SAVE - Simulated Annealing Applied to the Vertex Elimination Problem in Computational Graphs
28
0
0
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. SAVE - Simulated Annealing applied to the Vertex Elimination Problem in Computational Graphs Uwe Naumann. N° 3660 April 1999. THÈME 2. ISSN 0249-6399. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4)
(5) "!! #%$ '& ()*+%-, . / 0 $ 213*$"4 5 768$ 9!:
(6) ;% $ <>=*% !&? @ ACBEDFHG'IJFLK'KNM ; OQPSR TCU"V WYX[Z \S]^U0_a`cbd]ae ]^U _ U fge hi_jekl_nmpoqT rL`c_a]jsdklU tvuw`ixyUf5Oz5{[tv|~}Q z5hcSL`cu~fSU0u~UePSU uePSU3\L' dcdW#5Suw]^_ cdW#VilhibdU m % Scc OQPSU0ePlhi]a\uwkS_aUvkS\lShcTU \fwhc_`cu55kSf~`cThif~]je0g]^LU u~U \f~]jhf~]a`c\ ¡¢[£Q¤e hc\rLU"hi¥ l_^]aU f~`e `cTSk¥fhf~]a`c\Hhi_bcuhiSPHm¤uwU lu~UmpU \dfw]^\lb<¦dU e§fw`cu-kS\lef~]a`c\lm5]^\¨hiuwrS]^f~uhiuwo`cu¥U um-u~UmpkS_^f~]a\Sb]a\ S]©U uwU \f`cLU uhfw]^`d\lme`dkS\fwm-`cuQfwPSU"e hc_ae kS_jhf~]a`c\`i%f~PSU ]^u[ªchde`crl]ahc\ Thfwu~]jeUm «'¬vU uwoU )hck¥f~PS`duwm PHh®¦cU5_a`q`c¯cUhf¤f~PS]jm-]^\f~U u~Umyfw]^\lb mpklr¥xyU ef-m~`"¡hiuQhi\Hf~PSU u~U¢]am¤\S`<bcU \lU uhi_a_^ohce eU Sf~U CfwU uwT]^\S`d_^`dbco `duCSU hi_a]a\Sb°]^f~PJf~PSUmpU:e`dT rS]a\lhif~]a`c\lm<`i5fwPSU`cuw-hcuw>hc\l±uwU ¦dU umpU TC`¥¥UmC`i¢¢ «²OQPSUT]^\l]© T]a³ hif~]a`c\`if~PlU5\qkST rLU u¤`i´hiuw]©fwPSTUf~]je`dHU uwhif~]a`c\lm'uwU skS]au~U<`cuvfwPSUge hc_ae kS_jhf~]a`c\`cLfwPSUge `cTS_aUf~U ªdhce `crS]jhi\_^UhcSm-fw`hCe `cTSk¥fhfw]^`d\lhi_a_^o Plhiue `cT<rS]^\Hhf~`du~]jhi_L`cSf~]aTC]a³ hif~]a`c\:Suw`crS_aU T:« |µ\±f~PS]jm HhiLU u -U ]a_a_-¥Um~e u~]arLU h¨\SU ¶PSU kSuw]jmyfw]aehiSSuw`dhdePEfw`fwPSUm~`c_ak¥f~]a`c\J`iQf~PSU¦cU upfwU· U _a]© T]a\lhfw]^`d\ Su~`drS_aU T¸]a\±e`dTSk¥fwhif~]a`c\lhc_²bcuhilPlmPS]jeP±e hi\ Uhcm~]^_ao°hdShi¥fwU °f~`f~PSU;T`du~UbcU \SU uhi_ e hcm~U0`i'U _a]^T]a\lhfw]^\lb;U ¥bdU m «Q¥]^T<kS_ahif~U¨hi\S\SUhi_a]^\lb]am]j¥U _^ou~U bdhcuw¥Uhdm5h;m~kS]^fwhirl_^U0TUfwPS`¥`cu m~`c_a¦q]^\lb;e`cT<rS]a\lhfw`cuw]ahc_´`c¥fw]^T]a³ hfw]^`d\¨Suw`crS_aU Tm «-¹ºU"]a_^_'¥]jm~e klmwm5¥]^LU u~U \dfhi\S\lU hi_a]a\Sb;m~ePlU ¥kS_aU m hc\l<Su~UmpU \fmp`dTCU-fwU mpf²u~UmpkS_^fwm «'»%]a\lhc_^_ao"-U]^_a_SuwU bdhcuw"f~PS]jm²hcSSuw`dhceP<]^\e `cTlhiuw]jmp`d\ ]^f~P`ifwPSU u TU f~PS`¥SmQ`du5e`dTClk¥f~]a\Sb;ªchde`drS]ahc\lm-klm~]^\SbhCT]^\l]^Thi_+\klT rLU u`ivhiuw]^f~PSTUfw]ae[`dHU uwhif~]a`c\lm « ¼¨½¾¿wÀ Á Âc }¤`dTSk¥fwhif~]a`c\lhc_´bcuhiSP+Ã¥¦cU u~f~U ·;U _a]^T]a\lhfw]^`d\nÃlm~]^T<kS_jhf~Uhc\S\SUhi_a]^\Sb. ÄÅyÆjÇ5ÈÉËÊjÌSÍ+Î´Å§Ï Ð%ÈÑ®Ç5ÈÒ®ÒiÓÔÖէ׮خÉÙÈÏ ÉËÒ®Ú¡ÉÙÈÏ ÛaÚ. Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, B.P. 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone : 04 92 38 77 77 - International : +33 4 92 38 77 77 — Fax : 04 92 38 77 65 - International : +33 4 92 38 77 65.
(7) Q
(8) ;
(9) ¸"!!:
(10)
(11) 13*$"4: 5 9¸
(12) . / $ /?($5
(13) ?¶
(14) =*"!:& 68<Q
(15) `cklmlu~ZmpU \dfw`c\lm<kS\SU\S`dkS¦cU _^_aUhcSSuw`¥ePSU¥U¨e hi_jekS_¥Uªdhce`drS]aU \S\SUm rHhcm~Z Um~kSu _ Z _a]^T]a\lhfw]^`d\¥Umhiue mCShi\lmC_aUbduwhcSPSU:¥U:e hi_jekl_Ö « `dr¥xyU ef~]^[¥U¨e UfpfwUTZ f~PS`¥¥U:U mpf_ah°T]^\l]© T]jm~hif~]a`c\ ¥k \S`cT<rSuwU:SU¨T kS_^f~]aS_a]ae hf~]a`c\Hm;m~e hi_jhi]au~UmC\SZ e U mwm~hc]^uwU m º _ hce ekST<kS_jhf~]a`c\ ¥U¨_jh±ªchde`c rl]^U \S\SU kS\lU `d\le§fw]^`d\±¦cUe§f~`du~]aU _a_a! U kS\ hiuwbckSTU \f«Et`ckSuCeU _jh]a_¤¡hik¥fu~Zmp`dkl¥uwUkS\Jlu~`drS_^R TU `d¥f~]aT]^³hf~]a`c\e`cT<rS]a\lhfw`c]au~Ud« %h0TZf~Pl`qSU[¥U[uwU ekl]©fQmp]aT kS_aZg`cLuwUg_jh"L`dmwm~]^rS]a_a]©fwZ[¥U¢u~Zmp`dkl¥uwUgeU lu~`drS_^R TUc« "8Á ¿ # X[uhiSPSU0¥U0e hi_jekS_ Ã¥Z _a]^T]a\lhfw]^`d\¨¥U mQ\S`qU klSm ÃSu~UekS]^f5mp]aT kl_^Zd«.
(16) .
(17) . 68$<"5"? Á Â %i Á #¥ ½ Â ! ½ # #" &(&#)d¥* Á Á + ½-,0½ ½.0/ #) 1 ¥* Á 32 Á # ½ % ' l«^ }¤`d4\ 5lbdkSuwhif~]a`c\ ««0«0««0««0««0«0«[«0««0««0«0««0««0«[«0««0«0««0««0««0«0«[«0« l« V z5U hiuwuhi\SbdU TU \fwm-«0«0««0««0««0«0«[«0««0««0«0««0««0«[«0««0«0««0««0««0«0«[«0« l« {¢rSxyU e§fw]^¦dU[kS\le§fw]^`d\ ««0««0««0«0«[«0««0««0«0««0««0«[«0««0«0««0««0««0«0«[«0« l« g\S\SUhi_a]^\SbmwePSU SkS_^U ««0««0««0«0«[«0««0««0«0««0««0«[«0««0«0««0««0««0«0«[«0« 8 9 S ½ %Â ¾ H«^ ¥HU U _aHU \S\S]a\SbkS\lef~]a`c\««0««0«0«[«0««0««0«0««0««0«[«0««0«0««0««0««0«0«[«0« H« V qf~U hd¥ompfwhif~U0e`dT rSkHmyfw]^`d\Suw`crl_^U TY«0««0««0«0««0««0«[«0««0«0««0««0««0«0«[«0« H« }¤PlU rqo¥mpPSU ¦ sklhcSuwhif~kSuwU¢lu~`drS_^U T «[«0««0««0«0««0««0«[«0««0«0««0««0««0«0«[«0« Â ?n # Án$Á @ <; ½ > = 9 Á # % Á 3. B(B ÒCEDGFGFGH. $ 4 . ®V 76. 4:. Vc VS. A.
