C OMPOSITIO M ATHEMATICA
P. B AYER J. C. L ARIO
On Galois representations defined by torsion points of modular elliptic curves
Compositio Mathematica, tome 84, n
o1 (1992), p. 71-84
<http://www.numdam.org/item?id=CM_1992__84_1_71_0>
© Foundation Compositio Mathematica, 1992, tous droits réservés.
L’accès aux archives de la revue « Compositio Mathematica » (http:
//http://www.compositio.nl/) implique l’accord avec les conditions gé- nérales d’utilisation (http://www.numdam.org/conditions). Toute utilisa- tion commerciale ou impression systématique est constitutive d’une in- fraction pénale. Toute copie ou impression de ce fichier doit conte- nir la présente mention de copyright.
Article numérisé dans le cadre du programme Numérisation de documents anciens mathématiques
http://www.numdam.org/
On Galois representations defined by torsion points of modular elliptic
curvesP.
BAYER1
and J. C.LARIO2
1 Universitat de Barcelona, Dept.
d’Àlgebra
i Geometria, Gran Via de les Corts Catalanes, 585, 08007 Barcelona; 2 Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya, Dept. de Matemàtica Aplicada II, Pau Gargallo, 5, 08025 Barcelona© 1992 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
Received 7 May 1991; accepted 17 July 1991
Abstract. We verify Serre’s conjecture (3.2.49), stated in [Se4], for the special case of irreducible Galois representations defined by the p-torsion points of modular elliptic curves with potentially good, ordinary reduction at p. Also we treat the semi-stable case when the representation is not finite
at p.
Introduction
For a
prime integer
p, fixp
a closure ofFp. Fix 0
a closure of Q andput Go
=Gal(Q/Q).
For every continuous Galoisrepresentation
p:GQ ~ GL2(IF p),
Serre defines two
integers:
the conductorNp
and theweight kp,
as well as aDirichlet character
Ep: (Z/N03C1Z)* ~ F*p by
means of arecipe.
When p is odd andirreducible,
heconjectures
that p arises from a cusp form oftype (Np, kp, 8.)
withcoefficients in
IF p
which is aneigenfunction
of all the Heckeoperators (cf. [Se4], (3.2.4,,».
Suppose
that E is anelliptic
curve over Q. For eachprime
p, the action of the absolute Galois groupGu
on thep-torsion points Ep
ofE(Q)
defines acontinuous
representation
which is
always
odd andabsolutely
irreducibleif p >
163(cf. [Ma], [Se4]).
In this case, the
character ep
is trivial.Depending
on the arithmetic ofE,
wecompute
the conductor and theweight of p
in Section 1. If therepresentation
p is finite at p,p 5,
and theelliptic
curve is modular and has semi-stable reductionat p, we know that p verifies
(3.2.4?) (cf. [Ri], [Ca]).
In Sections 2 and 3 we show that p verifies(3.2.4?)
when E is modular and haspotentially good ordinary
orsemi-stable
(non-finite)
reduction at p. In these cases theweight k03C1
isgreater
than2 and the cusp form
f predicted by
Serre’sconjecture
can be obtainedby
amanipulation
of theweight-2
newform F attached to Eby
Eichler-Shimuratheory.
Partially supported by DGICYT, PB89-0215-C02-01 and UPC, PRE89.
Section 1
reproduces
the text of a talkgiven by
the second author in theFrey- Lamprecht-Zimmer
Seminar of the Universitât desSaarlandes,
inSeptember
’89. The results in this section are in accordance with the ones
given
in[Kr].
1. Conductor and
weight
formulaeThe action of
Ga
on the Tate moduleTP(E)
of Egives
rise to ap-adic representation 03C10:GQ ~ Aut(1;,(E) ~ Qp) ~ GL2(0p)
which is alifting
of therepresentation
p. Let N be the conductorof po; i.e.,
N is theproduct
of the localArtin conductors of po at the
primes
1~ p (cf. [Sel]).
