A NNALES DE L ’I. H. P., SECTION A
D. P AVÓN
D. J OU
J. C ASAS -V ÁZQUEZ
On a covariant formulation of dissipative phenomena
Annales de l’I. H. P., section A, tome 36, n
o1 (1982), p. 79-88
<http://www.numdam.org/item?id=AIHPA_1982__36_1_79_0>
© Gauthier-Villars, 1982, tous droits réservés.
L’accès aux archives de la revue « Annales de l’I. H. P., section A » implique l’accord avec les conditions générales d’utilisation (http://www.numdam.
org/conditions). Toute utilisation commerciale ou impression systématique est constitutive d’une infraction pénale. Toute copie ou impression de ce fichier doit contenir la présente mention de copyright.
Article numérisé dans le cadre du programme Numérisation de documents anciens mathématiques
http://www.numdam.org/
79
On
acovariant formulation of dissipative phenomena
D.
PAVÓN,
D. JOU and J.CASAS-VÁZQUEZ
Departamento de Termologia. Facultad de Ciencias.
Universidad Autonoma de Barcelona, Bellaterra (Barcelona), Spain
Ann. Inst. Henri Poincaré, Vol. XXXVI, n° 1, 1982,
Section A :
Physique théorique.
ABSTRACT. - In this
article,
a covariantnon-stationary theory
ofcontinuum irreversible
thermodynamics
isproposed.
Thespecific entropy
and the entropy flux as well as thethermodynamical
forces areexpanded
up to second order in the
dissipative
fluxes. As a consequence, thespeed
of
propagation
ofperturbations
is finite and thephenomenological
lawsare non-linear in the
dissipative
fluxes. In the non-relativisticlimit,
theseequations
reduce to those of extended irreversiblethermodynamics.
RESUME. - Dans cet article on propose une theorie covariante et non
stationnaire de la
thermodynamique
irreversible des milieux continus.L’entropie specifique
et le fluxd’entropie,
d’une part, ainsi que les forcesthermodynamiques
d’autre part, sontdéveloppés jusqu’au
deuxième ordre dans les fluxdissipatifs.
Comme uneconsequence,
on obtient des pertur- bations se propageant a vitesse finie et des lois non-linéaires dans les flux.Dans la limite non-relativiste ces
equations
se reduisent a celles de lathermodynamique
irreversiblegeneralisee.
1.
INTRODUCTION
In the last
deqade,
the interest ofphysicits
about relativistic thermo-dynamics
hasincreased, perhaps,
as notedby
Israel[1 ],
due in part topossible applications
toastrophysical
andcosmological problems
whererelativistics effects can
play a
main role. Inparticular,
theproblem
ofAnnales de l’Institut Henri Poincaré-Section A-Vol. XXXVI, 0020-2339/1982,’79.,’S 5,00/
© Gauthier-Villars .
PAVON, CASAS-VAZQUEZ
detection of
gravitational
waves has oriented the work of someauthors
[2 ] - [5 ] toward
thedissipative
solidwhich,
under suitable condi-tions,
could be utilized fordetecting
such waves.The common feature of some recent covariant theories
describing dissipative
processes in a fluid is theirnon-stationary, -causal-,
cha-racter
[6 ]- [12 ].
All of them avoid theparadox
of instantaneous propaga- tion of disturbancesby allowing
the inclusion of thedissipative quantities (heat
flux anddissipatives stresses),
in theexpression
of the entropydensity
and the entropy flux.
Indeed,
conventionalthermodynamical
approa- ches[13 ] - [16] ] postulate vanishing
contribution ofdissipative
fluxes tothe entropy and to the
entropy
flux. It is to say,they
maintain theequili-
brium
equations
of state for the entropydensity
and assume moreover alinear relation between the entropy flux and the heat flux.
Actually,
thisapproximation
is valid inquasi-stationary
situationsonly,
where thespace-time gradients
ofdissipative quantities
arenegligible.
All the above referred causal theories have Newtonian counterparts.
Thus,
those of Israel[6 ] and
Israel and Stewart[7] ] as
well as the Dixon’s[8 ]
one, rest on the Muller’s
[17] ]
classicapproach,
theBampi
andMorro’s
[9] ] [10 ] one
extends the method of hidden variables[18 ] to
therelativistic
framework,
whereas ourapproach
to heat and electric conduc- tion[11 ] [12] ] generalizes
their Newtonian treatment in extended irre- versiblethermodynamics [19 ] [20]. Recently,
the lattertheory
has beenused in the non-relativistic context in the
analysis
of severalproblems,
as the
thermodynamic description
of second order fluids[21 ],
the fluctua-tions of
dissipative
fluxes[22] ] [23 ],
and the fluctuations of the heat fluxnear a critical
point [24 ].
