• Aucun résultat trouvé

How to Answer in English to Questions Asked in French: by Exploiting Results from Several Sources of Information

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Partager "How to Answer in English to Questions Asked in French: by Exploiting Results from Several Sources of Information"

Copied!
8
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

& '( )+*-, /.10 2 24356 87"

9:';<33=:6 >

?9@BADCECGFH@BIKJ:LNMO@BPRQSAECUTBVWFHXYF[Z\CD]^FH_`JbacTBLdPeAEfOAD_g_`J:?9PRFH@hTi?FOaBPeADJjC5klCDCEMO@BX2T

m

FO@BPRF[nMOoipbJjFH@Bq=TksreFHatJbCECDJ:uvMOaBaiFKFOoiQ/woBoBJxADCEoiF^_

m ksu1fOPeMO@iyhT m ksn{zSk}|s~Nuz=TiL€ƒ‚j„2„(…i‚b†2‡2„[ˆPRr`FŠ‰/~dJYQSJ‹q

ŒBRŽb‘’^“•”H–—W’H“•”H˜N™EšD“›Ž`š‘–œ

ž:Ÿ5 R¡R¢‹£ ¤Y¡

¥ M:ai@BADCGQ›M2@BP\aBAECEADoBf2@iFHC=r`‰rg_`JjI¦T2§NJrg_eFOPg_©¨ªPeMOI«_`¬iJIKMOoBM2CDAEoBf2@iFHC5­9w m ~®r`‰Srs_eJbI¦T§¯¬BAEpR¬

¬iFOr(yiFHP`_`AGp‹AEyiFH_`JjQ$_`M yBP`JYp‹JYQSADoif ¥ uvZ~±°›Jj²^FHCE@iF^_eADM2oirb³ˆ@BP[atJjrg_[PeJjr`@BCD_er[§dJjP`J/MOaS_RFHAEoBJjQ

§¯¬BJbo®§dJ¦pR¬BM2r`J;_eM _eFH]2J;_e¬BJFOQS²AGp‹J8MH¨r`Jb²2JbPRFHCrgJYFHPRpR¬BJjrj³$V´AEPRrs_YT\§NJ8r`JjFOPepR¬"¨ªM2PKFOoir`§dJjPer

ADo<FPeJbCEAGFHaBCEJ;QSMSp‹@BIKJjo2_[p‹MOCECEJjpµ_eADM2ohT¶FHoiQ$r`JjpbMOoiQ"M2o"_`¬BJ;· Jbac³·>J•_`Pe‰_`M{IKFOADo _RFHAEo"_`¬BAGr

rs_ePeFH_`Jbf2‰OTFHoiQ8QSJj²OJbCEMOy•_s§dM[Pe@Boirj³ ¥ ¬iJ¸WPerg_NM2oBJ9AEr¯F(oBJb§1²OJjPer`ADM2o;MH¨¹MO@BP¯r`‰Srs_eJbIºAEoip‹CE@iQSAEoBf

I»@BCD_`AECDAEoBf2@iFHC©F2rgytJjp‹_erj³(wvoiMH_`¬iJbP:FHyiyBP`M FOpR¬MO¨\_e¬BJ›I»@BCD_`AECEADoBf2@BAGrgI¼yiP`M2aBCDJjI¼AGr9_`M8_`PRFHoir`CGF^_`J

_`¬BJ[½2@iJjrg_`AEMOo>FOoiQ¦_e¬BJbo FHyByBCE‰¦MO@BP9IKMOoBM2CDAEoBf2@iFHC¹rg‰Srg_`JbI¦T=AEoip‹CE@iQSAEoBf¦F•r`JjFHPRpR¬MH¨¾_e¬BJ[·>Jjah³

ˆ@BP:rgJYp‹M2oiQ{Pe@Bo"PeJjr`@BC¿_RrMH¨¯F¦p‹MOI(aBAEoiF^_eADM2o>MO¨d_e¬BAEr:CEF2rs_:PeJjr`@BCD_erFHoWQ{_e¬BM2r`J[¨ªP`M2I¼_e¬BJK¸iPRrs_

P`@Boc³ ¥ ¬BJ›PeJjr`@BC¿_Rr§dJ›M2aS_eFOADoiJjQ"p‹M2oS¸iPeIÀ_`¬BJ;¨ÁFOpµ__e¬iF^__e¬BJ;atJjrg_:P`JYrg@iC¿_Rr:FHPeJKMOaS_RFHAEoBJjQ a‰

p‹MOI(aBAEoiF^_eADM2o•MH¨¾QSADÂtJjP`Jjo _rgM2@BPepbJjrNMH¨¹ADoB¨ªMOPeIKFH_`AEMOoh³

à ÄhÅKƹǾÈ;ÉʦËNƾ̋È(Å

ˆytJboS|lQSMOI›FOADo8­@iJjrg_`AEMOoS|lwvoir`§NJbPeADoBf;Í}­9wΩAErNF:f2P`M^§¯AEoBf:FHPeJjF:MH¨hPeJjr`JjFHPRpR¬K§¯¬BM2r`JFOADIÏAGr©_eM:¸ioWQ;yBPeJjpbAEr`J

FHoWrg§NJbPRrt_`M½ @BJYrs_eADM2oir5AEo:oiFH_`@BPRFHCHCGFHoifO@iFOfOJOTj@BoBCEAD]2J\r`JjFHPRpR¬9JboBf2ADoBJYr=_`¬WF^_´PeJ‹_e@BPeoQBMpb@BIKJbo _erj³c·¬iJbo_`¬iM2r`J

JboifOAEoBJjr©FOCEr`MPeJ‹_`@iP`o›r`oBADyiyWJb_erjT F2r\?9MMOfOCEJjÐHTO_e¬BJb‰KFHAEIÑFH_©yBPeM^² AGQSAEoBf:FNÒs@irg_`AD¸WpbFH_`AEMOo›MO¨=QSMSpb@BIKJbo _er\PeFH_`¬BJjP

_`¬WFHo¯Òs@irg_¶fOAE² AEoBf_`¬BJdyWMO_`Jbo _eAEFOC FOoirg§NJbPY³¹ˆoBJNpR¬iFHCECEJboBf2J©ADo»_`¬BAGrc¸iJbCGQ»pbMOoir`AErg_ercADo»¸ioiQSAEoBfMOoBCE‰MOoBJNFHoir`§dJjP

§¯¬BAECDJatJbAEoBf$r`@SÓ;p‹AEJbo _`CE‰®pbMOoS¸WQBJbo _›ADo-AD_j³ ¥ ¬BJr`Jjp‹M2oiQ®yWM r`r`ADaiADCEA¿_s‰2TNpbMOPeP`JYrgytMOoWQSADoif{_eM>_e¬BJFHyiyBP`M FOpR¬

§NJ;QSJb²2JbCEMOytJjQ ADo®­9w m ~T´MO@BP:IKM2oBMOCEADoifO@iFOC©½2@iJjrg_`AEMOo<FHoWrg§NJbPeADoif8r`‰Srs_eJbI¦T¹pbMOoir`AGrs_RrADo$JYrs_eADI›FH_`AEoBf_`¬iJ

PeJbCEAEFOaBADCEAD_s‰{MH¨¯FHo$FOoirg§NJbPa‰ r`pbMOPeADoBf8AD_(FOpjp‹MOPRQSAEoBf8_`M¦_e¬BJ;]ADoWQ>MO¨N]oBM^§¯CEJjQBfOJKMOP_e¬BJ›]ADoWQ"MH¨yBP`MSpbJjrer

@ir`JjQ5³¹· J¨ªMO@BoiQ»_`¬WF^_©yBPeM^²AEQSAEoBfdÒs@irg_¾FOo(JjoiQSM2fOJboiMO@ir¹Jjrg_`AEI›F^_eADM2o(§FOr¹oBMO_\rg@SÓ;pbADJjo2_Y³ ¥ ¬@irjTH§NJ¯QSJjpbAEQSJYQ

_`M/FHyByBCE‰8MO@BPr`‰Srs_eJbIÔMOoFHoiMH_`¬iJbPr`MO@BPRp‹JMO¨¾] oiM^§¯CDJYQSfOJAEoMOPRQSJbPv_`M;p‹M2oS¨ªPeMOo _v_`¬iJ:P`JYrg@iC¿_Rr¯yBPeM^² AGQSJYQ/a‰

atMH_`¬8rgM2@BPRp‹Jjrj³¹·>J9pR¬BM2r`Jv_e¬BJbo•_`M:¨ÁFŠ²2MO@BPNp‹M2I[IKM2o;yBPeMOytM2r`A¿_eADM2oir©M^²2JbP©@BoiAE½ @BJ9MOoBJYrbT Jb²2Jbo;AD¨h_e¬BJjr`JCGF^_`_`JbP

¬iF2Q(F9¬BAEfO¬Kr`pbMOPeJO³cwr©r`@ipR¬»PeJjF2rgM2oBADoifatJ‹_`_`JbP©FOyByBCEADJYr¶A¿¨W_`¬BJvr`MO@iPepbJjr´MH¨=] oiM^§¯CDJYQSfOJNFHPeJNQSADÂ=JbPeJbo _©JboBM2@BfO¬cT

§NJpR¬iM2r`J_e¬BJ· JbaFOr¯r`JjpbMOoiQ8r`MO@BPRp‹J2³¶nMOPeJbM^²OJjPjT _e¬BJ:QSAE²OJbPRr`A¿_s‰;MO¨c_e¬BJ·>JjaFHoiQ/AD_er¯PeJjQS@ioiQBFHoWp‹‰•atMH_e¬

CEJjFOQ _eM¸ioiQ$FCDMO_»MH¨vFHoWrg§NJbPRrbT¹FOr§NJ•pjFHo<r`JbJ›AD_(AEoÖÕnFOfOoBAEoBA5Jb_FHC‘³\×H‡O‡ ×HFjØ}TÕnFOfOoBAEoBA5J‹_FOCU³\×O‡O‡ ×^a ؑT

ÕÙ~dCEFOP`]2JJb_FHC‘³\×H‡O‡i‚RØiFHoiQ8ÕLdPeAECDC5Jb_FHC‘³\×H‡O‡i‚Rؑ³

¥

¬BJyBPeMOaBCEJbIÚAEr¹_eMF2QBFHyB_¹_e¬BAGr¾rs_ePeFH_`Jbf2‰ADoKI(@BC¿_eADCEAEoBfO@BAGrg_`AGp

p‹M2o _`J‹q_Y³N·¬WF^_¬iF2rvatJbJjo{r`FOAEQ(Òs@irg_atJ‹¨ªM2P`J2TB_e¬BJ»AEo _`JbPeJjrg_vMH¨¶_e¬BJ»· JbaAGrvAD_erP`JYQS@BoiQiFHoipb‰OTiai@S__e¬BAErv¨ÁFOp‹_

AGr(M2oBCE‰>_eP`@iJ/AEo®Z\oBfOCEAEr`¬hT\F2r»yiP`M^²2JjQ"a‰‚O³

¥

¬@irjT¾_`¬BJ¦¬iFŠ²2J›_`M"r`JjFHPRpR¬$_e¬BJ8Z\oBfOCEAGrg¬<· JbacT©_`M>MOaS_RFHAEo

r`ADf2oBA¿¸tpbFHo _:PeJjr`@BCD_erj³/· J•QSJYp‹AGQSJ›_`¬iJbo"_`M_`Pe‰_s§NMrs_ePeFH_`Jbf2ADJYrKÛ(M2oBJ;p‹M2oir`AErg_erAEo<FHoWFHCE‰ XjADoif/_e¬BJ•ViP`JjoipR¬

