Plans d'expériences pour l'évaluation d'algorithmes évolutionnaires et la constitution de classes de référence
38
0
0
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Plans d’exp´eriences pour l’´evaluation d’algorithmes e´ volutionnaires et la constitution de classes de r´ef´erence Olivier Franc¸ois, Christian Lavergne. No 3601 Janvier 1999 ` THEME 4. ISSN 0249-6399. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4)
(5) !"#$ &%' (
(6) )* +,%.-0/1 " 2%. )3' 4 % 5 6%.,%' 7%.$ 8 9):: ; 9<=' >0?A@CB:@CDFEGHEJILKMFNO@CPFQRTSEU@CPWVJ@AIXKZY[I\BXDFEW]OKD ^_a`$bdc&eTfhgjikb)lamon=pqisrut0cpr v\pqisbdiowxnypxikr t z cwx{jw!px`WbdcWw|rubdvamsc$}\cWw ~xr cp!ga [nyv vLru!p z c&qcW|,_acWq|,_act) u a+fun tFjikc$&Wu fhyeTv n cWw 2'W$=a c$pnyxpxio|mkc z\ |qip)l tac7b pq_ar z r mkr uiscw!pqn=pqikw!pxioFlac2FlaivLcWxbdcpT0mC l\pxikmkikwqn=pqc$la z n m¡ ur qipq_abdcWw ur mkl\pxikr t t nyikxcUw z c&|$r t\¢L laqc$|ruxqcW|pxcWbTcWtFpmkcWwv n qn bd`pxqcWw z c|$cWwnymk ruxispx_ bTcUw$£j¤:n b px_ar z c¥wxc¦§rut z c¥wxla¨l tbTr z `Wmsc#wp,n=pxiow!pxioul c¥nyvavXc$m bdr z `$mkc[mkist nyikqc t ,nymkikw £y©¥tpxcWm bdr z `Wmsc vXc$qbdcp z c v ismkrypqc$)mkcWw z rutat cUwn m n=pqr ikxcUw+vaqr z laipqcWwv nymscUwn msur qipq_abdcWwW£:ªt«v nyxpxio|l msikc$U¬:mkcWw c$}\v xikc$t |$cWw|qr iow cWw#cp&v n wqw cWw#vXc$lauc$tFp$pxqcv xiow!cUw¥cWt®|$r bdv\pqcc$¯|Wn |$c$bdc$tFpW£O¤°cUwvaxr\| Wz laqcWw z cUwpqisbn=pqisrut c$p z cpxcWw!p[vXc$qbTc$p!pqc$tFp z =nymklac$mA c$±Xc$p z c&mknT=nyqion=pxikr t z cWwvLny,nybd`pqxcUwwxlamonTwxry¡ mkl\pqisrutTv xruvLrFw cv n HmC nymk ruxispx_ bTcu£=²³mC nyi z c z c[|c$p!pqcb px_ar z cu¬ymkctar b´axc z cWwqwxn ikw z c[w!ikb)lamon=pqisrut |$r qxcUw!vXr t z nytFp# |,_ n Flacd|rub)´aikt nyiowxr t z cdv n qn bT`$pxqcWw¥vLcWl\p+pxqcd|r tLw!i z\ ,ny´ mscWbTcWtFp¥ Uz laispW£6¤:n b px_ar z c#vLcWxbdcpnyl wqwxi z c| c$ z cWw|mon wqw!cUw z c#vaxru´amk`$bdcWw¨vLrula¨mkcWwqFlac$mowmkc#|$r bdvLru!pqc$bdc$tFp¢Lt nym z c[mC nymk ruxispx_ bTc¥cWw!p¨istj=nyqionytFpW£F¤:n|$r t w!pxispxl\pqisrut z c[pqc$mkmscUw¨|$mknuwxwxcWw¨vLcWxbdcp z n la bdcWtupqc$mknFl n msisp z cWwcWw!pxikbn=pqisrut wTlatµ|r ¶ap z c+|$nymo|l m°i z c$tFpxioFlac £ ·µ¸F¹Oºq»)¼ =½' nymk ruxispx_abdcUw ur mkl\pxikr t t nyikxcUw$¬¨bTr z `Wmscmsikt nyikxc¾ t qn msiow ¬vamonyt z c$}\v xikc$t |$c ¬ z ikw!pxqis´ l\pxikr tun bTbn £ ¿oÀ°Á!ÂÄÃUÅÁÆ ÇkÂÄÈAÉÊ. Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rhˆone-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST MARTIN (France) T´el´ephone : 04 76 61 52 00 - International: +33 4 76 61 52 00 T´el´ecopie : 04 76 61 52 52 - International: +33 4 76 61 52 52.
(7) ³ $/1 %. :*) <= + " 2%. +4$* +,%.-0/1 0. %.&%.°%. °® %'3"
(8)
(9) ^_aiown !pqik|$msc z cWwq|qis´XcWwTn¾w!pqn=pqikw!pxio|$n mbdc$px_ar z _ ik|,_ _ c$mkv wn¾l w!cWr ¦[c$ur mkl\pxikr t n x{ n msur qipq_abwpqr|r ta¢ la,n=pqc[pq_acnymk ruxispx_ab0 w¨vLny,nybdcpqc$,w$£j^_ac&bdcpx_ r z iow´ n wxc z lavXr t0nw!pqnypxiowpqi¡ |Wnymbdr z c$mH|$n msmkc z cWtac$,nymki $c z msiktacWn #bdr z cWmC£:gjlL|,_®n bdr z c$mHnymkmsr w¥pxr0bnytLny c)px_ac z nypqn _aio|,_ n xcdvaqr z l |$c z ´F{¾px_ac7n msur qipq_ab0£ |3pxlLnymkms{u¬:|qruwqw!c z n t z vLn w!p)w!ikb)lamon=pqisrutc$}\vLcWxikbdc$tFpqw+|Wnyt
(10) ´Lc c$¯7|ikc$tFpxmk{nu|$|rulatFpxc z ¦§ruW£ ª¨wpqisbnypxikr t7nyt z pxcWw!p¨vaqr\|c z laqcWwvXc$qbTisppqr)n wqw!cUwxw'pq_ac[c$±XcU|3ppq_ac[=nyqi¡ nypxikr try¦pq_acdv ny,nybdcpqc$,w¥_Ln w#r t¾pq_acw!rumslapxikr t v xruvLrFw!c z ´j{µpx_acdnymk ruxispx_ b£ #wn qcWwxlamp&ry¦px_ac bdc$px_ar z ¬=pq_actjlab)´Xc$Hr ¦ pqxionymowH|ruxqcWwxvLrut z ikta[pqr+cWnu|,_|rub)´aikt nypxikr tTry¦ pq_acv n qn bTc$pxcWqw|$n tr ¦ pxcWt ´Xc z ,n w!pxio|$nymkmk{+xc z l |c z £=^_acbdcpx_ r z nymowxr#cWt ny´amkcWw.pq_ac[|qcWnypxikr tr ¦X|mon wqwxcWw'ry¦Xvaxru´amkc$bw.¦§r _aio|,_ pq_ac¢Lt nym'´LcW_ nJjisru¥r ¦Hpx_acTnymk r qispx_ab4ikw#iktF=n xionytFpW£ xcUn=pqista7wxl |,_ |$mknuwxwxcWw¥c$ta_Lnyt |$cWwpq_acdulLnymkip{ r ¦:pq_ac+cWw!pxikbn=pxikr tLwn=p¥nd|rubTv l\pqnypxikr t n m°|ruw!p _aio|,_ qc$bnyikt wlatL|,_ nytauc z £ ¼ U º
(11) c$ rumslapxikr t n x{dnymk ruxispx_ab0¬j cWtac$,nymki $c z mkiktacWn bdr z cWmC¬jc}\vXc$qisbdcWtup,nym z cUw!ik t°¬jFnybdbn z ikw!pxqis´ l\pxikr t°£.
(12)
(13) ! "# $ %&' ( )* +%+, -. ."$ %&/+0 . . %: ¨%. ¤:cWwnymk ruxispx_abdcUw ur mkl\pxikr t t nyikxcUw43Cnymk r qispx_abdcWw: t pqikFlacUw$¬Jwpqqnyp ikcWw z rumsl\pqisrut°¬Ucpq| £ 5637 ry¡ uc$mA¬#U 9 8:5dc$p z cxcU|laispµw!ikb)lam 3 ¥n !p,w2c$<p ;#r ,wpU¬¥U: =:=95T¦§r qbdc$tFp l tac ¦ n bdismkmsc z nymk r qispx_abdcWw w!pxr\|,_ nuwpqikFlacUw z c xcU|,_ac$,|,_ac z c$}FpqxcWbn z rutupTmC c¯7|Wn |isp cWw!pTqcW|$r tatjlac2bdn ikw z rutupTmscUw)q`$umkn cUw qc$mk`$uc$tFp¨monvamklav n !p z l7pqc$bdv w z c#mA c}\v xikc$tL|c[vXc$,w!rutatacWmsmkc z c#mC l\pqismkikwqn=pqc$laU?£ >¥c¥pxc$mownymk ruxispx_abdcUw wxr tFp¥wxr lauc$tFpl\pxikmkikw w¥msruqwqFlac&msc+vaqr ´ ms`WbTc z cxcU|,_ac$,|,_accWw!p[pxq`Ww¥|r bdvamkc}\c&cpul cvLcWl z ikt\¦§ru!¡ bnypxikr tt° cUwpnyt n ms{FpxioFlac$bdcWtup[nu|$|cUwxwxik´amscu £ >#n t w z c&pqc$mkmscUw[wxipql n=pqisrut w$¬\mkcWw[x`W mkcWw¦§r t z\ cUw[w!l z cWw uqn t z cWlaqw'nytLnymk{upqikFlacUw z ldvaxru´amk`$bdcc$tjjikwqny wxr tFpHvaxrFwx|$xispxcUw$£ cUw ,nyt z cWla,w.wxr tFpHc$tdc±Ocppqxruv wxr l c$tFp z is¯|$ismkcWw¥cUwpqisbdcWc$t0va,n=pxioFlac £ > n vaq`Ww&mkcpq_ rux`WbdA c @B7'C ¤ 3DrumsvXc$xp+cFp E¾nu|$cUn z {u¬W 9 8:5¬Xl t®n msur qipq_abdc z rutat tacdvXc$l\p $pxqc vamkl w vLcW!¦§ruxbn tup c$t bdr={ cWtatac wxlalat vaqr ´ ms`WbTc®|,_ar iowxi#nylZ_ n wqny z Flac t° ikbTvXr xpxc®Flac$m n l\pxqcdnymk r qispx_abdcp,nytFp+ul: n l |lat cd|$r tatLnyiowxwqnyt |$ct° {¾cWw!p+istycW|3p cu£6 m'cUwp Fi z cWbTbdcWtup+cUwxwxc$tFpxikc$m z c|,_aruikwxiklat nymk ruxispx_abdc z c wxr mkl\pqisrut c$t xcWmknypxikr t nJucW|2mscvaqr ´amk`$bdc FlacmA rut«wxr la_ n ipqc ¡ wxr l z xcu£ c$mondt |cWwqwxipqc z cvXr laur ik[va Wz ikxc+mkc)|$r bdvLru!pqc$bdc$tFp z c)mC nymk ruxispx_abdc&cp z cvXr laur ik[msc vLny,nyb pqxcW|$r qxcU|3pxcWbdc$tFpW£ 7Ln |c#latv xru´ams`Wbdc cWmC¬Upxrul\pHva,n=pxio|ikc$t)v n wqw!cv n 'l tacv _ n wxc z c umkn c z cwxcWw'nymk ruxispx_ bTcUw$£ c$p!pqcva_Ln wxc z c monyuc¨|rubdvLru!pqc z ctarub)´aqc$l wxcWw.w!ikb)l mknypxikr t wW£=¤°cbTcWismkmkc$labdr={ cWt z culLnytFpxis¢ c$ mkcWwvXc$x¦§r qbnyt |$cWw z c z isuc$,wn msur qipq_abdcWwvLrulal t vaqr ´ ms`WbTc z rutat cWw!p z c v pxcW z cWwcWwqwqnyiow z c wxikb)lamon=pqisrut z nyt w z cWw¨|$r tFpxc$}jpxcWw z i± qc$tFpqwW¬ cWt7|,_ nyt cWn tFp z n msur qipq_abdcmkc[vamkl ww!rula cWtupHvXruwqw!ik´amkc £ >nytLw|c$p!pxc z\ bny,|,_acu¬6ismcWw!pcWwqw!cWtupqiscWm z c7mkikbTispxcW)mkctar b´aqc z