ƒN N`eŠoZŽ `lU _ N e _ ‹l_ N"VbU []† ‡ ` ` g X _ †ŒgZe†INWT VJc>‚ƒV Nl_ ‰‚Œ‚N)V U(_ fWN"Vb‚cZVJ[[]†N"` X g_ U(N"N)g4U][ [(_ N9XEgZXZN g _ N)`l‚ _ Vbe []_ † N ` g eNeŠT ‘<Ž N"gZY4†([ N"c>gZV U]_ † ` ‚ƒg N eŠeZ†ƒŽ `dU []_ †ƒe gZ_ f"Nl[ ”YUWE”@@ g/g N:»_ N"N"[p‹l‰IVJ‚gEV+f L U]cNl‰N)T f"c † ‘>` fWX VJ_ [ † ‚ƒ` N"gU _c>VbN"†ŒXEU `[gZf U` g4N)T []‹ N"` gE74† X_ N"T eZN"N)U Uf"e† —ˆN"TeZc>N)N)U]gZU]XEe>UWVJ‰gEf"‚ƒN"N"UUfWN"VJg4cE[ _ []NN"X eZ_ N"UUgZVbN ‚ V c_ O ` X N"_]U_ `eEg4N„[U †Œc>[ VJN"UU ‡‚ƒN"` U X _`dgE_ †e _ _ N"eŠU Ž †ƒ` g4oZ‡ `dU]N_ O“_ ‹VbN"T []N"†U(` g9f ` eZg4N []†ƒN"egZN)TgEc>N"N"g4gE[e>O VJgZ` f)†ƒN“gZU c eZ` N X _ _ N"eZ‚VJN"[ U† ` VJgZ‚VU_ eZONN"eUN"T eEc<NN"gZU]e>†ƒ[ VbN"gZUf"N eZ†ƒ74U][XZ†ŒNgEf"‚ƒN"[]UUpj” `d?_ e N"_ ‚N"V U†ƒU]gZceZN)TXZf"†ƒ† ([ ‘ N"T77U XEVMN [ _ Vp‹l6 N _Ž ` U(f)‚ƒf"N X __]N)_ T N"U]gZNWVbf"X9N+eŠeZNŽ XZc>g VJ` gEX gZN"eZUWNt” cZ‚ƒXZU]†ƒN"X _ U `d_ e _ N"U(c>V _ [ †ŒN)‚ŒUeZNO ` []† ‡®UeŠŽ VJ‚V _ ON"Ue<VJgZUXZg N"gZU]N)OoZ‚ƒN eŠŽ `d_ 6 e V _ N"74UXZ‡ N)` U]X []_† `gEg“†Ic>eEV N_ ‚‚ƒV N"U_ N"fWf Vb` cZgE[]g>N)VJX †ƒ_ U]UUVJU]gZNf)[ N_ VJN"eEU][XZ†ƒVJ[(‚ `lVJ_ ‚ `lU _ UN"g []N _ ONeŠŽ N"Y4[]N"gEU]† ` g eŠŽ `l_ e _ Nd” @T [VJg4[e ` gZgN T “‰  []N)"‚ 74XZN  N"T [ N"gZe ” 6 V _ N)T c ` gZU]NN)U][g ` ge N"M U 74XZN‚DŽ ` oZU]N _ ‹lVJ[ † ` g f ` g4[]†ƒN"g4[XZgZNeN"T c<N"gZe>VbgZf"Nf ` g4[ _ VJeZ†ƒf"[ ` † _ NVp‹lN)f ‚V+U]cN"T f"† ‘>fWVb[]† ` gŠ” ?N"‚Vc<N _ ON"[eZNeZ†ƒU f _ †ƒO†ƒgZN _ ‚ƒN"UO ` []† ‡®U eŠŽ VJ‚V _ ON"Up” `l_ _ _]` _„M `d_ _ _ _ _ ` _ eZeŠNŽ XZDc>‚IgEVbN(UWgZŽ VbUZgZNulT N"77†ƒU[ XEN"Vb‚DgZŽ ‚ N)f"gZNU]UN"eEeZON(N oE[ ‚Œ_ N)N VJ[ gZU †ƒXZeZ[]‹l† N)` N U(gZVJUV ‚fV `d77_ O_]XE_ N"N)N"‚ U]U c ` ` oZe gZU]e>N NVb_ ‹c<g4N"[]V T NN"U[ c<†ƒN"f N ‚I`d_ _]O U]_X N)N"U][]c [eZ_` N"VbgZU †Œe9[ N"T [ eZc ,† N77` XE[ _ N"N"N"g4[][ [_][]N"`†ƒN"U(XE‚ƒ‹l‚ƒeZN"N NO_ ‰4[ N)u g7VJ_ [pgEVb8 ” U]f"6 †ƒN []V† VM f gE‚D` UŽ VJgZeZ‚ƒg>u X Vb`d†ƒ_ U]†ƒN"U–[T VbU L NWgZOVJf"X NN eZNtf ` gZU [ _ XZf"[]† ` g9eŠŽ N"YN"T f"XZ[ † ` gŠ‰4‚DŽ]N"T ‚WN"T ON)g7 [  eEN‚V‡ˆVbO†ƒ‚ƒ‚’N 4” _ N"f ?L N"N [_` []f NL Vb_ g4N"f[` ` eEgEN"g>` U VJ†ƒ` U]f"Uf"VJX gZ_]f)_ N„N)gZc<f"N"N"XZ_U[(eEVbN‚ `dO _ _ U` U[ N†’‡©Uo<eŠVJU]Ž VJN ‚_ V U]_ XO_ N"‚DUpŽ ” VJ‚ƒu `d_ †ƒ[ ` L ON_ eZNf ` ` gZU [ _ _ XEf"[]† ` g eŠŽ N"YN"T f"XZ` [ † ` gŠ‰4N"g ‡` `doZ_ U]O N• _ N‹XZN"eZT N"UNUWc‰<‚DŽg †ƒXEg4` ‹‡XZ`lU_ gEO“c U(` VpN"XZ[ g4‹† ‹4` ` g9†ƒgZU–VJUeZude†ƒNU]` c gZ` XEfgEg“†ŒN"oEg [ ‚ŒNd‡ˆVb"”VJ†Œ[† @_N"NOg VJN)N oZg7:»U [N"[ [p_N ‰VJf"‚ƒ[N"fW†U„VJ` f"geN+N"T‚ eZc>`lN"N)_ UUgZe>eEVJoZN(gEU ‚Nf"V N"‹lU_ N)VbfN)[]L†g7N[ gE__ N fU L fWN+NVbf", eZcZXZN[]N"N"UpO X ‰I_ ` N"U[]g9† gZ‡®N"UWN Y4” cZ6U]N ‚ V_ ` †Œe[g4N)VJT [f g4` [c>O VJ‚VU— c‚V` U c>†Œ[V † _ ` []gŠ†ƒN ‰IN)eZg XXZO gZN` []c† ‡ `l77_ []XE† †` g‚ŒN c<f V ` _ gZfWf"VbN _cZgZ[]NlN)X”_ • ‰` eŠXZŽ XZUgc `O XE` ‹ [ ` †’‡gEUc<N VJ_ ‚ O `l_ N"U„[c eŠ_ Ž `WN"a Y4N"[ [ _ N VJ_ † _ ‚ƒNlN ‰Š_c N)T` U]X NWVb_ Xxf L eZV N977XEc>NVbgZfWgZVJN"cZU[ N"U X X _ _ ‰ ‚ƒf N"L UVbfWf"XZVJcZg[ N"eZX N"_UUWfW” VJ^GcE` []X N"X_ _ f"UN"‚gZVEN‰Z‚f V+` gZU]U][ N_ XZ_ ‹lf"N[ X c _ N` X eE_ X f L_ N"V$T U 74NWXZVJNXO eZN` [ c<†’‡VJgZ74gZXZN)NU‚V+N)U]c[(`deE_ XZ[ †cZ` ‚ƒg ,† 7774XXZN"T N†Š‚ƒU]NX _f ` ‚ƒgZN"Uf"N fW_ VJgZcENl[]”GN"n4X XZ_ aU†ƒ[]`EN N"VM[ f"O N)[]` [][]N† ‡®Upc Y” _]@`Wa g N)f"N []:I† ` N"gG[p‰‰ZXZc gZ` NtX _ U]\4XEgZgf LZO _]` ` gZ[ †ƒ† U–‡Vbe []`† ` gEg9g NleET ‰N"Uf L fW$V VJ74cZXZ[ NN"X c _ U`l_ N)[]U]† [(` ggN"TeEf"X N"U U–O VJ`† _ []N† ‡c e ` ` X †ƒ_[ ‚N"8 V [ _ _ N N)f ` ` oZgZU]g<N VJ_ ‹†ƒU]N"TUN9VJgZc>f"V N+_ eZ‚ƒNN fWeZVbN cZ.[]N)UX V _ 0 fG` c gZ`df)_ N [ _ † g` Ndg9T ”"eZ?XN"‚O V+` U]†ƒ[]ul† ‡–gE” †’‘<@NgZU]74XEXZ†Œ[NNlf‰IL XZVJgf)XZ[]g9N)U]eZ[NeZN+f)N"[]UN _fWOVJcZ†ƒ[g>N"VJX †ƒ_U U` g e `N"g4†ƒ[ [ _ ` NoZU ‚ŒN)N U_ ‹dfpN VJ_ cZ[ [ ` N"XZX []_ N"UtU‚ŒN)‚ƒN"X U_ Vbc>‚ VN __ OO N"N"[U eZNtU]NON"[ [ _ NeGŽ Vbf"f `d_ e c ` X _ ‚VteN"T [ N"f"[]† ` g9eZX O ` []† ‡–” D! \M KI I"O YNj] TLI QSI"KXT I"\LI_K Q  V[ V\] I_K 6 N)U Vb‚ V _ O N"UU ` g4[U XZU]f)N"cZ[]†ƒoZ‚ƒN"UeGŽ N)8 [ _ Nc>N _ eZXZN)U‚ `d_ UeEN(‚V _ N"O ` g4[ZN"T Ne>VJgEU‚ƒN _ N"T U NWVJX eZNudN"U][ † ` gŠ” ?N"Uc>N _ []N)UeGŽ Vb‚V _ O N"U†ƒgZeZXE†ŒU N"g4[eZN"U . Š[ _]` XEU 0 Ie>VJgEU‚ŒN)U `l_ e _ N"U ‡ ` X _ gZ†ƒUc>V _ ‚ƒN"UfpVJcZ[ N"X _ Up‰If"* N 74XZ† . . . . . .

