Numerical Resolution of a Multiphasic Optimal Mass Transport Problem

Texte intégral

(1)Numerical Resolution of a Multiphasic Optimal Mass Transport Problem Jean-David Benamou, Yann Brenier, Kevin Guittet. To cite this version: Jean-David Benamou, Yann Brenier, Kevin Guittet. Numerical Resolution of a Multiphasic Optimal Mass Transport Problem. [Research Report] RR-4022, INRIA. 2000. �inria-00072619�. HAL Id: inria-00072619 https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00072619 Submitted on 24 May 2006. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés..

(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Numerical Resolution of a Multiphasic Optimal Mass Transport Problem Jean-David Benamou , Yann Brenier , Kévin Guittet. N ˚ 4022 Octobre 2000. ISSN 0249-6399. ISRN INRIA/RR--4022--FR+ENG. ` THEME 4. apport de recherche.

(3)

(4)

(5)

(6) ! #" $ %&' ()

(7) +*,% - ." ( / ) '0%1,23)4

(8) 5 687:9<;0=?>9A@CBEDGF7H;I9<JK8LGMON0P9<;);QFRS7T;)BU7TRWVNIXZ7HY @CBE;Q['L)BE\]\S7T\W^ _`bcea dcgf} hji:kld a mAnloqprkts:uvcpsHwxpykldklz{oqpyk|sHu czr~zrp c]sqdcc]p5zg

(9) us:d} c]wAz ntcAc]z oTwxw<s p } c c] ` c ` c3uqf:HThjHmAklu'qTH(h wxoTTc]z W 0]xTT cvc

(10) Apyce}u } p ` c'

(11) nloTz{zykloTn Os:uATc` E } oHuHprs } s¡k| `` sH¢An|c]d£` klu¤p ` cvdmAntprk|} w ` oTzrk|} prssHu:p py` cklAzpw ¥§ ¦sH¢Aun|oTc]dvmA:Ädk|prc]zu:cpy©ªc

(12) nlk|oqc]ux oH~uA¢<TckloTkluAu«umx ` dc]c?¬Tk|c ]}oqnT dktp c` p ¡s o k|mxsHzrmxc zdklu(cp p ` s c} dz]¥s:uAsHw oTzrk| ]oTzrc k|z§o oHwApyc °® ¯²r± ³Eéµ ²± ¶0·|³U¸U¹

(13) º Ã)Æyë]»½ð ÇÉË:Û:Ò¼¿Æ$Ðß¾0ñTÊÀCÄ?ÈæE¼°Æ$Æ{ÁÅòEÂ1Ä?Ä?ÇÉÎqæíÃ0Êì0Ä?ËHÇÉÈSÅó Æ$æíÆ$ÇîÈÆeÇÉÆ$ÈSÒ ï|Í Ê3æáeàíÊËSÊ3È]ÎSÅÌ<Ä?Êô æíÍÉÎSÇÉõ]ÏÎSÊyÆ$Ê?Î:Â÷ÂÑö§ÈSÐ0Ç ë

(14) Ò ÊÓAæEÒÉàEÔyÇ Õ

(15) ò]Ê5ÖØô Óx×$Æ$ÙeæEÇÉÔràÖ$Ú,øeÂ<ù(Û:ÊÝúeÍîÆ$ÜßÏyÊÞSÊê$àEÎSÈSàíÆyàEáâÇÉÊÎ:ÏÂ8Ê×?ËSÖ?Êä×?ãHÖ?ÂZû(åSÓ÷æUÆ$Æ$æíÈSÇÉàÏÊ?ÏÂQÊËSÊäÊäã«ç°ÅÕ

(16) Æ$Ö]ÇÉÂ<ÍéåSæEè ê$Æ$ÊyÈSÆ$ÏÈeÊ

(17) ç Ò ÊçlÅþ Æ$ÇÉÿ ÍxÏè Ä?ÐßÍÉæíÊIÊÈS¾ÇÉÄ?ÊæíæäÅì)Æ$Æ$ÈSÍÉÊÈ:]ÎÒ üýSÎSú8àíàEÊô ÇÉæíÊÇÉÎ:ÊyÎeÒ ïtæEæ Ê?ÂSùÖ]ÂæíÎSÊ Ë:ó ö§ÍÉÅ!Â×?Ö$Õ?Õ

(18) ÖÓxÆ$æEÇÉàrÂSåSæUÆ$ÈSÏÊ?ÂÊäç°ÅÆ$ÇÉÍAè ?ÎSÇ òýòEÊäòUì0ÏÍÉÇ úSúqÊyæyÒ ÊÈSàrÒ ïtæ. Unité de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex (France) Téléphone : 01 39 63 55 11 - International : +33 1 39 63 55 11 Télécopie : (33) 01 39 63 53 30 - International : +33 1 39 63 53 30.

(19) 0

(20) ª W'y %)4 5 )) ')%1 % - - (0 %]'0 5) %&' (

(21) a } } a ` m÷duAs: c uA}sHcew ux` zyoTk|zrp kc prmAsTcp{c oqc]n|zrcoTp w÷xo w÷ } sc oTcHwApI¥p w0c c o(cezyo'da ceuHcnl o ppr`c s ntc]c} zrcsTw nlu:mAs:m÷pr¢Aktd s:n c]u c d }kc cªmAcccW} p cw oH 0uxsHoqz{¢Aw÷ n ce as oTduxp cHT¨§k|cc]c]u pdoH} oHmA!kzrHzrccd oceceuHu:wxppyn|cc]mx zzrmAk|¡pyc]k|cm n| k| z "k zIc< cw]oqw<proHsHktzys:m ceux zz ¨:ntcoSzys:¡TuHoTcepz c#8ce

(22) p{m c cez¥.

(23)

(24)

(25) ! "#$

(26) &%'"( )* + &,- $."$ 0/1-324. 5. c c

(27) Apy} ceu } p ` c(

(28) nloTz{zykloTnb OsHuAHc

(29) U` oT} u:pys s} ¡kl `` sH¢An|c]d kluW` p ` c(d mAn|pyklw ` oHzy}klg

(30) sHu:} prc

(31) Ap¥ ¦5` u oHw mA s:H¢AdntcecedvuHprÄc ktp{znloqc

(32) ©ª

(33) oHk|uAc]Tu÷kl

(34) oT~Wu ¢<ucmxkluAdªc kl` ceoT?n ¬qdc }Wcp kts p ` ¡Smxo zr c k|sHm÷k|zudp c]cvp ` ds } sHz]ux¥ sHw oHzyklW]oTzrcWklzo oHwApyc pys1p k|z. ÀÀ,È06ù

(35) Õ

(36) û?û.

(37) f. (

(38) -

(39) )1 ) . )) O' )

(40) u fU¨÷ou:m÷dc kloTnCdcp ` s } prszrsTn|¡Tc p ` c¿sTn|nts kluAdoTz{zp oTuxz{w÷s pw sH¢xntced! " k|¡Tceup s¢<sHmxu } c } ¨w<sHzrktprkt¡Hcdcezrm oH¢Antc#ým÷ux

(41) prkts:uxz%$'&oTu } $)( k|p ` z{oTdcdoTz{z klu«p ` cpys mxz *,+-/.'012. ¨ <u } oHuoHwxwAn|k|]oqpyk|sHu43 k| ` ceoqn|k65]c]z)p ` cp oTuxz{w<s p sHd7$)&prs8$)('klup ` c#¿sHntn|s k|ux zrc]u÷zyc4/9÷s oqn|nC¢÷s c]nCzyc]p;:¨3 zroTpyklz<¿~Hc]z . . =?>A@)BDCFEHG. oHu } oT ` |k c¡Hc]z p ` cdkluAkldoTn§

(42) s:zyp. $'&IJLKNMOJ +. ='E. $'(PIJQK<MRJTS. IDUVK. IEOK } } _` ` pu` mxkldz«c sH wAklc'proTk|ddnCk|doTuxnk|c]dpd` oqoHs nwb}

(43) ¨s:` ozyoHpuAprk|k|zdsHpcuUc p sH` u:cpyoTkl¿uz{sHzymAntc n|sHs mxzr pyz c]k|uxk| u c`¿ sdc] c]z{dmAp mAn|p8k|nloqpy¢÷k|sHc]u.p sc]gc]up ` $'cO&w oH u sH¢xnt$'ced(I¥ oHu¤zs k|u:p c s } prmxs c

(44) }s:d¥ wx_mA` pycc acb 'd fehgehg ,+# i - #$Tj )Y . ( ki .ml CFnpo q`Gsr =RtLuQ= ( Xx X k|?u $I]vwSDJQK IvwSyJQK MOJMOvwS I5 K & r}| 2 )!- )~ * h*)# )p "$ )$" ) z # #$ ! )x *#$ 6{ $hIvwSyJQK IvwSyJQK -/. c3$ )~ Qm )]~ 6 ! ~ )) )# $ w !

