HAL Id: jpa-00209109
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/jpa-00209109
Submitted on 1 Jan 1979
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Chemisorption on a model transition metal : ordered overlayers with C(2 x 2) and (2 x 1) structures
K. Masuda
To cite this version:
K. Masuda. Chemisorption on a model transition metal : ordered overlayers with C(2 x 2) and (2 x 1) structures. Journal de Physique, 1979, 40 (3), pp.299-308. �10.1051/jphys:01979004003029900�.
�jpa-00209109�
299
Chemisorption on a model transition metal : ordered overlayers
with C(2 x 2) and (2 1) structures
K. Masuda
Department of Materials Science and Engineering, Tokyo Institute of Technology, Ookayama, Meguro, Tokyo 152, Japan (Reçu le 9 octobre 1978, accepté le 20 novembre 1978)
Résumé.
-On étudie l’effet de la chimisorption de couches atomiques ordonnées, C(2
x2) et (2 1)
surla
surface (001) de métaux de transition
enutilisant le formalisme des fonctions de Green et la technique du déphasage.
La structure du substrat métallique est décrite
encombinaison linéaire d’orbitales atomiques (LCAO) suivant
la méthode de Allan, Kalkstein et Soven. Les substrats sont soit cubique simple, soit cubique à corps centré.
Chaque adatome est représenté par
unseul niveau d’énergie
nondégénéré. Les adatomes sont placés
surla surface,
à la fois
surle site et
aucentre de la configuration à quatre sites. Le changement de la densité d’états à la chimisorp-
tion est calculé suivant le modèle de Newns-Anderson. On montre que les effets d’ordre à longue distance dans la couche adsorbée, de géométrie d’adsorption et de structure de bandes du substrat
surla structure électronique
des couches ordonnées sont importants. On montre aussi qu’il y
adeux types d’états
nonliants pour les couches ordonnées.
Abstract.
2014The effect of chemisorption of ordered atomic layers with C(2
x2) and (2 1) structures
onthe
(001) surface of model transition metals is investigated using the Green’s function formalism and the phase shift technique. The electronic structure of the metallic substrate is described by the Linear Combination of Atomic Orbital (LCAO) scheme and is obtained by the method developed by Allan and Kalkstein and Soven. For compa- rison, both the simple cubic and body centred cubic substrate models
areused. Each adatom is represented by
a
single non-degenerate energy level. The adatoms
areplaced
onthe surface in both the on-site and centred fourfold- site configurations. The change in the electronic density of states upon chemisorption is calculated within the Newns-Anderson model. It is shown that the effects of the long-range order of the adsorbate layer, adsorption geometries and the band structure of the substrate
areof great importance for the electronic structure of the ordered overlayers. In addition, it is shown that there
aretwo kinds of non-bonding states characteristic of the ordered overlayers.
LE JOURNAL DE
PHYSIQUE
TOME40,
MARS1979,
Classification
Physics Abstracts
73.20
1. Introduction.
-There has been a great deal of theoretical and experimental work concerning the
electronic properties of chemisorbed systems Il, 2]. In
order to develop a qualitative picture of the complex chemisorption process, simple model calculations have been very useful [3]. Using Green’s functions
coupled with the phase shift technique, several authors have investigated the electronic structure of chemi-
sorption systems. Allan, using this technique, has
obtained the binding energy of single transition metal atoms adsorbed on the (001) surface of tungsten, simulated by a fivefold degenerate s-band simple
cubic (sc) crystal [4]. Einstein [5] has calculated the
change in the electronic density of states (DOS) due
to single atom chemisorption on the (001) s-band sc crystal. Furthermore, Ho, Cunningham and Wein- berg [6] have studied the chemisorption behaviour
on the (001) surface of the s-band body centred cubic
(bcc) crystal.
Other simple methods have also been used to study
the chemisorption behaviour. Cyrot-Lackmann et
al. [7] have used the moment method to calculate the
local DOS for the adatom on the (001) surface of the sc crystal in three different adsorption geometries.