Our main purpose in this paper is to
develop
aphenomenological
causal
theory
for a relativisticdissipative simple fluid,
which can be under- stood as the covariant version of the afore-mentioned classical extendedthermodynamics.
In this connection we get a set ofequations describing
the evolution of
dissipative
variables of that fluidalong
the world lineby
means of the
expansion
of thespecific
entropy as well as the entropy flux and thethermodynamical
forces up to second order in thedissipative
fluxes. As a consequence, the constitutive
equations
obtained are moregeneral
than those of earlier relativistic formulations of continuum thermo-dynamics.
2. CONSERVATION LAWS
AND THERMODYNAMIC ASSUMPTIONS
We start
introducing
the notation and some useful relations. Let54
bethe four-dimensional
space-time
of thespecial
orgeneral relativity
and gl1v the metric tensor withsignature ( - ,
+, +,+ ).
Comma and semicolon representpartial
and covariant derivativerespectively. Symmetrization
Annales de l’Institut Henri Poincaré-Section A
81
ON A COVARIANT FORMULATION OF DISSIPATIVE PHENOMENA
is indicated
by
roundparentheses
around thecorresponding
indexes. The dimensionlesshydrodynamical velocity
ul1 fulfills the normalizationcondition
1. Differentiationalong
the world line is definedby
A .’.’.== ul1
A ...;11
where A . ’ . ’ . , is ageneric
tensorialquantity.
In
particular ul1
= stands for the acceleration vector, which satisfiesu u
= 0. Thesymmetric spatial projector
=gl1V
+projects
any vectorial or tensorialquantity
in thetri-space orthogonal
to i. e.= = 0. With its
help
any vectorV~
can besplit uniquely
intoa «
temporal part »
jjparallel
to uu and another «spatial » orthogonal
to uu,Vu =
II+ I VI1 11-,
~~and V~ L being respectively I
jj = -ul1uvVV and I VI1 11-
=~~’’Vv. Likewise, following
to Bressan[25 ],
any tensor of rank two can be
decomposed
intotemporal,
mixed andspatial
partsaccording
towith
Finally,
we denote the trace-free part, or deviator ofAl1v by
Let us consider a heat
conducting
viscoussimple fluid,
with momentum- energy tensor TI1Vsymmetric
and conserved. Let p be the massdensity
of the system in its proper frame and JIl =
pUll
the mass flux which is submitted to the restrictionJI1;11
= 0provided
that chemical reactions aswell as creation and annihilation of matter are excluded. From that relation the
continuity equation
follows
immediately, v being
thespecific
proper volume.Such as Bressan has shown
[25 ] the expression proposed by
Eckart[13 ]
is
adequate
to describe our fluid. In(2)
thequantities
8,ql1
and standrespectively
for thespecific
internal energy, the heat flux and the pressure tensor; these two laterquantities
are ofspatial
type, i. e.qu = I ql1 11-
and11-.
Usually,
the pressure tensor isdecomposed
in theirequilibrium
andviscous parts
according
top
being
thehydrostatic
pressure. In turn, WI1V admits thefollowing
decom-position
Vol. XXXVI, n° 1-1982.
CASAS-VAZQUEZ
where II =
( -
is the bulkviscosity
and the traceless shearviscosity
tensor. Both WJlV and WI1V are ofspatial
type, and if moreover,as in our case, the fluid is structureless
they
are alsosymmetric.
When the momentum-energy conservation
equation TI1V;v
= 0 issplit
in their
temporal
andspatial
parts, itgives
rise on the one hand to thelinear momentum conservation =
0,
and on the other hand tothe energy conservation
uIJTI1V;v
= 0.By using (1)
and(2),
a brief calcula- tion shows that these relations can be writtenrespectively
asThis latter is the relativistic version of the first law of
thermodynamics,
which we will use later.