(18)
(19)
(20) . %*$:
(21) $<. 6. + Á ¥* ½ ½ * S* Á ShfwU mvrlhde¯ hcm¡hcu²hcmcclÃPSU \ 5z U m~U hiueP ]a\Cf~PSU5lU _jC`i z"«
(22) «c¹ºU \lbcU u~fg ¹ºU \lc£!5lumyf²Suw`cL`dm~U f~PlUghik¥fw`cThfw]^`d\<`cf~PSU5e hi_jekS_jhfw]^`d\C`cSU uw]^¦hfw]^¦dU m'rqo<h lu~`dbcuhiT ]a\`cuwT `if~PlUgrlhdmp]jeQ`cuwQhiu<T`¥¥Ud«v¥]^\le U5fwPSU \ h"_^`cf¤`in-`cuw¯ PHhcm²rLU U \ ¥`d\SU5]a\;`cu¥U u fw`Thc¯cU0g3¡hcmpf~U u5hc\lTC`du~U]j¥U _aohcSS_a]ae hirS_aU¡m~U U Ù}¤`X[uS%hc\l 5}QXc£§«²¢3]amgh ¡hdmyf hc\l±e `c\q¦cU \S]^U \f -h®oE`cue hc_ae kS_ahif~]a\SbE¥]auwU e§fw]^`d\lhi_-¥U uw]a¦®hif~]a¦cUm"`i5¦dU ef~`cu kS\lef~]a`c\lm<\qkSTU uw]ae hi_a_^o klfw`>ThcePS]a\SU:SuwU e]jm~]^`d\Suw`¦q]aSU Jf~Plhif;]©f ]jmbd]^¦dU \ hcmh>e`dTSk¥f~U uSuw`cbcuhiT:« `cf~]jeUdäfwPlhf ¢.]jm-e`cTS_aUfwU _ao¥]©U uwU \f²uw`cTfwPSU¢hcSSuw`dhcePCfw`<e`dTSk¥f~]a\Sb SU uw]^¦hfw]^¦dU m\klTCU u~]je hc_^_ao<f~PSuw`ckSbdP S]^¦q]j¥U :¥]^LU u~U \leUm « OQPSU"e `cTSk¥fhfw]^`d\`c%fwPSU ªchde`drS]ahc\ Thfwu~]^· `chC¦cUe§f~`du-kS\le§fw]^`d\ !#"$ % '&("$)*+,&.y£ ]jm"Um~m~U \fw]ahc_]a\±Thi\qo°\qkSTU u~]je hc_¤hi_abc`du~]^f~PlTm «¨»S`du Suhcef~]je hi_¤u~Uhcm~`c\lmT`myfekSuwu~U \f~_ao°h®¦hi]a_ahcrS_aU ¢ m~`i fyQhiuwUlhce¯hcbcU mlu~`¦q]j¥U`c\S_aofy-`hilSu~`hcePSUm[f~`Ee hi_jekS_jhfw]^\lb:f~PSUªdhce `crS]jhi\ Thfwu~]^·°`c hif"f~PlUe kSu~uwU \f<hcu~bdkSTU \f /°fwPSU;`du~Qhiu hi\l>f~PSUu~U ¦cU um~UTC`¥¥Um Pl]aePJhcu~U rlhcm~U `d\>f~PSU hcSS_a]ae hfw]^`d\º`cf~PSUePlhi]a\>u~kl_^Ufw`]a\ fy¤`ES]©U uwU \f Qh®o¥m «105`-U ¦dU uÃnfwPSUePlhc]^\>uwkS_aU e hc\>rHU hcSS_a]^U°f~`Ee `cTSk¥fhf~]a`c\Hhi_²bduwhcSPlm`i¦dU e§fw`cukS\He§f~]a`c\Hm"]a\±hi\qo°hcu~rS]^f~uhiuwo`duw¥U u Ã%PS]jeP>u~UmpkS_^fwm ]a\S]©U uwU \f`cLU uhfw]^`d\lm e `ckS\fwm<`du<fwPSU¨e hc_ae kS_ahif~]a`c\±`c5f~PlU¨ªdhce `crS]jhi\>Thif~uw]©·2'«JOQPSUbcU \SU uhi_ fhcm~¯¨`iU43;e]aU \f~_ao¨U ¦hi_aklhif~]a\Sb52>kHmp]a\Sb:hi\°hcSSuw`dhdePPS]jePE]jm[m~`cTU f~]aTCUm[u~U U uwu~U:f~`:hcm7698;:=<><? 6;:A@BDC,8EFHGJILKIJBNMOCPIQ:B<]amve `c\xyUe§f~klu~U"fw`[rLU t' Plhcuw´«'OQPSU-¡hcef'f~Plhif²ªdhce `crS]jhi\Hm%e hi\ rLU5e hc_ae kS_jhf~U rqo°U _a]^T]a\lhfw]^\Sb¨]a\f~U u~TU S]ahif~U¦cU upfw]ae U m0]a\>e`cTSkSfwhfw]^`d\lhi_vbduwhcSPlm]jm0-U _a_²¯q\S`\>mp]a\leUfwPSU_jhf~U
(23) Rd m «²OQPSU u~U"hcu~U0hCU )HhiLU umrqo ¦hiuw]^`dklmhikSf~PS`duwm-fwPlhfgT`cf~]a¦®hif~U"he _^`mpU u_^`q`c¯hffwPS]am5f~`dS]ae ËX[uzU l ÃS -]jm~d «T0g`¤U ¦cU u ÃvfwPSU uwU:]am\l`ºbdU \SU uwhc_^_ao±hce eU ¥f~U±fwU uwTC]a\S`d_^`dbco `cu;SU hi_a]a\Sb°]^f~P fwPSU m~U0e`dT rS]a\lhfw]^`d\lmQ`i%f~PSU`du~Qhiu hc\lu~U ¦cU um~U¢T`¥¥U mQ`c'¢ ÃHmp`C¡hiu« |µ\`ckSuhcSSuw`dhdeP<-UU·¥LU e§ff~PSU5¦dU ef~`cu'kl\le§fw]^`d\f fw`"rLUgmpkHePf~Plhif]©f e i h \ rHUQ¥U e `cTL`dm~U 0]a\f~`¢h¢mpUskSU \le U²`iLm~e hi_jhiun¦hi_akSUkS\lef~]a`c\lm.gh
(24) ij UZ^ U] k5"l f~PHhf[fwhi¯dU<h ¦cU ef~`duSmonp qiChcmgf~PSU ]^u0hcu~bdkSTU \f[hc\l¨uwUf~klu~\Eh U\[ ¦®hc_^klUfrs*tgu+vmw-~«¹ºUe hi_a_¤m~kleP kS\lef~]a`c\lm<½ # ½ ½ # «|µ\JTC`myfCe hcm~U m f~PSU¢¦cU ef~`du²kS\lef~]a`c\f ]jm²bd]^¦dU \;hdmh"e `cTSk¥fwU ulu~`dbcuhiT8uw]^fpf~U \;]a\ mp`dTU UWV UX UZY PSmpL]^bdU P¥e ] 5H_^U e ¦chU fw_]^`dl\±u~`d`ibcuhiT]jTm<]^e \Shibº_a_^U_jhi>\S½bdkl hibd# %U¥m~* kl ÁeP hc mÁ +xLÃw* xA yA½ y>]^5`cu]©fzOe {}hc|A\±~|OrH
(25) U´rS« uw`cOQ¯cPlU ]a\ m h°mpUskSU \le U `cgm~e hi_jhiu<hdm~m~]abc\STU \fm"`igf~PSU `cuwT+P .-,* U] UZ^ ¥g`+P\±W-vP]a\dfw`º [rohcmwmp]abc\S]a\Sb f~PSU0uwU m~kS_^fQ`c%U ¦cU uwoU _aU TU \dfhi_kS\He§f~]a`c\ g[fwPlhf `qe ekSum¢]^\¨fwPSU lu~`dbcuhiT fw`h kS\S]jsdklU ]a\dfwU uwTU ¥]jhfwU ¦hiuw]ahcrS_aUjc«S0gU uwU7 U\[ ]amgf~PSU<]^\H¥U·m~Uf¢`c'f~PSUhiuwbckSTU \dfm`ig<hc\l:¤UC¥U \l`if~U ]©fm¢e hiu¥]^\Hhi_a]©fyo U e`dTCl_^U f~U ªdhce`drS]jhi\E`c UWV UX UZY rh±oTbc]a ¦cU A\ %¦cqU]a\le§fwe`cUu;`dkSklu0\l`ce§fwrS]^xy`dU \ e§fw]^¦dPSU]je]amP.fwe``d\le hcmp]j_ampe fwkSm_ahi`if~0UCf~f~PlPlU° lhcupfw]ahc_¢¥U u~]a¦hfw]^¦dU m;`c ~ f S P U. ¥ U L U H \ ¥ U \ < f ¦ c h ~ u j ] i h S r a _. U m } 4 b 4 9 b ^ ] ~ f ± P w u. U `iQf~PSU »]abckSuwU
(26) _`+,acb>de%]^f ]am¤kS\HShiTm~LU \U fe§hif0_Lfwf~``CU hchdmwempP ^ ] H \ ¥ U L U l \ S U \ f ® ¦ c h ~ u j ] i h l r ^ _ U m 4 b 4 9 b S k T U¢f~PSU A `c_a_^`]a\Sbc_. B(B ÒCEDGFGFGH.
