HAL Id: jpa-00208904
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/jpa-00208904
Submitted on 1 Jan 1980
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Optical nutation in a gaussian beam resonator
F. Rohart, B. Macke
To cite this version:
F. Rohart, B. Macke. Optical nutation in a gaussian beam resonator. Journal de Physique, 1980, 41 (8), pp.837-844. �10.1051/jphys:01980004108083700�. �jpa-00208904�
Optical nutation in
agaussian beam
resonatorF. Rohart and B. Macke
Laboratoire de Spectroscopie Hertzienne (*), Université de Lille I, 59655 Villeneuve d’Ascq Cedex, France (Reçu le 17 janvier 1980, révisé le 24 mars, accepté le 25 mars 1980)
Résumé. 2014 Nous examinons la réponse transitoire d’un résonateur plan-sphérique excité continûment et rempli
par un gaz optiquement fin qui est brutalement amené en résonance exacte avec le champ excitateur. Contraire- ment aux traitements antérieurs, notre approche prend en compte la distribution du champ dans le résonateur
2014 aussi bien axiale que transversale 2014 et les mouvements moléculaires à travers l’onde stationnaire. Ceci est obtenu en projetant la polarisation induite dans le gaz sur le mode gaussien fondamental du résonateur et les résultats sont donnés sous une forme quasi analytique. Une réponse oscillante n’est obtenue que lorsque la fré-
quence de Rabi est grande devant l’élargissement Doppler et le résonateur de mauvaise qualité. Certaines de
nos prévisions théoriques ont été confirmées par une expérience à une longueur d’onde de 6 mm.
Abstract. 2014 We examine the transient behaviour of a plane-spherical resonator driven by a continuous wave
and filled by an optically thin gas which is suddenly switched on exact resonance with the driving field. Contrary
to previous treatments, the axial and transversal field distributions and the molecular motions through the standing
wave are taken into account. This is achieved by projecting the induced gas polarization on the fundamental
gaussian mode of the resonator and the results are given in a quasi analytic form. An oscillatory response is only
obtained when the Rabi frequency is large with respect to the Doppler line width and for a bad quality resonator.
Some of the theoretical predictions have been supported by an experiment at a 6 mm-wavelength.
Classification Physics Abstracts
42.50 - 42.60D - 42.65
1. Introduction. - In
analogy
with the well known transient nutation effects in nuclearmagnetic
reso-nance [1], the term of
optical
nutation is currentlyused to describe the transient response of an
optically
thin gas of 2-level systems suddenly excited by a strong resonant
optical
field [2]. Oscillations at the Rabifrequency
have been predicted [2] andobserved
[3]
when theoptical
nutation is excited bya
travelling
wave. We discuss in this paper the cor-responding phenomenon occurring
inside a cavityresonator. This study is motivated by the
frequent
use of intracavity arrangements in order to achieve strongly
saturating
fields in laser spectroscopy and by the recentprediction
of Rabi oscillations in transient absorptiveoptical bistability
[4, 5, 6] whenthe
driving
field is switched from the lower to the upper branch of the bistability curve [4].Since we are interested in the Rabi oscillations,
the calculations are made in the
infinite
saturationlimit : the Rabi period is assumed to be very short with respect to the radiative lifetime, the collisional lifetime and the transit time across the
optical
beam.(*) Associé au C.N.R.S.
For the strong optical fields
required
by this condi- tion, we can assume without loss ofgenerality
thatthe gas is
optically
thin. On the other hand, we willtake a full account of the field distribution (axial
and transversal) and of the molecular motions
through the
standing
wave [7] which are usually neglected inspite
of theirimportance (1).
The arrangement of the paper is the
following.
Our basic model is presented in
section 2
which isdevoted to a general calculation of the gas
pôlarization
projection
on the fundamentalgaussian
mode of thelresonator. Theoretical
shapes
of the timedependence
of this polarization and of the resulting transient
response of the resonator are discussed in section 3.
