Le rationalisme constructif à Toulouse
Texte intégral
(2) LE. EC O. O. D NA O LE C U S M U EN PE T RI SO EU U RE M IS D AU 'AR D CH R IT O E IT C D TU 'A R U E TE D U E R T. IO. AT. N. U SE. U LO.
(3)
(4)
(5) . "-4-9+1-4-5;:. EC O. LE. N. AT. IO. D NA O LE C U S M U EN PE T RI SO EU U RE M IS D AU 'AR D CH R IT O E IT C D TU 'A R U E TE D U E R T. O. U LO. U SE. 4 C84=B C>DC 3Z01>A3 P A4<4A284A <4B CDC4DAB 34 <T<>8A4 A0=R>8B4 ;0=2 'T<8 %0?8;;0D;C4CD3A4G>DA14108BB4?>DA;4DA022><?06=4<4=CC>DC0D;>=634;Z0==T4 HWTXLRQWVXPHJXLGHUGDQVPDUHFKHUFKHHWIDLUHDYDQFHUPDU¥ɀH[LRQGDQVODERQQH 38A42C8>=?>DA0AA8E4A0D?>8=C>V4;;44=4BC0D9>DA3Z7D8 4C84=B0DBB80A4<4A284A;4"DBT434BD6DBC8=B4C?;DB?0AC82D;8SA4<4=CD3A4G >DA203408=B8@D4;Z064=24'%@D8<Z>=C?A>2DAT34B8=5>A<0C8>=B4C34B3>2D<4=CB SU¥FLHX[TXLPȀRQWSHUPLVGHG¥YHORSSHUFHP¥PRLUHFRPPHMHOHG¥VLUDLVHWTXLPȀRQW SHUPLVGȀDOLPHQWHUPDU¥ɀH[LRQHQPHIRXUQLVVDQWXQVXSSRUWGRFXPHQWDLUHLPSRUWDQW -HWLHQVHQȿQUHPHUFLHU$QQDHW&DUROLQHSRXUOHXUVRXWLHQWPRUDOWRXWDXORQJ 34;Z0==T44C;4DABA4;42CDA4B3434A=8SA4<8=DC4.
(6) . .
(7)
(8)
(9) . #644)19E0=C?A>?>B. . U LO O. D NA O LE C U S M U EN PE T RI SO EU U RE M IS D AU 'AR D CH R IT O E IT C D TU 'A R U E TE D U E R T. . &D4BC8>=343T?0AC C0C34;Z0AC %A>1;T<0C8@D4 G?>C7SB4B !>68@D4343T<>=BCA0C8>=. U SE. 5;96,<+;165. .
(10)
(11). 4-9/-5+-,<7962-;;0H691-:-;+65;->;-. $0H691-,-&1633-;3-<+3-9);165)31:4-+65:;9<+;1. 0*=4?4=BT40E0=C60A38BC44=AD?CDA4 1!42>=24?C0E0=C;05>A<4BZ0??DG4ABDA;4?0BBT 2!4A0C8>=0;8B<42>=BCAD2C85 65;->;-,-7962-; 0!034<0=3434;0E8;;44C3D2>=B4AE0C4DA 1OE>;DC8>=B?A>94CB4C0A278C42C4BBD224BB85B.
(12)
(13) . $9)=)13,-+6476:1;165,<*E;14-5;. . 9/)51:);165,<73)5 0%A>94C34+8>;;4C;4D2;05>A<4BD8E0=C;05>=2C8>= 1%A>94C340A2G030?C0C8>=B4C09DBC4<4=CB 6476:1;165,-3).)F),-:<93)9<-3:)+-699)15 0%>=3TA0C8>=4CBG<TCA84 1%A>?>AC8>=B4CCA0<4 .
(14)
(15)
(16) . IO. );1G9-:-;41:-:-56-<=9-. EC O. LE. . N. AT. 1-99--;*918<0!01A8@D4CA038C8>=C>D;>DB08=4 1!0?84AA4?>AC4DB43Z>A=4<4=C -9-;*61: 0*=4270A?4=C4<TC0;;8@D4?>DA;4BB0;>=B34?48=CDA4 1+TA8CTBCAD2CDA4;;44C3T2>A. 65+3<:165 1*316/9)701- $)*3-,-:133<:;9);165: 55->-:
(17) . .
(18)
(19)
(20) . =)5;79676:. EC O. LE. N. AT. IO. D NA O LE C U S M U EN PE T RI SO EU U RE M IS D AU 'AR D CH R IT O E IT C D TU 'A R U E TE D U E R T. O. U LO. U SE. 0=B ;4 24=CA4 34 )>D;>DB4 A0A4B B>=C ;4B 6A0=34B ?4A2T4B 0DBB<0==84==4B CG?8@D4B34B<DC0C8>=B3D--S<4B8S2;42><<4>=?4DC;4E>8A30=B;4B0DCA4B6A0=34B YLOOHVGH)UDQFHFRPPH3DULVRX%RUGHDX[/HVVHXOHVJUDQGHVYRLHVGHFHWWH¥SRTXH P)>D;>DB4B>=C;0'D434"4CH4C;0'D4;B024!>AA08=4>=BCAD8C4B?0AD=4T@D8?4 3Z8=6T=84DAB?0A8B84=B?>DAA4;84A;060A4"0C0180DP;00A>==44;;4B>=CTCT;Z>220B8>= GHFRQVWUXLUHGHQRPEUHX[LPPHXEOHVGHUDSSRUWW\SLTXHVGHFHVJUDQGVD[HVHWGHV 14B>8=B 34 ;0 1>DA64>8B84 34 ;ZT?>@D4 !>8= 34B BC0=30A3B 4= DB064 P)>D;>DB4 24B LPPHXEOHVGHUDSSRUWDUERUHQWVRXYHQWGHODSLHUUHRXSRXUFHUWDLQGȀHQWUHHX[GHOD 1A8@D42;08A4>D34;01A8@D4?48=C4 %>DAC0=C30=B24?0GB0647><>6S=45>A6T?0A;4B<>3S;4B0DBB<0==84=BD= 1QC8<4=C A4BB>AC 34 ;0 <0BB4 ;4 "DBT4 34B D6DBC8=B 4C ?;DB ?0AC82D;8SA4<4=C ;Z08;4 'DUF\9LROOHWOH'XF GX QRP GH VHV DUFKLWHFWHV | OD FURLV¥H GHV GHX[ SHUF¥HV 1RUG (D34CBC $D4BC?AT2T34<<4=C01>A3T4B8;3T?;>84D=4E0BC42>=BCAD2C8>=<0BB8E434 1A8@D4BA>D64B?A>?A4BP;0CA038C8>=C>D;>DB08=48<?>B0=CB0<0BB434?D8B;0?;024 B@D8A>;4C30=BC>DC;4?0GB064DA108=34;0E8;;4.
(21) . .
(22)
(23)
(24) . 5;96,<+;165 !<-:;165,-,H7)9;. D NA O LE C U S M U EN PE T RI SO EU U RE M IS D AU 'AR D CH R IT O E IT C D TU 'A R U E TE D U E R T. O. U LO. U SE. /ȀDLOH'DUF\9LROOHWOH'XFHVWFRQVWUXLWHORUVGXSHUFHPHQWHWGHOȀ¥GLȿFDWLRQGH OD UXH$OVDFH/RUUDLQH SXLV GH OD 5XH GH 0HW] OD ȿQ GX ;,;¤PH VL¤FOH /RUVTXH OȀRQ A460A34;4B0DCA4B6A0=3B?A>94CB34)>D;>DB4P24CC4T?>@D4;050R03434;ZO2>;4 GHV%HDX[$UWV HWODEDVLOLTXHGHOD'DXUDGHSDUH[HPSOH
(25) RQVHUHQGFRPSWHTXȀLOVRQW WRXVOHVGHX[¥W¥FRQVWUXLWVHQSLHUUHGDQVOHSXUVW\OHDFDG¥PLTXHRUGUHVPRQXPHQWDX[ DOO¥JRULHV FRPSRVLWLRQ Q¥RFODVVLTXH HW GRQF DVVH] GLȾ¥UHQWV GX SURMHW GȀ(XJ¤QH +8>;;4C;4D24C344=8B0A2G184=@DZTC0=C2>=C4<?>A08=B /RUVGHODFRQFHSWLRQGHFHW¥GLȿFH9LROOHWOH'XFDG¥MGHUUL¤UHOXLXQHLPPHQVH FDUUL¤UHGHUHVWDXUDWHXUHWGHWK¥RULFLHQGHOȀDUFKLWHFWXUH|WUDYHUVVHVGLȾ¥UHQWV¥FULWV $ =>C0<<4=C;4B+1/$1'$+002/)B /"&'1$"12/$?D1;8TB4= 4C
(26) 8;?A>?>B44C3T54=3 D=40A278C42CDA4=>E0CA824A0C8>=0;8BC4?A>?A40D--S<4B8S2;4AT?>=30=CP 7)B ))' +"$ #$) %,/*$ 3$")$0!$0,'+0$1 3$")$0*,5$+0#$",+01/2"1',+9 'DQVFHFRQWH[WHHWDXYXGHFHTXLHVWFRQVWUXLWODP¦PH¥SRTXHFHWWHH[WHQVLRQ 3D"DBT434BD6DBC8=B0??0A0UC3>=22><<4TCA0=648=0CC4=3D4(02>=24?C8>=4= 3T20;0640E4224@D8B4508CP;ZT?>@D4?>B4@D4BC8>=4C4BCP<4CCA44=;84=0E42;4B A4274A274B0E0=C60A38BC4B34B>=2>=24?C4DA?A8=28?0;Z4BC24CC4?0AC82D;0A8CT24CC4 C4=B8>=4=CA40E0=C60A344C24@D8B4508CP24CC4T?>@D4@D80TCT;4?A4<84A<>C4DA GHU¥ɀH[LRQHWGHUHFKHUFKHVXUFHVXMHWDSSURIRQGLHWU¥RULHQW¥SDUODVXLWH &HP¥PRLUHD¥W¥PRWLY¥SDUOHVWUDYDX[DFWXHOVGHOȀ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ȀHQVHPEOHGHVGLȾ¥UHQWVFRXUDQWVWUDYHUVOD)UDQFHSHQGDQWFHWWHS¥ULRGH'X =T>2;0BB828B<4P;ZT2;42C8B<44=?0BB0=C?0A;4=T>6>C78@D48;?4A<4C342><?A4=3A4 OHVHQMHX[OHVUDLVRQVHWOHVFKDQJHPHQWVGHOȀDUFKLWHFWXUHHWGHVHVFRXUDQWVWUDYHUV ;4 B8S2;4 !ZT;0= ?0CA8<>=80; 34 ?ATB4AE0C8>= 4C 34 A4BC0DA0C8>= 4BC ;D8 0DBB8 01>A3T 4C 9LROOHWOH'XFQHSHXW¦WUH¥YLW¥VXUFHVXMHWPDLVVRQU°OHGHUHVWDXUDWHXUHVWELHQSOXV. %$, ,
(27) +-, - ,$ ' ,$'.,-+$ %% , ,-(',-+.$-',% ,''5 , )+%6+#$- - $ ++ ,*.$55-.$'-.0 .0
(28) +-, +$, ' -+'+$0 (& ' %('3($-.' !3 '5(%,,$*. (+'5 "+' , %%5"(+$ , % $'-.+ % .%)-.+ % +/.+ - %6
(29) +#$- -.+ % ,- '(-&& '-(''.2(.%(., )(.+%6&5'" & '- %%% ,%%.,-+ ,.)$-(% ."4' (+ % -(&)"'$ 5$- .++$, 55$-5)+ '!(%$(5$-$(',+$,
(30) .
(31) . .
