Adult identification in
SlOutlq4ql apparentdependence
of polyteny
on food goureeln .olplghian
tubuLe and nurse ceLL
nuclei duri:lg
oogeneale.Flnal
Reportl{lLliam S.
ProcunierW.H.O. COIJABORATING CENru
f6r the studf ol
SIMULIIDAE & PHLEBOTOMINAB rn relation to
ONCHOCERCIASIS & LEISHMANIASIS
Department
of
EntomologyBriti.sh
l'luseun(ttaturat Hletory),
Londou, Unlted K5rtgdom, SU| lBD
*^-rerary adviser to the
OCP/OMS Program, Ouagadougou Burkino Faso, l{ay 1985.,.sffir oT7
t4'
; ?Za
6tr
:.?".q',--;}
1.
This
study vas undertakento
determilechromosone poJ.ytenizatioa and
to
asoees tboparity
determinations..inS.
damnosums.l.
the
opti.mumtloe 36j
na.lplgblaupbysiological
ageof the fllcs for
fhe
optinurntime for
malpighlan tubul.e"h"oro.ooe
polytenization
appeana to occurafter a
bloodnealfor the
ti.meperiod the
oocarte eatersaeiosls
upto
rndiacluding the
karyosome stage(I'igures IB-LD).
The nucl,el (karyoeome) becoaoa condensed and rernainsat this
etageuntil fertillsed,
uhereuponthe let
and 8ndmei.oti.c
divisions are
cornpletod andthe
spern fusesnith the
functioaa-1 oocytrto
forma zygote,
The malpighian nuclej- appearrto
break downat the
onsetof vitellogenesis (laying
dowuof yolk) (Figure IE).
Onsetof
meioetevarlee
anongspecies and
especially
between aevann4$anrl*forest llploe:
optimum tLne- forest I-4 hrs; savarurah
T-11 hrs.Previous
to this
studyit
was suggestodthat
chromosomepolytenlzatlon
appeared
to
be dependent on food Bource (Procunier 1984 and Procunler & poat L985)with the
degreeof
polyteny being stagespecific.
I{enceby the
tLmeadult flice
obtained
a
bLood meal moet ehould already beat
stageII
(Procunler 1984) polytcny.Most
tissues
i.n whichhigh
metabollcturnover is
requiredduriag
ontogenetledevelopnent appear
to
respoadto the
demandeither
througheelectlve anpllflcatlon of
genes and,/orthe
whoLe genone (Ashburner 198O).In the
caseof the
whole gonome (chromosome conplenent)thls
oay ta]<e the formof
polytenyor
endoduplicatloa (doubllngof
cbromosomenumber).
Siace ma-lpighiantubules function
as an excretory organ whichj.lvolves
water ba.Lance(Wiggleswortb 1984)
great
demands would beput
ontbis
organ uponacqulriag r
bl-oodrneal.
Further, the time to
synthesise DNA froma
normal 2c valueto
2ol4ovalue (tutt polyteny)
wouldalso requlre a certain length of tine.
Consequentlythe
observation that,the flias are
alreadyat
stageII
pollrEeayis consistent ultb
tbe
tj.rneconstrainls put
onthe flles
syetem j-norder to
oalce readythe
nucl"car oachiaeryfor high
metabolicturnover in
responseto the
bloodrneal.Eovever,
littLe ig
known about ceIJ,cycle in blackfliee ulth
regard toDNA synthesj.s ti.me (except Bedo 1984
-
doesnot glve actual length of tlror ln his
paper) a.rrd hovlong the celIs are in mitotic (melotic) divlslon.
s
G2 M
G1
DNA synthesis 'Gap
2
mltosts
(meiosis)Gap 1
) ({,
^o.;;
tq6L )
In
DrosophiLa (Kfng I97O)the time required for
meiosis upto
karyosone etagcts
27
hrs with the total time for
egg maturationbelag 4 days. In
noequitoeathis detailed
j-nformationis not
avaiLable coucerningaIL the
atagesof
oogcacsla exceptthe half gravid (yolk ])
etage can occur 12hre aftar a bloodneal.
Boncver,i:r
mosquitoes readable chromosomesare
frclmthe
nursece1ls.
