• Aucun résultat trouvé

An Architecture for Collaborative Ontology Library Development

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Partager "An Architecture for Collaborative Ontology Library Development"

Copied!
15
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

* "+#)-,.!##/102'

346587:9<;.=>58?A@CBEDF9<G8HIBJ9<KCLNMPOQ?I5SR>TVU<W<KCOQK

XZY\[^]`_Aacbd[^egf#hjilkm_n^bd[oY8pq[sr8t._u\vQadecw_YexhQizyh{wu8|8ec_Iam}q~[^_Y\~I_

€‚ƒ€\„h"…‡†QˆŠ‰s‹Œ_hjn^no[^bd|8|\bdpjvQec|:†QŽ

‘g’m“g”{”j”<•I–XZ’Zg—.˜l™.}qš‹›œ‚.1k.˜z‘}qž’mŸAr8‘[^Y\novjY\ 

}q_w#vjYec[^~¡yh{wu8|8ec[^Y\¢ƒ™m_Ibd_"vQac~¤£:¥mach{|8u

£edecuJ¦§{§"¨x¨x¨€~Ib€£8_n^bd[^Y\pq[F€©ª§Q¢Qach{|\uV§Qbd_~Ih§

ec|\hjw#vjb€p`hjacu8[^n«vQ£ec[E¬Z~Ib€£8_n^bd[^Y\pq[F€©Jr\_I_Iach8€£f<]`h{Y8_Yª¬Z~b€£8_n^bd[oY8pq[s€©

­#®¯°±²V³j°{´ƒµ

_œ~hjY\bd[o 8_Aa¶~h{n^novj·ªhQa¤vQec[^]`_¸hjYqechjn^h{¢jfn^[^·8a¤vadf 8_]`_Inohju\w_Ye"r

¨£8_Iac_Sh{Yechjnohj¢{[^_b'vQac_ac_I“¹|\bd_" º·fº[oY8~n^|V <[oY8¢Nec£8_[»aac_bdh{|<ac~_b[^Y hQec£\_Ia¼h{Y8“

echjnohj¢{[^_b€

µ

£\_YvjY[^Y\~n^|V <_" :h{Yech{n^h{¢Qf+[^b~¤£VvQY\¢{_ Nec£\_ƒh{Yech{n^hj¢jf[oY8~n^|V <[oY8¢

ac_bdhj|8ac~_IbZiEachjwec£8_>whq <[»©V_" ŠhjY\_>w#vfŠ·ª_~Ih{w_¡h{·8bdh{n^_Iec_{€C‹£8[obmuVvQuª_IavQYVvQ“

n»f<½_b.ec£8_¾_I¿6_~AecbhjixhjYqechjn^h{¢jfN~¤£VvQY\¢{_¾h{uª_Ia¤vec[ohjY\bechS <_uª_Y\ 8_Ye.hjYech{n^h{¢j[o_Ib

vQYV :w_Ie¤v{ 8vQe¤v<€JÀÁ~n^[^_Yed“¹bd_Iac]`_Ia>vac~A£8[^ec_I~Iec|8ac_>iÂhja¡~Ihj“¹h{uª_Ia¤vec[^]`_¼h{Yechjnohj¢jfNn^[»“

·<a¤vQadf‡ <_]`_n^hju\w_YeP[^bZu8ac_Ibd_Yec_" Šec£VveZ£8_n^u\bmechw#vQp`_¡h{Yech{n^hj¢jf‡~¤£VvQY\¢{_IbZ[^Y

bd|8~A£Nv¼¨xvfSec£\vQeZec£8_ƒhjYech{n^h{¢Qf:]`_Iacbd[^h{Y8bmac_w#vQ[oY:·\vj~¤pq¨vQa¤ <bZ~hjwuVvQec[^·8no_ƒvjb

wƒ|\~¤£1vjbƒuªh{bdbd[^·\n^_{€‹£\_#bšf<bšec_wÃvjn^bdh‡ec_n^nob>ec£\_# <_]`_n^h{uª_Aacb>ec£8__A¿6_~Iecb>hjiPv

~¤£VvQY\¢{_.ech¾hjec£\_AaP 8_uª_Y\ 8_YexhjYech{n^h{¢j[o_Ib.vjY\ ac_uªhjbd[»echjac[^_b€ªgY'ec£\[^bx¨xvf'vj~I~[»“

 <_Ye¤vjn^n»f 8_Ibšedac|\~Iec[^]`_xwhq <[^©\~"vQec[^hjY\bz~"vjY·ª_Pv"]`h{[o <_" ¼vjY\ ¾ec£\_xhQec£\_Ia 8_]{_n^h{u8“

_IacbhjiCec£\_h{Yech{n^hj¢jf#n^[^·8a¤vQadf¼~"vjY©VY\ ¼h{|<e¨£Vvewhq <[^©\~"vQec[^hjY\bxvac_mY8_~_bdbcvadf

[^Y1ec£\_I[^aƒh"¨YÄh{Yech{n^hj¢{[^_bƒiEhja¾[oYec_Iachjuª_Ia¤vj·8[^no[»egf€ÀÅu<achjechjegf<uª_hQixec£\_#bšf<bšec_w

hjY+ech{u1hQixec£\_#achjecÆ¢jÆI“ž†j”j”{”:h{Yech{n^h{¢Qf+_ 8[»echjaƒ£VvQb>·ª_I_Y1[^wu\n^_w_Yec_" NvjY\ 

u<ac_n^[ow[^Y\vQadf#ec_bšecbxiÂhQaZ|8bd[oY8¢¼[»ePvQac_¡u8ac_Ibd_Yec_" C€

Ç ÈŠÉÊ ËÌJ̓ΜÏÐÉÑcѤËÒ#ÉÌCËÓVÔcÕP֨׶ÙmÓªÉѤÉÚxÛÜÝցÕPÖlÑcÉÞƒßØÖlÙZÓ

à K8HI5<DÂ5<á8BÂOj;#âEãqä"å`æP9<?AOS7:9<çGCBEKCO'ç587‡@6?IOQG6OjKC;¤BÂè6DÂO#éVK65êDÂO{Lªá<O'7‡5VL6OQDF;ƒHAGC9qH#Oëª@6DÂBFçBEHADÂT

7‡5VL6OQD.?AO{9qDêZ5<?IDFL¶ç58KCçOj@ªHI;S9qKJLì?IOQDF9HI5<KC;Qíx3.G6OQTì;AG65846DFL¶èŒOÄ@646è6DÂBFçDÂTî;¤GC9<?AO{Lì9<KCL

BEK\HIOQ?I5<@ŒOQ?9qè6DÂOPBÂKŠ5<?LªOQ?HI5#7:9qé8Om@Œ58;I;ABEèCDEOmHAGCOïs46DÂD6èŒOQK6OQð6HI;x5<ï‘HAG6O>ñVOj7:9qK\HABFçPò OjèÄâ«ãQægí

ó çQç58?IL6BEKCá#HA5Nô¾?I46èŒOQ?jõ;¡5<K\HA58DE58á<TSLªOj;ABÂá<K+@6?IBEKJçBÂ@6DÂOj;>âöqægäCO{9<çG+?AO{9qDêZ5<?IDFLNç58KCçOj@ªHBF;

LªOðCKCOjLî5<KCDETÐBÂK÷5<K6O‡58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8Tqäz9<KCLî9qDÂDP;ATV;¤HAOj7:;4C;AO‡HAGCON;A9<7‡O:LªOðJK6BEHABÂ5<KÐïs5<?HAGC9qH

ç5<KJçOQ@6HQí

à

K\HA58DE58á<BÂOj;ƒ;¤GC5<46DFLºGCOQKCçQO‡èJO‡?IOQ4C;I9qèCDEO'HA51DÂOH58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8T1OQK6á8BEKCOQOQ?;ƒèJOjK6Oð6H

ïs?A587øHAG6OBÂKCçQ?AO{9<;ABÂK6á#KV467ŠèJOj?Z5<ïL6B«ù‘OQ?IOQK\H¡Lª587:9qBÂKªúd;¤@ŒOjçQB«ðŒç.5<K\HA58DE58á<BÂOj;Qí

ûCüžû ý‡þ‘ÿ

ó çQ5<7‡7‡58KÄêZ9`T+HA51?IOQ4C;AOŠ5<K\HA58DE58á<BÂOj;.BF;ƒHA5+BÂKCçDÂ4CL6O#HAGCOQ7 BÂKÐ5qHAGCOQ?¼5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<BÂO{;äC9<KCL

HAG6OjK¶9<L6LÐK6OQêøçQ5<KCçQOQ@ªH;9qKCL ?IOQDF9HIBE58KC;Qí‘R>5êmOjU<OQ?jäêG6OQK HIG6O:BÂKCçDÂ4CL6OjLº58K\HA5<DÂ58á<T1BF;

7‡5VL6B«ðJOjL+9<çQçQ5<?LªBÂK6á#HI5SHAG6OOQU<58DÂU\BÂK6á'@6?I5qHA5<HcTV@JO¼7‡5ªLªOQDPâ<ægä6HIG6O#çGC9<K6á<O{;.7:9`T:@6?I5U<O

(2)

HAGC9qH¼7Š4ªHI4C9qDÂDÂTLªOj@JOjKCLªOjK8H58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8BÂOj;¡9<?AOŠLªOQU8OQDÂ5<@ŒOjLºçQ5qúš5<@ŒOQ?9HIBEU8OQDÂT:BÂK á8OQ58á<?9q@6G6BEú

çQ9qDÂDÂTÄLªBF;cHI?ABÂè646HAOjLÐDÂ5ªçQ9HIBÂ5<KC;ƒèVT LªBEùŒOj?AOjK\H¼@ŒOQ58@6DÂOqí ó çQ5qúš5<@ŒOQ?9HIBEU8O#5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8T+DÂBÂè6?9q?IT

LªOQU8OQDÂ5<@67‡OjK\Hƒ9qKCLÐ7:9qBÂK\HAOjKC9qKJçO9<?IçG6BEHIOjç"HI46?IOK6OjOjL6;¾HI5+èŒOSOj;¤HI9<è6DÂBÂ;AG6O{L1BEK 5<?LªOj?>HI5

7:9qKC9<á<OƒHAG6OOjU<5<DÂ4ªHIBÂ5<K:5<ïLªOj@JOjKCLªOjK8H¡58K\HA5<DÂ58á<BÂOj;>â{æží¡OjU<OQ?AHAGCOQDÂOj;I;äª7‡OQHAG65ªL6;9<KCL

HA5V5<DF;mHA5:;A46@6@Œ5<?AH.HAG6BF;ç587‡@6DÂOëSHI98;¤éç5<7‡@CDEOQHAOjDETS9q?IO¼7‡BF;A;ABÂK6á:âæží

à K8HI5<DÂ5<á8TÐ7:9<KC9qá8OQ7‡OjK8HçQ5<KC;ABF;cH;5<ï¾LªOjU<OjDE58@67‡OQK\Hjä@646èCDEBF;AG6BÂK6á6äOQU85<DÂ4ªHABÂ58Kä9<KCL

7:9qBÂK\HAOQKJ9qKCçQOƒ@6?I5ªçO{;A;AOj;gç"ïdíŒðCá<46?IO‡ã "íƒ46?IBEKCá'HIG6O! "$#%&%&mHIG6O#5<K\HI5<DEú

5<á<T1LªOjU<OQDÂ58@JOj?ƒç?IOj9qHAO{;>9:KCOQê 5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8TNèVT's@Œ58;I;¤BÂè6DÂT Z?AOQúž4J;¤BÂK6á‡OQëVBF;¤HABÂK6á‡58K6Oj;Qí‘3.GCO

(*),+-&"./+0213! "#&%&BF;4C;AOjL'HA5ç58K\HA?I5<DV@646è6DÂBFç.9<çjçOj;I;HA5¾HAGCO5<K\HA58DE58á<T4`B«HxOjKC;¤4C?AO{;HAGC9qH

HAG6OSç58?A?IOjçH>U<Oj?I;ABÂ5<KÄ5qïxHIG6OŠ5<K\HA58DE58á<TBÂ;¾9`U9qBÂDF9qè6DÂO¾BÂK LªBEùŒOj?AOjK\H¾ç58K\HAOëVH;í65658?ƒOQëª9<7Sú

@6DÂOqälHIG6O:5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8T1L6OQU<OjDÂ5<@ŒOQ?;ƒ7:9`T êZ9<K8HHI5Äêm58?Aé êB«HIG÷9ÄLªBEùŒOj?AOjK8HU8OQ?;¤BÂ5<KÐ5qï.HAGCO

5<K\HA58DE58á<TSHIGC9qK+HAGCO9q@6@CDEBFçj9HABÂ58KNLªOQU8OQDÂ5<@ŒOQ?;Z5<?.HIG6O#OQKJLVúž4J;¤Oj?I;Qí

ó

ïFHIOQ?>@C46è6DÂBF;¤G6BÂK6á'HAGCO

5<K\HA58DE58á<Tïs58?PHIG6OƒðC?I;¤HPHIBÂ7‡Oqä<HIG6O78+098:#%;! "$#%&%&èJOjá<BÂKC;Qí\R¡Oj?AO>HAG6O¾5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8T#BF;

7‡5VL6B«ðJOjLºLª4COHI5U9q?IBÂ5<4C;>K6OQO{L6;Qí65C5<?¾Oë69q7‡@CDEO<äCHIG6OŠL65<7:9qBÂKÄ7‡5ªLªOjDEO{L15<?¾HAGCO'K6OjOjL6;

5qï>HIG6OÄ5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8T 4J;¤Oj?I;Š7:9`T¶çGC9<K6á<O<äx9<KCLìHAG6OÄ58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8TÐ7Š4C;¤H‡èJOÄ9<L65<@ªHIOjLìHA5îHAGCO

çGC9qK6á8OjLŠ4C;AOƒçQ5<KCLªBEHIBE58KC;Qí{òÝGCOQK:58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8BÂOj;9q?IO7'46HA4C9<DEDÂT#LªOj@JOjKCLªOjK8Hjä\BžíOqíEä8êG6OjK:5<K6ú

HA5<DÂ58á<BÂOj;PBEKJçDÂ4CLªO¾?AO{;¤5846?çOj;Pïs?I5<7&O{9<çG+5qHAGCOQ?jäCçGC9qK6á8Oj;ZK6OjOjLHA5SèŒO@6?A58@C9qá\9HIOjLSïs?I5<7

5<K6Om5<K\HA58DE58á<T>HA5¼9qK65<HAG6Oj?Qí`3.G6BF;zBF;;¤46@C@J58?¤HIOjLèVT¼HAGCOm58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8T<:,(=+>?! "$#%&%&HAGC9qH

BEKJçDÂ4CLªO{;¼5<K\HA58DE58á<TÄçGC9<K6á<O:9<KCLîçGC9qK6á8O‡@6?I5<@C9<á89HIBÂ5<Kº@6?I5ªçO{;A;AOj;Qíz3.G6O:7:9<BEK\HIOQKC9<KCçO

@6?A5ªçQOj;I;#BÂKCçDÂ4CL6Oj;#;A4CçQçQOj;I;¤BÂU8OŠOjU<58DE46HABÂ5<Kî9qKCL¶@646è6DÂBF;¤GCBEKCá+@C?A5ªçO{;A;AOj;QäzêG6BFçG÷?IOj98ç"H#HI5

HAG6O1çGC9qKCá<OjL¶4C;¤Oj?'KCOQOjLC;'5<ïHAG6O158K8HI5<DÂ5<á8BÂOj;¼9qKCLìé<OjOQ@÷ïsOjOjLªBÂK6á HAG6O+5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<TÐ4C;AOQ?;

êB«HIG4C@ªúgHI5qúdL69HIO¼U<OQ?;ABE58KC;m5qïzHIG6O5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8Tqí*@7%#%<A+-&%&B+>‡OjKCL6;58K\HA5<DÂ58á<TŒõ;PDÂB«ïsO<í

Maintenance

Development Publishing Evolution Decommission

CED-F ´GV´ ‚ZYech{n^h{¢QfŠn^[»iÂ_~Af8~Ino_u<ach~_bdbd_b€

ûCüIH Jlÿ$Kªÿ .ÿ$L NMPO`ÿ

3.G6OQ?IO+9<?AO+9q@6@C?A5\9<çG6O{;9qKJLì;ATV;¤HAOj7:;HIGC9H:9qBÂ7 HA5î;A5<DÂU<O‡HIG6O+@6?A58è6DÂOQ7:;@6?AO{;¤OjK\HAOjLí

= ó à âQªä%Rªä%æ8BF;9qK'5<K\HA58DE58á<T¾LªOQU8OQDÂ5<@67‡OjK\HlOQKVUVBE?I5<KC7‡OQK\HzLªOQU8OQDÂ5<@ŒOjL9HHAG6OTS¡KCBEU8OQ?Aú

;¤BEHcTŠ5qï=9<?ADF;A?A46GCOqíVUdK+= ó à 9q?çG6BEHAO{ç"HI46?AO.HIG6O¾BEKJçDÂ4CLªO{LS5<K\HA58DE58á<BÂOj;x9<?AO¾Lª46@6DÂBFçQ9qHAO{L‘í

W GC9qK6á8Oj;Š9q?IO9<DEDÂ5êZOjL 5<KCDETÐHA5ÐHAGCO+58?ABÂá8BEKJ9qDx5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8TÐ9qKJLì9q?ION@C?A58@C9qá\9HAO{LîHA5ÐHAGCO

Lª46@6DÂBFçQ9qHAOj;QäCçQ9<4C;ABEKCá‡7‡5<?IO¼çGJ9qK6á8Oj;BÂK1HAGCO5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8BEO{;HIGC9H¼9q?IO?AOQúž4J;¤BÂK6áŠHAGCOQ71íŒ3.GCO

?AOQúž4C;AOQ?;Z9q?IOƒ9<;Aé<O{L:BEïlHIG6OQT‡êZ5<46DFL‡DÂBÂé<O¡HA5‡9<çjçOQ@6HmHIG6O¼@6?A58@J5\;¤O{L:çGC9<K6á<O{;P58?Zé8OQOj@:HAGCO

