HAL Id: jpa-00210893
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/jpa-00210893
Submitted on 1 Jan 1988
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Ellipsometric studies of the nematic-substrate interface
J.P. Nicholson
To cite this version:
J.P. Nicholson. Ellipsometric studies of the nematic-substrate interface. Journal de Physique, 1988,
49 (12), pp.2111-2118. �10.1051/jphys:0198800490120211100�. �jpa-00210893�
Ellipsometric studies of the nematic-substrate interface
J. P. Nicholson
Dept. of Physics and Applied Physics, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow G4 ONG, Scotland, U. K.
(Requ le 16 mai 1988, révisé le 18 août, accepté le 31 août 1988)
Résumé.
2014L’interface entre la phase nématique du 7CB et une frontière solide a été étudiée par ellipsométie optique. La différence de phase entre les rayons ordinaire et extraordinaire, 0394
=03B4p - 03B4S, et l’angle
03C8
=tan-1 |rp/rs| ont été mesurés en fonction de l’angle d’incidence et de la température. La modélisation des données expérimentales exige une zone de séparation exponentielle avec une densité 0,6 à 1,5 % plus grande et
un paramètre d’ordre 17 a 40 % plus grand que ceux en masse. L’épaisseur de la région interfaciale varie de 135 Å à 250 Å.
Abstract.
2014The interface of a nematic 7CB - solid substrate has been studied by optical ellipsometry. The phase difference between 0 and E rays, 0394
=03B4p - 03B4s, and the angle 03C8
=tan-1 | rp/rs | are measured as a
function of incidence angle and temperature. To fit the experimental data, an exponential interfacial region having a density rising to ~ 0.6-1.5 % and an order parameter 17-40 % greater than bulk is required. The skindepth of the interfacial region varies from 135 A to 250 Å.
Classification
Physics Abstracts
61.30
-42.80
-68.00
1. Introduction.
There is considerable interest, both theoretical [1-6]
and experimental [7-13] in the interfacial region
between a nematic liquid crystal and its enclosing boundary wall. Apart from the well known alignment
effect of a microgrooved [18] or obliquely coated [19]
substrate which is of practical application to L. C.
electro-optic devices, there exists also an effect on
the order parameter in the vicinity of the substrate.
Thus the order parameter S (o ) at the substrate boundary is expected to differ from the bulk value
S (oo ). The functional form of S (z ) in the interfacial
region has yet to be determined, although several investigations [7-11] have been made with the nema-
tic material above its nematic/isotropic transition temperature. Measurements in this case are facili- tated by the fact that birefringence now only exists
within the interfacial region itself ; this can be
measured by obtaining the phase shift between
transmitted ordinary and extraordinary ways. How- ever, more recently total internal reflection ellip- sometry [11] has been used to investigate the iso- tropic - substrate interface, from which some knowledge of the shape of S (z ) can be inferred.
Measurements on the interface with the bulk L. C. in the nematic phase are less copious as in this
case the dominant birefringence arises from the bulk nematic phase. Semi-qualitative measurements at the nematic-substrate interface have been obtained
by Mada and Kobayashi [12] and by Salamon and Skibinski [14] who both show an enhanced order parameter near to the substrate, but obtain no
information on the skindepth of the interfacial
region. The only other work by an optical method is by this author [13] who has measured the optical reflectivity of the nematic-substrate interface. Con- siderable deviation from Fresnel reflectivity is ob-
served in the case of 7CB which leads to estimates of enhancement of the order parameter by - 15 % near
the wall and of density by -11/2 %. If a simple
linear refractive index profile is assumed, Refer-
ence 13 indicates a full skindepth of - 800 A. These results compare favourably with methods [25, 26]
which obtain S (z) from the force separating the
walls of an L. C. layer as a function of thickness.
The method used in reference 13, however is relatively insensitive to the assumed shape of S (z ). In this paper, which is essentially a continua-
tion of that work, the classical technique of ellip-
sometry [17] is used, which under certain circum- stances (e.g. varying incident angle or varying wavelength) can produce information on the index
profile of the film under investigation.