(27) . 4
(28) $. . 1&+ Á
(29) 7 E 4 4 > E !#"%$'& (
(30) )* 4
(31) $ +
(32) E ,4- .( g / > )0 *21
(33) b3eb44b5476 8+ :9 $ ; E .E<(:= G ( G
(34)
(35) %( > 9?. @. @. g +PBAA-CA . . Dn . . E+4
(36) F %(C=
(37) 7 4
(38) $E( G(
(39) +H +4* FISKJ! + ? ML. OQPlU¨u~U _ahif~]a`c\ rHU fy¤U U \ f~PlU¦hiuw]ahcrS_^Um]a\ h bd]^¦dU \ U ¦hc_^klhif~]a`c\ uw`ck¥fw]^\SUe hi\ rLU¦q]am~klhi_a]a³ U rqoh S]^uwU ef~U Jhceo¥e _^]je;bduwhcSPONP * +RQbTS-PS]jePe `c\fwhc]^\lm<hi_a_Q]^\¥`du~Thif~]a`c\±\SU U ¥U>fw`ErLU:hcrS_aU;f~` e `cTSk¥fwUvf~PlU²U \f~uw]aU m´`cfwPSU¤ªdhce `crS]jhi\n«%»Suw`cT.\l`°`d\0¤Uv]a_^_du~U U u+f~`UNP hcm´f~PSU Á 1& + ¥ Á # " & + ¡hi_jm~` ¿ " & + £²¹°Ug]^_a_H¥]jmpf~]a\SbckS]jm~P;rHU fy¤U U \ ? V T]a\S]aThc_ ]^\H¥U LU \lSU \fW ÃW ? X ]a\f~U u~TU S]ahif~U0hi\l ? Y Th·¥]^Thc_ ¥U HU \l¥U \df9%¦dU u~f~]jeU m_ V ?[Z D b44bW B \ ] b X ?[Z b44bW' ^ \ _ b Y ?`Z ' ^ a b44bW' ^ a % \ OQPlU uwU-U ·¥]ampfwmvh¥]au~Ue§fwU CU ¥bdU E+ DRb 0c-+e`d\S\SUe§f~]a\Sb0h[¦cU upfwU· ]^f~Ph[¦cU upfwU· ]a8\ NP.]^ ¥]au~Ue§f~_ao SU LU \lSm<`c\ ]a\ « gmChirL`¦cU;-U m~Uf b Qf~`°rHU f~PSU:m~Uf<`c5]^\H¥]ae U m<`ighc_^_-SuwU ¥UeU mwm~`cum m~kle e U mwmp`duwmW`cQh¦dU u~f~U· «e e`duw¥]a\Sbf~`¢m~m~kST¥f~]a`c\ d«^C_ahcrHU _am > 9 Ã%u~U SuwU m~U \f~]a\Sbf~PSU_a`¥e hi_ Hhiu~f~]jhi_´¥U uw]a¦®hif~]a¦cUm ÃShcu~Uhf~fwhcePlU f~`;hi_a_´U SbcU m + DRb 0c-w; n S ¹°U5hcu~UQ_a``d¯q]^\Sb[`duh[TCU f~PS`¥C`iLf~uhi\Hmy`du~T]a\Sb[f~PSU5e bduwhcSP `cD)mpkHeP UZ^ f~PlhifQ-UbcU f¤fwPSU"ªchde`crl]ahc\2hfQfwPSU_^`-U mpf-L`dmwm~]^rS_aUe`dmpfQ]^\f~U u~TmQ`i%f~PSU U] \klT rLU u `cQmwe hc_ahcu0T kS_^f~]aS_a]ae hfw]^`d\lm0]a\¦d`c_a¦cUE]a\ f~PS]jm"lu~`¥eUm~m « |µ\º¡hde§f Ã]^ U\[ ro;m~kle eU mwm~]^¦dU _ao U _a]aTC]a\lhif~]a\SbChc_^_L¦cU upfw]ae U mu~U Su~UmpU \f~]a\Sb"]a\dfwU uwTU ¥]jhfwUg¦hiuw]© hirS_aU m ]^\ fwPSUkS\lSU uw_^oq]a\Sb±U ¦hc_^klhif~]a`c\ Suw`cbduwhcT PS]jeP ]jmU skS]a¦hi_aU \f;f~` U hc_^_'U¥bcUmPlh®¦q]^\SbU ]^f~PlU u"hi\º]a\dfwU uwTU ¥]jhfwU<¦dU u~f~U·ºhcmmp`dkSueUcà UWV UX UZY `c_au-]^TPlh®]a\l¦qh]^\Sfw]^bC\Sb mpkHePh"¦dU u~f~U ·hdm²fhiuwbcU f Ã`cu-rH`cf~PnÃ¥] « Ud«vhi_a_ILBDC\FH89KfdF c}I MOC\F'F ceeF;<w£ U] UZ^ ¤S_^UQU f~bcUU f'rS]af~l`"hch[upfwmy]©ffwU-hibcbdUduwÃihcS/P PSU f u~U-f~PlUQhie\l bduwf~hcPSSUQP _jhiuwrLU lU _ju~m UmpU 9\d f? m'h[m~kSd h rSbdNuwhcvS¡P
(40) ] i[`cllÃfw4PS4U5´eà \¥`dT<c à > <g % 5x i[SÃ4´Ã T<£5`c\¨fwPSU U¥bcUmge `c\S\SUe§fw]^\Sb f~PSU<T]^\S@ ]aThi_@ ¦cU upfw]ae U m5]^f~PEf~PSU U\[ Thi·¥]^Thi_´`d\SU m ÃShiuwUU·Shcef~_aof~PlU[\l`c\S³ U uw`CU \f~uw]^Um¤`c%fwPSU ªdhce`drS]jhi\ Thif~uw]©· UWV UX UZY `ihcue§fw]^`dn\EOQfwPlPlUChf"U _^-]aTU]^\Hh]^f~_a_²]a`crS\°kl]^`i_jº]a\`cf~\ U u~]^T\ºU `cSkl]au"hif~hiUCSU S¥uw`dbdhdU m[ePnu~«CU S| uwf U m~e U hi\\ºfwmgrLf~UPSu~UCU bdU hi_aU uT¥UU E\dfhchim _ »]abckSuwU"Ve_`T+ 1
(41) bWac- f~PSU f~PSUCePlhi]a\¨u~kl_^U"hcSS_a]^U:f~`;U ¦hi_aklhfw]^`d\uw`ckSf~]a\SU mg]^\¨`du~T `i²e bduwhcSPlm « }¤`c\lm~U skSU \dfw_^oE¤U¥]jmyfw]^\lbckS]jmpPºrLUfy-U U \°fy-`Qh®o¥mgfw`:U _a]^T]a\lhfwU;hi\EU¥bcU ]aj \ NP8hc\l¤U]a_^_nuwUU uQf~`Cf~PlU Thc7m k Á À ¥Â hi\l S @´À ¥Â U¥bcUU _^]aT]^\lhif~]a`c\n« X[uhiSPl]ae hi_a_^odÃf~PSU°`cuwQhiuU _^]aT]^\Hhf~]a`c\N`i hc\ U ¥bdU + D>Cb 0c-C]jm UskS]^¦hc_^U \dff~` e`c\l\SU ef~]a\Sbhc_^_ lu~U¥U e U mwmp`duwmC`i 0]^f~PoJlu~`¦q]j¥U Jf~PSU oPHh®¦cU:\S`if;rLU U \ e`d\S\SU ef~UrLU`du~Uhdm-U¥`>\S`if LU uwT]©f-T kS_^f~]aS_aUgU¥bcUmw£`d_^_a`-U rqo<klLShif~]a\Sb"fwPSUgU ·¥]ampf~]a\Sb"`dubcU \SU uhfw]^\lbf~PSU¢\SU _a`¥e hi_Hlhiu~f~]jhi_ SU uw]^¦hfw]^¦dU m<hi\l´Ã 5H\lhi_a_^odÃ'f~PSU¥U _aUfw]^`d\±`ij+ DRb 0c-~« OQPS]jm ]jm ]a_a_^klmpf~uhfwU >]a\J»]abckSuwUE`du fwPSU U¥bcU +,acbdA-9¤|µ\ e`du~uwU m~H`d\l¥U \leU¨]^f~P fwPSU°ePHhi]a\ u~kS_aU-UT kl_©fw]^S_ao f~PSUE¦®hc_^klU m;`c mpkHe eUm~m~]a¦cU¨U SbcU m + DRb 0c-²hi\l5M+ 0}5b lD-'PlU uwU hcm--U0hcS f~PSU¦hi_akSUm¤`c%lhcuwhc_^_aU _U¥bcUm¤PHh®¦]a\Sb<f~PSU"mwhiTUmp`dkSueUhi\l f~PSU mwhiTU fwhiuwbcU f «ºOQPkHm Ã'fwPSU;`du~Qhiu U _a]^T]a\lhfw]^`d\±`i[hi\±U¥bcU + DRb 0c-[]a\q¦c`d_^¦dU m"hE\klT rLU uC`i¢mwe hc_ahcu m Ð Bnm
(42) o.
(43)
(44) . T<kS_^f~]aS_^]je hif~]a`c\lm[fwPlhf"]jm0UsdkHhi_'f~`fwPSU;e hcuw¥]a\lhc_^]^fyo¨`i-f~PSUlu~U¥U e U mwmp`du[m~Uf"`c-]^fwm0m~`ckSueU~«¹°U ]a_a_e hi_a_lfwPS]jm¤\qkST<rHU u-f~PSU ¿  ½ " ½q½`c7u k Á À ¥Â " ¥ @HÁqÀ : ½ " ½q½C`i E+ DRb 0c-vhi\l¥U \S`cf~U[]©f rqo5 g }* >©« OQPSUbduwhcSPS]je5]a\dfwU uwSuwUfwhif~]a`c\`i+fwPSUrlhce¯qQhiuU _a]^T]a\lhfw]^`d\`c+ 1}bWac-]jm m~PS`\º]^\>»]abckSuwU;V¥«;gm"]^\ºf~PlU;e hcm~U`i¤`cuw-hcuwEU _a]^T]a\lhfw]^`d\º-Ump]aTS_ao U PHh®¦cU¤f~`0]a\lmpU upf²\lU U ¥bdU mve`d\S\SUe§f~]a\Sb
