La Recherche floue

Texte intégral

(1)La Recherche floue Gabriel Gallezot, Michel Roland, Jacques Araszkiewiez. To cite this version: Gabriel Gallezot, Michel Roland, Jacques Araszkiewiez. La Recherche floue. Document numérique et Société, Paris, CNAM, 17-18 novembre 2008, Nov 2008, France. pp.411-429. �sic_00340835�. HAL Id: sic_00340835 https://archivesic.ccsd.cnrs.fr/sic_00340835 Submitted on 22 Nov 2008. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés..

(2)

(3) !#"%$'&&)(*$+,- .0/21354568796;:#4=<>6;4?@/A14 35BC#6<>DEF8CG796;:#4513 /A6<IHKJ86/L<>C#:9F;M#1:N#6;796;:#4D6#?O1/A1D3PNG796RQ SUT V V WYXR T Z[; T \ T X-; ] ^XR _^Va` T ;bcd e5fbhg'i S!j bk&)l(&;mU n no

(4) YXn!p,h,hm `h #' Vq T er

(5) -s t@o

(6) ;=u vI ^ R2dwVx5 ;= UgOx [[e ya;z h hk{ s S # g T

(7) }|h` T rY T G T x _^V5s hZ[ X-

(8) $G~ );efb A`vOi lhm(*p(m$+h~Y(&&)(m. La Recherche floue • • •. w S y'y't@aUbhwU ; b- qo^LzVOi T ` x S eq =fbnU>#A`@b+ j b Y T "PZ V!y S i\b j T x; b- qo^LPVOi T `

(9) x S [ h b>#A`b ; G T "PZ S S `

(10) U*t[t@abA T _^nfbn qo^LzVOiR T `

(11) x S [q h b*i- T Vg!G S b \- )*X-; ]e Z[ eXR [ (g XX^ T

(12) nb

(13) f+ j b e e; q xG" T "PZ. # ¡£¢8¤> ¥L¦§¡h§¨;©A¢;ªe« §¡G¡5¢8¬q§¡

(14) ®)¬5¯«q°q©A¢8§L¡°z¨± ²A¬ ¤¯«q°³²A¨¨;§Pq§¡h§¨@¤>°qP°q§e¢O¢)¨)°%´;§¬[¡µ°P«q¯°z¬§G« §e¨8¶§Ä«·#¬§f®8²)¡§¬^¡5¢)¬q§K¤>²A¶)¸³§K¶)§KP¯K± ¬¯L¹*«³¢)¬§ ¨¢)¤> e¬°q©A¢;§#º) ¨8 e¬¯e« °q²L¨)¨;§qq§»A²L¼>q§#¤>°z³°q§e¢@¢)¨;° ´;§¬[¡°%« ¯°z¬§]§L¡5«°q¤O®)¯¹f«r K¶)§K³½ §¾A« ¬5°q§e¢)¬®)¯¬q§¡

(15) ¢¡¯º§¡h¶)§¡h¿)À ÁÀqÂqÃAÄÅ8Ã)ÂzÀzÆÇÈ*É8§e«·' [´;¯L%¢;§¬ q§¡

(16) ®)¬¯e« °q©A¢;§¡h¶)§¡h e«q¢)¶°³¯Ä« ¡G¡§q²AÖq§e¢)¬ ¹¯¬5«¯e´;§¹K¹§]©¢8§Kq§¡h¤a ¶)°q¯« §e¢)¬[¡h§¡£« °P¤>§e¨«³§L¡#Ê Ë;²A¨¨8§L¡®)¬¯f«r°q©L¢;§¡eÊeÌLÍdÖ¤>²A¶§]¶;½ [´;¯Lz¢)¯«q°³²A¨ ¨;²LÖ¨8²L¬¤O¯«q°z±n¤>¯°r¡Ë;¯A¡ '¡5¢)¬ ½ §e±=± °q¹°q§¨;¹§]¶§¡G¡5« ¬5¯« º°³§L¡¶§#¬§¹eÎ)§¬¹Î;§G®8§¬5¤>§e«q«q¬ ¯L°%«¶§G¬§¨;¶A¬§#¤O°³§f¢8¾O¹²A¤O®«r§K¶)§Ï³§f¢)¬¶A°%´;§¬[¡°z« G´)²A°q¬§ ¶§]q§e¢;¬°zÄ´;§¨«r°%´;°z« AÌÍ'¨;§G« §qq§] [´;¯Lz¢8¯e« °q²LÏ¡5¢®A®8²)¡§Ï¢8¨;§#¨;²L¢A´;§q³§K¹²A¤O®;¬ Î;§eŸ¡µ°q²¨>¶§]¹§¡G¡5«³¬5¯«r º)°q§¡eÌLÐ«³¬¯e´;§¬[¡«q¬²A° ¡¯¾)§¡h¶)§ ©¢8§¡£« °³²A¨¨;§¤>§e¨«Ñ=¹²A¨¨8¯°r¡*¡¯¨;¹§K¶)§L¡¬§¡*¡²L¢8¬¹§¡[»¯®)®)¬²L®)¬°P¯«³°q²A¨@¹¬°z«³°q©A¢;§#¶)§¡h°z¨)« §e¬5± ¯L¹§¡*»A¬ ¯A¡[¡µ²A¤O®)« °q²¨¶)§#q¯'¡5¢2ËeÒ*§¹f«r°%´;°z« ]¶§¡ ®;¬ ¯«³°q©¢8§¡µÓ¨;²L¢Y¡h§¡µ©A¢;°r¡*¡²A¨¡