(88) . . ,º. h_h jiWkl'mk.

(89) P. W

(90) e

(91)    

(92)  . UU N(` g4[ [_ VJeZeZN"XEU †Œ[` oZc>U V N _ _ ‹l‚V(Vb[]g † `` gZ[]† U ` gVM eZ. IN([ _]U ` ` XZXZUU¥— 0`d©”_ e 6 _ V(N(74U]XXZ_N"U ‚D[]Ž †` ` oZg U N eZ_ N‹lVb‚[]V † ` _ gN"f ` gZ”dg>• VJ`†ƒU XZU–UVJgEg f"` N„[ ` U gZNU [ _ VJeZXE†Œ[VJ‚  `d_ U`IXc>M V ‚ƒ_N"U  @T [–Vbg4[e ` gZgN T D‰    t[]N)‚Y77XEN IN"U][XZg U ` XEUD— `l_ e _ NeZN N)[ sN)T []N"gZe ” 6 V977XEN"U][ † ` g/eEN _ N"f ` gZg>Vb†ŒU U–VbgZf"NN)U][+†Œf)†[ _ VJgZU¥‡ `l_ OxN"T N+c>V _ ‚DŽ V a` XZ[(eŠŽ XZgEN77X<VJg4[]† ‘>fWVb[]† ` g c>N _ — O ‚ƒNN"fW[]Vb[U(VJg4u[N"T geZN TN _ VJc ‚D_‰<N"‚ gEV e _ _ N"N ‚VJN"[ g † ` g f ` N"O g4cZ[ _ []N N+[ ` GNXZ"[][ N"U‚ƒN"gGUtŽ N)c>U]N [(_ []gEN"†ŠU XZc gZ` N U]U_ †ŒN"oE‚VJ‚ŒN)[ UW† ` ”Gg • eZ` N+XEU„U ` c XE` UDXZ— `l‹ _` e gZ_ UtNl‰<g gZ` [†GN XZ_ gZ74N XZ_ NdN"‰‚VJe>[]VJ† ` gZg U eŠŽ N"Y4^ [ VN"gZ_ U]VJ† †ƒ` ‚ƒg9‚ŒN)X eŠ_ Ž Up`l‰"_ f"e N"_ [ Nl[]” N[ _ VJgZU¥‡ `l_ O“VJ[ † ` g(eEN‚jV 74XZN"U []† ` gteZN _ N)f ` gZg<VJ†ƒU]UVJgZf"Nc<N"XZ[VJXZU U]†4U]N _ VJO N"gZN _VM XZN"g gENe[N"T _ e VJ` gZXZU¥oZ‡ `l‚VJ_ O“g4[VJ‚ƒ[ N"† U ` g([ _ eEVbXgZU]_ †ƒN"[T U]† `NpVJgZX+UeZeZNN‡Dc>V-Vbf , gZ` gZg N"UpVM ” c @_ gN)gZN e:»_N"N[p‰pN"‚ŒgN)UŠf c<` NO_ [cEN"[]UNeŠ‚ŒN)Ž VJU‚VU ` _ OXZU¥N"— `dU<_c>e N)_ XZN"‹lUN"c g4`[ U N"8 U][ †ƒ_oZN‚ƒN"N"UY4eZc XZ_ †ƒUOxVbN"XZT N"Y U c<gŠNŽ N"_ U [ [(N"Uc>VbeGU Ž Vb`d‚_V eZ_ O †ƒg>N"VbUW† _” N6 eZV9X O ‡ˆVb†ŒU †Œ[N674VbXŠX Ž †ƒc‚I`‡ˆVb†ƒg4XZ[[eZ[ _ N Vp‹lf"VJN"[]†ƒ‚ƒ[ ‚ŒN N _ [ ‚D_ Ž Vb†ƒg7gZ[ZUDN‡ T `l_ †ƒ_ N"O X _ VJ[ eZ† `N"U9g/N)TN)[]U],† [+74XZN"N"g[][ fN"`UX eZ_ N"U„UeG[ Ž]_ N)T VJ[]gZXZUeZ†ƒNd[]†‰` fWgZV Up_ ” ^ N"‚ƒV ‚ƒN_ _ 8 ` _ _ _ _]` ` ` M _ _ _ eZVb†ŒNr‚ƒ‚ƒ‡ˆN"-V X f , ` UWg‰peZU N` XZO cZN"‚ƒO Nf""N N"74UXZVJNcZc c _]X` Y4†ƒ‚O“V c>VJ[N † ` []gZNUpeŠ” Ž Vb‚ V O N"UW‰‚Vc o<VJoZ†ƒ‚ƒ†ƒU–VJ[ † g(eEX„O e N"‚ƒN'c<N ON"[eZN[ Vb†Œ[ N  %)*

