HAL Id: hal-00893838
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00893838
Submitted on 1 Jan 1990
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of
sci-entific research documents, whether they are
pub-lished or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés.
Resistance to experimental infections with Haemonchus
contortus in Romanov sheep
G Luffau, J Vu Tien Khang, J Bouix, Tc Nguyen, P Cullen, G Ricordeau, C
Carrat, F Eychenne
To cite this version:
Original
article
Resistance
to
experimental
infections
with Haemonchus
contortus
in
Romanov
sheep
G Luffau
1
J Vu
TienKhang
2
J Bouix
2
TC
Nguyen
P
Cullen
4
G Ricordeau
C Carrat, F
Eychenne
Institut National de la RechercheAgronomique;
1
Station
de Virologie et d’Immunologie, Centre de Recherches deJouy-en-Josas,
78350Jouy-en-Josas;
2
Station
d’Amédioration Génétique des Animaux, Centre de Recherches de Toulouse, BP 27, 3i326 Castanet-Tolosan Cedex;s
Laboratoire
des GroupesSanguins,
Centre de Recherches de Jouy-en-Josas, 78350 Jouy-en-Josas;4
Laboratoire
de Génétique Biochimique, Centre de Recherches deJouy-en-Josas,
78350 Jouy-en-Josas, France(Received
22August
1989; accepted 28 February1990)
Summary
-Responses to immunization with
aggregated
human serum albumin(HSA)
and to repeated experimental infections with H contortus were studied in 51 female lambs
of the Romanov breed, born from 8 sires and 36 dams. The 8 sires were of
haemoglobin
genotype Hb
AB;
the 51 lambs were distributed into 3 groups of 17 each,corresponding
tothe 3 genotypes
HbAA,
HbAB and HbBB. In addition theexperimental
lambs weretyped
for antigens of the major
histocompatibility
system(OL./1).
Theparasitological findings
were the
following:
a repeatability of faecal egg counts between successive infections, anegative
correlation between peak faecal egg counts and self-cureintensity,
a positivecorrelation between faecal egg counts and
degree
of anaemia, an acquisition of immunityto the parasite by previous contact with the parasite and a reduction of this immunity
by anthelmintic treatment.
According
to thegenetic
investigations, there weresignificant
sire effects on variables
reflecting
the resistance. The faecal egg counts did not seem to be related to thehaemoglobin
system, butmight
be affectedby
1 or several genes located inthe OLA complex or close to the latter. The humoral response to HSA showed a negative
correlation to parasite resistance.
sheep / Haemonchus contortus / humoral response / haemoglobin / OLA system
R.ésumé - Résistance à des infestations expérimentales par Haemonchus contortus
en race ovine Romanov. Les réponses à une immunisation avec de la sérum albumine humaine
agrégée
(SAH)
et à desinfestations
expérimentales répétées avec H contortus ont été étudiées chez 51 agnelles de race Romanov, issues de 8 pères et de 36 mères. Les 8 pères étaient hétérozygotes AB pour le systèmehémoglobine
(Hb)
et les 51agnelles
*
étaient réparties en tmis groupes de 17 correspondant aux trois génotypes Hb AA, Hb AB
et Hb BB. Par ailleurs, les agnelles
expérimentales
ont été typées pour le système majeurd’histocompatibilité
(OLA).
Sur leplan parasitologique,
les résultats obtenus mettent enévidence: une
répétabilité
du taux d’excrétion des oeufs entreinfestations
successives, unecorrélation négative entre niveaux des pics d’excrétion et intensité de l’autostérilisation
(&dquo;self-cure&dquo;),
une corrélation positive entre taux d’excrétion et degré d’anémie, uneacquisition de l’immunité parasitaire par contact préalable avec le parasite et une réduction de cette immunité par
vermifu ation.
Sur le plangénétique,
on observe deseffets
pèresignificatifs
sur des variablesrejetant
la résistance. Le système hémoglobine ne semble paslié au taux d’excrétion mais pourrait être lié au degré d’anémie
consécutif
àl’infestation.
La résistance à H contortus pourmit être influencée par un ou plusieurs gènes situés dans lecomplexe OLA ou à sa proximité. La réponse humorale à la SAH présente une corrélation
négative
avec la résistance au parasite.ovin Haemonchus contortus / réponse humorale / hémoglobine / système OLA
INTRODUCTION
Since the
publications
of Warwick et al(1949),
Whitlock(1955, 1958)
and Whitlock and Madsen(1958),
the existence of agenetic variability
in the resistance toHaemonchus contortus has been shown in several studies: the
heritability
estimates range around 0.25-0.30(Le
Jambre,
1978;
Albers etal,
1984, 1987;
Piper,
1987).
As there are almost nogenetic
correlations between the resistance and variousproduction
traits(Alberts
etal,
1984, 1987; Piper,
1987),
selection on resistance toH contortus would be
possible
andeconomically justified
in conditions where thistype of
parasitism
leads tolarge
productivity
losses(Holmes, 1986).
However,
it doesnot seem to be
possible
to use the response to anexperimental
infection as alarge-scale selection criterion because of the difficulties of such an
experimentation.
It would therefore beinteresting
toidentify
resistancepredictors,
eitherimmunological
traits orgenetic
markers(Courtney,
1986;
Alberts andGray,
1987;
Cabaret andGruner,
1988).
Several studies suggest that
haemoglobin
A alleleprovides
ahigher
resistance toH contortus than the
haemoglobin
B allele(Evans
etal,
1963;
Jilek andBradley,
1969;
Radhakrishnan etal,
1972;
Allonby
andTJrquhart, 1976;
Altaif andDargie,
1976, 1978a,
b;
Preston andAllonby,
1979;
Dally
etal,
1980;
Luffau etal, 1981a,
b;
Courtney
etal,
1985).