cUwxwqnyioG w 3§vLnyx¦§r iow|ru¶\pxcWl\} 5cp z c pqisqc$¥v nyxpxi z c)mA ikt\¦§ruxbn=pqisrutµ|r tFpqc$tjlac z n t w[mkcWw¥cWwqwxn ikw¥|qr iow w$£ ©¥t¾vamonyt z c}\v qiscWt |cUw¥n z\ Fl nyp vXc$qbdcp z c z isbdiktjlac$mscTtarub)´aqc z cWwqwqnyiow$£X mcWw!pnymkr ,w#t |$cWwqwxn isqc z l\pxikmkikwxc$ z cTbdn taik`$qc) mkr ´Lnymkc mA ist\¦§ruxbnypxikr t z r tat cdv ny+mkcWw+wxisblamon=pxikr tLw&cp z c|rubTv xcWt z qcdFlacWmkw&cUwxwqnyiow&w!rutFpt |cUwxwqnyikxcUw$£O m wW ny isp[nyl wqwxi z iktFp uxcWc¯7|$nu|cWbTcWtFpmkcWwc$}\v xikc$t |$cWwv nuwxw cUw$£ >nyt w|cdpqqnJ=nyikmA¬°tar lLwny´Xr z r tLw+|cpxpxc2FlacUwpqisrut 0mC nyi z c z c2bTr z `WmscUww!pqn=pqikw!pxioFlacWw z cp{jvLc -GH :I <$+J0 + G)9J0$K,£¤ istFpxqr z l |pxikr t z lat³bdr z `$mkcvLcWxbdcp z c}\vamkr ispxcWdc¯7|$nu|c$bdcWtup mkcWw¥w!ikb)lamon=pqisrut wn=¢Lt z c z\ pqc$qbdistacW[mkcWw[|$r t\¢ ula,n=pxikr tLwruv\pxikbnymkcWw z cWwv n qn bd`pxqcWwW£\ªmkmsc)vLcWxbdcp n l wqw!i z c2 Wz laisqc2mkctar b´axc z cWwTwxisblamknypxikr t wT¾uc$taikU£'¤.n¾b pq_ar z r mkr uiscwp,n=pxiow!pxioul c wxcw!pxql |3¡ pqlaqccWt¾pxqr iow pqn vLcUw$£6¤.n2vaqc$bdik`$qc pqnyvXcd|r tL|c$qtacmC i z c$tFpxis¢L|$nypxikr t z cmonwpqxl |pxlaqcw!pqnypxiowpqikFlac |$r qxcUw!vXr t z nytFp+0mC =nymkl nypxikr t z cmonµw!rumsl\pqisrut
(14) vaxr z l ipqc7v ny+l t nymk r qispx_abdcdvLrulalat v xru´ams`Wbdc z r tat £L¤.n7w!cU|rut z c pqnyvXc|$r qxcUw!vXr t z 2mkn7|$r t w!pxql |pxikr t z lat¾bdr z `$mkcn lµtaisucWn 'l + +"H £6 m wW ny isp z c+bdr z\ mkiow!cW¥|c$p!pxc =nymkl n=pqisrut0vLrula[latµvaqr ´ ms`WbTc+c$p¥latac&¦ n bdismkmsc z n msur qipq_abdcWw z rutat w$£ ¤.ndpxqr iowxis`WbTc pqn vLcT|ruxqcWwxvLrut z 7mon2|$r t w!pxql |3pqisrut z lat¾bdr z `$mkAc )::L z cmC =nymkl nypxikr t¾vXr la#mkn bdWbTc¦ nybdikmsmkc z n msur qipq_abdcWw#cp&lat®c$t wxc$b´amsc z cdvaqr ´amk`$bdcWwW£O¤°cdwp,n z clampqisbdc z cTmkn z\ bdn q|,_ c z iktFp uqnypxikr t z cmC ista¦§r qbdnypxikr tcWw!pmon&|rut wpqipql\pxikr t z c$t wxc$b´amkcWw z cvaqr ´amk`$bdcUw z c ¦ xcWt |cvXr la mon¦ nybdikmsmkc z nymk r qispx_abdcWwcWt0FlacUwpqisrut°£ c$p!pxc za bny,|,_ac&w!cWqn)ismkmslLwpq c&TmA n i z c z lat c#¦ n bdismkmsc&v n qn b pxqioul c z nymk ruxispx_ bTcUww!pxr\|,_ nuw¡ pqikFlacUw z cqcW|,_ c$,|,_ac z c}jpqxcWb)lab0£¤:n ¦ nybdikmsmkc ¬tar p Nc MHO?PRQF¬ za vXc$t z z latZv n qn bd`pxqc ucW|pxry¡ qikc$4m S#T£ >#i± qc$tFp,w|$r bdvLru!pqc$bdc$tFp,w)wxr tFp)n=pxpxc$t z l wvLrula z cUw=nymkc$l qw z ikw!pxikt |pxcWw z l v n qn bd`pxqc £ @¥r l w)w!rula_ nyispxrut w z\ pxc$qbdist c$U¬°vLrulalat
(15) vaqr ´ ms`WbTc z c7bdistaikbdikwqn=pqisrut z r tat ¬°lat c2|rut\¢ l qnypxikr t z lv n qn bd`pxqc)FlaiHFny,nytFpxisp z cT´Xr tatacUw&vLcW!¦§ruxbn t |cUw$£X~r la&|cWmkn ¬Xt r l w&wxr la_ n ipqr t w#l\pqismkikwxc$+l t v mkn t z c}\v xikc$tL|cWw z cp,nyikmsmkc) Wz laipqc U£ @[rul w¥wxr l _ nyispxrut w[cWt w!l ipqc)tarul w¥qc$vXr xpxcW#2latac|$mknuwxwxc z c 1. 2. VTVXWZY\[]^H_.
(16) e. (H K
(17)
(18) "# ):. v xru´ams`WbdcWwv nymony´amkc$bdc$tFp pxl z i w¨vXr lamkcWwqul c$mow¨monv n qn b pxqiowxnypxikr tdr v\pqisbn msc#cWw!p|rutatjlac £jgjiOmsc v xru´ams`Wbdc&n vav n !pqiscWtup[TmonT|$mknuwxwxc&c$t0FlacWw!pxikr t°¬ tar l wlapxikmsiow!cWxrut wmonvLny,nyb pqxiowxnypxikr t z r tat c+v ny mon7|$mknuwxwxc z c ¦ qc$t |$c £ ikc$t¾cWtupqc$t z l°¬X|$cpxpxc za bny,|,_ac)wxl wq|ispxc z cWl\}¾FlacWw!pxikr t w[¦§r t z nybdc$tFpqn mscUw$£ ¤.nTvaxcWbdis`Wxc+FlacWw!pxikr t0|rut |cWxt cmond|mon wqw!cu£ gjc$mkr tµFlacWmkw|$xispx`WxcUwcp¥|rubdbTcWtFp[vLcWl\p!¡Äc$mkmsc+$pxqc¦ ny´\¡ qioul c #¤:nw!cU|r t z c¥FlacWw!pxikr t7|$r t |$c$qtac[mkc¥vaqr ´ ms`WbTcu£ rubdbTcWtFp¨pxcUwpqc$w!rut2nyvavLnyxpxc$tLnyt |$c[latac |$mknuwxwxc z c+ ¦ qc$t |$c c$pnyxpxio|mkccWw!pw!pxql |3pqla 7z c7mkn¾bdn taik`$qc7w!laik=nytFpxcu
(19) £ >nyt w)mknµwxcW|pxikr t \¬:tar l wva w!cWtFpxr tLw+msc |$r tFpxc$}jpxc z nyv vamsio|$nypxikr t z c¥tarypqxc za bny,|,_ac £ ªt7v n !pqik|$lamsikc$U¬ t r l w z\ |$xik rut wHmkcWwv xru´ams`Wbn=pxioFlacWw c$pTmkcWwTnymk ruxispx_ bTcUw|,_ r iow!iowvXr laTpqcWw!pxc$d|c$p!pqc z\ bny,|,_ac £ >#n t wTmknw!cU|3pqisrut a¬tarul w)v w!cWtupqr t w mkcWwpqxruikwTtaik cUnyl\} z c0tar pxqc za bny,|,_ac Hi z cWtFpxis¢L|$nypxikr t z c0mkn®wpqxlL|3pxl xcu¬HbTr z `Wmscikt z ikFi z lacWm[cp bdr z `Wmscumsru´ nymA£y©[tv n qn ,nyva_ c¨ikbTvXr xpqn tFp¨w!cWqn&|rut wqn | mkn z cUwx|$xikv\pqisrut z cWwHbdr z `$mkcWwmsikt n isqcWw t qn msiow w 3 E¾| l msmonyu_ cGp @[cWm z cWW¬U: = 9 53£ >#n t wmkn®w!cU|3pqisrut e ¬tarul w)v w!cWtupqr t wmkcWwT w!l mp,n=pqw ru´\pxcWtjl w¨vXr l mkcWwvaqr ´am bnypxioul cWw z c¥pqcWw!piktFpxqr z laipqcWw z nytLw¨mon)wxcW|pxikr t a£j^.r lapxcWwmkcWwvaxr\| Wz laqcWw z cUwpqisbn=pqisrut+r tFp p n msiow cWw6vLnyxpxik z lmkr uik|$iscWm J$ ? 3 _ nyb´LcWqw:cp #n w!pxikc ¬uW r l Hc$tLny´amkcWw c$p¥ikvamscW{ ¬6U :53£ %. d%. >nyt w¥|cpxpxcwxcW|pxikr t°¬\tarul wiktFpxqr z laikwxr tLwmsc+|rutFpxc}jpqc z n vavamkik|Wn=pqisrut|,_aruikwxi6vXr lapqcWw!pxc$¥mknTb ¡ pq_ar z r mkr ikcw!pqnypxiowpqikFlacu(£ >¥cdbnyt is`WxcT t ,nymkc ¬XismwW ny isp z cbdiktaikbTiowxc$+latacT¦§rut |3pqisrut z\ ¢ taikcTwxla l t2w!rul w!¡AcWt w!cWb)´amkc¥|$r bdv n |p z c &¬ "!$#u¬F)mC nyi z c z n msur qipq_abdcWw rumsl\pqisrutat n isqcWwwxv |is¢LFlacUw$£ @¥r l wv w!cWtupqr t w z cWl\}7p{jvXcWw z c+vaqr ´ m bdnypxioFlac#c$p[latac¦ nybdikmsmkc z nymk ruxispx_abdcUwv |iow!cu£ c|$r t\¡ pqc}jpxc+t r l wwxc$qjis,n)dva wxc$tFpqc$mscUw w!l mp,n=pqw|$r t |$xc$pqw z c&mondw!cU|3pxikr t0eL£a¤°cWw|,_ r is}2c±OcW|pxl w[w!rutFp n x´ ipqqn isqcWwW%£ iscWt7c$tFpxcWt z l°¬Fmon+b px_ r z c#Flac[tarul w¨n msmkr tLwva wxc$tFpxcW¨wxc[ t ,nymkikwxc[ z c#tar b´aqc$l\} n l\pxqcWwp{jvXcWw z c+v xru´am bn=pxioFlacWwc$p z n msur qipq_abdcWwW£ &('*) + ,.0/2143576 8. 9;:*<>=@?AB/DCFE 5>G HIKJIKJ L ¼M ON ¼M d ¸ $ ' ¸ ¸ @¥r l w pxl z isrut wF80v xru´ams`WbdcWw z c7bdiktaikbTiowqn=pxikr. t
(20) ¦§ FlacWbdbTcWtFp)l\pxikmkikw w+vXr l pxcUwpqc$mkcWwnymk r ¡ q ispx_abdcWw rumslapxikr tat n isqcWwW£H¤:n z ikbdc$t wxisrut z l³vaxru´amk`$bdcµ=nyqisc z latac wxispxl nypxikr t³
(21) mC nyl\pqxcu£~r la pqr l\pqcWw#mscUw¦§rut |3pqisrut w#7bTiktaikbdikwxc$U¬LmkcWw|rjru z rutat cWw[wxr tFp z\ ¢ taikcWw z nytLw¥mA iktFpxcWx=nymkmkcQPSRUTWV XYZ#\[B] t adcA3e: ,I $¬ z ikbdc$t wxikr bt f*5cWw!p z\ ¢ taikc z c&mkndbnyt is`Wxc&w!l is=nytFpqc ^ XBYW#_[_`Ä£\¤:n¦§r t |pxikr b ¤.n¦§r. k s ghbi TjV XBYW#_[] ^ XBYW#_[_`lk]ma con hp R$a c%n h c ]OYqYqYO] h k p R r s hu Y t c t |pxikr tba u 3 z ikbdc$t wxikr tv[%w9¨5 cUwp z\ ¢ taikc z c+monbn tais`Wxc+wxlaikJn tFpxc 2s u*z s xg hyi TWV XYZ#\[B] ^ XYZ#\[o` uDz ]ma u n hxp R$a u n h co]OYqYOY{] h u*z p R r s hu V|q}~ n h [ p ^ #Y t c. RVl .
