HAL Id: hal-00894007
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00894007
Submitted on 1 Jan 1993
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of
sci-entific research documents, whether they are
pub-lished or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés.
A genetic analysis of variable number of tandem repeats
(VNTR) polymorphism in the horse
G Guérin, M Bertaud, B Billoud, Jc Mériaux
To cite this version:
Original
article
A
genetic analysis
of variable number
of
tandem
repeats
(VNTR)
polymorphism
in the horse
G Guérin
M
Bertaud
B
Billoud
JC
Mériaux
2
1
INRA, Laboratoire de
Génétique Biochimique;
2 INRA,
Laboratoire desGroupes Sanguins,
78352Jouy-en-Josas Cedex,
France(Received
3December
1992;accepted
1July
1993)
Summary - Restriction
fragment length polymorphism
detected with the 33.6minisatel-lite
probe (Jeffreys
et al,1985)
wasanalysed
in 3 horse families ofpaternal
half-sibs and ina
sample
of stallions from 4 breeds.Among
the bands detected on Hae IIIgenomic
DNAdigests,
it was found thatstrongly hybridizing fragments
behaved as alleles at 2 differentloci. These 2
loci, showing
7 and 3 detectablealleles,
were notclosely
linked to each othernor to informative blood groups and protein markers. No neo-mutation in allele
length
was observed at these 2 loci ip the 3 families. In the stallion
sample,
8 alleles were detected at the first locus and no differences were found between theirfrequencies
in the 4 breeds.Heterozygosity
andpolymorphism
information content(PIC)
values estimated in the 4 breeds show that theThoroughbred
is the least variable breed and the Arab the most. In the wholepopulation
the PIC values were 0.73 and 0.70respectively.
horse
/
variable number of tandem repeats / linkage / genetic marker/
polymorphismRésumé - Analyse génétique du polymorphisme du nombre variable de répétitions en tandem
(VNTR)
chez le cheval. Lepolymorphisme
delongueur
defragment
derestriction détecté par la sonde minisatellite .!,!.6
(Jeffreys
etal, 1985)
a étéanalysé
chez le cheval dans troisfamilles
dedemi-germains paternels
et dans un échantillon d’étalons de quatre races. Parmi toutes les bandes révélées à partir d’ADNgénomique
digéré
parHaeIII,
lesfragments
donnant unsignal
intense se comportent comme des allèlességrégeant
à deux locusdifférents. Ceux-ci,
quipossèdent
respectivement sept et trois allèlesdétectables, ne sont pas étroitement liés entre eux ni avec les locus
informatifs
des groupessanguins et des
protéines
du sang. Aucune néo-mutation delongueur
des allèles n’a été détectée dans les troisfamilles.
Dans l’échantillon desétalons,
huit allèles ont été observésau premier locus et aucune
différence
defréquence n’apparaît
entre les quatre races.Les valeurs
d’hétérozygotie
et les valeursinformatives
despolymorphismes
(PICJ
estiméesla race Arabe. Les valeurs estimées sur la
population
totale sont respectivement de 0,73 etde
0, 70.
cheval / nombre
variable de répétitions en tandem / liaison/
marqueur génétique/
polymorphisme
INTRODUCTION
It is now well established that the genome of a number of animal and
plant
species
containsregions
that arehighly
variable,
among which are the minisatellites.These
regions
are detectedby probes
from a differentorigin containing
sequences severalbase-pairs long, tandemly repeated. Initially, highly polymorphic
patterns
displaying
alarge
number offragments
on Southern blotsresulting
from variation in the number of tandemrepeats
and calledfingerprints
were obtained in manby
Jeffreys
et al(1985).
These authors used arepeat
found in the second intron of themyoglobin
gene todesign
aprobe
that revealed related human sequences, someof which were themselves later used as
probes.
This was the case for the 33.6 and 33.15regions
that revealed extensivepolymorphism
in a number oforganisms.
Other
probes containing
repeated
sequences such as a sequencefrom
the M13bacteriophage
(Vassart
etal,
1987),
a sequencehomologous
to theDrosophila
Per gene(Shin
etal,
1985),
in the 3’region
of the aglobin
gene(Jarman
etal,
1986)
and a number of
others,
cloned from the human genome(see
forexample
Nakamuraet
al,
1987),
were found to detect veryhigh
levels ofpolymorphism.
