·ii
:'.".::'....:\::., :
,". ,-:
120. I:'.,cell (2,5) is indi?atecj,a payment,pf421>by jiJgeria to UAR which is compoe ed jof' 1 + 35; +,391, all. Of;which ro;,e payments, indicated
'.:--'.
in column 5 of table 12. In cell (4,3) is ent~red,~paYrileniof 2,017 to be made by Libya to Tunisia. It is composed of 579 and 1,438 shown in bblfunn,)il;i'
tabi~ 1~. in
cell(4,5) appear~;
a,~j'ymer:t
01''5,058 to bemadeiJ;1ilig~i'i
'to Ttinisia. This i soomp()s~dC1f5,005
+ 53both, ',',: .:'. (5 ;;,;
of which items are contained in column 5 of table 12; Cell (6,3) is an entry of 669 which indicates that
Li~y~has
to make this payment to Morocco.This±scom:P";;l"lef)6f'~ii:p;l:Y1U~i;bY:LiDy,f6f
'417 on behalf '"Y'Y'l....:.... ,·of··{f1ljR·~..;I:·,~·direci;p"J'!meni;''Q¥ 'I;;ib;ya ·to Jl[oroqcc,' off
?5'2. ;m:p·eTrr(6,J)'--·..···_·
, '_ ~" I ~ I - , - ' I ~ -~ • t )
i_ \iE! ..
~.e!)t~;y, .«f:
.23,,:1;85·_i_Th:l$.
is ,pp.l1lpusetLof·1direcf
-P8¥meiitb.y4~1'·ia ~:~ i
...:t.oJ:I.oiFoci:!i'L2f:<,.2,4.4I
.m;ig...
ill1.::mJ.tij;:e.c:t,;J/.aym,ent! of' .,7.38.\.as..
indicated !bY,'···' ., , , cLf:,.""-I
r'" I , I ) , j . I ' :,'h,,_,
the aprows in !column 5 !Of table ~2. Finally
1
thereI
is a..~.i:re..ct Ijay-ment~yMaurit;ania
of 314 to be mad.e.~i:i' ~4orocqo. i.t,Lf.L{ .
" I
I! , \ ! .
121.
i The marg,inal co Lumn in tab~e 13 oontaixjs the ~or~:iontal sums ofI ; , . 1 ; i . '
all t"-e
paymen~s
reoeiV)ed by the: countries,~t
the left end of "tb;e! I '. ' i ( !
'TOws •\"'J:'hr,re--eptr ±es'l;\r;e. shOwn ..
iiji·tliismargiffa1·"coIijimn,·
th'e UAR':'reoeiyeB·-a:J:tog~ther5,6~9"·-TuiiishT;075"andilliI6r66C92j;888. "The: sum
j i i ; , _j I ;
of th~se threejpayments; is 36, 60? A.Lthe f'10t 0.1' the table, th<we
i I ; . t. '. i , . ;
isa marginal TOW which~ conta fnej the·sUm·tote:! of paymenta which :the
I
I ..., .. ' .. . " ."... '
j... ·'Couni;:i:-±es·at·the·tl-eads
~ftM
co:l.tllfiii'- haveti5'.. iriiake·tJ other Horih! .i ~ -1 I " ! I i i i
:···""·--il.£ricb"'Ccun-trii:es
;·"TheJ:.e-·a::re···foi)ir··entries·il1j··thisiiargiiial' rOW;I"""'"
; I ! 1 · ! '
- 1 ! . ;
, !~udan
I
has to mfke total! payments' 01'4.,.669; L~by,,:3,229; Algel;' ia! i
'28,670/ and Maufita~ia 3f·Thesrn
t~tr,;J. of~heSeP4yments is agaj~. .;'''- · ..'36 ,-fiot · ····_..
-r .": .r "', ".... .
j. l' i i i t
! r I l
I
J·'·---1.Q2-...
J
-If we' -ooit""u-p'an~he
paymeAts in "table]"} toos'
made to UAR,'Tunisia and Morooco, the sum total is 36,602. This, as table
11
shows, is also the sum of the total intra-North Afrioan positive
If
th~re,
e:;crste'a.a~ul
tiJ;t'eral Plea¥ingsch~me3q,602
:would have. to"be paid to the
clea:r'h,g;~~on:~y t~e·<l.ebtcr co~tries
and the 'creditorboui1tr'i'e~ \~6U:ld'
riice:ive36, 602fr6Iit'theclear':ing uilion.The
Lc6irip:;m~;a'tidftsch'ejjje
J:nhefetrt:inc.l~il.rIhg':'unid~:pl'ocedute
i13always ,.;, th'e'tiJo'St' 13ilnpl'e,:pGs'hb1'e~' . Cl '.~,:-I c"·
123. The compensation agent could have, devised a, compensation scperne
~'l:~ :·3.·:.'r)r~< ~t':· -:;::\', '.~ .,' ._-.~ -",'" .\_',
B differ mg from, scheme, A in table 12. This compensat i.on ~?heme B
"Sudan
E/ ON .14/WP. 2/4 E/ ON .14!AlII\A/12
Annex I:.
