• Aucun résultat trouvé

"Some strange mix of public and private" - Vito Acconci's methodology of connecting the private with the public: Writing on the page - Following the casual passer-by - Inventing the city

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager ""Some strange mix of public and private" - Vito Acconci's methodology of connecting the private with the public: Writing on the page - Following the casual passer-by - Inventing the city"

Copied!
7
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

HAL Id: halshs-00745945

https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-00745945

Submitted on 26 Oct 2012

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access

archive for the deposit and dissemination of

sci-entific research documents, whether they are

pub-lished or not. The documents may come from

teaching and research institutions in France or

abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est

destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents

scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,

émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de

recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires

publics ou privés.

”Some strange mix of public and private” - Vito

Acconci’s methodology of connecting the private with

the public: Writing on the page - Following the casual

passer-by - Inventing the city

Paul van Beek

To cite this version:

Paul van Beek. ”Some strange mix of public and private” - Vito Acconci’s methodology of connecting

the private with the public: Writing on the page - Following the casual passer-by - Inventing the city.

Ambiances in action / Ambiances en acte(s) - International Congress on Ambiances, Montreal 2012,

Sep 2012, Montreal, Canada. pp.305-310. �halshs-00745945�

(2)

!"#$%&'()*+,%&$-.&#/&0123-4&*+5&0)-6*(%7&

!"#$% &''$('")*% +,#-$.$/$01% $2% '$((,'#"(0% #-,% 34"56#,% 7"#-% #-,% 389/"':%

;4"#"(0%$(%#-,%360,%<%=$//$7"(0%#-,%'6*86/%36**,4<91%<%>(5,(#"(0%#-,%'"#1%

9(:;#<=>#!??@# 2#0'3$4*-,*5()%6/*70%(/0()8*9"$()%)*:/%;(")%$4*<-33(6(8*9/$=("+*:/%;(")%$48*>(36%'.** *(:;AB()'..CD(&,./-/A'.#

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

8+()#514(-#+&

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

)-.(* )$"#/6(* .%Q* -,* +'13%0* #/C* +"%;#$(R# K9:';-+# /*(+.# -/# ,F.# (-&# /*(+.# '.,H..)# '20-./# ()0#

-)12&3(,-2)# ()0# 2,F.&# '20-./G# *:';-+# /*(+.# -/# (# 3-M# 21# .;.+,&-+# +:&&.),# ()0# /.M:(;# 3(LJ ).,-/3OA#T=++2)+-G#"UUVW#

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

X#33#".Y* $-* >"--C$K#(")# ()0# -)# 2,F.&# ,.M,/G# ,F.# 1;:-0-,I# 21# ,F.# ,.&&-,2&-./# 21# ,F.# 0-11.&.),#

0-/+-*;-)./#+()#'.#,&(+.0#,2#,F.#1;:-0-,I#21#,F.#*:';-+#()0#*&-B(,.#/*(+./#-)#,F.#*2;-,-+(;#&.(;3A# ############################################################################

FM*===M,#0(1--AM0-.Z/-$(M+K+[/-$(\%C]LGG^^^IF__`8*E3#)$*#00())(C*FaZa^ZaIFFJS*-)#+2)B.&/(,-2)R#

<-,2#=++2)+-#H-,F#^.;-(#!(_2#()0#!&(-)(&0#`(&.I8*X#4*aIIH8*14*D%$-*900-/0%*-/*2"%C#48*X#"0K*aI8*aIIG*

(3)

67a

#5#####V)0#X),.&)(,-2)(;#`2)L&.//#2)#=3'-()+./G#b2),&.(;#V7"V#

ZF.#C.I#+2)+.*,/#21#,F-/#*&2+.//#&.;(,.#,2#,F.#/.)/2&I#&.;(,-2)/F-*/#'.,H..)#,F.#/*(+.#()0# ,F.# '20I# ()0# ('2B.# (;;# ,2# ,F.# (3'-()+.J&.;(,.0# &.;(,-2)/F-*/# '.,H..)# *:';-+# ()0# *&-B(,.# /*(+./A#