According
toCuperlovic
et al(1978),
this enhanced resistancemight
be related to ahigher
humoral immune response.From a
genetic
point
ofview,
the mainobjective
of the presentexperiments
was to confirm or invalidate thishypothesis.
Because thetyping
of animals in themajor
histocompatibility
system( OLA)
wasperformed retrospectively,
a search forrelationships
between resistance to H contortus and the OLA marker was alsoincluded in this
study.
From a
parasitological
point
ofview,
theexperimental
goals
were tosupply
additional information on the
following
phenomena: repeatability
of faecal eggcounts between successive
infections, relationship
between egg counts andself-cure,
relationship
between egg counts anddegree
ofanaemia,
acquisition
ofimmunity
to the
parasite
by
previous
contact with theparasite
and effect of anthelmintictreatment on this
acquired immunity.
MATERIALS AND METHODS Animals
Several studies have shown that females
develop
strongerimmunity
against
H contortus than males(Colglazier
etal,
1968;
Yazwinski etal,
1980;
Luffau etal, 1981a; Courtney
etal,
1985; Watson,
1986):
henceonly
females were used inthe present
study,
ie 51 female lambs of the Romanov breed born from 8 sires and 36 dams. Thebreeding
animals were chosenaccording
to theirhaemoglobin
genotype.
All sires were Xb ABheterozygotes.
The damsbelonged
togenotypes
Hb
AA,
Hb AB or Hb BB. The 51 lambs fell into 3 groups of17,
eachrepresenting
1 of the 3haemoglobin
genotypes.
The number of animals in the 3haemoglobin
genotypes
was balanced within each sire progeny so as to reduce risks of confusion between apossible haemoglobin
genotype
effect and apossible
sire effect.Fifty
lambs and 24 of their 35 dams weretyped
forantigens
of the OLAsystem.
The sires were not
typed
but theirgenotypes
could be inferred and transmission of markers determined in many cases.The
experimental
female lambs were chosen so as to form a group ashomoge-neous as
possible
for age,weight,
maintenance conditions and health in order to reduce uncontrolled factors of variation. The animals were maintained on a grassfree diet from birth to avoid environmental exposure to H contortus.
Typing
methods forhaemoglobin
and OLAsystems
Haemoglobin
types
were determinedby
electrophoresis
(Nguyen
andBunch,
1980).
Class I
antigens
of themajor
histocompatibility
system were testedby
themicro-cytotoxicity
method on bloodlymphocytes;
the test was carried out over aperiod
of 2h 30 min
(Cullen
etal,
1985).
Lymphocytes
of each animal were tested with120 antisera
against
22provisional
specificities,
&dquo;OLA-P&dquo;. Ninehaplotypes,
eachcarrying
1 or 2specificities,
were identified in the tested animals.Immunization
experiments
withaggregated
human serum albuminThe 51
experimental
lambs were immunized at the age of about 6 months with heataggregated
human serum albumin(HSA:
200mg/animal)
by
intravenousinjection.
Their serum was collected before and 14 d after the administration of the
antigen,
titred
by passive haemagglutination using
red blood cells tanned and sensitized with HSA(Weir, 1978).
Thetechnique
used to determine the serumagglutination
titre has been described
previously
(Nguyen, 1984).
Experimental
infections with H contortusAccording
to variousstudies, sheep develop immunity against
H contortus from the age of about 7 months(Jarrett
etal, 1961;
Manton etal,
1962;
Urquhart
etal,
1966a, b;
Knight
andRodgers,
1974;
Wilson andSamson, 1974;
Benitez-Usher etal,
1977; Duncan
etal, 1978;
Riffkin andDobson, 1979;
Smith andAngus,
1980).
Our
experiments
thereforebegan
when the lambs were about 8 months old.During
sheepfold
fitted with a slattedfloor,
diets based oncompound
feed concentrates,hay
and straw ad libitum. Five infection
experiments
were conductedsuccessively
using
3-week old larvae. Animals were infected with larvae obtained
by
faecal culturesaccording
to the method of FJS Robert and PJ O’Sullivan and collected with Baerman’s apparatus(Luffau
etal,
1981a,
b).
Therequired
number of larvae werecounted
microscopically
andsuspended
in 20 ml ofordinary
water. Thissuspension
was administered
orally.
The strain maintained at the Station ofVirology
andImmunology
wassupplied
initially by
Professors GMUrquhart
and EWAllonby
(Glasgow).
Experiment
1In
experiment
1,
lambs were divided into 3 groups:-
18 animals were
given
3 infectionssuccessively:
aprimary
infection on DO with5 000
larvae,
asecondary
one on D32 with 10 000 larvae and a 3rd one on D64 with20 000 larvae
(group 1);
-
18 animals were
given
2 infectionssuccessively:
aprimary
infection on D32 with10 000 larvae and a
secondary
one on D64 with 20 000 larvae(group 2);
- 15 animals
were
given
an infection of 20 000 larvae on D64(group 3).
The 3 groups were formed so as to obtain a balanced distribution of the various
paternal origins
andhaemoglobin
genotypes.
The kinetics of faecal egg counts was established for each animal.
Eggs
laidby
H contortus females and eliminated with the faeces were counted
using
faecalsamples
of3g
using
the Mc Master method. Measurements were made on thefollowing
40 dates:D17, D21, D24, D28, D31, D35, D37, D39, D42, D44, D46, D49,
D51, D53, D56, D58, D60,
D63, D65,
D67, D70, D72,
D74, D77,
D79, D81, D84,
D86,
D88, D91, D95, D98, D107,
D114,
D119, D126, D133, D140,
D147 and D156. Each measure(number
of eggs pergram)
was the mean egg count of 3 differentsamples. These egg
counts weregood
indicators of the worm burdens of the animals(Roberts
andSwan,
1981).