(45) 4 z x ) $8Î$ K + Iý'f K r 4 v h J -/. h 2 . )# ) )r

(46) Q2 ( h )

(47) $ $IE S^K + $)&RS_$hI Sp^K + $)(P^ IOK _` ` cgpykldc

(48) ä

(49) ` s:uHprk|umAs:mxPz ¿s d mAnloq prkts:ù ` s c¡Hc ]oT} uª¢<c c

(50) A} pyceu } c } kluWod mAn|pyklw ` oHzykl sHu:pycA2p IoT z klp u'` c p c¡Tc sHdn|mxsHpyuAk|sHs:uw Rs ÷oTzrp kl` (cHoTntzrs:cT¢x¨ oqn }cc]¬u÷uAzysk|pä~T¥ p _c ` c]k|uAu k|ppykl` oqcn0w oT u sH¢xnt8ceuxdZoqn k|z0pyc]s ux}zrktc]prpyktcec z d¨ß¢xk|uxmAcp p ` ccoTklu:n|zrpysªc w dcc]}

(51) klk|zro c n|~(~zr¬pruAoqprs c]z Rs p ` czy~Azrpyced¥ Os c(sHux c]pycn|~T¨ c ` oS¡Tcgpysªdkl>uAkldk 5c(p ` c¬:k|uxcpykl c]uxc T~ = ( =?W x Xx X I$hS K + U I])K O? & $ IvwSyJQK IvwSyJQK MRJhMRv kluvp ` cn|oHzrz Rs ýmxu÷

(52) pyk|sHu÷zzrm÷ ` p ` oq8p =?WYX. X J[ZY3\I]JQK $ & IJQK<MRJ_^. ¼¿¾0ÀC¼°Á.

(53)

(54)

(55) ! "#$

(56) &%'"( )* + &,- $."$ 0/1-324. $ v > IcKwS O. v I SD$ MOv MOJQKwS ^ + S. x x + $ S . + h $ $ S $ . E. r $ I Sp^K + $ & S#$ I pS ^K + $ (. . I RK I

(57) )K I )K. } } } } } ` oHu } o cp÷mxzc }

(58) s:Tuxn|sHzyk ¢xoTc n } pyc]klduxzrcktpä¢<~ sHWmx u z{oqopyklz ~ ¿~:kluAoTpro p ` csHdwxoTpyc#kl<¢AuAktn|c k|pä~ox

(59) ¥ s:cTu¥0} sHk|u pyk|sHuxz k|p uAs:uäuAc:oqpyk|¡Tc¡oqnlmAcez¨ $>. 4I$ & DS $ ( K >. D. í. + $ I S^KwS $ & DI ^K ) ) ='W & S $ ID^K > . *. r + h $ ( yI ^K $ I pS ^KPS. . . oHu } zyc]p. +. =?W. $ ( Iy^KPS. . r = W & = W vP S $ ID^K + $ IvwSp^KP^ h ). . I$'&Sy$)( K +. klu' . x I$hS K. . ]. IyU )K IyURUVK. e. IyU OK. IyU 5 K. ¿s I$ S K z{mx ` p ` oTp8I RK?¨HI

(60) 'KoTu } I 'K ` sTn } ¥ } c]ux} zrktpä`~H` ce¨ u« cp ` c` ce

(61) c5skl¡HzIc sH uxp nt` ~c sHpyuAkldccw U` oTsH` zru:c pyklIíukímA¥ cTsH¥%m÷3 zO}+ sHuxUTK$¨c oT_u } oTu÷k6 zrw<s c pce` wd ssH¡H¢Acn|c]` p dv` cg¥

(62) ps: u }oTk|u'pyk|¢<sH` ucssH uklp u:` pyc5c Hc]ntzrs:p¢xpyoqs n pzrpr` m klz~wxm s w÷s:zycHp ¨ c« c

(63) s:s:uxuAzrntp ~oq

(64) klsHuHu÷pgzysHk } u c p p c«` cTn|dsH¢AsHnluAoqs n } klceduxc]zyuxk|päzr~k|sHoHux

(65) oTprnßz ]s:oTuzrc p s)c«p ¢÷` c(c p oS ¡oHktuxs:zym nloqprskts: uªp sRcª)ozr~Azrzypyprc]c]wCdv¥ ¥49÷s `p} c kluuAk|p py` kloqc n oH u zrp } ` c

(66) <xuxoHoT` dn§wx pyklntcHd_¨ c] ` z]c¨<¢x mxsH} uxp zr k } k|cp ` s:p mA p5s

(67) w s:` ux oTzrzrp c] z)oqklz{` uHmx8p ` I

(68) )p K?` ¥ ` oT_p ` p òTpcklHznts:p ¢x` oqc n c} ceo ux` zyc(k|päp ~ klsªz wo(} `

(69) oTs:zruxc]zrz]pr¨ oT u: p` ` kl¿s ` p ` s sHcd½uA¢xsTn|ppmA` zycc(c]cntklkluAuAc]k|coHpykl zoq` nCs sTpr sp zp c ` p c` ¥ c<uxc¡ToTc sHn§n|zrmxc prpyoqk|prsHntc]klu'uAz]c¥ s IsHup ` ÷c :Hm nts:c8¢xUoqn z } sc]u÷zyzk|päp ~T¥ c c¡HcsTnlzrmAcpyc k|sHp u` oTsp5Cp p ` c c } cezruxp zyk|pycek|c]uxzzyk|p pä ~ToT¨ u÷zynloqk|prntcc u'p ` czrc]sHu } c

(70) xoHdwxntcH¨ c

(71) s:uxzyk } c p sªw ` oTzrc]zz{mx ` p ` oqpp ` c Hnts:¢xoqn } c]uxzrk|pä~Wklz5oqn oS~zo w sH ceuxzrzrzrprk|oH¢xu:ktn|pkt¥ pä~g

(72) usHu÷p zy` p c oT k|c]u:z{pmA¥ n|przgz ` s uk|u ÷Hm cA¨ czrcc ` s p ` cw ` oHzycez s:zrzmxu } c p ` ck|u÷

(73) sHd . x. ÀÀ,È06ù

(74) Õ

(75) û?û.

(76) (

(77) -

(78) )1 ) . timestep 1. timestep 5. timestep 9. 2. 2. 2. 1.5. 1.5. 1.5. 1. 1. 1. 0.5. 0.5. 0.5. 0. 0 timestep 13. 0 timestep 17. timestep 21. 2. 2. 2. 1.5. 1.5. 1.5. 1. 1. 1. 0.5. 0.5. 0.5. 0. 0 timestep 25. 0 timestep 29. timestep 33. 2. 2. 2. 1.5. 1.5. 1.5. 1. 1. 1. 0.5. 0.5. 0.5. 0k|Hm c4UR)Os:uAsHw ` oTzrk|

(79) Uzrpä~ntc zrpyc]wp oTu÷zynloqprkts:u. 0. 0. 0. 9. timestep 1. timestep 5. timestep 9. 2. 2. 2. 1.5. 1.5. 1.5. 1. 1. 1. 0.5. 0.5. 0.5. 0. 0 timestep 13. 0 timestep 17. timestep 21. 2. 2. 2. 1.5. 1.5. 1.5. 1. 1. 1. 0.5. 0.5. 0.5. 0. 0 timestep 25. 0 timestep 29. timestep 33. 2. 2. 2. 1.5. 1.5. 1.5. 1. 1. 1. 0.5. 0.5. 0.5. )k|Hm c?k|w ` oTzrk| zrpycewp oHuxzrn|oTpyk|sHu. 0. 0. 0. 9. ¼¿¾0ÀC¼°Á.

(80)

(81)

(82) ! "#$

(83) &%'"( )* + &,- $."$ 0/1-324. . _` cgOp s oq c]c]s¡Tpyc s ¨:k|c]p `zc k|uxIvwSysHJQdK w o c]c z{zyp kl` ¢Ac(k|ntk|k|päu:~Wpyc] sH uxoqzrnbp m oq klu:¡Hpc]z oHs

(84) pr)zp `sHuc(¡Hp `cn|c(sA

(85) p k|päoq~c]

(86) prs ktcez s)p ` c<mxk } wxo rp k|ntcez¥ x IvwSyJQK + I]vwS I]vwSDJLKDK S IyU'f K IESyJQK + JT^. ` ` ` ` ` ` ]} oTk|dzrcTc]üu÷k|zyppWk|sHklcubz¨ßduAp sHsH` uApªcs:pp w mAoqoTc1c]zrkloT?pyu:äs zy~A pädk|~c]n|z5s c ]cHoToH¥ uzycH_c]¨8¡T` p cecucw z wx ` c]o s zr c]pyu:kl

(87) zypyn|s:c c d} c oSce¡Hzrcm mx ntoW¡p{zWoqp{sHom ux zrcOcproHcs:u:ßcuAp5]c ¡Tpr} c]z]klnt¥8dsA90c]ktpäuxk|H~Hzrm¨ßkts: ¢÷uxcemAzoqpnE5 ¨kluO¢xoTumAp p} ck|f'u ¢Aoqk|w` n|n|kts oT ` zrc k|o ¡klzrm÷oqnC

(88) s:dwxo k|zrsHuWs0p ` c(p oqc]

(89) prs ktcez k|u'¢<sTp ` cAoHdwAntcez¥. ÀÀ,È06ù

(90) Õ

(91) û?û.

