Reconciling Distance Functions and Level Sets
19
0
0
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Reconciling Distance Functions and Level Sets José Gomes and Olivier Faugeras. N° 3666 Avril 1999 THÈME 3. ISSN 0249-6399. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4)
(5) !"$#% &'(
(6) *)+, -/.1032546.1798:0 ;/<>=@?BADCDEFCD8:GH ;JI>K18:G3;/0 L MONPRbdP+QT]lSkeUWQmjOVYnoX:c`Z[Q Xf\^XO]`p _aQ3Z[m bdcejOX_ c`MfXOc`XfPR]`biPRm[m[Q]lghXfPR_ ]eQm_^MObiXOQ`j qr\[clstQ Z(uc`v/clZ[w:bxm u(]lyfyJce\zZ(noQ{\[Q_^MOQ\[_^MfQ|X/}S`~e~`~5U Fw\[bdr3`e{U$ yJ]lk`Q3m. q Onol\[ebd weQ XL Q w`MOcebimdOyfZbi]lc`y/XQ \clbxm]6_ _c`iceXfm_ QQ n\[XOmzQOn\D]`_ bdZQRMv: 5ZMfPRQQmz]lbiPXJmTOxcl]Z[bd]lceX%XbdclPRTyOZiMObx_QbdZq>\]`Q\zyOZ[\[bi]`QmQ X:Z[bd]l1ZQ bi\[c`Q X¢X:¡RZbxVY]lX% PReceJmz]ZZ]lbic`yoX g yO_iicebi_m]QZ[n bdcemzXfOm \jD]`Z[_ MOQ`Q{¡ Xf¥£]lmZMOOQ \^\]l¢]l_^XfMOn cebi¦_ QQ£Z[MO¤c`bi]`\X Z[MOyOQ{\[c`bdPRy/ceyOmiQ(bx_Z[bdcZ(\QQw`yOce\dweQ3mzQQZX:MOZ[QT]Z[nobdcebxmtX Z^]lbxm Xf_ ZQMfQ'¤fmzXfbik`_aZ[XObdQ3cenBX nobimzbdZZ[MB]`Xf]_Q£§¤]`OPRXJbd_adZZbicec`XoX gY¨eZ[]`cR_ Zc`MOvOQ b ZQMfMf:] Q fwe]lQyOZZ\^bicBc`]`X¢_²aZ¡>\[bxQ _ ©(bi]lXOXOb°¤Z[]lc`biyO\]`ZyOdObii³ bxXfQ_ ]l]²ZZ[ZQbdMfced QX¯ZnoclMObxQ(mtZ^Z[m]lMOc`XfQ i_ oQ(ZiQ bi¤c`weOXQ XJZ_acTmZQbic`Z[ZMOX/P«bx´6mªQ Q§(Z:MOcfcoµ]ln¯Znobibxc`cmX«yObim(iQR]`¬/k`²a\[OQ ®JQ3bin%]£XOb°nOZ[bibi]`mzb°Z[Z[dM±bi]`³ XfQm_²fQ _^Z¤M9MOOQTXJ:no_aOZbxQmtbic`mzZ^Z]lXFbiXfc`¡>_ XfQ(mmª¤]`O]TmXJ__aceZXfbiMOc`mzQ X/Q3X±´B:OnO>Q cXfZ[_`_ ¡dQ`¡iQ ¡j ]lX MObx]l_^dM*ZQ\[\Q Xfwe]lQZ]`biw` Q]Zc«nobxZmMO]`QTk`\[fQ mQQ£P«clQ,X:§Z«]lv/PRQZtbddZceQ QXoX±gt¨`Z[]eMO_QBc`vfZbJMOQ3Qec`J\[ 9]Zbi]lc`XfXJn*mbdZ[MfmRbi_^biP«MyfQ diQbdPRP«biQXfX:]Z[Z[]QZ[mbdceZX¢Mf¡µbimL _ c`MOX:bxZmR\^]`yfno]lbxy/_aQ Z[bd\+ceX¢yO¶F\[c`biX y/cec`mOQ\m PRyOiQQ Z[PRMOQ coX:n'Z^]Z[MOZbiQ c`X«bdPRnoyOciQbi_ mb°XOZrc`\[ZrQ yOnO\[b°Q1mQ Q \X:¤Z^\[]c`ZP·bic`X'ZMf]`Qd Z[MO] oQ cemF\\[ 'Q P+]`X]` :bdXfPRmce]£\Qeno¡FbimzL Z[]`MOXfbxm,_Qbxmr¤O]`_^XfMf_bdZQbiw`c`QX«n{vZ 'MO_\[c`c`OXJkemtZ[M'\fZ[MO_ZQbic`biX:X¢Zjl\[]`coXfnon{f_aZ[Z[MObdQceXbdP«c`g ]{]`nOXOw Q]`µX:Z[Q]l:kefQ]lm Zbic`MOX¢bi¡>_^M¸QmQTbinonoQ3QmªP«bdZ[cem XfZmzMOZ\^Q]c`Z\[QQZ[bdbiX _]lZfMO]e\[noQ QTw]l]lX:yfZ[yO]`dk`bx_ Q]lmZjlbiZ[c`MOXfQm¶yf\ ceb¹ªyJZ[c:MOmzQTQ3nmzQPRk`PRQ ZQ MOX:coZ[n]lZ]`biic`mXc'c`Mf¢]emZMfmQ£Q w`MQO\[P+]`O]`yOX \^]`__ceZ\zbxZ[_ Q]lº mrOf\z_ D]edbx_noQ3Q3m]lX5¤\[c`mP¼Â`Qd»6Q ZceuXfVm(bdP+c`]l] keQSemÃfmzmbiOXO\kD]`Zt_Qecj _bic`bdb¹fyOZ[dMOQ3Q«n½\mQ3O_\c`DXJ]`_mtZ[Q3\m'f¾À_¿lZ~ bic`Áhj X6 bic`b¹ªZZ[MOMOQ«Q«mz_ fc`\zXfDmz]eZ_\[Qf_c`Zbic`S`XÃc`c`vO]stQMO_abiZ^Q m(\^]lZ[MO\^_^\[Mc` Okec`M mzZQ \[Q c ¾i3¿ Áh¡ Ä6® Ï Å:¬«Æ1ÇØÈÕ ÌaÉ Î Ì Ê,Õ ÒeÚl ® Ï l¬ ËÖÌ ä/3ÍÌÝÌ ÎaÐ ÏDÏÐ'®áåÑærÐ ®çeϹ® ÒÌ Ì+¬ Î^Ó Ï ll¬f¬ ®YÖ æÔoÔ Õ Î^Ð Ö>ÝèÏ ×Í Ì ÕÚl¬ ¬J®>ÞJØéÌ ÕÝdaÌ Ùo®hÚlÛe¬ ÚlÎ^®Ö Ï lÓ ¬ ÖªÕa®ÜFÌ Ì ç Ò Þ1Ì ÝÌ Û`Þê Ì ® Ì ¬fß ®YÚÌ ®®áÏà3¬(Í Î^ë^Ö>Õ[âê|ÏxÎ ß ®hÚlì(¬ Ð^í ÌÖÞ × ® ÔoÌ ¬ Õ Ì Ð ã ë^Õlê Ü,ÌÒÌ ÝÞ1Ì ® Î î. Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, B.P. 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone : 04 92 38 77 77 - International : +33 4 92 38 77 77 — Fax : 04 92 38 77 65 - International : +33 4 92 38 77 65.
(7)
(8)
(9) ! !¼ ,
(10) ) ' " &' . pQmZ'Q X:]lZ[\]lZZbxbi_c`iQ+X½_biPRceXfyO_iQbi_ \XOb°Z[Q«Qxn] f\[XOpmQc`imzofZ[\zbdDce]eX_Qno¤Q3Q m\[P«ª:pQRf]Q Z[X%bdcePRXfm{c`O]lweOQ º5PRQ X:p\Zbi¡+w`p£QmT]lXfq>mT]lx\] ZbiQ yOiidOQ3yfm ]l \ªZ£noq Q3m{]lnoyopgg _\[bi
(11) w ]`X: ZTx
(12) ] \ Q O y [ \ yOQZibi_¦]Q Z[ZbdMOcebxXf]lm XBj,yOi] \[c`\[y/Q ceyOm\[Q pX:mQ ZX:noZ^Q{]Zmzbicec`OXPRbiP«QZyfZ\[dbxQ£_bd_ ZQQ+ZzZ[XfQT]l¤Zc`OXf\[_Q ZiibiQ+c`X QmzbdZ'PRiyO]Bibxno_bdbxZmtQZ^]l«Xf_ Q]`_mzZbik`bic`XfXBp Q nBfXOi]6QTpmO:f\D]]`Z[_ bdQceX ¤QnO\PRQT§pQ`]l¡PR¥£bi°Z[mMOc`XoQ \g _y/¨ece]`ceX:_mceZQ\^vO]`xb]no¡ bx:_a»6OZ[bdQ3]`cemtdX¢Z[MObd¡'QceOX½r\[X%Q nof½_mc`Q \[XJPRpmzZ^Q p3]lX:evOZ3fij,bxQ mXf]lmQ J_ PRQ`_jOQ XOxX:] QRZTPR¤noceQbxXfmzQ«_ax]+Z[Q bdce¤XceX9Xfc_anoQ Z[bxObdmtcewZ^X5]l\[QXfno_ nobxQ+mzQRZ[X]lx] XJQ3_mtPRQ`Z«¶(pmzZ[ce_ MOc`dcooPRnoZ[bdPRQRceX¯Q noX:b°noZ[ZTQ+QdQno_QQ DmZz]lZbi[Q\¦QRªO´ \D]`qj¢_ :jrQfm£_]lQnoXfQ :nO bdQbdQweDmzQ]lZ']`bio\OQRº XO ^Q´ j ¡i¡d¡ªL,q>c`]lo\'Z[Q mbdX::ZO\[coQ3mtnoZ[fbdce_XfZbimc`X9]lonºO:OOXOQQdiQXOm c`Ox]weQ ZiMOdQpc`ª\[bdQTqyOjr\[c`_y/Q Zcem]lp \Q£ZbxXO_Q{iQ\[p yOy/\[c`c`Xfy/ncemyfQ+]`OmXO¡ Q ]ldZQ\Xf]lZbiw`Q!6 oZbidbxm[]Zbic`X*noQm ¤pifc`:XJ]lfX:_a]lZZZbij/bic`c`_X½XfQ'mbd:PRnoOyOQ b¢ipbi§_ dbib°]`PRZ[PRQbdXfQ3bddQ{mtZZ3ceZj/XoceyJgYo¨e]lZ]`\Q'_ _ c`:c`vOOXfbQ3mzmteZZ[\[fbdfceb _XBp Zbiimc`biOP«X6\(biXOQiQ'Z"Q \[ _ pQZ^_^Z]lMfZvO]eQ i:bi_ m[Oc`mQ'Q X:PRZbiXf\^Q ]`mtX:Z^noZ(]lbx_aX:noZ[ZQ'bdj/cexxX¢]R]«¡B¤¤c`c`FXfXfwe__QZZ_bibic`c`_ X6X½QZznonOZ[bxbiQmtmzZ^Z[XO]l]`ceXfXfO_ _Q`w`Q ¡Q+d¥iQRi]oZZQ3mz\[_^fQ'MO\zmzXODQ3]ebxm(e_Q'f] Q`wpj>]lw`Xocli] gg Z[]l]`yfk`yOQ3dm¢bx_ Z[]lMOZp bic`ceXf\bxm:¶ OQb¹m(jlx_] Q ZzmzZQQ k`]lPRyfQ yOX:\Z[co]l_^ZMObic`QX]nono5Q3m>_] c`w \]`ZQ X:º6Z[]lM:kefQmFPRyO]`\[bd]lX#Zbx:OyfQ]`m\zZ[:bdO\£bOnomzQ«ceX:nOZc`noXOpXOP«pQcemX:ZVt\[up»%mnOj ]l XfbibxmixQ] __]`cenoXf\[QmzZnO\[fQ _aZ[Z[\bdcecebiX m Zn\[ bxOnoXObdPRQTMOQXebip Z[\^bdce]lXO\^_^XOMOQbidQ£iQnom Q{yfm[]`:\(OmtQ Z[ip Q\[Zp ZcQwmbxQmzfbic`_X¢ibi¡ nObdQXfmn OXOQTD]lPRbidiQ{noQ{mzf\zD]e_Qmj bibdb¹x]\[Q_ c`XfmzZ\[f_Zbic`X noQ{m[_NXOQm $|× É¬ Ð ® ÏÇ &¬ %
(13) â+Ïx Î ®hÚl¬ Ó Ð^ÌÖr¬f®YÞ,( ÔoÔ Õ ÌÎÝdÌ Ñ® ® Ð Ì® Î Ï ë æ Î«Ô ËÐ' ÝèÏ3Í Í ÏD'Ì Îa¬ Ï)Î^( ÖªÔ ÌÞ1Î^Ì Ö Û`ßê Ì' ¬f®áà®YÚ3Í® Ï Ì ¬%Í ÌaÍÎ£Ô Þ ÓÔoÕ¤ëÕaÚ ® Ð^Ì Ìaç.Î -TÍ Ì+ÙOÚ*'Õa®Ï¹Ò Ï ÕÌ ÚÍ0Ô`/ çízì£Ö Øß Õ Öª'Î Þ Ì ® Õ ' Ò Õ Ú' ® Ï Ò3Ïx¬½ÎaÏ Í ¬ Ì{Ý Ú.
