Quantifier rank for parity of embedded finite models

Texte intégral

(1)Quantifier rank for parity of embedded finite models Hervé Fournier. To cite this version: Hervé Fournier. Quantifier rank for parity of embedded finite models. [Research Report] LIP RR2001-09, Laboratoire de l’informatique du parallélisme. 2001, 2+15p. �hal-02101892�. HAL Id: hal-02101892 https://hal-lara.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-02101892 Submitted on 17 Apr 2019. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés..

(2) Laboratoire de l’Informatique du Parallélisme ´ Ecole Normale Supérieure de Lyon Unité Mixte de Recherche CNRS-INRIA-ENS LYON o n 8512. SPI.

(3) . .

(4) . ´ Ecole Normale Supérieure de Lyon 46 Allée d’Italie, 69364 Lyon Cedex 07, France Téléphone : +33(0)4.72.72.80.37 Télécopieur : +33(0)4.72.72.80.80 Adresse e´ lectronique :

(5).

(6)

(7)

(8). . ! "

(9) !

(10) "

(11)

(12)

(13) # ! . " # $

(14) % . !"

(15) &

(16)

(17)

(18) ' "

(19)

(20)

(21) #.

(22) . ( % )

(23)

(24) . * !

(25) . +

(26) % !

(27) !

(28)

(29)

(30) # , %

(31) . . -

(32)

(33) . +- # ,

(34) % .

(35)

(36)

(37) . '

(38)

(39)

(40)

(41)

(42) #. . /

(43)

(44) % (

(45) .

(46)

(47) .

(48) .

(49)

(50)

(51)

(52)

(53)

(54)

(55)

(56)

(57)

(58)

(59)

(60)

(61)

(62)

(63)

(64)

(65)

(66)

(67)

(68)

(69)

(70)

(71)

(72)

(73)

(74)

(75)

(76)

(77) 0 . . " !

(78) # 0

(79)

(80)

(81) # )! % !

(82)

(83) !

(84) # 0 " !

(85) . !

(86) . %

(87) !

(88) # 0

(89) . ! !

(90) 1 ! .

(91)

(92) " 23# * !

(93) . "%

(94)

(95) # )

(96)

(97) . !

(98) 24% % 5% 63% %

(99) %

(100) ! "# 7%

(101) !

(102) . ! %

(103)

(104)

(105) . # (

(106) 8 $

(107) % !

(108) "

(109)

(110)

(111) 9 : ; <# = . !

(112)

(113) " 1

(114) # $

(115) 6% !

(116) ! " 253 1 " !

(117) "

(118)

(119) %

(120) !

(121) " # 0

(122) " / % %

(123) # 0 ! !

(124) "

(125) % ' "

(126) % 23#

(127) ! # .

(128)

(129) ! 1 !"

(130) &

(131)

(132)

(133) ' "

(134)

(135)

(136) 9

(137)

(138) .

(139) 263# 0 " "

(140) . !

(141) .

(142)

(143) " :

(144) <#.

(145)

(146)

(147) . 7 ! # !

(148) "

(149)

(150)

(151) 1

(152) .

(153) % . ! # 0

(154) ! ! # > :?< . . . ! . % # * . #

(155) :< "

(156) .

(157) # $

(158) % :< @ # * : < @ : < @ ::< :<< :< @ :< @ ; :<# *

(159) ! #

(160) . !" "

(161) ! !

(162) . % # :< # .

(163) . # % > :?< . ! "# $ "% > :?< # /"

(164) ! 2A3% > :?< @ > :?< @ ! ; :<# 0 !% !!

(165) # 7% .

(166)

(167) # # $

(168) " % > :? < @ > :? <# $%

(169) % : < @ ' " ? # B C: < :< .

(170) @ # B @ @ C: <# B # $ ? : < @ # 7

(171) @ % @ : < @ # $ ? % : < @ % : < @ # 0 . . ? % > :?< > :?< " "" > :?< @ > :? <# 0 D > :?<

(172) ". # ¼.

(173)

(174) )( " !

(175) "

(176)

(177)

(178)

(179) : @ <# @ #

(180) !

(181)

(182) ! "

(183) % .

(184) !

(185) "

(186) # $ .

(187) % ! #. > :?<

(188) ! ; . 0

(189) % ! ! !

(190) "

(191)

(192)

(193)

(194) # B !

(195) "

(196)

(197)

(198)

(199)

(200)

(201) ! ; ;# B !

(202) " E % @ ; # !! .

(203) ! ! : < : <# %

(204) @ : <# B @ @ @ $ # )

(205) % !

