• Aucun résultat trouvé

Sensitivity and stability analysis of a rigid canopy flow

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "Sensitivity and stability analysis of a rigid canopy flow"

Copied!
11
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

O

pen

A

rchive

T

OULOUSE

A

rchive

O

uverte (

OATAO

)

OATAO is an open access repository that collects the work of Toulouse researchers and

makes it freely available over the web where possible.

This is an author-deposited version published in :

http://oatao.univ-toulouse.fr/

Eprints ID : 14503

To link to this article: URL:

http://hdl.handle.net/2042/57596

To cite this version : Luminari, Nicola and Airiau, Christophe

Sensitivity and stability analysis of a rigid canopy flow. (2015) In:

22ème congrès Français de Mécanique, 24 August 2015 - 28 August

2015 (Lyon, France).

Any correspondance concerning this service should be sent to the repository

administrator:

[email protected]

(2)

!"#$%$&$%' (") #%(*$+$%' ("(+'#$#

,-( .$/$) 0,-(",1' 2,3

! "#$%&'(%

) *! +%(%'#

! "#$%& '#( ))*+ ,-(./"-01'0.& '234567389 :5 %;<=;<75& >==95 :< 06! , ?3==5 .;<= & @AB** %;<=;<75& $6 2C5&

23C;= !=<?32 63D3?E8!E6&CF6378;GF5! 363 <D3?E8!E6

!"#$%&#'

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

,-./0(123 2-&2%4%5%4.) '160%&4) 24'7%8%4.) 9'&0:.

( )*#$+,-&#.+*

H<6 6575 6CF 32856578 C;4567 8F5 ?;:5==32I ;E J;K ;456 C;?G=5L 7<6E C57 MC;?G=3 28& G;6;<7& 2;8 7?;;8F !!!N 8; 3245783I 85 G;773O=5 :6 I 65:<C83;2! > 7<6E C5 C;4565: OP 2 66 P ;E 63I3: CP=32:567 755?7 8; O5 I;;: 78 6832I G6;O=5?

(3)

! "#$"%#$" "& '()(*& &)+ ,"#-" *#$" "(.& "& %()$&) &/&- + !0 "& 1!, !.&) +2-" ( )#$#34 '!)!2+ (03 (0#+! )!'#- *&3#2*5

6# " "& '2)'!+& !7 "& -!2'%&3 1!, ")!2$" (03 !.&) '&)*&(8%& %(9&)+ "& *( "&*( #-(% *!3&% ')!'!+&3 89 :"#+(%8&) # (03 ;&'7 <=> "(+ 8&&0 (0(%9+&35 ?)!* ( +& !7 &@'&)#*&0 + !.&) ( )#$#3 -(0!'9 <=> ( '()(*& )#- -!*'%&@ *!3&% "(+ 8&&0 82#% 2+#0$ ( 3)($ 720- #!04 ( 2)82%&0-& *#@#0$ %&0$ " *!3&% (03 "& *!*&0 2* 12#3 1!, &A2( #!0+5

B0 <C> ( +#*'%&) *!3&% #+ ')!'!+&3 82 "& -!*'()#+!0 ,# " &@'&)#*&0 (% 3( ( (''&()+ ! 8& !7 %!,&) A2(%# 9 "(0 "& #0# #(% *!3&%5 D!*& *!)& -!*'%&@ ('')!(-"&+ -(0 8& 7!203 #0 <E4 F> 82 ,& #0.&+ #$( & "&)& "& G)+ '()(*& )#-!)#$#0(% -(0!'9 *!3&% <=> 8&-(2+& # #+ 82#%3 7)!* "&!)& #-(% &A2( #!0+ (03 &@'&)#*&0 (% 3( ( G #0$ (03 8&-(2+& "& ')!G%& -(0 8& )('#3# %9 -!*'2 &3 ,# " +!*& A2# & $!!3 ($)&&*&0 ,# " &@'&)#*&0 (% 3( (5

D#0-& "& *!3&% #+ %()$&%9 8(+&3 !0 &*'#)#-(% 720- #!0+ &@ )('!%( &3 7)!* &@'&)#*&0 (% 3( ( ( +&0+# #.# 9 (0(%9+#+ "(+ ! 8& '&)7!)*&35 H"& *(#0 #3&( #+ ! 3&G0& ( A2(0 # 9 ,"#-" A2(%#G&+ "& ')!G%&5 I+ #0 8!203()9 %(9&)+4 (0 #0 &$)(% "#-J0&++4 +2-" (+ "& 3#+'%(-&*&0 "#-J0&++ δ1 *(9 8& ('')!')#( & (03 # #+

