• Aucun résultat trouvé

  223:+8324.+13159/  998.+4.+13159/+9463-/7797.

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Partager "  223:+8324.+13159/  998.+4.+13159/+9463-/7797."

Copied!
17
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

CWRTQEGUUWUFOKPPQXCVKQP RÃFCIQIKSWG

7PGEQPVTKDWVKQPFW)TQWRGFGUÃEQNGU FGUVÃNÃEQOOWPKECVKQPU

#TPCWF)CNKUUQPL*WIWGU%JQRNKP 5CTCJ.GOCTEJCPF

GVCTVKENGUGRTQRQUGFGRTGPFTGRQWTHKNFKTGEVGWTNCFGUETKRVKQPFG NC FÃOCTEJG INQDCNG SWK RGWV EQPFWKTG WP ITQWRG GUUGPVKGNNGOGPV EQPUVKVWà FOGPUGKIPCPVU OCKU CWUUK FG FKXGTU RCUUKQPPÃU EH n3WCVTKÂOG ÃVCRG€ FOWP ÃVCDNKUUGOGPV FOGPUGKIPGOGPV UWRÃTKGWT FG NC EQPEGRVKQPFOWPnUKORNG€UWRRQTVRÃFCIQIKSWGOWNVKOÃFKC´WPRTQEGUUWU INQDCN FOKPPQXCVKQP RÃFCIQIKSWG=%41 C? 2TÃEKUÃOGPV KN KPUKUVG UWT NGU FKHHÃTGPVGUKPPQXCVKQPUSWGEGVVGFÃOCTEJGRCTCÉVUQNNKEKVGTKPPQXCVKQPUSWK NQKPFOÄVTGGUUGPVKGNNGOGPVVGEJPQNQIKSWGULOÄOGUKGNNGUUOKPUETKXGPVFCPU NGECFTGFGNOWUCIGFGUVGEJPQNQIKGUFGNOKPHQTOCVKQPGVFGNCEQOOWPKECVKQP LUGODNGPVVQWEJGTRTQHQPFÃOGPVCWZTÏNGUGVUVCVWVUFGURGTUQPPGNUFGEGU ÃVCDNKUUGOGPVUGVFCXCPVCIGGPEQTG´NOQTICPKUCVKQPOÄOGFGEGWZEK

&GWZÃNÃOGPVUÃENCKTGPVNGUVCVWVFGEGVCTVKENG6QWVFOCDQTFUOKNUOCRRWKG UWTnNOJKUVQKTGHKEVKXG€FGEGITQWRGKNEQPXQSWGDKGPGPVGPFWFGPQODTGWZ ÃNÃOGPVUTÃGNUTGPEQPVTÃUGVCPCN[UÃUCWEQWTUFGEGVVGGZRÃTKGPEG/KGWZEGV CTVKENGGUVNOQEECUKQPRQWTPQWUFGFTGUUGTNGDKNCPFGEKPSCPPÃGUFGVTCXCKNCW

%

(2)

UGKPFW)TQWRGFGUÃEQNGUFGUVÃNÃEQOOWPKECVKQPU)'6´NO'EQNGPCVKQPCNG UWRÃTKGWTG FGU VÃNÃEQOOWPKECVKQPU '056 FCPU NG ECFTG FW %GPVTG FG TGUUQWTEGU GP KPPQXCVKQP RÃFCIQIKSWG GV VGEJPQNQIKGU %4+26 &CPU EGVVG RGTURGEVKXGEJCEWPGFGUÃVCRGUFGEGVCTVKENGCDQTFGFGWZRQKPVUFOWPGRCTV NOJKUVQKTG FW ITQWRG FOGPUGKIPCPVU GV FOCWVTG RCTV NGU NGÁQPU SWOKN PQWU UGODNG PÃEGUUCKTG FOGP VKTGT &GTPKGT ÃNÃOGPV GPHKP EGV CTVKENG PG XGWV RCU UOKPUETKTG FCPU NG ECFTG TKIQWTGWZ FOWPG CRRTQEJG RU[EJQUQEKQNQIKSWG FG NOKPPQXCVKQP RÃFCIQIKSWG KN TGNÂXG RNWVÏV FOWPG FÃOCTEJG TÃHNGZKXG CWUUK FKUVCPEKÃG SWG RQUUKDNG RCT TCRRQTV ´ WPG GZRÃTKGPEG FQPV NC HKPCNKVÃ GUV GUUGPVKGNNGOGPVQRÃTCVKQPPGNNGGVUVTCVÃIKSWG

.GURTGOKGTURCUFOWPITQWRGFGRKQPPKGTU

2TGOKÂTGÃVCRGFGUGPUGKIPCPVUCODKVKGWZRÃFCIQIKSWGOGPV

0QVTG JKUVQKTG CRRCTCÉV FG RTKOG CDQTF CUUG\ ENCUUKSWG WP ITQWRG FOGPUGKIPCPVURKQPPKGTUUOKPVGTTQIGUWTNGURQUUKDKNKVÃUFWOWNVKOÃFKCFCPU NG ECFTG FG NGWTU GPUGKIPGOGPVU +NU FÃEKFGPV CXGE NOCRRWK FG NGWT ÃVCDNKUUGOGPVFGUGNCPEGTFCPUNCEQPEGRVKQPFOWPOWNVKOÃFKCRÃFCIQIKSWG RTGOKGTRCUFG NOWUCIG FGU 6+% FCPU NG ECFTG FG NC HQTOCVKQP UWRÃTKGWTG FCPU NGWT RTQRTG FQOCKPG UEKGPVKHKSWG 0QVQPU SWG NC RTCVKSWG FGU J[RGTVGZVGU GZKUVCKV FÃL´ FCPU NOÃVCDNKUUGOGPV GV SWOKNU UG VQWTPGPV TÃUQNWOGPVXGTUFGUWUCIGURNWUPQXCVGWTUEHn&GWZKÂOGÃVCRG€

&GWZVTCKVUFWTGUVGNKÃUECTCEVÃTKUGPV PQUGPUGKIPCPVU+NUÃXQNWGPVFCPU WP EQPVGZVG QÔ NC EQORQUCPVG VGEJPQNQIKSWG GUV VTÂU UKIPKHKECVKXG FW EQWR EGUVGEJPQNQIKGUUQPV´NGWTFKURQUKVKQPGVNGWTTÃVKEGPEG´NGWTÃICTFGUVSWCUK PWNNG 'P EQPUÃSWGPEG GV EOGUV NG UGEQPF RQKPV NGWTU KPVGTTQICVKQPU UQPV GUUGPVKGNNGOGPVRÃFCIQIKSWGUKNURTQHKVGPVGPSWGNSWGUQTVGFGNOKPVTQFWEVKQP FGU6+%FCPUNGWTGPXKTQPPGOGPVRQWTUOKPVGTTQIGTUWTNGWTURÃFCIQIKGUVQWV

´HCKVVTCFKVKQPPGNNGUGVCUUG\NCTIGOGPVDCUÃGUUWTWPGTGNCVKQPRÃFCIQIKSWG FGV[RGVTCPUOKUUKHQÔNGRTQHGUUGWTFÃVKGPVNGUCXQKTGVNGFKURGPUG´UGUÃNÂXGU OÄOG UOKN GZKUVG FGU CEVKXKVÃU HCXQTKUCPV RTKPEKRCNGOGPV NG VTCXCKN FG NOÃNÂXG%GVVGRÃFCIQIKGNGWTUGODNGRNWVÏVCFCRVÃG´NCUQEKÃVÃKPFWUVTKGNNGFW :+:GUKÂENGFCPUNCOGUWTGQÔEJCSWGKPIÃPKGWTCWPGHQPEVKQPSWOKNCESWKGTV NQTU FG UC HQTOCVKQP KPKVKCNG GV QÔ NGU KPHQTOCVKQPU SWOKN C ´ OCPKRWNGT POÃXQNWGPVSWGRGWFWTCPVUCECTTKÂTGGVNGWTCRRCTCÉVCEVWGNNGOGPVFGOQKPU

%GEGPVTGTGITQWRGCEVWGNNGOGPVPGWHRGTOCPGPVUGVFGWZFQEVQTCPVUTÃRCTVKUFCPU NGUVTQKUÃEQNGUFOKPIÃPKGWTFW)'6'056'056$TGVCIPGGV+06.GUKVGKPVGTPGV FW%4+26YYYETKRVGPUVHTRTÃUGPVGNGURTQLGVUNGUVJÂOGUFGTÃHNGZKQPGVNGTÃUGCW FGRCTVGPCKTGUGVNGUOGODTGUFGEGEGPVTG

(3)

GPOQKPURGTVKPGPVG=2.1?'PGHHGVFGNGWTRQKPVFGXWGNCHQTOCVKQPKPKVKCNG FGNOKPIÃPKGWTPOGUVSWGNCVQWVGRTGOKÂTGRKGTTGFOWPGHQTOCVKQPSWOKNFGXTC EQORNÃVGTVQWVGUCXKGFÂUNQTUKNUGUVKOGPVSWGEOGUV´NWKNGHWVWTKPIÃPKGWT FOÄVTGNOCEVGWTGVNGTGURQPUCDNGRTKPEKRCNFGUCRTQRTGHQTOCVKQP%GEKFOCWVCPV RNWUSWGNGUKPHQTOCVKQPUSWOKNUGTCEQPFWKV´OCPKRWNGTUQPVFGRNWUGPRNWU FKURGTUÃGUFGOQKPUGPOQKPUHKCDNGUCRTKQTKGVFGRNWUGPRNWUÃRJÃOÂTGUGP VGTOG FG RGTVKPGPEG &CPU EGU EQPFKVKQPU KNU UG FGOCPFGPV UK NC XKG RTQHGUUKQPPGNNG GV UQEKCNG FCPU NG ECFTG FG EGVVG PQWXGNNG nUQEKÃVà FG NOKPHQTOCVKQP€ =2.1 ? POKORNKSWG RCU FGU ECRCEKVÃU UKPIWNKÂTGU FG V[RG nOÃVC€ECRCEKVôEGTPGTNGUNKOKVGUFGNOKPHQTOCVKQPFQPPÃGGVUQPEQPVGZVG FOÃOKUUKQPECRCEKVôETÃGTWPTÃUGCWUQEKCNEQNNCDQTCVKHRGTOGVVCPVFGXÃTKHKGT UCNÃIKVKOKVÃFGVTQWXGTFGUÃNÃOGPVUEQORNÃOGPVCKTGUGVE&CPUEGEQPVGZVG PQU GPUGKIPCPVU RKQPPKGTU EJQKUKUUGPV FG UG VQWTPGT TÃUQNWOGPV XGTU WPG RÃFCIQIKG EGPVTÃG UWT NOCEVKXKVà GV UWT NOCWVQPQOKG QW UGOKCWVQPQOKG GPVGPFWGKEKGPWPUGPU´FKUVKPIWGTUQKIPGWUGOGPVFGNCUQNKVWFGFGNOÃNÂXG QÔ EG FGTPKGT GUV RNCEà CW EGPVTG FG UC HQTOCVKQP=#7/ ? %G V[RG FG RÃFCIQIKG PG UG FÃRNQKG FCPU NG EQPVGZVG FG PQU GPUGKIPCPVU SWG FCPU WP PQODTG TGUVTGKPV FOCEVKXKVÃU NGU RTQLGVU RCT GZGORNG OCKU UWTVQWV KN PG UOCEEQTFGSWOGZEGRVKQPPGNNGOGPVCXGENCRJKNQUQRJKGFGNOQTICPKUCVKQPINQDCNG FGUEWTUWU

