• Aucun résultat trouvé

Adjuncts and the Syntax of Subjects in Old and Middle English

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Partager "Adjuncts and the Syntax of Subjects in Old and Middle English"

Copied!
26
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

Book Chapter

Reference

Adjuncts and the Syntax of Subjects in Old and Middle English

HAEBERLI, Eric

Abstract

Old English (OE) shows characteristic properties of a Verb Second (V2) language. However, certain phenomena can be found in OE which suggest that V2 in this language cannot be dealt with in terms of analyses that have been proposed for the Modern Germanic V2 languages. Different alternative analyses have therefore been explored in the literature which account for the different properties of OE. Although there seems to be a general consensus on certain points, the different analyses vary with respect to several issues. In this paper, some of these issues are addressed and it is argued that important evidence can be obtained from a comparative analysis of OE, later stages in the history of English and the Modern Germanic languages with respect to phenomena concerning the distribution of adjuncts and subjects. In addition, it is shown not only that the comparative evidence used provides information for the analysis of OE, but also that the OE data contribute to a more detailed understanding of a general Germanic word order phenomenon.

HAEBERLI, Eric. Adjuncts and the Syntax of Subjects in Old and Middle English. In: S. Pintzuk, G. Tsoulas and A. Warner. Diachronic Syntax: Models and Mechanisms. Oxford : Oxford Universtiy Press, 2000. p. 109-131

Available at:

http://archive-ouverte.unige.ch/unige:35360

Disclaimer: layout of this document may differ from the published version.

1 / 1

(2)

! " # !

! ! #

$ # ! " %

& !

! " ' ! #

!

! " ( # !

! #

# #

$ # ! #

! )! ! ) " (

# ! #

! ! # !

# # "

*" ( ! + & ! )

' # $ $ # !

& #

# ! " , #

! !

## ! " ' #

$ # ! & # #

- # ./0+ 0 "

1 2 3 2 ' , ( 4 5

' !

6, ! "6

( ) ##

"

&

! $ # ! !

7 & # $

# ! " ( # ! )

8 # ! 9 %

& : ; < =! ../ 4

( : > ! $

'! ! ../ " ( ! < < ! !

!# ! ## ! " ' #

! # "

(3)

! # "

" " - # ./0+ 4. " 8 7!< .. + 55 " 4 ..5 " ,

! & # # 8 7!< .. + 4 "

1 ! # 3 1 3 2 :8 *4" 0

<

6 < "6

, & # ) " ?!

! )

# ! ) 5 "

; & ! ) !

# ! ! @

! ! ! # < 6 6 "

- # ./0 8 7!< .. ..5 " &

! 5 "

5 1 3 A # # B> C" //

! # 6 <

6D ! < # E6

( 5 ! ) @ ! ! ) # "

5

! ! 7 #

$ # ! " "

# F8@# # 1 :83 # # :" (

# < 5

! ! !# ! ) !

! ! ! < !

@ # ! ) @

: # & " 5

( F # #

7 # " : G H .. ! < G

- # ..0 - # ../ - G , ..0 8 7!<

.. ..5 " #

I J # K @ J @ # +

C 1:8 1F8 I 1;8 @ """ 333

: F C !

# # 1 :83"

! ) ! ! ) "

( # C ! @# # F

! ! ) " (

(4)

5

# F ! ! ) ! " ( 5

# : ! ) !

"

% # !

C !

! " , # ! 9 "

9 ( , ! @# # F C

+ ( 8 7!< .. ..5K L ! < G - #

..0K ' : G H .. K ' !

- G , ..0 "

(( , ! ! ) 1 ;83 C +

1 83 8 7!< .. ..5K 1 ,83 ! < G

- # ..0K 1 ' 83 : G H .. "

((( , 1 :83 ! < G

- # ..0 - G , ..0K 1 (83 8 7!<

.. ..5K 1 ' 83 : G H .. "

( ( ! !

