RESEARCH OUTPUTS / RÉSULTATS DE RECHERCHE
Author(s) - Auteur(s) :
Publication date - Date de publication :
Permanent link - Permalien :
Rights / License - Licence de droit d’auteur :
Bibliothèque Universitaire Moretus Plantin
Institutional Repository - Research Portal
Dépôt Institutionnel - Portail de la Recherche
researchportal.unamur.be
University of Namur
Comment « reguler » la protection des données ? Réflexions sur l'internormativité
Poullet, Yves
Published in:
Mélanges Paul Delnoy
Publication date:
2005
Document Version
le PDF de l'éditeur
Link to publication
Citation for pulished version (HARVARD):
Poullet, Y 2005, Comment « reguler » la protection des données ? Réflexions sur l'internormativité. Dans
Mélanges Paul Delnoy. Larcier , Bruxelles, p. 1075-1097.
General rights
Copyright and moral rights for the publications made accessible in the public portal are retained by the authors and/or other copyright owners
and it is a condition of accessing publications that users recognise and abide by the legal requirements associated with these rights.
• Users may download and print one copy of any publication from the public portal for the purpose of private study or research.
• You may not further distribute the material or use it for any profit-making activity or commercial gain
• You may freely distribute the URL identifying the publication in the public portal ?
Take down policy
If you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact us providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediately
and investigate your claim.
-
0 ~ v. N -g. .-< ~ ~. ~ " C". .' 0"' ~ ~ n ~.~
= n 0 = -~.'.
"
-t-.. ~n~~."
~.'
!"'
~ .0 -.. :.,.~!"'=tO :l'',,,'"''C~. g.. ~J"-~=""~.o
~
0"'"
C
:lë~~~
> as. ~ ~ ~ ~~ ..~ .~ ~ ~ g. ~ ô' ~. -: =,,-'
t-
'"
=
'"
~Ô' :Sc '-' ~ ~. ~S3
~n
.,,!;
'"
,,~.~
~ '"' 0 ~ = 0 N -~. 0" ~. ~ 0 ~ ..."""~
~~
~;. ~o: 0:. .~. ;J ",n ~'" ,!..9 J"'g ~~ (")~ ~~ "'" .C ;r -~. ~"
""
p. ~ n g ~~ C .."
..(") C..~
C ~. ~ = ~""
...
= =0 ~ g N~ < NO;-"- .~ n ~ ô. ~ ="
C
'"
::g '$.~ ~ "" 0=-.'"'"
a.~
ri
~
~
n
n
o ; P-0=~;J ~'" ~ .=
n
_.~
==
:.
~
s
~
~.
~
~
~
p-;-gn~
nSS~
~~,.g~
n ~ p- ~ ;J. ~ ...n S 0 = --~ ~ ~ ;J f;\ -_.n n H ~ n = _.~ e: n ~... \..1 <=r...n~nO""8 a.-M (i. ~ ~ ~ e: ["... S S 0 ~ Z ~ n.. ~ -~.. S "'"' = ~ 0 p-"'! n '" ..n -=-;J "n ~~.
~
'-
'"
'"
'"'
'"
'"'
0;::-
=
<,.~
~
0
-.-,.
'"
~ 0 ~.g ~. 3 f;- '*" = ~ ~ ~ n 6 ~. ~ p- ~ = '" ~ ~ p- S ':I~~""o~", n -""~=,",<.",oo -n ~ "' '" n n -.S g = ~ = = '" ;J ~ '" -.~ ~ ;J =: ~ p- < 0 n ~ ...= n ~ -.n 0 Q. p- n.. ~ ~ <. '" = a. = n.. 0 ~ ~... ~ _.p- n.. n.. ~ p-~=~.~f;\R~n- S"';1 p- ~ ~ o' ~ ~ ;:: ~ -~ n S ~ n -"" = 0 ~ S ~o
-.DO -n,",'" nQ.o~ "'.ri' _':~ ~J '" p- p- ~~ 0 = n = --.= n ~ n = ~ S =- ~ O'~~"'~="'n~ -.n~ ...~.~ "" = =-"' -.~ ~ 0 n.. n n -'" n ;J"'~ -;-""=n n..= ~p- ""'no =~
...
n
0
=
"'
0 ~. ~" ~ n -.n ~ 1 ~ '."'" ...0
=
ri..
n
n
=
-n
n..
n'
p-?~n~':" ~f;\~~ ~ =-n::_.'"
=
."
~
~
~
n
~ --,~ '"' = = ~ ~ ~ .-~ g n n;;. n ~ -.0 =- S ~ p- 0 n;;.
=:
g
R
=.
~
5
1::;
Q
-9 ~ ~ ri M !.! t""'.. '"' <"' =- 1"' " _.~ ...0 --.;J o.""rJl:
g.g
~
f;\~,
~
;<.
~
n 0 p- 0 ~. _.-..~ '" n 1: I:;S. p- ~ -n.. 1: 1: ;- ~ n n n.. n ClIn "'P- '" '" ~ ~ ;J _.p- 1: -...~ ~ -~ ~ n.. ~. ~. 0"'_'"' 01:- n ~ a. .0 '" n -, = n n- 0", n, = -.n n ...n;J n n _.n '" 1 n 1 l "' n -..~
~
~
:s
~" ~~
"
~
t""
..~~
~~~
"
,.,.