%GEJQKZRÃFCIQIKSWGCFGUEQPUÃSWGPEGUVTÂUHQTVGUFWRQKPVFGXWGFG NC EQPEGRVKQP FGU UWRRQTVU OWNVKOÃFKCU RÃFCIQIKSWGU SWG XGWNGPV KPKVKGT PQUGPUGKIPCPVU%QPUÃSWGPEGUDKGPUÖTUWTNGURTQFWKVUGWZOÄOGUEHn.C EQPEGRVKQP GV NG FÃXGNQRRGOGPV FG RTGOKGTU OWNVKOÃFKCU RÃFCIQIKSWGU€

OCKUCWUUKGVUWTVQWVUWTNGTÏNGFGNOGPUGKIPCPVXKU´XKUFGEGUUWRRQTVUUC TGNCVKQPCXGENOCRRTGPCPVPOGUVRNWUGUUGPVKGNNGOGPVWPGTGNCVKQPVTCPUOKUUKXG OCKUWPGTGNCVKQPFGVWVQTCV=$#7?QWFOCEEQORCIPGOGPVFGNOÃNÂXGFCPU UCEQPUVTWEVKQPGVUQPCUUKOKNCVKQPFGUUCXQKTU=)+7?

7PRTGOKGTV[RGFOKPPQXCVKQPNKôNCTGNCVKQPRÃFCIQIKSWG

0QWUVQWEJQPUKEK´NCRTGOKÂTGKPPQXCVKQPRTQHQPFGNKÃG´NCFÃOCTEJG FG PQVTG ITQWRG FOGPUGKIPCPVU EGNNG NKÃG ´ NC OQFKHKECVKQP GV PQP NC FKURCTKVKQPFWNKGPRÃFCIQIKSWG=*'5?GPVTGNOGPUGKIPCPVGVNOÃNÂXG

%GVVGKPPQXCVKQPEQPEGTPGQPNGUCKVFGUÃNÃOGPVURTQHQPFUFCPUNCEWNVWTG FGU GPUGKIPCPVU &G EG RQKPV FG XWG NGU RTGOKÂTGU TÃCEVKQPU TGEWGKNNKGU RCT PQVTGITQWRGCWRTÂUFOGPUGKIPCPVUPQPRKQPPKGTUNQTUSWOKNNGWTRTÃUGPVGEGVVG

n#WVQPQOKG€FÃUKIPGKEKRTÃEKUÃOGPVWPGPUGODNGFGECRCEKVÃUnOÃVC€´IÃTGT NGUEKPSFKOGPUKQPUFGNOCRRTGPVKUUCIGSWGTGEQWXTGPVRQWTPQWUNOCHHGEVKHNGEQIPKVKH NGUQEKCNOCKUCWUUKNOGURCEGGVNGVGORUFGNCHQTOCVKQP

(4)

ÃXQNWVKQPFGNCRÃFCIQIKGCRRCTCKUUGPVCUUG\V[RKSWGUn5KXQWUUWRRTKOG\

OGUEQWTUXQWUUWRRTKOG\NGUTGNCVKQPUSWGLOCKCXGEOGUÃNÂXGU,GUWKU´NGWT ÃEQWVGRGPFCPVNGUEQWTU€.QTUSWO´EGUTÃCEVKQPUKNGUVRTÃEKUÃSWGNGUUCXQKTU FGUEQWTU RQWTTQPV ÄVTG RTQRQUÃU UWT FGU UWRRQTVU OWNVKOÃFKCU URÃEKHKSWGU CUUQEKÃU´FGU UÃCPEGUFGVWVQTCV QÔ NOGPUGKIPCPV CEEQORCIPGTC NOÃNÂXG FCPU UQP CRRTGPVKUUCIG GP TÃRQPFCPV ´ UGU SWGUVKQPU GV GP NOCKFCPV FCPU UGU FKHHKEWNVÃUNGUGPUGKIPCPVUPQPRKQPPKGTUQPVFGWZPQWXGNNGUTÃCEVKQPUn/CKU SWGNNGU SWGUVKQPU XQPV OG RQUGT NGU ÃNÂXGU!€ n1P PG RGWV RCU OGVVTG VQWU OGUUCXQKTUUWTFGUUWRRQTVUOWNVKOÃFKCU€

%GU TÃCEVKQPU GZVTÄOGU UWIIÂTGPV EQODKGP NGU OQFKHKECVKQPU FG NC TGNCVKQP RÃFCIQIKSWG VQWEJGPV ´ FGU ÃNÃOGPVU FÃVGTOKPCPVU FG NOKFGPVKVÃ RGTUQPPGNNG GV RTQHGUUKQPPGNNG FG NOGPUGKIPCPV UQP GURCEG FG TGURQPUCDKNKVÃ GV FOCWVQTKVÃ KN POGUV RNWU UGWN FÃVGPVGWT FGU UCXQKTU KN NGU RCTVCIG CXGE FGU UWRRQTVU TKEJGU GV FG ITCPFG FKHHWUKQP UQWU HQTOG ÃNGEVTQPKSWG UQP UVCVWV U[ODQNKSWG XKU´XKU FG NOÃNÂXG KN RCUUG FG VTCPUOGVVGWTFCPUNGECFTGFOWPUEÃPCTKQTGNCVKQPPGNDKGPJWKNÃFQPVNGTÏNG RTKPEKRCN NWK GUV ÃEJW ´ CEEQORCIPCVGWT QÔ NG UEÃPCTKQ NWK GUV KPEQPPW GV FQPVNGTÏNGRTKPEKRCNGUVQEEWRÃRCTNOCRRTGPCPV

%GVVG RTGOKÂTG RJCUG SWK RTGPF GP EQORVG NC FQWDNG J[RQVJÂUGWUCIG FGU 6+% FCPU NG ECFTG FOWPG RÃFCIQIKG EGPVTÃG UWT NOCEVKXKVÃ FG NOÃNÂXG FÃENGPEJGFQPEFÃL´WPRTGOKGTRTQEGUUWUFOKPPQXCVKQPFÃNKECV+NRGWVÄVTG TGRTÃUGPVÃUGNQPNGUEJÃOCFKFCEVKSWGUWKXCPVGPRCTVKEWNKGTRCTNGRCUUCIG FGNCHKIWTG´NCHKIWTG

(QTOCVGWT

#RRTGPCPV 5CXQKT

'PITCUTGNCVKQPRTKPEKRCNG

(KIWTG2ÃFCIQIKGVTCPUOKUUKXG

.GUKPFKECVKQPUKEKRTQRQUÃGUUQPVVTÂUDTÂXGU'PRCTVKEWNKGTPQWUPOGZRNKEKVQPURCU NGU SWGUVKQPU FKHHKEKNGU NKÃGU ´ NC F[PCOKSWG FG EQPUVKVWVKQP FG NOKFGPVKVÃ FGU GPUGKIPCPVU8QKTUWTEGVVGF[PCOKSWG=217?2QWTWPGCPCN[UGRNWUURÃEKHKSWGFGU TGRTÃUGPVCVKQPUFGUGPUGKIPCPVUFGNO'056´NOÃICTFFGUJ[RGTOÃFKCURÃFCIQIKSWGU GVRQWTWPGOKUGGPÃXKFGPEGFGNOKORQTVCPEGFGNGWTGURCEGGVFGNGWTVGORU=%*1?

(5)

(QTOCVGWT

#RRTGPCPV 5CXQKT

6+%

'PITCUTGNCVKQPRTKPEKRCNG

(KIWTG2ÃFCIQIKGEGPVTÃGUWTNOCEVKXKVÃFGNOÃNÂXG

2QKPVKORQTVCPVUKNGU6+%nCIGPVUPQPJWOCKPU€=%#.?PGUCWTCKGPV ÄVTGEQPUKFÃTÃGUEQOOGFGUQWVKNUPGWVTGUCWUGTXKEGFGHKPCNKVÃURTQRTGOGPV QW RWTGOGPV JWOCKPGU GNNGU PG UCWTCKGPV ´ NOKPXGTUG ÄVTG EQPUKFÃTÃGU EQOOGRQTVGWUGUGPGNNGUOÄOGUFOWPGRÃFCIQIKGFÃVGTOKPÃG2CTGZGORNG KNGUVVQWV´HCKVRQUUKDNGFGOGVVTGGPRNCEGFGUEQWTUOCIKUVTCWZRÃFCIQIKG VTCPUOKUUKXG WVKNKUCPV NGU 6+% UQKV FG HCÁQP U[PEJTQPG GP WVKNKUCPV NGU VGEJPQNQIKGU UWRRQTVCPV NGU nEQPHÃTGPEGU GP NKIPG€ UQKV FG HCÁQP CU[PEJTQPGGPRTQRQUCPVFGUGPTGIKUVTGOGPVUXKFÃQUKNNWUVTÃUQWPQPRCTNGU VTCPURCTGPVUKPKVKCWZ