Page 47
1S4. The paYlll"nts".;Wl:t~chrow:l.:s#"j[s"·a§b,,ing -dus tQ:Su(lan have again been assignedt9 ~hEl'UJ\.R as::sho.'ffi bY:':l;l",,-f,u+:l lijJ¢,rarI'ows, There is no differende '~6'far 'b\'\tw~en,.cpmpensatio)'l,:sqlj.elJ)e~A1'!nd:--l), In the
sElcQnd'row, however,::d:i,:~ferencesapPE'iar under oOID.'Pft'llsation scheme E.
:
Libya has to make a di~'.ect pay)llen t to the
]J1\.R
0:\:,.,;1;:,500 fI'om,:,~hich no assignmen t i s made to·other·l:toul1tries...'" ', . - -. ", ... - ' . . '-'.. '-," . ,--'-- The YAR -und.er- compensat:i;oll::Scheme Bis a,ss:iji~niJlg.tw,opayments due. frpm·:t4eSudan to itsel:e: to.
Tunisia and Morocco respeo,i;iv,e1Y" F:L1.1,l,J;;ine""rr9"ws show that ,Sudan . pay.s,fI,J{Ji;p. TunisAa anq.i{H,,1;o ,lVloroopo.:, ThstQ;i;a1.net payments whioh:,'
the,UAJ1, can nOyvA::1aim,.frolllEl;uda,n to "ttfj\eJ,f i,s 3,673.. . -,',' _ J_ ... " . .[
125. :"!Another big dit:t''er''ehdeappears''ih'l}d-w
4'
Jt\unisia is entitled' '.'< ( , ' , ' , I" ," . ' . : - ; . ,.,
to reoeive 5,778 from Alger ia and no as'S,ignnien't"ls made OU1; of' this'"
sum. Howev,yr, tl).'" 1~A91 :Mjliph T¥n~l'!:tE\"is':E>ntit1eq. to receive ,frpm Libya are: split !tPiJ;l~o thre8;,ass,i,gpp1eut's.a,nd on,e direct paym","'t;:.,.
Tunisia requests Libya to transfer
35
from .cell (4,3) toceU,,{!l.,4):and from here to cell (2,1)., This is a9ircuitous route w~icp-,pan be short
circ~iteci
by Libyap~yingdi;~ctly
to the UAR the sum of 35 • A" , J:--;", ""'\""j!c~ ~:;r:"·:afLf·I:X.
short circuit transfer of 35 at"the order of Tunisia is shown by a broken line arrow from cell (4,3) t"o"
ce1'i
1"'( 2 , 1 ) , Morocco, as shown,::.:Lc,_b;V an
a:!:'J;pJ:l,Liaf.>Bigns3,91.:f&'<lm'"d:kcl,;i,:(-~4)'-:t-04J~h (1"j6};~ir
om which, i t "\r",
r-" ,--- ~s r e,..as;i~nif(L_:by SUd'fn- fromc",U,{1-,--6)- tGC ell, (2,IJ.--This is.a" - . ~'-._---'
-'-:-!
\- i . .:',:;i'J:Tjf:,-; ':::~, ",'), i i::'_j~··-H;;"".:,!.~;. i ,:,~.:_:,'~ CC'-- " ".;--:c:.,>J" i "
i.-".- ,;;::u~:~~S
. .(::;; e
' "._.._._._t:h.~:li~r~~~)'.-S~~h~~:~ll~~~i~;~d~~/:~~t: ::r:d;;:l~----
_.".,\_, ...,~ ~.__ -, \.._ - _ -.. - - , - - .. f'·---'~- ~:;_~-:'~·,,~·..·..--,..---i-O • • . .·_~o, • _ _ "..----..•...
::~::··.,:-f
.._'_:J~:'~lpayment to the UARo t'cide1tally, !this is
1 S00c~:le~
fotr linkS i -.i
circuit. Th'fthree cE\ncelled ci.r-ctidts linkEj ar~fromcel1
(4,3)
toI . . .."
4;;11'("6,4),
~';om h~~'~ !t~(i;-6)-;~~d~f,~~~--th~,:j~-;;;-(2,l);---~~d
theone--f-!----'--:-~;~ll
. .~~~:~~-.;ii.:~:i_l~~~·~~~~~~~~=~~i3~j5iE(,~:1):~=+::·:::-;,~.:::: -~.::~,.- ... i,:-:-::-:f-cL:::::::-:~j:~~~ij!
