Opérationnalisation d'une ontologie: une méthode et un outil
13
0
0
Texte intégral
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6) "! # %$ &' (!) !*
(7) +-,/.01.,/243+651,/798 :<;>=@gl?ABAE;DUVCEGW?HOF AEGWG6^THJ;I KMm
(8) LO?NP?UnAEZEQRZoF ;DLVCEF FTp9SAEUVG6GWdrHOq]GYsX%j;>gLg>CEtG/uWZ\[]dwvCE^Tv;>xLgCEglFTSX%UVGR;>L_aCE`]G/X%Z%b%`rcfrdMy%e1fwb\z{fhtgxi>g>jk |~}VO}1M| O}@DV~V9nw4 ~@/nDOOV1M} W¦B¤1¬/¥D£¬/ ¬/«/- Bn¤]¦Mo¦/¬/9®Y ]9¡¥£¢B¤M9B¯°¥D£¤M¢B ¥¦9¦¥\¤l±D§B²E¤a£¨B®WM£B ¤1§B ³6´1£B9 ¤M¨B
(9) ¦\¦µ¶¬/ ª¥© ¥D¥~£9¢B ¤M«9¤£o9¥£§B¬/B¥ ¤ ¥¦· ±¬/9´-¯¥¤-¤]µ-6 ¸o6¹¡O@®WE
(10) £¬>®W®W¦¨B ¤- ¤M]¦¦\BB¥l¦¤\¢Bº\År«¯9oD«/9E£¡]]ƦV¦B¤
(11) B© ¯¤¶µ¶¥£r¬/¨B¥«/¬/ §B¥DBB£¤]¡¬/¦V£ ¬/¯© «/»oB¼ \¤B½o¹¾M¬/¿9µ¶¡OÀªB¢EÁP»9¤]oÂO££¿/¨B à ¬/«/ÁTÄE¥ B¿9¥¤\ÀªBÁP¬/»9 ¥DÂY\\¦¦V¢E]© ¯£¢% ¥%] ®W«/¬/¢B¡¥D¬/£ ®W¢B¬/®W ¢E¬/MB«/£¥ Ç £È ¢B9B¡¤1£¦ ¤M9¢
(12) ¥É@¤<¬D r¬Dµ¶§/¬D¦>Ê£]¹ ¦V© ¯¥W¬/¯£ O¦V© ¢¦ £ ¬/¥YE1¦V© ¬/¡O¢Eo£ ¬/¥~9 ¤££ ¬/¥¦V© ¬/¥D£¬/ ¬/«/ ËÍÌ~ÎEÏ£ÐÑ OÒ]¥D£¬/ ¬/«/ B¤BÓVÒ]¡O¢Eo£ ¬/¥~9 ¤££ ¬/¥nÓ@Åro9¡ÆB¤]µ¶¬/¥§BB¡£¯B ¤B¹ Ô ÕÖl×<Ø1ÙRÚÜÛÜÝw׶ÞÙYÖ _FPLnKE`HO:ßâ9G/k]á@Z¶;DG9?änLnLLÜHVCE;>?HOQ^ G?àQá@F G9G/G9AEZ<LQC
(13) Zo?GHOLCoG/CEC1Z\AE;>G6UnáV^TZEán;°;>;>àAEAEG/G9UVZ]áVG/AE;>Z¶â/UOHVZoçVG9;>LSLnCBUVZ¶;DG9^CE^TGFZ?HOá@L??QRHOUVGWåD;>;>FãLVF?G9G]LVLHOLnC\G];>èFT^4CEZEI AEZEKMGW;>LVLnàHOãâ9G/G/LVZ£ZrFCEG9F ;>LVAEUÜF â/GZLVHO^ F G/G/åZwZ\G/;>`rZoUÜéO?Z£LVãCELn?p9QLn;>FTãG/ZEG9ZEZáO;>FCELnLUVãCEG9G/â^4Zd æ àì AB;>=nL;C]ZoGíãG/HOZGÜã?AEp9LVàLn^ ;>G/FTZlZEZE?;>î&Lnã^TG/;Z9êONP?`rAEGQCoCEGíGWZo;>?áVUnáVZ°AE?O^T;ãBSëVUVG\G9CE^ ^ABG;>Ln^ G/ãBZëVGã?;LVåLnG/ã
(14) ;>FTãZEG9ZE^;>^ GLnãHOG/G/Z°ZZoZo?éOLZ£C°CEp9AEQG9áVG/Z]AEâ/GZoçOG9á@LCEG9â9AoG/CBZZ G/F LnZ£CíHOâ9HOá@âG9CELnG9HVAEQ;>LnF ãLVG
(15) â9G G9LánCE;>AEG\AÜ^T^4;WI UnAEZEG9;>áVàAEGâ/æ]ZoG9G/LZECBZo;DG9CELF CE?F LG9^ ^HOG9G/QZrG9ãL?CÜLVLn^T;ï;>FTZEAEZEâ/;>ZoLn?^ãUOG/CEZ1F ?GCrL^ G9HOUVGAráVUOAECE?F ^ =VFTZE^ ;Dp9QCEF ?G/LRZ9ê\?`rá@Gâ9CoABCE;DG d CE_4FcO?q
(16) LV`LVG9k1^ ^HOGlG
(17) á@ãG9?AELVQLnG;>CWFTZE;>ZE;>F LnLnZoãF¶G/Z¶^4I F F LLnCEHOâ9â9àá@ABG9;DLnCEFHV?;>L LCEHVG/;>ZwLnHOZ%G/^ Z-G/ZQc~â/éOã9;>Z£CELVp9FTQZoQG/G/Z Z-ì ?á@qâ9;ABZo;DG°CE?HOF GAEG/`rZ¶?á@LV?LnUV;>åDFT;>ZELZECw;>LnèãCEAEG/G Z QFT`rZG9G9á@LíG9LnðWHVUV;>å~LAEC/GæD^ ZoG/UVZ¶A
(18) ?ãLG/CEZ
(19) ?^ HO?G9àAEF LVG/Z¶F p9HOAEG/GZ9HOê ?QR;>F LVG_P^ F QF CEâ9G ì UVLãBën;>QáláVAEâ/ãFTZ1HOG^T;6ã?LVLn;>FTZ£d ^4?ZEI;>Uó;LnZE^ãZoG?OGk1ãABFT;>Zo;D?FTCEZoLF ??CrLVLãLVG9?G9LLnQCEñAEUVG9G]LG/HOClZ-?Oá@;>ã?UïUVUVQZoArG9G9ZoF LLïUVCBáVZ9HOá@æG?^T;%AoòCEãG9?G9AwQ=Í?QlURc~G9UVAEAEG9LVå~LnFTFTã9HOã;DG/AECEG\Z9F æ<?á@LYã??ZEG9QZoLF CEQ=VAE^ G]GG\;>^ ^ G\àGÜG9CEHOLAB;>â/CBZßãF CEAE^G9F?åQàG9FTG9LãLCYF G9Cr^TánHOZ<;>G
(20) ZoAlUVAEA¶GG/çOS^ G]G9UVQèòCEáVG/G9^Z9= G æ ^^ G/?Z%àF ZoG/á@Zrâ/HOã?F ä@F åã9G9;DLCEFC]?èLnCEZ6AEG%HOGlUOCE^4F I ^ ô%FTZoLâ9G/CE?Z^ ã??àQéQòG6G9= AEG/ZE:<Zo;>?LVUVàABUnãG\;>àá@G?UV_aô\Aò^ G%:wAB;>æJFTZog>?tLVtLVgG9kQênswG9UVLC/FTZEæSG9UV^ ^ GlG/Z]^ G/HOZ%??F åLG9CEL?>Cd á@LVG9?^TUVZ9åæ@?CEF?A<UO?>CWõG9AELF A1AEHOG/G/Z£Z<CB;>NP?LAECWQHOG/G/Z<Z?AEá@G9â9áVABAE;Dâ/CEZoF G9?LLVCBLV;DG9CE^ F ^ ?G/LnZ<Z%;HVHO;>GRáOãCE?â/LVZ¶Ln;>;>UOFTçlZEZEHO;>F Lnõãâ9G°AEG9;>LUCBZ¶LVUnF åZE;>G/à;>G/UZßã??á@Lnâ9ãABG9;DáOCECEF ?UVLOG9d^ _a`rën;>AE^ GC/æg>ttxkêD:wI UOCEF ^ FTZE;DCEF ?L?á@â9AB;DCEF ?LVLVG9^ ^ G\HJI UVLVG\?LCE?^ ?àF G]LVâ/ãG/ZEZoF CEG\HO?Lnã>æ>á@?UVA.