.CEQPEGRVKQPGVNGFÃXGNQRRGOGPVFGRTGOKGTUOWNVKOÃFKCURÃFCIQIKSWGU 5GEQPFG ÃVCRG FG NOCRRTQEJG RÃFCIQIKSWG ´ NC EQPEGRVKQP GV CW FÃXGNQRRGOGPV FOWP RTQFWKV GZRÃTKOGPVCN GV FOWPG EQNNGEVKQP RÃFCIQIKSWG J[RGTOÃFKC

/WPK ´ NC HQKU FG EGVVG CRRTQEJG RÃFCIQIKSWG EGPVTÃG UWT NOCEVKXKVÃ GV NOCWVQPQOKGFGNOCRRTGPCPVGVFGNCXQNQPVÃFOWVKNKUGTNGU6+%PQVTGITQWRG FOGPUGKIPCPVU EJQKUKV FG UG NCPEGT UÃTKGWUGOGPV FCPU NC ETÃCVKQP NC EQPEGRVKQP GV NG FÃXGNQRRGOGPV FG OWNVKOÃFKCU RÃFCIQIKSWGU +NU QPV FGU EQORÃVGPEGU GV FG NOGZRÃTKGPEG RÃFCIQIKSWG FCPU NGU FKUEKRNKPGU UEKGPVKHKSWGU SWOKNU GPUGKIPGPV UEKGPEGU FG NOKPIÃPKGWT GV EQPPCKUUGPV DKGP EGTVCKPGU VGEJPQNQIKGU EQOOG EGNNG FG NOJ[RGTVGZVG RCT GZGORNG KNU NOWVKNKUGPV FOCKNNGWTU FÃL´ RQWT OGVVTG ´ FKURQUKVKQP NGWTU RQN[EQRKÃU 6QWVGHQKU EG SWK NGU KPVÃTGUUG EOGUV FOCNNGT RNWU NQKP GV VGUVGT FOCWVTGU RQUUKDKNKVÃU RÃFCIQIKSWGU QHHGTVGU RCT NOWUCIG FGU 6+% VCPV CW PKXGCW FG

(6)

NOQTICPKUCVKQPFGEGURTQFWKVUNCSWGNNGFQKVÄVTGUGNQPGWZRGPUÃGOQKPUGP VGTOGUFGnPCXKICVKQP€SWOGPVGTOGUFOCEVKXKVÃURÃFCIQIKSWGUUKOWNCVKQPU RÃFCIQIKSWGURCTQRRQUKVKQPCWZUKOWNCVKQPUUEKGPVKHKSWGUEGPVTÃGUPQPUWT NOCEVKXKVà FG NOÃNÂXG OCKU UWT WP EQPVGPW GZCEV ´ UKOWNGT QW FG ECTVGU FG EQPPCKUUCPEGU=2#3?GPICIGCPVNGUFKOGPUKQPUTÃGNNGUCHHGEVKXGUEQIPKVKXGU XQKTGUQEKCNGUXKCRCTGZGORNGFGUUKOWNCVGWTURÃFCIQIKSWGUEQNNCDQTCVKHU

=#7/ )+1 ? SWOCW PKXGCW FG NC HQTOG GV FGU EQPVGPWU OÄOG FG EGU UWRRQTVUN´GPEQTGRCTGZGORNGNOWVKNKUCVKQPFGNOKOCIGGVFGUCPKOCVKQPU POC RQWT GWZ FG UGPU SWG FCPU NC OGUWTG QÔ GNNG GUV UKIPKHKECVKXGOGPV UWDQTFQPPÃG´WPSWGUVKQPPGOGPVFGNOÃNÂXG

&CPUEGVVGRGTURGEVKXGNGWTEWNVWTGFOGPUGKIPCPVEJGTEJGWTNGURQWUUG´

EJGTEJGT FGU TÃHÃTGPEGU GV FGU VTCXCWZ GZKUVCPVU RQWXCPV TÃRQPFTG ´ EGVVG RTQDNÃOCVKSWG .G RTGOKGT TÃUWNVCV FG EG VTCXCKN GUV NC EQNNGEVG FG OCKITGU TÃUWNVCVUVQWUVTÂUNQECWZGVUWTVQWVOQPQFKUEKRNKPCKTGURQTVCPVRCTGZGORNG UWT NOKPVÃTÄV FGU VGZVGU KNNWUVTÃU FCPU WP OCPWGN UEQNCKTG GP RU[EJQNQIKG EQIPKVKXG .G FGWZKÂOG TÃUWNVCV EQPUKUVG GP NOKFGPVKHKECVKQP FG FQEWOGPVU RÃFCIQIKSWGUGZKUVCPVUUQKVFCPUNGFQOCKPGFWUEQNCKTGQWFWRCTCUEQNCKTG PKXGCW OCVGTPGNNG ÃNÃOGPVCKTG QW UGEQPFCKTG UQKV FCPU NG FQOCKPG FG NOGPUGKIPGOGPVFGUNCPIWGU

#RTÂU CXQKT ÃVWFKà EGU TÃUWNVCVU KNU GP CTTKXGPV ´ NC EQPENWUKQP SWG EQPEGXQKT GV FÃXGNQRRGT FGU UWRRQTVU OWNVKOÃFKCU RÃFCIQIKSWGU RQWT NOGPUGKIPGOGPVUWRÃTKGWTFCPUNGUFQOCKPGUFGUUEKGPEGUFGNOKPIÃPKGWTCXGE NCFQWDNGJ[RQVJÂUGnWUCIGFGU6+%FCPUNGECFTGFOWPGRÃFCIQIKGEGPVTÃG UWTNOCEVKXKVÃFGNOÃNÂXG€GUVWPGCEVKXKVÃRKQPPKÂTG+NUFÃEKFGPVFWEQWRFG OGVVTGGPRNCEGWPGFÃOCTEJGTÃRQPFCPV´FGWZECTCEVÃTKUVKSWGURTKPEKRCNGU

&OCDQTF EGVVG FÃOCTEJG GUV FG V[RG nGUUCKEQTTGEVKQP€ ECTCEVÃTKUVKSWG CUUG\ENCUUKSWGEJG\NGU#PINQ5CZQPUOQKPUGP(TCPEGEQPFWKUCPV´

2QUGTFGUJ[RQVJÂUGUCXGEFGUNCDQTCVQKTGUFGTGEJGTEJG

&ÃXGNQRRGTEQPETÂVGOGPVFGUUWRRQTVUOWNVKOÃFKCU .GUÃXCNWGT

%QTTKIGTNGUKPÃXKVCDNGUGTTGWTU

4GNGXCPV FOWPG CRRTQEJG nTGEJGTEJG GV FÃXGNQRRGOGPV€ EGVVG FÃOCTEJG FQPV NOQDLGEVKH GUV FOCTTKXGT ´ FGU UQNWVKQPU PQWXGNNGU C ´ NGWTU [GWZRNWUKGWTUKPVÃTÄVUGNNGRGTOGVFG

2TGPFTGFWTGEWNGPEQPHTQPVCPVGVÃEJCPIGCPVFGUKFÃGU 2QUGTFGUJ[RQVJÂUGU

#XQKTFGUTGVQWTUnVGTTCKP€GVFGNGUÃXCNWGT

(7)

/WPK FG EGVVG FÃOCTEJG nGUUCKEQTTGEVKQP€ NG ITQWRG FOGPUGKIPCPVU FÃEKFG NQIKSWGOGPV FOCPETGT NC TÃCNKUCVKQP FG UGU RTGOKGTU OWNVKOÃFKCU RÃFCIQIKSWGU FCPU NC TÃCNKUCVKQP GV NOÃXCNWCVKQP FOWP RTGOKGT EÃFÃTQO GZRÃTKOGPVCNNGRTQLGV2TKUOÃQ

5GEQPFG ECTCEVÃTKUVKSWG FG NC FÃOCTEJG TGVGPWG RCT NG ITQWRG FOGPUGKIPCPVUUCFKOGPUKQPEQNNCDQTCVKXG'PGHHGVNOCRRTQEJGTGEJGTEJGGV FÃXGNQRRGOGPVUWRRQUGDKGPGPVGPFWFGEQNNCDQTGTCXGEFGUNCDQTCVQKTGUFG TGEJGTEJGRGTVKPGPVU&CPUEGVVGRGTURGEVKXGNGUGPUGKIPCPVUKFGPVKHKGPVFGU NCDQTCVQKTGU VTCXCKNNCPV FCPU FGU FKUEKRNKPGU PG TGNGXCPV PK FG NGWTU EQORÃVGPEGU PK FGU UEKGPEGU FG NOKPIÃPKGWT OCKU SWK NGWT UGODNGPV KPFKURGPUCDNGU ´ NC EQPEGRVKQP GV CW FÃXGNQRRGOGPV FOWP OWNVKOÃFKC RÃFCIQIKSWGFGDQPPGSWCNKVÃVCPVFWRQKPVFGXWGFGUGPUGKIPCPVUSWGFG EGNWK FGU ÃNÂXGU &OWPG OCPKÂTG RNWU IÃPÃTCNG PQVTG ITQWRG FOGPUGKIPCPVU ENCUUGNGUFKUEKRNKPGUKPFKURGPUCDNGUGPFGWZGPUGODNGU

LEGNNGUSWKTGNÂXGPVFOWPGEQNNCDQTCVKQPnTGEJGTEJGGVFÃXGNQRRGOGPV€

FKFCEVKSWGRÃFCIQIKGRU[EJQNQIKGEQIPKVKXGRU[EJQUQEKQNQIKGUÃOKQNQIKG RCT GZGORNG GV SWK KPVGTXKGPPGPV UWTVQWV FCPU NGU RJCUGU FG EQPEGRVKQP FOÃXCNWCVKQP GV FG TGEQOOCPFCVKQPU EQPEGTPCPV NGU OWNVKOÃFKCU RÃFCIQIKSWGU

LEGNNGUFQPVNGUKPVGTXGPVKQPU UGHQPVCWUUKGPRJCUG FG FÃXGNQRRGOGPV KPHQITCRJKGGTIQPQOKGUEÃPCTKUCVKQPFTQKVRCTGZGORNG

#RRW[Ã RCT NGWT ÃVCDNKUUGOGPV PQVTG ITQWRG FOGPUGKIPCPVU RKQPPKGTU C FWEQWREJQKUKFGETÃGTFOWPGRCTVWPTÃUGCWFGRCTVGPCTKCVRQWTVTCXCKNNGT CXGENGRTGOKGTGPUGODNGFOCWVTGRCTVNG%GPVTGFGTGUUQWTEGUGPKPPQXCVKQP RÃFCIQIKSWG GV VGEJPQNQIKGU %4+26 TÃWPKUUCPV NGU EQORÃVGPEGU FW FGWZKÂOG GPUGODNG GV KPUVKVWCPV FQPE CW UGKP FG NOÃVCDNKUUGOGPV WP EQPVGZVG RNWTKFKUEKRNKPCKTG RGTOGVVCPV NG FÃXGNQRRGOGPV FGU OWNVKOÃFKCU RÃFCIQIKSWGU