½ @BJjrg_`AEMOocTHFHoiQ»_`¬BJjo»_ePeFOoir`CEFH_`J©_e¬BJKÜgAEo _`JbPeJjrg_`AEoBfyiFHP`_ereÝMO¨iAD_¹_eM@WrgJN_`¬iJbo(_`¬BAGr´_`PRFHoir`CEFH_`JYQ_`JjP`I›r´_`Mr`JjFOPepR¬

_`¬iJ¯P`Jb¨ªJbPeJboipbJpbMOCECDJYpµ_eADM2o(MO¨=QSMSpb@BIKJbo _erj³ ¥ ¬iAEr¾§¯¬WF^_©§NJN§¯AECECipbFOCDCS¨ª@iPg_e¬BJbP¶_e¬BJvI»@iC¿_eADCEADoifO@iFOCSI[MSQS@iCDJ2³ ¥ ¬iJ

r`Jjp‹M2oiQ/MOoBJp‹M2oirgAGrg_erAEo•_ePeFOoirgCGF^_eADoif(_e¬BJ½ @BJjrg_`AEMOo8ADoZ\oBfOCEAEr`¬;_e¬iFHoi]rN_eM[_`¬BJ¬BJjCDy8MH¨©~NZ\w§¯¬BJjP`J_`¬iJbPeJ

Þsß´àhá5â•ãsäRåRæÙç^åeèUéÙêµëŠì¶åRíUã¾î`åRï¯ðŠåRéÙñµëŠìhêµí‘ñ‹åRëŠéÙìUãgò9óbôvèUõŠã©ö´÷Áøjß¾ù^õ‹èÁè‘ð ùúµú`èUí‘ãsîµûëŠéÙìÁè`ûñµêgä

üeõbèÁè‘ð2ùúµú`ýcýhý©ûñµêbêµñµæÙã‹ûîsêµï

(2)

¥

AGrFOoFOpbpbJjrer¯_eM/F›yBPeMH¨ªJYr`r`AEMOoiFOCc²OJjPer`AEMOo¦MH¨dz‰Srg_`PRFHoO³

¥

¬BJjohT=§dJ»pjFHo{FOyByBCE‰¦MO@BPJ‹qSAErg_`AEoBf;IKM2oBMOCEADoifO@iFOC

r`‰rg_`JjI¦T¹AEoipbCD@iQBADoBf{_`¬BJ•·>JjargJYFHPRpR¬h³ ¥ ¬BJ;¸WPerg_(rg_`PRF^_`JjfO‰>fOAE²OJjr»MO@BP:¸iPerg_»Pe@BohT¶_e¬BJ•r`Jjp‹M2oiQ"MOoiJ;AEr»_`¬iJ

p‹M2I»aBAEoiFH_`AEMOo{MO¨©_`¬iJ[I(@BCD_`AECDAEoBfO@WFHC‘TcFHoiQ_`¬BJ[_s§NM/IKM2oBMOCEADoifO@iFOC´PeJjr`@BCD_erKͪM2aS_eFOADoBJYQAEo{_e¬BJ›p‹M2CDCEJjp‹_`AEMOohT5M2P

MOo/_`¬iJ·>JjaWε³

w¯¨_eJbP:AEo _`PeMSQS@ip‹AEoBfM2@BP»rg_`@iQS‰>MOo _`¬iJ;I»@BCD_`AECEADoBf2@BAGrgI¦T¶§dJ›§¯AECEC©yBPeJjr`Jbo __`¬BJ•fOCEMOaiFOC©FHPRpR¬BA¿_eJjp‹_`@BPeJKMH¨

MO@iPvrg‰Srg_`JbI¦TBFOoiQ/_`¬BJjo¦QBJ‹_eFOADC=_e¬BJI»@iC¿_eADCEADoifO@iFOCcrg‰Srg_`JjI8³

ÊRƾÌjÌbÅ(ÊÌ ÉÌÇÅ[ƦǾÈË

¥ M{atJ/FHaiCDJ•_`M>QBJjFHCN§¯AD_`¬<I(@BC¿_eADCEAEoBfO@BAGr`I8TdrgJj²OJbPRFHCdrgM2CD@S_eADM2oir[FHPeJ;yWM r`r`AEaBCDJ2³ ¥ ¬BJ•¸iPRrs_[MOoBJ8p‹MOoWrgAGrs_Rr:AEo

_`PRFHoWrgCGF^_eADoBf>_`¬iJ¦½ @BJYrs_eADM2oh³ ¥ ¬iJ¦F2QS²^FHo _eFOfOJ8AEr(_e¬iF^_›_e¬BJ¦I[M2oBMOCEAEoBfO@iFOC¯rg‰Srg_`JbI I›FŠ‰"_e¬BJbo-atJ¦FOyByBCEADJYQ

§¯AD_`¬BM2@S_;FHo‰$IKMQBA¿¸WpjF^_eADM2oh³ ¥ ¬BJ¦I›F^ÒsM2P(yiP`M2aBCDJjI AGr»_e¬iF^_K_e¬BAEr›FO@S_`M2I›F^_`AGp•_`PRFHoir`CEFH_`AEMOo pbFHoioBMH_›rgM2CD²2J

QSAGr`FOI»aBAEfO@WF^_`AEMOo›yiP`M2aBCDJjI›r\AEo•M2yWJjoS|}QBMOI›FHAEo•½ @BJjrg_`AEMOoB|}FOoirg§NJbPeAEoBf:rg‰Srg_`JjIKrj³¶k}_NAGrd_`¬BJr`MOCE@S_`AEMOo;§NJF2QSMOyB_

FOr¶F9aiF2rgAGpNCDAEoBJN¨ªMOP¶_e¬BJ~dCDJb¨=‡O†9pjFHIKyiFHAEfOoc³ ¥ ¬BJ¯r`Jjp‹M2oiQ»r`MOCE@S_eADM2o(AGr¹_`M9_`PRFHoWrgCGF^_eJ\_e¬BJvp‹M2I[yiCDJb_`J¯p‹M2CDCEJjp‹_`AEMOo

MH¨hQSMSpb@BIKJbo _erj³¶kloK_`¬BAGr\pjFOr`JOTH_e¬BJv_ePeFOoir`CEFH_`AEMOo[IKFŠ‰[atJvfO@BAGQSJYQKa ‰(_`¬iJp‹M2o2_eJ‹q_jT2_`¬iJrg‰Srg_`JjIÑQSMJYrgo_\¬iFŠ²2J

_`M¦atJ•pR¬iFOoBfOJYQ5³ ¥ ¬iJ;p‹MOCECEJjpµ_eADM2o>oiJbJjQiro{_eADIKJYrA¿_RrAEoBA¿_eAEFOC©CEJboBfO_`¬ ¨ªMOPo CEFOoBfO@WFHfOJYr›wÑIKMOPeJ›QSA¿Ó;pb@BC¿_

ytMOAEo2_AGryWM rgJYQ{a‰¦_e¬BJ›ADIKytM2rergAEaBAECDAD_s‰¦_`M8_ePeFOoirgCGF^_eJ»_e¬BJ›· Jba ¥ ¬BJKCEF2rs_:r`MOCE@S_`AEMOo>AEr9_eM¦yBP`MSpbJbJjQ_`M8_`¬iJ

FHoWFHCE‰r`AGrvMH¨¾_e¬BJ(½ @BJYrs_eADM2oAEo_`¬BJKr`MO@BPRp‹J:CGFHoifO@iFOfOJ;ÍÁViP`JjoipR¬¨ªM2P@irRεT5FHoWQ¦_`M•_`PRFHoir`CEFH_`J_e¬BJ[ADoS¨ªM2P`I›FH_`AEMOo

AGr`r`@BJjQ•¨ªPeMOIÏ_`¬iJFOoiFHCE‰SrgAGrj³´klo/_`¬BAGrvr`MOCE@S_`AEMOocT §NJQSMOo__`Pe‰›_`MKM2aS_eFOADo8F[pbMOIKyBCEJ‹_eJ_ePeFOoirgCGF^_eADM2ohTaB@S_¯MOoiCD‰

_`¬iJ_eJbPeI›rN_`¬iFH_¯FOP`Jp‹M2oir`AEQSJjP`JYQ•F2rADIKytMOP`_eFHo _vF^¨_eJbPN_`¬iJ:FHoiFOCD‰Sr`AErNFHPeJ_ePeFOoir`CEFH_`JjQh³¹k}_vAGrN_`¬iJr`MOCE@S_eADM2o•§NJ

FOQBMOyS_¨ªMOP9MO@BP9I»@BCD_`AECEADoBf2@iFHC¹IKMSQS@BCEJO³k}_9AGr_`¬BAGrI[MSQS@iCDJ(_`¬iFH_9§NJ(QBJ‹_eFOADC¶AEo_`¬iJ»¨ªM2CDCEM^§¯ADoif•yiFOPeFOfOPRFHyB¬irjT

F^¨_eJbP¯yBPeJjr`Jbo _eADoBf›FOo/M^²2JbPe² AEJb§ MH¨c_e¬BJ(­9w

m

~Ör`‰Srs_eJbI¦³

!vÇ"/Ì$# È%'& ÊRƶÌ(bÌjÅ(Ê)+*-,/.10

¥

¬BJKfOCEMOaWFHC¾FHPRpR¬BAD_`Jjp‹_`@BPeJ[MH¨©_e¬BJ/­9w

m

~r`‰rg_`JjIÀAErAECECD@irg_`PRF^_eJjQ V¹ADf2@BP`J›×S³KV¹ADPRrg_jThAD_er½ @BJYrs_eADM2o>FHoWFHCE‰r`AGr

IKMSQS@BCEJFOADI›r¯FH_QSJYQS@ipbADoBf›pR¬iFOPeF2pµ_eJbPeAErg_`AGpbrd¬BJbCEyBAEoBf[_`M(¸ioiQ8ytM2rergAEaBCEJ9FOoirg§NJbPRrNADo¦r`JbCEJjpµ_eJjQ•yiFOrer`FOfOJYrdFOoiQ

_`M›PeJ‹¨ªM2P`I(@BCGF^_`J½ @BJYrs_eADM2oir¯AEo¦F›QBJjp‹CGFHPRF^_eAD²2J9¨ªMOPeIº_`¬iFH_AGr¯fOAE²OJjo/_eMK_`¬BJ:r`JjFOPepR¬8JboifOAEoBJ;ÍU?9MMOf2CDJŠÎµ³ ¥ ¬iJjr`J

pR¬iFOPeF2pµ_`JjP`AGrg_`AGpbr©FOP`J_`¬BJ½ @BJjrg_`AEMOo›¨ªMSpb@irbT _e¬BJI›FOADo;²2JbPea•FHoWQ;rg‰o _eF2pµ_eAEpP`JjCEFH_`AEMOoir©¨ªMOPNI[MSQSAD¸iJjPerj³¶k}_NAGr\M2o