These organlaua provi.de someclues
concerningduration of
temporal events duri.:rg,^oogenesla.ft
J.simportant to establish that a particular
r,:t;rge can be usedconsistantly
aaa'.
physiological
markerof age. Cytologica]
observationsfrom a nunberof differcnt species, !.
yahenserg. ryttpqu.].i,9.
glggg4ggr[.
soubfense B (Procunier & Poet1985),
S.
oyapockensy'roralmense anrl3.
Iimbatum (SheHey, Moraes, LunaDtar
&Procunier 1985) suggests
that a relative
tlrueperlod exists for
coneistenblyobtaiaing
readable malpighiantubule
chromogomes. Thle concLusionis firthcr
supported by
the
observationthat individaals
which show dj-fferentia-Lfolllcular
development
(Fig.
2C aad 2D) remalnat
stageI11 polytenizatioa
independentof tine after a
bLoodmeal (a6long as
aomefollicles are at the right
stage)rhtle
those
individuals uhich
sbow gonotrophic concordance cannot be readafter
the ooclrteenters vitellogenesis.
Tiaing of
onsetof meiosis, polfienlzation
and clurationof
oogenesla La undcr hormonalcontrol.
These processes seemt()
be dependeut onthe
productionof
R'ddt$"1 o',,1 Je'tata
llll
ecdysone and
its derivatives
and,/orjuvenile
hormone (, '.). lcccrtly it
has been shownthat
Juveni.Le hormone can inducepolyploldization la folllclo cerls
(Lapointe et aI
I 9g5)
duri ng vi tet logeriesi! (r'igie
28 )6.
,.
The seguence
of
hormonally medlated evontsduring
oogenesis appearto
bca function of
marryfactors -
eogo blood motabolism, excretoryregulatioa tto.o
tr'ormation
of the peritrophic
merobrane occursvery
rapidLyafter
acquirenentof
abloodnea1
in
manyblackfliee vith the laylag
dounof
nenbrnnesvaryiag ln ttnc
Reirt + LeLare'
and
type
(1981).
Formatlonof the
nembrane has been lookedat ulth rcgard
to understandingfactors Il-triting the traasolssion.of
onchocerca(PUf[ppon
X977 anclR"''<J*lqhcrt-
r 198f).
However, formationof the peritrophic
meobrane tray arso bca
x.l,nttlngfactor in
deterrniniagthe
onsetof
meiosis and srlbeeouentvtteLlogerresLe. It ts interesting to note that
myresults for
onsetof
meiosis (optinumtlne for
chromosome
polytenization) correlate poeitively with the ti:ne
takenfor fornatlon of
membranes. Savannah species which havea thick
membranarequire 6
Ura?to lay
down
while forest
species(again the idea of d,lscrealttr" periods for
oarktngdevelopmental events) which have
a thin
membranerequlre only I tlr. (PnUlppo\
:lg??).Further, differences in saturation
(oogenesis) tlmes between species ui].J.certainly affect vector
dynanicswith respectto transmission.
Paraelteg havc evolveda
growthtime to L,
staSe whichcorrelate with
egg developmentso
that gonotrophic concordancewill
ensureparaeite survlval
becauseit is infectlvc at the Jrd
bloodmea-l. Ti.mefor
oogenesis would provldea strong isolating
nrclranlcofor
parasi*'edifferentiation
which could aJlowfurther selective
procesaeato
accountfor differences
between savpnnah and Fores.:;;Ilr:;^tfiXi.:'itlii*',i"*u
be
that
species foundinterfacing the
twoecologlcal
zones wouldexhibit ainilar
maturation tlmes and hence could
allow
developnentof
botb rrstrainsrrof paraeite.
A
series of
photomicrographsdepictlag the
eventsof
oogenesisis
gtveawith
appropriate notes discussingparlty
and gonotrophlc concordaace (FlgureeIA-LI
and2A-2G).