0ÃEGUUCKTG NC RTÃUGPEG FG EG EQPVGZVG INQDCN TÃUGCW FG RCTVGPCKTGU GV

%4+26PGUWHHKVRCUFCPUNCOGUWTGQÔKNUGODNGOCKPVGPCPVKPFKURGPUCDNG FCPU NG ECFTG FG FÃXGNQRRGOGPV FG RTQFWKVU RÃFCIQIKSWGU FG SWCNKVÃ FG OGVVTG GP RNCEG WP VTCXCKN EQNNCDQTCVKH KPVGTFKUEKRNKPCKTG EOGUV´FKTG QÔ EJCEWP TGRTÃUGPVCPV FOWPG FKUEKRNKPG CRRQTVG UC RKGTTG ´ NOÃFKHKEG VQWV GP TGURGEVCPVEGNNGUFGUCWVTGUXQKTGGPGUUC[CPVFOGPEQORTGPFTGNGUKPVÃTÄVUGV NKOKVGU

2TKUOÃQWPCPFGEQPEGRVKQPGVFÃXGNQRRGOGPVVTGPVGGPUGKIPCPVUGV XKPIVÃNÂXGUKORNKSWÃUWPCPFOÃXCNWCVKQPGVWPTCRRQTVHKPCNFGSWCVTGEGPVURCIGU YYYETKRVGPUVHTRTQLGVUKPFGZJVON GV YYYETKRVGPUVHTTGEJGTEJGKPFGZJVON

=%*1?

(8)

.C NÃIKVKOKVà FG EGVVG CRRTQEJG ´ NC HQKU FG V[RG nTGEJGTEJG GV FÃXGNQRRGOGPV€ GV EQNNCDQTCVKXG GUV NCTIGOGPV EQPHKTOÃG CWZ [GWZ FGU GPUGKIPCPVURCTNGURTGOKGTUFÃXGNQRRGOGPVUTÃCNKUÃU.GUKVÃTCVKQPUGUUCKU EQTTGEVKQPU QPV RGTOKU PQP UGWNGOGPV FG TGRÃTGT FGU GTTGWTU OCKU CWUUK GV UWTVQWVFOKFGPVKHKGTEGTVCKPUKPVÃTÄVUGVNKOKVCVKQPUFGEGV[RGFGOWNVKOÃFKCU RÃFCIQIKSWGU GV FCXCPVCIG GPEQTG FG EQPHKTOGT NG XKFG CEVWGN GV NOKOOGPUKVÃFWVTCXCKN´TÃCNKUGTCWVQWTFGEGVVGRTQDNÃOCVKSWG6TCXCKNSWK NGWT CRRCTCÉV FW EQWR FOCWVCPV RNWU KPFKURGPUCDNG FOCDQTFGT FG OCPKÂTG EQNNCDQTCVKXG GP RCTVKEWNKGT CXGE FGU NCDQTCVQKTGU FG TGEJGTEJG FCPU NGU FKUEKRNKPGUPQPUEKGPVKHKSWGUUOKPVÃITCPVFCPUNCEQPEGRVKQPFGOWNVKOÃFKCU RÃFCIQIKSWGU

4GUVGSWGNCOKUGGPWXTGFGEGVVGFÃOCTEJGEQNNCDQTCVKXGRTQOGVVGWUG GVKPFKURGPUCDNGGUVNQKPFOCNNGTFGUQKRQWTNGUGPUGKIPCPVU%GVVGFKHHKEWNVÃ NGWT GUV CRRCTWG CXGE HQTEG UWT FGWZ V[RGU FG EQNNCDQTCVKQPU NC EQNNCDQTCVKQP GPVTG GPUGKIPCPVU FOWPG OÄOG FKUEKRNKPG UEKGPVKHKSWG NQECNGOGPV´WPÃVCDNKUUGOGPVGVNCEQNNCDQTCVKQPCXGEFGUEJGTEJGWTUFCPU WPFQOCKPGVTCPUXGTUGCWNGWTGTIQPQOKGQWRÃFCIQIKGRCTGZGORNGOCKU KPFKURGPUCDNGCWTÃUWNVCV INQDCNFWVTCXCKN2CTGZGORNGNGWT EQNNCDQTCVKQP CXGE WP EJGTEJGWT GP RU[EJQNQIKG EQIPKVKXG C GZKIÃ WPG RÃTKQFG FOCRRTGPVKUUCIG NQPIWG NGU HKPCNKVÃU GV NGU OQFGU FG HQPEVKQPPGOGPV XCNGWTUTCRRQTVCWVGORU´NOGURCEGCWVTCXCKNEQNNGEVKHFGURTQVCIQPKUVGU ÃVCPVGZVTÄOGOGPVFKXGTIGPVUKPKVKCNGOGPV

7PG FGWZKÂOG KPPQXCVKQP NKÃG CW RCTCFKIOG FG VTCXCKN TGEJGTEJG GV FÃXGNQRRGOGPVGVEQNNCDQTCVKQP

%GVVG FGWZKÂOG ÃVCRG UQNNKEKVG CKPUK WP FGWZKÂOG V[RG FOKPPQXCVKQP PG RQTVCPVRNWUURÃEKHKSWGOGPVUWTFGUSWGUVKQPURÃFCIQIKSWGUOCKUDKGPUWT NG RCTCFKIOG FG VTCXCKN FG NOGPUGKIPCPVEJGTEJGWT EGNWKEK ÃXQNWCPV FOWP VTCXCKN FG V[RG nTÃHNGZKQP RWTG€ EJGTEJGWT KPFKXKFWGN QW ´ FQOKPCPVG KPFKXKFWGNNG VTÂU NQECNGOGPV EQNNCDQTCVKH XGTU WP VTCXCKN FG V[RG nGUUCK EQTTGEVKQPU€ ´ FQOKPCPVG EQNNCDQTCVKXG GV KPVGTFKUEKRNKPCKTG GZKIGCPV NC OKUG UWT RKGF PÃIQEKÃG FG PQWXGCWZ TÏNGU V[RGU FG TGNCVKQPU GV GURCEGU VGORUKPFKXKFWGNGVEQNNGEVKHFGVTCXCKN=/10?

%GVVG FGTPKÂTG FKOGPUKQP EQNNCDQTCVKXG PQWU CRRCTCÉV RCTVKEWNKÂTGOGPV ETWEKCNG +N UGODNG FOCDQTF GP GHHGV KPFKURGPUCDNG XW NC VTÂU ITCPFG URÃEKHKEKVÃFGUUWRRQTVURÃFCIQIKSWGUCEVWGNNGOGPVFÃXGNQRRÃUUQWXGPVNKÃG

´WPEQWTUFOWPÃVCDNKUUGOGPVGVXWNOKORQTVCPEGFGUOQ[GPU´OGVVTG GP WXTGFCPUNCEQPEGRVKQPNGFÃXGNQRRGOGPVGVNOÃXCNWCVKQPFGOWNVKOÃFKCU RÃFCIQIKSWGU FG HCKTG EQNNCDQTGT FGU GPUGKIPCPVU FOWPG OÄOG FKUEKRNKPG XGPCPVFGFKXGTUÃVCDNKUUGOGPVU.GUGEQPFCURGEVVQWEJG´NCECTCEVÃTKUVKSWG

(9)

RNWTKFKUEKRNKPCKTG FG NC EQPEGRVKQP GV FW FÃXGNQRRGOGPV FG OWNVKOÃFKCU RÃFCIQIKSWGU KN GUV CRRCTW GP GHHGV SWG NOGTIQPQOKG NC FKFCEVKSWG NC RÃFCIQIKG NC RU[EJQNQIKG NOKPHQITCRJKG NC UEÃPCTKUCVKQP NG FTQKV QW NC UÃOKQNQIKG ÃVCKGPV FGU EQORQUCPVGU KPEQPVQWTPCDNGU =%*1 ? 1T DKGP GPVGPFW EG VTCXCKN KPVGTFKUEKRNKPCKTG EQORQTVG FGU NKOKVGU NC EQNNCDQTCVKQP GPVTGFKUEKRNKPGUGVRCTHQKUOÄOGEWNVWTGUQWHCÁQPUFGRGPUGTRQUCPV FG PQODTGWZ RTQDNÂOGU 0QWU CXQPU FÃL´ KNNWUVTà NGU FÃDQTFGOGPVU GPVTG GTIQPQOGU GV RÃFCIQIWGU=%*1 ? #HKP FG UWIIÃTGT NC EQORNGZKVà FG EGU SWGUVKQPUPQWURTQRQUQPUKEKFGRTGPFTGEQPETÂVGOGPVNOGZGORNGFGTGNCVKQP SWGPQWUCXQPURWQDUGTXGTNQTUFWFÃXGNQRRGOGPVFWRTGOKGTVKVTGFGNC EQNNGEVKQPRÃFCIQIKSWGFOJ[RGTOÃFKCFW)'6'PSWGUVKQPUNGUTGNCVKQPUSWK UGUQPVÃVCDNKGUGPVTGNOKPHQITCRJKUVGFW%4+26GVWPGPUGKIPCPVFWITQWRG 0QWUPQWUUQOOGUCRGTÁWUSWGOCNITÃNCDQPPGXQNQPVÃFGUFGWZCEVGWTU GPRTÃUGPEGNOKPVGTFKUEKRNKPCTKVÃUOGUV JGWTVÃGGPSWGNSWGUQTVG ´ WPG VTKRNG nVGPUKQP€QWDCTTKÂTG

LGP VGTOGU FG VGORU NOKPHQITCRJKUVG VTCXCKNNG UWT FGU ÃDCWEJGU UQP OÃVKGTEQPUKUVG´RTÃUGPVGTCNQTUSWGNOGPUGKIPCPVPGXGWVVTCXCKNNGTSWGUWT WPGXGTUKQPHKPCNKUÃGFWFQEWOGPVUQPOÃVKGTCEVWGNEQPUKUVG´VTCPUOGVVTG FGUUCXQKTU