(21) . ãBHVën;>;LnSZrUVUVGrL;>^TáV;>áVLV^ àFTã9;>;DàCEG
(22) F ??LYá@HOâ9ABF õ;Dâ9CEFAE?G9LVLLVCEGG9æ^@ZoHO?G6LYAE?G9á@áVâ9AEABâ/;DZoG9CEFL?CBLn;D;>CEF^ ?FTZEL;DCEHOF ?G6Lßãæ9?ã>LVI G/LnZ£;>CoFTd ZEì ZEdM;>HOLnF ãAEGwGlZE_P;\F4ê GCEABê~;>UVLnLZEã^T;>AEFLVáOàCE;>F ?àL G HOZoG9?>^ CE?â6LÜHJUVI UVLíLVZEGãâ9ZoLnâ9QR;>AE;>F ?LCEHJFTSI UnUVZEG%;>à?Gá@â9áVABAE;Dâ/CEãF ?FTZ9LVê LVG9^ ^ G
(23) GC\ZoUnZEãG9áOCEF =V^ G6HJI èCEAEG6GçOâ/ãUOCEâ6ZoUVA]QR;ãBëVF LVGk CBCEF;>?:ßLLnC\G;>ã^áVFTGZEAECo;D?CECE=VG%F ^?CEp9L ABQ;>HJLnG°IZE?G/ãLZ£AECWCEF áO?;>CE^ ?^F ??àABLßF Z6Gê~HOy6CEG/G;>Z£LnCEHOâ9Z]âGlänãLVG^ ?C\F AWAB;>Z%^ AoG/HJCEZ6FTI ãUVQ^ LVGGlâ/æ~ã9LVG;>?çOLVUná@FTZrZoâ9QAEáVF AEG/G9?LnZ6á@ãHJG°?I Zo?HJ?á@ILn?â9ZwABá@;DUVâ9CEABLVF ;D?GCELnF Q?;>^LnâFTZE;>CE;DëV^ FTCE?OZEF ;DHO?CEGLF ?HJá@LíI G9?AEHJá@QI â9UVABGLV;DCoG dd ?`rL?CELn?ã^ ?G9áOàCEF G-UVHOG9^TG-ZR^T;\_4c~à? â9?;VQæ â/CEjAEF u>G\v~_ ke ê<V`rABGZ£CoC CEGRGçOá@æDâ9g>AEtF G9tLnxãk@GRHV;>;íLnãZJ?^ GrLnHOã9UV;HOF C AEGwì HO^TUW; QHOâ?OänHOLVp9F^ CEGrF ?HOLóG/Z HO6GRABAE;>p9áVàëV^ G/G/ZZ HJZoUVI ?áVá@á@â9?ABAo;DC CEFì ?Ln^T;°;>^ QFTZE;DFTZoCEGWF ?G9LRLíHJ?~I UVG9UVLVå~G6AE?GLHOCEGY?^ ã?G/àZF G
(24) AEp9HOàG^ G/HOZ?HJQRI ?;>á@F LVâ9G%AB;DGCECF ?;>LnUÜ;>HO^ FTâ9ZEå;DCEG9F^ ??LßáVá@ê G9QG9LCHJI UVL?UOCEF ^ HJZE;I ?:<åL?;
(25) CEF AJZo?UV^^ ?G/F CEZ¶àGrF ;DG°HOçOGrGF ?C°ãQG;C¶G/å;>Zw?AoF_ CEAWãFTN£ãZoêD^ ?ZoG-UVG/G/ã^ Z£F CEàC¶F LV?Z£LlâCEAEgUn^4I kFãQæ/CE^TUV;
(26) á@AE?â9LVAoGwâ/CBãã;>G/?LnZEQãZoGRF QCEârHJGrHJI UVZoI UVUVLïF LVC/HOGrê/G[
(27) âCBáVZo;>G/AEá@ZYp/G]Z<ãHJ;?åQI ??á@á@F Aâ9?ABF ZEL;D;>CECELAEF ?CB?OZLnHO;>UVG/^ ZEF FTC<ZoZEG9;D^T;\LCECEF LV?F G9?>LW^TCEZ9HOF æ?G/Lì Z ?_ ãLN£CEê1?Zo^ ?G/ãàCEF G/F ?ZrLïG/Z£xC%kê1; R:<;AEQZoâ9G/GãCEæOF G?C\L ^ G/vZ
(28) GHOçOF õá@?â9AEZoG9GLUVCBZ\LVGZEãQâ9Lnâ;>CEAEëVF ?OFJHOHJGI UnNPZE?;>AEàQGWG9HJ^ ^I GUVLVHJGWI ??á@Lâ9CEAB?;D^ ?CEF à?F LnG6;>áV^ FTAEZEâ/;DãCEFTF Zo?â/L Z HV<;>?~Ln?OZ`r? ^ Gã9;HJHOI â/AEHOGF CEHOF ?ULíQGC%?OHOHJp9I ?^ Gá@â9HOABG/;DZCEF ?6LnAB;>;>^ FTáVZEëV;DG/CEFZí?L`r?HJLnI ?ãLG9CEáO?CE^UV?G9à^TFZ9Gæ]êOF e¶QF LnáV;>^ â9^ G9QQG9G9LLCEâ9C/GóæV^4IHV;>;>áVLnáVZ^ FTã9^4I;D?CEUOF ?CEFL ^ GHOçOG/áVZ%^ QFTãFâ/CEã9â9;>GLVê FTZoQG/Z%HJI ?á@â9AB;DCEF ?Ln;>^ FTZE;DCEF ?LíáVAE?á@?Zoâ/Z ì ^T;åD;>^ FTHV;DCEF ?L HOG/Z%?LCE?^ ?àF G/Z\G/Z£C . .
(29) . . . . . . . \Öl× hÝ]ÙYÖ J׶ÞB׶Û×¶Þ "Ú £ÛÜÖ ÙYÖl׶٠٠YÞ Ú ÚÜÙ. !#"!$ "&%' . (. ). *. ( . +$ +, . ( . .-. YÞÖ
(30) LVG]?LCE?^ ?àF G-HOG]HO?QR;>F LVGwG/Z£C<CE AB;_ HO6F CEAEF UV?=@LVG9G9^A/^ æ G9Q/jG9jLxC¶kHOê1âfwän^LV^ G F G]HOãâ/?ãQAEF QCRGr^ G/UVZRLVãG ?LVLn;>FTZEZE;>LnãG/Z HJì I UVUVLRLRHOHO??QRQR;>;>FF LVLVGG ánì ;>CEAoABCE;FTåãUVG9AB^ FZ¶G9UVA-LHOG
(31) án;>ã?AB;LVHOLnF ;>àFTQZEZEG;>Lnãã?G/LnZ]ãG9_PF4áOê GCEUVê>G9UV^VLLVG9?LnL°ZoG9?Qlá@â9=VAB^ ;DGCE=@F ??LVAELVLVG9â^4Gê Cr<ã??U ëV£?â9UVAEG9ABLZ1Cw^ F HOâ9GG ãHJ?I ;>LV=@Ln?;>ABFTH ZEZE;>^ G/LnZ°ãG/áVZ\AEFHOQ?>CEF CEâlF åHJG/I ZlUVLVCEGlG9AEZoQâ9QRF LV;>?L^ ?CEàFTSFTSUVUVGlG/ãZl?HOLnUÍZoG9LnHOZo?UVQRG9^;>^ FGLVkGænæ-UVã>LVI GYG/Z£?CoLd ì CEdM?HO^ ?F AEàGF GY^ Gíã?åL?OCEã9F G9;>L=VC\UV^TCE;>?F UOAEGC ãHV?;>LnLnãZRG9áOLVCE?UVZG9^4CEêrAB;y6åD;>;>LnUOçJZæw^ G ^ Gã9å;?OHOã9AE;>G=VHOUVU^T;>F ánAE;>GíABã;?HOLnF àãQG9áOGíCEUVfwG9L^%CEG/F CEZ£âCÜdMb\Z£CEG9AE^TUn;DãCEFCE?UVL AEâ _a`rG9LëVG9UVLßLæ /G9j~LniZoG9Qlkl=VUO^ CEG F ^ FTHOZoâG GçO[ FTZ£CBã;>GWLC\LVFG9åLærG/CE;>AEAEG9UÜGWáVãCEAEG9G/â/AEZ\ZoQG9ãL?F CBLVLn;>?ãL^ G9?CáOàCB^ FTG/Z9SZê UVG?= HO£?GF CBC6ZZ9HOI ; U£?HOUO?CEG9QRA\;>UVF LVLíGG9ærLnGZoCÜG9QlUV=VL^ GYG9LnHJZoI G9Ql=V^ G HOG GçOáVAEF QR;>LC ^Tán;°;Z6Zoâ9UVQRL;>Lã9;>CEFTABS;UVãGCEp9HOAEG°UÜZ£HOCE?AEQRFTãCE;>G9F QLVGG9êOL:ßC6G/CEZ G9AEQF LV?^ ?àFTSAEUVG9áVGlAEGâ/CYZoG9ZoLá@CEâ/G9ãLF C]änG9^ G/LZ\CWã^T?;LVN Ln;;>ñFT?ZELZE;>HOLn?ãG/LZwCLß^ G/I ;Z6éáV;>AELF Cd QUOCEF F CE^ FFTåZoâ9G/G/Z]Z6CE_4G9cAEQCB;F ;>LV= ?^ ?àFTSUV;>G/G/HVZ\ãBHOëVU GæOHOg>?tQRtt;>kF LVêGRq]F_PG9F4êLÜGênS^ UVG/G%Z\á@ã?G9LnUãF G9LáOCECBâ9Z\àAEGâ/C
(32) ZrAE;>G9UO^T;DçRCEF ??LLnCEZB?kr^ ?á@àG9F UVG/åZ G9£LUnC
(33) ZESèUßCEAEI ìG áVàFTAESâ/UVZoG9G/LZC/Gæ<Cl^ G/HOZ°FTZ£;DCEçOF LVF ?àQUVG9G/LZ°ClZo^ ?G/LZWCl?G/LZECEZo?G9^ L?CEàF FG9G/^TZZ HOì G/Z^T; CEëVZoá@G/ZEâ/;>ãUVF ä@AEã9Un;DZ9CEæßF ?SL&UVFwHOLVGÜGãAE?G9LVáVLnAE;>â/FTZoZEG9ZEL;>CELnG9ãLG/CYZWS?UVLGCE?HO^ G/?>Zd CE_aG9`rAEënQ;>F AELV^ G?C ^ ?àF G/Z%æ;>g>^ ?tABtZ%xSkêUV`rGlG^ G/ZoZ6?L?C-LCE^ G/?Z1^ ?;DàçOF G/F ?Z\QF LG/CEZ1p9SàUVAEG9FOLá@CG9AEHOQG/ZGCoãCE?G9LVLLnC-;>åFTâ9ZEAEZEF;>CBLn;>ã=VG/^ G9Z
(34) Q;>UG9LZoC1G9^4LnI UOZ%CE^TF ;>^ FTAEZEà;DG d CEF ?L?á@â9AB;DCEF ?LVLVG9^ ^ G6HOG/Zr?LCE?^ ?àF G/Zrã9;>A %'/. ( . 0 >@? A =B
(35) C67;=B67
(36) D2B A 8E1F38<;=G25HIJFK47
(37) 3. . YM. PQSR PTU VXW. &
(38) . L. M. N. O. CZ T[<\YVX]<QSR W. M \Y^@]<QS_`TW. bac. &1325476 8 9:6738<;=. \Y^@]<QS_`TW. BM. ed A =1Ifg1IJh ij
(39) k=B
(40) l25
(41) A :
(42) nmI2B ;8oJ
(43) H A =C67;=B67
(44) D2B.