5<DFLªOQ?ƒU<Oj?I;ABÂ5<K+5qïHIG6OBÂKCçQDE4JLªOjL158K8HI5<DÂ5<á8TqíJ= ó à @6?A58@C9qá\9HIOj;HIG6O'çGJ9qK6á8Oj;¡èŒOHcêZOQOjK

HAG6O'?AOj7‡5qHAO58K\HA5<DÂ58á<TNçQ5<@6BÂOj;TXC46OQK\HIDET<íUšH¾@6?A5UVBFLªO{;ZHA5V5<DF;.HI5:G6OQDÂ@1HIG6O?IOúš4C;AOQ?¡HI5:46Kªú

LªOQ?;cH9qKCLHAG6OZBÂ7‡@C9<çHI;l5<ï6HAGCOm@6?I5<@Œ58;AOjLçGJ9qK6á8Oj;9qKCLDÂOQHI;zHAG6Oj7 LªOjçQBÂL6OPBEïªHAG6O.çGC9<K6á<O{;

(3)

ïs5<?¼5qHIG6OQ?;íl3.G6BF;¾7‡Oj9<KC;>HAGC9qH¾HIG6O‡LªOQU8OQDÂ5<@ŒOQ?¾5qï.9N?IOúš4C;AOjL 5<K\HA58DE58á<TBÂ;¾K65<H#çQ9q@J9qè6DÂO

5qïlá<OQH¤HIBEKCá#BÂKªïs5<?I7:9HIBE58K#ïs58?POQU9<DE4J9HABÂK6áLªBEù‘OQ?IOQK\Hm7‡5ªLªOjDÂBEKCá¾LªO{çBF;ABE58KC;Qí<3.G6Oƒ;ATª;cHIOQ7 BF;

K65qH¡çQ9<@C9qèCDEO¾5qïK65<HABEïsTVBEKCá#HAGCO#LªOQU8OQDÂ5<@ŒOQ?ZêG6OQK1G6O¼7:9<é<Oj;.9SçGC9<K6á<OƒHAGC9qH¡è6?IOj9qéª;mHAGCO

èC9<çéVê.9q?L6;>çQ5<7‡@C9qHABÂè6BÂDÂB«HcTN5qïPG6BF;¾5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8TqíŒ= ó à Ø9qDF;A5NDF9<çéª;¡HAG6OSïs46KJç"HABÂ58KC9qDÂBEHcT:HI5

;¤46@C@J58?¤H5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8T'@64Cè6DÂBÂ;AG6BÂK6á'@6?A5ªçQOj;I;äªêG6BFçGNBF;Z5<KCO¾5<ïzHIG6Oé<OjTNç587‡@J58K6OQK\HI;m5qïHAGCO

5<K\HA58DE58á<T'7:9qKC9<á<OQ7‡OjK\H@6?A5ªçQOj;I;íª3.G6O¼;¤Tª;¤HAOQ7ø@C?AO{;¤OjK8HIOjL‡DF9qHAOQ?mBÂK‡HAG6BF;Z@C9<@JOj?Z9qH¤HI98çéª;

HAG6O{;¤O¼@6?I5<è6DÂOj7:;èVT:@6?I5UVBÂL6BEKCá9qK+BÂK8HIOQá8?I9qHAOjL‡HA5V5<DŒHA5‡;A46@6@Œ5<?AH5<K\HA58DE58á<TŠOQK6á8BÂK6OQOj?ABÂK6á

êm58?Aé2XC5ê¼í

?A5<Hjáúcåâ«ãæCBF;x9¼@Œ5<@646DF9<?x5<K\HA58DE58á<T¼OjL6B«HI5<?jí:UšHP5qù‘OQ?;9<KŠBÂK\HA4CB«HIBÂU<OZá<?9q@6G6BFçj9qD

4C;¤Oj?#BÂK\HAOQ?Aï¹9<çQOqäz9<KCLîBEHI;#;A46@6@Œ5<?AH#ïs5<?5<K\HA58DE58á<TÄBÂKCçQDE4J;¤BÂ5<KÐBF;5<K6O‡5<ï.HAG6O:èŒOj;¤HBÂKîHAGCO

ðCOQDFL‘í?A5<HjáúcåŠçQ9<Kº;cHI5<?IO#5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<BÂO{;PBÂK1ðCDÂOj;>9qKCLÄBÂK1?IOQDF9HIBE58KC9qDL69qHI9<èC9<;AOj;QäCè64ªH

5<K\HA58DE58á<T:BÂKCçQDÂ4C;¤BÂ58KNBF;¡;A46@6@Œ5<?AHAOjLº5<K6DÂTNBÂK+ðCDÂOúšèC98;¤O{L58K\HA5<DÂ58á<BÂOj;Qí63.G6O;ATV;¤HAOj7 7:9<BÂKªú

HI9qBÂKC;#5<K\HA58DE58á<BFçQ9<DçQ5<KC;ABF;cHIOQKCçQTºèVTÐ@C?AOjU<OQK\HIBEKCá+4J;¤Oj?I;¼ïs?I5<7 7‡5ªLªBEïsTVBEKCáNHIG6ONBÂKCçQDE4JLªOjL

5<K\HA58DE58á<BÂOj;Qí

ó

DED6çGJ9qK6á8Oj;7'4C;¤HHAG6Oj?AOQïs5<?IOZèŒO.7:9<LªOmHA5¾HIG6O.5<?IBEá8BÂKC9qD85<K\HA58DE58á<T<í

W

GC9<K6á<O{;

9q@6@ŒOj9<?¡BÂKNHIG6O#BÂKCçDÂ4CL6BEKCá'58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8BÂOj;P98;¡;A5\58KÄ9<;ZHAGCO#BÂKCçDÂ4CLªBÂK6áŠ@6?I5 cO{ç"HI;9<?AODÂ5\9<LªO{L‘í

R¡5êZOQU<Oj?Qä?I5qHQáúcå:Lª5VOj;#K65qH@6?I5UVBÂL6O'7‡O{9qKC;ƒHA5Ä;AOQO‡êGC9qHOù‘Ojç"H;¼HAGCO:çGC9qK6á8O

GC9<;ƒBÂKºHAGCO'BÂKCçQDE4JLªBÂK6á‡5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<BÂO{;í*ƒOQU8OQDÂ5<@ŒOQ?;>çj9qKºHIGV4C;¾Oj9<;ABÂDÂTNè6?IOj9<éHIG6OŠBEKJçDÂ4CLªBÂK6á

5<K\HA58DE58á<BÂOj;Qí:¡5'OQU<58DÂ4ªHABÂ5<KS;A46@6@Œ5<?AHmBF;P9`U9qBÂDF9qèCDEO<í46è6DÂBF;¤GCBEKCá#9qKCL‡5<HAG6Oj?P7:9<KC9qá8OQ7‡OQK\H

?AOjDÂ9qHAO{L BF;I;¤46O{;#9q?IOSK65qHŠç5<KJ;¤BFLªOj?AO{L‘älOQBEHAGCOQ?jí à 46?;ATª;cHIOQ7 OëVHAOjKCL6;P?A5<HQáúcå:èVT

7:9qKC9<á<BÂK6áHAG6O5<K\HA58DE58á<BFçQ9<DxLªOQ@ŒOQKCL6OQKCçQBEO{;9<KCLîèVTî98L6LªBÂK6áÄ58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8TÄOQU85<DÂ4ªHABÂ58K 9<KCL

@646è6DÂBF;¤GCBEKCá';A46@6@Œ5<?AHQí

à K8HI5<DÂBÂK6á<4J9Äâ«ã8ãæBF;¼9Äç58DEDF9<èJ58?I9qHABÂU<O¼5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8T1L6OQU<OjDÂ5<@67‡OjK8HƒHA5V5<DHAGC9qH;¤46@C@J58?¤H;

OQU<OjK+çQTªçDÂBFçQ9qDJ5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<TŠBÂKCçDÂ4C;ABÂ5<Kí/>O{;¤@CB«HIO¼5qïBEH;.@J5êZOQ?Aïs46D‘BÂKCçDÂ4C;ABÂ5<K‡7‡OjçGJ9qK6BF;A71ä8BEH

Lª5VOj;lKC5qHz@6?I5UVBFLªO;A46@6@Œ5<?AHlïs58?çGC9<K6á<BÂK6ámHAG6Om5<?IBÂá<BÂKC9qD{5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8T¡9qKCL¾HIG6OQK@6?I5<@J9qá89qHABÂK6á

HAG6O#çGC9<K6á<O{;mHA5SHAGCO¾BÂKCçQDÂ4CLªBÂK6á58K\HA5<DÂ58á<BÂOj;Qí

ò Ojè

à

>Mìâ`æ<BF;l9êZOQèèC98;¤O{Lƒ58K\HA5<DÂ58á<T¡O{LªBEHA5<?BÂK6BEHIBÂ9<DÂDET.LªOjU<OQDÂ58@JO{L>ïs58?lOjL6B«HIBÂK6á

à

U

5<K\HA58DE58á<BÂOj;QíUšH¡4J;¤O{;¡9SL69H9qèC98;¤O¾HA5‡;¤HA58?AO¼5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8BEO{;í8ò Ojè

à

ƒMÁ4ªHABÂDÂBQOj;PHAGCO#ç5<KJçOQ@6H

5qïz4C;AOQ?.á8?A5846@C;PHA5SOj;¤HI9<è6DÂBÂ;AG:9<çjçO{;A;Zç58K8HI?A58DCHI5'58K\HA5<DÂ58á<BÂOj;Qä89qKJL:GC98;Z;ATVKCçG6?I5<K6B{9HABÂ58K

7‡OjçGC9<K6BF;¤7:;zHA5@6?IOQU8OQK\HOQ?I?I5<?;zïs?I5<7Øç58KCç46?I?IOQK\H9<çQçQOj;I;í:UdK:9¼êBFLªO¡;AOQKJ;¤O<äqHAG6BF;xçQ5<46DFL

èJO‡HIG65<4Cá<G÷5qï¡98;#9Äê.9`TÄHA5º@C46è6DÂBF;¤Gî9qK÷58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8TÄèVTÐ9qDÂDÂ5êBÂK6áN@C46è6DÂBFçŠ98çQçQOj;I;¼HA5ºBEHjí

3.G6OS7‡OjçGC9<K6BF;¤7Lª5VOj;¼K65<H¼;A46@6@Œ5<?AH#ç58KCç46?I?IOQK\Hƒ4C;AOS5qïZ7'46DEHIBE@CDEO58K\HA5<DÂ58á<T+U<OQ?;ABE58KC;

ïs5<?LªBEù‘OQ?IOQK\H#BÂK\HAOQ?IOj;¤Há<?I5<46@J;äz;A4CçG¶9<;#5<K\HA58DE58á<TÄ?IOúš4C;AOQ?;äl9q@C@6DÂBÂçj9HIBE58K LªOjU<OQDÂ58@JOj?I;Qä

9qKCLÁOjKCLVúš4C;AOQ?;í.3.G6O 9q46HAG658?I;N5qïòîOQè à ƒM ;¤HI9qHAOÄHIGC9H1BEH;¤4C@6@J58?¤H;NçQ5<DÂDF9qèŒ5<?9HABÂU8O

5<K\HA58DE58á<T'OjLªBEHABÂK6á'9HZHAG6O¾éVK65êDÂOjLªá8O¡DÂOQU<OjDžä<è64ªH¡Lª5'K65qH.Oëª@6DF9qBÂK‡7‡58?AO¡@C?AO{çBF;¤OjDÂTêGC9qH

HAG6BF;7‡O{9qKC;Qí ó çQçQ5<?LªBÂK6áZHA55<4C?l46KCLªOj?I;¤HI9<KCLªBÂK6áCä"ò Ojè à >MÐLª5VOj;K65<Hz@6?I5UVBÂL6O7‡O{9qKC;ŒHI5

@6?A58@C9qá\9HIOP5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8T¾çGC9<K6á<O{;lHI5¾L6OQ@ŒOQKCLªOjK\H5<K\HA58DE58á<BÂOj;‘BÂKŠ9ƒêZOQDÂDEúdç5<K\HI?A58DEDÂO{L¡7:9qKCK6OQ?jí

à K8HI5<MPL6B«H.âEã{å`æ6BF;x9<K'58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8T¼OQK6á8BEKCOQOQ?IBÂK6á¡OjK\UVBÂ?I5<K67‡OjK8Hjä{êGCBÂçGŠç58KCçOjK8HI?I9qHAO{;58K

HI9<;Aéª;?IOQDF9HIOjL'HA5'5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<T?AO84CBE?IOQ7‡OjK\HI;x;A@JO{çBEðJçQ9qHABÂ5<Kläq?AOQðCK6OQ7‡OjK\HQä\9<KCL‡OjU`9<DÂ4C9HIBE58Kí

UšHNç5<7Šè6BÂK6O{;#7‡OHIG65ªLª5<DÂ58á<T\úžèJ9<;AOjL 5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<T÷LªOjU<OjDE58@67‡OQK\HêBEHIGœçQ5<DÂDF9qèŒ5<?9HABÂ58K 9<KCL

BEK6ïsOQ?IOQKCçQOqí>4CO¼HA5‡BEHI;mïs5ªç4C;¡5<KHAG6OO{9q?IDETS@6GJ9<;AOj;.5qïHAG6O58K\HA5<DÂ58á<TŠDEBEïsO¼çTªçDÂO<äVBEH¡Lª5VOj;

K65qH¡5<ùŒOj?¡9qKVT:;¤4C@6@J58?¤Hïs58?5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<TŠ@646èCDEBF;AG6BÂK6á58?OQU85<DÂ4ªHABÂ58Kí

3z5Sç58K8HI?ABÂè646HAOƒHA5ŠHAG6O?IOj;AOj9<?IçG9qèŒ5U<Oqäª5846?.@C9q@ŒOQ?@6?IOj;AOQK\H;Z9S;A5<DÂ4ªHIBE58KN9q@C@6?A5\9<çG

HAGC9qH'BÂK\HAOQá8?I9qHAO{;¾HAG6O+9<;A@JO{ç"HI;'5qï¡çQ5<KC;ABF;cHIOQK\H#5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<TÐLªOQU8OQDÂ5<@67‡OjK\HQäl5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8Tº@646èªú

(4)

@C9HIBEèCDEO+ê.9`Tì9qKCL¸;¤HI9`T¶BÂKªïs58?A7‡O{Lì9<èJ584ªH‡HAG6OÄ?IOQDÂOjU`9<K\H‡çGJ9qK6á8Oj;ŠBÂKœ58K\HA5<DÂ58á<BÂOj;#HAGC9qH

HAG6OjT9q?IO¼?AOQúž4J;¤BÂK6áCí >OQê 5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8TŠU8OQ?;¤BÂ58KC;mçj9qK1èŒO@646è6DÂBF;¤GCOjLBEK19‡ç58K\HA?I5<DÂDÂOjLS7:9qK6ú

K6OQ?jí;ƒBÂ;¤HA?IBÂè64ªHIOjL 5<K\HA58DE58á<T÷LªOjU<OQDÂ58@67‡OQK\HSBÂ;‡;A46@6@Œ5<?AHAO{L‘äm9<KCL¸5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<Tî@64Cè6DÂBÂ;AG6BÂK6á

9qKCL7:9qBÂK\HAOjKC9qKCçQO>@6?I5ªçO{;A;AOj;.çQ9<KèŒO@64ªHƒBEK@6DF9<çQOqí

UdKºHAGCOSïs5<DÂDÂ5êBEKCá6ä6êZOðC?;¤H¼@C?AO{;¤OjK8H9qK 9qKC9<DÂTV;ABF;¡5<ïP5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<T1çGC9<K6á<O'5<@ŒOQ?9HABÂ58KC;

êB«HIG¶?IOj;A@JO{ç"HHI5Ð58K\HA5<DÂ58á<T LªOj@JOjKCLªOjKCçBÂOj;QäxçDF9<;I;9<KCL÷@6?I5<@ŒOQ?AHcTÐGCBEOj?I9<?IçGCBEO{;9qKCL¶BEK6ú

;cH9qKCçQO#L69H9S@6?AO{;¤Oj?AU9qHABÂ5<Kí.9<;AOjL+5<K+HIG6O#9qKC9<DÂTV;ABF;äª;A5<DÂ4ªHABÂ58KC;.9q?IO¼;A46á8á<Oj;¤HAO{L:ïs58?HAGCO

K6OQO{L6;¾5qïmO{9<çGÐ@6?A5ªçQOj;I;>@6?IOj;AOQK\HIOjL‘äl9qKJL 9+@6?I5qHA5<HcTV@JO'BE7‡@CDEOj7‡OQK\HI9qHABÂ5<K+BF;ƒL6Oj;Iç?IBEèŒOjLí

3.G6O@C9q@ŒOQ?¡çQ5<KCçQDÂ4CLªOj;ZêBEHAG19SLªBF;AçQ4C;I;¤BÂ5<K9qKCL+9S;¤467‡7:9<?ATS5<ï5<4C?.ðCKCLªBÂK6á\;í

×¶ÙZÓªÉÑcÉÚxÛ Ï>ËكÚÖ ×îÞ#ÖlÌCËÓVÔ¤ÉكÎ

à K8HI5<DÂ5<á8TºBÂKCçDÂ4C;ABÂ5<KÐ7‡Oj9qKJ;#BÂKîHAG6BF;@C9q@ŒOQ? ¹9<;'BÂK ?I5qHjáQúdåÐâEã æI ¼HIGC9HŠ5<K\HA58DÂ5qú

á<BÂOj;#9<?AONOëª@6DÂBFçBEHADÂTÄBÂ7‡@J58?¤HIOjL BÂK\HA5 9<K65qHIG6OQ?'5<K\HA58DE58á<TºBÂK¶9 @6?AO{LªOðJK6OjLî58?ILªOj?êBEHAG6ú