(93) +G'%" 6 N eZ†Vbulg ` U][]†ƒf e ` †Œ[VJXO †ŒgE†ŒO+XZO ‡ ` X _ gZ† _ XEg N"T [–Vb[f ` X _ VJg4[eZN ‡ ` gZf)[]† ` gZgEN"ON"g4[+eZX _ N"T U NWVJXG” ` _ _ ?N"‚ƒXZ† —Df"†N"U [„N)guN"T gN T _ VJ‚f ` gZU][ †Œ[ XN cZf ` ‚ƒXZX Up_ ‰4Vbgg4[]` U(XEU(c ` Vp[ ‹ N"` g4gE[]U†ƒN"‹4‚ƒUfX N"74[XZcZN‚ƒXZ‚ƒNU]†ƒgN"X` g{_ U“—ˆeTN"T N)‹T eŠ[]` N Ž ‚ƒXZ_ XZOg[]† †ƒ`N"gZgZgE†ƒU]UUO N"c ON` oZU c<U]‚ƒNN"†ƒoZXZeŠ‚ƒ[(N"Ž]UWN"VbT ”[–OVb[]N"UgZN f _X V+M fVJ` g4gZ[]UU]†ƒeeGN Ž]T N)_ T ‚WN N)T_ OXZN"gg4[]N"UgEU]eZN"X OoZN)T‚ƒU]NNWVbeŠXŠŽ]N"T ”[–Vb€[]NU 6 Ž †ŒeN"T NN"U][VJ‚ `d_ UeZN ‡ ` X _ gZ† _ XZgu _ Vbc L Nf `d_]_ N)U]c ` gZe>Vbg4[(VJXeN"T cE‚Œ†VbulNeZN‚ Vc>V _ [ †ŒNeZX _ N)T U]NWVbXeZN c>eŠVbŽ N"TgZ[gZVJ[N"UUeZc>NV _ c>f VJ` gEX gZ_ XEN"U N` ‚ X`d_ eUN"T eZu N_ Vb‚e>V VJ_ [ N"† `f `gZgEUW”g>@VJ†ƒg U]UN VJ:»gZN)f)[WNl‰4”I†ƒ•‚ZN"` U XZ[U †Œg4` [ZoZN T [ _ N"N"g U U–` VbgZg7U[pc‰4c` []` N"X g4_ []†ƒ‚N"V‚ƒ‚ƒudN"N"O U][ N"† g4` [gXZeZgZN N+_ N"U]T XZU]Npf"VJf)XZN"U]YIU ‰4† ` eZg N f ` gZg>6 V N"8=U[ _ []N N)f 74L XZgZN)†,‚Œ77UXEN)N"gZUf LeZVN 8= gZeZN"†O VJudN"g g4` []U U[]†ƒeZfNXZc [ L †ƒ‚ŒN"T†ƒgUVJ` g4O [N"M ‚ƒgZN"N"U+U c ` _]g4` [o>VJf `oZgZ†ƒ‚ƒeE†ƒ[ZXZN"T †ƒU+[ c<VM N ‚D_ Ž]O N"T [–N"Vb[][[ N"f g4` [X _ eZVJN g4[p‡ ” ` X _ gZ† _ XEg eZN"u _ N T eZVbf"N f `l‹l_ VJe‚ƒ†ƒN"TeZN†ƒ[ZVJNT X eŠO Ž XZ` g e N)MeZ‚Œ†ƒNu7VJ‹4g†ƒU ` U]V+M [ †ƒ‹4f“†ƒUc eZ` NtX _ f"N"XZ[][gZN N ` ` oEoZU]U N N _ _ ‹l‹lVJVb[][]† †` ` gŠg ” e ` gEg N"T EN `VJ†ƒgZU † 77XGŽ XEg eZN"u _ N9T eEN“f ` g4‘»VbgZf"N `O e €_ N"M N"‚ƒaNXEY/` VM gZ_ †ƒ‚‹dVtNW‡ VJ` XZ†ƒUYc VJ` X X _ O _ O ` †Œ†ŒgEN)U(XZY U ` ` _ g4N"T [„U]†ƒU]N"[ g4N ‹4_ †ƒU–VbVbXZulYNWVbo