! ) )! $ $

# ! ( ((( " L! # (

C !

$ # ! ! M$

#

# $ # ! "

, # 7 " (

# ( !

! $ # !

! " 5

" C !

# 9 !## 7

"

*" ' ) ! ) !

*" " ' ! ! """

, # ! &

$ # ! #

' # ! N! @ # ! )

# ! ) ! ! " " 1 F83

! ! C & # 0" " ' !

! ! ! ! ! " (

" ?! " ...+ 0 /

! "

(5)

C

! ! )!

## ! ) " ( # !

6F8@ ! ) 6 ! # #

! " , ! * #

! )! 88 & # K "

...+ C < ..9 # "

* " D < !

" $ O 7 <!

" D ) )< P 7 <

" D < < 7) < )

" D < < O <

8 = @ # !

68 = ! # "6

" $ # < # 7 < 7

" ! O " < ! # Q 2

8 = M$" ! #

68 = ! # "6

" % ! O ! <R

" % S < < ! ! <T

)" % < << ! ! <)R

, M # ! M !

6, # ! M ! "6

( # %! L ; U )!

! )

D L # ' < ( % "5

' ! ! )!

! ! ! #

! " , N!

! @ ! ) @ )

! " !

# )! " , ! ! !#

! 6F8@ ! ) 6 )! (8

# ! ! )! " " "

# ..5 < ..9 "

?! ! ! # # " ,

# N! ! 6F8@

! ) 6 ! ## " # !

(8@ )! ! # " "

! ## ! 6 ! !

5 U # # ! $ &

6 ! 6+

# O ! # E

(6)

9

# ! (8@ )! !

N! !

" ( !

6 #! ! 6 # !

! ## 6F8@ ! ) 6 ! N!

# ! " ' # N! #

)! ! #" ( *

# ! (8@

)! # ! #

# !

! ! #" ( !

& ! ! ! * "

( ! * N!

# #

)! # " '

...+ C " , #

# + ' ' )! # & #

) ! ! )!

! ) ! (8 ! ! ! ' 8

,8 ! ! K ? : * !

& ! ) K #

! ! ! ) )

! ) ! ! )

! ! ! ! ) @ )

! ) # ! )

&" , ! 0 J # "

0 " 1:8 V8 1F8 """ 1;8 """ 333

" 1:8 V8 1F8$%""" 33 @ ! ) )

" 1:8 V8 1F8 """ 1;8$%""" 333 @ ! ) @ )

N! # # 0" )!

! ! ! ) "

)! # & # ) "

' # " L )!

! ! ! )

L8 # ' & ! ..0 : N!

- ..C " , )! F6@ )

!# & # : # < ..9+

59 " , !## 7 / "

/ " 1:8 V8&1F8 F 1L8 L 1;8$%""" 3333

" 1:8 V8&1F8 1F6 1F6 F 1;8$%""" 33333

(7)

*

, # /

/" )! F /" "

?! # : $ #

! F

# # $ # !

/ "

' !# )! !

/ 6F8@ ! ) 6 # #

! 7 # ! ! 0

# & ! ) " > !

0" ) ! 0"

@ ! ) @ ) " ' ! ...+

C ! !

* & # ##

! ! ! # #

@ & " L

$ # ! ! (

# " D

! ! ! ! 0 /

! !

# $ # ! "

*" " W

* ! # !

!

! ! !

& " *" " *

## " ( $ #

! # 6F8@

! ) 6 " ' & # < ..9+ 45 "

# ! ) < ! !

) ! < #

6F8@ ! ) 6 @ # ! ) " ,

! ) ! . ! # *"

. "

. " D O < ! "

8 @ # !

" D < !

8 = @ # !

, ." ." 7 !#

< ! ) ! ! ! )

! < # 1 F83 0" / " , #

(8)

0

& # < $ # !