(17) ¢)¨¨;²L¢2´;§¯¢O®8¯¬ ¯L¶A°qº)¤>§#¶;½ ¢)¨;§Ê5¬§¹eÎ;§¬¹Î8§0± q²L¢8§AÊ©¢8°¯A¡[¡µ²A¹°q§]q¯K¤O¯Ôz«³¬° ¡§K¶)§¡h²L¢«r°z ¡^¡µ§q²AÖ³§K¹e¬°%« ¸¬5§]¶§ q¯#¬§³§*´;¯¨;¹§K·]z¯¡ e¬§¨;¶A°z®8°Õ«r K§e¨@«r¯Ä«©A¢½ §Pq§'¡5¢®)®8²)¡µ§] ½ ¯f®)« °%«q¢8¶§#·K¯¹¹f¢8§°qqP°z¬r½ °z¨8¯f«³« §e¨;¶A¢Ì Ð#Ë¡£« ¬¯¹e«[¥ ÖÎ;§#¤O¯Ä×>¡5¢;¬ ´;§×¡h¯eË;²L¢)«°z¨)±5²A¬¤>¯e« °q²A¨¢¡¯º§¡h°PÖ¯L¹¯¶)§¤>°q¹]§Ä´;°z¬²¨;¤>§e¨«;«r§e¨;¶'« ²'¬§¡£«²L¨«qÎ;§#¤>²A¶)§²L±« Î;§Kº)§e¨;§¬ ¯«³°q²A¨¯ ¶°qº)°%« ¯¶A° ´;°q¶§»A¯L¹¹²A¬¶°P¨;º'« ²'Ø'Î;°q¹Î@«qÎ8§Ï¯¹¯L¶)§¤>°q¹#Ø'²A¬q¶° ¡°z¤O®)¯¹f«r§¶±5¬²A¤Ù²L¢«=¡µ°q¶)§Ë×@«rÎ;§@Ê¶A°³º°%« ¯;¨)¯«³°%´;§¡fÊ¢Y¡µ¯º§¡eÌAÐ¡

(18) ¯ ¹²AŸ¡µ§©A¢;§¨;¹§»«³Î;§[×@« §¨;¶@« ²§[´;¯Lz¢)¯« §'¡5«q¢)¶)§Ä« ¡°z¨)±5²A¬¤>¯e« °q²A¨®)¬5¯L¹e« °³¹§¡h¯¹¹²A¬¶)°P¨;ºk«r²k«³Î;§#¶°r¡£«³¯¨;¹§Ï± ¬²A¤Ú«qÎ;§Êº)²A²A¶@®;¬ ¯L¹e« °q¹§¡eÊh¯2¡ ¹²A¨8¹§°P´;§¶'Ë)×@« Î;§K¤>§¶)°z¯« ²A¬[¡*ÌAÐ¨8²A¨Ûq¨;²L¬¤O¯«q° ´;§K§[´;¯Lz¢8¯«r°q²LÖ¤>²A¶)§»LË;¯A¡§¶O²AÖ§e±5± °q¹°q§¨;¹×;»¹²L¢8q¶Oº)°%´;§K¯#Ë;§e«q« §¬´;°q§eØÜ²AÖ«³Î;§K¶A°%´;§¬£¡µ°z«Õ× ¯¨8¶@°PÄ´;§¨«³°%´;°z«P×O²A±« Î8§'¡5«q¬ ¯« §º)°q§¡fÌ)ÝA¢;¹eÎa¯¨>§[´;¯LP¢)¯«³°q²AÖ°P¤Þ®8P°q§¡h¯K¨;§eØ9¢)¨;¶)§¬[¡=« ¯¨;¶A°P¨;º@²L±« Î;²)¡§K°P¨± ²A¬¤>¯f«r°q²LÖ¬§e«³¬5°q§[´;¯5ÌLÖÎ)¬²L¢8ºAÎk«³Î¬§§ q°z¨8§L¡²L±©A¢;§¡5« °q²A¨;°P¨;ºaÑrß)¨;²LØdq§¶º)§K²A±¬§¡[¡µ²L¢8¬¹§L¡[»¹¬°%« °q¹¯;¯®)®)¬²®8¬5°q¯e« °³²AÖ²L±°qÄ« §e¬5± ¯¹§¡[»¬§¯A¡[¡£¢)¤O®)«q°³²AÖ²L±¡5¢AËÒ[§L¹e« °%´;°z«³×)ÓØ§Kº)°%´;§K¯ ¡£ß8§e« ¹ÎÞ± ²A¬¯]¨;§eØ9®;¯¬5¯¶°Pº)¤>»2«³Î;¯e«²L±¯OÊ5± ¢8ààe×>¡§¯¬¹ÎÊØ'°³¹Îa¯A¡[¡µ²A¹°q¯« §¡h¤>¯A¡5« §e¬°P¨º'«qÎ8§Ï« ²A²A ¡¯L¹¹²A¬¶°P¨;º'« ²k«³Î;§G¬§q§[´;¯¨;¹§K¹¬5°z«r§e¬°z¯#Ø'°z«³Î ¡µ§¬§¨;¶A°z®8°Õ«Õ×O¯A¡h°q¤®;%×)°q¨;º'«qÎ8§0«³¬¯°z¨8§¶¯®)«³°z«q¢8¶§G« ²ºA¬§§f««³Î;§G¢)¨;§¾L®;§¹e« §¶Ì á-²L« ¡[Û=¹q ¡¥ ¬§q§[´;¯L¨8¹§»®8§e¬ « °z¨8§e¨;¹§»;¡µ ¬§e¨8¶A°z®;°%« »A¬§¹Î;§¬¹eÎ;§Ï± q²L¢8§»®)¬5¯«q°³©¢8§¡h°z¨)±5²A¬ ¤>¯f«r°q²A¨¨8§Pq§¡ â§e×Ø²A¬¶8¡¥ ¡§¯¬¹Î)°z¨;º)»)¶A°qºA°z« ¯;¨)¯e« °%´;§¡*»8¡µ§¬§e¨;¶)°z®)°z«Õ×;»± ¢8àLàe×>¡§¯L¬ ¹ÎY»°P¨± ²A¬¤O¯«³°q²AÖP°z« §¬¯L¹[× ãåäUæçè'éçèëêíìæç8îGäïUð9ñ'çòAäUæ h` 5s - ! T q;b K ;X K)XGb_^{rVh X- ; G qo^LP Y³L!f

(19) Z[z ;zd! óef8o

(20) hz ^X) _^óOf Y Gk_^ ; ];X-µkY T #f;_5 qZ[

(21) n ;X; bhZ[ T V*d T

(22) * )'_^!. z^ [ -[Kz#'f n ;XR _^";\- ; @ k n[=V ! T xn T x T 5; e Ze _^ ]õô!=X- *d T x _^dd 2[r_^ eq= ; -ö-p#"P,G"ya T T W nVd

(23)