(14) ì Ì^Ð ¬ ÐÏ¹Ý°Ï ¬:Û â'ÏxÎ ®YÚ¬ Ð^ÌT× Ôo¬ Ð ® Ï ¬ Î Úl¬/Í ÜFÌ Ò Ì ÝÞÌ ® Î ,(, É Ê ,l É Ê , Å É , ÈÉ
(15) ¿o¡i Æ ) bd\^mz Z( QºO)%¹]l PRÉ yOÇ iQ O¡{ É ¡T ¡{ ¡TÅ ¡{,¡{o¡£ ¡{É ¡T¡{ !¡T¡{Ê ¡TÉ¢¡{Å ¡{¡T É ¡{"¡£,¡{ ¡TÅ ¡{Å ¡{ J¡TÅ ¡{Ê#¡T¤¡{¡T ¡{ ¡{Å%¡£$ ¡{ ¡Tl¡{ ¡TÉ ¡{'¡T& ¡{¡{¡ ¿o¡À¿ ¦Q3_c`XJnQ ºO]lPRyOiQ ¡T¡{¡T¡{¡{¡£¡{¡T¡{¡T¡{¡T¡{¡{¡T¡{¡£¡{¡T¡{¡{¡T¡{¡T¡{¡T¡{¡{¡£¡{¡T¡{¡T¡{¡T¡{¡{¡ * ƱÈÅ É %¤+Ê , Å Å /Å Å #Ê ¤ %Å $ l É & 6ÉÈ / ¡ 0OÉ ¡i , Å u ÅQP+ J]lÅ \[Â/ ¶ ¡TÅ ¡{ .¡T- ¡{Å ¡{Ê¡£#Ê ¡{¤¡T¡{ ¡T ¡{%Å ¡T$ ¡{ ¡{l¡T ¡{É ¡£& ¡{¡T¡{¡{¡T¡{¡T¡{¡T¡{¡{¡£¡{¡T¡{¡T¡{¡T¡{¡{¡ ( o ¡i % )Å bd\^mzÅ Z mtZ[oQ y¢ ¶ªÉ _ c`PRyOoZ^]Zbic`X cl4 3%c`6X 5 ¡T¡{¡{¡T¡{¡£¡{¡T¡{¡{¡T¡{¡T¡{¡T¡{¡{¡£¡{¡T¡{¡T¡{¡T¡{¡{¡ o¡À¿ ¦Q3_c`XJn mzZQy¢¶ª_cePRyOoZ[]lZbic`X cl48 c`XZMOQ{Xf]`\\[c vf]`Xfn ¡T¡{¡T¡{¡T¡{¡{¡£¡{¡T¡{¡T¡{¡T¡{¡{¡ , 9~O¡i# .% ¤`c`O\ ZQ É º m Q k`PRQXeZ^]Z[bdceX fmbdXfk_c`fyOdQ3nmO\D]`_ Qm¡r¡£¡{¡T¡{¡{¡T¡{¡T¡{¡T¡{¡{¡£¡{¡T¡{¡T¡{¡T¡{¡{¡ ~O~O¡À¡ S¿ >¦:Z[ºQ Z\[\^Q ]`cR_Z\biQ3c`_X ceXfclmtZ[Z\MOJQ'_aZmbic`Â`XQdQ wZbice]«XiQ c`w`Q]l¢X mzQ Q Z[wemc`¡(iw¡Tbd¡{XOk+¡{m¡TO¡{\D]`¡£_¡{Qe¡½¡T¡{¡{¡{¡{¡T¡T¡{¡{¡T¡T¡{¡{¡T¡T¡{¡{¡{¡{¡£¡£¡{¡{¡T¡T¡{¡{¡T¡T¡{¡{¡T¡T¡{¡{¡{¡{¡¡ ;=< É %F É . >?>A@CBEDGFGFGF. S. . ( ,. . ,1 27 7 :. 3S¿. .
(16) /. Î 'Ë ê ÌÎ Úl¬/Í ÝèϹÒÏDÌ Õ × ÚÔ`Û Ì ÕÚ Î. +" ª> " & à . Z MfQQTZ_bic`P«XJQemzbxjonoZQ MJ\']Z(]Q Dwe]`c`P«iw`biiQT ½]`cl__c`M\^ :noy/biXOQ \^kmOZc«\zD]eZMO_Q3QTm ¤ce
(17) dicbiXOk«biXq Jj¶ MOQ \[Q µyf]l\^]lPRQ ZQ \[bi³ QmZMfQmzO\D]`_ Q+]lXfn bim . .
(18) 3"! 3 w`Qdco»B_ b°bdQ ZtZ +ZM½MO¤cobifXOnOXfbdmRZ_abxZ[]lc`bdrce£XB__cef]`Xf\Xfnowen*bdQZm«bi
(19) c`&Q Xfwembic`m(
(20) iom#c`Z biPRc` %X*QTbi$ ¤XOc` b°\+Z[ bi]`mQ F
(21) 'k`_&lPRijceQmXeQMOZ^n]Q\mzZ[Q(fbdce\z!X¢D]ejª_Z[bxQ`m\[¡ ]eZ_^MOÂ:Q«biXObik%X: ]l]lXf\^n*n6\[OQ Xfk`b°bxZ{mzZXO\^]ceZ\biP+c`X±]lw`QQ3\_aQ Z[c`bd\X:Z[c`\)co
(22) nofj _ 3Qn*bxm£bdX] _ ce]`PRmQ yOioiQZmQj \+TwbibxP«mzbic`PRX9Qv ]lXJ+{n%]`¦Om[]lm yOj,biµ \c¯bdZ¾ Â1biÁ X±]lXf]lXfn%n±v LFQT+ \³bxc`_^MOy/Qc`XfO]`icem[mm+]`¾iP3 Á ¡Ì ®TL Ú MOÝdQî mQ ¾iQ~lw`Á c`bdiX%oZ[Z[bdMOceQ Xfm{_ c`X:Q Z\[Q Qº:Z'\Q c`¤(c`\[qªPOrx]ghZ[noQ\[n%biw`vQ X . Z_¾iMffSoQ\jªwemQ«Q m+/ qªj¢]l£XJÁhnµ¡ m'mz-¢O]lQ\XJw`DnQ ]`r_ clQm1mQ¡@Z'Q \^PRm£L Qk`MOZ[QQMOc`\coPRQ6nOQbxmTmZ[\bx]`_ Q Xµ]`\[,Q/Qbiº.JX:Z\[ZQmzQ XfZ{\[mzyObdbiX:\[w`QZQ6Z^\[]coiZbdnoZbifc`Q \^XJ_ ]QmZ[n5O]em\[v:QB %ZQ ¥£Mfiª]lmzMOZ]`Qm]`\{\nO]lQ3nOXfmz\fn%Q3°mZ^¦mmQQmc`Z[MOZbxOMf]lXOQXbx:ZbdXMfOQ Q c`¾ÀXf¿o\[QaQm[Á Z[m{bibi_X5]l]lXf(Zn½MO]eQQmzy/ºo_ Qbic`mz_ZX:Z[QZm+XfQ º:_c`QZ clmc`) i0fw:biOXObxk9nPRmfQ_^_^MµMf]`qªXO£bx_ m£ m]l¡|Xfn6VYXyf\Z[cMOwcebxnomQ6Qv/PRclQZ[ZM5Mfc]nfXfm bij _ QZ[MOZ[QMOQ Q cewe\c`Q iZobxZ_ bi]lc`FX ¤\[]`3PRRQ bxmc`]e\[_^ MObd]`QXfw`n6Q3n*2Q 1v _ bdQPRXeZTQ]lyOXJ\^m+]`_clZ'bx_ ]l]lXµ,ZbicPRceiyOmibi¤_ c`b°Z\ \[Q yO\[L QMOmQ Q(X:ÂeZ[]lQ Zbic`binoXQ3cl]{FbiXZ[MO¥£Q'mzmMOOQ\z\ D]e]l_XJQ3n
(23) ¦¡ QZ[MObi]`X m ]lyfyO\c:]`_^M«bimªZc'biX:Z\[conof_Q(ZMOQ¤fXf_aZ[bdce5X 4768 39 ;:<mzJ_^M ZMJ]Z ¿` 4=
(24) >$;? ¸ *nobd1Q \[Q X:Zbx]Z[bdceX ]lXfnµ]`dceXOk%b°Z[@M ! BADG CFE G ]`Xfn zjQcevoZ[]`bdXZMfQ½§]`P«bidZc`XOgY¨e]`_ c`vOb H Q:f]lZbic`X¢¶ CFE 4 3I J/4FI Se bdZMbdXObdZbx]l_c`XJnob°Z[bdceXfKm 4 LM 4N&OPQ[jMOQ\RQ 4N& bim+mc`PRQBbdXfb°Z[bi]` ¤OXf_aZ[bdce;X :S mzJ_^M±Z[Mf]Z 4N&O=
(25) '&8 T$ ¡TVhZTMf]`m£v/Q Q X5yO\[cw`Qn $ Z[Mf ]Z£¤c`\{] i]`\keQ_x]`m[m(c`ª¤OXf_Zbic`Xfm34¯]lXJn74N&j1ZMOQR³Q \[cdQw`Q>mQZ{]Z ZbiPRUQuQ kec`]lF\^Z[noMObiXOQ'kmzceZdMOOQ+Zbi¤c`fX Xf_aclZ[ bdce SeX 4Vbxm &`j,ZMfbdZQ'bxmzm{cedPRoZ[cebdmzceZ'X cl]l¹ZZ QZX9biP«_^MOUQ cemQ clX Z[ c6a¡ vJQ+Z[MOQ mbdkeXOQn%nobxmzZ[]lXJ_QR¤OXf_Zbic`X%Z[cBZMOQ _icemQn mO\zD]e_Q3
(26) & ¡ªL MfbimyJ]l\Zbx_Ox]l\ biP«yfdbx_bdZ¤OXf_Zbic`X6_ ]`Xv/Q'_^Mf]l\^]`_ZQ\bi³ Q3nv +ZMfQTZtcRQ:f]lZbic`Xfm¶ WYX[Z \4 & X >$^]
(27) & ]lXfn J/4 & %_ / VYnoXfbxmtnoZ^Q]lQXfn_ jªQ£Z¤MOOQ Xf_aP+Z[bd]lcek`X Xf¤b°\Z[cef`P noQ
(28) cl& (biZ[XMOQZ[MOkeQ'\[no]enobi\biQ3Q _aX:Z[ZbdceclX XO4Vce&\P+bim«]`Q3JeZ[Jac ]l
(29) & Zj c5ÏDî¹ZÌ3MOî jfQ bdZ(P+bx]lmk`QXf:b°fZ[f]`no1Q Zc c`(¡ ZMfQ noQ\biw]Z[bdweQ clZMOQ h V ª Z x b ª m  O X c X ¤ \ e c P À ¾ O Á [ Z f M ] ª Z [ Z O M Q m ` c i o Z i b ` c a4c` Se ÏxÎ ¬1®oZ[MOQmbdkeXOQnRnobxmzZ[]lXJ_Q ¤_OXf_Zbic`XRZ[cTZMOQmc`ioZ[bdceX X
(30) µcl a¡ªL MObxm_ ]`fmzQ3mmzQw`Q\[]`/yf\cevOdQP+mMfbi_^M6]l\[QT]lXf]`d ³ Q3n biX ZMOQT¤cedicbiXOk«mQ_Zbic`X¢¡ m]lOXJ\zn DVh]eZbi_PRQbbxmyO
(31) d]`Qi¡{PRmc+L Q X:MObdPRZ[Q]ly/Q Zc`biºc`\ZXBZ[Q ]`XJclXemzZbic` ZXSecc`¡ªXO c`L 39ZMObx_Q ¤Q{\[\[c`Q{Z[PcMf]l]\[QT
(32) @Z 39PRZc]`bdX bdZXfMOd +Q«Se ZtbxMOmcRc`nOi2QQ.f] nOXO oc`mQ3P+n6cl]lrbi7XbinoXce bdXO k«biZ[mTMOMOQ] bim\Q3¡ _ ]`\m J_biXbx]l yJ cebdb°X:Z£Z£bim¤c`no\2Q .JZMOXOQRQnB]lXfce]`XBd oZmMObiQ m »BcemzZ(clZMOQ'ZbiP«QTZ[MObxm(QºZ[Q XfmbdceXbxmXf]lZO\^]l ¡ )fc`\QºO]`P«yfdQejOb° 3 joZMOQ{PRQ3]lX6_O\[w]Z[O\QTc`