(45) L]©fwPhi_a_lmpkHe eUm~m~`cum`iDv]^f~PSU o U] UZ^ S`\S`if<U·¥]ampf<hc_^uwU hd¥oS£hi\l>bdU \SU uwhif~U\SU `cu"kSShif~U;fwPSU U ·¥]ampf~]a\SbU¥bcU _jhirLU _jmge `cuwu~UmpL`c\H¥]^\lbc_aoc«»]^\lhc_^_aocà + b D>-]jmguwU T`¦dU u~`dT fwPSU<e bduwhcSPn«Q| f U\[ fhi¯dU mw b g mwe hc_ahcu´T kS_^f~]aS_a]ae hf~]a`c\Hmf~`U _^]aT]^\lhif~Uhc\U ¥bdU`E+ DRb 0c-Srlhde¯Qhiu´« UX UY b H¥U \l`if~UmfwPSU<Á n ¿  ½ " ½q½° %l @´À ¥Â " ¥ @HÁqÀ ºÂ ½ " ½q½¥£Q`i U + DRb 0cg -vPS]aeP:]jmQU sklhc_f~`f~PlU0\klT rLU u b q`i'mpkHe eUm~m~`cum-`i%f~PSUfhiuwbcUf` UWV +Uf5fwPSU0_^U \SbifwP:`ivhlhfwP:e `c\S\lU e§fw]^\lbhc\:]^\lSU LU \l¥U \fg¦cU upfwU· ]^f~Ph U] UZ^ SU LU \l¥U \f5`c\SU[rHU"SU 5l\SUhdm-f~PSU\qkST<rHU u`i%U¥bcUmQ]©f5e `c\lm~]ampfwm-`cy«²OQPSU \ `d\SU¢e hi\mpPS` fwPlhfQfwPSU[m~kST¶`cnf~PSU[fw`ifwhc__^U \SbifwPlm-`i%hc_^_¥]jmyfw]^\leflhfwPlm-]^\ fwPSU"e§ bcuhilP ]jm5myfwu~]je§fw_^oT`c\S`cf~`c\l]ae hi_a_^o SU euwU hdmp]a\Sb¥kSuw]^\lb<fwPSU"Suw`¥eUm~m-`i UX UZY U _^]aT]^\Hhf~]a\Sb0U¥bcUm «¹°UgTh®oCe`d\le_akl¥UQfwPlhfU¥bcUU _^]aT]^\Hhf~]a`c\]a_^_Lhi_a-h®o¥m UWV fwU uwT]^\lhif~Ud«'OQPl]amQm~U U Tm¤f~`rLU`crq¦q]^`dklmrlk¥f]©f]jm-e U u~fwhc]^\S_ao;euwkle ]ahc_l`du-`dkSu »]^bdkSu~U0 c_ . hcSSuw`dhdePn« OQPSU¢`cuwQhiu rlhde¯q-hcuwALU _a]^T]a\lhfw]^`d\ `c%hi_a_H`dk¥fp U SbcU m ]^\¥ U SbcU mW`i%h ¦dU u~f~U · %_^UhcSmf~` f~PSU¢U _a]^T]a\lhfw]^`d\;`i%]^fwm~U _^¤¡»]abckSuwU¢ £§«}¤`c\lm~U skSU \f~_aocÃdf~PSU¢U _a]^T]a\lhfw]^`d\;`i+hc\ ]a\f~U u~TU S]ahif~U¦cU upfwU· ´]^\q¦d`c_a¦cU m > ; b9imwe hc_ahcuvT kS_^f~]aS_a]ae hfw]^`d\lmvPS]jeP]am²klmpkHhi_a_^oCu~U U uwu~U"fw` hcm fwPSU " S @LÁqÀ  ½ " ½q½ `iw ËX[uwz5U S; «vq`0¡hcu Ãcf~PSU[hiSS_a]je hfw]^`d\`if~PSU¢ePlhi]a\u~kS_aUfw` e§ bcuhiSPHm PHhcmnrLU U \"]a\dfwU uwSuwUf~U0hcm+¦cU u~f~U ·[U _^]aT]^\Hhf~]a`c\+« v¦dU \0fwPSU²U ±hfpfwU T¥fmnfw`gT]^\l]^T]a³ U²fwPSU-\klT rLU u+`c T<kS_^f~]aS_^]je hif~]a`c\lm\SU U ¥U"fw`0e hi_jekl_ahif~U¤f~PSU5ªdhce`drS]jhi\ hcu~U-rlhcm~U `c\ f~PSUQ]j¥U h[`iHU _a]^T]a\lhfw]^\Sb¦dU u~f~]jeU m ÖmpU U`du'U·ShiTS_aU -]amwc¥`duu ËX[uzU l £«.0g`¤U ¦cU u à f~PSU u~UQhiuwUlu~`drS_^U Tm%PlU uwU²f~PlU-`d¥f~]aThi_q¦cU upfwU· U _^]aT]^\Hhf~]a`c\;m~U skSU \leU5S`Um²\S`cf¤T]a\S]^T]a³ UfwPSUg\qkST<rHU u`cT<kS_^f~]aS_^]je hif~]a`c\lm « nUf-klm²]a_a_^klmpf~uhfwUf~Pl]am ]^f~PºfwPSUPSU _a `ihi\ºU·ShiTS_aU¥]am~S_jh®ocU]a\ »]abckSuwUCl«| f mpPl`5m[h:e bduwhcSPE`cQhSuw`crS_aU T]^f~P fy-`:]^\H¥U LU \lSU \f #à 5l¦cU;¥U HU \l¥U \dfÃ%hc\l°fy¤`]^\fwU uwTCU¥]jhf~U¦hcu~]jhirS_aU m «OQPSU uwUhiuwU<fy-`¨¥]^LU u~U \df ¦dU u~f~U ·¨hc\l\qkSTU u~`dklm¥]©U uwU \fU ¥bdU<U _^]aT]^\Hhf~]a`c\º`cu¥U uwm «"OQPSU<fy¤`¦cU upfwU·¨U _a]^T]a\lhfw]^`d\°`duwSU um uwU m~kS_^fg]a\ +W+P bWB AA- * Ud 6 1* T- 1dhi\lp+9+PB AAb9 - * a 6 1 * 5- 14aT<kS_©fw]^l_^]je hif~]a`c\lm «5q`lÃHklmp]a\Sb hlkSu~U ¦dU u~f~U ·"U _a]^T]a\lhfw]^`d\mpf~uhfwU bdo0`c\Cf~PS]jmv¦dU uwo"mp]aTS_^UU ·ShiTS_aU-bd]^¦dU m'klmfwPSU¢ªdhce `crS]jhi\ `cu²he`myfv`i´hf _aU hdmyfC ;T<kS_^f~]aS_^]je hif~]a`c\lm « `0ômpklSH`mpU<¤U<U _a]^T]a\lhfwU+ DRb 0c--m~U lhcuwhif~U _^orHU `cuwU B A`c_a_^`-U :rqo fwPSUCU _a]^T]a\lhfw]^`d\`iw9´OQPS]am¢-`ckS_j:fwhc¯cU<`c\S_ao 1;T<kS_^f~]aS_^]je hif~]a`c\lm¢PS]jeP]jm¢`drq¦]a`ckHmp_ao_aU mwmgf~Plhc\ 1a * Z +P9bW A -9b4+, A b9- \ ]^\f~PSU"lkSu~U<¦cU upfwU·U _^]aT]^\Hhf~]a`c\¨T`¥¥Ud«5|µ\ hikld'¤U"PHh®¦cU0bc]a¦cU \ hc\U·ShiTS_aU`du²f~Pl]am «v»SkSu~f~PSU u~T`du~UdÃc-U5Plh®¦cU5m~PS`\Cf~PHhffwPSUL½ ½ .¿w½  " ½ ! i ½ &% ¾E¥`qU m \l`if'U·SeU U hg¡hcef~`du`c + 3OR+ 3! 3-W- `cuve§ bcuhilPlm%e `c\fwhc]^\l]^\Sbgfy¤`¢]^\fwU uwTCU¥]jhf~U-¦cU upfw]ae U m «%OQPSU lu~`drS_^U Tu~U Thc]^\HmgkS\Hmp`d_^¦dU :`du¢fwPSUCbcU \lU uhi_%e hcm~U ]a\q¦c`c_a¦q]^\lbe§ bcuhilPlm5]^f~; P W#"[3;]^\fwU uwTCU¥]jhf~U ¦dU u~f~]jeUm «h0g`¤U ¦cU uÃvrSkS]a_j¥]^\lbº`d\J\qkSTU uw`ckHm fwU mpfu~UmpkS_^fwmC-Ue `c\xyUe§fwkSu~Uf~PHhff~PSU:¦dU u~f~U·q U ¥bdU S]amweuwU lhc\leo]a_a_nrHU0_aU mwmQ`cuUsklhi_fw`V `duQf~PSU0bdU \SU uwhc_e hcm~Uc« »l`cu¤hCªchde`drS]ahc\Thif~uw]©· 2¨hcmwmp`¥e ]ahif~U C]^f~P h"bc]a¦cU \¦dU ef~`cukS\lef~]a`c\f)-U¢hiuwUbc`d]^\lb0f~`0fwPS]a\S¯ hcrH`dk¥fghQh®o;f~`;e `cTSk¥fwU"hi_a_+]^fwmU \f~uw]^Um5hfghT]a\S]aThc_+e`myf«¤»l`cu5uwU hdmp`d\lm¥U mweuw]arHU]a\ hikHc -UPlh®¦cU¥Ue]j¥U f~`uwU bhiuf~PlU0\klT rLU u`iT kS_^f~]aS_a]ae hfw]^`d\lmuwU skS]au~Uf~`;e `cTSk¥fwU[f~PSU"e `cTS_aUf~U B(B ÒCEDGFGFGH.
(46) R. 4
(47) $. ªdhce `crS]jhi\ hcm0f~PSU e `dmpf hi\l -U]a_^_-¥U \S`cf~UfwPS]jm"`crSxyU e§fw]^¦dUkS\lef~]a`c\>rqo Z 2 \ %¥HUe] 5He hc_^_aocà -U]^_a_nfhi¯dU¢fwPSU"e§ bcuhilP;NP `i hc\l¤U]a_^_mpUhiueP;`du5hi\:U ¥bdUU _a]^T]a\lhfw]^`d\:m~U skSU \leUfwPlhf T]a\S]aTC]a³ Um Z 2 \ OQPSUmpkHe eUm~m~]a¦cUU _a]^T]a\lhfw]^`d\>`iU SbcU m"u~`dT¸fwPSU e bduwhcSP>¥U 5l\lU m0fwPSU m~`iµe hc_^_aU ½ " &!+ U
(48) * R+ NP7- * R+ Q 5b S fwPSU¦dU u~f~]jeU mr A n `i0PS]jeP uwU lu~UmpU \df hc_^_¢¥]©U uwU \f e bduwhcSPlmCf~PHhf U