Ç)~I\-~~~
Iot""~
,,-
~
~"
~~~~
~;;-.~<
;;-""!O &\~~~
"0
~~~O:s " '" c:: ~. ~"~ t"" ~ ~~" f;;~.
..-~
.;
t
"
~. -~a
~~"
~
~.
a"
~
~.
..".
';'
1\-
~
b~~
Iô 1~~~ ~~~
"
t""
~
~
t""
~.
~
~"
~
~
§~
O~(j
Z~O
~~~
~(j~
c:~
~-~
~~~
z
~
~o~
~~C')
~og
OO~
~
z~
z~
~,
"--i~~
...,
tr1--
0~
-
0 ::::J"
..~..
~
"'~--i..",~.~~"'t=~~':-'
:r.,:r'O:r.g
.,...o~..,~
~[~~
~~
~§JJ;-Ft.~
t=
",p.:I:~'"",,:- ~,,---~ >:n~ ,!;;~.",...'-OV\no ~ ~::J ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ g. ~';;' :.~ .:3. ,<. cr" p.? NO~. ~~~;;'"~=""n "";<,,~ 'j;'!'o'fF~Q~g~-':GG8: ;'~~nt"6':r.:3" ~'-O~~ '0"":t:~g8;;'- ?'n~ ",V\'-:r'O ~~ .,-."",,""T1"o.,a-n.,o -"'~.,~c::p.~:3no.go
o",~p."-,,,,~~..;le.,p.
"'~~"--:r
!'ë~.,,:.'-'
~.~n~_5"';I"
-'s.
~ ~ :3.'" '-O:!- .fj t":3 '" n "p.:! '-00 ~ ~'-"" .",.;! '-000 0:3 ~ ~n,,":3:\-n
:3n";;'~.:3
~
0 '" ~ n '" "0' ;: p. 0 .-~ n N~ ~ ~"'"'~':3 .."",~- n~~J..i!n ~ -'" N p. :3 ~ -, n ""Nt".~ fj]"t--p. ~ 0"" -~ '0" 0'0 :3 n"'~ii~-""~"
(I-~~:;.n
.,
:t.
~
~
n
o,;o~
V\ '0", '0 ~t"o"
(1
~.~~:..~
~'"
~
-'
~
~
~
9,.
a
:s ." ~. ~. n t--~] ".. " :3 ,o~~ n ~.'" ,,~,", n:t.
~
~
n!'-
~
~.
'0 ~ '" ~ ." '0-;: ~ 0 =;~2""",~
,,-
'0
g"
-"':;'
a
~ " ~ -" a':i":3 '0 ., n:3~~o~
~
...~n""~l:3
:t. ~ ..n. ~ " n ~ ~. Ii- 5":r~ ~ n. ~ ~ ~. ~ ~~ ~ ., ~ ...~ !} -"'~" ..~ ~;;,' ,,- 'T1 ~ ., "'. : '" Z 1)..0 ~ ~ ~ ':""_.1} ~'a -" ~ ~ n:3 ~ R e --i ..'... :3 ~ :r ~ ~ .Q ~ 0< ~. e "'~,.. cr ,;: 0 Oh ~ n~. :3 !' " ~ ""- p. c:: ~. ~. .g g: t=~ E :3 ~ :.. ., ~ ~ " ~-..,
-nn-..,-0
0
;:
n.,
non
---'" ~ 0 5 :D n ~ n g. ~ P: >- ~ @ 3 ~ 3 ?:.g ~ ~ ~'? ~;.., ..O~., a: 0 ~ ê1'" ~.'g ~ ~ a ~ A ~., n -:l.:1.?" .,'" nA "A8Sa-~~~-.n ligNii~", B:,..; ~a", ~~ Q",:=:A ~"-A 7-a~" ~--.I~.n n S ~ 0: ~ ~ 3 ~ 3: g.g ~ ~ ~ 8 ~ ~ ~ ~ 5. ~ ~ '"" ~ o'~~.~.~.~~~~~" ~~.; 9.9.~ g.~!".. 8"'Q
o.~
,,~.";;!i
à A"",A:ln.O"~ ~. ~ N "'.<..n:;-;; g-:oo"~~~n~Qo "';;. -.;JO :1... AOAA~ ,:o~... ",n °Z~;;'~.n""~3'!~<'g~~--.1~.;;.;;.g. :I.~ ~ ~ ~ a à.g ~ ~ 9. â. ~ fi- ~ ~ g. ~ [ ~. a a. ~ g ~ ...tt ..~ ~ < " ~ 0 ~ -~ ~ 0 ;;. ,,' :o~~ë'Ae!..~A~.~."SotOA,,'~:OAO §. ~~.~ 0 g.s-;~; ~g-!!.:1."";'~ A ~,;~ ~~~ ~ ~~An"OA~O<-.'O<~:- ., ~" ~. a-:=~.~." 0 ~ g ~. :;- ~ ~ e!.. ~ 0:." ~ S- n ~O_..A.., ft'3nn.n.a~--.'!'~." ..AA ~ ~ ~ :. g: ~ ~ ~. ~. ~~ ~~! g [t ~ ~ l ~ § ~~. a"'A..O~ "~"O ,,-A~. ~"o- A"""~A;;.,."A-no~,,"" ~.. ~ n.<",'A ,,_"~"AO~."""-oS" Q An." S ~ ~ ~,;: A :1... ~ :0 0 '- "-.g 3 ~".,,~...Q.. "A':-'O~...g'",..o' O -AO ~~.G!";j::;:1.'" ~an t;"'~". ~'&.~~.
