Extinction Coefficients retrieved in Deep Tropical Ice Clouds from Lidar Observations using a CALIPSO-like Algorithm compared to In-Situ Measurements from the Cloud Integrating Nephelometer during CRYSTAL-FACE

HAL Id: halsde-00136133

https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/halsde-00136133

Submitted on 12 Mar 2007

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Extinction Coefficients retrieved in Deep Tropical Ice Clouds from Lidar Observations using a CALIPSO-like Algorithm compared to In-Situ Measurements from the

Cloud Integrating Nephelometer during CRYSTAL-FACE

Vincent Noel, David Winker, Tim Garrett, Matthew Mcgill

To cite this version:

Vincent Noel, David Winker, Tim Garrett, Matthew Mcgill. Extinction Coefficients retrieved in

Deep Tropical Ice Clouds from Lidar Observations using a CALIPSO-like Algorithm compared to In-

Situ Measurements from the Cloud Integrating Nephelometer during CRYSTAL-FACE. Atmospheric

Chemistry and Physics, European Geosciences Union, 2007, 7, pp.1-8. �halsde-00136133�

Extinction Coefficients retrieved in Deep Tropical Ice Clouds from Lidar Observations using a CALIPSO-like Algorithm compared to In-Situ Measurements from the Cloud Integrating Nephelometer during CRYSTAL-FACE

!"#"$%'&()*+-,/.%0%1234(!"!5,6378

9:.;%(.<=>%(@?A!5BCDB%EFGAIH.JKGLMNOP..QR.SMT%1.

&UWVYXVZ9:.-F[3H \]Q(.%1_^a`AUD%(6V/bcXV

4b >de[fgb/D.^ba)'b XV

8UYVYX[Vh,6??.%(?cXi.AT>F^P`*Dj%([,@%(j;kD!l9:b XmV

XM;JkD?@=*n6o>p qrtsuvwSx3y/z{uvp xrjo|c}~6€uS|rSxGyjr

`*m%D%(QEim?m-F.SM=^%j

N_U

9:.;%(.<=>%(@?A!‚BSDBm%DmF3A H.J3LMAƒ=OX9

„…m†AO'>HUD^GLM

‡ˆS‰gŠ@OP.3._Q1.CMT%(.

dR‹3Œ53J?g‹i>HDN_^3LMf%

)'^Q i.ij%{i%(UQ((Q:./mJIi.%( Q1mKf'G3?.% %(.C=gQ:.?adm[kMJK6=C=†mKf0fE33(Q =%DmiN.

3lM?[Q( %1C=%EdN?5MQ(F";Q(%Edm.CE†mQcf%([J Y >gQ==%0MJK_U(Qj =^-‰0J zGq €uS|grSx3y_r

x7}wE`{O9(.?=^Y7 Q(kM z3q<~ov gw<}ox7~!#" vGsuv$GqpIvUo7vwD`…ƒ%*i%(;&]=^ [Q==%0MJK(Q

a%( JYMDN? .>%E;mm%E i.CDf=%EJcQ ?M%(F =^ `{\('KX[)'V@9)TV `{„ .J i.7F .? m$

JK.Q0M%(JK(Q Mi= *$[Jc`*73?:;gQ1%0d.SE[Q f%([J Y .Q1Q*[f 3 M?eQ*†[.SD?cm

=ihmf ?i mUdC=>d QEHgQ0DJcQ .%(‚J ig.j%(?gAT>%SQ0D/73?.% %(.C=†eQ .%( %(C%Ed? f%(J `{O9

;gQ(j%0d.CDgQ:mf .C3DM.SD?a;m.$Q(.CDj%EmMQ(-Fc.@%(C=%=Gdm._e._F%(k=^J f=m%:mi.NLM6†M?cQ(GJ3.%'D

lMQ(? =^ %(UE>H 3.CM^? `AV 9 ƒ0O:X+ JWQSQ( .? J i.%(? D %(UQ0Mk(Q f%(J =^

%(FM.%]`{O 9 ._F%(k=^Jc)'^Q(3G?.j% %(.C=†eQ].%( MQ(U? = %(2=%Ddc=SE [f=fE3GU*i%Ef=G3Q(

I^G^ .%(Y[JIi.%(?D .<M.;Q1%Ed.CD[Q f%([J =^K`ƒ 7<Q(kM i%1;m iM3=7-F =^Y_JYi^.Q(0Q

a=^>%{d%0=†.ed.j% 3.;Gk=H#"^K;gQR%0dm.CDmgQ:G?N[%(C=%E3d.Qf=%([J ;=^gQ0=%0MJa_U(Q:.%R

dj%1H Q(GJK73.%1W =^Z3Jk(Q [f [N.C=g YfEfD%RUQ .%( Fj%(.7H d.%(3.C=gQ .j%(M? =^

.Cdm%(.F i%([f=3Q1 .? F%1._*=%(?[QKm‚3.%EF%cQEi.C=./QR.GUQc.%1,a %(i%1[?MN?g)'^ I

gQ0=%0MJY(Q5.F%(-a73YkD^ . .d%1.F ?m3f0fD%R fl3Q<Q =^. /. miU=U. ?[i=^

%(C %Ed.QS\]Q=Mgk(Q*Q=MFFQ==^/`…V@9 ƒ0O:X+ YNic`*dNCE†mK.Fm%E=^J .W;m]=%0MQD?6 ?>d%

%(.Q0D@Q=EJK.CDQ fg=^@G?.j%'%(.C=m†.?7F WF? %(<=%Edm._Q fˆ/D7CDma[f=f033(QS

1. Introduction

`At%E%0MQ M?[Q .%( ^F^Y.kDkM?@M?[Q JYgQ0=>HKN[J ieQ1? fˆU@%EHQ0D.QSX[NA=^HYNmgQ(Q0DjD7H

d% JYm%1 =^.h . fW=^ U.%0=^

Q Q0M%(f=.U # HG3‚C . j‡‡1]=^_t% [fE>MN =^

%(.?.CD ;M?FC/.j ;m dj% †[$? <XDi^gQYS/.6j‡‡ R')'^c%(.?3.C=>d fE>M [f].

F†dmc>%E%0MQ…M?K?i?gQJYQ0=>H [ =^/?[3.SD];m._3.U ;mCak(Q…._>;?c.j?F%(^MQ1

f0fDC(Q1g.?gmK.@. Q1.3gYk(QJY3%(i^HgQ(3U..?i=.[i%1mi%==QSU!‚gQ0'=.;Hm=^

LM.UEk=Hamf Q0MGF[^U%(f=GNCD?6;HK.@%E%0MQ M? E.?I=^UMQ k(Q .>;?f=fDC GQ ?7%1CD†HIEN?ID k(Q

i=. =^3$QSQ

τ

τ

α

 =^ dj%0=3.lDF%1.C= f k(QZD7CDm

f=fE3_3

α ( )

?>%(CD>Hh?i? m"k(Qcd%0=†. i%(f03G‚[f $-=CD N[f=f033_UR V F?Z$I?F‚[f

-ESE f0f=3GU(Q( .? =^MQ‚i=N._ ?i=^ >%D%0MQ‚M?eQ aM? 3.? D . ;C3D%

Q==7JK.CDYfe=^7%'Fj%(..†;N?f=fENCR

/M =^ ^F^ ._EkM? f@>%E%0MQIM?[Q(?>%(NC@x>~lr2xolJYU.Q=M%(JU@fA=^>% J3%1mi^HQ(GN.

i%(iC%=Q/Q .c?fEfE3CMk*D.QE$ =^.C].*;iM%<Q=MN? . QEHQ0DJK.CE† ;m.Q(Q2e!5m%(Ndm%('7 =^

=%DmiUQ 3YM?[Q .%(Y[fGD .CD?c=i mf:?i mUdSE>dQEHQ0DJcQ( Q(UY‹Fg,/.%E%(<G…<:.