(49) e `ckS_j L`dmwmp]arS_ao rLU°SU uw]^¦dU uw`cT NP rqoU¥bcUU _^]aT]^\Hhf~]a`c\+« +hcrHU _^]a\Sb fwPSU;U¥bcUm]^ \ ]©fwP f~PSU;e `dmpf"`ibcU fpfw]^\Sb:uw`cT¸f~PSUbduwhcSP u~U SuwU m~U \f~U U rqo f~PlU ]aum~`ckSueUf~`±fwPSUº`c\SUºhcmwmp`¥e]jhfwU ]^f~P fwPSU ]aufwhiuwbcU f-UU \H kS ]^f~Phm~PS`dupfwU mpf5lhfwP¨Su~`drS_aU T `c\f~PSU TCU fwhcbcuhiSPn«QOQPSU0U¥bcU"_jhirLU _jm5hcu~U e `c\lm~]j¥U uwU fw`°rLUf~PSU¨¥]jmyfhi\le U mChi\lJ¤U]a_^_uwUU u fw`EfwPS]amCSuw`crl_^U T hcm fwPSU " ½ ½ # ½  " ½½ #) 1 S* Á &+ Á # ½ «vOQPSU¥]J3;ekS_^f~]aU mhcu~]jmpUgu~`dT fwPSU¡hceff~PlhifrH`cf~Pf~PSU0\qkST<rHU u5`i¦cU upfw]ae U mhi\H;fwPSU0\qkST rLU u5`c%U¥bcUmQ]^\ »]^bdkSuwU[N_²qkSuwSu~]jm~U fwPSU TU fwhibduwhcSP¨¥U LU \H¨`c\:fwPSU \qkST<rHU ug`i²]a\f~U u~TU S]ahif~U"¦dU u~f~]jeU m5]^\¨fwPSU `du~]abc]a\lhc_Le bduwhcSP;U·¥L`c\SU \f~]jhi_a_^od«OQPSU u~U `cuwUcÃ¥hi\U·¥Plhcklmyfw]^¦dU[m~U hcuwePhcm¤¤U _^_nhdm¤hc\o;hc_^bd`cuw]©fwPST`cu e `cTSk¥fw]^\lb:h:m~PS`cu~f~Umyflhif~Pº]^ \ hcu~UC\S`cfluwhde§f~]je hcrS_aUc«C|µ\°`duw¥U u[f~`¨¥U e u~Uhcm~U fwPSU;e`dTS_^U ·¥]©fyo `c+fwPSU0Suw`crS_aU T¶fw`mp`d_^¦dU¢-UPlh®¦cU¢f~`Thi¯dU[e U u~fwhc]^\u~Umyfwu~]je§fw]^`d\lm ÃdfwPqklmuwU ¥kle ]^\lb<rL`ifwP:m~]a³ U`if~PSU TU fwhibduwhcSP:¥U 5l\lU :rqo;fwPSU"\qkST rLU ug`iv]©fm5mpfwhibdU m5hc\lf~PSU \klT rLU u5`c'¥]^U uwU \fglhif~PlmQfw` ePSUe¯L« OQPl]amhcSSuw`dhceP]^_a_´_aU hcfw`m~kSrSbduwhcSPlm-PS]jePhcu~U[fwPSU \¨m~kSr¥xyU eff~`hi\:hi\Hhi_a`cbc`dklm-mpPS`dupfwU mpflhfwP lu~`drS_^U T:«%¹ ]^f~P;U ¦cU u~o<u~Umyfwu~]je§fw]^`d \ C-Uge hc\hdm~m~`¥e]jhfwU5h"e`du~uwU m~H`d\l¥]a\SbT]^\S]aThi_e`my f Z 2 \ `c¤e`dTSk¥f~]a\Sb f~PSU;ªdhce`drS]jhi\¨rqomp`d_^¦q]a\SbfwPSUmpPS`dupfwU mpf¢lhif~P°Su~`drS_aU T`c\Ef~PSUC]^\H¥kleUEm~kSrSbduwhcSP "! 7`ivfwPSU TU fwhibduwhcSPnÃL]Ö« Uc#« Z 2 \ * > $% Z 2 \ `du¢m~`cTU > "& 1
(50) n{¢rq¦q]^`dklmp_aocÃH¤U -`ckl_a_a]^¯dU0f~PSU"¡hce§fw`cugf~`rLU<hcmgmpThi_a_%hdmL`dmwmp]arS_aU hcmQ`dug_jhiuwbcU¦hi_akSU m > f~PSU ePl`dm~U \:u~Umyfwu~]je§fw]^`d\ -`ckS_j:\S`if[rHU<¦cU u~oklm~UkS_ «{¢\SU<H`m~m~]arS]^_a]^fyo]jm5fwPSU uwU mpf~uw]je§f~]a`c\:fw` U _^]aT]^\lhif~]a\Sb ¦dU u~f~]jeUm]^\Ef~PSU e bduwhcSPPS]aeP¨]a_a_+rLU"U·¥S_a`c]^f~U:]^\:fwPS]amglhiLU u«QOQPS]am¢hiSlu~`hceP _aU hdSmfw`f~PSUCmp`c e hi_a_^UfL½ ½ . ½ " & + (' ! hi\]a\lmpfwhc\leU<`i²PS]jeP]jm¢m~PS`\¨]a\°»]^bdkSuwU 6¥«[»S`cu¢kSu~f~PSU u¢]a\¥`du~Thfw]^`d\ `d\ fwPSU0bcU \SU uhi_U¥bcUU _a]aTC]a\lhif~]a`c\:Suw`crS_aU T uwUU u-f~`1 hikHc « ¹ºU²Plh®¦dUv¥U ¦dU _a`cLU [\SU hi\H0hcShc¥f~U[m~`cTUv-U _a_© ¯q\S`\ hc_^bd`cuw]©fwPSTm¨`duºm~`c_a¦q]^\Sb fwPSU e`cT<rS]a\lhfw`cuw]ahc_ ) *1,.03+ `d¥f~]aT]^³hfw]^`d\lu~`drS_^U T:«-OQPSUmpU0TU f~PS`¥Sm¢e`c\fhi]a\_a`i ) *1,/./+ ) *1,0-+ )*.0-+ ) ,/.103+ bde hi`c_´uw]©PSfwPSU kSTuwm ]ampf~hc]j\le mQ±hchmQ-e `cU _a_a_^_nUe§hcf~mQ]a`c¥\Joq\l`ihc5Tmp]a]aT e[klS_auwhi`cf~bdU uwJhcTChi\ST\S]aU\Shib<_a]^hc\l_©b `d¥f~]aThi_ )*,-+ ) *1./+ )*203+ ) ,/.-+ ) ,0-+ ) .103+ ¦dmweU PSu~f~UU ¥·±kS_aU U _am]^T`d]a\luhf~fwPS]^`dU°\ e`cm~U TsSkSkSU \lfwhefwU]^m `d«J\ OQ`iPlU\SU _jhhcf~u~f~_aoJ U u]^_a_rHU _a`q`c¯dU Ehif"T`cuwUCe _^`mpU _^o]a\°f~PS]jm0lhcHU u «5_a_vfwPSU;hi¥ lu~`hcePSUmgSuw`cL`dm~U ºhiuwUC]^TS_aU TU \fwU hcmlhcupfm[`i-h ) ./+ ) 0-+ ) *+ ) ,-+ xAyAylu~`dbcuhiT¸\HhiTU ? / !9 ? " 2 ÃnPl]aePJhc_^_¤`ckSu fwU mpf5u~Umpkl_©fmQ]^_a_nrLU0rlhcm~U `c\n« }¤`d\lm~]a¥U u~]a\Sb;_a`¥e hc_%PSU kSuw]ampf~]je mg`cu¢U ¥bdU `cu[¦cU upfwU· »]^bdkSu~U 6O_¬vU upfwU5 · 4:Ufhibcuhil6 P (' U _^]aT]^\Hhf~]a`c\]^\ e§ bcuhilPlm"fwPSU uwU:hiuwUcò`dr¦q]a`cklm~_aocÃ'fy-` m Ð Bnm
(51) o.
(52)
(53) . . fwu~]a¦q]ahc_Le hcm~U m_ +Uf [SU \S`cf~U5fwPSUmp]^f~klhif~]a`c\;PlU uwU¢h"¦dU u~f~U ·%]jmU _^]aT]^\lhif~U;rLU`cuwU
(54) ¥OQPSU U _^]aT]^\Hhf~]a`c\`cu¥U u-oq]aU _j¥]a\Sb r A75 n D!0 ]a_a_¥rHU-u~U U uwu~U0fw`[hdm+fwPS U k Á À ¥Â H½ ® ½ .E½ #) 1 S* Á Á  ½ , «i5\lhc_^`dbc`ckHm Ã-U-SU 5l\SU fwPSU S @´À ¥Â L½ ® ½ . ½ # 1 ¥* Á Á  ½ , « -`ifwP , hi\l1 , hiuwU e`d\lm~]a¥U u~U fw`°rLU:U skS]a¦hi_aU \f<fw`ºf~PSU¨e`du~uwU m~L`c\l¥]a\SbU¥bcUU _a]aTC ]a\lhif~]a`c\ TC`¥¥ Um « q]^\HeU: `ckSu`dr¥xyU ef~]a¦cU]am<f~` T]a\S]aTC]a³ Uf~PlU:e `dmpf<`c¢e`dTClk¥f~]a\Sb°f~PSU¨e`dTS_^U f~U¨ªchde`drS]ahc\>]©f;e U u~fwhi]a\S_ao Thc¯cUm<m~U \lm~Uf~`fwPS]a\S¯ hcrH`dk¥f;PS`ePSU hcS_aoJh lhiu~f~]jekl_ahcu]^\f~U u~TU¥]ahif~U¨¦dU u~f~U· "e hc\ L`dmwm~]^rS_aoJrLUU _^]aT]^\lhif~U´«NOQPSU _a`cbd]ae hi_-u~Umpkl_©f-`ckS_j±rLUf~` `cu¥U uhi_a_]a\dfwU uwTU ¥]jhfwU¦dU u~f~]jeU mC]a\leuwU hdmp]a\Sbd_^o rqo f~PSU ]^u 4hiuw¯c`¦q]©fw³ SU bcuwU Um¢hif[UhcePºmyfhibcUC`if~PSUTUfhibcuhilPn«"-f"h lhcupfw]ae kS_jhiu0myfhibdU r A n ('¤UCU _a]aTC]a\lhif~UCf~PSU ¦dU u~f~U ·]^f~P:f~PlU _a`¤Umyf 4¨hcu~¯d`¦q]©fw³SU bcuwU U"hcT`c\Sb;hc_^_n]a\f~U u~TU S]ahif~U"¦dU u~f~]jeU m «QOQPS]am¢hiSlu~`hceP]am ¯q\S`\:hcm-fwPS U ÁqÀ ½ ¿ " ¥ @HÁA ¿ ½ " ½q½d ¿ ® , " mpf~uhfwU bcoD_ r A 5 n ' ' A b A