(32)
(33)
(34) . IO. D NA O LE C U S M U EN PE T RI SO EU U RE M IS D AU 'AR D CH R IT O E IT C D TU 'A R U E TE D U E R T. O. U LO. U SE. DSSX\¥ HW G¥YHORSS¥ TXH VRQ U°OH GH WK¥RULFLHQ HW GȀDYDQWJDUGLVWH SRUWHXU GȀXQ A4=>DE40D34;Z0A278C42CDA44C8=8C80C4DA3D<>DE4<4=C<>34A=4@D8B43TE4;>??4A00D B8S2;4BD8E0=C M)>D;>DB424CC478BC>8A46T=TA0;434;Z0A278C42CDA40D--S<4B8S2;44BC?AT28BT4 30=B ,2),20$
(35) $0 =)'"$0 #$ )B*'1 1',+ T2A8C ?0A ;Z=BC8CDC A0=R08B 3ZA278C42CDA4 0=B 24C >DEA064 B>=C 3TE4;>??T4B ;4B A4BC0DA0C8>=B 34 +8>;;4C;4D2 30=B ;0 E8;;4 (C(4A=8= >=9>= 3D 0?8C>;4 >;;S64 (C '0G<>=3 ;4B 6A0=3B ?A>94CB 34 ?4A2T4B 70DBB<0==84==4B?0A;Z8=6T=84DA"06DSB!4"DBT434BD6DBC8=BG4BC<4=C8>==T<08B 2>=24A=0=C;0A4BC0DA0C8>=AT0;8BT4?0A(CG<%>??4A30=B;4B0==T4B ;4?A>94C34 9LROOHWOH'XFHW'DUF\SRXUOȀH[WHQVLRQGXPXV¥HSDUWLUGHQȀHVWTXHVRPPDLUHPHQW <4=C8>==T4 !4<DBT434BD6DBC8=B0;D80DBB8508C;Z>194C34?;DB84DABT2A8CB=>C0<<4=C30=B ;0 A4ED4 ,++ '00 +"$ #$0 /10 =J
(36) 9D8; 0>DC >D '#'5/=+=$0 1/'*,'+$ >ABBTA84=J!4BA4274A274B4C3TE4;>??4<4=CBB42>=24=CA4=CBDA;02>;;42C8>=34 FKDSLWHDX[URPDQVH[SRV¥VGDQVODQRXYHOOHDLOHGXFRXYHQWP¥GL¥YDORXGHOȀ¥JOLVHGH BCG;46>C78@D4<TA838>=0;<08B;P4=2>A4;02>=24?C8>=3D1QC8<4=C34+8>;;4C;4D24C 0A2G=Z4BC@D4<4=C8>==T43T2A8C42><<4I?0;08B34BCG;4=T>A4=08BB0=24L !4CA0E08;34+8>;;4C;4D2?0AB>=8<?>AC0=244CB>=20A02CSA40E0=C60A38BC40 TCTCASBTCD38T30=B;4BD=8E4AB8CTB0<TA8208=4B<08B=Z0?0B2>==D0DC0=C3Z0CC4=C8>=4= )UDQFH6RQU°OHHQWHPSVTXHUHVWDXUDWHXUSRUWHXUGXPRXYHPHQWVW\OLVWLTXHHVWOȀREMHW GH QRPEUHX[ ¥FULWV HW UHFKHUFKHV FRQFHUQDQW 3LHUUHIRQGV OH 9¥]HOD\ &DUFDVVRQQH 6W 6HUQLQ
(37) 6DYLVLRQQRYDWULFHGHOȀDUFKLWHFWXUHSU¥ȿJXUDQWOHPRGHUQLVPHGX;;¤PHVL¤FOH 4BC01>A3T4?0A#82>;0B%038>D30=B;0A4ED4'3/ '0,+0#B&'01,'/$#$)B /"&'1$"12/$;G ?A>?>B4 D=4 BG=C7SB4 4=CA4 ;4 CA0E08; 0E0=C60A38BC4 34+8>;;4C;4D2 4C ;Z0203T<8B<4 3470A;4B0A=84A2>=C4<?>A08=3D?A4<84A4C6A0=33T54=B4DA3DBCG;4I#0?>;T>=L T2;42C8@D4 (QȿQGȀDXWUHV¥FULWVELHQTXHSRXYDQWVHUDSSRUWHUFHSURMHWGRLYHQW¦WUHFRQVXOW¥V FRPPH VXSSRUWV GH U¥ɀH[LRQ FRPSO¥PHQWDLUHV PDLV WRXFKHQW GHV SUREO¥PDWLTXHV 0DCA4B@D8BZT;>86=4=CB4=B81;4<4=C3D?A>24BBDB342>=24?C8>=3D1QC8<4=C2>4DA34 ODU¥ɀH[LRQG¥YHORSS¥HLFL FRPPHRQYDOHYRLUGDQVOHVK\SRWK¤VHV
(38) $LQVL ',))$1)$2" )B=")$"1'0*$/ '0,++=34AD=>>D20AC>D ,2/2+$&'01,'/$#$0*20=$0 2<*$0'<")$ GH'DQLHO6KHUPDQGRLYHQW¦WUH¥FDUW¥VGXFĎXUGHODU¥ɀH[LRQGRQWFHP¥PRLUHIDLW ;Z>194C. N. AT. 96*3H4);18<-. EC O. LE. +8>;;4C;4D24BC0??4;T?>DA;02>=BCAD2C8>=3ZD=4=>DE4;;408;43DI)4<?;4 GHV$UWVzSU¥H[LVWDQWGDQVOHFDGUHGXSHUFHPHQWGHODUXH$OVDFH/RUUDLQHGDQVOH 34A=84A@D0AC3D--S<4B8S2;4;2>=R>8C4C?ATB4=C4D=?A>94C4=0BB>280C8>=0E42 'HQLV'DUF\HQ&HSURMHWHVWȿG¤OHODSHQV¥HUDWLRQDOLVWHGHVRQFRQFHSWHXU @DZ8;0;0A64<4=C3TE4;>??T430=BB4BT2A8CB=>C0<<4=C;4B +1/$1'$+002/)B /"&'1$"12/$ 41QC8<4=C?A>?>BT?0A;Z0A278C42C4?0A8B84=4BC0??A>DETP;ZD=0=8<8CT?0A;4>=B48; "D=828?0;4C;4>=B48;T=TA0;34BQC8<4=CB8E8;B4C 7)B /"&'1$"12/$#$) % ; #$ $01 !0,)2*$+1 #,-1=$ 9 !>AB@D4+8>;;4C;4D2 <4DAC 4= P !0DB0==4 0A2G 9DB@DZ0;>ABB8<?;42>;;01>A0C4DA34E84=CA4B?>=B01;43D?A>94C;BZ0??A>?A84;4CA0E08; 34 B>= <0UCA4 0??;8@D4 34B A42><<0=30C8>=B 508C4B ;>AB 34 ;0 E0;830C8>= 3D ?A>94C
(39) . .
(40)
(41)
(42) . HQHWOȀH[WHQVLRQRULJLQHOOHGH9LROOHWOH'XFVHPRGLȿHSHXSHX/HFĎXUGH ODU¥ɀH[LRQLFLYDFRQFHUQHUODQDWXUHGHFHVPRGLȿFDWLRQVHWOHXULPSDFW =@D>8;4 ?A>24BBDB342>=24?C8>=4C34AT0;8B0C8>=3D?A>94C0C8;?4A<8C>D=>=;0?TA4==8CT 34BC7T>A84BA0C8>=0;8BC4B34+8>;;4C;4D2. ?76;0G:-:. U SE. . D NA O LE C U S M U EN PE T RI SO EU U RE M IS D AU 'AR D CH R IT O E IT C D TU 'A R U E TE D U E R T. O. U LO. %>DA5028;8C4A;4CA0E08;34A4274A2748;50DC03<4CCA4D=24AC08==><1A43ZT;T<4=CB FRPPH¥WDQWDFTXLVHWTXHOȀRQQHFKHUFKHUDSDVY¥ULȿHU /RUVTXHOHSURMHWHVWUHSULVSDU'HQLV'DUF\HQLODE¥Q¥ȿFL¥GȀXQHOLEHUW¥GH 2>=24?C8>=@D8;D8>=C?4A<8B34BT20ACB4C34B0??A>?A80C8>=B3D?A>94C3410B4<0;6AT ODYDOLGDWLRQGHFHGHUQLHU,ODSXSUHQGUHGHVOLEHUW¥VHWPRGLȿHUOHVSODQVDFFHSW¥VSDU OHVDXWRULW¥VTXLRQWHQWUDªQ¥OHVPRGLȿFDWLRQVTXLVRQWOHVXMHWP¦PHGHFHWWHUHFKHUFKH 4CC47G?>C7SB44BC022AT38CT4?0AD=2><?C4A4=3D3D>=B48;"D=828?0;3DA0=C;0 2>=BCAD2C8>=@D8;4;D804BC38A42C4<4=CA4?A>27T 0DCA4?0ACBDAD=24AC08==><1A434?>8=CB8;50D3A038BC8=6D4A=>B2>==08BB0=24B 02CD4;;4B30=BD=24AC08==><1A4343><08=4B34;02>=BCAD2C8>=4C;4B2>==08BB0=24B GHODȿQGX;,;¤PHVL¤FOHVXUOHVTXHOOHV9LROOHWOH'XFHW'DUF\RQWSXV DSSX\HU6XUOHV SURSUL¥W¥V SK\VLTXHV GH FHUWDLQV PDW¥ULDX[ QRWDPPHQW VXU OD S¥UHQQLW¥ GH FHUWDLQHV SLHUUHVXUOHVSURSUL¥W¥VGXP¥WDOGHVDɁUPDWLRQVGH9LROOHWOH'XFV DY¤UHQWDXMRXUG KXL IDXVVHV/RUVTX XQGHFHVPDW¥ULDX[HVWXWLOLV¥LOIDXWOHUHPHWWUHHQSHUVSHFWLYHDYHFOD 2>==08BB0=2434;T?>@D44C=>=0E4224;;4@D4=>DB4=0E>=B0D9>DA37D8. 6/18<-,-,H465:;9);165. EC O. LE. N. AT. IO. 3RXU U¥SRQGUH OD SUREO¥PDWLTXH OH SODQ YD ¦WUH G¥YHORSS¥ HQ RS¥UDQW XQ ?0A0;;S;44=CA4;4BT2A8CB34+8>;;4C;4D24C;4?A>94C@DZ8;02>=RD4= ?>DA<4CCA4 HQOXPL¤UHOHVTXDOLW¥VLVVXHVGHVDSHQV¥HUDWLRQDOLVWHHWOHSURMHW HWVHVPRGLȿFDWLRQV
(43) @D40A2G02>=RD4CAT0;8BTP?0AC8A34 3RXUUHQGUH¥WDWGXSURMHWODU¥ɀH[LRQSRXUUDVȀDSSX\HUVXUGHQRPEUHX[VXSSRUWV A4;4ETB8=B8CD3D1QC8<4=C02CD4;<08B0DBB8;Z4=B4<1;434B0A278E4B2>=B4AET4B0D"DBT434B $XJXVWLQVHWDX[$UFKLYHVPXQLFLSDOHVGHOD9LOOHGH7RXORXVH GRVVLHUVGȀH[¥FXWLRQVGRVVLHUV GHFKDQWLHUVUDSSRUWVGLYHUV
(44) &ȀHVWSDUXQHDQDO\VHȿQHGHODFRQVWUXFWLRQHQDOODQW 274A274A34B8=5>A<0C8>=BBDA;02><?>B8C8>=6T=TA0;434BE>;D<4B<08B0DBB8P?4C8C4T274;;4 VXUODFRQVWLWXWLRQGHVPXUVVXUOHVPDW¥ULDX[HPSOR\¥VTXHOȀRQSRXUUDIDLUHOHOLHQDYHFOHV C7T>A84BBDA;4A0C8>=0;8B<42>=BCAD2C85@D8B>DBC4=34=C>D=>=;02>=BCAD2C8>=3D1QC8<4=C Z0DCA4 ?0AC @D0=C 0D CA0E08; BDA ;4B C7T>A84B E8>;;4C;43D284==4B ;4B +1/$1'$+0 02/ )B /"&'1$"12/$ $ G¥YHORSSHQW SOXVLHXUV JUDQGV WK¤PHV GH U¥ɀH[LRQ WUDYHUV OHV YLQJW 4=CA4C84=B $DCA4 D=4 78BC>8A4 34 ;Z0A278C42CDA4 6A42@D4 A><08=4 1GH0=C8=4 6>C78@D4 4CD=42A8C8@D40BB4H024A1434;Z4=B486=4<4=C34;Z0A278C42CDA44=A0=244C34;ZO2>;4 GHV %HDX[$UWV LO H[SRVH GH PDQL¤UH ODUJH HW DSSURIRQGLH VD YLVLRQ GH FH TXH GRLW ¦WUHOȀDUFKLWHFWXUHGX;,;¤PHVL¤FOH|WUDYHUVXQFHUWDLQQRPEUHVGȀHQWUHWLHQVLOG¥SORLH SRLQWSDUSRLQWWRXWHVOHVFDUDFW¥ULVWLTXHVGHFHWWHDUFKLWHFWXUHHWOȀLOOXVWUHGȀH[HPSOHV C7T>A8@D4B $XȿOGHVHQWUHWLHQV9LROOHWOH'XFDERUGHOȀHQVHPEOHGXSURFHVVXVGHFRQFHSWLRQ 3ZD= 1QC8<4=C ;Z8<?>AC0=24 3D ?A>6A0<<4 ;0 5>A<4 P 3>==4A P B>= 1QC8<4=C ;4B
(45) . .