oZ_ ‚ƒXZN"†ƒU„[]U cL `bO X `_ VJGU ‚D77Ž M†ƒX<g7VJ[ _]ul` N)eZUXZN"f)[[]_ † c>` N g_ []eZN"NUeŠc Ž _]Vb_ ` ‚ o<V VJ_ O oZ†ƒN"‚ƒ†ƒeU [ZdN"T UN"[` e<OVJgZ†ƒU+N"_ XZ‚ƒY N_ eZ‚ƒN"†ƒUU f ‚ƒ†ƒ†ƒN"OgZU†ƒgZeZN N”fW€+VbXZŽ XZU–VbgZ‚ƒN †Œ[ZN„c>T V N)g7[p[ ‰_ N‚Vc>Vbf gZgEgZg>N"UVJ†ƒc>U]UV VJ_ gZ‚f)VN/c eZ_]N)` Uo<VJc oZ†ƒN)‚ƒT †ƒg [ZNT O c N"` gZX N"_ U f eZL XV$74XZN)TN+U]NWfWVbVJX XEU–c<VJ‚ƒN †ƒ[ZO N+T N"eZ[N+eZU]N9N+c c _]` gEeZe XEN T † _ N Nl” ?N"[ []Nc ` gZeN T _ Vb[]† ` gxeEN/‚V _ N"‚VJ[ † ` gxeZNfWVJXEU–VJ‚ƒ†ƒ[ZN T c>N _ ON"[ eZN _ V gEN _ ‚ V eZ†ƒU]f _ †ƒO†ƒg>VJ[ † ` g N)g7[ _ N ‚ƒ‚ƒN"N"UUG77N)XET ‹ N"` ‚ƒ‚Œ‚ƒN)XZU[ † eE` N"gZUUO“c ` VJU]UGU 74†ƒoZX>‚ƒVJN"udUN"Uc `U `X g7_ [‚ƒN U]XZ_ U N"Tf"U N"NWcZVJ[ XG†ƒoZa” ‚ƒ?N"UN"‚eZV N+c<U]N N+_ O c _]N"` [eZeZXEN† _ cZNl”I‚ƒXZ€+UŽ VbeZXZN[ [_ _NVbc>†Œ[ V N _ _ [W‰<eZ‚N"V+U+c<U]†ƒN []_ X<[ NVJ[]eŠ† ` Ž gZVJ‚UV _e>OVJgZN"UU ceZ_†ƒU ` f eZ_ XZ†ƒO†ƒ[†ƒg>XZVbgZ[]N † ` eg NT eZ‡ `dN_ O“c>VbVbgZ[]gZ† ` N"gUp"” eZ?N N"[‚D[]Ž ` N+oZe U NNT _‡ ‹l`dVb_ O“[]† ` VbgŠ[]† ‰G` eg ` c>g7N)[+XZ†ƒ[ ‚N"8 ‡D[VJ_ XZN„[+Up[]Ž N)N"Y7gEc † _ _ †ƒfO` NOc>cZV [ N_ N"‚ `lY4_N"U„O eZcZX ‚ƒNc N)_]g ` f"VbN)U]U]U U]` XEf"U†VbeZg7N[ VN"M U [f L c<V$N 74_ XZeZN„XENlVb‰‚ V ‚_VO c N(_ ` XZo>gZVbNtoZc†ƒ‚Œ_]†ƒ`[ZNo>T VJc oZ` †ƒX ‚ƒ†ƒ_ [ZNTf"N)eŠ[]Ž []N"8 N[ _ VbN‚Vc<_ N O _ eENXZeŠNl”Ž N"8 6 [ _ `lN_ UGN 74:IXŠN"Ž f"XZ[ gZ†Œ‹dN„N"VbO‚ V N)_g7O [tN(c>NeZ_ †ƒeZU][ XZ†ƒNgZulc<X>N Vb_ g4O [N"eZ[N"eZXZNY f O LZ`` †ƒ[]U † †‡®_U ‚ƒNf ` O c `d_ [ N"ON"g4[N :»N"f)[]† ‡‚ƒNcZ‚ƒXZUc _]` o<VJoZ‚ƒNeZX _ N"T U NWVJXGg” @g4‘<gŠ‰Z‚ `l_ U 74XŠŽ XZgZNN"Y4[]N"gEU]† ` g9‚ƒ†ƒgNWT Vb† _ N(N)U][ . . . . . .

