Fracture of complex metallic alloys: An atomistic study of model systems

Texte intégral

(1)Fracture of complex metallic alloys: An atomistic study of model systems Frohmut Rösch, Hans-Rainer Trebin, Peter Gumbsch. To cite this version: Frohmut Rösch, Hans-Rainer Trebin, Peter Gumbsch. Fracture of complex metallic alloys: An atomistic study of model systems. Philosophical Magazine, Taylor & Francis, 2006, 86 (06-08), pp.10151020. �10.1080/14786430500256326�. �hal-00513575�. HAL Id: hal-00513575 https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00513575 Submitted on 1 Sep 2010. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés..

(2) Philosophical Magazine & Philosophical Magazine Letters. rP Fo Journal:. rR. ee. Fracture of complex metallic alloys: An atomistic study of model systems. Philosophical Magazine & Philosophical Magazine Letters. Manuscript ID:. TPHM-05-May-0182.R2. Journal Selection:. Philosophical Magazine. quasicrystals, molecular dynamics, fracture complex metallic alloys. ly. On. Keywords (user supplied):. w. Keywords:. Rösch, Frohmut; Universität Stuttgart, Institut für Theoretische und Angewandte Physik Trebin, Hans-Rainer; Universität Stuttgart, Institut für Theoretische und Angewandte Physik Gumbsch, Peter; Fraunhofer, Institut für Werkstoffmechanik. ie. Complete List of Authors:. 24-Jun-2005. ev. Date Submitted by the Author:. http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/pm-pml.

(3) Page 1 of 23.

(4)

(5)

(6) "!#%$ &(' % # )*# ) ,+-!./0-+1

(7) 23#4!#

(8) 20# 5 687:9;3< =?>A7C@ BEDF9HG:IJLK1G:IBNM>1GPOQIRS6-TU6ERWVOXI Y[Z \]^_]` ]a8`4b cedef4gFhicgF]^j\kEf4g?` Z lnmoZ4pigFqriZ l4]gsUfutC\^_v w)xoZ ^_yigFcE\^_]zr{b ]}|:]`4]]p~r{cN]Fw saQrWgZPqrijl cN^jZ4p~ Pw W~i{n|:]`4]]p~r{c]FwogFcNriZPt. Fo. U Rz=RS6 <;3V B8DF9 YZ\]^_]`4]aE`4b c}`4yigFcErib \\^_pivig^j]yih~Zri`4]g^j_gZ`Z l|:tC\]ggZw x}Z ^jyigFcN\^_]zr{b ]?r{cEj\cN` f giwCri^j\gFcN\]cz:w {CC1r{cNj\cN`f4giw4gFcNriZPt 4cEri` Z f4hiaQgFcY[Z \]^_]`4]aE`4b c/gFcvC\]h{gkNfriZ ^_v w h~b f _gFcE\]ci{w { CF~¡A4cg^_¢)`4cp4wogFcNriZPt £:<I R3¤C¤¥¤:¦C¦4§. ee. rP. ?¨ ©ªE«N¬F~®« ¯°z±³²E´µu±³¶z·U¸i¹{ºu¶z»o¼½Ń¾U¾¼³»eµu±³¶¿À¼³°zºu¾U°ÁÂŃ·¶S´[ÃÄ~·°zÄu¶zÅS¶¿À¼³°zº¶·²eÄ:²N·ÀÁj°z·»²E¸ Áj°z·U¿ÇÆ°?²È{¿À·²N»² É¶z¾À²E¾}°Á´°z»Ä~±³²Èn»²¿[¶±³±É¼½´,¶±³±É°F¹i¾1ÊQË¯ÌU¾ÍÎ1ÏÐº¶Ñ»°i¸i²E±"ÒWµu¶S¾¼½´·¹i¾Ç¿[¶±2¿ÀÓ~²,¾¿À·µu´¿µ~·À² ¼½¾o¸~²Ô ¿²N·»¼Éº~²8¸ÑÕ{¹Ń±Éµu¾¿À²E·¾U°Á"¶F¿°z»-¾NÖCÆ×Ó~²E·À²8¶z¾¿ÀÓ~²»°i¸i²N±2ËUØÙ?Ú)¶Ûz²E¾UÄ~Óu¶S¾²}¼³¾¶1¾¼³»Ä~±³²oÄ:²N·¼³°{¸~¼³´ ¾¿¶S´[Ã{¼Éº~Å-°zÁ¶µ~º~¼É¿´²E±É±QÜ×Ý"Ó~²e¾À¼É»}µ~±½¶F¿À¼³°zºP¾×·À²EÛz²8¶±4¿Óu¶F¿%¿Ó~²Õu¶S¾¼½´Õ~µu¼É±½¸i¼³º~Å?µ~º~¼É¿¾°Á¿ÀÓu²e¾Ç¿·ÀµP´Ô ¿µ~·²E¾¶z±³¾À°-Åz°FÛS²N·º¿Ó~²N¼³·%Áj·[¶z´¿Àµ~·²Õ:²NÓu¶Û{¼³°zµ~·8Ü"Ì¿À°z»-¾¼Éº,¿Ó~²}Ú)¶Ûz²E¾%Ä~Óu¶z¾À²Ä~±½¶¹ ¶-Ń°z»Äu¶z·¶zÕ~±É² ·°z±³²U¿À°}¿ÀÓ~²´±³µu¾¿À²E·¾¼³º¿Ó~²ÒSµP¶z¾À¼³Ń·À¹i¾¿¶±QÜÌ%±É¿ÀÓ~°Sµ~ÅzÓ1¿ÀÓ~²±½¶F¿À¿À²N·×¶z·À²Uº~°¿×·¼ÉÅS¼³¸µ~º~¼É¿¾EÖ{¿ÀÓ~²E¹?Óu¶Ûz² ¿°-ÕP²·²NÅW¶·[¸i²E¸1¶z¾"¾À¼ÉÅSº~¼ßÞ:Ń¶ºW¿×Ä~Ó{¹i¾¼½Ń¶z±4²NºW¿À¼É¿À¼³²E¾EÜ à. iew. ev. rR. á âã äå?æç,èãéå}â. ê h~ë)_gìígF]rijî^jkAriî_hztC\,r{cg^jZP]gFcNgF]rijj^îkÑkh~ëh~` Z l\1q}^_]fíîr{cpign` Z ^_],kgjj\,kh~ZP]ri^jZ ^jZ4pïaQch~ ]gZ \o`4ë]hA]f4h~` \riZl \hia%r{]h~\oðoaQ]gZw)l ^î\]^jZ k]ejh:kFri2r{ccNriZ4piggZP]\}hia%r{]h~\eñ3kFj` \]gFcN\ñkFriZ ¢geyC^_gFqglAri\¢` ^îjl ^jZ4p-` Z^_]\F"Uhi]fw:]f gokFj`\]gFcl^jrigF]gFcriZ lÑ]f gojr{]]^îkgokh~Z \]riZu]^jë)_t_gZ4pi]f \kFri_g\q}f ^jkNfò\f4h~`jl¢gocgFó gk]gln^jZòëfPt:\N^jkFriëchiëgFc]^_g\F êô m}\aQcgõ:`4gZu]jtkh~¢^îZ4g-^jZu]gFcNg\]^jZ4p ë chiëgFc]^jg\j^_vigf ^_p~fög_]^jZ4p/ëh~^jZP]FwUf ^jp~fö]gëgFcNr{]`4cg\]cgZ4pi]fwriZ l÷jhzqøl4gZ\^_]tiúùehSqUgFyigFczw ëh~\\^_¢)_ger{ë ëî^jkFr{]^_h~Z \r{cgohiaX]gZnj^î^_]gl¢:tÑgìC]cgg¢ cE^_]]_gZ4g\\r{]_hzqûhicri1¢^_gZP]]gë gFcEr{]`4cgi d2hÑgZ j^jp~fu]gZ]f4g?ch~_ghia%kFj` \]gFcN\}riZ lëgFcN^jh:l ^îkF^_]tÑ^îZaQcNrik]`4cgiw)qUg1ë gFcNaXhicNøh~_gkF` jr{c}l4t:Zri^jkF\ \^j ` jr{]^jh~Z \,hia}]ÀqUhígì:]cNggkFri\g\Ñhia êô mo\FümoZ÷^jkh~\Nrif4gl4cNriõ:` ri\^îkct:\]ririZ l÷r ê LýÂrzyig\ ëf ri\gi(mo\òqUg/r{cg^jZP]gFcg\]glû^jZþ]f4gïpigZ4gFcNri-õ:` rij^_]r{]^_yigaXgr{]` cg\3hia?]f4g/\]cN`k]`4cg\Fwqg` \g ]f4cgFgÿl^jgZ \^jh~Z rihCl4g \tC\]g\kh~Z \^j\]^jZ4phiar{¢h~`4] yigo^îjj^_h~Zr{]h~Ñ\riZ l3h:l gëhi]gZP]^jrij\ ýgZZ r{cNlCÿ ~h~Z4g\ E2def ^j\l4gî^_¢gFcNr{]g×kNf4h~^jkg^jZ-]f4gëri\]hiaQ]gZf4gjë gl]h}cgFyigriPaQ` Zl rigZP]ri~ri\ëgk]\ hiaaQcNrik]`4cg \gFgAgi p4"m}¢ cNrif ri {i~ Edef4gÑõ:` ri\^jkctC\]riUkFriZL¢gyC^_gFqglíri\ r êô m qe^_]fíriZ ^j Z )Z ^_]g_tjr{cpig` Z ^_]2kgjÐwi\` kEf]f r{]×Z4h}ëgFcN^_hCl ^jkF^_]Àt^î\Âë cNg\gZu]riZ l,kFj` \]gFcE\2r{cg]f4gri^jZ1aXgr{]` cgUhia ]f4g\]cN`k]`4cgiðZ ]f4ghi]f4gFc%f riZlwi]f4g ê ýÂrzyig\%ëfri\gfri\% r{]h~\%^jZ ]f4gkF`4¢)^jkU`Z ^_]"kgj4riZ l Z4h,kFj` \]gFcE\F×df4g\]cN` k]`4cNg}hia]f gý2ryig\ëfri\g\^j\Ul gF]gFcN^jZ4glA¢:tëgFcN^_hCl ^jkF^_]Àt ¢)`4]rijcgril4tÑõ:` ^_]g kh~ëjgì w\N` kNf ]f r{]kh~ëî^jkFr{]glHl4gFaXhicEr{]^_h~ZHgkNfriZ ^j\\,^jp~fu] ggFcpig \gFgngi p4 ê f^j\f4h~j gF]eriÐ {i~ E. ly. On. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60. Philosophical Magazine & Philosophical Magazine Letters. http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/pm-pml.

(9) Philosophical Magazine & Philosophical Magazine Letters.