Haydock and Kelly [8], using a similar method, have
studied the adatom DOS for (001) surface of a bcc metal. More recently, Moràn-Lôpez, Kerker and Bennemann [9] have calculated the local DOS for the adatom on a disordered alloy surface, using the
continued fraction method.
In addition to the studies for the single atom adsorption, these approaches have further been
applied to the various chemisorption systems. Einstein and Schrieffer [10] and Burke [11] have studied the pair
interaction energies between the adsorbate atoms. Ho, Cunningham and Weinberg have investigated the change in the electronic DOS due to the adsorption of
a monolayer of atoms (0
=1) on the (001) surface
Article published online by EDP Sciences and available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/jphys:01979004003029900
both of a model bcc metal (one-band) and of a model
two-band crystal with the CsCI structure [12, 13].
The present author [14] has studied the effect of having
the monolayer of atoms on the tight-binding metal surface, using the two-peaked DOS model for the substrate.
So far, however, no theoretical calculations have been performed for the change in the electronic DOS due to the adsorption of ordered atomic layers with general coverage 0. Furthermore, in view of the fact that surface superstructures are found in many
chemisorption systems by low energy electron diffrac- tion (LEED) [15], e.g., C(2 x 2)-H structure on W(100) and Mo(100), C(2 x 2)-0 structure on Mo(100), (2 x 1)-0 structure on Mo(100), Mo(110)
and W(110) and (2 x 2)-0 and (4 x 1 )-0 structures
on W(100) surface (see also table I), it is desirable to
perform the chemisorption calculation for the ordered
overlayers with general coverage. It is the purpose of the present paper to investigate the changes in the
electronic DOS due to the adsorption of the ordered
atomic layers with 0
=1/2, i.e., C(2 x 2) and (2 x 1) overlayers. However, the method presented in this
paper is quite general and the ordered overlayers
with 0=1/4, (2 x 2) and (4 x 1) structures, are treated in the Appendix.
Table I.
-Ordered overlayers with 0
=1 j2 and 1/4
on the transition metal surfaces. (From Somorjai, ref. [15].)
The present method uses the LCAO scheme and the tight-binding approximation to describe the semi- infinite crystal (1). For comparison, both the sc and
the bcc substrate models are used. Each adatom is
represented by a single nondegenerate energy level.
Two binding sites, the on-site and the centred fourfold- site, are considered. The Green’s function formalism and the phase-shift function approach are used to
calculate the change in the electronic DOS due to
(1) The d-bands of transition metals
arewell described by the tight-binding model and
agood description of the properties (such
as
the chemisorption behaviour) of transition metals
canbe obtained from this model [Friedel J., The Physics of Metals (Cambridge University Press) 1969, p. 340].
chemisorption. These particular system and method have been chosen so that a direct comparison can
be made with the results of references [5, 6, 12]
and [14], where the single atom chemisorption and
the monolayer chemisorption are discussed under
same assumptions. The main advantage of the phase-
shift technique is that it gives directly the change in
the electronic DOS due to chemisorption. This
information is quite important since it is directly applicable to photoemission. No other method gives
this same information in such a straightforward
manner.
The format of the present paper is as follows : In section 2, we present the formulation for obtaining
the phase-shift functions for the ordered overlayers.
It is also shown that the change in the electronic DOS due to chemisorption is easily calculated from the
phase-shift function. Results of the numerical calcula- tions and the related discussions are given in section 3.
The final section (section 4) is devoted to conclusions.
The extension of the theory to the chemisorbed systems with 0
=1/4, (2 x 2) and (4x1) overlayers,
is given in the Appendix.
2. Phase-shift functions for the ordered overlayers
with 0
=1/2.
-The most straightforward derivation
of the phase-shift functions for the ordered overlayers
with general coverage is first to obtain the phase-
shift function for a complete (1 x 1) ordered over- layer (0 = 1) and then to modify it taking account of
the structure of the ordered overlayers. Therefore, we first derive the phase-shift function for the (1 x 1)
ordered overlayer, commensurate monolayer. In the
case of the monolayer chemisorption, one can use the fact that the whole system has translational symmetry
parallel to the surface.