"2+ +& (+ !8K&- #.& 720- #!0(%5 H"& +&0+# #.# 9 (0(%9+#+ (%%!,+ ! 3& &)*#0& "& $)(3#&0 !7 "#+ 720- #!0(% ,# " )&+'&- ! (09 .()#(8%& !7 "& *!3&% ! +"&3 %#$" !0 "& 3&'&03&0-#&+ (03 "& #*'!) (0-& !7 "& -"!#-&+ ')!'!+&3 #0 <=>5

I7 &) "#+ + 239 ,& (%+! (0(%9L& "& %#0&() + (8#%# 9 !7 "& ')!G%& 8(+&3 !0 ( *!3(% ('')!(-"4 (03 ,& #0# #( & "& + 239 !7 "& +&0+# #.# 9 !7 "& &#$&0.(%2&+ 32& ! *!3#G-( #!0 !7 "& 8(+& 1!,5

!"#$%& %"'"()*'+, ($-).

H"& 1!, -!0G$2)( #!0 (03 0!M ( #!0+ ()& 3&G0&3 !0 G$2)& = N)#$" O5 H"& ')!8%&* #+ (++2*&3 ! 8& !0&M 3#*&0+#!0(% (03 '()(%%&%4 "& #0-!*')&++#8%& 8!203()9 %(9&) 1!, #+ +& #0 *! #!0 89 "& +%!'& !7 "& $)!203 +2)7(-& >?@5 H"& -!0 )#82 #!0 !7 "& -(0!'9 ! "& 8(+& 1!, #+ *!3&%%&3 89 ( 3)($ -!&P-#&0 (+ ( 720- #!0 !7 0!)*(% -!!)3#0( & z ,# " (0 &A2#%#8)#2* &A2( #!0+ ,)# &0 (+ Q

gS = ∂u ′w′ ∂z + 1 2CD(z)aU (z) 2 N=O

g #+ "& $)(.# 9 (--&%&)( #!05 u′w′ #+ "& 2)82%&0 + )&++ (03 U(z) #+ "& *&(0

+ )&(*,#+& .&%!-# 95 ?)!* "#+ &A2( #!0 ( -!*'%& & *( "&*( #-(% *!3&% #+ 3&)#.&3 (03 3& (#%&3 #0 <=>5 R&)& ,& +#*'%9 )&'!) "& *(#0 &A2( #!0+ ! +!%.& ,"#-" -!0+ # 2 & "& -!0+ )(#0 + !7 "& +&0+# #.# 9 (0(%9+#+Q

(4)