(46)
(47)
(48) . EC O. LE. N. AT. IO. D NA O LE C U S M U EN PE T RI SO EU U RE M IS D AU 'AR D CH R IT O E IT C D TU 'A R U E TE D U E R T. O. U LO. U SE. PDW¥ULDX[HPSOR\HUHWOHXUVFDUDFW¥ULVWLTXHVOHWUDYDLOGHSURSRUWLRQVGHSHUVSHFWLYHV 4C3Z><1A4B0<4=0=CP;02><?>B8C8>=34;050R034;4B?A8=28?4B2>=BCAD2C85B4=5>=2C8>= GHVPDW¥ULDX[HPSOR\¥V2QSHXWDLQVLDXWUDYHUVGHFHWWHWK¥RULHUHFRQVWLWXHUFHTXH GRLW¦WUHXQHDUFKLWHFWXUHTXȀLOHQWHQGFRPPH¥WDQWSURSUHDX;,;¤PHVL¤FOH %>DA AT?>=3A4 P ;0 ?A>1;T<0C8@D4 8; B4A0 30=B D= ?A4<84A C4<?B 8<?>AC0=C 34 G¥ȿQLU FH TXȀHVW SRXU 9LROOHWOH'XF OH UDWLRQDOLVPH FRQVWUXFWLI SRXUTXRL HVWFH XQH C7T>A84 8=CTA4BB0=C4 @DZ4BC 24 @DZ4;;4 0??>AC4 @DZ4;;4B B>=C B4B 20A02CTA8BC8@D4B %D8B DXȿOGXG¥YHORSSHPHQWVHUDDERUG¥HSRLQWSDUSRLQWODFRQFHSWLRQGHVGLȾ¥UHQWHV E4AB8>=B3D1QC8<4=C0DA460A334;0E8B8>=C7T>A8@D43TE4;>??T430=BB4BT2A8CB4C A4=3A42><?C434;4DA0??;820C8>= /HSODQTXLG¥FRXOHGHFHWWHORJLTXHGHG¥PRQVWUDWLRQUHFRQWH[WXDOLVHOHWUDYDLO 34+8>;;4C;4D2 4C ;4B C7T>A84B @DZ8; 3TE4;>??4 B4 ?4=274 ?;DB ?AT28BT<4=C BDA 24;;4 GX UDWLRQDOLVPH FRQVWUXFWLI DX FĎXU GH OD U¥ɀH[LRQ DYDQW GȀDERUGHU OHV SURMHWV GH OȀH[WHQVLRQGXPXV¥HGHV$XJXVWLQVHWGHPHWWUHHQSDUDOO¤OHFKDTXH¥O¥PHQWUHOHY¥VXU ;41QC8<4=C0E42;Z4=CA4C84=>V8;4=4BC@D4BC8>=.
(49) . .
(50)
(51)
(52) . C4-9/-5+-,<7962-;;0H691-:-;+65;->; $0H691-,-&1633-;3-<+3-9);165)31:4-+65:;9<+;1. 0*=4?4=BT40E0=C60A38BC44=AD?CDA4. U SE. . D NA O LE C U S M U EN PE T RI SO EU U RE M IS D AU 'AR D CH R IT O E IT C D TU 'A R U E TE D U E R T. O. U LO. /Ȁ$FDG¥PLH GHV %HDX[$UWV TXL IRUPH OHV DUFKLWHFWHV DX ;,;¤PH VL¤FOH HW Rµ 9LROOHWOH'XFHQVHLJQHEUL¤YHPHQWGH
(53) DG¥YHORSS¥DXȿOGHVDQQ¥HVXQH 0??A>274?0AC82D;8SA434;02>=24?C8>=0A278C42CDA0;4'827434BA4;4ETB34B0=C8@D4B QRWDPPHQWFHX[U¥DOLV¥VSDUOHVSUL[GH5RPHMHXQHVDUFKLWHFWHVGLSO°P¥VHQYR\¥V 5RPHSDUOHV%HDX[$UWVSRXU\¥WXGLHUOHVDQWLTXHV
(54) XQHGRFWULQHYLVDQWUHSURGXLUH ;4B5>A<4B8BBD4B34B0A278C42CDA4B?0BBT4BT<4A64?4DP?4D30=B;Z4=B486=4<4=C34 OȀ$FDG¥PLH/HPRXYHPHQWQ¥RFODVVLTXHTXLODȿQGX;9,,,¤PHVL¤FOHDDPHQ¥XQVRXɂH =>DE40DBDA;Z0A278C42CDA40E4234B5>A<4BT?DAT4BD=BCG;4=>DE40D30=B;Z83T>;>684 U¥YROXWLRQQDLUHHWXWRSLTXHGHFHWHPSVOVHSHUGSHXSHXDX;,;¤PHVL¤FOH(QHȾHW OȀDUFKLWHFWXUHHVWHQJUDQGHSDUWLHDXVHUYLFHGHVSRXYRLUVIRUWV QRWDPPHQWLPS¥ULDX[
(55) @D8GCA>DE4=CD=1>=<>G4=3Z0BBDA4AD=48<06434A8274BB44C3Z>?D;4=24?0BB0=C?0A ;Z4<?;>801>=30=C3Z>A=4<4=CB343T2>A0C8>=B4C3ZTE>20C8>=B34?D8BB0=24B?0BBT4B. 3UL[GH5RPH%A>94C?>DAD=?0;08B34BACB?0A4A=0A30BB84=4= . N. AT. IO. 4BCG;4T2;42C8@D4;4?A>94C4<?AD=C4B02>D?>;4P24;;43D%0=C7T>=34'><4B4B>A3A4B2;0BB8@D4B DX[UXLQHVJUHFTXHVODID£DGHGHVHVSDYLOORQVDX[DUFVGHWULRPSKHURPDLQVSRXUFU¥HUXQEWLPHQW @D84=A4?A4=0=C24B28C0C8>=B274A274P8<?>B4AD=48<06434?D8BB0=244C3Z>?D;4=240??DGT4?0A ;0BG<TCA84<0A@D434?>DE>8A4C34BC018;8CT. EC O. LE. %>DA AT?>=3A4 P 24CC4 34<0=34 ;Z203T<84 E0 ?4D P ?4D 4=B486=4A =>= ?0B ;0 2>=24?C8>= 0A278C42CDA0;4 2><<4 >= ;0 2>==0UC 0D9>DA3Z7D8 <08B D=4 <0=8SA4 34 A4?A>3D8A44C34BZ8=B?8A4A34B0A278C42CDA4B?0BBT4BCASB5>AC48=B8?;DB84DABB8S2;4B0?ASB ODSURGXFWLRQGHVRULJLQDX[RQHQFRXUDJHXQHFRQFHSWLRQTXLSXLVHGLUHFWHPHQWGDQV ;4B5>A<4B?A>3D8C4B?0A;Z=C8@D8CT>D;4">G4=N64?>DA2>=24E>8A34B0A278C42CDA4B ;4 ?;DB B>DE4=C 0D B4AE824 3D ?>DE>8A "08B 24 508B0=C ;Z203T<84 =Z0 ED 30=B 24B 0A278C42CDA4B ?0BBTB @D4 ;4B 5>A<4B 4C =>= ;4B 2>=24?CB @D8 >=C ?A>3D8C 24B 5>A<4B l1HYR\DQWTXHGHVHȿHWVHOOHVȁHVWIDLWQ¥RJUHFTXHQ¥RURPDQHQ¥RJRWKLTXHz%>DA
(56)
(57)
(58) &( !#%!" )%&##$ ))%)"# !!)%! $#$
(59) . .
(60) . .
(61)
(62)
(63) . EC O. LE. N. AT. IO. D NA O LE C U S M U EN PE T RI SO EU U RE M IS D AU 'AR D CH R IT O E IT C D TU 'A R U E TE D U E R T. O. U LO. U SE. 0BB>DE8A;4B14B>8=B3Z>?D;4=2434<>=D<4=C0;8CT4C3Z0??0A4=2434A8274BB43D?>DE>8A ?>;8C8@D4;Z203T<8400;>AB4<?AD=CT34B5>A<4B3D?0BBTB4;4B0AT0??A>?A8TBB0=B HVVD\HUGHSHUFHUOHFRQFHSWTXLD¥W¥P¦PHGHSURGXLUHFHVIRUPHVTXȀHOOHGHPDQGH DX[QRXYHDX[DUFKLWHFWHVGHUHFRSLHU %0A245>=2C8>==4<4=C34;Z4=B486=4<4=C34;Z0A278C42CDA4C>DC0D;>=63D--S<4 B8S2;4;Z0A278C42CDA44=4BC0AA8ET4P?0AC8A34B0==T4B P;0?A>3D2C8>=341QC8<4=CB RQ¥UHX[QHU¥SRQGDQWTXHUDUHPHQWDX[EHVRLQVGHODVRFL¥W¥HWGLɁFLOHPHQWFRPSULVSDU OHSXEOLF(QHȾHW7)$0 /100,+1* ) #$0)B /"&'1$"12/$0$*$2/1 20$'+#$) -/,0-=/'1=
(64) HOOH VH PHXUW GȁH[F¤V MRLQWV XQ U¥JLPH G¥ELOLWDQW z !Z0A278C42CDA4 4= <8<0=C 34B ¥GLȿFHVSDVV¥VSRXUU¥SRQGUHDX[YRORQW¥VGHSRXYRLUHWGȀLPDJHGȀXQU¥JLPHSROLWLTXH IRUWVȀHVW¥JDU¥HHWDSHXSHXSHUGXOȀHVVHQFHGHFHTXLǿHOOHGRLW¦WUHVHORQ9LROOHWOH D2PB0E>8AlXQHQVHPEOHUDLVRQQ¥GHGLVSRVLWLRQVJ¥Q¥UDOHVXQHPDQLIHVWDWLRQYUDLH GHVEHVRLQVGHVXVDJHVHWGHVPďXUVGȁXQHFLYLOLVDWLRQz !0@D4BC8>=345>=301>A3T4 828@D8B>DBC4=3C>DC4;0?4=BT4A0C8>=0;8BC4@DZ8;3TE4;>??430=BB4B4=CA4C84=B 4BC;0 VXLYDQWHFRPPHQWSURGXLUHXQHDUFKLWHFWXUHTXLU¥SRQGHGHPDQL¤UHVHQV¥HHWHɁFDFH DX[EHVRLQVGHODVRFL¥W¥GX;,;¤PHVL¤FOHHQVHG¥SDUWLVVDQWGHVGRFWULQHVFODVVLTXHV" M;Z>??>BT34;0?4=BT434;Z203T<84+8>;;4C;4D23TE4;>??40;>AB30=BB4B +1/$1'$+002/)B /"&'1$"12/$?D1;8TB4= 4C
(65) D=42>=24?C8>=@D8B4A08C?A>?A4 $ P B>= T?>@D4 ; 0E0=24 C>DC 3Z01>A3 ?>DA G AT?>=3A4 ;0 =T24BB8CT 01B>;D4 34 B4 3T?0AC8A34B5>A<4B3D?0BBT@D8=Z>=C?;DBA84=PE>8A4CP0??>AC4APD=42>=24?C8>= TXLVHUHYHQGLTXHUDLWSURSUHDX;,;¤PHVL¤FOH(QHȾHWSRXU9LROOHWOH'XFOȀDUFKLWHFWXUH HVWXQWRXWLVVXGHOȀ¥SRTXHGHVPĎXUVGHODFLYLOLVDWLRQGHVVFLHQFHVGHVKDELWXGHV 4= 02C8>= 0D <><4=C 34 B0 ?A>3D2C8>= $A ;4 --S<4 B8S2;4 4BC D= B8S2;4 =>DE40D VXU GH QRPEUHX[ DVSHFWV VRFL¥WDX[ ¥FRQRPLTXHV LQGXVWULHOV 2Q QH SHXW GRQF SDV WURXYHUXQHDUFKLWHFWXUHG¥MSURGXLWHSDUOHSDVV¥TXLSXLVVHU¥SRQGUHDX[QRXYHDX[ G¥ȿVTXLVHSRVHQWHWODFRSLHHQVHLJQ¥HSDUOȀ$FDG¥PLHQHIDLWSOXVVHQV(QG¥WHQDQW OȀDSSUHQWLVVDJHGHOȀDUFKLWHFWXUHHOOHDIDLWSDVVHUFHWWHGHUQL¤UHF°W¥GHWRXWFHTXH ;ZT;0=34?A>6ASB4C3Z8==>E0C8>=3D--S<4B8S2;40?D?>AC4A30=B;4B8=3DBCA84B30=B ;0 ?48=CDA4 30=B ;0 ;8CCTA0CDA4 l /H ;,;¤PH VL¤FOH HVWLO FRQGDPQ¥ ɀQLU VDQV DYRLU -,00=#=2+$ /"&'1$"12/$:)2' 9 3RXUG¥YHORSSHUOHVSULQFLSHVP¦PHGHSURGXLUHXQHDUFKLWHFWXUHSURSUHVRQ C4<?B+8>;;4C;4D2508CD=438BC8=2C8>=8<?>AC0=C44=CA4I ) %,/*$4C $ )$",+"$-1 5 +1 -/,#2'1 ) %,/*$ 9 20A 2Z4BC 30=B 24CC4 38BC8=2C8>= @D4 ;Z203T<84 0 B4;>= ;D8 ?4A3D OȀDUFKLWHFWXUH GHSXLV OD 5¥YROXWLRQ 3RXU U¥SRQGUH DX[ EHVRLQV GH OD PDQL¤UH OD SOXV MXVWHHWODSOXVKRQQ¦WHSRVVLEOHOȀDUFKLWHFWHGRLWSUHQGUHHQFRPSWHWURLVOHYLHUVVHORQ 9LROOHWOH'XF ,O IDXW WRXW GȀDERUG IDLUH DWWHQWLRQ DX[ EHVRLQV OH SUREO¤PH DXTXHO OH EWLPHQWGHYUDU¥SRQGUHHWVȀDGDSWHU
(66) DX[XVDJHV DXWUHPHQWGLWOHVKDELWXGHVHWODYLH GHVSHUVRQQHVGDQVOHEWLPHQW
(67) HWHQȿQDX[PDW¥ULDX[GHFRQVWUXFWLRQGLVSRVLWLRQ 4BCA>8B?AT24?C4B3>8E4=C2>=3D8A4;02>=24?C8>=0A278C42CDA0;48;=Z4BC?;DB@D4BC8>=
(68) ')! " "$&" #!*&'$$% **&*#$ !""*&"!%$%
(69) !