~~6. __T:unisiEl.~alao._"l=ltr-uc,ts
Libyaro."~&",,al-!i"-i3.nsf
61:' of :l47--<W,-MoP-0-0<jO'r·':·----·-'-~l
,~~:s;::i::~~~~t
' ' ' ' -~,-';'" --:"\"'" " . , : . : :ao~u~~b~~~oa:~~I;:~~:~~:~~C:~lc~~~3~/~)C:~17~idr-.
, ''':=.' ';·~"::'-:·<-::1"; . ! . '."- .""- c.::;"i
and is dOUbly! underlinjed indioating; that thii' is a paymeni; wi thin the
~ ' . ' j ,
orj,g:i,n.a,1 meaningq:t'.ge,u,1(4,3)·· from:Li):l,Yacto!·Tunisia'.."
EI.CN.14/WP.
".~~,22/
.... 4;Ej ON .14/AW12
Annex .
Page 48
127.. ",J:h)o<jw 6appeg,r a .few
differ~n.d'es,between
com'pensa.tion ,schemes A and.$.
The. debt by I.,iby1> fct][o;rocco;shown in eel! (6,3) ispa:r"£l;r paidi ' ,~' '., - '-" •
bf a'
tr.ansfcerencepf53
fr.omAlgeriato Morocco. on beha:l;;e of' . Libya';; " , ~showrr by"atran,et'er a:rrcw fr4m .. cel1.f3.,5} .bo cell
(6,3;.'"
Ther.esidua'J:"amcU;:Jctpf 199 -i.s a direct payment from Libya to Mdrocc~withi:n,'the ).;
origina;];; mea!J..ing of cell (6,3). Thispaymen t of 199 is "doubly 'under...
=
Li.ned.' Th,epsyment,of73S'from Tunisia to MOrocco whiQhis'" shown <in cell (6,4),isindi~ectly'made.tothe exteht'of 391 byaehort'circuited paym.ent fr.om Lg,bya' ,to the UAR'and:Ls also 'p'artly made by a transfci' , from Libya to MoroCQc.,of, 347 asshdwn' .by
.a
transfer ·arrow. The Alger:Lan debt to Morcocco of,~~ :Lsa,d:Lrect payment by Algeria to jIIIorpcco with:in the,::' .l.._' .. : ... :;,.~eaningof~ell
:,,~;:',', 0,,' ' .'(6,5).'': ,_,.'. ' f··:£0: '_ .:,..\ "l28.Similarily,there :Lsa d.irect payment from Mauritania. to,MOrooco'"
of 34 wi.thin the; 'msahing of cell (6,7)" Thispaymen't:!-scoimnon 'to the '.
compensation. scheme's' A and,Jl. .'"
129;' On the Milis of
tabi~ 14,
the final payments obligations arising under cempen sation scheme can be" drl.t'Wn';:up.;.,
1
.')_.'
TABLE 15 ': "
.. ;:.'
North Africa: Final Payments 01;Jligat i.ona arising under Com:eensat:ion Scheme
:6,
1961~,.
,
.
In US $,1000Sudan' UAR Libya Tunisia
.
Algeria' Morocco liIaurHania 1'.
'.,1••
2 " ',i 3" , '. 4 , 5 • 6 "'1"-:t pH _;Mn-'- .w· lh 'the aecond row of this table, we find in dell '(2,1) the direot 130.
pa'AW-~.~f}j,~73,p;y:,Sudap,;.Lt.ot~e llA:Il,\41.the.sa.lll$.ro\f.
th"i'e, is, a " b • direct· payment by Libya to the UAR of 1965'which is composed' of the·:' ',d.f;'f.ollowing four :payments by .Libya shown.in column 3 of ;tab1e,14~3~L*
:"",.,:,_ .. ' ,.,.~: :,: .; :;~ .Ln:;,:~' ""~ ": ",,", .. .'_. -";";:.".:.' ;'-'.-. ( ' , , - - - ' ' ' 7 ' •• ,_,: •• :''',;
1,500,+35 +39hFu:£thermore row 2 of table 15 shows,a:pii!ymen·t,py
;':ri;rJ' .-c''-',L" .,:~. "i:;-.":~'::'..[ ~:rC ..' "";' ", ... ' . "~'" ;.," . ,
Algefiaof l'to theUAR inc;eLj.(2,5)..',:t"tVf;"-:;'-;,d ~ ".:_ :::""<;,,,-:1 ,c,. • '''',,''', "",', ,,'., ..c,··, Row 4 of tabl, : ' , . ~.":LC:''''''':'
e,,15AhoVTs
.' , aU the .. -~ -"paym~l'f:!'l:l't,81f:lticll. '):'wlisiaia WIt;l.tleq.,it r ecei"!3~ ,519, f:r:olllthe ~d"·'h.
i.LI:'If' ".
L,'...
