Implementing Proof by Pointing without a Structure Editor
24
0
0
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Implementing Proof by Pointing without a Structure Editor Yves Bertot, Thomas Kleymann-Schreiber and Dilip Sequeira. N˚ 3286 Octobre 1997. THÈME 2. ISSN 0249-6399. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4)
(5) . !"
(6) $#%&
(7) (')
(8) +*-,
(9) )/.0
(10) () 1324&
(11) . 5 67984: 79;<>=?<9@AB=CED?8/FHGI7KJLCED?MMNOPQB;R7KSUT079;WVXD?MY3Z4SIGUSI[O7K\^]79SI;>DLV?V _a`cb"d e fgihkj"lcmneporqtsKmrumne"o evwuxWoyuz{o^|~}d?qtormyKz{e qtev xtc?qt vcep eRu`ceu`celKKfWKgku&vqtce "tkgift {xWsKe"|. " ¡Q¢c£t t¤ ¥cq9qt¦ } ?qtmrl9v mrlcsEz§|~e"/mrlKve ¦IxtueuqKd¨§qKlcel9v4xtonorqQ© |ªxEz{|~e"/vq«¬mre"u&vv `ce uqtzc| eqW¦x/cqqW¦xK| | my|vxWl9v}®| eore"u&vmnl{s/ved¨|k©mnv `¯x/d¨qKz{|~eK°²±z{u`³x/sKe"|~v zcemy|´mrlKvecev eR xK|x `cmnsK`¬µ¶one"·teovxtuv myuxWoL©`cmru`4v mrstsKe|x¨| e"9zce"l{ue´qW¦orqQ©aµ¸ore·Keo{xt| myupuqtd¨dxWl§c|¦¹qtav`ce cqqW¦ e"lcstmrlceK° _a`cexWorstqK mnv `{d+mrlc`ceel9von}4 e"onmre"|wqtl®xª|~v z{uv zceµºuqKl{| umnqKz{|ael·mr qKlcd¨el9v"»xt| xªlcqQ·te"o¼v} ©e| `cqQ©¯`cqQ©¯cqqW¦½µ¶9}9µ¶§qKmnl9vmnlcswd¨x>}ke"xK|~mror}?emrl9v e"stxQv eR´mnl9vqxWlmnl9v e"~¦IxKue©mnv `{qtz¬v¾xw|~v z{u&vzce eR¬mnv qtR°4¿e4¬mr|uz§| |pmrlÀ¬evxWmrov`ceªz{| eªqt¦al{e"|~v e"Á| eore"uvxtconeªv eÂvesKmnqKl{|k¦¹qt²z{| e mrl9v extuv mrqtl^à v`ce d q¬¬mnħu"xQv mrqtl§|wlceRueR| |xW}/vqªv`ce²{ qqW¦½µ¶el{stmrlceqKz¬v czcv"Ã^xWl§v `ce¨xWorstqK mnv `{d%¦¹qKmrl9v e" cevmnl{s | eore"uv mrqtl{|xt|cqqW¦uqtd¨dxWl{c|"ém¼v`/{xt~vmruzcoyxW e¦¹eel{ue v q¨xuqtl{u ev emnd¨cored¨el9vxQv mrqtlz{| mnlcs Åkƾdxtu"|xWl{ÇLÆh ²° ÈHÉ9ÊËÌÍ ¡QÎ(t¤ d¨e"u`{xtlcmr| e"«cqqW¦Ãd¨xtl¬µ¶d¨xKu`cmrlcemnl9v e"xKu&vmnqKl^Ã{ qqW¦k}À§qKmnl9vmnlcs§ÃÇLÆ0h ²Ã Æd¨xKu|. ÏyÐ^Ñ~Ò¶Ó"ÔÑaÕ(ÖrҶ׸ØÙ Ú¬ÛUÜ~ÝÜÞàßá¸â&ãRäUåæ"ãåæ¨â&ã"ä¸ÛIå çQÜÛßàåè&ÛIâ&ã>çWåwé>åä¸ÛUÜ~ÝÜÞàßêÚ^ëì?í?îåºä0ßàåç>ÛUâ&è&ÛUÜïïåÚLðpñÁé>åßòÜpóâ&ïïã>æ>ÜãRä¸ô í§ã>ÛIâ&çWô~åæ>æRåõtÜÞàæRá¸Þ9öã>åçQÜÛ^ßàå¾ç>ÛIâ&è&Û¸Üïïåí?ìî"ñ^ó4é>ãkè&â&ãRÝåÛIæ>åïåæä÷>ÛIÞ ä¶Üæ>æRÞàö"ã>å&ø ùwúû óLîWõQí§éRÞàæ"÷>ãRÛUè&üpýLæ>Þ ÝåÛUáUÞ ä½þ ù&ù úû óLîWõQí§éRÞàæ"÷>ãRÛUè&üpýLæ>Þ ÝåÛUáUÞ ä½þ. Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004 route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 SOPHIA ANTIPOLIS Cedex (France) Téléphone : 04 93 65 77 77 – international : +33 4 93 65 77 77 – Fax : 04 93 65 77 65 – international : +33 4 93 65 77 65.
(12) . . )¨(. 2. *. 4( ) . 4* .0
(13) (² L*
(14) 2
(15) ). ê
(16) )/.0
(17) ().
(18) . ¤ l{e²mrl9v e ¦Ixtuez¬vmnormy| xWv ez{?qtzckoyx/cez{·te {xtk| jore"uv mrqtl®?ed¨e v ªzclz¬v mrormr|xQvezc c ecmnmnsKe¨o j"·tqtorz¬vmnqKl« zcl |~}¬|~v b"d eH¬ecez{·te4mnl9v e"xKu&vm¼¦kel |~j"oneRu&v mrqtl{l{xWl9vª¬e"| ved¨e"|¨x>·teRu oyx4|~qKzc my|"° Ç^e"|´sKe"|~v eR|| qtl9v´mnl9v e" { jv j"|´uqtd¨d¨e ¬eR|vxtuv my9zce"|p¬e `{xtz¬vplcmn·Ke"xtz9zcm¾¬j"uone"l{u`ce"lKv z{lce | jmre²¬e¨uqKd dxtl{¬e"|k¬e²{xt| e?qtzc´ore | }¬|vbd¨e²ce²cez{·tet°´ Ç xWorstqK mnv `{d e² e"§q9|~e ¬e ¦I x qKl mrlc`cj" e"l9v e | zc zclHe"l9·mr qKlclce"d e"l9vwKz{m¬qKm¼vwd x rv my|~e"orx/|v z{uv zce ¬eR|a¦¹qtdzcore"|"°aÇLx¨lcqKzc·teRxWz¬vj celcqtv epv x>·QxWmroLe"|~vk9zcelcqtz{|d¨qtl9v qtl§| uqKd d¨e"lKvkorxªc e"zc·te{xW´|~j"oneRu&vmnqKlH§e"z¬v v e mrlKvjsK j"e {xWl{|z{lce mrl9v e ¦Ixtue®| xtl{|jR¬m¼vezc4¬e |~v z{u&vzcet" ° ! qtz§|/¬jvxWmroronqKl{|o z¬vmnormy| xWv mrqtl!¬e®jsKmnqKl{|ª¬e veÂv eR| | el{| mn{oneR# | ¨orx| qtz{ my|aev mrdcmyKz{je"| §qKzc o mrl9v extuv mrqtl¬e o zcv mronmy| xWv e"zc"Ã{oneR|d¨qcm¼Ä§u"xQvmnqKl l{j"ueR| |xWmre cxWl{|ore v eÂv e{ q¬¬zcmnv´{xWone |~}¬|~v bd¨e ¬ecez{·te evko xtonsKqtm¼v`cd¨e9zcm(mnl9v e" { bv e ore"| qK§j"xWv mrqtl{|¬e´|~j"oneRu&v mrqtl§|uqtd¨d¨e¬eR|auqtd¨dxWl§¬e"|¬ekc e"zc·teKìx>·te"u zclcek j¦¹jel{uew{xt~vmruzconmrbe$ z{lcepd¨mr| e´e& l %pzc· e´uqKl{ubve´z¬v mronmy|xWl9vÅƾdxtu"|evwÇÆ0h ²° £ ( ¤ ' Í R Ë ) cez{·te|~zc¨qK¬mrl{xWv ez{"þmrl9v extuv mrqtl«`cqtd¨d¨eµ¶dxtu`cmrlcetÃ0c e"zc·te4{xt | jore"uv mrqtl^à ÇÆ0h ²Ã{ƾdxKu|.
(19)
(20)
(21) !"
(22) $#%'&%
(23) ( )*
(24) +& ,
(25) -&%/. 0'
(26) 1'. 2. .