(33) bdX ajoc`XfQ£_]lX_^Mfc:c:mzQ 3 fdag jZMOQTPRQ]`X_f\w]Z[O\[Qcl,ZMOQTiQ weQ 1mzQ Z >c`'dK4Be yf]`m[mbdXOkZMOceOk`M X bdX S:a¡ ZMfS:bim ZQ MO º:QRZ[Q VYwXfX]lmiObimc`c`QRX PRclbiQR m3h_ Z]`MJjmiV]QZ((mbdbiZ X¾À¿ Mf/ bijF3no'¿ Q30omj¢]lMO¿ XQ Áh\[j1bdKQ PRZMOiy/bxmTc`bim£\QZ[ºZ[]lMOZX:QQ+Z(Xf_nomibdQceceyJmX½QQXfmzbxZ{mnoQ XfyJXJclce_Z{bdQTX:yJZTclc:#Zmc 35mbiXvObiXdQevJ¡QSedL ceXOMOk`QbdbiX½ZXOM kc`\XfZQ3Qkc mzy/P+
(34) Q¡+] _Z L Z]`MOcam[QRm46bdyOke]lX6\[Xfc`nZvOc iQ 3hP QT XmMO(bdcZbd MX biXBmL Q_MOZQbic`ZX MO/\[fZmzMfZ]lclZ( bdX ZMOZbxmMfbiyJm(]l_y/]`Q m\£Q bi m£Se]bx\[m{Q¤¬/cel\®¢P]RO§i]l]lZbiPRc`X6bi°Z[c`c`rXoZgtMO¨e]`Q«_dceQvOw`b1QQ:mQfZ£]lZP«bic`Q X¢ZMO¡ conOmbiXeZ[\conoJ_Qnv: ½¥£mMOQ \T]lXJn y¤/¦\[Q Q c`Z\[X:MObdcoZbx]lnoc`Xbx\_ ]`bd³ XdQi\ ¾ ¿Oc«ZaiMOÁQ Q+Zw`c£Qno¢Q bximzmtbdZ^Q PR]lZXf¡ªbiXf_ L ]Q'Z[MOQ¤Q{OmXJbic`PR_aPRZyObiQ c`ibiXc`_O]c`ZZ\biMfc`QZXJMfyOm Q\[clc`XO>vfQc`dQQOnPR\ ZmFc Zc`MJt\[]biÂXZrw`]l]lQ \[\[X:Q£QZ v/ ]clZ] Z[Z[]eM we_^Q MOZiMOQcQnT_ c`b°Z[Zt\[ck QZbd.fbxZ_ j`Q]`Q`i¢n5¡ kf]l] ¡¢XfZ[nMO] yOQ \^XO¤]`\[Q _c`Q3ZPn{bx_ Z]lZc£ Mf¡ \[QQ biQXOw`b°c`Z[bii]`wdbdbiXf³ kQ lm'nYoprq s8outo o,wOoyx{z|ouo q x# wrqOou x#q p o out 8tjx|tjproutV,Kq"x#n } x|x#nro @r@ z @ @rv x#q @ nroutohNprou @ @rv x }r o } t'oy@3 }h ~ q v }q x q @ @Yx{nr oh}v ou } x#q @} @} @ }F @ } = #>{¡.
(35) ì Ì^Ð ¬ ÐÏ¹Ý°Ï ¬:Û â'ÏxÎ ®YÚ¬ Ð^ÌT× Ôo¬ Ð ® Ï ¬ Î Úl¬/Í ÜFÌ Ò Ì ÝÞÌ ® Î
(36) a,
(37) «' B ¯+ T> " +T F,&'" l VY§X6]`PRZ[MObdbidm£ZcemXoQgY_a¨eZ[bd]`ce_ X¢c`jfvOb1Q3QemJO]yOZy/bic`ceXJmm Q{clZFMJ]Z[MOZ QT3±¤c`bim\[P QºZSeQ Xfno]lQ3\[n6QTXO]`clm(Z(Q noºobxyOmziZ[]`]lbdXJXf_QQTnB¤biOX Xf_ Zbic`¡XfL m MOMJQ']`m D]`v/_aQ ZQ ZXBMf]lyOZ\[cZ[w`MOQ3Qn+m¤c`cei\oP+Zbi]lc`iXJi mZbdXc ¾À Áh¡> _ c`XwbdXJ_biXOkkeQ ceP«Q Z\[bi_]l/bdX:Z[Q \[yO\Q Z[]lZbic`X c`FZ[MObimD]`_aZbxm XOc kebdweQ X ZMO\[c`OkeMZtc+mzMOce\zZ QºO]`P«yfdQ3m ¡ . !#"%$'&)(*,+.-0/!&. ZQ -¢MfiQ iQ bdZyffQmQ3XOm«Q _\[ce]`k`XfXf %mzn±bxc`nobiQXO\]5bdZZ[bx_ MO]lOiQ{bd\[³yOw`QRQ½\[c`4 vO¾ &7iÁhQ Z¡ P!c-FZc`QMfZRQBmfQ mkembiP«k`¤XOc`QQ3\^X:n*_ZQbiXOnoZk«bxMOmzZ[]«QB]lXJÂbiXO_XOb°QcZ[bi¤]`OXXf_c`_aOvoZ[bd\[stcew`Q3XQ _aZ ZZc%c5]`XZvJMOQ QbxdmRQibdºOyJQ ]eimzd_aQ biyfZ im %biQ`XBjZ]lMfZX MOQ QbdmX*P+c`i]lQokew`ZQcebic`dvweX Q* PR4µZ[MObiXOQBbibdP«Â:ZM*Xfbi³ cZbiXOMOXkQ §]`PRVhZTbddZbim£ceXoc`gYv¨ew]`bi_ c`c`fvOm(b1ZQ3Mfe]lJZ]Z[ZMObic`QX ³Q S:\[ac ¡ iQ weQ rmzQ Zc`) 4 iQZTfmT_ ]li
(38) & Z[MObxmQdibiyfmzQ (biiXfclZTQ w`cedweQ`jmbdXf_ QbdZ{bim Z (Mfc`Q'Zbxmz_ceQdoMOZ[cbdceX Qw`Z[Qc \ Z3Mf ]l]`ZXf\[n Q yO3hx]` X_ bdXOZ k
(39) 0+& v f2 1$ ¡ Z ·bdX ¿`(bdPRyOibiQmv: Bnobd/Q\QX:Zbx]Zbic`XZMOQ«m]`P«QQ:f]Z[bdceX S:aj MObx_^MPRQ]`XfmrZ[Mf]ZZMO0Q 1dQw`Q /mzQ Zc` 4 iQZ fm_ ]`dfZMObxm
(40) 43ª_f\weQ3r]`imc'Q wec`iw`Q3mª]`__c`\^nobiXOkTZ6c 5 3"!·¡ VY X½ z_ ¡c`XfmQ:OQXf_Qej 3h XZ
(41) 43: 9 $ ]`XfRn
(42) 43(Q w`cedweQm Z[c]`\[n
(43) & bdX½c`\^noQ \Zc PRbiXObiP«bi³ Q«bdZ[mQ XOQ\ke58 e 7 _at¡ .fkf¡ ZbiPRUQ >$ ZbiPRUQ >; $. 3. >$. 3. 36; $ 3<= $. 3<;. >$. $. 36=.
(44) &.
(45) @?)A $
(46) @?)A# $. RP)bdbdkeXfObdPR\[Q bi³ `QT¶(ZMfQ dbi\(Z[MOcQX iQ weQQ XOQ \[mzk`Q Z[ m£clbdhZM 4 Z[ MOmMOQ{cQ1X½Q_]eZmZMfmbd]lXfZk`ZiQMOQ'_fno\bxwemzZ[Q]lm^XJ _PRQ£c¤w`OQ{Xf_Z[Zcbic`XB]`\[binOm m(XfZclMOZ(QyOQ \[iQdmbiyfQ \[mw`bQ Q3
(47) 'n&¡ biXc`\^noQ \Zc Zc«Z[L MOQ{MObxQ mridmzbiMfyfcm(Q(m
(48) Z& Mf]l]lXfZrn ZMOZQ(MfQ m\[MOQco¤_^c`Â'\[Q£ Z] Mfw`]lQZ/QI :J/f4F]Z[I:bdbdceXJX _\[ QSe]`mQ\[Qm :nOO]`biXO\Q3k`m,QZ\Mfcef]lZmd]l ei¡ oZMOQiQ weQ OmQZ^m>clN4mzMOceOxn«_ c`Xw`Q\keQ B. DC &4EF>GIHJ&)(*K+.-L/ & Q\ke ON X X &UPST R 9 bxmPR]ZcwbdXOk+]`¡dceL XOMfk«Q'ZdMOQw`Q{Q\[FQmz]`Q Zdbiw`XOQQ{\[mbibiX c`X ce\[clnO>Q Z\ MOZbxc m PRyO·\[bdc`y/XfvOc`bdPRibiQ XePÃbiZL³ Q'M$ bbimªdZ[Zmc'Q bdnoZXOM6QQ.f\_XOkec `Q c`¡ 4\^ 5no& biXfceQ{X]¤Z[ceZ[Q \[MO_ X7Q(QT\[Z ZQMO]`@QOdyJ]`biXOXfceQbdn X:]eZ0Q mFXO$ M Zc+v/Q]lZ Q 4 & X X A X & ]lXf$ n«Z[c{Q we c`i$ w`Q 4 bdZMRZ[MOQ§]`PRbddZceXogY¨e]`_ c`vOb Q :f]lZybi&:c`XV;= 5 58 g7 = X 55¡g ¡L L MOQ{MfQ³Q mz\[cecRdOdQZbiw`c`Q XB,mzbim Q Z(4 cl X,46 bim XbiXfW no7 XQQAn Z[X \[& ] ¡weQ L ibdMOXOQUk.fZk`cROZ[\[MOQ Q{ ¿ec`\[bik`mMObiX2c(ÃY m vO45o]lZZZMOSRQ'ZbimPRdceQ'yJQ{bdXJc`mtZ^]l4½X:Z[bimm H biXf_\[T Q]eP mzQ3mQºoyJceXOQ X:Z[bi]`di biXZ[bdPRQe¡ 55 $Kg ZW 7 ]lXfn P u(x,t) 1. 0.5. 0. O. M(t2) M(t1). M(t0). -0.5. L)bdMOkeQTO\[¤OQ«XJ¿o_a¶£ZbiL c`XRMOQ«4yJjobdceXfbdX:b°Z[Zbi]`M di PRc`cmw`dQcemyJc`QRX½`jfZMOvJQ«Q3_MOc`c`PR\[biQ3³ m c`X:P«Z^ce]l\Q{dbi]`XOXfQ«n bdX5PRc`ce\^\noQTQ w`\QZ\zc Z[bi_PR]lbdXO¡ biPRbd³QbdZ[m£QXOQ \[k` [N X -1 -0.5. >?>A@CBEDGFGFGF. 0. 0.5. 1. 1.5. x. \P]T R ¡.