(55) A } b AA 0gU uwU5 A bD> A Q¥U \S`cf~Um0f~PlU \qkST rLU u<`i5SuwU SU eUm~m~`cum mpkle eUm~m~`cum²`c5h¨¦cU upfwU·pjn NPhf hºeU upfhi]a\ mpfwhcbcUr A n (' ]a\JfwPSU±¦dU u~f~U·l£ TUfwhcbcuhiSP+«gmh°-U _a_© ¯q\S`\JPSU kSuw]ampf~]je;`duf~PSU T]a\S]aTC]a³ hif~]a`c\C`iHf~PSUbdU \SU uwhif~U 5l_a_© ]^\¥kSuw]a\Sb[f~PSUm~`c_ak¥f~]a`c\C`implhcuwm~UQmpo¥mpf~U Tm`iL_^]a\SUhiuvU sklhif~]a`c\lm fwPSU 4¨hcu~¯d`¦q]©fw³rHhcm~U 0hilSu~`hceP¢f~`fwPSU²¦dU u~f~U·[U _a]^T]a\lhfw]^`d\0Suw`crS_aU T)]^\"e bduwhcSPlmPlhdm+hc_^uwU hd¥ogrLU U \ U ·ShiT]^\lU :]a\EmpU ¦cU uwhc_nlhiLU um5_a]a¯cU0`dug]a\lmyfhi\le U"]a\h X[uzUSH «05`-U ¦dU uÃS\qkSTU uw`cklm5f~Umyfmgm~PS`¤U fwPlhfÃS]a\bdU \SU uwhc_Öà , " ¥`qUmQ\S`ifg¥U _^]a¦cU uQ`c¥fw]^Thi_+U _a]^T]a\lhfw]^`d\m~U skSU \leUm « +Uf klme`d\lmp]j¥U u;hi\ ]aTClu~`¦dU ¦cU um~]^`d\`c[fwPSU , " PlU kSuw]ampf~]jei«)¹ºUE¥U 5H\SU¨f~PlU &+ ¿  ½ & ½  ½ ¾  ½ " ½q½`c5h:¦cU u~f~U · n Y X¶hcm * l°]©QfwPSU uwU hiuwUlhfwPlm"e `c\S\SUe§fw]^\Sbh Thi·q]aT klT¶`i l;TC]a\S]aThi_´¦cU upfw]ae U m¤]©fwP «²g\lhi_a`cbd`cklm²f~PSU0Á n &+ ¿  ½ & ½  ½ ¾  ½ " ½q½`i%h ¦dU u~f~U · n V jX ]j m . * l¨]^h Th·¥]aT kST¸`i) lETh·¥]^Thc_¦dU u~f~]jeUm[hcu~U<u~UhcePlhcrS_aU"uw`cT « »l`cuh<¦cU u~f~U · j n XN-U[¥U 5l\SU]^fwm  ½ & ½  ½ ¾  ½ " ½q½;hdm U ? SOQPSU0¥U HU \l¥U \Heo SU bcuwU U`cQh:¦dU u~f~U·°]am0]a\q¦hiuw]ahc\df0]^f~P>uwU m~HUe§f0fw`:f~PSUSklu~U¦dU u~f~U·°U _a]^T]a\lhfw]^`d\ mpf~uhfwU bdoPS]jeP Thc¯cU m²]©f-]a¥Uhi_¥`du²fwPSUg]aTS_^U TU \fwhif~]a`c\`i´\SU PSU kSuw]jmyfw]ae m «'|µ\lhcupfw]ae kS_ahcu Ãd¤UPHh®¦cU]aTCl_^U TCU \f~U fwPSU ¿ ½ #¡¥* L½d¿ " ¥ @LÁqÀ ¿ ½ " ½½d¿ + ½ +7¡ , ® r A n5 ' ' A b A A A b A kSTU uw`cklm<fwU mpfm~PS`-U fwPlhffwPS]amCPSU kSuw]ampf~]je]amm~kSHU u~]a`cuCfw` , " ]a\ TC`myfe hdmpUm «J¹°U:]a_^_ ]a_a_^klmpf~uhfwUgfwPS]jmklm~]^\Sbhc\U ·¥hcTS_^U[bc]a¦cU \ rqofwPSU"e§ bcuhiSP¥]am~S_jh®oc U;]a\:»]abckSuwUS«¤{¢rq¦q]^`dklmp_aocÃ]^f5]am Uhcm~of~`mp`d_^¦dU¢fwPSU"uwU m~kS_^f~]a\Sb¦cU u~f~U ·U _^]aT]^\lhif~]a`c\:Suw`crS_aU T ]^\:fwPSuwU U0]a\dfwU uwTU ¥]jhfwU0¦®hcu~]jhirl_^Um «²| f¢]am U ¦cU \<L`dmwmp]arS_aU-f~`"ePSUe¯ hi_a_S¥]^LU u~U \df²`duwSU um « `ifw]ae UQf~Plhif , "#¥`qU mv\l`if²¥U _a]a¦cU u'fwPSUT]^\l]^T<kST ]a\°f~PS]jm¦cU u~o¨m~]^TS_aUe hcm~Uc« | frLU PHh®¦cU m¢_a]^¯dU , 8u~UmpkS_^f~]a\Sb ]^\>VcV T kl_©fw]^S_a]je hfw]^`d\lm «C}¤`c\lm~]j¥U uw]^\lb , -UPlh®¦c U * O b * ! * "hi\l mp]a\le U " a # <f~PlU[¦dU u~f~U · $ ]amQU _^]aT]^\lhif~U 5Huwmpf «--f5f~PSU \SU·qfgmp fwhibdU0¤U0bdU% f "&(' hi\lfwPSU uwU`du~U , ¤`dkS_a:hde§f5fwPSU"m~hcTU0-h®o hd m , ¥U _a]a¦cU uw]a\Sb fwPSU0T]^\l]^Thi_+`cLU uhf~]a`c\Hm-e `ckS\fPS]jeP:]amR `duQf~PS]jmU ·¥hcTS_^Ud« ¤ÁqÀ ½. . B(B ÒCEDGFGFGH.
(56) . 4
(57) $. ¤} `d\lmp]j¥U u~]a\Sb mpf~uhfwU bc]aU m`cugU¥bcU U _a]^T]a\lhfw]^`d\¤U. \ U [ W U P V ] Z U ^ W U V U ] W U P V ^ PHh®¦cUcÃ-hiT`c\lbº`cf~PSU uwm Ã-Su~`dH`mpU>fwPSUEe_jhcmwm`i 5l_a_© ]^\ rHhcm~U PlU kSuw]ampf~]je m «<OQPlU5H_^_^ ]a\ºbcU \lU uhf~Urqo¨fwPSUU _a]© [\Y ],Y T]a\lhfw]^`d\ `i-hc\ ]^\f~U u~TU¥]ahif~UU SbcU1E+ DCb 0O-5]jm0¥U 5l\SU hdm¤f~PSU\qkST rLU uQ`c%U SbcU m-]a\ fwPSU0e§ bcuhiSPh f~U uT]^\qklm . fwPSU;\qkST<rHU u `iU¥bcUm"rLU`cuwUfwPSU;U _a]aTC]a\lhif~]a`c\n« v¦ , ] X ^vX [\X U u~o[U SbcU_jhirLU _aU ]©fwP<hc\"U _aU TU \fhiuwo¢lhcupfw]ahc_SU uw]^¦h fw]^¦dU]am¤hH`cf~U \dfw]ahc_S¡hde§f~`du²]a\f~PSU5U _^]aT]^\Hhf~]a`c\lu~`¥eUm~m ^,Y Pl]aePu~U SuwU m~U \fwmf~PSU"e `cTSk¥fhfw]^`d\lhi_Suw`¥eU mwm¤`ihde§ e kST kl_ahif~]a\SbCf~PSU e `cTS_aUfwU0ªdhce `crS]jhi\+«² _^`dbc]je hi_´e `c\¥ UX U\[ UZY U] m~U skSU \leUg`i´f~PlU m~Ug`crHmpU u~¦hfw]^`d\lmv]jmvfw` ¯cU U fwPSUg\qkSTC rLU u<`iQf~PlU m~U;¡hcef~`duwm"hdm0_a` hdm"L`dmwmp]arS_aUPS]jeP±]^TC. v X V l_^]aU m¤f~PlU¢T]a\S]^T]a³ hif~]a`c\ `cnf~PlU[_a`¥e hc_^_aoSu~`¥¥kHeU 5l_a_©. Z Y V ]a\n«"OQPS]jm[]aSU h]am¢U·¥S_a`c]^f~U]a\f~PlU ¤ÁqÀ ½ ¿ # # ¿ ¿ UX ® U¥bcU¨U _^]aT]^\Hhf~]a`c\ PlU kSuw]ampf~]je± / 5£«u0gU uwUcà W U V Y -U5hi_aQh®oqm'U _^]aT]^\Hhf~U5f~PSU5U¥bcUlu~`¥¥kle ]^\lbf~PSU5_a`-U mpf . X Y V V 5H_^_^ ]a\\SU·qf « . V X ±S]©U uwU \f+hilSu~`hceP¢f~`5m~`c_a¦q]^\Sb-fwPSU²bcU \SU uhi_U¥bcU U X U V U U _^]aT]^\Hhf~]a`c\<Suw`crS_aU Tm%]am'rSkl]^_^fv`c\"fwPSU-u~U Su~UmpU \fwhfw]^`d\ U Y `c²f~PlUªdhce `crS]jhi\hdm¢ePlhc]^\lU ¨Thfwu~]^·¨Suw`qSkle§fm «"OQPSU »%]abcklu~U0O_ NP hc_^bd`cuw]©fwPST PS]aeP ]a_a_[rLU°SU \S`cf~U ro 2 ]am¥Umy e u~]arLU ]^\p hikHc « ²SbcUU _a]^T]a\lhfw]^`d\]a\¨e§ bcuhiSPHmThi¯dU m¤kS_a_nklm~U`i+fwPSU0myfwu~kHe§f~kluwhc_nmplhcuwm~]^fyoC`c+fwPSU0bc]a¦cU \ Suw`cr¥ _aU T:«º| fC]jmC`i fwU \±L`dmwmp]arS_aU;fw`°uwU ¥kHeU;fwPSU \qkST<rHU u<`cgT kl_©fw]^S_a]je hfw]^`d\lm<u~Usdkl]^uwU ºfw`ºhde eklT kS_jhfwU fwPSU"e`dTS_^U f~U ªdhce `crS]jhi\rohC¡hce§fw`cuQ`if~Plu~U U"hi\lT`cuwUe `cTlhcu~U;fw`<fwPSU0TUfwPS`¥:Su~`dH`mpU;rqo U 5mwhiThi\Hz5hiTmw¥U _a_u U z5h}Rc «0OQPSU<mwh®¦q]^\Sbmge `cTlhiuwU fw` fwPSU¥U \lm~U"`du~Qhiu¨hi\H¨u~U ¦cU uwm~U T`¥¥Um-hcu~U[U ¦dU \TC`du~Um~]^bd\S] 5Le hi\f«¹ PlU \Su~UmpU \f~]a\Sb fwU mpfu~UmpkS_^fwm-]a\qU ef~]a`c\ 6<-U¢]a_a_ne`c\Hmp]j¥U u fwPSUQhcePS]aU ¦dU 0¦hi_akSUm%uwU _jhfw]^¦dU²fw`¢_a`¤U u%rL`ckl\lSm%`cu'¦hi_akSU m`cSf~PSU-rLU mpfvePl`c]jeU`dk¥fv`iHSU \lm~U`du~Qhiu hc\lu~U ¦cU um~U¢T`¥¥U m0 " £§ÃS] « Ud« % Z 2 \ * Z +P. 6jW-9bW + 6GW- \ b hc\lCf~PlU¢e`du~uwU m~L`c\l¥]a\Sb0T]a\S]^T<kST `cLU uhfw]^`d\lme `ckS\f¤hdePS]^U ¦cUroh0kS\l]©µ¥]au~Ue§f~]a`c\Hhi_HhcSSuw`dhdePC`c fwPSU0TUfwPS`¥rqo U 5mwhiT hc\l:z5hiTmw¥U _a_² £¤PS]aeP:]jm Z 2 \ * Z +P 6GW->b + 6jW- \ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
(58). . . m Ð Bnm
(59) o.
(60)
(61) . d.