In
pets
and domestic farmanimals, polymorphisms
were found indogs
and cats(Jeffreys
and Morton1987),
in cattle(Georges
etal,
1988),
inpoultry
(Hillel
etal,
1989),
insheep
(Drinkwater
etal,
1990)
and inpigs
(Coppieters
etal,
1990)
using
either
human,
viral orhomologous probes.
In
horses,
restrictionfragment length polymorphisms
(RFLP)
have been detectedusing
differentprobes
such asM13, Jeffreys’
minisatellites or core sequence,Per,
humanVNTR,
(TG)n,
ahomologous
horseprobe
andsynthetic
tandemrepeats
(Georges
etal, 1988;
Massina etal,
1989;
Troyer
etal,
1989;
Bernoco andByrns,
1991;
Broad etal, 1991; Hopkins
etal, 1991;
Ellegren
etal,
1992;
Giulotto etal,
1992;
Mariat etal,
1992).
However,
very little or no information aboutsegregation
of the
fragments
andlinkage
analysis
has beenreported
as limited families weretyped.
In this
report,
we show thesegregation
of DNAfragments hybridized
witha human minisatellite
probe
in 3large
horsepedigrees
andgive
somegenetic
characteristics of theregions
detected in 4 horse breeds.MATERIALS AND METHODS
Animals
Three horse families
consisting
of a stallion and half or fullpaternal sibs,
along
combinations were
30,
27 and 30 for the 3stallions,
IrisLandais,
Artichaut and Matador duBois,
respectively.
All animals were of SelleFran!ais
origin.
Asample
of stallions from 4
breeds,
Arabs(AR,
N =47),
Thoroughbred
(TB,
N =43),
SelleFran!ais
(SF,
N =40)
and TrotteurFran!ais
(TF,
N =43)
were also obtainedfrom different state stud-farms. All animals were blood
typed by
the Laboratoire desGroupes Sanguins
desChevaux,
INRA-CRJ,
Jouy-en-Josas,
for the blood groupsystems
(A,
C, D,
K,
P, Q,
U)
and theprotein
systems
(Alb,
Tf, A1B,
Es,
Pi,
Gpi,
Pgd,
Pgm)
and alloffspring qualified.
Purification of DNA
Blood
samples
were drawn in tubescontaining tripotassium
EDTA(Vacutainer)
and DNA was extracted
according
to the method ofJeanpierre
(1987).
Blood wastreated twice in a solution of 10 mM
NaCI,
10 mMEDTA,
pH
8,
for 30 min at+4°C.
Pellets
containing
leucocytes
werehomogenized
in a solution of 5 Mguanidine
HCI,
0.5 M ammonium acetate,1.25%
N-lauroylsarcosine containing
0.1mg/ml
proteinase
K for 1 h at 60°C. DNA was thenprecipitated
with 2 vol ethanol and washed twice with70%
ethanol.Restriction endonuclease
digestion
andelectrophoresis
Seven pg
samples
of horse DNA weredigested
for 20 h at 37°Cby
restriction endonucleases HaeIII or HinfI(BRL
orBoehringer)
according
to the manufacturer’s recommendations.Complete
digestion
was achieved with a total addition of 5 units per Ag DNA. Restriction endonuclease DNAfragments
weresubjected
to horizontalelectrophoresis
in1%
agarosegels
25 cm inlength
in Tris-acetate buffer(40
mMTris,
20 mMAcOH,
2 mMEDTA;
pH
8.3).
Electrophoresis
wasperformed
withcirculating
buffer at 55 V(HaeIII)
or 60 V(Hinfl)
for 18 h. Calibration was achievedby
adding
asample
ofBstEII-KpnI-SmaI digested
lambdaphage
DNA.Transfer
Transfer was
performed
onBiodyne
B membrane(Pall
Industry,
SA).
The DNAdigested fragments
in thegels
weredepurinated
in 0.15 N HCI for 10min,
denatured in a 0.4 N NaOH solution for 30 min and transferredusing
the method of Southern(1975)
at roomtemperature
for 18 h with 0.4 N NaOH.Hybridization probes
The 2 human VNTR
probes,
33.6 and 33.15 werekindly provided by
AJJeffreys.
They
were labelledby
theprimer
extension methodaccording
toJeffreys
(1985),
except
that the radiolabelled insert was not extracted from theplasmid.
Prehybridization
andhybridization
except
that0.05%
sodiumpyrophosphate
was added and sufficient radiolabelledprobe
toprovide !!
1 x10
6
cpm/ml.