(92) (

(93) -

(94) )1 ) .

(95). 1. 0.8. 0.6. 0.4. 0.2. 0 0. 0.8. )k|Hm c 5 Os:uAsHw ` oTzrk|

(96) Uzrpä~ntcp oce

(97) pys k|c]z. 0.9. 1. )k|Hm c f k|w ` oTzrk|gp oce

(98) prs ktcez. 0.8. 0.9. 1. 0.1. 0.2. 0.3. 0.4. 0.5. 0.6. 0.7. 9. 1. 0.8. 0.6. 0.4. 0.2. 0 0. 0.1. 0.2. 0.3. 0.4. 0.5. 0.6. 0.7. 9. ¼¿¾0ÀC¼°Á.

(99)

(100)

(101) ! "#$

(102) &%'"( )* + &,- $."$ 0/1-324. . ` cvdmA} ntprk|w ` oTzrk|voHzycvz ` s z klu:pyc c]zrpykluA w sHw<c pyk|c] zk|u.ktp{zyc]n} ¥ ` u } cc } ¨p ` cv} sHu } ktprkts:u m A p p ` s:du mAn|p pyklwAcntk|Tc n| sHkl¢xz§oTp n ` ccew ux zrc]ktz{päzr~ m oTcT¥ prz_oT` z c ¿oHs u dk|u÷oT

(103) nHsHs:dwAwpykldc]z{oqzrn|k|kt¢Apä~(k|n|kt

(104) päs:~ u

(105) } s:k|pyuxk|zysHp uxz0oTk|s:u:u(p]¨0p ` oHc u nloq kloTzuxoHTzrklzroTsAu

(106) skloqxprp c ` cn|w oT s:¢AoTn|uAc]Hd c o c x X. . X. . . . . í. ). +. . O $ [Î$ K + r $ I S^K + $ & Sy$ I Sp^K + $ ( > . k|u°S r k|u ° S r k|u ° S r k|u * S k|u ° S r. + . . + $ I]vwSDJQK $ IvwSyJQK . * S. IyUsOK. * S. IyUp)K. * S. IyU R K IyU )

(107) K. * ^. IyU ) K. } ` _ + } + ` ` c s mx oq¬proTktp ¬:s:` kluxcuAz

(108) ÷¿sT¥ $n|nts _ ` klsHuAUOzrc«oTc

(109) cu Ak|mxzrpyoq ceprux kts:

(110) uxc(z p ` ` U coSs ¿¡Ts cªced!¢<c]c¡Tc]c u ~ zrprm ¨} ktc } c klu c]sT :EuA¨ k6oT5]u c'} p c cª ]oTsHu d} sHc T} c]mxux

(111) k65]cmc s:¡Td s pyc c]UuAz k|c c c] zp | x acb 'd fehgHg ,+# - k I$ S + $ K ~ )) hs Q & # . & # )# + !

(112) . I c K ! Ic K. = =. ". X $ . ". $ . . U X. Xx. . X ZY# OM JMOv. $ X MOJMOv X U X $ . . ) . X. . K. S. S. Uq IU?UVK IUTO K IU 5 K I )K. S. I] $)&RSD$'( K ^ )4 %]

(113)

(114) ( '!

(115) '& i !

(116) $()V *+,.x I]$S K +. I]$ S. . . ` ` ` ` sRp g` k|uxz5zyc sHn|p mAprckts:w ub¥ s:_¢Ant` cekld zk|klzzgp ¬:` uxcs wxm u w<pysHs zrc oSs¡Tc p òczysH¿sTn|mxn|n|pys k| sHubk|uA¨8«p zrcc]pyk|mAsHc]ubzr¥pyk|sHuds¡Hc]z5pysWp csHdwxmAp{oqprkts:u ÀÀ,È06ù

(117) Õ

(118) û?û.

(119) e. (

(120) -

(121) )1 ) . U. / &'ª5 -)&' _` c¿sHntn|s kluA«

(122) sHdwxoH

(123) puAsHproqprkts:uxzo c mxzyc } p `x sHmA ` sHmxp p ` klzzyce

(124) prkts:uT *,k+ lz- p .` 0c12z{. wxkloTzpyklp oq` nbc w< o c } k|kts ce}uHpk| klu mxuA-/k|p5. ¥]mx¢÷cH¨ S r ßklzo xAc } pykldc(k|u:prc ¡SoTní¥ ) kk|zlzp `p ` c(cpyklz{dwxoTc py}kloqc n kt¡oHoTwApyk|nl¡ToTcT

(125) kl¥ oTuWk|u -/. ¥ ^xoH uoo } +X ^ X )} ceSkuAsTprc (p kl` zc(p `kluxc uAprc k| dw c

(126) äsz{wx} oTmx

(127) cgp oT u o } } k|p c]` u:cpk|u m÷

(128) - n|k } ceoT- uv. ¥ uAs dÝklu -/. ¥ 2 + k|zp ` c(pykldc

(129) äzrw÷oT

(130) c 0oTwAnloTk|oHuWklu - -/. ¥ w s #} mx9÷s p ¥ p sª¡Tce

(131) prs zklu - -/. ¨

(132) hS oTu }

(133) ]Sí¨

(134) hSO^

(135) S +

(136)

(137) ?V^ } ceuAsTprc]zp ` ck|u÷uAc . "!$#&%(')#+* %(,-#.*. (c mxzrc p ` c 0oq oHuATkloTu ¿s `dmAn|oTpy k|sHu«} sR} p ` c(d mAn|pyklw ` _oH` zykl5s:wApy kldoqnßpykldc

(138) ä

(139) s:uHprk|umAs:mxz doHzrz p oHuxz w<s pw sH¢An|c]d½uxs zrcpsHup cw÷> c k|s k| sHdoqklu0/¥ c 0oq oHuATkloTu«klzTk|¡Tceu¢:~ X X = ( = W I]vwSDJQK ) + 2I$ S S S K Z $ Z ^ MOJMOv > & $ I]vwSDJQK O? r =?W & Z $ IE Sp> ^K Z $ ( I Sp^K FMOJ )) = ( = W $h IvwSDJLK Z $ IvwSyJQK I]vwSDJLKNMOJMOv;S IU'f K & O ` c cgp ` c oTu } o c p ` c(nloq oHuATcgd mAn|pyklwAn|ktc zs 0sHuxzrp oqklu:prz I

(140) 'K$¥ co c p ` ceun|c } prszrsTn|¡Tc p ` c ¿sTn|nts kluAw sH¢An|c]!d CFn o G C o G kl'u z{mxw 2 I$ S S S K IUR OK 1 2 1 31 4 _` c I¿s doqn KIs:wApykldoqn|ktpä~v

(141) s:u } k|pyk|sHux z ¿s p ` klzw sH¢An|c]d o c. ¼¿¾0ÀC¼°Á.

(142)

(143)

(144) ! "#$

(145) &%'"( )* + &,- $."$ 0/1-324. . UOU. X X ) + + $ $ ) $ ^ + r > $ I S^K + $ & Sy$ I S^K + $ ( $ I]vwSDJQK + $h IvwSyJQK ). r k l l S * S u r l k l S * S u r IU)K l k l S * S u * S í l k u klu l S r * ^ } mx

(146) c } c«kluuAsTp pr` k|cc w p ` c¡oqpk|sHmxz]zroTc]u pyk|¢÷sHcu_cn|k|dkluxoqprc } ¨CoHu } p ` c]u ce

(147) s¡Hc p ` csHwAprk|doqn|k|pä~O

(148) sHu } ktprkts:uxzk|u:p sq X X r ) l k l S * S u + r K + klu l S r * S $ 6 ^ ] I $ > + & IU RK * S $ Ií S^K $ Sy$ I S^K + $ ( l k u $ I]vwSDJQK + $h IvwSyJQK klu l S r * ^. . . ). . ' -#

(149) ),(* . up ` cp ` ¿sTk|zn|n|s zrc]k|pyuAk|sHub ¨ ` o c oH

(150) c`py¿c s k5]d oTmxpyk|n|sHoTu«pycgklu:p `p cs w} mxsH

(151) ¢xc nt} ced½k|uYmx 5 zrk|EuA¨ `p ` k| c(` pyklc z dp ` kloTuApsT¨?n|sT¿sH ~«w÷ss:#zy k| py5k|¡TE¥c $8¨ c p c ` c` oSc¡T¿sc c(mxzyc X X + zrmxw

(152) O$ V^ IU

(153) )K. $ & c(p ` ceuvc]oTzrk|nt~ªHcp ¤ Hgehg )' #$ )4 z ))

(154) 2 4 h*+ !

(155) l . . + $ S. . z. z. ). "- 2 )(+*) cl. ÀÀ,È06ù

(156) Õ

(157) û?û. . +

(158) S + S ) 1 I K +! W " r # I LK +%$ W I S ^K $'& ZI S^K $'( ( & I K +' | $ & $ ( $W S +'$ & $ ^ S. r. U. I ) K. í. o o -wo | ' I K # I Q K & I Ky S Z ^. z{mx, w 3 k|u. 4. . . . I 5 )K.