(49) Î 'Ë ê ÌÎ Úl¬/Í ÝèϹÒÏDÌ Õ × ÚÔ`Û Ì ÕÚ Î __fceXf\wemL QQ MO\[biw`QRXQmzZQ3nOMO_bimzceQaZ[Xf]`.fnXf\^_mzQ ZTQºoQ ]`¤OºOPRXf]lyO_PRZdQ«biyOc`ibxXfQ`m£m¡R]]`VhXfZ'\[Q n biyOmTbiMOXBXf\^c]`]`mnObiXOnoc`k bdZvbic`wc`biXc`fdQ3m£Mf]`]lnOZ£mMMf ½Z[]`c«yOnofy/\[X:bdQ wv/XfbiXOc`mTfkBbiXfX]lnoiZ[Q>MOnZQRMOwQ+XO]lc`iiO\[Q P+QwemQ ]lªc`rmnoQI Z[biJb\mTQ34F_ac`I°Z¡bic`4¯VYX½X ZyObdc\^Z]`M Z_MOZ QRbxS:_ TQ]lw`_ c`]`]`iXOyOwXOyObdXfclib°k Zg c`_ ]lvZwbiVYbic`c`X+XffmZ[mMOj:d c`QXOXO]RQ£Q _ ºbic`mZX:_mZceQ\^PR_a]`Z[noyJbdbxceQ_aX¢dZ[ibdj:QcenXQ£Z]`c_Xfc`tn X\[Q wbibiXOXfMObd_biZ_^QbxMB]lZ[ibdMOm³MOQ£Q c \(Q3Z]`mMOnoQ£]«Qbi\rkeP«]lZyfMfy d]lbxv/Z_bdQP+Z Zt¤]lOQ biXfX:Q Z[_aX]`Z[bdbdZceXOMf*X biQTXO4/k ZMO4ZQc«c`]`\[vJm QT]']l]noXfnObxnmzbiZ[mzbd]lZ[Z[XJ]`mXf_\[Q(_QQ]`¤f¢¤OXf]lXf_ayOZ[_yObdZceibibxXc`_ X ] Z[b bd¡ ceQeMfX¢¡ªbi¡ _^mzMJ_^biM m ZMJ]Z/I Jb4FI _ noO\[biXOk+]li1ZMOQTZ[bdPRQ{clZMfQ{Q w`cedOZbic`X bxm(noQ .fXObdZQd noQmbd\^]lvfdQejmc`PRQ ZbiP«Q3m_\[f_bx]l ¡ Ã
(50) " F,&' "B ¢,l < L ]MOZMOQ\QQ{c`\[]lQ\[Z[Q{bi_]]lZ(c`iQXf]eQTmtZ ]`ZtXfn c«]R\[yOQ]e\[]emzce_aXfZ[bim_]l¤c`1\c`XOyOQe\[Q¡ mQ \[wbdXfkZ[MOQ'mbdkeXOQn nobxmtZ^]lXf_ QT¤OXf_aZ[bdceX ZcRZMfQ{Q w`cedwbiXOkRmzO\D]`_ Q`j ]lmbdXJken XO Qbd n'Z[m(nO)fmbi\bimzcek`Z[PÃXO]`Q3Xfn Z[_MOQ noQ(¤bxOmtZ[Z^XfMO]l_aQ XfZ[cebd_ \ceQ£Q XZ¤bxObx_ mFXf]`fJ_aXOZ[wbdbibice:Q RX OQ4y/d 'c`]lbinOXe\[Q£Q2Z3.fj`Å XOZ[ MOQ3 Q£n ¡ yf ]l \^%ce]lÅ XPR w` QQ Z[\^Ê Q mQ \[Å bdi³ ``Qj n+]l XFno TQ3mbdÉPR_ \ yObiyo ibi¡rZ[_ bdVYb°ceZXfX+¤noOclQ XfQ3_n
(51) ZjObic`ke mzX/bdQweQ 4«Q X Xm[]]`]`Z[m Xbimz ]¤ mzmzbdffXOvf\zkKDmz]eQ I _J/ZQ 4Fc`
(52) ' I jO bd Z[m bZxm>MfZQTMOmQ(Om\biDk`]`XO_ Q3Q3n«¾ nO/ biÁhmz¡ªZ[¦]`XfbiXf__QQ£¤OZMfXfQ_mZQ£bic`noXRQ3Z[mcT_ \]{biyomZ[Obdce\XfD]`m _ Q]l\[yfQdfQ:m O]{biw_]lc`iXJQ mtX:Z^Z]ljX:ceZ XO Q£ZMf_bi]lmrX x]`Zmz\^Z ]lXf_cemyJXfc:mzZ[mz]lQX:bdZrPRbxPRm>Z[Q]`nOÂ`biQ ]lX«ZQ Qi +:fyO]`\[c`Zy/c Q \0T ZbiceQX _m cl 1 Z[Ê MOQÉ .f \^% mtÆ Zc`$XO
(53) Q(biX: ZOc{ yO \[Éc`y/ Q /\Å ZbiQ- mªÅ clÊ 1ZMO Q£MOmzbxQ3_^_M6ceXfbimn«XOc`clXOZQZ]`\[XfOn«Q'wbibd_ ZQ(Mw`§Q\[]`m[PR]O¡#bdd)OZcec`Xo\ gYQ¨eºO]`]l_ PRc`vOyObiQ`Q3j:f] Z[bdfce'X É Se J]eÅ _ _ c`- \^Å noÊbdXf k $ Zc«Z[»BMOQ{ce\i]eQmtcZw`Q m\3Qj1_Zc`biXOc`XJQ+_¡ ]lX¯noQnOf_Q+biX:ZQ \[QmzZbiXOkBbiXeZ[\biXfmbi_«yO\[c`y/Q \ZbiQmTc`
(54) v 5] ico_ ]l Â:XfcdQ3nok`Q«cl 4,¡+VYX ZZ¾ SMfMfÁhQQjJbdmmZQ :k`fbxm(PR]`yO\QQ3\[Xen½cZ^w`]noQ3Z[bxnbdmtceZ^X6Z]lMfXfcl]l_ rZQ«ZZMf¤MfOQQXf__amceZ[Qbd\z_ceZ[ceX¢QXfºB¡+n fVY¤X¯mObdXOXf]`k nfnO]lnOZtPRb°Z[Q cbdceX:X¢_Z[c`]`jFfFmyOc`¤cedPRQ3\n6PQ+mz]lclfyOF \zyOD
(55) i]ebx__ _ Q]]lmZ[X6bdce¾ ¿`Xfv/~ m£QÁrbd]`_ X%c`m[mzPRPROyOPRQonOQ{Z[bi_QZ[]ln6Mfr]JbiZ£PRmzbiZXO]`Mfk+k`QQ+Z[noMO]lbxQmtXJZ^]l]lnoiXfQ \_ mbiQ'bxwm£]v/mZ[QfbdZtwe_^QM%mQ Q ]`c`X m Z\[MfQ:Q£OmbiO\Q3\Dm ]`Z[_MOQ3Q'mªbxnomQ Â:ZQXf_cZbic`X XB]clZ ,]lZXMO «Q'ZmbibiP«XOk`QeO¡ªx]l\[mbdZ]'biQxm ]`clmzZb°Q Z^ºOm(]lnoPRbxmtyOZ^i]lQ`Xfje_ ZQ£MOQT¤O_Xfce_aP«Z[bdyfceoX%Z[]l¾d Z7 bic`Á ¡Xc`¢ZMOQTmÂ`Q iQZ[c`Xc`F]mO\D]`_Q nclobd/ZQ Mf\ QRQ Xf¤_O)fQ3Xf\mFce_a\[PZ[Qbdce:Z[X¯OMObiQbi\[m'Qyfm1i\[]`Z[]eMO\_akeQZQ«bx_^_ Mf]`]`c`XfObxn%w_bdQªQ]c`xfyJ]l](ce\[k`bdmzX:QyJZ3\ ]jeZ Z[bx]lXMOQbdmz XZQ OZy MOPRQR QX \¤fbx¡r_ Xf]`¥_aJZ[XO]lbdQceyfX¯_^yOMO\Mfcc ]`ceºom{mbiP+Qmm¢P+]]Z]lbimzc`iP+ªX«w]`cl]ld \[Z[bi]lMOX ZQbib°c`fnOXfZQ MOm\[¡Qbdwmz¦]iZ[bdc`XJbdy/we_QQ Q+mr iZc`Q MOw`QQ4 k`v\^m]` KQnoZ[.fm{biQ XO]`X:bdZ\Z^QQ PRk`\[cebxnmzZ(y/clc`¹biZ[XeQ Z3XB¡rbdVhPRZyObim iQ cePRv:wQXebic`Z[fQn mZ[c`MfXB]Z \[Q ZkeMfObim(i]`]`\ yOk`yO\[\[bic nOºombdjoP+bdZ(]biZ[mbdcePRXcebx\m QTP«Q2ce1\QT_ bdQ]`Xe_Z_OZ[\^c+]Z[fQmQbd,Z[Z[MOMOQQTm[XO]lc`PR\[PQ{mtZ[c`Q FyZMf Q£X ke \[]e_nobi¤Q ceX:\ZQc`]e _^4M ZbxmMJ]ÂZ XOcZQ MfQ'X XfcnoQ MO\[bdbxnow_^]lQMBm[Zbi_biw`m\[QbiZvJmMOQBc`Q']_4]`XOm]`Q Q\QT]lbd]lZiyOM6yO] no\[ ocebxmtm ]eZ^_^]l_M¯ceXfPR_ ZQTMJyO]¤oOZ+Z[Xf]`yO_vO\[ZiQbiQ£c`mXfQ \[m(bdw`ZmQMfbim'Xfc`_oZ5QMOZQZ[I JbMOmQ{4Fbik`IXOXO %Q Q3Q3n±n_ h¡noZbxc+TmtZ^Qt]l\[Q XfQ yObi_ biXOQ XObd[kZ¤bxf]lI J/Xfibd_a³4FZ[Q bdI (cevJX4,ce¡ O]`XfXfnon¯Q3nBZ[MO]`Q m[\[mzQO¤ce\[\QQm PRQ Q Z[m Z[MOQmQ£ZtcR\[Q:Obi\QP«QX:Z[m¡ , F,&'¼ , " " , l ª < ZVYXBc«Z[ZL MOMfQ{biMOmQ(bdXfmzvJQ3b°Z[_a]`biZm]`bibic`F_XFmzbifnojf\zQ3D]{]eQ_bxmªmz3Q fZ[
(56) 'yOc&lyJ_^¡ c:Mfmz]`QTXOZ[k`MfQ(]Q3Z :4Vf& ]Z[ bdceX4 PMSe $ª bdXbxm(mzbifXO_^bdMZbx]l]{ibd³Q] n6 Z]MJ3Z ] Z ]lZ$ Q3]`]`_^mMRZ[MOZbiQPRmQbdkebiXOXfQmznBZ[]lnoX:ZbxmzZ[4]lbxXJmª_Z[Q{MO¤QOXJmbi_ak`ZXObic`Q3Xn nobxmtZ^]lXf_ QR¤OXf_Zbic`X¯Z[cBZMOQ mzcedoZ[bdceX
(57) |cl a¡ VYX¯c`\^noQ \{Z[c]`_^MObiQ weQRZMObxm'kece]`áj,Q+icc`¤ce\] ¤OXJ_aZbic`X X X no8 bxmtZ^6V ]l XfQ£_ Q£Q 9 ºo¤OyO Xf\TQ3_amZ[m: bdceZ[X¢MO j Qm mbdQ{b¹f__^ceZM½MfXfQ{ZmtMfZ[³ \[]lQ ]`Z \[bdXJc«5 58m gd7 Qw` b°Q Z[¢M8 mQZ[MOZ(]lQ'Xfc`n½ m 46mzZQMOQw`biP _^c`Miw`clQ3m]lm QZ]`:bxum_ f.J_ ]lQc`Zm\^bic`noZXfbiMOXOmQ«k¶ ZtZ[c c 3_ c`¡ XfmzZ\^]lbiXfm¶ b¹ : 4 PMbim{]. ` 8 G g & 3
(58) 4 ~e 8 1l I J/4,I _ Q£MOQce\voQ Z[8]`bdXFG g¶ & noQ XOc`ZQ3m ZMOQ{\[QmzZ\[bx_aZbic`X cl 8 Zc«Z[MOQ'³ Q\c«iQ w`QFmQZ(cl 4,¡¸ nob°1Q \[Q X:Z[bi]lZbiXOk ~: ]lXfn 1`aj 7e J 4 > J"8 ]lXfn I J/J/44FI L J/ 4 ;$ ~. = #>{¡.