~
&
~
:..
--.1
g
8
a.
~ 3.g.
ë.
~
~
~
~
f)
~"a
~ ,A aotO A e!..~ "'~ 0 .t!1 :1 0 ~ :0.. ::::j"'~" ~ R ~'E-a ~3
G! ~:=:. ~ Ii A~~,-,C~A!"~:I.
0.0.
g
~@'"
~
.,
~
.,'
~
~
~.
ë
~
8
g
r:::~
~o'
ë.
e-
~
5
-§"
~f
",,--
o~"
~
"'"~~,,~~!;'"..~
"t;'-~~~~~.g~.g~
;--~~~
n s..-:~~f\' n ,, ~~. " ., ~"'" ~!:) '" -"OS =" .0~~A..Ot!..,.,~
...~."o<
§ "'n~ e:~o ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 n R' n. g ~ ~ ~ g, 2:., ~ ~. 0 ~ ~--~
~
0
~
~
a
g.
~
~
.,
~
0
.,3
n
~
~
g
'""
~
~
~.
",~~~..~
-~
,,-
Ii
"'A.~'"n
,,0
~. ~ e, ~ ~ 3 ~ ~ .~ ~ '6' ~ Ii g ..5 n *" g ~. g; ~: n~. ~ 8 W ~Ji:"" otO } o ;t ~ !:: 5:~ "" ~nA "'.,~ " o-~,, ""-' ~ :0"00- A"A,- .~:=:"A ~ ,,~ ":I.G!~Ro" o-.Q!T1 ~.~.P.g.no~:o. o.or;. ..0 ~ ~ -.."-~ ~ ~ ~ ~" * '" ~ A A ~ 0 0 -"'" ~ n. n ., § D.,? !O- N-","A""i:"O~ ."'"~O ~"3 o"'n. ~'nR""'~* gJ ~3 -,,' .A., '!'c:"g' AC:~~ '"*=,,3g5$~ t=:;:;;'t
"'~A
nO
Z
n~n"..~.:..,,-
.,
t
t""'." 0 A~. '" 0 nO" A --.1- ~ ..,~ O~O* "'_.~""""-~' ~ ~ ~Na-.., n'-ot""' ,,~~,,~.,.:o 0" ~.OA~ @.~A
°"
A"A"-S
3 œ-O~
~:I.f?;
" 0 0 ~ n. 0 O~. '"~
.0 Z'~~8
A
33ao
~
O@
[
~O
NO",
.""'" A .0 ~ 0 '" A 0 0 .'" ~-""~ AO':I. a-""~00~ o':!, :o~'"o 0",_.0 A~3~...;;~~. N:=.C1 " A "'" ". 0 0 '" A .,', .n :0 .-. ~~-Q ~= ~1I(;;-Poo-Poo ~ :3,~'O;;-~ = ~':-'~~ Poo Poo Poo g ~ 0- 5"' ~ S' Poo Q, ~"~ n ~ fb'.. "'" ~ Q, =0: r;'!J. ~ '3 n '3 ~ ~'...n"'~"'~'onaq-t""'~ ~-<~"'~ n~t""""~, t""' ~ 0 ., n" ~ ~ = R ~ tri- ~ g. Poo ~ g, n ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ., ~ g ...'"2' ~ ~~!J.8-~", ~;;o , ~'E.n..n..g~@~ n... ,"."" R aq ~ ~ !J. 8, ~ ~ ~ 9 ~ rJ!I' ~ -.:0' ~ e!, ...n '" t::: n.. ~ ~ ë' tT1 5; .Q; ~ E. ~ ' -, 0 ., -~... ~ n n.. ~ ,.'... ~ < 0 0 aq n ;;0 = =.:0 ~ ., ~ n " ~ = Poo ~ ~ Poo t1 ;;- '" 03, n ...n ~ 0 Q, ~ ~ n ~' n n ~ ... " s'"o CI? ~ Q..!J. g g: n.. n Q, ~ ~;;: @ ~ ~ ~ e:. ~ Poo ~ n s' n n ~ ~==~!"!J.3~~'g~g ",;§~~=g.~,:"_E.g =~~n @ ~ ~0
!J.