_`¬iJjr`J»JbCEJbIKJjo2_Rr¯_e¬iF^_9§dJ¨ªMSpb@irM2@BP¯_ePeFOoirgCGF^_eADM2oJ‹Â=MOP`_erjTWF2rvJ‹qSyBCGFHAEoBJYQADo¦_e¬BJ»oiJ‹q_9r`Jjp‹_`AEMOoh³ViMOP9~ m Z\V

‡H†;pjFHIKyiFOADf2ohTB§NJ:QSJb²2JbCEMOy8_s§dM›²2JbPRrgAEMOoWrMH¨¶_`¬BAGrvIKMSQS@BCEJ›ÛNMOoBJ¨ªM2P½ @BJjrg_`AEMOo¦AEoVBPeJboipR¬hTtFHoiQ8_e¬BJ:MO_`¬BJjP

2 øjðHãgîséåRæèUõ^åRë43bì´èUê65¹æÙéäYéÙãsí7^ãsí‘íUãsè98Dí‘êµï â5á;:=<>7^í‘ãsëŠî‘õ:â=ãgë‹èUãgí98Eêµí9:5è‘êµï¯éÙî¹átëŠãsí‘ñRô4?hýcõŠêNðŠí‘êgäYéÙòŠãsì´çŠìcèUõŠãsì‘ã¾èUí}åRëŠìUæåA@

(3)

ks€¶Ti_`¬BJ(P`M2aB@irg_rg‰o _eF2pµ_eAEpyWFHPRrgJjP¯MH¨vÕOØ}³vVBM2P¯_`¬iJ(FHoWFHCE‰r`AGrMH¨¶_`¬BJ»_`PRFHoir`CGF^_`JYQ¦½2@iJjrg_`AEMOohTW§dJ:@WrgJ:ksV¾zS€¶T

_`¬iJyBP`JYp‹JYQSADoif(PeMOaB@Wrs_¯rg‰o _eF2pµ_eAEp9yiFOPer`JbPMH¨ÕOØ}³d­@BJjP`AEJjrFHPeJ9oBMH__`¬iJ:r`FOI[J¨ªMOP_e¬BJ·>JjargJYFHPRpR¬/FHoWQ;¨ªM2P

w­wks

¥

rgJYFHPRpR¬>ÍÁw­wvks

¥

AGrN_`¬BJPeJ‹¨ªJjP`Jjoip‹J

¥

uvZN~Öp‹M2CDCEJjp‹_`AEMOoW΋³¹klo/_`¬iJCEFH_g_`JjPvpbF2rgJ2T §NJ@ir`Jn>?

¨ªMOPP`Jb_`PeADJj²ADoBf›yWFOrer`FOfOJjr¯¨ªP`M2IÔF;½ @BJjP`‰8I›FOQSJ»§¯A¿_e¬{wÑFOoiQ{ˆ9uMOytJbPRF^_eMOPRrb³¯ViMOP½ @BJjP`‰AEoBf›_e¬BJ»· JbahT

§NJvpR¬BM2r`J_`M»r`JboWQ›FoBJjFOP`CE‰»JbqSF2pµ_©¨ªM2P`I(@BCGF^_`AEMOo[MH¨=_e¬BJFOoirg§NJbP©F2r`r`@BIKAEoBf_`¬iFH_©_`¬iJv·>Jja;PeJjQS@BoWQBFHoipb‰»§¯AECDC

FHCE§FŠ‰rNyBPeM^²AEQBJ9QSMSpb@BIKJbo _erj³

V´AEfO@iP`J:×SÛ

¥

¬iJ(­9w

m

~Örg‰Srg_`JjI

u¯Jb_`PeADJj²OJjQ$QBMpb@BIKJbo _erjT¯‚O‡O‡yWFOrer`FOfOJjr:§¯A¿_e¬®n{?ÍÁMOow­wvks

¥

Î(FHoWQ×H‡>QSMSp‹@BIKJbo _Rr:¨ªPeMOI _`¬iJ

· JbahTSFHPeJ¯_e¬BJbo;yiP`MSp‹JYr`r`JjQh³ ¥ ¬BJj‰›FHPeJvP`Jb|‘AEoiQSJbqSJjQKa‰»_e¬BJ½ @BJYrs_eADM2o›_`JjP`I›rdFHoiQK_e¬BJbAEPN²ŠFOP`AGFHo _RrbT2P`JjMOPRQSJbPeJjQ

FOpjp‹M2PeQSAEoBf»_`MK_`¬iJ9]AEoiQ8MH¨´_`JbPeI›rN¨ªMO@BoWQ•AEo8_`¬BJjI8TWrgMKFOrN_eMKr`JbCEJjp‹_vF[r`@Bair`J‹_¯MO¨c_`¬iJbI AEo8_`¬BJpjFOr`J9MO¨¹n{?[T

_`¬iJ•· JbaQSMSpb@BIKJbo _er(aWJjADoif{FHCECd]2JbyS_Y³FOI[JYQ$Jbo _eA¿_s‰ P`JYp‹M2fOoBAD_`AEMOo$yBPeMSp‹JYr`r`Jjr:FOP`JK_e¬BJbo®FHyByBCEAEJjQ5³ ¥ ¬iJ

FHoWrg§NJbP9J‹q_`PRFOp‹_`AEMOo>yBP`MSpbJjrerPeJbCEAEJjr9MOo"F•§NJbAEfO¬ _eADoBf¦repR¬BJbIKJ[MH¨\_e¬BJ›rgJjo _`JboWp‹JjrjT5¨ªM2CDCEM^§dJYQa‰¦_`¬iJ;FHoir`§dJjP

J‹q_ePeF2pµ_`AEMOoAD_er`JbCD¨s³9·>JKFHyByiCD‰QSADÂtJjP`Jjo _yBPeMSp‹Jjrer`JjrvF2pbp‹M2PeQBADoBf;_`M;_e¬BJ»]AEoiQMO¨©J‹qSytJjpµ_eJjQFOoir`§dJjPjTtJjF2pR¬MH¨

_`¬iJbI CEJjF2QSAEoBf8_`MyBPeMOytM2r`J[FOoir`§dJjPer9§¯AD_`¬$F¦§dJjADf2¬ _j³ ¥ ¬BJK¸ioiFOC©rs_eJby͝¨ªM2PMO@BP:r`JjpbMOoiQ>Pe@BoWÎp‹M2oir`AErg_erAEo

p‹M2IKyiFHPeADoif•_e¬BJ›P`JYrg@iC¿_RrAErerg@iJjQ>¨ªP`M2I w­wks ¥ T5¨ªPeMOI¼_`¬BJ›· JbaÖͪ¨ªMOP_`¬iJK_`PRFHoir`CEFH_`JYQ>½ @BJYrs_eADM2oireÎ9FOoiQ

_`¬iJ•PeJjr`@BC¿_RrAGr`r`@BJjQ$¨ªP`M2I _e¬BJ;I»@iC¿_eADCEADoifO@iFOCdr`‰rg_`JjI¦T¶FOoiQ$p‹M2IKyB@S_`AEoBf F¦¸ioiFOCdrep‹MOPeJO³8k}_er(yBPeADoWp‹AEyBCDJ•§NF2r

_`M/aWMM rs_FHo{FOoir`§dJjPAD¨dFHCECc_e¬BJKpR¬iFHAEoirPeFOoB]OJYQ¦A¿_ADo{_`¬BJ(_`M2y ›yiP`M2yWM rgAD_`AEMOoirjT=Jb²2Jbo§¯AD_`¬>P`JjCEFH_`AE²OJbCE‰8CDM^§

rep‹MOPeJjrj³

Ç:Å "9ƶÌbÈ(Å È!%Æ" Ì È(ǹÆ:Å[ÆÔÆvÇ

A¿Â=JbPeJbo _»IKJ‹_e¬BMSQBr:FOP`JKytM2rergAEaBCEJK_`MyBPeMSp‹JbJYQ>_`M¦_`¬iJK_`PRFHoir`CEFH_`AEMOo §dJ›oiJbJjQh³ ¥ ¬BJ›atJjrg_»PeJjr`@BC¿_RrI›FŠ‰{atJ

MOaB_eFHAEoBJYQ•a‰/FKQSJjJby8_`PRFHoWrgCGF^_eADM2ohTSaiFOr`JjQ/MOo¦r`JbI›FHo _`AGp9fOPRFHIKI›FHPRrbTM2o2_eMOCEMOf2ADJYrb³E³D³¹aB@S__`¬BJPeJj½ @BAEP`JYQ;_eMMOCGr

QSM¦oBMO_:J‹qSAErg_:AEo M2yWJjoS|lQSMOI›FHAEoh³›wvIKM2oBf8_`¬BJ›MO_`¬BJjP_`PRFHoir`CEFH_`AEMOo yWM r`r`AEaBADCEAD_`AEJjrjTc§NJKpbMOoir`AGQSJbP_e¬BJ›JjF2rgAEJjrg_

MOoiJOT §¯¬BAEpR¬;pbMOoir`AGrs_Rr©AEo›@irgAEoBf»F:aBADCEAEoBfO@iFOCtQBAEp‹_`AEMOoiFOP`‰»_`M_ePeFOoirgCGF^_eJ¯_`¬iJv_`JjP`I›r©¨ªP`M2IÚ_e¬BJr`MO@BPRp‹J¯CGFHoifO@iFOfOJ

_`M{_`¬BJ/_eFOP`f2J‹_`_`JjQ<MOoBJ2³

¥

¬iAErKr`ADIKyBCEJ•IKJ‹_e¬BMSQ<yBPeJjr`Jbo _Rr:_s§NM{yBPeMOaiCDJjIKr/Û;AD_[AGr(ADIKytM2rergAEaBCEJ•_eM>QSAEP`JYpµ_eCD‰

QSAGr`FOI»aBAEfO@WF^_`J»_`¬BJK²^FHPeAEMO@irIKJjFHoiADoBf rMO¨©_`¬iJ[§NMOPRQBr_`M/_`PRFHoir`CGF^_`J2T5FHoiQ_`¬BJ[_s§NM•CGFHoBf2@iFHf2JjrvI(@irg_atJ[MH¨

Jj½ @BAE²^FHCEJbo _CEJ‹qSAGpbFOC´PeAEpR¬ioBJjrerb³

¥

¬BAGrCGFOrg_9pbMOoirg_`PRFHAEo _AGr²2JbPeA¿¸iJYQ¦¨ªMOP_`¬iJK×^|‘@ByiCDJ»Z\oBfOCEAGrg¬HVBPeJboipR¬cTW§NJ»§¯AECDC

p‹M2oir`AEQSJjP¯_`¬iAErI[Jb_`¬BMSQ5³

¥

M›fOAE²OJ(FHo¦AEQBJjF›MO¨¹_e¬BJ»FOI»aBAEfO@BAD_`AEJjr§dJI›FŠ‰8JboipbMO@Bo _eJbPvAEoF/­9wp‹M2o _`J‹q_YTi§NJ

rg_`@iQS‰ _e¬BJ8pbMOPeyB@ir»MH¨¯_`¬iJ{‚2…O„ ¥ uZN~«½ @BJjrg_`AEMOoir(AEoZ©oBf2CDAGr`¬h³>wv¨_`JbPKFHoWFHCE‰r`AGrbT¶§NJ•]OJjJby<…2‡O‡O‡MH¨¯_`¬iJ