We present in section 4 some
experimental
resultsobtained at a 6
mm-wavelength
which are in good agreement with the theoretical ones. We conclude in section 5 by summarizing the main features of thisstudy and by
evoking
someapplications.
2. Transient gas polarization. - 2.1 BASIC THEO- RETICAL MODEL. - We consider a commonly used
(1) Let us note however that the axial field distribution in a ring cavity is taken into account in Ref. [8].
Article published online by EDP Sciences and available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/jphys:01980004108083700
838
laser resonator of large aperture, which consists of
a flat mirror facing a
spherical
one of radius Ro larger than thelength 1
(see Fig. 1). This open reso-Fig. 1. - Plane-spherical cavity. (1) is the wavefront cutting the
resonator axis in z ; x (res. y) is the M-curvilinear coordinate measured along (E) parallely to the zOX (resp. zOY) meridian plane.
nator is driven at the
frequency
co of one of its funda-mental
gaussian
mode by an external c.w.optical
field, and is filled by a gas of two level systems ini- tially off resonance. At time t = 0, the transitionfrequency
mo of the two level systems is suddenlyswitched on exact resonance with the
driving
fieldand we are interested in the
resulting
timedepen-
dence of the induced gas electric
polarization
P andof the
optical
field E inside the resonator. These evolutions aregoverned
by the well-known Bloch- Maxwellcoupled equations.
By a slightadjustement
of the Lamb’s laser theory [9], the
equation governing
the electric field is conveniently written down as :
1 __
where Q is the resonator
quality
factor and E(O) thec.w.
optical
field in the empty resonator case.Since the losses of the empty resonator are exactly
compensated
by the externaldriving
field, E(’) is asolution of the
equation :
with suitable limit conditions
(E(O)
= 0 on the mir- rors).As indicated before, we are interested in the
opti- cally
thin resonator case(the
so-called one atomsolution or non cooperative state in
optical
bistabi-lity [4]).
The absorbing molecules are notcoupled
with one another but interact
individually
with the optical field which remains nearly unaffected by thegas (E cr
E(’».
Fromequation
(1) andequation (2),
this condition is
easily
derived as :The maximum available gas
polarization
is gene-rally ny where n is the
population
difference per unit volume and y the transition dipole matrix element.In the
optical
domain, the Doppler width kvo (k = colc ;vo most probable molecular velocity) is generally large with respect to the Rabi
frequency
(m= IÀE (0)/h)
and we have to take account of the hole burnt by the optical field in the velocity distribution. Its width is about n1/2 mi and the actually available gas pola-
rization is then
nyn’12 (collkvo). Introducing
theabsorption
coefficient fi = n1/2nJU2/heo
vo propor- tional to the pressure, the condition(Eq. (3))
becomes :where F is the resonator finesse [10] (F =
nQI kl, l :
resonator
length,
seeFig.
1).Equation
(4) meansthat the resonator must be
optically
thin in the linearregime.
On the other hand, when the whole
Doppler
pro- file is excited (co, »kvo),
the conditiongiven
byequation
(3) may be convenientlyexpressed
byintroducing
the linearabsorption
coefficient at infi-nitely
large pressure oc,,, =wnJ12
7:lneo c, where i isthe molecular mean free
path
duration. Equation (3)then becomes :
Hence, in so far as the saturation parameter mi i is strong, the resonator must not
necessarily
beoptically
thin in the linearregime.
În the bistabilityterminology
[4], afF 12 ’Tt
isnothing
else that thebistability
parametera,, É/2
T = C where T « 1 isthe
transmittivity
of the two mirrors. If the resonatoris
actually
bistable (C > 4), equation (5) expresses that the applied field has to be sufficient to put it in the non cooperative region as indicated before. Tocome back to the crude estimations of equation (4)
and
equation
(5)(corroborated by
more exact forth-coming equations
(10) and(11)),
the condition ofoptical
thinness in the linearregime
appears then to be sufficient in all cases but notalways
necessary.Besides, we are in this paper interested not in the relaxation processes but in the nutation
signal
andin the influence of the field
inhomogeneity
and ofthe molecular motions on this
signal.