(70) ')!" "$&" #!*&'$$% **&*#$ !""*&"!%$%
(71) !
(72) ')! " "$&" #!*&'$$% **&*#$ !""*&"!%$%
(73) ! .
(74) . .
(75)
(76)
(77) . 1!42>=24?C0E0=C;05>A<4BZ0??DG4ABDA;4?0BBT. D NA O LE C U S M U EN PE T RI SO EU U RE M IS D AU 'AR D CH R IT O E IT C D TU 'A R U E TE D U E R T. O. . U LO. U SE. 342AT4A34B1>UC4B>A=4<4=CT4B3ZD=BCG;48=3T?4=30<<4=C3424@D4;41QC8<4=CE0 022D48;;8A70$/ 1')'$21 !)$,2"23$11$98=B8;05>A<43D1QC8<4=C3>8C0E0=CC>DC CA03D8A44C3T2>D;4A3D?A>6A0<<434BDB064B4C34B14B>8=BB0=B01>A34A;4?A>1;S<4 P;Z4=E4AB4=?A>3D8B0=CD=45>A<48BBD43ZD=43>2CA8=43Z8<8C0C8>=3D?0BBT30=B;0@D4;;4 >=C4=C43Z8=BTA4AD=?A>6A0<<40=B24CC4?>B8C8>=CASB5>AC4?>DA;ZT?>@D44=C>C0;4 AD?CDA40E42;Z83T>;>68434;Z203T<8401>A3T4?AT2T34<<4=C>=?4DCE>8AT<4A64A;4B GRFWULQHVGHOȀDYDQWJDUGHGHVDQQ¥HVHWGXPRXYHPHQWPRGHUQHTXLSU°QHUDOH 2>=24?CI5>A<5>;;>FB5D=2C8>=L2><<4;438C!>D8B(D;;8E0=30=B;4B0==T4B . EC O. LE. N. AT. IO. /HV LPSRUWDQWV UHOHY¥V U¥DOLV¥V SDU OHV SUL[ GH 5RPH GHSXLV OHXU FU¥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ɀTXHPRHOOH ?4AB?42C8E430=B;ZT?>@D44C;028E8;8B0C8>=30=B;0@D4;;48;0TCT2>=BCAD8C7 ",*-,0'1',+ DUFKLWHFWRQLTXH GHYDQW G¥ULYHU DEVROXPHQW GX SURJUDPPH LPSRV¥ HW GHV KDELWXGHV #$ ) "'3')'0 1',+ 2 *')'$2 #$ ) .2$))$ ,+ 3'1 9 8=B8 ;Z8<?>AC0=C 30=B ;Z0=0;GB4 34B 0A278C42CDA4B?0BBTB24=Z4BC?0B34A4?A>3D8A4;05>A<420A24;;4280TCT382CT4?0A;0 FLYLOLVDWLRQODPDLQGȀĎXYUHGLVSRQLEOHOHFOLPDWOHVPDW¥ULDX[GHVSHQV¥HVLG¥RORJLTXHV 43>=C8;4BC4=A4E0=274?>BB81;434C8A4A?0AC82Z4BC;42>=24?C;0<0=8SA434508A4 ;4*,#20,-$/ +#'TXLDSSOLTX¥DXFRQWH[WHDSURGXLWODIRUPH ' 7B=12#$#2- 00= $01+="$00 '/$'+#'0-$+0 !)$* '0:) ",+#'1',+#B$+#=#2'/$#$0-/'+"'-$0-)21@1.2$ #$0%,/*$09 8=B8;Z0A278C42CDA4C4;;4@DZ4;;4B4?ATB4=C4;>AB@D4@DZ8;T2A8CB>=CA08CT0 140D2>D?P?D8B4AB84;;4C4=C4342><?A4=3A424B?A8=28?4B@D8B420274=C34AA8SA4 ;4B5>A<4B 7 "&,+0"$.2$+,200,**$0-,2/0 3,'/"$.2$+,20#$3,+0$1-,23,+0 % '/$9 OC01;8BB0=CD=?0A0;;S;40E42;4B0A278C42CDA4B0=C8@D4B6A42@D4B4CA><08=4BCASB ¥WXGL¥HVSDUOHVSUL[GH5RPHLOSURSRVHXQHQRXYHOOHPDQL¤UHGHYRLUOHSUREO¤PH3OXW°W @D434A4?A>3D8A4D=B8<D;02A434%0AC7T=>=;>AB@D4+86=>=4CDET2>=BCAD8B4=C;ZT6;8B4 GHOD0DGHOHLQH3DULVLOYDXGUDLWPLHX[WHQWHUGHFRPSUHQGUHFRPPHQWODG¥PRFUDWLH 0C7T=84==4T2;08AT44C?0BB8>==T4?0A;4B0ACB30=BD=2;8<0C0A8340E42?4D34<08= GȀĎXYUHHWGHVPDW¥ULDX[GXUVH[WUDLUHHVWSDUYHQXHSURGXLUHOH3DUWK¥QRQ3OXW°W
(78) (*"" "!!# ' ""# #% '#!$"+'(%%& ++'+$% "# #+'#"&%&
(79) #"&" "
(80) (*"" "!!# ' ""# #% '#!$"+'(%%& ++'+$% "# #+'#"&%&
(81) #"&" "
(82) (*"" "!!# ' ""# #% '#!$"+'(%%& ++'+$% "# #+'#"&%&! #%&" "
(83) (*"" "!!# ' ""# #% '#!$"+'(%%& ++'+$% "# #+'#"&%&
(84) $&" "" " .
(85) . .
(86)
(87)
(88) . . . D NA O LE C U S M U EN PE T RI SO EU U RE M IS D AU 'AR D CH R IT O E IT C D TU 'A R U E TE D U E R T. O. U LO. U SE. TXHGHUHSURGXLUHXQHIRUPHGHFRUQLFKHRXGHPRG¥QDWXUHGHVIRUXPVLPS¥ULDX[LOIDXW SOXW°WWHQWHUGHFRPSUHQGUHFRPPHQWSDUH[HPSOHOȀ(PSLUHURPDLQDSXSURGXLUHDYHF XQH JUDQGH PDLQ GȀĎXYUH EHDXFRXS GH PDW¥ULDX[ GLVSRVLWLRQ HW XQH RUJDQLVDWLRQ SROLWLTXH IRUWH HW HɁFDFH OHV WKHUPHV GH &DUDFDOOD RX GH 'LRFO¥WLHQ TXL VRQW GHV U¥SRQVHVMXVWHVXQEHVRLQGHOȀ¥SRTXHGDQVXQFRQWH[WHSDUWLFXOLHU 3RXU VȀHQULFKLU VH G¥YHORSSHU HW HQȿQ U¥SRQGUH DX[ YUDLV EHVRLQV GH VRQ WHPSV 0?ASB 34B 3T24==84B 3Z0203T<8B<4 ;Z0A278C42CDA4 0 140D2>D? P ?D8B4A 30=B 24CC4 FRQWRUVLRQGHODSHQV¥HFHQĎXGHVVHQWLHOGHODFRQFHSWLRQDUFKLWHFWXUDOH/ȀLPSRUWDQW =Z4BC ?0B 34 A4?A>3D8A4 D=4 5>A<4 20A >= =4 A4CA>DE4A0 90<08B ;4B 2>=38C8>=B @D8 >=C 508C T<4A64A 24CC4 5>A<4 ;0 ?A4<8SA4 5>8B %0AC0=C 3D ?ATBD??>BT @D4;4B 0A278C42CDA4B 0=C8@D4B B>=C I EA084B L P B0E>8A @DZ4;;4 AT?>=34=C 34 <0=8SA4 A08B>==T4 9DBC4 HW HɁFDFH XQ EHVRLQ GDQV XQ FRQWH[WH SU¥FLV LO QH IDLW SDV VHQV GȀHQ UHSURGXLUH OHV IRUPHV (Q HȾHW FHV GHUQL¤UHV QH IRQW VHQV TXH SDUFH TXȀHOOHV VRQW SURGXLWHV HQ D= 8=BC0=C 4C D= ;84D ?AT28B ?>DA AT?>=3A4 P D= 14B>8= ?0AC82D;84A D2D= 34 24B CA>8B ?>8=CB =4 B4 A4CA>DE0=C 34 <0=8SA4 834=C8@D4 4= A0=24 0D --S<4 B8S2;4 8; =4 508C 3>=2 0D2D= B4=B 34 A4?A>3D8A4 D=4 2>A=8274 3D %0AC7T=>= >D ;0 2>;>==4 )A090=4 !4 --S<4 B8S2;4 A8274 34 ;0 ATE>;DC8>= 8=3DBCA84;;4 3D 3TE4;>??4<4=C 34 =>DE4;;4B WHFKQLTXHVGHODSURGXFWLRQGHQRXYHDX[PDW¥ULDX[GHOȀHVVRUGXFKHPLQGHIHUSU¥VHQWH D=42>=9>=2CDA490<08BED49DB@DZ0;>AB5>AC4346A0=34B8==>E0C8>=B3>=C8;50DCC8A4A?0AC8 l/HVPDW¥ULDX[QRXVDUULYHQWGHWRXVF°W¥VIDFLOHPHQWSLHGGȁďXYUHODPDLQGȁďXYUH HVW FK¤UH OH WHPSV SU¥FLHX[ ,O VHUDLW GRQF SU¥I¥UDEOH GH VRQJHU FRQVWUXLUH VHORQ "$0+,23$))$0#,++=$09 'DQVFHFRQWH[WHODUHSURGXFWLRQGHIRUPHVGXSDVV¥HVW 203D@D4=4508C?;DBB4=BB4;>=+8>;;4C;4D24C8;4BC8=38B?4=B01;4343TE4;>??4AD=4 DUFKLWHFWXUHSURSUHDX;,;¤PHVL¤FOHU¥SRQGDQWVHVEHVRLQVVHVPĎXUVHWVHVPR\HQV GHFRQVWUXFWLRQGDQVXQHIRUPHQRXYHOOHHWG¥EDUUDVV¥HGHVIDQW°PHVGXSDVV¥ 2!4A0C8>=0;8B<42>=BCAD2C85. EC O. LE. N. AT. IO. l (Q FH TXL UHJDUGH OȁDUFKLWHFWXUH WRXWH IRUPH TXL QȁHVW SDV LQGLTX¥H SDU OD 01/2"12/$#,'1>1/$/$-,200=$9
(89) &HSRVWXODWGHEDVHIRUWHWWUDQFK¥ORLQGHFHTXHSU°QH OȀ$FDG¥PLHODP¦PH¥SRTXHYD¦WUHOHȿOFRQGXFWHXUGHODWK¥RULHYLROOHWOHGXFLHQQH FRQFHUQDQW VD FRQFHSWLRQ DUFKLWHFWXUDOH (Q SDUWDQW GH OȀLG¥H TXH WRXW FH TXL H[LVWH 3>8CAT?>=3A4PD=14B>8=0=0;GBTB>DB;4?A8B<434;0A08B>=;0BCAD2CDA4?A4=3D=4 38<4=B8>=CASB8<?>AC0=C430=B;41QC8<4=CC>DC24@D8=4?0AC828?4?0BP;0BC018;8CT GHFHGHUQLHUHVWVXSHUɀXHQWURSHWGRLW¦WUH¥YLW¥ !4?A06<0C8B<44C;0A0C8>=0;8CT34+8>;;4C;4D2@DZ8;3TE4;>??430=BB4BCA08CTB C>DC0D;>=634B020AA8SA4BZTC4=34=CPC>DB;4B3><08=4B34;Z0A278C42CDA44C34;0 2>=BCAD2C8>= 4= B4 3T?0AC8BB0=C ;4 ?;DB ?>BB81;4 34 24 @D8 4BC 508C 30=B ;Z0A278C42CDA4 RɁFLHOOH GHSXLV OH ;9,,¤PH VL¤FOH /D SLHUUH MXVTXȀDORUV H[SORLW¥H GDQV OHV EDVVLQV FDOFDLUHVGHJU¤VGHJUDQLWYD¦WUHGHSOXVHQSOXVXWLOLV¥HGDQVGHVU¥JLRQVDXWUHV 4CE034E4=8A;0=>A<434;Z0A278C42CDA43ZOC0C$A0D--S<4B8S2;4>V24CDB064B4 UHQIRUFHHWVȀLQWHQVLȿHOHVFDUUL¤UHVVȀ¥SXLVHQWHWOȀRQYDFKHUFKHUOHVSLHUUHVHQFRUHSOXV
(90)
(91)
(92) &( # !#%!" )%&##$ ))%)"# !!)%! $#$
(93) !"