Membranes were then washed twice for 15 minat room
temperature
in 2 xSSC,
0.1%
SDS then in the same solution for 30 min at65°C
(in
morestringent
solution at the sametemperature
ifnecessary)
andfinally
rinsed in 2 x SSC at roomtemperature.
The restriction endonucleasefragments
were vizualizedby autoradiography
in a cassette with aKodak
XARfilm. and
Cronex LI-PLUS
intensifying
screens at -70°C.Dehybridization
This was
performed by washing
the blot for 1 h at 37°C with 0.4 NNaOH,
followedby
washing
for 1 h in a 0.1 xSSPE,
0.5%
SDS,
0.2 M Tris-HCIpH
7.5 solution(1
x SSPE = 0.18 MNaCI,
0.01 MNaH2P0!,
1 mMEDTA).
Linkage
analysas
Calculations were
perforined according
to the Lod score method of Morton(1955).
RESULTS
Probes and enzymes
DNA extracted from our group of horses was
digested
with HaeIII and with Hinfl.Whatever the enzyme
used,
the 33.15probe
gave alarge
number offragments
withrather
homogeneous
intensities and no clearpolymorphism
(results
notshown).
Conversely,
the 33.6probe
detected fewer bands with differenthybridization signal
intensities. With
Hinfl,
allstrongly hybridizing
bands were detected in the rangeof small
fragment lengths
(less
than 3.5kb) (fig la). HaellI
gave moreevenly
distributed bandsspread
over theautoradiograms
(fig lb).
Since,
with DNAdigested
withHinfl,
the different levels of bandmigration
appeared
to be moreheterogeneous
than withHaeIII,
it was decided to take into accountonly
resultsobtained with the 33.6-HaeIII
probe-enzyme
combination.Fragment
identification andpolymorphism
Blots
usually
consisted of DNAdigests
from 1 sire and itsoffspring along
with DNAdigests
from their mothers. The 3 sires were also run on the samegel
to comparethe
respective
mobilities of their bands(fig 2).
Twomajor
groups of bands with astrong
radioactivesignal
appeared
in the range of medium(2.5
to 5kb)
and smallfragment
length
inferior to 2 kb(fig 2)
on HaeIII blotsprobed
with 33.6. A totalof 15
fragments
weregiven
a letter as an identification code(A
to0)
according
totheir
mobility
andintensity
while the rest of the bandsgiving
lowsignals
were notSegregation
of thefragments
Transmission of
single paternal
fragments
was followed in the 3 sireprogenies.
Only
informativedam(s)-offspring
combinations,
that is damnegative
for eachfragment,
were taken into account. In this way, the presence or absence of a band in theoffspring
could beunambiguously
interpreted.
It was observed that agiven
fragment
present
in the sire was transmitted to half of his progeny(table I)
suggesting
a Mendelian inheritance of thecorresponding
allele.Locus identification
Two
approaches
wereconsecutively
used to determine the number of locicontrolling
the
fragment polymorphism.
One is based on theanalysis
of the relativesegregation
of
paternal
fragments
in their progeny, theother
considersthat,
in the sameanimal,
anyfragment
should nottriplicate
with othersalready
assigned
to a locus. In themedium size range of
fragments
(2.5
to 5kb),
sires exhibited 2 bands that werefound to behave as alleles at one locus. As no dam or
offspring
possesses morethan 2 of these
bands,
it was concluded that thesefragments
were alleles at asingle
locus. Six allelespresent
in the sires were thus identified(B,
C, D, E, F,
I).
Inaddition,
onefragment
(H)
which wasonly
present
in some mares andpart
of their
offspring,
but did nottriplicate
with the 6previously
definedalleles,
wasalso
assigned
to this first locus. The samearguments
wereemployed
for the smallerbut the existence of
negative
animals in this bandcategory suggests
that there areother
fragments
generated
by
this locus not detected in our conditions. Some otherfragments
were not allocated to anyspecific
other locimainly
because insufficientgenetic
information could be obtained(bands
A, G, J,
K andL).
Mutation rate in allele
length
Each
fragment
belonging
to 1 of 2 locipresent
in anoffspring
was alsopresent
inone of its
parents
whichstrongly
suggests
that no mutation or mutation-like eventhad occurred in these 3 families. The upper limit of the
5%
confidence intervalof the mutation rate based on the Poisson distribution is thus
1.8%
at the first locus and4.4%
at the second locusaccording
to the number of observedfragments
transmitted to the progeny(168
and 66respectively).