(206) "

(207) F G # . ! " #.

(208)

(209) : < : < .

(210) .

(211). .

(212) . .

(213) . . .

(214).

(215) .

(216)

(217) # @ # =%

(218)

(219)

(220)

(221)

(222) !

(223) " # ) : <# B . # 0 ; # H" "

(224) " # /" ""%

(225) . .

(226) : <# B #

(227) . # 0

(228) #

(229) 1

(230) # 0

(231)

(232) : < @ # 0 @ # B . # $ % % : < % # / ; ; @ # 0 " " % # " : <# = % @ # ?

(233) " . "% . 1 : < : <%

(234)

(235) # 0 : <% # I

(236)

(237) 1 # I

(238)

(239)

(240)

(241) ! ! ! # B :< @ # B

(242) @ # B . #

(243)

(244) : <

(245) # 0

(246) # 0 .

(247) %

(248)

(249) . " # /

(250)

(251)

(252) # 0 : < "

(253)

(254) # =%

(255) %

(256) # 0 : <

(257)

(258) % # =% @ 6.

(259)

(260) # 0

(261) ! # 0 . > :? ;< # ) > :? <

(262) !

(263) % > :?<

(264) ! ; # ¾ "

(265)

(266) #

(267)

(268) % " # !

(269) 1 > :?< > :?<#. > :?<. .

(270) ! ; . . .

(271) ! ; # '.

(272) @

(273) @ ; ; ;

(274) . . . !

(275) :<

(276)

(277) :< '

(278) @ # :< @ :< :< @ :< : <# *

(279)

(280)

(281) :

(282) :<< @

(283) ! # $ "%

(284) :<% !

(285) @ ; ; ;

(286) # " %

(287) :< "

(288) ! .

(289)

(290)

(291) :< :< " :< @ :< @ ; # ( " :

(292) :<< @ :

(293) :<<# 0

(294) @

(295) :<

(296) :< . # *

(297)

(298)

(299) . @ # % " @ # @

(300) # 0 % : < . # 0 # ¾. > :?< @ > :?< @

(301) ! ; . $ D

(302) . "

(303) " # ¾. . . :<. . . . !:< @ :< :< @ ( . ! . )(

(304) . !: < % . ! " " 9 # B

(305) .

(306) #

(307) !

(308) " " @ #

(309) % C " . ! # ) : < @ :C < : < @

(310) ! % ! @ ! # ¾. . .

(311) . .

(312) .

(313)

(314) # $ "

(315) .

(316) # % ! "1 % @ % @ : ; <% 5.

(317) !

(318) # % :< @ # 0 % % : < @ : < : < % % :< @ # ) % :< @ :< :< @ :<# #. .

(319). &

(320) & % B

(321) & % # " ! ! # / ! ! % !

(322) & #

(323) . "# B .

(324) "

(325) ! # /"

(326) " % . : < @ :!:<!: << "#

(327)

(328)

(329) ! ! 9 2A3 9

(330)

(331) #

(332) " ! 32 " 32" @ #

(333) 1 :< # /"

(334) % :< @ :!:<!:<<

(335) !: < "# I

(336)

(337) 1 :< @ # B @ @ #

(338)

(339) . "

(340) !: < @ $

(341) : < @ :!: <!: <<% $

(342)

(343) : < @ #

(344) " @ ' ' !

(345)

(346) : < @ # $ ! # " %

(347)

(348) . "

(349) ! @ $ ; ' 1

(350) !: <

(351) :!: <!: << @ % : <# B . ! & 3!: <!: <2# ) :!: <!: << @ "

(352) % :!: <!: << % # 0 !

(353)

(354) % @ : ; <% % !

(355) . . .

(356) .

(357)

(358) . !

(359) "

(360) . #.

(361) .

(362). "# ¾. ! #. > :?< @ J:! <. $ %

(363) ! !

(364)

(365) :( < :) <#

(366) : # <

(367) ( : # ) <# @ *:< # /"

(368) ! ( %

(369) @ ! ! % # ! 1 :< @ % :< @ # :<% . : < @ . 0 :< @ ! # 0 : < @ :0 :< <# B :0 :<< @ 0 :<# +

(370)

(371) D

(372) # K ,

(373) %

(374) L

(375) :+:,<< ! ,#

(376) ! :) <# % #

(377) "% & # B (

(378)

(379) " @ - - - - @ % 9

(380) ! A.

(381)

(382) !

(383) # $ "% ) @ L

(384) : < @ . . .