(159) S. (

(160) -

(161) )1 ) . U. o. oHzozrkluATn|co - ¡So kloT¢xntc(oTu } p ` c]u } ceuAsTprk|uA[I/K + 4 ¨ cgHcp8 z{mx, w kl 'u I K # I KD S[I/K Z | H^ I 5 UVK im÷ ` 0oq oHuATkloTu4¿s dmAnloqpyk|sHu÷z o c(q mxzrc } kluYx 5 H¿s x zrsTn|¡k|uA«w sH¢xntcedzsRp ` c¿s d dk|u I K # I K S ` c c ¨ # o c(

(162) s:uH¡Hc

(163) ýmxu÷

(164) pyk|sHu÷oqnlzoTu } klzontkluAc]o sHw<c oqpys ¥ ` ` ` ` } } 5 ` } # zrp kl

(165) upyn|~Ws s:c c pyktsm¡HcTýÄmxoTntn|u ~O}

(166) s:d` wxoTntz~ prsªk|p¢÷c(pkluSc c]py~Ak|¡Tw<c sTp k|c]p zr` k|zosH

(167) u n|sHzrc ¨ } ¨CoHuAoHTu cH¥ Ømxzyc klu U¨L9 oTzpys'¢÷c ` ` B UT¥ cn|oH?¬¤

(168) sc

(169) k|¡ktpä~.sH w÷c p{m ¢÷c } ým÷ux

(170) prkts:u u 9 ¥ ¦zyklB dwAn|c oS~¤prs xp klzªw sH¢An|c]d klz«prs cewAn|oH

(171) c ¢H~p c _ oT¬:kluA. + I S K. . . . . I K + I KH. . S. |. ^. c + z ` s:mA_n `} d ceuHprkts:u p ` oTp}¨k|uéw oH}

(172) pykl

(173) cH¨ csH¢xproqkluýmAn|nt~ zroTpyklz<ýoH

(174) pys ~ cezrmAn|prz(ymxzyp k|p ` ÷¥ k|z k|n|n§oqnlzys¢<c k|z{m÷zrzrc n|oTpyc ¥ A¥5

(175) i:n|klsHuxzr

(176) c c} p ` oHcOuATcHoT¥ n|]mAn|oTpyk|sHuxzo c'w÷c ¿s dc } klu o 8uAktprc } kldceuxzrkts:uxoqnz{wxoTcT¨ oqn oS~Az ` oHzo 5 ¥ c oHuHp prs ` oS¡TcoTu1kluSc]pyk|¡Tc ¥ _ }o x} ktprkt¡Hc

(177) sHu÷zyp{oTu:pÄz{mx ` p ` oTp !k|zk|uSu ceý

(178) oTprkt¡HpcT¨ ¥ c«oHu oqn oS~Az ` ssHzrc#ds } mAn|sOovz{mAk|proH¢Antc "# % *

(179) -#.% ')#+* %(,-#+* #+*

(180) * ' ,

(181) #

(182) ! . u9)k zrp p` ¨ klz zyc ce}

(183) prc#kt<s:uAubc ¨ p c` c zrkl {doTwxmAnt:~.doHc]wxu:wApyc n|~}

(184) p `0coq oT mxoHHuAdTklc]oTu:u pyc } oT oTuAHk|oHu1pyc] ` uAkmAcvs4 5 Ií ` oHwApyc 5 K$¥ . o B | o o 4 Z | # + I S S S K I H K I L D K k S I 5 OK Z Sk 4 Z S ` c c k|z5ow<sHzrk|pyk|¡Tc(wxo oTdc]pyc ¥ w s:w÷_s:` zycec ub} ¨÷pyosªzrzrk|sTdn|¡TwAcgn|cp òqn|cTsw k|s:p ¢A` n|dvc]!d ¨x]oqn|ntc } ¦ " A¨<¢xoTzrc } sHu c]n|oqxoqpyk|sHu÷zRs p ` c25eo ooqn|Ts k|p ` d k|z z{mx, w 3 k|o'u 4 o - I S S S K^ I 535 K c } cp{oqk|n¢<cn|s p ` cªoqn|Ts k| p ` dv¥ p(kl` zovp `x}x } ccªzrpycew k|pyc oTpyk|¡Tcdcp ` s } ` k| `

(185) s:uxzyp m÷

(186) prz(o zrcmAceux

(187) c4I HS QS QS ?K sHu:¡Tc Hk|ux pys«p cz{o n|c(w÷sHk|u:p]¥ C . ¼¿¾0ÀC¼°Á.

(188)

(189)

(190) ! "#$

(191) &%'"( )* + &,- $."$ 0/1-324 U. 5. o cgTk|¡Tceub¥ i:pycew'¦ 9)klu } I LS K zrm÷ ` p ` oq8p I S S S K I S S S KS I S Kw^ I 5 f'K i:pycew 90klu } vzrmx ` p ` oq8p I S S S K I S S S KS ^ I 5 OK o i:pycew )/gs + I Z K I 5 )K | oHdcpyc ¨ kl ` oHu¤¢<cp{oT¬qceu c mxoTnprs Ïp ` cwxo oHdcpyc sR5p ` c I ` c c | k z o x w o } ¦5mA:dc]u:pyc 0oq oHuATkloTuK?¥ " sª¢xoT?¬prsªzyprc]w'¦¥ } o c zrk|dwAn|~ o } cnloxoqprkts:ud cp` ` s } } ¿s p ` cdkluAkldk 5]oTpyk|sHu wxo p s p ` cz{o }÷} ntc : i r p ] c w Ý ¦ T o u w<sTklu:pw sH¢An|c]dv¥i:pycew klzo o k|c]u:pzyprc][w ¿s p c mxoTnCw sH¢An|c]dv¥ I S S S K. . . *

(192) ' ')

(193) #

(194) ), *

(195) )

(196) . cuAs |k u:pyc w c]p ceoT ` s0p ` cezyczrpycewxzk|uvprc dzsR0s:m ýmxuxpyk|sHuxz oTu } # ¥ Hg

(197) ge b cªuA` sHpykl

(198) c« p ` oqpp ` c _ ` zypzrpycew1k|zod` kluAkldk5]oTpyk|sH` u1sHu ¢<sTp ` ` oTu } ¨p ` oT pklzo} dk|uAkld k65eoqprkts:u s: u uv} pcc c(} ¨x¡6ko kloTc ¢An| c zr¥p ` c]?k|z¬ªklp z` w<c(sHs:z{wAzy> klpy¢Akldn|c(oqp n|ktpäoH~Wux¬sHz>u py} s«ktprp kts:ucýkloTu p¨ p oqc p T cp8oHu'¢÷ccxw cezrzrc kluprc d½sR ¥ I 5 RK $ Z $ ' I

(199) Z O Z K + c(p ` ceu } c } m÷

(200) c(p ` oq8p ) ) > > . +. . >. U . I. . U. Z $ '

(201) Z K $c O O R . I 5 )

(202) K. _` cs:wApykldoqn|ktpä~

(203) s:u } k|pyk|sHuk|Ou(W k| u1 Tk|¡Tceu¢:~p ` c } k!ßc c]u:pykloqprkts:u s ß klu(¥ c5z ` Hs mxn } ` oS¡Tc. ÀÀ,È06ù

(204) Õ

(205) û?û.

(206) ]f. (

(207) -

(208) )1 ) . U. >. . = ( = W IDZ ) NK $ ZY ^ MOJMOv & O?> . +. E. = W & ( I r S^K MRJ Z $ I p S ^ K Z $ )> ) . = ( = W

(209) Z Z & )> . uSce

(210) prk|uAp ` c ¡oqnlmAcOs ¨5uAsTp{oqprk|uA w<c k|s } k| ¢<sHmxu } o ~W

(211) s:u } k|pyk|sHuxz]¨ c Hcp8 > . o. . . > Z. . . U ) I Z . öTu } p ` ]c uéklu:pyc] oqpykluA¤¢:~ wxo rp z |k p `. U + O .

(212) . . ) . . Z $ KL. Z. . r ) I pS ^K +. U . . ?

(213). U ). $. ) I

(214) Z $ K Z. +. . k|p ` p ` c ¿sTn|nts kluA¢÷s:mxu } o ~

(215) sHu } ktprkts:uxzkluprk|dc Ií S^K + Z I> $ IESp^K Z $ & Z . MOJMOv . ( = W = I Z# Kw^ RM JhMRv & > )'. . . . I 5 ) K. ^6I Z.

(216). . E. . . í. I S^KDK. Z ) I Sp^KZ. . KPS. U. >. Z $c. í . $ I Sp^KPS 6 r r > > Z I $ I S ^KZ $ ( Z

(217) I Sp^KyK r r U Z ?

(218) Z I S^KZ U $c Z $ I S ^KP^ 6 . . czyc]c(p ` oTp c ` oS¡Hcgo } k!ßc c]u:pykloqnCs:w÷c oTpys } ceuAsTprc } > ¢:~W o S; I QK + Z U O ^ . . . ífH. I )K. íf. I UVK. . íf:. I OK. ¼¿¾0ÀC¼°Á.