(10). å?æâ,æ"ã,å?æ. df4g,]f4cNgFgÿl ^jgZ \N^_h~Z rih:l gõ:` ri\^îkct:\]ri`\gl/^jZïh~`4c?Z:` gFcN^jkFrigìCëgFcN^jgZP]\f ri\¢gFgZë ch{ÿ ëh~\gl¢Ptù}gZ _gFtriZ lj\gFc i¡iri\r3\]cN` k]` cg1hCl4g2aXhic-^jkh~\Nrif4gl4cNri moÐwÉZ ô p"!W-YÀ]^j\ ¢` ^î_]?`4ë aQch~ ]f4gÑë cNh~jr{]gAriZ lLhi¢jr{]gAcNf4h~1¢ h~f gl4cNrnhia]f4gA]f4cgFgÿl ^îgZ \^_h~Zri×s2gZ ch~\gò]^jj^jZ4p4 mo\qgl4hÑZ4hi]ol ^j\]^îZ4p~` ^j\fA¢gF]qgFgZmoÂriZ lïZn]t:ëgr{]h~\Fw qg?]gFcNø^j]\el4gkhicNr{]^jh~Z^jkh~\rif gl4cNri ¢^jZr{cthCl4g aQhicl4gF]ri^jî\-\gFggi p4$ # h~b \kNf gF]riÐ {i~ E3YZ]f g`4ëkh~^jZ4% p p~`4cNg\]f4gÑmo%riZ l Zï]t:ëgr{]h~\ mr{]h~&\ or{cgl ^j\ëîrtiglri\picgFt h~Zj^jZ4giücNgl ¢)rijj\Fw qef4gFcgri\ ô p3]t:ëg,r{]h~Ñ\ r{]h~Ñ\ r{cNg1\f4hSqeZ^îZ¢jrikNv h~Z j^jZ giü¢j` 'g Edf4g\f hic]g\]l ^j\]riZ kg¢ gF]ÀqUgFgZï]ÀqUh3mr{]h~\^j\ l4gZ4hi]g) l (+*Ñqef ^jkEfLkhiccg\ë h~Zl \?]hr{¢h~`4] :ß m, Y[Z f4gFcgZP]1^jZL]f4gA\]cN` k]`4cgòr{cg3UgFcNp~riZCÿÇ]t:ëg kFj` \]gFcN\Fw4qef ^îkNfnrij\hkFriZ¢g-y:^_gFqglri\¢)ri\^jk¢` ^îjl ^jZ4p ` Z ^_]\ mo\-Z4hncgj^îr{¢_/ g .[cNgrij^j\]^j1k 0òggk]^_yigëhi]gZP]^jrij\-r{cgrzyWri^jîr{¢_g aXhic?]f g aQcNrik]`4cNghia êô m}\w]f4g ^jZP]gFcNrik]^_h~Z \1r{cgAh:l4gî_gl¢Pt/\^îë_gýÂgZ Z r{cNlCÿ ~h~Z4g\-ëri^jc?ëhi]gZu]^jriî\ \gFgn|:gk{U{2w #1h~b \kEfLgF] riÐ {i3 4EwPriZ5 l # h~b \kNf,gF]"riÐ {i~ Edf4g\gUëhi]gZu]^jriî\ÂvigFgFë]f4ghCl4g:\]r{¢_gUgFyigZ` Z l4gFc\]ch~Z4pl4gÿ aQhicNr{]^_h~Z \%hic^jZP]ch:l` k]^_h~Z hia)ëh~^jZP]×l4gFaQgk]\riZ lfryig¢gFgZ` \gl^jZ,h~`4c%pich~` ë]hipigF]f4gFcUq}^_]f,]f4g ^jkh~\rif gl4cNriC¢^jZr{ct1hCl4gC]h\N^j1`jr{]gl ^j\_hCkFr{]^_h~Z,hi]^_h~Z |CkNf rir{agF]riÇ {i~ %riZ lgFyigZÑ\f4hCkv qryig\ #hi]f {i~ E7 6×gFct\^j^îjr{cëhi]gZu]^îrij\ef rzyig \Nf4hzqeZ]hò\]r{¢^jj9^ 8Fg-]f g1^jkh~\rif gl4cNriÂr{]h~Ñ^jk \]cN`k]`4cg #hi]fgF]eriÐ i i EtA]f4g1kNf4h~^jkghia2]f4g\ghCl4gëhi]gZu]^jriî\riZ lhCl4g\]cN`k]`4cg\ qgeõP`rij^_]r{]^_yig_t1ë chi¢g]f4g^jZ4ó)`4gZ kghia\]cN` k]`4cNri4ri\ë gk]\%hia)]f4g}^jZuyig\]^_p~r{]glkh~ëh~` Z l\"qe^_]fCÿ h~`4]¢g^jZ4p3\ëgkF9^ k1]hr3\ëgkF^jriv:^jZlhiar{]gFcN^jriÐ ô hCl4gëhi]gZu]^îrij\-r{cg,hiaX]gZL` \gl^jZïaXcErik]`4cg \^j ` jr{]^jh~Z \-riZ l/f rzyigA_gl/]h` \gFa ` ×^jZ \^jp~fu]-^jZP]ha ` Z l rigZP]ri×gkEf riZ ^j\Ñ\ \gFgÑgi p4me¢cNrif ri {i~ ELdf gA^jZ^j1`hia]f4g3ýgZ Zr{cNlCÿ ih~Z g\ëhi]gZP]^jriaQhic,]f4g3^jZu]gFcErik]^_h~Z \ ¢gF]qgFgZ r{]h~Ñ\ hial ^½gFcgZu]vC^jZ lï^j\-\gF]-]hn]Àqe^jkg]f4gy{rij`4g,hia]f r{]-aXhic?r{]h~Ñ\-hiaU]f g\rig]t:ëgi ù}hzqgFyigFcw]f4g kh~Z kFj`\^_h~Z \l4cNrzqeZïaXcNh~ h~`4c?\^j ` jr{]^_h~Z\ecgÑri^jZg\\gZP]^jrij_t` Z rWgk]gl/¢Ptï\gF]]^jZ4priî2¢)^jZ l ^jZ p gZ4gFcp~^jg\gõP`riÐw4qef ^jkEfnr{p~ri^jZ^îZ l ^jkFr{]g\]f r{]eqUgr{cNgri^jZ jtë chi¢^îZ4p\]cN` k]`4cErig gk]\F m aQ`Z l rigZP]ri¢` ^îjl ^jZ4p1` Z ^_]hia]f4g\^j ` jr{]glnõ:` ri\^îkct:\]ri)ñÑ]f4g?ë ch~îr{]g-cNf4h~1¢ h~f gl4ch~ZAñ ^jZrn\j^jp~fu]_tl4gFaXhicEglïqrztïaQhicN\]f g,kF` ¢^jk ê òýÂrzyig\?ëf ri\g,7m :F ¢PtëgFcN^_hCl ^jkr{cNcNriZ4piggZP]F `4]^jZ]f^j\}\]cN` k]`4cg,Z4h3kFj` \]gFcE\ehia%]f g,õ:` ri\^îkct:\]ri2r{cg ë cg\gZu]F-gkFri` \ghia%]f g,kFjh~\g \]cN` k8ÿ ]`4cNriÂcgjr{]^_h~Z\f ^_ëhia×]f g ê AýÂrzyig\}ë)f ri\g]hA]f4g,õP` ri\N^jkctC\]riÂhCl4gÐwqUg,` \g?]f g \rig1hCl4g ëhi]gZu]^îrij\F ð` c\Nrië_g\f rzyigÑl ^jgZ\^_h~Z \ehiar{ë ëchì4^jr{]g_; t u{3 ( *=< {3 ( *=< W3 ( * riZ l/kh~ZP]ri^jZ/r{¢h~`4] yig/^jîj^_h~Z÷r{]h~\ sgFcN^_hCl ^jk¢ h~`Z l r{ct÷kh~Z l^_]^_h~Z \òr{cg/r{ë ëj^jglþ^jZþ]f4g/l ^_cNgk]^_h~Z ë)r{cNrij_g}]h ]f4gkcNrikNvíaQch~ZP]F d2h \^j ` jr{]gnhCl4g3YaQcNrik]`4cNgiwq> g cN\]l4gF]gFcNÑ^jZ4gòë h~\N\^_¢_gòkF_gry{r{pigë)jriZ4g\F mokFkhicNl ^jZ4pL]hHocN@^ ?]f iC+ AkcNrikvöë cNhiër{p~r{]^_h~Z÷¢gkh~g\Aëh~\\^_¢)_giw%qef4gZ÷]f4ggjri\]^jkngZ4gFcpit ^j\,\ ` ?AkF^_gZu]1]h/pigZ4gFcNr{]gn]ÀqUh Z4gFq aQcNrik]`4cgn\`4cNaQrikg\F defP` \w%kF`4]\,r{],f g^_p~fu]\,q}^_]fíjhzq \`4ca rikg gZ4gFcp~^jg\ò\Nf4h~` jl ¢ gï]f4gh~\]nj^_vigjtHkFjgry{r{pig ëjriZ4g\ Y[Z ]f gõ:` ri\^îkct:\]ri}\`kNfû\`4ca rikg\3r{cg \ëgkF9^ kÑ]qhiaXh~îl riZA l yigFaQh~jlíëjriZ4g\ \gF> g #1h~b \NkNf gF]riÐ {i~ ELdef4gFcg3r{]h~^jkFrij_t \Nf r{cëH\gFgl kcNrikNv:\}r{cg^jZ \gFc]gl%df4g-\rië_g\r{cg?`Z ^jrWì4^jrij_t\]cEri^jZ4glnëgFcëgZ l ^îkF` jr{c]hÑ]f4g?kcNrikvnë)jriZ4g-`4ë ]h3]f4gÑocN9^ ?Ñ]fïjh~rilïriZl]f gZcgjrWìCgl]hnhi¢]ri^jZï]f4gl ^j\ëîrikggZu7] gjlhia]f g,\]r{¢_g,kcNrikvr{] 8FgFchA]gëgFcNr{]`4cgi}|C` ¢\gõ:`4gZu]jtiw r]gëgFcNr{]`4cNghia×r{¢h~`4]1FC BED?hia×]f g1g_]^îZ4p]gëgFcNr{]`4cg ^j\ r{ë ëî^_gl2def4ge\rië)_g^j\%a `4c]f gFc_h~ril4gl¢:tj^jZ gr{c%\kFrij^jZ4phia ]f g}khiccg\ë h~Zl ^jZ4p-l ^_ë)jrikggZPF] gjl aQhico]f^j\e]gë gFcEr{]`4cgi?df4g1cg\ëh~Z \g hia%]f4g\tC\]g ]f4gZ^j\oh~Z ^_]hicNgl¢:th~jgkF` jr{cl4t:Zri^jkF\ ]gkNfZ ^jõ:`4g\F*df4gïcNril ^îr{]^_h~Zúg^_]]glú¢Ptþ]f4gïë chiër{p~r{]^jZ pHkcErikvû^j\Alriëglúrzqrztþh~` ]\^jl4griZ gjj^jë ]^jkFri\]ril ^j` ]hë cgFyigZP]cgFó gk]^jh~Z \ \gFG g # h~b \kNfgF]eriÐ {i~ eriZ l`¢\NkNfngF]eriÇ i ~H E. iew. ev. rR. ee. rP. Fo. ly. On. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60. http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/pm-pml. Page 2 of 23.