5<4ªHLª46@6DÂBFçQ9qHABÂK6áS?IOj;A5<46?çO{;í

W

TVçQDÂBÂçL6OQ@ŒOQKCLªOjKCçBÂO{;ƒ9<KCLº58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8TN9qDÂBÂá<KC7‡OQK\H¡9q?IOK65<H

ç5<KJ;¤BFLªOj?AO{L‘í

ó

KîBEKJçDÂ4CLªO{LÄ5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<TÃBÂ;¼çQ5<KC;ABFLªOQ?IOjLÄèJ9<çéVêZ9<?ILC;>ç587‡@C9HIBÂè6DÂO#BEïPHAGCO

5<K\HA58DE58á<BÂOj;HAGC9qHBEKJçDÂ4CLªO¼9Š@6?AOjUVBE584C;ZU<Oj?I;ABÂ5<K:5<ïØçQ9<K?IOQ@6DF98çO¡HIG6O@6?IOQUVBÂ5<4C;ZU8OQ?;¤BÂ5<K

êB«HIG+HAG6O#KCOQêÅU<OQ?;ABE58KNêBEHAGC5<4ªH>çQ5<K XCBFçHI;.5<?¡LC9HI9SDÂ5\;A;Qí à 46?¡á<5\9qDBF;ZHA5ç?IOj9HIO9‡;¤Tª;¤ú

HAOQ7 HAGJ9H¡G6OjDE@J;ZHAG6O#LªOjU<OjDE58@JOj?ZHA5:LªOjU<OQDÂ58@NèC98çé\ê.9q?L6;.ç587‡@C9HIBÂè6DÂO>5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8BEO{;êG6BÂDÂO

9qDÂDÂ5êBEKCá'7:9qëVBÂ7:9<D‘ïs?AOjOjLª5875<ïP5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8T:7‡5ªLªBEðJçQ9qHABÂ5<KíŒ3.G6O'LªOQðCK6BEHABÂ58KÄ5qïP58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8T

BEKJçDÂ4C;ABE58KŠ9<DÂDE5ê¡;4J;HI5'çGC9<K6á<OHIG6O¾BEKJçDÂ4CLªO{LS5<K\HA58DE58á<T#BEïHIG6O¾çGJ9qK6á8O>Lª5VOj;mK65qH.9ù‘OjçH

HAG6OÄ@C9<?¤H;SHAGJ9HN9q?IO1?AOQúž4J;¤O{LìBÂKœ5qHAGCOQ?‡5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8BEO{;íR¡5êZOQU8OQ?jäx;A5<7‡OQHABÂ7‡Oj;'9qK¸5<K\HI5<DEú

5<á<T ?IO \46BÂ?AO{;#;A5º@6?I5qïs5<4CKCL÷çGC9qKCá<Oj;#HAGC9qH'BEH'BF;K65qHŠ@J5\;A;ABÂè6DÂO'HI5 é8OQOQ@ìB«H'èC9<çéVê.9q?L6;

ç5<7‡@J9HABÂè6DÂO<íUdKÐHAG6BF;¼çQ98;¤O'HAG6O‡;ATª;cHIOQ7;AG65<46DFL BEK6ïs5<?I7 HIG6OS4C;AOQ?êGC9qH¼çQ5<KC;AO \46OjKCçO{;

G6BF;>çGC9<K6á<OêZ5<46DFL1çQ9<4C;AOqäJ9<KCLÄ4C;AOHAGCBÂ;>BÂKªïs5<?I7:9HIBE58K:HI5:G6OQDÂ@º;A5<DÂU<O¾HIG6O'LªOj@JOjKCLªOjKCçT

@6?A58è6DÂOQ7:;mBEïzHAGCO#çGC9qK6á8OƒBF;.OQëVO{ç4ªHIOjL‘í

¡5Tî9qKCL =¼DEOjBÂKœâEãjöqæZBFLªOjK\HABEðCOjL¶å8åÄ58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8T çGC9<K6á<O5<@ŒOQ?9HABÂ58KC;#9qKJL¶9qKC9<DÂT jOjL

HAG6Oj7 êBEHAGî?IOj;A@JO{ç"H¼HA51HIG6O‡BÂKC;cH9qKCçQOúdL69H9N@C?AO{;¤Oj?AU9HIBÂ5<K LªBÂ7‡OjKC;¤BÂ58Kí‘3.GCOQT LªO{;AçQ?ABÂèŒO

êGC9HL69H9êm5846DFL¾èJOmDE5\;cHz9qHlHAGCOPBÂKC;¤HI9qKJçOj;lBEK¼HIG6OmçGJ9qK6á8OjL¾5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<Tƒ9qKCL¼êZ5<46DFLƒHAGCOQ?IO

èJO7‡O{9qKC;HA5#9`U85<BFL¼HIG6O¡L69H9¾DE5\;A;QíR¡5êZOQU<Oj?Qäq9¼çDÂ5\;¤Oj?BÂKC;A@JO{ç"HIBE58K5<ïJHIG6O¡çGC9qKCá<OZ5<@ŒOQ?Aú

9HABÂ58KC;xHIG6OQTSGC9`U8O>BFLªOQK\HIB«ðJOjLŠ?AOjU<O{9qDF;HAGJ9H;¤587‡O¡5qïHIG6OQ7&çj9qK:èŒO¾çQ5<7‡@Œ58;AOjLŠïs?I5<7ØHAGCO

5qHAGCOQ?.5<@ŒOQ?9HIBE58KC;xèVT‡@ŒOQ?Aïs5<?I7‡BEKCá¼HAG6O¼5qHIG6OQ?Z5<@ŒOQ?9HIBÂ5<KC;PBEK9'çQOQ?AHI9qBÂKN;AO \46OjKCçO<í

ó

;.9

ç5<KJ;¤O84COQKCçQOqäqHIG6O>;I9q7‡O.?AO{;¤4CD«H;9q?IO.@6?IOj;AOQK\HAO{LŠ;AOQU8OQ?9qDVHIBE7‡O{;ïs5<?mLªBEùŒOj?AOjK8HPçQ5<7‡@Œ58;AOjL

5<@ŒOQ?9HABÂ58KC;BEKŠHIG6OQBÂ?P9<KC9qDÂTª;¤BF;Qí`3.GCBÂ;P;¤46á8á<O{;cH;HAGC9qHm97‡5<?IOZOëª@6?IOj;I;¤BÂU<O.;A5<DÂ4ªHABÂ58K'êZ5<46DFL

èJOZHA5LªOQðCK6O9¾;¤OQH5<ïŒ9qHA5<7‡BFççGJ9qK6á8Om58@JOj?I9qHABÂ5<KC;lHAGC9qHx@JOj?¤ïs58?A7 ïs4CKCL69q7‡OjK\HI9qDVçGC9<K6á<O{;

HA5HIG6O>58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8T;¤HA?I4Cç"HI46?AO<ä\9<KCLŠHAG6OjKN9qKJ9qDÂT QO.HAGCO>7‡5<?IOç587‡@6DÂOë58@JOj?I9qHABÂ5<KC;èVT‡9qK6ú

9qDÂT QBÂK6á#HIG6O#ç587'èCBEKCOjL‡OQùŒO{ç"HI;¡5qïHAG6O#9qHA5<7‡BFç>5<@ŒOQ?9HABÂ58KC;mHAGC9qH>9q?IOƒ4C;AOjLHI5:ç5<7‡@Œ58;AO

HAG6Oj71í à 46?7‡5<?IO¾çQ5<KCçQBF;¤O¾;¤OQH¡5qïmãQS9HA587‡BFç¡5<@ŒOQ?9HIBÂ5<KC;ƒâ«ã qælBF;ZèC9<;AOjL5<KHAGCO#çGC9qK6á8O

5<@ŒOQ?9HABÂ58KC;5<ï?>5T¶9qKCL¸=¼DÂOQBÂKÝâEãjöqægí UdK HAGCOº;¤OQH:êmO1GC9`U8O+;AOQDÂOjçHAO{L¶HIG6O15<@ŒOQ?9HABÂ58KC;

HAGC9qH¾çQ9<KÄèJO'4C;AOjL+HA5+ç587‡@J5\;¤O¾HAGCO5qHIG6OQ?ƒ5<@ŒOQ?9HIBE58KC;QíUdK 9<L6L6B«HIBÂ5<KHA5:HIG6OBÂKC;¤HI9<KCçOQú

L69H9‡@6?IOj;AOQ?IU`9qHABÂ5<K1LªBÂ7‡OQKJ;¤BÂ5<Klä\HIG6OQBÂ?¡OQùŒO{ç"H;>58K1HAG6OŠçDF9<;I;9qKCLº@6?A58@JOj?¤HcTG6BÂOQ?9q?çG6BÂOj;

9q?IO9qDF;A5 9qKJ9qDÂT QOjLä9qKJL÷HAGCO+çGC9<K6á<OOù‘OjçHI;Š5<KìHAG6O+5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<BFçj9qDLªOj@JOjKCLªOQKJçBÂOj;Š9q?IO

ç5<KJ;¤BFLªOj?AO{L êG6OjK¶91?AOQúž4J;¤O{LÐ58K\HA5<DÂ58á<TÄBF;#çGC9<K6á<O{L‘íz3.G6ON9<KC9qDÂTª;¤BF;¾BF;¼DÂBE7‡BEHIOjLÄHI5ÄHAGCO

(5)

HAG6O¾9HA587‡BFçmçGC9<K6á<O58@JOj?I9qHABÂ5<KJ;x9qKCLŠHIG6Oƒ9<KC9qDÂTª;¤BF;?IOj;A46DEHI;ïs46DÂDÂT'LªO{;AçQ?ABÂèŒOjLŠBÂK1â«ã qæží<òîO

LªOQ7‡58KC;cHI?I9qHAO.HIG6O>BFLªO{9¼G6OQ?IO¡èVTS@6?AO{;¤OjK\HABÂK6á¾HAG6O¼9qKJ9qDÂTª;¤BF;5qï‘HAGCOƒ58@JOj?I9qHABÂ5<K OQ7‡5UVBÂK6á

9'@C?A58@JOj?¤HcT‡ïs?I5<7 9ŠçQDF9<;I;í

²\® G\´ y£\vjY\¢j_+hjuª_Ia¤vQec[^h{Y8b‡vjY\  ec£\_[»aŠ_I¿6_~Iecb€myÃ~novjbdbŠ£\[^_Ia¤vQac~¤£frx&u8ach{uª_Aadežf

£8[^_Ia¤vQac~¤£fr8 ¸[oY8bše¤vjY8~_¡ \ve¤v<r8t˜œh{Yech{n^hj¢jfŠ 8_uª_Y\ 8_Y8~[^_b€

!

" # $&%'"

yac_"vQec[^Y\¢¼v¾~novjbdbrVv¾u8achjuª_IadežfhjamvQYS[^Y\bše¤vjY8~_

t._n^_Iec[^Y\¢¾v¾~novjbdb ( ( (

t._n^_Iec[^Y\¢¾v¾u8achjuª_Iadežf ( ( (

t._n^_Iec[^Y\¢¾vjYS[^Y\bše¤vQY\~_ ( (

ÀP 8 8[^Y\¢ƒv¾u<ach{uª_Iadegfech¼v¾~novjbdb

™m_wh]q[^Y\¢ƒv¾u8achjuª_Iadežfi«ach{wv¾~novQbdb ( ( (

ÀP 8 8[^Y\¢ƒv¾bd|8uª_Iac~novjbdb

™m_wh]q[^Y\¢ƒv¾bd|\uª_Aac~novjbdb ( ( (

ÀP 8 8[^Y\¢ƒv¾bd|8uª_Iacu8achjuª_Iadežf

™m_wh]q[^Y\¢ƒv¾bd|\uª_Aacu8ach{uª_Aadežf ( ( (

™m_I“¹~novQbdbd[^i«f<[oY8¢vjYŠ[oY8bše¤vjY8~_¡vjbPv¾~novQbdb ( (

™m_I“¹~novQbdbd[^i«f<[oY8¢v¾~novQbdbZvQbmvQYS[^Y\bše¤vQY\~_ ( ( (

t._~novQac[^Y8¢¾ež¨h¼~novjbdbd_bm 8[^b*)šh{[^Ye ( ( (

t._I©VY8[^Y\¢ƒv¾u8achjuª_Iadežf#eda¤vjY8bd[»ec[o]{_hjaPbšf<ww_Iedac[^~ ( ( (

µ [o 8_Y8[oY8¢¼vƒac_Ibšedac[o~Aec[ohjYŠiÂhQa.vƒu8ach{uª_Aadežf

’.vQadach"¨[^Y\¢¼vƒac_bšedac[^~Iec[^h{YŠiEhjaZv¾u8achjuª_Iadežf ( ( (

OQ7‡5UVBÂK6á9Š@6?I5<@ŒOQ?AHcT,+ïs?A587Ã9SçDF9<;I;.- ?IOQ7‡5U8Oj;mB«H.ïs?I5<7øHIG6O#;A46èŒçQDF9<;I;¤O{;m5<ï/-'ä

HA5V56í UdKC;¤HI9<KCçO{;P5<ï0- ¹9<KCL‡5<ïzBEHI;Z;¤46è‘çDF98;A;AOj;% DÂ58;AOHAGCOQBÂ?mU9<DE4COj;xïs58?.+ŠíV3.G6O¼çDF98;A;&- BF;

K65:DÂ5<K6á8OQ?BÂK6G6Oj?ABEHIOjLHA5NHAG6OL65<7:9qBÂK15qï1+Šõ»;>;A46è6@6?I5<@ŒOQ?AHABÂO{;äJ9<KCL+HAGCOBÂKC;¤HI9qKJçOj;¡5qï2-

9qKCLŠ5qïŒHAGCO>;¤4CèŒçQDÂ98;A;AOj;5<ï- DÂ58;AO9qDÂDªU9qDÂ46Oj;ïs58?xHAG65\;¤O@C?A58@JOj?¤HIBEO{;íUšï‘HAGCO¡?I9<K6á<O.5<ï3+ BF;

9>çDF98;A;58?9<K#BÂKC;cH9qKCçQO14'ä{?IOQ7‡5UVBÂK6á.+œïs?A5875-Á?AOj7‡5U<Oj;9ƒ;¤Oj7:9qK\HABFç?IOQDF9HIBE58KƒèŒOHcêZOQOjK

- 9qKCL1HIG6O?9qKCá<O#çDF98;A;58?>BÂKC;¤HI9<KCçO64'í‘3.G6O';ABEHA4C9qHABÂ5<K1èŒOjç587‡Oj;U8OQ?IT4CKCçDÂOj9<?G6OQ?IOqä

èJO{çQ9q4J;¤OHIG6O¡é8OQTŠBÂL6Oj9¼5qï?IOúš4C;ABEKCá¼9<K‡5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<TBF;HI5#?IOúš4C;¤O¡9<KCLSOQKC?ABFçGŠHAG6O¾;¤Oj7:9qK\HABFç

BEK6ïs5<?I7:9HABÂ58K ;¤HA58?AO{LîBEKìB«HjíòÝGCOQK¶HIG6BF;BÂKªïs58?A7:9qHABÂ5<KÐBF;'9<D«HIOQ?IOjL‘äzHAG6O1ç58K8HIOëVH'5<ï¡HAGCO

5<K\HA58DE58á<T¼çGC9qKCá<Oj;Qí

ó

;x9¾ç5<KJ;¤O84COQKCçQOqä{HAG6O;AOQ7:9qK\HIBÂçj;l5<ïCHAGCO.çGJ9qK6á8OPBÂK#HIG6O.BEKJçDÂ4CLªBÂK6á

5<K\HA58DE58á<BÂOj;¼9<?AO‡46KCé\KC5êKí

ó

HŠêm58?I;¤HQäHAG6O+çGC9qK6á8O:çQ9<K¶è6?IOj9qé HAG6O+;¤Oj7:9qK\HABFçj;¼5qïHAGCO

5<K\HA58DE58á<BÂOj;PBÂKCçDÂ4CLªBÂK6á'HAGCO#çGC9qK6á8OjL5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<T<í UdK198L6LªBEHABÂ58KäVHAG6O#BÂKCçQDÂ4CLªBÂK6á58K\HA5<DÂ58á<BÂOj;

ç5<K\HIBEKV46OºHA5ì?IOïsOj?NHI57+ ïs?I5<7%HIG6OÐBÂKC;¤HI9<KCçO{;:5<ï8- 9qKCL 5qï#BEHI;+;A46èŒçQDF9<;I;¤O{;ím3.GCOj;AO

?AOQïsOQ?IOQKCçQOj;9q?IOSè6?I5<é<OjKíl3.G6O:çGC9<K6á<OSDÂ58;AOj;¼L69qHI9+5<KîBÂKC;¤HI9qKJçOŠDEOjU<OjDgä7:9`TÄè6?IOj9<éÄHAGCO

;¤Oj7:9qK\HABFçQ;¡5qïPHIG6OSçDF9<;I;¡7‡5ªLªOjDgä9qKJLº7:9`T+BEK\HI?A5ªLª4CçQOBÂKVU9qDÂBFL?IOïsOj?AOjKCçO{;>BÂKÐ?AOQïsOQ?I?ABÂK6á

5<K\HA58DE58á<BÂOj;Qí

3.G6Oƒ9<KC9qDÂTª;¤BF;x?IOj;A46DEHI;P5qï9qHA587‡BÂççGJ9qK6á8Oj;Pçj9qK:èŒO¼4C;AOjLSHI5Š9<KC9qDÂT QO¡7‡58?AOƒç5<7‡@CDEOQë

5<K\HA58DE58á<T çGJ9qK6á8O‡5<@ŒOQ?9HABÂ58KC;í ó ç587‡@6DÂOë 58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8T çGC9<K6á<O:58@JOj?I9qHABÂ5<KîçQ9<K÷èJO+LªOú

(6)

OQU<Oj?Qä8BEKS;A5<7‡OçQ98;¤O{;HAG6O>Où‘Ojç"HZçQ9qKSèŒO>;A7:9qDÂDÂOQ?jí5658?Oë69<7‡@6DÂOqäêG6OQK:9çQDF9<;I;BÂ;7‡5U8OjL

HA5N9<K65qHIG6OQ?è6?9qKJçG+BÂK+HAGCOçDF9<;I;ZHA?IOQOBEHðC?;¤H>DÂ58;AOj;ZHAGCO#@6?I5<@ŒOQ?AHABÂOj;ZBEH>BÂK6G6Oj?ABEHAO{L‡ïs?I5<7

HAG6O¼5<DFL:;A46@ŒOQ?çDF9<;I;AOj;P9<KCLNHAG6OjKBÂK6G6Oj?ABEH;xHAGCO¾@C?A58@JOj?¤HIBEO{;ïs?I5<7 HIG6O¼K6OQêÅ;¤4C@JOj?IçQDÂ98;A;AOj;Qí

ñV5<7‡O5<ïHIG6ODÂ5\;cH¡@6?I5<@ŒOQ?AHABÂO{;.7:9`TNèŒO#?AOQúžBÂK6GCOQ?IB«HIOjLBÂKHIG6O';AOjçQ5<KCL1@CGC9<;AOqíJ3.GCBÂ;>GC9q@6ú

@JOjKC;BEïªHAG6O.K6Ojêì;¤4C@JOj?IçQDÂ98;A;AOj;zGC9`U<OPHAG65\;¤OZ@6?I5<@ŒOQ?AHABÂOj;Qí3.G6OmU9<DE4COj;5qï6HIG658;AOm@C?A58@JOj?¤HIBEO{;

K6OQO{LSK65qHPèŒO¡DÂ58;¤HQí\3.G6O>;ATV;¤HAOj7 êZ5<4CDÂL'K6OjOjLŠHA5?AOj7‡5U<O.9qKCL‡98L6LS5<K6DÂT9;¤46èJ;¤OQHP5qï‘HAGCO

@6?A58@JOj?¤HIBÂOj;.HIGC9HƒHAG6OŠ9HA587‡BFç¾çGJ9qK6á8Oj;¡êZ5<4CDÂL+?IO \46BÂ?IOqíJ3.G6Oj?AOQïs5<?IOqä6HIG6OQ?IOBF;¡9<Kº46@6@ŒOQ?