Linkage analysis
No close
linkage
was found between these 2 loci and between them and any of theother markers that were
heterozygous
in at least 1 of the 3 sires(A,
D, P,
Q
andU blood groups and
Al, Tf, Es, A1B, Pi,
Pgd
andPgm
for theproteins).
No Lod scores exceeded 1.0 for recombination valuesranging
between 0.01 and 0.5.Polymorphism
in the 4 breedsAs for the
families,
allstrongly hybridizing fragments
werepolymorphic.
The Ffragment,
detected infamilies,
wassplit
into Fl and F2fragments
that wereconsidered to be alleles.
Conversely,
H and I were difficult todistinguish
as these 2fragments
are notfrequent
andmigrate
very close to each other and thus wereon the albumin locus
(mean
valueX
2
=1.28,
df
=3).
Allelicfrequencies
for the
firstminisatellite locus are
given
in table II and no differences were detected between thepopulations
(
X
2
=0.94,
df
=21).
Heterozygosities
andpolymorphism
informationcontent
(PIC)
values(Botstein
etal,
1980)
aregiven
in table III.DISCUSSION
In an initial
screening,
horsegenomic
DNA wasdigested
with HaeIII or Hinfl andSouthern blots were
subjected
tohybridization
with either the 33.6 or 33.15probe.
Itappeared
that the 33.15probe
gave about 25hybridizing
bands per individual with a lowdegree
ofpolymorphism
and somebackground signal.
On thecontrary,
33.6,
in the sameexperimental
conditions allowed the detection of a smaller numberobservable on Hinfl DNA
digests).
This observation confirms theprediction
that thepolymorphism
detected with VNTRoriginates
from the number of tandemrepeats
and not from mutation in the DNA restriction site of the enzyme.The
banding
pattern
of the 33.6-HaeIIIprobe-enzyme
combination resemblesmore a
single-locus
VNTR situation than afingerprint
and shows that at least 2 loci arepredominantly recognized
due to agreat
similarity
between the horseminisatellite core sequence and the human
probe
sequence. On thecontrary,
the 33.15probe
detects afamily
of DNAfragments,
the sequences of which are more similar to each other and are mostprobably generated by
agreater
number of loci. The 33.6-HaeIII combination allowed ananalysis
of thesegregation
ofstrongly
hybridizing fragments
in sireprogenies,
anapproach
which hasproved
to be very tentative or evenimpossible
with truefingerprints.
Two loci were identified with 7 and 3 detectable alleles in these 3 families. No closelinkage
was detected between any of the red cellantigen,
protein
and DNA loci detected in thisstudy
and nomutation event could be observed which indicates that these loci are rather stable. In the stallion
populations,
8 alleles were detected at the first locus whosefre-quencies
did notsignificantly
differ between the 4 breeds.However,
this observation has to be confirmed on alarger
number of animals. On the otherhand,
some bandsat this locus
migrated
very close to each other and we havecertainly
underesti-mated the real level of
polymorphism
of thissystem.
It can be observed that the lowest PIC value is found in theThoroughbred,
which confirms the well-knownhomogeneity
of this breed(Bowling
and Clark1985;
Gu6rin andM6riaux, 1986;
Ellegren
etal,
1992).
Conversely,
the Arabsample
is the mostheterogeneous
of the 4 breeds. At the second locus in thepopulation
sample,
identification of alleles was rendered somewhat hazardous due to the low power of resolution in thispart
of thegel.
Bands were found to be less distinct with variable intensities and levelsof
migration heterogeneous.
These characteristics were much lessimportant
in the familiesprobably
because animals wereinterrelated,
thusreducing
thevariability
observed in unrelated animals of the same breed.In
spite
of some limitsimposed by
the resolution of thetechnique,
thehigh
polymorphism
detected with the 33.6probe
makes it a very useful marker for horseidentification and
linkage analysis
in thisspecies.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We are very
grateful
to the Haras Nationaux forproviding
bloodsamples, pedigree
in-formation as well as financial support, to the breeders of the horse families and to AJ
Jeffreys
forproviding
the minisatellite probes. The referees suggestions aregreatly
appre-ciated. This
study
wassupported by
the Minist6re de la Recherche et del’Enseignement
Sup6rieur,
contract No 88R0703.REFERENCES .