We know that theconductor
Np of p must
be a divisor of N. Since the wild ramification groups at 1are
pro-1-groups
andl ~
p, the wildexponents
of N andNp
coincide. We havefor every
prime l ~
p.Here, Il
denotes some inertia group ofGU
for 1.Let now
Fl
denote thespecial
fibre of the Néron model of E at 1 and consider the exact sequencewhere
03B50Fl, 03A6l
are theidentity component
and the groupof components of Fl,
respectively.
We recall thatFl
if E hasgood
reduction at1,
0Fl ~ { Gm,iF, (over l)
if E hasmultiplicative
reduction atl, G.,[F,
if E has additive reduction at 1.To
compute codimFpEIlp,
we use theisomorphism E(Ql)[p]Il ~ Fl(l)[p]
ob-tained
by
reduction(cf. [Se-Ta]);
oneeasily
checks that2
if E hasgood
reduction at1,
dim
Fl(l)[p]
= 1 + dim03A6l(Fl)[p]
if E hasmultiplicative
reduction at1,
dim
03A6l(l)[p]
if E has additive reduction at 1.On the other
hand,
2
if E hasgood
reductionat l,
dim(T,(E)
~Qp)Il =
1 if E hasmultiplicative
reductionat l,
0
if E has additive reduction at 1.From what
precedes
it is clear thatfor every
prime l ~
p.The
following
tablesyield
the exact value of the ’abaissement’vl(N/N03C1)
interms of the reduction
type
of the Néron model at l.For
p=2,
The
recipe
tocompute
theweight kp
is moresubtle;
itonly
involves the localrepresentation
at p. Let p p :Gp ~ GL2(Fp)
be therepresentation
obtained from pby
restriction to somedecomposition
groupGp = Gal(Qp/Qp)
ofGu
for p. Letpp
denote its
semisimplification.
The action under03C1ssp
of the tame inertia groupI of Gp
isgiven by
two characters4J, 4J’
of level 1 or2; by writing
them in a suitableway as powers of the fundamental characters one
gets
the valueof kP (cf. [Se4]).
Recall that each character
of I is
determinedby
itsinvariant
a modZ[1/p],
where a is a rational number
(cf. [Se2]).
Assume for
simplicity
that p > 7(cf. [Kr]
for the casesp 7).
Let c4, C6 be theusual invariants of the
elliptic
curveE,
determined up top-units
from a p- minimal Weierstrassequation
for E.PROPOSITION. The
weight k03C1 = 2 + 03BB(p-1)
and the invariants03B1(~), 03B1(~’)
=pl(p - 1) - a( 1J) of
the characters attached to therepresentation
can be read
from
thefollowing
table:Proof.
The results in the second table can be obtained from the results in the first tableby twisting
with thequadratic
character ramifiedonly
at p. If E has semi-stable reduction at p, the values of03B1(~)
and arealready given
in[Se4].
Therefore,
weonly
need to consider the cases when E has reductiontype II, III,
or IV at p.
Let
The
elliptic
curve Eacquires good
reduction over the field L =Qnrp(03C0),
where03C0e=p.
LetEL = E ~ Qnrp L
and letm: EL(p) ~ E(p)
be theGal(QpIL)-
isomorphism
obtainedby
basechange.
We search for some 1-dimensionalsubspace of the iFp[It]-module (Fp 0 Fp Ep)SS.
We first recall the basic
setup
of[Se2].
Let E be the formal groupof EL
and leth be its
height.
The kernelEp
of themultiplication by [p]
containsalways
a non-zero
Fp-vector space vL
on which the tame inertia groupIt,L
ofGal(ap/L)
acts.The
dimFp VL
and the action ofIt,L
onFph
QVL
can both be read from the Newtonpolygon
of the formal series of themultiplication by [p]
onÊ.
A case-by-case
verification shows:where
03B8p-1, Op2 -1: It,L
~*p
are fundamental characters onIt,L
of level one andtwo,
respectively.