We shall thenassume that the mean Rabi
frequency
is much largerthan collision and radiative broadenings
(infinite
saturation
regime).
This is achieved at lowsample
pressures for which the resonator is actually
optically
thin.
2.2 DERIVATION OF THE INDUCED GAS POLARIZA- TION. - Within the
previous assumptions,
the Bloch-Maxwell
equations
areuncoupled
and the gas pola-rization is simply calculated from the unperturbed
field E(0) (fundamental
gaussian
mode). This field isquasi-linearly polarized,
i.e. tangent to thespherical
wave front (I) and parallel to a fixed meridian plane
XOz (see Fig. 1). We characterize a
point
M insidethe resonator by z being the abscisse of the z-axis
equiphase
point and by x and y being its curvilinear coordinates measuredalong
the wave front (1’).This change of coordinates involves some
simplifi-
cation to the
expression
of the fielddescribing
thefundamental gaussian mode
(approximate
solutionof
equation (2))
[11]. In complex notation,omitting
the eiúi time
dependence,
the component £(0) of E°>according the x-coordinate becomes :
n’o is the beam waist on the plane mirror (minimum
beam waist) :
M (z) is the beam waist in z :
W(z) is a
phase
shift given by :and the nth gaussian fundamental mode is defined
by the condition of resonance :
which means that the
optical
field is zero on the plane andspherical
mirrors.In each
point
M defined by r = (x, y, z) we cancharacterize the interaction between the optical field E(’) and a molecule by a Rabi frequency (1)l(r) which
depends
on r and has a maximum value mi =.uE,,Ih.However the beam waist n’ is always much larger
than the wavelength 2 nlk and the
gradient
of (1)1 (r)is nearly perpendicular in each
point
to the corres-ponding
wave front. Then, only molecular motionsperpendicular
to the wave fronts have to be consi-dered.
This
approximation
is obviously related to theinfinite saturation limit considered here
In this limit, we can calculate the induced gas
pola-
rization by using the result obtained by one of us [7]
in the case of a plane standing wave with a full account
of the molecular motions.
Taking
account of theactual distribution of the
optical
field in thegaussian
mode, the polarization P(r, t, v) in r due to molecules having a v-velocity along the wavefront normal is easily written down fromequations
(13), (14) and (19)of the quoted paper. In complex notation
omitting
(’) On the contrary, in lineshape calculations made in the low saturation limit [12, 13], the transverse motion plays an important
role.
the rapid time
dependence
ineirot,
thepolarization
component according the x-coordinate becomes :
with :
To obtain this result the rotating wave
approxima-
tion has been made and
P(r, t,
v) is assumed not to changeduring
a time of the order of w -1 (slowly varyingamplitude approximation).
2.3 PROJECTION OF THE POLARIZATION ON THE FUNDAMENTAL MODE. - In the case of a plane standing
wave, the
polarization
wasdeveloped
inspatial
harmonics and only the first (fundamental)
spatial
harmonics in exp[± ikz] were shown to contribute
to the detected
signal
[7]. In the presentproblem,
we can also reasonably presume that the induced gas
polarization
has the same axial spatial quasi-periodicity
as theoptical
field E(’) and then that theresonator
eigenmodes
with aprincipal
number dif-fering
from n are not excited. On the contrary, it is obvious that thecorresponding
transverse(higher
order) modes of suitable symmetry [9, 11] are actuallyexcited. However, two
physical
arguments may begiven to limit our calculations to a monomode
approximation
[14] :(i) the transverse modes are only weakly excited
in so far as their distance Am apart the driven funda- mental mode is generally larger than the width of the Fourier spectrum of P(r, t, v) around the zero-
frequency
(extendedslowly varying amplitude
ap-proximation).
Moreover even excited, these modes,owing
to their poor quality factor, will contributeweakly to the transient response of the resonator.