‰( I^3^ JK.gQ ^F^E.kDkM? ;Q(%Ed.SE[QZ.%( . UUQSQ(k0H&].CMQ( [f =^% 3.%EF

^%(UD.:._? dm%0D.*DQ([gQ1 =^Q1 QEHQ0DJcQ/^.d . 3.%EF (Q(.3 %1.?m3.CD>d JYi.C]m =^

i.C Q=M%(f=. .? .SEJYgQEi^%( Y.j%0=JK._ C .=lj‡‡‰Ec.j? =^_t% %(N.CE†m =^%(MF^ f=.Q0

dmS=mK3.?gQ QDi7fDG/JW3%1mi^HQ(G/.?Kmi=U.i%(mij%=UQ!‚T.%(LM^.j%.?aHJ Q(fDG3?

j‡‡YHJcQ(fE3G? .? !‚T.%1LMg^.%(@j‡‡ SebIf=%0M.CDj†Hm a^ ?MCDF‚Q(.CDGkD Q=M?m†Q

MQ(F i.UQSQ(†dY%(JYD Q(j[Q(F k*Q@fGD ?mfEfDGSMgk:= Q1i.%(.CDK. i=U.7H =^7 GNM? 3.Hj%

f%([J .WM?j% HF mdmCD>dQEHgQ=D_Ja JKU._F ^F[^YMgj%0D.DQ*=^ %(C=%E†Ndm.Q(D`A^>%(3.U

C:.m‰2[)'^Q@Q0=%(UQ<Q(UQ{=^YN? f=%*.CD>d6%1_J DWQ(j[Q(FˆQ0Me_^ .Q 73?.%( I^gQ(WQR[Q(E>dkEH

O3.CGD@j‡* /.? N._ F[>d dm._>M.;3 gQ(F[^U(Q6UD 3 _†M? J3%(i^HgQ(3Q GK[ C].ˆ‰2

9:?[.j%'%(C%Dd._Q fD7CDma[f=f033(Q .%1@._a_f=f(S=†dmADmf=%Q0M?HF =^@i=†.?i=^a[f

3YM?gQ M:f{%(N.^ mf Q(M ;gQR%=d.CDgQ(ˆ.j? .%1a*Q=M;RC = i.QRQ(>d %(JYD Q1[Q(F

G3JkD.S=mgQ1[.UQˆ=^ d.%(3.;G3k0Ha[fDCDY_f=f=G(Q Q ;gQ(j%1dm?Y.Q . fMCDYmfiS=%(.C=[

gQ(3?5=^ M? .H%S !5m%(Ndm%( =^--‰0J Q(i.NN;mm%D G?.j% "=^ f%(.JK Y%E$ mf=^

`V 9 ƒ=OX+ JKQRQ([ 0#"$%‚C .Y‰ Q CM%E%(U=†H i%(?MF %(C=%E†Ndm.Q [f DCD[

f=fE3_3(Q].? =^UMQ@i=. ?i=^gQ] .YF[;.AQRN._†'d f=m%*=%Ei. GNM?eQ]mcDi f

i=.37H/=^Gj$NmdmCD†dm6QEHgQ=D_JcQ2

ƒE6=^ i%1Q( Q=M?H.CGDUM.CD?6;.U$gQ1.CD%'i%Df03GQ ;gQ1%Ed?K?iY=%EiU.g3/_†M?[QˆMQ(F

=^ z 3ql€uS|rSxGyr x}w,E`{O9Ym +(MgH ‰gŠK.?5‰‡K?M%(7-F5=^ z…xw<w mr v x3q~}oS| q

wSqEs*x3y} n]~Nx7rc}~ZzxGw<w r

}S|vwSr GqwSx} n wjv}Zzx7wSw/r0s*vwSxp vj~o E`{\ 'KX){V 9)0TV/`:„…

+SQ( S .g‰@.%1aMQ(N? = %(<=%Ed33?.% %(.S=eQ1 MQ(F =^`AV@9 ƒ0O:X+YNi `*mdmUC=

%(C %Ed.._F%(k=^J D#Z7$j%( ‰ S\]Q=Mgk(Q .j%(YJYi.%(?= %12%Ed. QMQ(Fc=^ %(FM.% `{O9

.>F% =^JYA=^ YkD^ .SM._@2Q(Mh;Q(%Edm.CE†mQcf%([J =^l.%E;%E 7†g.CD?‚i%E; z 3q

<~ov gw<}ox7~! "/vGsuv 3qp v_o7vw D`…ƒ@,/.%E%(SGK<K. ‰ S*)'^l`{\('KX[) V 9)DTV/`{„ .JYi._F 0Q

i%(Q1DN?5 XSR ‰*.F Yk=^ =^ gQ0=%0MJa_U(Q6MQ1? ;Hl=^ i%(Q1_UYQ0M?H ) ^ `V 9 ƒ=OX+

ai `*dCD %1C=%Ed. .Fm%(k=^J Q i%1Q(DN? .? k(Q %(Q0Mk(Q][J i.j%(? YE^ %(Q=Mgk(Q]f%(gJ

=^ `:O9 .Fm%Dk=^J XCR/g 9†?.% %(.C=† %(S=%ECdm._Q .%15=^ MQRN? = %(2=%Dd DCD[

f=fE3_3]i%Ef=G3Q XCR ^†_^ .%1 J ig.j%(? l Q(kM `ƒ ;gQ1%Ed.CD[Q2 YQ(CMQ<Q(†e

.?WNm_>MQ(Y.%( F>dY7 X[NCR

2. Volume extinction coefficient retrievals during CRYSTAL-FACE

)'^/`:\('KX){V 9)0TˆV/`{„ .JYi.F[ a.Q^_3?+(MgHc‰‰ dm% T%E?./._?a=^6, Mgf fˆ!‚3

.? .JK? D i%Dd? =^"[J i%1^[Q(>d JU.QEM%1_Ja_U(Q N?? D ;mCDS% M?%RQ0D.? =^

J3%1mi^HQ(GN._ .? %(.N?m3.CD>d i%(i% =3Q .? f=%(JY.C=ci%([NQ<Q1Q f3M?[Q mDi mf'=^3$

dmS=†d M?ZQEHQ0DJQ2 T>d J3?6=‚^>F[^E.kD†M? .t%(%(.fGa.%E%E3? MJK%(MQYx7~‚rSxo .?