(22)
(23) ! "# $ %&' ( )* +%+, -. ."$ %&/+0 . 8. ¤.n¦§r t |pxikr tbaG3 z ikbdc$t wxikr tv[%w95¨cUwp z\ ¢ taikc z c+monbn tais`Wxc+wxlaikJn tFpxc. s uDz r s gxh i TWV XYZ#\[B] ^ XBYW#_[_` u*z ]ma n xh p R n [dw h ^ wY X p u ct tacmonµv n !pqisccWtFpxik`$qc z l wx|Wnymonyikxc OX£:¤.n0¦§r tL|3pxikr t % + a 3 z. r O z\ w!ik za ¢ taikc z c&mondbdn taik`$qcwxlaikJn tFpxc. ikbTcWt wxisrut [%w*5cUwp. s uDz s gxhbi TWV XYZ#\[B] ^ XBYW#_[_` u*z ]ma n hp R r s h u ^ wBY X. t c s r cUwp#latac)=n xiony´amkcnym nypxruisqc z c)mkr i.latais¦§r qbTcw!la n wB]O# p 3 xcWtar l c$mkm c z cbn tais`Wxc)ist za vXc$t\¡ z nytFpxc)|,_ nuul c =nymkl nypxikr t/5 £F¤.n+¦§r tL|3pxikr tya
(24) y¬jnyvavXc$m c¥¦§r t |pxikr t z c B#% ):+ 3 z ikbTcWt wxisrut95¬ucUwp. za ¢ taikc z c&mondbdn taik`$qcwxlaikJn tFpxc. . ghbi TWV XYZ#\[] ^ XYZ#\[o` m ] a
(25) n h p $ R a
(26) n h c%]qYqYOYq] h p R r s . t c. s s h u V #Ow0|{}~ n [ h p ^ #\w Y. µ¼ ¸ I ¤:cvaqr ´amk`$bdc a c cWw!p)|rut wxi z\ |rubdbTcd¦ nu|ikmscu£:¤°c7|,_ r is} z latac z ikbdc$t wxisrut®¦ nyik´amsc7|$r t\¡ pqxik´alac|c|$n qnu|3px`Wxcu£=~r la|c[v xru´ams`Wbdc ¬ rut2n=pxpxcWt z7z c#´LrutatacWwvXc$x¦§r qbdn t |cUw z cUw¨nymk ruxispx_ bTcUw$£ ² mA ruvavLrFw ¬ mkcWw#vaqr ´amk`$bdcWw ad] a Tw!rutup&|rut w!i z\ w¥|rubdbTc z\ mkio|$n=p,w 3 ruisqcbnym z\ ¢Ltaic$t|$cFlai |$r t |$c$qta(c a \53£ ªt z isbdc$tLw!ikr ty ¬Umon#¦§r t |pxikr t z c[n w!pxqik iktry±OxclatTvaqr ´amk`$bdc z c|rubTv msc$}jisp vamkl w mscW cFlacmkcWw¨nyl\pqxcUw$ £ @¥r l wHwxr la_Lnyispxr tLwH|r tLw!cWxuc$mscbdWbTct r b)´ xc z =nymkl nypxikr t w z cUwwxr mkl\pxikr t w vXr l pxr lLwmscUwvaqr ´amk`$bdcWwW£\~r la[|$cpxpxc+,nyiow!rut°¬\tar lLw pxl z isrut wmkc+vaqr ´amk`$bdc a
(27) 3 z ikbdc$t wxikr t09e 5Flai vXc$lap[pxqc& w!rumsl z n t wmsc+bdWbTc&ru z qc z cpxcWbTvLw z c|$n mk|$lam°Flac a £ . ¼ N \O N ¼ M \2
(28) ¸ ½ b¸ M'¸ . ¼ M'¸ HIKJI H ¤.nTwxcW|$r t z cv xru´am bn=pxioFlac&l\pxikmkikw c+vXr laikmkmsl w!pxqc$monTb px_ r z cwp,n=pxiow!pxioul c+cWw!p|$c$mkmsc z cmA nyv\¡ v xrJ}\ikbdnypxikr t z latac¦§r t |pxikr t¾ cWmsmkc a'¬ z\ ¢ taikcwxla#mA istFpxcWx=n msmkSc TWV#d] ^ #q`A¬Lv ny#lat wxcWn l z c)t c$l\¡ qr t cWw¨n !pqi¢X|ikc$mow z c#p{jvLcvXc$,|c$vapxqr t°£j¤:nwpqxl |pxlaqc z c¥ wxcWn l2|,_ar iowxisc#cWw!plat cw!pxql |3pqlaqc[¢a}\c £j¤:n wxr xpxikc z c+|$c+ w!cUnyl2cUwp z r tat c&v nymon¦§r qb)lamkc+w!laik=nytFpxc. s gbi TjV#] ^ #{` ] n p R ^ r. r ! cWw!pmkn¦§r tL|3pxikr t0mkr uikw!pxioFlac gbi TjV#] ^ #{` ]. ! n. . t c. . s. !. n . s. . # p R # ^$#&%' n V p. ^. ". p. c$pmkcWw|rjc¯7|ikc$tFp,w( Zwxr tFp¨ikt |rutatjl wW£u¤ ikt z io|c*)'cWw!piktFpxqr z laisp¨v ny|rutFuc$tFpxikr t z c#taryp,n=pqisrut°£ c$p!pxc w!pxql |pxlaqc z\ ¢ t ip[lat0vXc$,|cWv\pxqr t0pxqr iow|r lL|,_acWwW¬jed|$c$mkmsl mscUw[|$nu|,_ cUwc$p[latacwxr xpxikc#mkikt n isqc £ VTVXWZY\[]^H_.
(29) . (H K
(30)
(31) "# ):. ªHp,nytFp z r tat Xv r iktup,w$¬ M ] # Qu¬|rutFpxc$tjl w z nytLw2mA iktFpxcWx=nymkmkc za ¢ taiowqw!rut wmC c$qqc$la z nyvav xrJ}\ikbdnypxikr t z c+mknTbnytaik`$qc+w!l is=nytFpqc
(32) n . p R # r. t. c. TjV#] ^ #q`A¬t r. l w. n n p V a n *p p u Y. ¤.nTvaxru´am bn=pqikFlac&|,_ar iowxisc+|rut wxiks w!pxc+Ts bdistaikbdikwxc$¥mC c$qxcWla
(33) n p $c t s ¬acWt0wxlavavXruwqnytFp g. . ] . ] . ] . ". i P R TWV XY wB] ^ XY wo` ]. . i P Y. ¤:cWw)vaxru´amk`$bdcWw z n vavaqrJ}\isbn=pqisrut®|$r t wxi z\ w z nyt w)mknw!cU|3pxikr t ew!cWxrutup)nuwxwxr\|i wn l\}®¦§r t |pxikr t w aUR ay ¬ a ¬ a ¬a z r tFp mkcWw ,nyva_ cWw2wxr tFp za ¢ taiow z nytLw2mon ¢ ulaqc £¤°ctar b´axc z c vXr iktFpqw z nyt wTmA iktFpxc$q=nymkmsk cTjV#] ^ #q`cUwp Fnym R #\wdw Y m[w$ nyuip z c0vaxru´amk`$bdcWw z c0bdistaikbdikwqn=pqisrut cWt z isbdc$tLw!ikr t un msc®ZUa£¤°cUw cWxqc$l qw|ruxqcWwxvLrut z n tupqcWw7wxr tFp0taryp cUw 7R y¬ u¬ k ¬ £ ©¥t vLcWq|$c$v\pqxrut pxqr iow)|$r l |,_acUw+vXc$l\p za ¢ taik)l t nyvav xrJ}\ikbdnypxcWla+lataik cWqwxc$m 3 ruisvLnyc$}jcWbdvamsc [isvamkc${ 3U 9 5!5£ E¾nymk_acWlaxcWl wxc$bdc$tFpW¬ msruqwqFlac&msc,nyt z cWw[|$rFc$¯7|ikc$tFpqw cWw!p[´Lruxt c$p¥mkctar b´aqc z cd|$c$mkmsl mscUw|Wn |,_ cWw#cWw!p+msikbdip ¬°|c$p!pqcdny¯xbn=pqisrut t° cWw!p+v n w=nymki z c (£ @¥r l wtac|rutat n ikwqs w!rut wnymkr ,w n l |l tac+´Lruxt c+ist\¦ xikc$l xc+va,n=pqikFlacWbdc$tFp[l\pxikmkikwqny´amkc+vXr la[mA c$qxcWla z nyvavaqrJ}\isbnypxikr t £ cp pqn=p z c#¦ n ip¥n la bdcWtupqc&mkn z is¯7|lamsp )z l vaqr ´ ms`WbTc z c+bdiktaikbTiowqn=pxikr t:£ µ¼ ¸ I ¤:cWw vaqr ´amk`$bn=pqikFlacUw2|$r t wxi za cWw z nytLw2mkcWw z cWl\} w!cU|3pxikr tLw2vXc$lauc$tFp $pxqc®|$r t wxi z\ cUw |$r bdbdc r lac$pqw ,¬X|y cWw!p!¡ =¡ z isqc+vXc$l¾ n msiowpqcWwW£ ^.r l\pqc¦§r iowW¬Likm:v n qn kp z i¯7|$ismkc z cT|rulajxik[mA lat isuc$,wxny¡ mkisp &z cWwvaqr ´ ms`WbTcUwn ´Lru za wv nymkcWwnymk ruxispx_abdcUw ur mkl\pxikr t t nyikxcUw$£j¤°cUwvaxru´amk`$bdcWw z nyvavaqrJ}\isbny¡ pqisrut w)wxr tFpwxl wq|cWv\pxik´amkcWw z c |$r t w!pxispxlacW)lat c |mon wqw!c z c ¦ qc$t |$c7vLrula)mA nymk r qispx_abdc2Flac7t r l w pxl z iscWxrut w$/£ @[r lLw[ cWxqr tLw z nyt w[mkn7wxcW|pxikr t0e2FlacWm:taik cUnyl z c)wxisutais¢L|$nypxikFisp |cpxpxc)ny¯xbn=pqisrut vXr l x,n2$pxqc|r tLw!i z\ c|$r bdbdcTc$}an |3pqc (£ @¥r l w+uc$qxrut wnyl wqw!i|$r bdbdc$tFp+pxcUwpqc$Fl° latacd¦§rut |3pqisrut t: n vav nyxpxikc$tFp[v nuw¥7|$cpxpxc |mon wqwxc 3£ @[r pxr tLw¥FlacmkcWw¥vaxru´amk`$bdcWw z c wxcWnyla} z ctac$laqr t cWwrutup z cWw |Wny,n |p qiowpqikFlacUwd´aiscWt xcU|rutatjlacWwW£¨¤°cUw7bdiktaisbn mkr\|$n l\} t r b)´ xcWl\}«c$p2mC c}\iowpqc$t |$c z cvamknypxcUnyl\} ¦§rutFpFlacmscUw¨b px_ar z cUwtjlab xioFlacWwmsr\|WnymkcWw 3L: 0J0)9%&2cp=nyqikn tupqcWw 5H|rutj c$q cWtFpw!rula cWtFp mkc$tFpqc$bdc$tFpr l
(34) uc$,w z cWwwxr mkl\pqisrut w+vXc$l iktup qcWwqwxn tFpxcW.w 3Cisv mscW{ ¬¨U u* 53£°¤:cWw+b px_ar z cUw ur mkl\pxikr t\¡ tLnyikxcUw.rutFpHwxr l c$tFp p nyvavamkioul cWwH z cUwvaqr ´amk`$bdcWw z lTbdWbTcp{jvX c 3!¥ik#t "¨nyrL¬\W u* 5?¬ 3 [laiA¬ ¤.nyb c$p _acUna¬:U 53£L^:rul\pxc$¦§r iow$¬Lism.cWw!p¥qn xcWbdc$tFp¦ nyisp#bdc$tFpqisrut z l tac)b pq_ar z c z cT|rut\¢ l qnypxikr t z cWw n msur qipq_abdcWwl\pqismkikw wW£ &(' &. $ &: % . 8/2AB, =@5>G. @¥r l w®nJ rut w¾|,_aruikwxi z ikmsmkl w!pxqc$ t rypxqc b px_ar z c mC nyi z c z l tnymk ruxispx_abdc rumsl\pqisrutat n isqc Lv ny,nyb pq v n z c$la}³|$r bdvLrFwxn tFpxcWwW£H m#wW ny isp z c¾mA nymk r qispx_abdc('*)+-,.+ Eµl\pqnypxikr t0/# gjcWmscU|3¡ pqisrut2ªur mkl\pxikr tLnyq{dgFpqqnypxcW { 37 qn t21ruikwW¬LU *=*53£ c|,_ r is}dcUwpbdrypqis v n mon)´Xr t tac|$r tatLnyiowxwqnyt |$c FlacTtarul w#nJur t w z cd|cp+nymk ruxispx_ bTccp z cdw!rut ikbTv mkn tup,n=pqisrut°£ ikc$tc$tFpxcWt z l°¬6|cd|,_arui}µcWw!p+nyq´ai¡ pqqn isqc £L mcWw!pvXruwqw!ik´amkc z pql z ikc$ z cUw#n msur qipq_abdcWw# t pxioFlacWwA3 3 5¬ z cWw&w!px,n=p ikcWw z rumsl\pqisrut 3 ª g 5'rul z cUw.b px_ar z cUw_F{j´aqi z cWw'|rulavamonytFp'v xr\| Uz laqcWw.tjlab qikFlacUw.c$p rumslapxikr tat n isqcWwW¬ z lqcW|$laip wxikb)lam ¬ucpq| £s¬uikwqwxl w z c¥´ais´ msikrypq_a`WFlacUw¨w!pqnyt z ny z iow cWwW£ cWwH¦ n bdismkmscUw z nymk ruxispx_ bTcUw z\ vLcWt z c$tFp z lat. RVl .