(94)  . 

(95)  .

(96) . . . . . Æ. 5 _h576.

(97) P.  

(98) 

(99)     "! $#% '&('*)+'#+#,).- /0 #% '1 '$2. fO ` `O[]†O‡®U XZc>gEN N _ OVM N"eZ[ N"[]N"XZg4Y[O eZN` []f †LE‡®Up` ‰I†ƒU]‚† V9_ ‚Dc Ž]N"_ T `‹ o>` ‚ŒVbXEoZ[]†ƒ† ‚ƒ` †Œ[ZgN T ‚VteŠŽ cZ` ‚ƒf)XZf"UX _]‹ _ _ N"VJgZ†ƒUf"U]NN"OeZN9oZ‚f)VbN"oZ[]‚ƒ[ NlN9” N"Y4[]N"gEU]† ` gxc ` X _ f L JV f"XZg eZN"U.

(100) !p'%)

(101) ,h/ (% „( ` ` _]` ` ` _ ` ` _ _ [‡Z`dN"T _‚W• N"O T f ` N"XZO ‚ƒ‚ŒU'N)OVpUW‹‰XZf"gZN"gZ[†ƒUGfW[]NVbc []VJ† `cZc gŠc ”¥_]UZ•` NTf ` LXZXENgZUŠNVpc \4‹4_ VJ`†ŒUg4c † [` gN"UT u4` c VJgZ‚ƒUŠN)N"T f"OXE†ƒgZU]N)NNg7eZO[<N"c ` U` egX N)T _ ‚Œ†ƒ[]oZU† VJXZ[]gE[Š† UŠ`‚VgeZNU e>c c>VJN"T gZVJf"UGgE†VJgZ‚ƒ‚ƒN'N"†ƒU–UŠfpVbVJN)[]e [ † `_ VbNg‚VeŠeZŽN O XZU–[ N"Vp†ƒ‚ŒUI‹ †ƒUe>` VJ†Vb_[]gZl† ` UŠ‡DgVJ‚ƒN"† eZ_ U NGNe OxN)T N"U]T NW‹lN)T Vb[N)LZXZ‚ ` ` YcZeZeZcN"NNU T e>c _VbN"gZT fIU(N"T eE‚ƒNN"gZe f"` N+O“fWVbVJ†ƒXEgZU–N(VJ‚ƒeZNN)Ue>VJU gZ\4U U][ XZN)M gO[N"N"U O_ N"cZT c>U V ‚ _ ` [ ul†ŒUp†,74"” XZ?NlN"”l‚€V+N"c<UN Ox_ O N)T N"[ LZ[(` g eZ` N"[–U VbOc _]O` o>N)VJg7oZ[ †ƒ‚ƒeZ†ƒU]N„[ N"f U` gZU `U †Œg4e[N T _eZN N_ cZ‚‚ƒV+XZUg ` XZ[][ † †ƒ` ‚Œ†ƒg UZN"T eZN"NU c ` X 6 _ Ž VVJ‚ƒu gZ`d_N †ƒ_ [ L ‚ƒNO O N(` eZe N N"M _‚ƒNN)f N"` [(gZ‚ƒg<N"VJU†ƒU]OxUVJN"T gZfWVJf"gEN †ŒUeZONN"O Up” ` []† ‡®UeŠŽ Vb‚ V _ O N"UN"U][tN"gf ` X _ UeŠŽ N"T ‚Vbo `d_ VJ[ † ` gŠ” D‚'UpŽ VJc4— cZ[ZN"XET ‚W†ŒN"T N f _ ` V+O U]OX _ XZXZgZgZ†ƒfWNVb[]Vb† e>` VJgŠcZ” [VJ[ † ` geZNt‚ˆŽ Vb‚Œu `l_ †Œ[ L ONeZN (†ƒ[ N _ oZ†VJX fWVJUeZN"Uc>VbgZgZN"Ue>VJgZU‚ƒN"U _ N"T U]NpVJXZY eZN `l_ L ` ` _ ` `l_ ` _ ` _ ` _]_ 8 _ eZO †ƒU` [ []?_ † †ƒ‡®N)oZU[“XU NVJTN"‚‚ƒc>`u gxV _ †ƒ‚ƒ[ cN"U _]O`pfWa N VbN"f"cZ‡ [ []† N)`gZX g f)_ []Up†U ” X gZ_ gEgZ‚ƒN N"NUtV U]fW\4VJVJgZXcZf [ LZN"‹ X_ ` _‚ˆgZ‰UW‰†ƒ‚ Uc>VJV[]U† _ ` eEgxN"N/Y4N"N"‚DOg4Ž [ cEoZ_ N‚ŒU NN fWN)‹lVJg VbcZ[][ XZ† N"[X g †Œ_‚ƒ†ƒU9U–eZVbN"U]g4U9N [_ VVJXE‚VgZVJN‚ O`le_ N)UN"TUWf ”XZ` [DO†Œ‚(‚ƒc†ƒc UZ` N)T UN9X †Œ[ c † ` `V gX N"_ eZ[ N"‚ƒNNU eZ†Vbulg ` U][]†ƒfeZNc>VbgZgZN"Up”  . .    - 1 *1 G$#a  #, - '')+