%(JYDWQ(j[Q(F gQ==%0MgJa_U(Q( Yk=^ Q(3J MgkD.MQ:F%(M?;m.Q(? ;gQ(j%1dm.CDmQSV6JYFc=^Q1[=^

YVYX[V z 3q €uS|r2xGyr

x7}w `{O9:. =^-%( a.CdF=^ D JY -‰ J .? j J

;.N$ Q1.CD%:73?.% !‚,/GGPC:.g‰‰( Y.Q*†[$F ?I a.%(?cf%([J =^@VYX[V „ \ 0‰ .>%R%(.fG

IF ._?c.‰ *.?i%1d?? Q1Ndm%(.?.HgQ*f ;Q(%0dm.CDmgQ*f%1[J .Q*^F^c.Q:‰$[JY Y=^ .

dj%0E†.'%(Q(kME†m [f* J .? . ^m%D_mUD._%(Q1m>MDm f‰ J .C=^ H-i[3U.ˆ„{\ 0‰ f=7HF

QEiN? f‰ J >QE)'^K`{O 9 D_3Q1if033? mfd QKj

µ

3Q<Q =^._ JYCDj% Y?{k- %(MF^>H j DJUQWQ(JK.G3% =^. `AV 9 ƒ0O:X+

QS) ^Q/Nmf=FM%(.CDm

.a? Mg3LM6JYkDm%D7-Fc[f'†/M?[Q.CD?K DmiYf =%DiGN._emdmCD>d QEHgQ0DJcQ( ^3^

aM? ; GJYigQ<Q(>;g3 f%([J =^lF%(M?Z;m.CMQ(‚mf =^5 a% 3.Hj%<Q [f =^3$ Y.SD% M?[Q

;$7F =^cG3?.% iC=%(.C=ggT%(J =^Y%(. ;.$gQ(.CDS%(? .Q1%@GF^ JY.Q0M%1? ;H =^c`:O9

DQ1miNei%Di% =†Q…mf:M?c._? .N%(gQ( 3.Hj%<Q .%(6%(C %E3Cd?7†M?F=^ .kDkM? [f M?

;.Q1 .?hM? =i6(Q miU=U. ?i=^

τ

i[3.? !5,6G3C:.0‰ (.? 3Q;.QR?cW=^WQ0D.j?.%(?3?.%*d%<Q(WD^3LM D‹F

Xi[^>%( C].@j‡[Š- I3C=@j‡[Š/Sg# ^ igQ<Q(>;3 1 >ˆf=%/i=.37H =^ M?[Q 1P=^ 3G?.j%

=^-%EMF^ . %(.j[Q(JQSQ(EgQSQYD^3LMS{#"^5=^QcQcYieQRQE>;3 E*f=m%Ki=U.7H‚=^3$

M?[QQ0M^ .QYdUC=>dm QEHQ0DJcQ ( ‚GQIi%(dG?U? ;m_† jS` ;H‚. LM.N?%(.CD fGMgCE†m [f

DJ ij%(.CM%( ak=^ } U‰*‡ E =‰k[Š-‡$ .?Zy U-‡

Y†.Nd$. i%(>d.CDlJYJ Mg3U.C= ‰ ! .CW. a.NdmG-F=^"mf -‰"J E. ?fEfEj%(KLM.?%1.C=3

fMgCE†m Q6MQ1? .C j J 2PT m%@DJ i%1.CM%(Q Y.%(JYj%6=^. j<`*{=^ dm._>M @ *g>Š Q

MQ(N?gV dm%EH Q(3J3G.j%WD^3LMlQYMQR?Y^_ ..†HU7FZ;QR%0d.C=gQcf%(J =^ QEi.U;%E

vqrSyx3v~yv }rSvwn ox7pIvUo7vjw S|grjovp Y.7HKS'.‰‰S

)'^/`…ƒ i%(;m a.Q*JYMgUD? =^ # & *.%(%(.fGD I^3^%a.Q:.;3]Df=7HY=^-%(MF^ =^ DmiKf

D.dNCE>dmWQEHgQ=D_JcQ'=^.-$gQ D(Q{^F^KGF DMiY=lŠI$J S)'^/`ƒ JK.UQ0M%(Q:D7CDm

f=fE3_3(Q f%1[J =^ Q1.CD%E-F [f M? i.%0=†_Q f . J 3.QRj% F^ 7UD Q1gQ(%<Q1

[Q(Q0DF f %(CM3.%/7F^ E?f0fMQ(F ?mQE$Q/.? i^=J6MkEti[3Gj%<Q E,/%E;%/S@.'‰ <)'^Q1

Q(Q(%<Q JK.Q=M%(=^ f=m% Y.%1? Q(.SGD%(N?l.? ;.$QR.C3D%(? 7F^ ;Ca"jK.? * <f%(J

I^G^=^Idm[kMJKW-ESEci.%(.JYSD%* Q fEj%E%(? ;m.Q(N? . Q0=JK.CDYmf'=^Y7F^:f=%Y.j%(?

Q(N.CDC%1?a;HK?GfDf%(.UC=„*Lg*K,/%E;%:C .j[‰ SgX/?Gf=f0%(.NCE†mK Q:UQSQ1.%(7H m6^.Gf

f QRN.CGD%1?Y%DFmHm=^@[JYkD? f%(.CDY Q:gQ0=%1.?K._?WQ:Q0DJK.CD?6= ;@g * gk‰-)'^

Yj% =^-%(Q(^?lf=m%I -ESElJK.Q=M%(JY ;H =^ `ƒ a.Q g J jc.? =^ Q0DJ.SD?

MN%0D.=H 7c=^YJK.UQ0M%(JK(Q ?M%(F `{\('X)'V 9)TˆV/`{„ a.QY !. f=%d._MQ fDCD[

F%(.SD%{=^.j .N;mM…gˆ6JUg)'^Q %E%(% Q0=JK.CD ^.Q@Q(W;N_cd.3G?.SD? MQ(F F%(M? ._?

.>%E;%E6=%(.j[Q(JQRQ([JKCD%*i%D;mQ(E,/%0;m%( ‰* ,/.%E%(C3=‰* E ^3^ .%(YGUQSQ@Q(gQ(kD†d6=^._

=^@`ƒ ;MP.S%(@=t%(7HYfEt%CQ=i%Ei[3Q2

3. The CALIPSO Deep Convection Algorithm

1. Lidar ratio retrieval

T%/.Q0D;.j$gQR.CDS%@73?.%RQ(ˆd[kMJKcD7CDm f=fE3GU i%Df03GUQ

α

;gQ(j%0d.CDgQ:[f'.CDjM.CD? ;.j$gQ(U.CGDj%{i%Dmf=G3Q

β

=^A;m.$Q(.SD% .?Y -ECE†mYN[f=f033_U(Q JaMQ=;/.Q<Q=MgJK?g +6fGDY?f0?Y.Q

= α β

=^ 3?.%

%(.C=†[=^-QP%(.CDmYQ .QRQ0MJK?6 Q=D.CHamQ0D.U Yk=^Y.@M?W.Hj%S

)'^ JK.F[M? [fˆ=^ 3G?.j%%(.C= ?i?[Q…mY=^YJ3%(i^HgQ(3.i%(i%0=Q…[fˆ=^I_†M?g;M:7

JK.H‚.Q1Q U. ;m %(C=%Dd? f%([J .CDUM.CD? ;m.$gQ(.SDC%I;Q(%=d.CDgQ .ˆƒ( =^ %(M-=

.._HgQRQf `AV 9 ƒ=OX+ ;gQ1%Ed.CD[Q(?mfEfD%( .>F%EkD^JcQ.j%(]MQ1??jig?F m =^/i.k0HW[f

=^K.C=JYgQEi^%(c3.H%S[T m%/Q(JY =%(.[QDi.%(A_†M?[Q1'.a=%(.Q(JYkD.UK._F%Ek=^J Q MQ(?ˆ;.UQR?

a=^6?f0fD%(/7c3?.%{%1CM%EcQ(>F.f%([J _3U.% %(FgQ.;mdm6.?W;m =^ M?G.Hm%SƒE

=^ .Q( mf f MGH .C3DM.SEF .Hj%CQ1Q0M^ .Q ?Ui =%Ei. =^$ NmdSE>d"QEHgQ0DJcQ(6=^

=%(.Q(JYkD.NW.F% =^J N._ ;Y.ii3?ˆ.Q=^ G.Q1% .:iC=%1.2D =^ fGMg3ˆ3.H% .?