CDC = 1 + 10Re −2/3, R e= Uhd/ν !" U2− U1 Uh = (h − z1)ΩCDAη¯1a  1 − U1 2 Uh2  #" ¯ η1 = f ( ¯β1); β¯1= z1 h, U1= u1(z1), U2= u2(z2) $" ∆U Uh = 1 + 16ad %" CDA = CDC 1.16 (1.16 − 9.31ad + 38.6ad 2 − 59.8ad3) &" CD(z) = η(β)CDAχ(z) '" d dz  du1 dz 2 = 1 lc  1 2CDau 2 1(z) − gS  z1≤ z ≤ h (" tml = α(h − z1) )" lc = 0.22(h − z1) *+" lac = 0.22 ξ tml **" u2(z) = Uh+ 2√gS 3lac  (z2− h)2− (z2− z)2  h ≤ z ≤ z2 *!" U1 = s 2gS CD(z1)a = u1(z1), Uh= u1(h) = u2(h) *#" ,- ./0 12030-. 4526 40 3107897:;;< 8-.25=>70 :- :==8.85-:; 0?>:.85- .5 8@A 1530 ./0 75-.8->8.< 5B ./0 =028C:.8C0 48./ 203107. .5 z 128@0 0D15-0-." :. ./0 .51 5B ./0 7:-51< z = h" u′ (h− ) = u′ (h+)48./ : χ B>-7.85-E χ(z) = 1 − e−σ(z−h) z1−h *$" F/0 7:-51< 83 @:=0 5B 3@:;; 7<;8-=023 5B /08G/. hH 5B =8:@0.02 d :-= a B25-.:; :20: 102 20B020-70 C5;>@0 =0-38.< 5B ./0 7<;8-=02"I F/0 125J;0@ 83 =8C8=0= 8-.5 .45 20G85-3 300 9GI * 28G/."H ./0 923. 5-0 8-=0D *" 8-38=0 ./0 7:-51< :-= 48./ ./0 3.20:@4830 C0;578.< u1(z) :-= ./0 3075-= 5-0 :J5C0 8. 8-=0D !" 48./ ./0 C0;578.< u2(z)I F/0 =2:G 750K780-. CD 83 30. .5 L025 :J5C0 z = h :-= 83 @5=0;;0= 48./ 30C02:; B>-7.85-3 8-38=0 ./0 7:-51<I F/0 7:-51< @5=0; J0G8-3 :. z = z1H >-=02 ./83 /08G/. ./0 C0;578.< =503 -5. 7/:-G0I F/0 .>2J>;0-70 @5=0; 83 :33578:.0= 48./ ./200 ;0-G./ tmlH lc :-= lacI ,- :==8.85-H ./0 0?>:.85- * 7:-J0 8-.0G2:.0= :-:;<.87:;;< :J5C0 ./0 7:-51< .5 <80;= u2(z)I M8-:;;<H : -5-;8-0:2 51.8@8L:.85- 125J;0@ 48./ # -03.0= N04.5- 8.02:.85-3 83 20?>820= .5 35;C0 ./0 B>;; 30. 5B 0?>:.85-3I M8G>20 * 3/543 ./0 1259;0 5J.:8-0= B52 7:30 O 5B ./0 20B020-70 1:102 :-= 8. 83 75@1:20= .5 ./0 0D1028@0-.:; =:.: 48./ 02252 J:23"I P5@0 3@:;; =837201:-7803 :20 5J302C0= =>0 .5 ./0 752207.85- @:=0 ./25>G/ ./0 χ B>-7.85- .5 30. 75-.8->8.<

(5)

χ n1 = 20 qi n2− n1= 3 Qi(z) qi= [a, d, h, α, ξ, z1, z2, Uh, U1, U2, lc, lac, ¯η1, β1, tml, CDC, CDA, Uh ′ , σ, β] i = 1..n1 Qi= [χ, CD, u1] i = 1 + n1..n2 L = E + L E E = ǫ0E + n1 X i=1 ǫi q2 i 2 + n2 X i=1+n1 ǫi Z h 0 Q2 i 2 dz E

(6)

E = δ1= Z z2 0 [U2− u(z)] dz = Z h 0 [U2− u1(z)] dz + Z z2 h [U2− u2(z)] dz

!" #"$%!&' ǫi()" *'")+,"-".,".& (., &(/" $.&0 (110*.& &!" ,$2".'$0. 03 &!"

-()(2"&")'4 5(.6 0&!") 1!0$1"' 30) E ()" -0''$78" .(&*)(8869 (., 10))"'-0.,$.% 2(&!"2(&$1(8 ":-)"''$0.' 1(. 7"102" ;*$&" 80.% (., 102-8":4

L ,"'1)$7"' &!" 10.'&)($.&' 03 &!" 0-&$2$<(&$0. -)078"24 =. L ()" $.18*,", &!" 10.'&)($.& #$&! 10.'&(.& -()(2"&")' )"3"))", (' ci (., 10.'&)($.&' #$&!

3*.1&$0.' )"3"))", (' Ci(z) 4 >"'-"1&$?"869 &!" @(%)(.%" 2*8&$-8$")' (''01$(&",

&0 10.'&(.& (., 3*.1&$0.' ()" )"3"))", (' pi 0) Pi(z)A

L = n1 X i=1 pici+ Z h 0 n2 X i=1+n1 Pi(z)Ci(z) dz BCDE

!" '".'$&$?$&6 sqi 0) SQi ()" ,"&")2$.", 3)02 &!" ,")$?(&$?"' 03 &!" 8(+

%)(.%$(. 3*.1&$0.(8 #$&! )"'-"1& &0 &!" 1!0'". -()(2"&")' (' δL = δE = n1 X i=1 sqiδqi+ Z h 0 n2 X i=1+n1 SQi(z)δQi(z) dz