The
following
3haematological
parameters were recorded in all animals: number of red bloodcells, packed
cell volume andhaemoglobin
content. Thesemeasure-ments were made on the
following
dates:D9, D16, D23, D30, D39,
D45, D53, D58,
D67,
D74,
D88, D95, D102, D109,
D116, D123,
D130, D137, D144,
D151 and D158. The number of red blood cells(per
pl
ofblood)
was determinedby
measuring
the variation in the
potential
difference(Celloscope
401 -Ljungberg - Stockholm,
Sweden)
inducedby the passage
of red blood cells(blood
dilution1/800)
in anelectric field. The apparatus was
periodically
checkedaccording
to themicroscopical
method of Malassez.For
measuring
haematocrit(packed
cellvolume),
blood wascentrifuged
inheparinized capillary
tubes(inner
diameter: 0.55 mm;length:
75mm)
using
Janetzki’s TH-12centrifuge
at 1500r/min
for 5 min.For
measuring
thehaemoglobin
content(g/100
mlblood),
haemoglobin
of the red blood cellslysed by saponin
was fixed and transformed intocyanmethaemoglobin.
Thehaemoglobin
content was measuredby
spectrophotometry
(absorption
atExperiment
2The
surviving
49 animals were divided into 2 groups,irrespective
of the groupthey
were part of in
experiment
1:- the 26 animals of
group 1 were not drenched
prior
toexperiment
2;
hencethey
were carriers of a residual H contortus
population;
- before
starting
experiment
2 the 23 animals of group 2 were drenched with ahighly
effectiveanthelmintic,
Thibenzole MSDpowder
(thiazolyl
benzimidazole-thiabendazole
ND,
Paris,
France).
In these 2 groups, each animal was
given
10 000 larvae on DO ofexperiment
2(263
days
after DO ofexperiment
1).
Faecal egg counts were made on thefollowing
20 dates:Dl, D0,
D17,
D20, D24,
D27,
D31, D34,
D38,
D41,
D45, D48,
D56,
D59,
D80, D83,
D88,
D91,
D95 and D98.Experiment
3Experiment
3 was areplication
ofexperiment
2. The infection on DO tookplace
366days
after DO ofexperiment
1. The faecal egg counts were made on thefollowing
18 dates:D5, D8,
D9, D12,
D15, D19, D22, D26,
D29,
D33, D36,
D40, D43, D47,
D50, D54,
D57 and D64.Experiment
4 .In
experiment
4,
each animal was drenched andgiven
10 000 larvae on DO(485
days
after DO ofexperiment
1).
The faecal egg counts were made at thefollowing
19 dates:D5, D0, D3, D6, D10, D15, D19, D22, D26, D29, D33, D36, D40, D44,
D47, D50, D55,
D65 and D72.Experiment
5Experiment
5 was areplication
ofexperiments
2 and 3. The animals of each group(drenched
and notdrenched)
weregiven
10 000 larvae on DO(560
days
after DO ofexperiment
1).
The faecal egg counts were made on thefollowing
41 dates:D0,
D17,
D21, D24, D28, D31, D35, D38,
D42, D45,
D49,
D52, D56,
D59,
D63,
D70,
D73, D77, D80, D84, D87, D91,
D94,
D98, D101, D108, D115, D119, D123, D126,
D129,
D140,
D143,
D147, D150, D154,
D157, D161, D164,
D168 and D172. Statisticalanalysis
Choice of variables and factors Variables
The
immunological, parasitological
andhaematological
variables used aregiven
intable I. The
parasitological
variables were defined from decimallogarithms
of meanegg
counts
over certainperiods
(in
order to normalize distributions and obtain moreThus,
in each of the 3 groups ofexperiment
1,
apeak
faecal egg count wasobserved after the
primary
infection(fig 1).
Thispeak
was located from D24-D37 ingroup 1, from D56-D57 in group 2 and from D88-D107 in group 3: the PRIMPEAK
variable reflects this
peak.
In groups 1 and 2 of
experiment 1,
thesecondary
infection was followedby
a verygroup
2):
this was the classical self-curephenomenon.
Variable SELFCURE reflectsthis
phenomenon;
it is defined as the difference between theprimary
peak
andthe
depression
subsequently
to the self-cure. Asecondary peak
could be observedimmediately
after thisdepression
(D46
to D53 in group 1 and D84 to D88 in group2):
variable SECPEAK reflects thispeak.
In
experiments 2, 3, 4
and5,
the faecal egg counts increased after the infection(fig
2).
VariablesPEAKEXP2, PEAKEXP3, PEAKEXP4
and PEAKEXPS reflect thehigh
egg counts after the infection(from
D27-D48 inexperiment
2,
D26-D54 inex-periment 3,
D26-D55 inexperiment
4 and D28-D52 inexperiment
5).
Thesynthetic
variable PEAK2,35 is the mean of the 3 variablespreviously
defined inexpriment
2and in its 2
replications,
ieexperiments
3 and 5 alsoinvolving
2 groups of animals(a
group drenched before infection and a non-drenchedgroup).
Thesynthetic
vari-able PEAK235 does not include
experiment
4 in which all animals were drenchedprior
to infection.The
haematological
parameters are defined as means ofgiven
measures overcertain
periods.