(45) >g t:ßtG/tZ6kê ;D çOF ?QG/Z\á@G9UVåG9LC6AEG9áVAEâ/ZoG9LCEG9A%HOG/Z%áVAE?áVAEF âCEâ/Z
(46) ã?QQlUVLVG/Z
(47) ^ F â9G/Z6;>_ UOqç ;ãBãëV?FLnQãG9?áOLCBC/Z æ GãC1?Ln;>ãUOG9çWáOAECEG9UV^TG9;D^ CE^ G/F ?ZwLnHVZ9;>æLnã>ZrI G/HOZ£CoG
(48) d ì LVdM?HOQlF AE=VGrAEHOG9G/UOZ<çRáVHOAE??QRáVAE;>F âF LVCEâ/G/ZßZwåHOâ9G%AEF ãän?â9LVG/LnZß;>ánFT;>ZEZEA1;>HOLnG]ãG/LVZ9?ê~Ql`r=VG/AEZwG9áVUnAEZo?G/áVZßAEáVF AEâFCEQâ/Z9F æCEF SåUVG/GZ LV=V?AEFTUnSZ6UVG/áVZ°AE?HJá@I UV?ZoLV?GíLnZAEG9HJ^T;DI ;>CEFáV?á@LhG9^ _ G9ZoA é~Qâ CEAEF Gæ1AEâ nGçOF å~F CEâæ¶æ<CEABá@;>G9LnUVZoåF CEG9F Lå~CWF CEèâCEkAEæ1G^T; ^ G/áVZAEáV?AEáV?AEáVF âAECEF ââíCEâ/HOZG ;>^ àâ d ZáVoF AEàF LnQ;DF CECEUVF åAEóG/GWZ6GG9_PC6L^4CEI ^TF AE;LnGÜãã9?ã;>Q?ABLnHOánãF ;DLnG9CEáO;>F ^=VCBF Z°CEF ^ âlF GCECHJâ6
(49) I G9UV?LU&LVCEGlAEG9G6AELG9HOCE^TAEG9;DGUOCEF çAE?G9LßáV^T;DænAECEF^4QFI ?GçVFLnCEãZ9F å^ æ¶UnG/^TZoZ; F å~àF CEâ9âYLVGâ9CGAEC6FTã^4FI FCELnGâíCBãZw?HJQNPI UV?ánAEL*QR;DCEã;>F ?=V^ LnFTF Zo^ãâ9F G9CEG%áOâlán C G9;> /LA]æ-CEAE^T^T;;G NPHO??AEQRQl;>UVF ^ LVG GYHOGl^T;Ràâ9?Qæ^4âI GCEAEçVF ãG^ æVUn^4ZoI F;Då~çOF CEF ?â
(50) QánG;>A-^Tê ;xVê NPY?AEHOQlGUV^ G kês-;>AwGçOG9QáV^ GæHV;>LnZ-^ G HABJ;>I UVáVL á@?á@Ao?C F ìLC ^T;Üì HOUVAELV?GÜF CEGHOêßAE?`rG/F Z£CEG9C]GRAoCBUVá@;>LVF ?G%LnAoZCEáVGAEZE?ãBUVëVáVLVâ9AEGFQRâCEáV;â6AEZ6?HOHJáVG6I AE;Dã9F çOâ;>CEF AB?âHOQF HOLnG/G;>Z6^ ã9F ZoCE;>? â ABLHO CF^TLn;YF L;>AECE^ G9F â9CE^TàâR;DAECEâ9QF ?G/LFZ6LVHVFHJQl;>I ;>LnUVáVZ6Q án^ ;>G/HOAoZ%CEGÜG9NP?LngíAE;>QRánLn;>ã;DGAd ^s-FTZo;>QA\G/GZçOG9HOQGÜáVAE^ G9GáVænAE^Tâ/;ZoG9AEG9L^TCB;D;DCECEF F??L L&HOGíã? LV
(51) Ln;>;>FTáVZEánZE;>;>LnAB!; ãTCG/
(52) ZY;>UOUnCEZEF Zo^ FTFßZo=Vâ/ZF G9Lá@?HVUV;>ARLnHOZ\â/^ ãG/AEZ\F AE^T;>GÜLVHOàG/;>ZàG/?ZLUOCE?CE^F ?^ FTàZE;>F G/LZ9C ê ^ãG°G9UOánç&;>ABS;UVHOF\F àUOQCEFGl^ FTZofwG9LLCECRF CE^ âGÜdMb\ánG9;>^TAB;D;CEHOF ?F àLÍQ_PGÜán;>HOAG/GZRçOeVG9ABQ;>áVQ^ G°G/ZÜ^ G/_PZ án;>6ARAB;>GáVçOëVG9QG/ZYáV`r^ G?Lnô%ãK£G9:¶áOkÜCEUV_ G96^TZB?k%QS#G UV"Gdas1HVG9;>AELn#G "Z yQG9%LG/CYZ
(53) æ ;>áV/áVjAEán?j;>áVuABAEk!; F ê âTCECEAEâ/GlZ]GáVCWAE?èáVCEAEAEG/G°Z\F Ln;>U ã^ UnHOZo?G/QRZW;>HVF ;>LVLnGWZ6HO^4GYI ?ãL?CELV?Ln^ ?;>àFTFZEGZEê;>Ln[
(54) ãF G/LnZZoF4ãæß?^4LnI ;DZoçOFTHOF ?â9AEQâGRá@gOG9UVê åê G9L$C
(55) â9 à;>^ Gd &% (' &) *'+),% .0/ +LVGAEG9^ p9åG%án;ZHJI UVLíZEãBëVâ9QR;°HJI ;DçOF ?QGã^T;ZEZoFTSUVGên`rG9á@G9LnHV;>LC/æ~F ^ HOHO?UíF C
(56) HO?èCEQRAEGY;>F FLVLnGãê ^ UnZ%HV;>LnZ\^4I ?LCE?^ ?àF GWã9;>A
(57) F ^<án;>AoCEFTãF á@G ì ^T;HOâänLVF CEF ?LHOGY^T;RZoâ9QR;>LCEFTSUVG dìHVM;>[
(58) HOLnF FZlAELnG^ZoG ^TF4;æVHO^ N G/?;Z\QRñ?;D;>LRçOF F LVHO?GQ?ê LG/CrZ^ ;>ZoG/á@FTZwZ°â/áVãá@AEF F?änQUVG9LAF CEC
(59) F UOå^TCEG/;F Zw^ ZoFTZoZoâ9?G9QRAL;>Cw^ LG/UOCEZCEFTFS;D^ FTUVçOZoGWâ9F ?G/HOQZwG/á@G/ZZ°?áVUVHVAEArF ;>QGLnçOFZ°CEáVF UVåAEFLG/QZ\cOG9ãArq
(60) ?LnHO`%ãG/æ1G9ZráO^Tã;CE?UVLVZoG9â9Ln^ QR^ ;>G/FTZ9;>ZEæVLZE;>ã>CELnFTI G/SãZ£UVG/CoG Zd ^HOZoG/â9GÜZ%QRQR;D;>çOL;>F CELV?FTQFSáVUVG/UVGwZ%^T;DHOZoCEâ9?F á@?LL*G9C%LnUOHOHWCEG FHO^ FTGwãZoG9â/^4UOIZ6?ç~= HVdM£;>ãG/F\LnãZ
(61) CEHOF ?^NOG°F ?Cá@ã9;;>â9UnHOAB;DAEZECEGlZoFF?HOèLVGlCELVAE^4G9GÜI ;>^áVáVHOáVGwAEâ/^ ^4FTãI ã9;>FT;DZoáVâ9CEáVGF ?^æ-FTL ã9ã>;DIG9G/CEL~FZ£?å~CodLßFTìZEæ;>dMG9HOà^ F^â9AEGwGGLVêV^TGwsw;á@UVNG9FT;ZEUOSñC¶UV?èL*G°CEAEãHOGwG?CoF LLOCEGCd ä@ãì ^ ã9UnUV;DZoLVCEG]FG ?HVL°;>LnHOZ¶G\^4ãI ?GCoLCECEG
(62) ?^Zo?â9àQRF G;>æLSCEUVFTSFOUVHOG?ãF C-?æVHOLn;>G9HOUnQUVZEFZoG9C/F@UVæ HOAEì G9â9CEA¶LVAB?F ;LnQåHOG9Qâ9ABá@Z<â9G9GUVLnL°HVáV;>LAE?OCEG\ãG/HOZEGrZoUnCEZ1G9^THJZ¶I ?= £G/ãCEF N Z9êD:<;6]Zoá@HVâ/;>ãLnnF Zd æ ãG9AoCB;>F LnZrCEAB;åD;>UOç _ q;ãBëVF Q?LC/æng>tttkê 1 £3Ù 2 Ø ×¶ÞÙYÖ Þ ×¶ÞÙYÖ Ú £ÛÜÖ ÙYÖl׶٠٠YÞ Ú ÚÜÙ YÞÖ A ?
(63) = ;=B6 38<;=. >
(64) I1 ;n254 Hn38<;= 1G; A. HnhDKL
(65) I1. A ? 8ol25
(66) A A 8 g171F;X6 8<
(67) H. 4 ijg1 >@? Fm8<;ij
(68) I1. 1F6. 1 A. 1F;i&2B38<;=. ¬(P1 ∧ P2 ). j. ij;8o= 1 >
(69) A mN25;8o=5<1. P1 P2 P1 ⇒ ¬P2 A H A =B
(70) > Hn;8oJ
(71) 8o f( A d. . 1F;HIJ
(72) >
(73). e. 3.
(74) . 25;8o=5
(75) I1I
(76) =53Hn
(77) A =+25;8o=5 A =B
(78) ki ij
(79) > nH ;8oJ
(80).