(11) Page 3 of 23. I. JK çãLMâ,æ æé" è%ç=éåoâ. Y[Z,]f4ghCl4gCõP` ri\N^jkctC\]riCqUg^îZuyig\]^jp~r{]glf4hzqþkFj` \]gFcN\×riZl,]f4gëjriZ4g\]cN`k]`4cg^jZ4ó)`4gZ kgkcNrikv ë chië)r{p~r{]^_h~Zm ër{ëgFc?h~Zí]f ^j\?l gF]ri^j_glL\]` l4t/f ri\1cgkgZu]jt/¢ gFgZLë`4¢î^j\f4gl \gFN g #1h~b \kEfígF] riÐ {i~ Ewqef4gFcg ¢ cN^_]]jgaQcNrik]`4cg,qe^_]f h~`4]oriZPtkcErikvï]^_ëëjri\]^jkF^j]tqri\cgFëhic]gl?df g1aQh~j_hSqe^jZ4p cg\`_]\aXcNh~]f r{]?ër{ëgFc?^jZl ^jkFr{]g]f r{]?]f gkFj` \]gFcN\l4gF]gFcN^jZ g ]f g¢ cN^_]]jg,kFjgry{r{pigÑaQcNrik]`4cghia ]f4geh:l4g4õ:` ri\^îkct:\]riÐü2"^_cN\]FwukF^_cNkF` 1yigZP]^_h~Zhic^îZu]gFcN\gk]^_h~ZhiakFj` \]gFcE\%\_hSqe\%l4hSqeZ]f4gekcErikvC\F |:gkh~Z lw]f gAaQcNrik]`4cg3\`4cNaQrikg\ \f4hSq kEf r{cNrik]gFcN^î\]^jkòf4g^_p~fP]1y{r{cN^jr{]^_h~Z\p~^_yC^jZ4pcN^j\gA]hïriZ hzyigFcErij ch~`4p~fZ4g\\%h~ZÑ]f4g}kFî` \]gFcU\NkFri_g \gFg"^_p4){wC_gFaQ] E%ýÂ^jZ g\%ri_h~Z4p1qef ^jkEf]f4gekFî` \]gFcN\Ur{cgojh:kFr{]glòr{cg rij\hòyC^j\^_¢jg^jZ]f4g f g^_p~fu]ë cNHh _g\Fdf ^_cElw ]f4gkcNrikNv^jZP]gFcN\gk]\-_g\N\okFî` \]gFcN\}]f riZròëjriZ r{ckF`4] qe^_]fnjhzq \` caQrikggZ4gFcNpit3l hPg\ \gFg1^jp4) EmoZ4hi]f4gFchi¢\gFcyWr{]^jh~Znhia2]f g?\^j ` jr{]^_h~Z \^j\]fr{]]f4g ëjriZ go\]cE` k]`4cgrij\h^jZ4ó)`4gZ kg\UaXcNrik]` cgi ê cNrikNv:\jh:kFr{]gl3ëgFcëgZ l ^îkF` jr{c%]h,]qhiaQh~jlnriZ % l yigFaQh~jl rWìCg\ó` k]` r{]gr{¢h~`4]r/kh~Z\]riZu]Af4g^_p~fP]F df:` \Fw]f4gnch~`4p~f Z g\\,hiae]f4gkcErikvö\`4ca rikg\kFriZö¢g ri\\^jp~Z4gln]h]f4g1kFj` \]gFcN\w4qef4gFcgri\kh~Z\]riZu]oryigFcNr{pig,f4g^_p~fP]\hia"]f4g?aQcNrik]`4cNg?\`4ca rikg\cgFógk]]f4g ëjriZ g\]cN` k]`4cg-hia"]f4g?õ:` ri\^îkct:\]riÐ O}hzqqgkh~ër{cg\^j ` jr{]^jh~Zcg\`_]\ehia]f4gõP` ri\N^jkctC\]riÂ]h3]f4h~\g hia]f4g ê Ñý2ryig\-ë)f ri\gi 4hic-]f ^î\}\]cE` k]`4cg qUgrij\hAhi¢\gFcyig,¢ cN^_]]_g1aQri^îj`4cgi`4]}]f g aQcNrik]`4cNg \` caQrikg\r{]-_hSq(jh~ril \eñ^ja r{]erij)ñòh~Z _t3r{cg-ch~`4p~fnh~ZriZr{]h~^jk\kFri_gidf^j\¢ gkh~g\er{ë ër{cNgZu]aQch~ "^_p~\F2?riZ l: Y[ZA"^_p4C-h~Z jtr{]h~\Z4gr{cr ii+ aXcNrik]` cg}\` caQrikgr{cgol ^j\ëîrtigl"df4go\gFglAkcErikvA\Nf4hzqeZÑh~Z ]f4go]hiënë chiër{p~r{]gl3^j Z P 4 Q3 QS Rl ^_cNgk]^_h~Z×df4gor{]gFcN^jri ëgFcaQgk]_tkF_gryigl ^jp4C:w4¢hi]]h~T EwCqef ^îkNf cg\`_]gln^jZn\h:hi]fnaQcNrik]`4cg1\`4ca rikg\F Y[Zû^jp4\gk]^jh~Z \3hiapigFh~gF]cE^jkFrij_t \NkFriZ Z4glúaXcErik]`4cg/\`4ca rikg\3hia?]f4g/^jkh~\Nrif4gl4cNrihCl4g õ:` ri\^jkctC\]ri _gFaX] riZ l÷hia-]f g ê Lh:l geýÂrzyig\òëf ri\g Ñ^jl l _giwcN^_p~fP] ,r{cgkh~ër{cNgl df4g kF_grzyWr{pig1ëjriZ4g\r{cNg?_h:kFr{]glëgFcëgZ l ^jkF` îr{c]hÑr]ÀqUhiaQh~jl jgFaX] riZlU r P 4F RrWì4^j\ ^îl l _giwCcN^_p~fP] E df4gkcNrikvë chiër{p~r{]gl,ri_h~Z4por]ÀqUhiaQh~jl _gFaQ] riZ l 5 r P½F4& R rWì4^j\ Ñ^jl l _giwScN^_p~fP] Edef4gkh~_h~`4c"khCl ^jZ4p ^jZ3]f4g?jgFaX]^jÑr{pig?^j\ri l V` \]gln]h]f4g1kFj` \]gFcl ^îrigF]gFc h~Z j^îZ4giü"aXch~ ¢j`4go]hcgl E×ûf4gZkh~jh~`4c khCl4glî^_vig?]f4g õP` ri\N^jkctC\]riÐw]f gaQcNrik]`4cg,\`4ca rikg\hia]f4g ê AýÂrzyig\oëf ri\g jrikvriZPtch~`4p~fZ4g\\ ^jll _giw h~Z î^jZ4giüh~Z _tnpicgFgLZ Eom}aX]gFc-ri l V` \]^îZ4pÑ]f4g,kh~_h~`4ckhCl ^jZ4p4w r{]h~^jk chzq}\e¢gkh~g y:^î\^_¢_g cN^_p~fP] EU|:h4wCaQcNrik]`4cg\`4ca rikg\hiaÂ]f4gõ:` ri\^jkctC\]ri r{cgch~`4p~fAh~Zò]f4g-kFj` \]gFc\kFri_giwCqef4gFcNgri\U]f h~\g hia"]f4g?ýÂrzyig\eë)f ri\g-h~Z _tòr{cg?ch~` p~fnh~ZriZr{]h~Ñ^jk-\kFri_gi df:` \FwCr{]h~\^îZA]f gý2ryig\ë)f ri\goëjrtòr,kh~ër{cNr{¢jg}ch~jgo]h]f gkFî` \]gFcN\^jZA]f4g-õP`ri\^jkctC\]ri ñA]f4gFtnl4gF]gFcE^jZ4g]f4g?hSyigFcNrijÂch~`4p~f Z4g\N\hia]f g-aXcNrik]` cg\`4cNaQrikg\FUdf4g?r{]h~^j\]^jky:^jgFq hia×kF_gryPÿ r{pig3h~Zír 4i+ ëjriZ4gò^jZL"^_p4$ cNgFyigrij\,riZí^jZP]gFcg\]^îZ4pggkS] WzüYa]f4gA\gFglHkcNrikNvL]f4gFcNgÑqh~` jl ¢gAkh~ZP]^jZ:`4glw"]f4g3l ri\f4gl j^jZ4g\?qUh~` îl ]gFcN^îZ r{]gA]f gò`4ëë gFc1riZ líjhzqgFc,fri_yig\hiae]f4gò\Nrië_gi ù}hzqgFyigFcw%ri\kFriZL¢ gA\gFgZL^jZ]f gÑ]^jg\gõP`4gZkgÑhia"^_p4X 4w]f ^j\?^j\Z4hi]?]f4gòkFri\giü def4gl4tCZ ri^jk kcNrikNvL^jZ \]gril ]r{vig\ ; r 8^_p{Yÿ 8r{pj^_vigch~`4]gi> UZu]^_cNgÑr{]h~^jkÑchzqe\1ri_]gFcNZ r{]gjthzyig3`4ëPqr{cNl \1riZ l l4hSqeZuqr{cNl \df ^j\o_gril \o]hncNr{]f gFc?\t:ÑgF]cN^jk `4ë ëgFcriZ l_hzqgFc?aQcNrik]`4cg\`4cNaQrikg\Fw]f4gkcNgr{]^_h~Z hiaq}f ^jkNfrij\hòcNgõP` ^jcg\rnkh~ër{cNr{¢jg,rih~` Zu]hiagZ4gFcpiti,df ^j\}cNr{]f4gFc?\t:gF]cN^jkFri"kcgr{]^_h~Z/hia aQcNrik]`4cge\N`4ca rikg\^j\"a ryih~`4cNglwPgFyigZA]f4h~`4p~fÑr-ëjriZ r{cUkF`4]%qh~` jl_gril]h1\`4cNaQrikg\×q}^_]f_hSqUgFcU]hi]ri gZ4gFcpiti%defP` \wi]f4grik]` ri4aQcNrik]`4cgë)r{]fkFriZ Z4hi]%¢gë cgl^jk]gl,¢Pt r?\^jë_ggZ4gFcpit,kcN^_]gFcN^_h~Z×|C`kNf r,¢gf ryC^_h~`4crij\h qri\hi¢\gFcyigl^jZ3= O}^îm} \gFg-gi p4 -` ¢)\kNf {i4+ eriZ l3^j\rkh~Z \gõ:`4gZ kg-hia jr{]]^jkgo]cNr{ë ë)^jZ4p df h~\h~ZgF]riÐ ~ :+ Ew qef ^îkNf,ñ\^j^îjr{c%]h ]f4gosg^_gFcEj\%¢r{cNcN^_gFcaQhicl ^j\_hCkFr{]^_h~Z hi]^_h~Zñrij_hzq}\ehSyigFcN_h~ril \aQhicokcErikvC\]f r{]ol hòZ4hi]ocg\`_]}^jZkcNrikvë chiër{p~r{]^jh~Z}df g ^jZkcgri\gl _h~ril3aQhicerkcNrikNvA]hëchiër{p~r{]g-qe^jî]f4gFcNgFaXhicg?Z hi]Z4gkg\\r{cN^î_tA_gril3]haQcNrik]`4cNg?\`4ca rikg\hiajhzqg\] gZ4gFcpiti%def4gel ^j\NkcgF]gZ r{]`4cgehiaÑr{]]gFc^j\%cg\ëh~Z \^_¢)_gUaQhic]f g\gehi¢\gFcyWr{]^jh~Z \F×df4gaQcNrik]`4cgeër{]f. iew. ev. rR. ee. rP. Fo. ly. On. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60. Philosophical Magazine & Philosophical Magazine Letters. ZY[;\^]`_a]cbcd"egfHhji dk+]`lm'eX]`\Xl&f \^heYkShnpoqleXrYi hFleY]chstrud"rY]`l&sv\î'l"wXs7]csvxy]cz+{4|~}9_a]n'n'b`h&teY]`z&i1r{. http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/pm-pml.