>.H#c2&C.&#<-,2#=++2)+-#-/#(#12&.&:)).&#21#+2),.3*2&(&I#(&,#(/#H.#C)2H#-,#,20(IA#=;,F2:LF# F.#F(/#).B.&#3(0.#H2&C#,F(,#-/#.(/I#,2#.MF-'-,G#,2#+2;;.+,#()0#,2#/.;;G#F.#F(/#).B.&#F(0#()I# ;(+C#21#(,,.),-2)#1&23#L(;;.&-./#(&2:)0#,F.#H2&;0A#X)#,F.#/.+2)0#F(;1#21#,F.#"Ua7/G#=++2)+-#-/# (#*2.,#-),.&./,.0#-)#,F.#/*(,-(;#S:(;-,I#21#,F.#H&-,,.)#H2&0A#X)#,F.#1-&/,#F(;1#21#,F.#"Ud7/G#F.# 32B./# ,2# ,F.# K&.(;O# /*(+.# 21# ,F.# *.&12&3()+.G# :/:(;;I# :/-)L# B-0.2G# 1-;3# ()0# (:0-2A# ^:&-)L# ,F./.#I.(&/G#F.#*&2*2/./G#(++2&0-)L#,2#(&,#+&-,-+#@(,.#e-)C.&G#K(#).(&;I#:)'&2C.)#/:++.//-2)# 21# *&2_.+,/# -)# HF-+F# ,F.# /.;1# -/# 0.1-).0# -)# ,F.# 3(,&-M# 21# -,/# &.;(,-2)/# ,2# /*(+.G# ,2# -,/# /2+-(;# 2&0.&G#()0#,2#-,/.;1G#2&#-)#HF-+F#=++2)+-#.M(3-)./#,F.#/,&:+,:&.#21#(&,#*&20:+,-2)G#'&(+C.,-)L# ,F.#,.&3/#f(&,-/,Gg#f(&,#2'_.+,g#()0#fB-.H.&gOA#ThW#ZF.#*&2_.+,/#21#,F-/#*.&-20#.MF-'-,#=++2)+-g/# /F(&*#()(;I,-+#&-L2&#(/#H.;;#(/#,F.#,F.2&.,-+(;#.).&LI#+2332)#,2#Kd7/#=3.&-+()#(&,#Te-)C.&# "UiiWAO#j&(0:(;;I#,F./.#+-,IJ'(/.0#-),.&B.),-2)/#-)#,F.#*:';-+#/*(+.#,:&)#-),2#L(;;.&I#-)/,(;;(J ,-2)/#-)#>.H#c2&C#`-,I#()0#?:&2*.G#()0#.B.),:(;;I#-)#,F.#"Ui7/#-),2# B.&-,(';.#(&+F-,.+,:&(;# *&2_.+,/A#X)#"UiiG#32&.#*&.+-/.;I#(1,.&#F-/#.MF-'-,-2)#U!'13%0*7+#0()U#(,#ZF.#b:/.:3#21#b20J .&)#=&,#-)#>.H#c2&CG#F.#12:)0/#,F.#+2;;('2&(,-B.#.),.&*&-/.G#=++2)+-#Q,:0-2A##

=;;# ,F./.# /F-1,/# -)# 3.,F20/G# +2)+.*,-2)/# ()0# 0-/+-*;-)./# 3(I# /..3# '-L# /,.*/G# ':,# ,F.I# (&.# 0.B.;2*.0# /2# (**(&.),;I# /.(3;.//;I# 'I# =++2)+-# '.+(:/.# F.# F(/# ).B.&# 0.B-(,.0# 1&23# F-/# *.&/-/,.),# ,F.3(,-+# *&.2++:*(,-2)# H-,F# *:';-+# ()0# *&-B(,.# /*(+.A# k).# ,F-)LG# F2H.B.&G# +()# '.#/(-0#1&23#,F.#2:,/.,G#=++2)+-#F(/#'..)#()#(&,-/,#:)(1&(-0#21#1(-;:&.A#k)+.#F.#.),.&.0#,F.# &.(;3# 21# *.&12&3()+.G# 1(-;:&.# '.+23./# ()# -),.L&(;# *(&,# 21# F-/# 3.,F202;2LI# ()0# ,F.3./A# =;/2#,F./.#(03-//-2)/#21#1(-;:&.#F(B.#(;;2H.0#=++2)+-#,2#32B.#.112&,;.//;I#,F&2:LF#0-11.&.),# /,I;./#()0#,2#+F()L.#+2)+.*,-2)/#&(0-+(;;IA#

9)-(-+,&#+&(:%&0*,%&

=++2)+-# /,(&,/# (/# (# H&-,.&A# P.# F(/# (;H(I/# H(),.0# ,2# '.# (# H&-,.&A# X)# F-LF# /+F22;# ()0# (/# ()# ?)L;-/F# b(_2&# (,# :)-B.&/-,IG# F.# H&-,./# /F2&,# /,2&-./# ()0# *2.3/# -)# ,F.# /+F22;# ).H/*(*.&A# e(,.&# F.# (,,.)0/# (* W"%$("U)* W-"A)K-+* (,# ,F.# %)-B.&/-,I# 21# X2H(G# HF.&.# F.# 1-)0/# (# C-)0&.0# /*-&-,# -)# Q(3:.;# !.+C.,,G# 12&# HF23# H2&0/# (&.# ,F.# *&-3(&I# +2)/,-,:.),# 21# ,F.# (&,# 21# 1(-;:&.A# `F(&(+,.&-/,-+#21#!.+C.,,l/#;-,.&(,:&.#(&.#,F.#('/:&0#*.&/*.+,-B.#()0#.M*2/-)L#21#,F.#F:3()# +2)0-,-2)G# ,F.# -&2)I# -)/.&,-)L# (# *;(I1:;# .;.3.),# -)# ,F.# H2&CG# 0./*-,.# 3-/.&I# ()0# '2&.023G# ()0# ,F.# 1;(/F./# 21# -;;:3-)(,-2)# ()0# -)/-LF,# ;-LF,-)L# :*# 1&23# ,F.# 1;2H# 21# H2&0/A# ZF.# /(3.# F:32&G#-&2)I#()0#K/,&-*,.(/.O#21#3.()-)L#(&.#(;/2#,2#'.#12:)0#-)#=++2)+-l/#*2.,&I#()0#-)#F-/# ;(,.&#*.&12&3()+./A#X)#"UamG#=++2)+-#&.,:&)/#,2#>.H#c2&C#`-,I#()0#;22C/#12&#2**2&,:)-,-./#,2# ;(:)+F#(#+(&..&#(/#(#H&-,.&A#P.#/..C/#+2),(+,#H-,F#,F.#>.H#c2&C#Q+F22;#*2.,/#()0#,F.#'.(,# L.).&(,-2)# *2.,/# (+,-B.# -)# ,F.# "U87/# ()0# "Ua7/A# ^:&-)L# ,F-/# *.&-20G# F.# 0.B.;2*/# F-/# /,I;.# HF-+F# '.+23./# 32&.# ('/,&(+,A# P.# '.L-)/# :/-)L# ,F.# *(L.# (/# ()# (+,-B.# 1-.;0# HF.&.# L.).&-+# /*(,-2J,.3*2&(;#,.&3/#.3.&L.#/:+F#(/#F.&.G#,F.&.G#:*G#1(&,F.&G#;2)L.&G#)2HG#()0#,F.)#T\-()G# "UUVWA#

