EUGENE: a STEP-based framework to build Application Generators

Texte intégral

(1)EUGENE: a STEP-based framework to build Application Generators Alain Plantec, Vincent Ribaud. To cite this version: Alain Plantec, Vincent Ribaud. EUGENE: a STEP-based framework to build Application Generators. 1st Australian Workshop on Constructing Software Engineering Tools, CSIRO-Macquarie University, Nov 1998, Adelaide, Australia. �hal-01078451�. HAL Id: hal-01078451 https://hal.univ-brest.fr/hal-01078451 Submitted on 11 Sep 2015. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés..

(2) .

(3)

(4) "!$#% & '(' #$!%)*+!$-, ./, 012. 53 47698;:=<?>A@CBD:=<%EGFH47IKJML%:ON%E PRQTSVUDWYX[Z]\ @CB^: PRQ_SÙCa b :[BcN?8d>]@fe E?@ \gX BhJd@^<%Bc@ \îRS 6kj[lnm i]o m o j[p SÙ @ \ >DqV@CE?@cr iRb]U :=<%Bc@ X[Zs\ @CB^: a t=uwv N%:xJyE?@ 8;:{z |[N%:O<]@ i%o m o lnl SÙ @ \ > i$b]U :=<%Bc@ }~ :J8 a C 8;:=<?>A@CB iU JdL%:=N%E$[N]<?Jd ~ L U @ \ >C4 U 3 ]U J8 iRt l i m[m[j DAc^ ¨¡CÄc¢[¾;`Â§T³AÈ[´[ÀcµºC¶[Äh^É7¥A Å¨·¸³h¡C°¢¤Ê;¦¨^£¡¦ ¥A®§¨¢[¥5¥AË§¨¦T?^¶[ ¥A¡CTA¶H¦¨ª©§5«nc ^¥A¦_¨§¨^¡¦¨¢n¥h¢[§¨«wd§D^[ §¨¥HT¦¨^¡=§ ¨«[¥h¬n®±¥hAA¨¥Aª§`©¢=¨^§D^ ¢5¢=¡CÌ?¢[¨¡¥§5«[«¢=¥A^¦ ¨T¹¡wÍ¥A[§ «%¨¦¨¦¨´¡=¬n«[A¬[¨h¬[¨¦ §¥A§d[d¦ ¡C£¹¦_¥h^«®¯ºC§»½°¼«[¾¿»d¡=ÀCAÁn¬[ÂC®±ÃA»d¥hÄh¢xÅÆT¡Cc¦² Ç `¢Ç ^n[¹c^¨¡¢Î£¥A¢[¥A¦T^ ¡C¦5Ì[¬[«[¥A¦¯¡^Ï]¥A¦¨§{GËyc·¸¨¡¸«[¥T©¢[¥§ ¥hAª©^ ¡C¢0M¢[£C¬?^£C¥h§±^¢[« «[§¨^ÑC§¨¥A§ ¥h¦¨¡=¹¥hÍCA¨d¡C^¨¢n¨¡C¥h§_¢«w³D¡¡CÊK¢^¦ A§¨¨¡=¥A¶[«[¦ §§¥°$´§ ¨¨¡¯¦ µR¬[¥A«[A®¯¥A¨§¨¬n[h¦¨¦¨d¥C^´Ì ¥A¥±Ð§Ò¢h¢[¡C®±«5¢=¡C_¨§ ¦TV¹c¢*ÍCÌ[¥A¬n¦ ¹§¨¥D«[®¯¥h¨¹¦¨Ó=¶n§ ¥°R¬[«n®±¦¨¥¯¥A¥A¦¨T¡^ÍCcÊK^²®± h¡C¡C¡=®±¢«[®5¥A¹§Æ§9^§ ¢[§¨ «n¦¨¥A§¬[hA7¡C©? ?¬[¥A¥A«¤¦¨¦_¥±Ë¨¢[¢[¨«w¶£ ¡¡±¥A¢Î®±§¨ ?n¶[¥AM¥wAª¨Ê;¥A®¯·§D¥A¨½_¶[¡CÔ¥¦ ² ®±¡=«[×O¥AµV§ÕØÙÚ¢[«5§DÖC^¦¨¢¤¥c^Ð¨ÖÒ×nÛ h¡x«nÜ¥ÝCÞ«[ÝCÞ5¦¨¥Ah§ _¨·±¢[«[^¬n¦ «¤¹¢5«[¥h ÍC¶[¥A¥Æ¡C[?¦¨¥A¡=«ß«[¬[¨h¡¨§Êà´ A¹T^¨¥Dn¦¨¡=«[¬[AD¢=Ê¿¡C¦¨®5^ ¹¡¢w§¨¶?^¦¨¢[£ Ìx¹¢=·¯ ¥A§¨¢[?«[¥A¥AA«ªÊ;·= ¡5¢[£D§¨_§¨¬O¢[á±«A¦¨¥A«[¢=VäA¥D§¨¥hA®H¡¢[Â¢=¥A n¹`¨¬A¡C¢= §¨¥A¨¦ ¢=¬[AÊ; ¡¬[¦¦¨¥A«§D^T¡DÊy^¢=¢[Ê¿«5¡C¦¨¨®5¶n¥A^ ¦¹¡¬[¢[§_§9£C¥A¥C¨´¶[ÙR¥A¦ ^¦ £C¨¥h§V¢[¡¥AÊâ¦¨Ð¨C×[°$Ûã¡C¦åÜcËÝCÞC¹ Ý¶[ÞÒ¢2¦¨¥ §¨¡C¬[£CÌC·=æT°¥h®HAK^¢[¦¨¥·Ò5½¢±¥C´ ¡£ÌC´$æT®±¥AA¥A`T¶¡C¦¨¢[¥A¢=A §_¥A³h«5´×=®±_¡=¢[«[«¥A^¦ ¢[«[£ÆäAM¥A«5¢[£C¬?¦¨^¨£C§Æ¥Æ^ç¦ ¥KèV¥héÓxênç9¦¨¥Aë[§ ëH§¨¥A«¢[Ë«w¨¶H« _«nD¥A«[AA^¥A § ¥A§V«5¢=¨¨¥A¥AT¦ì¶[Êà¢nÂ¡C¥ª² ´ ^ç ¢[îÕ«*×OïµV ç¶[Øð`¥wÙÚç®±°] ¥A¨n¶?T¹¶[^¥h¢[®±¡C¥A§¡¢=£C_¢=·¨¨¥A¡^¡C¢nÏ]¢«[¥A¥A¦¨¡«§DÊÒÍÊ;^¡¥A[¦K¦¨[· ¶[¬[¥±§ ¥T¨ÌnÊ;¡C¬[¬[¢ß¹«n§ £C¡^¹¥h¢nÊ;¢[£±Ë¥A¦_¡^^ÊV¦ ¨¥±^¡n¦¨ §¡x[´k¡¹c§Òí^¨^¥¢[¡«¢{¬[§¨c£¥A^¥A«0¢¤¢[¥A¨Ì?¦T¶n^¥H¹¨§¯¡¦¨[§c^[´±?^µ¥AÌ[«¶[¥¯Ê¿¨¡C®±¦¥A§D¥A T¶[c¢¥±²®±«[¥h¡=§¨ «[¡=£C¥A¡C¢ § Ë^¦¨¹¥å ¶±×O«[µV¥T¥A©®DØ¢[Ù+Ì?¥h¥A«w«[¹«nË®¯¥A«5¨§V¶{ _¡{^ØR¦ ñÆ£C§ _¥AÙ^`òV¢nA«Ø¡=^«[×[¦ ¥C×5«[´ äA§¨T¥±¶[A¥h¡®H¢[^§¨T¥h[¢[°?§¨¬[^§D¢[«5«?Â_¡=ó«[¥§¨? ¥A¥AA®±ª©nM¨¨¥A¡C§V¢[§c¦¨°¥ [¦¨¹¡¥h£C«*¦T^ÂT®±ôCô?®¯É¹»d¥A¼T«DÂ¾;»d¢wÀÁ5ØRô]ñKÃ¨ÙÀC¾¿ò`Àc¼_ØÀ×[É7ÅA× ° ¥A[Ó=¦¨¡=_¶?A¥A^§ ¢[§£¦¨¥A¥A«{¥A^§¢n«H¡¢D§ ¶§¨¬[^¦ h¥AA«¥A§¨§ ¨¶[ÍC¦ ¥Æ¡C¬[«£^¶[TÆ¡C¬[®±V¡=«[¢w¥h¹¥A§R¢[«[£¥õ©¢[¢[¥A¥A¨¦ ¹¡C¢n¢$£D°CAÌ¡C®¯§¨¥A®D«D¬[¡¢[¢D§¨·xT´$^¢[µ«¶[¥Ò¦¨«[×OµVäA¥hØ«±ÙßA¡§¨T¢[^§¨¢[ ¦¨«?¬[Â¦¨ «n§¹äc¦¨^¥A¨¬n§¨¡¥C¢ ´ µ¡C¨¶[¶n¥{¥Aí¦¨£§¥¡x®¯«[¥TV¥A©_¢[Ô§±¥h²à®¯ «f¡Î¡=ö«[Ìn®±¥A¬[¥A§¹ ´`«*¶[µR¡=¸«¥A®±®±¢[[¥h§¨d[_c¨¦ ²¥A¥A®±§Æ«¡=^Ê¿«[¦¨¦¨¡C¥h¥ Õ®0Ä¶n¨¥A¡¶n¢¤§¨¹¥§R^[[¨¦ ¡ßn¡=¹A¨¥A¥A¶[§¨«¥§c°x¨_¡¯¢[¦¨¨«£¶[¥A5§¨§R®¯[®±¦¨¥A¡=_n«[Ô¹¬[²à¥h®¯h®D¡=°`¥A«[¢=Ê;¥A_¡^¦¨´ ®HV¡C¢§å¹Ë·Ì¥A¨«[¢n¶D¥A¥T¦ ©ç ÍC¨îÕ§ ¥A«÷ï¡^çÊ9Ê;¦¨ð`¨¡¶[ç® § ´ ®±A¡C¥A®¯ ¶[[¡=¥A«%Ó=°^¹¨¶n· ¥9¡^©ÊR¢A¡=^n«[®±¥ ¥A¥AT®±c²[®±d¡=¨«[¥A¥A§9¡^§Ï]£C¥A¦¨¦¨¥c§^Æ¨¶[·D£C¦ ¥A¶n«[¥A¬[¦ÕA^¥hÌn«%§¨´ ¨¦TÂ ¡C¢D¡^Ê]¨¶n¥£C¥A¢[¥h¦_^ ¡C¢D[¦ ¡xh¥A§¨§c°^¢n«D¨¶[¥ øRùúâûRü¯ýwþ±ÿ9ú AüDù 3 ] 8¹J;B^:=>õJM|n< [@^<]@ U :=>A| U\ > U :=< \ 8½:O>A@ \ |[N U Bc@ \T @CBhJ âB^:=>õJM|n< \ Jd<>A|¯>: U n@^> ]U |sE?N%Bc> \ : \ö ]U | U : {\ | U E?|]B ~ N @^<?>:=>TJd|[< \ 4 ]@ Z N \ @HE]:O>: \ > U N%Bc>AN U @ \ B^:88M@C

(5) E K| U ! "#K>A| \ >A| U @D$> ]@ \ |[N U Bc@ @CBh%J âB^:O>TJd|[< :O<%E5Jd<?>A@ @CEnJ;:=>A@ @ @ @^<?>:=>TJd|[< 4ö3 Jd<¤Bc| J8d@ &> ]@ @±: @ (> 'K| :Jd<àN]<%Bc>TJd|[< \ Jd\T<Î :)n@^<]@ U :=>A| \ U+a * &, -.DUA |=>$ ]@ \ |nU N ]U BcU @ \ \T @CBhJâB^:=>T\ Jd|[< \ \ :=<%E>$w ]@D >c: U U[\^@î >Bc|]U E?@/.0U 1 $4 .