(12) Philosophical Magazine & Philosophical Magazine Letters. ^j\-\]cNh~Z4p~_t^jZ4ó`4gZkgl¢:tï]f4gr{ccNriZ4piggZu]?hiar{]h~\1Z4gr{c?]f4gÑkcErikvaXcNh~Zu]Fw2qef ^jkEf/l4gFëgZ l \oh~Z ]f4g^îZ ^_]^jri kF_gry{r{pig ëjriZ4g-ri\qgjri\e]f4g?kcNrikvnëchiër{p~r{]^_h~ZAH ""+3 å}â,èEç= éNå}â=â,æ å}ç1ãNå?å . Y[Zkh~Z kFî` \^_h~Zw)]f4g,\^j ` jr{]^_h~Zcg\` _]\}hia%]f4g ]qh3gì:]cNgg kFri\g\hiahCl4g êô mo\}^îZ l ^jkFr{]g1]f r{] ]f4g¢)ri\^jk,¢` ^îjl ^jZ4pò` Z ^_]\hia]f4gÑ\]cN` k]`4cg\?pihzyigFcNZ rij\h]f g^_c-ëfPt:\^îkFri×ë chiëgFc]^_g\,def4gch~_ghia r{]h~\,^jZ/]f gAýÂrzyig\ ëf ri\gò^j\ñaXch~ rkgFc]ri^îZLëh~^jZP]?hiayC^_gFqñëjrtiglí¢:tï]f gAkFj` \]gFcN\^jZL]f4g õ:` ri\^jkctC\]riÐ%mo_]f4h~` p~f3]f4g\gr{cg1Z4hi]cN^_p~^jln`Z ^_]\FwC]f4gFt3r{cg\^jp~Z 9^ kFriZP]ëfutC\^jkFrigZP]^_]^_g\ d2ha `4c]f4gFcgZ j^jp~fu]gZ3]f4g-aQcNrik]`4cNg-ë chCkg\\g\^jZ3]f g ê ýÂrzyig\ëfri\giw4qUg?kF` ccgZP]_tÑëgFcaQhicN \^j ` jr{]^jh~Z \ qe^_]föaQhicNkgÿr{]kEf4gl \gF; g %cNkh~jg\\^riZ l m}l riÑ\ i 4ri\ÑqUgîri\Ñch~gFcòriZ l rib f jgFc Y ê Uggk]^_yig-g1¢gl l4gl3r{]h~ gF]f4hCl3ëhi]gZu]^jriî\UaQhiac Oe¢ ê c : # h~b \kNfgF]riÇ `Z4ë`4¢4ÿ j^j\Nf4gl E"m}_]f h~`4p~fqg}gìCëgk]U]fr{]U]f4g}hzyigFcNriî)õ:` rij^_]r{]^jyige¢gf ryC^_h~`4c gi p4C]f4gech~` p~f Z4g\\hia]f4g aQcNrik]`4cgo\`4ca rikg\ "^j\Uri_cgril4t,cgFëcg\gZP]glqgj ¢:t,h~`4cU\^îë_ghCl4g ëhi]gZP]^jrij\FwPcg\` j]\%kgFc]ri^jZ jt qe^jî~l ^½gFcõ:` riZP]^_]r{]^_yig_taXhic"l ^_yigFcN\gUr{]gFcN^îrij\Fwi^Ð gi{^jZu]gFcErik]^_h~Z \F2 \ëgkF^jriî_tiwS]f gjr{]]^îkgU]cNr{ëë^jZ4p gZP]^_h~Z4glr{¢hSyig\]ch~Z4p~jtòl4gFëgZ l\h~Zn]f4g?ëhi]gZP]^jrij\` \gl ` ]`4cg\]` l ^jg\}q}^jjÂkh~ZkgZu]cNr{]gAh~Z/r{]gFcN^jri"\ëgkF9^ )k1\^î1` îr{]^_h~Z \}h~Z/\t:\]g\hia êô mo\Fw^jZ qef ^îkNfkh~ëh~` Zl \×qe^_]fÑyigFctl ^½gFcgZP]` Z ^j]%kgj\@^ 8Fg\riZ lA_h:kFri)r{ccNriZ4piggZu]\UgìC^î\]F OegFqúggk]\ r{cg?gìCëgk]glgi p4 q}f4gZn]f4g?\@^ 8Fg-hia]f g?` Z ^_]kgjriZlkFj` \]gFcl^jrigF]gFcN\¢gkh~g1kh~ër{cNr{¢jgi . èXâ,å%æâoã. rR. ee. rP. Fo. "^jZ riZ kF^îri}\` ë ëhic]AaQch~ ]f4gog`4]\kEf4gL4hicN\NkNf:` Z4p~\pigg^îZ \kNfr{aX]` Zl4gFcnkh~Zu]cNrik]ZP` 1¢gFcòd# 4{{WÿN,^j\picNr{]gFa ` j_t3rikvCZ4hSqe_gl4pigl. iew. JKtäâ,èF. ev. ÜÜuÌÕ~·¶zÓu¶»,Ö~ÌU¸iÛF¶ºuŃ²E¾"¼³º=ÂÓ{¹{¾À¼½Ń¾C òÊ¢¡SÍÖC£t¤ £?Ê¥¤t¦'¦+§SÍÜ ¯nÜ¨ Ü:Ë2Óu¼³¾ÀÓ~°z±³»,Ö¨C© Ü¨ª µ~»-¶z·EÖ~¶zºu¸5 Ü4« ¶t¬N¬ ±³²E¸i¼³º~²SÖï© ´¼³²NºuŃ²4®y¯ Ö4£1¦~ØÊ ¤+¦+¦WÙzÍÜ ËUÜÀÚÂÜ%« ²Eº~±É²E¹1¶zºu¸±e° Ü¨Â² ±³¾À²N·8ÖH Ó~¼³±XÜP¯¶ÅPÜ3³´¨3 Ê S§ ÍÖuÚ)Ù+ µ ÊØµ'¡+S¶ ÍÜ Ü¨·°W¸ ¾À´[Ó ÖPË2ÓÜ¨×· µu¸iÓP¶·À¿EÖP¹ Ü¨×· °¿Ó Ö « Ü Ô^ · ÜuÝ)·À²EÕ~¼ÉºÖu¶ºu¸± Ü¨ º µ~»}Õu¾À´[ÓÖ¨ Ó{¹i¾NÜH·×²EÛCÜ¨³»¯E¼PÖ¨¤~Ø½½½½ Ê¥¤t¦+¦WÙzÍÜ ÜL·°S¸ ¾´[Ó Ö2Ë2Ó Ü×· µu¸iÓu¶z·¿8ÖX Ü º µu»eÕu¾´[Ó Ö¶ºu¸; « Ü Ô · ÜÝ)·À²EÕ~¼³º Ö¯¶F¿8ÜL%· ²E¾EÜ{© °i´zÜ{© ¹{»Ä Ü ·°i´ÜL¾C®y4 ÖÚ)Ú¿µ~Ü §~Ü³Ø Ê¥¤t¦+¦+WÀ ÍÜ oº Ü}Á Ü4i© ´[ÓP¶z¶FÁÇÖP¹ Ü¨×· °z¿ÀÓ Ö~¶zºu¸=« Ü Ô· ÜuÝ·²NÕu¼Éº ÖÂ Ó~¼³±XÜu¯Ñ¶ÅuÜ¾Cn Ê ~¤ Ø8ÍÖ¨¤1À+À 1 µ Ê¥¤t¦'¦+S§ ÍÜ ¹PÜ×· °¿Ó Ö¨ Ó{¹i¾EÜ×· ²NÛCÜ³»¯E:¼ Ö¦+¶tPÀ Ø¦ ? ¤ Ê ¤+¦+W¦ ÙzÍÜ ¹PÜHö Â Ü¨×· °¿Ó Ö¨ · ÜCi© ´[Ó~¼³±É±³¼ÉºuÅuÖu¶zºu¸5e « Ü Ô^ · ÜuÝ)·²NÕ~¼³º Ö Ó{¹i¾EÜ×· ²NÛCÜ¨³)E ¼ Ê ¤'z¤ ÍÖ4Ø8Ùt¡'§+ § ÊÇØ&µ+Sµ ÙSÍÜ ÌÜÌÜ4º ·¼oÃ ¿Ó Ö¨Â Ó~¼É±³°S¾EÜ~Ý)·¶zºu¾NÜ· Ü¨{© °i´ÜuÚ°zºu¸4Üï© ²N·8ÜuÌÄ 4 E:¼ Ö4Ø¶+ § ÊÇØ&µ'~¤ Ø8ÍÜ Ü¨ º µ~»}Õu¾À´[ÓÖ4C© ÜP¹ Ü4:Å Ó~°Sµ Ö~¶ºP¸± ³ ÜÚÜ%« °S±É¼½¶ºÖ Ó{¹i¾NÜ×· ²EÛCÜ¨³)Cò Ê¢S¶ ÍÖ¨§tÀ'WÀ Ù1ÊÇØ&µ+µ z£ ÍÜ Ü¨ º µ~»}Õu¾À´[ÓÖu¯¶F¿²N·8Üï© ´¼QÜ¨Â² º~ÅuÜ~ÌÆ¿¼3ÇÈjy :¼ ÖCØ?Ê ¤+¦+~¦ ØÍÜ ·ÜuÝ"Óu°z»-¾°Sº ÖPËUÜ« ¾À¼³²NÓ Öu¶zºu¸±e ° Ü¨· ¶ºu¶uÖu¹ Ü~ÌÄ~Ä~±QÜ¨ Ó{¹i¾NÜÉ ò Ê¢W¡ ÍÖü§ Ø8Ùt À ÊØµ i£ Ø8ÍÜ. ly. On. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60. http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/pm-pml. Page 4 of 23.