Photomicrographsof tha adult
poLytene chromosome complenentof 3
cpeclcois also given. It
should be notedthat
lndividual"s whicbgive
mediocre prtparattoas(marginal)
can be analyzedwith
appropriale photomicroscoplcset-up
and hrvLngpreknowledge
of larval
banding aequences.5
i-udividualsof g.
sirbanum wcrc alaopositively identified;
however, photomicrographs worenot
takon because alldee uere madeat
Bamako.Research Recorunendations
The f ol l owi ng stud'ies
are
envi saged:l) To
determineif malipighian tubule nuclei will give consistently
readablo chromosomes so asto
be usedfor routine adult identification
nov{that the
optlmumtime for
chromosomepolytenization has been
detenfitlnedfor 3 spccles ln !.
damnosum s. I .
2) To
determineif a techno'logytransfer in adult ident'ification techniques'ls possible using
DNA probesand malpigh'iantubule
chromosomesfrom the
samefly.
Under
(l) study sites
andprotocol for adult identificat'ion as outlined'in
theprevious advisorship (Procun'ier .l984) can be followed.
Under
12) as'in (l)
exceptthe fly
wouldbe
severedin
two- with the
abdom{nalpart
being usedfor
chromosome'identification andthe other half for
DNAanalyrls.
Dr Post has 3 probes
now wh'ichcan differentiate 3 species pairs;
pS03:
sancti paul i /soubrense
B,
pS01'l -
squamor,uT/yahenseaffi
pSQl-
si rbanug ( Post '1985-
PennState). fhis
techn'iqueallows
populationsto
be separated byquantitativa
meansbased on the
amountof
bi nd'ing
( radi oact'i vi ty) the probe
shows whenanneaiing
to the
DNAof a particular species.
However,the
technique needsto
beverified
againsta
standardto
ensurethe quantitat'ive difference don't overltp especially for siblings in sympathy. If quantitative difference hold
upthe
DNAmethod would have tremendous pract'ica1
value not
on'lyfor identifying the
vectorbut also to
determinerelative vector potential (could
probably process 200-500 f1 i es/day) .One
of the study sites
shouldchromosomes
preparations
wereapproximate
time to look for
thebe at Tienfala, Mali
because(l ) identifiable
obtai
ned
from there (S
'indi vi dual s ); (21
theoptimum.chromosome
pglytenization in S.
sirbanum'i
s known;
(3) 0r Post
already has a
probeConsquently,
th'is population gives the
greatest'i
n
i denti f i cati on techni ques .which can identify
S. s'irbanum.prom'ise
for
a technologytransfer
A
seconds'ite
could be
Soubre where al though Iarval
popu'l ations of
-S. yaheEeand
sanctipauli are in allopatry the sites are close
enoughfor the adults to be
considered'in sympatry.
AgainDr
Post has probes which can separate yahensefrom s.anctipauli. Alternatively,
someother site
wherepopulations occur ln
sympatry,especially
damnosums.s, (Neither
oneof us has
lookedat
damnosum.)Another
possibi'lity is to
go whereS.
s'irbanumis zoophilic in its distribution.
3) A s'imilar study could
be undertakenw'lth Dr
AngelaPhilips. I st'lll
do notknow whether
they
have donethe critical analysis to show'if
peak dlfferences between2 populations (single adult) are additive - this is
necessaryto
differentiate between intra and interspec'ific variatjon. i.e.
suppose thefolIowing
G.C.profiIes
were obtained:I adult
(sirbanum) 3mmI adult
(yahense)does A
+
Bgive a
peak height4)
Parity
determinat'ions
should be
f easi b'le(.l984).
However,an in-depth study
should befollicular relicts
are mosteasily discernible'
6mm A
-/
UM4.5mm
A^^
using the
techniquesof
Procunler doneto verify the
stageat
whiqhReferences
Ashburner, M.
1980.
Some aspectsof the structure
andfunction of
polytene.chromosomes
of the Diptera.
Symp.R.
Entomol. Soc. London.I0.
BlackwellScientific Publicat'ions,
Oxford, 20pp.Detinova,
T.S. 1962.
Age grouping methodsin
Dipteraof
medicalimportance.
t.lHOmonograph
series
No.47.
Geneva, Swrueer'lBnd. 216pp.Bedo, D.
G.
I982.
Patternsof
polytene-chrornosome rep'l i cati on(Diptera:
Simul i idae).
Gentica59:
9-2.l .Cupp, E.I.l. & Colf
ins,
R.C..l979.
The gonotroph'ic
cycie
in Ann.J.Trop.