Let us take V :=
IFph
Qm(VEL),
whereVEL
is theimage
ofVL
under theembedding of p
into the groupEL,p
ofp-torsion points
ofEL(p).
NowIt acts
on V and its action can be
computed by
means of m. Forthat,
we look at theaction of sm :=
m-1 s m
onFph O VL,
for s EGal(p/Qnrp).
We carry out thewhole
computations only
when E has reductiontype
1 vat p, p
~ 2(mod 3),
andVp(C4)
> 2:and
If
s~Gal(p/nrp)
and z= -03C0x/y~ VL,
thenFinally,
for 1 Q(x, y)
~V weget
Now, case-by-case,
we fill up the tableby taking
into account therecipe
for theweight.
2. Serre’s
conjecture
in theordinary
caseOur
goal
is to prove thefollowing
THEOREM. Serre’s
conjecture (3.2.4?)
istrue for
an irreduciblerepresentation
p :
G ~ Aut(Ep)
provided
that E over 0 is a modularelliptic
curve withpotentially good, ordinary
reduction at p > 7.
We look for a modular form
f
= Eanqn
oftype (Np, kp)
with coefficients inif p’
eigenfunction
of all the Heckeoperators,
andsatisfying trace(p(Frob,»
= al anddet(p(Frobl))
=lk03C1-1,
for all
1 f pN p.
We should like to remark that numericalevidence,
collectedby
computer calculations,
led us to guess how the normalized newform F attachedto our
elliptic
curve E should be handled toproduce f.
First of all we fix someterminology:
Set
Cn
for acyclic
group of order n. Fix aprimitive
root mod p or,equivalently,
fix anisomorphism (Z/pZ)* ~ Cp-1.
Let(p in Q
be aprimitive p th
root of
unity.
Realize the groupC p -
1 as Galois group as follows:GQ ~ Gal((03B6p)/) ~ (/p)*, by sending
aconjugation
classFrob,
to 1 mod p for all 1 =1= p.Fix
embeddings
for each
prime
1 and define a Dirichlet characterso that under the
mapping
03BCp-1~ *p
we have03C8(n)n ~
1(mod p),
for alln~, (n, p)
= 1.We denote
by
the Galois 1-adic character deduced from
03C8.
Note thatby
reduction modp, 03C8p yields
the inverse of thecyclotomic
character mod pwhich is
given by
the action ofGo
on thep th
roots ofunity.
Finally,
for future use we state thefollowing
notations:From now on we
put m = p -1
.e
LEMMA 1. Let F be the normalized
newform
associated to anelliptic
curve Esatisfying
the samehypothesis
as in the theorem and let N be as in Section 1. Then the levelof
F isp2N
and there exists anewform
having
the sameeigenvalues
system as thetwisted form
F 003C8m.
Proof.
The first claim follows from theassumptions
and[Ca].
Observe thatF
~ 03C8m
is aneigenfunction
for the Heckeoperators
witheigenvalues system
{al03C8m(l), 03C82m}lpN.
Therefore there exists a divisor M ofp2N
and a newformg E S2(M, tf¡2m) having
the sameeigenvalues system
as FQ tf¡m.
Infact,
being Up,
resp.Bp,
theAtkin,
resp. thedegeneracy, operators
as in[At-Li].
We must prove that M = N if E is of
type I*
at p, and M =pN
otherwise.Let 1 be a
prime
such that(1, pN)
= 1.Using Eichler-Shimura,
ifdenotes the 1-adic
representation
attached to E thenis the 1-adic
representation arising
from Fp t/Jm.
Noticethat 03C1l Q 03C8ml
is also the 1- adicrepresentation
for the newform g.Since after
Carayol’s
work it is known that the level of a newform agrees(outside 1)
with the Artin conductor of its 1-adicrepresentation,
we have reduced theproblem
tocompute
the conductorof 03C1l Q 03C8ml
attached to g.Moreover,
since03C8l
is unramifiedoutside p
weonly
need tocompute
the actionof 1 p’
the inertiasubgroup
of Gal(Qp/Qp).