["~~
~~
g;oPoo
g
~
~ft'~g
~
~
~
~
g-~
~
@=:::
== Poo ~, ...~ ~... ~ ., n- n... -n '" n = C'} A ~ !:: 3 -n.. = nO... Poo~' ~"6' '" n n.. ~ ;;- ~ = ~ -!cl Poo" =- 0 0 ;:";;0 /JO n !J. 8 ë' Poo g ~ ~,~ ~ -n ~ 8 '" '" ~ no., ~ ' ~ ~ ~ u~, n = ~ '" ., n ;;- g, ~ e g !J. Q'~' g 8 .Q; n ë' ~ S' g- ~ ~ n ~ Q: ~ ~ ~ '3 ij' ~ -=~""n~"'n.. ~~'~~=n~"'=O"~' =... ~ ë' Poo ri"" n '" 0 Poo!" :::... ~ ::: ~ ~'... o-~, 0 = = ...'< ~ ~ Q, Poo 0' ~ ., ~ Poo!J. ~ 3 ~ ~ g !J. n.. n.. ~ ~ ri"" ri""'~ ~ q 3 ~'!J. ~ ~, r!; g = ae. ~ ~ n ~~'!J. ~ t;1 ~ ~ ~ ~ go ~ ;;' 'g 'P' ;' E, 9 g.; ~ :..!J. n ~ ~ ~= ~, ...nn_=",~x", ;;0"'", n n poo 3 Q; ;;- ~ r;' ~ Ii- ~ ~ P:: ~ 9 S~ ~ ~~,~' g ~ 'g g '" Poo 'ë 0 g. 3 n ~ g ~ ~ ., cr:g = n ~ = R ~ n.. 0 0 = ;;-:3, '" '" Poo ~~ ~ 3 = E. ~ n'ë
g
;;-
~
g
0
~
g
;;-!"
~
8.E::?
@
~;
~
g
~
5.
~
3
e
g,
~
=
~
.,~
,
3
n
~
3
-3
~~
'"
-.,
...3
n..n
no
-=
n
:'1
~
Ii-
g'
g
.!J.
~
~
~,
~.
g,
~
"@
~,
~
~
0
~
l
g
9
~
i
~,
~
~
~
~
~
0
9
'"
<'
~
3
r!;
='
n
~
;;-
P!
~
Poo
ri""
Poo
Poo
n
E.
~
!J.
ri""
~
ff
ft'
~
@
~
!J.
~
~
n
n
~
=
Poo
a.
p!
Q
o
,.""
~
3
n
§
~
~
,"
~
'"
!J.
" --n= "'Poo=n ".~, =n~'non ...~~ 5" 8 !J. g. 5" g R ~ "n.. ~"~ ~ § ~ ~ ~ ~ a: g 5. n !i g 2 3 g .:0' = Poo 8 ~ q = ~'2 n:. = ~'." 0 ~'!:: Poo ~ 0 Poo ~ "8 n ~ ~ n n '" ~,n n ...~~ n n.. n = = ~ ~ 0 3 Poo n n ~'., 0 = ri""'" .Q; :> 3 .'" n> '-g = ;; n = '" ~:3, = ~> ~!J. 3 ~ ;;-rf~' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ E. ~ w. f8' e!?!J. ~ 8 ~~ a. n p! ~ S' Poo 9 g-",~~~rJ!I'~~t=:'~~ ~S::< o n~~~-:--~~", ~.:~ o~~"~-~
,..."
;;00-
-'n-,"""~'
0",
g
~
Q
o
'~,
ri""
~
~
~
ae.
n..
~
~
~
=-=
0""
~
~
'"
~
'":;--'
~
~
n
Poo
'3
3
-< ~ '" , ,.,~, ...= 0 FI -:-- ...n n == ~ Poo n> ~ n = ~ ~ n n =- ~... 0 n.. ...~ : -, ~ n ~'~ 3 ~ p! " n n ~ Poo ",' .'" ~ ~, ~ = n f);- < ~ '--' ~ n ~ ~ = ~ n n ~ S' @ Poo 2 ~ g 'fJ ;;- 0' ~ §.: ~, :. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Poo @ 0"" n" ~ s' ~ 3 ~ == ~ ., ~ n n ., = 0, ~ 3~' ~ ~,~ '" '<; ~ " = ~ n = -n n.. n '" '" ~ n" n.. ...fb'.. ~ ~ ~, = aq .., -Q, FI " -Poo Poo -Poo 0'] ~ ~ ~ g ~ ri"" 8 9 ~ ~,~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ] ~ ~ ~ I ~nnnnl"'I""""," "l''',~II',,,,,,,,,, ...~ ;S, ~,~ p, 3 3 ~o f), ~ r6- ~ ~ ~ ~ 3'"
~
~
'"
""""O~.,
"'
3
~P'
P'"
,.-n.. ~,o ~ '" 5 ...~ ~'~ ~'~, '" ~Z
SÔ'... nn
O! ~ -..~ 1: 3~0.., ... 3 '" ",_0 ..' ,'" ~ ...~ ~ (;; ~ p, ~ n.. ~ f), -0 0' ~ a. A ~ ~ hA-=o"'~' ~'" 38=i o~ ~ ~'"d ..."'~ n ~Jt: g ~ g- g n 3-~ g a ~... ~,g.~ ~ ~ ~'~ ,~=~' ...~ ~... ~,~, "'... '" '. ~, "'-~. n'" ~ n ...g ~,D ~ < ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 n 3 ~. < n ~ 1: ~~' 0 ~ 1: n~' n ~ '" ~ ~ ~ n.. ""'" ~~n"'n n.. ...",00...""" ...-..