!" ?()$(&$0. 03 &!" @(%)(.%$(. 3*.1&$0.(8 #$&! )"'-"1& &0 (88 &!" -()(2"&")' 8"(,' &0 ( 8$."() '6'&"2 30) &!" *./.0#. @(%)(.%" 2*8&$-8$")'4 !" 3*88 '6'&"2 $' 2(," 76 FG )0#' B.*27") 03 )"2($.$.% -()(2"&")'E (., CH 108*2.' B.*27") 03 )"2($.$.% 10.'&)($.&'E #!$1! 1(. 7" '08?", 76 )",*1&$0.4 !" z+,"-".,".& '".'$&$?$&6 3*.1&$0.' 1(. 7" I)'& '08?", (.(86&$1(886 (., I.(886 ( 8$."() '6'&"2 $' 8"3&9 $4"4A

∂L

∂qi = Ai,jpj+

∂E ∂qi

#!")"9 30) ":(2-8"9 &!" 2(&)$: 0. &!" )$%!& !(., '$,"9 30) i = j = 19 )"(,'A A1,1 = ∂L ∂a = n1 X i=1 2 p12gS a2C DAη¯1 − p1d16Uh − p8CDC !3 a 2d3(59.8) + 2 ad2 (38.6) + d(−9.3) + + p10  1 − U1 2 Uh2  (h − z1)ΩCDAη¯1− 2 (ad16 + 1)d16  + + Z h 0 p17(z)CD(z)u12(z) lc2 dz BCJE BFKE =. &!" -)"?$0*' ";*(&$0. &!" 3*.1&$0. p17(z) $' &!" (,L0$.& 03 &!" ?"801$&6

-)0I8"9 (., $& $' &!" '08*&$0. 03 &!" (,L0$.& ";*(&$0. #$&! !020%"."0*' 70*.,()6 10.,$&$0.A

(7)

−2 d dz  du1(z) dz dp17(z) dz  −p17(z)CD(z) au1(z) l2 c = h !"# $% &'( ) *'++ ,%-'. ,/%0+'1 *2(3 ) -45)/' 267'/(20+' 1)(/289 -%1' ,)/)1'('/-3)7' (% 0' )--51'. :%6-()6(9 )6. (3' :%//'-,%6.26& -'6-2(272(2'- 7)62-3; <6 (3' =%++%*26& *' =%:5- %6 (3' -'6-2(272(2'- )--%:2)('. (% (3' =%++%*26& =%5/ ,)/)1'('/- > a (3' =/%6()+ )/') %= (3' :)6%,? ,'/ 562( 7%+51'9 d (3' :?+26.'/ .2)1'('/9 h (3' 3'2&3( %= (3' :)6%,? )6. α (3' =/):(2%6 %= (3' -3')/ +)?'/ (3)( +2'- *2(326 (3' :)6%,?; @ -':%6. )6)+?-2- *)- .%6' )--5126& α :%6-()6( )6. 0? )..26& (3' -'6-2(272(? (% (3' ,)/)1'('/- ξ; <( )++%*- (% 7'/2=? 3%* (3' -'6-2(272(? %= a9 d )6. h :)6 :3)6&' *3'6 *' -'+':( .2A'/'6( ,)/)1'('/- (% -%+7' (3' -?-('1; $% :%1,)/' -'6-2(272(? *32:3 )/' .'B6'. *2(3 .2A'/'6( 562(9 *' .'B6' (3' /'+)(27' '//%/ )-> ∆E E = sqi qi E ∆qi qi C' )/02(/)/2+? -'( ∆qi/qi= 1 = ǫrqi; ∆E E ǫra DE;!! F ǫrd G;H"F ǫrh DI;IGJK F ǫrα K;JE F ǫrξ I ∆E E ǫra DE;K! F ǫrd G;HE F ǫrh DI;IGE F ǫrα I ǫrξ DI;"LM F $)0+' "> N'+)(27' '//%/ ()0+' =/%1 (*% )6)+?-2-; @- B/-( :%6:+5-2%69 (3' /'-5+(- -3%* (3)( (3' ,)/)1'(/2: 1%.'+ 2- -'6-2(27' (% (3' 26,5(- a )6. d *32:3 )/' &'%1'(/2:)+ ,)/)1'('/- %= (3' :)6%,?; $3' 1%.'+ ),,')/- (% 6%( 0' 7'/? -'6-2(27' (% α )6. ξ *32:3 )/' ,)/)1'('/- /'+)('. )( (3' 12826& +'6&(3 (3'%/?; $32- )6)+?-2- :)6 0' 21,/%7'. 0? %(3'/ ('-(- )6. 0? ,'/=%/126& =5/(3'/ -'6-2(272(? )6)+?-'-;