(6) 3 <: ] 8J½B^:O>TJd|[< [@^<]@ U :=>A| U L]N?J¹8;E?@ U |@ U\ : @C:=< \ >A|HE?@%<]@ \T @CBhJâB^:=>õJM|n<8;:=< [N%: n@ \ :O<%E: \A\ | ~ BhJ;:=>A@CE : U\ @ Uc\î >A|±E?@ \ B U JdL%@±:=<%E> U :[@ U\ @K>& ]@ @^>: ~ |sE?@c8 \ > U N%Bc>AN U @Ò:=<%E5>A| \T @CBhJ Z >$ ]@DE?@ U Jdx:=>õJM|n< |[<Ú$> ?J \w\ > U N%Bc>AN U @[4 Q < | \ >5L]N?J¹8;E?@ U\i E?@ U Jdx:O>TJd|[<ÚJ \w\T @CBhJ%@CE ' JM>& Ú>A@ w 8;:=>A@ \ | Uw\ @c8d@^>A|[< \ |= Bc|]E?@[4 @ w 8;:=>h@ \ Bc|[<?>:Jd<.: Jr]>AN U @|=fBc| :=<%E \ | @ U :=>TJd< ß|[<>& ]@ @^>c: ~ |]E?@c8 \ :=<%E U @C:8 Bc|]E?@HEnJ U @CBc>T8 Z Jd< \ @ U >A@CE2Jd<>A|$> ]@ ]U |]E?N%Bc> \ 4 6YJ :=< l l >:=<%E]: EE?@^n@c8M| @CEk>A|0¨:[BhJ8Jd>:=>A@ |]E?N%Bc>Jd<?| :=>õJM|n< %: Jd< ÚL @\T CX BhJ¹ } Z JM< \ \ NBhJMQA@^ X <?

(7) > \ @ t :O<t÷>TJ;\ BBc|n<>A@Û <?>à| U E]:=> : :=<%E¯>$ ]@cJ U N \ : [@[4Õ ]6U : U > \ |= Qh X

(8) UA l t l t : U \ @`Jdh@^<%E?@CEZ >A| \ >:=<%E]: U EnJ ^@ÒBc|[<%Bc@ >AN%:8 \ > U N%Bc>AN U @ \ |=$JM<?| UA :=>TJd|[)< ' ?J;$B w: U @K@cJd$> ]@ U n@^<]@ U J;BÆ| U 'ÆJd$> ?Jd<2: \ N] L T@CBc> : U @C: @[4 $4 @C$B %:O<?J½B \ 4 X >:O<%E]: U EnJ ^@CE : U > \ : U @¯@cr ]U @ \h\ @CE 'ÆJd$> Î:E?@CEnJ;B^:=>A@CEß>A@C&B ]<]|=8d| Z[i$ :Jd<?8 Z :=<¸|[ L T@CBc> ~ | U Jd@^<?>A@CE |]E?@c88JM< G8;:=< [N%: [@5B^:88d@CE } 6Ì }ÆX]X :=<%E¸: \ >:=<%E]: U EE]:O>:{:nB^Bc@ \A\ Jd<?>A@ U ¨:[Bc@ B^:88d@CE X z3 Q 4 3 ] 8J;B^:=>TJd|[< n@^<]@ U :=>A| U L]N?J8;EnJd< ¤B^:=<L%@^<]@ %>å U | $> ]@ X } 60>h@C$B ]<]|=8d| Z :=> \T @CBhJ âB^:=>TJd|[<*:=<%E J w 8d@ @^<?>:=>TJd|[<ß8d@^[@c8 \ d[=iÕ l ¨4 ÷@HN \ @CE¤&> ]@ \ @wB^: :=L?J8JM>õJM@ \ Jd<:>A|?|=8 i B^:88d@CE } f} }i $> %:=> J \ Jd<>h@^<%E?@CE0| U $> ]@{L]N?J8;EnJd< Ú|=f: ] 8J;B^:=>TJd|[< [@^<]@ U :=>h| U\ ½Co ¨4 ]@ @^>: ~ |sE?@c8 \ : U @2E?@ %<]@C

(9) E 'ÆJd$> } 6V6+I }ÆE]:=X]>X¤:\ :[&B B^ ]Bc@ @ :=>Jd<? : >A"]@ Bc|]¨:[E?Bc@5@[>A4 @ w 8;:=>A@ \ : U @ ]U | U : w @CEJM< !} 6VI } X]X :=<%E¤: U @ JM<?>A@ UA ]U @^>A@CE¸L Z : ! X } \A\ U #%$'& ( ý ),+Rÿû .-±ú Aüg0 * ù /fùgý 12-*3.)415) ù6ú /Æú Aüg7 ù 12)9ú 8gü¯:ý + ;4<>=?!@:ABC?ED>DGF¿I H>JKâL JM=4NPORQTS UIVWYX[Z \^]_a`cb XedfS ]gWh`^]ikjYXeie]glml SPWhn9l VWhn[ogVng]epqYrh]>Vsesel S _hV`tS XuW iuV`tV>VhdP]6ie]Ut_dvSPZ]ai SPWwUt_rh]jwV`xVyp z:Ut_grh]jwV,rgVU>`{rh]Y`|es]Yie]{}MWgS `tS XuWhU VWhi,`Rrh]YX[Z \^]_`~ie]Ut_dvSPsh`xS X[WhUXh `Rrh]kVsesel S _hV`xS X[W>_Vlml ]ai4 IP Pv {hpzYW ]gWh`tS `|!S UkjwVie]oes!X.6V` `{dvSPZeoh`^]UVWhi_XuWhUt`{dvVhSPWh` ie]Ut_dvSPsh`tS XuWhUhp qYrh]4_XuWhUt`{dvVhSPWh`Ûw]{usd]UtUt]iSPWVW]Wh`xS `|,ie]{}MWgS `tS XuW_hVW%Z]X.>X[oedYhSPWhieUhw.`Rrh]%.evg E_aX[WhUt`{dvVhSPWh`wVlml X.~Uk]gWh`tS `| V` `{dvSPZeoh`^]U`^XZg]_XuWhUt`{dvVhSPWh]i:` XZ]:oeWgS oh]]hS `Rrh]dYUtX[l ]gl |Xed\^XeSPWh`Rl |h9a`{rh]G[ {^ _gl VohUt]GS UohUt]i:` Xd]sd]Ut]gWh` _aX[j!seoh`^]aiCV` `{dvSPZeoh`^]aUh `Rrh]¡~¢ {R _l VohUt],XhwVW]Wh`tS `|4_XuWhUt`{dvVhSPWh`Ûw]hV_rSPWhUt`tVWh_]X.wVW]Wh`xS `|4SPWhiuS £gS iogVl l |¤VWhi R¥!`Rrh] {tR 4_l VohUt]S U!ohUt]i` XUsg]_hS |,`Rrh]SPWh£.]gdPUt]!_V.diuSPWgVl S `|!_XuWhUt`{dvVhSPWh`Ûhp!¦IWh`tS `tS ]aU9jwV{|SPWerh]dvS `6V`^`{dvSPZeoh` ]UwVWhi _aX[WhUt`{dvVhSPWh`Û~tdX[j§`{rh]hSPdIUoesg]d`|es]Uhp. % à. [. ;4<>=¨D~;?,Aª©><~« .¬ IFYYF^=¯®R° e± 4ie]{}MWh]UwVW]{g_rgVWhn]!Ut`Rdcoh_a`{oed]ohURSPWhnV,_l ]V.d `^]R`6]Wh_XeiuSPWhn4XhksgdPXeioh_a` iuV`xVXedYrgS _rV_XuWh_]sh`RogVl jYXeie]glMS U!Us]_S }]iGSPW`{rh]¦u²Y³ ´ ¦Tµ[µl VWhnuogVng]epqYrh]%jwVsesgSPWhnxdPXuj¶`Rrh]¦u²9³ ´ ¦Tµuµ l VWhnuogVng]!`^X4`Rrh]!Ut|eWh`tV{X.`{rh]!]{g_rgVWhn]!Ut`Rdoh_`{oed]!S U6Us]_S }]iSPW4N ·Qxp. sc $[ ¯[có¯C Oc % = ¨. ;4<>=D IHY¸ u¸¨¹ y= ºhH = ® e=»tµ½¼ zY¾ ¿N ÀQMie]{}MWh]U6VWV__]aUtUksdX` Xe_X[lhXedM Á!Â~Ã9~ÄuÄbRjYXeie]lml ]i ui V`xVZgVUt]UVWhi S Uie]{}MWh]i:SPWhie]gs]Whie]gWh`{l |,tdXuj'VWh|:sgV.d`xS _oel V.d>Ut|hUt` ]jÅVWhi¨l VWhn[ogVn]p:q9rh]:d]sgdP]aUt]Wh`tV`tS XuWXh!`RrgS U xoeWh_`tS XuWgVlgSPWh` ]dm V_]YSPW¤V,sgV.d`tS _oel VhdLsgdXn[dvVj!jwSPWhnl VWhnuogVn]!S U>d]{]ddP]ai4`^XVUYV!l VWhnuogVn],ZgSPWhiuSPWhnwSPWY`Rrh]kUt`tVWhiuV.diIpz~U VW]{Vj!sel ]eL¾ µuÆÇOÈÀÈgÀbx·ÀS U~`{rh]µeq9¦I³ sgV.d`>ie]Ut_gdfSPZgSPWhn!`Rrh]!É Ê!ÊËµ¼ zY¾ZgSPWhiuSPWhnN ÌQxp qYrh]>}£h]!jwVhSPWkngXeVl U~X.I`Rrh]kµ¼ zY¾uV.d]e>h6`^XV__]UtU6VWhijwVWgSPseoel V`^]YiuV`tVY9rgS _grwV.d]kie]Ut_dvSPZg]i4ohURSPWhnk`Rrh]k¦u²9³ ´ ¦Tµuµ l VWhnuogVng]eI Y`^XVlml Xh*V__]UtU>` Xj!oel `xSPsel ]iuV`xVEd]sgXURS ` XydvS ]U>Za|!VkURSPWhnul ]YVsesel S _hV`tS X[WV`>`{rh]YURVjY]k`xSPjY]eI 6`^XVlml X. _aX[j!jwS `VWhi:dX[lmlmZgV_4XuWVUt]`wX.wµ¼ zY¾Xus]gdfV`xS X[WhUh~{¥`^XGVlml XhÍV__]UtU!` X%`{rh]¦u²Y³ ´ ¦µuµ%ie]{}WgS `xS X[WX.9VlmlIiuV`xV ]gl ]jY]Wh`ÛY`RrgV`Y_hVWZ]jwVWgSPseoel V` ]i%Z|VWVsesel S _V`xS X[WsdXe_]UtUhIVWhi*Î¤`^XVlml X.Ï`{rh]!£gVl S iuV`tS X[W¤X.6`{rh]!_XuWhUt`{dvVhSPWh`Û ie]R}Wh]iESPW4¦u²9³ ´ ¦TµuµLp zYWµ¼ zY¾I_hVW%Z]ESPj!sel ]jY]Wh`^]aiVUVWSPWh`^]gdcsgd]`^Xed Xhk¦u²Y³ ´ ¦µuµ%Ut_rh]jwV`tV4Xed6VUV4Usg]_hSmVl S Ð]iiuV`xVSPWh`^]dm V_]epwq9rh] SPWh` ]dsd]` XydSPj!sel ]jY]Wh`tV`xS X[WS UdP]R]dd]i` XSPW`{rh]Ut`tVWhiuV.di¯N ÀQVUk`Rrh]4µ¼ zY¾ l V` ]ZgSPWhiuSPWhnTp>z9WEµ½¼z9¾Ml V` ]ZgSPWhiuSPWhnS U ng]Wh]dvS _SPWWgV`Roed]ep q9rh]!Usg]_hSmVl S Ð]iSPj!sel ]gjY]Wh`tV`tS XuWS UYdP]R]dd]i`^XSPW!`Rrh]kUt`xVWhiuVhdPiVUY`{rh]µ¼ zY¾[]V.dl |4ZgSPWhiuSPWhnp Ñ Ò ÓRÒ Ô[Ò~ÕYÖÒ × NO{Q ¾ µuÆÇOÈÀÈgÀbROOp>ÂØahÙgÙÚ6 Á!Â~Ã9~ÄuÄ%ÛØeÜIeØ{Üy ,ÃY {Ý {R {TÞ ,ß¯ØaIyØRà Ohágá.Ìp N ·Q ¾ µuÆÇOÈÀÈgÀbx·yOp>ÂØahâeÙÚwãàv .ØäI {åI~ ÞaæeeÜCæhÝYf¢ ! åuÞç¢IØeÜu ÄIfhÞthR Oáá.ÌTp N ÀQ ¾ µuÆÇ¼Y¾ µGOÈÀgÈÀbx·g·[p>ÂØah~ââyÚ6ÄI^ØT½ØaR¯è!Øe^Ø!é¤ÞÞ {tYê I {tÝ^ØhÞa LOáá.ÌTp N Ì.Q ¾ µuÆëÉ¼ÖÈÀÈgÀbx·Àup>ÂØahâeìÚwãYí!í¨Â RæÜeØaî4î,eÜCÛ ØeÜIeØ{Üu ïTeÜÏæf¢T !Ä[è>éwêYÄðL ÞçñTÞ.ØePvæhOááhòp. o.