(27) (2)/.0
(28) (². _a`{e²my| | zce²qW¦0dxWlcµ¸dxtu`{mnlce²mnl9vextu&vmnqKlH¦¹qt´cqqW¦0xK| | mr|~vxtl9v|`{xt|§e"el eRuqtsKlcmy|~eR¦¹qt´x/©`{mnoret° 3®xWl}¯v eRxWd| mnl9v e" eR|ve"Emnl cq9qt¦| }|~v e"d¬e·Keorqtcd¨e"lKv¨`{x>·Ke/cz¬v/| mrstlcmnħuxtl9v² e 4qt v| mrl9v q³v `ce ce·te"onqKcd¨el9v qW¦x| §eRumnħupdxWlcµ¸dxtu`{mnlcepmrl9v e"~¦IxKuet ° 5ºl®| qtd¨e uxK|~eR|Ã{uqtd¨dz{lcmru"xQvmnqKlv`cqtzcsK`x sKxtc`cmyuxtotz{| e µ¸mrl9v e"~¦IxKuemy|v `cemnl9vel{¬eRz§| xtst e 6U|~e"e0¦¹qK(mrl{|~vxtl{ue0v `ce| }|~v e"d. | !wzcco 7 ' 8¶ÃW on9 ¦ 7r"' 8¸Ã 50: Æ 7r ;'8¶= à <txt§> e 7 ; 8@?&/ ° 5ºl | qtd¨eqtv `ce"uxK|~eR|Ã?xªsKxtc`cmyuxWoLz{|~e"~µ¶mrlKve ¦Ixtuepmr|kxt>qKmnl{e"vqxª| }¬|ved ©`{mru`4xWoy|~q²c qQ·my¬e"|x²corxtmnl/v~v}z{| e µ¶mnl9v e"~¦IxKueKÃK{xK|~eRªqKl/{xt| mnl{s²uqKd¨d¨xtl{c|xWl{/cmnl9v mrlcs qtz¬v e"| zconvA | 6I| eek¦¹qKmrl{|~vxtl{ue´C _ B%DkkE Ç 7nG F8êv `§xQvz{| e"|v `ce´sKxtc`cmyuxWo?vq9qKo Bmnva_(u@o HQC _ BI7rt 8LxWl{H0v&q¬ 7r+ 8axWl{ÁJ u DkkK Ç 7r"G 8v `{xWvz{| e/x®uqKd¨dzclcmyuxWv mrqtL l Bm¼v {xt| e"³qtl³v`ceªcqtsKxtd d¨mrlcsel·mnqtl{d e"l9v sKelce"xWv qKe"lKvxWzcM 7r> 8?° | el{| mn{oneaxWc{ q9xtu`u"xWl²xtor| qw?ev q´cqtsKxtd xk|~?e"um¼Ä?ue"l·9mrqtlcd¨el9v(z{|~mrlcs´xw{ qKstxWd¨dxWcore veÂve"cm¼vqt¾orm BKeaÆd¨xKu | 7NFG8¶°Æ¾·te"l²v`cqtz{st`²v `ce { qKstxWd¨d¨mnlcsel·mnqtl{d e"l9v¾u"xWl¨|vmnoroc?e ¬e"|umr§eR xK|O x P(Q*#R$,Q('We"l·9mrqtlcd¨el9vRÃK| mnl{ueav `cewe"¬mnv qK0uxtl `§xWl{¬oredz{o¼vmncore¦¹qKlKv|xWl§uqtorqt|"ÃQ§qKczcªxWl§ {zconoy¬qQ©ld e"lz{|ÃxWl{ d qKz{| e mrl9v e"xKu&v mrqtlLÃ?mnvpmr|pxtor| q¦IxWmrvqmrl{¬myuxWv e v `§xQvpel·mnqtl{d e"l9v|czcmro¼v v`cmy|a©x>}ªxt e´xWoy|~q xtcxt¬v eRªvq¨©qK B¨qtl4coyxWmrl/ved¨mnl{xtor|"ìxt|aorqtlcs¨xt|v`ce"| ekv ed¨mnl§xWoy|xWexW{onekv q `§xWl{¬oreuzc| qt|"°¿ `cel³uqtl§|~my¬emrlcsªÆ¾dxtu"|µ¶{xt| e"e"l·9mrqtlcd¨el9v|Ã?x©mrcexWlcsKe qW¦e"orxt§qKxWv mrqtl u"xWlª?e´xtu`cmre·Ke"ê°¾±mrd {onekel·mnqtl{d e"l9v|0u"xWlª{ qQ·my¬e `ce"on/¦¹qt Bte}©qt `cmnsK`cormnsK`Kvmnl{s{Ãuqtd¨dxWl§ | el§¬mnl{s{Ãxtl{E| e"|| mnqKlEe"uqKcmnlcs§Ãe"| ?e"umyxWoror}À|~mrl{ue4v`ceHƾdxtu|¨ormrcxt mre"|²cqQ·mr¬exlcmrueH|~ev¨qt¦ d¨q¬¬zcore"|xtcxt¬v eR³¦¹qtpv`ce"| e¨vxKS| B¬|"°Hwv`ce e"l·9mrqtlcd¨el9v|puxWl¯cqQ·mrced qK eª| ?e"umnħu¨¦¹eRxQvzc eR|à ©mnv ` | §eRumyxWo©mrl{¬qQ© |²¦¹qt·QxWmrqtz{T | Bmnl§c|¨qW¦´cxQvxcÃ0d¨e"l9z§| v `{xWv¨e"·tqKon·Ke©mnv `«v `ce®|~vxWv eqW¦v `ce { qqW¦ê| }|~v e"dÃKxWl§ | qpqtlL°¾±¬}|~v e"d|¾onUm Bte W VkX ± 7rRf 8?qtW 5S3®0Y ± 7à 8?xtc·te v my| eeR|~?e"umrxtonor} v`cemrÆd¨xKu| e"l·9mrqtlcd¨el9vR°(wl/qtmrstmrl{xWo?uxt| ewmy | ZqqKd?qtsWµº[ 7 G 8¶Ã¬©`cmyu`ªmy|ce·te"onqK§eRel9vmneor}¨mnl4ƾdxtu|0v q { eR|~e"lKvav`ce´vxKS| Bªqt¦(| }¬|ved cqQ·mnl{s xK|v `ce ¬mre"u&v eR¬mnv mrlcs¨qW¦c qqt¦Lv e" d|amrl4v}9?e´v `{eqt}t° lce²mnd¨?qt vxtlKvmr||~z{e mnl®v `ce ¬e·Keorqtcd¨el9vwqt¦¾v `ceR|~e²cq9qt¦¾el·mnqtlcd¨e"lKv|my|v `{e²mrd¨§qK~vxWl{ue qt¦w|v z§u&v z{ ee"¬mnv mrlcs³·te| z{|pveÂv eR¬mnv mrlcs{°E±9v z§u&v z{ ee"¬mnv mrlcs³cz¬v|²v`cee"d¨c`{xt| my|qKlÁv `cev ee |~v z{uv zcewqt¦orqtstmyuxtoc¦¹qK d²zcorxK|xtl{/uqtd¨dxWl{{|\ ° 5¶vad¨Px BteR|mnva§q9| | mn{onev q cqQ·9my¬ed qK eeoyxW?qtxQve l{qWvxWv mrqtl{|¨xtl{«v q¯stmr·ted¨qte`{eor«vq³v `ceHeR¬m¼vqtRÃ0mrl v `ce¦¹qK dqt¦kd¨e"l9z§|¨©`cmru` mrl{¬myuxQvev `ce uqtl{|~v z{uv|´v`{xQv¨xWe/xWoronqQ©e"³mrlÁv `{euz{ el9vuqKl9v eÂvR°³l¯v `ceqWv`ce²`{xWl{^Ã|~v z{uv zceªe"cm¼vmnlcs {z¬v| uqtl{|~v xWmrl9v|qtlv `{epe"¬mnv mrlcscq¬ue"||"Ã9©`{mru`H| qtd¨e´z{|~e"|dx>}Ä{l§z{l9©mreoy¬}K° _a`ce {xt§e" 7àf 8¾mnl9v q¬¬z{ue"|kxªdxWlcµ¸dxtu`{mnlcemnl9v e"xKu&vmnqKlHv eRu`clcmyKz{e²uxtonore"I *Q] ']^%
(29) tà ©`{mru`ªdPx Bte"|0m¼va?qK||~mrcorev q²§e"~¦¹qK d el9vmnewcqqW¦I|0mnlª{ qK§q9|~mnv mrqtl{xto{orqtsKmruz§|~mrlcsqKlcor}²v`cewd¨qKz{|~e vq uqKl·te}v `{e/mrlKvel9v mrqtl§| qW¦v`ce/`zcdxtlÁz{|~e"mrlEx®·Ke} e _umne"l9v²©ax>}t°®_a`cemnl9v z{m¼vmn·Ke/my¬e"xHqt¦ v`cmy|´v eRu`clcmyKz{emr|kv`{xQvpv`ceªcqqW¦| }¬|ved¥cmr| coyx>}|kv`cestq9xWoy|´mnlÁx4stxW{`cmru"xWo©mrl{¬qQ©pÃxtl{v `ce z§|~e"0uxtl sKzcmy¬eav `cewc qqt¦?cq¬ueR| |¾} |~mrd¨con} mrl{¬myuxQvmnl{s´v `cew| zc¬µ¶e¬ce"|| mnqKl{|(qW¦v `ceR|~ewstqKxtor|(v`{xQv xt emnd¨?qt vxtlKvR°¾_a`ce{ qqW¦L| }¬|ved v`cele¬e"uz¬v eR|uqtd¨dxWl{{|v`{xQvcmnl{s v `{e"| ek| zc¬µ¶e¬ce"||~mrqtl§| vT q `v `ce¦¹qtesK qKzcl{ apxWl{®xtccormneR| v mr·mrxtoLe"xK|~qKlcmnl{s¨Ä{stzce"|"°w_a`ce xWz¬v`cqt| qtb ¦ 7 Gf 8(mrl{| mr|~vwv`{xQvkv `ce ve"u`cl{mr9zce´eormneR|qtlx lceeR/¦¹qKv `{epe"¬mnv mrlcsªuqKd¨§qKlcel9vav q?e x>©xt eqW¦(v `ce |~v z{uv zcepqW¦(onqKstmyuxWo ¦¹qK d²zcoyxt|xWl{v `{e} eÂ{orxtmnl²v `{xWvv `ce"mn¾z{| eaqW¦xWl el·mnqtlcd¨e"lKv{xK|~eR qtl¨|~v z{u&vzc eaeR¬m¼vmnl{skdPx Bte"| v`cmy| uqKl{|vxtmnl9vae"xK|~}vquqt?e´©m¼v`^° _a`cmy|4{xW?euqKd¨conev eR|/v`ce³©qK B qtl c qqt¦½µ¸}9µ¸?qtmrl9v mrlcsÀ} |~`{qQ©mnlcs«`cqQ© v `{e³uqtl{|~v xWmrl9v qt¦²|~v z{u&vzc e³x>©xt e"lce"||ªu"xWl3?e³`{xWl{coneR!©mnv `cqKz¬v®xE|~v z{u&vzc ee"¬mnv qK"° _a`{ecqqW¦xK| | mr|~vxtl9v §xt||~eR||~v z{u&vzce²mrl¬¦¹qtdxQvmnqKlxWorqtl{s/©mnv `v `ce²v eÂ9vpqt¦cxWvx/v qv `ce¨e"cm¼vqtRÃê©`cmru`³uqKl9·Ke v|wv `ce. ññ. æ"cJd+e+f+g.
