Derivation of supersaturation and nucleation flux in a stirred tank from tracer concentration measurements

(1)

HAL Id: hal-01717490

https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01717490

Submitted on 6 Nov 2019

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access

archive for the deposit and dissemination of

sci-entific research documents, whether they are

pub-lished or not. The documents may come from

teaching and research institutions in France or

abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est

destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents

scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,

émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de

recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires

publics ou privés.

Derivation of supersaturation and nucleation flux in a

stirred tank from tracer concentration measurements

A Fall, Olivier Lecoq, R David

To cite this version:

A Fall, Olivier Lecoq, R David. Derivation of supersaturation and nucleation flux in a stirred tank

from tracer concentration measurements. Chemical Engineering and Technology, Wiley-VCH Verlag,

2003, 26 (3), pp.322-324. �10.1002/ceat.200390049�. �hal-01717490�

(2)

!"#$%&'$() (* +,-"#.&',#&'$() &)/ 0,12"&'$() 32,4 $) & +'$##"/

5&)6 *#(7 5#&1"# 8()1")'#&'$() 9"&.,#"7")'.

!" !" #$%%# &" '()*+$# %&' ," -$./0

()* +,-. /+0%&%1 ,%2*1 -&'34*' .0351*24*&4* (*4)&673*8 9*:)5' 62 %;;06*' :5 '*:*196&* *<;*169*&:%00" :)* =6*0' 5= 23;*12%:31%:65& 6& % 2*;%1%:* '53>0* ?*: 1*%4:6@* ;1*46;6:%:51 =159 :)* 054%0 6&2:%&:%&*532 =6*0' 5= 45&4*&:1%:65&2 5= %& 6&*1: :1%4*1A ()* &340*%:65& =03< 6& :)* 96<6&B 1*B65& 62 '*16@*'A

: ;)'#(/,1'$()

()* 6&'32:16%0 ;15'34:65& 5= 2506' ;%1:640*2 >" ;1*46;6:%:65& 51 1*%4:6@* 41"2:%006C%:65& 62 323%00" 4%116*' 53: 6& 9*4)%&6D 4%00" 2:611*' :%&E2A -& :)*2* ;154*22*2 :F5 51 951* 06736' 2:1*%92 %1* >153B): 6&:5 45&:%4: 6& % 951* 51 0*22 45&:1500*' =%2)65&A ()* 45&:%4:6&B %&' 96<6&B 45&'6:65&2 5= 1*%4:%&:2 B5@*1& :)* 23;*12%:31%:65& '62:16>3:65&# 45&2*73*&:0" >5:) &340*%:65& %&' B15F:) E6&*:642# F)64) 6& :31& %==*4: :)* 41"2:%0 26C* '62:16>3:65&# &%:31*# 951;)505B" %&' ;316:"A G34) 6&=03*&4*2 5= 96<6&B 45&'6:65&2 5& 41"2:%0 ;15'34:2 )%@* >**& '*2416>*' 6& :)* 06:*1%:31* HIJA

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

()* 73*2:65& 5= :)* 1*0%:65& >*:F**& :1%4*1 *<;*169*&:2 %&' *<:*&: 5= 4)*964%0 1*%4:65&2 )%2 >**& :%4E0*' >" ,*@*&2;6*0 HPJ 2*@*1%0 "*%12 %B5A -& >*:F**&# G)**&5" %&' (551 HQJ 2)5F*' :)%: :)*1* 62 % 1*0%:65& >*:F**& =**' =1%4:65& 5= %& 6&*1: :1%4*1 %&' :)* *<:*&: 5= %& 6&2:%&:%&*532 4)*964%0 1*%4:65&# ;15@6'*' :)%: :)* 950*430*2 )%@* 26960%1 '6==326@D 6:6*2A