Since E has
potentially good ordinary
reduction at p, Eacquires good
reduction over the
ring
ofintegers
ofOP(n),
with03C0e = p and p
~ 1(mod e);
therefore p, restricted at
1 p
factorizesthrough
acyclic
groupCe
of order e. Inparticular,
this forces the restriction03C1l/Ip
to bediagonalizable.
Moreoverdet
03C1l(Ip)=1
and hencewith a character 8:
Cp-1 ~ ,ue(Q,).
We may view e as a Galois character unramified outside p, still denotedby
g,But,
e should bet/liJ::.m. Since, being Qi fixed, only
two characters ofCp-1 ~ 03BCp-1(Ql)
of order e exist if e =3, 4
or6,
andonly
one if e = 2.So,
now it isclear that p, ~
has
Artin conductor withexponent
1 at p if e =3, 4,
6 or 0 ife=2.
We also need some
knowledge
on the behavior of the ’hidden’ coefficientbp
ofthe newform g attached to the modular form F. In the next
lemma,
wereject
theeasy case when E is of
type IÓ
at p.LEMMA 2. Let g = E
bnqn
be the normalizednewform of
Lemma 1 and assumea =1. Let K be the number
field generated by
the Fouriercoefficients bn for
allni 1. Then we have:
(i)
Thefield
K isequal
to(ii) |bp|
=vP.
(iii) If vp
denotes the normalizedp-adic
valuationof 0 fixed by p,
thenProof.
It is clear that the coefficientsbl
withlpN belong
to the fieldU(tP’).
Since g is
anewform,
it then follows from a theorem ofMiyake (cf.
Theorem B in[Mi]),
that all the coefficientsof g
lie inQ(03C8m).
Since g
is a normalized newform and it hasprimitive p-Nebentypus (in
thesense that its level and the conductor of its character have the same valuation at
p),
a result ofOgg-Li-Asai (cf. [Og], [Li], [As]) yields Ibpl
=fi,
and thereforevp(bp) + vp(bp)=1, where
the bar denotescomplex conjugation.
Sincebp
is aninteger
of K and psplits completely
inK,
we havevp(bp)
E{0, 1}.
The next lemma makes use of the
theory
ofdeforming
residual Galoisrepresentations.
Recent work of Mazur and Tilouinesuggest
how to makeexplicit
links betweenordinary
deformations andordinary (potentially) elliptic
curves
(cf. [Ma-Ti], [Hi]).
We
let g
= Xbnqn
denote the’complex conjugate’
form of g.LEMMA 3. Either g or
g
isordinary
at p,depending
on thep-Kodaira symbol of
E:
II, III,
IV orII*, III*,
IV*.Proof.
Since E haspotentially good ordinary
reduction at p, the restriction of p to1 p
is reducible. It isgiven by
(~p-m0
*
when E is oftype II,
777 or 1 v at p,and
We obtain
Therefore, by
a theorem of Wiles(cf. [Wi]), g
cannot beordinary
in the caseswhen E is of
type II*,
III* or IV*at p, resp. g
cannot beordinary
in the caseswhen E is of
type II,
III or 1 V at p. Since we know apriori
that one of the twoforms is
p-ordinary,
the claim follows.REMARK. From now on let
i3
be theplace of Q
fixedby
our choice ofQp.
Letg
denote the
p-ordinary
cusp form in Lemma 3. In thering
ofintegers
(9 of(03C8m)
we write
( p)
=pp
where p= i3 m
U. Denoteby Ale
the abeliansubvariety
ofJ 1 (pN)
attachedto g by
Shimura’stheory
and consider the -rationalmultiplication
under which the action of
l(n)
isgiven by
the Heckeoperator T",Alb acting
on A.By using
a theoremof Langlands [La],
Aacquires good
reduction overQp((p) (or
even moreprecisely,
over thesplitting
field of the characterf/¡2m).
Denoteby
B the Néron model of A over
Spec Zp[03B6p].