=++2&0-)L#,2#@(,.#e-)C.&G#12&#=++2)+-G#,F.#*(L.#21#(#*2.3#-/#_:/,#K(#).:,&(;#L&2:)0#2)#HF-+F# H2&0/#(&.#0:3*.0G#0.*2/-,.0#2&#,&()/1.&&.0#1&23#()2,F.&#;2+(,-2)#Te-)C.&G#"UiiWAO#nF(,#F-/# H&-,,.)# H2&0/# *&-3(&-;I# 02G# -/# ,2# 0.,.&3-).# ,F.-&# *;(+.# -)# 1&2),# 21# ,F.# L-B.)# /*(+.A# X)# *(&,-+:;(&G# ,F./.# H2&0/# (&.# /.;.+,.0# ,F(,# (&.# +(*(';.# 21# .),.&-)L# -),2# (# +2)1-&3(,2&IG# &.(;G# .M+-,-)LG# ('/:&0# 2&# *(&(02M-+(;G# ':,# (;H(I/# 0-&.+,# 0-(;2L:.# H-,F# /*(+.G# -)# ,F.# /(3.# H(I# (/# 3-)-3(;# (&,# /+:;*,:&./# (&.# 3.(),# ,2# 02# -)# ,F.# HF-,.J'2M# 320.&)-/,# L(;;.&-./# 21# ,F.# "Ua7/A# =++2)+-#+2)1-&3/#,F-/#H-,F#,F.#/,(,.3.),#,F(,#F-/#-),.),-2)#-/#KT,2W#:/.#;()L:(L.#,2#+2B.&#(# /*(+.#&(,F.&#,F()#,2#:)+2B.&#(#3.()-)L#Te-)C.&G#"UiiWAO#!I#,F.#.)0#21#,F.#"Ua7/G#=++2)+-l/# *2.,&I#-/#/2#/,&-**.0#'(&.#,F(,#,F.#H2&0/#(**.(&#(/#2'_.+,/#2)#,F.#.3*,I#/*(+.#21#,F.#HF-,.# *(L.G#(/#3(,.&-(;-N.0#2&#&.-1-.0#;()L:(L.A#

(4)

X)# ,F.# "Ua7l/G# ,F.# b())* %)* X-"(# 2&# 5-%/6* X-"(* =%$K* b())# 21# ,F.# 320.&)-/,# (&+F-,.+,:&.# -3*(+,/# 2)# ,F.# B-/:(;# (&,/G# ()0# 2)# ;-,.&(,:&.A# ZF.# &.0:+,-2)-/3# 21# ,F.# 3-)-3(;# ()0# +2)+.*,:(;# (&,# 21# Q2;# e.n-,,G# ^2)(;0# [:00G# ^()# E;(B-)G# =0&-()# 9-*.&G# ^()# j&(F(3G# \2'.&,# !(&&IG#e./#e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l/# 0.;-+(,.# 0&(3(/# 21# ,F.# H-,F0&(H)# +2)/+-2:/).//# J# *(&.0#02H)#,2#.//.),-(;/G#+:,#211G#21,.)#&.*&./.),.0#(/#*FI/-+(;;I#-332'-;-/.0#ThWAOV# E&23# "Uad# ,2# "UaUG# =++2)+-# ()0# ,F.# >.H# c2&C# Q+F22;# *2.,# !.&)(0.,,.# b(I.&# /.,# :*# ,F.# 3-3.2L&(*F.0#_2:&)(;#I*$-*GA#ZF.#3(L(N-).#-/#,F.#1-&/,#-)#&.;.(/-)L#,F.#+2)+.*,:(;#H2&C#21# ^()# j&(F(3G# =0&-()# 9-*.&# ()0# Q2;# e.n-,,l/# 7(/$(/0()*-/* <-/0(+$'#3* 9"$A# E2&# ,F.# 1-&/,# ,-3.# ()0# *.&F(*/# ,F.# 2);I# ,-3.G# ,F.# 3(L(N-).# /:++..0/# -)# :)-,-)L# .M*.&-3.),(;# *2.,&I# ()0# +2)+.*,:(;#(&,#-)#,F.#"Ua7/A#X,#'.+23./#(#*(&(0-L3#21#,F.#(**&2*&-(,-2)#21#,F.#H&-,,.)#H2&0# (/#,F.#2);I#&.3(-)-)L#3.,F20#12&#+2)+.*,:(;#(&,#-)#-,/#&(0-+(;#&.0:+,-2)-/3A#*