(219)

(220)

(221) ! "#$

(222) &%'"( )* + &,- $."$ 0/1-324. UV. c oTu:ppy szysHnt¡Hc p ` klzzr~zrpycedv ¨:k|p z + s§w kldo ~| kldw÷ s p{oTuxcprs& zrc c * c]p ` c p ` > k|zzr ~Azyprc]d i : l k x u c klzIsRCcn|ntklwAprk|5pä~w<cs uAsHp¥ sHdwxmAprk|ux I LK > 2I LKS ¿s oTu:~( & I Dv K ¨ c5Tcp I LK Z ^ _` ` klz(klz(uAsTp ceuAsHmA `` prs' c]uxz{m ( cc] B ntn|klwA pykl

(223) k|pä)~T¨0'¢x mAp c]o } k|uAvp ` cªoqnlmxn|oTpyk|sHu¢÷oT?¬ o } z¨ czrcc p oqps:uAn|~ª¡Tce

(224) pys z sRp c¿s d I S S^p^^S K IvyK oHux

(225) c]nC¥ > > } } _ ` s S o H ¡ T s k p l k z w : s A ¢ t n e c v d ¨ c d x m y z p < u o } c <uA c + ) ¥ c(p ` c]u'sHdwxmAprc ) oS> ~2 prsI LxK ¨ p <` u k|zg} klmxuAux ¬uAs u ým÷ux

(226) prkts:ub¥ cp ` c c¿s c + Z $ [Î Z K ^ Iíf 5 K ) im÷ddkluAªmxwvp ` c¢÷s:mxu } o ~WsHu } ktprkts:uxzk|u'o> w<c kts } kl } sHdoTk|ub¨ c Tc]p8 & S $h Ií S^KZ )> $ + 4 r $h I S^KZ O $ ( + 4 ^ zrp oq_klu:` prcez]zy¨ cª k|sH` u } ktprc kts:` uxsHzw<c(o pyc«s«oq¢÷n c(oS¡H~Ac z( k"<z{oqc pr} k|z ÷c } ¨zrk|uxc«p ` c]~ `c ¿c pysp ` cW

(227) s:dwxoqprk|¢Ak|n|ktpä~ s p ` cWsHu.

(228) ! ¤)A

(229). l. HgHg 1 #$ 3 ) 2Q3V z # #$2Q3 w~ h )

(230) $

(231) . . h .)[l. . r J S % v S Z . . + I Z >. . . Kw^ Z S. ífTf. I 'K. r S Z + I Z K^ Z ^ Iíf)OK ) _` } k|z u klz ¢÷uAsHsTp `po¢<sHzrmxm u w }} c k|}zrcoTzru klux}

(232) cw<c p ` k|sc } zr k|~Azypr` c]oTd zrc]z] ¨ oT }xzc} uAdsHp klzrsRzg§oWcn|n|¢<k|wAsHprm÷k|u } päo}~A w<~cT¨x

(233) s:¢x} u mx} p k|pyk|sHc uoTprus sHx¢÷zycp ` ¡Hcc5w p ` sHoq¢Apn|c]p dv` c ¥ klp u ` c]c]u pyc} c]d

(234) k kl} uxcoqprprkts s:<u u } c]oT n|z mxk|p uA` k :o(mxcun|mA~ n|n<dk|p c]oHcu oHu¿s o c¡Hktc pr kt ~¡H8c v0ýk|mxu ux py k|rsHu E¥5cesw÷ ceu klc uA` WoSs:¡HuAcn|oT~us:cu'n|n|pyk|wAkldprk|cH¥ cmxc oqprkts:oHuu klu ¿s c¡Hc ~ªpykldcT¥ guxc c ` oS¡Hc5¨.klzsH¢Ap{oqkluAc } zrsTn|¡k|uxp ` Pc ¿sTn|n|s k|uA5n|oHwAn|oH

(235) cc mxoqprkts:u ¿s c¡Hc ~ Y U 3 h . ÀÀ,È06ù

(236) Õ

(237) û?û. J S v .

(238) (

(239) -

(240) )1 ) . Us. . . . o. . +. . ) > . U ) . $. ) I

(241) Z $ K Z. U ) I

(242) _ Z Z $ KL ^6I Z # . . íf ` ` ` 5 g A u c T o ' u H o r z ª ¬ H o ÷ ¢ : s A m p p c w A ~ y z l k T o § n d ] c zroHcz)cgpysp ` ¬Toqcp c]wklIEz RntklK§ux¡¬qoqc n|} k } pr¥ s _` ¨xk|z oTu klz)} n|k|p ux` ¬ToTc p } o py}xs(} pkluAoH` uAc k|ýz{uxoTmx« p `s )p o` p oTýp mxc u÷sHo

(243) uApyn|¢xk|~ sHktp uW} c o py s k|~ ¡éoqýprm÷kt ux¡H` c]

(244) oTz)pruAktss:Hubc]zª¥ o s ycmxsHzr¬:dpk|uxc]k|oHuvuAoTz{klmxuAp I ` ýmA

(245) )o nEK?¥ ¨ oS~cc } ` ` ` ` kluSsHuxce

(246) n|pym k|¡ktc pä~p sk| z(ªzrc]¥ pyk|sHuO¢:~s:¢xzyc ¡kluAªp oqp xAkluAWp k|z(m÷ux¬uAs u ýmxuxpyk|sHu k|zgp c oS~'pys cezyprs c Hg

(247) g b ` cW]oTuxuAsH p } ` !k 8c ceuHprk|oTpycW ` ktp `¤ c]z{w÷ce

(248) p(pys ¥ _` c c« k|z uAsO

(249) } s:mxwA` n|k|uA ¢÷c]p ` c]c]u p ` c } !k 8c ` ceuHp s:w ¢AproToTzrk|c]ux z c }¿s ¢H~p zyklsHznt¡zyklpruAc] -wbÏ¿s zr sB cp¡Hc cv ~ d kluAkldk 5]oTpyk|sHo u¤]oTu¤¢<c'w÷c ds do c w oTzrc¢:~ w | oHzycH¥ klz p c]u kl'u 1 I Kf o Z S Z Iíf RK | 7 QS Z S ` k| ` k|zcmAk|¡SoTntceu:p prs o o kl'u Z ; S Z ; | ^ p(klz kldw<s proHu:pgprsOuAsTprk|cp ` oTp(p ` klzdk|uxk|dk 5]oqprkts:u ]oTu1¢÷cªw<c ¿s dc } w÷sHk|u:p klzyc«klu1zrwxoH

(250) c«oTu } o prk|dcH¥ §cpm÷zzyc]8p . . IvwSDJLK +. . KP^. I O)K. I]vwSDJLKS IvwSyJQK + I]vwSDJQK I]vwSDJQK ^ . k|zs:¢AproTk|uxc } ¢H~zysHnt¡kluAX k|u? X X I

(251) cZ IvwSDJLKDK Z IvwSyJQK X ^

(252) S O^ vw^

(253) _` k|zk|zozykl dwAntcsHuAc ` } kld} ceuxzrkts:uxoqnßw sqc]pyk|sHuªw s:¢Antced ` k| ` oTuW¢÷c

(254) s:dw÷mApyc } oTu÷oqn|~:prk|]oqn|nt~s m÷zykluA«o 5c prsHu'dcp s ¥ Hg

(255) g

(256) b ipyc]w k|zzrkldwxnt~p ` cw<sTklu:p k|zrc(mxw } oqpyc o _` ceu. . I vwSDJLK +

(257) I vwSyJQKS I vwSyJQK. I vwSDJLK + I vwSyJQKH I . . . I]vwSDJLK . Z ]I vwSDJQKyK#^. ¼¿¾0ÀC¼°Á.

(258)

(259)

(260) ! "#$

(261) &%'"( )* + &,- $."$ 0/1-324 .

(262) #+*. .