(59) 1. ì Ì^Ð ¬ ÐÏ¹Ý°Ï ¬:Û â'ÏxÎ ®YÚ¬ Ð^ÌT× Ôo¬ Ð ® Ï ¬ Î Úl¬/Í ÜFÌ Ò Ì ÝÞÌ ® Î fmbdXfkZ[MOQ¦o_^M ]l\Z³£Q:f]libdZt 5 58C 7 g J 5 58g7 joQ{k`Q Z¶. e J/45LYJ"8 > $ 8MOnobx_^cM¢Qjm£ZXOcek`clQ ZTZwMO]lQ\[\ 6]lb°Z[ic`M XOk ` ZMO]`QRXfn_^Mf]l~e\^]`_noZQ QZ\Q bx\[mtPRZ[bi_bdXfm(Qc`m )Z[4 MOQT Z¤MfOQ«Xf__^ZMfbic`]`X\[]e8_aZ[¡ªQ \[ubimzQZibx]l_ Zmbic`clX )4¯ :]l\[mzQ'Z[]lZ[ZMOQ3Q«mbdZX:MfZ]lQZk`\^Z]lMO>QT_¤OO\[XJw`_aQ3Zm(bic`c`X J/41¡rVhZ]lxmzc«PRQ]`XfmZMf]lZZMOQ'_^MJ]l\^]`_aZ[Q \[bimzZbx_ mcl,4 ]lXJn 8!]`\QTc`\ZMfc`k`ceXf]l ¡ yO\[c`y/VYX%Q \c`Zt 6\^no¾ Q / \£Á ¶ Z[c6 k`Å c c` XOoQOmzZ`Q y5Å ¤¤f \zZ[¤MO`Q \{É!biX%$ ÊZMOD Q+3 \[Q m c`Å io$Z[ bdce X½lclÉ Z MfQOmz oÅ mzZQ PB j, .- Q+ !P%f mt Z{Å \[ Q_ _a]lti¡FªJ.]lX%kf¡ bdPR S:y/zac`¡ \Z[]`XeZ . . .
(60) . . )bdkeO\Q{Sf¶ MJ]l \^]`_aZ[Q \[bimzZbx_£_O\[w`Q3mc`,Z[MOQ(.fQinRJ ª¡ iQ w`QL ¢MOmzbiw`Q bxQ m{Z(X'clbiP«]`Xyf4 £dbi]Qy/Zm'c`]«biZX:MfyJZ ]lceX[Z bdX:Z8 Z( bxm MOjQ_]`\ceX'Q XfmzQ8 Z[:]lfbxX:m ]lZZÂbi]`XOc`dX'cceXOc`kX oZmt]eMOZ[_ Q\[_ ]`_^c`bdMf\^keno]lM:\^bdZTXf]`ki_biZXOZ[Q Qc \[mbxmt¡6 Z[`biL _>¡ MOc`Qm4Qyfi]ebdXOmQ3mbdm Xfk ceZ\MO\[\^c`] f ok`m[M biX XeZ[biQ m\^*mzQ3: _aZ{X Z[MOQ ³J/Q \[4c ¡ ¦³ QbiXf\c_QTdQZ[w`MOQ Q'/mznoQ bxZmtZ^c`]lXf4,_ QT¡ cl ( c`X Zbx_ZQcRZZMfMf]lQ{Z³ iRQ \[bic«mªZdQMOw`QTQ _Fibicem mQ4mz Z X y/ c`]lbiXfX:nZ ZI cJbX4 mX f_^I M+ Z[Mf_ ]jZ ZMO4 Q{i y/ c`biX:Z ¡ri _ _ X c`A\^no4|biXOJ/k{46Zc'bim(ZA MOc`Q£XiZ]eMOmtQZ \[Q]`mc`XfbdXOkJjQTMf] weQ 8* X *8 jiV )3 X A 4|Jb4 ¡rL MOQ\Q ¤c`\[Q`j:ZMfQ'mzcedoZ[bdceX fZ[cR$ ZMOQ{biXObdZbx]lFm omtZ[Q P bxm¶ 4 h3 X 4NJ/4 e0 A Q:bdfZM9]lZbibiXOc`bdX Zbx]l e0 _ c`bxXfm(nOXOb°Z[c`bdZceX]+4 §]`PMPR$ bd dZ ceXogY4 ¨e& ]`\_ PMc`¡5vObL Q3MO:bifm]QZ[:bdcefXB]lZmbibic`XfX¯_QUbxm{45Z]lMfyOQ y/P+Q]`]l\[bimX¯biXB\Q3ZmzMffQ'°Z\c`bik` M:ZZMOg MfQ]`yfXf]ln y/mzQ bx\3no¡ Q (]`Xfc`n ZQ+yOZ[iMf] o]Zm ]PR]lstc`\\cedQe¡XbiX:ZQ\yO\[QZ^]Z[bdceXcl 0:ªbxmZMOQ¤c`idcbiXOkJ¶FZ[MOQT³ Q \[ciQ weQ mQZ cl'4BbxmnO\biw`QXv 5 g 3. ]` vm yOyO\[c`\y/ceyfce]lmQk:nB]Z[vbdce ½XJ¥£>Z[mzMOMOQ{Q\Q we]lXJc`in½oZ¦bic`QZ[X MOclbx]l>X¢]l¡£i¢L clMOZ[MOQQ Q\w`ic`Q iweoQ Z[¢bdcemX6QZ[clmr¡ ZMfbimyf]l\Zbx_fi]`\mzf\zD]e_Q'keQ c`PRQ Z\[bi_]lid no587Q2.f XfQm &?& Å %o
(61) r yfÚ]`ÙO\[? ]`Î d i® Q FÌ ,Õ ¡Ï ZL c Õ MOÏ
(62) jfbxmc`]lXO_ ZTQ(]`noXkebxOmzv/Z[QQ]lm[mXJyOQ_\[mrQ!cZ[w`MfQ3]n¤Z \[c`v P B Å no
(63) bd / mQ MO\Å Qc`-JXeO Z[xbin6 ]l% Zv/bi Jc`Q«Å X6ZMOQ! bdÉ ZMdc`\[QQ¢w`mQQy/:Qfm_aQ]ZZTZ[Zbdceclc X)4]`¡'Xf0eL n ªMObiFm bxm£¡(ZMObiVhmZ£QZmzQc Z[:]lfv/Z]lQQ«Zm(bi_ c`Zc`5XMfPR]l4Zyf=]l
(64) Z[\[MOQ Qn6mZO! c\DZ]`MO_ QQ _ceXfmzZ\^]lbi*X 4=
(65) f$;? bdX:Z\[conof_ Qnv: B¥£mzMOQ\(]lXfnB¦Q ZMObx]lX¢¡ L MOQ'L mMOQQ ZOclXO>bxy/:c`ObiQ XeXfZ^Qm m[clm>F clfZ[ MOQ(MO_iQ ce\[mUQ QmzJ/Zr46yJcebim bdX:XOFZ c`i{ZZ[noc 2Q .JX XOmzQfn _^MbxmZMJ_ ]l]iFZ iQ4 niVZMO Q f $
(66) Å bxm>% Å c` XOÉ i ' k`c`J ]l
(67) \^]lX:_ZtQF¡ Q.fn'kJbd¡ Jb / 4a ¡X ¢QºobxmtZ^m ¡ 4 5687 6:9&;<. >? $" #&R %('*),+.-,#0/*'1). R . . . >=. 4
(68) 5 68 7 6: 9&;<. . 32 $" #&% l ),+ -,#0/ l ) *2. )bdkeO\Q / ¶>L MfQ'mzÂeQ iQZceX c`,Z[MOQ{³ Q\c«dQw`Q¢mzQ Z(bimno Q Z Q\PRbiXOQn v +ZMfQ{yJcebdX:Z[m(MOQ \[QUJb46bxmXOc`Z(noQ2.fXfQn¡ >?>A@CBEDGFGFGF.
(69) 7. Î 'Ë ê ÌÎ Úl¬/Í ÝèϹÒÏDÌ Õ × ÚÔ`Û Ì ÕÚ Î ]Q«:vf :¦]lyfZÂebi\Q c`coiX QnoZfce _XfZ(0emTcl]l>bd\[XBc`QOwe\MOQ Xf\[bx_^ 6Q MB bdPRmzy/yOy/\Qcec`_ biyJ\]`Z[c:F]`mzXe_ Q3ZT]`n\biQ£QXw`bic`m_ ic`Z[oPR]lZ[ÂebdyOceQ oX¢X Z[joQ cl\{,Q'wZMObinOmQ'Qbic`m[_ _X±c`\[PRbd¾ v/~OyOQTjrobdZ^X 1:]jFZZbiMf¿`c`¿ Q'X Á XO¡clQ¦ºZbiZXfMf_mQ'QQR_mzÂebdZZTbiQ c`iZXBQOZ\[ce]lXfX¢XBmT¡ bdc`PROyOZ£iQ Z[PRMf]QZTXeZ^Z[]MOZ[Q bd ½ceX]`\c`Q B
(70) (,{ VY]`X«m,Z[ZMOMOQ(bxmªmzmbiQk`_XfZQbinc`X¢nOjlbimzZ[Q ]`XfyO_\[Qc`y/¤OceXfmQ_Z]Tbic`mzXZ\^Z]lc£bik`ZM:MfZzQ¤cebiXO\ bdZ]lbx]l\^fn{mbiOP«\Dyf]`d_ QQ`P«'¡ Q X:Z[Q ].OZ[bdbº ceX4c`]lJZrZ[]MOQyf]`yO\z\[Z[Q biw_ Obic`if]`\>m,bdZXfMfmzQ Z[c`]`\[X: `FZ ¡ ,4+]lbxXfm>nbdXO_bdceZbxP«]liyfbi³ oQZn Q Zv/MfQQ«O\[y1Q]`nO]Z[.fQQ nxn%v8* 4X X > 3h X A 4|4J/ 4'X c`$X% ] 85XJ ]lX \[\c ^vf¡·]`XfL n9MOQ¾i _0OcejrPRoyOjroZ[ ]lÁªZclbic`hX
(71) cl¡ ¥8 Xf_ bxQ m8noc`bxXfm£Q6Â:bdXfXcZtX¢c9j|49mtZ[_ Q ]`yfX m _k`ce\[bx\n\[Q]`mXfy/nc`XfZ[noMObibxXOm(k_ ]`\[QXmy/MfQ] _aweZ[Q{bdwenoQ \[i]` P+Zc ] ZQ3bx_£:f_]c`Z[XJbdmzceQ3Xfem fQ `Xf_ Q]lm Xfbdn yO :\[c`a¡'y/Q L \MO_QR]l\[noQ£Mb 1+bxm _ XOOc`dZtZ 6Z[]lbimÂeQ ZX MJ]clZT,ZMOQQ'm[ce]l\PRÂByOc`ibdX5Xfk«]Q no/bxm[Q3__a\[Z^Qm Z¡ Q ZqMfc`Q bibiX:VY\(XRZ[m{_c`cc`\^c`no\^Q no \ªbi XfZj,c']Z[noQMOQ3m]lQbi\fmQ]lX bdZMRbdbxX:mTZ[ZMOQZcek`MfmQQQ\mzQQ 1ZbdQi_clZ[vJ mQ'bdjeX:nOZ[Q Q QXOk`biQc`Xe\[ZZ[mQ\jFn conovJbi i_ªQ(ivJcmQc`QPRno\Q Q_ XOXO]`c`mclZQTZ^Q3]n5dZ[Q bdZzvceZ[ 5XfQ \^m Om ¡>yOjoqy/Qec`¡Q kJbi\X:¡ Z[_X mr]`jfc`m]lQR| XJ dn Q Zz_ZmzQ]lf\[i_^dmQ3M«jn Q`Z[\[Mf¡ kfQ]¡]`Z 19XfyJc`cej>XObdX:]lQXJZ[c`mn ¡ Z_ Mf]`bidm(iVhQmnQZw`c c`bxºomQ Q]xm bdke¡ ¤MeO ZXf_aQ£weZ[c _bdºce]lQX*X+imZ[no¡ MOQbd.fXfXOÂ+Q3n¯cl c`X X ]` m ]jªy/]lc`XfbinX:Z X D]lbximibdXO]½k«\biQ3X]l]yJ_ ceObdv/X:QZ«¤mcef\_^PRM¯QnZ[Mfv:] RZ«QZbdMfkeQ MeZ w]lw`ic OºoQQmimcl'¡ Q]`Xf\clQ ZQ Â:Xf cX X ]Z ]`dw`c ºoQ xm«cl X [jQ6XOc`Z Q
(72) u X ZMOQw]`dOQ6c`TZMOQ6Z[\biibdXOQ3]l\+biX:ZQ \[y/c`x]Zbic`Xµ]lZ X ¡ VYX noQZ^]lbiáj bd X X H X T X H 1 H T 1 T 1 jMOQ \[ Q Z ]lXfn $ 1 = _ j(ZMOQX Q½Mf] weQ v]lyf *yO]%d bimXObdPRkRyO\Q3iQ_Oi\^bdXOmbdQ3we]lQ \+i biX:Z[ZMOQ bx\[my/\c`fxd]Q£ZbiZc`c X X H X X T X X ]lXf n _K A 1 H X H X X Tjf X c`XO QT XQºo1 yOH \[Qm[ mQH m _ X X T ]` mX ]« [i¡@bdXOQ3¸]l \ _clcePZMfvOQTbiXf_ ]lcZc`bic`\^noXBbdXJcl]rZZ[Q3MOm(QB1m[]lPR1 yO i1Qm([c`¡ 5]lZ(ZH MfQT w`c ºo Qim c` X H j/ZMO_QTQbdkeMe Z^m(v/Q biXOk+Z[MObd\^n6ce\[noQ\yJced XOcePRbi]`im -¢Q Z bv/Q«ZMOQH ¿l~lTg XfQ bik`MvJce\Mfc:conBc`ªZMOQRwec ºQ ±¡¦biXf_QRk`QXOQ \[bx_ ]lii Z[MOQR³ Q\cdQw`Q rmQZ{cl 4¯bim _ cec`PRXJyJmzbxc:nomzQ Q3\£n6Z[MOclQ«\[¤QO]`Xf,_ay/Z[bdc`cebiX"X:Z[! mj1nOQ«Q2.fXOXOQ Q3Q3n6nZ[c`c XnoZ[Q MOZQRQ\w`PRc ºobiXOQ Qxm£clMOªQZ[X5MOQ+]k`w`\[c bxn½ºoQ m f _^Mbxm£Z[Mf]e]n Z#sz]`! _ Q X:ZZ[ c Z[MObxm³b°Q \[c 4 iQ weQ L>; mzQ Z¡ ]l%'XJ& $n Z ! Ug ( ! _ & bd0B 9 4! g [¡ 5$ ¡¯Q _ ]liwe c 5!ºQ ZMO QmbxQmRZmcl]`rbin¯w`c ZºocQ xvJm(QB]en ]`szn ]`sz_ ]eQ _X:QZXeZZc+Zc5Z[MOg ZQ'MOQ ³Q ³ \[Qc+ \c5dQ$ w`dQQ w`QmzQ ZmQclZRF cl4 ¡ 4 5bd$Q ]l\[QTXOc biXByJc:mzbdg Zbic`X Z c+noQ3g m_ \biv/QZ[MOQTZtcRmzZQyfm cl>c`f\(_c`PRyOOZ[]Z[bdceX¢¡ ) . !#"%$ "%$ & -#* EF>+.-+ $ *4$