C " ,

! ) #

! ) #

: ! )! " , #

! 4 4"

4" $ # $ "

! ." ." # "

4 " + 1:8 W 1F8 I & 1;8 @ """ 333

" $ "+ 1:8 W& 1F8 I 1;8 @ """ 333

, ! # " @ #

! ) N! $ # ! " ?!

$ # ! # ! !

# )! & # /

"

/ " 1:8 V8&1F8 F 1L8 L 1;8$%""" 3333

" 1:8 V8&1F8 1F6 1F6 F 1;8$%""" 33333

( / )! # "

# & # ) F8 ;8 /"

)! F6 /" " , # <

" ' # @

: ! "K " 5

! F ! : !

" & # ! ! 4" " , # @

! ) )! ! ! F6@ ) " /"

@ ! ) @ ) ! ! #

:" ( & # F @ ! )

@ ) ! ! ! ) F6

! " ( # !

) F ;8 " /" @ ! ) @ )

! # : F"

! / "

, ! # !

* " L N!

!

! ! "

!

@ ! ) @ ) $

! ! ! 9 "

(9)

/

*"5 @ ! ) @ ) C

> ! ! " " N!

! )

@ # ! )

! # ! 6F8@ ! ) 6

"

*"5" # # # <

' < ! )

) " N!

# ! ! *" " (

! # ! ! )

@ ) +

' ' # #

! ) ! # #

@ # ) "

A ' ()

: ' 9C"0.4"

# ' "

6( # ' 6

? ' !# ! !

! ) "

A ! > ( 4"0C"

# # #

6, # # #"6

: , ! ) )! "

5 A * ! ? 9 "0

#! #

6, # 6

L ! # & ! ) ,

: ! " ' , ' !#

1 ;83 ! ) ! ! C 4 " L & #

! ! ) ! !

C( # < # ../ ? < @

@'# #@ < 8 : !

# ! "

(10)

.

! ) !# " " H ..0 8 7!<

../ " ' , ? ! #

& ! ) ! !

! " , ! <

( D L # N! @ ! ) )

" & # *" *" ) !

! ) " " " G 8 7 < ..9+9.

( # ..*+ C D L # " , # !

! @ ! ) @ )

& ! ! )

) ! ! # )

# ! )

! # # " !

, ? # # & ! ) "

( , ' , ?

! # ! & ! ) ! "

../ ! "

( ( ! , : ! " ?! !

*" @ !

& @ ! ) @ ) # @ @:

# # & & @# # )

:8 " ! ! C " , & # & "

*"5" @ ! ) @ ) @# # :

@# # : ! !

! ! < " , ! )

) &

# # ! " 8 7!< .. + C - # ..*

& # ! :

! ) " , C "

C " U !' * A &

""" %5 9/" "9/"5

# @ < """

6 < """6

" !"" !' A > 4"0C"

# @< # # 6 @ @ !

6' ! # 6 @ ! "6

88 )! ! " 5 %8 )! +

(11)

4

9 " G 2 2

! 6 @#!

6, #! ! 6 "6

D # 0*" /

" A ' % * * AX 2

# ! 6 @

6' # ! "6

? " 9 " 4

*"5"5 @ ! ) @ ) @# # : F

@ ! ) @ ) @ @: & !

! & # :" '

& # 88 )! !

! ) & "

* " # " ! X ' , C "9 " 4

# < !

6, < # ! "6

" G ' # + , #

# """ : ' * "/5*"

# $ < ? D @ &

< &

6 $ < ? D @ & <

& # "6

" ' # ) " ! A

?! #! ! ! @< : !

6?! ! < : ! #! ! "6

D # 0"5C

" ( 2 ' $ # " #

( # $ 6 ! D! <

6' # D! < $ "6

? 5" *4"

( *" @ ) #

: " *" " L *" @ )!

@# # : " D

! 6F8@ ! ) 6 #

:"

( !## C * 6F8@ ! ) 6 !

# " !

(12)

# # # ! *

N! ) ! ) "9

*"5"C ' N! + # )!