(30) G +
(31) 1'
(32) . ;. #%' (
(33) ' ( *] ) ,#R - L) & (. |~v z{uv zce mrl¬¦¹qtdxQv mrqtl mnl9v q R
(34) 1 *
(35) &°w_a`{e"| eeÂvel9v|d x Btem¼v´·te" }4e"xK|~}v qmnl9v e" { ev v `ce z{| e | d¨qKz{|~emrl9v e"xKu&v mrqtl§|(v qpcq¬¬z{ue§xQv `¨mrl¬¦¹qtdxQvmnqKl^Ãt©`cmyu`¨mr|mnl9v e" { ev e" }²x´{ qqW¦½µ¶}9µ¸?qtmrl9v mrlcs uqtd¨dxWl{¨sKelce"xWv qK"°L_a`{ew|v z§u&v z{ e qt¦v `cekuqtd¨dxWl§²sKelce"xWv qK¾m¼v|~e"o¼¦Lxtor| q ¬e"| e·teR||~v z{¬}¨xWl§ ©ep¬ed¨qKl{|vxWv e´mnv|| mnd¨cormrum¼v}4xWl{eÂvel{| mn{mnorm¼v}K° ¿³e¬q¬uzcd¨el9vv`ceeÂv el§|~mrqtlÁqt¦wxHz{| emrl9v e"~¦IxKue¦¹qK v `{eÇLÆh %c qqt¦xK| | my|vxWl9! v 7 ' 8©mnv ` { qqW¦½µ¶}9µ¸?qtmrl9v mrlcs{°(_a`ce mrlKve ¦Ixtue mr|0mnd¨cored¨e"lKve"mrl{| mrce v `{ewÅÆd¨xKu|v eÂve"¬mnv qK 7r"G 8¶°¿ez{|~e eÂcxWd¨core"|qt¦0uq¬¬extl{qtz¬vcz¬v¦¹ qKd ÇÆ0h v q/mroronz{|~v xQve qtz{ ©qK Bçcz¬v©e¬eR| u mr?epv `ce©qK B ©mnv `eÂv e"l9v|kmnl v e" d|qW¦xtl xW{|~v xtuvkcxWvxWv}9?e©`{mru`³uqtz{orHeRxt| mnor}§e mrd {one"d e"l9v e"mrl qWv`ce sKxtc`cmyuxto?e"l·9mrqtlcd¨el9v|° _a`cewcorxtl¨qW¦v `cmy|¾{xt§e"my|qtsKxtlcmy|~eRxt|¾¦¹qtoronqQ© |"°(±eRu&vmnqKl/fkc eR|~e"l9v|(v `{e qQ·te"xtonoqtsKxtlcmy| xWv mrqtl qt¦´v `ce®{ qqW¦½µ¶}9µ¸?qtmrl9v mrlcs³¦Ixtumrorm¼v}KÃv`ce uqtd¨§qKlcel9v|m¼v4mnl·Kqtor·te"|"Ãxtl{ v `{e®©x>}Ev `ce"}«mrl9v e"xKu&v"° ±¬e"u&vmnqKl ¬evxWmror|v`cee´xt| §eRu&v|qt¦^v `ceR|~epuqtd¨§qKlcel9v| (v `{ecev v}9µ¸cmrlKvmnl{s²d¨e"u`§xWlcmy|~d z§|~eRv q §xt||aeÂv x mnl¬¦¹qK dxWv mrqtl4v q¨v`cepv eÂv e"¬mnv qK"ìv`ce eÂ9vel9v| d eRu`{xWl{mr| d z{| e"4mrlv `cepveÂv~µ¶e"cm¼vqtav q mrl9v e" cev d¨qKz{|~e/mnl9v e"xKu&vmnqKl{|Ã(xWl{³v`ce/uqtd¨dxWl{¯sKelce"xWv qtR°4±¬e"u&vmnqKl ; uqKl9vxWmrl{| uqtl{uonz§¬mnl{s edxt B¬|"°. . L c
(36) (Q* . *² L *´
(37) (. { qKd v `cepz§|~e" | §qKmnl9v qW¦(·mne"©pÃcxtc¬mrlcs¨cqqW¦½µ¶9}9µ¶§qKmnl9vmnlcsv q v `{ek{ qqW¦(el·mnqtl{d e"l9vmrd¨conmre"|x. u`§xWlcsKekmrl4v `ce xK|~?e"uv qW¦(v `cmy|e"l9·mr qKlcd¨el9v xWl{x¨u`{xtlcste´mrl4`{qQ©!v qz§|~epmnv"W ° 5ºl4v`cmr||~eRu&vmnqKl^ì©e ©mroroêÄ{|vw¬eR| u mr?ev`ce dxWmrlHu`{xWl{ste"|cqtz{st`9vav q¨v `{e mnl9ve ¦Ixtue´qK s9xWlcmy| xWv mrqtl4xWl{/v q¨v`ce ©ax>}ªm¼v my|mrl9v el§¬e"v q¨?e z{| e"ê°_a`{el©epsKmn·Kepx²{ q9xtcmruv zcepqW¦(v `{ep·>xt mrqtz§|uqtd¨?qtlce"lKv|av `§xQv d x BKe v`cmy|qtsKxtlcmr|xQvmnqKlª?qK||~mrcore´xtl{`cqQ©!v`ce}mnl9v e"xKu&vR°. !. "$#&%')(+*-,./'!#102.3#4./57698:#<;>=@?A01B7'!;/#10DCE6F0G.. ¿³e©mronoÄ{|~v¬e"|umn?e|~z§uumrl{uv or}®©`{xQv ©e¨zcl{¬e"|~vxtl{³xt|kv `{emnlcmnv myxWo|~mnv z{xWv mrqtl^ÃLv `ce"l¯©e¨©mrono | `cqQ©!`{qQ©!v `{mr|my|d¨q¬¬mnÄ{e"4}ªqtz{©qK B°. HIJKIJ. ( PFM½ ¢¬ QM ÍKO I L ¡Q¢cÎM½ NM ÍKO ¢ . |x|vxW v mrlcsª?qtmrl9v"ée uqKl{|~my¬e"w©qt B9mrlcs©mnv `³x¨v eÂ9v´e"cm¼vqtv `{xWvdxWlcmrczcoyxQve"|k|~e"·te"xto^mnl§¬eµ ?el§¬el9vav eÂ9vz{xWoqK¬e"uv|"Ã9l§xWd¨e"/cz%4e|°0lcekqW¦^v`cekv eÂ9vz{xWoê¬q¬uzcd¨el9v|`{xtl{¬ore"|v `cepuqtd¨dz¬µ l{mru"xQv mrqtl ©mnv `xWl¨eÂvel{xWo¬cq¬ueR| |"Ã>v `cmy|¾cz 4?e"©mnoroc?e l{xtd eR²R x Q#% +&S &° 5ºl qKzc¾e¬?emnd¨e"lKv qt¦uqKzc|~eKçv`cmy|k| `ce"ononµ¸{%z 4?e"´©mnoro`{xWl{cone²v `ceuqtd¨dzcl{mru"xQv mrqtl §ev©e"el®v`ce v eÂ9v´e"cm¼vqtpxWl{®v `ce { qqW¦^e"lcstmrlceK°_a`{mr|a| `ceoro¼µ¶c%z 4emy|qK s9xWlcmy| e"¨|~qv `{xWvmnvmr|?qK||~mrcorewvqmrl{|~e"~vv eÂvmrlªv`cmr|cz 4?e""à | el§v eÂ9vk¦¹qtd v `cmy|c%z 4ekv q/v `ce eÂv e" l§xWoL{ q¬ueR| |"ÃxWl{He"uqt4v `ce qtzcv cz¬v´qW¦¾v`ce c q¬ue"|| mrl v`cmy|c%z 4eR" ° 5ºl/v`cmy| xWc{ q9xtu`^Ã9v `{e |~`ce"ononµ¶c%z 4e uqKl9vxWmrl{|?qWv `4v`cepz{| emrlccz¬vxtl{/v `cepeÂ9vel{xWo { q¬ueR| |qKz¬v czcv"° 3d qK ee"orxt§qKxWv eaqtsKxtlcmy| xWv mrqtl d¨Px BteR|¾m¼ve"xt| mre¾vO q Bte"e v xtQu B²qW¦v `cekuqKd dxtl{c|| el9vvqpv `ce e"lcstmrlceK°(_a`cmy|qtsKxtlcmy| xWv mrqtlz§|~eR|¾xWl eÂv xkc%z 4eRÃt©`cmyu`¨©e| `{xWoro{uxtonov`c+ e ,+
(38) {cz 4?e""ÃKmnl9v e"l{¬eR vq/e"uqtqtlcor}4v `ce uqtd¨dxWl§c|| el9vk9}4v`ce²z§|~e" v qv `{ecqqW¦el{stmrlcet°´_a`cel{qtd¨xtoL?e`{x>·mrqtzc. TVU(ñTXW.
(39)
(40)
(41) !"