(94)
(95)
(96) &( # !#%!" )%&##$ ))%)"# !!)%! $#$ " .
(97) . .
(98)
(99)
(100) . D NA O LE C U S M U EN PE T RI SO EU U RE M IS D AU 'AR D CH R IT O E IT C D TU 'A R U E TE D U E R T. O. U LO. U SE. ;>8=24@D84BC5028;8CT?0A;ZT<4A64=2434B274<8=B3454A%>DAAT?>=3A4PD=43>2CA8=4 LPSRV¥HSDUOȀ$FDG¥PLHOHVFRQVWUXFWLRQVHWOHVFKDQWLHUVVHIRQWGHSOXVHQSOXVRQ¥UHX[ FRPSOH[HV'HSOXVOHVJUDQGVEORFVTXHOHVFDUUL¤UHVVRQWP¦PHGHSURGXLUHDYHF GHQRXYHDX[RXWLOVVRQWG¥ELW¥VHQSHWLWVEORFVRµGHVRXYULHUVHQG¥JDJHQWXQJUDQG YROXPH XQH IRLV VXU OH FKDQWLHU HQWUDªQDQW XQ JDVSLOODJH FRQV¥TXHQW GHV PDW¥ULDX[ HW D=4 0D6<4=C0C8>= 3A0BC8@D4 34B 2>WCB 34 2>=BCAD2C8>= 30=B ;4 B4D; 1DC 3Z8<8C4A 34B DUFKLWHFWXUHV GȀXQH ¥SRTXH U¥YROXH TXL QH E¥Q¥ȿFLDLHQW SDV GHV P¦PHV RXWLOV GH SURGXFWLRQHWQHU¥SRQGDLHQWSDVDX[P¦PHVEHVRLQV7)0,+1$+",/$#$) -'$//$0,20 OD PDLQ RQ EWLVVDLW KLHU HQ SLHUUH GH WDLOOH FHWWH UDLVRQ VXɂW SRXU TXȁRQ EWLVVH HQ -'$//$#$1 '))$#$* '+9 !4<8<TC8B<434;05>A<4;Z4<?>AC4BDAD=4AT?>=B4?A>?A4P B>=C4<?B 2UGDQVFHWWHXQLIRUPLVDWLRQGHOȀXVDJHGHVPDW¥ULDX[HWGHODSHQV¥HFRQVWUXFWLYH ;Z0A278C42CDA4 4C B>= 4=B486=4<4=C >=C >D1;8T 4C 3T;08BBT 34B CA038C8>=B 34B B0E>8AB IDLUHGHVJLVHPHQWVGHVDYRLUVHWGHPDW¥ULDX[SURSUHVFKDTXHU¥JLRQ|7RXORXVHSDU H[HPSOHODEULTXHHVWSDVV¥HDXVHFRQGSODQSRXUOHVFRQVWUXFWLRQVRɁFLHOOHV +°WHOGH 3LHUUH FROHGHV%HDX[$UWV JOLVHGHOD'DXUDGH
(101) VLJQDX[GHULFKHVVHHWGHSRXYRLU ELHQTXȀHOOHVRLWIDFLOHSURGXLUHGDQVODU¥JLRQTXȀXQHPDLQGȀĎXYUHTXDOLȿ¥HSXLVVH ODPHWWUHHQRHXYUHHWTXȀHOOHDSSRUWHDXȿQDOGHJUDQGHV¥FRQRPLHVVLHOOHHVWXWLOLV¥H 4=?0A508C42>==08BB0=2434B4B?A>?A8TCTB4C34B4B@D0;8CTB 7=/'00$+1-)21@11,20)$0 *,+2*$+10#$ /'0$1"$.2B')0/$+%$/*$+1#$1/=0,/0-)21@1.2$#$/$",++ ?1/$) 3 )$2/#B2+ SURF¥G¥GHFRQVWUXFWLRQWURXY¥HWDSSOLTX¥HQGHKRUVGXF¥QDFOHGHVVRXWLHQVGXJUDQG /19 9LROOHWOH'XFG¥QRQFHLFLOHVGRFWULQHVDFDG¥PLTXHVTXLG¥ODLVVHQWGHVPDW¥ULDX[ ?ATB4=C0=C346A0=34B@D0;8CTB0G0=C3T9P508C;4DA?A4DE4B5028;4<4=C?A>3D2C81;4BP10B. EC O. LE. N. AT. IO. %A>?>B8C8>= 34 +8>;;4C;4 D2 ?>DA D=4 <08B>= 34 E8;;4 30=B B4B +1/$1'$+0 02/ )B /"&'1$"12/$
(102) !0 ?84AA4 2>WC4DB4 4C @DZ8; 50DC 0;;4A 274A274A 34 ?;DB 4= ?;DB ;>8= 4BC 4= 6A0=34 SDUWLHG¥ODLVV¥HDXSURȿWGX <TC0;4C34;02TA0<8@D4C>DB GHX[ PDW¥ULDX[ LQGXVWULHOV 5028;4<4=C ?A>3D8CB 0D --S<4 B8S2;4 ; B4 3T?0AC8C 34 3>6<4B 0203T<8@D4B ?>DA ?D8B4A 30=B ;0 AT0;8CT GHFHTXȀRȾUHVRQWHPSV.
(103)
(104)
(105) &( ! !#%!" )%&##$ ))%)"# !!)%! $#$
(106)
(107)
(108)
(109) &( ! !#%!" )%&##$ ))%)"# !!)%! $#$
(110) . .
(111) . .
(112) LE. EC O. O. D NA O LE C U S M U EN PE T RI SO EU U RE M IS D AU 'AR D CH R IT O E IT C D TU 'A R U E TE D U E R T. IO. AT. N. U SE. U LO.
(113)
(114)
(115) . EC O. LE. N. AT. IO. D NA O LE C U S M U EN PE T RI SO EU U RE M IS D AU 'AR D CH R IT O E IT C D TU 'A R U E TE D U E R T. O. U LO. U SE. ?0AC83424@D4B>=C4<?B?A>?>B4;4<TC0;0??0A0UC3>=2B4;>=+8>;;4C;4D22><<4 XQPDW¥ULDXGHFKRL[SRUWHXUGHJUDQGHVLQQRYDWLRQVHQDUFKLWHFWXUHVLOȀHQVHLJQHPHQW 3424CC434A=8SA43T283434BZ>DEA8AP24CC48==>E0C8>=4=B43TC0270=C34B3>2CA8=4B 0=B;Z>?C8@D4A0C8>=0;8BC4@D84BC;0B84==4+8>;;4C;4D2=Z4=C4=32>=B4AE4A@D4;4 Q¥FHVVDLUHIDLUHXQHDUFKLWHFWXUHYUDLHU¥SRQGDQWDXEHVRLQHWDXFRQWH[WHWLUDQWSDUWL GHVPDW¥ULDX[GLVSRQLEOHVHWGHOHXUVSURSUL¥W¥VVDQVK¥J¥PRQLHGȀXQGRJPHFRQWUDLJQDQW ODIRUPHGDQVGHVU¥I¥UHQFHVSDVV¥HV6XUFHGHUQLHUSRLQWLOWHQWHGHFRQQDªWUHDXPLHX[ OHVSURSUL¥W¥VGHVPDW¥ULDX[GHFRQVWUXFWLRQOHVSOXVFRXUDQWV SLHUUHERLVEULTXH
(116) HWGH FHX[TXȀLOYHXWLQW¥JUHUOȀDUFKLWHFWXUH IRQWHIHUF¥UDPLTXH
(117) SRXUWLUHUOHSOXVGȀDYDQWDJH GHFKDFXQGȀHX[,OIDXWGRQFFRQQDªWUHOHVFDUDFW¥ULVWLTXHVFRQVWUXFWLYHVVWUXFWXUHOOHVGH 270@D4<0CTA80D?>DA2>=24E>8A;4BBCAD2CDA4B;4B?;DB?4A5>A<0=C4B?4A<4CC0=C34;8<8C4A 60B?8;;064 4C 2>WCB "08B 0D 34;P 34 R0 8; 50DC 0DBB8 0E>8A 2>=B284=24 34 ;0 @D0;8CT GHV HVSDFHV DUFKLWHFWXUDX[ HW GHV HȾHWV TXH FU¥HQW OȀHPSORL GH FKDTXH PDW¥ULDX HW 34270@D4BCAD2CDA44C08=B8C8A4A?0AC834;0BCAD2CDA434B4B@D0;8CTB4C=>=?0B34;0 BD18A!0BCAD2CDA4@D82><<4>=;Z038C?AT2T34<<4=C?A4=3D=46A0=34?;02430=B;0 FRPSRVLWLRQ FKH]9LROOHWOH'XF G¥FRXOH GRQF GLUHFWHPHQW GX PDW¥ULDX FKRLVL OHV GHX[ B>=C8=C8<4<4=C;8TB7,++$/ 24* 1=/' 24) %,+"1',+$1) -2'00 +"$/$) 1'3$0:)B,!($1 )$0%,/*$0$4-/'* +1)$-)20$4 "1$*$+1$1"$11$%,+"1',+$1"$11$-2'00 +"$"B$01):2+#$0 -,'+10)$0-)20'*-,/1 +10#$) ",*-,0'1',+9 /HVPDW¥ULDX[GRLYHQWGRQF¦WUHXWLOLV¥VHQFRQQDLVVDQFHGHOHXUVFDUDFW¥ULVWLTXHV 4C34;4DAB@D0;8CTB?A>?A4BB0=BE>D;>8A508A434<8<TC8B<430=BD=4T2A8CDA4C4=C0=C34 A02>=C4A;4 3/ 'VDQVGLVVLPXOHUOHVȿOVTXLVRXVWHQGHQWODFRPSRVLWLRQ/HEWLPHQWGRLW¦WUH ' 2;08A4C2><?AT74=B81;4>=3>8C?0A;0<8B44=E0;4DA34;0BCAD2CDA42><?A4=3A42><<4=C ODVWDELOLW¥GHOȀ¥GLȿFHVHIDLWRQGRLWSDUODPLVHHQOXPL¤UHGHVPDW¥ULDXFRPSUHQGUH 34@D>8;41QC8<4=C4BC508C!0A4274A2743ZD=4ETA8CTBCAD2CDA4;;40A278C42CDA0;4C>D274 DXVVL OȀHPSORL GHV PDW¥ULDX[ GDQV OD FRQVWUXFWLRQ 2Q VH G¥SDUWLW GHV PDQL¤UHV GH FRQFHYRLU DFDG¥PLFLHQQHV TXL SU°QDLHQW XQ HPSORL ELHQ PRLQV VRXFLHX[ GH FHWWH ETA8CT0A278C42CDA0;4C0=C@D424;0B4508B08C0DB4AE8243ZD=48<0643Z01>=30=244C GȀRSXOHQFHGHOȀDUFKLWHFWXUHHPSUXQWDQWDX[IRUPHVGXSDVV¥ 72$#$0-) +"&$/0#$ IHUVRLHQWUHY¦WXVGHSOWUHSRXUɀJXUHUGHVSODIRQGVGHERLVz
(118) (QȿQOȀRUQHPHQWHVWXQ¥O¥PHQWIRUWGDQVOȀDUFKLWHFWXUHDFDG¥PLTXHHWDXVVLGDQV 24;;434+8>;;4C;4D2@D8=4B43T?0AC8C?0B34B>=DC8;8B0C8>=<0;6ATB4B8==>E0C8>=B SURFKHVGXPRXYHPHQWPRGHUQHTXLHQSU°QHUDOȀDEROLWLRQ0DLVGDQVOȀRSWLTXHTXLHVW ;0B84==4;Z>A=4<4=C?A4=3D=40DCA45>=2C8>=0D?0A0E0=CDC8;8BT2><<4>DC8;<>=CA0=C ;0A8274BB4?0AB0?A>5DB8>=8;34E84=C274H+8>;;4C;4D2D=T;T<4=C0DB4AE82434;0 BCAD2CDA4*C8;8BT0E42?;DB34?0A28<>=844C30=B34BT;T<4=CB27>8B8B4C281;TB8;E8B4 PHWWUH HQ YDOHXU HW DɁUPHU OD VWUXFWXUH TXL GRLW ¦WUH XQ GHV ¥O¥PHQW IRQGDWHXU GH ;02><?>B8C8>=7+,05$24) *$'))$2/$ /"&'1$"12/$$01"$))$#,+1) #=",/ 1',++$ -$21>1/$#'01/ '1$#$) 01/2"12/$9 /ȀRUQHPHQWSOXW°WTXHGHUHFRXYULUXQEWLPHQW JUDQGUHFRXUVGHȿJXUHVDOO¥JRULTXHVGHPRLQVHQPRLQVFRPSU¥KHQVLEOHVGRLWPDUTXHU
(119) ')! $ "$&" #!*&'$$% **&*#$ !""*&"!%$% !#
(120) ')! $ "$&" #!*&'$$% **&*#$ !""*&"!%$% !#
(121) ')! $ "$&" #!*&'$$% **&*#$ !""*&"!%$%
(122) "#
(123) .