Following
the lines of extended irreversiblethermodynamics,
wepostu-
late the existence of aquantity
s, callednon-equilibrium specific
entropy,which is a function not
only
ofequilibrium
variables but also of the dissi-pative quantities, namely ql1,
II andWI1V,
This means that the
thermodynamic
state of the system under considera- tion iscompletely specified
with theknowledge
of these variables in everypoint
ofspace-time occupied by
thefluid,
and thenexpression (7) plays
the role of the fundamental
equation
in thermostatics.The evolution of s
along ul1
isgiven by
means of ageneralized
Gibbsrelation. In order to write s up to second order in the
dissipative
variableswe
adopt
thefollowing equations
of statewhere an upper
prime
indicates that allquantities
but the onesubject to
derivation are to be
kept
constant.Obviously
all these derivatives are also functionsof ~,
u, II andThe first two relations of
(8a)
are similar to the classicalequations
ofthermostatics
defining
the absolutetemperature
T and thethermodynamic
pressure
respectively,
while(8b)
and the latter of(8a)
establish thedepen-
dence between s and the
dissipative
variables and vanishidentically
atequilibrium.
We have moreover introduced in(8)
threeparameters
ai functions of B and u which as we will show later are related to the relaxationAnnales de l’Institut Henri Poincaré-Section A
ON A COVARIANT FORMULATION OF DISSIPATIVE PHENOMENA 83
proper times. Note that in our
approach,
T and p arenon-equilibrium quantities
which can be related to thecorresponding
thermostatic or localequilibrium
variablesby
means ofappropriate expansions
in series around theirequilibrium
values.Taking
into account the aboveequations
of state differentiation of(7) yields
the covariant and second-order Gibbsequation
which differs
largely
of that used instationary
theories.Our next basic
assumption
concerns to thespatial
vector entropy flux It states that thisquantity
must be a function of the same variablesentering
in thespecific
entropy, i. e.whose most
general expression
up to second order in these variables readswhere the
Pi
are scalar functions of s and u, inparticular
the coefficientsP2
and
P3 couple
heat flux to bulk and shearviscosity respectively.
A compa- rison of(11)
with eq.(6)
from ref.[77] ]
allows us toidentify Pi
as1/cT.
Evidently
the r. h. s. of(11)
coincidesformally
with the usualexpression
of the entropy flux
only
ifviscosity
isneglected.
3. ENTROPY PRODUCTION
AND PHENOMENOLOGICAL RELATIONS
In order to derive the
phenomenological
lawsgoverning
the behaviour ofn, ql1
andWI1V,
it is necessary to obtainpreviously
the entropyproduc-
tion cr in terms of these variables. This
quantity
is related to s andI s by
means of the entropy balance
equation,
whose standard form readsBy resorting
to(9)
and(11)
a can beexpressed
aswith
Here ~, ~*,
y andy*
denote dimensionless factors with no other restrictionVol. XXXVI, n° 1-1982.
PAVON, CASAS-VAZQUEZ
that
r~ + r~* = y + y* = 1.
In the deduction of(13)
we have used the relationsql1 1 Xli = q | 1X 1,
and W 03BD2Xpv
=11- implying
thatonly
thespatial
parts of1 Xli
and2Xl1v
contribute to the increase of entropy.In the current literature
phenomenological
relations areusually
obtainedassuming
a linear relation between fluxes and forces.However,
we will follow a differentprocedure
since we are interested in the obtention of a moregeneral
set of constitutiveequations which,
as we shall seelater,
may be
interpreted
as evolutionequations
of thedissipative
variables.With this in
mind,
weexpand 11 Xli 11-, °X and 2X~v ~1
up to second order in terms of thethermodynamical .variables ; thus, taking
into accountthat 1X~ I1 and
arespatial quantities,
we write downthe au coefficients
being
functions of theequilibrium
variables.These
developments
are more consistent withequations (9)
and(11)
than the conventional linear relations between fluxes and forces. It is to say, if both s and
I~
have beendeveloped
up to second order in the dissi-pative quantities also °X and 2Xuv ~ 1
must beexpanded
up tothat
order,
because theimportance of ( 17)-( 19)
in thisapproach
isanalogous
to that of
equations (9)-(11).
Note that all thesedevelopments
could becarried out to some order
higher
than two, but the inherent formalcomplica-
tions would not be
compensated by
adeeper physical insight.