(ii) The contribution of the driven fundamental
eigenmode can be easily
picked
out with a suitabledetection scheme, namely with a
low-pass
filter eli-minating
the Acu - beats corresponding to theexcited transverse modes (heterodyne detection, see
section 3.2).
For these reasons and also in order to keep trac-
table equations, we limit our calculations to the pro-
jection P(t,
v) ofP(r,
t, v) on the driven fundamental mode :where the
integral
is extended to the resonatorvolume
( V), Un describes the fundamental mode [11](un
=È"IIE,,,
see equation(6a))
and Vo is a norma-lization volume such as :
840
The (x, y) integrations of
equation
(8a) are easilyperformed
but thez-integration
is more difficult.However, since beam parameters,
particularly
W(z)and w(z) are slowly varying vs. z at a wavelength scale, this latter
integration
can be split into a sumof n integrals (n : mode number), each of them being
calculated between two
optical
field nodes. Usingthe Fourier
expansion
ofexp(iz
sin 0) in Besselfunctions [15] and
approximating
the previous sum-mation to a z-integral (n » 1), we
finally
get :where H (t, v) is a reduced
polarization
given by :This result is somewhat general since it describes the case of a variable beam waist. The integral can
be
dropped
in the case of a nearly constant beamwaist (i.e. for Ro >
l).
In this case, theaveraging
on the velocity distribution gives :
We discuss in the
following
section thesignal shapes
of the reducedpolarization
II (t) given byequation
(9c) and of the resulting transient response of the resonator.3. Theoretical signal shapes. - 3.1 REDUCED GAS
POLARIZATION. - Our
study
is limited to the case ofa nearly constant beam waist
(Eq. (9c)).
Numericalcalculations (not
reported
here) have shown that nutationsignals
are notstrongly
distorted as longas the beam waist change
along
the resonator axis isless than 15
% (Roll >
4) whereas larger beam waistchanges
lead to an extrasmoothing
of the Rabi oscillations.The reduced
polarization
il(t) has beenplotted
infigure
2 for various ratio of theDoppler
widthkvo
and of the Rabi
frequency
mi (ç =kVolwl)’
The present result is interestingly compared to the
result obtained in the case of a
plane standing
wave(see Fig.
2 of ref.[7]).
The dramatic influence of the transverse distribution of theoptical
field is obvious.We must notice that this influence does not
depend
on the actual size of the beam waist. In the discussion
Fig. 2. - Calculated reduced polarization n (t) as a function of (j) 1 t for various ratios of the most probable Doppler shift (kvo) to
the maximum Rabi angular frequency (wl). All curves are norma-
lized to the unity.
of the motional effects, two border-line cases are of
particular
interest and are examined in thefollowing
subsections, as also sometypical
intermediate cases.3 .1.1 Negligible molecular motion case (k vo «
(01)’
- The reduced
polarization
H(t) derived from equa- tion (9c) takes a verysimple
analytic form in thiscase :
The
corresponding shape (Fig.
2, thick solid line)differs strongly from the
corresponding shape
obtainedin a
plane
standing wave(H (t)
= 2 J, (colt)).
The signal rise time is slower (first maximum for col t = 2.8 instead of 1.8) and the Rabi oscillations are drama-tically damped by inhomogeneous effects (relative amplitude of the 2nd oscillation : 5
%
insteadof 60 %).
Let us also notice that H (t) remains in the upper half
plane, namely
in theabsorptive
domain incontrast with the
travelling
wave case [16].3.1.2 Prevailing molecular motion case
(kvo > col).
- In this case, the molecules move so fast that they
pass through several nodes of the
optical
field duringa Rabi
period.
Equation
(9c) is then conveniently rewritten downas :
with sinc u = sin ulu. The error function [15]
erf
(kvo
tl2) describes the short time behaviour ofH(t) and is obtained by a
development
of equa- tion (9c) at the first order in Wl t. The maximum value n’/2collkvo
of II(t) is then reached for times t such ascollkvo «
mi t « 1 [7]. Asexpected,
theRabi oscillations are smeared out by molecular
motions and the time evolution of H(t) is reduced
to a
simple
transientpulse
with a duration of the order of the Rabi period (see Fig. 2, thick dashedline). Let us however notice a small overshoot in the negative lower half plane. This feature, which
contrasts with the negligible molecular motion case, is due to the fast molecules which are + kv off reso-
nance (v : z-component of the molecular velocity).