(42) $#%'&%
(43) ( )*
(44) +& ,
(45) -&%/. 0'
(46) 1'. F. my|v `{xWv´v `ce¨z{| e´e"cm¼v|wv`ceuqKd dxtl{c|kmnlv `{mr|´cz 4?e"´xtl{êÃ^©mnv `¯uqKl9v qto Bte}¬|qt´d¨elz{|"Ã^|~e"l{c| v`ced vqHv `ceeÂv e" l§xWocq¬ueR| |"°X5ºlKvel{xWoror}tÃ(v `ce/ e"one"·>xtl9v v eÂ9v²¦¹xtstd¨el9v my|²|~v mrorouqKcmre"³v q v `ce | `ce"ononµ¸{z%4?e"xWl{v `{eqtz¬vcz¬v|vmnoro{xtc§eRxW|v `ce" eKÃt|~qkv`{xQvv `{ez{|~e"uxtl BKee¨xWl e}KeqKlv`cmy|¾cz%4e vq|~e"ev`ce uqKd¨cz¬v eRcxQvx²qK u`ce"Qu B¨v`{xQvv`cmrlcsK| xt ekstqKmnl{s ©eoro¸° 5ºl®{xKu&v myueKÃ{v`cee dx>}4§e xt| dxtl9}|umn¬vkc% z 4e|wxK|v `{ez{| ek©xtl9v|"çxt|cxQvxd¨qQ·teR|qtlcor} ¦¹qtd | u mr¬v cz 4?e"|´vqv `ce|~`ce"ononµ¶c%z 4eR°l³v `ce/qWv `{ep`{xtl{êÃ(m¼vmy| | el{| mrcone¨vqH`{x>·te¨qKlcon}qtlce | `ce"ononµ¸{%z 4?e""ì©`{mru`dx>}§e u eRxQve"qtlcor}ª©`ce"l4{ q¬ueR| | mrlcsv`ce´Ä{|vaveÂv¦¹xtstd¨el9vR° Î(ÎM O. HIJKI H. . É ¡ Í^ÍUË ÊËwÍ M O QM O. . É ¢¬ L¡ É I. _a`{edxWmrl/d¨q¬¬mnħuxWv mrqtlª{ qKzcst`9vxt§qKz¬va9}¨cqqW¦½µ¶}Kµ¶?qtmrlKvmnl{s mr|v`{xQv|~qKd¨eqt¦^v `cekqtzcv cz¬v¦¹qtd v`ce³onqKstmyuxWoelcsKmnl{emy|/z§|~eR v q cq¬¬z{ue³uqKd dxtl{c|4xQv4v `ce³d¨eeuormyuQB qt¦ v `{ed¨qtz§|~eK° _a`{mr| qKz¬v {z¬v0my|¬my|~coyx>}teRmrlªxWl¨eÂ9vx´{z%4?e""ÃK©`cmyu` my|qK§e"lce" mn¦êlceeR¬e"¨xWl§¨zc?{xQv eR¨e·Ke}pv mrd¨ev `ce orqtsKmru"xWo§elcsKmnlcekcq¬¬z{ueR|0eore·QxtlKvacxQvxc°¾_a`cek e"one"·QxWl9vcxWvx uqKl{|~my|~v|qW¦^v`ceormy|v|qt¦xt|| zcd¨¬v mrqtl{| xtl{qtcormns9xQvmnqKl{|acqcz{ueR/©`ce"lqtlce´©qt B|©mnv `®ÇÆ0h vq§e"~¦¹qK d sKqKxto¼µº¬mr eRu&v eRªcqqW¦°_a`ce | ?e"umyxWocz 4?e"ue"xQve" v qk eRuemr·tev `{mr|¾cxWvxkuqKlKvxWmrl{|(x{%z 4?e"©ea©mrono¬e¦¹e"Lvq´xK|v `cb e J( cz 4?e""° Àd eRxWlcmrlcst¦¹zcoKuonmyQu Bwqt¦9v`ced¨qtz§|~e¾mrlpv `{mr|Lc%z 4eu"xWz{| e"|Lxalce©ÁuqKd¨d¨xtl{v q ?emrl{| e v e"´mrl x|umn¬v {%z 4?e"wxWl§/vq§ee¬e"uz¬v eR}/v `ceporqtsKmru"xWoêel{stmrlcet° 5ºl4evzcl^ìv `{mr| uqtd¨dxWl{u`{xtlcsteR|v `ce {xQvx cmr| coyx>}te"kmrlpv `{estq9xWoy|êc%z 4exWl{kv`ce0©`{qtore0|~}¬|~v e"d sKev|^ eRxt¬}¦¹qt(xlce©¯mrl9v extuv mrqtl^°qtd¨corev e sKqKxto¼µº¬mr eRu&v eR{ qqW¦I|uxtl ?ecqtlce z§|~mrlcs qKlcon} d¨qtz{| e mrl9v extuv mrqtl^°w|0mnl/qWv `{emrd¨cone"d¨el9vxWv mrqtl{| qt¦?{ qqW¦½µ¶}9µ¸?qtmrl9v mrlcs{ÃWd¨qKz{|~emrl9v e"xKu&v mrqtl¨uxtlªxWoy|~q´?e mrlKveoneRx>·teR©mnv `?qtz¬v|qt¦?dxWlz{xtoce"cm¼vmnlcs ?e ¦¹qtd¨e"4¬mr eRu&v or}ªmrl4v `ce |umncva{%z 4?e""°. . ; *>5D' . 6F*K.
(47) 7;/6. _a`{ekmrd¨cored¨el9vxWv mrqtlqW¦{ qqW¦½µ¶}9µ¸?qtmrl9v mrlcsmrlxtle"l9·mr qKlcd¨el9v§xt| e"qtlx²cqtsKxtd dxtconewv eÂ9v eR¬mnv qte"9zcmre"|auorqK| e´mnl9v e"xKu&vmnqKl?ev©ee"lv`ceporqtstmyuxtoelcsKmnlce xtl{/v `cepeR¬m¼vqtR°_a`cmy|mnl9vextu&vmnqKl e·Kqtor·teR|wxWqtz{l{ | e·KexWo¾uqKd ?qtl{el9v|´uqKd¨dzclcmyuxWv mrlcsv `cqtzcsK`{ q¬ueR¬zce u"xWoror|kqK´|~v e"xtd|qt¦ u`§xWxtu&ve|pxWl{¯e"xKu&vmnlcsvq e"·tel9v| cqQ·tRq Bte" }³z§|~e" mnl9vextu&vmnqKl^° ±qKd e/qW¦v `{euqKd¨§qKlcel9v| ©eextone"xK¬}³mnl«v `ce4cqqW¦ el{stmrlce4xtl{Áv`cev eÂve"cm¼vqt §e¦¹qte4|~vxt~vmnlcsqtzc e¬?emnd¨e"lKvxWl§ ©e´qtlcor}xKcxWcv e"/v `{ed%v q¨qtzc{zc ?qK| e"|"°wv `{ewuqtd¨§qKlcel9v|a©e" epue"xWv eR| §eRumnħuxtonor}¦¹qKv `ce l{ee"{|²qt¦wv`cmr| eÂ?emrd e"l9v"° 5ºlEv `cmy|| e"u&vmnqKlE©e©mroro e"·9mre© v `ceR|~euqKd ?qtl{el9v|¨xWl§Àv`ce4{xQvx |~v z{uv zce"|v `{e}uqtd¨dz{lcmru"xQvevqe"xKu`/qWv`ceR°. HI HIJ. Pê R¢¬ NM¹£ M É9Ì I. (mrstzceªuxtl?eªz{| e"v qHz{l{¬e|~vxWl§®v`ceªcqKxK®qtsKxtlcmy| xWv mrqtl qt¦qKzcpcqqW¦½µ¶9}9µ¶§qKmnl9vmnlcsv qqKoU°. _a`{e `{qtm"qtl9vxto{xt| `ce"³ormnlcemrl³v `ced¨myc¬ore e"ce"| el9v|v `{e§qK¬e"p§ev©e"elv©qcq¬ueR| | e"|"ÃL| q xt qQ© |uqK|| mnlcs v`cmr|ormnlce² e"ce"| el9vwuqKd d²zclcmyuxWv mrqtlmnl®v eÂv¦¹qtd4° _a`{e qWv`cekxW qQ© |a?ev©ee"l v`cepe"u&vxWlcsKzcoyxW§q>¬e"|ae{ eR|~e"lKv¦¹zcl{uv mrqtlqt{ q¬ueR¬zcepuxWoroy|° l´v`ce¾v eÂvLe"¬mnv qKL| mr¬b e 6Uƾdxtu"|L| mr¬Ge ?&ÃRv `{e§q>¬eR|ê e"ce"| el9vêc%z 4e|ÃQxWl§wv`ce0xt qQ© |? e"c eR|~e"l9v {xQvx d¨qQ·te"d¨el9v¦¹qtd+qtlce´c%z 4e v q v `cepqtv `ce""°_a`{e´{xQvx my|alcqWvwxton©ax>}¬|0{orxtmnl4v eÂNv ¾mnvwuxWlxWoy| q ?e v eÂ9v´el{ myu`ce" ©m¼v ` ÃêesKmnqKl{| v`{xQvpd x BKe²mnv´e"xt| }v q4d x BKev`ce v eÂvpd¨qtz{| eµº| el{| m¼vmn·Ke. ññ. æ"cJd+e+f+g.
(48) G +
(49) 1'
(50) . . #%' (
(51) ' ( *] ) ,#R - L) & (. User. goals buffer. Emacs side. script buffer. shell buffer. parser. pretty printer. proof-by-pointing command generator. formatter. logical engine. Lego side. (mnsKzce H 3 xWmrlxWu`cm¼ve"uv zce´qW¦Lv`cepz{| e µ¸mrl9v e"~¦IxKue. TVU(ñTXW.
(52)
(53)
(54) !"