(263) ( *( ')% *

(264)

(265) ' ,

(266) ' ,. U. . . ¦ do sH c uA:szy ps p ` } c]c zr cp `xI c]c K zr pyc]` w÷c z c¨8sHuAn|~Ok|zgi:p py` cecwOu¦ mxdklz¢÷Hc nt s:¢xsoqnEw<¥ sT_klu:` prk|zgzsdc]p oT` u÷c«zzrp w÷` oToq

(267) p5cEp pr` k|dccsHn|zroTppyprsk|cTi:¥ prc]_w ` Zoc T u zy} p 0oTwAnloTcªcmxoTpyk|sHu IEzyprc]w.¦K$¨ } mAcpys p ` c'w÷c k|s } kl

(268) k|pä~1klu¤z{wxoTI OcT¨ oHhu¤I _¢<KDcvKzrs:sTw÷n|¡Tc c }oTpyk|k|sHu uxz]¥ I __`K$¥ c«

(269) _s:` zycp ¿sHntn|s kluA oTwxn|oH

(270) ccmxoqprkts:uxz4Iízrpycew ¦ Kg]oTu ¢÷cªzrsTn|¡Tc } klu sRumxdp ` ¢÷klzc ds c])p kt` prcs } oqzprktk|s:z u p ` c py sªc¿s

(271) s: cªu:¡Tsc Ts cg } oTc u } 3 3 p ` c(uv mx d ¢<c O s p ` cw ` ` oHc zy cec z¥ v vk|zp ` cvuAc]c]z{zro ~ } ` ` ` } ` ` } _ ¢<sHc«doTwx¢AmAcn|cp{oqpyprsOskts:uxw u sT sp } cgmxoSuA

(272) ¡Hc]cc«c u} p mxpydc]s s c } cc#k|pr]<k|oquA]n)oqc(c]nIozrcepyzykldprsHk|u:doq¡Tpyoqccepr z c]Hz oTc]uuxsH}u c5oqp nl zyk|cWs pyc zr¿ sw<kl mxccdvp ` ¥ cs _w `

(273) cgoHs:

(274) u:s:py¡TwAklcpyoTkldTn cewxoquxn|m kt

(275) pä c~ªw÷s:Rs zysHcup }s cktprzrktds:pys:uxcwxzp wAIEskl uAR'¥Kpo ` scc } } ` } ` ` ` cem÷oTzyc `ýmALnw `¿s oHzy4c p oqpw÷m w<sHzrcT¥ coHuvk|u cc mxzrc p X c cezykX mxoTn8Rs 0p c y¡Hs pycWz c]cpc :m÷oqpyk|sHu÷ z

(276) c¿s + ) U S ` kl ` klzo ¢:~:äw s } _m÷`

(277) pIRs Cp ` c5oTntHs } ktp ` dv¥ _` k|z mxoT u:pyk| pä~

(278) sHu:¡Hc } Tc]z0prsoHz c5oTwxw s:oT ` p ` c zrsTnlmAprkts:uWRs 0w sH¢An|c]dv¥ c(uAs doTntk 5c sH>u:¡Tc Hc]uxc k|pyc klmxd½mxzrc klz W X X ( $ $ $ U & W v + 3 Iíf

(279) )K X X ^ $ & ( $ $ O O ]5')

(280) ' ª-5

(281) ))$0 . . . . . . .

(282) .

(283) . . . . . . . . . !. . ' ,

(284) # ')"+

(285) # %$

(286) #., * '& ,

(287) ))(. #

(288) -#*$. cw cezyceuHp5k|up ` klzzr c]pyk|sHuOumxdc kloqn ` cezr}mx ntp{z} sH¢xproq kluAc } mxzrk|uAo«} oqpr` n|oH¢O

(289) s } cH¥ _` c oqn|Ts } k|p ` ` d zrsTnlzrmAp(prktzys:c]uc]d8z(uxoqpysn|nt~1sH¢Au:n|s¡Tc zHcTmx¨Cwb¢x¥OmApguAo¿cªpyc oHu1o c

(290) xm÷wAu nloqkluc p ` ktprklcz oq¢:pr~kts:p ux` zc ¨ýooT¢xpo p ` ¢÷oqpc oScW¡kts:mxmzrc } oTw÷wxw÷o cep(o sz¨§p oH` u c p } cc s:w÷oqc py nloToTpy¢ s _ z s sT} nlk|¢÷¡ sS

(291) TboHü } oHu r} p o ` } c

(292) cò ¿ s c] u cO pdzyo prkt} n|n§c1o d} oTsTu:klu:~p¨÷klu:oHpyu c } w<¢÷sTo nloq} prktw s:` uxc]zux¥ sHd u!c]uxp o«` kl]zoTu]oTsAzrcT¨m p ` ¥ c } k!ßc c]u:pykloqn gehge e a ] c(}

(293) s:dw÷mA} pycgp ` c(zrsTnlmA pyk|sHu÷zklup ` c(¢<sS_ U`bRs w sH¢An|c]d Ix¨ ¨

(294) x¨ )K ktp ` p sw ` oTzrc]z Ap ` cgkluAk|pykloqn oHu <uxoqn c]uxzrk|pyk|c]zo 4c & ^6^6U U ^ $$ ( IIJQJQK K + + ^ ^f f IyIDUPU# Z I I JLJLKDKDKK¤ ¤ $ I]vwSDJQK + U k|py9)c k|klHmxm d, c klUzgz zr`pyk|s n|n0 ¡Hz0c p ` ~'cntp s s ¨ } ce` uxk|zyntk|c pyk|÷c]z):m s: ¢AcproTªk|uxz c ` } s o ¿zpyc p 0` `cmx

(295) u s:} u: ¡Tc c } Tk|pycec ux

(296) oTc pyk|`sHk|uxzrz]py¨s ~H` ¥ ceup c` czyc]csHu:p ` ¡Toqc p Ho c]¿uxprc c +. +. ÀÀ,È06ù

(297) Õ

(298) û?û. +,. ,.

(299) U. (

(300) -

(301) )1 ) .

(302) rho1. rho2. 1. 1. 0.8. 0.8. 0.6. 0.6. 0.4. 0.4. 0.2. 0.2. 0 1. 0 1 1. 1. 0.5. 0. 0.5. 0. 0. 0. −0.5. −1. )k|Hm c ?./ceuxzrktprktcezo¿prc eU Tktprc oqpyk|sHu÷z −1. −1. −0.5 −1. 9 6. 5. 4. 3. 2. 1. )k|Hm c8 sHu:¡Hc Tc]u÷

(303) c ` k|zrpys ~ pýoH`

(304) c p p ` zyoqpgpp p ` ` s:c mx}z{oTc]uux}zrk|zgpyk|k|c]pyzc o oT pyc(k|sH¢<uxcz]T¨bkluxp ` uAc«kluA k|pypys«c s:klmxzrdktn|nloq¢<pyccHT¥ kluxzgpys'ceuAn|o Hc } To doTpykloqn|n|~T¨ßc

(305) xw c]z{zykluAvp ` c 0 0. 500. 1000. 1500. 2000. 2500. 9. ¼¿¾0ÀC¼°Á.

(306)

(307)

(308) ! "#$

(309) &%'"( )* + &,- $."$ 0/1-324. . * #

(310) ' * # )

(311) , ( & #.

(312) ' (' .

(313) ) .

(314). U. .

(315) #

(316) ),(*. 5 ` } } } } oHu c]¡uA oc UkloT¨÷oqntp prk5kts:ccux} uxsH÷soquxn;¿c]zs wA

(317) pd s:Rs uxmA zrnloqTk|zrprc]prktuxzs:c u kluoq¢<n|d6k c5]p mAc ntprck|ce÷sw u ` oTp zr#z k| ¿s¤s ÷sw kl uxcez]zr

(318) ¥s: di:klwAklw uxpyc

(319) ce}c zrzrp zyk|` ¢xp{coqntcpy8mcew<Azc¥Ñk } ¿¦c]klzuép k|ux<mk|dAsHk w<ds zw k|prz5c]oHz{uHk|zyu:pªklp¢An|scTn|oH¨zrpmxzª` ccs(z{mxpmxdÝ` zrs:k|uAzysRc p ` sHc d } c]s:uxm zr ktprw ktce sHz5¢Aklun|c]dvp ` ¥ c u} }k"ßcc]c } c]Äu:klpuªw p ` ` oTc zrsHc]zuAcz ` } s:klmAdn }c]ux¢÷zrk|csHux

(320) s:uxuxoTnbzyp{oToTu:zrpcT¥ ¨p ` ccs zyc] }c c p ` sc]§up p ` ` c oq<mp A k }c w÷c o uApysHklpmAzrn|sc]z ýoklu ces:oT¢A pròTk|wu` p oT` zrcck|TzcewuAc ce zyoqc n|k 5¡Hc c } } ¨q÷szrs p ` doTk|p)uxprk|oTd¬:k kl5uAkluA(_ o I<)uxK?oq¥ n< zyp{c«oqpy]coTo uO} oTp ` wAc]pru1c } mxpyzrs(cp p ` ` cc<n|uxoToT n oT} uAc]Huxk|zroHk|päu ~} c

(321) k|xz{w< c]c

(322) prprk|c z{}oqpr¨ kt s:u c dc]p ` ss}cezrk|u:` p zs oT} ntmxHs c }ktp ` k|ud UfsHuxzrpyps« mx

(323) s:

(324) p{dzw÷oªmApyzrcc zrmAsTc]nlmAnCpys k|IsHu÷w<zc sd 0mAw p{ oqs:py¢Ak|ntsHceudAsHIk|xux¨ k|uA¨ x¨ )oTK$uv¥|¥|¥k|uxktprk|oTn0zrproTpyc Iýp{oT¬Tc]u'pys ¢ce<oTc `p ` wxco k } pyc]kl

(325) u:n|pyc k|päz ~ pK prosvceo

(326) py<s ux~HoT¥n i:zys«p{oqoqpycn|n c]cw ` c]oSzr¡Hc]u:cpyprc s } } ¢:s«~k|zoprw<s c } d c8mAuAp{c(oqprp kts:` ubc ¥ nloT zrp p zgw÷p c ` cedu mAprw<oTsHpyz{k|zysHklub¢A¥n|cpr[s ¿sHntn|s } c]ux_zrkts prktce} zso p ` c_oqp]òTO¨ z¿s