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`2)/.S:.),;IG# ,F-/# +2)).+,-2)# '.,H..)# ;()L:(L.# ()0# ,F.# H&-,,.)# H2&0# HF-+F# -/# .//.),-(;;I#(#*2.,-+#+2)/,&:+,-2)G#'.+23./#:;,-3(,.;I#(#*2;-,-+(;#2).G#,F&2:LF#,F.#-3*2&,#21# ,F.# 0.32+&(,-+# (3'-()+.# +2)+.*,A# KP:3()/# (&.# *2;-,-+(;# ()-3(;/GO# \()+-]&.# /(I/G# K12&# ,H2# &.(/2)/R#1-&/,G#'.+(:/.#H.#F(B.#,F.#*2H.&#,2#*:,#-),2#+-&+:;(,-2)#32&.#H2&0/G#f:/.;.//g#()0# :)).+.//(&I#H2&0/G#H2&0/#,F(,#.M+..0#,F.#1:)+,-2)#21#&-L-0#0./-L)(,-2)G#/.+2)0;IG#'.+(:/.# ,F-/#1:)0(3.),(;#('-;-,I#,2#*&2;-1.&(,.#H2&0/#-/#:)+.(/-)L;I#+2),./,.0#'I#,F2/.#HF2#+;(-3#,2# f/*.(C# +2&&.+,;IgAO6#ZF-/# 3-M# 21# ,F.# *2;-,-+(;# ()0# ,F.# *2.,-+(;# '&-)L/# ,2# 3-)0# (# C.I# H2&C# 21# b(&+.;#!&220,F(.&/G#<#"$(*C'*.-/C(*+-Y$%&'(#T"UaiWG#HF.&.#,F.#+2)+.*,:(;#(&,-/,#3()(L./# ,2# +F()L.# 1&23# 2).# ,.&&-,2&I# ,2# ()2,F.&# 'I# /-3*;I# &.*;(+-)L# (# 1.H# +F(&(+,.&/A# Q-3-;(&;I# ,2# <-,2#=++2)+-G#b(&+.;#!&220,F(.&/#F(/#'..)#(#*2.,#'.12&.#'.+23-)L#(#B-/:(;#(&,-/,A#

X)# "U"mG# ,F.# E&.)+F# *2.,# Q,o*F().# b(;;(&3o# H&-,./# ,F.# *2.3# :/* 0-'+* C(* CY)* c#.#%)*

/O#1-3%"#*3(*K#)#"CA#X)#"UaUG#,F.#!.;L-()#(&,-/,#b(&+.;#!&220,F(.&/#0./-L)/#F-/#2H)#B.&/-2)#21#

,F.#1(32:/#*2.3A#X)#V77m#(,#,F.#b:/o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dWAO#\()+-]&.#(&L:./# ############################################################################ aM*===M6--63(M1(Z'"3[)#]$d"0$]cd&]d()"0])d)-'"0(]=(1d0C]Fd;(C]I<<:e2c99d'"3]K$$+f`9fa2f a2===M%0#M-"6M'Afa2C-=/3-#CM+K+f`2%Cf`5_^Fd(%]F'.0Vg7=<g!Wg6hX%i4j5=d')6]92ec<?k57c W^a1D7Gl&1XAGK=)2-2<K=29*E3#)$*#00())(C*aGZIHZFaJS*7')#/*7-/$#68*=L(-)/,#X),.&*&.,(,-2)8*m-B 3#/CM*VK(*.#6#n%/(*-,*$K(*o<9O)*;%)'#3*#"$*+"-6"#..(*Z*%))'(*H*Z*/-;(.1("*aIIG*B*i#/'#"4*aIFI8*+M*H_* `M*K$$+SZZ===M('"-n%/(M0-.Z#"$%03()ZaII_BI`BIFB#")(/c'AB(/MK$.3p,--$?-$(a*E3#)$*#00())(C*aLZIHZFaJS* m#/0%q"(*&'-$(C*%/S*b'A#*9")(/c'A8*k)#[(+S:./#\()+-]&.8*IFMI`MaII_*

(5)

67i

#5#####V)0#X),.&)(,-2)(;#`2)L&.//#2)#=3'-()+./G#b2),&.(;#V7"V#

,F(,# *2.,/# ()0# B-/:(;# (&,-/,/# 3..,# HF.&.# ,F.# /*(+.# 21# ,F.# H2&0# 1;2H# -),2# ,F.# /*(+.# 21# ,F.# -3(L.#T!2-/+;(-&G#V77iWA#ZF.#3.,F20#:/.0#12&#,F-/#,&()/-,-2)#1&23#2).#3.0-:3#,2#()2,F.&#-/# ,(),(32:),#,2#1-)0-)L#).H#;()L:(L./#12&#H&-,-)L#(3'-()+.A#

