• Aucun résultat trouvé

nomograms allowing evaluation detrusor contractility in women

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Partager "nomograms allowing evaluation detrusor contractility in women"

Copied!
6
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

Disponibleenlignesur

ScienceDirect

www.sciencedirect.com

ORIGINAL ARTICLE

Usefulness of an algebraic fitting of

nomograms allowing evaluation detrusor contractility in women

Intérêt du lissage algébrique des nomogammes permettant l’évaluation de la contractilité du detrusor de la femme

F.A. Valentini

a,d,∗

, B.G. Marti

b

, P.P. Nelson

b

, P.E. Zimmern

c

, G. Robain

a

aHôpitalRothschild,médecinephysiqueetderéadaptation,5,rueSanterre,75012Paris, France

bHôpitalSaint-Antoine,75012Paris,France

cUniversityofTexasSouthwestern,Dallas,TX75390,USA

dUniversitéPierre-et-Marie-Curie,4,placeJussieu,75005Paris,France

Received29April2016;accepted21June2016 Availableonline15July2016

KEYWORDS Detrusor contractility;

Nomograms;

Bladderoutlet obstruction;

Women

Summary

Aims.—NomogramsbasedonValentini-Besson-Nelson(VBN)modelimplyingonly3measure- ments(fillingbladdervolume,maximumflow-rate[Qmax]anddetrusorpressureatQmax)were recentlydevelopedtoevaluatedetrusorcontractility(k)andurethralobstruction(U)inwomen.

Astheiralgebraicfittingleadstofastevaluations(Excel®software),ouraimswereapplications topopulationsofnon-neurologicwomenwithoutandwithbladderoutletobstruction(BOO).

Methods.—Thesoftwarewas appliedto measurementsobtainedduring pressureflowstud- ies.Hiddenhypothesisofnomogramswerenosignificantcontributionofabdominalpressure betweenonsetofflowandQmaxandstandardnervousexcitationsuntilQmax.Studiedpopula- tionswere202womenwithoutsymptomsuggestiveofobstructionand125womenwithproven anatomicalurethralobstructionwhounderwenturodynamicstudy.

Results.—Fornon-obstructedwomen,agoodagreementwasfoundbetweenthevaluesofk andUobtainedusingnomogramsoracompleteVBNanalysisoftherecordedcurves.Whatever theobstructivestatus,therewasagoodcorrelationbetweenthevalueofkandU.Evolution withageingwassimilarwithhighervaluesofkandUintheBOOgroup.Curvesk(age)andU(age) gavecoefficientsallowinganageadjustment.Thehighkvalueinthedetrusoroveractive(DO) groupwasconsistentwithasimilareffecttothatofBOOonthedetrusor.

Correspondingauthor.HôpitalRothschild,médecinephysiqueetderéadaptation,5,rueSanterre,75012Paris,France.

E-mailaddresses:francoise.valentini@rth.aphp.fr,favalentini@gmail.com(F.A.Valentini).

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.purol.2016.06.010

1166-7087/©2016ElsevierMassonSAS.Allrightsreserved.

(2)

Conclusion.—Evaluation of detrusor contractility (k) and urethral obstruction (U) can be obtainedfromthepoint ofQmax duringpressure-flowstudy.Evolutionwithageingissimilar with(highervalues)orwithoutBOO.DOalsoinducesanincreaseddetrusorcontractility.

Levelofevidence.—4.

©2016ElsevierMassonSAS.Allrightsreserved.

MOTSCLÉS Contractilitédu detrusor; Nomogrammes; Obstruction sous-vésicale; Femme

Résumé

Introduction.—DesnomogrammesdéduitsdumodèleValentini-Besson-Nelson(VBN)permet- tentd’évaluerlacontractilitédudetrusor(k)etl’obstructionurétrale(U)chezlafemme.Leur lissagealgébriquepermetuneévaluationtrèsrapide(sousExcel®)àpartirdesdonnéesd’un instantanémictionnelàl’instantdudébitmaximum (Qmax).Notrebutétait l’applicationde cetteméthodeàdesfemmesnon-neurologiques.

Méthodes.—Deuxpopulationsontétéétudiées:202patientessanssymptômeobstructifet 125patientesayantuneobstructionurétraleanatomiquedocumentée.Lesconditionsrequises étaientl’absencedepressionabdominalesignificativeetdesexcitationsnerveusesstandards entreledébutdudébitetl’atteinteduQmax.