(35) . 0.8. function f8. 0.5. 0.2. 0.6. 0.4. 0.7. 0.6. 0.8. function f6. 0.9. 1.0. 1.0. 1.2. 1.1.
(36) ! "# $ %&' ( )* +%+, -. ."$ %&/+0 . -1.0. -0.5. 0.0. 0.5. 1.0. -1.0. -0.5. 0.0. 0.5. 1.0. 0.5. 1.0. x - axis. 0.6. function f9. 0.8 0.2. 0.2. 0.4. 0.4. 0.6. function f7. 0.8. 1.0. 1.0. 1.2. x - axis. -1.0. -0.5. 0.0 x - axis. 0.5. 1.0. -1.0. -0.5. 0.0 x - axis. d 3qn va_acWw z cWw¦§rut |3pqisrut w;a y¬ a ¬a k ¬a £L¤:cWwc$}jv xcUwxwxisrut wnytLnymk{upqikFlacUw z cUw¦§r t |pxikr t w#w!rutFp a n p R
(37) n # ^ wBY X ~ u n X pDp ¬a n xp R ~ nK p ^ wBY [ |{}~ n X p ^ wBY ^ wY [ u ¬a k n xp R #V u ^ wY [ |{}~ n p ^
(38) 0cp a n p R wBY [ |q}~ n p V wY [ u ^ #Y r R n # ^ xp [\¬ bi TWV#d] ^ #{Ä` £. vLny,nybd`pqxc cW|pxruxikc$mA£6¤°c|,_ar is} z l®v ny,nybd`$pxqcwxcTvXruwxc z cdbnytaik`$qci z cWtupqikFlacdvXr la '*)+ , + rul vXr l mscUwnyl\pqxcUwb px_ar z cUw$£ @¥rypxrut w7Flacµmon b pq_ar z r mkr uisc z\ ¢ taikc z nytLw7|c0pqqnJ=nyikmcWw!p7¦§rut z\ c¾wxla7mon |rubdv ny,nyiow!rut z c vXc$x¦§r qbnyt |$cWwnyl2wxc$ikt z latac#¦ nybdikmsmkcv ny,nyb pqxioFlac z nymk ruxispx_ bTcUw$£F¤:n)bTWbdc¥pqcW|,_ataioFlacvLcWxbdcp n l wqw!i z c#|r bdv n xcW z cWwn msur qipq_abdcWwiowxwxl w z c¦ nybdismkmkcWw z iow!pxikt |3pqcWw 3 3 cpªgTv n c}\cWbTv msc#53£:@¥r l w z ikwq|l\pqc$qr t w|$c+vLruistFp z n t wmknd|$r t |$msl wxikr t°£ ¤¨ n msur qipq_abdc '*)+-,.+ z\ |qipmC ur mkl\pxikr t z lat cvXr val mknypxikr t z cTw!rumsl\pqisrut w z cpqn ismkmkc¢a}\c £6gjrut ru´\cW|pxis¦:cWw!p z c¥pqxrula cWmkcbTiktaikb)lab ny´ wxr mkl z latac¦§r tL|3pxikr t z\ ¢Ltaisc&wxlalat wxr l w!¡Äc$t wxc$b´amsc|rub¡ vLn |3p z c & £ >#n t w|cpqqnJ=nyikmA¬Ft r l wwxlavavXruwxr t wFlac&mkn)pqn ismkmkccUwplat c&|$r t w!pqn tFpx.c 3 Fnymkc RU # 5c$pTt r t l t v n qn bT`$pxqc £ c|,_arui} cUwpTbTr pxik v nyTmon |monyxp z cmkn z ikwq|lLwxwxisrut°£^:rul\pxc$¦§r iow$¬ t r l wnJ rut w¥ qi¢ Fl° nylaubTcWtFpxc$#mkn2pqn ismkmkc z c R #d#d R B#)vLnyc}\c$bdvamkct: n v n w z c±Ocp wxik tais¢L|$nypxis¦&wxlamon
(39) vLcW!¦§ruxbn t |c z c¾mA n msur qipq_abdc 3 vLrula7mkcWw7
(40) v xru´ams`WbdcWw|rut wxi z\ w z nyt w2|cp n !pqik|$ms#c 53£ ¤:cWw z cWl\}|$r bdvLrFwxn tFpxcWw z lv n qn bT`$pxqc z c+mC nymk ruxispx_abdc E /&gjªgwxr tFp[nyvavXc$m w 0!:c$p " L*L+$+% . : F- % %&L£ cWw[|$r bdvXruwqnytFpxcUwwxr tFptar p cU w )c$$p #:£ @¥r l wnJur t w z rut | S R n o]%# p Y. VTVXWZY\[]^H_.
(41) =. (H K
(42)
(43) "# ):. ¤¨ n msur qipq_abdc cWw!p z\ ¢ t i z c mon³bs nytaik`$qc wxlas is=n tupqc £¥¤.n³vLruvalamon=pqisrut ³mkn³ t qnypxikr tcUwp qc$s v w!cWtup c0v n 7mkn
(44) bnypxqik|$c R n O p ¬¨r O z\ wxik tacµmon `$bdc¾|rjru z rutat c z c¾mkn w!rumsl\pqisrut O ¬ # ) £j¤:n+vXr v lamknypxikr t7cUwpist ipqikn msiow c z c#bnytaik`$qc¥nyq´aispx,nyikxc z nyt w¨mC cWwxv n |$c z c#xcU|,_ac$,|,_acu£ ~rula|$r t w!pxqlaikxc#mknvXr valamon=pqisrut mkn) t ,n=pqisrut ^ # ¬jrutpxikxc&nyl _ n wqny z lattarub)´aqc w!cWmsrut7mkn mkr i6´ istarubdikn msc n V #d] # p £ ~laiowr tvLcW!s pqlaq´Lc+mkcWw 9vaqc$bdikc$,wucW|pxsc$l qw|$r mkr tatacUw z c&mkndbnypxqik|$c c$t nyr l\p,nytFp¥latacT|rjr z rutat c z Fc O 3 ) i Tj#]qYqYOYq] `+5¬ z iowxr t wBO ¬Xlatac=nyqiony´amkcnym nypxr ikqc. z cmkr i:latais¦§r qbTc+wxlamA iktFpxc$q=nymkmsc TWV o]& \` s s O
(45) R O ^ Y s ikc$t
(46) c$tFpqc$t z l:¬°r t
(47) |rutupqqn istFp+mon0tar lauc$mkmsc|$rFru z r tat A c O 0qcWw!pxcW z nytLw+w!rut®iktFpxcWx=nymkmkc z c z\ ¦ ¡ iktaispxikr t PL£ /#t xcWbdvamknu|c7cWt wxlaipqc2mkcWw)ist z isji z l wxcUwp,nytFpqw)v nymsc bTcWismkmkc$laTist z isji z l ru´\pxcWtFl«µmkn t qnypxikr t 3£ cp!pqc+vaqrj| Wz l xc&cWw!p[isp cl wqFl° valaiow!cWbdc$tFp z c&mkndqcWwqwxr la,|c z c|$n mk|$lamC£ mOw$ nyuipcWt¦ nyisp z latac# cWqwxisrut mkipqikw!pxc z c¥mA n msur qipq_abdc '*)+-,.+a£u~n xbdiLmscU$w ;ikt z ikji z l w z c[mkn vXr v lamknypxikr t°¬awxc$l mkw V #wxr tFp[w!lLwx|$c$v\pqis´amkcWw z c&wxla´aiklatac&bl\pqnypxikr t°£a¤:c z c$qtaiscWist z isji z l0cWw!pl t p bdr ikt z c&mknbdc$ikmsmkc$laqc+w!rumslapxikr t7pqxrula c z c$valaiowmon) t qnypxikr t2iktaispxionymkc £\ªtbdr={ cWtatac ¬\d|,_ nuul c t qnypxikr t°¬ n V # p #¾|$r bdv ny,nyiowxr t ww!rutFpc$±XcU|3pql cUwvLrula z\ pxc$qbdist c$mkcbdcWismkmscWla[ikt z ikji z l:£ ¤:r ,wxFlacmkcv ny,nybd`$pxqc #cWw!p¨vLc$pxispW¬FismLcWw!p¨vXruwqw!ik´amkc z c¥Fl nytFpqi¢ cWmkc¥|rubTvXr xpxcWbdc$tFp z c '*)+ , + cWt _ar qi $r t z c7pxc$bdv w)msruistFp,nyikt 3 K+ \k¬ 5£.¤:n¾vaxru´ ny´ ismkip vLrulaFlac2mkn¾wxr mkl\pqisrut®v xruvLrFw c vLnymA n msur qipq_abdc '*)+-,.+µwxcpxqr lauc z nyt w)lat ruikwxikt nyuc z lat bdciktaik b)lab ny´Lw!rumsl |rutj c$q cT cWqw u£°¤:njipqcWwqw!c z c7|$r tj cWxuc$t |$c)cUwp r b pxqikFlacu¬ z cdqn ikwxr t n # p £:¤¨ ikt z io|c z cd|$r tj cWxuc$t |$c xcWva wxc$tFpxc#msctar b´aqc¥bdist isbnym z c#bl\pqnypxikr t wt |$cWwqwxn isqcWw¨vLrulapxqr lauc$latac&w!rumslapxikr t z =n m¡ lLn=pxikr tbdc$ikmsmkc$laqcTv nyxpqn tup z lat®vLruistFp z is± xcWtup z lat®bTiktaikb)lab9ny´ wxr mkl z cdmon7¦§rut |3pqisrutru´\cW|pxis¦ 3 7a,ny2t 1$r iow$¬ W * =*5£ c¨ wxlamspqn=p.bTrutFpxqcmC ikbTvXr xpqn t |c z l)|,_arui} z l+v n qn bT`$pxqc vLrula:mA nymk r qispx_abdc £ g\r t2ikt l c$t |$ccUwp z\ pxcWxbdikt nytFpxc&wxlamkn ,nyt z c$la B£ ikc$tc$tFpxcWt z l°¬\mon)uqn t z cWlanyt n ms{FpxioFlac t: cUwp[v nuwn |W|cWwqwxis´amkcc$t0va,n=pxioFlac&vLrula z cUwvaxru´amk`$bdcWw|$r bdvamkc}\cWwW£ &(' ! 8B?#" ? E(1 ?%0$ A & 8 /25>E 8G >#c&tar b´axcWl\}nyxpxio|mkcWw¨¦§r tFp pqnyp z c#px,nJ=nyl\} z c&|rubTvLny,nyiow!rut z n msur qipq_abdcWw¨cp z =nymkl n=pqisrut z cvXc$x¦§r qbnyt |$cWwW£u m°wW ny isp´aiscWt cWtFpxc$t z l z l tacpx_ bdnypxioFlac&bdnyc$laqc z nyt wmond|r bdblat nylap &z cWw n msur qipq_abdcWwwpqr\|,_ n w!pxioFlacWwW£j m°cWw!pisbdvXruwqw!ik´amkc z c&|$ipqc$pqr l wmkcWwpqqnJ=nyla} 3§ ruisU¬jv nyc$}\c$bdvamkc ¬\ t\¡ u´LcW&cpruwxc$t 3U u* 53¬O~Hny '' 3Wu* 8*53U¬ ;&cWn tac 3!Wu 553£O¤°cUw+wp,n=pxiow!pxioul cWw&w!rutFp&wxr lauc$tFp&va w!cWtFpxcWw bn ikwTc$mkmkcWwwxr tFpW¬c$t t ,nymA¬'l\pxikmsiow cWw z c bnyt is`Wxc pxq`Ww m bTcWtFpqnyikqc £¤:n®vamklav nyxp z cWwn l\pxcWlaqw wxc¾|rutFpxc$tFpqc$tFp z c¾ v pqc$ z c tar b´axcWl wxcWwwxisblamknypxikr t w z cWw2n msur qipq_abdcWwnJucW|latac¾=n xiony´aikmkip pqx`Uw¦ nyik´amkcdwxla+mkcWw&v n qn bd`pxqcWw z c7|$cWw+nymk ruxispx_ bTcUw$£Xªt
(48) t ,nymA¬6nyl |$lat®bTr z `Wmsc7w!pqnypxiowpqikFlac z c mA =nymkl n=pqisrut z cµmon
(49) w!rumslapxikr t t: cUwp7iktFpxqr z laipvXr ladpqqn ipqc$d mkr ´Lnymkc$bdc$tFpdmscUw z r tat cWwW£ >#cµqn xcUw pqqnJ=n l\} 3K cWxuc$qcpc;p cUwxwxc ¬°U 5¨bTcWtFpxikr tatacWtFp¥mscUwb pq_ar z cWw#wp,n=pxiow!pxioul cWw z c+v mkn t w z c}\v qi¡ cWt |cUw 3§v mkn t w+¦ nu|3pxruxikc$mow 53£:ª¨t\¢ t°¬.msc2px,nJJn ismHc$±XcU|3pql z n t w|$cpTn !pqik|$mscvXc$lapTwxc$qFik Jn msl c$mkcWw v xru´ams`WbdcWwpxcUwp[cWl\}j¡Abd$bdcUw 3 D _aispxmkc${u/¬ E¾nypx_aion wW¬a[nytLnc$p > Wla´Xc$,na¬6Wu* 8*53£. RVl .