()* %69 5= :)62 ;%;*1 62 :5 %;;0" 0%2*1 2)**: @623%06C%:65& %&' 69%B* ;154*226&B :*4)&673* :5 4)*4E 6= :)62 :";* 5= 4511*0%:65& >*:F**& @%16%&4*2 %&' &340*%:65& =03< 4%& >* @*16=6*' 6& :)* 4%2* 5= '53>0* ?*: 5;*1%:65& 5= % ;1*46;6:%:51 F6:) 2*;%1%:*' =**' 2:1*%92A R* 32* =0351*24*&: :1%4*1 2503:65& %&' F%:*1 %2 % '53>0* ?*: 95'*0 96<6&B 2"2:*9 6& % 2:611*' :%&EA -& :)* =612: 959*&:2 =5005F6&B :)* 6&:15'34:65& 5= :)* =036' 6& :)* :%&E# :)* 96<6&B 5= 6&*1: :1%4*12 F6:) &5 ;15'34:65& 5= 2506'2 62 26960%1 :5 :)* 96<6&B 5= :F5 1*%4:%&:2 6& 65&64 ;1*46;6:%:65& %2 :)*1* 62 &5 26B&6=64%&: 45&239;:65& 5= :)* 1*%4:%&:2 '316&B :)*

=612: 2*45&'2 5= 45&:%4: HSJA ()32# 96<6&B 6& 65&64 ;1*46;6:%:65& 4%& >* 4)%1%4:*16C*' >" =5005F6&B :)* 96<6&B 5= :F5 6&*1: :1%4*12# 51 96<6&B 5= % 26&B0* :1%4*1 6& 2503:65& F6:) ;31* 250@*&:# 6&?*4:*' >" :F5 2*;%1%:* =**' 2:1*%92A

()* +0%&%1 ,%2*1 -&'34*' .0351*24*&4* (*4)&673* /+,-.8 459>6&*' F6:) 69%B* ;154*226&B F)64) 62 % ;5F*1=30 9*:)5' :5 4)%1%4:*16C* :)* 96<6&B 6& 2:611*' :%&E2 62 32*'# HT#UJA -: 45&262:2 5= :)* 9*%231*9*&: 5= :)* =0351*24*&4* 6&:*&26:" 5= % :1%4*1 *<46:*' >" % @*1" :)6& ;0%&%1 0%2*1 2)**:A ()62 6&:*&26:" 62 :1%&2=519*' 6&:5 % 054%0 6&2:%&:%&*532 45&4*&:1%:65& =6*0' >" % 4%06>1%:65& ;154*'31* HTJA

< =4-"#$7")'&2

+"',-()* 269;06=6*' 24)*9* 5= :)* %;;%1%:32 32*' 6& :)62 F51E /2** HUJ8 62 2)5F& 6& .6BA IA ()* *<;*169*&:2 %1* 4%116*' 53: 6& % 2:611*' :%&E 5= KV '9M_{5= 2:%&'%1' 45&=6B31%:65&# F6:) 6&:*1&%0}

'6%9*:*1 ( W VAKU 9A ()* F%002 5= :)* 6&&*1 :%&E %1* *736;;*' F6:) =531 >%==0*2 5= F6':) (XIV %&' :)64E&*22 (XIVV %: 6&:*1@%02 5= UVYA ()* 69;*00*1 '6%9*:*1 /Z32):5& :31>6&*8 %&' >5::59 40*%1%&4* %1* *73%0 :5 LXM# F)*1* L W (1*;1*2*&:2 :)* )*6B): 5= :)* 06736' 6& :)* :%&EI8_A

()* 2:6116&B 2;**' 62 2*: %: [ W MAP 2\I_{A (F5 1*2*1@5612}

45&:6&35320" 23;;0" :)* :%&E F6:) *73%0 =05F 1%:*2 /]^W ]!

W VAQS '9M_96&\I_{8 >" :F5 6&4596&B =**' :3>*2 /6&:*1&%0}

'6%9*:*1 Q 998A ()* :F5 =**' ;56&: 054%:65&2 %1* 054%:*' %: :)* :%&B*&:6%0 @*1:64%0 ;0%&* :5 :)* 69;*00*1 %: (XIV =159 :)* >%==0*O 4052* :5 :)* 1%'6%0 '624)%1B* 5= :)* 69;*00*1 /;526:65& I8# %&' 4052* :5 :)* =036' 231=%4* /;526:65& K8A ()* :%&E 62 5;*1%:*'