!"#$%& '(%)"*"(+

,#%*+-"-$3' ('1,%/)+ +26')/ -()02+2(? )6)+?-2- 2- 0)-'. %6 (3' :+)--2:)+ =%/15+)(2%6 26 ('/1- %= 6%/1)+ 7'+%:2(?9 )6. ) .':%1,%-2(2%6 26 6%/1)+ 1%.'- (3)( /').-> w(x, y, z, t) = ˜w(z)ei(kxx−ω t) *2(3 kx (3' /')+ -(/')1*2-' *)7' 6510'/ )6. ω ) :%1,+'8 6510'/ *3'/' (3' /')+ ,)/( 2- ) =/'45'6:? )6. (3' 21)&26)/? ,)/( ) &/%*(3 /)(';9 $3' .'D :%1,%-2(2%6 %= (3' O%* B'+. *2(3 ) 1')6 O%* (3' ,/'72%5- ,/%B+' U(z)# )6. (3' ,'/(5/0)(2%6 w(z) +').- (% (3' *'++ P6%* Q//DR%11'/='+. '45)(2%69 *3'/'

(8)

!"# $ D2 %$ "# &%'() * !+&!,-" "# . ,%+& & $!/-"!/ 0!"# $ .1 ," "% "# +%$2-) &!$ ,"!%+ z3  (−iω + ikxU )(D2− k2x) − ikxU′′− 1 Re (D2 − kx2) 2 ˜ w = 0, Re = Uhd ν ω !. -+ !4 +/-)' 5%$ " 21%$-) ."-(!)!"6 -+& ˜w !. -+ !4 +5'+,"!%+7 8# !4 +/-)' 1$%() 2 !. .%)/ & 0!"# 9-")-( 0# $ "# :; <'-"!%+ !. &!.,$ "!= & '.!+4 - .1 ,"$-) .,# 2 0!"# ># (6.# / 1%)6+%2!-). ?.!= N@ -+& - 2-11!+4 ( "0 + "# . 2!A!+B+!" -+& "# .1 ,"$-) &%2-!+ CDE7

8# .1 ,"$'2 !. .#%0+ !+ B4'$ F7 8# 2%$ '+."() 2%& !. .#%0+ 0!"# -$ & &%" !+ "# B4'-$ -+& "# ,%-$-$ .1%+&!+4 !4 +5'+,"!%+. --$ 1)%"" & !+ B4'-$ G7

(9)

!"#$% &' u ()* w +%$,#$-(,!.) /%0.1!,2 +$.30%4 .5 ,6% 7.4, #)4,(-0% %!"%)7.*%8 9.,6 ,6% /%$,!1(0 ()* ,6% 6.$!:.),(0 /%0.1!,2 6(/% ( 7(;!7#7 !) 1.$$%4+.)< *%)1% .5 ,6% !)=%1,!.) +.!), .5 ,6% 1().+2 =.>? ,2+!1(0 .5 () !)4,(-!0!,2 .5 !)=%1,!.)(0 )(,#$%8

!"#$%&%'%&( &) '*+%*&%)#$ %# &," -"*# .)/

@!)1% >% 6(/% 4%%) ,6(, 4.7% /($!(,!.)4 .$ %$$.$4 .5 ,6% !)+#, +($(7%,%$4 1() 16()"% ,6% 46(+% .5 ,6% 7%() =.>? !, !4 !),%$%4,!)" ,. 1.7+#,% ,6% /($!(,!.) .5 ,6% 4+%1,$#7 *#% ,. 16()"%4 .5 ,6% 7%() =.>8 .00.>!)" ,6% >.$A +$%4%),%* !) B&C >% *%,%$7!)% ,6% 5#)1,!.) )(7%* Gu >6!16 7%(4#$%4 ,6% 4%)4!,!/!,2 .5 ,6% %!"%)/(0#%4 ,. 16()"%4 !) ,6% 7%() =.> +$.30%8 c = ω α, δc = Z ∞ 0 Gu K δU dz Gu= w∗(D2− kx2) ˜w − (w∗w)˜ ′′ D6% E#(),!,2 w∗ !4 ,6% (*F.!), %!"%)5#)1,!.) $%0(,%* ,. ˜w? ()* ,6% ./%$0!)% 7%()4 1.7+0%; 1.)F#"(,%8 D6% 1.)4,(), K 1() -% 1.7+#,%* 5$.7 !),%"$(,!.) .5 ,6% %!"%)5#)1,!.) ˜wG4%% B&CH8 D6% (*F.!), 5#)1,!.) !4 ,6% 4.0#,!.) .5 ,6% (*F.!), I$$<@.77%$5%0* %E#(,!.)? 4%% BJC ()* B&C 5.$ *%,(!048