(73) F>GQF ,- FG/.. LL MOMOQ,Q\.fQ \^]lmzZ,\[QªmtZ[ZtQ yTcbxm1 Z] MO oQm¢_Z[c`c£PRnOyOcOZ[Z[MO]biZ[mbd¡>ceVhXT cl3 bi3Rmrc`noX Q.f5XO¡Q3nL ceMOX/Qm Qr wjl]lZiOMOQQm¢X]`ce\XOQªQmzZ_ce]l\X«Q3n]`m[bimzX'bik`]X ZQ81PR0yJce\[]` \ (vf3ho/Q\F _ ]`di Qn Z 8150¡¡ Vh8# 0 39bxm c`XOi B3h3no24Q2\.f XfQnB c`XBZ Z[5MOQ'joXOcoMfnoQ Q3\[m(Qc`2
(74) r>]RbxmPRZMOQ3Q{mzM_ dnoc:Q3mzQ3m_ mtZ \biXOvOcobiXOnokRQTZclMf,Q'ZMO³ QQT\PRc+QiQ mweM Q ,Z[c«mQZZ(MOQTc`Fw`4,c ºojfQZ(MO 9QX¡>c`VYXOX Q'vJ_c`]l?ZXMB]e_ m]emmzbdQ3kem X j ZMf(Q (.fc`XfZ]lbx_ Q«w]`ZdMJO]Q{Z{c`Z# Mf8*? Qno2Q .fªXfbxmTb°Z[bd¬/celX®c`ZMO Q{5 w]`QdXfOmzQTfc`\Q34 m81Z[0Mf]@Z'bd jO4 ]` m XQ ºo yOi]`bdXfQZnMfQ bd5XX Z Mf Q'X mz7Q36_c`XJ5 n]lmzXfZQny¢¡biX_ c`XfmQ:OQXf_Q $ 8#0 X _ ]`Xv/Q'_ceP«yfoZQ3n¡. )B. CD&4EF>GIH " $ & - * EF>+.-+$ *@$
(75) !F>G F8,:9 F>G $<; & G *,
(76)
(77) F =?>I*KGIH. L85MO7QyOO \[yJc:8#mzQ0 bijmiNZc>yO\[c`MOyfQ]`\Qke]4 Z[ QTi ZMOQ«w]li]lOXfQn*mi«cl ibi8!Qm¤c`\[X c`PZMO5!QTmZ[]`cPRZ[QMO_^QMf]`\[Mf]ec`_aiZQQ\Xfbx]`mzZ\bx\[_c@cl'vJ4 ]lZ[XfMfn]l¡{X@L 9MObx¡ m bimTc`PRnoceyOXOoQZ[bdXOv k nZobibic`\XJQ3_a]lZ[>d ZcR i 4 ( bi X Ai1¡4|VYJbXf4½mzZQ3bim ]`nXOjFc`Z(Q\ce¤vOc` ;fidmz$cZ mzbiZXfMO_ Q+QT_^mMfP+]`]l\[i]e¢_aQ Z[\[Q \[\[c`bimz\^Zmbx_'biX7yfJ/]em46mbiXOPRk ] Z[ MObd\[X:c`Z[O\kecoM nof _ QTvi]` \kefQ XO\ b°ZQ \[mz\ZceQ\[yfm m yO_\tce¡KyJ.fcekf\zg ¡ ez¶.
(78) . . i8& iBA H Bi A A 4 jiBAN $. C. bdbdB B44M jjiDi AVA >>=; $. $. Z[Z[MOMOQ Q XX. EF X j4 jiDAVHGJIKL Fj4 iBAN\ J 4jiDAV E:I3 F4N i A GJI3KL Fj4M #ji A \\yJ1 {4 i A . OX:Zbi. Z L MfQ MObxP+m£]lPR\^]`_^M¯\[_^MfnobdbdXO\[Qk _Zbim£bic`noX@c`XfJ Q' 4¤c`jiB\£AVQ]e_^\[MQ:w`Oc bi\[ºoQQmTFZ[biX6MOQZMOQ Q«w]`Xfdf]`]l\\[Zcbic`@X¯vJc`]l XfJ/nj4Qw`]QZXBweZc MOºc:QmzimTQc`cl Z5 MOQ ¡£L k`\[MObiQ«n¡6_ceL P«MOyfQo_^Z[MO]lZc`bibxc`_XQ+c`c` = #>{¡.
(79) ì Ì^Ð ¬ ÐÏ¹Ý°Ï ¬:Û â'ÏxÎ ®YÚ¬ Ð^ÌT× Ôo¬ Ð ® Ï ¬ Î Úl¬/Í ÜFÌ Ò Ì ÝÞÌ ® Î . iN . iN 8 . 5. 8. ))Ocebdke\ O8\[Q joOZ[MO¶FQ'L _^MOMfQ]`_\[ce]eP«_aZyfQo\bxZ[mz]lZZbx_(bic`iXbdXOc`Q{ bxiNm¤ Uc`iicv: Q3iNn 3 v OXf b°ZA mzZ4Qyf Um biJ/X 4ce\[ nO,Q \bimZy/c+cl] Zw`QceX:biZnbx]lZiMOd 'bxmmOQ\vo\[stc`Q3\3_a¡Z>Zc£i]`\keQQ\\[c`\^m¡. ZZMfMfQQ«XmÂ`OQPRdQ Q Z\[c`bxX½_ ]lcl1hm[_^
(80) MO¡Q PR¥Q(f¤\£ce_^\ MOJ/cebi4_ Qbxm£vfbim]`_mQ\[fn6_ cebi]`X6/ZmMfbdXJQR_Qm[_^bdMOZ QPRP«] Q3 RmbiJX:mzZQ3\[n6cnObdX½f_ZQMOOQRXO\[\[QQm_c`ciweoQ Z\^bic`]lX6vOiQc`Q \[§\[]`c`PR\^mrbdb°dZce XogY¨edbi]`Q_ mc`cevOX b Q:MOfQ]lXOZQ bic`weXfQ \'m£]6MOmMOQ\coQ+_^½mMObxcom'_^noÂoQmZ[Qco__Z_QOn¢\+¡ ¾À¿` jFQ¿`QS ºoÁhyO¡RibxL _bdMfZQMOmQRQ \[m[Q+_^MOc`QfP«\Q3_^mTMOc`fbxm_QRQe*¡ m-¢bdQ Z[_^Z M5¤O Xf4 _aZ[bdceXf4 mTI MObx_^MZNO\[X5ce4 X5Ice\TclV ]lXJn 4 4 I V A 4I Af_ V[j1b°Z[MmbdPRbii]`\Q ºoyO\Q3mmbic`Xfm(¤c`\
(81) P+]`Xf n `¡ 5_ Q¤c`\[P A ZMfQQbdkeMeZ QmzZbiP+]PZ[c`\^m <I _ PPP|«clh J/4,joXJ]lPRQ i 1¶ H4 4 4 4 P 4 4 4 T4 P L8L8L 4 4 4 4 Y V X e c O > \ _ O [ \ \ Q : X , Z i b « P f y d Q « P Q : X [ Z ] [ Z d b e c ' X Q f m Jb4@ P (\[k:»]º I 4 I ¡VYXfnoQQnjl]`yf]l\ZF¤\[c`P y/c`biX:Z[m Q c`X'ZMOQ mzÂeQ iQZ[c`X{cl"
(82) 5MOQ\Q Jb4«bxmFOXJnoQ2f. XfQnj I J/4 I MObx_^MmMOc`Oxn{v/QQ3:f]leZcmbdXf_ Q)4«bim>]nobimzZ[]`Xf_Q. ¤OXf _ZQ{bic`fX¯mQ`bxm{¡ ¤§(ceOQXfXf_nQ{ZZ[c6MOQ'v/Qnobibi\X¯Q3_ayOZ[bd\^ce]`X _aZ[c`bi_ rQ+PRdQ3]lmºom{bdPZMfO]`P X¯mc`dce\'yJQ3Q'eJ]lZ]lr Z[c9bimZMOnoQ Qy/nOQ bdXJ\[noQ_bdXfZbikc`XBc`X%clZMOMObxQ_^M¯_iceclmQZmzMOZ(Q yJcec`bdy/X:Q Z(\^]Z[cZce \[m clHZ4 MfQ³ T Q4\c6PPiQ P|weQ m46QZ'bxm(c` nobx4m¡_ fL mmMfQQRnDbi]`XB_aZmQZ_MfZbi]lc`Z'XBZ~OMO¡ÀQ¿o¡ mzÂeQ iQZceX_]lX%v/Q noQZ[Q_ZQn%v _c`PRyf]`\biXOk ZMfQw`Q3_aZce\[m k
(83) T Z MJQ«]lXBXfcyO|\[Q wnobdQcem[f_m\[bdc`v/XOQQ3Zm MO¡ \[Q QR]lyOyfdbx_ ]lZbic`XfmMOQ \[Q«c`O\£XOQ ÃPRQZMfcn½bimTmMOcXZ[cc`\[Â6mzbik`XfQb .J_]lX:Zi BvJQ ZzZ[Q \ . F
(84) $ & ( "&>+.& G$ *4$
(85) F>G +I" G.EF +I-L/ & HJ"L+I<, *KE& " . Z Ì Mf®biQ£_^Ú ÂMJÝ ¡(XO] L Q3w`mQ£MOm QbdPR binoyOQ3i Q ]RPRPRyOPQ oX:zZZ[FQ¤¤n c`\[c`\[ZP MO]`Q{»6\[n mQ u(bik`X¯VFPRw`¾ Qce¿`Xed~ fZ^Á]P«bxZ[mbdQ ceZZ[X \[cbi_clQ FwenOc`Z]lMOiZ[w`]Q{Q{f_mcemzbdbi\zPXOZ[bikO_°]lZtZ^1]lXOk`cTQ\^_] c`ce RfOmP+yOi i]QZtZznZ[Q mzc O\ \mz Df]«]`\z_ weDQ]ec`m_iOyOQm(PR\[c`Qy/Zb°ce\[Z[bxmM_Qn{Qx] :bi `X fQ]l\¾ Z¿`bic`~ c`FÁOXfwvm]l c`\[ /bi>]`Q ZvOXOMOdkQQ ¤]lc`X6\[P ceoZ Qa\¡ªm(O\XD]`bd_Xf(Q XOQ
(86) \ mO\z_ D]l]eyO_ QZO
(87) \[QAm _Z[MO]lyoQZ[Q Oº\[ZQQ m \[Zbic`MO\(Q£v/vJc`ceOOXJXfnOnO]l]`\[\ Rc`v/QZtZ[MOQQ QkeX\[] Z MfQPR]lMOZzZ[bdZQ QT\3¡(]lXJL n+MOQZMfmQQ k`kePR\[] Q «XeZ[P+Qn6]Zz_ Z[c`Q \\Z]lbx_ XJ]ln k`\^] +P+]ZZQ \bxmZMfQ{w`g c`7 iOPRQTvJQ ZtQQ X ZMfQmQZtc+mzf\zD]e_Qm¡rL MOQTw`Qdco_bdZbiQm c`,Z[MOQTZtcRmO\D]`_ Qm ]l\[Q`¶. 33$( A. `3 ""!! A !%! A| $!K!K4#j4M g A 7 11 3¿` g7 A g7 A clMOMO.fbdZQ keQT\[OQ P+\Q !]Zbi~:mZQ aZ[¡\MO]`Q'Xfinco_ !%]l g ke7 \[¤] c` +\Z[biX:MOZQTQXfk`\^mzbd] Zt P+c`,]Z[ZZMOQQ\^»6j
(88) 1 ubiVmbdZP+Mf]`QTk`nOQ`Qj&m! bd\[A Qn]lXJZMOn'bx_^! Â XOg 7Qm[]`m \Q£]lXfZtn:c«!|ZMO]lXJ\[Qn@mMOBc`MfxnO] m weQ( ! Z[ AMOQ{¤cemz\ Mf]`ZyJMOQQ Zc!J-¢ A Q Zc`fX m
(89) biXe AZ[Q ¶r\[b°yOZ(\[bxQm ZZ[Q3MO:Q'fnO]Z[]bdZ^ce]RX ] ZzeZ^3]`a_^¡rMOPRL MOQXeQ Z(f. we\^mtQ ZicoZ_Q bd\[ZtP RZQ \[( PB! A ¡ L ! MOA|Q{, ¤mceQ\[__ ceQXfmrn Z[MOZQ Q£\[Pk`\^] !K i Q w`#4 Q Jg w7 ]` dO1Q3r mªP«Z[ccov/noQQ£im_ dZc:MOmzQQ. >?>A@CBEDGFGFGF.