(24) V T A 5X-

(25) L[

(26) Y [ A÷ P^ er

(27) - T V nøR k T LO d

(28) ; ' )'. T h*[[ T [ ù£ T G*[[ T [ -V K^ qo^L T XR; ;qf"µk

(29) G ) T VôV )ú T ro

(30) = n

(31) [e T YXR s 5X- µV_^)*^z dL] Z[

(32) X- ALô! s A`û # s 5X-A -{XY nK T X

(33) ]õs o ; T T

(34) [!wU " g )Y n ; d! T ) [ T ;XR T ;= Gkµüt S \b

(35) p,,lýnwþUtV`#`bp,,hm]

(36) ] = V_^! s µ Ae X eú z ;qVVwU h ! ' k^ Y ' s ;z] L T qKqo^VV s [ µ Ae -s [ n[ µ2"h`s 5*V ; h s A[;ÿ

(37) Is

(38) e ) µ A[

(39) nd T ;>e T x T x8bh T !Z[ (e h 'f T ; GA') -o ;z0 5s X-

(40) T V]5s ;Z[Ze T [qozV j S {g@9`-p,,lA"; nV^{[' ' A[ _#@ Z[ X Ae ; 5^ o ; T kd ; h n Y T x T xL'

(41) rn] ro^)Lz ; V !

(42) Uc' T ;bh ;! ' s Z[*(µcd T 8b.

(43) *]

(44) X-XR! Kp,,hm([p,, h"ta= V ! X=[ - T T k

(45) ;dXA ]!f T A÷=[f;b V T qVds o

(46) Yq^ ' T ;f

(47)

(48) 8 T V o; T A;be T ;f_^ n n# nn

(49) O #5s zGrVóe T x T xn{Z[ ^ó b_^q VôV {Z[ µ T xn Y G;XR; dfWk n-Z[ ;X- n _^V S S Ù*tO *tabhô! f L÷=[fbn n!X- h Z* T -{ s = ;= hq^55PV nRZ[ n T z ZKAK o; ^; ';X-; er

(50) Gô YZ[ZdóeZ* ó'f*^z 2" i #O nxn ;z

(51) b ' ! Ys G nV nêo

(52) er

(53) )*[ T Y V Ü; -* )'; ; ôV s Z*['A# YZ T x VV V z f{*'r*8úLAb

(54)

(55) n 0fbA - ;X- h '! s ; _ 8bhd5*ks #)fo

(56)

(57) nbh YrYXR; kôV_^ Z* õôo Z* fbhZ[ ;zôVnh T z)A"i- # T

(58) hk Y G' A[ _^ = Z[ X er

(59) nY n T

(60) Xfnk Y K ! ; OWd5 )eVz^ [ hfbh) [ noµr h - ;X- h VV5 ; ; zV T X; Y³V# ! T x T xV ; ; q T [

(61) 8;bh) u Lf T ; d ! [ -] VZ[

(62) T [

(63) x* _^VV n

(64) zV_^h n n#')X Vs f_GK^ o8 R ; hXR";t'd ^(e ô! n n# hs ;xnY n T ; T

(65) T ^;h n T L ;qfVô{ T hX;x; h -d [ _0 Gfeo; T

(66) X-XRVV ;Z*Z T qoz" i [>e GOf [* T ! [ 'O[e 5_^[er

(67) nYXR; | &"yaK qo^Lz ; T

(68) n YAfY (e= 'L T

(69) e r^ -5 V['5A T ;XKk nÜ*] öRnb ]X- A÷=[5; (* 5' T ;ks

(70) L[ -> T p#"ya !Z #Vo Y T V= Z[ T s = e [ -dLf n T - h n{ nGz(Y !*V W T ze Z' f Y ;XR; T o

(71) h_^ G s T [qozV! T x T xnVhs = Z[ XR er

(72) +G"ya !f [ T [r

(73) -s ^ *)ú T roPVes G -Z[ n T [ ' d 2[r_^n Z[ X er

(74) nY nk o^ ; T ; X-(e; !oz { Y =qG zV'[Gz AeV ! T x T xnVhs = Z[ XR er

(75) ìÙãåäææ >ò

(76) @æ9ñ>è è'ç )ç;îGò

(77) Ïè ï-è ÏäUð-îGñ>è G25 )hzd T VXRfV - o

(78) Y ] {Z[ õnX- W; T z=Z _^; ] T L' dh T T T nn e^ ; k o ; T nkd hfY ; T x T xnLA"YyaK qo^Lz ; T

(79) n YAfY (e= Of n T 5e qG£ -= V*'r T ;X-# nÜ[' ö-n#XR A÷=[5 (e 5' T ;kG5 e 2[ -a T "!$#&%(')&*+,#$-%.'0/1'0+,# *%.. \- G T ;VV {Z[ X- -ô{[ A`û Üf -{[=eZ[*#cd T ;( T R 5 T ;VG5 )*o; he T L[#K qo^Lz ; V 9 Af' 8R!Z[ X-

(80) b #O X-X; T T Ï o T ^ ; o

(81) ; T b GfY ; T x T xnLA'Kq5 [x T ;qf(eh T X-; Y *'hrK^ ro^)Lz ;qV ! h ^" i # o

(82)

(83)

(84) T R G)fo

(85)

(86) 'Z[ X-

(87) a

(88) 5G; ;ô T '5 T _^; ; ] T

(89) X

(90) *)X-; 0= e L[

(91) A"þ[f T ) T WfVYXhq _^VV5 VX-[xn h8b

(92) n n#Ao hOf n^ = ) T * k ;I| * )h ; !; dô! G'Z[ eXR [ Ga*d xn VG ; e5Af VVX ; Wo

(93) h ;qV o hr

(94) Y³"u V ZeZ; T V; [ T ;z^G_^G ;zd_]5 h n YPK nxn YP!Z[ X T q^ _G

(95) 2;

(96) PÏ n{Z[ X- ; h[ 8o

(97) hqOf nxn YP"g> [Vo ; T T

(98) nGP'ôV5[e ^)hõz^ [ GA";\- ) h 5 !fYX- W8bh T Of

(99) Krh; [ Ze ;fbh A ;O ] X-

(100) bX- ;@ [ hr Y³L T

(101) A÷=deúLôV T ;V0 T "Y\ @ f T ;bG[ no

(102) f no

(103) dO[ ; _^ T ; T A÷=[f{[ A; ; T Y³Vô{ T [qoz";\-V3 X ;XR;bh! )O T

(104) X- Gez Z[n h nY Vd*^ ; [= VA'> '