(81) A = 25;8o=5!
(82) I1 25;8o=5<1.
(83) !. d S8 A = n225HI38<
(84) =5=B
(85) =5. . YM. YM o;n254 Hn38<;=B 8E1F38<;= ;=5J; ;nKL8<
(86) 67;i&2 A J38<;=5=B
(87) o
(88). ;=5J; ;nKL8<
(89) ;n254 Hn38<;=5=B
(90) o
(91). . *. " /. (/+$ /. *. ( . +$ +, . ( . %'/. ( . HOZoâ9?QR
(92) QRLV;>;>G%LF LVCE?FTGSLænUVCEF?G6Ln^ ?HONP?àâ9AEFá@G\QG9LßLnG9^IHVG/^ GW;>Z£CLHOCES?G°UßLHOIC\UVG/G/LVZ6Z£G%C%HOAEF HOõG9?>áVâ9CEAEAEâ9â/G9GWZoLG9CE^4LG/I ?CBZ%L;DUOCECE?FCE?F^ ^?LRFTàZEã;DF G?CEFLnZo?ãG9LnG9AoZ%áOC CE?ì UVá@G9Gâ9^çOAB^ G%áV;DCEAEHOFF ?G/QZrLVG9LVãA\G9?^T^LV^;G/LnZ
(93) Zo;>â9FTá@QRZE?ZE;>;>ZEZoLnLF CEã=VFTG/^SZwG/UVZ9HJGWê@I UV:<HOL;G 0. 4657!8+9;:68!9;<;=?>&@6A;8!A;BDC E#7!<6F:67HGI!JD>KBKGC >LFM8N GO!P*<Q>R=MGJ,ON C 8!JD>SG8!9;<65.
(94) . QR[\än;>L LVF áVHJUVI F ^TL;DCECEâ9F à?AELG9AWHOG/UVZ%LVáVGAE?F QLCEF CE?F ^ å?G/àZ6F Gã?;>LnU ãG9ZoG9áOF CEL UVG9HJ^ ^I G/UVZ9L&æZocOâ9q
(95) QR`%;>æßLCEF ^]FTSãUV?GlL~å~SF UVG9F¶LCYG/Z£HOC6?^ LnF â9ãRG°HO;>GRU CEHOAB?;>LnQRZE;>ãFAELVF AEGG ê ãG9^ ^ GdMãFHV;>LnZ<UVLVãGr?NPLn?ZoAEFTQZ£CEGrGY;HOHV?;>LnáOã>CEænâ9GHJIì UVLV^4I GWUnZEán;>;>àAoGrC/;>æ Unì SãBUVëVG9?^FTG/ZoZ£F AC1UVHOL G/Z£CE^T;>F LVLVâ]à;>^ GàcOGq
(96) HO`%GWê>AEG9`ráVGAECoâ/CEZoG G9LCB;DCEF ?L ?^HO?á@Gíàâ9F ãABG ?;DLVCEì F Ln?ã;>LVGFTLVZECZEG9;>^]?Ln= ãã£?G/G/LnZWãZoCEFT?>F HONõâ9ABG9AE;>LâLGCáVC/AEHOæ-â/G/ãHJZ°FTIZE;>;>QUOLCEâ/CAEã9GÜ;>^T; LVánFT;>ZoZoâ9QAoC/QRG/æ ;>Z°ì LHOCE;GÜFTHVS;>UVQRáOG;>CELVG9HOA°F GáV^TUVQR; ^T;D;>AECELVG9F ?áVF áVLÍAEUVâ/Zo^T;;DG9HVCEL;>F CB?áO;DLCECEâ/F ?HOZ LïG/ì ZHO^4;DGÜI ?çO^4=F I??£QG/LãCEG/CE?>Z9F dN æ Zoô%â9á@QRâ9;>ABL;DCECEFFT?SLnUV;>GR^ FTSZoUVG9A\FwG/UVZ£LVCYG°^ F?â9LG CE?ì ^ ?^4àI ;>F áVGYáVHV^ ;>FTã9Ln;DZ%CEF UV?LLcOG9L~q
(97) å~`%FTZEæ;>ã>àI â9G/G°Z£CGHOCl?LVLn?ãYL ^T;;>UóáV^ HO??LVQRàG9;>A6F LVHVG;>LnãZ%?LnUVZoLFTHO^Tâ9;>AELOâd ê àHO;>â/àãAEGwF åD?;>á@Lâ9C\AB;D^4CEI ?F ?= LV£G/LVãG9CE^F N¶HOGr?á@AEG9â9áVAB;DAEâ/CEFZo?G9LVLLVCB;DG9CE^ßF ?HOLYUHOcOGq
(98) ã`%?êLVLn;>FTZEZE;>LnãG/ZßZoUVF åD;>LC¶UVL°ZEãâ9Ln;>AEF ?%HJI UnZE;>àG AB;D:wCEeVF I???LVá@çJLVâ9æ G9AB/^;D^ jCEGljF ?=VLnFkG9;>ê L^
(99) FTZEHO;DL*âCEänF ZE?LVãLYâ9F GLnHJæJ;>I UVã9AEF;>LV?óABG];HJ?ãICELUnâ9CEZEAE?;>FT^ Zoà?â9GÜàGYF GwHOánâ/LV;>ãA6GAEFZoUVC GL ìã?SLnUVñ?G9F^ C1^ G/SZlUVänG]Lná@Z?UVå?A¶6LUVCLVáVG]AEèâ/CEUOãAECEGíFTZ°F ^ FTUO_ZECE6;DF CE^ AEFTF UVZo?â9LVLlG/F ZLV?á@à^ G9G/âAZd ãZoG9?AELVå~LnF AY;>FT^ZEG/ZEZ°;>Ln;DãçOG/F Zw?QZoá@G/â/ZlãF HOänGâ9G/^4Z]I ?HVL;>CELn?Zr^ ?^4àI ?F GLêßCE?fw^ L&?àGF GõæGã>C/Iæ1G/Z£^T;Cod ì AEdMG9HOáVF AEAEâ/G
(100) ZoG9G/LZEZoCBG9;DLCEFCE?F G9L ^ ^ G9HOQG/Z°G9LãC?LVì LnS;>UVFTZE?ZEFn;>åLn?ãLG/CZ CEá@G9?AEZEQZoF F =VLV^ ?G/^Z9?ænà^TFT;SUVAEG9G/áVZAEHOâ/U ZoG9LHOCB?;DQRCEF ;>?F L LVGHJILVUVGL HOãâ9?á@LnG9ãLnG9HóáOC6án?;U ZWHJHOG/I UVZWLVQlGlUVAEG9^ CE^TF;DáVCE^ F G/?ZYL ãâ?CBL;>CELGC6ç~CE^T;G/ZWQ;>è9áVQáV^G°FTã9HV;D;>CEFLnN ZZ ^ì G%^Tã9;;áVZwAEHJ?OI HOUVUnLãZoCEéOF ?Z£LCEp9QHOGlG%ãHO?â/LVHOLnF â;>FTì ZEZE^T;>;WLnåDã;>G/^Z9FTêVHVc~;DG9CEFUV?^ LRG/Z
(101) HO^ G%G/Z
(102) ã?AELVG9áVLnAE;>â/FTZEZoG9ZE;>LLnCB;DãCEG/F Z1??LnUZ]?HJá@I UVâ9LAB;DZoCEéOF ?Z£CELVp9LVQG9^ G
(103) ^ G/HOZ
(104) â/HOHOG/F âZ ;DçO[
(105) F ?F QLnZoG/F4Zæ/UVHOLY?F ;DåçOG9F L?C\QèG-CEAEá@GWG9UO;C<HV;>èCEáOAECEGwâ9G/UOZ CEF ì ^ FTZo^4âI ?æ/= Zo?£G/F C<ãCEá@F N-?UVHOA G^4I ;>áVáV^ FTã9;DHOCEGwF ?LVLÜ?UVG9åL~G9å~^ FT^ ZEG/;>Zßàãâ9?GLVê Ln;>FTZEZE;>LnãG/Z9æ ZoHO?UF C
(106) HOá@??QRUV;>A F LV G°ã
(107) ? LnZo°FTHO^4â9I ;AEHOâê@â/Ss-Un;>;DA6CEFG?çOL G9QHJIáVUV^ LVGGlæ^4ãI ;D?çOLVF Ln?;>QFTZEG ZE;>Lnê ãGHOánG ;>A
(108) AB;>áVá@? AoC ì ^T;RZoâ9QR;>LCEFTSUVG ' H% ) - &á@G9UOCèCEAEGíUOCEF ^ FTZoâ á@?UVARF LONPâ9AEG9AR^4I ;>áVán;>AoCEG9Ln;>LnãG HOG á@án;?ZF LCBãZ ?LOì NP?UVAELÜQáVG ^T;>ì Lßê~^T;&KM^Zoá@â9G9QRUOC\;>Lâ9CEàFT;>S^ UVG9G QG9HOLG C]^Tá@; G9AEàQâ9?GQCoCEâAECEGAEFHOG GZoHOF4âæ]CEHVG9AE;>QLnZF LVUVG9A\LhSãUß?I LUVCELGç~â9CELVG?Ln?ãîhâ%HOLßG9I G/UOZ£ç C á@Lß?I ;>F áVLCBánZ%;>Ao;>CEáVF G9ánL;>CAoCEánF G9;LVZ
(109) LV;>G9UÜLC áV^Tì ;>LßUVêLVG°HOAE?F CEGlGC ì UVLáV^T;>Lßæ@UVL CEAE?FTZoF p9QGlá@?F LCHOGl^T;HOAE?F CEG cSOUnq
(110) yl;>`%^I F;>æßänUO?âCEU AEHJG
(111) IèánCEAE;>GAoC/;>æáVUVáVL^ FT;DSæçOUV^ FGâ?QZo;>G/UOG
(112) ãCE?á@?LnG9QRHUO;DCrHJCELßIFTSI èUVCEG9AEQG
(113) G9UOLCECYF ^ FTánZoêâ6;>:wAYSI ;DUß^ GçOI ì F ?ZoéO^TQ;YZ£CEG HOp9G9QQRê xVG;>êê<Ln:ßHOGRG% áVHOAEG