(55) $#%'&%
(56) ( )*
(57) +& ,
(58) -&%/. 0'
(59) 1'. . xtl{ v qHxQv vxtu`³xWlcl{qWvxWv mrqtl{|vq4orq¬uxWv mrqtl{|kmrl v`ce v eÂvRT ° 5ºl³qtz{ke¬§e" mrd¨el9v"Ãêv`ce"| e¨eÂv e"l9v|´`{x>·Ke ?ee"lc qQ·my¬e"ª¦¹qta¦¹eep}v`cepÅƾdxKu|ae"cm¼vqtR°¾¿e ¬eR| u mr?ev`cemrz{| eporxWv e"mnlH| e"u&vmnqKl4{° fc° lÁv`ce/{ qqW¦ u`ceRQu Bte"|~my¬L e 6IÇLÆh |~my¬e ?Ãv `ce§q>¬eR| ece"| el9v d¨q¬¬zcore"|²qW¦v `{eu`ceRQu Bte | mrd¨cored¨el9vxWv mrqtl^°¾_a`cekcxQvx |~v z{u&vzc eR|0uqtd¨dzcl{mru"xQv eR¨¦¹qtd qtlcewd q¬¬z{onev qpv`cekqWv `{eu"xWlª·Qxt } mrlÁ¦¹qK d ªmrlÀ{xt~vmruzcorxt"Ã(v`ce4uqtd¨dz{lcmru"xQvmnqKlÀ§ev©e"elÁv`ce4onqKstmyuxWoelcsKmnl{etÃv `{e/¦¹qK dxQv v e"²xWl§ v`ce¨cq9qt¦½µ¸}9µ¶§qKmnl9v mrlcs/uqtd¨dxWl{ ste"lcexQvqtkz{|~eR|´x/ece"| el9vxQv mrqtlHqt¦orqtsKmru"xWo¦¹qtdzcoyxt|wv `{xWvpmr| { qQ·my¬e"4}/v`ce v}?eu`ceRQu Bte |amnd¨cored¨el9vxQv mrqtlxWl{4v`{xQv´¬mrl{qWvl{ee"Hxtl}/d¨q¬¬m¼Ä?uxQvmnqKl¦¹qt qKzce¬?emnd¨e"lKvR° ¿ `ce"lª¬e"| mrstlcmrlcs´v `{mr|0qtsKxWl{mr|xQvmnqKl^Ã>v `ce" ew©xK|¾xpu`cqtmyueqt¦©`{ev `{e¾vq mnd¨cored¨e"lKv0v `ce { qqW¦½µ }9µ¶§qKmnl9v mrlcsuqtd¨dxWl{ªstel{exQv qK0mrlv `{ewveÂveR¬mnv qtqtqtlªv `cekcq9qt¦^u`ce"Qu BKe ||~my¬et°¾|| ee"l/mrl | e"uv mrqtl4c° cÃv `{e´u`{qtmyue´qW¦(mnd¨cored¨el9vmnlcs¨mnv qtlv `ce´cqqW¦u`ce"Qu BKe ||~my¬e´d x BKe"|stqq¬ªz{| e´qW¦(v `ce 3®ÇEoyxWlcsKz{xWsKexWl§®mnv|k{xQv v e" ld¨xWvu`cmrlcs¦Ixtumnorm¼v}vq{ qQ·my¬eeRxt| }4eÂv el§|~mrcmronmnv}t°²l v `ce¨qWv`ce `§xWl{êìmnvwuqKd¨conmyuxWv eR|v `ce uqtd¨dzcl{mru"xQv mrqtl4?ev©eelv `{epc qqt¦(u`ceRQu Btextl{ªv`ce´v eÂv e"¬mnv qK"° ÊFO ¢. HI HI H. . M¹£K. _q¨¦¹zcoron}zcl{¬e"|~vxtl{v `cepqK s9xWlcmy|xQv mrqtlqW¦(v `cmy|eÂ?emrd e"l9v"Ãcmnvwmy| xWoy|~q¨lceRueR| |xW}¨v q`{x>·Kepx v ed µ ?qtxWo·mne"© qt¦ m¼v|qK§e"xWv mrqtl^Ã(vq zcl{ce|vxWl{³v`ceu`{xtxKu&vemr|~v myu|pqt¦ e"xKu`ÀcxQvxv}§emnl·tqKon·Ke"êà xtl{Ávq¯zcl{¬e"|~vxtl{Àv`ceHuqKl9·Ke|~mrqtl§|pv `§xQvq¬uuz{ mrl e"xtu`«§q>Âê° ¿e©mronosKmn·Ke4xtlEqQ·Ke·9mre© qt¦ v`ce"| eªuqKl·te| mnqKl{|k9} ¦¹qtoronqQ©mrlcs®xHuqtd¨corev eªu}¬uoreqW¦av `ce/§e" dxWl{el9v¬myxWorqts§ev©e"el¯v`cev©q { q¬ueR| | e"|"° _a`ce v}9{mru"xWoêmrlKvextuv mrqtlH| uel{xt mrq¨|vxW v|©mnv `4v `{e z{| e mrlccz¬v v mrlcsªxuqKd¨d¨xtl{4mnlv`ce |umn¬v {%z 4?e"¾qW¦§v `ceaveÂve"¬mnv qK¾xWl{² eR9zce"|~v mrlcskv `{xWvv `cmy|uqKd¨d¨xtl{²§eae¬eRuz¬ve"²9} v `cecqqW¦u`ce"Qu BKeRà e"m¼v`cea}u`cqqK| mnl{s²xWlqt¬vmnqKlªmrlx²d e"lz/qt}¨v}cmnl{s x²|~?e"um¼Ä§/ u Bte"}ª|~eR9zcel{uet°_a`ce´uqtd¨dxWl§ sKqe"|Lv `cqtzcsK` v`ce|~`ce"ononµ¶c%z 4ev qv `{e{ qqW¦?u`ce"Qu BKe |{xW| eRÃR©`{mru`¨uqKl9·Ke v|Lm¼v¾mrlKvqpxwcq¬ueR¬zce u"xWoro¦¹qtav`ceponqKstmyuxto?e"lcstmrlce 6¹l{qWv e´v`{xQvlcqd¨q¬¬mnħuxWv mrqtl4qW¦v `ceporqtsKmru"xWoelcsKmnl{ek©axt|al{e"ueR| |xW} ¦¹qt qKzcwe¬§e" mrd¨el9Qv ?b ° 5ºl®ev z{ l^çv `{eorqtstmyuxto^el{stmrlce cq¬¬z{ueR|w| qtd¨e qKz¬v czcv"°_a`{emrlKvee"|~v mrlcs/u"xt| e ¦¹qKLv`cmy|§xW?emr|©`ce"l v `{eorqtsKmru"xWoKelcsKmnlc e |qtzcv cz¬v¾my|xlce"©Àonmy|~v(qt¦§xt||~z{d cv mrqtl{|(xWl{ qtcormns9xQvmnqKl{|°. . ¡ M O Q M O Í ¢ (I I _a`ce orqtstmyuxtoLe"lcstmrlc)e |qtz¬vcz¬v´stqe"|wv `cqtz{st`Hv`ce¦¹qK dxWv~v e"kxtl{v`ce²{ ev~v} { mrl9v ekqW¦0v `ce cq9qt¦0u`ce"uQBKeR°_a`ceR|~e²v©quqKd¨§qKlcel9v|kxWeesKzcoyxWuqtd¨?qtlce"lKv|wqt¦v `{e ÇÆ0h { qqW¦cu`ceRQu Bte""° 5ºlpv`ce0esKzcoyxW^mrd¨cone"d¨el9vxWv mrqtlpqW¦¬v`ce0{ qqW¦cu`ceRQu Bte""Ãv `cec ev~v}kcmnl9v e"Lmy|xwuorqK| e mrd¨cored¨el9vxWv mrqtl´qW¦v`cecev v}cmrlKvmnl{s xWorstqtmnv `cd!sKmn·Kel´mrl 7nRG 8¸ÃQxtl{v `ce0{xQvxv}9?e¾z{| e"´?ev©ee"l v`ce"| ev©q uqtd¨?qtlce"l9v|mr|| mnd¨mrorxt/vqEv`ce{onq¬Qu B cxQvxQv}?e³¬eR| u mr?e" v`ceet° _a`ce¦¹qtdxQv v e | mrd {on}Hcq¬¬z{ue"|´x/{onq¬Qu B®|~v z{u&vzc e²©`cmyu` v`ce²{ ev~v}Hcmnl9vepuqKl9·Ke v|mnl9vq/veÂv"Ãv x Bmnl{s4u"xWe qt¦¾onmrlce ce"Px Bmnlcsxtl{mnl§¬el9v mrlcsªmrl®x¨©ax>}ªv `§xQvwd x BKe"|av`ce|~v z{u&vzce e"xK|~}/v qªuqKd¨c e"`cel§ê ° cqt qKzce¬§e" mrd¨el9v"Ã(v `{e"| eªv©q uqKd ?qtl{el9v|²`{x>·te¨vq ?e/d¨q¬¬mnÄ{e"ê°³_a`ce/{onq¬Qu B¯cxQvx |~v z{u&vzc e/mr| xtzcstd¨e"lKve" ©mnv `ªx´lce"© uqtl{|~v z{uv qtv`{xQvd¨Px BteR|¾m¼v§q9| | mn{oneavq cmnl9v (
(60) (
(61) -$ /&° lclcqtvxWv mrqtl{| xt e0v eÂ9v¦¹xWsKd e"l9v|v `{xWv(©mroro¬§eacmnl9ve"²9}´v`ceacev~v}p{ mrl9v eRÃQcz¬v¾©`cq9|~ea| m "e©mrono¬l{qWv¾§ev x Bte"l mrl9v q/xKuuqtzcl9v ¦¹qKwormnlce²ce" x Bmrlcs/xtl{mnl§¬el9vxWv mrqtl^°k_a`cemrl9v zcmnv mr·teczc§q9|~e²qW¦v `ceR|~e xWlcl{qWvxWv mrqtl{| my|v q vxtl{|¦¹e"aonq¬uxtoêmnlc¦¹qtd¨xWv mrqtlv qxWl4eÂvel{xWo?v qqKoU%à BlcqQ©mrlcs²v `{xWvv `cmy|orqu"xWomrl¬¦¹qtdxQv mrqtl4©mrono ?e¨z{| e"cz¬v lcqtvp| `cqQ©lv q4v `{e z§|~e""°¨_a`cecev v}Hc mrl9v e" xWor©x>}¬|kuqtd¨czcv e"|kv`ce©myv `³qW¦v `ce e"one"d¨el9v|amnvwcmnl9v|" ° 5¶v my|d¨q¬¬m¼Ä§e"v q¨v x BtepxtlclcqWvxQvmnqKl{|amnl9vq¨xKuuqtzcl9Nv xtl4xtlclcqtvxQvmnqKlmy| | mnd¨cor}. ññ. æ"cJd+e+f+g.