(105) 5 T q5 '); ;b ! Gr er

(106) - Gfeo;V*] h -G4 A[!x X- W " j ; T K Yfbh #' o h ; o_^; _^K[ )zO ; 5 ; k' [r_^n Z[ eXR er

(107) nY '

(108) o T _0; 5 # = A h2" 5 ¦ 6z§¾A®;¬§¡[¡µ°q²A,¨ 8@¬§¹eÎ;§¬¹eÎ8§Ï± q²L¢8 § 9O§¡5«º) e¨; ¬¯³§¤>§Ä«§¤Þ®8q²× §K®;²L¢8¬¶ ¡°qºA¨;§e¬¢)¨ 8'¤>²A¶)§K¶)§K¬§¹eÎ;§¬¹eÎ;§ 7 ¶ 6P°z¨± ²A¬¤>¯e« °q²¨@« ²Aq ¬¯¨«r§G´;° ¡[Û=·2Ûz´;° ¡h¶-6%¯®)®)¬²A¾°P¤>¯e« °q²A¨¡²L¢>¶-6z§e¬ ¬§f¢8¬[¡Ñr± ¯¢)« §¡h¶-6z²L¬5«³Î;²AºA¬¯®)Î;§G®;¯¬§¾§¤O®8q§Ó¡£¢)¬q§¡

(109) « §e¬¤>§¡h¶)§Ï³¯ : ©¢8§¡£« °³²A¨§e«<; ²L¢>¶)§¡h¶²A¹e¢8¤>§¨)« ¡»2¢)« °Pq° ¡5¯¨«¶)§¡

(110) « §¹Î¨)°q©A¢;§¡G¡5«³¯«³° ¡£«r°z©A¢;§¡[»®)Î;²A¨; e«³°q©A¢;§¡h²L¢>¶)§#¬§¹²A¨)¨;¯° ¡[¡µ¯¨;¹§]¶§#±5²A¬¤>§79OÑ ¹f± ´²A¹¯eË¢8q¯°q¬§K¶)§#q¯&=²A¹»Ý)°%« §K¶)§K46PÐ =>'Ý8»YÌ@?G§e«q« §K§¾A®)¬§¡*¡°q²AÖ§¡5«P¯Ï«³¬¯L¶L¢8¹e« °q²AÖ¶)§A(B(CDCFE!È[ÇLÃ.G0HI>Ñ ²L¢1A.B(CDCJEKÃAÂLHMI)ÀzÅÁÓÌNGPq§#±5¯°z« ¬ f± ¬§¨;¹§K·]zO¯ A.BPCQCFE!JÄ RÁJÀ H'Ñ z¯]q²Aº)°q©¢8§Ï± q²L¢8§Ó²L¼»)·KP¯K¶)°z± ±5 ¬§¨;¹§K¶)§KP¯K³²Aº°q©A¢8§GË;²A²A §¨8¨;§#©¢8°¨8§K¹²A¨¨)¯Ô³«:¶ 6%¯¢«³¬§¡h e«q¯« ¡

(111) ©A¢8§G´;¬5¯°²L¢ ±5¯¢;¾8»Aq ¯ 8¬§¹eÎ;§¬¹eÎ;§#±5³²L¢;7§ 9@«q¬ ¯L°%« §K³§L¡ f«³¯«=¡

(112) ¯´;§¹#¢;¨8§Ï®)¬ ¹° ¡µ°³²A¨@¬§q¯e« °%´;§APÌ =¯¨¡¹§Ï« §¾A« §#¨;²L¢Y¡h q¯¬5º)° ¡*¡²A¨¡¶²A¨8¹K¹§e«q« §K¶) e± °q¨°P«q°q²Aä¶§ 8@¬§¹Î;§e¬¹Î;§#±5³²L¢;7 §9.

(113)

(114)

(115) . ya' T k{ !q5 [xW8_#f

(116) KAR nX- ; T Â') T h8_^Y T !-[ 52"g> T h[ ;zdôo

(117) Y 'Z[

(118) X-; 5;XR; ] K -A ;XRY O* A[5* _^ T 5 T 8' ' Ofeo T T XX^ h T XY [ -L`g@\2"Y\R; ;XR; ' T e 'Ao; ] 8 Y X h G A÷=[fVG5 A]*úô T XXRU = T 'ú*#[Lf-|nr {XR T ;A ; T V@ *' T O[' zVí`g@\ ] f e Ze T e

(119) V T o[VGr n VV nõ

(120) X- ; V^ ";c]zKdY n ; ;X; b

(121) V*[ T e -; [f q^5 x _^;bn nþ

(122) V!)r h _^b T )

(123) ^8bh T " G *] T

(124) ^"g>5!X- T

(125) n ;µA ) T [ A÷ ! T L ; ;XR; d' G Ae5Z T h^ AR T [ [f! ) L] 'f*^z ) #A"\ X ; W!; n ; ;bh T o5; '! n _^rndLf n T q5r n[xnW;_#! n ] d;X Wfnkô T

(126) *^z;2"Yya n[ ! T x T xnV-ö-9f

(127) 'Lo; K'f;

(128) X- ; 2"Yc] #rôV #AõÏ [ f

(129) T

(130) ]#[ b] ôV; T

(131) !r *u h V [ ] T xn YX-RG h T

(132) *dX- T ^" `h h n

(133) ; - n[!_^!rnZ[ T L)XÏb-;Z*Ze T T znb X-h T zR d GX-; ^= WfYXR; d o

(134) T d n' n! O T

(135) Z )ôa n[=[" þ] 5#A hAfVÏqG n! T Ví`ga\ R ö-

(136) bh G* o ] T ;XR - ; 5 [W' G "! _^8b

(137) T xnVGr^ V ; V; - = ! µ # 5 T zV] fX-; ]z^";ya T 'x* e _^bXA[x

(138) _^b T T )^Y O o) ]2# T

(139) X-XRV= [ A";yI5; o ;XR; d T XR; ;qVeÏ G;Zµ#f-|_^; _#@X n) [k h VZe; [V T xn T xVVwU h [GZ[Ze; dô! h³V')

(140) #[[= n; ^" $ &%(') *'+-,.. ya{X- A÷=[f;(eX- nf zd T [ YZ[Ze T Y T "h` # T L] ;bhr{X- > T xn T xfYX^ ! Z[ YPYXR; T