(50) .
(51) ! "# $ %&' ( )* +%+, -. ."$ %&/+0 . %.- m.c}\ikw!pxc z i± qc$tFpqcWwbnyt is`WxcUw z =nymklac$¥mkndvXc$x¦§r qbnyt |$c z l t¾nymk r qispx_abdc z cqcW|,_ c$,|,_acwxla l t vaxru´amk`$bdc z r t t £° mcWw!pt n=pqlaqc$m z cd¢a}\c$mkc7tarub)´aqc z =nymkl n=pqisrut w z c7mon¦§r tL|3pxikr t ru´\cW|pxis¦ c$p z ru´ w!cWxuc$mon¾=n mscWlaTnyp!pqc$iktupqc2v n mA nymk r qispx_abdc £. mcWw!pTnylLwxwxivXruwqwxis´amkc z c2¢a}\cWlat«w!cWlaism z c vXc$x¦§r qbnyt |$c+n=p!pqc$ikt z qc+cp z r ´Lw!cWxuc$msc+t r b)´ xc z =n msl nypxikr t wt |cUwxwqnyikqcWwvLrula z\ v n wqwxc$[|c wxc$l ismA£^:rul\pxc$¦§r iow$¬|cpxpxc z cWxt is`Wxcµnyv vaxr\|,_act |cWwqwxipqc z c¾|r t t
(52) n opxqc0mkn®=nymkc$labdiktaikbdn mscu£4>nyt w z ctar b´axcWl wxcWw+wxipql n=pqisrut w+va,n=pqikFlacUw$¬:|$cpxpxc=nymkc$la)cWw!p)istL|r t tFl ccpmon0vaxcWbdis`Wxc7n vavaqrj|,_ cTcUwp ¦§ FlacWbdbTcWtFpn z r vap cu£ ( '*) 35 $ AB/ x? A/*. $ 3 E =@.(3<>:*5 ©¥t¾bdr z `$mkc)t n ¦l\pqismkiow!cWqn ip¥monmkr i'un l wxwxikc$tatac+vXr l ¥bdr z\ mkikwxc$#mkn2=nymkc$la z c)mon7wxr mkl\pxikr tµvaqry¡ vXruw cv n 'mA nymk r qispx_abdc #£ @[rul wnymkmsrut w.¦ nyikxclatd|,_ar is} z is± xcWtFpW £ @[rul w'r ´ wxc$q rut w°l tacJn xiony´ mscvLrFw¡ ispxik cu¬ z iowxwx{jb pxqioul c ¬yvaqc$tLnytFpH¦§ Flac$bdbdc$tFp z cUw=nymkc$la,w mkc$ cUw$¬ nJucW|latbdr z c[wxr lauc$tFpvaqrj|,_ c z cWw=n mscWlaqw z =nymkl n=pqisrutbTiktaikbnymkcWw 3 ik|$i qrFlaiX|$r qxcUw!vXr t z +monwxr mkl\pxikr tc$}an |3pqc z l7v xru´ams`Wbdc z cbdiktaikbTiowqn=pxikr t z n t wmknvamklav n !p z cUw|$n w'pqcWw!p 5:£ >¥cvamkl wW¬y|c$p!pxc=n xiony´amkcvaxcWt z ¦§ ul c$bdbdc$tFp z cWw =n mscWlaqw mkc$ cUw$£O¤:n2msrui't r qbdn msctacdwxnypxiow¦ n ipv n w&2|$cWw&|rutFpx,nyiktupqcWwW£L² mC r v vLrFw ¬Xmon7mkr iFnybdbn vLny,
(53) n opbdikc$l\}0n z n v\p cvXr l bTr z\ msiowxc$latac&pqc$mkmsc+=n xiony´amkc £ ~r l #=nymki z c$&|c$p!pxcds nyq l s bTcWtFpqn=pqisrut°¬ t r l wnJ rut wc±OcW|pxl Wu 7wxikb)lamon=pqisrut w z c)mA n msur qipq_abdc vXr l mscUwvaxru´amk`$bdcWw a c$p vXr la[l tac&Jn mscWla¢a}\c z l0v n qn bT`$pxqBc S . . . . R. #dY [ ] # R wBY Y. ¤:cWw¨_aikw!pxru ,nybdbdcWw z cUw¨=n mscWlaqw z c¥monwxr mkl\pxikr tvaqr z laispxc[vLny¨mA nymk r qispx_abdc'*)+ , ++qcWwqwxc$b)´ mscWtup¨ z cWw'_aiowpqr ,nybdbdcWw z cmkr i\un bdbdnA3 ¢L laqc*53£y¤:cWw z c$la})vaqc$bdiscWqw'bdr bdcWtup,w z cmkn=nyqikn ´amkc pxl z i c 3§pqn ´amscUnyl«H 5#bdr tFpxqc$tFp+ul cTmkc|rubTvXr xpxcWbdc$tFp z cTmA nymk r qispx_abdcTcWw!ppqx`Uw z i± qc$tFp+vXr la|,_ nu|lat c z cWw¦§r tL|3pxikr tLw adc_]OYqYqYO] a
(54) £ ac. a. a. a. . a
(55). bTr={uc$tat c a£ u*8yF e £ u = £ :=*8 e £ *= £ = |$n !px¡Cp{jvXc a£ uyeuF a £ £sJy a£ 98 = £ :=98 'd Eµr={uc$tat cc$p |Wnyxp!¡Ap{jvLc z c+mA =nymkl n=pqisrut z c+mknwxr mkl\pxikr tvaqr z laispxc+v n '*)+-,.+a¬ QR #dY [\¬ # R wBY <3Wu v pxispxikr t w 53£ ¤:cWw_aiowpqr ,nybdbdcWwFlaiH|ruxqcWwxvLrut z cWtup&2mA =nymkl n=pqisrut z c*'*)+ , + vLrula adc_]a ]a 3 ¢ ulaxc:5 ¦§rutFpdn vav ny,
(56) n opxqc7lat c z iowqw!{jb pqxikc z n t wTmkn z iowpqxik´al\pqisrut z cmkn=nyqikn ´amkc £ c$p!pqc z u ikwqw!{jb pqxikc2cUwp v xiow!ccWtT|$r bdv\pxcmkr ,w z cmon#bdr z\ msiowxnypxikr tTv nyHmonmsrui\un bTbn £y¤ _aikw!pxru ,nybdbdcFlaia|$r qxcUw!vXr t z mkn ¦§rut |3pqisrut a 3 ¢ ulaqc9 5'cWw!pvaqrj|,_ c z c[|c$mklai z lat cJn xiony´ mscun l wqw!ikc$tat c £ @[rul w cWxqr tLw.vLnyHmon+w!laispxc Fl° latac¨bTr z\ msiowqn=pxikr t&v n °monmsrui un bdbdnt° cWw!p:v nuw6lat+ikt |rutj t iscWtupU£~r la:mkn¦§rut |3pqisrut z c¨[nuwpqxik ikt 3§¦§r t |pxikr t a
(57) 53¬¨mA n wxvLcU|3p z cWtupqc$mkm z cµmC _aiowpqr uqn bTbd' c 3 ¢L laqc¾* 5wW c}\vamkikFlacµv n mkn
(58) v w!cWt |c z c bdiktaikbdn[msr\|$n l\}pxq`Ww°v xr\|,_acUw z c¨mon[wxr mkl\pxikr t&ruv\pxikbnymkc £ cp:_aiow!pxr uqn bdbTcHt c|ruxqcWwxvXr t z [nylL|latac mkr i z c+vaxru´ ny´ ismkip |mon wqw!ioFlac £\¤°c|,_ r is} z l tac z iowpqxik´al\pqisrutFnybdbn)cUwp z r t |&nyq´aispx,nyikxcu£
(59). VTVXWZY\[]^H_.