‚2×H†»§NMOPRQBrN@irgJYQ•AEo8_`¬BAGr¯p‹M2P`yi@irb³ ¥ ¬BJIKJjFOo/MO¨´_e¬BJo@BI»atJbP¯MO¨¹IKJjFOoBAEoBf2rNAGr³„•³ ¥ ¬BJJ‹q_`PeJbI›F[FHPeJ

‚KͪJ‹qBFOI[yiCDJ[Û "!#%$"&'Á΁FHoiQ(H…8ͪJbqSFOIKyBCDJ[Û*)+""&,B΋³©wvPeMO@BoiQ;_`¬BJIKJjFOo•²^FHCE@BJ2TS§dJ¸ioiQ•§dM2PeQBrNr`@ipR¬

FOr.-/# 0+1.) 21.'3!&'4# 0&56#%W³ ¥ ¬@irjTW§NJ»pbFOoBoBMO_p‹MOoWrgAGQSJbP9F;QSAGpµ_eADM2oiFHPe‰•f2AD²AEoBf›MOoBCE‰8MOoBJ:IKJYFHoBAEoBf›¨ªM2P

F[§dM2PeQhTSaB@S_v§NJ9oiJbJjQ/_eMKQBJ‹¸ioBJ:F[IKJjF2rg@iP`JMH¨´_`¬BJ²^FOCD@BJMO¨¹F[_ePeFOoirgCGF^_eADM2o•AEo¦MO@BP­9wp‹M2o _`J‹q_Y³

·AD_`¬K_`¬iJjr`JvyiFHPRFHIKJb_`JbPRrjT^§dJrg_`@WQS‰:_e¬BJQSADÂtJjP`Jjo _dQSAGpµ_`AEMOoWFHPeADJYr¶§dJvI›FŠ‰:@WrgJ:Û´_`¬iJvMOoBCEAEoBJvQSAGpµ_`AEMOoWFHPeADJYr

7/8:9 8 9

(4)

_`¬iJ»QSAGpµ_`AEMOoWFHPeADJYr@BoiQSJjP9?€ m CEAGp‹JboWp‹Jjr»ÍÁr`@ipR¬FOrvn{FHfOAGpµ|AEp:° :MOPoBAGQSAEpO³ ¥ ¬BJMOoBCEAEoBJ»QSAGpµ_eADM2oiFHPeADJYr¯FHPeJ

fOJjoBJbPRFHCECE‰¦pbMOIKyBCEJ‹_eJO³:LN@S_9_`¬BJj‰P`JYrgM2CD²2J:_`¬iJ[FOI»aBAEfO@BAD_s‰"Ûv_e¬BJb‰M2oBCE‰8f2AD²2J»M2oBJ»_ePeFOoir`CEFH_`AEMOo¨ªM2P9F/§dM2PeQhT

FHoWQ_`¬@irQSM/oBMH_PeJjr`yWJYpµ_MO@BPrgytJjpbA¿¸tpbF^_eADM2oh³wvoBMO_`¬BJjPCDAEIKA¿_RF^_`AEMOo>AEr_e¬BJ»¨ÁF2pµ_9_`¬iFH_§dJ[pbFHoioBMH_IKMQBA¿¨ª‰

_`¬iJjr`JKQBAEp‹_`AEMOoiFOP`AEJjrjT5FHoiQ_`¬iFH_§NJ[¬iFŠ²OJ(_`M¦QSJjFOC¶§¯A¿_e¬ r`MOIKJ(_`JjpR¬ioBAEpjFHC¾p‹M2oirg_`PRFHAEo2_Rrr`@ipR¬"FOr_`¬BJKCEADIKAD_`JYQ

o@BI»atJbPMH¨¾P`JY½ @BJjrg_er§NJI›FŠ‰/FOQBP`JYr`r¯FOoiQ/_`¬BJ»F2pbpbJjrervQSJbCGFŠ‰Srb³~dMOoipbJbPeoBADoif(_e¬BJ(?€

m

QSAEp‹_`AEMOoiFOP`AEJjrjTS_e¬BJb‰

FHPeJ;M2a ²AEMO@ir`CE‰{CEJjrer»p‹M2IKyBCDJb_`J2T¹ai@S_(_e¬BJb‰"pbFOo<atJ•IKMSQ¸iJjQhT¶_`¬BJj‰ FOP`J;²2JbPe‰{¨ÁF2rs_[FHoiQ$IKM rs_»MO¨FHCECUT¹_e¬BJb‰

fOAE²OJr`Jb²2JbPRFHCt_`PRFHoir`CGF^_`AEMOoWrN¨ªMOPF[PeJj½ @BJjrg_jTWFOraBAECDAEoBf2@iFHCcQBAEp‹_`AEMOoiFOP`AEJjrj³©wvIKMOoifK_`¬BJ(?€

m

QSAEp‹_`AEMOoiFOP`AEJjrjTS§NJ

pR¬BMM2r`J/n{FHfOAGpµ|lQSAGpHT¾atJjpjFH@ir`J/MO¨AD_erKJb²2MOCE@S_`AE²A¿_s‰$FOoiQ$_e¬BJ¦yBP`JYrgJjoip‹J/MH¨v_eJbPeI›r(AEo<_e¬BJQSAGpµ_`AEMOoWFHPe‰OT¶_`¬iM2r`J

_`JjP`I›r(aWJjADoif F2QBQSJjQa‰"FOo‰ @WrgJjPjT¾aB@B_K²2JbPeA¿¸WJjQ$atJ‹¨ªM2P`J/aWJjADoBf AEo2_eJbf2PeFH_`JjQhT¾§¯¬BAEpR¬AEr[oBMO_(_e¬BJ8pjFOr`J;¨ªM2P

voiAEQSAGpH³©ViMOPNJ‹qBFHIKyBCEJ_`¬BJ½ @BJbPe‰[¨ªMOPd_`¬BJViP`JjoipR¬•§NMOPRQ -4/5 9fOAE²OJjr\_`¬iJ¨ªM2CDCEM^§¯AEoBf»PeJjr`@BCD_er9ͪ§NJM2oBCD‰›f2AD²2J

FHo¦Jbq _ePeF2pµ_µÎ9Û\ytMOP`_`JaiFOf2FHf2Jjrd|:CE@BfOf FHf2JbPRFOpR]=T2CE@Bf2f2FHf2JPRFOpR]•yWM2Pg_eJ»p‹AEf2FOP`Jb_g_`J9|:pbADf FHPeJ‹_g_eJ¬BMOCGQSJjP¯yWM2Pg_eJ

p‹CEJ‹¨Ár|(]OJb‰ |}P`AEoBf;ytMOP`_`J[yBCE@BIKJ»|»¨ªMO@Bo _RFHAEo{ytJbo{ytMOP`_`J(yiFHPeMOCEJOT=CEMSp‹@S_eJb@BP|Kr`ytMO]OJYrgI›FOoyWM2Pg_eJ:|KQSMMOPYT

f2FH_`J

¥ M›yBP`Jj²OJjo2_vAD_er@BoipbMOIKyBCEJ‹_`JjoBJjrerjTWFHoWQ¦aWJYpbFH@WrgJ:AD_¬iF2r¯atJbJbo{yBP`M^²2JjQ•_`¬iFH_v_`¬iJ»@ir`JMH¨©r`Jb²OJjPeFOChQSAGpµ_`AEMH|

oiFOP`AEJjrf2AD²2JjrNaWJYrs_vPeJjr`@BCD_erN_e¬iFHoF[@BoBAG½ @BJMOoBJ2TSA¿_v¬WFOratJbJbo¦JjoBP`AGpR¬BJYQ•§¯AD_`¬8_`¬iJ»?9M M2fOCEJQSAEp‹_`AEMOoiFOP`‰2³

È!%-Æ" ʵƶÌjÌbÅ[Ê È;ÉÊ

· J§¯ADCEChAECDCE@S_`PRF^_eJ9_`¬BAGr¯I»@iC¿_eADCEADoifO@iFOChIKMQB@BCDJM2o•_e¬BJ¨ªMOCECEM^§¯ADoBf[J‹qBFOI[yiCDJ›Û

4 5 2 & -/# $+#-4& $ *-4&!4#% &/#%4 &' & 2

¥ ¬BJ¦¸iPRrg_KIKMSQS@BCEJAGr[_`¬BJyiFOPer`AEoBf"MH¨_e¬BJVBPeJboWpR¬-½ @BJYrs_eADM2oh³ ˆoBJ¦MH¨9_`¬BJPeJjr`@BCD_›MH¨9_`¬BAGr;rg_`JbycTdAGrK_`¬iJ

CEAErg_›MH¨v_e¬BJ¦@BoBAD|U_eJbPeIKrKFOoiQFOCDCN_`¬iJ8aiA¿|‘_`JjP`I›r¦ÍÁr`@ipR¬-FOr &2 $53# ! $ " ' 5Î:§¯¬iAEpR¬ §dJjP`J/ADo®_`¬iJ

½ @BJjrg_`AEMOocT¶FOoiQ"_e¬BJ•JjCDAEIKADoiFH_`AEMOo<MO¨_`¬BJ8rs_eMOy<§NMOPRQBrj³

¥

¬BJ;aBAD_`JjP`I›r[FHPeJ;@ir`J‹¨ª@BC‘T¾aWJYpbFO@irgJ;_`¬BJj‰"FOCDCEM^§ÏF

QSJYr`FOI»aBAEfO@BAGreF^_`AEMOoa‰f2AD²AEoBfF[ÍÁr`I›FHCECGδp‹M2o2_eJ‹q_c_eM9F§NMOPRQ5³hklo»M2@BP¹J‹qBFHIKyBCEJOTŠ_e¬BJaBA¿_eJbPeI›r´FOP`JÛ -/# $+#-4&

$ - &!' #%/1 $ -4&!4#% &/#%+41 &+/#% & # &'2%$NFHoiQ>_e¬BJ;@BoBAD_`JjP`I›r•Û 1 -/# $+#-4&1 $ -4&!4#%+1

&/#% 1 &' & 2^³

·AD_`¬"_`¬iJ/nFOfOAGpµ|lQSAEpKQSAGpµ_eADM2oBoiFOP`‰2T´§NJ›_`Pe‰_eM_`PRFHoWrgCGF^_eJK_`¬BJ;aiA¿_eJbPeIKr/ͪ§¯¬BJjo"_`¬BJj‰>JbqSAErg_R΋T¶FOoiQ _`¬iJ

@BoBAD_`JjP`I›rj³NwCDC´_`¬iJ:yBPeMOytM2r`JjQ/_`PRFHoir`CGF^_`AEMOoWr¯FHPeJ_eFH]2Jbo¦AEo2_eM•FOpjp‹M2@Bo _j³dwCDCc_`¬BJ»_`JjP`I›rvFOP`Jf2PeFOI[I›FH_`AGpbFHCECE‰

_eFOfOf2JjQ5³Nk}¨\F›aBAD|U_eJbPeIÔpjFHoBoiMH_vatJ(QSAEP`JYpµ_eCD‰/_`PRFHoir`CGF^_`JYQ5TiAD_AGrvPeJjpbMOIKyWM rgJYQ/¨ªP`M2I _e¬BJ»@BoiA¿_eJbPeIKrjTB¨ªM2CDCEM^§¯AEoBf