DEBÂ7‡BEH¾HA51HAGCO:Où‘OjçHI;#5<ï¡9ºç587‡@J5\;¤BEHAOSçGC9<K6á<O<í3.G6O‡Où‘OjçHI;'çQ9qKCK65qHèŒO:á8?AO{9HAOj?¼HAGC9<K

HAG6OOQùŒO{ç"HI;¡5qïO{9<çG19HI5<7‡BFç>çGC9<K6á<O¾@ŒOQ?Aïs5<?I7‡OjLN;AO \46OjK\HABF9qDÂDÂT'58KNHIG6O5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8Tqí

3.G6O>ç587‡@J5\;¤BEHIO.çGJ9qK6á8O¡9q@6@6?I5898çG‡9qDÂDÂ5ê¡;4J;xHA57‡BEKCBE7‡BjOHAGCO>Où‘OjçHI;m5qïlLªBEù‘OQ?IOQK\H

ç5<7‡@Œ58;ABEHAOçGC9<K6á<O{;.è\T+è6?IOj9<é\BÂK6á'HAGCOQ7BÂK8HI5:9HI5<7‡BFçƒçGJ9qK6á8Oj;¡9<KCL+HAG6OjKÄOQDÂBÂ7‡BÂKC9HIBEKCá

?AO{Lª46KCL69<K\HmçGC9qKCá<Oj;xïs?A587 HIG6OƒçGJ9qK6á8O¡;¤O84COQKCçQOqí\3.GCBÂ;PO \4C9<DÂ;xHA5çj9qDFç46DF9qHABÂK6áƒHAG6O¾LªBEïFú

ïsOQ?IOQKCçQOèJOQHcêmOjOQKSHAGCO>;cH9HIO5qï‘HAG6O>5<K\HA58DE58á<T¼èŒOïs5<?IO¡9qKJL‡9ïFHAOj?xHAGCO>ç587‡@J5\;¤BEHAO.çGC9<K6á<O<í

×¶ÙZÓªÉÑcÉÚxÛ Ï>ËكÚÖºÌCɑÖzÎVÎ

3.G6O5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<T¼LªOjU<OQDÂ58@JOj?@ŒOQ?Aïs5<?I7:;OjLªBEHx5<@ŒOQ?9HIBE58KC;5<KŠHAG6OéVK65êDÂO{Lªá<OmèC9<;AOqí ó KŠO{LªBEH

5<@ŒOQ?9HABÂ58K‡BÂ;ZLªOQðCK6OjL9<;Z9';AOH.5qï9HA587‡BFççGC9qK6á8O>58@JOj?I9qHABÂ5<KC;Pá<?I5<46@ŒOjL‡HA5<á8OHIG6OQ?jíV3.GCO

çGC9qK6á8Oj;SçQ9<K èŒOÄ@ŒOQ?Aïs5<?I7‡OjLì;AO \46OjK\HABF9qDÂDÂT 58?‡BEKœ@C9<?I9<DEDÂOjDgí3.G6O17‡5VL6O+5<ïƒOQëVO{ç4ªHIBÂ5<K

BÂ;L6OHAOj?A7‡BÂK6O{LÄèVTºHIG6O‡OjLªBEHjõ;LªO{;¤BÂá8K6OQ?jíñª5<7‡O‡çGC9qKCá<Oj;¾K6OjOjLÐHA51èŒO‡@JOj?¤ïs58?A7‡O{LºBÂKî9

;¤@ŒOjçQB«ðŒçP58?ILªOj?zHI59<çQçQ5<7‡@6DÂBF;AGƒHIG6OLªOj;ABÂ?AO{L#?IOj;A46DEHQí OQ?Aïs5<?I7‡BEKCáHAG6Oj7 BÂKŠ9<K65qHIG6OQ?5<?LªOj?

êm5846DFLS@6?A5ªLª4JçOƒL6B«ù‘OQ?IOQK\HP@Œ58;¤H.5<@ŒOQ?9HABÂ58KS;¤HI9qHAO<íªñV587‡OHIBE7‡O{;HAGCOQ?IO>BF;xïs?IOQO{Lª5<7 BÂK‡HAGCO

OëªOjçQ4ªHABÂ5<K5<?LªOQ?jí5C5<?Oë69<7‡@6DÂOqäjêGCOQKŠ7‡OQ?Iá<BÂK6á>;AOQU8OQ?9qD8çQDF9<;I;¤O{;lBÂK\HA5¾5<K6O<ä{HIG6O.?AO{;¤4CD«HBF;

HAG6O;I9q7‡OP?IOQá\9q?LªDÂOj;I;l5<ïJêG6BFçGHcêZ5¾çQDF9<;I;¤O{;9<?AOm7‡OQ?Iá<OjLðC?I;¤HQí:UdK'HAGCOj;AO.çj9<;AOj;Qäq9qDÂDÂ5êBEKCá

@C9q?9qDÂDÂOQDJOëªOjçQ4ªHABÂ5<K19qDÂDÂ5ê¡;éVK65êDÂO{Lªá<OƒèC9<;AO¼@JOj?¤ïs58?A7:9<KCçOƒ5<@ªHIBE7‡B{9HABÂ58KC;í

3.G6O¼OjLªBEH5<@ŒOQ?9HIBE58KC;PHAGC9qHHAG6O58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8T‡LªOQU8OQDÂ5<@ŒOQ?.Lª5VOj;.7Š4C;¤H.èŒO#çQ9<@ªHA4C?AO{L9<KCL

HAG6OjBE?zOù‘Ojç"H;lU9qDÂBFL69qHAOjL>èJOQïs5<?IOxHAGCOQT¼9q?IOxOëªOjçQ4ªHAO{Lƒ58K¼HAG6OP46KCLªOj?ADÂTVBÂK6áméVK65êDÂO{Lªá<OèC98;¤O<í

5BÂá846?AONå+@C?AO{;¤OjK8H;917‡5ªLªOjDP5<K÷GC5êHI5 Lª5ÄHIG6BF;#BÂK÷9ºLªBF;cHI?ABÂè646HAOjL OjK\UVBÂ?I5<K67‡OjK8Hjí

ó

çGC9qK6á8O#BFLªOQK\HIB«ðŒçQ9HIBÂ5<KNDF9`T8OQ?BF;K6OjOjLªO{LÄèJOQHcêmOjOQKÄHIG6O58K\HA5<DÂ58á<T:O{LªBEHA5<?>4C;¤Oj?>BÂK\HAOj?¤ï¹98çO

9qKCLîHIG6O+é\KC5êDEO{Lªá<O‡èJ9<;AOqí lBF;cHIOQK6Oj?I;#HAGC9qHŠ9<?AO?AOjá<BF;cHIOQ?IOjLÐHA5 HAG6BF;'DF9`T<OQ??IOjçQOQBÂU<O:9<DÂD

4C;¤Oj?#5<@ŒOQ?9HIBÂ5<KC;¼9qKJL çj9qK¶çj9qKCçQOQDxHIG6OQ7 èJOQïs5<?IOSHAG6OjT 9<?AOS@ŒOQ?Aïs5<?I7‡OjL‘íz3.GCO:DÂBÂ;¤HAOjK6OQ?;

ïs5<?I7 9ŠçGC9<BEK‡5<ïlU9qDÂBFL69HI5<?;HAGC9qHmHIG6O¾5<@ŒOQ?9HABÂ58KŠ7Š4C;¤Hm@C98;A;mBÂK:5<?LªOj?HA5ŠèŒOƒOQëVO{ç4ªHIOjL‘í

3.G6OSBÂL6OQK\HABEðJçj9HABÂ58K+DF9`T8OQ?ƒ98ç"H;9<;¼9çGCOjçéV@J58BÂK8HƒHAG6?I5<4Cá<G êGCBÂçG 9qDÂDOjLªBEH¼5<@ŒOQ?9HABÂ58KC;

7'4C;¤H@C9<;I;Qí/UšH>9<DÂDE5ê¡;P5<K6O¾HI5‡BEK\HIOQ?IU<OQKCOƒ9qKJLOjU9qDÂ4C9HIO>HIG6O;A9qïsOHcT:5<ïHIG6OOjL6B«H;ZèJOQïs5<?IO

HAG6OjTN9q?IO>ê?IBEH¤HAOjK:BÂK:HIG6O¼é\KC5êDEO{Lªá<O>èC9<;AOqíª3.G6O¼BFLªOQK\HABEðJçj9HIBE58KSDÂ9`T8OQ?m7'4C;¤Hmá84C9q?9qK\HIOQO

HAGC9qH:HAG6OÐ9HA587‡BFççGC9<K6á<O{;‡9q?IOºç58?A?IOjçHADÂT÷á<?I5<46@ŒOjLœBÂK\HA5îOjL6B«H;íPòÝB«HIG65<46H:á<?I5<46@6BÂK6áCä

B«HŠBF;#K65<H'@Œ58;I;¤BÂè6DÂOSHA5 ç587‡@64ªHAO:HAG6O+@J5\;cHŠ5<@ŒOQ?9HIBE58K÷;cH9HAO<íRƒ9`UVBEKCáÄBEK\HIOQ?çOQ@6HAOjL÷9<K

OjLªBEH¡5<@ŒOQ?9HIBÂ5<KäªHIG6OBFLªOjK8HIBEðJçQ9qHABÂ5<K:DF9`T8OQ?Zïs5<?IêZ9<?ILC;.B«H>HA5N9‡çGC9<K6á<O¼ðJD«HIOQ?IBÂK6á'DF9`T8OQ?jíUšH

çG6Ojçéª;ŠBEï¡HAG6O1O{LªBEHSçj9q4C;AOj;Sç58K XCBFç"H;ŠBEKìHAG6O1BÂKCçQDE4JLªBÂK6áº5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8BEO{;í Ušï¼K65<HQäHAG6OÄO{LªBEH

çQ9qK÷èŒON;I9ïsOjDETÐ@JOj?¤ïs58?A7‡O{LÐ9<KCLîBEH#BF;¼ïs5<?IêZ9<?IL6OjLÐHA5ÄHIG6O:éVK65êDÂOjL6á<OSèC9<;AOqä5qHAGCOQ?IêBÂ;AO

ç5<?I?IOjç"HIBÂU<O>7‡O{9<;A46?IOj;Z;¤G65846DFL:èŒO¼HI9<é<OQKlí

MP9<çGNçGJ9qK6á8O>BÂKN9qKOjLªBEHZ5<@ŒOQ?9HABÂ58K:9ù‘Ojç"H;.9çOj?¤H9qBÂK:KV467ŠèJOj?P5<ïç58KCçOj@ªHI;mBÂK:HAGCO

5<K\HA58DE58á<T'HA5ŠèJOçGC9<K6á<O{L‘íª3.G6OçGC9qK6á8O¡ðCDEHIOQ?IBEKCá#DF9`T<OQ?PðC?;cHLªOHIOQ?I7‡BÂK6Oj;PHAG6OçQ5<KCçQOQ@ªH;

(7)

C D-F ‚ZYechjnohj¢jf'~A£\vjY8¢{_u8ach~I_bdb€

çQ9qDFçQ46DF9HAO{;ZêGC9H¡HIG6OLªBEù‘OQ?IOQKCçQOBÂKHIG6OQBÂ?¡;¤HI9qHAO#êZ5<46DFLèJO'èJOQïs5<?IO#9qKCLÄ9qïFHAOj?HAG6O'OjLªBEHjí

3.G6O#DF9`T<Oj?¡çG6Ojçéª;.ïs?I5<7 HAG6O';¤Oj?AU8OQ?¡BEïHAG6O'ç5<KJçOQ@6HI;¡êGC58;AO;cH9HIO#êm5846DFLNèŒO'çGJ9qK6á8OjL

9q?IO#?AOQïsOQ?IOQKCçQOjL1BÂK1HAGCOBÂKCçDÂ4CL6BEKCáŠ58K\HA5<DÂ58á<BÂOj;Qí2UšïxHIG6OQTÄ9<?AO<äCHAGCO'çGC9<K6á<O#OQùŒO{ç"H;>BÂK1HAGCO

BEKJçDÂ4CLªBÂK6á¼5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8BEO{;9q?IO>çQ9<DÂçQ46DF9HIOjLŠ;cH9q?AHABÂK6áïs?I5<7 HAG6O¾?IOïsOQ?IOQKJçBÂK6á¼OQDÂOQ7‡OjK\HI;QíVUšïlHAGCO

Où‘Ojç"H;Zêm5846DFL‡çQ9q4J;¤O¾9'çQ5<K XCBFçHm5<?ZDÂ58;I;5<ïzL69H9BÂK‡HIG6OƒBÂKCçQDÂ4CLªBÂK6á5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8BEO{;äHIG6O¼;¤Tª;¤ú

HAOQ7 GJ9<;>ïs5<46KCLÐ9:@6?I5<èCDEOj71íJ3.G6O'4C;¤Oj?¾çj9qK6KC5qH¾;AOQO'HAGCOj;AO@6?I5<è6DÂOj7:;èVT+DÂ5V5<éVBÂK6áS5<KCDET

9H¡HIG6O58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8T:G6O'BÂ;>çGC9qK6á8BÂK6á6íUcLªOjK\HABEïsTVBEKCáSHAG6Oj7KCOQOjLC;>BÂKªïs58?A7:9qHABÂ5<K:58KºG65êÅHAGCO

5<K\HA58DE58á<T‡BF;.?IOúš4C;¤O{L+BEK+HIG6O#BÂKCçDÂ4CL6BEKCá'58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8BÂOj;Qí\3.G6BF;BÂ7‡@6DÂBÂOj;PHAGC9qHHAG6Oj?AO7'4C;¤H¡èŒO

9:ç587‡7‡5<K19<çQçQOj;I;@Œ5<BÂK\H¡HA5+9qDÂDl5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8BEO{;m9<KCL1HI5‡HAG6OŠLªOQ@ŒOQKJLªOQKCçQT1BEK6ïs5<?I7:9HABÂ58Kí ó

;¤Oj?AU8OQ?èC9<;AOjLŠ58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8T¼DEBÂè6?9q?IT¼BF;x;¤46á8á<O{;cHIOjLïs5<?HAGCBÂ;@646?I@J5\;¤O<í à K6O¡;¤GC5<46DFL'K65qHIO.HAGC9qH

5<46?‡9q@C@6?A5\9<çG¶BÂKCçQDÂ4CLªOj;Š9 ç5<7‡@C?A587‡BÂ;AOqí UšH‡BF;ŠK65qH‡@Œ58;I;¤BÂè6DÂO‡HI5îá<46BFLªONHAG6OÄLªOjU<OQDÂ58@ªú

7‡OQK\H¾5<ïm?IOúš4C;AOjLº58K\HA5<DÂ58á<BÂOj;.êBEHAGC5<4ªH¼éVK65êDÂOjLªá8O5<KÐêGC9HBÂKºHIG6OQ7 BÂ;¾O{;A;AOQK\HABF9<Dzïs58?