(385) . . @ % ; # @ L

(386) :- - <% @ L

(387) :. . < " :- < @ . :- < @ . # , @ :- . < :- . < # )

(388) . ! " #. +:, < :< @ :, :<, :<< 0 : :<< @ :0 :<< / 0 : :/<< @ :0 :/<< B < :0 :<< . % . :0 :<< +:, <# B %

(389)

(390) <% , .

(391) "

(392) !

(393) +:, < # B . 1 <

(394) % %

(395) # B .

(396) !

(397) # $ # 0 # /" ""%

(398) .

(399) :( <# . ! "% . # B 0 L

(400) : < :0 <

(401) ( # B 1 @ :0 < +:, <# 0 % , ! ,.

(402) +:, < @ +:, < 1 # B

(403) !

(404) :0< @ :0 :0<<# B @ L

(405) : 0< @ : <# $ % % , , # B . # B

(406) # B . # B / % :/< @ # / @ !0 ; 2 2 ! # $ ! @ % 2 @

(407) # B . ! @ # 0 :2< @ :2< @ !:0< @ ! 0 :0<# 0 < 0 :2< @ ! 0 0 0# 0 0 :2< @ ! 0 0 @ !0 :0<

(408) . . , , # / % 2 @ !0 :0<# 0 @ 0 :0<% . ! / @ 2 ; !0 / @ *: :0 <<

(409) . "

(410)

(411) 0# ) 0 @ 0 :0<% 2 @ !0 " / @ # H <

(412)

(413) # B . < # B # $ %

(414) "

(415) % , , . # 7

(416) 0 @ !0 ; 2 0

(417)

(418) % ! 2 # 0 ! # 0 :< @ 0 :!0 :0< ; 0 :2<< :< " " .

(419) . $ . . ½. . " %

(420) . .

(421) .

(422). . .

(423).

(424) . . . . ½. ·½. ½. ·½. H1 < B . :0 :2<< :0 :0<<# 0 0 :2< @ 2 ; *: :0 :0<<< @ !0 ; 2 @ !0 :0< ; 0 :2< ; *::0 :0<<<# ) :0 :<< :0 :0<< "

(425)

(426) 0% :< "

(427) ! " # < . :0 :2<< :0 :0<<# < $ 0 :2< @ 2%

(428) 0 :2< @ 2 ; *: :0 :0<<< "# M.

(429) < * % :2 < @ # = @ 2 ; !0 @ 0 :2< ; !0 :0< ; *::0 :2<<<# ) 0 :2< ; !0 :0< 0 :2<% :< "

(430) ! " # 0 ! # 0 ::<< @ 0 :!0 ::0<< ; 0 ::2<<< . :<. H1 < B . :2 < # 0 2 @ 0 :2<# /" % 0 ::2<< @ :0 :2<< @ :2<# / :2< .

(431) " . . 0 ::2<< @ :2<# B

(432) :0< @ 0 ::0<< "

(433)

(434) :0<# /" ! 0 ::<< @ 0 :!:0< ; :2<< :<# < * :2 < @ # 0 0 ::2<< @ :0 :2<< . # / :< @ !:0<;:2< @ !0 ::0<<;0 ::2<<;*: :0 ::2<<<<# ) !0 ::0<< ; 0 ::2<< 0 ::2<<% :< "

(435) ! " # 3 < # B # @ !0 ; 2 2 ! # /" :<% 0 ::<< @ 0 :!0 ::0<< ; 0 ::2<<<# / 0 ::0<< @ :0< @ 0 :0< "

(436)

(437) :0<# =% " % 0 ::2<< @ 0 :2<# ) 0 :2< @ 0 :2<

(438) # /" " % ! 0 ::<< @ 0 : :!0 :0< ; 0 :2<<<# ( "% 0 :< . % 0 :< @ 0 :<# 0 0 ::<< @ 0 :!0 :0< ; 0 :2<<# :< 0 ::<< @ :0 : <<# < # B /

(439) / @ :<# 0 :/< @ 0 ::<< @ :0 :<< " < # =% @ ½ E 0 : :/<< @ ½ :0 :/<<# 0 < # $

(440) <# $ % " < 0 ::<< @ 0 :< @ :< @ ,:<# / :,:<< @ % :< @ ,:< # $ "% % @ ! ; *:< ! # /" < % :< @ !, :< ; *:, :<<# / , :< E , :< %

(441) :< # 0 %

(442) <# 0

(443) ! # > :?% ;< # ) % @ : ; < % > :?< @ J: ! <# ¾ . . ,

(444) 8

(445) ! #. . %

(446) . > :?< ! ! ; :< .