D6% $%(0 ()* !7("!)($2 +($, .5 ,6% 5#)1,!.) GU ($% +0.,,%* !) 3"#$% K ()*

!, 1() -% 4%%) ,6(, ,6% /($!(,!.) .5 GU ($% 1.$$%0(,%* ,. ,6% *%$!/(,!/% .5 ,6%

7%() =.>? ()* ,6%$%5.$% >!,6 !,4 4,(-!0!,2 +$.+%$,!%48 L%, #4 5#$,6%$ ).,% ,6(, ,6% 4%1.)* *%$!/(,!/% !4 30,%$%* -2 ( "(#44!() 5#)1,!.) -%5.$% !,4 #4% !) ,6% I@ %E#(,!.)8

(10)
(11)

!"!#!$%!&

!" #$%&'()*+,%- ./ '01 2*34- 5/./- 6$* (%7%,*1 8+9:,$ 94 ;*8*,',*1 &$*'+ ('<*+&/ >):-% ?-'"2%0-' ?-'-)%0@ =9(/ >?- @??>/

@" AB$7%1- C/D/ '01 5*00%08&90- E/A/- A,')%(%,< '01 6+'0&%,%90 %0 A$*'+ F(9:& A3+%08*+ G33(%*1 .',$*7',%B'( AB%*0B*& @??!

H" I9,,'+9- G/- J9+)*,,- C/ '01 KLB$%0% C/- 6$* *M*B, 94 )'&* N9: ;'+%',%90 90 N9: &,')%(%,< AB (C2+, .-0@B =9(/ >OP- @??H- 33/ @QHRH?@/

>" 2*34- 5/./- F(9: '01 ,+'0&39+, %0 +*8%90& :%,$ 'SL',%B ;*8*,',%90 8##2)C ?-D+-E "F (C2+, .-0@)#+0' =9(/ >>- @?!@- 33/!@HR!>@/

T" EL390,- A/- #9&&*(%0- F/- C<- J/- E* K'08+*- U/- 5*790- C/- '01 I+L0*,-V/- .91*((%08 :';%08 B+93& L&%08 ('+8*R*11< &%7L(',%90W B973'+%&90 :%,$ *X3*+%7*0,& '01 ' (%0*'+ &,')%(%,< '0'(<&%& AB (C2+, .-0@B ;9(/ PT@- @?!?-33/ TY>>/

P" I*(B$*+- A/U/- 5'+7'0- Z/2/- '01 F%00%8'0- D/D/- 6$* :%01 %0 ,$* :%((9:&W N9:& %0 49+*&, B'093%*& %0 B973(*X ,*++'%0 8##2)C ?-D+-E "F (C2+, .-0@)#+0' =9(/ >>- @?!@- 33/>OQRT?>/

O" G0,[9:%'[- G/- E<0'7%SL* 'LX ,*73& B9L+,& 1\L0 ,9L+)%((90 %&9(] C$/E/ ,$*&%& ^_0%;*+&%,] C'L( A')',%*+ 1* 69L(9L&*- F+'0B*- @??T`/

Références

Documents relatifs

OATAO is an open access repository that collects the work of Toulouse researchers and makes it freely available over the web where possible.. This is an

OATAO is an open access repository that collects the work of Toulouse researchers and makes it freely available over the web where possible.. This is an

OATAO is an open access repository that collects the work of Toulouse researchers and makes it freely available over the web where possible.. This is an

OATAO is an open access repository that collects the work of Toulouse researchers and makes it freely available over the web where possible.. This is an

Open Archive TOULOUSE Archive Ouverte (OATAO) OATAO is an open access repository that collects the work of Toulouse researchers and makes it freely available over

OATAO is an open access repository that collects the work of Toulouse researchers and makes it freely available over the web where possible. This is an

OATAO is an open access repository that collects the work of Toulouse researchers and makes it freely available over the web where possible. This is an

OATAO is an open access repository that collects the work of Toulouse researchers and makes it freely available over the web where possible. This is an