Résultats.—Chezlespatientesnon-obstruées,onretrouvaitunebonnecorrespondanceentre lesvaleursdeketUobtenuesparutilisationdesnomogrammesetcellesobtenuesparanalyse VBNdel’ensembledescourbes.Quelquesoitlestatutobstructif,ontrouvaitunebonnecor- rélationentrelesvaleursdeketU.L’effetduvieillissementétaitsemblabledansles2groupes avecdesvaleurssignificativementplusélevéesdeketUdanslegroupeobstrué.Lescourbes k(âge)etU(âge)donnentdescoefficientspermettantunecorrectiond’âge.Hyperactivitédu detrusoretobstructionurétraleconduisentàdesvaleursélevéesdek.

Conclusion.—Contractilitédudetrusor(k)etobstructionurétrale(U)peuventêtreévaluées àpartirdupointdeQmaxpendantunIM.L’obstructionanatomiqueconduitàdesvaleursplus élevéesmais l’évolution avec levieillissement est comparable. L’hyperactivité du detrusor entraîneelleaussiuneaugmentationdelacontractilitédudetrusor.

Niveaudepreuve.— 4.

©2016ElsevierMassonSAS.Tousdroitsr´eserv´es.

Introduction

Detrusorcontractilityandurethralobstruction(anatomical or‘‘urethralresistance’’)arethedrivingfactorsofthevoid- ingprocess.Thesemechanicalparametersarerespectively namedkandUintheVBNmathematicalmodelofmicturi- tion[1,2].

In aprevious study,k andU have been evaluatedin a populationofnon-neurologic,non-obstructedwomenfrom theVBN analysis of thewhole set of urodynamic tracings recordedduringapressure-flowstudy(PFs)[3].Inwomen, unlike in men, the impact of bladder outlet obstruction (BOO)onbladdercontractilityhasbeenlittlediscussed.

Recently, VBN-based nomograms have been developed [4]tofollowwomenatriskofobstructionovertime.They allowevaluating k andU froma PFs recording usingonly three measurements: filling volume (Vini), maximum flow rate(Qmax) anddetrusorpressureat Qmax (pdet.Qmax).More algebraicfittingofthesenomogramshaveallowedtocarry outausablesoftwareinExcel® orinanysimplehandheld.

Thus,itisnolongernecessary toextrapolatebetweenthe referencecurvesofnomogramstoobtainthevaluesofkand U.UsingtheExcel® software,valuesareobtainedinstanta- neouslyfromthethreemeasurementslistedabove.

Ouraimswere:

• tocompare thevaluesofk andUobtainedfromnomo- gramsandcompleteVBNanalysis;

• to apply the nomograms to data of large cohorts of non-neurogenicwomentestedurodynamicallyinorderto analyzetheeffectofanatomicalurethralobstructionon detrusorcontractility;

• toproposeacorrectionoftheeffectofageinginorderto separatetheeffectofageingfromaspecificeffectofa lowerurinarytractdysfunction(LUTD)onthemechanical parameters.

Materials and methods

ThisstudywasconductedinaccordancewiththeDeclaration of Helsinki. Urodynamic datawere obtained from 2large databasesfrom2institutions.

Non-obstructed group

The firstsample (non-obstructedgroup)comprisedwomen without symptom suggestive of obstruction (i.e. no

(3)

hesitancy,strainingtovoid,doublevoiding,slowstream...), nohistory of prioranti-incontinence surgery andreferred for evaluation of LUTD. After urodynamic session, urody- namicdiagnosisallowedcategorizationasnormal(N),phasic orterminaldetrusoroveractivity(PDOorTDO),urodynam- ics stress urinary incontinence (USI), intrinsic sphincteric deficiency(ISD)orhypertonicurethra(urethralpressureat rest>(110—age)+20%)).Forthatsample, accordingtothe localpracticeofEthicsCommittee,thereisnoformalInsti- tutional Review Boardapproval requiredfor retrospective studies.

Obstructed group

The second sample (obstructed group) comprised women with anatomically proven BOO. BOO diagnosis was based onhistory,presentingsymptoms,examfindings,andsiteof obstructionconfirmedonlateralvoidingcystogram.Forthat sample, thestudy wasapproved by thelocal Institutional ReviewBoard.

Methods

CriteriaforinclusionwerePFstracingsprovidingmaximum flowrateQmaxanddetrusorpressureatQmax(pdet.Qmax)with- outsignificantcontributionofabdominalpressurebetween onsetofflowandQmax(<3cmH2O(firstsample)and<10cm H2O (second sample)), a Qmax>2mL/s, an initial bladder volume(Vini)>100mL,andanon-interruptedflow.