Article published online by EDP Sciences and available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/jphys:0198800490120211100
2112
2. Experimental method.
The liquid crystal cell is shown in (Fig. l(a)). The
cell is filled with 7CB whilst in its isotropic phase (to
prevent flow alignment) and consists of two prisms
with their enclosing faces at a slight angle. This wedge shape enables the reflection from the upper
prism face to be selected ; the other reflection is
ignored. The upper prism is made of flint glass (Schott type F2) and has a hypotenuse microgrooved by briefly polishing unidirectionally with diamond polishing paste. The lower prism has an obliquely
coated layer of SiO such as to reinforce the planar alignment (perpendicular to the plane of Fig. 1)
caused by the microgrooving.
Prior to assembly, both prisms are subject to
intensive cleaning (the upper prism after microgroov- ing ; the lower prism prior to coating) as follows : (i) preliminary short ultrasonic cleaning (- 10 min) (ii) overnight soak in detergent (iii) several ul- trasonic rinses in distilled water (iv) several ultrason- ic rinses in 18 Mil cm deionized water. To be
pronounced satisfactory the optical surface should then be observed to drain-dry perfectly uniformly
i.e. without breaking into droplets.
Under high power microscopy the microgrooving
is seen to occupy a negligible fraction of the area of the unidirectionally polished surface. It therefore still behaves as a specular reflecting surface which is verified by the very low fraction ( 10- 7) of light
scattered off the surface. The microgrooving how-
ever, does assist in obtaining nematic alignment right through the cell (average thickness 100 J.Lm).
Uniform alignment after assembly was easily
checked by examination through crossed polarizers.
Before filling the cell with 7CB, however, the quality
of the F2 glass surface is itself investigated as
described below.
The L. C. cell is investigated for a variety of
incident angles by the apparatus shown in (Fig.1(b))
which is a conventional manual ellipsometer [17,.
The whole apparatus was enclosed in a temperature stabilised enclosure (not shown) enabling readings
to be taken throughout the nematic range. Ellip- sometry, unlike reflectometry, is sensitive to the
phase as well as the intensity of the reflected light. If rp and rS are the (complex) amplitude reflectivities
Fig. 1.
-(a) Liquid crystal cell investigated ; n is director orientation. (b) Ellipsometer used in the measurements.
L - polarized laser ; C - 1/4 wave compensator plate ;
L.C.
-L.C. cell shown in (a) ; A - Analyzer ; D - photodiode detector.
for the TM and TE polarizations, the respective phase shifts 8 p, 8
Sare given by :
An ellipsometer measures two quantities L1 and Q given by :
For a given incidence angle, A and Q are obtained by adjusting the incident polarization angle, P and analyzer angle, A to obtain a null response in the detector. This occurs for 4 independent values of P and A for a given compensator angle C, given by [17] :
These four null conditions were obtained for each
setting ; this not only provides a check on the reproductibility of A and Q but also leads to elimi- nation of certain systematic errors in the ellipsome-
ter, by a process known as 4-zone averaging [17] :
We also need to correct for the effect of the side faces of the prism. Assuming each side face to be a
simple dielectric interface [20] the amplitude trans-
mittance will have no phase retardation and there- fore d is unaffected. It is easily shown that the measured Q ’ obtained from equation (4) is related
to the actual Q for the nematic substrate interface
by :
tan Q
=cos2 (i 1- i2) tan .p’ (5)
where i1 and i2 are the angles shown in (Fig. 1(a)).
Values of A and qi were obtained as described above, firstly for the unfilled cell to obtain these parameters for the clean reflecting surface and then,
with the cell filled as described earlier with 7CB.
Quite small values of A were observed for the empty cell (~ 1° at 40° incident angle) compared with the
values for the filled cell (differing from the Fresnel value by 20-40°). Nevertheless these empty cell
measurements were unexpectedly important as we
shall see below.