(327) n|` sHc]zroTc ` oHzwxow< sH pyz{klzr

(328) k|n|¢Ac5n|` cvkluªpyp s1` c p ` c' zrw p zrc]pr oT pykl` ¢÷cH¨c } cgsHuA ` cesz¥ sHzrc5 k|c prz} } w s` oHcAzyc oH

(329) zy}prsnt~ p ` p oT` pcvp ` `z{oTc d [c} ` kl¿zrs c]ppy `c

(330) c 8 ` uxs:oqs:n0zyzyc5p{oqp py` cHc ¥ <uxoqcenbu w<c oSd ¡mAk|uxp{oqpr¿ktss:uc]pyoTs cezrw÷w<o c]pypkl

(331) p n|`csHktzrp{c5zww sHoTw<zrcc upyk|mxc]dz]¥)¢<¦c zrz{oTmxu dkluAktp{ zp s ` ccsHdkluwxoqp prk|kl¢xzgktn|w ktpä~oTzrsRcT§¨ p ` cc } ` oqpro÷¨p ` klz z ` sHmA n } u p w< sHzrcªoOw sH ¢An|c] dv¥ cWp ` ceu¤mx zrc ` sc] z{ ` z oq n|Ts ` k|p ` ` d oTz(k|prz s }u prs ` ` oS`¡Hc pdoTcpyw÷nloTo ¢ py

(332) kl

(333) s n|} c cHzI¨ p oc ce`

(334) oSpr¡Hs c«~Tpy¥)sOi

(335) k|uxs:dc wxmAcpycWp oT` u:c pI}pysc]ux

(336) zrsHktdprktcewxzo ¥ c5_p ` c c } cek|z{zrmA n|cprprz k65eoqktprp kts:up HsHktzr¡Hcc]zsH¢Ao p{oq} klceuAuxc zrktpä~ k|p ` p kl ` c c]oH¬:nt~¤sH u:¡Tc Hc]zpys p ` ` cOw cezrk|¢<c } {sH ux cT¥ u ` s } c py} s c] ¡oqnl mxoqprc ` s:ce` zr ` z«oTntHs ktp ` d sHu p ` k|z w s:¢Antcedv¨ c(

(337) s:dwxmApyc(p c cnloqpyk|¡Tcgc s sHup c¢<sHm÷u o ~T¥ c(p ceu oS¡Tc ¿sTn|n|s k|uA c]z{mAntp{z W X X $ & ( W$ $ 2 2 2 + v X X + UO^ qf U U] S $ &( $ $ 2 2 W $ I$ IíW SDJLK Z_$ & I]JQKyK MRJ + + v UR^É 5 _Ue 8 S $ I$ & I]JQKDK MRJ W $ & ( $ I]$ 2 W IvwSyJQK Z $ IvwSyJQKDK MRJhMRv + ^ 5 U] ß ^ + $ & ( $ I]$ 2 IvwSyJQKDK MRJhMRv . . . . . . . . . . . ` ` ` } } } ` ` ` Tpo ` n|doqps:zyp cWp` c(oHoHz(c u {

(338) n|sp sH zrklc«

(339) uxs:¬ pydsp w÷p mA` oTpycpc }p k|

(340) c ` sHpdc]zrceu÷sTzzynlmAk|dpypyk|k|oTc]sHk|zuxu ntw ~[oHzs p s:m÷` d½

(341) c]c~1sHom ¢: c~ oqsHn|Tu1ss c]p k|`z{p cW` dv¢<z sH¥ oqmx n|pu T} s c]o dk| p ~Toq¥ dklux_z o` ` mxcs z c] c¡T¡Hcªc c ]~ oTu1mAktcc]przrccpyklzrdkldu oqoTpy ntc n }' } } }x} ` ` s:proHsªum ¢÷zrcsT

(342) nlcmAsHpyo u:k|¡HsHc c]ubuAuA¨ k|sH c]p u:` pkl klkl`zru'oHklwxp z ` w<ceklsTdz5kluH]w proT` c zroTcTzr¥ k6¢:5] ~vc u } } ktp]c¢:¥ c ~ } puO¨8` o«oc5nts:k|zypyuAck|sH s ub ntdvs¨ s:¥ ¬Wcmoq¬xp5uApIps sH` m c oT¡¢<oTsHsHn|u:mAmA¡Tcepcz p sH c]cuxp sH`z{cc

(343) k|nlntoq nlk|oqpypr c soT kluxmx~Td kl¢<oTcuWzrczrceoSsTd¡nlk|mAzIs pruAkts:sTsRu p zw÷` o s pyklzmAp nlòqproTc pzrsHsTu¤nlmAppr`kts:cub¥¢÷s:mxu } o ~HÏk|p } "k ßc z s:d p ` c'p ` cs cprk|¡oqnlmAc]zklu.p ` czroHdc oS~ oTzp ` c ÀÀ,È06ù

(344) Õ

(345) û?û.

(346) T. (

(347) -

(348) )1 ) −0.5. −1. −1.5. log10(crit(n)). −2. −2.5. −3. −3.5. −4. −4.5 0. 200. 400. 600. 800. 1000 n. 1200. 1400. 1600. 1800. 2000.

(349) !" # %$&(') *+,( .-)*+-/ )0213,( .)2' 45!6 +,( . ''7 8*+ #219 8 &/2: ';)2 7"< =(*( >%? 6219 )2"; @A B!C)26)&& 8@!C( < 6& -'7 84D@)0;*( *FE GH +%)I,( J AK&/ *L1M, )ONQP:R(*( A!67,TS%PU) :V %EAGH +)0 LW,)0X )2K; ,(;K(*( >Y ( AQ)2';( BI,( Z-*)X) 8F? B!" )['\1M, 8*X (O)]';)2 )( L4

(350) (';&('7 8%> -(C) .4A&/ *FE ^ _`^ 6 aHbCcedgfQh#i jkc9l#mionpllCqsrutKc3vion6hiwxwgqsmc yo<,*( 8p L .zC ,{F? ")'7 7,4e)" @Q!CF>!" B)0

(351) |}*<-/*) +*) )L {< )2@ ( &/ *Z ';(H)*O,( + ';(H;O,( +-/0$H;*( EZ~B;(X 4L Z)4L >3!" A % ,)26%? @ =%) B1M@,( .1M''7Q!6;(A;(7 )'Y)*+|/)2'Y*( 8 7 7 8. Qgpp %( p 9 {V g S. % /` gp 6( < u I1MK,( +*)2,)K7 H;O < >9!C('7 + +\ Q!CK ( ,(' 1F-/,A%)2';%')@ 914,( #&) (') 64L %,((*AL ( 6' 1M>1 4p4u ((*A)Q1M )A* 8*] 8 )@],( =E 6( < A( O (Q!C.,)2

(352) ( ] 8;4'Q!6'7I Q!CB& )Q1M 8=)W* *Ho: 8 )ELGO +)O $&(';)2;I,)2=-X,( A1)%B,)2K!" A[I¡ )*O-/*) I*) )!C(;{ e¢. £M¤¦¥3£§.

(353) U.

(354)

(355) ! "#$

(356) &%'"( )* + &,- $."$ 0/1-324 Particulate method. Lagrangian method. 1.2. 1.2. 1. 1. 0.8. 0.8. 0.6. 0.6. 0.4. 0.4. 0.2. 0.2. 0 1. 0 1 1. 1. 0.5. 0. 0.5. 0. 0. 0. −0.5. −0.5. )k|Hm c

(357) ./ceuxzrktprktcezo¿prc UeTktprc oqpyk|sHu÷z ¡prk|oH]uAmAk|nlz oq` pycecvz¥.dci:p s ` s } cvTk|oH¡Tuc]z p oT` u¤oS¡Hm÷cWuxzrp d` cvssTp sH` u:¡Týmxc uxHc]pyuxk|sHubcªÏw ¢< c]s:]w÷oTc mx päzr~cWpc` AcWwxn|kloTu'k|¿uAs c } dkloqu.prkts:zrc]u pyTk|k|sH¡Tu.ceu x¥

(358) ÷s:¥ ux

(359) _c ` uxcvz wxp o ` c n| sAc oTppy`k|sHceuvuvsnts:)zyp c(` cw wxc]o k|zrpyktkls:uªmAn|c]kluWz5poT` u c }' c]

(360) c s:ùxoSzrp¡T c(mxpr

(361) s«prkts:TuWsªw¢x oHsA?