The choice ofperiods
here isagain
based on a kinetic examination.The number of red blood
cells,
thepacked
cell volume andhaemoglobin
contentFactors
The factors of variation considered are
given
in table II. Two of these factors(HBALLELE,
thehaemoglobin
allele received from the sire andOLALLELE,
theOLA
haplotype
received from thesire)
are nested within sire.According
toanalyses,
the response to immunization with HSA was considered as a variable or a factor.
Method of
analysis
Analysis of
the humoral immune responseTwo methods were used for the statistical
analysis
of the humoral immune response, iex
2
test andanalysis
of variance.Chi-square
tests ofindependence
were carried out between the RESPOND factor(accounting
for the immunization&dquo;responder&dquo;
or&dquo;non-responder&dquo;
character)
and various other factors of variation of table II(sire, haemoglobin
genotype and OLA, haplotypes).
including
all factors ofvariation;
there would have been numerous either empty orlow cells.
Accordingly,
severalanalysis
of variance models were used eachinvolving
a small number of factors. This can also beapplied
to theanalyses
of variance of theparasitological
andhaematological
variables,
treated in thefollowing
paragraphs.
Analysis of
theparasitological
andhaematological
variablesof
experiment
1 Table IV shows theanalysis
of variance modelsapplied
to theparasitological
andhaematological
variables ofexperiment
1. When the factors did not includeRE-SPOND
(immunization
&dquo;responder&dquo;
or&dquo;non-responder&dquo;
trait)
or TITRE(category
of anti-HSA
antibody
titre),
the ANTIHSA variable(reflecting
the humoralre-sponse)
was added in order tostudy
its correlation with theparasitological
andhaematological
variables. The sameprocedure
was used foranalysis
of the vari-ables ofexperiments 2, 3,
4 and 5.Analysis of
thepana,sitological
variablesof
experirrzents 2,
3, 4
and 5Table V
gives
the models of theanalyses
of varianceperformed
on theparasitological
of the variable of
experiment 4,
since in thisexperiment
all animals weregiven
theanthelmintic treatment before infection.
Analysis
of
variousparasitological
variables considered asrepeated
measuresof
the same characterA new
approach
consists ofconsidering
that theparasitological
variablesexperiments
1, 2,. 3,
4 and5,
respectively)
constituterepeated
measures of thesame
parasitological
overall variable OVERALL. Table VIgives
models ofanalyses
- the EXPGROUP factor
corresponding
to theexperiment
andgroup
combination in which the OVERALL variable wasmeasured;
- the ANIMAL factor
corresponding
to theexperimental
animal in which themeasure was made.
RESULTS
Analysis
of the humoral immune responseChi-square
tests ofindependence
between the&dquo;responder&dquo;
character and various other factors(sire,
haemoglobin
genotype
and OLAhaplotypes)
No x
2
was
significant
at the 0.05level,
with theexception
of the testof independence
between the
&dquo;responder&dquo;
character and the OLA -P14+9haplotype
(xi!
=5.953,
significant
at the 0.02level) :
thisx
2
resulted from apreferential
association between the&dquo;responder&dquo;
character and the OLA -P14 + 9haplotype.
Analyses
of variance of the ANTIHSA variablereflecting
the humoral immune responseAmong
the 23analyses
of variance described in tableIII, only analyses
no 8 and 19 showed asignificant
effect at the 0.05level;
in both cases, it was the effect of theOLA -P14 +9
haplotype
whose presence in the studiedsample
was related to anAnalysis
of theparasitological
andhaematological
variables ofexperi-ment 1
Table VII summarizes the results of the
analyses
of variance whose models aredescribed in table IV. Table VIII
gives
the residual correlations calculated onthe
parasitological
andhaematological
variables relative on theprimary
peak
ofexperiment
1 and on theimmunological
ANTIHSA variable. Table IXgives
theresidual correlations calculated on all
parasitological
variables ofexperiment
1(relative
to theprimary
peak, secondary peak
and to theself-cure)
as well as onthe
immunological
ANTIHSA variable.Analysis
of theparasitological
variables ofexperiments
2, 3,
4 and 5 Table X summarizes the results of theanalyses
of variance whose models aredescribed in table V. Table XI
gives
the residual correlations calculated on theparasitological
variables ofexperiments 2, 3,
4 and 5 as well as on theimmunological
Analysis
of the variousparasitological
variables considered asrepeated
measures of the same characterTable XII summarizes the results of the
analyses
of variance whose models aredescribed in table VI.
The
repeatability
of the character measuredby
the OVERALL variable wasestimated in model No 71
(including
the crossed EXPGROUP and ANIMALfactors)
by
the intra-class coefficient of correlation(ratio
of &dquo;individual&dquo; variance tothe sum of &dquo;individual&dquo; variance and residual
variance):
the estimatedrepeatability
was 0.26.
Figure
4 illustrates the effect of the TITRE factor(anti-HSA
antibody
titre)
onthe overall
parasitological
OVERALL variable. DISCUSSIONthe variable
reflecting
theself-cure,
the correlationbeing
only highly
significant
(P
<0.001)
between the self-cure and thesecondary peak:
in otherwords,
the animals with the lowest faecal egg counts were also those that bestexpelled
theirparasites.
Positive
(generally significant)
residual correlations were observed in thethe egg counts. The
highly
significant
effect of the ANIMAL factor on the overallparasitological
OVERALL variable(table XII)
illustrates therepeatability
of themean egg output
during
thepeaks
of the 5 successive infectionexperiments.
Phenotypic relationships
between faecal egg counts anddegree
of anaemiaThere were
highly
significant (P
<0.001)
correlations between the mean numberof red blood cells per mm3 of
blood,
the averagepacked
cell volume and themean level of
haemoglobin during
theprimary
peak
of eggspassed
inexperiment
1(table VIII).