;#33#<-+,&(:%&4*'1*3&0*''%)=2>&

X,# 02./# )2,# ,(C.# ;2)L# '.12&.# ,F.# /*(+.# 21# (# *(L.# -/# ,22# /3(;;# 12&# =++2)+-l/# '(+C# ()0# 12&,F# &.1.&.)+./# ,2# -)/-0.# ()0# 2:,/-0.G# ,2L.,F.&# ()0# (*(&,G# 2**2/-,.# ,2# 2&# -)# ,F.# 3-00;.# 21A# =++2)+-# +(;;/# ,F.# *(L.# 21# ,F.# *2.3# K(# 320.;# /*(+.G# (# *.&12&3()+.# /*(+.# -)# 3-)-(,:&.# 2&# ('/,&(+,#12&3#Te-)C.&G#"UiiWAO#P.#,F.)#L2./#-),2#,F.#&.(;#/*(+.G#':,#)2,#,F.#2).#21#F-/#211-+.# HF.&.#F.#H&-,./G#':,#,F.#2).#2:,/-0.#F.#H&-,./#('2:,A#P.#,(C./#,2#,F.#/,&..,G#-),2#,F.#+-,I# ()0# .M+F()L./# ,F.# *.&/2)(;# *&-B(,.# /*(+.# 21# ,F.# H&-,.&# 12&# ,F.# /2+-(;# *:';-+# /*(+.# 21# ,F.# *.&12&3.&# p# (&,-/,A# =# ):3'.&# 21# 1(32:/# *.&12&3()+./# -/# ,F.# &./:;,G# HF-+F# *;(I# 2:,# -)# ,F.# /,&..,/# 21# >.H# c2&C# `-,IG# :/:(;;I# )2,# 1(&# 1&23# F-/# F23.# ()0# H2&C# &223/A# ZF.# /*(+.# 21# ,F.# L(;;.&I# -/# -)+;:0.0# -)# ,F.# *:';-+# /*(+.# (/# H.;;A# k)# ,F-/# =++2)+-# /(I/R# Kn.# +F2/.# ,F.# L(;;.&I# '.+(:/.# H.# /(H# ,F.# L(;;.&I# TH.#=#/$(C# ,2# /..# ,F.# L(;;.&IW# (/# ()# ()(;2L:.# 21# ,F.# /,&..,G# (# &.*&./.),(,-2)#21#,F.#/,&..,R#2:&#320.;#H(/#,F.#>.H#c2&C#L(;;.&IG#;-C.#mV7#n./,#!&2(0H(IG# HF.&.#Y#&(,F.&#,F()#F(B-)L#_:/,#2).#L(;;.&I#(/#(#0./,-)(,-2)#Y#I2:#H(;C.0#1&23#1;22&#,2#1;22&G# I2:#3.()0.&.0#,F&2:LF#1-B.#1;22&/A#ZF.#L(;;.&IG#;-C.#,F.#/,&..,G#H(/#)2,#(#320.#I2:#/,2**.0# (,# ':,# (# +-&+:;(,-2)# &2:,.# ,F(,# I2:# *(//.0# ,F&2:LFq# L2-)L# ,2# L(;;.&-./# H(/# ;-C.# H-)02HJ /F2**-)L#rhs#T=++2)+-G#V77VWAO#

X)# 2-33-=%/6* !%(0(# T"UaUG# *.&12&3.0# -)# >.H# c2&C# `-,I# '.,H..)# k+,2'.&# 6# ()0# V8G# *F2,2J L&(*F-+#02+:3.),(,-2)#21#()#(+,-2)G#'tHWG#=++2)+-#12;;2H/#*(//.&/J'I#-)#,F.#/,&..,/#21#>.H# c2&C#`-,I#:),-;#,F.I#.),.&#(#*&-B(,.#/*(+.A#X)#<3#%.*kQ0("+$)*T"Ud"G#aVR""#3-)G#'tHG#/2:)0W# F.#.),&.)+F./#F-3/.;1#-)#,F.#'(/.3.),#21#(#L(;;.&I#-)#>.H#c2&C#`-,IG#U6#j&()0#Q,&..,G#()0# ,F&.(,.)/#B.&'(;;I#()0#H-,F#3.,(;#&20/#.(+F#*(//.&J'I#HF2#,&-./#,2#.),.&A#X)#7((C1(C#T"UdVWG# F.#32B./#+&(H;-)L#:)0.&#,F.#1;22&#21#,F.#Q2))('.)0#j(;;.&I#-)#>.H#c2&C#`-,IG#12;;2H-)L#-)# .&2,-+# ,F2:LF,/# ()0# H2&0/# ,F.# B-/-,2&# HF2G# -L)2&(),# 21# F-/# *&./.)+.# _:/,# :)0.&).(,FG# -/# H(;C-)L# (&2:)0# -)# ,F.# .3*,I# L(;;.&I# /*(+.A# ZF.# *.&12&3()+.# 7((C1(C# -/G# (;2)L# H-,F#

2-33-=%/6*!%(0(8#(#C.I#H2&C#-)#=++2)+-g/#u:B&.#()0#(#;()03(&C#-)#,H.),-.,F#+.),:&I#320.&)#

(&,G#,F.#+2)+.*,/#21#+'13%0#()0#+"%;#$(#1;2H-)L#(;32/,#/.(3;.//;I#-),2#2).#()2,F.&G#'2,F#2)# ,F.#*FI/-+(;#()0#,F.#/*(,-(;#*;().A#=++2)+-#*:,/#-,#,F-/#H(IR#K7((C1(C#/,(&,.0#'I#,(C-)L#(&+F-J ,.+,:&.G#/23.,F-)L#(//:3.0#(/#).:,&(;#()0#(*(&,#1&23#*.&/2)G#()0#1-;;-)L#-,#H-,F#*.&/2)R#Xg0# '.#*(&,#21#,F.#1;22&G#,F.#H(;;#H2:;0#'&.(,F.#Tn(&0G#V77VWAO#ZF.#.//.)+.#21#(;;#,F./.#'20-;I# *&(+,-+./# 21# &.*&./.),-)L# ()0# .M*&.//-)L# (3'-()+.# -/# (L(-)# 2)# +2B.&-)L# /*(+.# &(,F.&# ,F()# :)+2B.&-)L#3.()-)LA#

ZF.#-0.(#21#;.(B-)L#,F.#/*(+.#21#,F.#*(L.#()0#21#L2-)L#'(+C#()0#12&,F#'.,H..)#*&-B(,.#/*(+.# ()0#*:';-+#/*(+.#-/#.;('2&(,.0#-)#/23.#21#=++2)+-l/#1-&/,#*.&12&3()+./#HF.&.#F.#*FI/-+(;;I# +F(;;.)L./#,F.#'2:)0(&-./#'.,H..)#,F.#*&-B(,.#()0#,F.#*:';-+A#ZF.#'2&0.&/#(&2:)0#.(+F#21# ,F./.# (&.(/G# (&2:)0# ,F.# *(L.G# (&2:)0# ,F.# /,:0-2G# (&2:)0# ,F.# /,&..,G# ()0# .B.)# ,F.# 1&(3.H2&C# 21# ,F.# 1-;3# ,F(,# 02+:3.),/# ,F.# *.&12&3()+.G# (&.# *:,# :)0.&# *&.//:&.A# X)# VK"((*