Med. Hyg.28:
422-426.'ln
Simu I I umornaflf$.
Simulium ochraceum.
and parous
rates of
anthropophi'lic transmissionof
0nchocercaSimul I um damnogum
Garms,
R. 1975.
0bservat'ions onfilarial jnfections
blackflies in
Guatemala,with
referenceto
thevolvulus. frop.
med.Parasit. ?6:
.I69-182.King,
R.C. .l970. 0varian developmentin Qrolophill lg&lfggasler.
Academlc PressInc.
(London)Ltd.,
Berkeley Squaare House,London.
2?7pp.Lapointe, M.C. Koeppe,
J.K.
&Nair, K.K.
.l985.'Fo'llicle cel'l
polyp'loldy inLeucophaea maderae:
regulation
byjuvenile
hormone.J. Insect. Physiol. 3l(2):
I 87-t 94.
Lewis,
D.J. 1957.
Aspectsof the structure, biology
and studyof
Ann.trop.
Med.Parasit. 5l:
340-358.Madahar, D.P. 1967
"
Cytologica'lstudies
onblackf'l'ies (Simuliidae: Diptera)
Ph.D.thesis, University of
Toronto, Toronto,Ontario,
Canada.-2-
Phil'ipp0n, B. 1977.
Etude dela
transmission d'0nchercavolvulus
(Leuckart 1983)( Nematoda,
Simuliidae) (oRsroM).
0nchocercidae)
par
Simulium damnosum Theobald, '1903 (Dlptera:en
Afrique trop'icale. Trav.
Docum. Off.
Rech.Sc'i.
Tech.53:
l-308Procunier, l,l.S. 1984. In
Onchocerca/Simul'lumrelat'ionships in
regardto
the transmi ss'ionof
human onchocerc'iasisin
WestRirica.
l{HO/Fi 1 StlG document.(
In
press ) .Procunier,
I.l.S..l975.
A
cytological
studyof
two close-lyrelated blacltfly
specles:Cnephia dacotensis and Cnephia
or.nithophilia (Diptera: Simuliidae).
Can,
,1.Zool. 53:
I 622-1637.Procunier,
W.S.(D'i ptera ) :
and nurse
Rejd,
G.D.F. &simu'lijds,
mi rgrat'ion
&
Post, R.J. '1985.
Adu'ltidentiflcation of
simulium damnosums.l.
apparent dependence on polyteny on
food
sourcein
malpigh'ian tubulecell
nucle'iduring oogenesis.
Tropen. med.Paraslt.
(subm.itted)Lehane,
M.J. '1983. Peritrophic
membraneformation'in three
temperate Simulium ornatum,S.
equjmum andS. lineatana, with
respectto
theof
onchocercalmicrofilariae.
Ann.Trop.
Med.Parasit. 78(5):
527-539.Riddiford,
L.M. & Truman, J.W.1978.
Btodhemi$tryof rnsect
hormones and Insect growthregu'lations. In
Biochemistryof Insects.
Academic PressInc.
l'11Fifth
Avenue, New
York,
NewYork'10003.
Pp.308-355.shell€y, A.J.,
LunaDias, A.P.A.,
Moraes, M.A.P. & Procunler,l.l.S.1985.
The statusof
Simulium '---- oyapoekense -J -r s.'l ./rora'imense and Simulium limbatumof the
S.amazonicum group as
vectors of
human onchocerc'ias'isln
lowlandtropical forest land
savannah areasof Brazil. Bull. Ent,
Res. (submitted)l,{igglesworth,
V.B. .l984. Insect physiology. 8th edn.
Chapman &Hall,
733 Thlrd Avenue, NewYork,
New York.l00.l7. lglpp.
0ogelesis
ln
SimuliumPrev'ious
attempts to elucidate the events of
oogenes'lsin blackflies has
boenpart'ia11y restricted by available
techniquesapplied ln preparing
andstainlng material
andthe type of
photomicroscopyused'in
doEumentingthis process.
(Lewls1958,
Madahar1967,
Garms.l975,
Cupp and
Collins T$fgt. However.,'tillzatlon
of different fixation
andstaining
methods coupledwith the
useof
interferenca microscopy has pnovidedthe
meansfor
understanding ovarian development morefully.