_`¬iJ8Z\oBfOCEAEr`¬r`‰o2_RF^q5³>ViMOP[MO@BP[J‹qBFOI[yiCDJ2T¾§dJ/MOaS_RFHAEoBJjQ<¨ªMOP(_`¬BJ8aBAD_`JbPeI›r•Û -/#$#-4&$ - &!''&(!' &#

$ - &!''& 1 &#($ *-4&!)& 1 &# !* &'+$NFHoiQ ¨ªM2P:_e¬BJ;@BoBAD_`JjP`I›r/Û & ! &"-- &56#%41.-/# $+#-4&!' &# 1

$ - &!''& 1 ! +* &W³

¥ ¬BJYrgJ/_`JjP`I›r›FHPeJ/_`¬BJjo @WrgJYQa‰$_e¬BJ8¨ªMOCECDM^§¯AEoBf I[MSQS@iCDJYr›MH¨9I»@BCD_`AECDAEoBf2@iFHC­9w m ~T¾AEoirs_eJjF2QMO¨_`¬iJ

MOPeAEfOAEoiFHC5§NMOPRQBrj³ ¥ ¬BJ_`PRFHoir`CGF^_`AEMOo¦QSMJjr`o_¯_`Pe‰;_eM;rgM2CD²2J_e¬BJ:FHI(aBAEfO@BAD_s‰;atJ‹_s§NJbJbo¦_e¬BJ_`PRFHoWrgCGF^_eADM2oirÛ¾_`¬iJ

r`JbCEJjpµ_eADM2o§¯AECDC¶atJ(I›FOQBJ[QS@iP`AEoBf;_e¬BJKrgJYFHPRpR¬MH¨©_e¬BJ[QBMpb@BIKJbo _erj³k}¨©_`¬iJ[QSADÂ=JbPeJbo __eJbPeI›rFOP`J[rg‰oBM2o ‰I›rjT

ytJbP`_`AEoBJbo _»QSMSp‹@iI[Jjo _er§¯AECDC¶_e¬BJbo"atJ›P`Jb_`PeADJj²OJjQ{§¯A¿_e¬ _`¬BAGrrg‰oBAEo‰I8Th_`¬iFOoB]Sr9_`MF8CEFOP`f2JbPrgJYFHPRpR¬h³»k}¨N_`¬iJ

§NMOPRQ;AGr¯ADoWp‹MO¬iJbPeJbo _¯§¯A¿_e¬BADo8_e¬BJ:p‹M2o2_eJ‹q_jTSAD_ervADo-,W@BJboipbJ§¯ADCEChoBMO_¯aWJ:r`@SÓ;p‹AEJbo _¯_`M›aiP`AEoBfKoBMOAGr`JO³

w¸iPRrg_vJb²^FHCE@iF^_eADM2o¦MH¨¶_`¬BAGr¯_ePeFOoir`CEFH_`AEMOo¦I»@BCD_`AECEADoBf2@iFHC´IKMQB@BCDJ»¬iFOQ¦atJbJjoIKF2QSJ:M2o/_e¬BJ ¥ uvZ~1½2@iJjrg|

_`AEMOoWrbT_ePeFOoirgCGF^_eJjQ/ADoViP`JjoipR¬/a‰8uvw m kµ³

. * ÊvÇ0/ %HÈ(Ç Ê9ƶ̋È[Å

@BJN_`M9_`¬BJ· Jba[P`JYQS@BoiQiFHoipb‰OT^§NJNrg_eFH_`JN_`¬iFH_¹AD_¾AEr¶ytM2rer`ADaBCEJd_`M9¸ioiQ[QSMSp‹@BIKJjo2_Rr¹Jb²OJjo»§¯AD_`¬KF9²OJbPe‰rgytJjpbA¿¸tp

½ @BJbPe‰OT´FHoiQ{_`¬iFH_»F•yiP`JYp‹AGrgJ›½ @BJbPe‰§¯AECDC©CEJjF2Q_eM8¸ioiQ P`JjCDJj²^FHo _QBMpb@BIKJbo _erjTcA‘³JO³›QSMSp‹@BIKJjo2_Rrp‹M2o2_RFHAEoBAEoBf

_`¬iJKr`JjFOPepR¬iJjQ{FOoir`§dJjPjT5FHIKM2oBf•_e¬BJ[¸iPRrs_MOoiJjrj³

¥

¬@irjThMO@BPpR¬BM2AEpbJ(§FOr_eM/PeJ‹¨ªM2P`I(@BCEFH_`J(_`¬BJ›½ @BJYrs_eADM2o>AEo

FHo F^ӛPeIKFH_`AE²OJ»¨ªMOPeIÀ§¯A¿_e¬ F2rv¨ªJj§Ú²^FHPeAEFH_`AEMOoirFOr9ytM2rergAEaBCEJO³:VBM2PADoirg_eFOoip‹J2T=¨ªMOP9_`¬iJ[½ @BJYrs_eADM2o213 54 &6

7eõbèÁè‘ð2ùúµú`è‘í‘åRëŠì‘æåeèUéÙêµë8Yûð^åRí‘åRæÙéÙë43Oûîsêµï

9RõbèÁè‘ð2ùúµúeó^åRóHãgæGûåRæè‘ågäjéÙìUè‘å‹ú`èUí}åRëŠìUæåeè‘ãµûòYôjë

:

õbèÁè‘ð2ùúµú`ýcýhý©ûñµêbêµñµæÙã‹ûîsêµïúeæåRëŠñµçŠåRñµã è‘êbêµæÙì

; õbèÁè‘ð2ùúµúeñµí}åRëŠòŠòYéÙîsèUéÙêµëŠë^åRéÙíUãµûîgêµï

< õbèÁè‘ð2ùúµú`ýcýhý©û8Dí‘ãsãlè‘í‘åRëŠì‘æåeèUéÙêµë ûîsêµï

õbèÁè‘ð2ùúµúeïvåRñµéÙî @GòŠéÙîµûõŠêµï¯ãsçŠëŠé?OûëŠãlèlú

(5)

4 &6+ 22 '· J¦¸iPRrs_;½ @BJjP`‰$_e¬BJ· Jba®¨ªMOP;rg_`PeADoBf rK§¯A¿_e¬®JbqBFOpµ_›I›F^_RpR¬®AEoQSMSp‹@BIKJjo2_Rr›FOrKAEo

ÕLdPeAECDC5Jb_FHC‘³\×H‡O‡i‚RؑTFHoWQoBMO_›¨ªMOP[_`¬iJQSA¿Â=JbPeJbo _;§NMOPRQBr[MH¨_`¬BJ½ @BJjP`‰<Jj²OJjo®CEADoi]OJjQ®§¯AD_`¬w»T¯ˆ9u M2P

ZdwuƒMOytJbPRF^_eMOPRrdF2rADo$ÕnFHf2oBAEoBA5J‹_FOCU³\×O‡O‡2×OFjØcMOP:ÕvJjP`I9ÒgFOpbMOa8J‹_FOCU³©×H‡2‡2×jØ}³

Ê ¶Ì‹È[ÅÈ!% $!vÇ ¹È(ʦǾË$ ÔÈ%1ÌbÅ%HÈ(Ç 9ƶÌbÈ(Å

wr\A¿_d§NF2r©r`FOAEQ[AEo;rgJYpµ_eADM2oK„›ÍÁM^²OJjP`²AEJb§MO¨´­9w

m

~Î‹TO§NJ¯JbCGFHatMOPRF^_eJjQKFrs_ePeFH_`JjfO‰:aiF2rgJYQ[MOoK_`¬iJp‹M2I[yWFHPeAEr`MOo

MH¨=_e¬BJvPeJjr`@BC¿_Rr¾MH¨5M2@BP\r`‰rg_`JjI ¨ªPeMOI«_s§dM:QBA¿Â=JbPeJbo _dr`MO@BPRp‹JYr¶MH¨5]oBM^§¯CEJjQSf2JOÛ¹~

m

Z\V p‹MOCECEJjpµ_eADM2o›FHoiQ[· Jba›¨ªM2P

_`PRFHoWrgCGF^_eJjQ•½ @BJYrs_eADM2oirjTBFHoiQ•I»@BCD_`AECDAEoBf2@iFHC5PeJjr`@BCD_erj³

¥

¬iJ9]oBM^§¯CEJjQBfOJrgM2@BPepbJJbqyiCDM2P`JYQ;a‰›_`¬iJ9· Jbar`JjFOPepR¬

AGr\M2a ²AEMO@ir`CE‰(PeJjFOCDCE‰KI»@ipR¬;CGFHPefOJjP¾_`¬WFHo¦~

m

Z\V"p‹M2CDCEJjp‹_`AEMOo•r`JjFOPepR¬c³ rgAEoBf(r`@ipR¬•r`MO@iPepbJvaBPeADoBf r\M2@BPdr`‰Srs_eJbI

F>P`JjCDJj²ŠFOo _[§FŠ‰"_`M$p‹M2oS¸iPeI rgM2IKJ/MO¨AD_er›FHoWrg§NJbPRr(FOoiQ$_eM"P`JjADoS¨ªM2PepbJ/AD_erKpbMOoS¸WQBJboipbJ¦rep‹M2P`J2³vM^§NJb²2JbPYT

FHIKM2oBf[_`¬BJ:FOoirg§NJbPRryBPeM^²AEQSJYQ•a‰›_e¬BJ:· Jbar`JjFHPRpR¬hTBr`MOIKJ:FHPeJoBMH_pbMOPeP`JYrgytMOoWQSADoif»_eM;FHo‰•QSMSp‹@iI[Jjo _vMH¨

~ m ZdVN³izMiTBAD_vAGrN_`M›atJoBMH_eJjQ•_`¬iFH_¯_`¬BJ· JbaFHoWrg§NJbPRrFHCGrgMK¬iFŠ²2J_eM[atJCEMpjF^_eJjQ8ADo{~ m Z\V<pbMOCECDJYpµ_`AEMOoc³

¥ ¬BJYrgJ_`¬BPeJbJ9FHyByBCEAGpbF^_eADM2oir©MO¨¹­9w m ~ rg@ByiyBCD‰K¨ªM2P\JYFOpR¬•½ @BJYrs_eADM2o•F»r`J‹_NMH¨cFHoWrg§NJbPRr©§¯¬BAGpR¬•FOP`JvM2PeQBJbPeJjQ

FOpjp‹M2PeQSAEoBf(_`M›_e¬BJ:rep‹MOPeJ9_`¬BJj‰/PeJjpbJbAE²OJYQ/QS@iP`AEoBfK_`¬iJ:FHoir`§dJjP¯J‹q_`PRFOp‹_`AEMOo8yBPeMpbJjrerb³vJboWp‹JOTi_`¬BJPeMOCEJMH¨¶_`¬iJ

¸ioiFOChrgJjCDJYpµ_eADM2o8AGrN_`M;pR¬iM M rgJF[@BoBAG½ @BJ:FHoir`§NJbPaWJb_s§dJjJbo8_`¬iJjr`J_e¬BPeJbJMOPRQSJjP`JYQ•r`J‹_erj³