2"#.(* 7$'C%()# T"UaUJ"Ud7G# "7R8i# 3-)G# 'tH# ()0# +2;2&G# /-;.),G# Q:*.&# i# 1-;3# 2)# B-0.2WG# F.#

*.&12&3/#(#):3'.&#21#'(/-+#(+,-2)/#/:+F#(/#&:))-)L#-)#(#+-&+;.G#_:3*-)LG#*:/F-)L#/23.2).A# ZF.# H2&C# /F2H/# ,F(,# 12&# ,F.# ,&()/-,-2)# 1&23# -)/-0.# ,2# 2:,/-0.G# 1&23# *&-B(,.# ,2# *:';-+# ()0# 1&23#*&-B(,.#/*(+.#,2#*:';-+#/*(+.G#(#H&-,-)L#()0#&.(0-)L#3-)0#-/#-)(0.S:(,.#HF-;.#()#(+,-)L# '20I#-/#&.S:-&.0A#!:,#,F.#'2:)0(&-./#21#,F.#'20I#(&.#)2,#;.1,#:),2:+F.0#.-,F.&A#^./*-,.#,F.# .3*F(/-/#'.-)L#1-&3;I#()0#+;.(&;I#2)#,F.#*:';-+#/*(+.G#,F.#*&-B(,.#/*(+.#C..*/#(#B-,(;#*;(+.# -)#=++2)+-g/#*.&12&3()+.#(&,#-)#,F.#(**.(&()+.#21#,F.#'20IG#21#F-/#2H)#'20IA#X)#V"#C(.#"A)# T"Ud7W#12&#-)/,()+.G#=++2)+-#'-,./#F-/#2H)#'20IG#/+2&+F./#F-/#+F./,#()0#('023-)(;#F(-&#H-,F# (#+()0;.G#()0#,&-./#,2#+F()L.#L.)0.&#'I#*:/F-)L#'(+C#F-/#L.)-,(;/A# ^./*-,.#L-B-)L#:*#()0#;.(B-)L#'.F-)0#,F.#0-/+-*;-).#21#H&-,-)LG#,F.#H2&0G#H&-,,.)#2&#/*2C.)G# ;-C.# ,F.# '20IG# +2),-):./# ,2# *;(I# ()# .//.),-(;# &2;.# 2)# ,F.# .0L.# '.,H..)# *&-B(,.# ()0# *:';-+G#

(6)

'.,H..)# /:'_.+,-B-,I# ()0# 2'_.+,-B-,IA# e()L:(L.# -/# ,F.# '(/-/# ()0# *&.+2)0-,-2)# 12&# ,F.# 0.B.;2*3.),# 21# ()# -0.(# 2&# +2)+.*,A# e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g3# 0.*.)0.),# 2)# ,F.#2,F.&#*.&/2)h#bI#*2/-,-2)(;#B(;:.#+2:),/#F.&.G#)2,#3I#-)0-B-0:(;#+F(&(+,.&-/,-+/#Tn(&0G# V77VWAO#ZF.#/:'_.+,#-/#21#)2#/-L)-1-+()+.G#,F.#(3'-()+.#-/#,F.#+2)0-,-2)#()0#,F.#3.,F20G#()0# ,F.#/-,.#-/#,F.#+&-,.&-2)A#

8+6%+(-+,&(:%&4-(>&

ZF.# &.3(&C(';.# +2)+;:/-2)# F.&.# (&&-B.0# (,G# -/# ,F(,# ,F./.# '2&0.&# +&2//-)L/# 1&23# -3(L-)(&IG# -A.A#+2)+.*,:(;#/*(+./#()0#&.;(,-2)/#,2#&.(;G#-A.A#*FI/-+(;#/*(+./#()0#&.;(,-2)/#(;/2#3.()#,F.# *(//(L.# 1&23# 2).# 3.0-:3# ,2# ()2,F.&G# 1&23# H2&0# ,2# -3(L.G# 1&23# ;()L:(L.# ,2# (&,A# ?B.),:(;;IG#,F.I#3.()#,F.#*(//(L.#1&23#,F.#*2.,-+#,2#,F.#*2;-,-+(;G#-)#,F.#/.)/.#21#\()+-]&.l/# (//.&,-2)#,F(,#K(&,#-/#*&-3(&-;I#*2;-,-+(;#-)#+&.(,-)L#(#/*(+.J,-3.#/.)/2&-:3G#-)#+.&,(-)#320./# 21#'.-)L#,2L.,F.&#2&#(*(&,G#21#0.1-)-)L#'.-)L#-)/-0.#2&#2:,/-0.G#2**2/-,.#,2#2&#-)#,F.#3-00;.# 21AOm## ?;/.HF.&.#\()+-]&.#(&L:./R#K=#):3'.&#21#(&,-/,/#,20(I#/.,#2:,#,2#+&.(,.#)2#32&.#(&,H2&C/A# X)/,.(0# ,F.I# H(),# ,2# L.,# 2:,# 21# ,F.# 3:/.:3G# ()0# *&2B2C.# 320-1-+(,-2)/# 21# ,F.# /*(+.# 21# .B.&I0(I#;-1.G#L-B-)L#&-/.#,2#).H#12&3/#21#&.;(,-2)/G#ThW#,2#+&.(,.#).H#12&3/#21#/2+-(;#'2)0/# -)# ,F.# f'(0g# ).-LF'2:&F220/AO8#X,# -/# )2,.H2&,FI# ,F(,# ,F./.# K'(0O# ).-LF'2&F220/# *;(I# ()# .//.),-(;#&2;.#-)#,F.#*;(/,-+#()0#,F.#(&+F-,.+,:&(;#H2&C#21#=++2)+-#(/#H.;;A#=#*.&12&3()+.G#F.# /(I/G#-/#02).#KAAA#-)#,F.#/,&..,G#()I#;2+(,-2)#ThW#-)#(#)2)J*;(+.#Tn(&0G#V77VWAO#