(13) Page 5 of 23. Ü¨²·[´°S±É²8¾À¾À¼4¶ºu¸±¹PÜ³UÜPÌ¸~¶z»¾EÖ²µu·À°SÄ~Ó{¹{¾EÜiÚ ²N¿¿EÜy ¨ÊnÊ ¡SÍÖuÙt¡+§,ÊØµ+µ+ÀWÍÜ Ü ³ ·À°S»o»²E·¶zºu¸T ÜEºv¶¸ Óu±É²E·EÖËyÌÍÎÏ¥Ð9ÑSÍ~ÒÓtÏÍÔ¨Ï¥Ð¢Õ1ÖØ×FÙ"Ó1ÚÜÛÝ¨ÕS×Ð¢ÎÚÞS×jÏ^Õ1Ö`×FÙjÚÓ1ßàÕ'á"â^Ð9Ô4Ð9Ï Ð¢ÓTã+Õ1Ï^ÕFÖL·°i´²N²8¸i¼³º~ÅS¾°Á ÏÀËFäåuµ Ü Ü¨·°W¸ ¾À´[Ó Öe « Ü Ô^ · ÜuÝ)·²NÕ~¼³º Ö~¶ºP¸± Ü¨ º µu»eÕu¾´[ÓòÊîµ~º~Ä~µuÕ~±É¼½¾ÀÓ~²E¸uÍÜ. rR. ee. rP. Fo "^_p~`4cgn{ü ê h~_h~` c-h~Z j^jZ4g'o|:gk]^_h~Z\hia]t:ë^jkFri"aQcNrik]`4cNg\`4ca rikg\hiariZ/^îkh~\rif4gl4cNri×h:l4g"õ:` rWÿ \^jkcNt:\]ri _gFaQ]UriZ l3hia2r ê ,h:l4gý2ryig\ëfri\g ^jl l jgiwucN^_p~fP]E%df4g-kh~_h~` ckhCl ^jZ p ^jZò]f4g-_gFaQ] riZ ln^îl l _gë)^jk]`4cg^j\ril V` \]glò]h]f4g-kFj` \]gFcl ^jrigF]gFc h~Z î^jZ4giü"aXcNh~ ¢)j`4go]hcglE%4hicel gF]ri^jj\ \gFg?]gìC]FUdef4g?\^jl4g-_gZ pi]fnhia2]f g\õ:` r{cg\^j\r{¢h~`4]?S AZ n. iew. ev. ly. On. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60. Philosophical Magazine & Philosophical Magazine Letters. "^_p~`4cg:ü ê h~_h~`4ch~Z j^jZ 'g ê j` \]gFcE\kF`4]U¢Pt]f4gkcNrikNvÑ^jZÑr hCl4gõ:` ri\^îkct:\]riÐü×ð-Z _t ]f4g}\Ñrij_gFc ër{c]\hia]f h~\gkFj` \]gFcN\r{cgl ^î\ëjrztigl3]f r{]qgFcgl ^_yC^jl4glò¢:tA]f gkcNrikv ð¢PyC^_h~` \jtiw:]f gl4tCZ ri^jk kcNrikNv cN^_p~fP] U^jZP]gFcN\gk]\_g\\kFj` \]gFcN\]friZA]f go_hSqûgZ4gFcpitA\gFglòkcErikv jgFaX] Edef4gokFjgry{r{pig-ëjriZ4g ^j\_hCkFr{]glëgFcëgZ l^jkF` jr{cU]hÑ r yigFaQh~jlrWì4^j\Fw4]f4g1kcNrikv3ë chië)r{p~r{]gl^jZ3]ÀqUhiaQh~jll^_cgk]^_h~Z http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/pm-pml.

(14) Philosophical Magazine & Philosophical Magazine Letters. ee. rP. Fo "^_p~`4cg :ü ê h~_h~`4ceh~Zj^jZ4g'6^_gFq(^jZ \^jl grAkcNrikvhia×]f4g ê ÑhCl4gÂý2ryig\oëf ri\gisgFcaQgk]}¢cN^_]]_g kF_grzyWr{pig aXcErik]`4cg?^j\hi¢\gFcyigl. iew. ev. rR. r¨. ¢L. ly. On. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60. +k l "^_p~`4cgp 4ü ê h~_h~`4cUh~Z j^jZ g'"4cNrik]`4cNgohiar ê 1hCl4gý2ryig\ëf ri\giü"m]h~Ñ^jk}kh~ZE p~`4cNr{]^_h~Z\U^jZÑ]f4g yC^jkF^jZ ^_]Àthiar?ëchiër{p~r{]^jZ4p1kcNrikv ]^jge\gõ:`4gZ kg'E%df4gaQcNrik]`4cNge\`4ca rikge^j\_h:kFr{]glÑëgFcëgZ l ^jkF` îr{c ]h]f4gNP 4i&Rl ^_cNgk]^_h~ZwC]f4gkcNrikNv3ë chiër{p~r{]g\ori_h~Z4p]f4N g P½Fi Rl ^_cNgk]^_h~Z aXcNh~ _gFaQ]]hcN^_p~fP] E. http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/pm-pml. Page 6 of 23.

(15) Page 7 of 23. 281x87mm (72 x 72 DPI). w. ie. ev. rR. ee. rP Fo. ly. On. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60. Philosophical Magazine & Philosophical Magazine Letters. http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/pm-pml.

(16) Philosophical Magazine & Philosophical Magazine Letters. ee. rP Fo 158x63mm (150 x 150 DPI). w. ie. ev. rR ly. On. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60. http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/pm-pml. Page 8 of 23.

(17) Page 9 of 23. rR. ee. rP Fo 251x135mm (150 x 150 DPI). w. ie. ev ly. On. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60. Philosophical Magazine & Philosophical Magazine Letters. http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/pm-pml.

(18) Philosophical Magazine & Philosophical Magazine Letters 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20. For. Pee. Page 10 of 23. r Re. view. Onl. y. http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/pm-pml.

(19) Page 11 of 23 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20. Philosophical Magazine & Philosophical Magazine Letters. For. Pee. r Re. view. Onl. y. http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/pm-pml.

(20) Philosophical Magazine & Philosophical Magazine Letters 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20. For. Pee. Page 12 of 23. r Re. view. http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/pm-pml. Onl. y.

(21) Page 13 of 23 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20. Philosophical Magazine & Philosophical Magazine Letters. For. Pee. r Re. view. Onl. y. http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/pm-pml.

(22) Philosophical Magazine & Philosophical Magazine Letters.

(23)

(24) "!#$%&!"#$'() **# + , %-#." /0#.1! /2! 345768:9*;=<?5A> @CBD6"EF64CGH@.;57I62<9J*6K74 ;LEM756KONNPQ@R<5O;C6"EKONJ2S0KON@ TU<KOGVNPW4:X"4PWYGVN Z [A\.]_^H]_Ò]-aÒb cedgfAhUiQc.hC]_^V\j fhkÒ[)lnm-[OophCqsrQ[)lQ]thvuwfOxW\.^zyW{ |[A^V}QhCcC\.^H]LrQb ]~A]_Ò]_]zorQc ]_{0uaDrhC[AqsrLlQc ^H[OonO { LLLp~A]_Ò]_]zorQc ]_{-hCcCrQ[Ax P;CPQ4298RY@BD6 Z [\ ]_^V]_`7]aÒb cgÒ}QhCcCCrQb \.\ ôyhC^H]}WiQ[rQÒ]thC^_hC[2Ò[*l~xQ\.]thChC[A{ |[A^V}QhCcC\.^H]LrQb ]0rQcC \.cC`fAhC{0rQ^H\hCc \ ]_cDW{ LQprQc \.c `fAhC{=-hCc rW[AxnrQ[)l crQÒ[7fiaDhCc?Z [\ ]_^V]_`7]"a`7b c$hCcUyW\ ] i¡h.j f7rQ[A^zyW{ib f7hCc \ ]_cD¢LW{0 Q£pLQ¤vcUhC^¦¥Òc¦oQ{-hCc rQ[x §©¨*ª«U¬"ª¬sQ®_¯° ±"²p³7´D¯Lµ-ªD¶*¯L·gª¬U¬¸¯L¹L¹pºO»L¼L½L¹¾¿DÀLÀLÁLÂtÃ*²)¸¶ªsÄV« QÅC¬.Æ«.ª¸ÇÈÅDÉQ´.Q²ª¸Ç7« W®)Ê®ÌË¡Í=ÎËt±"Ç0ÚÈÎAÏQ®ª-ÅC«U³´¬ W®´ ÈÎÆ®Ì¬U« Q²AÈÏQ²¶LWÅDÆAÆÐÑQÎ)Çk²A¸¶ªÈÎ7¶LªD´¬.ÈÏW¬.ªDÇ¬.²Aª?ÅD®ª¸¸¶LWÏLªRÒA®QÎªD´ÈÎ7ËtÚÈÌ¬.Æk¨p³ÚÅ¸QÎÎAÈÎAÏ¬.ÆÎAÎAª®ÈÎÏÐÈË Å«.ÉLÚÅDÉQÒp³$¾ ÓÔÍÂC¯OÕ¢®ÉQÄÆ®z«ÒAW¬U¬.ª«.Î´sÈÎ¬.²Aª-Ó7ÔÍ:Ë ÈÐ?WÏLªD´"Öª«.ª-ÈÎp¬.ª«.Ò«.ª¬.ªDÇQ´sÅD®ÆA´¬.ª«.´sÉQÄgW¬.ÉQÐ´D¯©Ô²AªDÚª W«.ª¢ÚÈÏQÎAÈÌ×)Å¸WÎp¬(\.]_cC`j]_ÒcUrL7ÆAÎÈÌ¬.´wÉQÄØpÆ)QÚÈÅ«U³7´¬ W®´D¯sÔ²ª¢ªÙ7Ò*ª«.ÈÐªDÎp¬.´wÉWÄ§©¨*ª«U¬ªC¬Q®_¯7ÈÐÒA®Ì³¬.²AW¬¬.²ª³?W«.ª Q®ÚÉv´¬ QÄ®ªÚfOxW\.^¦j.rLªÎO¬.ÈÌ¬.ÈªD´Dº"$Ò7«.ÉLÒ*ª«U¬t³ÅDÉQÎp¬U«.ÉW¶Lª«.ÚÈQ®®Ì³nÇÈÚÅDÆÚÚª¸ÇkÅDÆ«U«.ªÎO¬.®Ì³p¯$ÛAÉQ«0ÅD®W«.ÈÌ×)ÅDW¬.ÈÉLÎÖª Ò*ª«UÄHÉW«.Ðª¸Çv¬.²ª×A«.´¬®«.ÏLª?ÚÅ¸Q®ªÄz« QÅ¬.Æ7«.ªÚÈÐ0ÆA®W¬.ÈÉQÎA´ÉLÎ¬.²«.ªDªËtÇ7ÈÐªÎAÚÈÉLÎAQ®©ÅDÉLÐÒ®ªÙvÄÈÎ)«U³´³´¬.ªÐ´D¯ Ükª?´¬.Æ)Ç7ÈªDÇ¬.²ª:Ò7«.ÉLÒAQÏ¬.ÈÉLÎÉQÄÐÉOÇªRÝÅC« QÅ Þ7´0ÈÎeWÎnÈÅÉL´.Q²ª¸Ç7« W®ÐÉOÇªD®ØpÆAQÚÈÅ«U³7´¬ Q®¨p³kÐÉQ®ªDÅDÆA®« Ç7³7Î)WÐÈÅ´w¬.ªDÅ ²AÎAÈØpÆAª´W¬®É¸Ö1¬.ªDÐÒ*ªC« W¬.Æ«.ªQ¯/Ý¡Î:Ò)W«U¬.ÈÅDÆ®W«Öª&ªÙWÐÈÎª¸Ç:²É¸Ö¬.²Aª(Ú²AQÒ*ª&ÉQÄ¬.²Aª(ÅD®ª¸¸¶QQÏQª ÒA®QÎªÈ´wÈÎ7ß)ÆAªÎAÅDª¸Ç¨p³¬.²ªÅD®ÆA´¬.ª«.´ÈÎ²Aª«.ªDÎp¬sÈÎ?¬.²ªÐÉOÇ7ªD®*WÎ)Ç²AÉ¸ÖàÈÌ¬ÇªDÒ*ªDÎAÇ´sÉLÎ¬.²AªÒA®WÎAª-´¬U«.ÆAÅ¬.Æ7«.ªL¯ ás«.ÈÌ¬U¬.®ª(Äz« QÅ¬.Æ7«.ª&ÖÈ¬.²=ÎAÉÈÎAÇÈÅ¸W¬.ÈÉQÎÉQÄ©Ç7ÈÚ®ÉpÅ¸¬.ÈÉLÎQÅ¬.È¶OÈÌ¬¡³:È´-ÉQÄÚª«.¶Lª¸Ç¯"Ô²ª&Å« QÅ Þ:ÚÆ7«UÄ_WÅDªD´W«.ª(«.ÉLÆÏL² ÉLÎ¬.²AªÚÅ¸Q®ªÉWÄs¬.²ª0Å®Æ´¬.ª«.´DºÄÆ7¬¢ªÙ7²È¨ÈÌ¬(ÅDÉQÎA´¬ QÎp¬(¶Lª« QÏQª²AªDÈÏQ²O¬.´-ÄHÉW«&ÉQ«.ÈªDÎp¬ W¬.ÈÉQÎA´&Ò*ª«.Ò*ªDÎAÇÈÅDÆ®z«¢¬.É ²AÈÏL²´³7ÐÐª¬U«U³$Ù7ªD´D¯Û7«.ÉLÐ Ç7ª¬ QÈ®ª¸ÇQÎAQ®Ì³7ÚªD´ÉQÄw¬.²ªÄz« QÅ¬.Æ7«.ª¸Ç´.WÐÒA®ªD´¢ÖwªÅDÉQÎAÅD®Æ)Ç7ª0¬.²AW¬&¨*ÉW¬.²gº¬.²Aª ÒA®QÎª´¬U«.ÆÅ¬.Æ«.ª0QÎAÇ=¬.²AªÅD®ÆA´¬.ªC«.´Dº´¬U«.ÉLÎAÏQ®Ì³ÈÎß)ÆªDÎAÅª0ÇO³7Î)QÐÈÅ(Äz« QÅ¬.Æ7«.ª0ÈÎØpÆ)QÚÈÅ«U³7´¬ W®´¢QÎAÇ¬.²AW¬-¬.²Aª ÅD®ÆA´¬.ª«.´¬.²AªC«.ªÄHÉW«.ª²A¸¶ª¢¬.É¨*ª(«.ªÏW« Ç7ª¸Ç$W´-Ò²p³ÚÈÅ¸W®gªÎO¬.ÈÌ¬.ÈªD´D¯ âúãsê.ûWä©ü/åý¸æWëtþçìCèíé7ÿzë ê.ëtìC¡íçLî¸ë¡ïLê¸ð ô ï¸WñLç ð òDì óO.ôOë îLûLõ¸ì ð ö¸öÌì ð ÷ôpè&ëCôý ñ¸ÌïLê ð øDç ñLðDëùs/ì þLûLæ Dè ì©ì Ìè¢ç Ìý¸æì. ee. rP. Fo . .