(447) . B . ! " #

(448) .

(449) % " %

(450)

(451)

(452) " @ # # 0 # B "

(453) ! :'< " : @ ' : << % # : < :< ; # 7

(454) " ! 263

(455)

(456) :. 4.

(457) % " . ! <# *

(458)

(459)

(460) : < #

(461)

(462) "% : < @ : <# )"!

(463)

(464)

(465) % : < ! ; :<# 0 . :< ! ! ; :<# ¾ ¼.

(466) !

(467)

(468) # 0 " (

(469) !

(470)

(471) #. > :(

(472) < @ J:! <.

(473) "

(474)

(475) "#

(476) ! @ :( < ( @ : < ' # @ # @ # %

(477)

(478) ' # )

(479) . "

(480) % > :?< > :(

(481) <;# $ " " $# ¾ *

(482) !

(483)

(484) " #

(485) > .

(486) # 0 ! #. > :?< @ :! <. 0 ! # 0 . 32 % ! 1 ¾

(487)

(488)

(489) 1 % # ) 1 " %

(490) .

(491) .

(492) # " . 1

(493)

(494)

(495) %

(496)

(497)

(498) #

(499) "# # 1 :<

(500)

(501) 32# 1¼ :< @ :< 32 ¾. 1 :< @ 1 :< 1 : < : < # # $ 1 :< % @ : < @ # :< @ 1 :< 1 : < @ : < # @ : < # # *

(502) 1:< @ :< # B @ @ ; : ; <# ! %

(503) #

(504) :< @ ½. ½. ½. ½. ½. ½. ½. 1 :< :< :<

(505) :<. . . ½. . N.

(506) 1. @ :<

(507) :< :<

(508) :< 0

(509) . " ½. ½. # 0

(510)

(511) # ¾. . > :?< @ O: ! < ¾ .

(512) . !

(513)

(514)

(515) ! " 253% .

(516) # B # 0 " @ % "

(517) %

(518) ! 1 )( !

(519) " !.

(520) . ! ! !

(521) " # 7

(522) !

(523) # B

(524) % #

(525) "

(526) ! . !.

(527) !

(528) "

(529) %

(530) . :

(531) <

(532)

(533)

(534) # 0 % " " : < @ !

(535) "

(536)

(537)

(538)

(539) % % @ % % ¾ % @ % 9

(540) #% % @ : < 9 !

(541) " # B : < :< .

(542) @ @ @ # : < : < !

(543) " :

(544) " <% # 0 D

(545)

(546) : < @ % # 7

(547)

(548)

(549) # ) 1 : < @ % "

(550) " % ; : < 9 2M3# 0 D

(551) ! )( 1. . ' 'P PP :P< P @ P ; 'P . P. . .

(552)

(553)

(554) .

(555) ! I( @ , , , % , " %

(556) # =%

(557) 1

(558) , # B "

(559) % "

(560) # .

(561) 7 " #

(562)

(563)

(564). % " " : "<% : <#

(565)

(566) % ! / B

(567) 263# 0 " " / 23 9

(568) 5#6# 0

(569)

(570) % .

(571) # B

(572) :P< 1@ !:P < !:P <

(573) #

(574) . . ! " !:P < # 0 . !:P< @ 4 4

(575)

(576) 5:P P<. 4 # =

(577) . ! "

(578) !:P < :

(579) " < I(% ! !:P <

(580) % ! " I(# 0 "

(581) !:P < 6 :P P < P @ :

(582) <#. " 6:P P< 6 :P P<

(583) # " 0 :6 P< $ 6 :P P0< !" . . %

(584) .

(585) . P. . #. @. . . . .

(586) . #$Æ

(587) % & '

(588)

(589) . 63. . 7. . & 2 Q. . #. @ 6 :P P < . . % Q :76 < Q # ' P " .

(590) . .

(591)

(592) . 8. :7 'P< Q "

(593)

(594) " 8 @ :6 P< $ & 26 3:P P 'P< " ! (" @ ' :P 'P< . %

(595) . & .

(596) . .

(597) . 8. '

(598) .

(599)

(600) . !!

(601) # B #

(602) ! !:P <# B ! :P 'P< !:P < 6 :P P <

(603) & 26 3:P P 'P<# B . . :P< 1@ 'P " ' :P 'P< ! :P 'P< . $ :P< . "#

(604)

(605) % D 263# B :P< :P<# B

(606) :P< :P<

(607) " ,: < ,

(608) # B

(609) :P<

(610) :P<#

(611) : @ :P<< : @

(612) :P<<# ¾ .