Criteriaforexclusionwereneurologicaldisease,diabetes mellitusand,inthefirstsamplegrade>2prolapse.

Allpatientswereevaluatedusingmedicalhistory,review ofmedications,bladderdiaryforatleast48hincludingvoid- ingtimesandvoidedvolumesbothdayandnight,physical examination,anddipstickurinalysis.

Urodynamic sessions for sub-population (1) were per- formed using the Dorado® unit from Laborie. Cystometry wasperformedwiththepatientintheseatedpositionwith a7-Ftriple-lumenurethralcatheterperfusedwithsalineat roomtemperature usinga fillingrate of 50mL/min. Pres- sure transducers were zeroed to atmospheric pressure at the upper edge of the symphysis pubis. Rectal pressure wasrecordedusingapuncturedintrarectalballooncatheter

filledwith2mLof saline accordingto thereportof Good UrodynamicPracticeguidelines[5].

Urodynamic sessions for sub-population (2) were per- formedusingtheAquarius® unitfromLaborie.Cystometry wasperformedwiththepatientintheseatedpositionwith a6-Fdouble-lumenurethralcatheterperfusedwithsaline atroomtemperatureusingafillingrateof50mL/min.Pres- sure transducers were zeroed to atmospheric pressure at theupperedgeofthesymphysispubis.Rectalpressurewas recordedusingarectalballoon.

Definitions givenin the standardization of terminology oflowerurinarytractfunction(ICS[6],itsFrenchadapta- tion[7] andICS/IUGA jointreport for female pelvicfloor dysfunction[8])wereusedtoclassifyurodynamicdiagnosis.

StandardvaluesofVBNparameterswerek=1.0(without unit)andU=0(unitcmH2O).

Statistical analysis

Dataarepresentedasmean±SDandrange.Analysisofvari- ance(ANOVA),ttest,andthechi-squaretestwereusedas appropriate.Allstatistical resultswereconsidered signifi- cantatP<0.05.Statistical analyseswereperformedusing SAS,version5.0(SASInstitute,Inc.,Cary,NC).

Results

Analysis using nomograms vs. VBN analysis of the whole recordings

Thenon-obstructedgroupcomprised202women,(meanage 58.1±17.2y;range[20—90y]).Inaprevious study[3],for partofthatgroup (125women),anassessment ofparam- eters(k andU)fromurodynamictracingsrecordedduring PFshadbeencarriedout.Asecondaryanalysisofdatausing nomogramsallowedcomparisonbetweenVBNanalysisand VBNnomograms.

Bland-Altman plots [9] showed a good agreement betweenthetwomethodsforevaluationofkandU(Fig.1).

So, the point of Qmax was eligible for evaluation of the mechanicalparameters.

Figure1. Bland-AltmanplotsforcomparisonofvaluesfoundfordetrusorcontractilitykandurethralobstructionUusing2different methods:VBNanalysisofthewholerecordedcurvesduringPFsandnomograms.

(4)

Table1 CorrelationskandUvs.ageinthe2studiedpopulations.FortheBOOpopulation,thenumberofagegroups arereduced,duetothesmallnumberofwomenyoungerthan30y(N=4)andolderthan80y(N=3).

Age(y) <30 30—39 40—49 50—59 60—69 70—79 >80

NowithoutBOO 8 16 26 40 37 46 29

k .64±.33 .63±24 .63±.29 .54±.22 .43±.24 .37±.18 .30±.17 U(cmH2O) 22.6±20.4 22.2±18.3 22.6±19.8 16.1±13.8 13.9±10.8 10.2±10.5 8.4±8.6

NowithBOO 13 17 36 38 21

k .87±.16 .89±.59 .71±.46 .64±.30 .54±.35

U(cmH2O) 37.6±13.0 37.6±31.9 29.4±23.9 27.6±16.9 23.1±20.0

Correlation k(U)

TheVBNparameterskandUwereidentifiedinthe2pop- ulationsusingthenomogramsfromVini,Qmax and pdet.Qmax

recordedduringPFs.

Non-obstructed group

In the non-obstructed group, the mean value and range wererespectively0.49±0.25,range[0.02—1.20]forkand 17.0±15.2cmH2Orange[1.2—73.9cmH2O]forU.

Therewasasignificantcorrelation(P<.0001)betweenk andU:k=.245+.014*U(R2=.747).