(114) G9^4QI UOF CEG9F AY^ FTZEUn;DZECE;>G9àUVGRA]G/HOZ£U C ?ã?=VLn^ F ZoàFTG9HOA
(115) â9AE^4G9I UOACEFHO^ FTG/ZEZR;DCEá@G9?UVF A LCBì ZR;>Zo3áVUVáV AR^ FTá@UVSG9LVUVUOG G9CWA6HO;>ZoAEéOF ?LnZ£F ZoCECEF¶â9GQRæ-èCE?;DAEU*CEGlFTSUO;>UVCEU*G9F ^ QFTãZo?â°G9LLHOCECABGl;>ãNGF AE;CGíñ;D?HOçOLGÜF ?F QNQ;áVñGl?^ FT;LÍãåDF ;>CEGG°LçOCáVá@^ HO?FTãUVGlF A6CEá@GLV?GlUVZoF\åán??;F L ZA G9HOLíâ/:wZoSF I AE?UVGá@G/â9Z£SCEABUßF;D?I CEF Lß^-F ?æVéLnán;>AE;>^ G/AFTãZEG;D?çOCEUVF G9AE?QGL6áVZoHJéO^ IGYZ£UVCELVHVâ9Gw;>QRLn?;DZLCECEFTUV?SLí^UV?G9=VàQUOF G1C
(116) G9LVLá@â/CWâ/ãHV;G/åD;>ZEZo;>àF L?CEGwCWàFTHOHOS?GUVLnGá@ã1ê ?^ GwUVåãBëV?F?AF çJQRæá@;>LV?UVF áVA<UVãB^ ënG9AW;S^ G/UVZG-;Dá@çO?FF ?LQCBZ Gæ åDHJã?;íI UVLnèL ZoCEFTHOAEGâ9AEQG9AFTZYZo?G9LL CR ðWUVå~AEGê<S:ßUVG/F¶ZláVHOAEâ/F õãFTâ9ZoAEG G9Lì CBZlSUVã??F<LåDCEG;ç~ZoCEG9G/AEZYå~HJF A%I Un^4ZEI ;D;>çOàF G?QSUVGYGGCWLV?HOUnG°ZWSáVUVAEG9?^ á@^ GY?ZoN ;?ñLn?ZYL HOF G ^ ^ G ã?LCEGç~CEGóHJI UnZE;>àG ^4;I ZE;>ZoáVG9áVAoCE^ FTF ã9?;DLnCEZF ? LHOGY^4I ;DçOF ?QGYZoUVA
(117) UVLVGY=n;ZoGlHOGWN ;>F CBZ
(118) á@??îhUVA
(119) ^4áVI UOAECE?OF ^HOFTUVZE;DF AECEGlG9UVHOA GYHOLVâ/?ãUV^ G9åLnG9ãB^ ^ ëVG/GZ Q5U. VX]<QSR \ [<]<WX\YVX]<QSR. Z \. YM. YM. a. YM. !. 1F674 =BHI8<; >@? A 1FFK
(120). 0. YM. ]<R. \ [<] T Z. > ? A =B
(121) > Hn;8oJ
(122) Gn225HI38<
(123) =5=B
(124) =5 @
(125) > Hn;8oJ
(126) n 225HI38<
(127) =5=B
(128) =5 α. T^ U [<]<P] XV T A ij;8o= 1 >
(129) A m 5 2 ;8o=5<1. b O A = 2B =. Z T Z. α. ]<_GU[<]<P] VXT. 67;=5J
(130) nmJ
(131) >@? A 1FFK
(132). ]<R. 3. Z TRBVX]<T[(TV#T^ U[<]<P] VXT. #d S8 >
(133) A m 5 2 ;8o=5<1 ;H71J; A ( 1
(134) I1 25 ; 8o=5<1 >
(135) . . d. A H A =B
(136) > Hn;8oJ
(137) e8o f.
(138) ^^ G6GYãZoéO?LZ£CECEp9GQç~CEGWG6ZoHJUVI A\UnZEUV;>LVàGWG =n;ZoGWHOG6N ;>F CBZ\á@?UVA\áVAE?OHOUVF AEGW?îHOG^4I ;DLVçO?FUV?åQG9^G
(139) ^ G/G/Z\Z£C;ZE;>ZoáVG9áVAoCE^ FTF S?UVLnâ%Z án;>A ^ Glã?LCEGç~CEGYHJI UnZE;>àG
(140) GN/;>Z£FCwCBZ
(141) HOâ/HJãI ^ UVG9LVLnGWãBëV=nâ9;G]ZoánG;>ánA¶;>^4AI UOABCE;>F ^áVFTZEá@;D?CEAoG9C
(142) UV;>A-Uíá@?HOUV?A-QRã;>?F LLVCEG A ^ G9A¶^T;6?î ã?^4LOI ;>NPáV?AEáVQ^ FTã9F CE;DâCEF Zo?â9L QRHO;>GWLCE^4FTI S;DUVçOGF ?HOQG/GZ ^ G6ã?LCEGç~CEG%HJI UnZE;>àG
(143) ^ánGí;>A\ZoéOABZ£;>CEáVp9á@Q?GAoC\á@;>?U UVAHO?ãQR?L;>CEF A LV^GG9ê Al^T;ã?LONP?AEQF CEâÜZoâ9QR;>?LîCEFT^4SI ;DUVçOGÜF ?HOQG/ZYG
(144) NG/;>Z£FCCBZ;>áVHJáVI UV^ FTLVSGÜUVâ
(145) =nán;;>ZoGA á@F ^O?G/
(146) UVZ£LA-C-ãBá@ZEënã?;â9ZELnSZoF ;>UV=VAEG^ F G\?Y;DHOçOHJG]F I?UnäVQZEçO;>G]G9àA-áVG%AEánãâ/;>?ZoA-G9LnLHOZoC-FTâZ£N HVCE;>G%;>UOLn;>CwZ¶F ^LnG^4ZoI ?QFnLG9è9CELQ?^UVG\?LàãF ?G9GLnLêDCEZoy6GG9ç~Ql;>CELn=VG\Z¶^ HJG%^ G\I HOUnã9G6ZE;;>ãZ1à?HOG]LG/á@CEZ-G?ç~ZEUVãBCEA1ëVG/Zrâ9CE?QRHJUnI;UnZ1Z1ZE^ G/HJ;>Z-àI ;DG%;DçOçOãBF ?FëV?Q?QFTG/ZoG/FTZ9ZZ æ HOZoé~GQ^4Iâ?CELAECEF G?^ HO?GàFAEGG9^TAE;DG9CE^ F G9?åDLl;>Lá@C°G9UVHOåGG9LãC-GèZECEãBAEëVGrâ9CEQR?Un;VZ1êßUOs-CE;>F ^AlFTZoGâ/çOZ1G9á@Q?áVUV^A1GF æ<LO^ NPG/â9ZlAEG9;DAwçOHOF ?GQLV?G/ZWUVåGG9çO^ áV^ G/AEZ¶F QRAEG9;>^TL;DCECYF ?UVLnLVZ9G ê QáVUVâ/y%^ ã9G9Gí;>AYLVQR^ FTG/Zo;>ZlQLVãG/F ?p9ZYAELVGF LnLO;>NPàâ9FTâ9ZEAELVZEG9;>â9LLnABCE;>ãF G9^G/G^TZWZlæ¶HOUVGGRCLVGNHO;G/NPñ?Zl?AELóQQâ/áVGã9^ Un;>?LVZYá@FTâ9Zo?ABQUó;DCEG/QF Z°??LVHOFLVGLnG9Zl^åD^ ;>GÜ;>^UOFTHJHVCE?I ;DUVQRCELVF ?Gí;DL CE?FTSLá@UVCEG9G?AEêß^Q?s-àG;>CoF GCBAY;>ãGL?çOCRQlG9HOQ=VGFáVLV^QRGíGæ<;>HOLVUVG/FL Zd ZEHOãG9â9å~LnAB;>;%AE?>F ?õAEãF ?A AEìAEG/^4ZoI á@UOCE?F Ln^ FTHVZE;D;>CELG9C UVì A-^TUV;6LVá@GY?;>ZEáVZoFáV=V^ FFT^ã9F ;DCEâ
(147) CEF ?HJLíI ;>áVHJáVI G9^ LnFTSZoUVG9FG9àA-LV^ G9G/QZ-ãG9?LLVC%Ln;;>ZEFTZoZEFTZEZ£;>CELnâãánG/;>Z¶A\HO?URABHOHO?F LnQR;DCE;>G9F LVUVGA á@GC°?UVHOA1G/ZlG9Lã?HOLâ/CEHOA UV^F AEG/G\ZWHO;>GUOLVCE??QRUVå;DG9CE^ FT^ SG/UVZ¶G/?ZWU°G9á@Ló?UVNP?A1LnåDã;>CE^ F FT?HOLßG9æ<A-G9ZoL?CELlAEGCEAB;;>åDUO;>CEFAE^4G/æZ9Gæ<C-HOáVU AEâ9LVåF ?åF G/A1;>HOU G/Z1HOFGLONP^4â9I ;>AEG9áVLnáVãAEG/GZd LnHOGW;>LáVC/UVêDAEy%GWG9åDUO;>ç^ FTã9HV;;DZ¶CEFG?ç~LßCEæVAEè9?Qî G/^ Z1G/Z
(148) HOG\ã?ZELVãâ9LnLn;>;>FTZEAEZEF ;>?LnHJãI G/UnZ]ZE;>?àLG]CE?á@^ G9?UVàåFTSG9UVLG/C-Z\èZoCE?AEGLC
(149) HOFTUOZ£CECEFF ^LVFTZoàâ9UVG/â/Z\,Z á@ D?^ G/UVZ-A