Q(>F.6Q .Ndm.G3.;Gl;H[?5=^ _†M? 3.H%S*V/"LM.C= . ;ml?%(>d?a^G^ %1_†.CDQY=^

M?1UDF%(.<D? .<GDUM.CD?5;m.$gQR.C3D% QD>F._

γ

O'†.C<'.j'j‡‡‡ j

γ

−

η

/

I^%(

η

=

Q( =^.C

γ

η

/)'^ 3?[.j% %(.C= ."=^MQ ; %(C=%E†Ndm? f%([J G3?.% i%1mf=GQ mf .CDjM.CD?

;.N$ Q1.CD% .? . Q0DJK.CDf

η

%(C %Ed DCD =^ DigQ fK?ihdUC=>d‚M?[Q D#Z7$j%( ‰ 2 )'^GQ .7F%Ek=^J

^JYmFjMQ JY3%(i^HgQRGN._‚N[J igQ(kE†m =^%(MF^M‚=^ M? .Hm% Q( =^ G3?.%

iC=%(.C=YQ{3JkD?YYmi=†.G7H/=^3$KdCD>d QEHgQ=D_JKQˆ=^Q{Q . %1.Q(.;[email protected]

2. Lidar ratio retrieval on July 29 ^th

+@ + M7H ‰‡1c. `{\ 'KX){V 9)0TV/`:„ JYQSQ(†[ f=NMQ1? . Q(JK._3 QR.3 dUC=>d QEHQ0DUJ

!5,6GC ._‰ =^.C /D?[?^m%(_mUD._Hcd%/jW$J .? MiDa=^ =%Dmimi.CMQ1 =^7F^j%

=^.j $J ( JY.F5=^ ^F^Q0KQ(Cdm%(. $G†[JcCDj%<Q Yj%( mJIieQ1? f 3 %EHgQ=D. Q2`{O9

;gQ(j%0d.CDgQK[fI.CDM.SD? ;m.$Q(.SD% ;Ca N‡ Š .? j‡‰ .%(5Q(^I‚7‚TˆF/ .Q .

fMgCE†m mf=JKc.? .kDkM?' .†mF.%(kD^JY3cm†m%/Q(U.G-[6M%(F =^Q =JKf0%1._JK =^a„ \ 0‰

.%D%1HF =^ `{O9 f03 d%@=^ dmCD†dm QEHQ0DJ . Q0=%1._tF[^U@.?l`{Oˆ9 ;Q(%Ed.S=mgQ

QE^ =^W mi mf=^ QEHgQ0DJ %(Q(Q/f%(J S‰ $J .C]†(Q ?FQ*= Jam%( =^. $J 7 k(Q/U=%(.

.%(N.[jeQ1AD =^@NmUdCD>d@UD%S-) ^@`:O9 a.Q .C;3AD iS=%(.2D=^@M? G.Hm% .C.Q0 m

$7†[JKCD% ;f=%( =^ 3.Q(% Q(>F._ a.Q [J i3NDj†H .C3DM.SD? T>F /15;M 3?_U

;gQ(j%0d.CDgQ f%1[J =^ E Q=^ Ie9: C…. ‰(.GQ( JYMD? =^

„ \ =‰eQD^ =^-Q M?QEHQ0DJ Dj??Y?I6=@=^6Q0M%DfE.N

)'^ 33?.%Y%(.CDeQY%1C=%Ed?‚?M%(7F =^ Q(.JK DJf=%(.JYl.j%(lQ(^ TF{‰MQ(F =^ `:O9

.>F% =^J E;3.U$*.?W=^ `AV@9 ƒ0O:X+ ai `*mdmCDm .>F%(k=^J ?Q(%(>;? .;d Ec%(? 2

&].CMQR f6=^ Q(JK._@fE33? fad3 [f =^l`{O9 gQ0=%0MJYa.?5=^ .%(QRQK[f@=^lM?

J MgEiG Q1.CD%D7-F Q gQ(7FGfDGN._UD6.j? =^ G?.j% %(.S= LM.S=m „*LgY/ .‚; Q(GJYiGfE3U?

=

γ

CM%E%1 Q0M?HcD `V 9 ƒ0O:X+ %(S=%E3Ndm. Q].Q@fD.% .Q].Wd.73? J MkD7i3 Q1.CD%E-F %E%(<= f=.UC=%*Q

.Cdm._33.N;3 a^WMQ(F=^ fGMg3[„…Lg /?M%D7-F=^ `*V69 ƒ0O:X+ .j.7HQ( Q2){^ I Q(S(Qfˆd.kMeQ*.%1

dj%1H Q(GJ33.%(6JYgQ0K =^l‰ %(.FN Y=^ Q1mJK M=Gj%cim(QKMiZ Š-AƒE‚=^ i.LM

i%=[Q f'=^M?e=^Y.F%(JY…GQAdj%1H F[?g.%=^YM? N?FQ(=:mi.LM (edm._MQ

i%(.<=m.g?AMQ(UQ . JY%(@.ii%(i%E†.CDA%(.j[Q(JD.U ;m.Q(? %(C=%Dd.=

)'^ Q(.JK [J i.j% Q1m a.Q:?MSD?K._3M?G.Hm%<Q:?[SDCD?YW+(MgHK‰‡ g.j?c Q(3J3G.j%

;gQ(j%0d.CDgQ Ja.?[Yc+ M>H ‰gŠ

) ^W.dm%(.FY?7fDfE%(Y.? k(Q@Q=D.?.j%(? ?d3.CD .%(QE^Y

c. F.%(k=^JYGQ1.G cTˆF.Q*. fGMCDc[fˆ^ JGJ MJ NmQ(G?j%(?ci=.?i=^

τ

#"^_ gQ(?%(7-F .GP_†M? 3.H%<Q

τ

+ M>H ‰gŠ( Q(^a7-F =^ ai `AdNCE†m .Fm%=kD^J 3.N?[Q5D M-%(.Q0D3 %1Q0Mk(Q Q0M^

?kDmQ('.Q]$iCD?ga YCdm%('.Q

τ

jWf=%

τ

τ

τ

TF{ QD^ Q/=^.C =^ `V@9 ƒ0O:X+ ai‚`*dCD .Fm%Dk=^J Q aG@Q0MkD? D =^ Q=M?H f

i=.37H/=^Gj$M?W3.Hj%<QS

3. Extinction retrieval

bKQ(7-F =^ `{Oˆ9 .CDUM.CD? ;m.$gQ1.CD%];Q(%Ed.SE[Q<XSR'g I.? =^c%(C%Dd?lG?.j%6%(.S=eQ