(60) U. 0.000. 0.001. 0.002 f1. 0.003. 30 0. 0. 0. 10. 10. 20. 20. 20. 30. 40. 40. 60. 50. 40. 60. (H K
(61)
(62) "# ):. 0.004. 0. 50. 100. 150. 200. 250. 0.2. 0.4. f2. 0.6. 0.8. f3. R7#Y [a¬!# R wBY *5. 0. 0. 50. 10. 100. 20. 150. 30. 200. O ¥ikw!pxru ,nybdbdcWw z c&mC =n msl nypxikr t z c+monTwxr mkl\pqisrut vaqr z laispxc&v n '*)+-,.+ !3. vXr l mscUw¦§r t |pxikr t w acU¬ a u ¬ ay£. 3. 4. 5 f4. 6. 0. 2. 4. 6. 8. 10. 12. 14. f5. 6B [iowpqr uqn bTbdc z c)mC =nymkl nypxikr t z cmkn7wxr mkl\pqisrutv xr z laispxcv ny '*)+-,.+ 3! R@#dY [\¬#vR wBY *5 vXr l mscUw¦§r t |pxikr t w a ¬ a
(63) £ @¥r l wl\pxikmkikwxr t w)vLrula¢ taiklat c2b pq_ar z c z c =nymki z nypxikr t uqn va_aioul c¦§r t za c wxlamsc %C£ m wW ny isp z c0px,n |$c$dmkcWw7Fl n tupqismkcWw z cµmC |,_ n tFpxikmsmkr t c$bdvaikxioFlacµc$t ¦§rut |3pqisrut z c¾|$c$l\} z latacµmkr i z c ¦ xcWt |cu£L¤.n7mkr i z c) ¦ xcWt |ccWw!pwxr isp#un l wqw!ikc$tat c 3 z n t w|cd|$n wW¬ rutµ¦ nyisp+nyvavXc$m7mon7vaqr\| Uz laqc -4w!rul w :$ ?!5&wxr isp)un bTbn 3§v xr\| Uz laqc %w!rul w J$ ?!5!5£.¤ _j{jvLr px_a`Uw!c z n za Fl n=pqisrut 2latac z iowpqxik´al\pqisrut cWw!p& nymkikw!pxcmsruqwqFlac)mkcWw#vLruistFp,w#ru´\pxcWtjl w¥vLny&mscUw¥b px_ar z cUw#uqn va_aioFlacWww!rutFp n msik t wW£W~r l |,_Ln |l tac z cWw 8[¦§r t |pxikr t wW¬JmC n z\ Fl n=pqisrut#mkn&w!pxql |3pqlaxcun l wqw!ikc$tat c¨cp#mkn&w!pxql |3pqlaqc Fnybdbn7cUwppxcUwp <c 3 ¢ ulaxcUw¥e c p 8:5£O¤¨ _j{jvXrypx_ `WwxcFnybdbn7cWw!p&Jn msi z\ c)vXr la adco] a u ] ao]a Tv nymkn b px_ar z c[uqn va_aioFlaccpv nyl tpxcUwp z c ;#r mkbTru ruxr=F¡gjbdisqtar=&nyl7wxc$laikmL £ £y~r l ¨mon&¦§r t |pxikr t z c ¥n w!pxqisuist°¬JmA n z\ Fl nypxikr tdmknmkr iaFnybdbn¥t° cWw!pv nuwJn msi z\ cvLnyHlatTpxcUwp z c ;#r mkbdr ur qr=u¡gjbdikxtar=O£. RVl .
(64) u.
(65) ! "# $ %&' ( )* +%+, -. ."$ %&/+0 . problem f1. 0.0000. 0. 0.0005. 2. 0.0010. 0.0015. 4. 0.0020. 6. 0.0025. 8. 0.0030. problem f1. -2. 0 Quantiles of Standard Normal. 2. 0.000. 0.001. 0.002 Quantiles of Gamma. 0.004. problem f2. 0. -1. 20. 0. 40. 1. 60. 2. 80. 3. 100. 4. 120. problem f2. 0.003. -2. 0 Quantiles of Standard Normal. 2. 0. 20. 40. 60 80 Quantiles of Gamma. 100. 120. c p %:vXr lamkcWwvaqr ´ ms`WbTcUw z c&bdistaikbdikwqn=pqisrutµn wqw!r\|i w adc#c$p;a u ^.r lapxc¦§ruikwW¬:mkcpqcWw!p) ,nyva_ ikFlacbdr tFpqxc 3§¢ laqc295+Flac7mon¾wpqxlL|3pxl xcFnybdbn0cWw!pvamkl w)n z nyvap c7 mA nyt n ms{\wxc z cUw z rutat cUwFlac&mkndw!pxql |3pqlaxc&Fnyl wqw!ikc$t tac £ (' & . 3 <>:25G :*/ $ & ? /*8B5>G % & $ & 8B? :*/DG & G rut wpqipqlac$l tac+|mon wqw!c z c& ¦ qc$t |$c#t |cUwxwxispxc&latac+|rutat n ikwqwxn t |cnyvav xr ¦§r t z ikc z l|$r bdvXr xpxc¡ bdcWtup z cWw&n msur qipq_abdcWw¥wxla#mscUw#v xru´ams`WbdcWw z cmon2|$mknuwxwxc £ >¥cTtar b´aqc$l wxcWw#w!ikb)lamon=pqisrut w¥wxr tFp z r t | ru´amkisFn=pxruisqcWwn=¢Lt z c&|$r lajqismkcWw z i± qc$tFpxcUw=nymkc$la,w z lv ny,nybd`pqxc S vXr la[|,_ nuFlac&vaxru´amk`$bdc £ @¥r l w'vaqr vXruwxr t w°latacbTr z\ msiowqn=pxikr twp,n=pxiow!pxioul c¨vXr la z\ |qisqcmkcWw. w!lamspqnypqw.vaqr z laip,w'v ny.mscUw'n m¡ ur qipq_abdcWwW£y©pqismkikwxc$Hl tdpxc$m bTr z `WmscvXc$qbdcp z c Wz laisqcw!cWt wxis´amkc$bdcWtupmkctarub)´aqc z c$}\v xikc$t |$cWwcWt lapxikmsiowxn tFp:mC ikt\¦§r qbn=pxikr t|$r tFpxcWtjlac z nytLw°mkcWw°ru´ wxc$qJnypxikr t w:ul iu|ruxqcWwxvXr t z cWtFp: z cWw:=nymkc$la,w:|$xruikw cUw z cWwv n qn bd`pxqcWwW£a¤:nTbdr z\ mkiowxnypxikr tµ|,_ar iowxisc+cUwp z l0p{jvXc ' 3 $ H 0
(66) Z+ H : 5 z nyt w mkc2|Wn wvLnyxpxio|lamkiscW z latac msrui¨un bdbdn £°~r lacWw!pxikbdc$)mkcWw)v ny,nybd`$pxqcWw&iktupqxr z l ip,w)v n monµbdr za mki¡ wqn=pqisrut°¬XismHcUwp&t |$cWwqwxn isqc z cwxcqc$v mknu|c$ z nytLw#mkcd|r tFpqc}jpxcTbn=px_ bn=pqikFlacdn wqw!r\|$i 2|cp{jvLc z c bdr z `Wmscu£j^.qr iow_j{jvLr px_a`Uw!cUw¨vXc$qbdcp!pqc$tFp z c|Wny,n |p qiow!cWla
(67) t '"jmon z iowpqxik´al\pqisrut z cmon=nyqikn ´amkc Xe -. VTVXWZY\[]^H_.
(68) J. (H K
(69)
(70) "# ):. problem f3. -2. 0.0. -1. 0.2. 0. 0.4. 1. 2. 0.6. 3. 0.8. 4. problem f3. -2. 0 Quantiles of Standard Normal. 2. 0.2. 0.4 Quantiles of Gamma. 0.8. problem f4. 2. -2. 3. 4. 0. 5. 2. 6. 4. problem f4. 0.6. -2. 0 Quantiles of Standard Normal. 2. 3. 4 5 Quantiles of Gamma. 6. cp %:vXr lamkcWwvaqr ´ ms`WbTcUw z c&bdistaikbdikwqn=pqisrutµn wqw!r\|i w a&c$p;a . U8B -. problem f5. 0. 0. 5. 2. 10. 4. 15. 6. problem f5. -2. 0 Quantiles of Standard Normal. 2. 0. 2. 4. 6 8 Quantiles of Gamma. 10. 12. 14. c$p %:vXr lamon¦§r t |pxikr t z c+[nuwpqxik ikt dc$}\vamsioFlac$U¬\mA c$}jv xcUwxwxisrut z cmkndmkikt n xisp bdcpxpqnytFp¥cWtTc$lµmkcWw=nyqiony´amkcWwc$}jv msio|$nypxik cWw 3 av Wz io|3pqc$la OB J-. RVl .
(71)
(72) ! "# $ %&' ( )* +%+, -. ."$ %&/+0 . U. mkikt n isqcH5#cpmon¦§r tL|3pxikr t Flaiqc$mkikcTmkcva Wz io|3pqc$la mA cWwxv qn t |cdbn=pq_ bn=pqikFlac z cmkn0=nyqiony´amkcT c$}\vamsioFlac$ 3§¦§r t |pxikr t z c+mkiscWt/53£ /#t tarypqc msc0ucW|3pqc$la z cp,nyikmsmkc z cUwdr ´ wxc$q=n=pqisrut w$¬' s nymkiowxnypxikr t z l³ucW|3pqc$lan m n=pxruisqc 3 =nyqikn ´amscc$}jv msioFlac$ 532£ /#t wxlavavXruwxc#FlacmkcWw|rubTvXruwqnytFpqcWw 3 ) R #]qYZYWYZ] 5 z c wxr tFpist za vXc$t\¡ z nytFpxcUwcp z ikw!pxqis´ l cUw[w!cWmsrut0latac+mkr i.n vav n !pqc$t n tup[dmonT¦ nybdikmsmkcc}\vXr tacWtFpxs ikc$mkmscn l0wxc$tLw z c @¥c$m z c$ 3 E¾| l msmonyu_ c$p @[c$m z cWW¬6U: = 9 53£\¤:n¦§rut |3pqisrut z c z c$t wxip z c+mon=n xiony´amk c wW |qisp s s s s. s s a n ] p R. s O V n
(73) p n p ^ n ]
(74) p ]. # % '. r cWw!platv ny,nybd`$pxqc J #cp
(75) latv ny,nybd`pqxc z c< K& 7wa£6¤°cUw[¦§rut |3pqisrut w +cp wxr tFpw!v |$i¢Xul cWw+µ|,_ nuul c z iow!pxqis´alapxikr t°£ c$p!pqcd¦ nybdismkmkc z cmsruikwxcW qr lavXcl t
(76) |$c$xpqn ist®tar b´aqc z cTmkr iow+|mon wqwxikFlacUwQ°´ istarubdikn mscu¬X~ruikwqw!rut°¬6taruxbnymkc ¬OFnybdbna¬Ocp,|y£6ªt
(77) v n !pqik|$lamsikc$&monmsruiHunybdbna¬ n z bdcpvXr la z c$t wxip c n p " ! ]# wB] w Y g\r t7cUw!v ,nyt |$c[cWw!p un msc¥ 2c$pwqn+=nyqikn t |c¥cWw!p Fnymkc¥ u £j¤°cUw¨c$}\vaxcUwxwxikr t w z l2v n qn bT`$pxqc |Wnytarutaioul ca¬ z c
(78) c$p z c OX¬$¥ cWt2¦§rut |3pqisrut z cWwv n qn bd`pxqcWwt nypxlaqc$mow z c&mondmsrui6unybdbndw!rutFp R ]# n p R&Z% }(' n p ]
(79) R # ] O n
(80) p R V
(81) Y g i ] n ] p n p R . rubdbTc z n t w'mscUwbTr z `WmscUw'msikt n isqcWww!pqn t z ny z wW¬WmkcWw'=nyqiony´amkcWw.c}\vamkik|Wn=pqisucWw'istFpqc$qFikc$t tac$tFpmsikt n isqc¡ bdcWtup z nyt wmonTbTr z\ msiowqn=pxikr t:£ /#t z\ ¢ taisp¥mkcv Uz ik|pxcWlamsikt nyikxc&v n ) R+* ,-]. r , cUwpl t cW|pxcWla z c7v n qn bd`pxqcWwikt |rutatjl w z cp,nyikmsmkc ¬°cp-* latac2bdnypxqik|$c /. |rutatjlac ¬ ¢ } c&v nymA c$}\v xikc$t |$c £a¤.nqc$mon=pqisrut mkionytFp0,®c$p1dcWw!p za |qispxcTmC nyi z c&mon32 % * * ,bR n n pDp Y ¤:cWw'|rjc¯7|ikc$tFp,4w ,w!rutFp:cWw!pxikb w'v ny'bn=}\ikb)lab z cjqn ikwxc$b´amkn t |cu£$¤:n¥bdikwxccWt65+lajqc z c|c$p!pxc b px_ar z ccWw!p za |qispxc|$i¡ z cUwxwxr l wW#£ >) nyvaq`Ww.mA _j{jvLr px_a`Uw!c z ist z\ vXc$t z nyt |$c z cUw|rjr z r t t cUw z c7¬Jmkn mkr ¡Aj,nyiow!cWb)´amonytL|c z l2ucW|pxc$l z cUwv ny,nybd`pqxcUw¨|WnytarutaikFlacUw ¬jn l2jl z l cU|3pqc$la z r ´ wxc$q=n=pxikr tLw O¬\cUwp s s s s s sC: s s;: V n p ^@ n ]
(82) pBA Rrs < %W}8'9 n p Y %W}8'9 n p R#rs < O n?
(83) p t c>= t c ¥istLw!iA¬ymon¦§r t |pxikr t>W% }8'9[¬=jlac[|$r bdbdcmsruy¡Äjqn ikwxc$b´amkn t |c z l cU|3pxcWla z cv n qn bd`pxqcWwD,¬uvLcWl\ppqxc. za qis cv ny,nyvavXr xp[dw!cUw z isuc$,w!cUw|r bds vXruwqnytFpxs cUw$£ @¥rypxrus t w E R ST ` RF n p Y VTVXWZY\[]^H_.