(124) . .
(125) LE. EC O. O. D NA O LE C U S M U EN PE T RI SO EU U RE M IS D AU 'AR D CH R IT O E IT C D TU 'A R U E TE D U E R T. IO. AT. N. U SE. U LO.
(126) LE. EC O. O. D NA O LE C U S M U EN PE T RI SO EU U RE M IS D AU 'AR D CH R IT O E IT C D TU 'A R U E TE D U E R T. IO. AT. N. U SE. U LO.
(127)
(128)
(129) . D NA O LE C U S M U EN PE T RI SO EU U RE M IS D AU 'AR D CH R IT O E IT C D TU 'A R U E TE D U E R T. O. U LO. U SE. !>AB@D4+8>;;4C;4D24BC0??4;T?>DA;4?A>94C34<DBT40D3T1DC34B0==T4B VHV SRVLWLRQV H[WU¦PHPHQW IRUWHV FRQFHUQDQW OD UHVWDXUDWLRQ OD FRQFHSWLRQ VRQ 3TC0274<4=C34B3>2CA8=4B0203T<8@D4B4CB0E>;>=CT3Z8==>E0C8>=B>=C184=2>==D4B !4B +1/$1'$+0 02/ )B /"&'1$"12/$ $ B>=C ?D1;8TB 4= 4C
(130) ;4 '"1',++ '/$ / '0,++= #$)B /"&'1$"12/$%/ +; '0$#2<*$ 2<*$0'<")$4BC?D1;8T4=CA4 4C $ ;Z'01,'/$#B2+$* '0,+4BC?D1;8T44= ?>DA=428C4A@D4B4B?;DB6A0=3B>DEA064B !0 AT?DC0C8>= 34+8>;;4C;4D2 4C B0 E8B8>= 34 ;Z0A278C42CDA4 B>=C 3>=2 184= 2>==D4B ;>AB@D4'>B270274C;0+8;;434)>D;>DB45>=C0??4;P;D84=0BBD<0=CD=?A>94C=>E0C4DA 4C4=A42>==08BB0=C34B@D0;8CTBP;Z0A278C42CDA4@DZ8;?A>?>B4 'HSOXV9LROOHWOH'XFDG¥MEHDXFRXSH[HUF¥GDQVODU¥JLRQ,ODVRQDFWLI ;0 A4BC0DA0C8>= 34 ;0 28CT 34 0A20BB>==4
(131) 4C 0 AT0;8BT 34 =><1A4DB4B UHVWDXUDWLRQV 7RXORXVH P¦PH ;0 10B8;8@D4 (C (4A=8= ;4 2>;;S64 (08=C '0G<>=3 >D;4>=9>=3D0?8C>;4 <4=C8>==T?AT2T34<<4=C 2XWUHFHVUHVWDXUDWLRQVLODDXVVLHȾHFWX¥XQYUDLWUDYDLOGȀDQDO\VHHWGHUHOHY¥GXEWL <T38TE0;C>D;>DB08=?>DA;0AT302C8>=34B>='"1',++ '/$/ '0,++=
(132) !>AB@DZ8;4=CA4?A4=3 ;4?A>94C3D<DBT434BD6DBC8=B8;03>=2D=41>==42>==08BB0=2434)>D;>DB434 B0 AT68>= 34 B4B <>34B 34 2>=BCAD2C8>= 34 B4B DB064B @D8 B>=C 0DC0=C 34 ?>8=CB SULPRUGLDX[DXYXGHODPDQL¤UHGHFRQFHYRLUTXȀLOG¥YHORSSHGDQVVHVHQWUHWLHQV(Q HȾHWVȀLOHQWUHSUHQGGHG¥IHQGUHXQHYLVLRQGHODFRQFHSWLRQU¥SRQGDQWDX[XVDJHVHW DX[PR\HQVGHFRQVWUXFWLRQGHORµLOFRQVWUXLWXQHERQQHFRQQDLVVDQFHGHODU¥JLRQ 4C=>C0<<4=C34B4B<>34B342>=BCAD2C8>=CA038C8>==4;B4BC8=38B?4=B01;4MCA0E4AB;4B 270=C84AB34A4BC0DA0C8>=B;ZTCD3434B<>=D<4=CB3D">G4=N648;?4DC08=B82>==0UCA4 ;4B20AA8SA4B;4B1A8@D4C4A84B;4B4=CA4?A8B4B@D8?>DAA>=C?0AC828?4A0D?A>94C . 1OE>;DC8>=B?A>94CB4C0A278C42C4BBD224BB85B. EC O. LE. N. AT. IO. SB B>8C0=B0?ASB;4?4A24<4=C34;0AD4;B024!>AA08=44C0;>AB@D4 +8>;;4C;4D2E84=C34?D1;84A;4B42>=3C><434B4B +1/$1'$+002/)B /"&'1$"12/$8;34BB8=4 $. D= ?A4<84A ?A>94C ?A8<8C85 ?>DA D= I"DBT4 34 )>D;>DB4L P ;Z4<?;024<4=C 34 ;Z0=284= U¥IHFWRLUHGXFRXYHQWGHV$XJXVWLQV'HV¥EDXFKHVGHFRXSHVHWGȀD[RQRP¥WULHVVRQW 34BB8=T4B4C;4?;0=B4A0??A>2743T9P5>AC4<4=C3D?A>94C@D8B4A0?A>?>BT4= 4B42>=3?A>94C
(133) 4BC2>=RD?0A+8>;;4C;4D24=2>;;01>A0C8>=0E424=8B0A2G 4C4BC?ATB4=CT0D>=B48;"D=828?0;4C0D>=B48;T=TA0;34BQC8<4=CB8E8;B4=0EA8; ,O HVW DFFHSW¥ YDOLG¥ HW P¦PH VDOX¥ SDU FHV GHX[ FRQVHLOV FRQGLWLRQ GH OD PRGLȿFDWLRQ GH GHX[ G¥WDLOV FRQFHUQDQW OȀHVFDOLHU GȀKRQQHXU HW OȀRULHQWDWLRQ J¥Q¥UDOH 3D1QC8<4=C"08B;4 3T24<1A4 0;>AB@DZ8;4BCP!0DB0==4?>DA;0A4BC0DA0C8>= 34;020C7T3A0;434;0E8;;4+8>;;4C;4D23T2S344C4=8B0A2GB>=T;SE49DB@DZ0;>AB 2>;;01>A0C4DABDA;4?A>94C34E84=CA4B?>=B01;44CE0<4=4A;4?A>94CPB>=C4A<4 (Q'DUF\SU¥VHQWHDX&RQVHLO0XQLFLSDOXQQRXYHDXSURMHWPRGLȿ¥ BDAD= FHUWDLQQRPEUHGHSRLQWVQRWDPPHQWVXUOHVDMXVWHPHQWVH[LJ¥VSDUOH&RQVHLOGHV%WLPHQWV 8E8;B4= !4270=C84A4BC;0=2T4= 4C?>DA;4<4=4A0A2GBZ4=C>DA434 40= 02@D4BB@D8T0BB>28T34+8>;;4C;4D2@D80CA0E08;;T0E42;D8BDA;0A4BC0DA0C8>=34;0 10B8;8@D4(C(4A=8==>C0<<4=C4C34;Z0A278C42C44=274534;0+8;;434)>D;>DB434 ! $#
(134) ! $$ $ 9RLUHQDQQH[HOHSURMHWPRGLȿ¥GH'DUF\SU¥VHQW¥HQSDJHV .
(135) . .
(136)
(137)
(138) . .
(139). .
(140). . . U SE. P >B4?70;8=84A SB;43T?0AC3D270=C84A;4?0E8;;>=3>==0=CBDA;0?;024B@D8A>;0D(D334 ;Z08;42>=BCAD8C44BC?ATED30=BD=4B42>=34?70B434;02>=BCAD2C8>=4CC4?0AC843D SURMHW VHUD IRUWHPHQW PRGLȿ¥H HW UDFFRXUFLH SDU OH SHUFHPHQW GH OD UXH GH 0HW] /H PXV¥HHVWȿQDOHPHQWWHUPLQ¥HWLQDXJXU¥HQ
(141) . D NA O LE C U S M U EN PE T RI SO EU U RE M IS D AU 'AR D CH R IT O E IT C D TU 'A R U E TE D U E R T. O. U LO. =0D6DA0C8>= T<0AA0643D270=C84A 3U¥VHQWDWLRQGXSURMHWPRGLȿ¥GH'DUF\ %ATB4=C0C8>=3D?A>94C34+8>;;4C;4D2 %A>94C?A8<8C8534+8>;;4C;4D2 %4A24<4=C34;0AD4;B024!>AA08=4. D6S=4+8>;;4C;4D2. 4=8B0A2G. EC O. LE. N. AT. IO. ,O YD PDLQWHQDQW ¦WUH DERUG¥H OD TXHVWLRQ GH OD U¥DOLW¥ GH OȀDSSOLFDWLRQ GH OD 2>=24?C8>= 0A278C42CDA0;4 34+8>;;4C;4D2 30=B ;4 3TC08; 34 24B ?A>94CB @D8 B4 B>=C VXFF¥G¥VOȀH[FSHWLRQGXSURMHWSULPLWLIGHTXLSDUVRQDYDQFHPHQWQHSHUPHW ?0BD=40=0;GB40??A>5>=38430=B;4203A43424<T<>8A4.
(142) . .
(143) LE. EC O. O. D NA O LE C U S M U EN PE T RI SO EU U RE M IS D AU 'AR D CH R IT O E IT C D TU 'A R U E TE D U E R T. IO. AT. N. U SE. U LO.