...
n --'" 3 ~, ~. '. ~"""-,,,_"'n -'""" ...~"" OQ ~~~ p'o>n ~I: ~"';;-~~~ f), 3 ~E:'n.. n n ~ ~ ...n f), -'" ~ 0 -n -n... 1: p, ~ --~ ~ n 0 ~,~. n.. '" P' P" 1: ...0 n f), ~ :] E f), ~ -'" ~,P. ~ OQ n P. ~ ~ 0 ~ '" -y~, ~::! ...'" 3 ~ 0 ...~, ...0 ~ '" P' '" ~ '" a, N, n P' ~ 0 ...~ ~ P. ~' ~ 3 a 1: n.. n 3 a 3 ~~~n:4cf),~~n3n- ~g-o ~ ~. P' '" ~ '" R' 1: ~ a.. < ~,~ ~ 0""8 "'. '" ~ 1: ~I:-~P' ~<nl:n.."'n..g", ~-!7f), n ~~",~P"CI>1:3!,,~~~...~l:n=:-: n' ~CI> ...~ ~ -"'~~~~ a n nPo. 1: ~ 0 n -~, P' ~ ~ g n -<'" -'" 1: ~ ... < ~o 1: 0 n ~... '" P' P' n ~P' n..g ~ '" g, P. 3 3 ? g ~ CI> n ~ n 5: P" ~ ~ g ~ n::'~' ~ n 0 'E. P' ~ ~ ~...g 0 0 0 ~. ~ CI> OQ ~ ~'OQ a;g P" ~ ~ ...n., ...~ sô' ~ ...~ "n -~, ::.. ~ '" ...n "'... ,,~ !:!') n.. !:!') 1: "'" CI> Po. (;:1 P' P' ;;- ~ ~ [" Po. ~ R' ~ R' 30 Q '"2' g. ~ ~, .'D n ~ g, ~ ,DOQ~ ~~" 3""""'0 -=... -1: n'" A ~ n Po.~, ~ ~ ~. p.: 1: ~ ~ c:: ~ ~ e; e:-3 Po. -~ ~ ~, .CI> n.. ~'~ 3 ...~ n ~ ~ ~,nnP""""'~"'-"'" -~.0Cl> "'~CI>"'I:_n~l:-ol:=:'n'n o~'" ... n..~", ...n~ -< n ~"'... -~ n n n Po. ~ 0 ~ ~ '" ~ '""' CI> ~ P' -~ 9.-f), ;.~' -'" f), ~ '"d ~ ~ -~ ~> n' '" 2 1: n ~ P' f), a a. 3 ~ Po. e; Jj;: E-:. f), ...3 a a n g .E' I:,D Po. 0 0 f), n '" ~,~ 0,9, ~ 3 ~ f)' '" -~ 1: f)' ..-~ Po.'" -~~'... 0., n n.. 0\ ~ n 1:"".CI>n~';;-;';"P'o """ 8 '" ~ y~ CI> ...~<...",~ ~p.~~3C1> 0' ~~~ P' CI> ~ 1: ~ ..~ ~ ~ < .0 ~ n.. 3 ~ ~ n.. 1: ~ ~ n n -e! 0... n ~~ "'OQ n FI'" ... ...n Po. go p" ...' 3...<' ~ Po n n e:- g: ~ n 3 ~ ~ P" 1: ~ ...1: ~ ~. ~ ...Po. ~ n n ",'" ~ ;;-"'n9..8."'.~n..p'~~OQ3~Po. ;;-~n OQ ~1:°"',D...~~-~n..~no n ~ ~ 8=i'" 0,9, ~ 1: ~ ~ e:- 3 n.. ~ g go ~ n N ~ n ~ ~ ~.g E- ~ ...1:" ~ n q ~ Po. n ~ 0 0 FI ~ n.. P,~. n P' n ~ ~ ~ ~ ;' e:- n E n 3 ,9; ~ 1: 1 1 1 CI> 1 CI> ~ ,. ,. 1 n ., CI> ...'" l "'"... 18
~
~ ~
C')c
t;;~
s:
""
~
§
z
0 t!1'"
0 0'2
ffi
"V~
~ 0§
1-" 0 "-J '-0
-
0 '-J 00 N N -~ 'D ~ '" "';:1Çg-n
~ ~.<>~g-~t%j~n~=o==o '-J~.g"'" n =_.=="!1!!-~.Oa~. ~"8=~",a !ARt-' R1Ç",~a=no",O!!-=~~~a"'...",'g...
",0'. ~ ""'P-!Aa.""""= 5 ~.~'""-. ...O"P-I ~",o=: ~ n -.""'-. ~_..tia"
-.F'g~'-o'-
""".lO
.-.