(141) o; A"`h #f V* T

(142) T hX-XVZ[ T 5 V õ fKL T ! !r^ [xW;_^-|&2 ;b ú

(143) [ ; G_^;5_^ T x GV_^hXR T o Y "YyaK fV

(144) ;>A "=" "Lú! #5 ; hd Z[

(145) T YXR _^Yr_^ T xn 0fG";tO YZ[Zb

(146) n nnK ; [ 5 'fA T k! þq n[xnW;_0;b

(147) T o5; ' T A÷=[;b X h GG5 );x; 0/21 31-/ R T hk T GXY ;q#Ü| X n h h ;bhr u

(148) ;b. *[* T L[

(149) nbh5 Ae -] O[ )h'fA n T Ld T X-; A"gA] [5A ) *5;XR; ;qV*] 2 T

(150) X-XRV G WV R )e-! X5 T zVGqe µf

(151) X- nAL T xn T x";cd ; WY ;XR; bõG= ) d]X- ; =Ze T T e ; Kr {XR ; W;b õ;X- ; T

(152) Xh ;b 5X- L> T xn T x ; qo; d Ld*^z 2"ya' W;XRGr^ ViR;5 j T erYZb nõr T r S XR T ; vV h+4µv S @Kt@y'y'tÞbp,, 2 56 -1.6 71 T G[ T h; e ! )w *Of

(153) -X- d T xn T x gx d'Z ;z T K2"µk ; d&8õ 2 [q A5 [

(154) R*5 V_^ ; zVd*^z Z[ ne 2"Ycd 8 n

(155) Y ;XR; b-Z[ ;zd{ A T T WVL T ; bh

(156) d2! 2# T

(157) X-XRV ' o{ V_^ ; zV T d*^z k ;XG' n

(158) eXR ; b T 5[(eô;(eq!xn

(159) 'L G' =Pe _^ T X _Â" 9 :'+ '+ ;=<<>') ?A@CB 3D31 EFG 1 BH 1 qÿI6 31 ÿ

(160) 31 B.B F H G F J6F K1 B ÿ B F 71-/Kÿ B GÿI6F 5 31 5ÿIL M 7N @7B Gÿ

(161) 31 H 6 3O ÿ

(162) IEFG 1 BPB F13L 31 F -1 B H G 3OEFLC1IF / 1 B.B F O6Q/]ÿ7LR

(163) 71.6 H S/:6 H H G 1 76M -1.6 H F0O B 6M*F

(164) T 31*F H L/

(165) 7OR H OR COR 7U*ÿ N @7B 3D31 F KL M1EFG 1 B O6

(166) 71 H L 31 VO6Q// W5.51 O3O VEF13L 31 O6

(167) 7F1 H

(168)

(169) B G 1 3O -1.6 F GÿR

(170)

(171) 7U[ÿ B 6 -61 7F @ VF GÿR

(172)

(173) H O6 X51

(174) / -1.6 :Y B Z 1 Z B 1 6 [R3\E

(175) F N*]\tI`c#>tV`(µya>iitÞ_^g>þUþdtag@A`#`t>bp,,. `. gA'A[ PKX

(176) [! 'x 5Ao; ;' ' K qo^z ;=f' T µ ne n' V ZeZe T ^zVGr# ; [ { q^5 [xW;_^µ nd T hfeo ; T

(177) X-XR T G5 Z[

(178) XR o ;5 ";cdÜ o

(179) Y G5 ;5 L_^V !zG )*dKfLf n T ! !qG

(180) [xnW;_^ T

(181) *^z T xnU- þ ; *qtdi>"Yc]z]'; ) ;5;XR; b ' n

(182) XfV* ; b[ ' 'fLf n T ] [ '; d h L = Z[ T K^ T x ;X-R G ;_^;G ] hf T T W)Of

(183) ]'X- Lk T x T x"V 2;

(184) P Yr

(185) Lk_^! ^ ;X; Krnd [

(186) _^ oz; d [ '!r !f; [ -GqG T

(187) #' f

(188) # T _^µfXR Y; T

(189) fV_^! K[ 5 AL T ; d R] T [r_^' ; A";\RX- T x T xVZ*r

(190) Jb ®)¬²Ë;q¸¤>§L¡q°q ¡h·K³¯aK²A²Aº)q§&=¯¨;¹§K§e«¯¢8¾b@¿ c R.Ge¿AÈÃ.

(191)

(192) LV ; L A9X- [GP 'Z[ nG"g> T h[ d'Ao ;XXR; dG5 A ]z# T;T Y d_]5 A TT hX VV[5 A 0f 2[Z[ T [ - o ; V= ;Uô V T no

(193) *! AO

(194) (eX ;XRVYZ[Z T ^;". %.#&%@ 0*

(195)

(196)

(197) %@ EE;N 3=<A14 35E: Q T * ; hXnVG5; n_; -X-55 - qo^LP Y V p,,+- t 2f(µ µk jS þga j ^ w!tÞþ{wþtÞb p,,+2d J!^

(198) T j f@Kt@ j tVt@ ^ þ*IOiRb

(199) p,,+bh) p,,h~-*'A qo^Lz' 5 ; jS >tV`g S d "p,,h~bh) p,,*K qo^=! 5 hVµ\Utþ`nc#>tþ`(µya>iit> ^ g>!þKt>g@A`G`tÞb p,,b p,,hm vþ;q5_^VZ ; T x VeKü*Ie>i bp,,hm;L'*'rn] ro^)LzvI n µütdi![taûL' )"Pb

(200) p,,hm" "q"%@;X T Z* XR@rnd*^z k! f! G)*o^ [ * T ; -|Y[= Z[5^Vk n[=x)YX h _^nkö