LGP VGTOGU FOGURCEG NGU GZKIGPEGU FG NOKPHQITCRJKUVG UQPV HQTVGOGPV EGPVTÃGUUWTNOJCTOQPKGFGNOÃETCP=517?KNGUVICTCPVFGNOKOCIGCNQTUSWG EGNNGUFGNOGPUGKIPCPVRQTVGPVFCXCPVCIGUWTNCEQORNÃVWFGNQECNGQWINQDCNG FGUEQPVGPWUKNGUVICTCPVFWEQPVGPW

LGP VGTOGU FG TGNCVKQPU UQEKCNGU NOKPHQITCRJKUVG UQWJCKVG SWG NOGPUGKIPCPV NWK HQWTPKUUG FGU ÃNÃOGPVU FG EQPVGPW HKPCNKUÃU CNQTU SWG NOGPUGKIPCPVRGPUGSWGNOKPHQITCRJKUVGGUV´UQPUGTXKEGGVSWOKNFQKVNWKHCKTG NGU UEJÃOCU SWOKN UQWJCKVG &CPU NGU FKCNQIWGU NOKPHQITCRJKUVG nOQPVTG€

CNQTU SWG NOGPUGKIPCPV nGZRNKSWG€W .GU FGWZ UQPV FÃVGTOKPÃU RCT FGU EWNVWTGU VTÂU FKHHÃTGPVGU GV KN HCWV WP VTCXCKN NQPI GV HCUVKFKGWZ RQWT SWOKNU PÃIQEKGPVWPGURCEGVGORUEQOOWPSWGNGWTUTÏNGUUQKGPVENCKTUGVSWOGPHKP KNUEQNNCDQTGPV

.C EQNNGEVKQP 'P SWGUVKQPU C ÃVÃ OKUG GP RNCEG GP 7P EQPUQTVKWO FG JWKV RCTVGPCKTGU '065 '056 $TGVCIPG +06 '0+% '0525 '2(. +76 FG %CEJCP

%0'&CÃVÃETÃÃRQWTNCEQPEGRVKQPFWRTGOKGTVKVTG6TQKUNCDQTCVQKTGUFGTGEJGTEJG QPV ÃVÃ CUUQEKÃU ´ NC EQPEGRVKQP %0'46# FG NO'0'5#& .#%1%045 FG NO7PKXGTUKVÃ FG 2QKVKGTU .2''2*'%045 FG NO7PKXGTUKVÃ FG 2CTKU 8 .GU VKVTGU FG EGVVG EQNNGEVKQP UQPV ÃFKVÃU RCT NGU UQEKÃVÃU +PHQVTQPKSWG GV +56+ YYYGP SWGUVKQPUPGV

(10)

.OÃXCNWCVKQPFGNCTÃCNKUCVKQP

3WCVTKÂOGÃVCRGÃXCNWGTNOKPVÃTÄVRÃFCIQIKSWGFWRTQFWKVFÃXGNQRRÃ

0QU GPUGKIPCPVU FKURQUGPV OCKPVGPCPV FG OWNVKOÃFKCU RÃFCIQIKSWGU VKVTG FG NC EQNNGEVKQP RÃFCIQIKSWG J[RGTOÃFKC SWOKNU XKGPPGPV FG ETÃGT GV FÃXGNQRRGTFCPUWPEQPVGZVGKPVGTFKUEKRNKPCKTGEQNNCDQTCVKHFG4&5OKNUQPV FÃL´RTQEÃFôFKHHÃTGPVGUÃXCNWCVKQPUFGNGWTUTÃCNKUCVKQPURCTNGUÃNÂXGUKNU UQWJCKVGPVFÃUQTOCKUHTCPEJKTWPPQWXGCWECRGPVGTOGFGTKIWGWTGVOGVVTG GP WXTG FCPU EGVVG RGTURGEVKXG WPG ÃXCNWCVKQP CWUUK TKIQWTGWUG SWG RQUUKDNGFGNOCRRQTVEQIPKVKHRQWTNOÃNÂXGFGNGWTUTÃCNKUCVKQPUOWNVKOÃFKCU .OQDLGEVKH GUV DKGP UÖT FG XÃTKHKGT NGU J[RQVJÂUGU RTKUGU GV FOÃVCDNKT FGU TGEQOOCPFCVKQPURQWTNGUOWNVKOÃFKCURÃFCIQIKSWGUUWKXCPVU

#VKVTGFOGZGORNGPQWUCXQPUEJQKUKFGRTÃUGPVGTNOWPGFGUÃXCNWCVKQPU TÃCNKUÃGU FCPU NG ECFTG FG NC EQNNGEVKQP RCT NG ITQWRG FOGPUGKIPCPV NC RGTVKPGPEG FG NOWVKNKUCVKQP FG NOKOCIG FCPU NG ECFTG FG NC TÃÃETKVWTG OWNVKOÃFKCFGUEQPVGPWU.GVGTOGnKOCIG€GUV KEK ´ RTGPFTGCW UGPU FG NOKOCIGCPKOÃGGVNÃIGPFÃG

&CPUEGVVGRGTURGEVKXGNGUGPUGKIPCPVUQPVRTQRQUôFGNGWTUÃNÂXGU GVUGNQPWPRTQVQEQNGRTÃEKUFÃHKPKGPEQNNCDQTCVKQPCXGEWPNCDQTCVQKTGFG TGEJGTEJGGPRU[EJQNQIKGEQIPKVKXGFGVTCXCKNNGTUWTWPGFGUFGWZXGTUKQPU FÃXGNQRRÃGU FOWP OÄOG EQPVGPW RÃFCIQIKSWG %GU FGWZ XGTUKQPU UQPV QRRQUÃGU FW RQKPV FG XWG FG NGWT VTCKVGOGPV FG NOKOCIG .C RTGOKÂTG XCNQTKUGNOKOCIGFGSWCVTGRQKPVUFGXWG

LVGORQTGNNGOGPVGNNGGUVFQPPÃGCXCPVNGVGZVGÃETKVQWUQPQTG LURCVKCNGOGPVGNNGGUVRTÃUGPVÃGCWEGPVTGFGNOÃETCP

LKPHQTOCVKQPPGNNGOGPV GNNG EQORQTVG WPG KPHQTOCVKQP UKIPKHKECVKXG GV POGUVFQPERCUUGWNGOGPVKNNWUVTCVKXGFOWPVGZVGQWFÃEQTCVKXG

LnKPVGTCEVKXGOGPV€GNNGRGTOGV WP HQTV EQPVTÏNG FG NOWVKNKUCVGWT UWT NG FÃTQWNGOGPVFGNCUÃSWGPEGOWNVKOÃFKCXKCNOWVKNKUCVKQPFGUKIPGURCUUGWTU FG V[RG nGUECOQV€ RGTOGVVCPV NOCEEÂU ´ WPG KPHQTOCVKQP TGNGXCPV FOWP PKXGCWFOCRRTQHQPFKUUGOGPV=$'6?

%GVVG ÃXCNWCVKQP C ÃVÃ TÃCNKUÃG UWT NG RTGOKGT VKVTG FG NC EQNNGEVKQP RÃFCIQIKSWG J[RGTOÃFKC 'P SWGUVKQPU FW )'6 EGEK GP RCTVGPCTKCV CXGE NG .#%1%045 FG NO7PKXGTUKVÃ FG 2QKVKGTU .GU VKVTGU FG NC EQNNGEVKQP FOJ[RGTOÃFKCU RÃFCIQIKSWGU FW )'6'PSWGUVKQPUUQPVQTICPKUÃUCWVQWTFGFGWZCRRTQEJGUFOCRRTGPVKUUCIGECTVGFG EQPPCKUUCPEG GV UKOWNCVGWT RÃFCIQIKSWG GV RTQRQUGPV FGU EQPVGPWU TÃÃETKVU GP WVKNKUCPVNCTIGOGPVCPKOCVKQPUKOCIGUEQOOGPVCKTGUUQPQTGUGVJKÃTCTEJKUCVKQP

(11)

.CUGEQPFGXGTUKQPKORNÃOGPVGFGURTKPEKRGUEQPVTCKTGUKOCIGUGEQPFG FÃXCNQTKUÃG URCVKCNGOGPV FÃEQTCVKXG UWUEKVCPV RGW FOKPVGTCEVKXKVÃ .C EQORCTCKUQP FGU TÃUWNVCVU FGU FKHHÃTGPVU ÃNÂXGU CPCN[UÃU XKC WPG OÃVJQFQNQIKG ENCUUKSWG FG RTÃVGUVURQUVVGUV C OQPVTÃ ´ PQU GPUGKIPCPVU SWG NGU ÃNÂXGU CXCKGPV FG DQPU TÃUWNVCVU SWGNNG SWG UQKV NC XGTUKQP VTCKVÃG CXGE QW UCPU KOCIGU XCNQTKUÃGU 'UUC[CPV FOKPVGTRTÃVGT EGU TÃUWNVCVU PQU GPUGKIPCPVU QPV EQPUVCVÃ SWGNGU ÃNÂXGU CXCKGPV RCUUÃ VTÂU RGW FG VGORU ´ VTCKVGTNGUKOCIGU#EGVVGEQPUVCVCVKQPNGUGPUGKIPCPVUCKFÃUGPEGNCRCTNGWT NCDQTCVQKTG RCTVGPCKTG QPV RTQRQUÃ VTQKU GZRNKECVKQPU PQP GZENWUKXGU NGU WPGUFGUCWVTGU