Obstructed group

Intheobstructedgroup(N=125),(meanage57.7±12.7y;

range [21—87y]), the mean value and range were respectively 0.67±0.41, range [0.15—2.61] for k and 28.4±21.9cmH2Orange[1.2—135.0cmH2O]forU.

Therewasasignificantcorrelation(P<.0001)betweenk andU:k=.192+.017*U(R2=.840).

Correlation k and U vs. age

MeanvalueofkandUwassignificantlyhigheraccordingwith agestratificationin theobstructedgroup(comparingnon- obstructedvs.obstructed:P<.0001foreachparameter).

Inthe2populations,valueofkandUremainedconstant until menopausal age, and then decreased regularlywith advancingage(Table1andFig.2).

Attempt to correct the effect of ageing in various clinical conditions

As the decreaseof k and U was roughly linear after 50y (Fig.2),decreasecoefficients(slopeofstraightlinebetween 50and80y)werecalculated.Inthenon-obstructedgroup theyweredk/dt=−0.009/yanddU/dt=−0.47/y,andinthe obstructedgroupdk/dt=−0.011/yanddU/dt=−0.48/y.

Afirstresultwasthattheslopesweresimilarwhatever theobstructivestatus.

Inthenon-obstructedgroupwomenwerecategorizedas normal (No=18), phasic or terminal detrusor overactivity (71 PDOand71TDO), urodynamicstress incontinence(15 USI),intrinsicsphinctericdeficiency(17ISD)orhypertonic urethra(No=10).

Meanageinthenon-obstructedgroupwas58.1±17.2y not so far from mean age in the obstructed group (57.0±13.0y).Anattemptwasmadetocompareallclinical conditionsofnon-obstructedsubgroupswiththeobstructed one. Thus, age adjusted value of k and U (<kadj> and

<Uadj>)werecomputedusingtheslopesofthecurvesk(age) andU(age)forthegroupswhoseagedifferedsignificantly fromthemeanage:PDO,TDO,ISDandhypertonicurethra (Tables2and3).

Figure2. ChangesinvalueofkandUwithageinginthenon-obstructedand theBOOpopulations.Square:non-obstructedwomen.

Triangle:BOOwomen.

(5)

Table2 MeanvaluesofkandUvs.urodynamicdiagnosisandanatomicalobstruction.

NormalUD Phasic DO (PDO)

Terminal DO (TDO)

USI ISD IHUP Allnon-

obstructed

AllBOO

Number 18 71 71 15 17 10 202 125

Age(y) 59.0±16.0 53.4±17.3 66.1±14.6 59.0±15.0 68.0±15.0 45.0±16.0 58.1±.17.2 57.0±13.0 k .47±24 .56±.30 .52±.30 .39±.14 .38±.14 .48±.20 .48±.20 .68±.40

Pvs.PDO n.s. — n.s. 0.0183 0.0060 n.s. — —

Pvs.TDO n.s. n.s. — n.s. 0.0317 n.s. — —

U 17.3±15.0 20±16.0 21±19.0 8.8±7.7 8.3±6.8 15.0±13.0 15.6±.14.0 28.5±22.0

Pvs.PDO n.s. — n.s. 0.0090 0.0048 n.s. —

pvs.TDO n.s. n.s. — 0.0289 0.0172 n.s. — —

Withageadjustmentthevalueofdetrusorcontractility intheTDOgroupbecameclosertothevalueobservedinthe obstructedgroup.InbothDOgroups,detrusorcontractility ishigherthaninthegroupwithnormalUD.

Discussion

Thefirstnomogramstoevaluatedetrusorcontractilityand urethralobstructionhavebeenrecentlyproposed[4]tofol- lowwomen atrisk ofobstruction over time.Inthisstudy, these nomograms (and the associated software obtained fromalgebraicfittingoftheirequations)areappliedtotwo differentpopulations,onewithoutsymptomsofobstruction butwithlowerurinarytractsymptoms,andtheotherwith provenBOO(obstruction aftersling placement,stage3—4 cystocele,meatalstrictureordistalurethralfibrosis).Toour knowledge,thereisnocomparisonofdetrusorcontractility betweensuchpopulations.

Thefirstissuewastotestthenomogramsvs.themodeled analysisofthewholerecordingsduringPFs.

An interesting finding is that nomograms, which imply attentiontothepointofQmax,andmodeledanalysisofthe whole curves of flow and detrusor pressure, give a good agreementbetweenvalueofdetrusorcontractilityandure- thralobstruction.