Oogenesis
in adult Slnuliun
daranoaurn ; i,r.ri.I.
aadf€'. roraltrcDseFigure IA.
MagnificationXIOO.
NeuJ.y emorgedS.
yahenseadult:
a-geraarlunlb -
proxi.aalfollicJ.er c -
distaJ.folllcle.
Nota nureecells arc
uoupolyteni-zed (etage
I - arrov f).
Oocyteis aot
dlsti-aguishableat thia
stage.
rf
igure IB. fiagnification XIOO. 9. gSlgllgli tr.s.
Tuo boursafter
bloodoeal.Nurse
cells polytenized (stage II-III).
Oocytele apparent.
Nucleusat
pa.chtrrtene stage
of
meioels(arrorl c).
figure lC. Magnificatioa XIOO. 9.
sa-nctipirulin.s. tlo
hoursafter
bloodncal.Precocious condensation
of
oocyte 'uucleua begindfifg(arror. e).
Nurse celLaare at
stageIII.
Fi.gure
LD.
MagnificationXl@. E.
sanc-tipaulin.s.
Four hoursaftar
blootlncel.Oocyte shows condensed nuclear
material in the
formof a
karyoooe(arrou
c)'.Yolk
forrnation (arrowe).
ViteJ"logeneeis appearsto
bestarting.
Figure LE.
MagnificationXIOO. g.
EBBS!&gg}!tr.s. Elght
hoursafter
bloodneal.YoIk forrnation *.
Karyosome preeent(arrow).
Nursecells
po).lrtenized(stage III).
FolLicuLar epi-h,eL1a1 ceJ-ls appearalso to
bepartially
polytealzed(arrov f).
Cel1 volume increasing.figure LF.
M,agnificationXj@.
5..eangtiq+uIi a.q Trelve
houreafter
bloodnoal.{)
yoJJxformation.
Karyosomestl}I vlslble.
Nursece}ls EtilL
stageIII
polyteny. r,ollicular
epitheU.unpartially
polytenized(arrou g). CelI
volnoc increasing.Fi.gure
lG. Magnification
X2OO.S. yahense.
22 hoursafter
bloodmeal.4/J
yo].kforrnatlon.
Ce11 volu.nelacreased.
Nurse ceJ.I etageI.
Iuterfcrence microscopy shovsyolk readily.
KaryosomeetiLL vialble.
Yolk doee notcover oocyte.
Figr:re 18.
!{agnificati.onX1@. g. Iglry.
24 hoursafter
bLoodroeal.Oocyte
sti11 vj.sibIe.
YoLk coversnost of
egg.Nurse cellspushed
to
oneend.
Karyosone appoarato
be brokea doUn.FiSure
)-I. Magnification XI)o. E. rorairr.nse'
48 hoursafter bloodreal' Interference microscopy.
Chorion formatj.on aroundegg.
Gernarluo andproximal,
foJ-licle
attachedoutside
cborlon(a, b).
Proximalfol1icLe
appcarato
beat a sinil.ar
stageas that
describedfor Fig. IB.
Nuroe ceLls aropolytenized (arotr f).
Paroue females mayrequire less tj.ne to
nature tlJlceproximal folLicle partial-ly
developed.Figure IJ. Magnification X150. E.
Loraimonse. 48 hoursafter
bloodneal'.Interference microscopy.
Chorlon presentuith
ce1ls eloughedoff
(arrown).
Probably nurse
cells.
Notealso
probable presencsof vitellln
membranc(partiaJ.ly
broken)with yolk
underneath (amowv).
w bc
B
Oogeuesis, Gonotrophlc Concordance and
parity
Figure
2A. Magnification XIOO. g. g!g,!gg.
Sour hoursaftar
bloodneaL.Note
the
pre6enceof 2 darkly
etalned heteropycnotlc bodj.eeln
each diataLfo]-licle (arro,rs e)
i-naicati-ngthat 2
karyosbmeaare
presentper fol).lclc.
th.is is
u:r-likethat
seenin
DrosophlLa, Toetse and mosquitoee, and haeaot
bcc!(PrccuxiC." lq? 5 )
reported
before in blackfli""A a -
Sermariun,b -
proximalfollicle' c - distal foLlic1e.
