On the performance of multiple description codes over bit error channels

(1)

)+*-,/.10324065/7895;:=<>*@?A0B897DCFEHG,IJ@G0BKL0$MN?A5OIJ1,/I8P*RQS8T10UM+8UVP065XWYI,+Z45/5/895[Q\.1<>*@*10$GM

]1^`_ab^dcfegihkjl;m(n

oqprstuv6w;pxypzu!{|{@}~z`syu!~

qup!`~q~ypysduv$kztN`~Nwp(zOt

b wOu!~Nbpy{bqu`>

p({yx!` !¡¢£!¤¥¦!¥¨§ª©¤©«U§ª©b

¬1hN®eb¯Ol±°²¯/eb³O³m

oiprbstbuvU´µu!¶yxp@·u{|{¸}~yz`syu!~

¹º~»sys}bs9¼6q½f¼·>¾´

¿!À!¿` ku!r`Áf~syru!xyyÂ~zp

p({yx¨Ãk !ÄÅN©k¢6§Æ!©bÇÇb£¥«k¡¥k!(ÅÈ§É¡

Ê

^jaËÌeÍÏÎ

Ê

^`j(Ðb^`ÑÑ(e

ÁP}Nyuky}Nx;·u{|{¸}~yz`syu!~9Ò`¶;t

k9yfÂpbp(xO¹º~»sys}bspiuv¨wpz~uxyu!