(90) 0. Î 'Ë ê ÌÎ Úl¬/Í ÝèϹÒÏDÌ Õ × ÚÔ`Û Ì ÕÚ Î \PM. _ A _. !K\PM. _ . A _. . )bdkeO\[Q~O¶>¦Mf]ly/Qmcl1Z[MOQ(¤OXJ_aZbic`XJm ]lXfn! biX+Q:f]lZbic`Xfm e`ji3¿`¡ ]`Xfn ]l\[Q ZtcU.OºoQn«ZcedQ\[]`Xf_Q3m ¡ . . bi Xe~:Z[aQ j,\^b°]` _dZcobic`_X ]lidv/ 6QZtZ[MOQ QRQZtX*
(91) c gmO7 \]`DXf]`_n Q3m{
(92) ]lA\[¶>Q«bdZ(]lZbim]BZ[MOnoQ'bimzZ[_]`ceXfO_yOQ ibdXf1 kZ[Q \[E@PBE¡>j_Z[_MOceQ \[XnobiZXOMfkQZ_c«c`fZMfyOQ'dbiXOmzMfk ]`ZyJQQT\Pc` Mf!«]`jfmTmXfQ Q3c .fQ ke/OQ3\_aQZ ! ª]`Xfan
(93) A Q wec`iw`QmªbdXce\[nOQ \ªZ[cm[]Z[bimz¤ bdZ[mnO]lZ[]']l ZzZ[]e_^MOPRQ X:Z Z[Q \[PB¡,Vh¢Z[MOQico_ ]`JnobxmtZ^]lXf_ Q(v/QZtQ Q X
(94) A f]`Xf$ n
(95) g 7 bimZccmzP+]`d = 1^Z[MOQ X !.; $ ]lXJ*n
(96) A mdc(mnocX biX6c`\^noQ \ Z[c+k`QZ¤f\zZ[MOQ \¤\[c`P
(97) g 7 ¡ ZVhcRZPRMfVhFQ(cZ[w`dMOcoQ{Q__ m]ldQTJc:nOmzQ Qwebimz\c`Z[iZ[]`oac XfZ_bi
(98) c`Q( Xfv/g m 7 Q¡ª]`Zt\ Q£Q QbdmPRXabdPRyO
(99) biii Q ]`A PR\]`QbdXfX:XenKZZ[QQ
(100) \nyf g\Q 7 b°Z[Z[bx]mrM Z[Z[bdZcec:MOXc{Q{x_]l§]l\[X ]`k`PRQ vJbdQ' d;ZnoceceXo1aXOgY¨eQTZ[]`MO¤_ Q c`c`X:\ vO!b/ 3Q¿e:= af¡ $]lZ]lbic`XJX nK
(101) Se A jomZyJMfQQ QXnOZm MOOQTy+¤cebiXdicc`\^nobdXfQ k \ coI_ Jb_ O4M\[ mAf¶+I Z[; MOQBaPR¡]`k`XOm«bdZ]Jno_ c`QXfmmclQ(:OZ[MOQXfQB_k`Qe\^j,]`Z[noMObiQ Q X:Q3Z^mtm'Z[bdclP+]l4 Zbi c`g X¯7 ]lclXfn@Z[MO4 Q A nObibimzXfZ[_]`\[XfQ_]eQmzQv/QZtb°Z[M9Q QXZ[bdPR
(102) Q A¯ ]lIhXfJ/ n 4
(103) g 7 I ; MO_ bi_^M±]lXJbin m Z[bxmT]`Â`XOQQ XBk:]]eZm biw`4MQ« AN_ biX X `¤ ce\ ]`X Xfcen5X yJ
(104) c: mzgbdZ7 biw`]`QRXfknbiX 4# 3g ¿e7 a Xj¢v/cl¤c`Z[\MX
(105) c`kX
(106) ]lXJA¢njfbx
(107) m A5cw`Q Qw`\Q3cemtdweZ[bdQP+bi]XZ[Qc`n\^no¡Q ¦\£bdXJZ_cBQ{v/Z[QMO_ Qc`PR_ceQOg yO_7 iicebdXfmkQ \{Z[Q ]l\[XJP n _VYX icec`mQ Z\MOQ¤\[\ c`P ce\[QnO]em_^j:M clb°Z[Z[MOM Q Z[\ MO Q{fXemtZ^Z[]lbd1XfZ[nOMO]`Q£\[nbdXObdQPRwb°yOZ^i]lQ vOPRiQQ X:\[Z^Q ]biXOZbibdc`ZbxgX]l7 iclbd³3¢]Z[Z[MObdceQTXdQclw`¢QZ[/MOmQ{QZ^nom bxjmtZ[Z^MO]lQXf_ biXfQ(_ ¤c`O\[Xf\_Q3Z_abiZc`XfQwm ]lbximfyJ]Z[Qbd\zce¤ceX \clPRFQ3ZnfMOaQ ¡ nonObx]lmtZ[Z^]R]lXf]_ ZQ(Z[]`¤_^OMfXJP«_aZQbiX:c`ZXJm Z[Q yO\[\[P+Q wemQ ZX:c+Z[mªyOZx] MO +QTZ_MfceQ ObiyO\i\bdXfcek'dQ3m ZQ¡ \P Z[c]`_Z_ c`\[\Q3_aZi R]lXfnj_ceXfmQ:OQ X:Z[d ej:]`imc'yO\[Q weQ X:Z[mªZMOQ bi\[Xec`Z[iQTQ ¥\^]e]`X«m_ZZmzbiMOcc`QceXXclvJZ[]`Q MOmZtQ Z[\ªMOQMJQ Q']lX5XfnobxnZmtMOj:Z^QR]lbdXfZtZ_ MOQTc Q3vJmzZQ(Q Q ZtQ\[w`P+QcemTQ doX biZ[mZbdceMO]`XfQT_^mªMOZtbi]`Q \wec+QQmzbin½PRfm\zyODbiXf]edQ__PRQQ«mQ ZX:bxMfm(ZQQ3_n+cenO\]\[Z^Qb°] Z[_MZ ]lZzc` Z^_af]`t\ª,¡_^MOXO.fPRQ kJµ¡Q X: qªZ{1`£zZ[aQ ¡ \[j:P¼ZMf_ Q ]`XX½]{¤OPiif ½_^M+yOxvJ] Q ZzZ[bdQ Z[\m A. B. C. )bdkeO\Q 1o¶ªuQmOdZ[m clZMfQ'mzQk`PRQ X:Z[]lZbic`XclZMOQ{ke\[] RP+]ZZQ \fmzbiXOk+nobd/Q\QX:Z]`dkec`\[b°Z[MOP+m jOmQ Q£Z[QºZ¡ Zc]BL noMObdQ31mzQ Q \[\[Q QX:mZ O° Z^mr]l9 \[Q noQ mPROvoc`gYXJmmtdZ[bx_\[QR]lZclQn]lbdX«X9Z[»6MOQ u(.fVk`bifP+\Q ]lk` Qe`1 ¡L MOMObxQa_^M.f\^mtQZXO_ cc`*iOPR_ c`X¯PRmzPRMOQ cX:(Zm£¡>ªZ[MO]eQ+_^Mc`\[\[bick`±biXf_]lcer\nO\[Q]lmZ[y/]6c`]lXfXJnOn m mc`PRQ{\Qk`bic`Xfm c`biX:ZQ\Q3mtZ _c`XJ_ ] wb°Z[bdQ3m[ ]`\QTx]lv/Q iQn6jJ¸ ]`Xfn ¡JL MOQmzQ3_c`XJn_ c`iOPRXmzMOc(m]+mbiP«yfdQ . . = #>{¡.