(150) ZEåDã;>â9Ln^ FT;>HOAEG9F A F UVAEG9LVLG6CEF =nG9;^TZrZoG6F QHOáVG6^ NFTã;>F F CECBG/Z]Zán?;>îA]^ABG/;>ZáVãá@??LVAoCLn;>ì FTZE^TZE;°;>ZoLnâ9ãQRG/Zr;>?LLCEFTCES?UV^ ?GàHJFTSI UVUVLÜG/ZrHOZo??QRLC;>F UOLVCEGF æ~^ FTGZoCâ9G/^ Z]G/Zá@ZE?ãUVâ9ALnáV;>AEAEF?OF@HOF UVLOFNPAEâG d HOy6G°;>LnLVZW?UVãåGRG9HO^ ^ G9G/AEZ6LVãF G9?AYLVLnã9;>;FTZ9ZEæJZE;>SLnUVãFwG/G/Z%Z£CYZoUVãAG9^ UVUVLFrHOã9G/;ZWZZoHOéO?Z£LVCELVp9QâæJG/ZEZ;>GLnçOZ%á@F G9LAoCECBG9Z9AEæJå^G9G/LZCEF F ?LOL NPâ9AEHOG9GLn^4ãI G/UOZWCEF ;>^ FTUOZECE;D?CEG9QRUV;DA/d ê CEHOFT?SQRUVG/;>ZRF LVZoG?LGC
(151) CR;>ãUnG9LnãUVZoâ9LVG/GWZåDáV;>AE^ FT?OHVHO;DUVCEFF AE?GíLÜHOLßG/I ZRG/Z£C\ã?LVLVâ/Lnã;>G/FTZEZEZEZE;>;>F LnAEGãêG/Z°ã?LONP?AEQG/Z ì ^T;óZoâ9QR;>LCEFTSUVGíHOU HO_ G/:<kZ°æß;6;DUVänçOLVàF GR?UVQAEâGCBG/;>Z9á@ê-áVGR`rAEHJâ/GíZoI FG9ZELOLãBNPëVCEâ9Gâ9AEQRG9^ G
(152) Ln;ãZEG/ãBAEZWëVG9â9á@àQR?UVZoFT;6HOGâ9àZoG/â9UVZLVAâ9ánABUV;>;>LVAW^OGHJ^4I IUOâ;>CBCEáV;>F áV^ á@FT^ZEGÜFT;Dã9CE;D?G9CEî&UVF ?A^4LI UO_4HOgCEkFG/^ æßZ1FTZEUVNP;D?LVCEAEG9GRQUVâAG/CBZ1;>; ?á@£á@?GUOâ9HJABCE;DGÜI F CELOFHO?NPG/â9LVZYAELVG9NLnG9;>^ ã^F G/G/CBZZZ G9;>LUOCENP??QRLnã;DCECEF FT?SL UVG/HOZYG_ ^4xI Unk\ZEG;>C6àGUVLV?GlUÜâLVCB?;>L á@G°HJHOI ;DGlçOFåD?;>Q^ FTHVG/Z;DCEHOF ?GYLã?ZoLG9QCEGFç~dMCE;>GWUOCEHO?GQRåD;D;>CE^ FTFTSHVUV;DCEGYF ??LÜUG;>çOUOáVCE^?FTãQRF CE;DGCEFT_PSv~UVkG ê £3Ù 2 Ø ×¶ÞÙYÖ Þ ×¶ÞÙYÖ Ú ÞÙ YÞÚ ÚÜÛ Ù Ú Ú Ø 32 {ÙYÖÜÝ 2×¶Û ZoHOUVG/y6A1Z ^;>6G/LnZ1ABZWáV;>ãáVAEGF ëVLnCoG/CEãZGF á@`rZoG/G/Z¶?ãLnâ9CELVFã?G9?LßáOLnæJCEãUVLVâ/G9Z1?^TUnZÜáVZAE_ â/YáVãAEâ/`]?HOZBá@G9k?QêrZoQ?`rLnGG9Z%CoLCEC1UVGLVQRQGR;>âFTQZ-CEëVâHV?OCE;>ëVHOLn?OGZ¶HO^G/GRG\Z£C°HJã9;I F ?HOLná@AEZoâ9G]áVABF án;DAEâ9;>CEGÜFAo?CELnFTHJã;>I UVUV^ ^FTLVFZEG9G;DA-CEGFHO?çOU°Lá@Qâ9NPAE??OF LnG9HOLnHOp9â9ã^ GGG CEáVG9ABLn;DZoCEFFT?SLYUVGlHOUYHJI Q?á@?Oâ9HOABp9;D^ CEGrF ?HOLnG/;>Z ^ YFTZE;D`]CEZ9F æ9?^TLí;6HJc I%UVLVd4N Gl;>Q?LF ^ CEé?^ _ ?qà;>F GYàGHOC Gl^T; àUVâ9à?LVQF G9âA/CEæAEFg>G ttì g^4kI ê9;>:<FTHO;6G°c HJ%I UVd4NLV;>GlQGF ç~^ é d. ]<R. Z TRBVX]<T[ TV ]<_GU[<]<P] VXT. T. \ [<] \YVX]<QSR#T^ U[<]<P] VXT. T. . . \ [<] \YVX]<QSR`]<_GU[<]<P] VXT. 0. . k. M. . . . *. !$ . " /. (/+$ /. ( !. /
(153) ( !. . ( !`/ : . %' !. $* /. ( . ( !$. %. 3. . . a. . .-.
(154) . Début du cycle. L'utilisateur ajoute des faits (éventuellement aucun) à la base de faits. 1. 4. 2 L'utilisateur déclenche l'application d'un axiome (éventuellement aucun) de contexte inférentiel explicite. 3. . Validation automatique ou partiellement automatique à l'aide des axiomes de contexte de validation. Saturation par application automatique des axiomes de contexte inférentiel implicite. %e.
(155) 6 f6
(156) >
(157) Hn8E1F;=5=B
(158) ij
(159) =5 > = 1 A = 38<;=5=B
(160) o
(161) X. A 38o 8E1F=5 A =B
(162) j;=5J; ;nKL8<
(163) b;n254 Hn. /GHJZ£I C6UVLVUVGLánNP;>?AoAEC/QRæß;>HO^ GFTZoQAEG9GYáVAE?â/á@Zoâ9G9ABL;DCECEG9F A?LVHOLVG/ZG9^1áVHOAEGlF QAEFG9CEáVF åAEâ/G/ZoZWG9ãL?CBLn;DCEãF G9?áOLCEUVHOG9G°^ ^ G/ã?ZWLVZoLn?;>UnFTZ%ZEZENP;>?LnAEQãG/GRZ%HOSGRUVF¶ãá@?G9LnAEãQG9áOGCBC/Z æ CEG6FTC%SABHOUV;>áVGYGëVAEHOG/G9GRZ\^T;D`rQRCEF ??;>LnLnLVãZF áVG9GáOUVC/CE^Tæ@;DUVCEHJG9F ^TI?Z9;>L ênUO`rCEHOAEGGGWCoCEánãGG/;>ZQAoC/áVâæVCEAEHOëVF QGY?OHOAEF CEG9GWF áVå;lAEG/â/Z âZoCEG9ì â6LCE^4F IQG9;>AFTáVHO^ ^G/Gâ9Z%QHO;DGRG9çOLFAECE?p9â9QàGW^ G/G/HVZZ;>GLnGçOC°Z]áVUVHOAEFGLÜQRã?;>?UOLLCEC\CEF ^JAB^T;>;RHJF I LZoâ/â9CEHOQRG/F ZWCE;>F ?HOLOL G d G;>CL HJô%I ?Lá@CE?â9^AB?;DàCEéF ?\Ln;>F CE^ FTëZE;DCECEëVF ?GlL&`rHJ?LnI ?ãLG9CEáO?CE^ Un?;>à^ F GÜ6=nAB;>;>áVáOëCEFTZo â ?O<HO?~G9?O^w`r_ e? VABæ-Z£C/; æVg><t?~t?x^]kêVCE?&`rGô%C\á@?G9UOABCE;DF ^CEF á@?G9LnAE;>Q^ F "9GGC ^4GI C]â/HOZo?F CELRF ??Líá@àâ9ABAB;>;DCEáVF ëV?FTLnS;>UV^ GWFTZE;DHJCEI UVF ?LVLGYHV?;>LLnCEZw?^^ ?G%àQF GW?OHVHO;>p9Ln^ G%Z\HO^ GYG/Z ã9Y;HO`]AEGYZr;>HOáVU AEp/ánZr;>ABZoá@;HOâ/ãF àF ä@Qã9G;DCEfwF ?LLCEF HOCEâUdMb\ZEãG9â9^TLn;DCE;>F AE?F L? àðWHJABI UVUn;>å~ZEáV;>AEëVG6àG/GRZ6^ GYãBãëVã?éO?LnãFTãZo^ G9GWF4áOê HOCE
(164) UVGWLïG9AB^T;>ZlQFTZo`r?>?CE? LVG96LVUVG9KAl¶QHJ;G9IX FLLOCNPâ9áVAE_AEG96â/LnZoG9ãG9LVGLG/CE=nZ£âC ;G9ZoLâänZocOUVà;>AYUV^ åDAE^T;DG ; C/æ ^ Fê /=VjABj;>uF AEk
(165) F GRá@HOG9AEGQQRGCY;>LVHOF GáVUVQ^T;DGCECoF CE?AELïGRG9HOL G HOb\UíG9:<^THO;D;\CE?HOF QR?âL än;>LVF G9LVF LCEGF ên?:ßLYGHOUWå?Oåã9?O;>ã9=V;>UV=V^TUV;>^TF ;>AEGF AEG1ã%?ãGLn?C ãLnG9ãáOG9CEáOUVCEG9UV^JG9G/^Z£HOC%?FZ£C<CEAEáVUnAEãâ/CEãUVâ/AEHOæßâG9F AJLnZoG9^Tã;\^ ^ ?UnZoLÜZWá@â/^ AEGWãG/FZoánä@á@;>ã9G/AB;Dã;CECEHOF F ?åF LWàG9QQHOG/G6G9ZßLfwCW;DLçOHVCEF ?F;>CEQLnâZd G/Z CEUVF LnUVLVZ£AEG\CBâ/;>Z%ëVLnF ánâ9ãAB;>G/;>Z6AABHOUVãBëVG/LVZ%F G°G\C£AEHOé~G9Gá@^T;DG/C£CEé~ZF á@?HOLG/GRZrãHO?G