(62) ¥]^T<kS_ahif~U>hi\S\SUhi_a]^\lb]am<hbd_^`drlhi_²`d¥f~]aT]^³hfw]^`d\>TCU f~PS`¥ fwPlhf¥]jmyfw]^\SbdkS]jmpPSUm"rLUfy-U U \J¥]^LU u~U \df _a`¥e hc_²`c¥fw]^Thl«¨qfwhiu~f~]a\Sb:uw`cT hi\ ]a\S]©fw]ahc_L`c]a\f Ãf~PSUhi_abc`cuw]^f~PST¸fwhi¯dU m"h¨mpf~U ±hi\lºfwPSUkS\He§f~]a`c\ ]jmU ¦hc_^klhif~U´«¹ PSU \ T]^\l]^T]a³ ]a\SbhkS\le§fw]^`d\nÃ%hc\qoE¥`\SPS]a_a_²myfwU ]am0hde e U ¥fwU ºhi\lEf~PSUlu~`¥eUm~m uwU LU hifwm u~`dT f~PS]jmC\SU L`c]a\f «>5\kSSPS]a_a_5myfwU ±Th®o rHU:hce eU ¥f~U´«>OQPkHm ÃvfwPSU:hi_abc`cuw]^f~PST e hc\ Um~e hiLUu~`dT _a`¥e hi_+`c¥fw]^ThS«QOQPS]jm5kSlPS]^_a_%SU e]jm~]^`d\]jm5Thd¥U0rqo fwPSU 4:U f~uw`cL`c_a]am5e u~]^f~U u~]a`c\+«¤gm5f~PSU `d¥f~]aT]^³hfw]^`d\Su~`¥e U mwmvSuw`qe U USm Ãif~PSU¢_^U \SbifwP`if~PSU[myfwU lm¤¥U e _^]a\SUghc\lCf~PlU¢hi_abc`du~]^f~PlT e_a`dm~U m²]^\`d\ fwPSUQbc_a`crlhc_d`d¥f~]aT klT«vq]a\leU-fwPSUhi_abc`cuw]^f~PST3Thi¯dU m%¦cU u~oU hcmwm~kST¥f~]a`c\lmuwU bhiu¥]^\lbf~PSU-kS\He§f~]a`c\ fw`rLU`cSf~]aTC]a³ U´Ãn]^f0]am0skS]^f~Uuw`crSklmpf]©fwP°uwU m~HUe§ff~`¨e `cT rl]^\lhif~`du~]jhi_Suw`crS_aU Tm « OQPSU¥U bdu~U U<`c uw`crlklmyfw\SU mwmQe hc\rLU"hc®xykHmyfwU rqof~PSU0kHmpU u « |µ\:bcU \SU uhi_ Ã¥e`dT rS]a\lhfw`cuw]ahc_H`d¥f~]aT]^³hfw]^`d\Suw`crl_^U TmQhcu~UePlhiuhcef~U u~]a³ Urqo hi\`cr¥xyUe§fw]^¦dU¢kl\le§ fw]^`d\fw`rLUTC]a\S]aT]^³ U f~PlUC`¦dU uhi_a_ 4hiuw¯c`¦q]©fw³ ¥U bcuwU U ]a\º`ckSue hdmpU®£ghc\lEh¥]jm~e u~U f~Ucô¦dU uwo:_ahcu~bdU e `c4\ 5HbckSuhfw]^`d\<m~lhce Uf~PS:U Wc¥]^U uwU \f²`cu¥U um]^\PS]jeP¤U5e hi\CU _a]^T]a\lhfwUf~PlU W]^\f~U u~TU¥]ahif~UQ¦cU up fw]ae U mQ]a\ fwPSU"e§ bcuhilPH£§«'»SkSu~f~PlU uwTC`du~UdÃf~PSU"e `c\le U ¥f`i: c
(63) IL8HF6CPIQ:Bf~U _^_a]a\SbklmhirL`ck¥7f eO:ILHB ece: B OILGJG `duQ\S`ifg¥`qUmQ\S`if5U ·q]jmpfQ]a\:`ckSu5e `c\f~U ·qf « OQPSU u~`q`ifm`if~PlU<m~]^T<kS_ahif~Uhc\S\SUhi_a]^\Sb;hc_^bd`cuw]©fwPST _a]^U ]^\¨TUfhi_a_^klu~bdoc«¤¢kSuw]^\lbf~PSU<hi\S\SUhi_a]^\lb lu~`¥eUm~m5`ivTUfwhc_+]^fwm¢hf~`dTmQ`cuwT e u~o¥mpfwhc_am «-g\`cSf~]aThc_%e u~o¥mpfwhi_+]amg`c\SU0]^f~PEh e`c\ 5lbckSuhfw]^`d\`c _a`-U mpfQU \SU uwbc o S«| v-U0u~kS\fwPSU e`q`d_^]a\SbSuw`qe U mwm-f~`q`¡hcmpff~PlU \:f~PlU euwo¥myfhi_jmQ]^_a_n\S`cfgu~UhcePf~PSU `d¥f~]aThi_le `c4\ 5HbckSuhfw]^`d\n«'{¢\fwPSU5`ifwPSU uPlhi\lnÃd-U5¥`0\S`cf-hc\fvf~PSUghc\S\SUhi_a]^\Sb0lu~`¥eUm~mvf~`fwhc¯cUQfw`` _a`c\lbl«OQPSU bc`dhc_´]amf~` 5l\l¨hkHmpU kS_%e `cTSuw`cT]am~UrHU fy¤U U \f~PlU"u~`drSklmpf~\SUm~mQ`c%fwPSU hc_^bd`cuw]©fwPST hi\H ]^fwmgmpLU U´«²OQPS]jmQ]am¥`d\SU0rqo;¦hiuwoq]^\SbeU upfhi]a\HhiuhiTUfwU um¤]^f~Pl]^\f~PlU"hi_abc`cuw]^f~PST:« +Uf¢kHmghcmwm~kSTUf~Plhifg¤U<hiuwU0_^`q`c¯q]a\Sb`cugf~PSU<e`c\ 5lbckSuhfw]^`d\:PS]aeP¨T]a\S]aTC]a³ Umgh;e U u~fwhc]^\¨e`myf kl\le§fw]^`d\n«vOQPSUhi_abc`cuw]^f~PST8e hi\<f~PSU \rHUQ`du~T<kS_ahif~U<hdm`c_a_^`5m_%fhiu~f~]a\Sb0`i hifhi\C]^\S]^f~]jhi_He`c\ 5lbck¥ uhfw]^`d\nÃdh<mpUskSU \le U5`in]^f~U uwhif~]a`c\lm]am¤bcU \SU uhfwU ´« ²hceP ]©fwU uhf~]a`c\;e `c\lm~]jmyfm²`i´fwPSU[uwhc\l¥`cTmpU _^Ue§fw]^`d\ `cnh"e`d4\ 5lbckluwhif~]a`c\Cu~`dT8fwPSUg\lU ]abcPqrH`du~Pl``¥C`i´fwPSU¢e kSuwu~U \dfe `c4\ 5HbckSuhfw]^`d\hc\lfwPSUge hc_ae kS_jhf~]a`c\`c fwPSUe`cuwuwU m~H`d\l¥]a\Sb ePlhc\SbcU<]^\Ef~PSUe`myf¢kS\le§fw]^`d\n« OQPSU<\SU ]abcPqrL`cuwPS`q`¥¨]am¥U 5l\SUrqo:f~PSUePS`d]ae U `c²hbcU \lU uhf~]a`c\TU ePlhc\S]jmpT:Ãl] « Uc«Q h §SuwU mweuw]a¥f~]a`c \ gfw`bcU \lU uhf~U"hCfwuwhc\lm~]©fw]^`d\uw`cT `c\lU"e`c\ 5lbck¥ uhfw]^`d\¨]^\fw`hc\S`ifwPSU u¢ro¨hmpThi_a_HU upfwkSu~rHhf~]a`c\+«¢| ²fwPSUePlhi\SbdU"]a\f~PlUCe `dmpfgkS\lef~]a`c\°]am¢\SU bhfw]^¦dU fwPSUfwuwhc\lmp]^f~]a`c\>]jm"kl\le`d\l¥]^f~]a`c\lhc_^_aoºhde e U ¥fwU ´«:| f~PlUe`myf0kl\le§fw]^`d\±]^\HeuwU hcm~U m0f~PSU f~uhi\lm~]©fw]^`d\ ]am hde e U ¥fwU ]©fwP:hCSuw`crHhirS]a_^]^fyo;rlhdmpU klH`d\fwPSUq-`c_^f~³ Thc\S\¨¥]ampf~uw]arSk¥f~]a`c\ R+ S-
(64) PlU uwU lE]amh e `c\lmpfwhc\fhc\l¨fwPSU fwU TLU uhf~klu~U ]jm[he`d\f~uw`c_lhiuhiTUfwU u«0OQPS]am¢fwU THU uwhif~kSuwUC]am bduwhd¥klhc_^_aog_a`¤U u~U5fwPSuw`ckSbdPS`ck¥f+f~PSU-hi_abc`cuw]^f~PST.u~`dT)h5m~ke3;e]aU \fw_^oPS]abcP"mpfwhcupfw]^\Sbg¦®hc_^klUg] « Ud«hf~U TC LU uhfwkSuwU<PSU u~UChi_aT`dmpf[U ¦cU uwo¨Suw`cL`dm~U :fwuwhc\lm~]©fw]^`d\nôrH`cf~PºH`mp]^f~]a¦cUhi\H\SU bdhfw]^¦dUcô]jmhce e U ¥fwU l£ fw` h uwU U ³ ]a\Sb [fwU TLU uhf~klu~U<PSU uwU<\l`;kSu~f~PSU u0ePlhi\SbdU mg`qe ekSu«|µ\ESuhcef~]jeUdÃHfwPSU<f~U TLU uhfwkSu~U ]jm;¥UeuwU hdmpUJ]a\ myfhibcUmhi\l hif;U hceP mpfwhcbcUf~PSU:fwU TLU uhf~klu~U¨]jm¯cU ¥f e`d\lmpfwhi\f;kS\fw]^_fwPSU uwThi_ sklhdmp]^ U skS]a_^]arSuw]^kST ]amuwU hdePSU n«OQPSU0PS`d_^U0`c'HhiuhiTUfwU um-SUf~U u~T]a\S]a\Sbf~PSU"f~U TLU uhfwkSu~U"SU euwU TU \df]a\S]^f~]jhi_Hf~U TLU uhfwkSu~UdÃmpf~`d;euw]©fwU uw]^`d\nÃdf~U TLU uhfwkSu~U¢¥U e u~U TCU \frHU fy¤U U \ m~kle eU mwm~]^¦dU5myfhibcUm à \qkST<rHU u`if~uhi\lm~]^f~]a`c\lm¤`cuUhcePf~U TCLU uhfwkSuwU[¦hc_^kSU®£-]ame hi_a_^U;fwPSU"e`q`d_^]a\Sbm~ePlU ¥kS_aUc«. B(B ÒCEDGFGFGH.