Lemma 3simply
tells us that the p-divisible group B
[pOO]
isordinary
at p; i.e. in the exact sequence ofp-divisible
groups
all the terms are non-zero.
The last lemma we need makes use of the Eisenstein series
El ,t/J. Briefly,
wesummarize its definition and
properties:
where
Here, L(s, 03C8)
is the Dirichlet’s L-function for thecharacter 03C8,
andis the Gauss sum. The Eisenstein series
E1,03C8
is a modular formof weight
1 andcharacter
onro(p)
which satisfiesand
Also we are
going
to recall the traceoperator
between modular forms. For sake ofsimplicity
weonly
take care of the casewhere 0
is a Dirichlet character modN, and 03C3j
denotes a set ofrepresentatives
ofthe
right
cosetsro(pN)Bro(N).
Let
W = px 1) PNY p), with
someintegers
x, ysatisfying
detWp = p.
It is the well-known Fricke involution. LetUp
be thepth
Heckeoperator acting
onS03BA(pN, ~).
In our case, the traceoperator
has thesimple expression
LEMMA 4. Let
h = 03A3cnqn ~ S03BA(pN, 03C8-t) be a newform with
1 x t p 1. Let d bea
positive integer
with d - t(mod p - 1).
ThenProof.
For theproof
we borrow some ideas of Koike and Shimura(cf. [Ko]).
We write for a moment
Since
E1,03C8 ~
1(mod ),
we look for aninteger d
such thatFollowing
Asai[As],
let us definec(p)n by
and
put
Then
h|[Wp]03BA = 03B4ph(p) being 03B4p = C(03C8-t)p-03BA/2p
thepseudo-eigenvalue
ofWp
at h.
By using (2)
we rewriteFinally, by taking
into accountStickelberger’s
theorem weget
and this proves the lemma.
Proof of the
theorem. Wegive
theproof when
E is oftype II, III,
or 1 V at p.For the other cases,
except
when E is oftype 16
which is eveneasier,
weproceed
in the same way, and therefore the
proof
is left to the reader.By
Lemma 1 wetake g
= Ebnqn ~
inS2(pN, 03C82m).
From Lemmas 2 and 3 weknow that in this case g is a
p-ordinary
newformsatisfying vp(bp)
= 1.By normalizing
theexponent
in the character of g, we can taked = m(e - 2)
inaccordance with Lemma 4.
Let be as in Section 1. If 0 denotes the
Ramanujan operator (cf. [Se3])
it isimmediate that
and its coefficients are
congruent
to the traces ofp(Frobl)
for alll pN.
Theweight
of this form is now theright
one and its level isprime
to p.If N is the conductor
predicted by (3.2.4?) (cf.
table of conductors in Section1),
we can take the form
f predicted by
Serre’sconjecture
as()m Tr(gE1 ,"’).
Otherwise,
since N isprime
to p, Theorem 1 in[Jo-Li]
allows tochange
the formTr(gE1,,,,) by
aform g’
such thatf
=03B8mg’.
REMARK. Notice that the
newform g
can be used toproduce
the modular formpredicted by
theconjecture
of Serre for therepresentation arising
from the p- torsionpoints
ofE*,
the twistedelliptic
curve of Eby
thequadratic
characterramified
only
at p.3. Serre’s
conjecture
in the semi-stable non-finite caseUsing
the sametechniques
as in thepreceeding
section we alsogive
thefollowing
THEOREM. Serre’s
conjecture (3.2.4?)
istrue for
an irreduciblerepresentation
p :
GQ ~ Aut(E p)
provided
that E over 0 is a modularelliptic
curve with semi-stable reduction at aprime p
5.Proof.
When therepresentation
p isfinite,
which isequivalent
to say that theweight predicted by
Serre’sconjecture equals 2,
it is a consequence of resultsgiven
in[Ri]
and[Ca].