<XC1'g‹‰ ( k/GQ/ieQRQ(>;g3Dl%(2=%Dd=^ .SM._ i.%0=CM3.CD;.$Q(N.CD%

β ( )

f%([J =^ Y0$ Yf=% Y.j%(?Q(kM=6D =^@3?.% LM.C= OP.CS.'j‡* j

β ( )

^β

( )

%

−

η

β

(

#)!*#

( )

0‰

Yk=^

β

( )

3.H%)E=^/M?aDif=%.@.?%Em$Fc33?.%G3$]=^6`{O9SV Q'=^@F[.f =^Q Q0M?HQ…._

i%(.<=m.6d.73?.C=h[fW=^ `V@9 ƒ0O:X + ai `*mUdCDh._F%Ek=^J RX[NCR@[/D . QEJYi[

.iiGN.CE†mYfg=^Q .7F%Ek=^J Y3Gi%(d3?@. F[? f=G%<Q='.jii%DJK.CDmYf=% J i.%(Q( iM%EigQ(Q2

+@;.U$gQ1.CD%@i-%Ef033Q

β ( )

α ( )

^β ( )

^⋅

( )

.Q(37H ;D.? f=m% .H F†d 3.Hj% <XCR G/S ) ^Q"D^3LM a.Q .ii[33? D `{O 9

;gQ(j%0d.CDgQ fˆ.SDM.CDN?I;m.$Q(.SD%'>Y3@M?gQ{f%1[J + M7HY‰gŠ .? ‰‡ <XCR-[‹‰S\]Q0Mk(Q

f…=^Q(c%(C=%Dd.Q a73{;i%(Q1D? .? [JIi.%(U? = Q(kM i%(;c;gQ(j%1dm.CDmQ =^c

Q(NCE†m

4. Coincident observations of extinction in cirrus clouds

/M% -F`{\('KX[) V 9)DTV/`{„…[>%E%=MQ M?[Q Y%1@;Q(%0dN?WJK.HY^M%<Qˆ;H =^@`{O 9 E6=^A„{\ 0‰

.? =^`ƒ Emc=^W# & * ( ;M JYgQ0 f{=^aD7JK =^;gQR%0dm.CDmgQ a%(c@QEJ MgD._MQS

)'^Q i.%0Kf =^ Q0M?H YGIf=[CMQ m =^li%(?[Q mf =JK Y^ =^ I [Q==%0MJY(Qa%(

fMgCE†mF Q(GJ MkD.MQ(7HK.?a=^>%'a.>%1%(.fG a%(@f0HF E^aQ1._JK/.%(.NeQ1a=^.S =^AI

gQ0=%0MJY(Q a%( Ja[kD%EF =^ Q(.JK _†M?g') lSd.>M.CD=^d.j% 3.;G3k=H f/ -ESE Yk(^

.kDkM?g.?a=^ %E%(.SE;SYjW%1Q=Mg(Qf=%([J ;m=^K7gQ==%0MJY(Q1g†H .QRQ Y^ =^@# &

* a.Q k=^j% G3J ;gF % ?Q(j?7F =^ _†M? .Hm%a%( [Q(3?%(N?gWOP%([?[Q f

;gQ(j%0d.CD fEk=F =^QI?Q(%(iDm f=%@+ M>H ‰gŠ .? ‰‡ .%(c?QR%(>;N? ){.;3lUeT m%/.N_^

`{O9‚i%(mf=G3%(?.CDQ…[fˆ=^Q=Miim%0=tFc„{\ 0‰ .%(%(.fG a%( N[J i.%(N? =^eQ1 mfˆ=^6# &

* =^l=7JKf%(.JK fc3?[N =^‚JY.GJWMJ ?_3.H";Ca ;m=^h.t%(%(.fG;m7F j

JMDQ2

VYQQ(N_ "XCR ‰'=^ +(Mg>H ‰gŠ .?l‰‡ .Q1Qa.%( H-i3. f =^ Q(JK.<Q1.G mdmCD>d

QEHgQ=DJQ@=^.C ?Cdi?lf%RLM=>H =^=%EiU.*.%(. JYmDm%(N?l?M%EF `{\ 'KX){V 9)0TV/`:„]

ImkMJK $-ECE†m f0fDG3(Q"%(S=%Ed? f%(J `{O9 ;.j$ Q1.CD%";gQ1%0d.C=†mgQ MQ(F =^

`V 9 ƒ=OX+ YNi `*mdmCDm .7F%Ek=^J <XSR[@.?cgk ….%(WQD^ cTF #=+ M†H ‰gŠ …._?

TF #0+ M>H ‰‡ (Y=^ =^W# & * .kDkM?.CAm_3?…im(Q i3D? dm%@ %(N? QEHJ ;m[QS

+@+ M7H ‰gŠ [=^6G?.j%iC=%(.<=c?i=^cQdm%EHd.%(.;3 W=JKWQ(.3Q*f{3QSQ =^. . JWMD

i%(f03QcQ(^ ?Ni% iS=%(.C= .?l%1.U_^hjl$[J E-F .%1M?l‰‰ * S )'^QcQ1JcQK?M D

%(.i? Q(JK.G2Q1.3Wd.%(3.CDmQ@ =^cQEi.CD. ?Q==%(†;-M=[ mf…_†M? a.CD%]DU()'^/D7CDm

f=fE3_3…Q F%1._37H c=^ j

j

J %(.F 0F%( mc=^K[%6Q1.S)'^cQ0M?U?

=JK_f%1._JK/mY+(MgHY‰‡0TF !Q(^KQ . Q0D.C;363G?.%'iC=%(.C=†mY?i=^ *$J K.Ndm%(.FNm;MP Q

3Q<Q ^[JamFMQ( Yk=^ Y3?%'d.j% 3.C=†mgQ Y%(C=%Ed?Y -ECE†m d.>MQEf%([J

×

S ƒEUDF%(.<=7-F =^Q( =C= i%(mf=G3Q/F[>dmQI.c^GF^H d.j% †.N;3EJK Q(%(3QImf]mi=†.?i=^gQ

0*QD^ ( Yk=^d.>MQ{=H-i[3.GHc%(.-F[Fc;CalI.? [V Q=^ i=.?[i=^ .ii%(.^Q

=^UQ(6^F^%d.>MQ1=^6%(C%Ed.Q;JY M%(3.N;3 f=% Ic%(.Q1mQj'/k GQYG$ Y=^.C

=^/f=m% a.%(?cQ(kM=W;mNmJKQ'M[Q0D.;3/.C'^>F^Kmi=3.?i=^gQ:.?N._Y;N[JY/?m>d%EFUO3.CG

C .6j‡[Š * (.j? ‰ =^ ;m.$Q(.SD%@%(<M%E Q(>F[.…;m[JaQ@d%EH aU.$ .? Q1 mCM%<Q([gQ

[f=>M6=^a%1C=%Ed? dm.†MQ2g)'^MQ@=CE†m _f=f=G3(Q].C* .kDkM?Q1 Q0Me^ .Q=^Wdj% H

^F[^ =SEgQK.C/=^ G.j%EFQ0IiC=%1.C=‚?i=^gQ =%(?‚ml=^l% Q1.3l7‚TˆF ".? !