HAG6OŠ?AOQúž4J;¤Oj?I;Qí W 5<K6ðJLªOQK\HIBÂ9<Dz58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8BÂOj;Z7:9`TKC5qHƒê.9qK\H¡HI5@C46è6DÂBF;¤G+HAGCBÂ;ƒBÂKªïs5<?I7:9HIBÂ5<Kí

W

5<7‡@6DÂOHIO¾çGJ9qK6á8OƒDÂ5<á\;mçQ5<46DFLèJO4J;¤O{L:HI5:;¤46@C@J58?¤H.HAGCOQBÂ?¡LªOQU8OQDÂ5<@C7‡OQK\HQí

ó

K#O{LªBEHz5<@ŒOQ?9HIBE58K¾HAGC9qHçQ9<4C;AOj;l@C?A58è6DÂOQ7:;‘BF;ïs58?Aê.9q?LªOjLƒHI5ƒ9@6?I5<èCDEOj7ÅL6BÂ;A@C9qHIçG6BÂK6á

BEK\HIOQ?Aï¹9<çO<ím3.G6Oj?AO LªBEùŒOj?AOjK8HN;A5<DÂU8OQ?;‡çQ9qK DEBF;¤HAOjK HI5ì@6?I5<èCDEOj7:;‡9qKCLÁ9qH¤HIOQ7‡@ªHHA5¶ðJKCL

;¤58DE46HABÂ5<KC;HA5¡HIG6OQ71í`MP98çG#OjLªBEH7:9`T¾çj9q4C;AOP;AOQU<Oj?I9<D<@6?I5<èCDEOj7:;í{3.G6OP@6?I5<èCDEOj7:;l9qKJL¼HAG6OjBÂ?

Où‘Ojç"H;#9q?IOŠá<?I5<46@ŒOjL HA58á<OHIG6OQ?êBEHIG HIG6O‡OjLªBEH¼HA51BFLªOjK8HIBEïsT1HAG6O‡?I5V5qH5qïZHAG6O‡@C?A58è6DÂOQ71í

3.G6OBÂK8HIOQ?Aï¹9<çQO¼L6BÂ;A@C9qHIçG6O{;ZHAG6OO{LªBEHHA5:9‡çGC9<BEK+5qï?IOQá<BF;¤HAOj?AO{L:@6?I5<è6DÂOj7Ã;¤58DÂU<OQ?;Qí\MP98çG

;¤58DEU8OQ?¼7:9`T ;A5<DÂU<OS9qKVTÐK\4C7'èŒOQ?#5<ïZ@C?A58è6DÂOQ7:;¼9<;I;¤5ªçQBÂ9qHAO{LºêBEHAG HAGCO:OjLªBEHjäçQ9<KCçOjDxHAGCO

OjLªBEHç5<7‡@CDEOQHAOjDET'5<?mïs5<?çO>HAG6O¼OjL6B«HmHA5ŠèJO¼@ŒOQ?Aïs5<?I7‡OjL‘í ó 46HA5<7:9qHABFç58?Z;AOQ7‡BEúd9q4ªHI5<7:9HIBFç

@6?A58è6DÂOQ7 ;A5<DÂUVBÂK6áZ7‡OHAGC5VLC;lç5846DFLƒèŒO4C;AOjLí{3.G6Oxïs58?IçQOx5<@ŒOQ?9HIBE58KƒBF;7‡O{9qK\H‘ïs5<?9qDÂDÂ5êBEKCá

HAG6Oƒ4C;¤Oj?xHA5@JOj?¤ïs58?A7HAG6OƒOjLªBEHPLªO{;¤@6BEHIO¡5qï‘HAGCO¡Où‘OjçHI;mB«HPçj9q4C;AOj;xHA5#5<HAG6Oj?P5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8BEO{;íUšï

HAG6O#O{LªBEH>BF;çQ9<KCçOjDEO{L+BEK+HIG6O;A5<DÂU<Oj?QäªBEHI;>@6?A5ªçQOj;I;¤BÂK6áŠOQKCLC;íUšïHIG6O#O{LªBEH>BF;.ïs5<?çO{LNHI5:èŒO

9<çQçQOQ@ªHIOjL‘äBEH¾ðC?I;¤H¼@C9<;I;¤O{;¼9qDÂD;A5<DÂU8OQ?;¡9qKCLÐBF;¡HIG6OQKîLªBÂ?IOjç"HIOjL1HI5+HAG6OSéVK65êDÂOjLªá8O#èC98;¤O<í

3.G6O'O{LªBEH¼9<KCLÄHIG6OS@6?I5<è6DÂOQ7:;¡B«HçQ9<4C;AOj;¾9q?IO'?IOjçQ5<?LªOjL+HI5+9DÂ5<á:HIGC9HçQ9<K èŒOS4C;¤O{LÄHI5

BÂL6OQK\HABEïsTÄ9qKCLÐG6OjDE@ ;¤58DÂU<O#HIG6OS@6?I5<è6DÂOQ7:;>BÂK HIG6OSBEKJçDÂ4CLªBÂK6á:58K\HA5<DÂ58á<BÂOj;QíS¡KCDEO{;A;ƒïs58?IçQOjL

(8)

èC9<;AOqí ó K65qHIB«ðŒçQ9HIBÂ5<K+BÂ;¡á<OQKCOQ?9HAO{L:ïs58?>9‡éVK65êDÂOjL6á<O¾èC9<;AO#7‡5ªLªBEðJçQ9qHABÂ5<KNBEK\HIOQ?Aï¹9<çO¾HI5

DEOQH.HAG6O4C;AOQ?BÂK\HAOj?¤ï¹98çO¼ç587‡@J58K6OQK\HI;Z?IOïs?IOj;AG:HIG6OQBÂ?UVBÂOQêÝ5<ïHIG6OéVK65êDÂOjLªá8O>èC98;¤O<í

×¶ÙZÓªÉÑcÉÚxÛ ËÙ>ËÚÖzß ÖlÙZÓ ºÌJÉ ‘ÖÎ\ÎËÙƒÍ ÏƒËÙ>ÚÖ

ÌCÉxރËÚËÓªÔcÉÙ

ó ;ATª;cHIOQ7?IO \46BÂ?IOjL1ïs58?¼5<K\HA58DE58á<T1LªOQ@ŒOQKJLªOQKCçQTº7:9qKJ9qá<Oj7‡OQK\H>BF;¾LªOQ@6BFçHAOjLÐBÂK 5BÂá<46?IO

öªí;UšH+BF;:9¶çDÂBÂOQK\HAúš;AOQ?IU<Oj?Š9<?IçG6BEHIOjç"HI46?IO198çéVK65êDÂOjLªá8OjLìHA5¶èŒOºHIG6Oºé<OjTìHI5ì;A4CçQçQOj;I;cïs46D

ç5<DÂDF9qèŒ5<?9HIBÂU<OOjL6B«HIBÂK6áâæžíC3.G6O#çQDEBÂOjK8HAúš;AOQ?IU<Oj?P7‡5ªLªOjDK6OQO{L6;.5<K6DÂT:èŒO#9ŠDÂ5<á<BFçj9qDŒ7‡5VL6OQDžä

êG6BFçG¼9<DÂDE5ê¡;‘LªBF;¤HA?IBÂè64ªHABÂK6áZHIG6OPéVK65êDÂOjL6á<OèC9<;AOxBEHI;AOQDEïª9<;HIG6OP58K\HA5<DÂ58á<BÂOj;JBÂK¼HAG6ODÂBÂè6?9q?IT

á<?I5êÝDF9q?Iá<OQ?Z9qKCLHIG6O#;¤Tª;¤HAOj7&á89<BEKJ;m7‡58?AOƒ4C;AOQ?;í

3.G6O¡;¤Oj?AU8OQ?x;ABÂL6OZéVK65êDÂO{Lªá<OZèC9<;AO¡9qDÂDÂ5ê¡;lê?9q@C@6BÂK6á¾HAG6O@ŒOQ?;¤BF;¤HAOjK8Hx58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8T;cHI5<?Aú

9qá<OBÂKC;ABFLªO¼9‡U<Oj?I;ABÂ5<KçQ5<K\HA?I5<D7‡O{çGC9qKCBÂ;A7 HAGJ9H>BF;ç58KC;ABÂL6OQ?IOjL+9SU<OQ?IT:BÂ7‡@Œ5<?AHI9qK\H5<K6ú

HA5<DÂ58á<TºDÂBÂè6?9q?IT ;¤Oj?AUVBFçO1âæží W 58KC;¤BF;¤HAOjK8H#U8OQ?;¤BÂ58K6BÂK6áBF;'9Ä@6?IOQ?IO \46BF;¤BEHIOïs58?';A4CçQçQOj;I;cïs46D

LªOQ@ŒOQKCL6OQKCçQT¸çGCOjçéVBÂK6á6íEUšH+BF;:BÂ7‡@JOj?I9qHABÂU<OHA5ìé\KC5êêGCBÂçGÁU8OQ?;¤BÂ58K 5<ï9qKÝBÂKCçQDE4JLªOjL

5<K\HA58DE58á<Tî;¤GC5<46DFL¶èŒO14C;AOjL êB«HIGìHIG6O1?AOQïsOQ?IOQKCçQBÂK6á 58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8Tqí3.G6OQ?IOÄ9q?IONHcêZ5 ïs4CKCL69ú

7‡OQK\HI9<DEDÂT#LªBEù‘OQ?IOQK\HP@Œ58;I;¤BÂè6BÂDÂBEHABÂOj;G6Oj?AO<í à K6O¡BF;HA5HI?AT'HA5'é<OQOj@SHAG6OƒBÂKCçDÂ4CLªBÂK6á¼58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8T

9qDÂêZ9`Tª;.46@ºHA5NL69qHAOŠ9qKCL14C;AO#HIG6O7‡5\;cH¡?IOjçQOQK\H>BÂKCçQDE4JLªOjL158K8HI5<DÂ5<á8T‡U<Oj?I;ABÂ5<K19`U`9<BÂDÂ9<è6DÂOqí

3.G6BF;BÂ;HIG6O¡;¤BEHI4C9HIBE58K#êG6OjKS9¾DF9q?Iá<OZ5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8TƒBF;xLªBÂUVBFLªOjLBEK\HI5¾;A7:9qDÂDÂOQ?7‡5VL646DÂOj;Qí{MP98çG

7‡5VL646DÂOƒ7Š4C;¤H.èŒO#êZ5<?IéVBEKCáêBEHAG+HAGCOK6OQêZOj;¤H¡U<Oj?I;ABÂ5<K:5<ïHIG6O#5qHIG6OQ?7‡5ªLª4CDEO{;ZBEK+5<?LªOj?

ïs5<?SHAGCOÄOQK\HABÂ?IO58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8T HA5÷èŒOºç5<KJ;¤BF;¤HAOQK\H‡9qKCL 4C;I9qè6DÂO<íP3.G6O15qHAGCOQ?‡@Œ58;I;¤BÂè6BÂDÂBEHcT ïs58?

5<K\HA58DE58á<T:BÂKCçQDÂ4C;¤BÂ58KBF;>HA5N?IOïsOj?¡HI59:U8OQ?;¤BÂ58K+58DFLªOQ?HIGC9qK HAG6O'7‡58;¤Hƒ?IOjçQOQK\H>5<KCOqí3.G6BF;

çQ9<;AO‡BF;#9qDF;A51U<OQ?ITÐçQ5<7‡7‡58Käz9<;'9q@6@6DÂBFçQ9qHABÂ5<KJ;ƒ9<KCL÷Lª5<7:9<BÂKÐ;A@JO{çBEðJç‡58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8BÂOj;ƒ7:9`T

K65qHK6OjOjLŠHI5èJO5<ïJHIG6O¡7‡58;¤Hxè6DÂOQO{LªBÂK6áƒO{Lªá<O.HIOjçG6KC5<DÂ5<á8T¾èC4ªHP?9HAGCOQ?HA5èŒO¡á84C9q?9qK\HAOjOjL

HA5êZ5<?Ié#êBEHAG6584ªHx@6?A58è6DÂOQ7:;QíUdKŠHIG6BF;ç58K8HIOëVHLªOQU8OQDÂ5<@ŒOQ?;5qïFHIOQKS5<@ªHxïs58?5<DFLªOj?U<OQ?;ABE58KC;

5qï;A5qïFHcê.9q?IO>9<KCL:HIOjçG6KC5<DÂ5<á8Tqä\9<?Aá846BÂK6áHIGC9HBEHZBF;mèJOQH¤HIOQ?.HAO{;cHIOjL+9qKCLBEHI;m@6?I5<è6DÂOQ7:;m9q?IO

èJOQH¤HAOj?méVK65êKlí2UšïHIG6BF;PBF;xHIG6Oƒçj9<;AOqä8HAG6O¼çGC9qKCá<OðCDEHIOQ?IBEKCá¾DF9`T8OQ?K6OjOjL‡KC5qHmêZ5<?I?IT'9qèŒ5<46H

HAG6O#?IOïsOj?AOjKCçO{;ç587‡BEKCáïs?I5<7;¤4CçGÄ9<K+58K\HA5<DÂ58á<T 98;ZHAG6O4C;¤Oj?¡BF;.7:9qéVBÂK6áS9‡çGC9qK6á8O

BEK+HIG6OBÂKCçQDE4JLªOjL5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<T<ä6G6O#BF;BÂ7‡@6DÂBFçBEHADÂTSç?IOj9qHABÂK6á‡9SK6OQê U8OQ?;¤BÂ5<K+5qïxBEHQíUšH>BF;.HAGV4C;

K65qH>KCOjçO{;A;I9q?IT‡HI5:êm58?A?ITN9<èJ584ªH>èŒOQBÂK6áSèC9<çéVê.9q?L6;ç587‡@C9HIBÂè6DÂOƒêBEHAG158K8HI5<DÂ5<á8BÂOj;PHAGC9qH

9q?IO¾KC5qH¡ç587‡7‡B«HAHAO{LSHA5‡é8OQOQ@+46@1êBEHAGHAG6O#L6OQU<OjDÂ5<@67‡OjK8Hm5qïHAG6O7‡5ªLªBEðCO{L:5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8Tqí

ó

;9ºK6OQêøU8OQ?;¤BÂ5<K 5qï¡9<K÷BEKJçDÂ4CLªO{LÐ58K\HA5<DÂ58á<TºBF;#çQ5<7‡7‡BEH¤HIOjL HA5ÄHIG6ONDÂBÂè6?9q?ITqäHAGCO

;¤Tª;¤HAOQ7 çj9qK 9<4ªHA587:9HABFçj9qDÂDÂTS;AOQKJLÄK65qHIBEðJçQ9qHABÂ5<KC;HA5:HIG6O'L6OQU<OjDÂ5<@ŒOQ?;5qïxHIG6O'58K\HA5<DÂ58á<BÂOj;

HAGC9qH:BEKJçDÂ4CLªONHAG6OºçGC9<K6á<O{L¶58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8Tqí

ó

XC5V5VLœ5<ïƒK65<HABEðJçQ9qHABÂ5<KJ;;AG65<46DFLìK65qH:5ªçQçQ46?jä

èJO{çQ9q4J;¤OZèJ5<HAG'@C9q?AHABÂOj;ê.9qK\HzHI5ƒ7‡BÂK6BÂ7‡BQOHAGCOQBÂ?KV467ŠèŒOQ?jí`3.G6O.LªOjU<OQDÂ58@JOj?I;z5qïC?IOúš4C;I9qè6DÂO

5<K\HA58DE58á<BÂOj;Sê.9qK\H+HA5¸9`U<58BÂL¸çGC9<K6á<O{;NGJ9`U\BÂK6á 9qK BÂ7‡@C98ç"HNèŒOQT85<KCL DÂ5Vçj9qD¼;AçQ5<@ŒOqí Oú

4C;¤Oj?I;ƒê.9qK\H>HI5N7‡BÂK6BÂ7‡BQO¾HAG6OŠKV467ŠèJOj?>5qïm7‡5VL6B«ðŒçQ9HIBÂ5<KC;.?IO \46BÂ?IOjL+BÂKÄHAG6OjBÂ?ƒ58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8T

9ïFHAOj?9ŠçGJ9qK6á8O>BÂK9<KBÂKCçQDE4JLªOjL‡58K\HA5<DÂ58á<Tqí ó DE58á5<ï@6?I5<è6DÂOj7:;ê.9<;.ç?IOj9qHAOjLNêG6OQKHAGCO

LªOQU8OQDÂ5<@ŒOQ?;Z5qïHAG6OBÂKCçQDÂ4CLªOjL5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8T‡7:9<LªO¼7‡5ªLªBEðJçQ9qHABÂ5<KJ;HIGC9Hƒçj9q4C;AO¼@6?I5<è6DÂOQ7:;mHI5

5qHAGCOQ?Š4C;¤Oj?I;Qí Z98;¤O{L÷5<KìHAG6BF;'DÂ5<á6äHAG6O+7‡Oj;I;AOQK6á8OQ?çj9qK¶BÂKCçQDE4JLªONBÂK÷HIG6OKC5qHABEðJçj9HIBE58KC;

@JOj?I;A5<KC9<DÂBjOjL1BÂKC;¤HA?I4Cç"HIBÂ5<KC;¡ïs5<?¼Oj98çG 5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8T+LªOjU<OjDE58@JOj?ƒ58KÐêGJ9H¾HAG6O‡K6OjêU8OQ?;¤BÂ5<K

5qï>HIG6OÄBÂKCçDÂ4CL6OjL¶58K\HA5<DÂ58á<T GC9<;Sè6?I5<é8OQK BEK HAGCOQBÂ?S5<K\HA58DE58á<T<í3.G6O17‡O{;A;AOQK6á8OQ?S;¤GC5<46DFL

BE7‡@CDEOj7‡OQK\HŠ9<KÝ9qèC;¤HA?9<çHABÂ5<K 5qï¼HAGCOºK65qHIBEðJçQ9qHABÂ5<KœçQ9q?I?IBEOj?AìOQ7:9qBÂDžä;¤GC5<?AH:7‡Oj;I;A9<á<Oj;Qä

(9)

çQ9q?I?IBEOj?'çQ5<46DFL¶èŒOÄ;¤OjDÂOjç"HIOjLìèC9<;AOjLì5<K HAG6O1BÂ7‡@J58?¤H9qKCçQON5<ï>HAGCO+KC5qHABEðJçj9HIBE58Kí ó ;ŠHAGCO

çGC9qK6á8OðCDEHAOj?ABÂK6áZDF9`T<OQ?LªOQHAOj?A7‡BÂK6O{;ŒHAG6OOQùŒO{ç"H;z5<ïV9<KOjLªBEHïs5<?zHAG6OPBEKJçDÂ4CLªBÂK6áZ5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<BÂO{;ä