¿kÓ Ò;}`~~p!9ÔsÕp(x~

p({yx>Ö`¥!¡×¥!¤!¤k!£¦` !×bÖ«©Ø/§º¥`ÇkÉ¦A§Ù

ÚqÛ(ÜÝÞ»ßà(Ý¸á âLãäåæçAäèêé;èëìíæçåæî/ïñð»âXòóµì!îOéèbëDô;õköè

÷

èkèï±çíîç¨îëèbéDå(îçíîböæøé;èdíî

÷

ãëåï;èbëëqõùNõNæï;ëåéõå(õäîëë

æøïDçõNì`úNèkå(ûëü|æÌåì!ôOèéDï;èkåüHîNí`úOë!ýqþ(ï±åôæëHç;õNç¨èkíkÿ/üHè²íèbç¨îNíå

íèbëãäåë î/ïXåôOè\ç¨èkí îNí±õNïì!èêî âXò ìî;é;èë üô;èïLãëèbé

îï ÷ æåÏèkí`íîNí ìô;õïï;èbäøëµü|æåô èkíí`îí±ìîNíí`èbì!åæï;ù+ì!îOéèbë!ÿ9æï

îíé;èbí@åîDô;õïéäèäîNëëHî ÷ äîOì`ú;ëHüô;èïDåô;èï;ã ÷ èkí@î èbíû

íîNí`ë4æøï[õ

÷

äîOì`úXèì!èkèbéAëåô;èêì!îNííèìåæï;ùXõ

÷

æøäøæÌå[î

åôOè

ìî;é;è/ý Xè$ïéXåô;õå âXò ì!îOéèbëõNçAç¨èkõí åî ÷ è î/ã;åç¨èkíû

îNí±èbé

÷ õ±îNíè åíõNéæåæî/ïOõNäPëëåè æïSüôæì!ôêëî/ãOíìè

õNïé ì!ôOõïAï;èbä6ì!îOéèç;õíõ±èkåèkí`ëõíè(îæïåä îNçåæDæèbé åî

±æïæDæè èï;é;ûåîû»èï;éYéAæøëåîNíåæÌî/ï$ý

! "#$%

´µ}xÔsrxyp²p(z(yrsyu!~'&´µo)(fu}zp@zuky~+*,-*. , id{|p(suk

vuqp~Nb~|0//p(p(~ksPy~vu{su~ u`!p(9sºÈu|zN`~~pxyfu²s`sfys

yPp(zuk`¶xypivu{=`~Ïu~pzN`~~p(xª¶}bs>yp(21}N`xÔsµbpzukk

y~|Pru!y¶xp1}~|¶uszN`~~pxyt>wÈpH´µo[zukby~|ru¶xyp{

È$uy!y~xyxÔ¸vøu`{¸}xÌsp²`Ufru!¶xyp{Luv/zu{|{¸}~yz`syu~@up(

rz43p(s~p(sÈu53kt6fuÈppkxu>uvs1z~duzz}y~Ï`~|zu!{²

{@}~z`syu!~»b»sp{[sN`s}pUp(uÈzupzs~@z(ukp9p~|sp

`{|u!}~ksquvp(u1p87bzppqsp¸p(u`@z(upz(sy~¶yxÔsyp1uvUsp

z(ukp!t kN~~u~#9z~~pxqz(uky~ sp(up{R»s`sp(ÏsNssp(p

vu1zukbp1uv}:|zyp~ssp!;sp(p¸p7y»s1zukbpi9Ôs4¶Ôs`yxÔ

{`xyxru!¶¶xyÔsºu`v¨bpzuky~¸p(u`¶}sUsp(pq`pis9xyp»s>sÈu

p7`{|rxypiu`v>Ôs}Nsu~9pp¸syy~u`sHrrxyz¶xyp!t¾q~p¸p7b

`{|rxyp>yU9p~|p(xÌ¸zu!~»sy~srp(p~s¨sp9}p9u`v/xu~1zukbpt

ÁP~u`sp(>p7`{|rxypP9zu{|{¸}~yz`syu~dup>z~~pxyÈvøu`>9yz

xyuÈp¸¶u}~N u!~Dsp|p(u@ru¶N`¶yxyysDp7y»svøu`¸z(ukpHuv ß;<