QE^M? ;A=%(.<D? Ik=^Y.CMDg

T%N.^K`{O 9 i%(f03GNgD7CDmKf0f=3GU(Q a%(I =%(.NCD?Wf%1mJ =^/`ƒ ?.CD./.C=^@im>U f

gQ(Q=ˆ# & *K._?a„ \ 0‰c7G?+6K+ M7HK‰gŠ m=^ # & *a f%(J jY$[J .S'‰‰ /Mi

= $J .j%(M? ‰k,DT>F 1'.M?,a.Q/;gQRj%0d? ;Ca ‰‰ .? ‰‰- g=^W„ \ 0‰

fE3 dm%ˆ=^[email protected]%(. ;mCYNY‰‰I.? ‰kg) Q1.J i[3A=^6JK.$3J MgJ [fM?Y?.CD.=^

# & *-a.Q fGD QEi%(.7F gQ(3?"M? QEHQ0DJcQ( Y^3^ Q#Y^H D^Q1 i[(Q .j%( 7

^-%(m[F[†. %(?%S )'^ DCD";Q1%0d? ;H"=^ `ƒ ?M%(F =^Q ij% †[?" Q Q(^Ih.Q

QEHJ ;m[Q TFc.UQ*. f MSEcf .kDkM? Yk=^c^%EUD.g;.j%<Q Q(^Y-F=^ MU%0D.j7U0H)'^

.Cdm%(.F DCD i%(f03l%(C=%DGdm? f%(J `{Oˆ9 ;gQRj%0d.CDgQ ?M%(F =^ Q1._JK =JKf%(.J 0Q

QE^a fGMG37NP=^ QE^.N?[? .%1. Q(^ YF =^ QED.j?.%(? ?Cd3.CD .%(M? =^c.Cd%1.F) ^

.F%(N_Ja_U;Ca";=^ [Q==%0MJY(Q Q F[? ;Ca jg* .? $JY YE^h. .dj%(.F

?7f=fD%(U"[f g

×

.>F% =^J QI^eQD7-F .ii%(i% †.CDWd.>MQ/f=m%

&/ jg* $JY [.C=†m ;SY .>%R%1._fG

a.Q@/Q0Mf=fE3GU f=%/J i.%(Q(g) ^ 3?.% Q1UQ .%DFWd._MQ mf DCD Mi ="j J

? 6 jk $J Y^%(A=^6Q(7F.FC(QˆD.†HW.CDCUM.CD? 0%(.N?.% ?.2D.6QD^ Q=^@M?I;m.QR a.Q

.CM.j7H J M^ a% SWT m% [N.CD? Ja.Q0M%(JK(Q1 =^ =JK ?fEfEj%( .? ^%(UD.U

?GQ0D.N ;SY .%(%(.fGZ.%( "jm%D%(.CDN? IkD^ ?m3f0fD%(U 7 DCD f=fE3GU(QS

ƒEUDF%(.<=7-Fl;=^ `:O9 .? `ƒ i%(f=73QImf]D7C=[ f0f=3GU/d%@=^ %E%(j.CD? %(FmgQ

jg*a5 Y$J *3U.?[Q=c%(QDiC=>d i=.'?i=^Q

τ

?%(>d? d.>M Q//. G.j%EF%ˆ=^.ja=^@`ƒD?%(†dm?adm.†MNYE^ =^@JK.Q0M%(JKMj%0D.7U=3Q

f6=^ Y gQ0=%0MJa_U(QS*)'^Q ?mfEfD%(lQ FGGF>;3l7 %(.?G.SE>d D%(JcQ( F†dm =^l3GJYk1?

iC=%(.C=Y[fg=^@`{Oˆ9 UƒEUDF%(.C=F =^@`{Oˆ9 D= i%([f=36d%ˆ=^6fGMG3.NHm%EjaD

$J 6F>dQY. JaM^ ^>F^%6dm.†M [f

τ

Q(>F.*.? =^ [email protected]%0]mf*=^ci%(mf=G3 Q/i%(;.;7H M%(3.;g3')'^ `ƒ ?CDS(QWQ1mJa

-ESE f0f=3GU(Q

α <

×

%(.?gQ(M?FgQ 3.CM^? .C@‰ f%(J ){.JYi.{‰*g*KAŠU‰g# =^.C/?-l].ii.%/ =^

G3?.%*%(S=%Ed.Q(0TˆF [=^Q( d.>MQ .j%(6d%EH gQRI =^Y`…ƒ Q(W3d

×

QE^M?Yg;@[Q(†?[%1?Y.Q .CM.ji.%0DGUQS

+6Y+(MgH‰‡ m=^ # & * KPf%([J S‰I$[J .C'‰aMiW l $J .C'‰m=^j? Ic.F.G

.C:‰S‰, %1? QEHJ ;[Q 7 TˆF !Sg`ƒ ;Q(%Edm.CE†mgQ f-ESE.d%(.jF? dj% .kDkM? ;7gQ

?M%(FW=^3Q{ij% †[? T7F* .%1aQD7JKG3.%'=K`:O9 %(C%DGSd.Q MQ(FW=^6`V@9 ƒ0O:X + ai `*mUdUC=[

.>F% =^J =^ 3.%EF %D%(m%/;.%<QY `ƒ -ESEgQY.j%( ?M D =^ Q0DjU [fYQ(dj%(. ?.SD.

i7U(Q 7K.6Q(FG/.kDkM?]; S`*gQ(Q0DUak=^ TˆF -^>F^K$-=C=N[f=f033_U(QE3.%EF%ˆ=^._

j

J .j%(@;Q(%Edm?g &]=^ i%(f03Q .%(@YF[? .F%(N_Ja_U'f%(J _†M?6=i Y$J ? 6D

G3?.% ;gQR%=d.CDgQ .C S‰K$[J Q@?M6D D.'Q(7F.P.CDM.S=mˆ.Q*%(.?.j% ;Q(j%0d.C=gQ6Q(^ .

Yj%*M?;.Q1[V Q*=^ +(Mg>H ‰gŠA.QR`{O9‚%(=%Ed.Q*.%1a^F^7Hcdm.%(G.;3 .C: .kDkM?Q

E‹Fg; j $J ( ?MW= YN.$ QE>F. ._? =^cGGJKkD?lQ0D.S;GG0H [f=^cd%<Q([ ._F%Ek=^J

ƒEUDF%(.<=m mf DCD i%(f=G3Q@3.?gQAD dj%1H ^GF^ mi=U. ?i=^Q E) .C;3‰j * .j? [Š-

%(QDiC=>d7HKf=% =^6`{O9‚.?a=^6`ƒ )'^Q1 d.>MQ.j%(6NmQ( Q=D =^a=^6fGMG0i%(f0336i=U.U

?i=^ f=m%*+(M†H ‰gŠ S) ^ Q(3F[^UE>H Yj% i=U.?i=^ f%1[J `:O9ZD7CDmgQ Q [Q(Q0D

Yk=^/=D.G3?.%Q(>F..CDUM.C=g

5. Discussion and conclusion

)'^QcQ=M?H i%(UQ((Qa. [J i.j% Q1m ;Caldm[kMJK D7CDm‚N[f=fE33_U(QY;gQ1%Ed? f%1[J .