LNJ‹¨ªM2P`J¦QSJjrep‹PeAEaBADoif>_e¬BJFHCEfOM2P`AD_`¬iIKr[§NJ¦§¯P`MO_`J8¨ªMOPK_e¬BJ¦¸ioiFOCvrgJjCDJYpµ_`AEMOocTd§NJ¦§¯ADCECQSJYr`pbP`AEaWJ8_e¬BJ§NFŠ‰

­9w m ~FH_g_`PeAEaB@S_`JYrvFKp‹M2oS¸WQSJjoip‹Jrep‹MOPeJ9_`MKJjF2pR¬/ytMH_eJbo _`AGFHChFOoir`§dJjPj³

"!#$

wvCEC¯_e¬BJrgJjo _`JboWp‹JjrKyiP`M^²AGQSJjQ®a‰$_`¬BJQBMpb@BIKJbo _;yBPeMSp‹Jjrer`ADoBf"FHPeJ¦J‹qBFHIKAEoBJjQ®AEo M2PeQBJbP[_`M$f2AD²2J•_e¬BJbI F

§NJbAEfO¬ _\_e¬iF^_P`J#,iJjp‹_erdaWMO_`¬•_`¬BJ9yWM r`r`AEaBADCEAD_s‰K_`¬iFH_d_e¬BJ9r`Jbo _eJboipbJp‹M2o _eFHAEoir\_`¬BJFHoWrg§NJbPYT FOoiQK_e¬BJytM2rer`ADaBAECEA¿_s‰

_`¬WF^_[_`¬BJ{­9w m ~Ïr`‰rg_`JjICDMSpbFH_`JYr»_e¬BJ¦FHoir`§dJjP(§¯AD_`¬iADo®_`¬BJ¦r`Jbo _`Jjoip‹J2³ ¥ ¬BJ8pbP`AD_`JjP`AGF_e¬iF^_K§NJ/@ir`JjQ®FHPeJ

p‹CEM2r`JbCE‰<CEADoi]OJjQ®§¯AD_`¬ _`¬BJaWFOr`AEp¦AEoS¨ªMOPeI›F^_eADM2o®Jbq _ePeF2pµ_eJjQ¨ªP`M2I _`¬BJ½ @BJYrs_eADM2oh³ ¥ ¬BJ¦PeJjr`@BC¿_eADoif"r`Jbo _eJboipbJ

PRFHoB]AEoBf r`¬BM2@BCEQ®oBMO_KIKAGr`rKM2a² AEMO@Wr[FOoir`§dJjPerj³-ˆ@BP;FOADI AEr[_e¬iF^_›_e¬BJrg@BaWrgJY½2@iJbo _›I[MSQS@iCDJYrKMH¨FHoir`§dJjP

J‹q_ePeF2pµ_`AEMOoFOoiQ¦¸ioWFHC´FOoir`§dJjPr`JbCEJjpµ_eADM2oFHPeJ»FHaiCDJ»_`M;PRFHAGrgJ(F;CEM^§dJjPv§dJjADf2¬ _`JjQFOoir`§dJjPv_`M/FHo@ByiyWJjPPRFHoB]

_`¬WFHoB]Sr_`M/F2QBQSJYQrgytJjpbA¿¸tp»p‹PeAD_`JbPeAGFB³ ¥ ¬BJ[p‹PeA¿_eJbPeAEF›_`¬iFH_§NJ»PeJ‹_eFOADoiJjQ@ir`J_e¬BJ»¨ªM2CDCEM^§¯AEoBf›¨ªJjFH_`@BPeJjr§¯A¿_e¬BAEo

_`¬iJ:pbFHoWQSAEQiF^_`Jr`Jbo _`Jjoip‹JYrbÛ

%

½2@iJjrg_`AEMOo8CDJjI[I›F2rbTS§NJbAEfO¬ _`JYQ•a‰›_e¬BJbAEPr`yWJYp‹AD¸Wp‹AD_s‰/QBJbfOPeJbJ^°`°ŠT

%

²ŠFOP`AGFHo _RrdMO¨¹½ @BJYrs_eADM2o8CEJbIKI›FOrjT

%

J‹qBFOp‹_§NMOPRQBrNMH¨´_`¬BJ:½ @BJYrs_eADM2ohT

%

I»@S_e@iFHChpbCDM rgJjoBJjrerMH¨´_`¬BJ:½ @BJYrs_eADM2o/§NMOPRQBrjT

%

yBP`JYrgJjoip‹J9MH¨¹_`¬iJJ‹qSyWJYpµ_eJjQ8oiFHIKJYQ•Jjo2_eA¿_s‰•_s‰yWJ2³

V¹ADPRrg_v§dJp‹M2IKyB@S_`J(FKaiFOr`AEp9§NJbAEfO¬ _vMH¨¹_`¬iJ»rgJjo _`JboWp‹JaiFOr`JjQ8M2o/_e¬BJ:yBPeJjr`JboWp‹JMH¨¾½ @BJjrg_`AEMOo¦CEJbIKI›FOr¯M2P

²^FHPeAEFOo _er9MH¨N_`¬BJYrgJKCEJbIKI›FOr›Íª_`¬BJ›_s§NM/¸iPerg_»p‹PeAD_`JbPeAGF2ε³ ¥ ¬BJ›aiF2rgAGp[§dJjADf2¬ _AGrPeJbCGF^_`AE²OJ2³K·>J;r`@Bair`Jj½ @BJjo2_eCD‰

FOQiQ>FOo>FOQiQSA¿_eADM2oiFHC¾§NJbAEfO¬ _9_`M8_`¬iAEraiF2rgAGp(§dJjADf2¬2_9¨ªMOPJYFOpR¬ FOQBQSAD_`AEMOoWFHC¾p‹PeA¿_eJbPeAEF•_`¬WF^_AErreF^_eAErg¸iJYQ5³(ZdFOpR¬

FOQiQSA¿_eADM2oiFHChpbP`AD_`JjP`AGF(§dJjADf2¬2_vpjFHoBoBMO_vaWJ¬iADf2¬BJbPN_`¬WFHoFHatMO@S_:‚Y‡'&ÑMO¨c_e¬BJaiFOr`AGp§NJbAEfO¬ _Y³

@BP`AEoBf8FHoir`§dJjPJbq _ePeF2pµ_eADM2o¦_`¬BAGr9§dJjADf2¬2_9AEr9rg_`AECDC¶PeJ‹¸ioBJYQ5³9k}¨©_`¬BJ[J‹qSytJjp‹_`JjQ>FHoir`§NJbPv_s‰ytJ(AGr9F;oiFOI[JYQ

Jbo _eA¿_s‰2TS_`¬BJjorgJjCDJYpµ_`JYQ¦FHoir`§dJjPerFOP`J_`¬BJ§NMOPRQBrMO¨´_e¬BJ:rgJjo _`JboWp‹J9_`¬iFH_p‹M2P`PeJjr`yWM2oiQ›_eMK_`¬BJJbqSyWJYpµ_`JYQ/_s‰ ytJO³

klo¦MOPRQSJbPN_eM[Jbq_`PRFOpµ__e¬BJ:FHoir`§NJbPYT_`¬BJ:r`‰Srs_eJbIº¸iPRrg_¯pbMOIKyB@S_eJjrvF2QBQSAD_`AEMOoiFOC5§dJjADf2¬ _erd_eFO] AEoBfKAEo2_eM;FOpjp‹MO@io2_YÛ

%

_`¬BJyBPeJjpbAEr`J9MOP¯fOJjoBJbPeAGpoWFHIKJjQ/Jbo _`AD_s‰;_s‰ytJMH¨¹_`¬BJ:FOoirg§NJbPYT

%

_`¬BJCEMSpbF^_eADM2o•MO¨´_e¬BJyWMO_`Jjo2_eAEFOCcFHoWrg§NJbP§¯AD_`¬¦P`Jjf2FOPeQ;_`M[_`¬BJ:½ @BJYrs_eADM2o/§NMOPRQBrN§¯AD_`¬BAEo¦_`¬BJ:r`Jbo _eJboipbJOT

%

_`¬BJPeJjQS@ioiQBFHoWp‹‰›MH¨¾FHo¦FHoWrg§NJbPAEo/_e¬BJ_`M2y8_`Jbor`Jbo _`Jjoip‹JYrb³

(6)

pbFOoiQSAGQBF^_eJ8r`Jbo _eJboipbJ/yBPeM^²AEQBJjQ<a‰"_e¬BJrgJjo2_eJboipbJ8r`JbCEJjp‹_`AEMOo®I[MSQS@iCDJ8AEr›FOoiFHCE‰SrgJYQ$@ir`ADoif{_e¬BJ¦J‹q_`PRFOp‹_`AEMOo

yiFH_g_`JjP`oF2r`r`MSp‹AGF^_`JYQ<§¯AD_`¬ _`¬iJ½2@iJjrg_`AEMOo _s‰yWJ8_`¬WF^_;¬iF2r›aWJjJboQSJb_`JbPeIKADoiJjQ a‰$_`¬BJ½ @BJYrs_eADM2o FOoiFHCE‰SrgAGrj³

Z¾q_ePeF2pµ_`AEMOo{yiF^_`_`JbPeoir9FHPeJ(pbMOIKyWM rgJYQMH¨NF/r`J‹_MH¨dpbMOoirg_`PRFHAEo _Pe@BCEJjrMOo_e¬BJKpbFHoWQSAEQiF^_`JKr`Jbo _`Jjoip‹JYrb³u¯@BCEJjr

FHPeJ©I›FOQBJ©@By:MO¨Sr`‰o _eFOp‹_`AGp¾yiFH_g_`JjP`oWr5_`¬WF^_¹FOP`J\@irgJYQ9_`MCDMSpbFH_`J©ytMH_eJbo _`AGFHC FHoir`§NJbPRr5§¯A¿_e¬BAEo_`¬BJNrgJjo _`JboWp‹JOT^FOoiQ

MH¨¶rgJjI›FHo _`AGp9P`JjCEFH_`AEMOoir\_`¬iFH_FHPeJ@WrgJYQ;_eM[²^FOCDAGQBF^_eJ9FOoir`§dJjPerj³¹€¶MO_`Jjo2_eAEFOC5FHoir`§dJjPerNFHPeJ9§dJjADf2¬2_eJjQ8FOpjp‹MOPRQSAEoBf

_`M[_e¬BJ:r`FH_`AGrs¸WJjQ¦p‹M2oirs_ePeFOADo _Rrb³¶nMOPeJQSJ‹_RFHAEChpbFOo8atJ¨ªMO@ioiQ8ADo"ÕQBJ(~d¬iFHCEJboiQiFHP¯J‹_FOCU³©×O‡O‡2×jØ}³

V¹ADoWFHCECD‰ F^¨_`JjP_`¬iJ;J‹q_`PRFOp‹_`AEMOo"FHoiQ"§NJbAEfO¬ _eADoBf¦yBPeMSp‹JYQS@BPeJOTh_e¬BJ›¸i²2J›aWJYrs_(§dJjADf2¬2_eJjQ"FHoWrg§NJbPRrFHPeJ›P`Jb|

_eFOADoiJjQ/¨ªMOP_e¬BJ¸ioiFOChrgJjCDJYpµ_`AEMOo8IKMSQS@BCEJO³

' #$ " " #$!