When
(17)-(19)
are introduced into(13)
the second law ofthermodynamics imposes
on the aij coefficients thefollowing
restrictionssince
qllql1
as well as 112 and arenon-negative quantities,
whilen,
can be both
positive
ornegative
andBy equating
the r. h. s. of(14), (15)
and(16)
with thecorresponding
r. h. s. of
( 17), ( 18)
and(19)
andtaking
moreover into account the definitionof the
projector
tensor as well as the set of restrictions(20)
we have thephenomenological
relationsAnnales de l’Institut Henri Poincaré-Section A
85
ON A COVARIANT FORMULATION OF DISSIPATIVE PHENOMENA
with
In the deduction of
(23)
we haveused
the restriction a20 =0,
whicharises from the
requirement W~~ _ ~ W~~ ~ .
The relativistic temperaturegradient T 1, + Tuv [13 ] [25 ] [26] ] occurring
in(21) through (24)
followsin a natural way from the inertia of heat
[27].
The vectoral ql1
appearsin
(22) split
into apurely spatial
part a10q +a1103A0q
+ +Q ,
and another
purely temporal
part03B11u q03BDu03BD.
Thisphenomenological
relationconstitutes a
generalization
of the issuealready
obtainedby
the authors[77 ].
which when
viscosity
isdisregarded
have identified the coefficient aio as1/kcT, k (~ 0) being
the thermalconductivity
of the fluid.Consequently,
a10 is a
positive quantity
such as was stated above. Likewise the relaxation coefficient a 1 iseasily
identified where z1 is
the proper relaxation time of the heat conduction process.In the local instantaneous rest frame one has
~~‘v
=diag (0, 1, 1, 1),
= =
(0, qk), Wo,
=0, (/’,
k =1, 2, 3),
~and ak.
being
the Cartesian components of theordinary three-velocity
and theordinary
three-accelerationrespectively.
If in that frame and in the absenceof heat flux
(22)
and(23)
arecompared
with thecorresponding
relaxational constitutiveequations [22] J
andthe
following
identifications arise :where ~
and p arerespectively
the bulk and shearviscosity coefficients,
and T-2 and L 3 stand for the proper relaxation times of the involved processes.Recently, equations
of that kind have been used in connection with cosmo-logical problems [28 ].
The above identifications confirm twoimportant points
of thetheory,
on the one hand thepositive
semidefinite character of aoand
a21 and on the other hand thenegativeness of a2
andIndeed,
eii 0
(i
=1, 2, 3) implies
a finitespeed whereby
thecausality
of thepresent
theory
isguaranted,
and if moreover Li is assumed to be of the order of a molecular mean collisiontime,
thespeed
of thecorresponding
dissi-pative
disturbance results notonly
lower than c but moreovercomparable
to the
velocity
of sound in the fluid under consideration.Relation
(23)
exhibits the tensorsplit
into apurely spatial
tensora21 W 03BD
+a23
q q03BD ~+
and another oneCt3 W 03C1u03BDu03C1
+which is not
purely spatial
nortemporal
but mixed.Israel and Stewart
[7]
have succeded inrelating
some coefficients(ocl,
ei2,f33
Q10, aoi anda21) appearing
in our constitutiveequations
to kinetic
quantities
for a relativistic quantum gas,by
means of the Grad’sVol. XXXVI, n° 1-1982.
method of the 14-moment. For the time
being,
andanalogous
determination of theremaining
ai~coefficients, -although desirable-,
has not beenmade,
at least to ourknowledge.
Except
for the termoccurring
in thespatial
parts of(21 )
and
(23)
reduce in the classical limit to the Newtonianphenomenological
relations obtained
by
Jou et al.[20 ],
thetemporal
and mixed parts take into accountpurely
relativistic accelerationeffects,
and thereforethey
have not classic
counterparts. Indeed,
in the local instantaneous restframe, (21)-(23)
differ from the referred Newtonianequations by
terms ofthe order
c - 2 only.
Extended irreversible
thermodynamics
concerns with the evolution of thethermodynamic quantities.
In our case, this evolution means evolution with respect to the propertime,
andconsequently
weinterpret
the consti-tutive relations
(21)-(23)
as thosegiving
the evolution of thedissipative
fluxes
along
the world line of each materialpoint
of the fluid. The evolution of theequilibrium
variables u and E isgoverned by
thecontinuity
equa- tion(1)
andby
the energy conservation law(5) respectively,
whereas the evolution of u" is furnishedby
the linear momentum conservation(6).