`ƒ (Q(kM i%(; .?%(C=%(d.Q*f%([J 3G?.j%…;m.$gQRU.C3D%EFci%(f=G3Q RX[NCR‰<)'^%(Im_3?

;gQ(j%0d.CDci%(?[Q .%(YJ i.%(?^F[^37F^DFc=^6d.j% 3.;Gk=H YkD^ .kDkM? <X2RS\]Q=Mgk(Q

QE^ .@d%EHYF[?.jF%(JY;CaW;m=^K7gQ==%0MJK(Q1gf=m%: DCDK[f=fE3GU(QAQ1[JYCDJKQ

.Q: .QIj

J TˆF‰2) ^Q*3JWi3Q'=^ `AV@9 ƒEOX+ ai `AdC=†m ._F%(k=^J Q:?[-F .

F? (; .C Q1_†CD7-F G3?.%/%(.C=gQ f=%/i.LM M?[QSY YSd%(ˆ=^QIm†MQ(†[ Y.Q/%(.^?

MQ(F"MˆQ(F `{O9 ;gQ(j%1dm.CDmQ Y^%( J MkD>i[3 QRN.CGD%D7-F f=fEUC(Q .%(‚F7F>;g3IX[l=^

f==i-%E]mf .SM._ `*V 9 ƒ=OX+ ;Q(%Ed.SE[Q(YG3{;%(MF^†HZj DJKQ Y3?% =^._#YkD^l`{O9:

J MgEiG Q(U.C3D%EF fEfDC(Q YG ^.d D ;m .NMDN? f=m% MQ(F . .ii%1mi%E†.CD J6MkEi3

Q(N.CDC%D7-F %E%(<= f=.UC=% „…L[ Sc\@<=%Edm._ f5=^Q"i.%(.JKCD%h?i?[Q .??kE†[.U

.>F% =^J QK.? ;Q(%Edm.CE†mQc.?‚^lQKM(Q(? =^lQ(i mf6=^ dm._33?.CE†m‚[f@=^ YNi

`*mUdC=Y.Fm%(k=^J k(Q1_3f(

+ d%(.3W=^"DCD _f=f=G3 i%(f03Q %(C=%Edm? f%([J `{Oˆ9 ;gQ(j%1dm.CDmQ Q(^ ^7F^j%

Q(JK.7 QRN._3 dm.%(3.N;3k0H EW=^ jEJKCD%<Q %(.jF'=^. =^ `ƒ ;gQ1%Ed.CD[Q1eJaeQ=E>H ?M]D =^

Q(>F. D0GQ(l%1.CE† *)'^ `{O9 dm.%(G.;G0HhN._ ; i[3.?Z;H =^ M[Q0D.S;G .SM%( mf =^

-ESE %(C=%Edm._ .F%Ek=^J „…Lgg‰@.<^tF[^ mi=3.P?i=^[Q1Y^3_^ %([email protected]%EFf0>MCM.S=mgQ

;.$gQRN.CGD%D7-F"f0f=3_3Kf%(J i%(f03G =5=^ Q(JY.G Q(N._3 dm.%(G.SE[Q 7Z`:O9

%(C%Ed.Q Q(^M?W=^%1_f=%( ;m =%(.<D?%Ik=^cN.CME†m .UQ{=^H J.H ';6i^HQ(GN._=+ d%(.G`ƒ

;gQ(j%0d.CDgQh.%( mfGD D.? YkD^7 =^ Q0D.?.%(? ?[d3.CD [f `{O9 %(S=%E3Ndm. Q2 VWQ

d.j% 3.CD[Qam‚3.%EF%Q1.3Qa.%( W_*%(i%1[?MN?: ^ %1C=%(d? i=.@?ji=^ QamH"Q(GF^=7H

.f0fDCDN? .?"/. ?fEfEj%( ;mCa =^ I gQ0=%0MJY(Q I^_ [Q(3?%(F D%RQ(CDF

;gQ(j%0d.CDgQ S'ƒE =^lQ(Nm? N.Q1 0+(MgH ‰‡ ({=^ =CD‚_f=f=G3(QI%(C=%E3d? f%([J =^

G3?.% a%( Q(GF^D>H†a%ˆ=^.6=^gQ(@;gQRj%0d?2Q(0MY;H D^/`ƒ -)'^ Q:.Y;/$i[3.?a;HIE^

G3?.%@Q(F. ;m_F fM7H .CDUM.CD?;H=^Yi=N._37Hc=^3$ †.NHm% mf'=^YdNCE>dm QEHQ0DJcQ(.?

=^MQcM.;3 D ijC=%(.<D =^ Y^[‚_†M? 3.NHm% JY.Q0M%1? ;H"=^ `ƒ + d%(.G@=^ 3G?.j%

i%Ef=%(JQ*%(.UQ(.;7H a7' Q=M_^ -=%(JK ?kD[Q Ed%EHK=^Gj$ mdmCD>dQEHgQ=D_J(._?

.Q ka.Q/Q(^ i%(dMQ(7Hc=^gQ(Y?Gf=fEj%(Q].%(>HlQ(FfE3.U* Q(JK._3QEi.CD.Q(N._3Q .?

.%(@>HK.6Q1?.%EHYfE>[email protected]%EF%Q(N._3A=%(j?[Q .?WDjF%(.CD? %(Q=Mk(QS

Yf=fE%1_UQc-ESEK_f=f=G3(Q*Q0DGQ0D=^MF^.?JYF[^Uˆ;m6?M D[Q0=%=MgJYUD._.?

.>F% =^JW3"GGJKkD.CD[Q 7 ;=^ %(<=%Ed. QR_^JQ %lQEi.S=.c.? DJ i%(.JYQ<JK.CDj^g T m%

gQ0D.Ne=^WG3?.%*%(.SE GQ].QSQ=MgJK?D Q0D.SH gQ0D.U* . M? i%(f=G3Q(<XCRgg/D I^3_^ 0Q

M%1.GQ0D 3f63.%EF ^.FQI7 JK3%(i^HgQ(3U._:i%(i%0=UQ ^.ii m . Q(F3 i%(f=G3 ;.Q(QS V

Q0M?H [f 3"%EHgQ=D._KQ(^.i"3.QSQ(fE3.CDm f=%(J ?im†.%(_.CE†mh%(.CDeQ Q0MFFQ=(Q >H GGJKkDU?