(25) . . . . . KO;C94PQ@ 0@;C6GH@4P A9GV4CPL@;4C9NgBWKp;PQJ4C5 @05 PQ4 8KON K7NJ nK7B pK 2B V9@ ;CPQ4@$Gz;GV@@ ;KO;CPQJ ;6Kp;;6PQ@CP;C6PQ4CP ¦574P 9K7@CGVBW4 *@ ;K V@KO4P:GVNA;CPQ4C8$P;DK zGHB=B578$I579NgJ@ &G;6 V57N OT BW579UN=HJ;C6NP&5O;I4C4PLPW@ IPQ4NPQ;@CPWK7NA4 ; ;GVB z4P 8 ¢PWP(NA4C;PQG;IgGz5PL4 @ ;57N$8$5 VPQBW9 HKO4J )NK78=GHBW@ 4DKON P A9K@ GzTIgPQ4CGV5*J*GVB;4K7N@ HKp;Gz5NK &54JPW4 X(6P I5@@ PL@C@ @CGV8R9 HKp;Gz5N@5 BW4KB I4C5IK AKp;CGV57NGzNàKv;64PWPTUJ*GV8$PWN@CGz5NK ¢P TUJ*P gNPQJ:Kp;C58$GVBI HKONPL@sK7NJ?6PQNBP(J*G 4DK7B;wP zPLB¸;4C58$K OT GHB5A@CK76PQJ4K 8$5)JP 9gK7@CGVBW4 *@ ;K gKp; V5 ;CPW8$IPW4DKp;94CP )PWPLJ NPW;CGHB&KONJ=8Kp;C;CPW4 (K 7PL@wGzNA;C5?@C6K74CI 4DK @CI5O;@ 9;;C6P BW4KB *@nKO4P2GVN@ PQ4 ;PQJ K z5N J*G PQ4CPQNA;eI HKONPL@K7NJ;C6PW4PWGVN K H@C5J*GH@ I HK àKp;C58$GVBB V9@.;PW4D@RK@?YK@ GHBvY9G HJ*GVN Y V5*B *@ 7E &65A@ PRK74C4DKON 7PW8$PQN;GVN@CIK7BWP?GH@0BW578$IKp;GzY zP &Gz;C6;C6P:I HKpT ¦K 9 z5N KOJNgG K PW)4@CPWPQNAJ;;CJ*5kGz4KOPQNB@;CGV57PQN4@ ;6X(P$64CP 5 z¦P:4K5 B¸;9B z4C9gP:@.I;PWHKO4D@0NPLGVNe@K7J 4CAP=NgBWKOK78$4CPWGVB T NK74@.;4C9B;C94P X(6PQ@CPB V9@.;PW4D@B5N@CGV@ ; ¦574P *K78$I zP5 @CP AT ¦4DK7B;C94P UN *PQB P0I45 AGHJ*P@C578$P04CP 9Gz4PW8$PWNA;D@-5N;C6P PW4DK @ 6P V@-5 ©GHB5@KO6PQJ*4DK @ )8$8=PW;C4 ¢PW4 78KON*TE K7B pK AT E ;6PW54CPW;CGHBWK ©J*PQ@B4GzI;CGV57Nk5 ¦4DK7B¸;94P UN )PLB ¢;6P?8$5*J*P I@CPW9J5OT nK7B pK ATB z9g@.;PW4D@ 04=;6P ¦54C8 I5 A;C5IgPL@WEP J*PLBWK 57NK I4GV@C8@WE &6GVBD6 VG Pn;6Pn9NGz;BP H@v5 ?IPW4GV5)JGVB 8$A9PWK;C@ 6GH5*B4J*@$@.;D;K 5 ¡EA);CGV6@C9PK 8$VGH5@ PVPQBW;C69 PVK744CPLJ @ )9 Nz;KO@v8$5 GHBW@¢;C6;PQPnBD6@CGzN8:G A9 9HKpP7;CEGVK757NNgJ@;CKO64PP B4 *@.;DK H@ @CIK7BWP7E©K z;C6579 6 &G;6 HKO4 7P:5 7PQ4 HKOI@ 9gK7@CGT 9NGz; TUBP IGVB;C94P MAKON5O;KONJ=57;C6PQ4@ (6K 7P(I5@ ;C9 HKp;PQJ 5K74C9*P; VIGVN4PQPQJ@CPWNA*;CPL9JY@CK7P NAJ9PW;CNA6; PQNE*J*GzN GV@B)9gPQ@CB @CPQJGzN ;6)P?PLB@CGz8:9 VKO;CGV57N4CPL@ 9 z;@ ;C6gKp;vKà@ P _TU@ GV8$G HKO4$6GVPW4DKO4DBD6GHBWK ¢K@C@CPW8:Y 5 0;6PB V9@ ;CPW4D@ GH@v4PQ@CIg5N@ GVY VP ¦574;C6P@ ;K7YG zGz; 15 9gK7@CGVBW4 *@ ;K H@KONgJ ¦574 8KON RI6 *@CGVBQK I4C5IgPQ4 ;GzPL@WE VG 7P(;C6P z5 P VPQB;C4GVB&BW57NJ9B¸;G AT Gz; S5 ¢P 7PQ4QEgG;GH@0KB57NA;4C5 PW4D@ GHK ©K7NJIPW4D@ GH@.;PWNA;JGV@B9@ T @CGz5N©E &6PW;C6PQ4;6PRB V9@ ;CPQ4@K74CP8$PQ4CP k@.;4C9gB¸;C94K ©9NGz;@574 &6PW;C6PQ4&;C6P 4PWI4CPL@ PQN;&I6 *@CGVBQK ©PQN;G;GzPL@ (X(6P?J*GH@B9@@ GV57N X(6P@.;4CPL@C@(BW57NBWPWNA;C4DKp;Gz5NKONJ;C6P@ ;C4PWN O;C65 ©;6P z5AK7J)T (K7@ ¦9P VPQJRY ?K7N?P *IPW4Gz8$PQN;5 YPW4C;sP;K OE &6PQ4CPGVBW5@KpT GVN Kp;K B4DK7B 1;CGVI K74CP J*P;PW48$GzNPLJ Y ;C6P 8K7BW4C5A@CBW57IGHB 6PLJ*4K zT nN*TJ ¢K@ ¦4KB¸;C94CPLJ9NJ*PW49 ;4K76G 76 KB998 PW58=PW;C4 KONgJ JGz8$PWNg@ GV57N@?5 K@CK78$I zP UN VGzNPQKO4RP HK7@ ;CGHB B5NJ*Gz;CGV57N@-Kp;-45)578 ;PW8$IPW4DKp;C94CP *BQKONNGzN ;9NNP zGVN ?8$GzT BW57NA;CGVN)998 8$PQBD6gKONGHBW@QE-K @ 6K74CI18$5)JP ¦57IPWNGzN à8$5*J*P B45@B5I RGV8$K 7PL@5 /;6PB VPQK pK P&I VK7NPQ@4P 7PLK VPQJ$P zPQ8=PQNA;@ BW4KB ?GH@-BD6K74KB¸;CPQ4CGH@CPQJ:Y $K?@CGzN 79 HKO4@ ;C4PQ@@ P VJK7NJK?BW574CT 5 ;5 nN8 GVN J*GVK78$P;CPQ4 X(6PKO9;C654@vK74 9Pk;C6gKp; 4PQ@CI57NJ*GVN JGV@CI HK7BPQ8$PWNA; P VJ©E &6GHBD6 Yg57;C6 KO4PnI457I574CT ;C6PQ@CPnKO4P;6PnB V9@ ;CPW4D@ &6GHBD6 PQ4CPkBGV4BW98 PWNA;CPLJ Y ;6P ;Gz5NK 0;C5 ;C6P @.;4CPL@C@GzNA;PWN@CG; KB¸;C54 X(6GH@ K7B¸;574GV@ B4DK7B K7NJ 6PWNBWP ¦54C8 6G 6 1@.;DKOY VPK 4CP Kp;PQ@R5 08KO; T I4C5Ig54 ;Gz5NK ¢;C5 ;6PnKOII zGVPQJ1P );CPQ4CNgK V5K7J KONgJ1BW57NA;K7GzN@ ;CPQ4 ;6PW4D@I57GVNA;¢59*;-;6Kp; gKp;;CPQ4C4DK7BWPQ@P 75 P57N 7P ¦5 VJ ;6P 7PQ578$P;4 $5 s;C6P@KO8$I VP @ GV8$I VPPQNPW4 YgK7@CPQJBW57N*T @C94 KBPL@R5 GT zT N*TU-J &6PQN1K7NNPQK zPLJ KO;=6G 762;CPW8$IPW4CT JG;Gz5N ¦574vB4DK7B I4C5IK AKp;Gz5N1GH@$;C6Pe4CG $;C6 BW4CGz;CPQ4CGV57N. rR. !#"$%%!. &. ('. *). +),). 1/ 32. -. ),). 4). 76. !-. +). 5. 1). ;-. -. 98. <. 1) '. #=. :). +/>/. 9). ),). +/. 7). +D. I. @ '. ). *). '. ED. +) ('. 'HG=. K75ML. 'ND. -. +) P6Q)9). 9). *). <. <. \'. +De05 f. H-. */. < +/. -. lD. 1). <. +). N-. /. :). 1). */*/. +D. 1). *5\qy. 1). Rd. +D. @. J'. 1/. o6Q< 7D >). ,/. 1). +51yS5. 0/. +D. 1) >5~q N). 1). 0/ 1). ~6 :). +). !/. ('. jD. 0). +D. @. http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/pm-pml. 1) *5;a. +/. ). 1/. K. ;6 :). P-. '[D. +). !). \'. HqlG. +D. :< >)9<. *). xd. ). v2. 1). )9'. '. \'. :/. +5Qq4q4q. r'. :) 1/. k<. cn. aP) I. @. (/. j-. 9/ 1)9'. :5mL. *D. 1/. ,/ H<. 1/. *5mq Rd. 1). {zm|k$%"#}. +) 5 ` +-. >5?d. 1'. 2. +). :2. *). i*5. 7). 4D. 9<. 1). 7). w5md. 1). +D ). <. *). 5. cD. +D. (). 1). #D. +D?D. +). [D. ). +D_^. hg. @. +). 7F. *)baP) I. '. 7). +). +5\q(qt-. >5td. 98. >). *). 2. 1). *D. 1/. m) -. (-. N<. SG7T2. :)9'. \'. J'. *5uq Hd. +). :5. +),'. D. r'. +). ('. ly. ). +D. (). )s2. Z8. D 0)9),'. 1). +/. *). 1/. *). @. *). +). 7). :'. ]D. *5 /05. ('. P) -. @ '. <. *D2. +) ,@. 0-. <. 1)9'. ,) '. +). -. /. (WX7Y. 1) 3D. -. JI. <. D. ) -. +D. @. *). (/. 5. On. :)ZD. '*5. .). *D. *),'. ),). 1/ R-. :UJKV*5. J'. @ A(B C. 1). /. c6. 1). +DE=. _AV. q. :'. 1). 1). F. O) 9@. +). :)9). \'. 1/. 0) -. *5. 0/. -. 7). 1). */. :5?=. 7). 0/. +). '. :2. @ '. iew. +). .). pX:A4C+5Sa. [I. ev. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60. Page 14 of 23. 7F. H5. ~D. +)). 1). /*'. 9. _AW+5.