In order to derive the phase-shift function appro-
priate for the (1 x 1) ordered overlayer, we need to
know the Green’s functions for both the adatom in its free state and the clean substrate. When the direct interaction between the adatoms can be neglected,
the Green’s function for each adatom is given by
where E is the energy and Ea is the orbital energy of the adatom. The Green’s function for the semi-infinite clean substrate crystal can be obtained, in a mixed
Bloch-Wannier representation, from the previous
work of Kalkstein and Soven [16]. For the (001) sur-
face of the sc tight-binding metal,
where
301
and
Here, t is the transfer integral between the nearest-
neighbour substrate atoms and k Il (k,,, ky) is the unitless
two-dimensional wave vector (a
=1 ; a is the lattice constant of the sc crystal) within the surface Brillouin
zone (SBZ). Furthermore, Eo is the energy of the middle of the band and the total bandwidth is 12 1 t f.
For the (001) surface of the bcc metal [17]
where
Here, T is the transfer integral between the nearest- neighbour substrate (bcc structure) atoms and the
bandwidth is 16 ! 1 T 1.
Following the phase-shift technique [4, 18-20], we
define the partial (kil dépendent) phase-shift function
for the chemisorption system as
where lis the identity matrix, V and G are the pertur- bation and the unperturbed Green’s function matrices, respectively, and x represents the adsorption geo- metry. In the following, we consider the two binding sites, the on-site and centred fourfold-site configura-
tions. For both binding sites, the unperturbed Green’s
function matrix is diagonal and is given by
The perturbation matrix V describes the hopping
interaction between the adatom and the substrate atoms and also describes the shifts of the orbital
energies of both the adsorbate and substrate atoms due to the formation of the chemisorption bonds [12, 18].
For the on-site adsorption where the adatom sits
directly over the substrate atom and is bonded only
to it, Vis expressed as
where Yt is the on-site binding strength, and bEa and bEe (2) are the changes in the orbital energies of the
e) Here, it is assumed that the perturbation is localized comple- tely in the monolayer of adatoms and the surface plane of substrate atoms.
adatom and the substrate atom directly beneath it, respectively. Both terms, âE. and BES, result from the redistribution of electrons upon chemisorption and
their magnitudes can be determined to satisfy the
Friedel sum rule. The corresponding perturbation
matrix for the centred fourfold-site adsorption, where
the adatom is situated above the centre of four sub- strate atoms and is bonded to all four of them, is given by
where
and bEs and ôEf correspond to ôE., and bEa for the
on-site adsorption, respectively. Here, V,, is the binding strength of the adatom in the centred fourfold-site to each of the substrate atoms.
Using eqs. (9), (10), and (11), we obtain the partial phase-shift function per unit cell for the on-site
adsorption
For the centred fourfold-site adsorption, we obtain a
similar expression
Once the partial phase-shift function is known, the change in the electronic DOS, àp(E), can be given by [19, 20]
where the total phase-shift function 1Jx(E) is defined by
Here, Na is the number of adatoms and the Heaviside theta function is added so that Ap(E) directly gives the
difference in the DOS between the chemisorbed system and the clean substrate. In eq. (16), we find
the sum rule
since we are adding an electron state to the system.
In addition, it is important to realize that àp(E) in
eq. (16) is the quantity of experimental interest since photoemission difference spectra are obtained by
subtraction of the clean substrate spectrum from the chemisorbed system spectrum. The magnitudes of the diagonal matrix elements, bE., and bEa (ôEf and bE.’), are in principle obtained from the Friedel sum
rule under appropriate assumptions such as
For the adsorbate atoms with one valency, the Friedel
sum rule is expressed in terms of the total phase-shift
function as
where Ef is the Fermi energy of the substrate metal.
We now derive the phase-shift functions for the ordered overlayers with 0
=1/2, C(2 x 2) and (2 x 1 ) overlayers, starting from the expressions of the partial phase-shift functions ?1,(k,,, ky ; E) for the
monolayer chemisorption. The modifications of eqs. (14), (15) and (17) are summarized as follows.