The non-linear terms
IIql1’ appearing
in ourconstitutive
equations
do not occur in other causalphenomenological approaches [6] ] [10 ]. Indeed,
these terms may benegligible
inordinary situations,
but theirimportance
increase as thethermodynamic
system isseparated
fromequilibrium
andconsequently they
can contribute withnew
phenomena, qualitatively
different from the linear ones.They
may have interest incosmological
andastrophysical problems
whererapid fluctuations,
fast rotations and stronggravitational
fields can occur[7].
Thus,
Novello and d’Olival haveanalysed
the Bianchitype-I
Universefilled with a non-linear Stokesian fluid
[29 ]. According
to theseauthors,
in a
highly compressed early epoch
of the Universe thelarge
scale aniso- tropy could be soimportant
as to induce a non-linear response. In factthey
find several newresults,
as forinstance,
a very sensitivedependence
of the
stability
of the Friedmann solution on the values of thequadratic
coefficient of
viscosity
and anon-symmetric
behaviour of the Universe under time inversion.Likewise,
thehigh
values of thephenomenological
coefficients
k, ç and f1
obtainedby
De Groot for some components of the cosmic fluid in thelepton
era[30 ] suggest
that the afore-mentioned non-linear terms must not be ruled out in such an extreme situation of the Universe.
Concerning
both the temperature T and the pressure p ourapproach
differ likewise from other causal theories.
Thus,
whereas on the one hand Dixon[8 ]
and Israel[6] ] use
their localequilibrium
values -To,
po -,it is to say the same ones used in
stationary approaches [13 ] - [16 ],
andon the other hand
Bampi
and Morro[9] ] [10 ] use
their so-calledempirical values,
the temperature and the pressure introducedby
us -in eqs(8)-
Annales de l’Institut Henri Poincaré-Section A
87
ON A COVARIANT FORMULATION OF DISSIPATIVE PHENOMENA
differ from the
equilibrium
onesby
terms of second order in thedissipative
fluxes. These second order terms could be found from the
equality
of thesecond derivative of the entropy, as obtained from
(8)
and(9), [31 ].
As aconsequence the identifications T =
To, p =
Po are valid to first orderonly
as Israel and Stewart[7]
have also noted.4. CONCLUSIONS
On the basis of extended irreversible
thermodynamics,
we havedeveloped
a
phenomenological non-stationary
relativistictheory
forheat-conducting
viscous
simple
fluids. This has been doneby including
the heat flux and the shear and bulkviscosity
in both the Gibbsequation
and the entropy flux andexpanding
moreover thethermodynamic
forces up to second order in thedissipative
variables.We have
presented
acomplete
set ofequations governing
the evolutionof the
thermodynamic
variablesalong
the world line: theequilibrium
ones from the conservation laws and the
dissipative
onesby
means of thephenomenological
relations. In this account, the evolution of thespecific
entropy is set
through
the Gibbsequation.
Usual extended irreversible
thermodynamics [19] J [20] ]
appears to be the non-relativistic limit of the presentapproach.
Three newcoefficients, namely
a11, a12 and a2 3 are introduced withrespect
to Israel and Stewart[7] ]
in the
phenomenological laws,
which are nolonger
linear in thedissipative quantities.
REFERENCES
[1] W. ISRAEL, Thermodynamic of relativistic systems, talk given at the Fourteenth
IUPAP International Conference on Thermodynamics and Statistical Mechanics.
Edmonton, 1980.
[2] G. MAUGIN, Magnetized deformable media in general relativity, Ann. Inst. Henri
Poincaré, t. 15A, 1971, p. 275-302.
[3] G. MAUGIN, On relativistic deformable solids and the detection of gravitational
waves, Gen. Rel and Grav., t. 5, 1974, p. 13-23.
[4] G. MAUGIN, Exact relativistic theory of wave propagation in prestressed non linear
elastic solids, Ann. Inst. Henri Poincaré, t. 28A, 1978, p. 155-158.
[5] M. KRANY0160, Relativistic elasticity of dissipative media and its wave propagation modes, J. Phys. A, t. 10, 1977, p. 1847-1875.
[6] W. ISRAEL, Non stationary irreversible thermodynamics: a causal theory, Ann.
Phys., t. 100, 1976, p. 310-331.
[7] W. ISRAEL and J. M. STEWART, Transient relativistic thermodynamics and kinetic
theory, Ann. Phys., t. 118, 1979, p. 341-372.