' ! *" " $ #

! ! ) &

! # ! ) ! @ #

! ) " ?! ! )

# " ( !

$ #

! # )! ! !

! ) " , 0 " 4 "

0 " + 1:8 W 1F8 I & 1;8 @ """ 333

" $ "+ 1:8 W& 1F8 I 1;8 @ """ 333

' ! *" " $ # !

! )!

0" " ! @ ! )

@ ) # 7 # #

)! " " # )! F8 ;8 0 !

! # # )!

0 + ) F6 !

! ) F8 ;8 " & # / " '

! *" " # ! "

9L # & # @ ! ) @ ) ! !

! ! ! 4 $ # !

! ! # # ! ) " !

! ! ! ! @ ! ) & #

"

$ # # # ) ! ' ) '

' ! " B> 5 0C"0C

# # !

6 ! # "6

! ! # # ! )

! ! & # ! #

# )! "

( !# ! ! ) #

@ ! ) @ ) ! ! !

4 $ # ! ! ) "

( !# # # &

! ) " $ & # C * #

! ! & " "

@ ! ) @ ) $ # # "

, # & # ! "

(13)

' * 6F8@ ! ) 6

# F :" , # )! @

! ) ! F6@ ) ! #! !

) F ;8"* , !

! ! 6F8@ ! ) 6 @# # F+

/ """ 1F8 &1L8 L 1;8$%""" 3333

, ! ! / /" "

, ! )! @ ! ) #!

! ! ) F8 ;8"

! !

)! # $ # ! "

, ! # !

# ! )! !

@# # #

! ! " ! ! # !

# ! # ! "0

*, 88 ! ) " *" @ ! @ ! ) )!

# # 7 & # " : "

< ..9+ 4* !# @ ! ) )!

$ # ! "

0 , # # ! !

" , # & /" " " )! #

) F ;8 #! ! ! #

/" " " F6@ )! #! ! ! " F6@ )! !

! & " : & # "

1# A 3 1" 3 1 3 1 3 &

? C/" 0K 8 7!< .. + 5

! @

6D !

( ! " ' !#

F ! ! ! 1 :83

! ) F6 ! & # " , ! !

! )! # /

## ! ! "

# F6@

)! )! " ( ! ! :8

# ! N! ! #! " " " H 77

..0+ .4 " .9 " ! :8 # " )!

! " " :8 # !

F6@ )! "

, # & ! "

)! F8 ;8

! ! # $ # ! " '

! F6@ )! < ( ! ! "

(14)

5

*"5"9 ' + # ! )

( ! ( @ ! ) @ )

# #

# " ( ( ! @

! ) @ ) ! 9

" " N! ! "

# < @ ! )

@ ) < # ! )

! " " @ @: & ! ) !

) " ( ! & # # !

! #

! ) " , ! # &

! :"

. O &- .@ @* !

, ! 9"(((

! & # 4 "

4 1 2 3 2 ' , ( 4 5

' !

!

< ( ; ! :8

1 F83 ! ! ! 1 (83 8 7!<6 .. ..5

1 ' 83 : G H .. " , ! 1

F83 4 '6@ " L! #

% & ' &( " !#

# ! ) # !

F" 8 7!< .. ..5 : G H .. !

! ) ! 7 1 F83

F" ! !# # . "

. ! ! + # )!

1 F83 1 F83 '6@ K 7

! ) ! # 1 F83K # #

:" #

! ! ! . "/

/ # . ! ! ! H 7 $ # " L

& # @ # # " " " < ..9+05 " "

@ ! # ! # " (

7 # # 1 :83 " "

M N! #

!# ! # 1 :83

# @ # # :8 " <

(15)

C

( # 7 " "

# 7 1 :83 ) N! #

: # ! ) !