3. Analysis of results.
Typical results for two temperatures are shown in
(Fig. 2) showing the variation of A and Q with
incident angle, 60. In order to obtain information on
the variation of S and density in the interfacial
region we need to compute the reflectivities rs and rp for given refractive index profiles for both E and 0 rays. This then leads to the expected values of d
and 0 through equations (1) and (2).
The computation of the optical reflection at an
interface having a varying refractive index is a well- researched problem [15, 16, 21] having a variety of
methods some of which were summarised in our
previous paper [13]. The optical geometry chosen in this investigation (optic axis perpendicular to the plane of incidence) means that the E and 0 rays remain essentially independent of each other. In
more complicated situations the 4 x 4 matrix method of Berreman [21] would be necessary to solve the problem ; in this case we can use the 2 x 2 matrix, method described in the reviews by
Abeles [16] and Jacobsen [15]. Then optical proper- ties of the layer are described by a matrix [Mij], and
the reflectivity r is given by :
with
Fig. 2.
-Ellipsometric data (points) and best fit curves
(for best fit case in Table I), for temperatures of 32.65 °C and 40.0 °C. (a) A
=5 p - 5,
sas a function of incident
angle, 00 within the upper glass prism (b) 41
=tan-1 rplrs I as a function of 00.
Here no is the refractive index of the first medium
(F2 glass) and n2o, n2 E the ordinary and extraordi-
nary refractive indices of the bulk L. C., 00 and 02 are the ray directions in the two media respect- ively.
The matrix elements are also different in the two cases being related to the assumed refractive index
profile in the interfacial region, n10(z) in the TM
case and nl E (z ) in the TE case. Profiles (shown in Fig. 3) tried were :
Linear profile
Inverse parabolic profile
2114
Parabolic profile
Exponential profile
Step profile
Modified Landau-de-Gennes See reference [2].
(P
=0 or E polarization).
Here No, NE and d are adjustable parameters whilst n2o and nz E are the bulk refractive indices of 7CB [23].
Fig. 3.
-Sketch graphs showing the functional forms tried for nlo (z ) and nl E (z), the refractive index variation in the interfacial region ; Inv. Par.
-Inverse Parabolic ; Exp.
-Exponential ; Lin.
-Linear ; Par.
-Parabolic.
In the case of the linear profile, the Mij could be
computed by the series expansion method (for d ..: A) outlined in section 3.1 of reference [13],
which was fast in computer time. The other profiles
were not analytically tractable by this method, and
were analysed by the step-matrix method in appen- dix 1, where the profile is subdivised into a large
number of small elements, each element of which
can be regarded as having a linear profile. The
accuracy of the computations were checked by comparing results with those obtained by direct integration of the EM wave equation described in
the appendix of reference [13].
4. Analysis of results.
Comparison between experimental and theoretically
calculated values of d and Q was achieved by minimizing the function M :
where yi and Ii are the experimental and theoretical values respectively (of either A and qi) for a given
00, and Ui the estimated errors.
It was found quite easy to obtain good fits to the A
data or the 1/1 data separately, especially with three
parameters (No, NE, d) available to adjust. How-
ever much more difficult is to obtain a simultaneous fit to both curves with the same parameters. To obtain such a simultaneous fit it was found necessary
to correct for the effect of the surface finish of the F2
glass substrate. Fortunately ellipsometric data had
been obtained for this surface prior to filling the cell ; this was found to be compatible with a glass
surface profile sloping linearly from the bulk value
of 1.61656 to surface value of 1.449 over a distance of 140 A, which is very similar to the results of Yokota et al. [24] on the effect on glass surfaces due
to surface leaching during polishing. The character- istic matrix [Mij] for the nematic-substrate interface is then obtained by simple multiplication [22].
where [Mglass ] is the characteristic matrix of the leached glass surface layer, and [MLC] is the matrix for the nematic interfacial region computed as
described in section 3.
With this procedure it was now found possible to
find good simultaneous fits to the Q and A data, for unique values of No, NE and d for a given profile.