[8] W. G. DIXON, Special relativity, Cambridge University Press, 1978.
[9] F. BAMPI and A. MORRO, Two approaches to nonstationary relativistic thermo-
dynamics, J. Math. Phys., t. 21, 1980, p. 1201-1204.
[10] F. BAMPI and A. MORRO, Relativistic heat equation in causal nonstationary ther- modynamics, Phys Lett., t. 79A, 1980, p. 156-158.
Vol. XXXVI, n° 1-1982.
[11] D. PAVÓN, D. Jou and J. CASAS-VÁZQUEZ, Heat conduction in relativistic exten- ded thermodynamics, J. Phys. A, t. 13, 1980, p. L77-L79.
[12] D. PAVÓN, D. Jou and J. CASAS-VÁZQUEZ, Electric conduction in relativistic
thermodynamics, J. Non-Equilib. Thermodyn., t. 5, 1980, p. 191-194.
[13] C. ECKART, The thermodynamics of irreversible processes. III. Relativistic theory
of the simple fluid, Phys. Rev., t. 58, 1940, p. 919-924.
[14] B. LEAF, The continuum in special relativity, Phys. Rev., t. 84, 1951, p. 345-350.
[15] G. A. KLUITENBERG, S. R. DE GROOT and P. MAZUR, Relativistic thermodyna-
mics of irreversible processes I, Physica, t. 19, 1953, p. 689-704.
[16] L. LANDAU and E. LIFSHITZ, Mécanique des fluides, MIR, Moscou, 1971.
[17] I. MULLER, Zum paradoxem der warmeleitungstheorie, Z. Phys., t. 198, 1967,
p. 329-344.
[18] W. A. DAY, Entropy and hidden variables in continuum thermodynamics, Arch.
Rat. Mech. Anal., t. 62, 1976, p. 367-389.
[19] G. LEBON, D. Jou and J. CASAS-VÁZQUEZ, An extension of the local equilibrium hypothesis, J. Phys. A, t. 13, 1980, p. 275-290.
[20] D. Jou, J. CASAS-VÁZQUEZ and G. LEBON, A dynamical interpretation of second
order constitutive equations of hydrodynamics, J.
Non-Équilib
Thermodyn, t. 4, 1980, p. 349-362.[21] D. Jou, J. RUBÍ and J. CASAS-VÁZQUEZ, A generalized Gibbs equation for second order fluids, J. Phys. A, t. 12, 1979, p. 2515-2519.
[22] D. Jou, J. RUBÍ and J. CASAS-VÁZQUEZ, Hydrodynamical fluctuations in extended irreversible thermodynamics, Physica, t. 101A, 1980, p. 588-598.
[23] D. Jou and J. CASAS-VÁZQUEZ, Fluctuations of dissipative fluxes and the Onsager- Machlup function, J. Non-Equilib Thermodyn., t. 5, 1980, p. 91-102.
[24] C. PÉREZ-GARCÍA and D. Jou, On heat fluctuations near a critical point, Phys.
Lett., t. 75A, 1980, p. 469-470.
[25] A. BRESSAN, Relativistic theories of materials, Springer, Berlin, 1978.
[26] G. MAUGIN, Sur le gradient relativiste de température, C. R. Acad. Sci., Paris,
t. 278A, 1974, p. 185-188.
[27] D. PAVÓN, D. Jou and J. CASAS-VAZQUEZ, About the relativistic temperature gradient, Phys. Lett., t. 78A, 1980, p. 317-318.
[28] V. A. BELINSKI~, E. S. NIKOMAROV and I. M. KHALATNIKOV, Investigation of the cosmological evolution of viscoelastic matter with causal thermodynamics, Sov.
Phys. JETP, t. 50, 1979, p. 213-221.
[29] M. NOVELLO and J. B. S. d’OLIVAL, Nonlinear viscous cosmology, Acta Phys. Pol.,
t. B11, p. 3-13.
[30] S. R. DE GROOT, On relativistic kinetic theory of transport processes, in particular
of neutrino systems, Ann. Inst. Henri Poincaré, t. 31A, 1979, p. 377-386.
[31] J. CASAS-VÁZQUEZ and D. Jou, On a phenomenological non-equilibrium entropy for a class of rigid conductors, J. Phys. A, t. 14, 1981, p. 1225-1231.
(Manuscrit reçu le 3 avril 1981 )
Annales de l’Institut Henri Poincaré-Section A