(10) X } 6 :xJ \ >A| \ >c:=<%E]: U EnJ^@ÎBc|n< \ @^< \ N \ E]:=>: \T @CBhJâB^:=>TJd|[< \î B^:88d@CE ** " - - * ( "# i @cr ~ B& %:=< [@CE:=<%E \ %: U @CE5>$ U |[N ]|[N]>Æ:=<w@^< =Jd<]@^@ U Jd< Bc| w N]<?Jd> Z 4 ]@ \ >:O<%E]: U EnJC:=>TJd|[< ]U |]Bc@ \A\Ù @c8JM@ \ |[< \ N%B^Bc@ \h\ Jd[@HE]:=>c: |]E?@c8yE?@%<?Jd>TJd|[:=<%E]: U EnJ^@CE¸Bc|[< \ > U N%Bc> U @^N \ @[4 ?J : @ : [N]@ >$ %:=>9>$ ?J |]Bc@ B^:=<5L%@ : 8JM@CEó| >& ]@ E?@ J n<{:=<%E¯>$ ]@`J 8d@ @^<>c:=>TJd|[<w|= : ] 8J;B^:=>T\9Jd|[ < [@Û <]@ UU :=>A| U\ \ 4 ]@n|\: ]8?U J \ >A|D\A\ L]N?J8;E: ]@^ >: ~ |]E?@cU 8âBh8d| \ @\>A|¯>$ ]@>: U [@^> w ]U |sE?N% Bc> i | UA :88 Z E?@ U Jd[@CE2 U | |[$> ]@ U @^>: ~ |]E?@c8 \ 4 @ w 8;:=>A@ \ : U @D$> ]@^<ß: ] 8JM@CE¸>A|$> ?J \ @^>c: ~ |]E?@c8ì4`3 \ L%@^<]@%> \ |=V$> ?J \å @^$> ]|]E i &> ]@ %<%:8 @^>: ~ |sE?@c8Õ½| @ Uc\ ): ?J ]@ U :OL \ > U :[Bc>õJM|n<8d@^[@c8 i $> ]@HBc| w 8d@crJd> Z |=VBc|]E?@ >A@ w 8;:=>h@ \ J \ U @C:=>T8 Z{U @CE?N%Bc@CE¤:=<%EG$> ]@ U @^N \ :=L?J8Jd> Z |= @^>: ~ |]E?@c8 \ J \ JM<%B U @C: \ @CER4 Q <| U E?@ U >A|DJ88dN \ > U :O>A@Ò&> ]@ÒBc|[<%Bc@ > \î : ]U :nBc>TJ;B^:8â@cr%: w 8d@åJ \ =Jd[@^<4 ]@ ]U |[L?8d@ Bc|=[@ U @CE5L Z $> ]@ @cr%: w 8d@wJ \ E?@ \ B U JdL%@CE÷Jd< \ @CBc>TJd|[< 4 X @CBc>TJd|[< o¸\ ]| ' \ ]| ' : [@^<]@ U :O>A| U J \ L]N?J8d> 'ÆJd$> ,} %D} } 4 3 U\ > \ |O8MN]>õJM|n ]@w@cr%: w 8d@ ]U |nL?8M@ J \ OJMn@^<4 Q < \ @CBc>TJd|[< t 'Æ@¯à|]BcN \ |[<÷$> ]@ X } 6 \ >:O<%E]: U EnJ C:=>TJd|[< ]U |]Bc@ \A\ 4 X @CBc>TJd|[< u*\ ]| ' \ ]| ' $> ?J \5 ]U |]Bc@ \A\ B^:=< ]@c8 >A|¸J w ]U |=[@: ] 8J;B^:=>TJd|[< [@^<]@ U :O>A| U E?@ \ J [<. 4 ]@^<Î:=<J w ]U |xn@CE \ |=8dN]>TJd|[<J \ =Jd[@^<4 ÿüDù±ÿ>û )>ú ) /-:-:3$Aÿ!/Æú AüDù ]@ ]U |nL?8M@ Bc|[<%Bc@ U < \ $> ]@¤B^: \ B^:[E?@GJdTJ;:8åJM<?>A@ U JM> Z : \ Jd>5J \ E?@ %<]@CE1Jd<Ú$> ]@3 DX[Q CQA X

(11) X ÒP m o\ >:=<%E]: U ER4g3 * J \ : \ @^>D|OKBc|=8dN < \ Jd<:>:=L?8d@{B^:88d@CEß$> ]@ * ( " i ' ?J;&B %:[@¤:ßEnfJ @ U @^<>x:8dN]@Gà| U @C:[$B U | ' |=D$> ]@>:OL?8M@[413 ( #.0 J \ $> ]@ \ : @ \ @^>H|OgBc|=8dN < \ Jd<%Bh8dN%E?@CE÷JM<Ú:=<]|[&> ]@ U >:=L?8d@{B^:88d@CE*&> ]@ 0 -" " a | U @C:[&B U | 'ãJM<÷$> ]@{&B ?J¹8;E÷>:=L?8d@ i $> ]@5x:8dN]@Jd< $> ]@ | U @cJ [< @ Z{ :=>&B ]@ \ :5x:x8MN]@gJd<¤$> ]@5Bc| UAU @ \T |[<%EnJd< ]U J : UA Z @ Z U | $> ]@ : U @^<?>>:=L?8d@[ 4 ]@ : =>c$B ?Jd ]@±$B ?J8;E¸>:=L?8d@ J \ * $|[<¤&> ]@ :=>&B ]@CE U | ' JM<¸$> ]@ : U @^<>Æ>:OL?8M@[4

(12) <]@|=$> ]@:[Bc>TJd|[< \ $> %:=>5B^:=<*L$@ @ U | UA @CE÷|[<*&> ]@2E?@ @^<%E?@^<> U | ' \ Jd<.:¸$B ?J8;EÚ>c:=L?8d@wJ \ $> ]@ B^: \ B^:nE?@ ' ]@^<5$> ]@ U @cà@ U @^<%Bc@CE : U @^<> @ Z x:8dN]@`J \ N E]:=>h@CED| U $> ]@ U @cà@ U @^<%Bc@CE : U @^<> U | 'J \ E?@c8d@^>A@CER4 Q > @C:=< \ $> %:=> i Jd<¤$> ]@5$B ?J8;Eß>:=L?8d@ i $> ]@ :=>&B ?JM< x:x8MN]@ \ ]|nN?8½E¸L$@±N E]:O>A@CE¸| U $> ]@ :=>&B ?JdA@CER4 U J [@ U\ B^:=<¯L%@ÆN \ @CE¯>A|@^<?| U Bc@Æ$> ]@ÆB^: \ B^:[E?@ U N?8d@[4 U J [@ U\U @ ]U @ \ @^<?>9> Z? J;B^:8%E]:=>: :=<%: [@ @^<> | @ U :=>TJd|[< \ $> %:=>KB^:O<wL%@D:=N]>A| :=>TJ;B^:88 Z [@^<]@ U :=>h@CE¯ U | >:OL?8M@DE?@ \ B U J >TJd|[< \ 4 ]@ U @ :Jd<%E?@ U |=$> ?J \ : U >õJ½Bh8d@@cr%: Jd<]@ \ $> ]@ÒE?@c8d@^>A@å> U J [@ U U | $> ]@å>:=L?8d@ 9>A|±:DE?@ @^<%E?@^<?>Æ>:=L?8d@ ]4 ]@ E?@c8M@^>h@ > U J n@ U Bc|sE?@gJ \\ ]| '<Jd< [N U @ 4 . . . .