ZF.# )2)J;-.:G# ,F.# :)0-11.&.),-(,.0# )2HF.&.# 2&# .B.&IHF.&.G# ,F.# F.,.&2,2*-(# H-,F2:,# -0.),-,IG#H-,F2:,#S:(;-,-./G#,F.#3.L(;2*2;-/G#,F.#3.,(*2;-/#21#>.H#c2&C#`-,IG#-)#2,F.&#H2&0/G# ,F.#/*(+.#,F(,#S:./,-2)/#()0#-L)2&./#,F.#,&(0-,-2)(;#2**2/-,-2)#'.,H..)#*:';-+#()0#*&-B(,.# /*(+.# ()0# HF.&.# /.)/2&I# ,.&&-,2&-./# ,F&2:LF# ,F.# :)12;0-)L# 21# :&'()# ()0# (&+F-,.+,:&(;# (3'-()+./#3-LF,#'.#':-;0(';.G#-/#,F.#/+.).#21#(+,-2)#21#=++2)+-g/#*.&12&3()+.#(&,A##

?M(+,;I#,F.#/(3.#-/#,&:.#21#F-/#;(,.&#H2&C#(/#()#(&+F-,.+,A#^./-L)-)L#,F.#*:';-+#/*(+.G#=++2)+-# *&.1.&/#HF(,#F.#+(;;/#,F.#;.1,2B.&#/-,./G#,F.#2:,;()0/G#K,F./.#,F&2H(H(I/G#,F./.#H(/,.;()0/G# ,F(,#*&2B-0.#,F.#;(/,#2**2&,:)-,I#12&#320.;#+-,-./G#,F.2&.,-+(;#+-,-./G#1:,:&.#+-,-./A#ThW#X,g/#2);I# -)#,F.#2:,;()0/#,F.)#Y#2);I#2)#(#L(&'(L.#0:3*G#/(I#Y#,F(,#I2:#F(B.#,F.#;:M:&I#,2#-)B.),#(# +-,IG# ,./,# 2:,# (# +-,IG# ()0# &.F.(&/.# (# +-,I# Tn(&0G# V77VWAO# !.+(:/.# 21# ,F./.# -)0.1-)(';.# F.,.&2,2*-(/#,F(,#(&.#/2#+&-,-+(;#12&#,F.#3.,F202;2LI#21#F-/#*.&12&3()+./#()0#(&+F-,.+,:&(;# 0./-L)/G#,F.#0-11.&.),#3.0-(#21#=++2)+-g/#H2&C#(&.#(';.#,2#';.)0A#

?4@+#<3%5,$%+('&

ZF-/#*(*.&#-/#1&(3.0#H-,F-)#(#9F^#&./.(&+F#*&2_.+,#-)#X),.&-2&#=&+F-,.+,:&.A#X#(3#*(&,-+:;(&;I# L&(,.1:;#,2#*&21.//2&/#j..&,#e.&)2:,#21#,F.#%)-B.&/-,I#21#=),H.&*#()0#`F&-/,-()#@-.+C.)/#21# ############################################################################ HM*K$$+SZZ(%+0+M/($Z$"#/);(")#3ZIFILZA#)$/("Z(/*E3#)$*#00())(C*#$*aLZIHZFaJS*i#0&'()*m#/0%q"(*&'-$(C*%/* i(/)*r#)$/("8%=&,-/,-+#X),.&)(,-2)(;-/3#()0#X)/,-,:,-2)(;#`&-,-S:.G#FF*aIILS*Em#/0%q"(*aIILS*__JM*m#/0%q"(8* i#0&'()*aIILS*P5%(*!-3%$%A*C("*r'/)$*'/C*%K"(*!#"#C-Q%(/R8*%/*%1%CMS*^-.#=:1,.-;:)L#0./#Q-));-+F.)A#^-.# 92;-,-C#0.&#@:)/,#:)0#-F&.#9(&(02M-.)8*(C%$(C*14*X#"%#*X'K3(8*>("3%/*E1\1--A)Z!-34+(/J8*++M*_^sFIIM* ^M*===M#"$#/C"()(#"0KM-"6M'AZ;a/FZ+C,)Z"#/0%("(M+C,S*i#0&'()*m#/0%q"(8*=./,F.,-+#Q.*(&(,-2)G#=./J ,F.,-+#`233:)-,IR#Q+.)./#1&23#,F.#=./,F.,-+#\.L-3.#21#=&,8*9mVdmk7k9m<NS*9*i-'"/#3*-,*oC(#)8*<-/B $(Q$)*#/C*X($K-C)8*D-3'.(*a8*?-M*F8*7'..("*aIIg8*+M*`M*

(7)

6"7

#5#####V)0#X),.&)(,-2)(;#`2)L&.//#2)#=3'-()+./G#b2),&.(;#V7"V# ,F.#%)-B.&/-,I#`2;;.L.#21#=),H.&*#=&,./-/G#()0#X#H-/F#,2#(+C)2H;.0L.#,F.#9F^#1-)()+-(;#/:*J *2&,#21#=&,./-/#%)-B.&/-,I#`2;;.L.#21#=),H.&*G#E(+:;,I#21#^./-L)#Q+-.)+./A#