LNGUÃNÂXGUPOCXCKGPVRCUDGUQKPFGEGUKOCIGUKNUQPVVTÂUDKGPEQORTKU UCPU

LKNUPOQPVRCUGWNGVGORUFGNGUVTCKVGT

LNGUKOCIGUPGEQTTGURQPFGPVRCU´NGWTUJCDKVWFGUFOCRRTGPVKUUCIGVTÂU NKÃGU´WPGRÃFCIQIKGFWVGZVGÃETKVQWQTCN

%GUFGWZFGTPKÂTGUKPVGTRTÃVCVKQPUQPVFQPPôRGPUGT´PQUGPUGKIPCPVU NC EQORNGZKVà FOWPG KPPQXCVKQP RÃFCIQIKSWG EJCPIGT NGU JCDKVWFGU RÃFCIQIKSWGU GZKIG FOKPVTQFWKTG FG PQWXGCWZ RTQFWKVU UCPU FQWVG OCKU CWUUK GV RGWVÄVTG UWTVQWV FG TÃHQTOGT FGU ÃNÃOGPVU VTÂU EQPVGZVWGNU GV VTÂU NKÃUCWU[UVÂOGUEQNCKTGNGUVCVWVFGNOKOCIGFCPUNOÃFWECVKQPGVNGTCRRQTV CWVGORUFGNOCRRTGPVKUUCIGNGEQPVGZVGVGORQTGNFGNOÃXCNWCVKQPTGUVCKVWP EQPVGZVGFGnEQPVTÏNG€ENCUUKSWGGPVGORUVTÂUNKOKVÃEGSWKPOCUCPUFQWVG RCUHCXQTKUÃNCOKUGGPRNCEGEJG\NOÃNÂXGFOWPGUVTCVÃIKGFGSWGUVKQPPGOGPV XKU´XKUFGUKOCIGUGVE

+N GUV FQPE FKHHKEKNG RQWT PQU GPUGKIPCPVU FG VKTGT FGU EQPUÃSWGPEGU UKIPKHKECVKXGUFGEGVVGÃXCNWCVKQPFCPUNCOGUWTGQÔKNHCWFTCKVCRRTQHQPFKT EGVVG ÃXCNWCVKQP RQWT UCXQKT UK FCPU WP CWVTG EQPVGZVG VGORQTGN RCT GZGORNGNOÃNÂXGCWTCKVVTCKVÃNGUKOCIGUGVFÃXGNQRRÃWPGKPVGTTQICVKQPGVWP SWGUVKQPPGOGPVRGTVKPGPVRQWTNOCRRTGPVKUUCIG

3WCVTKÂOGV[RGFOKPPQXCVKQPRGPUGTnU[UVÂOG€

%GVVGSWCVTKÂOG ÃVCRG FOÃXCNWCVKQP OGV CKPUK NG FQKIV UWT WP SWCVTKÂOG V[RG FOKPPQXCVKQP NOCRRTQEJG FW OWNVKOÃFKC RÃFCIQIKSWG FQKV ÄVTG PQP UGWNGOGPV KPVGTFKUEKRNKPCKTG QW EQNNCDQTCVKXG OCKU FCXCPVCIG GPEQTG U[UVÃOKSWG#WVTGOGPVFKVGNNGFQKVKPVÃITGT´NCHQKUNGUWRRQTVOWNVKOÃFKC RÃFCIQIKSWGNGUWUCIGTUGVNGWTUWUCIGUOCKUCWUUKNGEQPVGZVGINQDCNFCPU NGSWGNVQWVEGEKGUVRNCEÃDTGHNOKPUVKVWVKQPPGN

(12)

(QTOCVGWT

#RRTGPCPV 5CXQKT

6+%

+PUVKVWVKQP

#WVTGUKPUVKVWVKQPU +PFWUVTKGNU

'VCV

(KIWTG.GECFTGU[UVÃOKSWG

&G RNWU KN PG UOCIKV RCU UGWNGOGPV FCPU NG ECFTG FOWPG VGNNG CRRTQEJG U[UVÃOKSWGLCEVWGNNGOGPVTGXGPFKSWÃGFOWPGEGTVCKPGOCPKÂTGPQPUGWNGOGPV RCTNGUU[UVÃOKEKGPUOCKUCWUUKRCTNGUUQEKQNQIWGUGVRU[EJQUQEKQNQIWGUFG NOKPPQXCVKQP L FG VGPKT EQORVG FG VQWVGU EGU EQORQUCPVGU OCKU CWUUK FG EQPUKFÃTGTNGWTUTGNCVKQPUGVOKGWZGPEQTGNOÃXQNWVKQPF[PCOKSWGFGEGNNGUEK

=%41?

.CEQPUVTWEVKQPGVNOÃXCNWCVKQPFOWPU[UVÂOG

%KPSWKÂOGÃVCRGXGTUNGU[UVÂOG

.GITQWRGFOGPUGKIPCPVUGVUQPKPUVKVWVKQPOCKPVGPCPVSWOKNUQPVEQPÁW FÃXGNQRRÃ GV ÃXCNWÃ RCTVKGNNGOGPV FGU OWNVKOÃFKCU RÃFCIQIKSWGU UG RGPEJGPVUWTNGRTQDNÂOGFGNGWTKPVÃITCVKQPFCPUWPU[UVÂOGRNWUINQDCNGV RNWU RTÃEKUÃOGPV FCPU WP FKURQUKVKH FG HQTOCVKQP ´ FKUVCPEG (´&

UOCRRW[CPV NCTIGOGPV UWT NGU 6+% #HKP FG OGVVTG GP RNCEG WPG CRRTQEJG U[UVÃOKSWGNGUGPUGKIPCPVUGUUCKGPVFGRTGPFTGGPEQORVGFGUPQVKQPUVGNNG nNCHQTOCVKQPUWTNGRQUVGFGVTCXCKN€nNCHQTOCVKQPVQWVCWNQPIFGNCXKG€

QWNCnHQTOCVKQPLWUVG´VGORU€

%QOOG KNU UQWJCKVGPV ÃICNGOGPV ICTFGT NGWT FÃOCTEJG INQDCNG nGUUCK EQTTGEVKQP€ GV EQNNCDQTCVKXG KNU OQPVGPV WP RTQLGV FOGZRÃTKOGPVCVKQP FQPV

(13)

NOQDLGEVKH CUUG\ CODKVKGWZ GUV NC URÃEKHKECVKQP IÃPÃTCNG FOWP FKURQUKVKH FG (´&UOCRRW[CPVNCTIGOGPVUWTNGU6+%

.OQDLGEVKH FG NGWT RTQLGV GUV GP UOCRRW[CPV UWT NGU TÃUWNVCVU CEEWOWNÃU CXGE NGWTU RCTVGPCKTGU FCPU NG ECFTG FG NC EQPEGRVKQP FG OWNVKOÃFKCU RÃFCIQIKSWGU FG FÃHKPKT RCT GZGORNG NGU FKHHÃTGPVU ÃNÃOGPVU UWRRQTVU RÃFCIQIKSWGU VGEJPQNQIKGU CEVKXKVÃ RÃFCIQIKSWGU TÏNGU QWVKNU FG UWKXK EQPUVKVWCPV WP FKURQUKVKH FG (´& KPVÃITCPV NGU OWNVKOÃFKCU GV NGWTU TGNCVKQPU NC F[PCOKSWG FOWP VGN FKURQUKVKH QW UGU GURCEGUVGORU .GU J[RQVJÂUGU KPKVKCNGU EQPEGTPCPV NG FKURQUKVKH FG (´& RQTVGPV GP RCTVKEWNKGT UWT NG PKXGCW FOCWVQPQOKG FG NOCRRTGPCPV NOKORQTVCPEG FGU ITQWRGU FOCRRTGPCPVUNGEQÖVRQUUKDNGFOWPG HQTOCVKQP NG PKXGCW FG RÃTGPPKVÃ FGU EQPVGPWURTQRQUÃUGVE

&G UWTETQÉV PQU GPUGKIPCPVU UQWJCKVGPV KPVÃITGT ´ NGWT RTQLGV WPG ÃXCNWCVKQP UKIPKHKECVKXG EQORQTVCPV WPG EQORQUCPVG HKPCNG ÃXCNWCVKQP UQOOCVKXGOCKUCWUUKWPGEQORQUCPVGEQPVKPWGGVTÃIWNKÂTGCWEQWTUFGNC EQPEGRVKQPGVFWFÃXGNQRRGOGPVÃXCNWCVKQPHQTOCVKXG2QKPVFOCWVCPVRNWU FÃNKECV SWG EG V[RG FOÃXCNWCVKQP U[UVÃOKSWG PG TÃRQPF RCU CW OQFÂNG FOÃXCNWCVKQP FÃXGNQRRà GP RU[EJQNQIKG EQIPKVKXG EQPPW FÃUQTOCKU FG PQU GPUGKIPCPVU 3WGN V[RG FOÃXCNWCVKQP OGVVTG GP RNCEG! 'P RCTVKEWNKGT EQOOGPVEQPVTÏNGTNGURCTCOÂVTGUFOWPU[UVÂOGÃVCPVFQPPÃSWOWPU[UVÂOG PGTÃRQPFRNWUPÃEGUUCKTGOGPVCWOQFÂNGFÃVGTOKPKUVGWPGECWUGWPGHHGV UWTNGSWGNTGRQUGNOÃNCDQTCVKQPFGURTQVQEQNGUFOÃXCNWCVKQPFGURJÃPQOÂPGU NQECWZ EQPUKFÃTÃU GP RU[EJQNQIKG EQIPKVKXG! 8QKN´ NGU SWGUVKQPU SWG UG RQUGPV PQU GPUGKIPCPVU %OGUV RQWT [ TÃRQPFTGSWOKNU QWXTGPV WP RQUVG FG FQEVQTCPVUWTNGUWLGVn7PGCRRTQEJGVJÃQTKSWGGVU[UVÃOKSWGFGUFKURQUKVKHU FG HQTOCVKQP ´ FKUVCPEG€ # VKVTG FOCPGEFQVG KN NGWT C ÃVà KORQUUKDNG FG VTQWXGTWPECPFKFCVGP(TCPEGEGSWK´NGWTU[GWZVÃOQKIPGFGNCFKHHKEWNVà FG OGVVTG GP RNCEG WPG FÃOCTEJG INQDCNG GV U[UVÃOKSWG FCPU NG ECFTG OQPQFKUEKRNKPCKTGFGNCTGEJGTEJGHTCPÁCKUG

%KPSWKÂOGV[RGFOKPPQXCVKQPNCOQFKHKECVKQPFWU[UVÂOG

%GVVG EKPSWKÂOG ÃVCRG OGV FQPE NG FQKIV UWT WP PQWXGCW V[RG FOKPPQXCVKQP ÄVTG GP OGUWTG FG RKNQVGT WP RTQEGUUWU KPPQXCPV FG

2TQLGVFW)'6L/WNVKOÃFKCKPVGTCEVKHGVTÃUGCWJCWVFÃDKVGZRÃTKOGPVCVKQP FG HQTOCVKQP ´ FKUVCPEG /+4G*&'(#& YYYETKRVGPUVHTRTQLGVUKPFGZJVON 4ÃUGCWFGRCTVGPCKTGUFWEQPUQTVKWOFWRTQLGV'065'056$TGVCIPG+06'0+%

#NECVGN 7PKXGTUKV[ $WNN (QTOCVKQP %GPVTG FG (QTOCVKQP FGU 2TQHGUUKQPU FG NC

$CPSWG KPUVKVWV '4+'' ÃEQNG FGU OKPGU FO#NGU 5WRÃNGE 76% WPKXGTUKVÃ FG

$QTFGCWZ

(14)

EQPEGRVKQP GV FG OKUG GP WXTG FOWP U[UVÂOG FQPV QP PG EQPPCÉV RCU CRTKQTK NGU ECTCEVÃTKUVKSWGU U[UVÃOKSWGU RTKPEKRCNGU GP VGTOGU FG EQORQUCPVGUFGTGNCVKQPUGVFGNGWTUÃXQNWVKQPU

%GU ECTCEVÃTKUVKSWGU U[UVÃOKSWGU VQWEJGPV CW PKXGCW RU[EJQNQIKSWG FG NOCRRTGPCPV OCKU CWUUK CW PKXGCW RU[EJQUQEKQNQIKSWG FG NC TGNCVKQP GPVTG CEVGWTU VWVGWTU GVE GV FCXCPVCIG GPEQTG CW PKXGCW QTICPKUCVKQPPGN FG NOKPUVKVWVKQP=%41?