xyp~sOp!ttysp>¶xyuz431vø!b~zp=*> ,t$wÈp>rp(vøu`{~z(pÈuv;´µo

z(uky~²u~}zµzN`~~pxyPy9y~kp»syspOt

¾q}{y~ !u!xP|suDpÔv1~ 9p~Y´µo zukp|{?3p

p(~p1sud¶pH}p y~sfzu!~sp87kstqÂufsNsqr}ru!pÈpH»s}Nb

1{|p{|u`xypA@i}~µu}zp`~N|{|p`~d51}`pPp(u=&´b¼A(

by»susyu!~+{|p`}p!tCBDpzu!~p(ÏsºÈu ¶ÔspuÏz~~pxy

rÔPuv6y~Nbprp~p~s9¶y~`d»b{|{|p(syzqzN~~pxy&%D>·E(~

rÔ¨u`vNy~Nbprp~Nbp~sA¶xuz43ivy~fz~~pxyF&%DÈÂ·E(twuf{?3p$u!}

p(!`x}`syu!~OÈpPzu!~p(ÈsÈu1»b»sp{|t$¾q~pP»b»sp{B}p(È~Ï´µo

z(ukpqs`s>rbuk}z(psºu²bpz(yrsyu!~bpzµu`v9yzÏy>zN`~~p(x

z(ukpd~prp(~Np(~ksxÔd`~Nds`~{|Ôsspdu!~µu~piu`v¨spizN`~~pxyt

wÈpµu`sp(|»b»sp{-}ps!bÔsu~N`xPy~!xyp pzrbsyu!~G&bo)(

z(ukp(O9up¸u!}bsr}bsyiz~~px¨p~zukp±`~Nrp±up(fsp

sÈu z~~pxyt ÂuµspHDÈ·fP ¶xyuz3\zukp 9ys ?I»}»s¶xp

rbuspzsu~ rp(vøu`{|y~ zz(uy~ suspJ@qxy¶p(s@¶u!}~NK*,U

}~Ôvøu`{=zx`)1}~syÕp(q9Ôs `~ ursy{xp~su!rµz(ukp(O`~N

y~ sp´µo3zp!6dr`z(syzx$y~Np7D`y!~{|p(~ksL*. , yH}{|p

y~ spÏrp(vøu`{~z(pµz`xz(}x`syu!~têÂu|spJDÈÂ·fUspÏzN`~~p(x

z(ukprp(vøu`{~zp|y@{|ukbpxyp41sp¸xup(²¶u}~N u!~ `zyp

`¶xyp¶xyuz43 p(udru¶N`¶yxyysyp|9ÔsC&ko)(¸~ 9Ôsu}s+&´µo)(

y~sp(xypky~+*ÓM,`~Nsp1u}zp@zukp@rp(vøu`{~z(p@yi{|ukbpxyp

`>spqsp(y»susyu!~rpvøu{`~zpN*,t

O5P-QRFSTMUWV=S-XYZ4XUWU\[0R5]NTM^_FX8_-_\QRa`cb#dfe

10 ⁻³ 10 ⁻² 10 ⁻¹

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40

BER

SNR [dB]

zw{|}~L

Z5T?]R5US [_oQHXUWm[0u

Yo[0]jR=Xu]Z5R5un_oU\Xv][0Y\_\TMU%_o[0TMuXu]

W4MMjj4joj

ZoQXuuR5vZ5T]jR

)8w

~ h

Z5T][0uj S [_\Q

W4MMjj4joj

ZoQXuuR5vZ5T]jR

)8 ~{

h

Z4T?][0uS [_\Q

W4MMj5MMoMn

Z5T?]RGXu]_\Q^jY

v0TSR4U-Y\TM^U\Z5Rql[_ U\X8_oR

df[0McbR5U%xTMUW)XuZ5RNTx

L

Xu] h

Y\mY\_\R5=Y S[_\Q¡X£¢j¤jR5]