A%/%)%+4%'&

=++2)+-#<A#T"UUVWG#9:';-+#Q*(+.#-)#(#9&-B(,.#Z-3.G#[():(&I#"UU7G#-)#=332)#!(&N.;G#D%$-*90B 0-/0%G#b:/.2#0g=&,.#`2),.3*2&().(#e:-L-#9.++-G#9&(,2G#**A#"6mJ"6U# =++2)+-#<A#TV77VWG#9.&12&3()+.#=1,.&#,F.#E(+,#T.M,&(+,W#"UiUG#-)#E&(N.&#n(&0G#b(&C#`A#Z(I;2&# ()0#[.))-1.&#!;223.&G#D%$-*900-/0%G#e2)02)J>.H#c2&C#T9F(-02)WG#*A#"Vm# !(&N.;#=A#T"UUVWG#D%$-*900-/0%G#b:/.2#0g=&,.#`2),.3*2&().(#e:-L-#9.++-G#9&(,2G#X,(;I# !2-/+;(-&# =A# TV77iWG# k:B&(L.# &.+.)/o# R# eg./*(+.# 0./# 32,/# R# 0.# b(;;(&3o# v# !&220,F(.&/# 0.# [(+S:./#\()+-]&.G#7+%"#3(*S*9"$)*t*b($$"()*t*70%(/0()*K'.#%/()G#)w#VV7G#**A#V8JVa#

`F.B&-.&#[AJEA#TV778WG#9"$*#/C*:$-+%#S*X')('*CU9"$*<-/$(.+-"#/%*X9<>9G#b:/.:#0l=&,#`2)J ,.3*2&()-#0.#!(&+.;2)(#G#!(&+.;2)(G#Q*(-)#

e-)C.&#@A#T"UiiWG#<-,2#=++2)+-G#-)#<-,2#=++2)+-G#!K-$-6"#+K%0*W-"A)*FGLGBFG_IG#>.H#c2&C# \()+-]&.# [A# TV77dWG# eg?/*(+.# 0./# 32,/#R# E&23# b(;;(&3o# ,2# !&220,F(.&/G# -)# [o&x3.# j(3.# T.0AWG#!-"-')*>-'/C#"%()M*V(Q$)*#/C*o.#6()*%/*V=(/$%($KB<(/$'"4*2"(/0K*<'3$'"(G#9.,.&#e()L# =jG#!.&)G#**A#m"JaV#

\-()# [A# T"UUVWG# \.+2)).+,-)L# =&,# =)0# e-1.8* -)# =332)# !(&N.;G# D%$-* 900-/0%G# b:/.2# 0g=&,.# `2),.3*2&().(#e:-L-#9.++-G#9&(,2G#X,(;I# Q.)).,,#\A#TV7"7WG#ZF.#k*.)#`-,IG#-)#\-+CI#!:&0.,,#.)#^.I()#Q:0_-+#T.0/AWG#VK(*k/C3())*<%$4M* VK(*:"1#/*96(*!"-c(0$*14*$K(*b-/C-/*70K--3*-,*k0-/-.%0)*#/C*5('$)0K(*>#/AO)*93,"(C*N("B "K#')(/*7-0%($4G#9F(-02)#9&.//#e-3-,.0G#e2)02)J>.H#c2&CG#**A#VUaJVUd# n(&0#EAG#Z(I;2&#bA#`A#()0#!;223.&#[A#TV77VWG#D%$-*900-/0%G#9F(-02)G#e2)02)J>.H#c2&C#

?1(:#)&

9(:;#<()#!..CG#,.(+F.&#(,#,F.#=&,./-/#%)-B.&/-,I#`2;;.L.#21#=),H.&*G#-/#(#9F^#&./.(&+F.&#(,# ,F.# %)-B.&/-,I# 21# =),H.&*# ()0# ,F.# E(+:;,I# 21# ^./-L)# Q+-.)+./G# =&,./-/# %)-B.&/-,I# `2;;.L.# 21# =),H.&*A#P.#F2;0/#(#b=J0.L&..#-)#=&+F(.2;2LI#p#=&,#P-/,2&I#1&23#,F.#`(,F2;-+#%)-B.&/-,I#21# e2:B(-)A#P-/#&./.(&+F#1-.;0#-/#(&+F-,.+,:&(;#()0#+2),.3*2&(&I#(&,#,F.2&IA#

*(:;AB()'..CD(&,./-/A'.# #

Références

Documents relatifs

statement, along with the plants at home data from this study, has implications for the ways in which botanic garden visits are contextualised within school programmes and how

Starting with the circumstances of publication and their effects on the text, the article addresses the passage of these very private texts into public life, before turning to

Our algorithm, Market-based Iterative Risk Allocation (MIRA), finds the optimal solution by solving the decom- posed optimization problem and the root-finding problem it- eratively

So, positional preferences on public good contribution might lead to a decrease in social welfare because of an overall negative effect on positional externalities when

By presenting a range of diaristic texts composed by canonical Victorian writers, this article illustrates the variety of forms that Victorian diaries take and shows the ways in

Based on German panel data between 1984 and 1999, we are able to estimate household lifetime incomes and then derive a robust estimate of the private saving offset effects of

While ‘rationalist’ aims might have contributed to the EIB’s entrepreneurial promotion of PPPs, this paper argues that there is stronger evidence that norms

Our construction of RFE can be easily extended to the multi-inputs setting, resulting in the first construction, assuming only quasi-siO, of a FPMIFE for randomized functionalities