# # )! # & #

) " ' !# )! F8 "

*" " ) N! . ! # #

# ! ) 1 F83 " " & # C

# # :"

C 1:8 1F8 I 1;8 @ """ 333

( !## ! )! # ! )

! 7 # # # :8"

*"C @ ! ) @ ) $ .

! 6F8@ ! ) 6

! ! ! )! ! ) $

$ " ( ! # $ -

G , ..0 & (

# #

! " " ! )!

! ) " L! # ( ! $

! ( (( 9 "

*"C" , !

- G , ..0 -, &

! C # & $

$ D $ ! " 8 # ! )

& C" " !

& " U @ # ! )

& " , ! ! $

7 # @# # : F #

# @ # ! ) " C "

( ! )! ! )

! $ < " ' )! !

@ #

! ) ! & @

..9+09 " " , ! ! # #

! # ! ! . "

., $ < # 8 @ < 8 : ! $

! $ " +MM " "! " !M# "

(16)

9

# # : & @# # F" ,

@ @: @ @F "

" # * * A # - 5."5 /

! 8 N! #

6, 8 ! N! # 6

" U E 00"55/

6% E6

" A C "

6, "6

" L 2 ! ! 2 #

L @ ! # ! !

6, ! # ! !

"6 "9CC

" A < ) ) A """ 0 "/4

< < """

6, < < """6

*"C" ,

: ) * + & # !

C44 ! !# # U -,

! $ # !

& @# # " , ? & &

! & ! $ # !

# & ! ! $ " , !

# ! ? & ! ) @

! ) ! ! %8" ,

M ! $ ! ) ! &

& @ # ! )

! " 4

' -, ..0+5 C ! ! ) @

! !#

4 ' D ..0+5/. " ! # -,6 !

" -,6 # & ! ! ? #

# < & & ## "

; ! # # ! 7 ? &

& ## " ' ? &

# ! #

6F8@ ! ) 6 " ( # ? &

@ ! # ! # " ( !

? & # ##

! < # ## ! ! " ( !

! -,6 "

(17)

*

# :

$ # ! " , !

! !

! :

F @ : "

D ! !

-, # ! )!

! ) " ' ! *"C" !

< ! )! !

@ # ! ) &

@# # : & @# # F" (

& ! ! " D

& (& & '

! " , & # ! ) @ )

( , ' , ?

*"5" " " 7

! " ( ! ! 5 "

5 " ' ' ) ) * ! !

' 6'

"6 ? ! *"CC

" ( A """ ? ! "0

( ## ! ?

6( ? ## ! """6

' ! *"5" 5" ! ! )

! ) 5" #

! ) ! & # # "

5 ! @ ! ) @

) ! " " 6F8@ ! ) 6 , : " '

, : @ ) # ? & "

, N! , :

& # ? & " ( ! #

6F8@ ! ) 6 #

! ## ! & #

D L # ' < % ( " & # *

6F8@ ! ) 6 # ! !

! ! ! " ?

( ! < "

( 6F8@ ! ) 6 ?

& # ! 7 ! ( # &

! $ & # N!

@ ! ) @ ) " $ & ( !

(18)

0

!# & # ! ) 6F8@

! ) 6 ! ! ! !

! " , !# ! 5

" L ! ! " , !

@ ! ) @ ) !

! ! @ # ! )

! 6, @ 6 " , ( ! !#

! @ ! ) @ ) # 6 @

6 , ' ? : " ' # !

, : ! ( , ' ? # ! " ' #

! !# @ ! ) @ ) (

N! & !

!# 6 @ 6 " , !

, ! ! $ , 5 !

$ ? & "

, (& ' & ! ,- .

, @ , ' , ? , :

B> . 0 0"0P " P * 0"*P

B> .0 * *" P "4P "5P

' , .. "4P C C"4P * *" P

? . C C"5P . ."/P . 4"0P

? ! 0/ "*P "5P 9 *"CP

: ' 5*C 9 C" P C " P * C"CP

%: 50 9"CP "0P 9"CP

% C/ * "9P C /"5P ".P

> CC 4"0P 0"*P . 5" P

! .9 / /"CP C C" P 0 0"CP

D # CC 9 5"9P 4 4"4P . 5" P

P 9" P 5"/P "0P

, ! # ! ) ! # ! " : !