ThePRIMPEAKvariable, reflecting
thepeak
faecal egg countsduring
primary
infection wasnegatively
correlated with the 3haematological
variables.This
corresponds
to thephenomenon
of anaemiaclassically
associated tolarge
faecal egg counts
(Whitlock,
1955, 1958;
Evan etal, 1963;
Pradhan andJohnstone,
1972;
Altaif andDargie, 1978a, b;
Roberts andSwan, 1982;
Albers etal,
1984).
Effect of
primary
dose of infective larvae of faecal egg counts and anaemia The factor GROUPl(group
inexperiment
1)
had asignificant
effect on allparasitological
andhaematological
variables measuredduring
theprimary
peak
ofexperiment
1(table VII):
asexpected,
thelarger
the larvalintake,
thehigher
thefaecal egg counts and the
degree
of anaemia(figures
1 and3).
Effect of vaccination onimmunity
to theparasite
Considering
the kinetics of faecal egg output in group 1 ofexperiment
1(figure 1):
thepeak
faecal egg counts after the 1st infection(with
5000larvae)
washigher
thanthe
peak
after the 2nd infection(with
10 000larvae)
which washigher
than thepeak
after the 3rd infection(with
20 000larvae).
Likewise, in group 2
ofexperiment
1(figure 1),
theprimary peak
exceeded thesecondary peak although
the 2nd dose of infective larvae was 2-foldhigher
than the 1st one(20 000
larvae instead of10 000).
With the same dose of infective larvae
(10
000 larvae on D32 or 20 000 larvae onD64),
animals which hadpreviously experienced
infection with H contortus reactedby
eliminating
fewer eggs than those infected with theparasite
for the first time.These observations
(based
onfigure
1 and confirmedstatistically by analyses
ofvariances not shown
here)
illustrate thephenomenon
ofimmunity
to theparasite
(ie protection)
acquired by &dquo;vaccination&dquo;,
ieby
previous
infection with theparasite
(Clunies
Ross,
1932; Luffau,
1975;
Luffau etal,
1981a,
b).
Effect of anthelmintic treatment on
immunity
to theparasite
In
experiments
2 and3,
the group drenched before infection eliminatedsignificantly
more eggs than the non-drenched group
(figure
2 and first line of tableX);
the anthelmintic treatmentsubstantially
reduced theimmunity
acquired previously by
contact with the
parasite.
Thephenomenon
was more marked inexperiment
3 whichwas a
replication
ofexperiment
2. Inexperiment 5,
the same trend was observedof the
previous experiment
(experiment 4)
seemed to have reduced the difference between the 2 groups.All these
results,
which show the reduction ofimmunity
to theparasite
after anthelmintic treatment, confirm those obtainedby
Benitez-Usher et al(1977)
according
to whomapplication
of such a treatment after vaccination with irradiated larvae lowered theimmunity
to theparasite.
Phenotypic
relationships
between resistance toparasitism
and humoralimmunity
.Factors
relating
to the anti-HSAantibody
titre(RESPOND
andTITRE)
hadsignificant
effects on variousparasitological
variables ofexperiments
1(table VII),
2, 3,
4 and 5(table X)
as well as the overallparasitological
OVERALL variable(table XII).
Thehigher
theproduction
of anti-HSA antibodies thelarger
the faecal egg counts, as shownby adjusted
means infigure
4. Thispositive
relation betweenfaecal egg count and humoral
immunity
is also illustratedby
thepositive
coefficients of correlation between variousparasitological
variablesreflecting
the faecal eggoutput and the variable ANTIHSA
reflecting
the humoralimmunity
(tables
IX andXI).
Contrary
to thehypothesis
put forwardby Cuperlovic
et al(1978),
response to an immunization withaggregated
human serum albumin is not apredictor
of resistance to H contortus. Thisnegative
correlation between resistance to helminths and response to an immunization hasalready
been observed
in mice(Blum
andCioli,
1978;
Deelder etal, 1978;
Perrudet-Badoux etal, 1978; Wakelin,
1978).
Insheep,
Albers et al(1984)
did not find anysignificant
correlation between resistanceto H contort and response to an immunization with chicken red blood cells. Sire effect on resistance to H contortus
Significant
sire effects were evidenced on the PRIMPEAK variableaccounting
forthe
primary
peak
faecal egg counts inexperiment
1(table VII)
and on the overallparasitological
OVERALL variablepertaining
to allexperiments
(table XII):
these effects weresignificant
at the 0.05 and 0.10level, respectively.
The number ofexperimental
animals(51
offspring
of 8sires)
was too small to make aheritability
estimation.
However,
our results are in favour of a sire effect onresistance;
they
are inkeeping
with those of Le Jambre(1978),
Albers et al(1984, 1987)
andPiper
(198?)
who found aheritability ranging
from 0.25-0.30 for resistance to H contortus.Relationships
betweenhaemoglobin
system
andimmunological,
para-sitological
andhaematological
variablesNeither the HBGENO factor
(haemoglobin
genotype)
or theHBALLELE
factor(haemoglobin
allele received from thesire)
had anysignificant
effect at the 0.05 level on theimmunological
orparasitological
variables,
although
theexperiment
was
designed
toverify
the existence of such effects.and
Dargie, 1976, 1978a, b;
Preston andAllonby,
1979;
Dally
etal,
1980;
Luffau etal, 1981a, b; Courtney
etal,
1985),
butthey
are inkeeping
with the results ofLe Jambre
(1978),
R,iffkin and Dobson(1979),
Courtney
et al(1984),
Riffkin andYong
(1984)
and Albers andBurgess
reported by Piper
(1987),
who did not findany
relationship
between resistance to H contortus andhaemoglobin
system.Thus,
although
our data do not lead to detection of anyrelationship
of humoralresponsiveness
(to
human serumalbumin)
or of resistance to H contortus with thehaemoglobin
system, there is evidence of astatistically
significant
effect(P
<0.05)
of the HBALLELE factor(haemoglobin
allele received from thesire)
on the meanpacked
cell volume(table VII).