\

H$J ^A .%00 /*D9%60_ ^)9*'A.%00`*&2:69%4A=18# aA ,*457 /4511*2;5&'6&B %3:)51# *D9%60_ 0*457`*&2:69%4A=18# ZA b%@6' /*D9%60_ 1'%@6'`*&2:6D 9%4A=18# ,%>51%:561* '* cd&6* '*2 +154d'd2 '*2 G506'*2 b6@62d2# efZ g[ZG KMUK# h450* '*2 f6&*2 'i^0>6Dg%19%3<# g%9;32 j%10%1'# TIVIM ^,!- g( 4*'*< VU# .1%&4*A

3$>,#" :? h<;*169*&:%0 2*:3;A

\

(3)

6& :)* 45&:6&3532 95'* =51 :1%4*1 45&4*&:1%:65& 9*%231*D 9*&:2A ()* :1%4*1 62 Z)5'%96&* !A

@ A".,2'. &)/ !$.1,..$()

.612:# :)* 054%0 6&2:%&:%&*532 =6*0' 5= 45&4*&:1%:65&2 62 '*:*196&*'A .159 :)62# F* '*'34* :)* 96<6&B 6&'*<# :)* %@*1%B* =1%4:65& 4596&B =159 5&* 5= :)* =**' 2:1*%92# %&' :)* :*9;51%0 @%16%&4*A ()* =6*0' 5= 23;*12%:31%:65& 6& :)* 2%9* :%&E F)*& 45&26'*16&B % '53>0* ?*: 26:3%:65& 62 4%0430%:*' =159 531 *<;*169*&:%0 '%:% %&' =159 :)62 =6*0' F* '*'34* :)* &340*%:65& =03< 6& :)* 96<6&B C5&*2A ()* '*:%602 5= :)* *73%:65&2 32*' 6& :)* =5005F6&B 2*4:65& %1* %@%60%>0* 6& HUJA

^& *<%9;0* 5= 6&2:%&:%&*532 1*'34*' 054%0 45&4*&:1%:65& 5= :)* :1%4*1 62 2)5F& 6& .6BA K =51 :)* B6@*& B*59*:1" =51 =**' 2:1*%92 054%:65& KA -: @%16*2 >*:F**& V />0%4E 8 6& :)* ;31* F%:*1 =**' 2:1*%9 :5 K /F)6:*8 6& :)* =0351*24*&: :1%4*1 =**' 2:1*%9A

()* 6&2:%&:%&*532 96<6&B 6&'*< =6*0' 62 B6@*& >" :)* *73%:65& >*05F_ !/2#3#18 W I \ ! ! ! ! ! 4₅_{!2!3!1"# 4}_5V_!2!3" !K$ 6 # I"45!2!3!1"% 45V!2!3" ! ! ! ! ! /I8

()62 6&'*< @%16*2 =159 V />0%4E8# 6& :)* =**' 2:1*%9 ?*:2 4511*2;5&'6&B :5 &5 45&:%4: >*:F**& :)* :F5 06736'2 3; :5 % @%03* 4052* :5 I /F)6:*8 6& :)* 1*2: 5= :)* :%&EA ()* %@*1%B* 96<6&B 6&'*< =6*0' 62 2)5F& 6& .6BA M# =51 :)* 5:)*1 =**' 2:1*%92 054%:65&# 6A*A ;526:65& IA

^2 % 45&2*73*&4* 5= 2"99*:1"# :)* 1*230:2 5= :)* :*9;51%0 @%16%&4*# :)* 23;*12%:31%:65& %&' :)* &340*%:65& =03<# %1* 5&0" B6@*& 6& 5&* 5= :)* ?*:2# 6A*A :)* 16B): 5&* 4511*2;5&'6&B :5 :)* =**' 2:1*%9 5= :)* =0351*24*&: :1%4*1A