¥

¬BJ@BoWQSJbPeCD‰AEoBf›AGQSJjFKAGr_`M;pbMOIKyiFOP`J9P`JYrg@iC¿_Rr¯MOaS_RFHAEoBJjQ/¨ªPeMOIÔQSAD²2JbPRrgJr`MO@BPRp‹JYrMH¨¶] oiM^§¯CDJYQSfOJ2³dˆ@BPp‹M2I[|

yiFOP`AGrgM2o FOCDCEM^§vrK@ir;_`M$PeJbAEoS¨ªMOPRp‹J8_`¬iJ{r`pbMOPeJ¦MH¨:FHoir`§NJbPRr(atJbCEMOoifOAEoBf"_`M"_e¬BJ{QSADÂtJjP`Jjo _•P`JYrg@iC¿_•r`J‹_RrbTN_`¬@ir

FHCECEM^§¯ADoBfFr`ADf2oBA¿¸tpbFHo _©o@BI(aWJjP©MH¨=P`AEfO¬ _©FHoWrg§NJbPRr¹_`Mf2J‹_\F^_¾_e¬BJ¸iPRrs_©PRFHoi]t³

m

Jb_\@ir¾f2AD²2JFOoKJ‹qBFHIKyBCEJ¯§¯A¿_e¬

MOoiCD‰›_s§NMKrgJb_er¯MO¨´PeJjr`@BC¿_Rrb³

¥

FHaBCEJK‚p‹MOo _RFHAEoirFHo8J‹qBFHIKyBCEJMH¨¹_`¬BJYrgJr`J‹_er¯pbMOPeP`JYrgytMOoWQSADoif:_`MK_e¬BJ½ @BJjrg_`AEMOohÛ

13 2+ &'5 2 5 34- &'4# 3 &'* &2&

¥ FHaBCEJK‚OÛ©woirg§NJbPvr`J‹_¯JbqSFOIKyBCDJ

~dMOCECDJYpµ_eADM2o8FOoirg§NJbPRr ·>JjaFHoir`§NJbPRr V¹ADoWFHCcrep‹M2P`J

‡2ί­@BJjJbo¦Z©CEADXYFHatJ‹_`¬$ÍUr`pbMOPeJ(‚Š×H‡2Î ‡2΁Z\CDAEXjFOaWJb_`¬8k9ÍUr`pbMOPeJ[‚Š×H…2…2Î

‚YÎNZ©oifOCGFHoiQ ÍÁrep‹M2P`J[‚Y×O‡2×OÎ ‚Y΁Z\CDAEXjFOaWJb_`¬8k9ÍUr`pbMOPeJ[‚Š×H… HÎ

×OÎ !#" ÍÁrep‹MOPeJ…2×2Î ×O΁€\¬BADCEAEy8k`kÍUr`pbMOPeJ[‚Š×' ×OÎ

„2΁zyiFOADo$ÍUr`pbMOPeJ H×OÎ „2Î$ %&'() !#"+*,-# "/.021#023 .542120

¥ ¬BJ;FOCDf2MOPeA¿_e¬BI¼J‹qBFOI[AEoBJYrJjF2pR¬ pbMO@ByBCEJÍ(6879;:<,=;>`T?6'79;:<,=A@ŠÎµT #atJbAEoBf_e¬BJ›yWM rgAD_`AEMOo"MO¨¯FOo$FHoir`§dJjP

¨ªMO@ioiQ$AEo$_`¬BJ8p‹M2CDCEJjp‹_`AEMOohT%{atJbAEoBf_e¬BJ•ytM2r`AD_`AEMOo<MO¨¯F·>Jja®FHoWrg§NJbPYTcAD_er[r`pbMOPeJ›aWJjADoif_`¬iJ•atJjrg_(MH¨vatMH_e¬

rep‹MOPeJjrj³9·¬BJbo>aWMO_`¬>FOoir`§dJjPerMH¨©_e¬BJ[pbMO@ByiCDJKFHPeJ»JbqSF2pµ_eCD‰¦Jj½ @iFOCUTt_e¬BJ[FOCDf2MOPeA¿_e¬BIÀF^_`_`PeADaB@B_`Jjr9F/aWM2o @Wrv_eM

_`¬iJ;p‹MO@iyBCDJ›rep‹M2P`J2Th§¯¬BAGpR¬ AGrpbFOCEpb@BCGF^_`JYQ>F2pbpbMOPRQSADoif•_eMaWMO_`¬"yWM rgAD_`AEMOoWrbÛ #FOoiQ iÛ;Íg‚O‚CB1ÍED&FHGÎgÎI‚Y‡O‡i³

¥ ¬BJ[FHoir`§dJjP¯_`¬WF^_AGr¯¸WoiFHCECD‰¦PeJ‹_e@BP`oiJjQ¦atJbCEMOoBf r¯_`M•_`¬BJ[p‹M2@ByBCEJ:MOaS_RFHAEoBAEoBf›_`¬iJ»atJjrg_9rep‹MOPeJO³ ¥ ¬iJ»FOQBQBA¿_eAD²2J

atMOo@ir§FOr¯pR¬BM rgJjo/AEo/M2PeQBJbP_`MKyB@Wrg¬8_`¬iJ:p‹MOoB¸iP`IKJYQ/FOoirg§NJbPRrNaWJb¨ªMOPeJ9_`¬BJ@BoWp‹MOoB¸iP`IKJYQ•M2oBJjrj³

m MM2] AEoBf¦F^_ ¥ FHaBCEJ¦‚OT´§dJ›r`JbJ[_`¬iFH__`¬BJ;FOoir`§dJjPFH_:PeFOoB]_s§NM/AEo _`¬BJ;pbMOCECDJYpµ_eADM2o FOoiQ>_`¬BJ;FOoirg§NJbPFH_

PRFHoB]_e¬BPeJbJ¯AEo›·>Jja;FHoir`§dJjPer¶FOP`JN_`¬iJr`FOIKJO³

¥

¬BJ¯P`JYp‹JjAD²2JjQ(aWM2o @Wr¾AEr O‡O‡iTOFHoWQ»_e¬BJFOoirg§NJbPKJ &'$#KL:&,

AGrP`Jb_`@BPeoBJjQ8§¯AD_`¬¦AD_er¸ioWFHChrep‹MOPeJOہ‚O×B³

kloiQSJjJjQ5T2_`¬iJp‹M2I[yWFHPeAEr`MOoK¬iF2r¾aWJjJbo•pjFHPeP`AEJjQ[M2@S_\atJ‹_s§NJbJboK_e¬BPeJbJrg_`PRF^_eJbfOAEJjr©PeFH_`¬BJjP¾_`¬iFOoK_s§dM'$2AD_dpbMO@BCGQ

atJ:J‹q_`JjoiQSJYQ¦_`M;IKM2P`J_e¬iFHoM2oBCD‰/¸i²2J:FHoir`§dJjPerFHoiQ¦AD_p‹M2@BCGQ¦aWJ(I[M2P`J ,WJ‹qSADaiCDJ:a‰/_eFO] AEoBf›AEo _`M•F2pbp‹M2@Bo _

FHoWrg§NJbPRrNADoipbCD@WQSJjQ8MOoiJ9AEo8_`¬BJMO_`¬BJjPjTSAEoirg_`JYFOQ8MH¨¹J‹qBFOp‹_`CE‰;Jj½ @iFOChFHoir`§dJjPerj³

M N6 ¹ÊµÆ

¥

FHaBCEJ:×»yiP`JYrgJjo2_RrN_`¬BJPeJjr`@BCD_er§NJMOaS_RFHAEoBJjQ/¨ªMOP_e¬BJ_s§NM[Pe@Boirj³

¥ FOaBCEJ×BÛ©u¯Jjr`@BCD_erMO¨´_e¬BJP`@ioir

n@iC¿_eADCEADoifO@iFOC Vi@irgAEMOo

@BI»atJbPMH¨¶P`AEfO¬ _vFHoir`§NJbPRrdM2o•¨ÁF2pµ_eMOAGQ/½ @BJYrs_eADM2oirÍs‚O‡2Î ‚ „

@BI»atJbPMH¨¶P`AEfO¬ _vFHoir`§NJbPRrdM2o8QBJ‹¸ioBAD_`AEMOo½ @BJYrs_eADM2oirÍU×O‡2Î † „

¥ MH_RFHChMO¨´PeADf2¬ _¯FOoir`§dJjPerÍU×O‡O‡ Î ×2× „O…

~dM2oS¸WQSJjoip‹J§NJbAEfO¬ _eJjQ8r`pbMOPeJ ‡B³‡O„2„ ‡B³‡

· J(oBMO_`J»_`¬iFH_9_e¬BJKr`pbMOPeJ:MH¨©_e¬BJKp‹MOI(aBAEoBJjQ{P`@Bo>AErAEoip‹PeJjF2rgJYQMH¨‚Y‡O‡ &;T=p‹M2IKyiFHPeJjQ¦_eM•_e¬BJ(¸iPerg_M2oBJO³

(7)

%%

‚Y×STO„ &ÑMH¨¾_e¬BJ:_ePeFOoBCGF^_`JYQ8_`JjP`I›rv§NJbPeJ:p‹M2P`PeJjp‹_jTWaB@S_I›FŠ‰8aWJ(JboB¬WFHoipbJjQ$ͪA‘³JO³FOoBMH_e¬BJbP¯_ePeFOoir`CEFH_`AEMOo

§dM2@BCEQ/¬iFŠ²2JatJbJjo8atJ‹_`_`JjPRÎ

%

BT„O„'& MH¨´_`¬BJ_`PRFHoiCEFH_`JjQ›_`JbPeI›rN§dJjP`J9p‹MOPePeJjpµ_YT2ai@S_¯AEQSJjo _`AGpbFHCt_eM»_e¬BJ_eJbPeI›rdAEo;_e¬BJrgM2@BPRp‹JCGFHoifO@iFOfOJ

%

„O‡BTE‚j‡ &«MH¨´_`¬BJ_ePeFOoBCEFH_`JYQ;_eJbPeIKr§NJbPeJADoWp‹MOPePeJjpµ_

%

×ST†O† &«MO¨´_e¬BJ:r`MO@BPRp‹J_`JjP`I›r§NJbPeJ9AEoipbMOPeP`JYpµ_

k}_AGrMOa²ADM2@ir_`¬WF^_9_`¬BJ[QSAEp‹_`AEMOoiFOP`‰8§FOrvoiMH_9pbMOIKyBCEJ‹_eJ»JboiMO@Bf2¬¦¨ªMOP_`¬BAGrpjFHIKyiFOADf2oh³v· J»§¯AECDC¹MOaS_RFHAEo

F/fOPeJjF^_eJbP9p‹M^²OJjPa‰FOQiQSADoif/I›FHo@iFOCDCE‰rgM2IKJ(M2a ²AEMO@irJbPeP`M2Per(ͪoBM8_ePeFOoBCEFH_`AEMOoMO¨©_`¬iJ[ViP`JjoipR¬{²2JbPea4

AEo/AD_erIKJjFOoBAEoBf 5- &&^TS¨ªM2PJ‹qBFHIKyBCEJY΋³¹· JFHCGrgM[atJbfOAEo/_`MKFOQBQ;_`PRFHoir`CEFH_`AEMOoirNa‰›PeJj½ @BJjrg_erd_eM»_e¬BJ:?9M M2fOCEJ