Nomograms allow no-consuming time evaluation de detrusorcontractility; fittingequations [4]arerecalledin AppendixA,theExcel® associatedsoftwareisavailableon request.Sotheeasetouseandusefulnessofthealgebraic fittingofnomogramsaredemonstrated.

Some conditions are supposed: negligible abdominal straining and standard nervous excitations (detrusor and

Table3 Ageadjustedvalueofthemechanicalparam- eters (<kadj> and <Uadj>) for the groups whose age differedsignificantlyfromthemeanage(58.5y)ofnon- obstructedandobstructedpopulations.

PDO TDO ISD IHUP

<kadj> .52 .59 .47 .47

<Uadj> 17.6 24.6 13.2 11.2

Inthenon-obstructedgroupvs. obstructedgroup,references values are respectively 0.48 and 0.68 for k, and 15.6 and 28.5cmH2OforU.

sphincter) until the flow reaches Qmax. In this study, the firstcondition isfulfilled,thesecond oneis moredifficult toassertbutcanbeassumedsatisfiedinabsenceofbreak intheascendinglimboftheflowcurve.

ThesecondissuewastoevaluatetheimpactofBOOon detrusorcontractility.Are BOOandageingconcomitant or concurrent?

The consequence of BOOis an increaseddetrusorcon- tractilitytocompensatefortheurethralobstruction.

Whateverthe obstructive status,detrusor contractility remainsconstantuntilmenopauseageandthendecreases rapidly. An interesting finding is that the curves k(age) andU(age)fornon-obstructedandobstructedpopulations areroughly translated. There is also a strong correlation betweenkandU,whichimpliesanadjustmentofthedetru- sorcontractilitytothe‘‘urethralresistance’’.

Thethirdissuewastoseparatetheeffectofageingfrom thespecific effectofsome LUTD.Thechangesin detrusor contractility have led us to bring a great interest to the effectofDOandBOOonthismechanicalparameter.

Detrusorcontractilityisgreaterinwomenwithdetrusor overactivitycomparedwithotherclinicalconditions.Similar observationshavebeenreportedbyCucchi[10]inmenwith

‘‘unstablebladder’’,withandwithoutBOOandbyCucchi etal.[11] in women.Pfisterer etal. [12]studied women withorwithoutDOandfoundsameresults.

For PDO, the specific effect of DO is weak compared to that observed in the TDO population, (older than the PDO one). An interesting finding is that with the ‘‘age- adjustment’’, the value of the detrusor contractility of unobstructedwomen withTDO becomescloser tothat of women with BOO. In the PDO population, younger than thewholepopulation,‘‘age-adjustment’’keepsavalueof the detrusorcontractility higher than the value observed in all the other urodynamic diagnosis groups. So, DO has the same consequence on detrusorcontractility than BOO.

In thesub-groupsISD and IHUP, theeffectof ageing is preponderant;age-adjustmentgives valuescloseto those ofwomenwithnormalUD.

Thestudyhaslimitations,itisaretrospectivestudyandit impliessomeconditionsonabdominalstrainingandnervous excitationsuntilthetimeofQmax.

Toourknowledge,thisstudyisthefirstquantitativeeval- uationusingnomogramsoftheeffectofBOOandageingon thedetrusorcontractilityandforthefirsttimeanattempt tonormalizetheeffectofageing.

(6)

Conclusion

Algebraic fitting of nomograms allows a quick evaluation detrusorcontractility(k)andurethralobstruction(U)from thepointof Qmaxin PFs.Thesetwoparametersareeasily computedfromsimplesoftwareinExcel®.Astrongcorrela- tionwasnotedbetweendetrusorcontractilityandurethral obstruction consistent withan adaptive process whatever thestatusofurethralobstruction.

Afterageadjustment,DO(phasicorterminal)appearsto producehigherdetrusorcontractility andtheeffectofDO looksliketheeffectofBOOofthedetrusor.

Author’s contributions

F.A. Valentini: project development, manuscript writ- ing/editing,datacollection,computations.

B.G. Marti: project development, manuscript writ- ing/editing.

P.P.Nelson:projectdevelopment,manuscriptwriting,com- putations.

P.E. Zimmern: project development, manuscript editing, datacollection.

G.Robain:datacollection.

Disclosure of interest

Theauthorsdeclarethattheyhavenocompetinginterest.