~ ':::'i ~ ? ;; z ~ g. 5" g- ~;:;1 g ~ Q ~'91 ~ 0" n t%j'g.::r. _0 ~ ". "'. ~O ~~ ~ S F " ,.,..;; " a = ~ 8 0 ~ g "'"' 0 " t::? -'" 0\ n-."." "ne!,.=", -0""'--"'::r=g. ~""S",_.", '-J"'Ç"'),,~"'n:n n"c:.~ -~=~.Ë';;5\O8~~n!"~t%j~~So
i
ë~~~P-;;~
gt%j
~
"
P-""88 -."0.."" -=P-p-~"", o ~.""_o=~~.!!..,, P-,,
~
a "", q ,,= ",,~," ~" " -=" "0
""~E;"" 5 "q-!!~~:i"":!- ".c~ ..., ::r",,~. " 01" =o~ o"~ n'_""",E;""-_. q"12. -'"g 'i ~ '): ~ n " a ~'" 0", ~ ;; ~ "=Rcr ,-~""",- c"'o.." ,,= "'~. I -,.~, "", ~-o" ,,~ ..0 -.".lO""", :1-.n."'= " ro.=g-a- '-"""""-:!8'="="'" =2 ~P- """~""" ~a,o"" ... ",8'" c:."~~'g."s~°t-'g.,, p-a ..~~ ,,~--.~ ",,= _ 0 " "-0 n~ 0 "~"'P-rl" ",- P-'" :"~; -8 ~ P- 8" -.P- P- 0 P- '" 0" ~.:g-" ë.~g-g-;rg-~~.g:-~g s~ ,,_.~ -,~o~." oro.""'" "'~ "<", ="",...P-""",, '<~ "P-~ " rl .." " a &: " " " ".Q~ ~.'-'" ~.~"'-J"P- '" " ...=,~~rln o "'-0 .--0" '"' .." --.". " ..!) " 0""" ~"o~"n~" -",-.n =;0 -ohg. l " ;;~rl~'2.~~o "a ~~'" ~ ~p-~=,n;!n::;' "a Q!!. =,,_. .."...,,1"1-0- P-" "'-~ ~ -"~rl_'~" ",-' ".. .8 ~ ~~" "'~ -rl --"" nn'~ ~",,~~f).o":'" as ",E;"" ';:;-"'"'-" " ° -~ ,,~ ~ " ~ ~ ~ -= no" ' R'[:;;~ ~.E;""5"a~.a!!..,,~ ~R ~~ 0" """8aQ)n~_!13 "'" 8.9..~ .Qé!:~E..~~~g:: " ,,~~ ~E;"" ~ P- --.DO n;- "" ~. Q"-. P-~-~cr:""-'~" L'" ,"",~ O'-"rl.",rl"'" P--""'" ~ S 'g ~." '" o' ~. ~ 'i ? ~ a ~ 0 ~ g."," -",a? ,,~.. P-n " Ç"')n ~ rl -.""" " ~ " " c:. ~... "..cr <-A ~. " ..0'" ,.,~..,
,,-
-0;
'"
-rl
0 "".,0 0 " .." n ,,~ ~"'" .-" " '" " ..a. ~ " 8"' ~ ~ ~ 'g P- 0 '" ~ ~ B. "g = P-rln" ~ro'" a-.a.. 0 ,,'" oa ~o;'::- -"'~ i'\~ro. = n.P-'<-o -..'" 0 DO '" ~ E;"" ., "" .-"Tj "" p-. rl E;""~~' '" =.- c _o ' " ~.P- \0" ..-'" "cr" .,p- 0 00 \00 ::r."'~ ~n." ~aa Ii' a9 ~9 ~ ;: (;~
(J
~
~
g.
g.
g-~
~
~
8-
8
~
8g~"'==Mri,.'~"~~
~ri~~S'":I;33~[ff~~
M"" C.., =rOT 8 SM" t;'Q.""'~=o""~,,=r",, "'9"-!"'".~~=&;=0
"""~
Q.~~. n "M =rM.., M ~ ,,=,,- =r""'nOQ",-.o~ ...~~~~'OO1\."a~" g-O~~ri ~ ~§!' 8 ~~,~=~~0..~.."N'8..0..9
=~;;:;.="..=o..o=", "'-" 8 MO~0 n ac"Cl. "0-",Cl.-.=~ ",N:..."B8Ç;"'" "e-g,.. ~h"'M" =",_0..' C_.M S'..'Q.~ Cl.. "OS',LJ." .." a M Q.G.., n ."," c. ~ ~ Q.!I :;. É' ~ g ~ =r. Q." -". c =" ~ =M.;:;.o,. C M'.J "'- "n". "" ~ ~OO "'-O/")MM- 0 -c. "~è-"8"""-" 8;;-'" --C -'g" =r _.~ --.'.J a",ën"OJF~na"~:;:- o~.g,,~;; O~n ~ =-,,= ~-~o -"" = ,,_. "" ~. ;; = "è"'"~'Cl.a~~'=-o
.n Q.=.'--"""'<OOQ
-o.
.,,;:;,..
,,=-=
~
~'"
..n ' """ -.OQ 0 8 -.~ OQ Q. 0 ~"§.
à.
~
§
~
~
~
~
§
~
0'" Cl.",LJ =" "" = :? ~ œ. ~ c 0 -Q < .~ -;; M -" ~~.~ o:!;"'8
"0~
"fi
ln",
"'"
=
Z..=
"'N'" "0],,- Ma "0,," œ.=-=~~ Cl. ~o'"" -;"""' 0"
CQ.
0 -'" ..M ~" -'"~
_.".."