Bowling
AT,
Clark RS(1985)
Blood group andprotein
polymorphism
genefrequen-cies for seven breeds of horses in the United States. Anim Blood
Groups
BiocherrcBotstein
D,
WhiteRL,
SkolnickM,
Davis RW(1980)
Construction of agenetic
linkage
map in manusing
RFLP. Am J Hum Genet32,
314-331Broad
TE,
LewisPE,
PhuaSH,
CrellenLJ,
ForrestJW,
Pugh PA,
AndersonIL,
Farndale B
(1991)
DNAfingerprinting
of horses. Anim Genet22,
supp1,
83-84 BernocoD,
Byrns
GR(1991)
DNAfingerprint
variation in horses. Anim Biotechnol2,
145-160Coppieters
W,
Van deWeghe A,
Depicker A, Bouquet Y,
Van Zeveren A(1990)
Ahypervariable
pig
DNAfragment.
Anim Genet21,
29-38Drinkwater
RD,
Hediger
R,
Hetzel DJS(1990)
Polymorphism
and location ofminisatellite sequences in
sheep.
In:4th
WorldCongr
AnimalGenetics,
vol13,
129-132
Ellegren
H,
AnderssonL,
JohanssonM,
Sandberg
K(1992)
DNAfingerprinting
inhorses
using
asimple
(TG)n
probe
and itsapplication
topopulation comparisons.
Anim Genet
23,
1-9Georges
M, Lequarre AS,
CastelliM,
HansetR,
Vassart G(1988)
DNAfingerprint-ing
in domestic animalsusing
four different minisatelliteprobes.
Cytogenet
Cell Genet47,
127-131Giulotto
E,
BissonN,
Semino0, Vergnaud G, Brega A,
Di SansebastianoG,
Santachiara Benerecetti S(1992)
DNApolymorphism
in horse identification. In:43rd
Annu Meet EAAP.Madrid,
13-17September,
vol2,
558Gu6rin
G,
M6riaux JC(1986)
La distribution des marqueurssanguins
dans lesraces
6quines.
Analyse
sur un 6chantillon dePur-sang,
TrotteurFran!ais
et SelleFranqais.
In: l2eme Journ6e d’Etude duCEREOPA,
2-13Hillel
J,
Plotzy
Y,
HaberfeldA,
LaviU,
CahanerA,
Jeffreys
AJ(1989)
DNAfingerprints
ofpoultry.
Anim Genet20,
145-155Hopkins
B,
O’Connel, Hopkins
J(1991)
Use of DNAfingerprinting
inpaternity
analysis
ofclosely
related Exmoorponies.
Equine
Vet J23,
277-279Jarman
AP,
NichollsRD,
WeatherallDJ,
Clegg
JB,
Higgs
DR(1986)
Molecular characterisation of ahypervariable
region
downstream of the humana-globin
genecluster. EMBO
J 5,
1857-1863Jeffreys AJ,
WilsonV,
Thein SL(1985)
Hypervariable
&dquo;minisatellite&dquo;regions
in human DNA. Nature(Lond)
314, 67-73
Jeanpierre
M(1987)
Arapid
method for thepurification
of DNA from blood.Nucleic Acids Res
15,
9611Jeffreys
AJ,
Morton DB(1987)
DNAfingerprints
ofdogs
and cats. Anim Genet18,
1-15
Mariat
D,
Gu6rinG,
BertaudM,
Vergnaud
G(1992)
Modulation ofpolymorphic
loci detection with
synthetic
tandemrepeats
variants. Mammalian Genome3,
546-549
Masina
P,
DiGregorio
P,
RandoA,
Blasi M(1989)
L’impronta
del DNA perindividuare
paternità
errate nel cavallo. Atti Soc Ital Sci VetXLIII,
1789-1793 Morton NE(1955)
Sequential
tests for the detection oflinkage.
Am J Hum Genet7,
177-318Nakamura
Y, Leppert M,
O’ConnelP,
WolffR,
HolmT,
CulverM,
MartinC,
!jimoto
E,
HoffM,
KumlinE,
White R(1987)
Variable number of tandemrepeat
Shin
HS,
Bargiello
TA,
ClarBT,
JacksonFR,
Young
MW(1985)
An unusualcoding
sequence from aDrosophila
clock gene is conserved in vertebrates. Nature(Lond)
317,
445-448Southern EM
(1975)
Detection ofspecific
sequences among DNAfragments
sepa-rated
by gel electrophoresis.
J Mol Biol98,
503-517Troyer D,
HowardD, Leipold HW,
Smith JE(1989)
A human minisatellite sequence reveals DNApolymorphism
in theequine species.
J Vet Med36,
81-83Vassart