# 6 6 !

# # ! @ < " ?

../ "

, ! !

! & !# & # & "

, # ! & # #

7 " ( !

!# & # ! ! ! +

, @ + /.

, , '+ 9/ JC"9P

, , ?+ C J5" P

, , :+ 5 J 4" P

(19)

/

, (& ' & ! -$- .

, @ , ' , ? , :

' H C 5 0" P "CP 5 0" P

*5 C *"5P 5" P ."4P

- C. 9 4" P * " P . /"CP

> # / "0P 5 "9P 0 9".P

/ 5"*P 0" P 0 9"4P

, C/ C" P " P C" P

4 C 5"*P 5 "0P 0 *"CP

P 5 9" P C"*P "5P

, 5(& ' & ! ) * +

, @ , ' , ? , :

" ? * * C"/P 5 "CP 4 4"4P

, 5 # & # !#

& 6F8@ ! ) 6 ! ! " 6, @ 6

? & " &

! 6 @ 6 !

& # , : ? &

& # "

, ? & &

! ! & !# !

? &

N! ! & " ' ,

N! , ' 9" P ? 5"/P : "0P " L

! $ 9" P ' C"*P ? "5P : "

, " L ! $ N!

9" P ' C" P ? ".P : " N!

! & !# ! ? & " C 9

5 ( # !# ! $ & #

! " " +

, @ + C9/

, , '+ JC"*P

, , ?+ / J5".P

, , :+ C0 J 4"5P

C N! # , M , 5

# " ' ! 6 @ 6 ! $ !

@# # F :" ( $ # : 6 @

6 -,6 " , ! # ! @

@F & M $ ! #

$ $ @ @:"

( ! @ @: & @ @F &

! $ & # ! !

, : " ( < , : # N! @ @F &

@ @: & " ( ! $

(20)

.

, C -. ' / + ' (& 0

, @ , ' , ? , :

& * *"* 9" 9"4

* * 5 4

D !# , ' , ? !

& !#

, : ! " ( & 9 & # 6F8@

! ) 6 & # "

!

" ' " ? # 6 @

6 ! 7

! !# ! )!

! ! ) " , ! # !

)! )!

< )! ! )! # !

! F8@ 6F8@ ! ) 6 M $ "

> ! )! ? &

5 ! * 6 @ 6 ! C"*P )!

# #

! C"*P 6 @ 6 ! !

, : "

, N! 6F8@ ! ) 6

? & N! N!

)! " , N! #

" ' # ! $ & #

N! )! # 6 @ 6

# , :

@# # " 6F8@ ! ) 6 ! # N! @ @: &

@ @F & ! 9P " 4P " , ! @ @F # # &

# # M $ & !# $ , : !

, C 0"5 & & # , :

9"4 " , @ @F @ @: & ! !

# & & !# 6F8@ ! ) 6

$ !# ! "

@ @: @ @F

$ ! $

# ( ! @ @: @ @F

& ! # ! 6F8@ ! ) 6

( # N! $ @ @: @ @F

& "

9( # !# $ & " " 5 &

! ! " '# 0C0 6 @ 6 & # $ &

# ! 0. , ' C"9P 9. , ? 5"CP 0/ , :

4" P " , & !# $ ! + , '+

9"0K , ?+ C"5K , :+ "."

(21)

4

? & " , " L !