-~ ~ 0= M "", ~ ~~. -= Q. ~ r ~. n ln -" "M M " X "'0\'"" Q.°=r= ~c:: ° '" 0_" '"' -= ...= v_.." ..'-! ",' ~ """~,, N OQ ...' "" Q.-'", = " ~ = '"' ..~ a. ~ 8'8;;0." ;;-~ Q. on", ..'"'C
~
S~;:;~~
~~
M ~. ~ o:g ~ ~ e~. g. ~ ~::-'=:8~ ~',,-" ~ .,(!"C=.. 5~ ~ ~ 'È- ce- g. 5 ~ M :0 g §' ';";'?;;~ BE.~g
gg~
JI' ~CI)~'OZ-Q.
'"
'"
-'"
Q
n ...'" n ~ -.w. p.. n S @..~. ~ -a --."n n,. n n p.. '" '6' <13. -.p.. n n n n CI) ...'" CI) CI) ...CI) p;'"p..
n e .p.. p.. '" ~ Q. '" '" "';:10
...0
0
n
p..
~
CI)
~
0 w... "';:1n
CI)'"
n>
CI)
CI)
-.
"""~ ~~~n ~ ~ 0 0 ~.'O ~ Q. _.~ ~ '" p;'" 0 o~~ ~~n'O ~ 0' '" '" o'" ft'~3~
~~]S
p..n,.CI) """,,"'n n ~ -'" ",p..", p;'"q"'p.. n n -'" ""' n -n '0 -.l J n 0 wCI) n... 0'0 ~~~ ~~~'" ~ ~. n ~ p.. n gn
~
n
g CI) ~ CI) ...n n 5 n p.. o' Q. n~ no~g p..CI) g ~ ~ ~n o n~o~ n n n ...~ '" CI) CI) ~n ~""op.. -.n n,. CX) 0 ...~ n n--n
'"
v
S
~
~~~
n
"'
0 n _.ft' ~ ~ S CI) El ~ "'~. 0 w nn,.~ -~ -no v_,:-. ...n np..~
~p..""
a
0
'"
--"0
~
0
'"
..."'
0
~~. CI) p.. n ~ w'O -p.. -."'
n
O
nn
,,
'"
,JI' ...CI) g ~~ 6 :;' @ ~ Q ~'"8 ~ ~ g.. ~ ~ ~ 2 3 ~ ~ ~ a 3 ~ ~ ~ a < ~ '" ~ ""' Q 0 =-: Q, 3 '" ...0 ~ g, - -~ n ..rt' ,. 1:;, '~-' '" l J -.N aq '" ~ c.. ~ rx ~ ~ ~ = g" S. @ ~ ~ -~ 0 n 0' = 0 ~ ~ '" ~ ~. ~O~.n'n'" ~~ =V1~=!"=n-'I')"" ",n~",~" n "'~'"'tjo~n c..oo~ ===-"" ~ = \D ~" '" =. ~. ~ ~- = n n _.;::;" ~ ~ n- = 0" ~ S' 'NO < ..n~.",;h~ "'lJ=-:... n~..,~ n 0 ~ ~ ~ c.. ~. 0" C'" ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ trJ ~ ~. 3 Y' \D 3 ~ n-gRc..E.-~ n-g.D~g:2~ ~ :::;Onn>~V1~~~ '" ,- n w n c.." ~ ~.. -.-aq '" 3 " '" ""n"'=-:~"~ ~_,..,."'no -~~~~~,~o'~~ ~ n-""'" ~c..n= c.. n'" ",0\= p ~ N n '" ~ 6 ~ o' 8 ~ non ~ ~ -eo: n- ""'. c g ~ ~ g ~ a. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 8 ~ ~ ~ R ~ Q ~ ~ ~ n 0 ~ N Q. = -:; ~. ~. ~ "', 3 --r;. =, g ~ n- = "'~~.o@o~' n~~~2; 3~~n~,,=~=,",0 ~~~S~~ ~ ~~3na.§8~~\Dg~::i~~ ~~ "'~ ~ ",..n3n _.=;h~V1""~n'='" ~ ~ ~] ~ ~ g, §- ~a ~ ~,~ ~ ~ g = ~ ~ 8 §o: 8 .g '" 0 , -.= = , r;. -.= = ~ 0\ ~ = n = n c..O2; 3'" '" =~,..-~ o~n~~~.n!:"'" ~=np;--~.g 3 ft'~n~I')'~3n~.Q~g.,""=~5 ~ng,,",n n- """-'~~p;--~n o~~.., ~""" ,., 0 l J <'" -" -= = " n- -, ~ n < -~ = ~ g g.~.~. ~ ~ ~ n ~ ~ @ g nOS, E"" FI- ~ ~ 0=0""'= .D~c..n ~.., = ","'-_. C'" ~ ~. 3 ~.~,.g ~ E. Po ~ g g g ~ ~ ~ ~ 8 ~ ~ ~ 2; 0 -.., ~'= ~ a. ~ _.' 0 = -,... r g ~ ~ g =. ~n",naq.D .., 3°C'"~.D -0"""'" ,,0 3 ~ "8 §.