Hence arelationship
betweenhaemoglobin
systemand
post-infection degree
of anaemia cannot be excluded.According
to theadjusted
means, it seems that animalscarrying
the HbA allele were less anaemic than the others. These results are inagreement
with those of Evans and Whitlock(1964),
Radhakrishnan et al
(1972),
Altaif andDargie
(1976,
1978a,
b)
and Albers andBurgess
reported by Piper
(1987).
Thepost-infection
differences observed between animals of varioushaemoglobin
genotypes
might simply
be due to differencesexisting
in non-infected animals(Agar
etal,
1972).
These differencesmight
arise from oxygenaffinity
differences betweenhaemoglobins
A and B.Haemoglobin
A has ahigher
oxygenaffinity:
atequal
pressure, it releases less oxygen, whichmight
cause the creation of compensatory mechanisms in
haemoglobin
A carriers(Agar
et
ad,
1972).
Relationships
between the OLAsystem
withimmunological,
parasito-logical
andhaematological
variablesThe results obtained show
statistically
significant
effects of various OLAhaplotypes
on the humoral response as well as on the faecal egg counts and the
degree
of anaemia afterparasite
infections(tables
VII,
X andXII).
Thus,
we cannot exclude theexistence,
within or close to the OLA system, of genesaffecting
these variousphenomena.
These resultsdisagree
with those ofCooper
et alreported by Piper
(1987),
who did not find any association between OLA system and resistance to H contortus. Butthey
do agree with those ofOutteridge
et al(1984,
1985,
1986,
1987 and1988)
who found an association between the OLA system and the responseto a vaccination
against
Trichostrongylus colubrifo!rmas.
Arelationship
between themajor histocompatibility complex
and resistance to nematodeparasites
has also been demonstrated in the case of theguinea pig-Trichostrongylus
colnbriformis
system
(Geczy
andRothwell,
1981)
and themouse- Trichostrongylus spiralis
system(Wassom
etal,
1979).
CONCLUSION
In terms of
parasitology,
the results obtained lead to a more accurate determination of a certain number ofphenomena
such asrepeatability
of faecal egg counts betweeninfections, negative relationship
between faecal egg countpeaks
and self-cureintensity, positive
relationship
between faecal egg counts anddegree
ofanaemia,
In terms of
genetics,
the results invalidate thehypothesis
thathomozygous sheep
carriers ofhaemoglobin
A have lower faecal egg counts than the others as well asthe
hypothesis
that animals with the best humoral immune response are the most resistant toparasitism.
On the otherhand, they
do not exclude thehypothesis
thatgenes
within or close to the OLA systemmight
affect the resistance to H contortus.The latter
conclusion,
inkeeping
with those of otherstudies, emphasizes
the role of the OLA system as apotential
marker of resistance toparasitism.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors are
grateful
to K R6rat(Unite
Centrale deDocumentation, INRA,
Centre de Recherches deJouy-en-Josas)
for the translation of themanuscript.
REFERENCES
Agar
NS,
EvansJV,
Roberts J(1972)
Red blood cellpotassium
andhaemoglobin
polymorphism
insheep.
A review. Anim Breed(Abstr)
40, 407-436
Albers
GAA, Gray
GD(1987)
Breeding
for worm resistance: aperspective.
Int JParasitod
17,
559-566Albers
GAA,
Burgess
SE,
AdamsDB,
BarkerJSF,
Le JambreLF,
Piper
LR(1984)
Breeding
Haemonchus contort resistantsheep - problems
and prospects. In:Imrrcunogenetic approaches
to the controlof endoparasates
withparticular
reference
toparasates
of
sheep,
Proc of aworkshop
held atSydney
University,
October
22-23 1983,
on behalf of the Australian WoolCorporation, CSIR,O,
EastMelbourne,
41-52Albers
GAA, Gray GD, Piper LR,
BarkerJSF,
Le JambreLF,
Barger
IA(1987)
Thegenetics
of resistance and resilience to Haemonchus contortus infection in young Merinosheep.
Int J Parasitol17,
1355-1363Allonby
EW, Urquhart
GM(1976)
Apossible relationship
between haemonchosis andhaemoglobin polymorphism
in Merinosheep
inKenya. Res
Vet Sca20,
212-214Altaif
KI, Dargie
JD(1976)
Genetic resistance ofsheep
to Haemonchus contortus. In: Nucleartechniques
in animalproduction
andhealth,
Proc of aSymp,
Vienna,
2-6
February
1976, jointly
organized
by
the IAEA andFAO,
International AtomicEnergy
Agency,
Vienna,
449-461Altaif
KI,
Dargie
JD(1978a)
Genetic resistance to helminths. The influence of breed andhaemoglobin
type on the response ofsheep
toprimary
infections with Haemonchus contortus.Parasitology
77,
161-175Altaif
KI,
Dargie
JD(1978b)
Genetic resistance to helminths. The influence of breed andhaemoglobin
type on the response ofsheep
to re-infection with Haemorcchvs contortus.Parasitology
77,
177-187Benitez-Usher
C,
ArmourJ,
DuncanJL, Urquhart
GM, Gettingby
G(1977)
Astudy
of some factorsinfluencing
the immunization ofsheep against
HaemonchusBlum
K,
Cioli D(1978)
Paradoxical behaviour of Biozzihigh
and lowresponder
mice upon infection with Schastosoma mansoni. Eur J Immunol8,
52-56 CabaretJ,
Gruner L(1988)
Geneticvariability
of resistance toparasites.