(201) bhX- T ;[L ; T V n# - [ VdA T T X-; ; d hr_^VÏ5 e 2[r

(202) nbh f

(203) e - TT *^V![5 Z[ XR _^" gA5 T

(204) * L[ V ;AVZe T 5;XR; G[xn;X- µfO; ^ -X- hW; V_^ T e

(205) n-ô V )x; G h T

(206) X-X^ Ve ) ;VkYZ[Z[V o

(207) hz ^XR5_^b T ;z^hV -Z T ! GX5_^ f er

(208) nY -_^ G ;z] H 1WM1 B

(209) K1 D fb o

(210) T ! GXR _^V nRõ o

(211) bGen

(212) ;XR; - ;=x

(213) e - ; h[qG qoÂ' GXR _^Vd h[5 )e b -) Ae hdhq# ; T ; d T

(214) X T k]e T ; T )e W@ n n )XXR; d -X- Ae W)V! T xn T xVA'o

(215) ;= - * = Z[ XR A"g ) T e5[e _^V H 1 M1 B

(216) -1.D þ ;z# nV e [

(217) ;;b; T Lqo^ * T h T ; k n[=fb1 U' Z[ T nkö]"g>2 !Z T Vµd f T ;VVXR ; 5W)V ;Xqo^ ; ; -| 5 H 1WM1 B

(218) K1 D V25 µa dô![5 ;V o^ T VX- h ! GXR _^;bhX Y n_^ ; ; dd n[= T hX;x; G b G5 ; ; uGVd T ez _^VGr^ V Z[

(219) XR - x; n; ; h* T V] Lqo

(220) YXR; " S GG !z *d) _ T P; T (e*] T ZL ) # ' [ G^ ; e Rz^

(221) H 1 M1 B

(222) K1 D 2 o T #

(223)

(224) ' [ _^{ ! T x T xnV T ^X-; ;qf;bn)= k_^{Z[q^;b nn *£A; ; b ; h z^

(225) T XY ;q! T ; ; ][5qe* --ö-ARµ# )V{ !qG [xW;_^Vd þc S g>bh

(226) L[ -K

(227) V 8eb ' A[ _^#-; o ;O T A ;qV G *£Y o³

(228) n;X; '-öRX- ;@ ;X- K#f Oe T Ze _^; ; f' T ;z^ ( T ";t@d o

(229) T hP# n X- h G! 0 ; T bh T

(230) * T Z*qXR; d {Zf T ! n [r

(231) nY -|Y# VXR A Z'] n

(232) n( T z[ _0V n[=-öR 'r#d

(233) ^ ;qewU V# q G; fbh; ;A;XR; #o qV h n

(234) ) T Vk n[= T XY ;q T L _Â". V6#E:#D EE;N56RQ 9 Q'+ ; V' $ X , ,.< nVY n_!f 8V GK - [[ T 5VI! 1 #" 6 H $íµüt S \b

(235) p,,ld2] ;@[' 'f [ _^. = Z[ X er

(236) nY nk^ ; ` j [u#*g> 5;;b -g> ; 5Z[ e ;bG;XG T [8q T T h[ A"t Ze ;zd Ld L[ _^'zK T

(237) Z[ eXRô T V_^{ @Xõ; L] dô T h ) T

(238) X-XRV5 U [ _^#Ü| T xn T xkY Ur^5r n[xnW;_^;b n[=OG T ;5fb

(239) f T L -XR; L2" "q"&%L" { AKf qoµf T a*e; n Y '[GP T ] µ>f

(240) K A*#GqG nG qo^z T [xn h 5_^V ;XR T ; V G 5V XR ;= V>`ü9`R T

(241) en

(242) n d T ô n*f !; )

(243) _^V; r^)"µa*^Z*ZefY T nh ô{ _0_^! z^ [ - s *] 'xn hX- W VAÏn µ nb e( ô{ Oeun [xWfbG*' '*^z _ ' #X-

(244) [V_^! s ; !xn hX- ;zU T

(245) * L' T T xVd [ _^k

(246) qo^Lf Ze ;zd f ÷ [ T [f ; T X h V; [f! T h* A 2[ hk`n j eus g> h V T '[Gz AA". ' ²L)¢ ( RORÁÄzÇÁÇÅ)MÇ GÃÂPJÀ RAÅ¥2Ñ=¹e±[Ì **¯2¡µ²A,¨ +¬¯¨¶8»ÖÎ8§Ï°P¨± ²A¬¤O¯«q°q²Aä¤O°z¨8¶;¡§e«[¥.?hÎ)¯¨;º§¡°zÏ¡=«q¢8¶)§e¨« ¡¯¨;¶@°P¤O®;P°q¹¯«³°q²A¨¡±5²A¬ Î°qºAÎ8§e¬h§¶A¢;¹¯«q°q²A¨8»PN='Í$?0ÐKÍaÝ.N]§*´;°³§Ø»Aá-¯L¬¹eÎ;ÐK®)¬°z`-.-#/8»L®ÌL510YÌ Ó 2 3'²A°q¬§¨@± ¬5¯¨ 4¯L°r¡e6¥ 5nÌL¦¯¬5¶)§³q°q§e¬£» 7Ç 8R.BHÇKÇÂ;ÄqÃ'0È ROB.GeÀz:È 9#;GÅ=<B>ÂqÇ#È0B.G#ÄqÃH(BÄPÂJB.GeÇ#Å B.K,?MG[À@<OB)ÇK¿AÇÈ0Ã¿.RAÈ]ÑA+¯×¯L¬¶)» `#-.-#/)Ó*Ì 0 c@Ç A(RBAÅ8¿kÈJÂ B)¿AÇÅ8Âz1È 9BDCFEdÃ H(HÇÈ*ÈÇL¿ HPRAÅAÆAÇÅ)ÀqÇeÅ;Â%É)ÆAÇÂqÂqÇ¿AÉ;ÃAÅ;¿ÃÁÁ GÇ*ÁÃÂPÇL,¿ RLÅ;ÄPÀzÅ8&Ç GÇÈ RB.GQHLÇPÈ APG R.KHPROB G[ÈeÇ GeÇÃ¿AÀPÅLÁÈGÃAÅ8¿ Â I;7Ç HL.Ã KG81BÈ0Äz@À H.GÃ GLE:cÇ H@È[ÀqÂPÇIÉ BKJLEdJÂ ROÃÄzÇÈ*ÈMÇ G^NÇ MAÂqÇÅ)Âz

(247) É BÈÇL¿ O*Å)ÂqÇ GÅ;ÇÂÈÀqÂzÇÈ*É)È BHIOÃAQÈ P).Ã I RORSRÕTÉ ( R.RÁÄzÇÉ;ÃAÅ8¿cVÀ UÀ 8hÇ¿AÀqÃLÉÃLÅ8 ¿ BKWLEYX ROGU2ÇL¿ XGÀq<Â I8 G RFAAÇÈ[0È R.G[È R G^Äq@À H.GÃ G[ÀqÃAÅ)È RLÅ;[Ç Z"RL6Å ZRÅ)Ç]JÂ RkÅ8.Ã GDG R\X¿ R#XÅOÈÇL.Ã G0HI;ÇÈGÃAÅ8¿ HÄq.Ã GeÀ A EINÇ M]8hÇ HÂqÃAÂqJÀ RAÅ(È A.R.GGÃAÈ[ÈeÀ ÁOÅ K'ÇÅ8Âz_È ^.