They then
give
a contribution to thepolarization
evolving as sin(kvt),
i.e. unaffected by the wl-inho-mogeneities
[17].3.1.3 Intermediate cases (m i rr
kvo).
- The shapesplotted
for some intermediate cases show that the motional effects haverapidly
a great influence on the Rabi oscillationamplitude.
As anexample,
whenthe Rabi
frequency
isequal
to theDoppler
width (Wl =kvo,
see Fig. 2, thin solid line), all the oscilla-tions
disappear
and except for the rise time, thesignal
isquite
similar to the one obtained in theDoppler
limit.3.2 RESONATOR TRANSIENT RESPONSE. - As indi- cated before, only the fundamental
gaussian
modedriven by the external field is
significantly
excited bythe induced
polarization.
Theoptical
field inside the resonator is then conveniently written as :un(r) describes the nth fundamental mode, En the
maximum field amplitude in the empty resonator (Oth order solution) and Z(t) its first order change
due to the induced
polarization.
The output field,proportional
to En + Z(t) is received on a non lineardetector which, at the first order
approximation
gives a
signal proportional
to É(t) (heterodyne detec- tion). Some detectors have even a constant conversion factor in alarge
domain of incident power and in this domain, the time-dependent detected signal willbe directly
proportional
to Z(t) whatever En is.In all cases, É(t) appears to be the quantity of
experimental
interest. Bysubstituting equation
(12)in the starting
equation
(1) or more exactly in thecorresponding approximate
scalar equation andby projecting
on the nth fundamental mode, we getstraightforwardly :
where r,h = 2 Q/w is the mean photon lifetime
inside the resonator [5, 6] (resonator rise time to a step excitation) and where II (t) is the reduced pola-
rization
(see
Eq.(9)). Equation
(13) is the generalequation
governing the evolution of a system of timeconstant -rh submitted to a time - dependent external
excitation. Its solution
depends dramatically
on therelative values of the time constant zph and of the times
characterizing
the evolution of the II(t) sourceterm,
especially
the Rabiperiod
2 nlwl’In the bad quality cavity limit (col rph « 1) [18],
the
signal
£(t) follows exactly the time dependenceof the reduced
polarization
II(t) (adiabaticapproxi-
mation). On the contrary, in the good quality cavitylimit (mi Tph » 1)
[18],
the resonator cannot followil(t) which acts as a
pulse
excitation (suddenapproxi- mation).
This excitation is entirely defined by itsimpulse Loo 0 H(t’)dt’. The resonator response is
then easily written :
and the signal is reduced to a single
exponential
oftime constant iph.
In
figure
3 have beenplotted typical -signal
shapesobtained in the
negligible
molecular motion case(kvo «
roI) for different values of col iph. The Rabi oscillationsdisappear
as soon as roI Tph > 3 but onthe other limit the fall time constant remains twice
Fig. 3. - Calculated resonator response for a negligible Doppler
effect : (a) in the bad quality cavity limit (COl ipb 3), (b) in the good quality cavity limit (COI Tph -> 3). The curves are plotted as
functions of : (a) the nutation angle (col t), (b) the time in photon lifetime unit (t/Tph), for various resonator qualities characterized by the C01 Tph parameter. All curves are normalized to the unity.
842
larger than Tph for mi Tph as large as 30. This can be
attributed to the slow
falling
down of the H(t) func-tion
(see
Eq.(10))
evolving as (mit)-3/2
for a), t » 1.Similar results are obtained in the Doppler limit, excepted for the pulse response which is more marked since the II (t) duration decreases when kv,lct),
becomes larger.