(144)
(145)
(146) . EC O. LE. N. AT. IO. D NA O LE C U S M U EN PE T RI SO EU U RE M IS D AU 'AR D CH R IT O E IT C D TU 'A R U E TE D U E R T. O. U LO. U SE. ODIRQFWLRQ/HSURJUDPPHHVWDXFĎXUGHODU¥ɀH[LRQFȀHVWOXLTXLGLFWHOHVIRUPHVHWQRQ SDVFRPPHOȀDORQJWHPSVSU°Q¥OȀ$FDG¥PLHMXVTXHOXQHIRUPHGHVVLQ¥HGDQVODTXHOOH >=C4=C43Z8=CT6A4AD=45>=2C8>=70$/ 1')'$21 !)$,2"23$11$9 !4?;0=@DZ8;2>=R>8C ?>DA24?A4<84A?A>94C34 A4?A4=34C0??;8@D424B?A8=28?4B342><?>B8C8>=4C34 5>A<4BD8E0=C;05>=2C8>=?0A;06T><TCA844C;ZT274;;43>==T4BP270@D44B?024 )>DC3Z01>A3;4?4C8C2;>UCA4 E4BC8643D2>DE4=C?4AB8BC44CT?0D;4;4?A>94C 0D#>A3$=CA>DE44=BD8C4;4?0E8;;>=34;Z03<8=8BCA0C8>=4CB>=4B20;84A
(147) @D8A4?A4=3 ODODUJHXUGXSHWLWFORªWUHDYHFXQHIDLEOH¥FKHOOHFDULODFFXHLOOHGHVEXUHDX[HWGHV ?8S24BA4;0C8E4<4=C?4C8C4B+84=C4=BD8C4;Z4=CAT434B0AC8BC4B GHVWLQ¥HDX[¥O¤YHVGHV %HDX[$UWV GRQWOHVORFDX[VHWURXYDLHQWHQFRUHGDQVOHFRXYHQW
(148) &HWWHGHUQL¤UHHVW 38A42C4<4=CA4;8T4P;06A0=34B0;;434B=C8@D4B @D8A4?A4=3;0CA0<4BCAD2CDA4;;43D U¥IHFWRLUHHQIRUPDQWXQHJUDQGHJDOHULHGȀH[SRVLWLRQODUJHPHQWRXYHUWHVXUODUXH$X (D324CC460;4A84B4C4A<8=4?0AD=?0E8;;>=?;DB<>=D<4=C0; @D8<0A@D4;4?86=>= 0D (D3 4C 508C ;84D 3Z0??4; 4C 34 BG<1>;4 BDA ;0 ?;024 B@D8A>; BDA ;0@D4;;4 8; 3>==4 38A42C4<4=CD34E0=C3424?0E8;;>=D=?>A274E84=CB4?;024A30=B;43T20;0642ATT SDUOHELDLVGXSURMHWYLVYLVGHODUXH(QȿQOȀ(VWGHFHSDYLOORQRQWURXYHOȀHQWU¥H ?8TC>==4 3D <DBT4 08=B8 @D4 ;Z4B20;84A <>=D<4=C0; TXL YLHQQHQW WRXW GHX[ VȀLQV¥UHU 4=CA4;42;>UCA4;060;4A844C;4?0E8;;>= 'DQVODSKLORVRSKLHGHODIRUPHVXLYDQWOHVIRQFWLRQVRQSHXWLGHQWLȿHUGDQVFH SURJUDPPHGHX[JUDQGHVSDUWLHV'ȀXQHSDUWOHVHVSDFHVGHVHUYLFH HQWU¥HVHVFDOLHUV DGPLQLVWUDWLRQ
(149) HWOHVHVSDFHVGȀH[SRVLWLRQ&KDFXQDVDSURSUH¥FKHOOHHWGDQVOȀRSWLTXH UDWLRQQHOOHGH9LROOHWOH'XFLOQȀ\DXUDLWSDVGHVHQVFHTXHFHVGHX[¥FKHOOHVQHVRLHQW SDVGLȾ¥UHQFL¥HV2QUHWURXYHGRQFGDQVOHSODQOHVHVSDFHVVHUYDQWVGHSOXVSHWLWH T274;;42><?A8B30=BD=4B4D;4CA0ET434;0CA0<4>D184=2><?A8B4=CA434B1QC8<4=CB 34?;DB6A0=340<?;4DA4=
(150) 4C $XFRQWUDLUHOHVVDOOHVGȀH[SRVLWLRQQ¥FHVVLWDQWGH 6A0=3BE>;D<4B;08BBT4B;81A4B346A0=34B?>ACT4B4CD=46A0=3470DC4DAB>DB?;05>=3 SRXUODPLVHHQVF¤QHGHVĎXYUHVVHUHWURXYHQWHQ 4C 30=B;060;4A844C;4?0E8;;>= Z0DCA4?0AC;078TA0A278434B4=CAT4B3D<DBT4?4DC?>B4A@D4BC8>=0DED3424 @D4 ;Z0A278C42CDA4 2;0BB8@D4 P ?A>3D8C 9DB@D4 ;P 34B 4=CAT4B 5A>=C0;4B 24=CAT4B 30=B OȀD[HGHV\P¥WULH,FLOȀD[HGHV\P¥WULHHVWDEVHQWHWOHVHQWU¥HVVRQWPXOWLSOHVHQIRQFWLRQ 34B DB064B !4 ?0E8;;>= 3>==0=C BDA ;0 ?;024 B@D8A>; B4AC 34 ?>8=C 34 A4?SA4 30=B ;0 E8;;4 4C 2Z4BC 0DC>DA 34 ;D8 @D4 BZ>A60=8B4=C ;4B 4=CAT4B 3D ?D1;82 (DA ;0 AD4;B024 !>AA08=4>=CA>DE4;4?>A2743Z4=CAT4?>DA;4BE4=D4B4=20;S274B@D8B4?;02430=B;4 G¥FDODJHFU¥¥SDUOHELDLV/ȀDUFKLWHFWHWLUHDLQVLSURȿWGHVRQSDUWLSULVIRUWSRXULQW¥JUHU XQGLVSRVLWLIUHQRXYHO¥U¥SRQGDQWDX[EHVRLQVHWDX[XVDJHVGHVRQWHPSV/ȀHQWU¥HGHV SL¥WRQVVHIDLWHOOHGHOȀDXWUHF°W¥GXSDYLOORQSDUGHVJXLFKHWVGRQQDQWVXUXQMDUGLQ !Z4=CAT434B0AC8BC4B@D4;Z0A278C42CDA42;0BB8@D40DA08C?;02T4=0AA8SA43D?A>94C4BC4= A4E0=27438A42C4<4=CBDA;0AD4;B024!>AA08=430=BD=4CA0ET434;0CA0<4BCAD2CDA4;;4
(151) &HODDɁUPHXQHIRLVGHSOXVODSU¥SRQG¥UDQFHGXSDYLOORQGRQQDQWVXUODSODFH(VTXLURO 2><<4?>8=C3Z>A6D43D?A>94C.
(152) ),#
(153) $&!($"%#-()&&' --(-%& #$!$-($#'&'
(154) $&###*!%&$ ($!!(! )# %' .
(155) . .
(156) LE. EC O. O. D NA O LE C U S M U EN PE T RI SO EU U RE M IS D AU 'AR D CH R IT O E IT C D TU 'A R U E TE D U E R T. IO. AT. N. U SE. U LO.
(157) LE. EC O. O. D NA O LE C U S M U EN PE T RI SO EU U RE M IS D AU 'AR D CH R IT O E IT C D TU 'A R U E TE D U E R T. IO. AT. N. U SE. U LO.
(158)
(159)
(160) . D NA O LE C U S M U EN PE T RI SO EU U RE M IS D AU 'AR D CH R IT O E IT C D TU 'A R U E TE D U E R T. O. U LO. U SE. 4?0E8;;>=4BC<8B4=E0;4DA?0A;Z0E0=2T4?0AA0??>ACP;060;4A84<08B2>=B4AE4 OHVSURSRUWLRQVJ¥Q¥UDOHVGȀXQHWUDY¥HGHFHWWHGHUQL¤UHHOOHP¦PHLVVXHGHODWUDPH 3DAT542C>8A43D2>DE4=C0=BB4B?A>?>AC8>=B4=?;0=8;508C0DBB8T27>P;Z4=CAT434B 0AC8BC4B@D84BC4;;40DBB8D=4CA0ET434;060;4A84A4CA0E08;;T45>A<0=C3>=2D=4BG<TCA84 GHSDUWHWGȀDXWUHGHODJDOHULHV\P¥WULHTXLYDVȀDɁUPHUHQID£DGHFRPPHRQOHYHUUD 30=B;0?0AC84BD8E0=C4 0=B;4A4BC43D1QC8<4=C;0AT0;8B0C8>=4BC2>=5>A<40D?A>94C@DZ8;34BB8=44= 0E42;41808B@DZ022DB4;060;4A84E8BPE8B3D2;>UCA4;4?0E8;;>=34;Z03<8=8BCA0C8>=;4B JXLFKHWVGRQQDQWVXUXQVTXDUHDX1RUGHWOȀHVFDOLHUTXLVȀHVWDPSOLȿ¥HWDWRWDOHPHQW TCT A4ED ?0A 0A2G 4= 508B0=C D= 34B ?>8=CB 3D ?A>94C 8BBD 34 B0 2>=24?C8>= ?A>?A4 8=3T?4=30=C3D?A>94C3Z>A868=434+8>;;4C;4D2 6476:1;165,-3).)F),. 0%>=3TA0C8>=4CBG<TCA84
(161). . . 0R034BDA;0AD4;B024!>AA08=43D?A>94C34+8>;;4C;4D2 . EC O. LE. N. AT. IO. 'DQVOHSURMHWGH9LROOHWOH'XFOȀLQɀXHQFHGHVWK¥RULHVTXȀLOG¥YHORSSHGDQVVHV WUDLW¥VHVWWU¤VSU¥VHQWH(QHȾHWRQQHUHWURXYHDXFXQHV\P¥WULHGDQVODFRPSRVLWLRQ FKDTXHEWLPHQWHVWVRXPLVDX[IRQFWLRQVTXȀLODEULWHHWQHIDLWSDVGHFRQFHVVLRQXQH GRFWULQHHVWK¥WLTXH2QSHXWDXVVLLGHQWLȿHUWURLVHQWLW¥VGDQVFHWWHID£DGHFRUUHVSRQGDQW DX[HQWLW¥VGXSODQOHSDYLOORQGHOȀDGPLQLVWUDWLRQ
(162) ;060;4A84 0E42D=4CA0ET4 3T38T4P;Z4=CAT434B0AC8BC4B 4C;4?0E8;;>=<>=D<4=C0;3>==0=CBDA;0?;024B@D8A>; &HWWHGLȾ¥UHQFLDWLRQGHVWURLVYROXPHVHVWDSSX\¥HSDUODFRPSRVLWLRQGHVWRLWVFHOXL GHODJDOHULHHVWXQWRLWTXDWUHSHQWHVSDUWHQWL¤UHLOQȀHVWSDVXQOLHQHQWUHOHVGHX[ SDYLOORQVODW¥UDX[FRPPHOȀDXUDLWYRXOXODGRFWULQHFODVVLTXH =
(163) ;4 ?0E8;;>= 34 ;Z03<8=8BCA0C8>= 01A8C4 D= 4B20;84A 3>==0=C BDA ;0 50R034 FLGHVVXV &ȀHVW GRQF XQ YROXPH YHUWLFDO VDQV QLYHDX GH SODQFKHU LGHQWLȿDEOH TXL HVW DɁUP¥HSDUVDFRPSRVLWLRQSDVGHFRUQLFKHDXQLYHDXGXSODQFKHUEDVGXSUHPLHU TC0642><?>B8C8>=34B>DE4ACDA4BP?0AC4=C8SA44=5>=2C8>=34;Z4B20;84A@D8B4CA>DE4 GHUUL¤UHHWQRQGHODFRPSRVLWLRQGXUHVWHGXEWLPHQWDYDQWFRUSVDX[DQJOHVDɁUPDQW ODYHUWLFDOLW¥&ȀHVWGRQFXQYROXPHYHUWLFDOGLȾ¥UHQFL¥GXUHVWHGXSURMHWSDUVDIRQFWLRQ P?0AC4=C8SA4CA03D8B0=C4=50R034;05>=2C8>=@DZ8;01A8C44=8=CTA84DA D(D33424?0E8;;>=B43TE4;>??4;060;4A8434B=C8@D4B @D82><<48;0 TCT3TE4;>??T30=B;Z0=0;GB43D?;0=A4?A4=3;0CA0<434B2>=CA45>ACB3DAT542C>8A4 3Z>A868=4 4=2>A4 E8B81;4B 30=B ;4 2;>UCA4 4CC4 CA0<4 B4 ;8C 5>AC4<4=C 4= 50R034 ?0A
(164) . .
(165) LE. EC O. O. D NA O LE C U S M U EN PE T RI SO EU U RE M IS D AU 'AR D CH R IT O E IT C D TU 'A R U E TE D U E R T. IO. AT. N. U SE. U LO.
(166)
(167)
(168) . D NA O LE C U S M U EN PE T RI SO EU U RE M IS D AU 'AR D CH R IT O E IT C D TU 'A R U E TE D U E R T. O. U LO. U SE. (QȿQOHSDYLOORQGRQQDQWVXUODSODFH(VTXLUROYLHQW¥SDXOHUODJDOHULHHWWHUPLQHUOH ?A>94CB0=B?>DA0DC0=C2AT4AD=4BG<TCA840E42;4?0E8;;>=34;Z03<8=8BCA0C8>=;03>?C4 XQHDUFKLWHFWXUHSOXVPRQXPHQWDOHTXLDɁUPHOȀD[HFHQWUDOHWOHSRUFKHGHVFDO¤FKHV ?>DA4=508A4D=BG<1>;45>AC34?D8B;0?;024B@D8A>;;A4?A4=324?4=30=C140D2>D? 34 ;0 2><?>B8C8>= 34 ;0 60;4A84 30=B ;Z0;86=4<4=C 34B 7>A8H>=C0;4B =>C0<<4=C ?>DA VLJQLȿHUTXHFHVGHX[HQWLW¥VSDUWDJHQWXQHP¦PHIRQFWLRQ /DFRPSRVLWLRQGHODID£DGHGH9LROOHWOH'XFU¥SRQGGRQFDX[SU¥FHSWHVTXȀLO 3TE4;>??430=B;4B +1/$1'$+002/)B /"&'1$"12/$2>=24A=0=C;05>A<4BD8E0=C;05>=2C8>= $ 4C;02><?>B8C8>=3ZD=450R034?>=3TAT4B0=B2T34AP;0BG<TCA84702D=434BCA>8B HQWLW¥V G¥YHORSSH XQH ID£DGH TXL IDLW VHQV SDU UDSSRUW DX[ IRQFWLRQV TXȀHOOH DEULWH ;4B >DE4ACDA4B 34 270@D4 4=C8CT B>=C 4= 5>=2C8>= 34 ;0 ;D<8SA4 =T24BB08A4 P ;Z8=CTA84DA ;0 CA0<4 BCAD2CDA4;;4 3D AT542C>8A4 BD??>AC 34 C>DC ;4 ?A>94C 4BC 5028;4<4=C ;8B81;4 ?0A D=BGBCS<43Z0A2B343T270A640BBD<TB4CA08B>==TB$=?4DC24?4=30=C?4=B4A@D4 ;4B >DE4ACDA4B 3D ?A4<84A TC064 34 ;0 60;4A84 B>=C D=4 2>=24BB8>= P ;0 2><?>B8C8>= 2;0BB8@D434B>DE4ACDA4B4C@DZD=450R034C>C0;4<4=C0E4D6;40DA08C?D27>@D4A?>DA ;ZT?>@D4>V24?A>94CTC08C3T9PCASB=>E0C4DA4=;84=0E42B4C7T>A84B.