(62) G +
(63) 1'
(64) . . #%' (
(65) ' ( *] ) ,#R - L) & (. v eRxQve"xt| x|~v mrlcsª©`cq9|~ep©myv `Hmy| "eq{ìczcvmnvwmr|xWor©x>}¬|cmnl9ve"ê°ww¦¾uqtz{| et즹qK dxWv~v eR4v eÂ9v uqtl9vxtmnl{mnlcs4xWlcl{qWvxWv mrqtl{|´¬qeR|l{qWvponqqRB¦¹qtd¨xWv~ve" xWv xWoroUÃêczcv m¼vpmy|wv`cee"ue"mn·mrlcsªvqqto |qtv q e"|~v qK ev `{e´v eÂv |amrlcmnv myxWo^e"one"sKxWl§ue´}ª e"d¨qQ·9mrlcs²v `ce xtlclcqtvxQvmnqKl{|R° _a`ce®¦¹qtd¨xWv~vemy|ªxWoy|~qÁd¨q¬¬mnÄ{e"«vqÀcqcz{ueH?e v mrlcel9v/xtlclcqWvxQvmnqKl{|é`cmyu` ©mnorowd x BKeHm¼v ?qK|| mncore¨¦¹qtv `ceªv eÂveR¬mnv qtv qHel{cepv`ce|~v z{u&vzceqW¦av `ce/onqKstmyuxWo¦¹qtdzcoyxt|"! ° 5ºlÀxHlz¬v|~`{eoroUà xtlclcqtvxQvmnqKl{|ªxt e®mrl{| e v eR!xQvªv`ce ?esKmnl{lcmnl{s«xWl§!xQvªv`ce e"l{ qt¦ e"xtu`!| zc¬µ¶e¬ce"|| mnqKl qt¦pv `ce sKqKxtor|"°w_a`ceR|~e¨xWlcl{qWvxWv mrqtl{|uqKlKvxWmrX l %(
(66) $#¨mrl¬¦¹qtdxQv mrqtl®v `{xWvkmrl{¬myuxWv e"|wv `{e²e¬xKu&vkonq¬uxWv mrqtlHqt¦v `ce | zc¬µ¶e¬ce"|| mnqKl{|mrl!v `{esKqKxWo´|~v z{u&vzc eK° ÇLxQvemnl3v `cmy|4{xW?eRÃw©e¬e"·tqtv ex | e"u&vmnqKl v q«v `{mr| e"lc`{xtl{ue"d e"l9vaqt¦v`cepcev v}Kµ¶cmnl9veM 6I| eep| e"u&vmnqKl4{°nG ?&° Çxt|~v"Ã(m¼v mr|²xWoy|~qHmrd¨§qK~vxWl9vpv q®l{qWv eªv `{xWvv `{eªstq9xWoy|pxWec mrl9v eR¯§ev©e"el (P,'
(67) ° Ze¦¹qte |~vxt~vmnl{svqHcmnl9v´v `ce/stqKxtor|"Ãv `{eªcq9qt¦u`ceRQu Bte"k{ mrl9v|pxH| §eRumyxW" o Bte"}©qK z{|~eR¯|~qKone"on}H¦¹qKpv `{mr| {zc ?qK| . e 6IxWl4qt?el{mnlcs cxtQu BKevmrl|~qKd ep| el{| e ?°¾¦½v e"cmnl9v mrlcs²v `ce´sKqKxWoy|"Ã9mnv xWoy|~q cmnl9v|xtlcqWv`ce | ?e"umyxWo BKe}©qt 6½v`ceuqt eR|~?qtl{cmnlcs uorqK| mnl{s {xKQu Bte+v ?&°¾_a`ceR|~epcxtQu BKev|©mroro^§epz§|~eR/vq¨v mnsKste" | ?e"umnħu´xtuv mrqtl{|aqKl/v`ce´v eÂv e"¬mnv qK |~my¬et°. . M¹ (¹¢ Ê M O Í ¢ (¹ I lpv`ceveÂv(eR¬mnv qt(|~my¬eKÃ"v`ceaxWlclcqtvxWv e"kveÂvmy| eRuemr·teR É £ É MM O ¢ O Î mrlHv`ce²| `ceoronµ¸cz 4?e""° _a`cev eÂ9vke"¬mnv qKwmy| qK s9xWlcmy|~eR4mnl | z{u`®xdxtlclcewv `{xWv©e²u"xWl®| §eRumn¦¹}v`{xQv x¯sKmn·Kel cq¬ue"czc e©mrono§euxWorore" e·Ke}Áv mrd¨e |~qKd¨e®cxQvxÁuqtd¨eR|mnl ¦¹qtd$v `ce c qqt¦´u`ceRuQBte" 6ImnlÁÅkƾdxtu"|pv `{e/cq¬ue"czc eqKlcor} lce"e"c| v q®?e¬eRuoyxWe"¯xt| x
(68) ?&° cqKpv `{eªczc§q9|~e/qW¦qtzc e¬§e" mrd¨el9v"ì©ep|~?e"um¼¦¹}/x cq¬ueR¬zcewv`{xQv©mrono^orqPq B¨¦¹qKav `cep| §eRumyxWo Bte"}©qKc|z{| e"4xt|acxtQu BKev| xt qKzcl{/stqKxtor|"° ¿ `ce"lv `{euorqK| mrlcs cxtQu BKevqW¦^xp§xWmr0my|e"uqKstlcmy| e"êÃtv `cew|~v mrlcspv `{ew{xtmn¬eormnd¨mnv|mr|0cque"||~eR vqv x BKev`cepxWlcl{qWvxWv mrqtl{|mrlKvqxtuuqtzcl9vRÃ9ed¨qQ·Ke v `{e"| e´xtlclcqtvxQvmnqKl{|"Ãxtl{ª{ q¬¬z{uepxlce"[ © Bmrl{/qt¦ veÂv"ìe"lcmru`ceRª©mnv ` R
(69) 1 *
(70) &°_a`ce´§e"~vmnl{el9v xt| §eRu&v|qt¦^v `ceR|~e´eÂ9vel9v|"ÃcqQ·9my¬eR¦¹qt¦¹eek}v `ce Åkƾdxtu"|av eÂ9ve"¬mnv qK"Ã{xt ep¬eR| u mr?e"4mnl®| e"uv mrqtlc°àf¬°_a`ce´v eÂ9v©m¼v`4eÂv el9v|mr| v `ce"l4v xWl{|~¦¹e eR vq v `cepsKqKxWoy|c%z 4e ©`{eekmnv my|¬mr| coyx>}teRªvq²v`cepz{| eR° MO ¡ O L I qtd¨czcvxQvmnqKlÁ|vqt{|kv`ceetÃLv `ceªl{eÂv e"one"·QxWl9vpe·te"l9v´©mroro0uqKd e É ¢c£WQ Í É ¦¹qtd+v `cez{|~e""° 3q9|v qt¦½v elv`ce e"·tel9vw©mroro^§e²ste"lcexQve"z{|~mrlcsqKlce qW¦(v `{eqWv`cewz{|~e" mrlKve ¦Ixtue d¨eRu`{xWlcmy| d¨|"Ãczcv¨mn¦wv`ceHz{| eu`cqqK| e"|v q³cq¬ueeRÀz{| mrlcs¯c qqt¦½µ¸}9µ¸?qtmrl9v mrlcs{þ`{eqK¨| `ceHuormyQu B| qKl| qtd¨ee¬c eR| | mrqtl®mrl®v`ce¨stqKxto{%z 4?e""° _a`{eveÂvpe"¬mnv qK´xtz¬v qKdxQv myuxtonor}uqtd¨czcv e"|v`ce¨eÂv e"lKv v`{xQv uqtl9vxtmnl{|v`cmr|´e¬c eR| | mrqtl^°_a`{mr|´eÂ9vel9v uqKlKvxWmrl{|´x4c qK§e"~v}H©`{mru`mr|kv`ce¨{xQv`³e¦¹e" mrlcs vqªv`ce²e¬c eR| | mrqtl^°k_a`cmr|{xWv `®my|kstmr·telHmrl®veÂv z§xWo¦¹qtd xK|x|~eR9zcel{ueqt¦mnl9v e"ste"lzcd²§e"|"°k veÂv z§xWo¾uqKd dxtl{Hmy|kuqtl{|~v z{uv e" ©m¼v`®v`cmr|k{xWv `³xWl{|~e"lKvp¬mr eRu&von}vq/v`ce²{ qqW¦0u`{e"Qu Bte""Ã?·mrx v`ce | `ceoro¼µ¶c%z 4eR° ¡ Í £ É "Q M O ¢¬ I lÀv`ce{ qqW¦ku`ce"Qu BKe²| my¬etÃ0v `ce4{xQv`«mrl¬¦¹qK dxQvmnqKlÀmy|²{ q¬ueR| | e"À9}Àx | ?e"umnħud¨q¬¬zcoretÃv `{e®cq9qt¦½µ¸}9µ¶§qKmnl9v mrlcs¯uqKd dxtl{ stel{exQv qK"° _a`cmy|d¨q¬¬zcore xWoy| q³l{ee"{|¨v `ce |~v z{uv zce" e"ce"| el9vxWv mrqtl/qt¦v`ce sKqKxWoêz{l{¬e |uz¬vmnl}t°0¿ m¼v`v `ceR|~e´v©q¨cmneRueR|qW¦mnlc¦¹qtd¨xWv mrqtl^à v`ce{ qqW¦½µ¶}9µ¸?qtmrl9v mrlcs¨c q¬ue"||~qK ste"lcexQve"|coyxWmrl®cqqW¦uqKd¨d¨xtl{c|a¦¹qKwv`ce{ qqW¦u`ceRQu Bte"mnl x . óßàå~ÜÛUß þõQâ&æR å â&ã>ßàéã>á¸åá¸ã¶üpÜæ>æ>âä¸ÜäUÞàâ&æ>ánâ&Ûï Üæþwç>ã>ÛIçtâ&áUåá õWßàÞ&å¾Þàæ>é>Þ~ÜäUÞàæ>ènâ&æäâ&Ûâ&ßàâ&ã>Û¶üQÜæ>è&åá~õQä¸üã>á ç>ÛUâé>ã Þàæ>è Üá¸Þàïç>ßàå râ&ÛIï«â "!$#"% Ö'&)(Ö+*-, Ô/.Ö ø. TVU(ñTXW.