()* :*9;51%0 @%16%&4* "K_{/2#3#18 5= 054%0 1*'34*' 45&4*&:1%D}

:65& 5= :)* 6&*1: =0351*24*&: :1%4*1 62 '*'34*' =159 :)* =6*0' 5= :)* 45&4*&:1%:65& >" h7A /K8_ "K/2#3#18 WI₇ " 7 4₅_!2!3!1" 4₈₉ # 4₅_!2!3" 4₈₉ # $K /K8

h<;*169*&:%0 45&@*1B*&4* 62 5>2*1@*' F6:) &! IVVA "K_/2#3#18

73%&:6=6*2 :)* 96<6&B '"&%9642 6& :)* 6&?*4:65& C5&*2 /96<6&B C5&*28A L5346&* (1 $%" HMJ )%@* 2)5F& :)%: 6: 62 2:15&B0" 4511*0%:*' F6:) :)* %@*1%B* 41"2:%0 26C* ;15'34*' 6& :)* =**' ?*: 1*B65&A ,%1B*1 )6B) @%16%&4* C5&*2 5= 6&*1: :1%4*1 45&4*&:1%:65&# '316&B 45&:6&3532 96<6&B 2*;%1%:* '53>0*D ?*:# 4511*2;5&' 6& 1*%4:6@* 2*96D>%:4) 26&B0*D?*: :5 :)* ;15'34:65& 5= 29%00*1 ;%1:640*2 %&' @64* @*12%A

.6BA N 2)5F2 :)* =6*0' 5= :)* @%16%&4* 6& :)* 6&?*4:65& =**' =51 :F5 '6==*1*&: =**' ;56&: 054%:65&2 /2** .6BA I8A R)*& =**'6&B

>*05F :)* 231=%4* 5= :)* 06736' /;526:65& K8 % 0%1B*1 )6B) @%16%&4* %1*% /C5&* 5= &5&DC*15 @%16%&4*8 62 5>:%6&*'A g5&2*73*&:0"# 29%00*1 41"2:%02 2)530' >* B*&*1%:*' 6& ;526:65& K 459;%1*' :5 ;526:65& I F)64) 62 4052* :5 :)* 69;*00*1A

(5 B5 =31:)*1 6& :)* %&%0"262# 6: 62 6&:*1*2:6&B :5 4%0430%:* ;1*46;6:%:65& 1*0%:*' @%16%>0*2 234) %2 23;*12%:31%:65& 51 &340*%:65& =03<A ()* 054%0 6&2:%&:%&*532 23;*12%:31%:65& :/2#3#18 1*230:6&B =159 :F5 =**' 2:1*%92 ?*:2 45&:%6&6&B :F5 1*%B*&:2 62 '*16@*' =159 :1%4*1 45&4*&:1%:65&2 HIVJA -: 62 %2239*' :)%: % 96<6&B 1*B65& 1*230:2 =159 :)* 96<:31* 5= 231153&'6&B =036' /459;526:65& 4!# 4;8 %&' =1*2) *&:*16&B

=036' F6:) 45&4*&:1%:65&2 4"!V %&' 4";V 1*2;*4:6@*0"A :/2#3#18 1*;1*2*&:2 :)* '16@6&B =514* =51 41"2:%006C%:65&A R)*& F* ;52* <5W 45/2#3#18 X 489# :/2#3#18 4%& >* F16::*&_ :/2#3#18#4!4 & ;V =_: /<5\ <5K8 6& :)* @646&6:" 5= :)* :3>* I /!D=**'8 /M8 :/2#3#18#4 & !V4; =_: /M<5\ <5 K_{\ K8 6& :)* @646&6:" 5= :)* :3>* K} /^D=**'8 /N8 ()* 41"2:%0 ;15;*1:6*2 %1* 1*0%:*' :5 :)* 23;*12%:31%:65&# F)64) 62 '61*4:0" 6&=03*&4*' >" :)* =**' ;56&:2 054%:65&A +)606;2 (1 $%"HNJ )%@* 5>2*1@*' :)%: ;526:65& K 4511*2;5&'2# 6& 26&B0* ?*: 1*%4:6@* ;1*46;6:%:65&# :5 :)* ;15'34:65& 5= 29%00*1 ;%1:640*2A ()62 9*%&2 :)%: 054%0 23;*12%:31%:65&2 %1* )6B)*1 6& :)62 4%2*A .6BA P 2)5F2 :)* =6*0' 5= :69* %@*1%B*' 23;*12%:31%:65& :/2#3#18 ! =:X /4"!V 4;8 W :/2#3#18 X :V" 4%0430%:*' =51 :)* :F5