Figure
28. {agnification X!@.
,8. 933Siip39,tiIr.8. Zfi yolk fornatloa
sbowlngpolytenized foll,icular
epithella-Lnuclei
(arrowg)
covertngthe
oocyte.Nurse
ce1ls stilL partially visible.
Fol.Ilc1e celLsare
probablyactive in
synthesis
of viteLlin
(membrans).Tlris
stage corrgsPondsto
stageIII of Christopher for
mosquitoes and stage ]OAof !ryIlilg.
Figure
2C. Magnification )€oo, 9. su*Sgli n.s.
T'relve hoursInterference microscopy. Differential follicular
developmentig to
presenceof rod
andcircular like
fun51 (arrowc). Fo1licles
of
development from uewly emerged(arow p) to 4/)
yu.Lk forrnation (arrow5).
Figure
2D. Magnification
X2OO.l. S9!3:!9Eli !.s.
Same asfigure
2C excaptdifferential follicular
development probably under geniccontrol.
Notall' indj.viduals
show gonotrophic concordance(wilI affect vector
dynanics).rUrtL fetor4 io tnqr.,3rr.rrrort
Parlty
Figure
2E. Magnificatioa
X2OO.9. IgIgE.
Four houreafter
bloodmeal.Relict
egg(i)
and d.eveloping oocytes(k).
after
bloodlncal.probably duo '6hou raJxgc
Figr-rre
2F.
MagnificationX5@. ,8.
eoubrenseof a stalk (pedicle - arrou d)
attached toa - gernariun, b -
proxinaS. foJ.licLe.B.
Nonblood-fed.
Note prceenccdistal folIicIe (c);
One bour
after
blood.rneal. Probablepro:rMhl folJ.icle, es-
dLstalFigure 2G.
Magnificationfo].li.cular relict
(d) ;foLIicle.
X2OO.
S.
yabense.a-geraaf"luorb-
#.0
r.*
{i,
Ir's l-
,f
"*$rh
I p
/
';,k**
b
Adult
Si-ouliunsanctipaull
tr.s.Magnification
XIOOO.Diagnostic iaversions
i.ncludeI L
P+Q,lrd II-!;!Q!.
At tbe
SassandraR.
(Soubre)IT L 7 is polymorphic.
Tb.isladlvldual
shorathe II L-7 inverted
sequence(the p.b. oits distaL
andclose to the
cndof
chromosome) nhereas
in the j:rdlvidual in the next flgure
shouefi
L-7 sequence as standard (tUep.b. sits
moreproxinal).
IS IL IIs IIt
urs
III
Lshort
armof
chronosome oneloag aro of
chronosome onesbort
armof
chromosome onelong
a:mof
chromosome oneshort
armof
chromosome onolong arn of
chromosome oneC
-
centromerer RB- ring of Balblani,
db-
double bubbLe,pb
-
paraBalbiani,
NO- nucleolar
organizer.l-l
vf
frl
19/
l-i^
o.o
J
FraF{
Fr
r/
/.x,r i"{3
",ff
c hit ,t
o,", 'L
/ttl zt rn
-t H H
i,wE er\
--l*1rilr^'r-&:
J ''sl."q3-- Uf.
oroH -o llcr\55\-
= 2'
L,Adult
Sirnulium sanctipauLit1.8.
ard,E. 13!g
Maguification
XIOOO.A, C,
D show chromosome conplementof S. sancttbault n.s.
which is*eharacterlzedby II t -
4.6A beingfixed.
NoteII L-l
sequenceie
standard (conpareto other figure).
B
-
cbromosomeI of S.
Yahense.yahense
is fixed for the
heavy Uana(H) in the
centromereregion, unlike that for i. gg*g!i!3gE n.s.
compare banding betneen A andB.
Preknowledgeof diagnostic
sequencesgreatly facilitate analysis of
mediocre preparattoneespecially in
areasof
known cytotypeo'$na;=
. irl'ilb
Sl*
IL
-e',{^
"r(S
k *.b
ttu
NO
"61
lr"
',.;,.,:{i
-,. ,ii
,i
Fl
'il1l
._j il
:\ i,1
c
D
6r
t