(13) . . . .

(14) . . É´ ¦uzIq9¦qY´ ¾%&'&>¦L´Gie]l ÉrgSPl i tdXuj ³IVhdP]gWh` ¦ )eÆk´ ¦C¼Y+ ¦ *u¦uq9¦GÆ,¨³IV.d]Wh` ( ! )Æk´ ¦[z~. É -Ï´M. Æ / ¦ &#¾ , ( 0 ¼Y+ ¦ *u¦uq91 ¦ )´M Æ 2 ÉrgSPl i /3-6¦L´ ¦GÉrgSPl iI%p 4>XedP]S n[W R]|576¶ Æ*u¼wp84!sgdfSPjwVhdP| R]|5 ¦ ,>: ! ¼ 9. b J [N U @ [a ]@D> U J [@ U Bc|]E?@±@cr%: w 8d@. t. !#"%$.

(15) . þ .3Aý)cù. Aÿ ú Aügù)ÆùC)Vû>/ÆúRüÒû>+ õúY8. /-:-:3$ !/.

(16) & &. &. . X } 6ãJ \ Jd<?>A@^<%E?@CE >A|*E?@C:8 'ÆJd>$ ]U |]E?N%Bc>{E]:=>:]4 X } 6 >A||O8 Jd> \5 ]U |=nJ;E?@¤>A|?|=8 \ >A| \õ @CBhJ Z E]:=>: \ > U N%Bc>AN U @ \ 'ÆJd>$ } 6Ì }ÆX]X :=<%E¯>A| :=<%: [@ÆE]:=>:=L%: \ @ \ >$ U |[N ±>$ ]@ X z3 Q 43 \ : U >9|=âBc|[<?[@^<?>TJd|[<%:8 X } 6 ]U L| _@CBc> \i 'Æ@ :nE?@±: X } 6 ~ L%: \ @CEG>A||O8 Jd> \ >: U >TJd< 5 U | QhX kJ w 8d@ @^<?>:=>õJM|n< \C j½¨4 ?J \å : @ UD ]U @ \ @^<?> \D}f},Ò}åi :=<Î: ] 8¹J;B^:=>õJM|n< [@^<]@ U :=>h| U L]N?J8;E?@ U 4 S N?J8d>H: ] 8J;B^:=>TJd|[< [@^<]@ UA~ :=>A| U\ N \ @ X } 6B^: :OL?J¹8Jd>TJd@ \ Jd<:=<ß| U J OJM<%:x8 ' : Z 4 Q <÷|[N UDU @ \ @C: U B$ i9X } 6k>A@CB& ]<]|=8d| Z J \ N \ @CE¸Jd< | U E?@ U >A| :=<%: [@ @^>: ~ E]:=>:5:=<%EG>A| ]U |]E?N%Bc@ \ |=(> ': U @DBc| w |n<]@^<> \ 4 3 <Î: ] 8J;B^:=>TJd|[< [@^<]@ U :O>A| U L]N?J8M> 'ÆJd$> } f} } N \ @ \Æ @^>: ~ E]:O>:gJM<¸| U E?@ U >h| n@^<]@ U :=>A@±:5>c: U [@^> >A@cr]>AN%:8 U @ ]U @ \ @^<?>:=>õJM|n<4 ¸@^>: ~ E]:=>: Bc| @` U | : \ |[N U Bc@ \T @CBhJ âB^:=>õJM|n<2:=<%:x8 Z]\ J \ :O<%EH: U @ \ >A| U @CEfJd<{: \ | ~ B^:x8¹8d@CE ! 1 "."0.0 "¹4`z @ U Jdx:=>TJd|[< \ : U @ ]U | U : w @C)E ' JM&> 5J w @ U :O>TJd[@ àN]<%Bc>õJM|n< \î B^:88d@CE 1 "% #0 - ^ 4 ]@ Z : U @ :[E?@D|= ]r]@CE : U > \ $> %:=>D: U @ :Jd<?8 Z @cJd$> ]@ UÒ @^>: ~ |]E?@c8 > U :[@ Uc\ :8 U |nN]>TJd<]@ \ | UD\ > U Jd< ¤Bc|[< \ >:=<?> \ EnJ U @CBc>õ8 Z÷ N]> JM<?>A|$> ]@5>: U [@^>D:=<%E :[E?@5|=K=: U J;:=L?8d@ : U > \ >$ %:=>: U @Dx:8dN]@ \ @^>$B ]@CE U | $> ])@ ,$0(".% .0 ! "4 \ Jd< } f,} Ò}åi :O<.: ] 8J;B^:=>TJd|[< n@^<]@ U :=>A| U¯U @ \ N?8d> \ U | (> 'K|ß:[Bc>TJdnJM>õJM@ \ 4 ]@ U\ >w:[Bc>TJdnJd> Z :J {\ >A|+E?@ %<]@÷>A| [@^$> ]@ U Jd< } 6Ì }ÆX]X $> ]@ !0( "."0.0 ! ":=<%Ek$> ]@ ( ," - #0 - ^4 ]@ \ @CBc|[<%E¤:nBc>TJd[Jd> Z :J {\ >A| ]U |]E?N%Bc@±$> ]@5: ] 8J;B^:=>TJd|[< [@^<]@ U :=>h| UCi] :xJM<?8 Z :nE?@±|=V:=< X zå3 Q L]N?J¹8d> U | $> ]@ U @ \ N?8d> \ |=$> ]@ U\ >Ò:[Bc>TJdnJM> Z 4. STEP toolkit Source specification meta-model & translation functions META-LEVEL. EXPRESS schemata. EUGENE. Generator builder. CASE tool Meta-data Parser. Standard STEP file. Application generator. Realisation. SDAI. b J nN U @ o]a ]@¯L]N?J8½EnJd< ¤:=<%EG>$ ]@DN \ Jd< |=ö:O<¤: ] 8J½B^:O>TJd|[< [@^<]@ U :=>A| U J [N U @ o\ ]| ' \ >$ %:=>D:=<: ] 8J;B^:=>TJd|[< [@^<]@ U :=>h| U L]N?J8d>)'ÆJd>$ }f},Ò} J \ |[<?8 Z : ]U |sBc@ \A\ >$ %:=> b Bc|[< \ N @ \ @^>: ~ E]:=>c:w:=<%E ]U |sE?N%Bc@ \D\ | @ U @C:x8¹J \ :O>TJd|[<4 ]@ @^>c: ~ E]:=>:w: U @±>$ ]@ \ @c8d[@ \ ]U |]E?N%Bc@CE L Z |[>$ ]@ U9 ]U |sBc@ \h\ @ \ | U >A||O8 \ $> %:=>B^:=<¯N \ @Æ>$ ]@:=N]>A| :O>TJ;B^:88 Z L]N?J8d> X zå3 Q Jd<H| U E?@ U >h| ' U JM>h@ \ >:O<%E]: U E X } 6 ]8d@ \ 4 & ) ' (*+,.-/&01-/23!46574983!(:6.5;.!23!46 <>=?<@=BA E C D Ò ×#FHGÔÖÒJILK>Õ>MHG>K/MÒONËÒ"P#K/QRNSF6TYÒ/I. 3 \ |=Jd<>A@CE¸|[N]>åJdõJM|n< [@^<]@ U :=>h| U B^:=<ßL%@5N \ @CE2J \ EnJvBcN?8M>5:=<%E |=>A@^<*|]B^BcN U\ >h||G8½:O>A@5Jd<>& ]@58J¹@¤B Z Bh8M@[43 <]|[>$ ]@ U EnJvBcN?8M> Z J \ >A|ßBc|[<nJd<%Bc@ ]U |IT@CBc> :=<%: [@ Uc\ >A| u.

(17) Jd<n@ \ >V@| U > \ Jd< n@^<]@ U :=>A| U E?@^n@c8M| ] @^<> U :O>$ ]@ U >$ %:O<{Bc|[<%Bc@^<?> U :=>A@å>$ ]@Æ| U Bc@ \ |n<w>$ ]@ ]U |IT@CBc>9Jd> \ @c8õ4 *@L$@c8JM@^n@±$> %:=>9Jd<?> U |]E?N%BhJd< {:D<]@ ' \T @CBhJâB^:=>TJd|[<8;:=< nN%: [@åJM<%B U @C: \ @ \ >$ ]@ \ @ÒEnJf2BcN?8d>TJd@ \ 4 X | 'Æ@N \ @ $> ]@ \T @CBhJ âB^:=>õJM|n<8;:=< [N%: n@ \ Jd<>AN U <{|[<>$ ]@ ]U |IT@CBc> \ : \V\ |nN U Bc@8;:=< nN%: [@ \ >$ %:=>Æ: U @ >$ ]| \ @ \T @CBhJ%@CE U | Bh8;: \A\ J;B^:8: ] 8J;B^:=>TJd|[<E?@ \ J [< ,a