(84) We. (H K
(85)
(86) "# ):. ¤:cWw z\ xik cWwwxr tFp[s nymkr ,w$¬jvXr laspqr l\sp %Z}('9 , %Z}('9 ,. i s M #d]qYZYZYW] s Q ] i M #d]OYWYZYZ] Q ] s s s Z % ( } ' 9 # # s s s s s ) E R * n p n p O V?n
(87) Ep ] , ) E & E s s s # s n p n s V s p Y rs < * E E n E p u O n p ct. R R. ). ¥istLw!iA¬ac$t0|rut wxi z\ qn tFpmondbn=pxqio|c z iony rut nymkc s SR. s s s n O n p n E 2p u p t c . . mkcWw Fl n=pqisrut w z l0bn=}\isblab z c+j,nyiow!cWb)´amonytL|c¥vXr l 0,
(88) wW |qik c$tF< p * c ) n QV E p R w E r. 3H5. s. s s s ) R )ss s R n E p
(89) p c Y n E E t . ct ¤¨ n msur qipq_abdcip ,n=pxis¦6bdikwc$tvamon |$c[vX r la . w!< rul z qc|$cWw Fl n=pqisrut wHcUw< pmC nymk ruxispx_abdc z cUw¨wq|ruxcUw z c 7'iow!_ c$U£a m6vaqrj|$` z c+n l\}2isp ,n=pqisrut wwxlais=n tupqcWw 3 ! w*5 u W% }8'9. c. Z% }('9 A , = , , c R , ^ * c *"! * c ) QV E E. , c R , V . ¤.n)¦§rut |3pqisrut :. #. :"\ cUwp. . . !. Y. z\ ¢ taikc&v ny n. :$# : :# ' , p R$[&% %Z}('9 n p V %W}8'9 n , p(. #. r 9 n , p cWw!pmkn=nymkc$la z cmon)mkr ¡Aj,nyiow!cWb)´amonyt |$c[r ´apxc$tjlac&v nyxpxik z l v n qn bd`pxqc¥cUwpqisb ,£\¤:n ¦§rut |3pqisrut :"\ A + [cUwp za ¢ taikc)|$r bdbdc+mknd t qn msiowxnypxikr t z cmonw!rubdbTc z cWw[|Wnyq w z cWw wxi z l w z l0|$nuwunylLwxwxiscWt n : , # p R
(90) n : , # p gjrul w z cWw|$r t z ispxikr tLw z c ulamkn xisp nuwxwxc d t qn mscUw&vLrula)mon¦§r t |pxikr t z c2F,nyiowxc$b)´ mkn t |cdcp qi¢ cWw z nytLw¥mkcT|Wn w z cTmkn7¦ nybdismkmkcc$}jvXr t c$tFpxikc$mkmscu¬Lmon za jikn t |cTw!l ip+n wx{jbTvapxrypqikFlacWbdc$tFp#lat cmkr i z *l ) u 7 V z c$u w z cmkis´Xc$xp £y~r laHvamkl w z c z\ p,nyikmkwHwxlamkcWwvaxr\| Wz laqcWw z cWw!pxikbn=pqisrutTlapxikmsiow cWw z nyt w.mscUw ' c$p.mkc$la,w:v xruvaxi p wW¬$rutvLrulaqqn[wxc¨ ¦ xcW.n l)mkisjqc z c E¾| lamkmony _+c$p @¥c$m z c$ 3U: =u* 53£ c$p!pxcv xruvaxi p z c|$r tj cWxuc$t |$c)c$t®mkr i z cdmkn z\ jikn t |cTvLcWxbdc$p z cd|$r t w!pxqlaikxc z cWwpqcWw!pqw z c |$r bdv n qn ikwxr t z cTbdr z `WmscUw$£ /#t z\ wxikxcTpxcUwpqc$+mkcdbTr z `Wms,c + z |$r tFpxqcTmscbdr z `$mk&c + c ¬°nJucW| + z.RVl .
(91) #8.
(92) ! "# $ %&' ( )* +%+, -. ."$ %&/+0 . t wHqcWwxvXcW|3pqisuc$bdc$tFp z ¬ c c$p z ¬ cmscUw z\ FionytL|cWw w!i z lacWmsmkcWwHc$pmkcWw z c$ux`Uw z c[mkis´Xc$xp nuwxwxr\|i wTnyl\}«bTr z `WmscUw&+ cp + c=£¨gjr lLw z cWwd_j{jvLr px_a`Uw!cUw z cµ lamonyqisp |$mknuwxwxioul cWwW¬'mkcpxcUwp z c t isucWnyl0n wx{jbdv\pxr pxioul c cWz w!p za ¢ tai:v nymonT ikr t |$xispxioFlac R ) uc n z V c p ] nJucW| V- c +. cJ£*@¥rypqr. R. z.
(93). ]. r) uc n z V c p cWw!p¨mkc¥Fl nytF pxikmkc #V z c[mon+mkr i z l ) u n z V c pz c$ux`Uw z c[mkis´Xc$xp £ /#tqcc$p!pxc mkc&bdr z `$mkc + z |r tFpqxc + c#wxi ) uc n z V c p £ µ¼ ¸ I ¤:cWwv xr\| Uz laqcWwFlac+tarul w[n z r v\pqr t wv n mknwxlaispxcwxr tFp¥nytLnymkr l cWwd|c$mkmkcWw z c+mA nyt n ms{\wxc z cmonJn xionytL|.c 3J"5£ ¤:n z iowpqist |pxikr t0vaqr=jiscWtup z l ¦ nyispFlac&tarul ww!l vavLrFw!rut wFlac&mscUw=n xiony´amkcWw ru´ wxc$q cUww!rutFp z ikw!pxqik´al cUw2wxc$mkr t³mon msrui¥Fnybdbn
(94) vamslap ypul c¾mkn msrui¥taruxbnymkc £¤°cWw7vaxr\| Wz laqcWw Fnyl wqwxiscWtatacWw z cp{jvLFc "#vXc$lauc$tFpnyl wqwxiF$pxqcl\pxikmsiow cWwH#pqipqxcikt z io|$n=pqi¦Xbnyiowism\cUwpHvamkl w z is¯7|ikmsc z clLwpqi¢ cW[mkcWw z\ |iow!ikr tLwv xiow!cUw$£ ( ' & AB,.(3.0:*. %0/*5 ¼ ½ ¸ N M ½ N
(95) N ½ ¸ >I >IKJ @¥r l w'w!rula_ n ipqr t w°Fl n tFpxis¢ c$.mC c±Ocp z c|,_Ln Flac=nyqiony´amkcHistFpqc$q c$tLnytFp z n t w°mon¥wxr mkl\pxikr t+v xr z laispxc vLny+mon2¦ n bdismkmsc z n msur qipq_abdcWw '*)+ , + ¬°taryp c MHO P QF¬°w!la)lat
(96) vaxru´amk`$bdc z r tat £°~r l |c$mona¬6t r l w |$r t wxi z\ qr t wpqr l\pqcWwmkcWw|rjru z rutat cWw z l0v ny,nybd`$pxqc#ucW|3pqr qiscWmC¬\n ist wxi°Flac+mkc$la,wvalaiowxwqnytL|cWwW£ @¥r l wwxlavavXruwxr t wFlac z cUww!ikb)l mknypxikr t wrutup p c±OcW|pxl cWwvXr lal tac&¦ nybdikmsmkA c M h/P Q z c+=n mscWlaqw z lv ny,nybd`pqxcucW|pxr qikc$ m S¥£j¤:n z r tat c z c[mon&¦ n bTikmkmsc M h/P Q#|$r t w!pxispxl c[latac[vLnyxpxikc z lvamonyt z c}\v ¡ qikc$t |$cWwW£F~rula|$ny,n |p xiow!cW¨mkc&vamkn t cWt cWtFpxikc$U¬Fikm°cUwpt |$cWwqwxn isqc z c&va |iow!cWmkc&tar b´aqc z c& v pqi¡ pqisrut w&|ruxqcWwxvLrut z n tup&0|,_ n Flac |$c$mkmsl msc h P£°©¥t®v Uz ik|pxcWla&cWw!p+n msruqw|rut w!pxqlaipU£°¤°cUw#=n xiony´amkcWw c$}\vamsio|$nypxik cUwwxr tFp[|,_aruikwxiscUw|rubTbdc&mkcWwvalaiowqwxn t |cUw z cWw|$rFru z r tat cWw z c h P 3C: 5 ) P R , z ^ # P n h/P>p Y @¥r l wwxlavavXruwxr t wul c¥mA ru´ w!cWx=nypxikr t :P z cmon=nymkc$la z r t t cv nymC nymk ruxispx_ bTc#|r qqcWwxvLrut z nytFp¨n l vLny,nybd`pqxc h PcWw!p z iowpqxik´al c&wxc$mkr tlatac+mkr i6Fnybdbn z cUw!v ,nytL|cbdnypx_ bn=pxioFlac T P `xR # % ' n ) Pp Y 3 * 5 ¤:c |rjc$¯|$iscWtFp , iktFpxcWxuc$t n tup z n t w7mA c}\vaqcWwqw!ikr t z l va Wz ik|pxc$l P cWw!p nyv vLcWm +/% %A£¤°c vXr mk{jt bdc #/P«w$ nyz t tFl mscnyl®vXr iktup qr (£ >nyt w&mon0w!ispxl nypxikr t
(97) FlaiHtar lL) w+|r tL|c$qtacu¬6mscdv n qn bT`$pxqc S vXruwqwx` z c z cWl\} |rubdvLrFwxn tupqcW w S R n o] # p £ [ikt w!iA¬atarul wnJ rut w # P n h p R . VTVXWZY\[]^H_. , c h ^ , c h ^ , u h u ^ , u h u ^ YqYOYR n h p ^. . nh p .