(26) Page 15 of 23. Philosophical Magazine & Philosophical Magazine Letters . ;@ ;KO;CPL@;6Kp;KvB4DK7B GV@0GzNP A9G zGVY4Gz98 &6PQN;C6P=BD6K7N 7P GVN18$PQBD6gKONGHBWK ¢PQNPW4 IPW49NG;vK74CPLKn5 B4DK7B 2KJ pKONBWP ;C6P?PWNPQ4 4P VPQK@ P4DKp;P P A9K H@&;6PRBD6K7N 7PGVNn@C94 KBP PWNPW4 5 0;C6Pk; ¢5 ¦4KB¸;94CPk@C94 KBPL@WE UN B5NA;CGVNA998 8$PQBD6K7NGHBW@;C6P:PWNPQ4 4P VPQK@ P?4DKp;PRGH@I4C5Ig54 ;Gz5NK ";C5v;6P @ 9gKO4P5 s;6PR@ ;C4PQ@@(GzNA;PWN@CG; K7B;C574 ¦54K 7G 7PQN8$5*J*P B4DK7B :;C6PWN@C659 VJ@.;DKO4C;8$5 )GzN &6PWN;C6P@ ;C4PQ@@-GVNA;CPWNg@ Gz; K7B;C54&P BPQPQJ@¢;6P?B4G;GVBQK "4G $;6 pK z9P B5N;GzN)998 8$PQBD6K7NGHBWK ©JPQ@B4GzI*;Gz5Nk5 ¦4KB¸;94CPE*65 (T P PW4LE6K7@:K ¦P ÑJ4K &YKB *@ n3wGV4@ ;QE;6P4P A9GV4CPQ8$PWNA;@ ¦574 VGzNPLKO4P HK7@ ;CGHBGz; K74CPnN5 V57N PW4 pK VGHJ NPQK74v;6P BW4KB 2;GzI &6PQ4CPKO;C58=GHBY57NgJ@B zPLKO4 =YPQB58$PN5N*T VGVNPQK74-KONJvP 7PQN*T ;C9gK àY4PQK )PQBW57NJ/EKeB5N;GzN)998 ;6PW54 NP VPQB¸;D@?;6P J*GH@CBW4CPW;CPNKp;94CP5 ;C6P VKO; ;GVBWP 2X(6)9@QEG;$GH@ ¦9 2G 7N54CPLJ ;C6gKp; ¦4DK7B;C94P5 (8Kp;CPQ4CGHK H@GH@9 z;CGV8Kp;CP àBWK79@CPQJ Y Y57NJ Y4PQK AGVN =I45)BWPQ@@ PL@¢57N;C6P?KO;C58=GHB@CBQK VP ¢K ;5k9NJ*PQ4@ ;K7NJe;C6PI45*BPL@C@CPQ@GH@;C5kIPW4 ¦5748 N)9*T 8$PW4GVBQK P )IPW4GV8=PQNA;@QEs@CGzNBWP$P *IgPQ4CGV8$PWNA;K GVN ¦5748Kp;CGV57N 57N ;C6GV@ VPWN 7;C6@BWK zPGH@J*G vB9 z;(;C5=57Y*;DKOGVN 5 VPQBW9 HKO4(J )NKO8=T GHBW@@.;9J*GVPQ@6K 7PRI4C5 )GHJ*PQJn9@ P ¦9 GzNg@ G 76A;0GVNA;C5B4DK7B I4C5I*T K AKp;Gz5N GVN I94CPk8$P;DK H@KONJ @CGz8$I VPGzNA;PW48=PW;K VGVBkK V5 *@WE &6PQ4CPLK7@GVN B58$I zP 8$PW;K VGVBvK V5 *@;C6P8$PQBD6K7NGH@ 8@?K74CP N57; P;@ 5B VPQK74 ¢;578$GV@ ;CGHB @.;9J*GVPQ@@C65 ¦574kP K78=I zP ;C6gKp;0BW4KB )@¢4PW8KOGVN@.;DKOY VPGVNkK$4P Gz5NK74C59NJ;C6P:B4G;GVBQK @ ;C4PQ@@GzNA;PWN@CG; K7B;C54RJ*9P;C5k;C6PJ*GH@CBW4CPW;CPNKO;C94Pv5 ¢;6P HKp; ;GVBWP X(6GH@¢P PQB;GV@(BWK VPQJ VKO; ;GVBWP0;4K7IIGVN ¦94C;C6PW4 B5N@CP A9PWNgBPk5 ;C6PJ*GH@CBW4CPW;CP HKp; ;GVBWPGV@v;C6KO;;C6P ¦4KB¸;C94CP YPW6K )GV5794&GVNk57NPKONgJ;6P?@KO8$PI HKONPBWK7NJ*PWIPWNJ5N;6P B4DK7B $I457IgK KO;CGV57N )9BD657Yg@ PQ4 pKp;Gz5N@¢BWKONN5O; YPP *I VK7GzNPQJY K:@CGz8$I VPB5N;GzN)998Ñ8$PQBD6K7NGVBQK /J*PL@CBW4CGVI*T ;CGV57N q. @. *). (/>'. /*'. :2. . -. :2. '~D. ED. / ,<. '. Z. H< *). >5. +). xD -. ). -. ). -. ). +),)9'. D. @. ). H). *5. +). '. +) F. c). *). 9. 1). :)9'. <. (D. -. 7). ~). +D. x). 7F. 0). +). *D. RD. rR. x>97

(27) _A4Y5md. J'. -D. 1/\A4+5;aD. 1). F 1). *)9) '. *)9) '. <. +/. @. *)9). ee. 78. r'. /. '.D. @. 1). ,/. *)9). @. :2. *). 1). +),). :5a. *5. b5;I. rD. 1). 1) F. H'. *). D 1). +). (<. 1). +). ]5. | \ ¡\¢_£*¤_¥7¡\¦?§s¨v©_¡J¥7ª«l0¤_£*¦ +). \'. 7F. ¬-. :)02. 1) '. o^m). *). '. *)\-. 7A4`. )1D. +DG

(28) a) QK4Ix/05. 1). )E2. '. ,). +),) -. +D#=. c=. (/. 0/. -. \'. /. '. ('. 1/. ¶G. K. r/. ,<. 0). ¹). +/. !ºw»,g*» º ;-. *). -. oº. 1). G