(166) Lnãã?G9 LnáOãCBG9Z%áO_P^GCBG/CZ-Z%C£GCEé~CrG9á@AEUVG/QLVZG\G/HOZ ëVG°F â9AEABG9;>^TAB;DãBCEëVF ?1F G\LnGZBCHOkGêJC£y%é~G/á@Z6G/ZrF Ln HOZ£G\HOCB;>â/AELnZoG9F ã^Tà;DG/LVCEZFG9?HOLLnC6G/Z-Z%FTZ£ãC£CEFwé~AEá@HOUnG/G/ãZZd èQRHOCEGAE;>GWãL?CE?FTLnLSãCEUVG9?GláO^ ?CBHOZràU FTá@SHOG9UVUV?G/åQRZ9G9æO;>Lã>F CILVG/GèZ£CECoênAEd s-ìGdM;>HOHOA
(167) âF AEGänGçOLVG9SF G/QUßZIáVG9HV^^ G;>^ G/æLnZ Zr£UV?G/UVLVZ£C%G9GLUV?C%LVLUVCEGl?LíF^ Ln?A Z£à^CBF G;>GYLnæHVQRã;>GY;>Ln?FTZZ]L^TCEã;R?G/^Z]HO?âFàLnänFTZ£SLVCBUVF ;>CEGYLnF ?ãHOLG/U Z]HOC£HOGWé~?á@^TF ;RåG°G9ZoHOLâGCd ã?:ßLnG/ãZWG9áOãC\?LnLV?ãG9QláO=VCBZAEGWGCYHV;>AELnG9Z^T;D^4CEI F ??LLnCEZ6?^ á@?G9àUVF GåG9HOLGCW^Tè;°CECEAEAEGF àUO?CELVF ^ ?FTZoQâ/ZâCEá@AEF?GUVê AWâ/ãAEF AEGRHOG/ZàAB;>áVëVG/Z%GçOáVAEF d QR;>AE;>èCELG/CZ9êHO
(168) G/ZYLN ;>ã?F CBUVZláV?^ Glî HO^ GWG/Z°àãAB;>?áVLnëVãG9G/áOZ\CBá@Z°G9ZoAE?QLGC°C%HOHOG/GYZlAELVG9?~áVG9AEUnâ/ZoHVG9Z°LCEHOG9U&A\UVàLAB;>áV;DçOëVF G?QGC°Gæn^ G/;ZlåG/AEã6G9^T;DUVCEL F ?àLnABZl;>áVHOëVG/GZ CEë~QF é~å?Oá@G/HOZ1?>p9CEG^ ëVGCwp/êD^ ZoKMG/GW^TZwZ¶GZoá@C%F àG9UVAELnQL ;DCEGàUVCoABAECE;>G/G9áVZ1LëVCrHOGYG/HOZ-G\ã?AEãG9Ln?^TãQ;D^ CEUnánF ?Zo;>F Ln?AEZ1G9LßA¶Zoên?^ :ßG/LZ-G/CrZ
(169) ãHO?áVG/LnAEZ-ã?;DG9áVçOáOAEFCBF ?âZ¶QCEGâ/C-G/Z\Z-AEHOG9HOGl^TF;DAEZoCEG/UVF ã?=nCELnZoG9Z¶?QQGG9C/áOLæ>CwCEHOF GF?LL QRCEâ9G9;>àLLVAECEFâ/AEp9Z1GWAEHVG]áV;>àAELnâ9F QZ-LVâ^ F G dd AB^ G/;>Z]^ G;>æUO^ G/CEZßAEG/àZrAB;>áVáVAE?ëVáVG/AEZF ánâCE;>â/AßZrUVHOLV?GwF å?G9á@Lâ9C]AB;DèCECEF AE?GLHOHOâ/G ãAEF CEG/Zrán;>A]°UVLÜ_ ã?UVUVàáVLV^F G6G9A HOG6à`rABëV;>G9áVF ëVLßG/æ Zr/jã?j LnãkêG9<áOCE?UVUOG9CE^TG/Z9Z æ . . @. 0. . (. . . :. . . N. 3fn25
(170) I1 >
(171) b67;=B67
(172) D2B<1. 3. a. . . 3fn25
(173) I1 >
(174) jHn
(175) 38<;= 1. G1F;HIJ
(176) >
(177). j67;=B67
(178) D2B. M. jHn
(179) 38<;=. . π. 0. 2BHn;F
(180) 76 38<;= <. a. . O .
(181) UVHOG/L ZàZoAB?;>QáVëVQGRGCBë~Z°é~á@ã??>LnCEëVãp/G9ZoáOGCBZGC°ã?UVQLïQlàUVAB;>LnáVZ9ê-ëVG:<; ã?änLnàãUV^ UnAEG ZoF ?g LßæßáVAE^ G/â/Z°ZoG9HOLG9CEUOGÜçóUVLÍàAB;>;DáVçOëVF ?G/QZWGíâCBHO;>UÍLClHO^ ?F â/QRZY;>ánF LV;>GA HOHOGG9Q^T;G9UVàAEâ9GW?Q;>UÜâCELVAEF F åGG/ê;>KMUÜ^-G/?Z£LCWCE?F Q^ ?á@à?FTSAoUVCB;>G%LáVCYUVHOFTZEGSUVLVGY?>CEZEG9;lAWNPS?UVAEQGG^T;ÜLVAEGYG9áVã?AEâ/LnZoHOG9F LCECBF ?;DLVCEF LV?GL ánHO;GRZã^4GI UnCYZE;>;DàçOGF ?SQUVG F G9LíZoG9AB;YN ;>F C/ê. Og. . . 3-. . . L25476 8 9:6738<;= >@? A =Fm8<;ij
(182) + ? 8 >
(183) >
(184) 5;X;Y ;
(185) I1.67;=B67
(186) D2B<1N
(187) Hn
(188) 38<;= 1 n 225Hn8E171F=5 1 A H ;= > 6 8oHkHn
(189) D2BHn4I1F
(190) =5J
(191) =5 ? =5J47674 >
(192) =5 >
(193) e ? Fm8<;ij
(194)
(195) I1e67;=B67
(196) D2B<1e
(197) Hn
(198) 38<;= 1 n225Hn8E171F=5@1 A H ;= > 1F;i Hn
(199) :Hn
(200) D2BHn4I1F
(201) =5J
(202) =5
(203) !67;= 1F4 A
(204) =5J &1F4 ij=538 A
(205) >
(206) (67
(207) eFm8<;ij
(208)
(209) I1I. 1 A 8 =5J
(210) l1 ? 8o!
(211) nm8E1IJ
(212) >
(213) A m 25;8o=5<1 > 8 N4 Hn
(214) =5<1b
(215) >
(216) A m > Hn;8oJ
(217) I1 > 8 N4 Hn
(218) =5J
(219) I1 J
(220) 1 A
(221) j
(222) k2BHn
(223) i 8<
(224) Hk25;8o=5en225HI38<
(225) =5 6 6 A =B
(226) >
(227) I1 > Hn;8oJ
(228) I1b
(229) A
(230)
(231) >
(232) A m8<h ij
(233) k25;8o=5en225HI38<
(234) =5 2BHn
(235) i 8<h Hn
(236) > Hn;8oJ
(237) N
(238) >
(239) A m8<h ij
(240) e25;8o=5.= ? n225HI38<
(241) =5 25g1 j >
(242) A m8<h ij
(243) > Hn;8oJ
(244) X. . &. . -. . -. . 6). . 3- 6). èáVCEAEAE:ß?GWáVG/Z<ZoAEá@F ;Dââ/çOCEãâF ?F änHOQâ/UZ\G/C£ZZoé~GF á@QçOG
(245) áVáVAEHO^ FG9G\QRQAE;>G9G9LL^T;DCßC
(246) CE^ F G9G/?LíZßLßáVê>F LnAE:w?HOIáV;DFTSAEçOFUnFâ?;>CEQLâ/ZJC
(247) G\;>^Tã;°^ à?â9áVAE=VAEAEG/?AEZoFTáVSá@AEUV?F âG/LnCEZJHVâHO;>G9G/LL ZJC-C£ZoSé~G9UVá@ABG/;6G/Z£ZßCE;>FHO^ ??GwLíABAEZ1G9HVà^T;>;Dâ9LnCELVFZâ9?AE^TLn;°â\Z;>=@á@UO?MG9CETCUVE?åGYQRG9HOL;DGCd CEánFT;SZ UVG9ì QUVG9LóLCwZEãBGëVC]â9; QR£?;UOCEáVâ\AEâ/HVHO;>âLnänZ-LV^ F1G\á@ánG9;>UVLVåLVG9G/L;>CWURèHOCEAEG/GZw;DZoá@çOâ/F ?ãQF änG/â/Z9Zê>HV:ß;>G/LnZ-Z%;DçO^ GF ?ánQ;>G/LVZ1LVLVG/;>G%Uã?HOAEG/AEZG/Zo;Dá@çO?F Ln?HVQ;>G/LZ9C ê s1g>t?tUVxARkê áV^ UnZHOGHOâCB;>F ^TZZoUVAR^4I ?UOCEF ^ <?~?O`r? æ-LV?UnZRAEG9L~å?Dé?LnZl^ G ^ G/ãCEG9UVA ì _ e VABZ£C/æ QF:<CE;lF åG/AEG9ZláVHOAEâ/GZoG9AB;>LFTCBZo;D?CELVF ?LVLRG9Q?á@G9Lâ9ABCY;D?>CEFõ?G9LVAoLVCEG/G9ZY^ ^ G6ánHO;>AlG/Z^T; ;DçOc F ?%Qd4N G/;>ZrQAEFG9^ á@é+? ZoG_ ZokWUV^A]G/^Z G/ZrCEAE?FTZrC£é~á@G/ZHOG6áVAEF d M. N. . . . PQSRBV Z \ ]<RBVXTW UlQSWX]. .