Thus,
we suppose p isnon-finite;
then theweight
attached to p isk03C1 = p +
1.Applying
the same kind ofarguments
as in theprevious section,
now we havethat
FEp-11,03C8 belongs
toSp+ 1(pN), being
F = Eanqn
the newform attached to theelliptic
curve E. It is easy to checkthat g
=Tr(FEp-11,03C8)
willproduce
the cusp formpredicted by (3.2.4?)
because it has the correctweight,
p does not divide its level and since ap = ± 1 it satisfiesTR(FEp-11,03C8)
~ F(mod ).
Acknowledgement
We would like to express our thanks to J.
Quer
for manykey
discussionsand, especially,
for his valuablehelp
toperform
thealgorithm quoted
in[Se4],
2.9.Remarque
2.References
[As] Asai, T.: On the Fourier coefficients of automorphic forms at various cusps and some
applications to Rankin’s convolution, J. Math. Soc. Japan 28 (1976), 48-61.
[At-Le] Atkin, A.O.L. and Lehner, J.: Hecke operators on 03930(N), Math. Ann. 185 (1970), 134-160.
[At-Li] Atkin, A.O.L. and Li, W.-C.: Twists of newforms and pseudo-eigenvalues of W-operators,
Invent. Math. 48 (1978), 221-243.
[Ca] Carayol, H.: Sur les représentations l-adiques attachées aux formes modulaires de Hilbert,
Ann. scient. E.N.S. 19 (1986), 409-468.
[Hi] Hida, H.: Galois representations into GL2[[X]] attached to ordinary cusp forms, Inv.
Math. 85 (1986), 545-577.
[Jo-Li] Jordan, B.W. and Livné, R.: Conjecture ’epsilon’ for weight k > 2, Bull. Amer. Math. Soc.
21 (1989), 51-69.
[Ko] Koike, M.: Congruences between cusp forms and linear representations of the Galois group, Nagoya Math. J. 64 (1976), 63-85.
[Kr] Kraus, A.: ’Thèse: Sur l’arithmétique des courbes elliptiques’, 1990.
[La] Langlands, R.P.: Automorphic forms and l-adic representations, Modular Forms of One
Variable II, 361-500; Springer Lect. Notes 349, 1973.
[Ma] Mazur, B.: Rational isogenies of prime degree, Invent. Math. 44 (1978), 129-162.
[Ma-Ti] Mazur, B. and Tilouine, J.: Représentations galoisiennes, différentielles de Kähler, et
’conjectures principales’,Publ. Math. IHES 71 (1990), 65-103.
[Mi] Miyake, T.: On automorphic forms on GL2 and Hecke operators, Ann. of Math. 94 (1971),
174-189.
[Og] Ogg, A.: On the eigenvalues of the Hecke operators, Math. Ann. 79 (1969), 101-108.
[Ri] Ribet, K.: On modular representations of
Gal(Q/Q)
arising from modular forms, Invent.Math. 100 (1990), 431-476.
[Se1] Serre, J.-P.: Facteurs locaux des fonctions zêta des variétés algébriques (définitions et conjectures); Séminaire Delange-Pisot-Poitou 19 (1969/70); 0152 87. Springer, 1986.
[Se2] Serre, J.P.: Propriétés galoisiennes des points d’ordre fini des courbes elliptiques, Invent.
Math. 15 (1972), 259-331; 0152 94, 1986.
[Se3] Serre, J.-P.: Valeurs propres des opérateurs de Hecke modulo l, Astérisque 24-25 (1975), 109-117; 0152 104, Springer, 1986.
[Se4] Serre, J.-P.: Sur les représentations modulaires de degré 2 de
Gal(Q/Q),
Duke Math. J. 54(1987), 179-230.
[Se-Ta] Serre, J.-P. and Tate, J.: Good reduction of abelian varieties, Ann. of Math. 88 (1968), 492- 517 ; 0152 79, Springer, 1986.
[Sh] Shimura, G.: On the factors of the Jacobian variety of a modular function field, J. Math.
Soc. Japan 25 (1976), 523-544.
[Wi] Wiles, A.: On p-adic representations for totally real fields, Ann. of Math. 123 (1986), 407-
456.