_`PRFHoWrgCGF^_eADM2o•IKMSQS@BCEJO³

wvoiMH_`¬iJbPJb²^FHCE@iFH_`AEMOo/pbMOoipbJbPeoird_`¬BJaBAD_`JjP`I›rjT_eFO¬2_¯§NJ¬iFŠ²OJyBP`JYrgJjo _`JjQ8FOrN²2JbPe‰[AEIKyWM2Pg_RFHo __`M›QSAGr`FOI[|

aBAEfO@iFH_`JvFOI»aBAEfO@BM2@ir¾@BoiA¿_eJbPeIKrj³ ¥ M_e¬BAGr©JboWQ5TO§NJv¬iFŠ²2JQBJ‹_`JjP`IKAEoBJjQ[_e¬BJQSMSpb@BIKJbo _eFOP`‰»¨ªP`JY½2@iJboipb‰»MH¨5JYFOpR¬

_`PRFHoWrgCGF^_eADM2o•MH¨c_`¬BJQSADÂtJjP`Jjo _aiA¿_eJbPeIKrAEo/_`¬BJ»~ m ZdV<p‹M2P`yi@irb³¹k}¨c_e¬BJ¨ªPeJj½ @BJboWp‹‰›AGr¬BADf2¬hT _`¬BJjo8_`¬BJaBAD_`JjP`I

I›FŠ‰»atJFHo;F2QSJj½ @iFH_`J_ePeFOoirgCGF^_eADM2oh³´ViP`M2IÚ_e¬BAGr\rg_`@iQS‰2T2M2oBCE‰»†2„i³'&MO¨W_e¬BJvaBAD_`JjP`I›r\FOP`JvpbMOPeP`JYpµ_Y³

¥

¬@irjTO§NJ

oBJjJjQ_eM•JjoB¬iFHoWp‹J:_e¬BAGr_ePeFOoir`CEFH_`AEMOo¦_`MMW³zM2IKJ»AGQSJjF2rv_eM/QSM8rgM8FHPeJ:_`¬iJ»²^FHCEAEQiF^_`AEMOo{MH¨©_e¬BJ:_ePeFOoirgCGF^_eADM2oirjT

a‰>rep‹M2P`AEoBf8_`¬BJjI ¨ªM2CDCEM^§¯AEoBf¦_`¬BJjADP:¨ªP`JY½2@iJboipb‰{atMH_`¬$AEo<F¦aBAECDAEoBf2@iFHC\pbMOPeyB@irjT´FOoiQ ADo<FpbMOPeyB@irAEo"_eFHPefOJb_

CGFHoBf2@iFHf2JO³

· J»FHCGrgM›oiMH_`AGp‹J»_`¬iFH_FHoAEIKyWM2Pg_RFHo _§NMOPe]•¬iF2r¯_eM;aWJ[QSMOoiJ:MOoyBPeMOytJbPoBMO@BoWrbTtrgytJjpbAEFOCDCE‰/f2JbM2fOPRFHyB¬BAGp

oiFOI[JYrKFHoiQMOPef2FHoiADXYF^_`AEMOo"oiFOIKJjrj³<·>J/_`¬iJbo oBJbJYQ$_`M"QSJj²OJbCEMOyaBADCEAEoBfO@iFOCCDAGrs_Rr(¨ªMOP[_`¬BJ8IKM2rg_(¨ªPeJj½ @BJjo _

oBM2@Boirj³

· JvI›FŠ‰[pbMOoipbCD@iQBJvMOoK_e¬BJjr`JvPeJjr`@BC¿_Rr¾_e¬iF^_NMO@BPeI»@BCD_`AECEADoBf2@iFHCiI[MSQS@iCDJoBJbJYQBr¾_eM:aWJJboB¬WFHoipbJjQ5T aB@S_d_`¬iFH_

_`¬iJ:rgM2CD@S_eADM2o/§NJFOQSM2yS_FHCECEM^§vrd@WrN_`M›JjF2rgAECE‰;yBPeMpbJbJYQ;_eMKr`Jb²2JbPRFHC=MH¨´_`¬BJYrgJJjoB¬iFOoip‹JjI[Jjo _erj³

N% ÇŦË$

ÕLdPeAECDC5Jb_FHC‘³i×H‡O‡i‚‹ØZv³OLNPeADCEC‘TW³ m AEohTn$³2LFOoB]OMWT2z=³@BI›FHAGr\FOoiQ›w:³ vfWT ×H‡2‡B‚2³'FH_eF^|}klo _`JjoirgAE²OJ­@iJjrg_`AEMOo

wvoir`§dJjP`AEoBfW³ 5 ) ,1*&#53 ()+3!'1&

ÕQSJ(~d¬iFHCEJboWQBFHPJ‹_FOCU³i×O‡O‡ ׊Ø:?[³BQSJ»~d¬iFHCEJboiQiFHPYT ¥ ³ FOCDI›FOrjTSVN³iZ©CE]^F^_`JjaS|s?FHPRFBTBˆ(³BVBJbPePeJ‹_jTSL9³i?9PRFH@hTBn$³

v@BPRFH@BCD_g|l€©CGFHo _eJ‹_jTN?[³¾klCDCEMO@BX2T m ³©nMOoipbJjFO@Sq5T©kµ³©u¯MOaiaiFBTNw:³¾xAECEoiF^_YT×O‡O‡2×BT ¥ ¬BJ{­@BJjrg_`AEMOo wvoir`§NJbP`|

ADoBfzS‰rg_`JjI+­9w m ~ F^_ m ksn>zkµT\Z¾qSytJbPeADIKJjo2_Rr›AEo rgAEoBf$· JbaÖFOoiQ ·>M2PeQBJ‹_Y³""$1 5) ,1

.&'#5 34+()3!'1Öyiyh³B† Y|}†

ÕÙ~d¬ @B|s~NFOP`PeMOCECWJb_FHC‘³W×H‡2‡2×^ØW³¹~d¬@S|s~NFOP`PeMOCEC‘TOM2¬Bo$€©PRFHfOJjPjT´~d¬iP`AGrs_eMOyB¬iJbP· JbCD_s‰OTP`Xj‰r`X‹_eMH¨~dXj@BaiFFOoiQ

FŠ²AGQ1ViJbPeP`@ipbAU³×O‡O‡ ×S³¯w n@BCD_`AD|lz_`PRF^_`JjfO‰ FOoiQ1I»@BCD_`AD|}r`MO@iPepbJ"wyByBPeM2F2pR¬Ö_`M1­@iJjrg_`AEMOowvoir`§dJjP`AEoBfW³

5 )",1 *&#53 ()+3!'1&ÖyByh³h‚Š×^†O|e‚Y„O„

ÕÙ~dCEFOP`]2JJb_FHC‘³i×H‡O‡i‚‹Ø»~³

m

³¶~dCGFHPe]OJOT¾?[³cx(³¾~dM2P`I›F2pR]tT

¥

³´u³

m

‰oiFOI8T\~³¹n$³

m

AdFHoWQ<?[³

m

³´np

m

JjFOP`ocT

×H‡O‡i‚OTW·>Jja u¯JjADoB¨ªMOPRp‹JjQ ­@BJjrg_`AEMOo{woir`§dJjP`AEoBf>ÍUn@BCD_`A

¥

Jbq_Z©qSyWJjP`AEIKJbo _erv¨ªMOP

¥

PeJjp[×H‡2‡B‚Y΋T! "

5)",1 *&#53 ()+3!'1&

ÕVBJbCECEaiFH@BI ‚j…2…^Ø»~³BVBJjCDCEaiFO@BI¦³h‚j…2…B³· MOPRQBvJb_jÛ\woZ©CEJjpµ_eP`M2oBAGp m J‹qSAEpjFHC 9F^_RFHaiF2rgJ2³W~NFHI»aiP`AGQSfOJ2TBnw:Û

nk¥ €\P`JYr`r

ÕvJbPeI9ÒgFOpbMOa8J‹_FHC‘³i×H‡2‡2×^Ø »³ vJbPeI9ÒgFH]2MOahTHw»³OZ\pR¬BAE¬iFOaBASFHoiQ »³2nFHPRp‹@h³H×O‡O‡2×BT^F^_e@BPRFHC m FOoBfO@WFHfOJNLFOr`JjQ

u¯J‹¨ªM2P`I(@BCEFH_`AEMOo<u¯JYrgM2@BPRp‹J;FHoWQ$·>Jja®Z©qyiCDM2A¿_RF^_`AEMOo"¨ªM2PK­@BJYrs_eADM2o<wvoir`§NJbPeADoBfWT#$% 5) ,1

.&'#5 34+()3!'1

ÕnFHf2oBADoiA5J‹_FHC‘³i×H‡2‡2×OF^ØL³¾nFOfOoBAEoBA‘T\n$³©JbfOPeA‘T©u³©€©PeJb²2J‹_`J8FHoiQ :³ ¥ FHoBJj²=³¾×O‡O‡ ×HFB³´ksr[k}_(_e¬BJu¯ADf2¬ _

wvoir`§dJjP'&¦Z©qSyBCDM2A¿_eADoif(· Jba¦PeJjQS@BoWQBFHoipb‰K¨ªMOPvwoirg§NJbPx©FOCDAGQBF^_eADM2ohT( $ "2'# ! 53 ) 53*+-,>yByh³

† ×^|‘† „2×

(8)

¨ªP`M2I u¯JjyWJYF^_`JYQ{~dMH|}MSpbp‹@iP`PeJboipbJjrjÛ k`ˆ?ZdZFH_ ¥ uvZN~\|s×H‡2‡2×BT '5 ) , 1 *&#53 (+)3!'1

ÕnMOCGQSM^²^FHo8J‹_vFHC‘³W×O‡O‡2×^Ø(³5nMOCGQSM^²^FHohT=z=³ FHPRFHaWFHfOAE@hTiu:³=?9AEPÁÒs@cT=€¶³tnMOPRFHPeJjrep‹@cTiVN³

m

FOpbFH_`@ir`@hTtw:³5vMO|

² AGrepR¬BAUT¯w»³dLFOQBFOCDJYr`pb@FHoiQֈ(³dLNM2CDM2¬iFHohT¯×H‡2‡2×BT

m

~¯~

¥

MMOCGrK¨ªMOP¦­@BJjrg_`AEMOoÖwoirg§NJbPeAEoBfiT*

5)",1 *&#53 ()+3!'1&

Références

Documents relatifs

The annotation tags are used to find the candidate answer based on the type of the question, for example, a word with location tag is a good candidate answer to a where question, and

Historical /political/geographical map Une carte thématique A physical map Une carte physique A cartogram, an anamorphosis map Une carte par anamorphose. A dot map Une carte

In summary, four steps have been identified, and each of them needs to be addressed to be able to predict relevance using multiple sources of evidence, namely, sources selec-

In this work we present a study about cognitive agents that have to learn how their different information sources can be more or less trust- worthy in different situations and

Other works have shown how families of different cultures can be characterized by different argumentative styles (Arcidiacono &amp; Bova, in press), the relevance of an

In this context, we build on available multimodal articulatory data and present an inver- sion framework to recover articulation from audio- visual speech information.. Speech

express a single event in thousands of ways in natural language sentences. Therefore, paraphrase identification, which determines whether or not two formally

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des