2NWU EQPETÂVGOGPV CW PKXGCW FG NOKPUVKVWVKQP RNWUKGWTU RCTCOÂVTGU UGODNGPVDQWUEWNÃU

.OÃEQPQOKGGVNOQTICPKUCVKQPFGNCETÃCVKQPFGUUWRRQTVURÃFCIQIKSWGU

%GPGUQPVRNWUFGUKPXGUVKUUGOGPVU TÃRCTVKU FCPU NG VGORU RQN[EQRKÃ SWG NOQP COÃNKQTG FOCPPÃG GP CPPÃG OCKU FGU KPXGUVKUUGOGPVU KPKVKCWZ NQWTFU SWK UQPV ´ RTÃXQKT RQWT DCUEWNGT NGU UWRRQTVU RÃFCIQIKSWGU %G POGUV RNWU NOGPUGKIPCPV SWK ETÃG NGU UWRRQTVU OCKU WPG ÃSWKRG RNWTKFKUEKRNKPCKTG KPVÃITCPVNOGPUGKIPCPV

.COKUG´FKURQUKVKQPFGEGUUWRRQTVURÃFCIQIKSWGUFCPUNGECFTGFG FKURQUKVKHUFG(´&%GPOGUVRNWUWPGKORTKOGTKGSWKRGTOGVNCOWNVKRNKECVKQP RJ[UKSWG FGU UWRRQTVU OCKU FGU UGTXGWTU KPHQTOCVKSWGU GV FGU TÃUGCWZ RWKUUCPVUSWKNGUOGVVGPV´FKURQUKVKQPJGVLCXGESWKRNWUGUV WPGEQPVKPWKVÃFGUGTXKEGU

.OCEEQORCIPGOGPVRÃFCIQIKSWGFGEGUUWRRQTVU%GPGUQPVRNWUFGU GPUGKIPCPVU´JGWTGGV NKGW RTÃFÃHKPKU SWK VTCPUOGVVGPV NGWTU UCXQKTU OCKU FGU VWVGWTU SWK CEEQORCIPGPV NQTUSWG NOCRRTGPCPV GP C DGUQKP FCPU NGU NQECWZFGNOKPUVKVWVKQPQW´RCTVKTFGRQUVGUFGVTCXCKNNQECWZQWÃNQKIPÃU

.C NQIKSWG FG TÃRCTVKVKQP FGU CRRTGPCPVU %G PG UQPV RNWU FGU CRRTGPCPVU nECRVKHU€ SWK UWKXGPV NGU HQTOCVKQPU FG NOKPUVKVWVKQP OCKU FGU CRRTGPCPVU nENKGPVU€ FKURGTUÃU FQPV EGTVCKPU UGTQPV FCPU NGU NQECWZ FG NOKPUVKVWVKQPSWKXQPVEJQKUKTFGUWKXTGWPGPUGODNGFGOQFWNGURTÃUGPVKGNU GV´FKUVCPEGCRRCTVGPCPV´FKXGTUGUKPUVKVWVKQPU

.GUGPUGKIPCPVUFGNOKPUVKVWVKQPPGUQPVRNWUnECRVKHU€WPGORNQ[GWT RTKPEKRCNGVWPVTCXCKNFOGPUGKIPGOGPVFCPUUGUNQECWZKNURGWXGPVVTCXCKNNGT RQWTRNWUKGWTUKPUVKVWVKQPUFCPUNGWTUNQECWZOCKUCWUUK´RCTVKTFGEJG\GWZ

.C NQIKSWG FG RQUKVKQPPGOGPV INQDCN FG NOKPUVKVWVKQP FCPU NG EQPVGZVG FG NOGPUGKIPGOGPV UWRÃTKGWT %G POGUV RNWU WPG NQIKSWG FG RQUKVKQPPGOGPV KPFKXKFWGNRCTGZGORNGXKU´XKUFGUCURGEVUÃNKVKUVGQWXGTVÃEQNGWPKXGTUKVÃ IÃPÃTCNKUVGURÃEKCNKUÃGQWIÃQITCRJKSWGNQECWZPCVKQPCWZ+NUOCIKVFÃUQTOCKU FOWPG NQIKSWG FOCNNKCPEG UVTCVÃIKSWG CXGE FOCWVTGU KPUVKVWVKQPU C[CPV NGU OÄOGURQUKVKQPPGOGPVUÃEQNGUÃNKVKUVGUWPKXGTUKVÃUURÃEKCNKUÃGUGPUEKGPEGU FWTGU QW CW EQPVTCKTG C[CPV FGU RQUKVKQPPGOGPVU EQORNÃOGPVCKTGU

(15)

EQWXTCPV VQWVGU NGU UEKGPEGU FG NOKPIÃPKGWT RGPUÃG CXGE QW UCPU FGU QRÃTCVGWTU FG VÃNÃEQOOWPKECVKQP RQTVCKN FOCEEÂU CXGE QW UCPU FGU KPUVKVWVKQPU URÃEKCNKUÃGU FCPU NC (´& %0'& %0#/ CXGE QW UCPU FGU ÃFKVGWTUFGEQPVGPW.GUKPUVKVWVKQPUCWUUKXQPVFGXQKTEQNNCDQTGT

#WPKXGCWFGNOGPUGKIPCPVEGVVGHQKUEKNGUOQFKHKECVKQPURTQHQPFGUFÃL´

ÃXQSWÃGU FCPU NG RCTCITCRJG n.OÃXCNWCVKQP FG NC TÃCNKUCVKQP€ UQPV TGPHQTEÃGU

.OGPUGKIPCPV POGUV RNWU FÃVGPVGWT GZENWUKH FGU UCXQKTU KN NGU OGV ´ FKURQUKVKQPXKUUQPKPUVKVWVKQPGVFGHCÁQPINQDCNG

.CETÃCVKQPFGUUWRRQTVURÃFCIQIKSWGUPGUGHCKVRNWUKPFKXKFWGNNGOGPV OCKUEQNNGEVKXGOGPVCWPKXGCWFGNCHQTOGFGUEQPVGPWUOCKUCWUUKFWHQPF

+NPGVTCPUOGVRNWUFCPUWPGURCEGVGORURTÃFÃHKPKGVRTÃUGPVKGNHCEG´

HCEGRJ[UKSWGKNCEEQORCIPGFCPUWPGURCEGVGORUPÃIQEKÃCXGENOCRRTGPCPV GVnVGEJPQNQIKUÀGPFKTGEVQWGPFKHHÃTÃGPKOCIGQWGPVGZVG

+N POGUV RNWU WPKSWGOGPV NKÃ ´ WPG KPUVKVWVKQP GV UQP GURCEGVGORU KN VTCXCKNNG RQWT RNWUKGWTU FCPU NGU NQECWZ FG EGU KPUVKVWVKQPU QW ´ RCTVKT FG EJG\NWKUGNQPUQPRTQRTGGURCEGVGORU

'RKNQIWG

/CKPVGPCPVSWGVQWVEGFKURQUKVKHFGHQTOCVKQP´FKUVCPEGCÃVÃFÃRNQ[Ã NG ITQWRG FOGPUGKIPCPVU TGICTFG GP CTTKÂTG GV UOKPVGTTQIG QÔ GP GUVQP!

3WGN RTQEGUUWU PQVTG CEVKXKVÃ CVGNNG QW PQP IÃPÃTÃ! # SWGN RTKZ! 'V GP HQPEVKQPFGEGNCSWGNNGQTKGPVCVKQPFQPPGT´PQVTGCEVKXKVÃRQWTNGUCPPÃGU´

XGPKT ! 'P GHHGEVWCPV EG DKNCP KNU UOCRGTÁQKXGPV SWOGP RCTVCPV FG NC EQPEGRVKQPFOWPOWNVKOÃFKCRÃFCIQIKSWGCÃVÃOKUGPRNCEGWPRTQEGUUWU FOKPPQXCVKQP INQDCN SWK VQWEJG ´ NC HQKU NOKPUVKVWVKQP FCPU UQP UVCVWV UGU HQPEVKQPPGOGPVUGVUGUEJQKZHQPFCOGPVCWZGVNOGPUGKIPCPVFCPUUQPUVCVWV UQPTÏNGGVUGUTGNCVKQPUCXGEUGUEQNNÂIWGU

.C EQPUVTWEVKQP GV NOÃXCNWCVKQP FOWP U[UVÂOG VQWV EQOOG NOWVKNKUCDKNKVÃ FOWP QWVKN RÃFCIQIKSWG PQXCVGWT VGN NGWT RTGOKGT VKVTG .OÃNGEVTQPKSWG GP SWGUVKQPURQKPVGPVNCPÃEGUUKVÃFOWPGKPPQXCVKQPGPINQDCPVVQWVGUNGUCWVTGU WP RTQEGUUWU INQDCN FOKPPQXCVKQP 1P EQPPCÉV NGU GPLGWZ JWOCKPU GP RCTVKEWNKGTUQWNGXÃURCTFGVGNURTQEGUUWU+EKNCOÃVCRJQTGFGNOCRRTGPVKUUCIG CW UGPU EQPUVTWEVKXKUVG FW VGTOG CRRCTCÉV RTÃEKGWUG ECT WPG KPPQXCVKQP UGODNGDKGPKORNKSWGTWPRTQEGUUWUFOCRRTGPVKUUCIGCXGEVQWVNGFÃUÃSWKNKDTG