·:!·<!>:t, .."..., " ,','" . . , -:". ,,'.. - ;';':.' ',';'" ,',,' ._.as shown in co Iumn 1 of table 15, it also receiV\lS 718fromL;i,by?-, as .
•,.'~,,'-'~"" ....),.:j.,~:." . ,'>,," '" , . " . " ' . :.:,,~,:, .,:.-,,"','" ::.:;.;
shown in ge11(4,3)Q1' table 14 and it finally receives 5,n8from
Algeria,
as
snowTiiri\d<in(4i5 Hi1'tabie 14.1I6VT6 iif
table 15 shows , f 'four.
]k\ymen'ts:';:'''Fi:r~t'a
pikymen'i'of .417"b1Sudan, 'as" ~iio-Jn :fn661umn'
1of'ta],j!&)l4~ NeJt't'a
"paylnento!f546 by Libya: ;\0'M6;06c6 campd's"fiJi'
199 and 347 shown in cQhunn06f table 14, Furthermore; a
pay~~hid;
22~~~t.PY. A1e;"¥i!,: to Mor~pqy4;icb.;i1ilOOJll1"<'sBd of''P~l1letrt$ :22,;81}8 +d·53·
both
,Ht.
W'h~ph ,~r,e sg"Vffi::-¥1 o.pJ.l,1;l@5 q~,:table,lA. ,,·;Ii!iJ:!;A;l!ly,-,,;thJiir!i.is,j the. paymen..t,"'- 'by Mauritaniat.oMorp.cqo,pt:: 34, ',-'", ::-:'.. ,'_.... . .·.w:b.;i;;oh,' is,ooll\lllotkto•. both".oompensation scaemes , ." . ' " " . ' ,
_1\,1 i ".,;'. ','t',
1310" ,TaN,!"i,,J,;5
cOllta~ns
,a plargina1 :09ilu,rnn'ancl;?, ,marginal,,,,"owil';ike,.ta'ole 13.. J!h:t+'.l,.jj¥,cin,t,he llli>;!'gin;;.l. ,oolunm' o:t:dtable.:l5. ar-e iden:t,ical: -witjI: the', . " ,,. " . ' " ,
.
entries,,in
.tJ:J,.,
margiitl"1.co1u,rnn .of .ti'\bl'El,13. .:J'husrtlte ,rUARreoeives "5~639 aSfjlllown" ;\.nrow 2 of· tlJ,e m;;r·gi:!:lal cglullltlJW: botlJ,. tables. But in.,0:
table 13 these receipts show a different composi ti.on from the receipte in table 15 • In table 13 the UAjl.
reoeive~
4,669 from Sudan,. 543 frQ\llfYi.,l ',:i:; ::~\;;;:"",-,;,~,:". T .". ,/:',,~: ,,",;i,':-;;'''' '.',:.:. " • , ' " , " , ' " , , '
Libya and 427 from Algeria, totalling 5,639. In table 15 UAR receives
. ' " ' , ,," ;,0,1. ,;;,:);1',' ',:::i ",.', .: '" ·,;::.',,·,l,j" "i.', ':\:i <::"::"',~ -:'. "'.'. ':""':'.,',':
only 3,673 from Sudan, 1;lUt 1,965 from Liby?- .and pnly. l fro!!, Algeria~ .
,.1() ,,,: '"LL,~'i'i)l{; -2::?<:~"t " ..;,', "":i -.r. ,'-.i;":.k,:,r... ."," ,-<.: 1,';;'·.'l ',', '..',."'\', ,:,,: ..,~ :':", "
These three payments also total 5,639., ,," The tVTO compensation scheme.!?,..." , ' " ,.,.,..'
A.;md B resul t in the UAR receiving th~ .s~me tQ tal money, but they
differ in'tlil!';soul'tikls'iYromwb.iCh .
ulill r'eo~~v';;sthe sam~'i6tarJ~Yinet1i;. ,I'.,
:'." "' ;.)"t}.;:j;": j j(""~r t;::'~:' '~~i~,"' . , : .:") ,',;J' .-,,!'x .' '-: . ,i', .'~ ,'\(j,r ;;. ":;';;,.-:{;" .. ,. ,~,~,;.J,,:'...L,y\:
132.
~e~;,~¥o"~~Y~818gtb&ab,,~~sI H Ii~* *~'i~tf~e~e.s ty,t~e,,,?9m~osi
j;iPtlof
~!>~.~~;~~,p~iY,T'inJJgfl~Slt'8~~i?,~,~$H~,i~,!lnH~t,e.d, t9:s~~e~v~.
:rn<tap1e 13 i;l; ,is SlJ,OWh that'l'W;1isia receiveS! 2,017 from L~'bya and.
5,P58
from Algeri", in table 15 itis
'shown that Tunisia .reoeives 579.-rI