(108) ì Ì^Ð ¬ ÐÏ¹Ý°Ï ¬:Û â'ÏxÎ ®YÚ¬ Ð^ÌT× Ôo¬ Ð ® Ï ¬ Î Úl¬/Í ÜFÌ Ò Ì ÝÞÌ ® Î ` ZZMfMf\QBQ3mzmMOibice_ QinOmbdXOb°kZ]MOZ Q6!J_ AceO]`yOXfibdn Xfk!% Zg Q7 \¡P+L mRMO]lQ\[ZQ MfXfbd\^clnZ«_Z[ce]ldÂefQ P«X*X5bdX:mzZMOc%c(]`m(__ZceMOOQ«X:_Z\[¡9cem[L mtgYMOmbxQm«_aZ[bim«bdceXfm M %cl)Z
(109) MO Q3AmzQB]`Xf_nkf\
(110) weQ gm7 MfZ[] MOw`\[Q c`OZkeMOM Q Z m[Mf]l]lPRQ+X:ZQ«Q Q3w`mn5ceMfd\[]`OQ yJZkebiQRc`OXfx]`]lm m£\£biX½ZeMO3Z[bxT_^MOÂ]`Q+XOXfmzQn Q3m[_m c`¡3XJ¿eVYn½X]`_Zce\MfQRdQ+fbiP«PR¤c`XFyOO¡«d\QZ¥PRM9XOQ _ QRX:c`Zic`Q3Ovfn5PRmQ X¢\[j¢bdw`ZZ[Q3M¯MOmQ §Z[Mf]l_ ]c`PRZTObdyOdZZMficebiQRXOXokBgtm¨`Q Z]ekeQ_PR\c`P+Q vfX:m'bZQ3Q3]`:n\fQRk`]Z^\^Z[]l] bdceÂ` XQX%PR Se]lbdX:aZzZZ[¡cQ \{¥]eMfXf_ ]eQ«_ c`mceOXfvfX:clmZQ Z£\[]lZw`XJMOQn Q m m[no bi]bxX6mtZZ^bxyf\m]l.fXf]`Q\z_ n5Z[Q bi_ vOv/OoQi]`Z{Zt\(Z[Q MO]QZQX¯Z[nOMOZ]MOQZ^Q]B_ceZt]XfZz_ Z^c5] ]`w_^mbdMOOZPR\zbiQD]eQm _XebiQ3Z£Xfm'noZbxbxQm_ \]lPcZweQn Q \[]eQ biXBm£w]lXOZiMOfQ keUQ ]dZ[Q3.fQ_a\[nZmz¡½Q3Zn_VY¡+ceX9dL fZP«MOMfbxQ*X/m{.Obim{¹ZZ[MfnOM*]lOZ_ Q«c`ZZiMOOcBQPRZnoMfX¢bimzQjrZ[Z]`DMf]eXf_abi_m«Z{Q'mZ[_ ]`Mfc`PR]XfZ'Q mzZ\^Q ]lbdweZbic`MX:iZo ZbiS:mbic`X±ZMOQbidQm bi\[P«QmyfOd°QZ«P«]QZ«X:Z_ Qc`n%Xf_] wbdZb°M%Z[bdQ3Z[m MO¡Q+L XOMOQbxmqbimno OQbiX:Z[Zc\[coZ[noMOfQ_DQ3]en_aZbdXZ[MfZ]MfZbimZyfMO]lQ y/_Q ce\ OyO i0:bdXOak¡ Z¥Q XO\[P+Qm_]lmzX%Zcec`y¯vJMfmzQ] \wwebdQRXfk½]B]lPXf _^QM%1vJQ_aQ ZRZzZ[]`Q \m mmc:Oce\zDX6]e_]`Q3mmZ[]eMO_ Q_ c`no\^bxnomzZ[bdXf]lXJk_Z[Q'cRv/ZQMOZtQ{keQ \[Q] XB RZiMOQ Qw`QmOw\D]l]`iO_ QQmm¡ bxm_ c`\[\Q3_aZ(]lidcbiXOkRZ[MOQnO]lZ[]RZ[Q \[P Z[cno\biw`Q_c`\[\[Q_aZ[d ZMOQ. >?>A@CBEDGFGFGF.
(111) Î 'Ë ê ÌÎ Úl¬/Í ÝèϹÒÏDÌ Õ × ÚÔ`Û Ì ÕÚ Î. 3¿ B. ($ *,E $
(112) F>GQF , $<; & " & /!& $ FG F ,O*KGJ&>F>/ G ."L+I<, *KE& . Onm¦oQ Â`QX:m[Q Z^_i]Q\[Z[bdZv/c`bic`QXfX¯m+kebxd]`mce\vfQ6f]lmzrQ ¤yfbxOno\ QcedyJbd *X±Q\zfZ[Z[]emzbdQ3Q3mzmnÂomc`bdX mfce_ _^voM±c`stPRQ]e_yOZ[mmoce¡RZ[voQ L \stQMfw_biZbxmTmzbi\[\[c`QQ X_ yOc`\[ZklQc gg Xf¾ ~ob°Z[j¢bdce1:XjJ]l¿eXJ¿3nÁ ¡ \[Q k`bxmzZ\^]Zbic`X+v/Q_]lfmQ£clFbdZ[m _cePRyf]`_ZXOQ3mm XZ[fbdbiPR:OQB¥QRXObiXfbxQmTmtclZ^ZO]lMfX:Z[]lMOZ Z'Q]%b°]eZ'nonoyfwQ\]lm[cX:_w\[Z[bxbi]`yonok`ZQQ3bimc`m¢j¢X*cl]lOiclPRce£OceZ\mzMOZ£XOQ6Q ¤¯cem\TÂ`iQ Q ¤i\weQQQ Z[Q`c`jXmzQ ]Z,Z{clZ[QQ]eZ_^MO_^MoM Q g Qw`ced wbiQ+XOk«mzMOmcO|\D]`]`_ XQQceºO\]`³ P«Q \[yfc«dQ«dQclw`ªQ ,Z[MOmzbxQ mZ¡ ceX½ceXOQc`ªZMfQ\[Qg mmOQ_dZ[Zmbic`clX¢JF¡ ZMO QQ{mQ Z^ke]lP«Â`Q£QX:Z[MOZ[]Q{Z[c`bdceoXZ^mznobxnoQ3mQ'_ m\Obiv/\QD]`n'_biQTXc`Z,MOZ[QMOyOQ'\[Q _cew\zbic`Z[Qfº m QZ[]`Ow`Xf\[cen+Q`do¡,mZ[bdL PRbdceMfyOXZbiimb°¤5 58Q +e 7wec`bdZ DioJZd mzbibic`XO! XkbiPRm>mQ3MfMO]lQ cXo\[Q gY_XdObi\[X'wbx]mZ[Z[MOZOQ MO\Q«.fQ \[0JPRmzcZQ{_ ]`c`X½jeib O¡_QePRO¡\[XZwMO]c`Q g .Jk`O\[Q 7f¡ ¦biXf_Q£ZMfQ'nobimzZ[]`Xf_Q£¤OXJ_aZbic`RX 4BZ[cRZMOQ{³Q \[c iyfQ dweQQ Z1c£mzQ QZºZbx\^m ]`yO_\[ZFQ¤m\[Q c`\[P w`Q3bdn+Z>Z]MOZ Q Q w`mzÂeQQ \i +QZ[mzc`ZX'Qy¢vjo {b°Z fbxmmbdXf:kOZ[bdZMOQ{Q mDbd]eP«_aZg Z[¾ ~ MfÁh]¡µZL b°ZMObimbimRZMfbxm+QmmMOQcZc`¢X*yJbiceX*bdX:ZZ^MOmªQ6\[MObdkeQ\M:(Q ZRJb_ c`4iObimPRXOX*c`Zc` noQ .f.fkeXOOQ\n Q 7f¡Mfªc`L i]eQ£MO_^Q£biMP+mzmzÂe]lfQ ke\ziQ`DQ]e¡ Z[_c`QTXfmªbim]`\\Q3Qm__c`]lPRiQnyOObdX6ZQnce\[fnOmzQ bi\ XOkZc ZMOcQ£__noObiymzZ[ ]`XfZMO_QQ ¤icfc`XfÂ_aZ[¤bdc`ce\ªXµZ[MOZc±QweZc MOºoQ5Q xQ mrw`cedMOwQ biXO\[Qk9Z[mMOOQ\zDQ]ebdke_Q½MeZ]eQm+mzZ¤bicePRdi]lcZ(cem \[D¡m 5 4 Q Z[c`MO Q'J/m4RbdPRnOyOQ2.fiQ{XOQ3_\[n'b°Z[biQ X\[mbdceQX¢_Z¶ bic`Xnobd/Q\]dc`Z]`Xfn{Z[MO\Q3mzMfc`xn . . . I. 4. 4,I . 4 T I 4,I . MOQ\Q PMPQ>noQ XfclZQ3m>ZMfQnoc`Z yO\[cnOf_aZªc`/Ztc{w`Q3_ag Z[c`\^m L ]lMOXfbxm n _ 4]lXµ v/Q½H bi X:ZQ\yO\[4,QZ[¡ Qnµ]em ]¯PRQ]emzf\Q6c`{ZMOQ wbiX]`\ZbxMO]Q{Z[bdceXOXfQbdmkeclMrvJZ[ceMO\MOQcnOcobdn\[Qcl_ZFbiZ[c`MOXQ'c`m Â`Q JbiQ4 Z[c` XJMf¡ bi_^M½]`\Qi]`\keQ mMOQ'c_L iX{QMO]`Qbi\X'\i BQ3Z[mzMOmzfQQ°Q{Z^\[m>bik`MO¤M:cc`Z, \ _ZceZMOMOdQfQ«P«dQ mz¹biXZPRcl_yOOcedZ[dMb f.JMOP«_Q]m[X Z]lbic`PRclX6NFQ .fc`.Jk`>k`fZO\MO\[Q Q«Q 7emzMfrMO]`]`QyJ\\QQQ Z[c`MOFQ'Z[ MOmQbdclPRZ_QyOcei\zQbZ[Z[./MfQ_ º]]Z¯Z[ bddcev/Q ¹XQZ_ c`]`_,cefdbdmfZ[Qm(P«mbdX/Z¯Â`QyOdk`Q \[cZQceQmXmQ \[Z[w`c`\Qk`bim½k`Q M:ZZZ(MOMfQ_Q \cednoObib°PRmzZ[Z[M XJ]`XfZ¡MO_QQ ¤mfc`Xfyf_aMOZ[bibdmzceZX¢bx_ j]lZceQ3On \ _¤\[\^bd]lZQ PR\[bxQ]¤cece\\Âno]lQiZ[dQ c\[(P«mbiXOZbiMOXOQkRfZMfmQ5QTmc`Â`'QP«dQ Zcece\X Q ¾i 7Á¢vf]`mQnc`X ZMfbim(nObimzZ[]`Xf_Q£¤OXf_Zbic`X¢¡ D)]lbdPRkeObid\[ Q9cl7O>¶ mzO \c`D]`PR_ yOQOmjOZ[]mzQZ[bdQ£ceZX9QºclZ3 ¡ Z[MOQ mÂ`QdQ ZceXfm{cl]. = #>{¡.
(113) ì Ì^Ð ¬ ÐÏ¹Ý°Ï ¬:Û â'ÏxÎ ®YÚ¬ Ð^ÌT× Ôo¬ Ð ® Ï ¬ Î Úl¬/Í ÜFÌ Ò Ì ÝÞÌ ® Î . C$ & & F. S. & EF>GI" $ +LE $ F>G * /!& > & /" & $ " . VYyOX\[c`Z[vOMOibxQ mPx]`clmzªZ£mz]`ZyOQyO\Qibic_]\Z[Q3bd_ceceX¢Xfj1mtZ[\Q«J_amzZMObicc`X ¤Mf\[cc`P c` O\T]lyOyfw\biQ c:(]`_^mM6v:]l BidPRc(Qm]`Xf]m(Dc`]eªmtZ[]Q \Tqª_£ce>X:weghnOQ \\[bik`w`QQXfX½_Q{mzf\zDMO]eQ_X5Q'mbic`X:iZw\[bdcXOnOkf_ZMOQ3n Q vmbd keXO)fQb ./]`_ O]lk`X:QZ'\[]em[m ] w:]lbiXJXOn k:mT+TQQ]`\_^biMw`QZ[XµbdPRbdQRX Z¾dMf Q ¿3Áh_¡ c:mt»BZ'c`c`\[QZ[MOk`Q Q Xf_Q ce\^PR]liyOd eojZ[]lZZMObiQ%c`X%PRclQZ[MOZMfcoQn w`noQQ3dcom_ _\bdZtbiv/ 6QZ[n@Q \[bdP X Z3MObxbxm6m']lMO\bik`ZbxM¢_¡iQ½VYXc`/ZQMO\[Qm mzZQ \[Q cR]lyfyOdbx_ ]lZbic`XZMObxmweQ ic_ b°Zt bim kebdweQ X v: 1¶ Se 3 Vd A J L\! biPRMO]`Qk`\Q3Q md cl>bxZmMfZQ'MOZQ\[bxP«nobdQ3PR]lQX9Xfmz_ biOc`\XJw]l]lFZOm[_\[QQ+XOclQ{ Z
Documents relatifs
It is obvious that the steel showed the plastic strain memory effects at each test temperature, in other words, in spite of the hardness of the steel cyclic stress,
Les cités et leur territoire d'influence sont administrées par de puissantes familles, celles de l'aristocratie terrienne et marchande, qui tirent leur légitimité de
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des
In this paper, we have defined the steady-state control problem for MDP, and shown that this question is decidable for (ergodic) MDP in polynomial time, and for labeled MDP
constat, unanime en Colombie, que la résolution des conflits par élimination de “l’opposant” est l’une des caractéristiques de la violence nationale. Première
Automatic test data generation, structural testing, constraint solving techniques, global constraints 1.. Structural testing techniques are widely used in unit or module testing
Trois autres échantillons du pool CHAT étaient également gardés au Center for Disease Control et ont été inclus dans cette analyse (CHAT pool 13, CHAT type 1 Wy4B-5, CHAT 1FL)..
Un habitat de La Tène moyenne et finale à Berry-au-Bac au lieu-dit “ Le Chemin de la Pêcherie ” (Aisne).. Jérôme Dubouloz, Michel Plateaux,