N! )! ? &

M $ & # ! C"*P " C5"4P ? &

# & # ! !# " ,

$ & # 6 @ 6

@ )! ? & ? ! . & # K %: 5K

% 0K ' CK - 4K *K , 5K "

L! # $ & # # !#

? B> 5/K ' , 5CK ? 5.K 55K > # 50 " L

& # !# 6 @

6 )! B> 9 K : ' C0K > 00K

C0K D # ** " # M $ & # #

!# )! @ ! ! "

! !# ! & ? &

& #

, : "

, ! N! 6 @ 6

)! # ! , :

? & ! ! & !#

, : M $ " L M $ & (

! , : # 6 @ 6

# ,

: " " @ )!

" ( ! $

M $ " , ! " '# & #

, : # 6 @ 6 !

)! 9"*P" L $

."9P M $ 0" P" M $

! & !# , :

? & " *

, 9 -. ' / %! 1 + '

(& 0 / '

, @ )! , :

& 5 /"C

5 4

' ! & !

# , 9 , C "

*( # # ! ! C

! ! " L !

!# $ & # " " 5

& !# ! , : ? ! # 0"*"

@ @: # # & < ! M $ &

# " " C & !# ! ."C"

(22)

( !## $ ! ! ! &

9 ! # /"C & # , :

? & " , C 9 " (

! " ' ! # ! ##

! ! !

! & !#

, : ! ! 6F8@ ! ) 6

? & # !

! ! ##

$ "

, ! ! $ & !

& " -,

@ ! ) @ ) " , N!

# " ( #

( ! ! # ! #

-,6 !# # "

# $ #

! $ # # #" ,

# # ? & @2 3

5 ! 5

! " ( # # & "

- < .4 + & Y 4 ...+5. " -, ..0+5 0 "

? & & @# # : ! @

# # : " " F ! ! C

# # # " !

! !# @

" " F ' < # @

# # ' # " ' N! @

! @# # : " ,

& !

C !

@ "

( ! ! -,6 ! ( , Z 6

..* # # #

# # ' 8 " ? ) < ..9

? ) < G , Z ../ " ' !# F8 C

' 8 ' 8 # @

! # &

-,6 " ' 8

N! " H ! ! C C"

# ! ! C" ! !# F8 ' 8

;8 !# ,8 " " " ? ) < G = ..* 7

' 8 ,8 ! ) "

(23)

C " 1:8 1F8 I 1;8 @ """ 333

" 1:8 1' 8 I 1,8 @ """ 333

H ! # ( !# 6F8@ ! ) 6 !

! ) ! ! ) C

" & # / / " D ! ' 8

! ) " , ! ) C

# ! ) !# )!

" *" " #

) "

, ! 9 "

9 " M$ ! + 1:8 V8 & 1' 8 & 1,8 $%/""" 333 JJ[

" $ U + 1:8 V8 & 1,8 $%""" 333

' 8 U @

! ! ) " @

: ! ) ,8 ) :"

, # @ ! ) @ ) !

# $ ! !

9( 9(( " " N! ! )

:8 ! ! C " " C" " ? F8 ' 8 ;8

,8

< #

! $ ! "

# " @ ! )

) 9" # L8 ! ,8

)! " /" / ' 8" (

! # ' 8 \ &

\ " U G H ! ..0 " " !

! ! !

! < " $ ( L8 /" /

& ' < !

! \ \ )! ! < !

& " ' < &

,8 L8

' 8 " ...+ C # !

"

*"9 !##

( ( ! $

#

$ # ! " " ! )!

(24)

5

! ) 6F8@ ! ) 6 " (

! $ 6F8@ ! ) 6

# " , $ #

# 6F8@ ! ) 6 !

" ,

- G , ..0 & "

( ! @ ! ) @ )

!

# ! ! )! @ ! ) "

L ( ! 6F8@ ! ) 6 #

! ) ! !# 7

! :8@ #

# # # ##

! ! ( ; " '

$ ( ) :8

! $ ! ' 8 ! ! !

! ! ! !

$ # # #

" L @

! ) )! !

) (

# ! # $ # ! "

# ! @ ! ) @ )

! !

! # # !

# ! "

0

' & ! '" ..0" / ' ) 1 ! !