In:Proceedings
of
the 3rd WorldCongress
onSheep
andBeef
CattleBreeding,
19-23 June1988, Paris,
INRAPublications,
Paris1, 577-592
Clunies Ross I
(1932)
Observations on the resistance ofsheep
to infestationby
stomach worm
(Haemonchus contortus).
J CouncilScientafic
Industrial Research5, 73-80
Colglazier
MG,
LindahlIL,
TurnerJH,
WilsonGI,
WhitmoreGE,
Wilson RL(1968)
Effect ofmanagement
systems on thegrowth
of lambs anddevelopment
of internalparasitism.
J Parasitol54,
89-97Courtney
CH(1986)
Hostgenetic
factors in helminth control insheep.
Vet ClinNorth Am Food Anim Prac
2, 433-438
Courtney CH,
ParkerCF,
McClureKE,
Herd RP(1984)
Acomparison
of theperiparturient
rise in fecal egg counts of exotic and domestic ewes. Int J Parasitol14, 377-381
Courtney CH,
ParkerCF,
McClureKE,
Herd RP(1985)
Resistance of exotic and domestic lambs toexperimental
infection with Haemonchus contortus. Int JParasitol 15,
101-109Cullen
PR,
MillotP, Nguyen
TC(1985)
Sheep histocompatibility antigens:
apopulation
levelcomparison
test betweenlymphocyte antigens previously
defined inFrance,
England
andScotland,
andsheep
red cell groups. Anim BloodGroups
Baochem Genet16,
19-34Cuperlovic
K,
AltaifKI,
Dargie
JD(1978)
Genetic resistance to helminths: apossible relationship
betweenhaemoglobin
type
and the immune responses ofsheep
tonon-parasitic antigens. Res
Vet Sci25,
125-126Dally MR,
HohenbokenW,
ThomasDL,
Craig
AM(1980)
Relationships
betweenhemoglobin
type andreproduction,
lamb wool and milkproduction
and health-related traits in crossbred ewes. J Anam Sci50,
418-427Deelder
AM,
ClassFHJ,
De Vries RRP(1978)
Influence of the mouse H2 genecomplex
onexperimental
infection with Schistosoma mansoni. 7bans R SocTrop
Med
Hyg
72,
321-322Duncan
JL,
SmithWD,
Dargie
JD(1978)
Possiblerelationship
of levels of mucosalIgA
and serumIgG
to immuneunresponsiveness
of lambs to Haemonchus contortus. Vet Parasitol4,
21-27Evans
JV,
Whitlock JH(1964)
Geneticrelationship
between maximum hematocrit values andhemoglobin
type
insheep. Science
145,
1318Evans
JV,
BluntMH,
Southcott WH(1963)
The effects of infection with Haemonchuscontortus on the sodium and
potassium
concentrations in theerythrocytes
andplasma,
insheep
of differenthaemoglobin types. Aust
JAgrac
Res14,
549-558Geczy
AF,
Rothwell TLW(1981)
Genes within themajor
histocompatibility
com-plex
of theguinea pig
influencesusceptibility
toZ’richostrongylus colubriformis
Holmes PH
(1986)
Pathophysiology
of nematode infections. In: 6th IntCong
of
Parasitology, Brisbane,
24-29August
1986,
Pergamon Press, Oxford,
443-451 JarrettWFH,
Jennings
FW, McIntyre WIM,
Mulligan
W, Sharp
NCC(1961)
Studies on
immunity
to Haemonchus contortus infection: double vaccination ofsheep
with irradiated larvae. Am J Vet Res22,
186-188Jilek
AF, Bradley
RE(1969)
Hemoglobin
types and resistance to Haemonchus contortus insheep.
Am J Vet Res30,
1773-1778Knight RA, Rodgers
D(1974)
Age
resistance of lambs tosingle
inoculation with Haemonchus contortus. Procof
theHelmintholog%cal Society of Washington 41,
116Le Jambre LF
(1978)
Hostgenetic
factors in helminth control. In: TheEpidemiology
and Controlof
Gastrointestinal Parasitesof Sheep
in Australia(Donald
AD,
Southcott
WH,
DineenJK,
eds)
CSIRO,
Australia,
137-141 Luff
au G
(1975)
Quelques
problèmes poses par
Haemonchus contortus(&dquo;ver
de lacaillette&dquo;)
enpathologie
ovine. In: Premières Journees de la Recherehe Ovine etCaprine INRA-ITOYIC,
Les racesprolifiques,
tome 2(espbce ovine),
SPEOC,
Paris,
472-480Luffau
G, Péry
P,
Charley
J(1981a)
Réponse
immunitaire chez les ovins infest6sexpérimentalement
par Haemonchus contortus. Etudecomparative
chez le maleet chez la femelle. Ann Rech Vét
12,
173-181Luffau
G, Péry P,
Petit A(1981b)
Self-cure andimmunity
following
infection and reinfection in ovine haemonchosis. Vet Parasitol9,
57-67Manton
VJA,
PeacockR,
Poynter D,
SilvermanP, Terry
RJ(1962)
The influence of age onnaturally acquired
resistance to Haemonchus contortus in lambs. ResVet Sci
3,
308-314Nguyen
TC(1984)
The immune response in sheep: analysis of age, sex andgenetic
effects on the
quantitative
antibody
response to chicken red blood cells. VetImmunol
Immunopathol 5,
237-245Nguyen TC,
Bunch TD(1980)
Blood groups andevolutionary relationships among
domesticsheep
(Ovis aries),
domesticgoat
(Capra hircus),
Aoudad(Ammotragus
lervia)
andEuropean
mouflon(Ovis mus%mon)
Ann Genet Sel Anim12,
169-180Outteridge
PM,
WindonRG,
DineenJK,
Dawkins HJS(1984)
Association betweenlymphocyte antigens
insheep
andresponsiveness
to vaccinationagainst
intestinalparasites.