(1) For the on-site adsorption (eq. (14)), the sub-
strate Green’s function Gs(kl, ; E) is replaced by
where Kh("# (0, 0)) is a reciprocal lattice vector for the
ordered adsorbate lattice. This modification results from the physical considerations that an electron in the overlayer orbital ! 0, k Il > can hop into the first layer orbitals 11, kl, > and Il, kll ~ + Kh > by the hopping interaction (off-diagonal matrix elements of P), where 0 and 1 denote the adsorbate layer and the
first substrate layer, respectively [22, 23].
(2) For the centred fourfold-site adsorption (eq. ( 15)), a2(k ii ) Gr ,(k E) is replaced by
(3) The diagonal matrix element bE. is expected
to take the different values depending on whether the adatom is bonded directly to the substrate atom.
Note that in the first substrate layer, there are atoms directly coupled to the adatom and substrate atoms
coupled to a vacancy (vacant site). Therefore, it is
inadequate to assume the uniform values for bEs.
Since the rigorous treatment of ÔE, for the ordered
overlayers with the general coverage is complicated,
.we perform here the usual chemisorption calculation with the assumption bES
=bEa
=0.
(4) The summation over kx and ky (eq. (17)) extends
over only a reduced SBZ with half the size (hereafter
referred to as the adsorbate Brillouin zone (ABZ)),
since the real space unit cell area is doubled (see Fig. 1).
By the modifications (1) ’" (4), one can obtain the partial phase-shift functions for the ordered over-
layers with 0
=1/2. For the C(2 x 2) structure,
Fig. 1.
-Two-dimensional Brillouin
zoneappropriate for the
(001) surface (SBZ) of the
scand bcc lattice and those for the adsor- bate lattice (ABZ) with 0
=1/2 ; (2
x1) and C(2
x2) overlayers.
The lattice constant (a) is set equal to unity.
and
where t(c) denotes the on-site (centred fourfold-site) adsorption.
In addition, for the (2 x 1) type overlayers,
and
303
The method for obtaining the change in the DOS, àp(E), due to chemisorption is similar to the case of
the monolayer chemisorption except that the summa- tion over kll extends over the ABZ rather than the SBZ.
3. Results and discussi8lr.
-In this section, we present the numerical results of the change in the
electronic DOS due to the adsorption of the ordered atomic layers with 0=1/2 (C(2
x2) and (2 x 1) overlayers) on the (001) surface of the sc and bcc tight-binding metals (s-band approximation for the
d-band of the transition metals).
3.1 (001) SURFACE OF THE bcc METAL.
-The elec- tronic structure of the clean surface of the bcc metal
are now well known [b,12]. In figure 2a we present the
imaginary parts of the surface Green’s functions
appropriate for the on-site single atom adsorption (solid curve) and for the centred fourfold-site adsorp-
tion (dot-dashed) on the (001) surface of the bcc metal. The latter surface Green’s function is calcu- lated from
where Gs(kx, ky ; E) is defined by eq. (5). These Green’s function curves are helpful when discussing the chemisorption behaviours, Ap(F), for the ordered overlayers with 0=1/2.
Fig. 2.
-Imaginary part of the Green’s function for the single
atom adsorption
onthe (001) surface of the bcc(a) and the sc(b) lattice ; on-site (solid curves) and centred fourfold-site (dot-dashed) adsorptions. The energies
arein units of the half-bandwidth of the substrate band.
In figure 3, we present the changes in the electronic DOS, àp(E), due to the on-site adsorption of the C(2 x 2) and (2 x 1) overlayers ; all energies are expressed in units of 2 1 Tl. The corresponding
results (3) for the centred fourfold-site adsorption
are shown in figure 4. For comparison, we have also presented the àp(E) curves for the single atom chemisorption in figure 5. To relate our model (s-band
(3) For comparison,
wehave chosen
asVc
=Vt/2 [6, 12 and 13].
Fig. 3.
-The change in the electronic DOS, àp(E), per adatom for the (2 x 1) and C(2
x2) overlayers
onthe bcc(001) surface.
The adatoms (Ea
= -0.5)
aresituated in the on-site positions.
V,
=1.0 (dashed curves), 2.0 (solid) and 3.0 (dot-dashed).
1