(71) .
(72)
(73) !"
(74) $#%'&%
(75) ( )*
(76) +& ,
(77) -&%/. 0'
(78) 1'. e"uzc|~mr·tek¦Ixt| `cmrqtl^Ã{z{|~mrlcs/x vxWcore qt¦(¦¹qK d²zcoyx¨{xQv v el{| xtl{{xWv `{|"°_a`{mr|uqtd¨dxWl§sKelce"xWv qKmr| ce"|umn?e" d qK e¨uxt e¦¹zcoron}HmrlÁ|~eRu&v mrqtl³c° c° _a`ce¨stel{exQv eR®uqKd¨d¨xtl{c|pxt ewz{|v esK qKzc?e"Hmrl³x veÂv¦¹xWstd¨e"lKvv `§xQv my|cxtQu Btev eRª©mnv `H|~?e"umrxto Bte"}9©qtc|xWl{| el9v{xtQu Bªv q v `ce´veÂv e"cm¼vqtR°. . . £ Í ¡> Î MO ¢ O Î É £ LN M O É ²Í ¯¢ O Î( I lÁv `{e/veÂv eR¬mnv qt¨| mr¬eKÃv `ce|xWd¨e/cqWµ u e"¬z{ ev `{xWv¨|uxtl{|²v `ce4cqqW¦u`ceRuQBte" | qKz¬v czcv ¦¹qK¨cxKuQBtev e"ÀstqKxtor|²my| xtor| q z§|~eRÀvq³|uxtlÁ¦¹qt v`cepuqKd dxtl{c|aste"lcexQve"/9}ªv `cepcqqW¦½µ¶}Kµ¶?qtmrlKvmnl{scq¬ue"|| qtR°(_a`ceR|~e´uqKd¨d¨xtl{c|xt e´¬mr eRu&v or} mrl{| e v eRªmrl/v`cek|umr¬v{%z 4?e" xWl{/ eµ¶| el9vaxWz¬vqtdxQvmru"xWoron}¨vqv`ce´c qqt¦Lu`ce"Qu BKeRÃK©`cmyu`4c q¬ue"||~eR| v`ced xWl{dx>}ªcq¬¬z{ue´lce"© sKqKxtor|"°(_a`{e u}¬uorepuxWl4e"|~vxW v"° !wqWv myue´v`{xQvwv `ce ¾qqW¦½µ¶}Kµº(qtmrl9v mrlcsvqqtoLxKu&v|ad¨e" e"on}4xt|xuqKd¨d¨xtl{stel{exQv qK"°¾wo¼vel{xQvm¼µ ·Keor}tÃWqKlce uqKzcoy u`{q9q9|~evqp eRuqtv `cewcmne"uv0¾ qqt¦½µ¸}9µ¶(qKmnl9v mrlcsk eR9zce"|~vmnl v`cew|umn¬v{%z 4?e"0xWl§ vxtl{| {xWel9v or}4e¬e"uz¬v e v `{e²sKelce"xWv e" onqQ©aµ¶ore·te"ouqtd¨dxWl{|~eRKz{el{uet° zcp¬eR|~mrstl³¬e"umr| mrqtl eµ | zconv|0mnld¨qteeoyxW?qtxQveuqtd¨d²zclcmyuxQvmnqKl^\ ° D qQ©e·te""ÃQl{qQ·9myuez§|~e"|¾dx>}Ä{l{¨mnv0`ceor¬¦¹zco§v qpmrl{| §eRu&v v`ceqKz¬v {z¬vkqt¦v `{e²uqKd¨d¨xtl{HsKelce"xWv qtRD ° {zc~v`ced¨qtetçv `ce ste"lcexQve"Huqtd¨dxWl{®u"xWl®oyxQvek§e eR¬mnv e"}v `{epz{|~e""Ã9¦¹qKmnl{|~vxtl{uekvq¨xKcxWcvsKelce"xWv e"/l{xWd¨eR|v q v `cep| §eRumnħu´uxK|~eKìqtv q¨ecoyxtue | qtd¨e uqtd¨dxWl§c|k9}Hd¨qK e²e _ªumrel9v´qtlceR|° _a`cmy|kdxWlz{xWo(?qK|~v~µ¶c q¬ue"||~mrlcs/qt¦0cqqW¦}H§qKmnl9vmnlcs sKelce"xWv eR/uqKd¨d¨xtl{c|uqtzcoy/?epdxt¬epeRxt| mne"amnlHx ·QxWmrxtlKv©`ce" ekv`cepste"lcexQve"/uqtd¨dxWl{{|xWe qKlcor}Àmnl§|~e"~ve"«mnl v `{e®| u mr¬vc%z 4eRÃ{z¬vªlcqWvª| el9vª{xKQu BÀxWz¬vqtdxQvmru"xWoron}Ávq³v `ceHcqqW¦´u`ce"Qu BKeR° _a`{mr|kqt{§qK~vzclcmnv}¦¹qt´dxWlz{xWo?qK|~v~µ¶cque"||~mrlcsª©qtz{or³xWoy|~q4xWoronqQ© ¦¹qKkv `ceuqKd¨d¨xtl{®sKelce"xWv qK vq¨c q¬¬z§ue´mnl§uqtd¨coreve uqKd dxtl{c|"° É. . . ! . /
(79) . ;/# %
(80) * '!0.
(81) !'* ').. 0D0D# . ,.36% R6 &. @?. . 0D0D# . ,./'!#10. zcv cz¬vH¦¹qtd v `ceÁ{ qqW¦¨|~}¬|~v e"d mr| xWlclcqtvxWv e" }!v`ceÁcev~v}9µ¶cmnl9v e"4v q d x BKe³mrl¬¦¹qK dxQvmnqKl tx §qKz¬v v`ce mrlKvel{xWo(|v z§u&v z{ epqt¦¾v ed| x>·QxWmrorxtcore´v qv`cez{| ewmnl9v e"~¦IxKueuqtd¨?qtlce"lKvR°Æxtu`®| zc¬µ e¬c eR| | mrqtl¨mnl4x sKqKxWo§qt`9}?qWv`ce"| mr|my|0ceÄ{ÂeR©mnv `x|~eRKz{el{uewqW¦^mrl9v e"ste|¾v`{xQvaece"| el9v|v `ce §xQv ` mrl²v`ce xW§|vxKu&v¾|~}l9vxW v eexQv¾©`cmyu`²v `cmy|| zc¬v e" d mr|qqWv eRê° cqt¾eÂcxWd¨coretÃQv`ceuqtd¨dxWl§. "!$#%'&( +) *-,/.0,1 3245#66 798-,/. :24;. #6=< ¦¹z{onor}xtlclcqWvxQve"êà k > §eRuqtd¨eR| ?A@CB C( B D. EGF % ? F$ ?LK F ?LK;K F NM ! ?LKPO FRQ MM % ?$O F ¡ Í SM * ?$T F ?UTVOWK FX, ?UT OWKYK F MZ?UT O[H+K\ICO[J K F], ?$TOWK5OWK\O[K F NM^?UTO[K]O[KK F$_ M ?UTYOWK\O[K\OYO FRQ M 6 M 6 M`?UTaK F$b M`?UTOYO FX, ?UT;OOYO[K F ?UT OYOOcKK F MZ?$TYOOYOWK5OWK F dMM^?UT OeOWK F$_ Mf?UTOOYOO F ?UT OYOYOO[K F M^?UTOYOYOYOOWK FRQ MDM 6 MMM ?NgDh i C. D jE0F k Ú^ü>å¾ÜæRæ>âä¶ÜäUÞàâ&æ>áã>á¸åéwÞàæç>ÛUÜ ºä¸Þ å0ÜÛIå¾á¸åßàå äUåéäUâa÷Wåå$l ÞàåæäUß þwçQÜÛUá¸Ü÷>ßàå&õWÜæ>éwüQÜ~Ýå÷WååæÛIåç>ßòÜ å~ékü>åÛUå¾÷þ ïâ&ÛUåÛIå~ÜéQÜ÷>ßàå ¶üQÜÛUÜ ºä¸åÛIá. . . ññ. æ"cJd+e+f+g. . . -. /. .
(82) G +
(83) 1'
(84) . R. ;"=[. . #%' (
(85) ' ( *] ) ,#R - L) & (. . . :. . T. . . TYO. . TYOWK5O. . . . . . . :. _a`ce" e´xWev `cee´¬m ?e" e"lKv mnl§c|aqW¦xtlclcqtvxQvmnqKl{|xW?qQ·te _a`ce´qtzcv ed¨qK|~v{xtmnaqt¦LdxW te|"à ? @CB C( B C. D jE0F xWl§ ?dgDhji D. jE0F &ÃQcxtu KevLv`cea|~eRu&v mrqtl²qW¦{qKz¬v {z¬vv qk§ecque"||~eR ¦¹qK cqqW¦½µ¶9}9µ¶§qKmnl9vmnlcs§°_a`{e H ´dxW ¬|v `cev e" d xt| xªstqKxto^qtxWlH`}§qtv `ceR|~my|°a l§H©m¼v`cmrlHv `ce ved mnv| eon¦LxWev `cek|v z{uv zce xWl{lcqWvxQv mrqtl§|°(Æxtu`ªxtlclcqWvxQve"¨|~z{¬v e" d `{xt|v `ce¦¹qKonorqQ©mrlcsk¦¹qtd¨xWvN ? M F 4. @a. CB. /`. (' '
(86) 1('
(87) $'. B. /`. a. a. G`. QB. B.