Appendix A. Supplementary data

Supplementary data associated with this arti- cle can be found, in the online version, at doi:10.1016/j.purol.2016.06.010.Theexcelsoftwarecanbe obtainedonrequesttotheaddressfavalentini@gmail.com

References

[1]Valentini FA, Besson GR, Nelson PP, Zimmern PE. A mathe- matical micturitionmodelto restoresimple flow recordings inhealthyandsymptomaticindividualsand enhanceuroflow interpretation.NeurourolUrodyn2001;19:153—76.

[2]Valentini FA, Besson GR, Nelson PP, Zimmern PE. Clinically relevantmodellingofurodynamicfunction:the VBNmodel.

NeurourolUrodyn2014;33:361—6,http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/

nau.22409.

[3]Valentini FA, Nelson PP, Zimmern PE, Robain G. Detrusor contractility in women: influence of ageing and clini- cal conditions. Prog Urol 2016, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/

j.purol.2016.03.004[Inpress].

[4]Valentini FA, Nelson PP, Zimmern PE. VBN-Based nomo- grams provide critical voiding parameters which can be used for invasive or non-invasive flow interpreta- tion of women at risk of obstruction over time; 2015, http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/nau.22893 [NAU Published online inWileyOnlineLibrary(wileyonlinelibrary.com)].

[5]Schäfer W, Abrams P, Liao L, MattiassonA, Pesce F, Span- berg A, et al. Good urodynamic practices: uroflowmetry, fillingcystometry,andpressure-flowstudies.NeurourolUrodyn 2002;21:261—74.

[6]StandardizationICSAbramsP,Cardozo L, FallM,GriffithsD, RosierP,UlmstenU,etal.Thestandardisationofterminology oflowerurinarytractfunction:reportfromthestandardisa- tionsub-committeeoftheInternational ContinenceSociety.

NeurourolUrodyn2002;21:167—78.

[7]Haab F, Amarenco G, Coloby P, Grise P, Jacquetin B, Labat J-J, et al. Terminologie des troubles fonctionnels du bas appareil urinaire : adaptation franc¸aise de la ter- minologie de l’International Continence Society. Prog Urol 2004;14:1103—11.

[8]HaylenBT, de Ridder D,Freeman RM,Swift SE, Berghmans B, Lee J, et al. An International Urogynecological Asso- ciation (IUGA)/International Continence Society (ICS) joint reportontheterminologyforfemalepelvicfloordysfunction.

Int Urogynecol J 2010;21:5—26, http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/

s00192-009-0976-9.

[9]BlandJM,AltmanDG.Statisticalmethodsforassessingagree- mentbetweentwomethodsofclinicalmeasurement.Lancet 1986;1(8476):307—10.

[10]CucchiA. Differentvoiding dynamicsin stableand unstable bladderswithandwithoutoutletobstruction.NeurourolUro- dyn1998;17:473—81.

[11]CucchiA,SiracusanoS,GuarnaschelliC,RoveretoB.Voiding urgencyand detrusorcontractilityinwomenwithoveractive bladders.NeurourolUrodyn2003;22:223—6.

[12]PfistererMH-D, Griffiths DJ, Rosenberg L, Schaefer W. The impactofdetrusoroveractivityonbladderfunctioninyounger and older women. J Urol 2006;175:1777—83, http://dx.

doi.org/10.1016/S0022-5347(05)00985-7.

Références

Documents relatifs

This paper firstly reminds the Model of Manufactured Part (the MMP) [1, 11, 12] ; a method for modeling the different geometrical deviation impacts on the part produced (error

The study of welding processes currently appears as an area of research both open and complex because it requires to share of knowledge in different fields of physics

The study of welding processes currently appears as an area of research both open and complex because it requires to share of knowledge in different fields of physics

In the paper, we investigated the different data embedding methods that are usually used in JPEG semi-fragile watermarking systems such as LSB and various QIM

In order to visualize the development of the ozone plume over semi-urban region at south of Grenoble (e.g. Vif) we present the simulated time evolution of ozone in a south to

In this strategy, a rendezvous is important both for data exchange and neighbor discovery: two nodes can communicate if they have a channel in common. The number of channel switches

Three state-of-the-art methods were compared: LDLA (linkage disequilibrium and linkage analysis), a method that considers haplotypes clustered by approximate

ُكوبسيفلاُداور تنلاُربعُدوجولاُةسراممو ُ م داور فادهأ فلتخت او اوتلا عق ص ءاضفلا اذه ربع كوبسيفلا يعامتجلاا ل ؛ ىري نم مهنمف هيف ةليسو م يف ،تقولا