(169). . . 0R034BDA;0AD4;B024!>AA08=43D?A>94C340A2G . EC O. LE. N. AT. IO. !>AB@D4 4=8B 0A2G A4?A4=3 ;4 ?A>94C P ;0 <>AC 34 +8>;;4C;4D2 4= 8; A4?A4=3 2><<4 ED ?;DB 70DC ;4 ?;0= 3Z>A868=4 @DZ8; 0;86=4 BDA ;0 AD4 ;B024!>AA08=4 HW RS¤UH GHV PRGLȿFDWLRQV VXU GHV SDUWLHV GX SURJUDPPH OȀHVFDOLHU QRWDPPHQW /HV CA>8B4=C8CTB3TE4;>??T4B?;DB70DCB>=C2>=B4AET4B184=@D42702D=42>==08BB434B PRGLȿFDWLRQV/DID£DGHGXSHWLWFORªWUHHVWLQW¥JU¥HDXSURMHWFDUOHQRXYHDXSODQHQ 1808B?0AA0??>AC0D2>DE4=C2ATTD=4BDAT?08BB4DA@D4;Z0A278C42C4CA0E08;;4 )>DC3Z01>A3;4?0E8;;>=34;Z03<8=8BCA0C8>=
(170) 4BC5>AC4<4=CA4<0=8T606=44= KDXWHXUHWHQYHUWLFDOLW¥HWVRQVW\OHFKDQJH,OVȀRUQHGHGHX[QLFKHVGHJUDQGHKDXWHXU DSSX\DQW OD YHUWLFDOH HW VRQ VRPPHW HVW DJU¥PHQW¥ GH GHX[ ¥FKDXJXHWWHV HW GȀXQH V¥ULHGȀDUFV&HYROXPHYHUWLFDOVHGLȾ¥UHQFLHIRUWHPHQWGHODFRPSRVLWLRQGXUHVWHGH ;0 50R034 4<?AD=C4 34B T;T<4=CB P D= =>DE40D E>201D;08A4 30=B D=4 28C0C8>= @D8 SRXUUDLW¦WUHTXDOLȿ¥HGȀ¥FOHFWLTXH'HSOXVOHFHQWUHGHODID£DGHVȀRUQHGȀXQJUDQG 6A>D?4 B2D;?CT CASB 0203T<8@D4 @D8 E84=C >A=4A B0=B B>D;86=4A @D4;2>=@D4 ?>8=C 34 BCAD2CDA42><<4;4E>D3A084=C;4B?AT24?C4B34+8>;;4C;4D222>;T40D?0E8;;>=34 ;Z03<8=8BCA0C8>=;Z4=CAT434B0AC8BC4B B43TE4;>??44C?A4=3D=4?;DB6A0=34?;024 30=B ;0 2><?>B8C8>= 84= @DZ4;;4 B>8C 4=2>A4 8=CT6AT4 30=B ;0 CA0<4 34 ;0 60;4A84 ;4
(171)
(172)
(173) &( !#%!" )%&##$ ))%)"# !!)%! $#$
(174) . .
(175) . .
(176) LE. EC O. O. D NA O LE C U S M U EN PE T RI SO EU U RE M IS D AU 'AR D CH R IT O E IT C D TU 'A R U E TE D U E R T. IO. AT. N. U SE. U LO.
(177) LE. EC O. O. D NA O LE C U S M U EN PE T RI SO EU U RE M IS D AU 'AR D CH R IT O E IT C D TU 'A R U E TE D U E R T. IO. AT. N. U SE. U LO.
(178)
(179)
(180) . D NA O LE C U S M U EN PE T RI SO EU U RE M IS D AU 'AR D CH R IT O E IT C D TU 'A R U E TE D U E R T. O. U LO. U SE. CA0<434;060;4A844C;4C>8C3D?0E8;;>=3Z4=CAT44C34;060;4A844BC2><<D=E4=0=C4= FRQWUDGLFWLRQDYHFODV\P¥WULHLQGXLWHSDUOHVGHX[SDYLOORQVLGHQWLTXHV 7RXWDXORQJGHOȀDYDQFHPHQWGHFHSURMHWHWGHFHVPRGLȿFDWLRQVDSSRUW¥HV ?0A4=8B0A2G;4B?AT24?C4BE8>;;4C;43D284=BB4<1;4=C?4DP?4D38B?0A08CA430=B;0 FRPSRVLWLRQGHFHWWHID£DGHSULQFLSDOH/HG¥FRXSDJHHQWURLVHQWLW¥VYLHQW¦WUHSHUWXUE¥ SDUOHWUDYDLOU¥DOLV¥VXUOHSHWLWFORªWUHSDUOHVPRGLȿFDWLRQVLPSRUWDQWHVDSSRUW¥HVVXUOH SDYLOORQ6XG TXLVRQWHQSDUWLHVGXHVGHVHQMHX[XUEDLQVLQG¥SHQGDQWVGHODYRORQW¥ 340A2G4C?0A;02>=24?C8>=34BC>8CB@D8>B28;;44=CA48=3T?4=30=2434B?0AC84B4C 3T2>D?064=4C4=0=C?0B2><?C434;02><?>B8C8>=B>DB9024=C4 'DQVOHSURMHWG¥ȿQLWLIODV\P¥WULHDSSRUW¥HSDUOHQRXYHDXSDYLOORQ6XGDQFUH SOHLQHPHQW OH SURMHW GDQV XQH FRPSRVLWLRQ FODVVLTXH GHX[ SDYLOORQV HQFDGUDQW XQH JDOHULH2U9LROOHWOH'XFVȀRSSRVHIRUWHPHQWODV\P¥WULHLQMXVWLȿ¥HGDQVGHQRPEUHX[ SDVVDJHVGHVHVHQWUHWLHQV'ȀDSU¤VOXLVLGHX[YROXPHVQȀDFFXHLOOHQWSDVODP¦PHIRQFWLRQ LOQHGRLYHQWSDV¦WUHLGHQWLTXHVRUFȀHVWFHTXHIDLWLFL'DUF\LOQȀ\DSOXVGHKL¥UDUFKLH HQWUHOȀHQWU¥HGHVDUWLVWHVHWOȀHQWU¥HSXEOLTXHOHVGHX[VRQWLGHQWLTXHV (QȿQXQHUHFRPSRVLWLRQGHVSURSRUWLRQVGHODID£DGHGDQVOHVSURMHWVGH'DUF\ RȾUHXQHSODFHSOXVLPSRUWDQWHODPRG¥QDWXUHHWODG¥FRUDWLRQTXLTXLWWHODIRQFWLRQ 34 B>D;86=4<4=C 34 ;0 BCAD2CDA4 2><<4 ;4 ?AT2>=8B4 +8>;;4C;4D2 4= 4<?AD=C0=C P GLȾ¥UHQWVVW\OHVGLȾ¥UHQWHV¥SRTXHVGHVSURȿOVHWGHVIRUPHVTXLSUHQQHQWHQLPSRUWDQFH BZTC4=34=CB438;0C4=C4?>8=CB4A001>A3T?;DB?AT28BT<4=C30=B;Z0=0;GB434;ZDB064 34;0?84AA42><<4BD??>AC34;Z>A=4<4=C30=B;41QC8<4=C (Q G¥ȿQLWLYH l 6XU OD U¥DOLVDWLRQ G¥ɀQLWLYH OH SURMHW GH 9LROOHWOH'XF DYDLW OH P¥ULWHGȁXQHSOXVJUDQGHVREUL¥W¥GDQVODG¥FRUDWLRQHWGȁXQHKDUPRQLHPHLOOHXUHGHV -/,-,/1',+0 '$+13,2)2/ --$)$/"$))$#2/=%$"1,'/$#'0- /2:)B$*-) "$*$+1#2.2$) ')0B=)$3 '19 1%A>?>AC8>=B4CCA0<4. EC O. LE. N. AT. IO. !4B?A8=28?0;4BC7T>A84B34+8>;;4C;4D22>=24A=0=C;4B?A>?>AC8>=B4C;06T><TCA84 GȀXQ¥GLȿFHUHSRVHQWVXUOȀXVDJHGXWULDQJOH¥TXLODW¥UDOHWGHVG¥FOLQDLVRQVTXHFHOXL FLSHXWRȾULU(QHȾHWVLODPRG¥QDWXUHRXODFRPSRVLWLRQGRLYHQWPRQWUHUHWPHWWUHHQ OXPL¤UHODVWUXFWXUHLOFRQVLG¤UHTXHOHVSURSRUWLRQVGȀXQ¥GLȿFHGRLYHQWIDLUHVHQWLUVD BC018;8CT$A8;3T2A8Cl/HWULDQJOH¥TXLODW¥UDOHVWGHWRXVFHOXLTXLVDWLVIDLWSOHLQHPHQWOHV \HX[>@DXFXQHɀJXUHJ¥RP¥WULTXHQȁHVWSOXVVDWLVIDLVDQWHSRXUOȁHVSULWDXFXQHQHUHPSOLW PLHX[OHVFRQGLWLRQVTXLSODLVHQWDX[\HX[U¥JXODULW¥VWDELOLW¥z
(181) ;3TE4;>??4D=40=0;GB44<?8A8@D43424CC4C7T>A844=0=0;GB0=C;06T><TCA84 GHJUDQGV¥GLȿFHV¥J\SWLHQVDQWLTXHVGHEDVLOLTXHVRXGHFDWK¥GUDOHV&KDFXQGHFHV ¥GLȿFHV SU¥VHQWH HQ HȾHW GHV SURSRUWLRQV GLFW¥HV SDU FHUWDLQV WULDQJOHV ¥TXLODW¥UDX[ @D80??D84=C34B;86=4B34;02>=BCAD2C8>=4C34;0BCAD2CDA430=BD=A0??>AC3DC>DC DX[ SDUWLHV 0DLV FRPPH LO OH FRQF¤GH 7 $ 1,20 )$0 *,+2*$+10 #B /"&'1$"12/$ "$24 .2' 0,+1 '0,)=0 .2' +B,+1 - 0 1 +1 2+ " / "1</$ #B21')'1= .2$ #B /1 !0,)2 #,'3$+1 -/'+"'- )$*$+10B 11 "&$/:-/=0$+1$/2+$& /*,+'$- /% '1$9. 33
(182) 3
(183)
Documents relatifs
CENTRE CONFEDERAL D'EDUCATION OUVRIERE (C.G. CERTIFICAT D'APTITUDE AUX FONCTIONS DE BIBLIOTHECAIRE, B. diplome unique, voeu. CHAMBRE DE COMMERCE. CHAMBRE DES DEPUTES.. Association
We have shown in a previous paper [17] that, in the continuum limit, the model can be effectively described by a Fractional Boussinesq Equation (FBE) in terms of the space-time
Pour innover dans l’enseignement, il a été décidé de faire construire, par l’équipe des bibliothécaires et enseignantes en documentation, une vision partagée
that gives a certain probability p of return yields a problem hardly any more difficult than calculating the probability for a given !: it just adds the need to use a
En d'autres termes, si les élèves formés à la négociation orthographique ne font pas beaucoup moins d'erreurs que les autres, ils apparaissent plus compétents dans
De même, dans le récit de Luc, le « comme si elle me délivrait un message d’apaisement » ne porte pas directement sur la présence— dont le degré d’intensification
From the base to the top of the section, these units are: (U1) - initial development of reef building upon submarine volcanoclastic deposits during the Middle Givetian (middle varcus
Analyser la pertinence des données LiDAR terrestre et des photographies aériennes à basse altitude pour la création de MNTs de bassins versants agricoles. Estimer et comparer