=)+1 %41? NG FCPIGT NC TGOKUG GP ECWUG NGU CEEQORCIPGOGPVU CWUUK SWG EGU RTQEGUUWU UQPV UWUEGRVKDNGU FOGZKIGT RCT GZGORNG RQWT PQU GPUGKIPCPVU=$17?#WVTGOGPVFKVTÃHNÃEJKTUWTNOKPPQXCVKQPRÃFCIQIKSWG

(16)

EOGUV DKGP TÃHNÃEJKT UWT NOCRRTGPVKUUCIG L GV RCTVCPV NC HQTOCVKQP=&'8?L FGU GPUGKIPCPVU FGU CEVGWTU CW UGPU NCTIG KPENWCPV NGU ÃNÂXGU GV RNWU TCFKECNGOGPV GPEQTG FG NOQTICPKUCVKQP ÃFWECVKXG GNNGOÄOG EOGUV NOKFÃG nFOQTICPKUCVKQP CRRTGPCPVG€ 3WGNU V[RGU FOCRRTGPVKUUCIG XGWVQP UQNNKEKVGT! 5OCIKVKN FG HCKTG ÃXQNWGT NOQTICPKUCVKQP QW RNWU TCFKECNGOGPV GPEQTG FG SWGUVKQPPGT UGU HQPFGOGPVU OÄOG! 5K VGN GUV NG ECU SWGN CEEQORCIPGOGPVFGEGVCRRTGPVKUUCIGOGVVTGGPRNCEG=$41?!

+N UOCIKV FÃUQTOCKU RQWT NG ITQWRG FOGPUGKIPCPVU FOÃXCNWGT CXGE NOKPUVKVWVKQP GV UGU CEVGWTU SWGNU UQPV NGU EQÖVU HKPCPEKGTU GV JWOCKPU FG NOKPPQXCVKQP´OGVVTGGPRNCEGLNOKPPQXCVKQPJWOCKPGDCUÃGUWTNCTGOKUGGP ECWUGRGTUQPPGNNGEQORQTVCPVWPEQÖVÃNGXÃLGV´RCTVKTFGN´FOGPXKUCIGT CXGEGWZFCPUSWGNNGOGUWTGKNUUQPVRTÄVUGPRC[GTNGRTKZ

$KDNKQITCRJKG

=#7/?#7/106 $ /'50+'4 2/ 'PVTGRTGPFTG EJGTEJGT EQPFKVKQPU FG NOCEVG FOCRRTGPFTG6JÂUG2CTKU8

=$#7?$#7&4+66WVGWTWPGRNCEGFGUHQPEVKQPUWPOÃVKGT!27(

=$'6?$'64#0%1746 / n&G SWGNSWGU QRVKQPU FG RTÃUGPVCVKQP FGU KPHQTOCVKQPU FCPUWPFQEWOGPVOWNVKOÃFKC€*[RGTOÃFKCUGVCRRTGPVKUUCIGU2TÃCEVGUGEQNNQSWG

%JCVGPC[/CNCDT[OCK+042+7(/%TÃVGKN

=$17? $174)'1+5 ' n+FGPVKVà GV CRRTGPVKUUCIG€ KP (QTOCVKQP GV F[PCOKSWGU KFGPVKVCKTGU'FWECVKQPRGTOCPGPVGPu

=$41? $41%*+'4 & n.C HQTOCVKQP FCPU NOGPVTGRTKUG WP XGEVGWT RQVGPVKGN FOCRRTGPVKUUCIGEQNNGEVKHFWEJCPIGOGPV€KP(%TQUFKT&[PCOKSWGUFWEJCPIGOGPV GPÃFWECVKQPGVGPHQTOCVKQP+042+7(/8GTUCKNNGU

=%#.?%#..10 / FKT .C UEKGPEG GV UGU TÃUGCWZ )GPÂUG GV EKTEWNCVKQP FGU HCKVU UEKGPVKHKSWGU2CTKU5VTCUDQWTI'FKVKQPUNC&ÃEQWXGTVG%QPUGKNFGNO'WTQRG7PGUEQ

=%*1?%*12.+0*2TKUOÃQWPGGZRÃTKGPEGFGEÃFÃTQORÃFCIQIKSWG 4CRRQTVHKPCNDKNCPGVRGTURGEVKXGU%4+26)'6

=%*1 ?%*12.+0 * $100'#7 / %146'5+)417 0 )#.+5510 # n+PVÃITGT NGU J[RGTOÃFKCU FCPU NC HQTOCVKQP GV GURCEGVGORU RÃFCIQIKSWG NOGZRÃTKGPEG FG NO'056€KP#EVGUFWGEQNNQSWGGWTQRÃGPUWTNOCWVQHQTOCVKQP2TCVKSWGUFOCWVQHQTOCVKQP FCPUNCUQEKÃVÃFGNOKPHQTOCVKQP)4#('0'5#&&KLQP

=%*1?%*12.+0*GV%146'5+)4170n'PLGWZRU[EJQUQEKCWZNKÃU´NOKPVTQFWEVKQP FG PQWXGCWZ UWRRQTVU FCPU NOGPUGKIPGOGPV€ KP * %JQRNKP ÃF 2TKUOÃQ WPG GZRÃTKGPEGFGEÃFÃTQORÃFCIQIKSWG4CRRQTVHKPCNDKNCPGVRGTURGEVKXGU%4+26 )'6

(17)

=%*1?%*12.+0 * GV )#.+5510 # n.OGTIQPQOG GV NG RÃFCIQIWG€ .GU %CJKGTU RÃFCIQIKSWGUOCTU

=%41C?%415(n.OKPPQXCVKQPGPÃFWECVKQPGVGPHQTOCVKQPXGTUNC EQPUVTWEVKQP FOWPQDLGVFGTGEJGTEJG!€.OKPPQXCVKQPGPSWGUVKQP'FWECVKQPRGTOCPGPVGPuCXTKN

=%41D?%415(FKT&[PCOKSWGUFWEJCPIGOGPVGPÃFWECVKQPGVGPHQTOCVKQP+042 +7(/8GTUCKNNGU

=&'8?&'8'.#;/2GWVQPHQTOGTNGUGPUGKIPCPVU!'5(ÃFKVGWT

=)+1?)+14&#0 # 8'%%*+ ) FG .GU QTKIKPGU FGU UCXQKTU 0GWEJ¸VGN &GNCEJCWZ

=)+7?)+756&'524#+4+'5(n.CHKIWTGFGNOCWVTGFCPUNOÃEQNGTÃRWDNKECKPG€4GXWG KPVGTPCVKQPCNGFG2U[EJQUQEKQNQIKGXQN8Pu

=*'5?*'55 4 .C TGNCVKQP RÃFCIQIKSWG $KDNKQVJÂSWG GWTQRÃGPPG FGU UEKGPEGU FG NOÃFWECVKQP

=/10?/1067.'6$.GUGPLGWZURCVKQVGORQTGNUFWUQEKCN.O*CTOCVVCP

=2#3 ?2#37'.+0 & n.GU ECTVGU FG EQPEGRVU QWVKN RQWT NGU EQPEGRVGWTU GV NGU WVKNKUCVGWTUFOJ[RGTOÃFKCÃFWECVKH€KP'$TWKNNCTFCNÃF#EVGUFGUGLQWTPÃGU

*[RGTOÃFKCUGVCRRTGPVKUUCIGU%JCVGPC[/CNCDT[OCK+042'2+2CTKU

=2.1? 2.1/2 6 $47//'.*7+5 # 2'.)47/ 9, n0QWXGNNGU CRRTQEJGU FG NOGPUGKIPGOGPVFGNOCRRTGPVKUUCIGGVFGNOWVKNKUCVKQPFGUVGEJPQNQIKGUFGNOKPHQTOCVKQP GV FG NC EQOOWPKECVKQP FCPU NOÃFWECVKQP€ KP 2GTURGEVKXGU XQN ::8++ Pu UGRVGODTG

=217? 217%*#+0#84+. % n&GU GPUGKIPCPVU FW UGEQPF FGITà GV FG NGWTU nF[PCOKSWGUKFGPVKVCKTGU€'FWECVKQPRGTOCPGPVGPu

=517? 517%*+'4 ' n.O'ETKV FOÃETCP 2TCVKSWGU FOÃETKVWTG GV KPHQTOCVKSWG€

%QOOWPKECVKQPGVNCPICIGUR

Références

Documents relatifs

- Cela te permet alors de compléter le carré à gauche au milieu, puisqu’il ne manque plus

- Attention : chaque chiffre ne peut apparaître qu’une fois par ligne, par colonne et par carré.. Il suffit de le compléter avec le

- Puis on peut compléter la ligne du haut ou la colonne de gauche selon la même

Ùn c’hè chè una regula : ogni sciffru ùn ci pò esse chè una volta nentr’à una culonna, nentr’à una linea è nentr’à un quadrettu

Une seule règle prévaut : chaque chiffre ne doit figurer qu’une seule fois dans la même colonne, ligne et région (carré 3X3). Complétez

[r]

%G POGUV RCU NG NKGW FG FÃXGNQRRGT KEK NGU TÃUWNVCVU FG NOCPCN[UG FG EGU FQEWOGPVU 0QWU NOCXQPU HCKV CKNNGWTU 4GRTGPQPUGP EGRGPFCPV SWGNSWGU ÃNÃOGPVU GUUGPVKGNU TGNCVKHU ´

#WZ'VCVU7PKUNCETKUGNKÃGCWZCVVGPVCVUFWUGRVGODTGGPRGTOGVVCPV CWZ CIGPEGU FG TGPUGKIPGOGPV FG TGPFTG RNWU GHHKECEGU NGU OGUWTGU FG UWTXGKNNCPEG FGU KPFKXKFWU TKUSWG CWUUK FOCEEÃNÃTGT