(98) U. (H K
(99)
(100) "# ):. r c$p w!rutup z cWl\})vXr mk{jt bdcWwl tai z isbdc$tLw!ikr tat c$mow$£y¤:cWwH=nymkc$l qw z cUw|rjc¯7|$iscWtup,w z lTvLrums{jtubTc px,n z laikwxc$tFp&mC c±Ocp z lv n qn bd`pxqcFS wxla&mkn=nyqikn ´amkc)r ´Lw!cWx c- P £O¤:cdbTr z `WmscTcWw!p z\ pqc$qbdist Lv nymkc&|,_ r is} z cWwbdrut bdcWw z c # P |$r qxcUw!vXr t z nytFp z cWw|rjc$¯|$iscWtFpqwtaruttjlamowW£ µ¼ ¸ I >nytLwmC Fl nypxikr tµa¬ tar l w[l\pxikmsiowxr t wl tµmsikc$t0mkr un xispx_ bTioFlac £ cWmkndFny,nytFpxispmkndvXruwxispxikFisp z c)mon7bdr={ cWtatac £>) nylapxqcv n !pU¬ tarul w¥px,nJJn ismkmkr t w#nJ cW| z cWw#=nymkc$la,w[vaqr\|,_acWw z c qr £X¤°cmsikc$tmsru nuwxwxlaqc¨latbdc$ikmsmkc$laH|$r bdvLru!pqc$bdc$tFptjlab qikFlac z cWw'cUwpqisbn=pqc$la,w z cbdny}\isblab z cF,nyiowxc$b)´ mkn t |cu£ ¼ ½ ¸ ¼ >I >I H ¤.nTwxcW|pxikr tva | Uz c$tFpqc&|$r t |$c$qtaclat0c$t wxc$b´amsc z c z r tat cWwiowxwxlacUw z l t lat ikFlac+vaqr ´ ms`WbTc z c qcW|,_ c$,|,_ac z c}jpxqc$blab0£W mFcWw!p.iktFp qcWwqwqnytFp z c|r tLwpqxlaikqclatbdr z `$mkc¨cWta mkr ´LnytFp:mkcWw z r tat cWw.iowxwxlacWw z cvamonytLw z c$}jv qikc$t |$cWwul i|r qqcWwxvLrut z c$tFp# vamkl wxiscWlaqw#vaqr ´amk`$bdcUw z ikw!pxikt |3p,w$U£ @¥r l w&wxr la_ n ipqr t w t r twxc$l mscWbTcWtFp'cUwpqisbdc$'mA c$±Xc$p z c|,_ nuFlac|$r bdvLrFwxn tFpxcWw z lv ny,nybd`pqx4c S®wxlamknwxr mkl\pxikr tv xr z laispxc vLnymscUwnymk r qispx_abdcWwW¬Fbdn ikwn l wxwxiOmC c±Ocp z c|,_ nuFlac#v xru´ams`Wbdc £j~r la|cWmkn ¬jtar l w|$r t wxi za qr t wFl° |,_Ln Flac+vaqr ´amk`$bdc|$r qxcUw!vXr t z latµt isucWnyvl a z c+¦ nu|3pqc$laU£L^{jvaikFlacWbdc$tFpW¬Xw$ ism.{npxqr iowvaqr ´amk`$bdcWw z i± qc$tFpqwW\¬ a)vaqc$t z mkcWw:=nymkc$la,wH ¬J\¬Ua£$¤:cbdr z `$mkc z r isp:vaqc$t z xc¨c$t|rubdv\pxcmkcWw°c±Ocpqw z istFpqc$,n |3pqisrut cWtFpxqc[mscUw¨t isucWnyla} z l7¦ n |3pqc$lacpmscUw¨=n xiony´amkcWw h/P £j¤°c#va Uz io|3pxcWla¨cUwpnymkr ,w z rutat vLny¨monqc$mon=pqisrut 3§9e 5 ) P R&, z ^ # P n h/P>p ^ ^ # P n hPp ¤:c|$rFc$¯7|ikc$tFp [bdcWwxlaqc¨mA c$±Xc$p.vaqr v xc¨n l+vaqr ´amk`$bdFc aTwxla:mon¥wxr mkl\pqisrut+vaxr z l ipqc¨v n :mA n msur qipq_abdc O?P£ ¤:c&vLrums{jt ubTc #PwW n tatjlamsc&cW t qr £ @[rul wnJ rut w. # P. # P n h p R&, c h ^ . , c h ^ , u hu ^ , u hu ^ YqYqY. g\i°mC r tvXc$l\p z\ |i z c$#ul c&|$c&vLrums{jt ubTc+cUwpi z c$tFpqikFlacWbTcWtFp[tFl m:nymkr ,wism6cUwp[vXruwqw!ik´amkc z c|rut |mklaqc F lac¨msc|r bdvXr xpxcWbTcWtFp6¢ t nym z cmA nymk r qispx_abdcHcWw!p.mkcbd$bdcvLrula°pqr l w:mscUw°vaqr ´amk`$bdcUw°vaqikw:c$t|$r bdv\pxc vLnyTmscbdr z `$mkc ¬Hnyl ¦ n |3pqc$la a vaq`WwW£ªt v nyxpxio|lamkikc$U¬.tarul wTvLrula rut w z\ pqc$qbTiktacWlat v n qn bT`$pxqc ruv\pxikbnymUS |rubTblat0nyl\}2v xru´ams`WbdcWwc$tµFlacUwpqisrut°£ ½ ¸
(101) o N ¸ M ¸ d ¼ $ ¸ >I >I M >nyt wmA ru´\cW|pxis¦ z i z cWtupqi¢Lc$ z cWwbdr z `$mkcWwikt z ikji z lac$mowr l mkr ´Lnyl\}6¬ t r l w¨istFpxqr z laiow!rut wmkc¥v mkn t z c$}jv qikc$t |$cWw°wxlaikJn tFpW£W¤:cWw z r tat cWw.|ruxqcWwxvLrut z cWtup°mA =nymkl n=pqisrut¢ t nymkc z c¨mC nymk ruxispx_abdc '*)+ , + n vaq`Ww u =nymkl n=pqisrut w z nyt wmsc&|$nuw z cUw¦§rut |3pqisrut w¨pxcWw!pl w!l c$mkmscUwcp 8yu Jn mslLn=pxikr tLw z n t wmkc&|$n w z cWwvaqr ´amk`$bdcUw z n vavaqrJ}\isbn=pqisrut°£=¤°cUwv ny,nybd`pqxcU.w A3!!: 95c$p # 3K0:L:L+$+% : B- % %&?5w!rutFp z ikwq| pqikw w z c+monTbdn taik`$qc&wxlaik=nytFpxc s . h s R Bw Y [) ] ) R7#]qYqYOYD[%w ] h R wBYZ#&) ] ) R7#]qYqYOY{#Ow Y s ~rulamkcWwvaqr ´amk`$bdcUw a ¬ ) R #d]qYO YqY{]\X ¬|,_ n Flac |c$mkmklamsc 3 |$r qxcUw!vXr t z nytFp)¾mon¾=n mscWlaT|$xruikw c z cWw vLny,nybd`pqxcUw05:|r bdvXr xpxc#W# v pxs ispxikr t wW£=¤°cvamkn tT|$r bdvamkcpH|rubTvXr xpxc z rut | u z r t t cUw$£J~r lamkcWw v xru´ams`WbdcWw z nyv vaxrJ}\ikbn=pxikr t ¬ )0 R B]OYqYOY{
(102) ] ¬L|,_ nuul c|c$mkmklamsc|r bdvXr xpxcF8T v pqipqisrut w$£X¤°cv mkn t |$r bdvXr xpxc z rut |Wu z rutat cUw$£W¤ r ´\pqc$s tFpxikr t z c|cWw z r t t cUw6t |$cWwqw!ispxcul c$moul cWw6bdiktFlapxcWw z c¨|Wnymo|lam 3Cwp,n=pqisrut 2 E 5vXr lamkcWw[vaxru´amk`$bdcWw(a c$p[edG 8 _acWlaxcUwvLrula[mkcWwvaqr ´ ms`WbTcUw z nyvavaqrJ}\isbnypxikr t wW£. RVl .
(103) o.
(104) ! "# $ %&' ( )* +%+, -. ."$ %&/+0 >I >I. .
(105) \= ¸ . ¨¤ ru´\cW|pxis¦ z lbdr z `$mkc#ikt z ikji z l c$m6cWw!p z i z cWtFpxis¢ c$mkcWwvLrums{jtubdcWw c$p FlaiOiktFpxc$qjiscWtatacWtup z nyt wmonTxcWmknypxikr t ST `xR # % ' n , z ^ n p ^ n # pDp Y 3 8:5 ª¨t z nyl\pqxcUw+pqc$qbTcUw$¬'ikmwW ny isp z c |$n qnu|3p qikwxc$mon za vXc$t z n t |c c$tFpxqc2mA =nymkl n=pqisrut bdr={ cWtatac z c mon0w!rumslapxikr t®vaxr z l ipqcv ny '*)+ , +0c$p&mkcWwv ny,nybd`pqxcUw cp #.£ c$monvLcWxbdcp z cUwpqisbdc$+mon0=nymkc$la ruv\pxikbnymkc z c|cUwv ny,nybd`$pxqcWwW£j¤¨ i z cWtupqi¢X|$n=pqisrut z cWwvXr mk{jt bdcWwiktFpxcWxuc$t n tup z n t wmondxcWmknypxikr t 3 8:5 wxc¦ nyispv nycWw!pxikbn=pqisrutc$p'pqcWw!pqwHw!pqnypxiowpqikFlacUw$£ {FnytFp z iowxvLrFw!ispxikr tmscUwr ´ wxc$q=n=pxikr tLw:iowxwxlacUw z lv mkn t z c$}jv qikc$t |$cWw|r bdvamkcpvLrulamkn2¦§r t |pxikr t acJ¬Otar lLw#|,_acWq|,_ r t w¥lat ´Lrut )bdr z `$mkc|$r qxcUw!vXr t z nytFp )|cWw¨r ´ wxc$q=n=pqisrut w$£ ~'rula|c$mona¬utar lLwv n !pqr t w z l t7bdr z `$mkc#wxlaxvLny,nyb pq #¬y|y cWw!p!¡ =¡ z isqc[|rut w!pxqlaip v nyxpxik z cvXr mk{jt bdcUw z c z c$u w mscW w$£¤°cv ny,nybd`pqxc®wp,n=pqikw!pxioFlac , cWw!pcUwpqisb cp0mscUw Ä¡ =n mslacUw¨wxr tFp|Wnymo|la# m cUw 3 mscUw¨=nymkc$l qw z cWw Ä¡A=n mslacUw z rutatacWtuplatac#ist z ik|Wn=pxikr t z c¥mon)wxisutais¢L|$nypxikFisp #z cWw |$r bdvXruwqnytFpxcUw z c , 53£J¤:n#w!ik tais¢L|Wn=pxikjip cWw!p:pqcWw!p c¨ |$c[mon¥w!pqnypxiowpqikFlac z c z is± qc$t |$c z c z\ jionyt |$c cWtFpxqcTmkc7bdr z `$mkc7|rubdvamsc$pcp)mkc7wxr l w!¡Abdr z `Wmsc z n t w+mkcWFlac$m¨mscUw|rjc¯7|$iscWtup,wFlai¨|$r qxcUw!vXr t z c$tFp& l tacÄ¡A=n mslac¦ n is´amkcwxr tFp mkisbdikt wW£ ©¥tbdr z `Wmsc+ikt z ikji z l c$m r v\pqisbn m &cWw!p¥nyikt w!i:i z cWtFpxis¢ £aª¨t w!l ipqc ¬ rut |,_ac$,|,_ac7 =nymklac$mknµqr ´ l wpqcWwqw!c z l bTr z `Wmsc r v\pqisbn mµlat c2 Wz l |pxikr t z cUw z rutat cWwW£:~r la |$c$mona¬Flat7vamonyt2 Uz laispcUwp|r tLwpqipql cWt wxlavavaqisbn tup z cWw z rutat cUw$£F¤°c#bTr z `WmsccWw!p qr ´al w!pxc ¥latac Wz l |3pqisrut z lTv mkn t7w!iamkcWwcWw!pxikbdnypxikr t wr ´\pqc$tjlacWw¨nJ cW|mkcc$l z c z r tat cWwHqcWw!pxqc$iktFp|r t z laiow!cWtup¨n l\} bdWbTcUw|$r t |$mslLw!ikr t wW£ ~rula¨mkcWwvaqr ´amk`$bdcWww!l is=nytFp,w$¬Fmkn)bd$bdc z\ bny,|,_ac[cWw!pbdiow!c#c$t7v mknu|c ?£ >nyt w mon¾wxcW|pxikr t eL¬:tarul w|,_ c$,|,_ac$qr t w+ =nymki z cW)mkc2vamonyt Wz laipd|rut wpqxl ipdµv nyxpxik z cWwr ´ wxc$q=n=pxikr tLw ru´\pxcWtjlacWwTv n !pqis z c adc#cWt mA l\pxikmsiowqnytFp[vLrulamkcWw[n l\pxqcWwvaqr ´amk`$bdcUwl w!l c$mow$£ ¤¨ iktFp qp z l7bdr z `$mkc[umsru´ nymLcWw!p z l\pxikmkikwxc$U¬ cWt7vamkl w z l7vamonyt7|rula,nytFpW¬umC ista¦§r qbdnypxikr t7|$r tFpxcWtFl c z nyt w z cUw+vamonyt w z c$}jv qikc$t |$cWw+|rut |cWxtLnytFp z cWw+vaqr ´ ms`WbTcUw&v n wqw wW£°©[t
Documents relatifs
Dans chaque ville et pour toutes les lignes de tramway considérées, il faudrait disposer des trafics avant et après ouverture d’une ligne et de plusieurs projections d’évolution
Le fait d’écrire à partir d’une oeuvre d’art visuelle ressemble à une forme de contrainte; nous croyons par ailleurs que cette pratique a eu un effet durable sur l’écriture
variables d'ordre psychologique: soit f.amiliale ou personnelle, soit so- ciale, soit professionnelle, soit une combinaison de ces facteurs. Ce patient a récupéré
For the two coolest objects in Figure 3.6, HD 4539 and PG 1716+426, both at Ta < 27, 000 K, there is a good match between the predicted synthetic spectra and the FUSE data: the
lui inculquer le registre li'lquistioue, les l1abitudes alimen- taires et vestimentaires ainsi que le comportement des bour- geois de Québec. Pierrette Paul doit
La conciliation emploi-famille : des mesures à développer dans les milieux de travail Tableau 4 : Les dispositions favorisant la conciliation travailfamille dans les
Figure 2.4 Predicted (continuous lines) and observed values (filled circles: stands aged from trees with root collar; open circles: stands aged from trees without root collar)
Cette posture permet de dégager deux idées centrales : le poids des milieux professionnels locaux dans l’intermédiation et le transit des idées, modèles et pratiques