(88) +. _ `{e²¦¹xWsKd¨el9vT
(89) 1 + d¨x>}Hmnv| eon¦uqtl9vxtmnl³xWlcl{qWvxWv eR| zc¬ved¨|"°±q/v`ceqtzcv cz¬vp`ce" e ece"| el9v| a v`ce | }9l9vxQÂv eepqKl/v`cmy|{xWsKetÃmrl4©`{mru`H| qtd¨e´eÂcxWd¨core´{xQv`{|a`{x>·te´?ee"l4dxtBKe"ê° !wqWvev `{xWvlcqtvxWoro{qt¦v `celcq¬¬e"|0mnl¨v`cext§qQ·Keav eewxt e xtlclcqWvxQve"¨mrl¨v `cec ev~v}9µ¶c mrl9v e"qtz¬vcz¬v. ¦¹qKeÂcxWd¨coretÃRv `cecqqW¦{| }|~v e"dmnl9vel{xWoron}´ece"| el9v|Lx¦¹z{l{u&vmnqKl²xW{conmyuxWv mrqtlxK|xw{xWmruqtl§|~my|vmnl{s qt¦¾v `ce²¦¹zcl{uv mrqtl¯xWl{ xªormr|~vkqt¦xWstz{d e"l9v|"çczcv´| z{u`®ormr|~v|kqt¦xWstzcd¨e"lKv|wxt e²lce·KextlclcqtvxQve" `{eev`cexWstzcd¨el9vkonmy|vpqt¦ /mr|´mnv| eon¦x4|~z{¬v e" d qqWve"®xWvkv`ce¨{xQv` Ã^©`{mru`mr| l{qWvwce"| el9vxtd¨qtlcs¨v`ce²xtlclcqWvxQvmnqKl{| ° 5ºlHsKelce"xtoUÃ?xWlcl{qWvxWv mrqtl{|wxWe qtd¨mnv~v eR¦¹qtk|~z{¬v e" d|v`{xQv xt e `~dz¬v+e ak©mnv `e"| §eRu&vvq²v`cepcqqW¦½µ¶9}9µ¶§qKmnl9vmnlcs¨xWorstqK mnv `{d4° _a`cmy|pece"| el9vxQv mrqtlmr| ·te }
(90) {e¬mncore ¦¹qtpeÂcxtd {one¨v`cecq9qt¦e"lcstmrlce¬qe"| lcqWv¬my|~v mrlcstzcmy| ` ?ev©ee"lÁmnlcÄc¯xtl{¯ceÄc¯qt?exQvqt|Ã(uqKl9·Ke|~mrqtl§e"mnl{s ?e ¦¹qtd eR³9}v `{eªcev~v}9µ¶cmnl9v e"xWl§ §xW|~e""°( lclcqtvxWv mrlcseRxtu`ª| zc¬v e" d ¦¹zcoron}my|0x²|~mrd¨corew©ax>} v q²el{| zcev `§xQvmrl¬¦¹qK dxQvmnqKlªxW?qtz¬vv `ce mrl9v e" l{xto?|~v z{uv zceqt¦^v e" d|my|{ eR|~e" ·Ke"¨e·Kelv`cqtz{st`ªv`ceekd¨x>}?ekcmr|ue{xtl{umre"|?ev©eel/v `ce ved |~v z{u&vzc eaxWl§mnv|(veÂv z{xto¬ e"ce"| el9vxWv mrqtl^= ° 5ºl qtz{¾eÂcxWd¨coretÃ>v`ceqt?exQvqt ©mnv `²v `{e{xQv` xtc§eRxW|?ev©eelHmnv| Ä{|v´xWstzcd¨el9v ©mnv `®§xQv ` xWl{mnv|k|~eRuqKl{ xt sKzcd¨el9v©mnv `À§xQv ` ° DwqQ©e"·te""æ¹zcoroaxtlclcqtvxQvmnqKlÁmr|²·te" }³·te" ?qK| et° 5ºlÀqt¬e vqª¬e"u eRxt| ekv `cep·Kqtorzcd¨epqW¦¾cxQvx¨©`cmru`my|ste"lcexQve"4xWl{4{xt| e"^Ãce"xKu`4xtlclcqWvxQvmnqKlmy|ce"ue"¬eR }v `ceone"lcsWv`ÁqW¦v`ce/ceÄ{³mnv | `{xWe"| ©m¼v`Àm¼v| ce"ce"ueR| | qtRA ° czc v `{eRÃ| {xKue"|xWeªqtd¨mnv~v eRÁmrl xtlclcqtvxQvmnqKl{|´xWl{v`ce¨mnl9v e"ste"|´©`cmyu`³d¨Px Bte¨zc³v `{e{xQv`³uqtd¨§qKlcel9v|pxWe e{ eR|~e"lKve" 9} v `ce uqt eR|~?qtl§¬mnl{s±§ 5S5u`{xWxtuv e|"ÃRdPx B9mrlcskv `{e xt||~zcd¨¬vmnqKl v`{xQv{xWv `xWl{lcqWvxQv mrqtl§|qKlcor}uqKlKvxWmrl mrl9v e"ste|a|~dxtonoreav`{xWlHPf Ftc° cqKeÂcxWd¨coretÃv`ce xW?qQ·te´xWlcl{qWvxWv mrqtl4mr|ae"cz{ueRªv>q . TYOWK]OWK\O. 24. TYOWK]OWKeK. TYO[K\OWK]OO. 2D4 TYOWK]O[K]OWK. ?A@CB C( B D. EGF H+ICJ % ? J F ? J K F ?LKK F NM ! ?LKXO F Q MM % ? J O F ¡ Í SM`? J T F ? KXO K FX, ?UT K F M ?UTO K FX,. . TVU(ñTXW.
(91) K.
(92)
(93) !"
(94) $#%'&%
(95) ( )*
(96) +& ,
(97) -&%/. 0'
(98) 1'. ? O K F NMG? K F$_ M^? OO FRQ M 6 M 6 M`?LKDK F$b M"?LK ODO F , ? TO K F ? K F M ? DO K F dMMG?UT K F _ Mf?UTDOO F ? K F M0? O K F Q MM 6 MMM ?NgDh i C. D jE0F . . . . . . . wo¼v`cqtz{st` qKlHv `{mr|´| d¨xtonoe¬xtd¨conev `ce ·QxWorzce qW¦¾v `{e"| e²qK¬v mrd¨mr|xQvmnqKl{|wmy|klcqWv´©`cqKonor}Huqtl·mrl{umrlcs{à v`ce|~}l9vxW v eeR|(qtz¬vcz¬v}pv `{ec qqt¦§u`ce"uQBKe¾xWev}9{mru"xWoron} `{mnsK`con}zcl{xWoyxWl{ue"êÃ>v`z{|¾©mnv ` orxt sKe e¬c eR| | mrqtl{|©e´xKu`cmre·te´| mnsKlcm¼Ä?uxWl9ve"¬z{uv mrqtl{|amrl4qtz¬vcz¬vw| m "et°. O £ Í ÎM O. FIJKIJ . OOLÍ "¢c NM Í-O . ±¬mnl{uewv`ce´cev~v}9µ¶cmnl9v mrlcs xWorstqtmnv `cd mnv| eon¦uqKl{|~my|~v|qW¦x eRuzc| mn·Ke v x>·te"|xWo{qW¦^v`cep|~}l9vxW v e"età Kx c¬mrlcsª{xWv `®xtlclcqWvxQvmnqKl{| e"9zcmr eR|qtl{on}v `{xWv©eOBte"evxKuQBqt¦(v`ce²uzc e"lKv{xQv`^Ã?xtzcstd¨e"lKvmnl{s mnvxQveRxtu`ªe"uzc|~mr·te u"xWoroxtl{cmrlKvmnl{smnvaxK|xc eÄc¨v q²e"xtu`|~zccv ed qW¦Lmrl9v e" eR|vR° {qteÂcxWd¨coretà v`ce uq¬¬e. . h . C( B h . ]h ; K O h. E h B :E ( K . C( B K ( O . C( B O h C( K ^? E B ( h eE M ( O h i. . . . .
(99) . .
(100) .
(101)
(102) . .
(103) . . . . . .
(104) . . .
Documents relatifs
constat, unanime en Colombie, que la résolution des conflits par élimination de “l’opposant” est l’une des caractéristiques de la violence nationale. Première
Automatic test data generation, structural testing, constraint solving techniques, global constraints 1.. Structural testing techniques are widely used in unit or module testing
Trois autres échantillons du pool CHAT étaient également gardés au Center for Disease Control et ont été inclus dans cette analyse (CHAT pool 13, CHAT type 1 Wy4B-5, CHAT 1FL)..
Un habitat de La Tène moyenne et finale à Berry-au-Bac au lieu-dit “ Le Chemin de la Pêcherie ” (Aisne).. Jérôme Dubouloz, Michel Plateaux,
It is obvious that the steel showed the plastic strain memory effects at each test temperature, in other words, in spite of the hardness of the steel cyclic stress,
Les cités et leur territoire d'influence sont administrées par de puissantes familles, celles de l'aristocratie terrienne et marchande, qui tirent leur légitimité de
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des
In this paper, we have defined the steady-state control problem for MDP, and shown that this question is decidable for (ergodic) MDP in polynomial time, and for labeled MDP