(102)  0 ' &(' ”   K ‰IPWklkdjZ” ŒP   _

(103) <)+

(104)  );- #%),'  )+

(105)   $#, '&(' ”   K ‰IPWklkdjZ”  j   _

(106) <)+

(107)  *-' )+

(108)   

(109)  '/ "!1 j1& / ”   K ‰ŠPpklkdjZ”  3     @” N"U][VbgZe/R”Z€N"‹4†ƒ‚ƒ‚ƒN _ Up”(n4'N 74XZN"g4[ † Vb‚'VbgZe ? ` gEf"X _]_ N"g4[ N L Vp‹4† ` X _ †ƒg ^ N"[ _ †•(N"[ U KL N `l_ \4” Y

(110)  G)+$#

(111) j

Références

Télécharger maintenant ( PDF - 20 Page - 424.40 KB )

Documents relatifs

Le tramway : au coeur des enjeux de gouvernance entre mobilité et territoires

Dans chaque ville et pour toutes les lignes de tramway considérées, il faudrait disposer des trafics avant et après ouverture d’une ligne et de plusieurs projections d’évolution

Deux bols de lait ; suivi de La poésie de Stephanie Bolster

Le fait d’écrire à partir d’une oeuvre d’art visuelle ressemble à une forme de contrainte; nous croyons par ailleurs que cette pratique a eu un effet durable sur l’écriture

Le rôle de l'affectivité dans la recuperation des langues chez les aphasiques polyglottes /

variables d'ordre psychologique: soit f.amiliale ou personnelle, soit so- ciale, soit professionnelle, soit une combinaison de ces facteurs. Ce patient a récupéré

Deux études spectroscopiques d'objets évolués et compacts

For the two coolest objects in Figure 3.6, HD 4539 and PG 1716+426, both at Ta &lt; 27, 000 K, there is a good match between the predicted synthetic spectra and the FUSE data: the

La maison dans les romans et les nouvelles d'Anne Hébert /

lui inculquer le registre li'lquistioue, les l1abitudes alimen- taires et vestimentaires ainsi que le comportement des bour- geois de Québec. Pierrette Paul doit

La conciliation emploi-famille: des mesures à développer dans les milieux de travail

La conciliation emploi-famille : des mesures à développer dans les milieux de travail Tableau 4 : Les dispositions favorisant la conciliation travailfamille dans les

Effet de l’âge des peuplements sur l’erreur d’âge et l’estimation de la productivité chez l’épinette noire (Picea Mariana (Mill.) B.S.P.)

Figure 2.4 Predicted (continuous lines) and observed values (filled circles: stands aged from trees with root collar; open circles: stands aged from trees without root collar)

Expertises nomades au Sud. Eclairages sur la circulation des modèles urbains.

Cette posture permet de dégager deux idées centrales : le poids des milieux professionnels locaux dans l’intermédiation et le transit des idées, modèles et pratiques