B«HxçQ9<KŠ98;A;ABÂá<K#9¾@6?IBÂ5<?IB«HcTƒ5<?x;AOQU<Oj?ABEHcT¼7‡OHI?ABFçïs5<?HAG6O.O{LªBEHQõ»;OQùŒO{ç"H;í83.GCBÂ;7‡OHI?ABFçmçQ9qKŠèŒO

4C;¤O{LSHA5ŠLªOHIOQ?I7‡BÂK6O.HAG6Oƒ7‡Oj;I;A9<á<OçQ9<?A?IBÂOQ?jí:UdK:5<?LªOj?HA5'èJO¾9qè6DÂOHI5';AOQKCLŠHIG6O¾7‡Oj;I;A9<á<Oj;Qä

HAG6OS;¤Tª;¤HAOj7KCOQOjLC;>HI5N?IOQá8BÂ;¤HAOj?>êG6BFçGºLªOjU<OjDE58@JOj?I;>9q?IO'LªOjU<OQDÂ58@6BÂK6áSêG6BFçGº5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<BÂO{;ä

9qKCLÐ?AO{ç58?ILºçQ5<K\HI98ç"HBÂKªïs5<?I7:9HIBÂ5<K+ïs5<?¾HAGCO:LªOQU8OQDÂ5<@ŒOQ?;í‘3.G6O‡;A9<7‡O'7‡5ªLª4CDEOŠç5846DFLºèŒO

4C;¤O{Lîïs5<?'4C;AOQ?S9q4ªHIG6OQK\HABFçj9HABÂ58K 9<KCLîïs5<?'@6?I5U\BFLªBÂK6áÄçQ5<7‡7Š46K6BFçQ9qHABÂ5<K ;AOjçQ46?IB«HcT<äzêG6BFçG

9q?IO¾KCOQOjL6OjLBEK19ŠK6OHcêZ5<?Ié:9q?çG6BEHAO{ç"HI46?AO<í

òÝG6OQKHAG6O¼LªOjU<OQDÂ58@JOj?m5<ï9qKBEKJçDÂ4CLªBÂK6á#58K\HA5<DÂ58á<T?IOjçQOQBÂU<O{;xHIG6O¼K65qHIB«ðŒçQ9HIBÂ5<KSHAGJ9H9

çGC9qK6á8O¡BÂKN9qKNBEKJçDÂ4CLªO{LS5<K\HA58DE58á<T#GJ9<;ZçQ9q4J;¤O{L‡G6BF;P58K\HA5<DÂ58á<THI5è6?IOj9<éJäVG6O¾çQ9qKN4C;¤OƒHAGCO

7‡Oj;I;A9<á<OƒHA5:BFLªOjK8HIBEïsT‡HAG6O@6?A58è6DÂOQ7Ã9<KCL1ç58KC;¤BFLªOj?.HAG6O'çGC9qK6á8Oj;.?IO \46BÂ?IOjLNHA5‡7:9qé8O¼G6BF;

5<K\HA58DE58á<T+ç5<7‡@J9HABÂè6DÂOêBEHAG HAG6OSK6Ojê U<Oj?I;ABÂ5<KíUšïmG6OSLªO{çBFLªOj;>HA519<LC9q@ªH¾HAG6OS58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8T

HA5îHAGCOºçGC9qK6á8Oj;QäHAG6OÄ7‡O{;A;I9qá8OLªOQHI9qBÂDF;SçQ9<K èŒOÄ4C;AOjL HA5÷G6OjDÂ@ G6BÂ7 L65ÐHIG6OºçGC9<K6á<O{;

;¤Oj7‡B«úd9q46HA5<7:9qHABFçQ9<D«DETqíCR>O‡7:9`Tº9qDF;A5êBF;AGºHA5Äé8OQOj@ HIG6O‡5<DFLªOj?¾U8OQ?;¤BÂ58KäŒBÂK êG6BFçG çj9<;AO

HAG6O#LªO{çBF;ABE58K:BF;Zê?ABEH¤HIOQK+BÂKNHIG6O#LªOQ@ŒOQKJLªOQKCçQT;ATª;cHIOQ71íâQqæ

×¶ÙZÓªÉÑcÉÚxÛ >҃ÑcԤΠƒÔcÙ>Ú ºÌJÉ ‘ÖÎ\Î

3.G6O¼5<K\HA58DE58á<BÂOj;P46KCLªOj?¡LªOQU8OQDÂ5<@C7‡OQK\HZ;AG65<4CDÂLNèJOé8OQ@ªH¡9<@C9q?AHmïs?I5<7&HAG6O@64Cè6DÂBÂ;AG6O{L:5<K6ú

HA5<DÂ58á<BÂOj;'ïs?IOQOQDÂTœ9`U`9<BÂDÂ9<è6DÂO:HI5÷HAG6OÐêBFLªO 9q4JLªBÂOQKCçQOº9<;‡BÂDÂDÂ4C;cHI?I9qHAO{LìBÂK 5BEá846?IO 6íZ3.GCO

?AO{9<;A5<K'ïs5<?xHIG6BF;xBF;Hcêm5<ïs5<DFL‘í

à

KS5<KCOGC9qKCLä\9q@C@6DÂBÂçj9HIBE58KLªOjU<OQDÂ58@67‡OQK\HK6OQO{L6;xHIG6O>;I9q7‡O

5<K\HA58DE58á<TU8OQ?;¤BÂ5<KHA5#èŒO¡4C;AOjLSêBFLªOjDÂT#BÂKS9<@6@6DÂBFçQ9qHABÂ5<KC;BÂKS5<?LªOQ?xHI57:9ëªBÂ7‡BQOm;A5qïFHcê.9q?IO

BEK\HIOQ?I5<@ŒOQ?9qè6BÂDÂBEHcTqíl3.G6BF;Š?AO84CBE?IOj;#HAGC9qH:9Ð;A@JO{çBEðJç5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<TÐU<Oj?I;ABÂ5<K÷BF;Š@646è6DÂBF;¤GCOjL¶98;

HAG6O#58K6O¾HA5‡èŒO#?IOïsOQ?IOQKJçOjL+9qKJL?IOúš4C;AOjL‘äC9<KCLHAG6OjKÄ@6?I5<7‡5qHIOjL:HA5‡HIG6OêBFLªO9q4CLªBÂOjKCçO<í

à HAG6Oj?AêBF;AOqälBEHBF;G6BÂá<GCDET DEBÂé8OQDÂT1HAGC9qH'O{9<çG÷9q@6@CDEBFçj9HABÂ58K êZ5<46DFL 4C;AON9ÄU<Oj?I;ABÂ5<KÐ5qïHAGCO

5<K\HA58DE58á<THIGC9H.BF;PLªBEù‘OQ?IOQK\HPïs?I5<7ø9<KCL‡@Œ58;I;¤BÂè6DÂTBÂKCçQ5<7‡@C9qHABÂè6DÂOZêB«HIG‡HAGCOƒU8OQ?;¤BÂ5<KJ;4C;¤O{L

è\TŠHIG6Oƒ5<HAG6Oj?m9<@6@6DÂBFçQ9HIBÂ5<KC;Qí OïsOj?AOjKCçOƒ5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<TU<OQ?;ABE58KC;xêZ5<46DFLS46KJLª5<46è6HAOjL6DETS9q?IBF;¤O<ä

è64ªH'BEHêZ5<4CDÂLÐH9qé<ONDE58K6á<Oj?#9<;#HAG6OjT êZ5<4CDÂL K6OjOjL HI5Ð9<çjç467Š46DF9HIOŠ9 çOQ?AHI9<BÂK 7:98;A;#5qï

BEK\HIOQ?I5<@ŒOQ?9qè6DÂO¡9q@C@6DÂBÂçj9HIBE58KC;HA5ŠèŒOjç587‡OƒLªOƒï¹9<çHA5S;cH9qKCLC9q?L6;í à K:HIG6O¼5qHAGCOQ?ZGC9qKCLäª9<K

5<K\HA58DE58á<T<ä`98;9qKVT;A5qïFHcê.9q?IOqäK6OjOjL6;HI5èJO>46@ŒLC9HAO{LS9qKCLŠBF;DÂBEé8OQDÂT¾HA5#çQ5<K\HI9<BEK'è646á\;í83.GCO

(10)

HAG6Oj?AOjè\T LªOjçQDF9q?IO'BEH¼HA5ÄèŒONç587‡@6DÂOHIOqä‘HAO{;cHIOjL‘ä9<KCLî;¤4C@6@J58?¤HIOjL èŒOjç587‡Oj;9<K O{;A;AOQK\HIBÂ9<D

?AO84CBE?IOQ7‡OjK\HPïs5<?¡9<K58K\HA5<DÂ58á<TSDÂBEèC?I9<?AT<í

C D-F ´Œ´ ‚ZYech{n^hj¢jf'u\|\·8n^[obd£8[^Y\¢¾u<ach~_bdb€

46è6DÂBF;¤GCBEKCá19<K¶5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8TÄïs?A587 HIG6OL6OQU<OjDÂ5<@67‡OjK8H#DÂBÂè6?9q?IT1HA5 9º@646èCDEBFçS58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8T

DEBÂè6?9q?IT¼7‡Oj9<KC;HAGC9qHm9;A@JO{çBEðJçZ5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<TU8OQ?;¤BÂ58Kä`HA5<á8OHIG6OQ?xêBEHAGŠHIG6O>ç58?A?IOjçHxU<OQ?;ABE58KC;

5qï>HIG6O15<K\HA58DÂ5<á<BÂO{;¼B«HSBÂKCçDÂ4CL6Oj;QäBF;'7:9<LªO+@646è6DÂBFçDÂTî9`U9qBÂDF9qè6DÂOqíz3.GCO+58K\HA5<DÂ58á<T DÂBÂè6?9q?IT

;¤G65846DFLN;A46@6@Œ5<?AH.HAG6BF;Z@6?I5VçQOj;I;í63.G6O¼BÂK\HAOj?¤ï¹98çO¡HI5ŠHAG6O¼@646èCDEBFçƒ5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<TŠDÂBÂè6?I9<?ATŠ;¤GC5<46DFL

9qèC;¤HA?9<çHHIG6OLªBEùŒOj?AOjK8HBÂ7‡@6DÂOQ7‡OQK\H9HABÂ58KC;‘5qï6HIG6O.DÂBEèC?I9<?AT<í5658?Oë69q7‡@6DÂO<äQHAGCOZ58K\HA5<DÂ58á<BÂOj;

ç5<4CDÂLSèŒO¾è6?A5ê¡;AOjLSUVBF9¼òÁòÁò ä \46Oj?ABÂOjLŠHIG6?I5<46á8GN9qK:BÂK\HAOj?¤ï¹98çO<ä\9qKJL:Lª5êK6DÂ5898LªOjLSUVBF9

LªBEùŒOj?AOjK8HP;A5qïFHcê.9q?IO

ó

Uc;Qí<òÝG6OjK:9¼K6OQê¸U8OQ?;¤BÂ5<K'5qï9qKS5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8TBÂ;BÂKC;AOQ?AHAO{L‘äqBEHP;¤GC5<46DFL

èJOÄDÂBÂK6é<O{L÷êBEHAG HAG6OÄ@C?AOjU\BÂ584C;U8OQ?;¤BÂ58Kí ƒOj;A@6BEHAOÄ9<DEDZHIG6BF;äHAGCOÄBEK\HIOQ?Aï¹9<çOHA5÷98L6L 9<K

5<K\HA58DE58á<TŠHA5ŠHIG6ODÂBEèC?I9<?ATS;¤GC5<46DFLK65qHèŒO#9ù‘Ojç"HIOjL‘í

× ºÌJÉxÓªÉxÓqÛ.Þ#Ö

ó

K9<?IçGCB«HIOjçHA46?IO>;A46@6@Œ5<?AHABÂK6á#HIG6O¾@6?A5ªçQOj;I;¤O{;PLªBF;Iç4C;I;¤O{L:9qèŒ5U<O>BÂ;m@6?IOj;AOQK\HAO{L‡BÂK5BÂá<46?IO

ó

@6?A5<HA5<HcT\@ŒO:BÂ7‡@6DÂOQ7‡OjK\HI9HIBÂ5<KÄ5qï.HIG6ON9q?çG6BEHAO{ç"HI46?AO‡çj9qDÂDÂOjL

à

>=?USâ«ã qæPGJ9<;#èŒOQOjK

è646BÂDEHZ9HmHAG6OS>K6BÂU<OQ?;AB«HcT5qïR>OQDF;¤BÂK6éVBŒ9<;Z9@C9<?¤HZ5qïlHIG6O?>9HIBÂ5<KC9<D

à

K\HA58DE58á<T ?A5 cOjçHZBÂK

5BÂK6DF9<KCL Qí

à

ƒ=?UP4C;AOj; ?A5<Hjá#åVí+â«ãæz9<;ZHIG6O#58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8TSOjLªBEHA58?Qí63.G6OBFLªOjK\HABEðJçQ9qHABÂ5<K

DÂ9`T8OQ?jäHAG6OçGC9qK6á8OSðCDEHAOj?ABÂK6á1DF9`T<Oj?Qäz9<KCL HAG6O@6?I5<è6DÂOQ7 LªBF;¤@J9HIçGCBEKCáDF9`T<Oj?#9q?IO‡BÂ7‡@6DÂOú

7‡OQK\HAO{L+98;¡9 ?I5qHQá@CDE4CáqúšBEKlí W 587'èCBEKCOjL‡HIG6OQT1;AOQ?IU<O9<;¡9<K1OjLªBEHA58?.HA5NL6OQ7‡5<KJ;cHI?I9qHAO

HAG6O58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8T‡çGC9qK6á8Oƒ@C?A5ªçO{;A;Qí

3.G6O à >=?U;AOQ?IU<Oj?@6?A5<HA5<HcT\@ŒO#BF;èC98;¤O{L15<K<OQKC9:åªí‡âEã`æžíŒ3.GCOLªOQ@ŒOQKJLªOQKCçQT1?AOQú

DÂ9qHABÂ5<KJ;ïs?I5<7Ã9‡çQ5<KCçQOQ@ªHBÂK19qK+BEKJçDÂ4CLªBÂK6á'5<K\HA58DE58á<TŠHA5‡9‡çQ5<KCçQOQ@ªHBÂK+9<K1BEKJçDÂ4CLªO{L:5<K6ú

HA5<DÂ58á<T9<?AO;¤HA5<?IOjLŠBÂK\HA5#9ƒOQ@ŒOQKCL6OQKCçQT à K\HI5<DÂ5<á8TBEK<OQKC96í ó ;HAG6O>BEKJçDÂ4CLªO{L58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8T

£edecuJ¦§{§"¨x¨x¨€~Ib€£8_n^bd[^Y\pq[F€©ª§Q¢Qach{|\uV§Qbd_~Ih§QhjYech{n^h{¢j[o_"b¤§

(11)

BÂ;çGJ9qK6á8OjL‘ä‘HAGCO:çGC9qK6á8OŠðCDEHAOQ?IBÂK6áNDF9`T8OQ?¼çQ9qDFçQ46DF9HAO{;¡HIG6O:9ù‘OjçHAO{L 58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8T1OQDÂOQ7‡OjK8H;

BEK1HIG6OçGC9<K6á<O{L15<K\HA58DÂ5<á<T:9<KCLÄçG6O{çéV;ïs?A587ÃHIG6O';AOQ?IU<Oj?B«ïHIG6OQTÄ9q?IO?IOïsOQ?IOQKJçOjLïs?I5<7

5qHAGCOQ?S5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<BÂO{;í UšïƒHAG6OjTì9q?IOqä9 ê.9q?IK6BÂK6áº7‡Oj;I;I9qá<OBF;'LªBF;A@6DF9`T<O{L HA5 HAG6O14C;AOQ?‡9<KCL

HAG6OŠLªOH9qBÂDF;m5<ïxHAG6OOjLªBEH>58@JOj?I9qHABÂ5<K19qKCL15<ïHAG6O#?IOïsOj?AOjKCçO#9<?AOê?ABEH¤HIOQK1BÂK\HA5:9‡DÂ5<áŠðCDÂO<í

3.G6O¾çQOQK\HA?9qDÂBQO{LŠé\KC5êDEO{Lªá<O>èC9<;AO¾9<KCLSHIG6O¼@646è6DÂBF;¤GCBEKCá@6?A5ªçQOj;I;m9<?AOƒ@6?A5<HA5<HcT\@ŒOjLNêBEHAG

W

ñ1âEã$QqæJ9qKCL:êB«HIG‡9 OQ?IDJ;Iç?IBE@6HHAGC9qHHI9<á8;m9#;¤@ŒOjçQBEðJç.U<Oj?I;ABÂ5<KŠ5qï‘HAG6Oƒ5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<BÂO{;9<KCL

ç5<@CBEO{;.BEH¡HA5:9SòÁòÁò ;AOQ?IU<Oj?QíC3.GCO#@6?I5qHA5<HcTV@JO#Lª5VO{;K65qHƒT<OHƒBEKJçDÂ4CLªO¾HAGCO#7‡Oj;I;¤OjK6á<Oj?