3$>,#" <? ^& *<%9;0* 5= :)* 6&2:%&:%&*532 1*'34*' 054%0 45&4*&:1%:65& =51 ;526:65& KA

3$>,#" @? ^@*1%B* 96<6&B 6&'*< =6*0' =51 ;526:65& IA

Pos ition 1 Pos iti on 2

6 mm

(4)

;526:65&2A R* 4%& 2** :)%: /%8 :)* =6*0' 62 26960%1 :5 :)* @%16%&4* 5&* /.6BA N8 F6:) :)* 2%9* 0696:2 5= :)* 1*0*@%&: %1*% %&' />8 :)%: ;526:65& K 6&'34*2 :)* 0%1B*2: C5&*2 5= >5:) )6B) 23;*12%:31%:65& %&' @%16%&4*# 6A*A 29%00*1 ;%1:640*2# F)64) 62 6& %B1**9*&: F6:) :)* 1*230:2 5= >5:) +)606;2 %&' L5346&*A

()* 2*45&' 41346%0 ;%1%9*:*1 :5 055E =51 62 :)* &340*%:65& =03< ,>6& :)* 96<6&B C5&*2A ^4451'6&B :5 :)* k509*1 1*0%:65&

/HIIJ8# 6: 62 B6@*& >" :)* =5005F6&B *73%:65&_ ,>$ % <5 ' K <5 ' V *<; # ;> 05BK₍ !:!2!3!1"" # $ 9/<580<5 /P8

()62 ;%1%9*:*1 B6@*2 69;51:%&: 6&=519%:65& 5& :)* 054%0 :69*D%@*1%B*' &39>*1 5= ;%1:640*2 B*&*1%:*' 6& :)* 96<6&B C5&*# /.6BA Q8A -: 62 =612: &5:64*%>0* :)%: :)*2* =6*0'2 %1* @*1" 26960%1 :5 :)* ;1*@6532 23;*12%:31%:65& %&' @%16%&4* =6*0'2

/.6B2A N %&' P8A -& :)* 2%9* F%" 0%1B*1 C5&*2 5= &340*%:65& =03< %1* 5>:%6&*' =51 ;526:65& K %2 459;%1*' :5 ;526:65& IA ^B%6&# =**' ;526:65& K 2)530' ;15'34* 29%00*1 41"2:%02A

B 8()12,.$().

^;;064%:65& 5= :)* +0%&%1 ,%2*1 -&'34*' .0351*24*&4* (*4)&673* /+,-.8# 459>6&*' F6:) 69%B* ;154*226&B F%2 32*' :5 ;1*'64: 73%06:%:6@*0" 41"2:%02 26C* '62:16>3:65& 6& % 2:%&'%1' ;1*46;6:%:65& :%&EA ^: 5&* )%&'# F* 4)*4E*' F6:) 1*2;*4: :5 :)* 06:*1%:31* 1*230:2 :)%: :)* :*9;51%0 @%16%&4* =6*0' 5= :1%4*1 45&4*&:1%:65& F6:) % 2*;%1%:* '53>0* ?*: ;1*46;6:%:51 62 4511*0%:*' F6:) :)* %@*1%B* &340*%:65& 1%:*2A -& :)* =**' ?*: %1*%# 29%00 1*B65&2 5= )6B) @%16%&4*2 4511*2;5&' :5 0%1B*1 41"2:%02 %&' @64* @*12%A a& :)* 5:)*1 )%&'# :)* =6*0'2 5= 23;*12%:31%:65& 6& :)* 2%9* :%&E >3: 6& % 1*%4:6@* 26:3%:65& F*1* 4%0430%:*' =159 531 *<;*169*&:%0 '%:% /:)* =6*0'2 5= :)*

:1%4*1 45&4*&:1%:65&8 %&' =159 :)62# F* '*16@*' :)* &340*%:65& =03< 6& :)* 96<6&B 1*B65&A Z*230:2 5>:%6&*' F6:) :)*2* :F5 ;%1%9*:*12 %1* 6& %4451'%&4* F6:) :)52* 5= L5346&* %&' +)6006;2A ()62 %;;15%4) %005F2 5&* :5 )%@* % 1%;6' 4)*4E 5& :)* 5;*1%:6&B 45&'6:65&2 :5 45&:150 >5:) 41"2:%02 26C* %&' ;15;*1D :6*2 6& %& 6&'32:16%0 ;1*46;6:%:51A