(613)

(614) :P<% :P < @ :P<#

(615)

(616) . !" " :P<%

(617) P % :P < . :P <

(618) #. (. $

(619)

(620) .

(621) . B !"

(622) # 5# B O

(623) 9:P P<# B R O ! # /

(624) . !" R % !

(625) R P P :P P < :P P < . $ !% P # B #

(626) : P< R "

(627) % :P P <

(628) # 7

(629) 1 R "

(630) % " # !

(631)

(632) #

(633) 1 : P < R "

(634)

(635) @ :P P < . :P P <# $

(636) !

(637)

(638) " " "

(639)

(640) :P 'P0< 1@. . . :P 'P 0<. : 'P < R "

(641) # $ "! :P P < % "%

(642) # :0< 1@ :P P 0<# 0

(643) : P< R "

(644) :P P <#

(645) % ! :0< 1@ :0< :P P0<# $ : < : <% ! @ # *

(646) !# ?

(647)

(648) %

(649) : < " # 0 . .

(650)

(651) . # " !

(652) # B % @ # 'P " % 'P @ 'P 'P 'P 'P @ # P R 'P " % &

(653) 26 3:P P 'P< 0

(654)

(655) :P 'P0< 6 :P P0< =% '

(656) . . "!

(657)

(658) :P 'P < " !

(659) # B ?"

(660) :P 'P< 0

(661)

(662) :P 'P0<# B :P P0< :P P0< ( :P P< 9

(663) :P 'P P< 0 :

(664)

(665) :P 'P0<

(666)

(667) :P 'P<< :P P0< . ) H

(668) B

(669)

(670) :P 'P< 1@ P 9

(671) :P 'P P< 0

(672) '

(673) :P 'P< 1@ ?"

(674) :P 'P< H

(675) B

(676)

(677) :P 'P< .

(678) I

(679)

(680) 1 : P< R "

(681) % ! :P P <

(682) # B $26 3:P P< 0 0 0 @ 0 6 :P P0< . . . 7

(683) !

(684) ! " & 26 3:P P 'P< 1@ $26 3:P P<# ) . ' :P 'P< 1@ # Q @ R % % @ % .

(685) %

(686)

(687) " 5 # $ 8 !

(688) % # $ P 'P<

(689) !

(690) " # 0 :P P < : P <% : P '

(691) :P '< . 8 @ &

(692) 23:P 'P<# * 8 @ & 23:P 'P< : " 'P<# ( " 7 Q 'P ".

(693) < < # $ 7 @ P% ' :P 'P< "!

(694)

(695) :P 'P < :" ?"<% . "!

(696)

(697) :P 'P < . !

(698) :" H

(699) B

(700) <% &

(701) 23:P 'P< . !

(702) # * 7 @ E .

(703) ! 1@ :P P. < . "

(704) #. . :P P. <. *

(705)

(706) ! @

(707)

(708)

(709) . # =

(710)

(711) ! !

(712) ! " & 23:P 'P< : " 'P<# ¾.

(713)

(714)

(715) 1

(716) % : ; < @ :<; :< :< @ :<; :<# ) ' # ) ' " " : < # # 0 ' " :< !

(717) . # " ' "

(718) "

(719) " : : .

(720) " .

(721) :< @ ::< @ 2N3# 0

(722) &

(723)

(724)

(725) ' "

(726) # ! #. . & :< :< # #$ . %

(727)

(728) . . . !.

(729) . . . $ ¼. . % .

(730)

(731) . ' . ¼.

(732)

(733) . ". . :< @ :< @ . . $ ! &

(734)

(735) " . ! " 1 " ½ ! # 0

(736) & @ : ; < # ¾. . . . . %

(737)

(738) . . . & . (@.

(739)

(740) .

(741)

(742) . .

(743) :< @ @ :< @ . .

(744) . . %

(745) .

(746) . . % # #$. . $. ¼¼. ; :< ; :<.

(747)

(748) . ¼¼. ( ; :< @ @ ( ; :< @ @ . . . . . /" %

(749) . $ & # $ # % % P

(750) !

(751) Æ

(752) "

(753) Æ

(754) ; # B 9:P < 1@ :< @ ; :< @ # 0 (H : ( H"<%

(755) ' "

(756) 9 2N3.

(757) % ! & :$<# 0 & @ & :$< $ & #. ¾. ). )

(758) '

(759)

(760) . . 5# B #

(761) 1