~. ~ ~ ~ ~ =,Ji;:~. ~ a' ~ 3 ~ ~ 3 §-"E.. ~ C); ~ ~ = 0 ~ P' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ = n .., ~ P' n '" ,. = ...'" = 0 ~ ~ n n " ~ p ~. n ~ ~ ~. _o .nO.., ~. n ~ n ~ _." .'o~ o w n -'n '~""O .., ~ , '" n M ~ 1')' = ~ ~ n n-~ '" ~ n- c.. a.~ = 003 ln aq -CIO c.. ~ n ~ l')'n '" n n ~':O"'~' n -.nSn=n 1')'3~"'-E.c..""" =. g c.. ft' h = ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 c.. ~ ~ ~ ~ n g. ~ ~..,n=", ~ n""n~~ ~~§-~oR-g~", -p;-- -~ c.. On =. C'" ~ g ~ g. -= = '" os. rx ~. ~ 0 ~ O'.~ 0 n"' "" """'=O.D = ~"E..c..~~~ = o~ !j;-~ ~p;--ft'~~~p;--n"" ~.g g = trJ Q ~ .g ~ ~ 1')' 0 c.. eo: Y' ë. ~ n eo: ~ ? n ~" ~ n- .., ~ ~n ~ n.., n '" ~ 0.., "'... ~..,~n-.."" n-.~ < n-.v"'=~-",aq ~""=3°' =~~;;n ~n,.~ n,<;"" 0' c.. c.. 0 C'" 0 ~ ~.., ~ 6 =..D ~ ~ g =. ~ n = ~ ~ 'j' '\' = g ~~. Or'; ~ cr ~ E. ~ 'j' ~ ~ rr ~?-
t""'
po...
~,
03- ~3
~=
~
..'
0=
"0 1: 0--.g'
~
C'IOI
~~
f;'""i
~~
~~
g~
98
o~
ZC'
C'~
~~
C'C)
o~
~E
~-
VJOZ
ri""S"O'""I ~"OQ...ort ~S'" ,0' ~ ~ r1f 8 0' ~. ~ a g~. gcg8'-~noS-~h~()..S
t\ ._.~ '" v '" rt -1n '" rt n ~ t\ ~ 0 '" '" ~ _. ;:: no 1'" o' 0 o' "0 '""1 Q.. ~ Q.. C ~. t\ '" _.= ~ = ~ Q.. t\ 0 C no
()..~=-rt
'""It\"'=",
0 Q.. rt '" "";. Q...rt '" Q.. Q.. ~ = C ~ 0 P'.o ..~ = t\ rt ~ no 0 c ë cg Q..g 0 '""1 t\ t\"= = E..: P. t\ rt 0 < g ~ ().. 3 S c g t\ '. 0 -= _.'" "0 t\ ... = = = ..;t ~ = ~ t\ '" '-. Q.. Q.. rt '" = ~"C ()..~ '" ~ Q.. C t\ ~ ri"" t\ e!.. ~ ~ ~ t\ rt P. ().. ~. p;-'" S -., ~ ..0 t\ 0 q Q.. ~ 0 '" ." rt -~ n = ~ C ~ t\ ~ "", =r rt.o'~ rt n Q..'""IrtQ..= t\=t\ -c~
t\ P. t\ ~ '""1 t\ ~ -.~ ~ t\ C < -~ Q o v .'""1 ...~c« .cc'""lpr. ~'" fi- ~ '" t\ ~ ~ t\ t\ ;. ~ P. Q.. '" rt t\ CÀ ...S '" '" '" 0 0 t\ "',< ~'""Irt'()..= ='" Q.. C ...n _.rb t\ ~ t\ = t\ '""1 n ~ 0 ln = -rt Q.. e!. 0 ~ n t\ S = ~ S c. ~ 0 = '""1 ln ~ '" '. rt t\ = = '" ~ = -'""1 _.-rt rt _.'" no ~ c' E.. C;: S .i n"O P;- S ~ 8 ~ ~..g. § ?- ~ n ~ ~ 1n' =~~~rr'g.rrt\:R-[
~g
~rtO~()..",n"O"'~ =()..~ri""no"'=
~ 9~8~ "OS '" ~ 0 0 '""1 -Q..' -P. n o' R- S ~ ri"" t\ § ~ .0 0 =.'" t\"~ E-< '" t\ t\ ~ = = ~oQ.. "0'" rt ~ n t\ ~ rt "0 ~.. ~ "0 =r ~ ~ o' (l ~ ~ '""1 nrt"O~-",..
~
t\
t\ '""1 n 0 C" -Q... ~-'" 0 =r 0- -t\ ~ ~. '""1 "0 C n "0 t\ e!.. P. = C t\ "0-' g~I"".~ ~8~ oR-n t\ ~ ~ ~ S 0 rl.. g. ~-(l Q..'" -~ ~ S~ t\ ~ ~ ~ ~ g. E. S n; t\ E.. 1'" ~ 8 Q.."O E:Q..O (l S~C;: = ~ '""1 '" t\ ~ _.~ ~ 8' ~ « p. P;- A R-.A g 9 'j' 'i'~
~
~ ~
~
~
~
~
C)c
!:;;~
f;'
'"
~
§
0z
0~
0 0z
ffi
'v0 œ 0