(248) J ,.; I ,K')Q'+ 3;, ,]X;'+ . cKf h' );X-h ;b X-h ; _A T z;fb

(249) !z#' T ; VG [V; b T ; V_G

(250) *] ro^)LzvI nVµüUt'iI*taûL] "Pbp,,hmA"` T

(251) G[ # ; T e

(252) nrY ô{[5 XfL f Y ;b T [ G'[Gz A' [ T ^5 L'o ; ; T ) ; ] ^ ; T 5 A ; ]"`#55 T * # ' *[ ; T V T

(253) * #r n

(254) Y bh ; - 5XPY ' ! [;V R q d!XR [V -_^[[ r þo

(255) Y A5 T qo^ X hW; V_G #(µ) G" i #'rW8o

(256) h_^ A[! V T K h Ü| `h T [ f Knµ

(257) K[ =; ]er

(258) z ³;X; Kn n'rL' T x T xn@ X- Lk T x T xnV X T ( T rb T *dôm~ 66M B U_]5 Ï) zb=> T ) ; d+l ô[ 5). 66M B

(259) 3OR36 B

(260) "{] ' K[ er_^-wV 5nb 66M B

(261) 3O R36 B

(262) I[G - [ [Wk

(263) Z[ZefY d X- ' n ; µ["e* T =Z5_^;XR; d[[= nV T ^ ro^)Lz ; V T x) T xA] Z*ZV T;T W ô V T XR; [r

(264) ) ; ;XRY ]µ[ ! n] ! T xn T x A" j ;5 +l Gq[ 5

(265) Gr^ [ Ï T Y !o5; nY ] ^ ; T )@ T

(266) G[ #X- L Z'k Gr[ er

(267) -G [='; n ;5*A" \õ5 ) ]z]_^ 66M B

(268) 3OR36 B

(269) bh_Gf n^Z[ZV{ VX-;Z* ; T VXR; Lô![ ; zd!. XR ;µf

(270) 66M B Ud! T T ef T V_]5

(271) o ; ]Z[ ; LV AR n[ µXRµkY h T ! ) T ( T e )Z[ T - T ^X-; [ -; T [

(272) r_^ ->`ga\ [[ T ^ 5)eb G n[] ' [ T ^5 W;XR; ]

(273) XR T XR;5 ALA" - $ k T [ ) ' ^r 5; nú ;XR Y R )X-; ] K ÏG"g{ *(eô8(eqV_^V Vu ;X _^ • ö-p#"P, R;X5V ! K n T x' T [ fbRX- h G ) G@r T ;VV Lk T roPn T 8YXR _Â"{'rn T T e* _Â; ;5 T V_]

(274) ;= ö-p#"P,:- F M H O6 5b [ T = Ae bx e z8bh;XR;5 Ae G" " " /2L K6 $P/:1

(275) n! *]L; [5; V o; 5'f [ _^' ; A H 1 M1 B

(276) -1.D e" yI Y n_ A T h[ Þ n{ X-

(277) VX- ; V!Z[

(278) X Ae -ôV ! T xn T x;b ; ;=u^V][ 8nhr hz • V5 hZ[ X- -*zKkV, Úb T

(279) * L[ -_Go) d T [f ; T - o TVT ; 5Ï ; _ k_G

(280) _^ ; Y # X Y n_^VG5 ] ' {Z[ X- - T X; Y³ L" S G b ' T µ

(281) ) Kn2µ

(282) õX- h hfb 66M B V # *] ] Vo ; T V µ h([Z*Z[ ; " ta Z* [ ; _ !;Z[ W VZ[

(283) VX- ; nV*hPKV, ) T d; T -! T k • G-1 /2L 1 71 K1 6 ]" H S GG A÷=d_^5;Z[ T P T hXA T ' Z[

(284) X- Ae ; 5 T [ Kf[ hOf

(285) #;)µb ;X5; T

(286) T Y T !X- ; n_#";ya z^ [r

(287) #£*d T T ; 5VGq^ T

(288) Zf

(289) 2[ Y³LV) [ J z) [ #nbh Y T ; V] ! n no^; "@ ]) - ;A ; ') X h T [f ; T - o^ T T ; f Y^_^V '[Gz A![5; _ A T ;= Z[ 5; Gfb

(290) [; _ Aµ

(291) V5X- G T

(292) T q# hX-XR[ 5; e _^ A" •. . ;') , . i # o

(293)

(294) '; ; V ) [ - T d [ T G V) _-Z[5 x _^*[r

(295) n Y V AW T x T xnLõ 8

(296)

(297) f 2µ

(298) qf!+ j Vr^ qo^LzVOiR T `h x ;( S q h A";ya !Z[ Yq^ !

(299) Ae f

(300) nVA 5 T

(301) n

(302) z hV[5; n_ { ; ^[ ! n µf

(303) ^"YtÞ= ! # ; Z[ ;z] X- = Gk A÷=[8b T xnU T x T xnLK[f

(304) ! )' A T r n T X-XR H 1 M1 B

(305) K1.D )b ! ) Vro

(306) LzV[[ r T xn T xV øR* n T ) ; ] T A÷=[V T ) T 5* _Ô[[ L [eq^; ^

(307) H 1 M1 B

(308) K1 D I[ ) T VVw V; *[ T ^ eX- ;µdhq# RX- h hX- G ;b Z[ h5' . /. N¨@®)¯¬5«q°³¹f¢8q°q§# ¬ "OHI RAÄq.Ã G´;¯d¡µ§¬ ´;°P¬h¶)§#¤²A¶)§K-¶ 6z¯¹¹¸¡h·]q¯K¶)²A¹e¢;¤a§¨)«q¯« °q²L¨> q§¹e«q¬²A¨)°q©A¢;§#¯¹©A¢8° ¡µ§#®;¯¬4 6Õ¢)¨;° ´;§¬[¡°%« ¶ 6P¯®)®)¯¬5«r§e¨;¯¨;¹§AÌ¦§#®)¬°q¾k± ²A¬5«¶)§Ï¹§#«P×®§]¶:6P¯L¹©A¢;° ¡°%« °q²LÖ®8²)¡µ§]¶:6%¯¢«³¬§¡