(362) ¬ªc]z{prz]s«¥0p ¦` czk|} uvc]uxp `zrktc prktwcez c] ¡:k|k|sHp `m÷zo«zrmxsH¢÷mxzyceu:

(363) pypykluAk|sHªuCd¨ cpc ` s oH} u ¥ sHdwxo cgp ` c c]z{mAn|prz −1. −1. −1. −1. 9. . . . . v , + v . . W. $ & ( W$ $ &( $ $ . . +. $. W. í. $ , X. ,. X. X. , ,. I]$ I W DS JQK Z_$ $ I$ & I JLKDK W $ & ( $ I$ , I]W vwSDJLK $ & ( $ I$ , . . X + ? ^ . . e S. 5 _U. . & ]I JQKDK MRJ + ^ MOJ. . . ] ß S U . Z $ I]vwSDJLKDK MOJMOv + _ ?^ U I]vwSDJLKDK MOJMOv. U] 8 ^ ` ` } } } ` ` } `} pz{`dcoqn|w÷unío¥ p py_klkl`zmAc ]nloqoT} przrk!cc8c d cecuxpc `

(364) ccªs } p¢<¨ cc p ` ¢÷ck|s:n|cec mxu u p `¢÷ocsHp

(365) ~` s:u:d¡ToTccprpoW `Tosceux} c

(366) zc(klz(k| z{

(367) p k|s:`pyc u:c] upyklklmxu:s d mxsHp ¿mx`s z] cW¨<pp zr` oHccd~nlcoqo s c oH} uA¢÷c To kloToTn|uvz~dp oT` wxccWwp ` w÷sHs o oH} pyk|klz5c mA¡Tnlcoq¢: pr~~ c k|pyc klmxdv¥ _` mxz c ]oTuvzrm÷wxw÷s:zyc p ` oqps:m dcp ` s } Hkt¡Hc]zTss } c]z{mAn|prz]¥ . ÀÀ,È06ù

(368) Õ

(369) û?û. . . +. . .

(370) H. (

(371) -

(372) )1 ) . O ]5')

(373) ' ª-5

(374) ))$0. gkl z m 8 uAdktprc]cTp ¥ ` s } uézyp c]` c]c_dz oTpys«d¢<c cs oT ¢A¬ n|cgspy sª8m

(375) As:k d} wxdmApycec ` HoTc]uxuAk|c ] zoT¨8ntkU5c } } kld÷s c]uxzrzPk|sH¿sux uxoT n5` prk|c]`zrprzvp ` o c ucmxuAdsT¢÷pWc s s)w w k|`doTo zr c]~ z k¿ldsHntn|w÷s s klp{uAoTªuxp cT` ¨:coTuoTw÷}w s:coTo ` csRds VcU¨Qklu:$ pyc ceoHzyuOprc ¢<} ck|uzrcp c]` uc5oTzrprzgm o } ~ } klszy§p{oTux }ckldsHc]uOuxzrp k|` sHcuxux¡ToTc nA prc

(376) k|A]oqc]dnoqwAAn|c]k|z]z]¥ ¥)_O` s ce ubcs¨ß¡HsHc m ¨ `c} k| k|d` pc]u÷

(377) sHzyk|u÷sHzyuxp u÷ oToqk|nbuAdc } s } klu:c¡nCk|z{oH

(378) uk } ¢<<sc k|u:zpr¥c w c]pyc } oHz ozrp oqprk"÷c } 5 } k|dc]u÷zyk|sHuxu÷oqnßc¡HsTnlmApyk|sHuds } c]nQ¿s . . ,-'

(379)

(380) #

(381) . cw ec zyce uHp klu«p ` k|5 zzyce

(382) pr5 kts:u«u:53m÷5 dc kloTn÷prc]zrprz]¥ _` c5uAs } doqn|k65]c } } z{wxoTc

(383) Upykld c } sHd oqkluklz }} klzr c]} pyk5c } m÷ ` zykls:uAs: zyceo upy]cs HoTmAwxnlo w sHoH ` p ` !cgsH uxc]zm÷nlzyoqc pr} pykl

(384) kluTcT¥ fREuA¥ k| pyp kloqk|nzpoT` u c]uW<w<uxsHoTz{nzrk|¢An|c]c5u÷przysk|pyk|zrc]cz«co p ` c c c]mxw oqn|c]ktp{zroqc]pru:ktpy¡Hc c }¨k!oH8cu ceuxo

(385) cc ` ` } ` ` _` s:¢<uAck|ppn|~` cwo'ce uOc]

(386) zrs:p c]uxu:zrcpproTd¢Au:kls:p w uA` TsHoHn|wsHzy¢÷kl oqoTnzr÷sk|}c]oTu÷z u zyk| pä~k|p p ` Iyc«U c d +:m÷mAoqn|$ pyn kl+w c$oHk|zykl` ps:$

(387) wAspyK$ckl¥d©«_oqktn `cedu:c proT}z8z{c]z5¿uxs pzr k|pyoH¢<k|uxc]sTz(z{p w÷` klsuw pgp ` ` oTw c zrc]s: z ¢A n|zyI c]pd w z` +¥ oTzrc« co K$ ¨)c coTuoTnt} c n ¢÷oTzrc_} ` csHu w÷o " oToTmxdz{czyprkloTc u÷ zz sR} c]pux` zrck|pyk|dc]zcps ` s } } c`¿o s c dproqoHpr¬qktces:uuWoHsRz H oHmx+ z{zyxkloT¨ ux z]¥ + ^ T UoTu } + U Iíf

(388) 'K§oTnts:uAgp ` ck|pyc oTpyk|sHuxz0sßdcp ` s } ` ` ` : s H u H ¡ c T e c x u

(389) c | k r z y p s ~ z s 0 z p c

(390) H s : u H ¡ c T ] c ÷ u

(391) c | k y p c l k x m d " ` ` r ` ` ` } k|¦ pyc 9)oTpyklxk|uxsH¥ oquxn|z]nt~H¥ ¨sHu:¡Tcc THk|¡Tc]c ux¿s c } k|!k zr8cpys ce~ u:pc]¡Tprc]k|duGcz zrpys cewxzzp z{` dcgoqntn|c]n¡Tcc]n<oqm pr k|¡H c]¢÷zIc Rs HoS$<¡¥ kts _` oc ¿py<c uxoTn<p ¡coqnlmA czrs pWHp$oqsHpmxz{proTk|du c zrpycew 535 oqn oS~Azdoqpr ` $'(I¥

(392) gehge e a ] u¤s } c prsoS¡TsHk } p ` cw<c k|s } k|«#c 8ce

(393) p{z¨ p ` k|zpycezypw c]zrc]u:przoOzrdoTntnp oTuxzrn|oTpyk|sHu Rs oHoHmxzrzrkloTu } c]ux zrktpä~H¥ u zrmx ` ` o.oHzycH¨p ` c c]¡TsTnlmAprkts:u s p ` c } ` ceux zrktpä~é` kluép `` c1dsHuxsHw ` ` oHzyklO]oTzrcklz}zrk|dwAn|~ po oHp uxoTzru÷n|oTzypynlcoqpr kts:ktup ` o«ktp sHuxo1zrpr

(394) oHs:u:uxp zr¡HproTcu:n|sAp

(395) k|¡Tpäc]~ªntsAoT

(396) u k|pä} ~T¥p ` oqpcp ` zyc(c]c HoTm÷c zrzrck|oHp uªoqklzpzyp n|k| c` prpysHn|~ w} s6k ¿5s p dc'c } HoT¥ m÷zrzrk|oHu s uAsTp

(397) gehg a ]( c w<c ¿s d ` p ` cp oHux zynloqprkts:u'oTu } sTp{oqpyk|sHuvRs oHu'cn|ntklwA prk|]oqn|nt~ ` } `c ¿s d} c } HoTm÷zrzr} k|oHub ¥ 5c c c oHu cezrcoTc zrktpn|~ª` oqzrpccgp ` p c(c(¡Tc]p ntsAoH

(398) uxk|<zpä¿~ªc klzs uAsTop8z{IEddoToqntklnbuAoHnt~dK s:mxsHu:uxpzrsproH0uHdp]¥ oHzrzoT s:zrzp c w<c k|s k| ¢<sHmxu o ktcez¥ ¦:oqklub¨ c

(399) gehg

(400) a ] _` k|zpycezyp} w c]zrc]u:przp ` cgn|o ` Hc]zrpw<sHz{zykl` ¢An|c5p oTu÷zynloqprkt` s:u Ií¢<c]oHmxzrc5s p ` cgw÷c k|s } k| g¢<sH mxu } o ktcez K ¿s o :prs oTmxp z{` zrck|oHudsHuAc]uxs:zrw kt` pä~HoT¥ zrkl¦5Wz oHk|uªzyc p c ` dc sHcvuAs:p ` w c]~ oTzr klc c'oHzyzrcHk|¨Hdp wAcn|~¤:mxoTmxuAz{k6¿zrs k|oH duntz{~¤wAn|pktp{ z oHuxk|u:zDpy¿ccs c¿sH} m s:u¤wxo p ` prcvz]¥ c } uªT

(401) cvs:su:gp p oT` zrc p prs mxz]¨Hp ` cgw<sTklu:przs §¢Ak|THc]zrp } ceuxzrktprktcez ` c cgzyc]c]d pysproH¬qcozyn|s c zrpro p]¨Hp ` c]uWpysz{w<cc } mxwbÄoTu } ¼¿¾0ÀC¼°Á.

(402) 5.

(403)