(29) =. K. *). b5. %-. E-. #<. A i B Ap 5. '. j<. 0/ a. ). 7F. <. D. xD. ~=. *). K. ,) '3-. 7F. ('. '. 7). +D. 2. '. '. *D. P2. ('. +) 5. +). 9). +). D. HD. 0). *D. *5. ½k{r¦,£*¾s¦,¡>¥#¤Qª_©_¡\«H¨v !¿£>¢s©s¨,ÀQ¾_£. @-GV@-5 _;PWNJ*5NPGVN ¦4DK7B¸;94P@ GV8R9 HKp;Gz5N@ t@ PQPP Y4DKpT g6 KO8 ¢P&9@ P@CGV8=I zP "PWNNK74J*TM57NPL@Ig57;CPQN;GVK V@;C58$5*J*P ;6PGVN;PW4DK7B;CGV57N@ wX(6P ¦5 z5 &GVN K7B;@ VPQJ;C5=;C6GV@BD657GHBP 3wGz4D@ ;QEs;C6P 7PW4 ¦P Ig57;CPWNA;GVK V@?K pK7G HKOY VP ¦574 9gK7@CGVBW4 *@ T ;DK H@RK74CP9N@C9G;DKOY VP ¦54 :@ GV8R9 VKO;CGV57N@ X(6PQ@CPIK7Gz4 I5O;PWNA;CGHK H@@.;DKOYG zGH@CPR;6P A9K@ GHB4 *@.;DK s57N ¦574K *PLJ 75 T 98=P Gz;C6 ¦4PWP@C94 KBPL@KO;C58$@@C578$P;Gz8$PL@@ GV8$I P pKOI*T 54KO;CP P &Gz;C6 I5O;PWNA;CGHK H@=YK7@CPQJ257N;65@CP5 SK ¦NPW4$P; K PW4 V57N OT4K7N 7PLJI5O;PWNA;CGHK H@ &Gz;C6234GVPQJ*P -5@BG VKOT ;Gz5N@ ¦P ;C65A@ P¢5 zT "PW6 K7NG)P;-K ¦4CP 9PWNA; RJ*GH@ I VK @C9BD6 VK74 PB576PQ@CG PPQNPW4 7GVPQ@;6Kp;NPQKO4 vN5$P HK7@ ;CGHBJ*P ¦54 T 8KO;CGV57NGV@&I5@@CGzY VPKONJGVN@.;PQKJGVNA;C4GzNg@ GHBB4DK7B *@(J*P P V57I )PLB57NgJ/E)8$K7N $@CGV8R9 HKp;Gz5N@6K PI45 7PQN$;C6KO;¢8$5*J*P I5OT ;PWNA;CGHK H@KO4P6P VIGVN à;C5à9NJPW4D@.;DKONJ ;C6PP zPQ8$PWNA;K74 I45OT a. +D. oD. oC4ÁK?-. :5. l<. +). !D *),) -. *). %Ã´(³>Ä7Å Ær´(Ç. ,). *5 /05Ja. #2. '. <. *». 9). 1) D. 0). +). 'É). 0/. (/. 1),'3D. +) Ê-. 9<. \'. ). R< >). /. 2. ),'. <. 1/. ,),). (),'. 0) '. ). @. 1). <. +D. :). *)5 C(CK]D. 1). +). o61F. *D. 1/. \'. ('. 1)9'. +DsaP) Â. d. S2. :». +). G >5 /Q5. ). E). 4D. ÉG *5 /05?-. H). 1/#D. 1) D. D. *)5 CA7K5Hy. G. *). 'xD :-. +). >5SÈ. 1). 0) PÂ. ®G

(30) a. / *). FD. +). (/. ,/. ,/. *@. +D. *) +D. 9/Q5;g. <. >). ¸. 05 E- !Ix/. r'. oG. +). R-. o<. 1/. ). +),)9'. 1/. *D. 7F +/. *D. Q). =. +). ¼D. Z6. '. +D. QK5·aP). +D. (/. ) 5kq. 1). ,/05!g. =. %6. 7D. < ). <. b5. :). :). ('. ly. ,) 1/. -. P=. 5. t-. :). +). +) :5a. j. +)E¯7°²±s³´µ. \'. ) D K S-. +),'. ®2. [aP). ,/05wgoG. \'. ,<. On. +) :5. '. 1). *). *Dg>» ºw5. 7F. 1/. iew. UN ;C6P N)98$PW4GHBWK P *IgPQ4CGV8$PWNA;@ P 9@CP K ;C64CPQPT *J GV8$PWN@CGz5NK 8=5*J*P A9K7@CGHB4 )@ ;K &6GVBD6$6K@YPWPWN$I457I5@CPQJ Y :SPWN VP $KONJ V@CPW4 &K7@K@ ;C49B¸;94P8$5)JP ¦54;C6PGVBW5@KpT 6PLJ*4K -I6gK7@CPv5 tE N X(6GH@?GH@?;6P@CGz8$I VPQ@ ;:I5@@ GzT Y VP8$5*J*P A9K7@CGHB4 )@ ;K ;C6KO;:GH@:@ ;K7YG zGH@ PLJàY eIK7Gz4:Ig57;CPQN*T ;CGHK H@ -394C;C6PW48=54CPGz;0K V5 @ ¢94 7PQ4@&BWGz4DB9G;K7NK *@ GH@&KONJ GH@K1I4C57;C5O; )IPà5 ¢PQ4 8$K7N*T¡; AIP 9gK7@CGVBW4 *@ ;K H@ @ P J*5 N5O;J*GH@.;GzN 79GH@ 61YgPW; PQPWN &KONJ N1KO;C58$@QE ¢Pv;PW48 ;C6GV@J*PLB54KO;CGV57NnGHB5A@CK76PQJ*4DK =8$5)JP ;?BWK7NYP=5Y*T ;K7GzNPQJY J*PQBW574DKp;GzN ;6P0@ ;C49B;C94PP zPQ8=PQNA;@5 /;C6P;C64CPQPT J*GV8$PWN@CGz5NK PWN45@CPk;CG VGzN gE(;C6Pe57Y HKp;PKONgJ;C6PI4C5 VKO;CP 46578:Yg56PQJ*4DK t@ PQP 3wG 7E0;C5I KONgJ N Kp;578@ Kp;578@ KO4P=I VKBPQJ 5Ne;6P 7PQ4 ;GVBWPQ@K7NJe;C6Pv8$GHJ*I57GVN;D@5 ;C6P&PQJ PQ@w5 g;C6P&46578:Yg56PQJ4K "X 5 Kp;578@ Kp;C58@ J*G )GVJ*P;C6P V57N ?Y5*J vJ*GHK 57NK 5 ©PLK7BD6vI45 HKp;P46578:Yg56PT J*457NàGVN4KO;CGV5@ /E &6PW4P GV@;C6P 5 HJ*PWNà8$PQK7N kX 5 I45 HKp;P¢K7NJ?; ¢557Y HKp;P4658RY576PLJ*4K &Gz;C6$KBW578$8$57N 7PQ4 T ;CP ¦54C8 K46578:YGHBJ*5*J*PQBQKO6PLJ*4C5N X"525Y*;K7GzN;6P GHB5@KO6PQJ*4DK AYGVNKO4 ?8$5*J*P ¡EOGVNR;6PQ@CPJ*5*J*PQBQKO6PLJ*4DK&;C6PKp;C58 Kp;;C6PBW578$8$57N 7PQ4 ;P GV@4CPQ8=5 PQJ KONJ ;6P ¦594NPQG 6*T Y5794GzN Kp;578@KO4P;C4DKONg@ ¦54C8$PQJGVN;5 KO;C58$@ (3sGVNK +). R<. *D. ev. 7h!#}[|k[}c !. q. 9D. r/. ,/. +) *5. 1). ;6PQ@CP:KO;C58$@KO4P:@C6G _;CPLJ;C5;C6P=BW578$8$57N PW4C;CP k;5J*G )GVJ*P ;6PPLJ 7PL@R5 &;C6PkB54C4PQ@CI57NJ*GVN 46578:Yg56PQJ4KGVN K4KO;CGV5 5 3wG ¦Y5O;C;C578 zP _; (@C65 @¢;C6P gNK ©J*PLB54KO;CGV57N5 ;6PQ@CP&J*5*J*PQBQKO6PLJ*4DKEpGVN &6GHBD6:;C6P 2KO;C58$@ ¦54C8 6P K 57NK YGzI )4K78$GVJ*PL@ X(6GV@08$5)JG gBQKp;Gz5NGzNBW4CPLK7@CPQ@;C6P:NA98RYPW45 ¢PQ4 8$K7N*T¡; AIP:B z9g@.;PW4D@ @CPWP3wG 7E©Y5O;C;C578 4CG 76A; GVN6PQ4 T PQNA;0GVN;C6P=@.;4C9gB¸;C94CPE VPQKJ@&;5K6G 76PW40@ ;K7YG zGz; &G;6;C6P I5O;PWNA;CGHK H@9@CPQJ/EKONJR;K 7PQ@wYP;C;CPW4-GzNA;C5KBWB59NA;s;6P&P *IPW4GT 8$PQN;DK R57Y@CPW4 7PLJ?@.;57GHBD6GV578$P;4 5 ;C6P 9gK7@CGVBW4 *@ ;K "X(6P ¢PQ4 8$K7N*T¡; AIPB V9@.;PW4D@(8K K H@ 5=YPGzNA;CPQ4CI4CPW;CPQJK7@(Y9G HJ)T GVN 9NG;D@&5 w;C6P A9K@ GHB4 *@.;DK /KONgJK74CP;6P?8KOGVN ¦PQKp;94P5 ;6P?@ ;C49B¸;94CPK7IKO4C; ¦4578 ;C6PI VK7NP@.;4C9B;C94P. \'. rP. <. +/. :/*). kD 0)9),'. 7F. 1/. <. ('. 1/. a-. D. < +). )9'. +D. *@. -. :2. 1/. *@_5d. +D. ). +D?D. @ 5. '. >5a. 0/-. +). a. ). 4D. +). <. 7F. . 5q. ). 1). <. r<. 1/. 4D. *D. @. 1/. @. +). D. (/>'. D. +D. ). +D. 2. ,). /*'. Fo. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60. 9/. :5. *)9),'. ÛÝUÕ0¯¿ "ÔÈ®ªD´ÉQÄg¬.²Aª¢ÈÅDÉQ´.Q²ª¸Ç7« W®g¨ÈÎAW«U³?ÐÉOÇ7ªD®ÇªDÅÉQ« W¬.ªDÇRÖÈÌ¬.² ¬¡ÖÉ0¬¡³7Ò*ªD´ÉWÄ"W¬.ÉLÐ´WÎ)Ç?¬.²Aª&áwªC«.ÏLÐ?QÎ7Ë¦¬¡³7Ò*ª¢ÅD®Æ´¬.ª«¸¯ /Ò«.ÉQË ®z¬.ª=«.²AÉQÐ¨*ÉQ²Aª¸ÇO«.ÉLÎ2¾_®ªÄV¬CÂWÎ)ÇnÉLÄ®¬.ª$«.²AÉLÐ0¨*ÉL²ª¸Ç7«.ÉQÎ ¾H«.ÈÏQ²O¬CÂC¯ «.²ÉLÐ¨ÈÅsÇ7ÉOÇªDÅDQ²AªDÇ7«.ÉLÎ?¾_®ªÄz¬CÂQÎAÇ&¬.²ª ¬.ÉLÐ´¨ÆAÈ®Ç7Ë ÈÎÏ¬.²ª=ásª«.ÏLÐ?WÎË¦¬¡³7Ò*ª?ÅD®ÆA´¬.ª«$¾H«.ÈÏQ²p¬CÂÈÎA²ª«.ªDÎp¬ÈÎ¬.²AªRÐÉOÇªD® ØOÆAQÚÈÅ«U³7´¬ Q®_¯ ÓOÐ?Q®®ÏQ«.ª³eWÎ)Çe®«.ÏLªÄ®WÅCÞnÚÒA²ª«.ªD´RÇªÎAÉQ¬.ª$Ê QÎ)Ç:áW¬.ÉQÐ´«.ªÚÒ*ªDÅ¬.È¶ªD®Ì³p¯ Ë. cÌ\ÍÎsÏ. Ð;Í+ÑÑÍ7ÒoÏ. http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/pm-pml. ¼ÓÔ.