^._-Fg J3%1mi^HQ(GQ ak=^ .kDkM?.;d S‰ $J dSE>dcN.Q1Q/;gQ1%Ed? + M>H ‰gŠ

.?‰‡c?M% F `\ 'KX) V@9)TVI`:„ GK[jC:.‰ ;(g^ YSd% Q(JK.G<Q(N._36d.%(.CD[Q .%1WQ0D

igQ<Q(>;3m\]F.%1?mFc=^`ƒKˆ.UQYkD^ JK.H =^%*i%(;Q1ˆk^.QA;m .%DFM? =^.C*N%EHgQ=D.Q

.cQ(^.CDC% I^YJYi.CD?6;H =^@._%(j%(.fG'% =^ i%E;@k(Q1_f=[3U.?F D.a.%0=f033.g%(.Q(@G

`{\('X)'V 9) TVI`{„ YHJ Q(fDG3? S . ‰ Q0MFFQ= =^.C ?M =^ Q i^_[JK

;gQ(j%0d.CDgQf%1mJ =^ `ƒ JYF[^UYd%1Q0=JK.CD ^ -ESE‚f=fE3_3D*iDU=.GH ;H5.Q

J M^.Q:.6fD.CD% mf‰,/%0;j%0‰* :.?K,6.%D%(CG ‰* ^.dm %(;-MD?6=^GQ Y%E$g.%DFM7-F=^.C

=^ fD%E%(N? %E%Dm%RQ a%( =^"%(Q=Mgk mf f=.CMk=H %l.jii%(mi%D.CD NmJ i.j% Q1mgQ2@C=^GUQ<QR

.??kDm.Y%E$ JYF[^U =^%(f=%(Z;m %(LM>%(N? = ?SD%EJY 7f =^ F? .F%(jJY f=M?

;SY %(UQ0Mk(Qlf%1[J ;=^ [Q==%0MJK(Q 7 =^ i%(Q(j Q0M?H Q =^ ;Hi%(?M2 f ?mQ0=C

;gQ(j%0d.CD..?.._HgQRQ{;3.Q(QcN.^K7gQ==%0MJYD I^3_^ aM?cJ i[Q(.SD6f=m%:.^K=^%

.? N[3?_UD.7H GN.? D5QEJKG3.%@%(Q=Mg(QS + =^ =^%@^.j?ˆ=^cf=.S=^.C %(UQ0Mk(Q/f%([J ;m=^

gQ0=%0MJY(Q1 MQ(F dm%EH ?fEfD%( DN^3LMQ( Q(^ . F? .F%(jJY Q==%(F=^[Q"=^

f03?N7 $-ECE†m f0fDG3(Q %(C%E3Ndm? f%(J ;m=^ gQ0=%0MJYU(QS[!‚%(jdm%('Cdm =^

.Q1@[[email protected]=>d ;3.Q1=^ f=.UC=^.Cg=^]dm.%(3.C=[Q:mfDCDYf0fE33P.%(6Q(J33.% Yk(^

.kDkM? Q(.JK E?.H‚i%(f=G3Qf%(J N.^ gQ0=%=MgJYUQ==736Q=MFFQ=(Q =^ dj%0=3. d.%(.;G3k=H [f

G3?.%:%(C=%Edm._Q .;m =%0MQ0DN?[ƒEc.jH .Q(Ne%1C=%Ed.Q*f%([J ;=^cgQ0=%=MJY(Q*.j%( [Q(Q0DU f=m%

dm._>MQ mfK=C= D;m j

JY=^.C aM?"Q0D73@%(JK._ Q(JK.G/.fGD% .lMJK%(GU.U

%0%1C=g )'^ %(Q=Mg(Q .j%( UQEiUG.7H GJYi%0D.CU Q(N %(S=%E3Ndm. Q f%([J =^ QEi.U;%E

`V 9 ƒ=OX+ JYQSQ([ #"$% S ._ ‰ #Y7 QRm"; .dm._33.N;3Y3.?7F .j -DgQ(>d

JK.ii7FKfˆ3@M?YmiU=.g.?WJY3%(i^HgQ(3.[i%1mi%=Q2

! "# %$&!'")($!*,+-+./10 "2345+6$-106798:0; <>= =@?A$-4CBEDF G8)HI "# "$-!'"KJ6 "4L0 M*4-2 "N'M.4L0O$'C0

<>= EPCQSRCTURCV-W-X J6DF.-*2Y6#8U#F'Z>?[2-$-\I]+.4#.% "2^798_<6= =a`6H$-2$L0b\.4 'MF "4'M "Y#.MBUS$&c

$-4-2_798<>=

=d`fe$-10;_gh7i! "#jk4CB

8U%0b "cmlneg So

.Fp\p-b'M

X

`^% 3.N5!" `^i[fD%(* VY'Y3.d.3A!" Y.f=fE37AO: /M;M QSQ1m‚.? O:

'I.F'‰ ƒ(J i%(dF \/C=%Dd.Q f `A%E%0MQ `AM? OP.%=3 X[U `AMiF 9:G?.j%/.?

)'^%($E^.\/.N?mJS=%EAD^3LMQ( .4L0]D8h "$L0] " HI MjM\ %( [Š *

,/.%E%(C3:)A+‹ c,6j%0;%1e g,Y &].CMJ F.%1?m%(ˆ`@c) I^He g,Y &].CMJWF.j%(?m%(.?

„] !"'#"gQ0D$*‰ XmJa._33 ^7F^7H‚%1_fDGNCE>dmlU j%1HQ0D.Q †EG.SEkM? >%E%=MQS

M.,+6#8U

X

HI "

X

?[ C0\0 ?=jgj‰‡‰, 9:ˆŠ g

,/.%E%(C3 )+N[VY+ YHJcQ(fE3G?[!Z+!‚N,6G3 & VY\]3?m3H[ ,W!&@.SMgJYF.%(?j%(g)*O:

&*MgP.? ` \I[#";Q0Dj%A‰ g`*mUdUC=>d F%(.S=[ [f:7%D%0MQ .%=^6=%(ii.CMQ1

X

M.,+6#8U X HI Mj X ‰'S‰

,/.%E%(C3/)*ˆ+'‰* `mJYJKI S„*f=fEUC=>d %(.N?m>MQYf/GN M?li.j%0E†_3 iiM.CDmgQ

?%(>d? f%([J ._%(j%(.fG/i%(;mQ ;H YHJcQ(fE3G?‚CI.0‰ S

X

=50;c.

X

g'M "$-4

X

- M'"

X

.NiD?g

,/%0;j% c 'K ) .$.[")* +‚,6.j%E%(<G .? O K Y;;Q ‰ Ki[^[JKCD%

JK.Q0M%(JK(Q mf‚=^ VYQEHJYJKC=%EH i.%(.JKCD%( kMJ D7CDm f0f=3_3 .?

&].$gQ1.SGD%%(.2=†7IV@%0E†@_†M?[Q1

X .\p =h0]c. X 'MX !

‰' E

,/%0;j% C .'‰* `*[JYJK m C„*f=fDCD†dm %1.?mMQImf/3 M? i.%0=33 iiM.CDmgQ

?%(>d? f%([J ._%(j%(.fG/i%(;mQ ;H YHJcQ(fE3G?‚CI.0‰ S

X =50;c. X g'M "$-4 X - M'" X

.NiD?g

a.%0=JY.{ ˆ9 {.j? +/$% &]_{!ZP„] .? !‚3^QR:!Zˆ9 j‡‡‰')'^ f=f=UC/f

M? H-ig@Y.%==^"Q %DFmH ;m.G.Y-,6;...7HQ(Q(

X .\pJ6DFc5$L0

'S‰gŠ/j

aNHJcQ(fE3_3?[VY-+.?a!5NT .%(LM^.%(,W!Z j‡‡+ =^@^F[^K.>;?gQf'.jdG>%E%=MQG

=^ =%Ei. i.GfE3%a.%(J i[=ˆJY3%(i^HgQ(3.1%Ei%(SD.2=[Q/f%(J `:„ O„$# .? f%(J