K65qHIB«ðŒçQ9HIBÂ5<KN;AOQ?IUVBÂçQOqí

3.G6O

à

>=?UZ@6?I5qHA5<HcTV@JOê.9<;.HIOj;¤HAO{LêBEHIGÄ5<K\HA58DE58á<BÂOj;m9qKCL+7‡OQHI9<LC9HI9'ïs?I5<7 HAG6O';¤OQú

7:9qK\HABFç@Œ5<?AHI9qD ÄâEãVäjã$qægíUdKHAGCOPHIOj;¤HI;QäjHIG6OZL6OQU<OjDÂ5<@67‡OjK8Hê.9<;;¤BÂ7Š4ªú

DÂ9qHAO{L#4C;ABÂK6á¡HIG6O@6?I5qHA5<HcTV@JO<í3.GCOm@6?IBÂ7:9q?ITƒá8589<D\ê.9<;zHA5LªOj7‡5<KC;¤HA?9HIOHIG6O9q?çG6BEHAOjçHA46?IO

BEK19<çHABÂ5<K+9qKCL+;AG65êÝHIGC9H¡BEHBF;Zçj9q@C9<è6DÂOƒ5<ïçQ5<?I?AO{ç"HADÂTS?IOjç58á<K6BjBEKCá#@6?I5<è6DÂOQ7:;Qí

´C´

(12)

OQ?IOQKCçQBEKCá#5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<BÂO{;zHIGC9H.BÂKCçDÂ4CL6O¡HAGCO¾;I9q7‡OHI5<@DEOjU<OjDC5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8Tqä89<KCL:ö'èJ5<H¤HA587øDÂOQU<OjD

5<K\HA58DE58á<BÂOj;HAGC9qH#BEKJçDÂ4CLªOS9qDÂDHAG6OS46@C@JOj?#DÂOQU<OjD5<K\HA58DE58á<BÂOj;QíJ3.G6O:;ABQO{;ƒ9<KCLÐçGJ9q?9<ç"HIOQ?Aú

BÂ;¤HABFçj;¡5qïPHAG6OS5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8BEO{;çQ9<K èŒO'ïs5846KCLÐBÂK 39<è6DÂOŠåªí3.GCOŠBÂKCçQDÂ4C;¤BÂ58K1;¤HA?I4CçHA46?IO5<ïPHAGCO

L69H9'BF;.@6?IOj;AOQK\HIOjL:BÂK 5BEá846?IO Q6í

3.G6O17'4C;AOQ4C7Lª5<7:9<BEKì5<K\HA58DE58á<T ó à BF;Š4C;AOjLìHA5÷;¤HA?I4Cç"HI46?ABjONHIG6OÄLª5<7:9<BEKì5qï

7'4C;AOQ4C7ç58DEDÂO{ç"HABÂ58KB«HIOQ7:;Qíq3.G6O ó ç"HI5<?;5<K\HA58DE58á<T¼BÂK\HA?I5VL64CçO{;L6B«ù‘OQ?IOQK\Hx5<?Iá89<K6Bj9qHABÂ5<KC;

9qKCLîBÂKCLªBÂUVBFLª4C9<DÂ;¡HAGC9qHGC9`U8O:;¤587‡OŠ?I5<DÂOSêBEHAGî?IOj;A@JO{ç"HHA5ºHAG6O:BEHIOQ7:;¼BÂK HAG6O:7Š4C;AOQ467

ç5<DÂDÂOjçHABÂ5<KJ;í‘3.G6O l5ªçQ9qHABÂ5<KJ;ƒ58K\HA5<DÂ58á<TÄLªOðJK6Oj;LªBEù‘OQ?IOQK\Há<Oj5<á<?9q@CG6BFç#DÂ5ªçQ9HIBÂ5<KC;Qí‘3.GCO

W 5<DÂDÂOjç"HIBÂ5<KC;Œ5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8T¡;cHI5<?IOj;lBÂKªïs58?A7:9qHABÂ5<Kƒ9qèŒ5<4ªHHAG6OZLªBEùŒOj?AOjK8Hç5<DÂDÂOjçHABÂ5<KJ;CBÂK#LªBEù‘OQ?IOQK\H

7'4C;AOQ4C7:;íª3.G6O¼7'4J;¤Oj467:;PGJ9<LBEKJLªOëªOjLNHAGCOQBÂ?ç5<DÂDÂOjçHABÂ5<KSBEHAOj7:;Z4C;¤BÂK6áS9'HAOj?A7‡BÂK658DE58á<T

;¤@ŒOjçQB«ðŒçïs5<?ZOj98çG:7Š4C;¤Oj4671í\35S9<L6LSHIG6Oç58DEDÂO{ç"HABÂ58K'BEHAOj7:;5<ï9#7Š4C;AOQ467 BÂK\HA5#HIG6O¼;¤Tª;¤ú

HAOQ71ä69'7:9q@6@CBEKCá5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8T'ê.9<;Zç?IOj9qHAOjL:HA5‡ç58K6K6O{ç"HZHAG6O¾HAOj?A7:;m4C;AOjLBÂK:HAGCO¾7Š4C;AOQ467

BEKJLªOëªBÂK6áŠHA5‡HIG6OçQ5<KCçQOQ@ªH;¡4C;AOjL1BÂK ó à

í 9q@6@6BÂK6á‡58K\HA5<DÂ58á<BÂOj;Pïs5<?ƒ7'4C;AOQ4C7

ó

9<KCL

êmOj?AOS9`U9qBÂDF9qè6DÂO¾ïs5<?¾HAGCO'HIOj;¤HQíñVBÂ7‡BÂDF9q?7:9<@6@6BÂK6á:58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8BÂOj;GC98LºèŒOQOjK çQ?AO{9HAO{LÄïs58?

5qHAGCOQ?.HA58@1DEOjU<OjDŒ58K\HA5<DÂ58á<BÂOj;QäqHA5V5Cä6è64ªH¡HIG6OQT:êZOQ?IO¼K65qH>9`U9<BEDF9<è6DÂOqí

3z5 9<K6K65<HI9HIO‡HAGCONBEHAOj7:;¼5qïHAGCON7Š4C;¤Oj467 çQ5<DÂDÂOjçHABÂ5<KC;Qäl9ÄèŒ5qH¤HI5<7 DÂOQU8OQD58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8T

GC9<LîèŒOQOjKìç?IOj9qHAOjL ïs58?O{9<çG÷7Š4C;¤Oj4671ílMP98çG÷B«HIOQ7 5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<T BEKJçDÂ4CLªO{L 9<DÂDxHA58@¶DÂOQU<OjD

5<K\HA58DE58á<BÂOj;Qí à K6OBEKJ;cH9qKCçQO:BÂK÷HAG6O+BEHAOj7 58K\HA5<DÂ58á<TÐçQ5<?I?AO{;¤@Œ5<KJLªOjL HI5 9<K¶5<è cO{ç"HŠBEK 9

7'4C;AOQ4C7 çQ5<DÂDÂOjçHABÂ5<Kí<3.GCOƒBÂKªïs58?A7:9qHABÂ5<KS9qèŒ5<4ªHZHAGCO¾BEHIOQ7 êZ98;mçQ5<KVU<Oj?¤HIOjLŠHI5'?IOïsOj?AOjKCçO{;

HA5S5qHIG6OQ?OjDEOj7‡OQK\HI;ZBÂKHAG6O58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8TŠ9<KCL+BÂK:HAGCOBEKJçDÂ4CLªO{L:5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8BEO{;í

3.G6O.5<K\HA58DE58á<BFçQ9<D<LªOj@JOjKCLªOQKJçBÂOj;êZOQ?IOPðC?;¤HDÂ5\9<LªO{LBÂK8HI5>HIG6O ƒOQ@ŒOQKCLªOjKCçTº9qKJ9qá<OQú

7‡OQK\HmñVTª;cHIOQ71õ»; ƒOQ@ŒOQKCLªOjKCçT à K\HA58DÂ5<á<T<íq3.G6O¡7:9q@C@6BÂK6á¼5<K\HA58DE58á<BÂOj;GC98L'èŒOQOjK:4C;AOjL‡98;

9Sè6?ABFLªá8OƒèŒOHcêZOQOjK ó à

HIOQ?I7‡BÂK65<DÂ5<á8TŠ9<KCLHAG6O'ç5<?I?IOj;A@J58KCLªBÂK6á7Š4C;AOQ4671õ»;ZDÂ5Vçj9qD‘HIOQ?Aú

7‡BEKC5<DÂ5<á8Tqä\;A5ŠHAG6OjT:êZOQ?IO¾GCOj9`UVBÂDET‡çQ5<K6K6O{ç"HIOjLNHA5 ó à

íC3.G6OBEHIOQ7&58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8BÂOj;PL6OðCK6O{L

;¤58DEOjDÂT KCOQêÃBÂKC;¤HI9<KCçO{;'HAGC9qH:GC9<L¸9qKœBÂKCçDÂ4CL6OjLìçQDF9<;I;Š98;ŠHAG6OjBÂ?SL6BE?IOjçHSHcT\@ŒOqíP3.GCOÄBEK6ú

;cH9qKCçQOj;x@Œ58;I;¤BÂè6DÂT#?IOïsOj?AOjKCçO{LSOj98çGŠ5<HAG6Oj?P58?5qHIG6OQ?BÂKCçQDÂ4CLªOjLŠBÂKC;¤HI9<KCçO{;9qKCLŠHIGV4C;êZOQ?IO

9qDF;¤5ŠG6O{9`U\BÂDÂTSLªOQ@ŒOQKCL6OQK\H¡5<K+HAGCO¾BÂKCçQDÂ4CLªOjL5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8BEO{;í

ó

ïFHAOj?PHIG6O>BÂK6BEHIBÂ9<D6;¤OQHA46@5<@ŒOQ?9HIBE58KC;HAGCO ƒOQ@ŒOQKCL6OQKCçQT

à

K\HI5<DÂ5<á8Tç58K8H9qBÂK6O{Lã`å:R/R

BEKJ;cH9qKCçQOj;9qKJL VR2V'LªOQ@ŒOQKCL6OQKCçQT?IOQDF9HIBÂ5<KC;QíV3.GCOHAO{;cHƒ;AOHI46@1BF;@6?IOj;AOQK\HAO{LBÂK139<è6DÂO

åVí

W

5<DÂ467‡KC;

W ä œ9<KCLPUmBÂKCLªBFçQ9qHAOHIG6O¼K\4C7'èŒOQ?Z5qïçDF9<;I;¤O{;ä\@6?I5<@ŒOQ?AHABÂOj;Qä\9<KCLNBÂKC;¤HI9<KCçO{;

HAG6O:58K\HA5<DÂ58á<TºLªOQðCK6Oj;Qí

W

58DE4C7‡K M ;AG65ê¡;¼HIG6O:KV467ŠèJOj?5qï?IOïsOQ?IOQKJçOjLÐOQDÂOj7‡OQK\HI;¼BÂK

HAG6O46@C@JOj?xDEOjU<OjD\58K\HA5<DÂ58á<BÂOj;Qäj9qKJL#HIG6OKV467'èŒOQ?5qï‘?IOïsOQ?IOQKJçBÂK6á>OjDÂOQ7‡OQK\H;zBÂK#HIG6OèŒ5qH¤HI5<7

DEOjU<OjDz5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8BEO{;í W 58DÂ467‡K ;AG65ê¡;>HAG6OŠKV467'èŒOQ?ƒ5qïmL6OQ@ŒOQKCLªOjKCçTÄ?IOQDF9qHABÂ5<KC;HA5ê.9q?L6;

HAG6O146@6@ŒOQ?‡DÂOjU<OQD.58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8BÂOj;Qäz9qKCLìHAG6O1KV467ŠèJOj?S5qïƒLªOj@JOjKCLªOjKCçT ?AOjDÂ9qHABÂ5<KJ;¼ïs?A587 HAGCO

èJ5<H¤HA587 DÂOjU<OQD58K\HA5<DÂ58á<BÂOj;Qí5C5<?‡HIG6O ƒOQ@ŒOQKCLªOjKCçT à K\HA58DE58á<T<ä ;AG65ê¡;ŠHIG6OºKV467ŠèJOj?

5qïPLªOj@JOjKCLªOQKJçT1?AOjDF9HABÂ58KC;;cHI5<?IOjL1BÂK1HAGCO'7‡5ªLªOjDgí W 5<DÂ467‡K ¡M ;¤GC5ê¡;HAGCO'9`U<Oj?I9<á<O

K\4C7'èŒOQ?¡5<ïPLªOQ@ŒOQKJLªOQKCçQT1?AOjDÂ9qHABÂ5<KJ;m@ŒOQ?ƒ?AOQïsOQ?IOQKCçQOjL1OjDEOj7‡OQK\HBÂK1HAG6OHA5<@ DEOjU<OjDl5<K\HA58DÂ5qú

á<BÂOj;Qäz9qKCL HIG6ON9`U8OQ?9qá<OŠKV467ŠèJOj?5qï¡LªOQ@ŒOQKJLªOQKCçQTÐ?IOQDF9qHABÂ5<KC;¾@ŒOQ?#?IOïsOj?AOjKCçBÂK6á1OjDEOj7‡OQK\H

BEKÐHAGCOŠèŒ5qHAHA587 DÂOQU8OQD5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<BÂO{;íJ3.GCOŠDF98;cH¼DÂBEKCO'BÂKÐHAG6OŠHI9<è6DÂO‡;¤G65ê¡;ƒHIG6O‡;¤BQOŠ5qïZHAGCO

>Oj@JOjKCLªOQKJçT à K\HA58DÂ5<á<T¾BÂKHAGCO.;AOQ?IU<Oj?Qí3.G6OZU9qDÂ46Oj;Mî9qKJL M 9<?AOmK65qH9<@6@6DÂBFçQ9qèCDEO

HA5ŠHAG6O ƒOQ@ŒOQKJLªOQKCçQT à K\HI5<DÂ5<á8Tqí

à K8HI5<DÂ5<á8TLªOQU8OQDÂ5<@67‡OjK\HŒê.9<;l;ABÂ7'4CDÂ9qHAO{LèVTƒ@ŒOQ?Aïs5<?I7‡BÂK6áZ9;AOQ?IBÂOj;‘5<ï\O{LªBEHl5<@ŒOQ?9HABÂ58KC;

HA5 HAG6O1DF9q?Iá<O{;cH'46@6@ŒOQ?‡DÂOQU8OQD.5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<T<ízòÝG6OjK ó à ê.9<;Š5<@ŒOQK6O{Lì9<KCLì7‡5ªLªBEðCO{L‘äx9

(13)

²\® 6´

%

%

" # % %

SÀP‚ ˆ •{• ” †•"”<• <•j•– •I–

Àx~Iechjacb •– ˆ •q• •{ˆ Q– ˆ

Jh~vQec[^h{Y8b †q• {ˆ`† j” {ˆ •

yh{n^n^_~Iec[^hjY\b •"” †j •†j • –jˆ<• {†Q–

Svju8u\[^Y\¢¼À <• ˆ †Q– †jˆ{ †q• •

Svju8u\[^Y\¢¼„ j– ˆ †–Q •ˆ{” •j •

gec_IwbxÀ •  •j•{† •j•`† •{•jˆ

gec_Iwbx„ •  •{† •<• • Q •”

gec_Iwby •  †•{•” †•{•"” †j”{†j” •”

t._uª_IYV 8_IY\~If'‚ZYech{n^hj¢jf •"” • •"†! “ j” “

HA5+è6?AO{9qéŒí W G6OjçéVBÂK6áN9<KVTÄBEKJLªBÂU\BFLª4J9qDlO{LªBEHƒHI5\58éÄDÂOj;I;¡HIGC9qK':7‡BÂDÂDEBF;AOjçQ5<KCL6;QäªOQU8OQK BEï

9qKºOjK8HIBÂ?AOHA5<@ DEOjU<OjDè6?9qKJçGÄêZ98;ƒLªOjDÂOHAO{L1ïs?I5<7 ó à íl3.G6OŠK\4C7'èŒOQ?ƒ5qïmLªOj@JOjKCLªOjKCçT

?AOjDÂ9qHABÂ5<KJ;¡BÂKºHIG6O>Oj@JOjKCLªOQKJçT à K\HA58DÂ5<á<T19qKJLºHIG6OSK\4C7'èŒOQ?¼5qïZ?AOjDF9HABÂ58KC;.HAGCOS;ATª;cHIOQ7

7'4C;¤HNGC9<KCLªDÂO 9qH+9qKVT¸çDÂBÂOQK\H:?IO \46Oj;¤H+9<?AOºïs46KCç"HIBÂ5<KC;N5qïHAGCO KV467ŠèJOj?N5qï#58K\HA5<DÂ58á<BÂOj;

;cHI5<?IOjL BEKœHIG6O ƒOQU<OjDÂ5<@67‡OjK8H lBÂè6?9q?IT÷9qKCL¸5<ïƒHIG6OºDÂOQU8OQD.5qï#LªOj@JOjKCLªOjKCçBÂOj;SèŒOHcêZOQOjK

HAG6O¼5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8BEO{;í<3.GCOj;AO¡ðCá846?AO{;.LªOQ@ŒOQKCLN5<KG65êÁHAGCOƒ58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8BÂOj;x9q?IO>?IOQ4J;¤O{L‘ä69qKCLNU`9<?AT

G6Oj9`UVBÂDÂT:êBEHAG1HAGCO';A@JO{çBEðJç4C;AOçj9<;AO#5qïxHIG6O58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8TqíUdKÄHIG6BF;>çj9<;AOHAG6O'èJ5<H¤HI5<7DÂOQU<OjD

5<K\HA58DE58á<BÂOj;.GJ9<Lº9N?AOjDÂ9qHABÂU<OjDÂT‡G6BÂá<GºDÂOQU8OQD5qïmLªOj@JOjKCLªOjKCçT<í3.GCO'9q7‡5846K\H>5qïm?AOQïsOQ?IOQKCçQOjL

OQDÂOQ7‡OjK8H;mçQ5<7‡@C9<?AO{LSHA5ŠHIG6O¾HA5qH9qDl9<7‡5<46K\Hm5<ïOjDEOj7‡OQK\HI;mBÂK:HIG6O5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<TŠU9q?IBÂOjLSïs?I5<7

HAOQK+HI5ŠOjBÂá<G\HcT‡@JOj?IçQOQK\HQí

3.G6Oj;AOÄðCá846?AO{;:êZOQ?IO çQ9<4C;AOjL¸èVTœHAG6OÐêZ9`T HAG6O 5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8BEO{;êZOQ?IOº?IOúš4C;AOjL¸BÂKÁHAGCO

7'4C;AOQ4C7 @6?I5 cO{ç"H'HAGC9qHS;AOQ?IU<O{L÷9<;HAG6ONHAOj;¤H‡L69H9ªíñV4CçG¶G6BÂá8G¶DÂOQU<OjDF;¼5qïƒLªOj@JOjKCLªOjKCçT

;¤46á8á<O{;cHN@C?A58è6DÂOQ7:;SHI5ì5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8T¶7:9qBÂK\HAOjKC9qKCçQOÄ9qKCL ç5<KJ;¤BF;¤HAOQKJçT 98;‡HIG6OÐ58K\HA5<DÂ58á<BÂOj;

OQU<58DÂU<OqíQ3.GCOQT¼9qDF;¤5Z46KCL6OQ?IDEBÂK6OHIG6OK6OjOjL¾ïs58?;AOQ?IBE584C;Œ@6?I5VçQOj;I;l9qKJL¼@6?A5ªLª4Jç"Hz7:9<KC9qá8OQ7‡OQK\H

@6?I98ç"HIBÂçQOj;‡BÂKÁ58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8TìLªOjU<OQDÂ58@67‡OQK\H‡BÂKÁ5<?LªOQ?‡HI5ì@6?IOQU8OQK\HçGC9<58;‡BÂK¸HIG6O 58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8T

DEBÂè6?9q?ITqí`R¡5êZOQU8OQ?jäjHIG6O.?AO{;¤46DEH;êZOQ?IO.çQ9q4J;¤O{L#èVTHAGCO.LC9HI9ƒHIGC9HçQ9<7‡OPïs?I5<7 58K6O.@6?I5 cOjçH

5<K6DÂTqíz3.GCO:;A9<7‡@6DÂOŠL69qHI9+7‡BÂá<G\H#çQ9<4C;¤OSè6BF98;¼BEKÐHAGCO‡?AO{;¤46DEH;í >OQU<Oj?¤HIG6OQDÂO{;A;QäB«ï;ABE7‡BÂDF9q?