! ." '# #+ ? ) # "

? >" " ../" , ! + 6 # 6

6 # 6E 8 4 ( :

> ! $ "

? ) < =" ..9" $ ! .4 % ! . ( ' 8 "%"

" $(,"

? ) < =" %" = " ..*" ! ) ,8"

5 6 ! 0" .9@ 5*"

? ) < =" " , Z " ../" , 6

" ! . "50@0 "

: '" (" H " .. " : ! ! ! F@ " $ "

"

: # < U" ..9"% $ ) " : # + $(, 8 "

: N! " " / ' 0 / 7 !

) " & + & 8 "

(25)

C

" ../" # ! @ #

! ) $ " 8 4

( : > !

$ "

" ..." 8 1 ! . &

! ( 5

8 "%" " "

" " D 6F8@ ! ) 6 #

> ! " , % 9 1 /

5 "

# >" ..*" : D L # " ( '" '" V <

" " 59@ *C" + : >( 8! "

>" :" 8 7 <" ..9" 8 ! ! + '

" : ) / ! .9*"C0@*."

# '" ..5" , ! ) (8 $ "

: ) / ! .9 " .@C "

! < '" '" - # " ..0" U & !

! ! " ( 8" ! $" H " 4 ! .

" '# #+ ? ) # "

- H" ..C"% ! ! ! ." : # + $(, 8 "

- # '" " ./0" ! 1 $ 1

7 ! - " % + L "

- # '" " ../ ! ! !

" ( (" , < @? " , D" D!

" 7 ! - " C0@ *9" ? + $ !

! "

- < " '" .4 " ( ! " ( "'" - <" % $ -

( * + " > + , &

4"

- # D" ..*" + '

! " ( %" ? " - 7 5 ;<<="

'# #+ ? ) # "

- '" '" , " ..0" # # $ +

! " ( '" - # U"

" ) $ ! 1 " .0@5 9"

: # + : # 8 "

U >" '" H ! " ..0" 8 & ! !

" -5 >?" /0@54C"

8 7!< " .. ") 1 4 ( 1

, - , 8 "%" " 8 "

8 7!< " ..5" + # # ( "

% 5 * / 4"9@59"

8 7!< " ../" L # " $ "

; <"

(26)

9

H 77 >" ..0" , ! ! " ( >" # "

- " / @550" % + - ! "

H (" ..0" %

" ( '" - # U" " )

$ ! 1 " 5.0@C *" : # + : #

8 "

, Z " ..*" @ ! ! " (

D" ' # " " $ " 95@ / " '# #+

? ) # "

< " ..9" ( ' $ / -. / '

5 " & + & 8 "

D '" ..0" , ! ! # @# #

" ( '" - # U" "

) $ ! 1 " 5/[email protected]" : # +

: # 8 "

Références

Documents relatifs

On this view, an anaphor can be understood as a type of pronominal whose internal structure allows it both to approximate coreference with a local antecedent, and at

Old and Early Middle English had relatively frequent occurrences of adverbs between a subject and a finite main verb (SAdvV order) due to a certain variability in subject and

On the basis of quantitative data tracing the diachronic development of the distribution of verbal elements with respect to adverbs, this paper argues that the path towards

On the other hand, a dual version of the Loomis-Whitney inequality, in which the sharp lower bound of the volume of a convex body is given in terms of its (n − 1)-

Cambridge: Cambridge University Press) fi ts with our results. More speci fi cally, by comparing the rate of language change with major language-external events, such as the

The analysis of the English language textbooks, used at both middle and secondary school levels, will shed light on cultural, educational aspects and language proficiency

However, to distinguish between a simple lexical unit such as lamer /leimə/ and a componeme like laser /leizə/ involves a second order analysis since despite its similarity

17 To build the dataset 2 , all occurrences of the three proforms (by using their POS) were extracted from the corpora and placed in a table-like structure in which each variable