ZoQXuuR5vZ5T]jRqX8_AXa_oT_oXvUoX8_\RqTx¦¥§l[_\Y¨8YoX=iv0RM

n ©«ªf¬)® "cª¯°j® $%±j ±

·u{|rNu~²pµ¶pp(~ {pd¶p(sºpp~\bo=~\´µo=zuky~b

9p(p>sp>zN`~~p(x1}N`xÔs²`~N¸spÈsu`sxsp)&~b}{¸¶p(6u`v/z~b

~px»b{¸¶ux>rp>u!}bzp»b{¸¶u!x(69zu~»s`~kst$wÈpqp}xys>u

s`sy~Y`x{|u»sÏxyxfÔs}`syu!~iko zukb~4y}rp(yudsu ´µo

z(uky~btÂu`ispDÈÂ·f;y~sp(xypky~yi{|upHp8:|zyp~sfsN~±´µo

z(uky~bt$ÂuÈsp§DÈ·fsp9p}xysÈz~¶pqp7rxy~p²vÌu!{3ÂAybt

9yzu9Ps`sPy~z(p`y~²spz(p~sx;y»susyu!~u`v¨spH´µo

z(ukp(;p}zpsp$rpvøu{`~zp$vøu`¨!uuk1z~~pxy¨`~Ny{|rup

Ôs¨vu$ruu$zN~~pxyt¨boêzukby~q9Ôs@spÈ{|pp(u$zu`pz(sy~

z(ukp|y1¶p(ssp(sN`~4`xx$sp´µo zukpvu@!uukDzN`~~p(xH`~N

up²vu1ruuHzN`~~p(xt6quÈp(p(;¶k y~z(py~µsp²rbuspz

syu~±y~±sp¸zN`~~p(x¨zukp(¨boBzuky~z~ u!}bsrp(vøu`{ xyx6sp

´µo zukp(P»b»sp{|Èvuqxyx;zN`~~pxc1}xyÔsp(t

?nE¯ "c²!±?$% ±

¹~HsyAÈu53pÈNpp(ruspHu!~xÔHu!~pprbpp~s`sypp(}xÔs6uv

f»»sp({`syz>»s}Nk@y~¸9yz¸pP~N`xÔÕ(p@sp>}p(vø}xy~p$uv;´µo

z(ukp$su¸bpx9Ôsdxyu!Èu`vA`sy~dp`xzu!{|{@}~z`syu!~²»b»sp{|

9Ôs ~up `²spÏ{nIºuzN~~px>y{|rÔ{|p~st\´µ}z su±u!}

}bryp!;ÈpN³N~ s`sH`rrNp~sxÔ¨´µo3z(ukpHuµ~us1rpvøu{

`>ÈpxyxA`>ÈpiÈu}xµ!pip87brpz(sp/t

Áf~µp7bsp(~Npdpu~uv¨syÈÈu53dz`~¶pqvøu}~`s

´4µ5µ¶k·¸5¸5¹4º»¼5½5½5½¾¿o¶4À¹¾Áº\´8¸4Â5Ã5¿rÄ5¼¿rµ4µÅ5¸o¶5Æ4Ç8¹4È5º»µ8ÈÅoÉÃ5¸5È5Ã5ÈoµÊ5Ë5ËÌWÇk¾0´µÍ8¹

Î£ªf¬ªfªf"#ª#±

Ï

ÐecÑaÒAÓ4XUWTSqÔjÕrÒAuNX Y\TM^UWZ4RqZ5T?][0u)iUWTMlv0R5ÖS [_oQ_ST=ZrQXuuR5v0Y

Xu]2_oQUWR5RUWR5Z5R4[nR5UWYÔ×qØÙÚÚÛkÜMÝrÞ%ß#àkÙoá5âßkãjßäÔMnTMvÁ?åMæjÔnijiw4æMçMæè4æMéjMÔ

R5ZMw4æM¥Mçj

Ï

é8Ð)ê2Fë2êX[0Y\QX=iX5m?XuwÔEÕ

R5Yo[0MuKTx)2^v_\[0iv0Rì]R5YoZ5UW[0ij_\[0TMuYoZ4XväXU

í

^Xun_o[0Ó5R5U\Y4Ô×Fî\ï#ïcïàð\ñMòÝ5ßîròóônðõ ßàwâÙoônðÜMÔMnTMvÁ?öMæjÔnijiw?¥Méjrè¥Mö÷Ô

X5mL4æMæMöj

Ï

ö8Ð«pEøFujTMii Xu]§bfë28Ñ^2lv0R_Ô4ÕoÒAu2Z5T?][0uAxTMUflv0TZoVqxX][0uZrQXujù

uR5v0Y4Ô×2î\ï#ïcïCàðWñnòÝßfîòóôMðõ=ßAàwâjÙrôMðÜMÔnTMvÁ÷nújÔiiw4¥MæèéMçMåjÔwû?Xu

éMçMçMçj

Ï

÷Ð«pE` üväXQ^_ÔwàâjÙrôMðÜqñMòýþ-ðWñnáÞÁÿárÙ ô\óqñnÞÁñàðWñMòÝrõ§ÿÝrÝrÿôMò¦ôýnÙÝo

R5ij_4`s` Ô u[?Txv0v0[0uTM[0YÔUWlXuX8ù%sQX=iX[0MuwÔjéu])R4] iUWR5ù

v0[0=[0uXU%m=]U\X8x_rÔ4æMæ

Ï

å8ÐecÑaÒAÓ4XU\T4SqÔ h h QX)X[ÁÔXu]Lëa

£mjuR5U5ÔÕujxTMUW)X8_\[0TMu_oQjR5ù

TMUWR_o[0Z£Z5TMuYo[0]jR4U\X8_\[0TMuYxTMUZ5R5v0v0^väXU=TMl[0v0RU\X][0TÔ× î\ï#ïcï àðWñMòÝ5ß

Ù5âß àÙráâòônÚßäÔnTMvÁ÷nöjÔijiwöMåMæèö¥jÔ

X4mL4æMæ÷

On the performance of multiple description codes over bit error channels

10 −3 10 −2 10 −1

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40

BER

SNR [dB]

10 ⁻³ 10 ⁻² 10 ⁻¹