In:Immunogenet%c approaches
to the controlof endopams%tes
withparticular reference
toparasites
of
sheep,
Proceedings
of aworkshop
held atSydney
University,
October 22-231983,
on behalf of the Australian WoolCorporation,
103-111,
CSIRO,
EastMelbourne,
103-111Outteridge
PM,
WindonRG,
Dineen JK(1985)
An association between alymphocyte
antigen
insheep
and the response to vaccinationagainst
theparasite.
T’richostrongylus colubriform%s.
Int JParas%tol 15,
121-127Outteridge
PM,
WindonRG,
DineeJK,
StewartDJ,
Skerman TM(1987)
Breeding
forparasite
and footrot resistance insheep using
ovinelymphocyte antigen
(OLA)
markers. In: Merinoimprovement
programs in Australia.Proceedings
of aNational
Symposium,
Leura,
Australian WoolCorporation, Melbourne,
277-379Outteridge
PM,
WindonRG,
Dineen JK(1988)
An ovinelymphocyte antigen
marker foracquired
resistance toTrichostrongylus
colubriformis.
Int J Parasitol18, 853-858
Perrudet-Badoux
A, Binaghi RA,
Boussac-Aron Y(1978)
Z’richinedlaspiralis
infection in mice: mechanism of the resistance in animalsgenetically
selected forhigh
and lowantibody production. Immunology
35,
519-522Piper
LR(1987)
Genetic variation in resistance to internalparasites.
In: Merinoimprovement
programs inAustralia,
Proceedings
of a NationalSymposium,
Leura,
Australian WoolCorporation,
Melbourne,
351-363Pradhan
SL,
Johnstone IL(1972)
Haemonchus contortus:haematological
changes
in lambsduring prolonged
exposure todaily
andweekly
doses of infective larvae.Parasitology 64,
153-160Preston
JM,
Allonby
EW(1979)
The influence ofhaemoglobin phenotype
on thesusceptibility
ofsheep
to Haemonchus contortus infection inKenya. Res
Vet Sci26,
140-144Radhakrishnan
GV, Bradley RE, Loggins
RE(1972)
Host responses of worm-free Florida native and Rambouillet lambsexperimentally
infected with Haemonchuscontortus. Am J Vet Res
33,
817-823Riffkin
GG,
Dobson C(1979)
Predicting
resistance ofsheep
to Haemonchuscontortus infections. Vet Parasitol
5,
365-378 .Riffkin
GG, Yong
WK(1984)
Recognition
ofsheep
which have innate resistance totrichostrongylid
nematodeparasites.
In:Immunogenetic approaches
to the controlendoparasites
withparticular
reference
toparasites
of
sheep,
Proceedings
of aworkshop
held atSydney
University,
October 22-231983,
on behalf ofthe
Australian Wool
Corporation, CSIRO,
EastMelbourne,
30-38Roberts
JL,
Swan RA(1981)
Quantitative
studies of ovine haemonchosis. 1.Relationship
between faecal egg counts and total worm counts. Vet Parasitol8, 165-171
Roberts
JL,
Swan RA(1982)
Quantitative
studies of ovine haemonchosis. 2.Relationship
between total worm counts on Haemonchus contortus,haemoglobin
values and
bodyweight.
VetParasitol 9,
201-209Smith
WD,
Angus
KW(1980)
Haemonchus contortus: attempts to immunise lambs with irradiated larvae. Res Vet Sci29,
45-50Urquhart GM,
JarrettWFH, Jennings FW, McIntyre WIM,
Mulligan
W,
Sharp
NCC
(1966a)
Immunity
to Haemorcchns contortus infection: failure of X-irradiated larvae to immunize young lambs. Am J Vet Res27,
1641-1643Urquhart GM,
JarrettWFH, Jennings
FW,
McIntyre WIM, Mulligan
W(1966b)
Wakelin D
(1978)
Genetic control ofsusceptibility
and resistance toparasitic
infection. Adv
Pamsitol 16,
219-308Warwick
BL, Berry
RO,
TurkRD, Morgan
CO(1949)
Selection ofsheep
andgoats
for resistance to stomach worms, Haemonchus contortus. J Anim Sca8, 609-610
WassomDL,
DavidCS,
Gleich GJ(1979)
Genes within theMajor
Histocompati-bility Complex
influencesusceptibility
to Trichinellaspiralas
in the mouse.Im-munogenetics
9, 491-496
Watson TG
(1986)
Immunity
togastrointestinal
nematodeparasites
in domestic stock withparticular
reference tosheep:
a review. Proc N Z Soc Anam Prod46,
15-22
Weir DM
(1978)
Passivehaemagglutination
withspecial
reference to the tanned celltechnique.
In:Immunochemastry,
Handbookof Experimental Immunology,
Blackwell SciPub,
3rdedn, 1,
20Whitlock JH
(1955)
Astudy
of the inheritance totrichostrongylidosis
insheep.
Cornell Vet45,
422-439Whitlock JH
(1958)
The inheritance of resistance totrichostrogylidosis
insheep.
1. Demonstration of thevalidity
of thephenomena.
Cornell Vet48,
127-133 WhitlockJH,
Madsen H(1958)
The inheritance of resistance totrichostrogylidosis
in
sheep.
2. Observations on thegenetic
mechanism intrichostrogylidosis.
CornellVet
48,
134-164Wilson