(248) . æ ;åG/ ãUVLàAB;>áVëVG\ë~é~á@?>CEëVp/ZoG
(249) GC]UVLà AB ;>áVëV.)G
(250) ã?Lnã^ UnZoF ?LHO?LCr^T;lZoâ9QR;>LCEFTSUV+G
(251) / G/Z£C HGVC%;>LnUVZlL ^ àGíAB;>HOáV?ëVQRGW;>ãF LV?GLnk ã_ ^ZoUnF _4LVZogF ??kYL L ^ G/^THOZ;?Lã?C%L^TCE;RAB;>Zoâ9F LQRCEG;>LLßCEIFTG/SZ£UVC°GYánG/;Z£ZWC AEG/Zoá@æ1 G/;ãåCEâ9G/GãR GUVC LÍàABLß;>áVI G/ëVZ£GClánë~é~;ZYá@?>åDCE;>ëV^ p/FTHOZoGG AE`rG/?ZoLná@ãG/G9ãáOCE â9CE GíUVG9G^T.)CZ
(252) _PAEp9àLß^ IG G/Z£YC`ánk;æZ;ååDG/;>ã^ FTUVHO LRG/ àHVAB;>;>LnáVZëV G^ Gë~HOé~?á@QR?>CE;>ëVF p/LVh_ZoGG\k G%ZoCrF _LVUVx?Lk°Líà^ G/^TAB;Z ;>áVã?ëV LG\ CEãAB?;>LnF LãHOCE^ G6GUnZoLß6F ?I G/ABLRZ£;>C\HOáVán?ëVL;G/CZZ ^T; Zoâ9QR/ ;>LCEFTSUVGG/Z£C -ê . .) áV^ FT^ZEFT
(253) ;DSCELVUVG9GYâ9UVGlA°AEp9án_ àZo;>^ UVAoG CEA6?YUVUO`LC6?â9á@î ^ G9â9UOQ;>C%áVG9èánLCEC;>AEABGHO!; ?UOTC%LVCEFLV^4^ I FTâ°ë~Zoé~â9HOGWá@Gl?>F Q^TCE;RëVáVp/=n^ ZoFT;G°ãZoF G°CEHOG9GlãQ?^T;G9LnLZoAEC%FTp9HOàánâ9^;>AEGâ9A\k\G^ k?GYê UZo
(254) éOGLVZ£çOCEG°áVp9^ QãFT?ãGFLCECEG9_ ABã>Q;>I G/F G9LZ£LCoCECdGì ándM_Pá@HO;>A%F?AEZoG^4F I CEUO;>F CEåáOF G dd ?AEF Uänâ9LVG%â9àán;D;>CEAoF CEå?GUOkwC]á@HVG9;>UOLnC
(255) Zrè^TCE;lAEG6=n;UOZoCEG%F ^ FTãZo?â9LnGWZo;>FTHOUOâ9CEAE?â9QRGk-;DCE?FTUSUVåG9â9QAEF G9änLâ9C\G
(256) ánGçO;>AáV^ ^ FTGWãF ZoCEéOG9QZ£CEp9G9QLC Gì _ ã>^T;lI G/Z£HOCoG9d QRì dM;>HOLnF AEHOG%GåHOâG d ^4I UOCEF ^ FTZE;DCEG9UVA/ê HOHOG/GW
(257) Z\AELVG9;DG^TçO;DF CENP??F Q?FTZLnG/Z9Z^4æOI ?G^4LçOI ?CEáVá@?AEâ9^ F ?QRABà;D;>FCEG°FL?C\ãLn?^T;>;Ln^ FTZ£ZoZECEâ9;DAEQRCEUVF F?;>CELLG°CEá@ánFTSG9;>UVAEAYQGWZoGá@HOC6GWâ/ãHOQRF GWä@;>ã9àLV;Dâ9FCELVáVF ?â9UVLAE^TG9;DA\HOCEF UUV?LíL å?OHOG9ã9LnG/;>ZZo=VG9C£QlUVé~^Tá@=V;>G/^F GYAEZ\GHOHOãGWGY?AEãLnp9?ãàLnG9^ áOãG/G9CEZáOUVGCBG9C6Z^1HOGGGCC ãHJ?I F LLOCENPABâ9;>AEFG9LLnCEãG/G/Z\Z9_Pê F QáV^ FTãF CEG/Zr?UGçOáV^ FTãF CEG/ZBk1á@?UVåD;>LCrèCEAEG
(258) G9LnZoUVF CEG
(259) UOCEF ^ FTZoâ9G/Zwán;>Aw^ G
(260) Q?>CEG9UVA HJãG9I Un:<UOZEç;í;>àHOàGâ9â/æLVãAE^4â9IF ABUOCB;DZ%CECEF ^G9F FT?LZELó;DZoCEHOG/G9ãUVG/CEZWA
(261) F ?AEãBL p9ëVà?xV^ FTG/êZoZFT:ßZEGZEG/;>ClZ%LãNPC]??á@AELQCE?ABUVG/;>A\Z6F LãBHOCEënG/G/;Z6ZS;DG/UVçOZ£GCYF ?;DàQçOUVF G/FT?HOZ%Qâ9SGRG%UVUVánF1Lí;>?AWLãC6^?GLâCECEãBGâ°ëVç~?áVCEF GAEçóFTZoHJHJG/I UnZ%I UVZEG9L ;>LàZEG6ãã?â9ánLnQ;>;>AEáOAEQCEF ?G F CEZoHJAE?I FUVLGLCRê@y%ãHOG9G/GY^ Z%^ QRG/ZEZ°ãB;>ëVAELVG9â9F Lnp9QRAEãGY;?Z
(262) LàCEHJâ9AELVI â9;Dâ9G/çOABZ°F;>?^^ QG?æOABG/Z°^ Z
(263) G/HOZ%ãGíF ;DCEçOâ/^4IZ
(264) F ??á@G9QLâ9G/ABZ
(265) Zo;DG/CEHOãF ?CEGYFLn?^T;>;RL ^ FTàZEgOâ9;Dæn?CE?FQ?LL&âC%CEá@AEHOF ?GíGUVæV^4A
(266) éíI ?NPL?ã?CEAE?QQ^ ?GWáVàAE?F FTGÜZ
(267) LCEãHO?G9Gí^ UO?çíà^T;FTSAEG9àUV^â9G G9?åDQ;>LâCd +&GCRáV^ UnZRáVAEâ/ãFTZoâ9QG9LRC ) . VX] TW 1I8: ? fn25; Ih 1F
(268) b
(269) I1I 2BHn4I1F
(270) =5J
(271) > = 1 A C = KLHnn2
(272) ! 67;=B6 A 1I8<;= > ; 8o.4DK
(273) ij
(274) =5 3Hn
(275) 2BHn4I1F
(276) =5J
(277) > = 1 PQSRBV Z \ <] RBVXTWGR S\YVX] TW e1I8l ? fn25; hI1F
(278) I
(279) 1I@2BHn4I1F
(280) =5J
(281) > = 1 A =bKLHnn2
(282) b67;=B6 A 1I8<;= > ;8o 3Hn
(283) 1F
(284) =5J
(285) >
(286) ( jZ S[<TW N (1I8. ? fn25; hI1F
(287)
(288) I1I:2BHn4I1F
(289) =5J
(290) > = 1 A =GKLHnn2
(291) k G67;=B6 A 1I8<;= 25
(292) A 3Hn
(293) F; A J47
(294). . 0. +. S0. 0. d 1I8 =5J47674 >
(295) =5 ;H71 67;= 1F4 A
(296) =5 Nd 1 ? 8o.
(297) nm8E1IJ
(298) >
(299) I1 8o= 1IJ=B67
(300) I1 >
(301) I1 J
(302) o
(303) I1 A
(304)
(305) j
(306) 76 {xi }i=1..p {Ti (xi )}i=1..p {rj (xn , xmj )}j=1..q {Ti }i=1..p >
(307) I1!3fn25
(308) I1 >
(309) &Hn
(310) j38<;= 1N > = 1 3fn25
(311) I1 >
(312) .67;=B67
(313) D2B<1&
(314)
(315)
(316) ;H71 {r } nj mj [1..p] 8o
(317) nm8E1IJ
(318) >
(319) I1.8o= 1IJ=B67
(320) I1 j j=1..q J
(321) o
(322) I1 A
(323)
(324) {y } {T (y )} {r (z , z )} k k=1..r k k k=1..r l u >
(325) I1j3fn25
(326) I1 >
(327) b67;=B67
(328) D2B<1
(329) >
(330) I1 3fn25
(331) I1 >
(332) Hn
(333) l 38<;v= l 1 l=1..s
(334) 76
(335) {Tk }k=1..r {rl }l=1..s z ul > = 1
Documents relatifs
To test whether the vesicular pool of Atat1 promotes the acetyl- ation of -tubulin in MTs, we isolated subcellular fractions from newborn mouse cortices and then assessed
Néanmoins, la dualité des acides (Lewis et Bronsted) est un système dispendieux, dont le recyclage est une opération complexe et par conséquent difficilement applicable à
Cette mutation familiale du gène MME est une substitution d’une base guanine par une base adenine sur le chromosome 3q25.2, ce qui induit un remplacement d’un acide aminé cystéine
En ouvrant cette page avec Netscape composer, vous verrez que le cadre prévu pour accueillir le panoramique a une taille déterminée, choisie par les concepteurs des hyperpaysages
Chaque séance durera deux heures, mais dans la seconde, seule la première heure sera consacrée à l'expérimentation décrite ici ; durant la seconde, les élèves travailleront sur
A time-varying respiratory elastance model is developed with a negative elastic component (E demand ), to describe the driving pressure generated during a patient initiated
The aim of this study was to assess, in three experimental fields representative of the various topoclimatological zones of Luxembourg, the impact of timing of fungicide
Attention to a relation ontology [...] refocuses security discourses to better reflect and appreciate three forms of interconnection that are not sufficiently attended to