?AO{;¤46DEH;#êZ5<46DFLîèŒO58èªHI9<BEKCOjL ïs?I5<7 9º7‡58?AONL6OHI9<BÂDEO{LîLªOQ@ŒOQKCL6OQKCçQT¶9qKC9<DETª;ABF;¼5qï>5<HAG6Oj?

5<K\HA58DE58á<BÂOj;Qä8BEHêZ5<46DFL:èŒO#9qK+BÂ7‡@J58?¤H9qK\HmBF;I;¤4CO>ïs58?5<K\HA58DE58á<TS?IOúš4C;¤O<í

3.G6OÐ;ATª;cHIOQ7%êZ98;‡ïs5<4CKCLÁHI5¶ïs46KCçHABÂ5<KÝ98;NOQëª@JO{ç"HAO{LÁêBEHAGÁHIG6O á8BÂU<OQKœHIOj;¤H+L69qHI9ªí

3.G6O

à

>=?UZ@6?I5qHI5qHcTV@JO#;A4CçjçOj;I;¤ïs46DÂDET‡BFLªOjK\HABEðCOj;ZHIG6OçGC9<K6á<O{;.HAGJ9Hƒçj9q4C;AO@6?I5<è6DÂOQ7:;ZBÂK

LªBF;cHI?ABÂè64ªHIOjLì5<K\HA58DE58á<T÷LªOjU<OQDÂ58@67‡OQK\HQí UdKœHAG6OÄ@C?A5<HA5qHcTV@ŒOBÂ7‡@6DÂOj7‡OQK\HI9qHABÂ5<Kî46@‘L69HIBÂK6á

HAG6O <OQKC95<K\HA58DE58á<TŠBÂKC;¤BFLªO¡HAG6O¼@6?I5qHI5qHcTV@JOƒ5qïlHIG6O>Oj@JOjKCLªOjKCçT 9qKC9<á<OQ7‡OjK\HZñVTª;cHIOQ7

HA46?IK6OjL¶5<4ªH'HA5 èŒONU8OQ?IT ;ADÂ5ê¼äzè64ªHS5qHIG6OQ?IêBF;¤OSHIG6ON@ŒOQ?Aïs5<?I7:9qKJçO‡BF;#G6BÂá8G÷OQK65846á<GîHI5

èJO¼4C;AOjLNBEKN?AO{9qDŒ5<K\HA58DE58á<TŠLªOQU8OQDÂ5<@67‡OjK\HQíVñ6çQ9qDF9<è6BÂDEBEHcTBF;I;¤46O{;m9<?AOƒDÂBEé8OQDÂT#HI5ŠçQ5<7‡O¡4C@BÂK

HAG6OŠïs46KCçHABÂ5<K 5qïPHAG6O‡@ŒOQ?Aïs5<?I7:9qKCçQO#DÂBÂ7‡B«H9HIBE58KC;.5qïmHAG6OS58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8TOjK6á<BÂK6OŠ4C;AOjLÐBÂKºHAGCO

>Oj@JOjKCLªOQKJçT 9qKC9<á<OQ7‡OjK\HñVTª;¤HAOj71í

ò O¾Oëª@ŒOjç"HZHA5S;¤HI9q?AHPHIG6O¼LªOQU8OQDÂ5<@67‡OjK\H5qï9'7‡5ªLª46DF9q?4C@6@JOj?.DEOjU<OjDC5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8T4C;ABÂK6á

(14)

3.G6O#êZ5<?Ié:?AO\46BÂ?AO{;9‡;¤58DEBFL:ïs?I9<7‡OQêZ5<?IéSHAGC9qHƒ;¤4C@6@J58?¤H;HIG6O#5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8T‡DEBEïsOçTªçQDEO¾ïs?I5<7

èJ5<HAG‡LªOQU8OQDÂ5<@C7‡OQK\H9qKJL7:9<KC9qá8OQ7‡OQK\Hz@Œ5<BÂK\HI;5<ïJUVBÂOQê¼í`ò O.OQëV@ŒOjçHHA5¾ïs46?AHAG6Oj?HAOj;¤HxHAGCO

@6?A5ªçQOj;I;¤O{;x9qKCL‡9<?IçG6BEHIOjç"HI46?IOZLªO{;AçQ?ABÂèŒOjL'BÂK'HIG6BF;x@C9<@JOj?P9qKCLSU9<DEBFL69qHAOmHAG6O>?AO84CBE?IOQ7‡OjK\HI;

ïs5<?:HI5<7‡58?A?I5ê¼õ;S58K\HA5<DÂ58á<T¶OjK6á<BÂK6OjOQ?IBEKCá OjKVU\BÂ?I5<K67‡OjK\HQíP3.G6OÐ@6?A5<HA5<HcT\@ŒO ;AOQ?IU<O{;:9<;9

ïs?I9<7‡OQêZ5<?IéHI51HAO{;cH#HIG6ON9<KC9qDÂTª;¤BF;ƒ5qïZHAG6O‡OQùŒO{ç"H;#5qï.5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8T1çGJ9qK6á8OŠ58@JOj?I9qHABÂ5<KJ;ƒ58K

LªOQ@ŒOQKCL6OQKCçQBEO{;èŒOHcêZOQOQKÄ58K\HA5<DÂ58á<BÂOj;Z9qKCL+HI5‡HAO{;cH¾LªBEùŒOj?AOjK8H¡@C?A58è6DÂOQ7 ;A5<DÂUVBÂK6áŠ7‡OHAGC5VLC;

HA5‡;¤58DÂU<O¼ç5<KXCBFç"HI;ZBÂK1LªBF;cHI?ABÂè64ªHIOjL‘ä6çQ5<DÂDF9qèŒ5<?9HABÂU8O.L6OQU<OjDÂ5<@67‡OjK8Hjí

ÜÁÔAÎ ¾ÎVÎ8Ô¤ÉÙ

à

K8HI5<DÂ5<á8T?AOQúž4J;¤O>çj9qKSèŒO>èC98;¤O{LS5<KSHAGCO¡7‡5ªLª46DF9q?IBj9HIBÂ5<K5qï58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8BÂOj;9qKCLS58KŠHAG6OƒBEK6ú

çDÂ4C;ABE58KS5qïHAGC58;AO>7‡5ªLª46DÂOj;xHA5'ïs5<?I7ØDF9<?Aá8OQ?x5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8BEO{;íqR>5êmOjU<OQ?jä8BÂK‡58?ILªOj?HI5';A46@6@Œ5<?AH

ç5<K\HI?A58DEDÂO{L15<K\HA58DE58á<T+OQU85<DÂ4ªHABÂ58KÄ5U<OQ?ƒHABÂ7‡O<äJHIG6O‡?AO{;¤4CD«HIBÂK6á:5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8BÂçj9qDzL6OQ@ŒOQKCLªOjKCçBÂO{;

7'4C;¤HHAGCOQKÄèŒO#7:9qKC9<á<O{LNBÂK15<?LªOQ?¡HA5‡é<OjOQ@1HIG6O#5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8BEO{;7Š4ªHA4J9qDÂDÂT:ç5<KJ;¤BF;¤HAOQK\HBÂKÄ9

DEBÂè6?9q?ITqíq3.G6BF;x@J9q@ŒOQ?P@C?AO{;¤OjK8HIOjLS9qKJ9qDÂTª;¤BF;5qï5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8T#çGC9qK6á8O5<@ŒOQ?9HIBE58KC;HAGC9qHPïs58?A7Ø9

èC9<;ABF;HA5#46KJLªOQ?;cH9qKCL'HIG6O¡Où‘OjçHI;P5qïl9qKSOjL6B«H58@JOj?I9qHABÂ5<KŠ5<KŠHIG6O¡5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8BÂçj9qDVLªOQ@ŒOQKJLªOQKªú

çBÂOj;QíUšHBÂ;O{;A;AOQK\HABF9<D8HIGC9HHIG6O5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<TLªOjU<OjDE58@JOj?I;9q?IOZé<OQ@6H46@HI5#L69HIO.5<K'HAG6OOQùŒO{ç"HI;

5qïCHIG6OQBÂ?OjLªBEH;äèŒOjçQ9<4C;AOmBÂK#HIG6OçQ98;¤Om5qïJBÂK\HAOj?¤údLªOj@JOjKCLªOQK\H5<K\HA58DE58á<BÂOj;9¼;AOQOj7‡BEKCá<DÂT>;A7:9qDÂD

çGC9qK6á8OƒBÂK+5<K6O¼58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8T‡çQ9qK1çQ9<4C;AO¾7:98;A;ABÂU<O¡OQùŒO{ç"H;BÂK+;AOQU8OQ?9qD‘5qHIG6OQ?58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8BÂOj;Qí

UdK8HIOQ?AúšL6OQ@ŒOQKCLªOjK\HŠ58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8TÐDÂBÂè6?9q?IBÂOj;9q?IOHcT\@CBÂçj9qDÂDÂTÐLªOjU<OjDE58@JO{L¶èVT¶ç587‡7'4CK6BEHABÂOj;

5qïç58DEDF9<èJ58?I9qHA5<?;Qí W 5<DÂDF9qèŒ5<?9HIBÂU<O5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8T‡?AOQúž4C;AOBÂKÄ9‡LªBF;cHI?ABÂè64ªHIOjLOQKVUVBÂ?A58K67‡OQK\H.?AOQú

84CBE?IOj;ŒHI5V5<D<;A46@6@Œ5<?AHlHA5á84C9q?9qK\HIOQOHAG6Omç5<KJ;¤BF;¤HAOQKJçT¡5<ï8HIG6OP58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8T.DEBÂè6?9q?ITqí35BÂ7‡@6DÂOú

7‡OQK\H;A4CçGHA5V5<DF;Qä{BEHBÂ;K6O{çO{;A;I9q?IT¾HA5¾BEK\HIOQá<?9HIOHI5<á<OQHAG6Oj?L6B«ù‘OQ?IOQK\Hx9<;A@JO{ç"H;5<ïJ58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8T

LªOQU8OQDÂ5<@67‡OjK\H8çQ?AO{9HABÂ58Kä8U8OQ?;¤BÂ5<KCBEKCá6äq@646èCDEBF;AG6BÂK6á6ä8?AOQúž4C;AOqäV9qKCLNOQU85<DÂ4ªHABÂ58Kí835';A46@6@Œ5<?AH

ç5<DÂDF9qèŒ5<?9HIBÂU<Oqä6LªBF;¤HA?IBÂè64ªHAO{LÄ5<K\HI5<DÂ5<á8T+LªOjU<OjDE58@67‡OQK\HjäŒ9+çDÂBÂOQK\H¤úd;¤Oj?AU8OQ?èC98;¤O{Lº58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8T

DEBÂè6?9q?IT9<?IçG6BEHIOjç"HI46?IO¡9qKCL‡BEH;P@6?I5qHI5qHcTV@ŒO

à

>=?Uxê.9<;m@6?IOj;AOQK\HAO{L‘í

à

ƒ=?UxG6OQDÂ@C;PHAG6O¾LªOú

U<OQDÂ58@67‡OQK\H5qï¡èC98çéVêZ9<?IL6;ç5<7‡@J9HABÂè6DÂOŠ5<K\HA58DÂ5<á<BÂO{;¾9<KCL÷DÂOH;HIG6OLªOjU<OjDE58@JOj?I;HA5ºðJKCL

5<4ªHN9<KCL¸ç5<7‡@J9q?IO:HAGCOÄOù‘Ojç"H;:5<ï¾LªBEù‘OQ?IOQK\H‡OjLªBEH:5<@ŒOQ?9HIBÂ5<KC;QíUdK¸5846?‡UVBEOjê¼äPç58KC;¤BF;¤ú

HAOQK\H58K\HA5<DÂ58á<TÄLªOQU8OQDÂ5<@C7‡OQK\HQäU<Oj?I;ABÂ5<K6BÂK6áCä‘9<KCL @646è6DÂBF;AG6BÂK6á+;AG65846DFL èŒON;A46@6@Œ5<?AHAOjL BÂK

BEKJLª4C;¤HA?IT8ú\4C9qDÂBEHcTÄHI5\58DF;#ïs58?SL6OQU<OjDÂ5<@6BÂK6áÄ58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8TÐ58?ABÂOjK8HIOjL÷9<@6@6DÂBFçQ9HIBÂ5<KC;QíR¡5êZOQU8OQ?jä

ç46?I?AOjK\H¼;A5<DÂ4ªHIBE58KC;¾9q?IO'7‡5\;cHIDETÄçQ5<KCçQOQ?IK6OjLÐêBEHAG 58K\HA5<DÂ58á<TÄç?IOj9qHABÂ5<K 9<KCLÐ?AOQúž4C;AOqäl9<KCL

DÂ98çéîO:çBÂOQK\H‡7:9qBÂK\HAOjKC9qKJçO9<KCL @6?A5ªçQOj;I;Š;A46@6@Œ5<?AHSHAGC9qH:BF;'?IO \46BÂ?IOjLîïs58?‡DÂ5<K6á<úgHIOQ?I7

5<K\HA58DE58á<Tî4C;I9qá8Oqí à >=?U'BÂK8HIOQá8?I9qHAOj;Š7:9<KC9qá8OjL¶58K\HA5<DÂ58á<Tî@646è6DÂBF;AG6BÂK6áÐ9<KCLœOQU<58DÂ4ªHABÂ5<K

@6?A5ªçQOj;I;¤O{;mBÂK+5<?LªOQ?ZHI5S;A46@6@Œ5<?AH>LªOjU<OQDÂ58@JOj?I;mBÂK58K8HI5<DÂ5<á8T'7:9<BÂK8HIOQKC9<KCçOƒ@6?I5<è6DÂOQ7:;Qí

UdKº5<46?ƒïs46?AHAG6Oj?ƒêZ5<?IéŒäJêZO@6DF9<KÄHA5BEKVU8Oj;¤HABÂá89qHAO¼êZ9`Tª;¡HA59<4ªHA587:9HIBÂçj9qDÂDÂT‡;¤58DEU8OHAGCO

ç5<KXCBFç"HI;ƒBFLªOQK\HIB«ðJOjLºLª4C?ABÂK6á+OjLªBEHIBEKCá6äŒ9<KCL HA5+7‡5<?IO'9<çjç46?9HIOQDÂT+?AOXCOjçH¾HIG6OS@6?I5VçQOj;I;¤O{;

5qï5<K\HA58DE58á<TSLªOQU8OQDÂ5<@C7‡OQK\HmBÂK19qK+BEK\HIOQá<?9HIOjL:HA5V5<Dží

ÖIÖlÌCÖlÙ ‘ÖÎ

•{€tƒ€z\_Y\bd_Ins€

! 1 , ,%1 !

€}qu8ac[^Y\¢j_Iad“¹—_Aacn«vQ¢8rV†j”j”<•{€

†q€™¡€{}qedac|\ 8_Ia"rQ—ƒ€™¡€j„_Y )dvjw[^Y\br{vjY\ ¾t¾€j\_Y8bd_nF€VŸY8h¨n^_" <¢{_x_Y8¢{[^Y\_I_Iac[^Y\¢8¦`lac[^Y8~[^u\n^_bzvjY\ 

w_Aec£\hq 8b€

#%'%0% .6$ 1 &% * *!

r8uVvQ¢{_b

Références

Documents relatifs

The concept behind the RAPOD is to establish intellectual control of the probabilistic ontology (PO) model, stimulate reuse, and provide a basis for development through

It is used through- out the paper as an example of human computer interaction where the ontology becomes a tool with domain knowledge to assist expert persons building a root cause

Keywords: cyber-security, ontology architecture, security standards, security automation, making security measurable, security information and event management, SIEM,

After creating the ontology in Protégé and using Notation3 to represent the data there are some other steps we need to go through in order to create our

With this information we expect to validate the hypothesis stated in Section 5 proving that this ontology testing framework reduces errors regarding the validation of the ontology

We have developed the Webulous framework and the accompanying Webulous Google App to tackle some of the issues associated with collaborative editing and engaging

This paper describes a generic Ontology Design Pattern (ODP) based on a project to convert bibliographic records from Montana State University’s Open Access Institutional

Based on this ontology representation, we may use logical rules and apply semantic reasoners to infer new knowledge about tasks that may be useful for agent programmers willing