4. Experiment. - The
previous
theoretical results have shown that good conditions for the observation of Rabi oscillations in a standing wave need a mode-rate Doppler effect and a rather bad quality resona-
tor
(3).
Thus, the microwave range seems suitable for this purpose, as it will be easy to get a saturationbroadening
muchlarger
than theDoppler
broa-dening.
The experiments were done on the J=0 - J= 1
line of CH3F at 51 GHz [19] : this very strong tran- sition is non degenerate, and has a large dipole
moment matrix element (p - 0.75
Debye)
com-bined with a moderate Doppler
broadening (kvo/2 n -
57 kHz at room temperature). The work- ing pressure was of the order of 1 mtorr, leadingto a moderate collisional broadening
A plane cylindrical resonator between Stark
plates
was used [20]. This device allowed the use of the Stark
switching
technique : the e.m. field was conti- nuouslyapplied
in thecavity,
so that only the tran-sient
absorption
was detected when the molecularfrequency was switched.
The excited modes were TE types with the electric field
parallel
to the Stark plates allowing for AM= ± 1selection rules.
Due to the Stark plates, the e.m. field is
slightly
different from a gaussian beam : the modes are
described
by
sine functions in the y-direction per-pendicular
to the Stark plates and a gaussian depen-dence in the other transverse direction. By
introducing
the curvilinear coordinates
(see
Eq.(6)),
the electricfield of the nth TE, fundamental mode is shown to be [20] :
where b = 15 mm is the
plate spacing
andkg
is thepropagation
constant of the TE, fields between twoparallel plates (k’
= k2 -n2 1 b2).
»,,D, n’(z) and W(z) are given by
substituting kg
to kin equations (6b, c, d), and
cP(l)/2
to0(é)
in equa- tion (6e). The curvature radius Ro is about 5 m andthe resonator length is about 1 m
leading
to a 10%
beam waist variation
along
the cavity. Except for acomplete
numerical treatment, theprevious
theory(3) This latter prediction agrees with the analysis given in Refs.
[4] and [5].
applies
and leads to quite similar behaviours withina 10 % difference.
The driven fundamental mode had a quality factor
of Q - 29 000 which gives at 51 GHz a photon life-
time of 180 ns. The nearest higher order mode
(TE3)
was 15 MHz apart, had a
quality
factor of about 10 000 and, as expected, was never excited in ourexperiments (see discussion of section 2.3).
The driving microwave power was supplied by a klystron phase locked at the zero Stark field line
frequency. The resonator
eigenfrequency
was alsotuned at this frequency. A uniline (25 dB
rejection)
avoided coupling
problems
between the cavity andthe klystron.
The Stark field was switched by a 1 500 volt pulse generator (rise time - 100 ns). The corres-
ponding
molecularfrequency switching
was about8 MHz.
The detection of the output field was achieved by
a Schottky barrier diode whose conversion factor is
nearly constant with a suitable bias for incident power up to a few mW. The detected
signal (8’(1))
was treated in a 256-channel digital averager (channel
width : 10 ns) working at a 3 kHz
repetition
rate.Although ground-loop currents were avoided by a
careful grounding of the
experiment,
residualspurious signals
were always eliminated bysublracting
the averagedsignals
obtained with and without gas. Upto 2 x 106 cycles were done without great problems
of resonator thermal drifts (total averaging duration
- 10 min.).
Experiments
were done with various microwave powers inside a 40 dB range. Special attention waspaid
to the low and strong power limits corres-ponding
to the bad or good quality cavity limit [18]in the theoretical discussion (section 3.2). Figure 4
Fig. 4. - Experimental transient resonator response in the bad
quality cavity limit : crosses are experimental and the solid line is obtained by least square fitting. The difference is given by the lower
curve. CH3F pressure N 0.5 mtorr, collision rate T (with r/2 x rr 13 kHz), microwave field En 87 V/m, Rabi frequency wt/2 n 350 kHz, saturation parameter wt/r 25, col iph 0.40, kvo/wl N 0.16. The standard error is 0.8 % the maximum ampli-
tude.