(18) ÚBh8;: \h\ |]E?@c8 \î E]:=>c:=L%: \ @E]:=>:DE?@ %<?Jd>TJd|[<8;:=< [N%: n@ zDz Pk \ &B ]@ :=>:¯| U !} 6VI } X]X2\ &B ]@ :=>: 4 ]@ |nN Bc@Æ8;:=< [N%: n@ @^>: |]E?@c8 Bc|n< J > Jd<¤: @^>Æ|= 6VI &B ]@ :=>:g$> %:=>ÆE?@ B JdL%@ $> ]@ |\ [N U Bc@D\8;:=< [U N%: n@HE]:=>:Bc|[ < \ > U N%~ Bc> \ 4 ]@ \ :\ Jd<ß\ Bc| w \ |n<]@^<> !} \ |=V: }Æ\ |[X]N X{U Bc\ @D8;:=< [N%: n@ @^>: ~\ U |sE?@c\ 8: U @ > Z @ \ :=<%Eß@^<?>TJd>TJd@ \î E?@ \ B U JdL?Jd< ÚBc|[<%Bc@ > \ $> %:=>5B^:=<*L%@N \ @CE 'ÆJd$> 0$> ]@ \ |[N U Bc@8½:O< [N%: [@[4 } <>õJM>õJM@ \ ]U |=nJ½E?@L]N%B @^> \ >A| \ >A| U @ @^>: ~ E]:=>: ' ?J8M@ =8d|[L%:8K:=<%EG8d|sB^:x8 !} 6VI }ÆX]X Bc|[< \ > U :Jd<> \ : U @5N \ @CEß>A| @^< \ N U @ @^>: ~ E]:O>: \ |[N]<%E?<]@ \A\ 4 q`|[< \ J;E?@ U Jd< *$> ]@@cr%: w 8d@|= \ @CBc>TJd|[< [i $> ]@ \ |[N U Bc@8;:=< [N%: n@wJ \X ÒP :=<%E [N U @ tß\ ]| ' \ : \ J w 8J %@CE X ÒP¸ @^>: ~ |]E?@c8¨4 ]@>c:=L?8d@ÒE?@ %<?Jd>TJd|[<wJ \Ù @c8;:=>A@CEó>A|±:å8J \ >K|O Bc|=8dN < \ 4 ]@ U @c@ U @^<?>TJ;:8 Jd<>h@ U Jd> Z Bc|[< \ > U :Jd<?>VJ \ÆU @cà@ UAU @CEw>A|¯Jd<¤&> ]@Ò@^<?>TJd> Z " w: \ $> ]@D:=>A> U JdL]N]>A@ ,1 . a :5$B ?J8;E¤Bc|O8MN < $> %:=>9J \ Bc|[< \ > U :Jd<]@CE5L Z : U @c@ U @^<?>TJ;:8]Jd<>h@ U Jd> Z±U N?8d @ %: \ :Æ| U @cJ [<Bc|=8dN TJd< ¯$> ]@$B ?J8;E{Bc|O8MN < >A|w&> ]@ : U @^<?>ÒBc|=8dN <4 ]@gJd<[@ Uc\ @±:=>A> U JML]N]>h@ |=Jd<?> \ >A|w&> ]@D>:=L?8d@±|=$> ]@±Bc|=8dN < \ 4 . .

(19) Utl iuS _`tS XuWgV.d| 9 URSPj!sel ] `|es] » ! »{d]hVl `|es]euSPWh` ]n]d `|es]eeUt`RdfSPWhn `c|esg]h¿t¿ " 9$##%# `xVZel ] 9 WgVjY] & 9 _Xulmoej!WhU!(' NOe ){Q _aX[lmoej!W 9*### " 9 _Xulmoej!W 9 WgVjY] & 9 9. ieX[jwVhSPW URSPj!sel ] `|es] 9 Xed]hS n[WE + '_Xulmoej!W 9,#-##. +. !. Xh9Wh]gd> `tVZel ] / _Xulmoej!WhU " 9$##%# " 0 9. 9. 1:R.à vÞPvæ.IØ32. b J [N U @ t]a 3Ò<¸@cr : w 8d@±|= \ |[N U Bc@ @^>: ~ |]E?@c8 a : \ J w 8d@ X ÒP EnJ;Bc>TJd|[<%: UAZ . <>=?<@=?<. Ò PuÔ K>Õ× I K/P$4LFYÕ7NSF6TYÒ/I CED S 1 "% #0 - : U @ ' U Jd>A>A@^<Jd<. ]@ }! 6VI } X]X :O<%E¤: U @ \õ @CBhJ%@CE¸Jd<ß>$ ]@ ( " " B\ ]@ :]4 ]@ \T @CBhJâB^:=>õJM|n<+|=Ò> U :=< \ 8;:=>TJd|[<0N]<%Bc>TJd|[< \ J \ : ]U | U : w JM< *:[Bc>õJMnJd> Z Jd< ' ?J;B& }! ~ 6VI J N @CE: :=<J @ :O>TJd[@D8;:=< [N%:![@[43> J½B^:x8Õ> :=< 8½:O>TJd|[<àN]<%Bc>õJM|n< @^>AN < : > Jd< {:=<%E J \ }Æ: UX]: X @^\ >A@ U\ J^@CE \ 'ÆJd>$ w> Z @ U \ >$ %:=> : U @D@^<?>TJd>TJd@ \ E?@Z?% <]@CEGJd<¤U >$ ]\ @ \ |[N U Bc@D8;:=< nN%: [U @ U @^>\: ~ \ |sE?U @c8¨4 ]@ U @ : \ N?: 8d>TJd< @^>A @ \ > > U Jd< @ U @ >$ ] ?U J @ \ @^:[<Bc>>TJd\[ Jd> : U >J |=|=V>$>A ]@^<¤@¯>B^::U88d[@C@Ê >å>A@crs>h N%:8 1&U .0@ ( ] U @ \ @^< >:O. >TJd|[<4 ¨S 4 @CB^:=N \ @5|=>$ ]@5<%:=>AN U @D|= U U Z \î \ Z \ * ) 7o i(5 b J [N U @ u \ ]| ' \ $> U @^@k> U :=< \ 8½:O>TJd|[< N]<%Bc>TJd|[< \ÚU @c8;:=>h@CE >A| $> ]@ : @ U @cr%: w 8d@[4 b N]<%Bc>TJd|[< \ " #.. " ß:=<%E " ..0 "HB^:O<*L%@wN \ @CEßJd<*| U E?@ U >A| ]U |]E?N%Bc@$> ]@{E?@ %<?Jd>TJd|[< \ |=KE?@c8d@^>A@w> U J [@ U\ à| UCi]U @ \T @CBc>TJd[@c8 Z[i : " :=<%Eß: "C4 ]@¯àN]<%Bc>õJM|n< " #.. DBc| w~ N]>A@ \ $> ]@ <%: @ |=y:g> U J [@ U U | " 5@^<?>TJd> Z 4 ]@ \ @D$> U @^@åN]<%Bc>TJd|[< \Ù @ ]U @ \ @^<?>Æ$> U @^@ Jd<%E \ |= p . &.

(20) .

(21) N]<%Bc>TJd|[< \ N \ N%:88 Z à|nN]<%EJM<¸>$ ]@D> U :O< \ 8;:=>TJd|[< |sE?@c8 a " #..0 "gJ \ :> U :Cn@ U\ :8N]<%Bc>TJd|[<Ú>$ %:=>gJd>A@ U :=>A@|xn@ U :88ÒBc|=8dN < \ |=Ò:¸>:=L?8d@I"`>$ ?J \ Jd<%E0|=N]<%Bc>TJd|[<0J \ EnJ U @CBc>T8 ZÚU @c8;:=>h@CE0>A|ß>$ ]@{> U @^@ \ > U N%Bc>hN U @{|OÒ>$ ]@ \ |[N U Bc@8;:=< [N%:![@ @^>: ~ |sE?@cR8 "9L%@CB^:ON \ @{&> ]@{:=>A> U JML]N]>h@ ( #.0G|=>$ ]@w@^<?>TJd> Z " J \ | >TJd|[<%:8 i >& ]@wx:8dN]@|=>$ ?J \ :=>A> U JdL]N]>A@ %: \ >A|5L%@¯>A@ \ >A@CE 'ÆJd>$ >& ]@ }! 6VI } X]X L]N?J8d> ~ Jd<ßàN]<%Bc>õJM|n< ±| U :88yBc|=8dN < \ |=Õ$> ]@¯>:=L?8d@ i " #..0 " J \ :E?@ U Jd=:=>TJd|[<÷àN]<%Bc>TJd|[<0$> %:=>DL]N?J8;E \ : : U >D|=K$> ]@>: U [@^> U @ ]U @ \ @^< ~ >:=>TJd|[<4 Q >DBc|[< \ J \ > \ |=V:wBc|[<%B^:=>A@^<%:O>TJd|[<|= ]rs@CE \ > U Jd< w=:8dN]@ \ :=<%Ex: U J½:OL?8M@ \ >c: @^ ]@ \ |[N U Bc@ 8;:=< [N%!: [@ @^>: ~ |sE?@c8 i " #..0 \T @CBhJ %@ \ $> ] @ ': Z Jd< ' ?J;&B {: > U J [@ U <%: @ÆJ \ L]N?J8M[> "?Jd>9J \ : ]U Jdx:=>h@ÆàN]<%Bc>õJM|n< ]U |=[J;EnJd< \ | @ U @C:[E]:OL?J¹8Jd> Z :=<%E \ | @ U @ ~ N \ :=L?J8Jd> Z 4 ]@ U @C:nE?@ U \ ]|[N?8;E<]|[>A@D&> %:=>Æ|[<?8 Z " ..0 " ¯N]<%Bc>TJd|[<GàN?88 Z E?@ @^<%E \ |[<$> ]@D@cr : w 8d@ ]U |[L?8d@ 4 ]@¸> U :[@ U\ :x8VN]<%Bc>TJd|[< " #..0 " : U >T8 Z E?@ @^<%E \ |[<Ú$> ]@ \ |[N U Bc@8;:=< nN%: [@ <%: @^>: @ ~ J |sL]E?N?@cJ8 8M>\ 4 > U N%Bc>AN U @f:=<%EG$> ]@ ]U Jdx:O>A@DN]<%Bc>TJd|[< " ..0 E?@ @^<%E \ |[<$> ]@ ' : Z :¯> U J [@ U \.

(22) . + ie]l `{dvS nng]d WgVjY]»^_X[l½_aX[lmoej!Wg¿k !- & 9 6Êë_X[lp Xh9Wh]gd^pmWgVjY]Ê ~ÊË_Xulp Xyd]hS nuWup XhYWh]d p WgVjY]h¿ + » " + 9 + ie]l `{dvS nng]d X. _aX[lmoej!W»^_X[l½_aX[lmoej!Wg¿k !- & 9 + ».

(23)

(24).

(25)

(26). 9. 1:Üu [ tà f^mÜÜy { IØî .

(27) !""#

(28) ~ÊËie]l `{dvS nng]d WgVjY]h»^_aX[l ¿YÊ

(29) %$&'()*(+'(,-

(30) 6Êë_X[lp Xed]hS n[Wup Xh9Wh]gd^pmWgVjY] .

(31) /&'(010'(23$"!,4)*(5&'(6-

(32) ~ÊË_Xulp XhYWh]d p WgVjY]Ê.

(33) 721-

(34) >Ê§_X[lp Xh9Wh]d pmWgVjY]Ê8

(35) :9

(36) Êë_aX[lpmWgVjY]Ê

(37) <;>=?'*()@9 M

(38) ÊÇ_aX[lp XedP]S n[WupmWgVjY]wÊ

(39) %,)@A

(40) ¿ 9 Ê. 1Ï[ çà f^mÜgÜu { æhÝ Þæà hî4. " + 9 + ie]l `{dvS nng]d X. `xVZel ]»^`tVZel ]4`xVZel ]h¿k & 9 ' ' Ut`{d~ !- & 6 9 " ' '9 WhX% 6' "+ »^`tVZel ]ep _X[lmoej!WhUR¿ % " »^`xVZel ]ep _aX[lmoej!WhUNWhX.Qxp Xed]hS n[Wg¿ . CB.