(309) ®)¬²Ë;q¸¤>§L¡©¢8°¡²A¬5« §e¨«¶A¢a¹¯¶A¬§K¶A¢@®)¬ ¡§¨«¯¬5«³°q¹q§AÌ : $ Í'Ö¬ ¯®)®;²¬5«¶)§ 5N&%(' ¨« §e¬ ¨;§e«Ñr¦§¨)Î¯¬5«r»Ð@Ì »2á¯¶)¶)§¨8»Lá9Ì »á¯L¹º°³qq»AÐOÌ'Ì*)ÝA¤>°Õ«³Î»AÐOÌ*+;ÇÇÅ)È^ÃÅ8¿@È R.HLÀPÃÄKÇ¿AÀqÃÌ Í'G¦ Î)«q«q®¥ ;<;qØKØ'ØaÌ ®8§Ød°q¨« §¬ ¨;§e«5Ì ²A¬ºP;q®8¶±£¡ ;@5,'F5 -/.8Ö§§¨¡-0.Ý)²A¹°q¯L0-/.)á-§¶°³¯1-0.#+°P¨;¯5Ì ®8¶A± Ì Ó¤>²¨«q¬§#©A¢;§]¶A¯¨¡

(310) ³§f¢8¬´;°q§d¡µ²A¹°q¯q§»q§¡Ò[§e¢;¨)§¡ º ¨; ¬5¯«q°³²A¨¡»¯¤> e¬°q¹¯°z¨;§¡h¯¢¤>²A°q¨¡»L®;¯¬=«r°q¹°z®;§¨«P¯¬º)§¤>§e¨«·]¹§e«q«r§Ï« §e¨8¶¯¨;¹§)¥ 2 ¦¯'¹²A¨«³¬¯L¶A°q¹e« °³²A¨>M¡ 6P§¾®8z°³©¢8§'¡¯¨¡

(311) ¶)²L¢)« §K§eÖ®)¯¬5«³°q§Ï®)¯¬q¯]¶°z± ± ¬§¨;¹§K¶)§L¡®¢2Ë;q°q¹¡h¹°%Ë;q§¡K¥A²A¨@®8§e¢«8®;§eŸ¡µ§¬©A¢;§#q§¡ ¶²A¹e« ²A¬¯¨« ¡^¡µ²AÄ«®)z¢¡^¡µ§eŸ¡µ°%Ë;³§L¡·Kq§e¢)¬[¡Ë;§¡²A°q¨¡h§Ö¹²A¤O®; e« §¨;¹§¡h°P¨± ²A¬¤>¯f«r°q²L¨)¨;§qq§¡h©A¢;§#¶)§¡h e«q¢;¶)°P¯¨)« ¡

(312) ¶)§KP°q¹§¨;¹§»®;²L¢)¬¶)§¡

(313) ¬¯°³¡µ²AŸ¡ ¶§d¡µ q§¹e« °q²A¨»A-¶ 6z§¾®8 ¬5°q§¨;¹§]§f«Y¶§#¨;¯e«q¢)¬§]:¶ 6%¯L¹e« ° ´;°z« #¯L¹¯L¶) ¤O°q©A¢;*§ 3 4 Ð9¤>¯5Ò[²A¬°Õ«P×O²A±¡5«q¢8¶§¨«=¡

(314) ¶)²'¨;²L«¢)¨;¶)§e¬[¡£«³¯¨;¶@Ø]Î;¯e«©¢)¯z°P«P×O¬§¡µ§¯¬5¹ÎO¬§¡²L¢;¬¹§¡h¯¬§#¯¨8¶'Î;²LØ9« ²q²A¹¯« §#« Î;§e¤VÌÐ¡

(315) ¯ ¬§L¡5¢8z« »)¡5«q¢;¶)§e¨«=¡h¡§§fßÞ¯#Ë;¯LP¯¨8¹§¶O¯e®)®)¬²A¯L¹Î@« ²¹²L¢;¬[¡6§ 5)¬§q¯« §¶'¬ §L¡§¯L¬¹Î8»q§[´;§¬¯Lº)°P¨;ºKË;²L«rÎO²A¨;P°z¨;§#¯¨;¶O²L± ± q°q¨8§Ï¬§¡²L¢;¬¹§¡eÌ 5 0§¹Î;§¬¹eÎ8§Ï± q²L¢8§ ;LN¨;©¢8ªe« §Ï± q¯2¡5Î>7Ñ ' '2áÓ.

(316) YrYXR; A #e X-

(317) T V9 qoV T xnV - q ;= bL'

(318) T Gk_]55# z] 0q5VG ; f T

(319) X! '[5 ;8_^ er

(320) -ô -X- W; 5_^" 9 , K'+ . , ) ') <& Q'+ , ,( ; . g nêo

(321) er

(322) @ n n#k YXWY n; dô!X-AV T #V o ; 5 T qoVd T eqqoVõX- hW; V! Zf T ! GX-) _^!; )

(323) n;5 G"; VA^; ; ! 31.D 71 $6 B.B M #6 H 6 R '. C1 -1 R 1 Z

(324) $í] !LA`g>b *^V >ú ; o 'p,,hmµgayabp,,hmfb0Y = Y - T ; T ) T hXA T = Z[ X er

(325) nY nkú^ '; f [ Gb;X-d T A#V { n [ - H 1 M1 B

(326) -1.D -X-

(327) [ '_^> n [ z T

(328) X X-; T ; G T T ) T )e LK n; dô!) V A;ú G x^ ; GK[ #' nG )A" c' ) 5 Lfb0 {Z T ! n ;5 ! # n[] ' A# hz^8bh 'f [ _0' ] dx X-

(329) W) Ü;. { 66M B M -1.6 õ H 1WM1 B

(330) K1.D "; µ£ T ! T ; d\- ) xvþ