+C7D(2. ,."/

;> H\J 45&2:%&:#W IVV# h7A /P8

4! H950 9\MJ 45&4*&:1%:65& 5= =0351*24*&: :1%4*1 4!?" H950 9\MJ =**' 45&4*&:1%:65& 5= =0351*24*&: :1%4*1 4; H950 9\MJ 45&4*&:1%:65& 5= ;31* F%:*1 4;?" H950 9\MJ =**' 45&4*&:1%:65& 5= ;31* F%:*1 489 H950 9\MJ ;*1=*4: 96<6&B 45&4*&:1%:65& 45 H950 9\MJ :1%4*1 054%0 45&4*&:1%:65&

45? H950 9\MJ 96<6&B :1%4*1 45&4*&:1%:65& 6&

:)* 53:0*: 6W @;X /@!l @;8 H\J W VAP 7 H\J &39>*1 5= 69%B*2 9A<5B H\J +b. 5= m(%: ;56&: /<#"8 =: H950K9\QJ 2503>606:" ;15'34: @!C@; H\J =**' 1%:*2 ,> H\J &340*%:65& =03< GV" W g^"V ! g!X +G H\J W IVVV# h7A /N8 <5 H\J 1*'34*' 054%0 45&4*&:1%:65& "K H\J 1*'34*' :*9;51%0 @%16%&4* !!; H\J 96<6&B 6&'*< \ _H\J _{:69* %@*1%B*} (3>* I W F%:*1 =**' 2:1*%9 (3>* K W :1%4*1 =**' 2:1*%9

A"*"#")1".

HIJ ZA b%@6'# =*D0(E 5()F7*%"<EE:# GHG# KA

HKJ ^A f*129%&&# 4E3I1$%%/J$1/*7 5()F7*%*K3 L$70M**N# f%14*0 b*EE*1 -&4# [*F n51E<EE:A

HMJ -A L5346&*# hA +0%2%16# ZA b%@6'# jA k600*19%3<# 5E$7I O4F(8P =$E1 ! :FFG# QR# KPKA

HNJ ZA +)6006;2# GA Z5)%&6# jA !%0'"B%# !O4FP S":FFF# TR AGB# TKA HPJ aA ,*@*&2;6*0# 4F(8/)$% ,($)1/*7 P7K/7((E/7KC 4F$9/1(E G? U V/2/7K *6

#%W/0I# R60*" o G5&2# [*FDn51E:FG:A

HQJ eA kA G)**&5"# LA ,A (551# !O4FP S":FFE# X AHB# KKSA HSJ ZA b%@6'# !A f%14%&:# !O4FP S":FFB# T? AXB# NKNA

HTJ -A L5346&*# LA k6@6*1# hA +0%2%16# ZA b%@6'# jA k600*19%3<# P29(E/8(71 /7 #%W/0I:FFH# HH# UPA

HUJ ^A .%00# aA ,*457# ZA b%@6'# 5E$7I O4F(8P =$E1 !<EE:# QY# TSQA HIVJ ZA b%@6'# ^A .%00# aA ,*457# b*16@%:65& 5= G3;*12%:31%:65& %&'

[340*%:65& .03< '316&B +1*46;6:%:65& =159 f6<6&B +%::*1& 5= %& -&*1: (1%4*1 6& :)* G%9* b*@64*_ g%2* 5= e&96<*' .**' G:1*%92# g*9A h&BA G46A<EE<# %44*p:*'A

HIIJ fA k509*1# ^A R*>*1# qA =F3I" 4F(8A:F<H# GGY# KSSA

Pos it ion 1 Pos ition 2

3$>,#" I? Z*'34*' %@*1%B* 23;*12%:31%:65& =6*0' 6& :)* =**' 2:1*%9 45&:%6&6&B =0351*24*&: :1%4*1A

Pos ition 1 Pos ition 2

3$>,#" H? [340*%:65&D=03< =6*0' 6& :)* =**' 2:1*%9 ?*: 45&:%6&6&B =0351*24*&: :1%4*1 /%1>6:1%1" ,>24%0*8A