(41)

(42) CB. DB. »^`tVZel ]ep _Xulmoej!WhUR¿ 9. Ut`{d6 6ëUt`{dÊëie]l `{dvS ngn]d Xh _X[lmoej!Wg»^`xVZel ]ep _aX[lmoej!WhUNWhX.Q¿ 9. " 9. " 9 + »Ût`{dv¿ 9 " + . FE. 1u çà f^mÜgÜu { æhÝ ^Ø àv . 9. b J [N U @ u%ab J Uc\ >[@ U\ JM|n<|=y> U :=< \ 8;:=>TJd|[<N]<%Bc>TJd|[< \ >$ %:=>ÒB U @C:=>A@ X ÒP E?@c8M@^>h@±> U J n@ U\ . HG. ')(!.*!IKJB3!5;: 2>+;+LJ-/23!465 :6.5;.!23!46. ]@ U @ \ N?8M>õJM< ¤: ] 8¹J;B^:=>õJM|n< n@^<]@ U :=>A| U J \å :[E?@DN |=>('K| : U > \â $> ]@ U\ > : U >ÆJ \ :58d@cr]@ U :O<%E¤: : Uc\ @ U | U >& ]@ \ |[N U Bc@D8;:=< [N%: n@±:=<%:8 Zs\ J \ "$JM> ]U |]E?N%Bc@ \ @^>: ~ |sE?@c8JM< \ >:=<%Bc@ \ " $> ]@ \ @CBc|[<%E : U >5J \ :*Bc|sE?@ [@^<]@ U :=>h| U $> %:=> ]U |sBc@ \h\ @ \ > U :=< \ 8;:=>TJd|[<0N]<%Bc>TJd|[< \ " >$ ?J \ ]U |]Bc@ \A\ Bc|[< \ N @ \Æ @^>: ~ |]E?@c8Jd< \ >:=<%Bc@ \ :=<%E ]U |]E?N%Bc@ \ >: U [@^>Bc|]E?@ \ 4. . M.

(43) ß:=<%:. =Jd< ¯Jd< \ >:=<%Bc@ \ :=<%E ]U |]Bc@ \A\ Jd< } 6Ì }ÆX]X N]<%Bc>TJd|[< \ : U @Ò>& ]@ :Jd<[|:8 \ |=y:O< X z3 Q 4 ?N \ :=< X z3 Q E?@CEnJ;B^:=>A@CE >A|0>$ ]@ @^>: ~ |]E?@c8ÒJ \ >$ ]@ :Jd<Bc| w |[<]@^<>|=±>$ ]@ U @ \ N?8d>TJd< +: ] 8J;B^:=>TJd|[< [@^<]@ U :O>A| U 43 < X z3 Q J \ @cJM>& ]@ U n@^<]@ U J;B| U :=N]>h| :=>TJ;B^:88 Zß ]U |]E?N%Bc@CE÷ U | }! 6VI }ÆX]X*\ B$ ]@ :=>: i ]@^<%Bc@5|[<?8 Z $> ]@ U\ > : U >J \ %:=<%E ~ :[E?@ i > Z? J;B^:88 Z 'ÆJd>$ Î: " DBc| |[<]@^<?> U @c8 Z Jd< |[< X zå3 Q \ @ U nJ;Bc@ \ 4 $ 8C)2#%$'& ( ý )+ gù û>/15) ü û : 3 àN]<%E]: @^<>c:8âBc|[<%Bc@ >V|O X } 6J \ $> ]@ÒE?@ %<?Jd>TJd|[<|=ÕBc|[< \ @^< \ N \ E]:=>: \T @CBhJâB^:=>TJd|[< \ >$ %:O>VE?@ \ B U JdL%@ >$ ]@DE]:=>:g>A|±L$@D@cr &B %:=< [@CE| U\ %: U @CE:=<%E$> %:=>ÆBc|xn@ UK\ | @ : U >TJ;BcN?8½: U : ] 8¹J;B^:=>õJM|n<ÎE?| :xJM<4 ]@ \ @ E]:=>: \T @CBhJ âB^:=>TJd|[< \ : U @fB^:x8¹8d@CE ** " - ( "# m i p ¨4 . '. . . .

(44) . G S ++KJ-/2.3!465 +;!4@3!4 -/4CJ*. 3 <ó: ] 8¹J;B^:=>õJM|n< ]U |[>A|]Bc|=8 3f6 J \ : : U >9|= X } 6>$ %:=>E?@%<]@ \ >$ ]@Bc|[<>h@crs> i=\ Bc| @:=<%EgJM<?| UA :=>TJd|[ \ | U E?@ \ J [<%:=>A@CE E?| :Jd< _\ :=<%E \T @CBhJ%@ \ >$ ]@ X } 6 U @ \ |[N U Bc@ßBc|[< \ > U N%Bc> \ N \ @CE >A| \ :=>õJ \ Z $> ]@ \ @ U @ v N?J U @ @^<?> \¨ m[¨403D6 \ 'Æ@ U @ U\ > ]U | | \ @CEÚ: \ : @C:=< \ |=Ò@^< \ N U Jd< 0>$ %:=> X } 6 'Æ|[N?8;E ]U |=[J;E?@Î: | U @ U @c8J;:=L?8d@ ': Z |=±@cr%B& %:=< =Jd< ]U |]E?N%Bc>2E]:=>c:]43D6 \ E?@%<]@ß>$ ]@| UA :=<%E Bc|[<?>A@^<?> \ |=V:wL?8d|]B |OKE]:=>:5>$ %:O>ÆJ \ >A|L%@5@cr B& %:=< [@CE2Jd< \ N%B$ ß:)': Z >$ %:=> Bh8½:xJ \ |=öBc|n<?à| Uh :=<%Bc@ >A|w&> ]@ \ >:O<%E]: U E| U : U >TJ;BcN?8;: Uf\ |=à(> ': U @ ]U |sE?N%Bc> \ B^:=<¸L%@ ]U | @ U 8 Z >A@ \ >A@CE d ¨4 Q <¸| U E?@ U >A|{:[|=J;E |=[@ U 8;: ] Jd< 0L%@^(> 'Æ@^@^<+3D6 \îåX } 6 \ >c:=<%E]: U EnJ ^@ \ Bc| w |[<Ú@^<?>TJd>TJd@ \ :=<%E+Bc| |[<ÚN \ : n@ \î B^:x8¹8d@CE - .0( ( !0( ^4 G & S ++KJ-/2.3!465 +;!4@3!4 -/4CJ;/ J46+7.5H3+!4 -/* *. ]@ n|:8V|=:=<*3D6-E?@^[@c8d| ] @^<> ]U |]Bc@ \A\ J \ >$ ]@{E?@%<?Jd>TJd|[<Ú|O :=< ** " - - * ( " 3 Q 4R3 <*3 Q Bc|[< \ J \ > \ |= : \ @c8d@CBc>A@CE \ @^>¯|=VJd<?>A@ U :=>h@CE U @ \ |[N U Bc@ \ ' ?J;B$ : U @ \T @CBhJ½:x8¹J^@CE i Bc|[< ~ \ > U :Jd<]@CE| U Bc| w 8d@^>A@CEG>A| \ :=>TJ \ Z >$ ]@gJd<?à| Uh :=>TJd|[ \ |=V>$ ]@5E?| :Jd<4 ]@¯3 Q \T @CB ~ JâB^:=>TJd|[<ßJ \ L%: \ @CEß|[<ß>$ ]@ U @^N \ @5|=`JM<?>A@ U :=>A@CE U @ \ |[N U Bc@ \â :=<ß3 Q J \ :=< }! 6VI } X]XÎ\ B& ]@ :>$ %:=> \ @c8d@CBc> \ $> ]@Ò: ] 8J;B^:=L?8d@±Bc|[< \ > U N%Bc> \ U | >$ ]@ÆJd<?>A@ U :=>h@CE U @ \ |[N U Bc@ \ : \ L%: \ @c8¹Jd<]@DBc|[<%Bc@ >AN%:8R@c8d@ @^<> \ 4 ?N \î $> ?J \±\ $B ]@ :J \¯\T @CBhJ;:8J^@CE 'ÆJd>$ :[E]EnJd>TJd|[<%:x8 Bc|[< \ > U :Jd<> \îRU @c8;:=>TJd|[< \ ?J %\ :=<%Eß@^<?>TJd>TJd@ \ ' ?J;B& Jd< ]@ U Jd>¯ U | Bc| w |[<*Bc|[< \ > U N%Bc> \ 4 ?J \D ]U |]Bc@ \A\ J \ B^:88d@CE ** " - - * 1 -~"Jd>H: \h\ J [< \ : @C:=<?Jd< Ú>A|÷JM<?>A@ U :=>A@CE U @ \ |[N U Bc@ \ Jd<k$> ]@ÎBc|n<>A@cr]>|=H: : U >TJ;BcN?8;: U E?| :Jd<4 ]@ ** "% - - * ( ]U |]Bc@ \A\ J \ :Hà| Uh :8Õ:=<%E 'Æ@c88Õ@ \ >:=L?8J \ ]@CE : U >å|=y&> ]@D3f6 E?@^[@c8d| ] @^<?> ]U |]Bc@ \A\ 4 ø 12-5ûâü /cù 9ú 8C) /þ h3A)ý cù -HûRü¯!ÿ )+>+7 Tú98 #G$'&¶( > . . . . . . S/*B3!5;: 3!(-/4:65.$2.3!465 +;!4 -/.** . 3 \ Jd<>& ]@¤Bc| w J8d@ U %@c8½E i Jd<>A@ Uh @CEnJ;:=>A@ U @ ]U @ \ @^<?>:=>TJd|[< \î Bh8d| \ @¤>A|*>& ]@>: U [@^> iU @CE?N%Bc@ß>$ ]@¤Bc|]E?@ [@^<]@ U :O>TJd|[< 'Æ| U. 43 \`\ |[N U Bc@ U @ ]U @ \ @^<?>:=>õJM|nA@ Uh @CEnJ;:=>A@ U @ ]U @ \ @^<?>:=>TJd|[<J \Æ\ >A| U @CEHJM<: @^>: ~ |]E?@c8¨4 ]@ \ > U N%Bc>AN U @¯|=y>& ?J \å @^>: ~ |sE?@c89J \U @c8½:O>A@CE>A|>$ ]@±>: U [@^>Æ8;:=< [N%:![@[4 ]@ @^>$ ]|]EN \ @CE >A|D|[L]>c:Jd<w$> ?J \ @^>c: ~ |]E?@c8 i B^:88d@CE * ( " ¨Q S i J \V\ J J8;: U >A|D>$ ]@ @^>& ]|sE5N \ @CE >A|{E?@ %<]@5:=<3 Q U | Jd<>h@ U :=>A@CE U @ \ |[N U Bc@ \ 4 ]@ [@^<]@ U :=>A@CE¸: ] 8J;B^:=>TJd|[<¸J \ |[L]>:Jd<]@CE&> U |[N $> U @^@ \ >A@ % \ _\ @^@ nN U @Hp ca :=<%:8 Z]\ J \ |= \ |[N U Bc@ \T @CBhJ%âB^:O>TJd|[$ ]@ Q S i [@^<]@ U :=>TJd|[<Ú|OÒ>$ ]@>: U [@^> U @ ]U @ \ @^<?>:=>TJd|[<4 ]@ @^>$ ]|]EJ \ 5.