Moreover the quality of the simultaneous fits shows small albeit definite preferences for some profiles
over others. Table I shows the best fit values of
No, NE, d and Mo, the (lowest) value of M for the refractive index profiles shown in (Fig. 3) and de-
fined in section 3. Apart from the results for 38.5 °C
which curiously show little preference, the trend at
all four other temperatures is a preference for a . long-tailed shape and against sharp cut-off profiles.
Thus best fits were obtain for the exponential shape, parabolic a poor second-best, linear profile an
intermediate fit, and inverse parabolic and step
profiles progressively worse fits. A profile derived
from the Landau-de-Gennes type theory of Allender
et al. [2] was also tried but the results were identical
to those for the exponential profile and are not separately listed. The theory had to be modified by allowing a density variation of the same shape as the
order parameter variation.
The results for the exponential (or modified Landau-de-Gennes) profile are shown in table II, together with those for the linear profile for compari-
son with our previous measurements [13]. This in-
cludes the surface/bulk values both for density and
order parameter which can be calculated from
No, NE, n2o and n2 E [13, 29].
Apart from the data at 32.6 °C (which may be
affected by proximity of the nematic-solid transition)
Table I.
-Best fits to experimental data for various re fractive index profiles and temperatures
Observed tc
=42.55 *C
the trend seems to be for d to increase steadily with temperature, and surface density and order par- ameter ratios to decrease.
Measurements were also taken above the nematic-
isotropic transition temperature but uncertainty in
the glass surface profile prevented meaningful con-
clusions being obtained. This is because in this case
the skindepth of the glass surface profile (70 A half-
width) is comparable with that of the L. C. surface
layer.
5. Discussion.
The results shown here are in qualitative agreement with our previous work [13] which indicated an unexpected large interfacial region, viz., d-
700-1 000 A assuming a linear profile. In this work for a linear profile, d ranges from 400 A up to 650 A
near the transition temperature. Thus results here,
would seem to give values of d lower by about a
factor of 0.6. However in adition to any sample to sample variations, one would expect a lower d for the present results as the previous work did not
include the effect of the initial state of the glass
substrate which, as we have seen (Sect. 4) can be represented by a surface layer having a linear profile
of thickness 140 A. This might also explain the higher surface order parameters observed in this work (11-25 % enhancement for a linear profile compared with the previous values of 9-17 % en- hancement).
Perhaps, more important, is to compare results with theory. Best fits for exponential or modified
Landau-de-Gennes profile are given in table II and range from d = 135 A at 34.2 °C to 205 A at 40.0 °C.
The theory by Allender et al. [2] predicts :
2116
Table II.
-Calculated values of density and order parameter enhancement from the best fit data for an exponential and linear profiles respectively. Statistical errors are random from (temperature) run to run, whilst the systematic error is due to uncertainty in the substrate surface profile and is therefore common to all runs.
and
Taking T, - T* = 1.4 °C and )
=5 A [7]
equation (9) yields values of d ranging from
d
=6.2 A at 32.6 °C increasing monotonically to
d
=20.9 A at 40.0 °C. These are well over an order of magnitude less than our experimental values. The
more sophisticated mean field theory of Telo da Gama [3] unfortunately only treats the homeotropic
case. The large skindepths reported here have also been demonstrated in the case of 5CB by measuring
the force between two substrates forming a sandwich
of the liquid crystal [25, 26] reference [26] describes
both a medium-range and short range regime. In the
short range, the force oscillates over a period of
~
25 A indicating local smectic ordering which de-
cays away completely after - 100 A. The medium range force exhibits a decay of near-exponential shape having a 1/e decay distance of = 200 A.
Whilst our measurements clearly cannot detect the
short range fluctuations, they would appear to agree very closely with the medium range force distribution which is related to an order parameter variation of similar shape.
Other work which support these conclusions have been detailed in the discussion of our previous
paper [13] but it is worth mentioning again the work by Gannon and Faber [27] who infer smectic layering
at the nematic-vapour interface from surface tension measurements on 8CB and 5CB, and the X-ray
diffraction results of Leadbetter et al. [28] who infer
local smectic ordering extending over
-