(45) Analysis. Source meta-model. Interpretation. Interpreted meta-model. Generation. Source specification. Generated application. b J [N U @±p a4 @^<]@ U :=>TJd|[<'ÆJd>$ ß:=<Jd<>A@ Uh @CEnJ;:=>A@ @^>: ~ |]E?@c8 U @^nJ \ Jd>A@CE¸>A|{E?@C:8 ' JM>& ¤$> ]@±E?@ \ B U J >õJM|n< ' JM>& }! 6VI }ÆX]X |Oy>$ ]@¯>: U n@^>V8;:=< nN%: [@ \ E]:=>:5Bc|[< \ > U N%Bc> \ :=<%E|=>$ ]@±E?@ \ B U J >õJM|n<Î|O ( ," - * ( $Æ>$ %:=> \ %:88ÕL%@¯N \ @CEL Z >& ]@D> U :=< \ 8;:=>õJM|n< ]U |sBc@ \h\ 4 |[@^>$ ]@ U 'ÆJd>$ 0>$ ]@ \ |[N U Bc@ @^>: ~ |sE?@c8 i :88>$ ]@ \ @ \ B& ]@ :=>:ß: U @wN \ @CE÷Jd<Ú>$ ]@JM<?>A@ UA ]U @^>A@CE @^>: ~ |]E?@c8¨4 ]@ Q S \ @ U [@ \ : \ $> ]@DL%: \ J \ à| U $> ]@ ]U |]Bc@ \A\ Jd< {|O ( " # - Ô4 1. & =?<@=BA . 23!2 4@J* F6YG ÔTÖ½ÒJK>Õ6TOP#K~Ô MÒ%P ILK>Õ@M6G@K/M~Ò NËÒ%P#K/Q NSF6TYÒ/I×uÖ D .Ò NSK/P#K. ]@ \ |[N U Bc@±:=<%EG>: U n@^>V8;:=< nN%: [@ @^>: ~ |sE?@c8 \ Bc|[< \ J \ >åJd<Î: \ @^>å|= } 6Ì }ÆX]X\ B& ]@ :=>:5>& %:=>E?@ ~ \ B (U JdL$@ >$ ]" @ $> \ ]|[@ N U |[Bc@ÆN :=Bc<%@HE¯:O><%: EU n>@^: >8;[:=@^< >`[8;N%:=:!< [[@N%!: E][:=@ >: Bc@^|[>< : \ > U N%|sBcE?> @c\ 8 4Õ6: : @±U :Bc88M|[@c< 8%>hJ;|ÒE?@ >$ ]@C@öEßJ;E?: @C:D -|= X .0 (} 6 (*,* !" ( -Ô4 i \ U U ~ \ U \ U \ q`|[< \ J;E?@ U Jd< 5$> ]@Ò@cr%: w 8d@D|= \ @CBc>õJM|n< [i $> ]@ >: U [@^>98;:=< [N%: [@ @^>: ~ |sE?@c8$J \\ ]| '<5Jd< [N U @ M 4 ?J \\ &B ]@ :ÚBc|[<?>:Jd< \ $> ]@ß@^<?>TJd>TJd@ \ "% #.. w&> %:=>2E?@ \ B U JdL%@ \ :x8¹8±<]@^@CE?@CE E]:=>:JM< | U E?@ U >A| ]U |]E?N%Bc@Î:ßE?@c8d@^>A@¤> U J [@ U :=<%E " #.. &H$> %:O>óBc|n<>:xJM< \ $> ]@8J \ >w|=±:88 > U J [@ U\5U @c8½:O>A@CE0>A|*: >:=L?8d@[4 .

(46) `{dvS nng]d9 + Utl iuS _a`tS X[WgVhdP| 9 `RdfS ngn]d9 _XulI _X[lmoej!W 9 WgVjY] & 9. " 9 ie]l ]a`^] `{dvS ngn]dU 9 `{dvS n l S Ut`Y(' - NmÈu ){Q ! `RdvS nn]gd 9 " 9. b J [N U @ M a ]@D>: U n@^> @^>: ~ |]E?@c8. =?<@=?<. Ò PuÔ K>Õ× I K/P$4LFYÕHK~Ô K@NÍÒ"PeÒ ÔT××uÖ D Ò NSK CED S. ]@ 1 "% * ( $ \ B$ ]@ :Bc|[< \ J \ > \ |=ö: \ @^> |=V@^<?>TJd>TJd@ \ E?@ \ B U JdL?Jd< ¤|[>$ ]@ U E]:=>:>$ %:=> : U @ N \ @CE L Z >$ ]@¸> U :=< \ 8;:=>õJM|n< ]U |sBc@ \A\ 4 Q >2:xJ \ >A|.E?@ \ B U JdL%@E]:=>c:*N \ @cN?8D| U >& ]@¤<%: Jd< Ú|=±>c: U [@^> ]U | U : w Jd< ßBc|[< \ > U N%Bc> \±\ N%B& : \ >$ ]@2Bh8;: \h\ | U > Z? @<%: @ \ 4 Q >HB^:=<Ú:8 \ |ßBc|[<>c:Jd<*>: U n@^> \TZs\ >A@ E?@ \ B U J >TJd|[< \ß\ N%B& -: \ >$ ]@*<%: @Î|OóL%: \ J;B*Bh8;: \A\ @ \ N \ @CEL Z+ ]U |sE?N%Bc@CEãBh8;: \A\ @ \ 4 ?J \ß\ B$ ]@ :÷J \ Bc|[< \ J;E?@ U @CEk: \ :*E?@ \ B U J >õJM|n<|OH: : U >w|O ]U | U : w Jdh@ U :=>TJd|[<|Oö:=<¤: ] 8¹J;B^:=>õJM|n< ' JM&> ?JM<ß:5>: U [@^> \TZs\ >A@ 4 q`|[< \ J;E?@ U Jd< ±$> ]@å@cr : 8M@ i |[<]@B^:=<$> ?Jd< :OL%|[N]>Æ: ]U @]r5JM<?| UA :=>TJd|[<wN \ @CEó>A|DL]N?J8½E>$ ]@<%: @ \ |=$> ]@D> U J n@ U 4 ]@±@cr%: w 8d@±> U :=< \ 8;:=>TJd|[< : U : @^>A@ Uc\K\ $B ]@ :óJ \\ ]| '<Jd< nN U @ 5 4 j .

(47)

(48) {` dvVioh_`tS XuW sgV.dvVjY]a`^]dU gW VjwSPWhn9 sd]{}u & 9$### " 9$##%#. 9. b J [N U @ 5 a ]@D> U :=< \ 8½:O>TJd|[< : U : @^>A@ U\\ B& ]@ :. =?<@=. . CED. . P. "P /T NËÒ%P#K/Q NSF9T9Ò/I×[Ö D ÒN K @^>: ~ |]E?@c8 Q S \ B& ]@ :Bc|[<?>:Jd<. Ò 4tÕ eÒÔ kÔuÒ eÒ. ]@¯Jd<>h@ UA ]U @^>A@CE \ :88KBc|[< \ > U N%Bc> \ |=K>& ]@H>c: U [@^> @^>: ~ |]E?@c8 \ B ]@ :]4 X N]L]> Z @ \ |=R>$ ]@@^<?>TJd>TJd@ \ U | >$ ]@Æ>: U [@^> @^>: ~ |sE?@c8 \ B$ ]@ :D: U @B U @C:=>A@CER4 ]@ÒB U @C:=>TJd|[< |= \ N]L]> Z? @ \ :88d| ' \å | U @ \T @CBhJâBw:=>h> U JdL]N]>A@wE?@%<?Jd>TJd|[< \ >A|L%@)=Jd[@^<¸Jd<Î>& ]@óBc|n<>A@cr]> |=y>& ]@ \ |[N U Bc@ 8;:=< [N%: n@ @^>c: ~ |]E?@c8 \ B$ ]@ :5:=<%E|=Õ>& ]@Ò> U :=< \ 8;:=>TJd|[< : U : @^>A@ U\V\ B$ ]@ : 4 ]@±Bc|[<>h@crs>öJ \ U @ ]U @ ~ \ @^<?>A@CEóJM<$> ]@ \ N]L]> Z @ \ L Z : \A\ |sBhJ;:=>TJd< 5>$ ]@ 'ÆJd>$ @^<>õJM>õJM@ \ U | >$ ]@ \ |[N U Bc@å8½:O< [N%: [@ @^>: ~ |]E?@c8 :=<%E2 U | $> ]@¯> U :=< \ 8½:O>TJd|[< : U : @^>A@ U\ 4 ]@ [|:8J \ >h| U @CE?@%<]@w:88y>& ]@H:=>A> U JdL]N]>A@ \ |O \ N]L]> Z @ \ |= $> ]@`>: U [@^> @^>: ~ |sE?@c8 \ &B ]@ : : \ E?@ U JMn@CEH:O>A> U JdL]N]>A@ \ Jd<5| U E?@ U >A|DBc| w N]>A@`$> ]@cJ U x:8dN]@ÆJd<5$> ]@ OJMn@^< Bc|[<?>A@cr]>C4 ]@DJ;E?@C:J \ [@ UAZ¤\ J J8;: U >A|w&> ]@ X } 6 ** " - - * ( ]U |sBc@ \A\ E?@ \ B U JdL$@CE¸Jd< \ @CBc>TJd|[< t 4 o Jd< ' ?J;$B ÷$> ]@±3 Q J \ $> ]@¯JM<?>A@ UA ]U @^>:=>TJd|[<ß|=Jd<?>A@ U :=>h@CE U @ \ |nN U Bc@ \ Jd<Î&> ]@óBc|n<>A@cr]> |=K: : U >õJ½BcN?8;: U E?| :xJM<4 . &.

(49) Utl ·.`RdfS ngn]d SPj!j 9 + `{dvS nng]d9 +0 R` dfVioh_`xS X[W sgV.dvVjY]`^]gdPU 9

(50) S `{dvS ngn]d + ^» `{dvS nng]dv¿ 9 WgVjÅ>WgVjwSPWhn9. Utl iuS _a`tS X[WgVhdP| 9 ¯I {^ðTR ^ØPvæ. Þæ.I RåI. . " . ' `{dvS nng]d p WgVjY] & 6¶WgVjp sgd]{}[ÊË_Xulp XhYWh]d p WgVjY]Ê " 9 S ie]l ]` ] `{dvS nng]dU + »îe]l ]` ] `{dvS nng]dUR¿ 9. .

(51)

(52) 6ÊË_X[lp Xed]hS n[Wup Xh9Wh]d pmWgVjY]9. `{Zel½`xVZel ]9[WgVjÅ>WgVjwSPWhn9. ¯I {^ðTR ^ØPvæ. Þæ.I RåI. . " . ' ie]l ]` ] `{dvS ngn]dUhp `{dvS n l S Ut`Y(' - NmÈu ){Q ! S `RdfS ngn]d6 6ë_X[j!seoh` ] `RdvS nn]gd l S Ut`t»^`RZelWgVjw¿ " 9. 9. + _Xuj!seoh`^] `{dvS nng]d l S Ut`x»^`{Zelu `tVZel ]9uWgVj >WgVjwSPWhn¿k(' S `{dvS nng]d9 ' 'ÏS `RdvS nU!(' ! S `{dvS nng]d~ 6 N Q 9 " ' '9 WhX% 6 ' " »^`{Zelp _Xulmoj!WhUR¿ % " »^`{Zelp _X[lmoej!WhUR¿ 9 +- »^`RZelp _Xulmoej!WhUNPWhXhQtp Xed]hS nuWg¿ . - »tS `{dvS nUhuS `{dvS nng]dv»^`{Zelp _X[lmoej!WhUNWhX.Qx )yIWgVjw¿È¿ 9 " - 9 " 9 + »tS `RdfS ngUR¿ 9 " + 9. DB. CB. DB. b J [N U @5j a ]@ Jd<>A@ Uh ]U @^>A@CE @^>: ~ |]E?@c8 q`|[< J;E?@ Jd< >$ ]@±@cr%: 8d@ $> ]@ ]| '<Jd< [N @5j Bc|n<>:xJM< >& ]@±@^<?>TJd> " #..0$ >$ %:=>`J \ Bc\ |[< \ UJ½E?@ U @CE¤: \ >$ ]@åwJd <>A@ i Uh ]U @^>:=Q >TJd|[<|O\ " #.. U &Ô4 i ]@±Bc|n<\>A@cr]>Æ|=Õ>$ ?J \Z Jd<?>A@ UA ]U @^>c:=>TJd|[<J \ @^<?:[>TJdE?> @ N "%|= >$ ]@ #.. "&KV:ON <%Ew@CE$> ] )@ | $> ] -@ . &B @^ ]<?@ >TJd>T:Jd@ \â Jd.<{.0| U E?:@ 8U 8Õ>A<]|H@^@CBcE?| @CE¸ E]N]:=>A>@Ò:5&> ]: @Ò@å:=à>A@^> >cU $B JML] ]N]@CE>h@ | . "% ]"%|= :=$> <% ]E @ Z \ U \ i U U -.¯@^<>õJM>õJM@ \ 4. m.

(53) .

(54) HG. . ')( 3!!2@5*!J23!465 7 4;@J. 6 U | U : Jd< *>$ ]@¤> U :=< \ 8;:=>TJd|[<1àN]<%Bc>õJM|n<ÚJ \ :[B& ?JM@^n@CE: \ E?@ \ B U JdL%@CEJM< \ @CBc>õJM|n< o 4 o 4 o]i @cr%Bc@ >>$ ]@ > U :O< \ 8;:=>TJd|[<5N]<%Bc>TJd|[< \ | @ U :=>h@K<]| ' |[<5>$ ]@ Q S U :=>$ ]@ U >& %:=<w>$ ]@ \ |[N U Bc@ @^>: ~ |sE?@c8¨4ÆqV| w N]>TJd< Jd< \ >:=<%Bc@ \ |=>$ ]@ Q S B^: UAU JM@ \ |[N]>±: : U >D|O >& ]@óBc|]E?@ [@^<]@ U :=>TJd|[<4 N \ >$ ]@ U @¯J \ 8d@ \A\ 'Æ| Uh 8d@c> :=<%E> U :=< \ 8;:=>TJd|[<GàN]<%Bc>TJd|[< \ : U @ \ J w 8d@ U 4 q`|[< \ J;E?@ U Jd< $> ]@±@cr%: w 8d@ i $> ]@±> U :=< \ 8;:=>TJd|[< |sE?@c8 \ ]| 'å<Jd< [N U @Hm i Bc|[<?>:Jd< \ <]| '|[<?8 Z >1'Æ| N]<%Bc>TJd|[< \ 4¯qV| w : U Jd< {$> ?J \å |]E?@c8 'ÆJd$> ¤$> ]@ |]E?@c8V|= nN U @ u%i >& ]@ U @C:[E?@ UD\ ]|[N?8;E¸<]|[>A@¯>$ %:=> >$ ]@ ]U Jdx:O>A@N]<%Bc>TJd|[< " #.. óJ \wU @ 8;:[Bc@CE L Z &> ]@¤E?@ U Jd[@CE+:=>h> U JdL]N]>A@ #..0 w|=D>$ ]@ QS" 5Jd[< N U >c@w:=<%j Bc@ i :O<% ]E¤@^<%&> Bc %@5:=>Ò$> ]&> @ ]@H@ > J U :<][|w@ U<]\ :@^8R@CEN]>h<%|HBc>T>hJd@ |[< >$> ]@c" J @c .r.0J >A @^<% Bc@[4 " | @ U :O>A@ \ |n<:ó8J \ >D|=Vx:x8¹J;E \ \î U \ \ U \. + ie]l `{dvS nng]d X. _aX[lmoej!W»tS `kS `RdvS nn]gdf¿! & + ». 9.

(55) !""#

(56) ~Ê S `pmWgVjY]¤Ê

(57) %$&'()*(+'(,-

(58) 6ÊËS `p _X[lp Xed]hS n[Wup Xh9Wh]gd^pmWgVjY] .

(59) /&'(010'(23$"!,4)*(5&'(6-

(60) ~Ê S àp _Xulp XhYWh]d p WgVjY]wÊ

(61) %21-

(62) ~Ê S `p _Xulp XhYWh]d p WgVjY]wÊ

(63) :9

(64) ÊËS àp _aX[lpmWgVjY]¤Ê

(65) /; =?'*()@9

(66) ÊËS àp _Xulp Xyd]hS nuWup WgVjY]wÊ.

(67) /,)@A

(68) ¿ 9 Ê. + 9 " + ie]l `{dvS nng]d X. `xVZel ]»tS `ÛwS ei ]l ]a`^] `{dvS ngn]dUR¿k !- & 9 ' ' Ut`{d~ !- & 6 9 " ' '9 WhX% 6' "+ »tS `Ûhp `{dvS n l S Utt` ¿ % " »tS `Ûhp `{dvS n l S Ut`x¿.

(69)

(70) CB Ut`Rd~ 6ËUt`{dMÊËie]l `RdfS ngn]d X. _Xulmoej!Wg»tS `Ûhp `{dvS n. " 9 + »Ût`{dv¿ 9 " + . DB. l S Ut`{NWhX.Q¿ 9. 1Ï[ çà f^mÜgÜu { æhÝ Þæà hî4. 9. FE. 1u çà f^mÜgÜu { æhÝ ^Ø àv . 9. b J nN U @±m aÆX @CBc|[<%EG[@ U\ Jd|[<|Oy> U :=< \ 8;:=>TJd|[<N]<%Bc>TJd|[< \ >$ %:=>B U @C:=>A@ X ÒP E?@c8d@^>A@¯> U J [@ Uc\ . . . 5/0;3!*. S @^<]@%> \ |O &> ?J \g @^$> ]|]Eß: U @{EnJ \ BcN \A\ @CEßJd< d ul 4 U :O< \ 8;:=>TJd|[<ßN]<%Bc>TJd|[< \¯ Jr*N EnJf @ U @^<> Jd<%Eß|= [@^<]@ U :O>TJd|[<2EnJ U @CBc>õJMn@ \ 4 ]@ x: U JM|nN \K\ B$ ]@ :O>:±: U @ÆJd<>A@^<%E?@CE>h|±| U ?:=<?J^@>$ ]@ [@^<]@ U :=>A| U E?@ \ J [<¤:=<%E J w 8d@ @^<?>:=>TJd|[<4 ]@ \ @ : U :=>TJd|[<¤L$@^>('K@^@^<¸>$ ]@ :=<%E>$ ]@ 0 J \ @^<?| U Bc@CE i >& ]@ Q S Bc|[<?>:Jd< \ E?@ \ B U J >TJd|[< \ |=Õ&> ]@Ò>: U [@^> ]U |sE?N%Bc> 0R>A/| [@^<]@ U :=>A@ i ' ?J8M@¯> U :=< \ 8½:O>TJd|[<wN]<%Bc>TJd|[< \ E?@ \ B U JdL%@ 0 >h|n@^<]@ U :=>A@[4 ]@Ò> U :=< \ 8;:=>TJd|[< : U : @^>A@ U\ $B ]@ :D¨:[BhJ8Jd>:=>A@ \ Jd<?>A@ U :O>TJd|[<{|OÕ$> ]@ [@^<]@ U :O>A@CE ]U |sE?N%Bc>ÆJd<?>A|5>$ ]@ ' ]|=8d@ \TZs\ >A@ $> %:=< ]\ >A|ß$> ]@¤Bc|[<?> U |=8|=D$> ]@<%: JM< 0:=<%E0> Z Jd$ ]@ \ : @ [@^<]@ U :O>A| U >A|wL$@ U @^N \ @CEJd<*EnfJ @ U @^<> Bc|[<>h@crs> \ 4 -:-*3&Aÿ!/Æú hüDC ù+ . . . 3. . . . +,!5-/.*. }f},Ò} %: \ L$@^@^<¤N \ @CEGL Z\ @^[@ U :x8 U @ \ @C: U B& ]U |IT@CBc> \ >h|HL]N?J8;Eß>$ ]@ |=88d| 'ÆJd< [@^<]@ U :=>A| U\ a : [@^<]@ U :=>h| U |=y@C: U 8 Z L?Jd<%EnJd< X z3 Q Jd< X[ :88d>:8 ?~ j[lw:=<%E2Jd<[:x: i ) : [:x): U : ?J;B^:8ÕN \ @ U JM<?>A@ U ¨:[Bc@ [@^<]@ U :=>A| U | U E]:=>:OL%: \ @ :=<%:![@ @^<?> i : [@^<]@ U :=>h| U ]U |]E?N%BhJd< ¤ : +@ : ]U | U : @ UU @c@ U @^<%Bc@HE?|]BcN @^<?>:=>TJd|[<G U | >$ ]@5:=<%:8 Zs\ J \ ) |=yBc| w @^<> \ Bc|[<>c:Jd<]@CEJd< \ |nN U Bc@ \ |= ]U | U : {\î l.