(65) ®V. 4
(66) $. }¤`d\lm~U skSU \fw_^ofwPSU`ckSu¯dU o;]a\Sbdu~U¥]^U \fwm-`cuQfwPSU0]aTCl_^U TCU \fwhfw]^`d\`c'm~]aT kS_jhfwU hi\S\SUhi_a]^\lbhcu~U}_ c«-f~PSU"SU 5l\S]^f~]a`c\:`c'e `c4\ 5lbdkSuhf~]a`c\Hm`c%fwPSU"mpo¥mpf~U T V¥«hbdU \SU uwhif~]a`c\>TU ePlhc\S]jmpT:Ã']Ö« Uc«°f~PlU¥U 5l\S]^f~]a`c\±`cgh\SU ]^bdPqrH`du~PS`q`¥ `c\±f~PSU:e`d4\ 5lbckluwhif~]a`c\ mpHhceUShCbcU \lU uhf~`duQ`i%uhi\H¥`cT ePHhi\SbdU m-]^\fwPSU"e`d4\ 5lbckluwhif~]a`c\ S«-f~PSU<ePS`c]jeU`i²he `dmpf-kl\le§fw]^`d\±¡hi\Hhi_a`cb`i'U \SU u~bdoS£¤f~PSU"T]a\S]aTC]a³ hif~]a`c\:`i'PS]jeP:]am5f~PSU0bd`dhi_ `if~PSU0lu~`¥eU¥kSuwU l«h5e`d\f~uw`c_ilhcuwhcTUf~U u >hi\l0hge`q`c_a]^\lb5m~ePSU¥kS_aUvf~U _^_a]a\Sb5klm%h f~U u+PS` Thi\qo¢uwhc\l¥`cT)ePlhi\lbcU m ]^\ e`d4\ 5lbdkSuwhif~]a`c\UhcePº¥`\q-hcuw¨mpf~U °]a\ 8]am[fhi¯cU \n« OQPSUhdm~m~]^bd\STU \f¢`cfwPS]ammwePSU SkS_^U u~UskS]^uwU mQ¥U U LU u5]a\lm~]^bdPfQ]a\f~`Cf~PlU0Su~`drS_aU T hc\lf~uw]ahc_©µhi\l¥ U u~uw`cu¤U·¥HU u~]aU \HeUc«.
(67) !" $#
(68) %&' |µ\o t²OQ¬[»V-¤UPlh®¦dUC`ckS\l>hEe`c\HeuwUf~U]a_a_^klmpf~uhfw]^`d\ `iQPS`8fw`EhilSu~`hceP e`dT rS]a\lhfw`cuw]ahc_v`c¥ fw]^T]a³ hif~]a`c\Jlu~`drS_^U Tm rqo±m~]^T<kS_ahif~U±hi\S\lU hi_a]a\Sbl«>OQPSU CP8HM (FHGJILHB e <M=GQFH<9K M=B*)D8;: +GFHK/¡O5¥t£<rLU _a`c\lbdmgf~`;fwPSUe_jhcmwm5`c t'µe`dTS_^U f~UCSuw`crS_aU Tm¢PS`dm~UCe `cTSk¥fhfw]^`d\¨f~]aTU `duhc\U·Shde§f0mp`d_^k¥fw]^`d\ bdu~`5m¤U·¥L`c\SU \f~]jhi_a_^o;]^f~P:]^fwm5m~]a³ Uc«²»l`cu5hc\U ·qPHhiklmpf~]a¦cU0¥]jm~e klmwmp]a`c\`i t'µe`dTCl_^U f~U \lU mwmQu~U U uQf~` ËXhdªc` i « OQPSUO5¥tNTh®o¨rHUuwU bhiu¥U hdm¢f~PSU §T`cf~PSU u "`i-hc_^_fwuwhc\lmpL`cu~f`c¥fw]^T]a³ hfw]^`d\ESuw`crl_^U Tm «< mwhi_aU m~LU ump`d\¦q]jmp]^fwm e ]©fw]^Um;]^f~P bd]^¦dU \ e`q`cu¥]a\lhfwU m1+,N9bW
(69) -~Ã5uwUfwkSuw\S]^\l1 b 5l\lhi_a_ao±f~`JPS]ame]^fyo`c `du~]abc]a\n« ²hceP;e ]©fyoC]am²f~`"rLU5¦q]jmp]^f~U`c\S_ao<`d\leUPl]^_aUgThi¯q]a\Sbf~PlU5u~`dk¥f~U¢hcm²m~PS`cu~fhcmH`m~m~]arS_^Ud«OQPl]am _aU hdSm-f~`CfwPSU0`cr¥xyUe§fw]^¦dU¢kl\le§fw]^`d\ S * , / +P N a - 6+P
(70) 5
(71) a +W+P a bW a - ? +P b9 -9ÖVc£ .- Pl]aeP ]jmfwhc¯cU \xyklmpf<hdm[f~PSUfw`ifhi_²_aU \Sbcf~P `i-f~PlU0xy`ckSuw\SU oc« OQPSUhirL`¦cU]am"U skS]a¦®hc_^U \f0f~` 5l\lS]^\Sb h10M=KILG,CZ:B 6WE69GQF[`i²T]a\S]^Thc_%_aU \Sbcf~P]a\¨fwPSU<e `cTS_aUf~U<bcuhiSj P f ]^f~PEU ¥bdU m5uwU lu~UmpU \dfw]^\lbf~PSU S]ampfwhc\leUm¤rLUfy-U U \;fwPSU0e]^f~]aU m «²OQPSU¢¦dU u~f~U ·;U _a]^T]a\lhfw]^`d\ Suw`crS_aU T¶ ]a\:h<e bduwhcSP;]jm¤¦dU uwomp]aT]^_jhiu-f~` fwPSU2 34«´OQPkHm ÃThi\qo:hi_abc`cuw]^f~PSTmfwPlhf[¤`du~¯-U _a_+`du5f~PlU<_jhf~f~U u[e hc\`i fwU \EUhcm~]^_aorHUChcShc¥f~U fw`mpU u~¦dU¢`dkSuSkSuwH`mpUm « 5 !!: ¤' $ Y$ '& *n%-, . / 0 $ 213*$"4 5. ¢ mhSuw`crS_aU T ]a\:mp]aT kS_jhfwU :hi\l\SU hc_^]a\Sb<f~PSU0¦dU u~f~U·U _a]^T]a\lhfw]^`d\Suw`crl_^U T ]am5Plhi\lS_^Uhdm-`c_a_^`5m_ 86 79 : %8;<=
(72) > %? OQPlU5¦cU upfw]ae U m²hcu~U5\qkST<rHU u~U D * 1
(73) b44bRW;hi\lUhceP`cLfwPSU T Plhdmh%4hiuw¯c`¦q]©fw³¥U bdu~U U > A 4 bD A SU LU \l¥]a\Sb`c\<f~PlUQmpfwhcbcUur A ]a\ fwPSUTUfhibcuhilPn«+ e`d\45lbdkSuwhif~]a`c\"]jmvh¢HU u~T<k¥fwhif~]a`c\C`ilfwPSUQ]^\H¥]ae U m 1}b44b W ]^\fwU uwSu~U f~U hcmf~PlU¢`duw¥U u¤]a\ Pl]aeP f~PSU[]^\fwU uwTCU¥]jhf~U[¦cU upfw]ae U m¤hiuwUgU _a]aTC]a\lhif~U n«²OQPSU¢¯dU o m Ð Bnm
(74) o.
(75) .
(76) . S]©U uwU \le U<rLUfy-U U \°`dkSuSuw`crS_aU T hc\l¨fwPSUCf~uh®¦cU _a]a\Sbmwhi_aU m~Thi\Elu~`drS_^U T]am¢fwPlhff~PlU"4hiuw¯c`¦q]©fw³ SU bcuwU U]jm"\l`if<hmpfwhif~]je¦hi_akSUc«¨| f uhfwPSU u<¥U LU \llm `d\ f~PSU;¦dU u~f~]jeUmf~Plhif Plh®¦dUrHU U \±U _^]aT]^\lhif~U m~`C¡hiu«05`-U ¦dU uÃq]^\f~PlU"O5¥t U ¦dU uwo e]^fyo PlhdmQ]©fm5mpfwhfw]ae0e `q`cu¥]^\Hhf~UmQThi¯q]^\lb<fwPS]jmSuw`crS_aU T U ¦cU \ U hdmp]aU u f~` m~`c_a¦cUd«-ÖOQPS]am]am¤\S`cf²f~`"rLU5fhi¯dU \_a]©fwU uhi_a_^ohcm'fwPSU¢O5St>]amSuw`¦cU \Cfw`"rHU t' Plhcuw 4-£.
(77)
(78) " ? 86 7 ¹ºUklm~U;h¨mp_a]abcPf~_ao°hc_©fwU uwU °¦cU um~]^`d\°`c¤fwPSU;T`¦cUm0mpkSbdbcUmyfwU °ro n ]a\ n]a\l 6= £«OQPSU u~U;hcu~UCfy-` fyoqLU mQ`cT`¦cUm4_ . . c«Q| +ED b44bD ^ -%]jm²fwPSU[e kSuwu~U \df¤U _a]^T]a\lhfw]^`d\ mpUskSU \le Uf~PlU \;-UguwU T`¦cU5h<¥U \HmpU[mpkSrHmpUsdklU \le U E+ D b44bTD 5a A-hi\H uwU S_jhce U]©f5]^f~P:]^fwm~U _^]a\f~PSU`clH`mp]^f~U0`duw¥U uQThc¯q]^\Sb +94bD, bD,5a A b 4bD,bD,5a A a b444f~PSU0\lU·qf5U _a]^T]a\lhfw]^`d\m~U skSU \leU[fw`rHU0uwU bhiu¥U `cu V¥«h¢SU \lm~U¤m~kSrlm~U skSU \leUS+ED b44bTD 5a A-L]jmu~U T`¦cU 0hc\l0fwPSU \<u~U S_jhceU0]a\ rLUfy-U U \ fy¤`¢]^\H¥]ae U m D à D "`c\°hc\S`ifwPSU uÃLuwhc\l¥`cT_aoePl`dm~U \nÃLlhiu~f¢`cvf~PSUCU _a]aTC]a\lhif~]a`c\Em~U skSU \leUdÃL] « Uc« +ED b44bD ^ rHUe`dTCUm +W4Tb DP Tb D,5 a A a b44b D \Tb DP
(79) b4b D,5 a A Tb D b44H. . Suw`¦]j¥U;fwPlhf. ". 06Ol«¤{gf~PSU u~]jm~UcÃ¥-U[bdUf. +W4bTD bTD b44bD 5a AA bTD b44bTD bTD 5a A a b44H0H«v¹ºU"¥`\S`ifLU uwT]©f5`cf~PSU uu~Uhiuwuwhc\SbcU TCU \fwm-hilhcupf-u~`dT fwPSU m~U[fy¤`H« . `cu. . & = % 86 7 6 ¹ºU]^\fwU \f¢fw`:TC]a\S]aT]^³ U fwPSUe`dmpf`i-hde e kST kS_jhfw]^\lb;f~PlUe `cTS_aUfwUªdhce `crS]jhi\Thif~uw]©·`c¤h ¦dU ef~`cu kl\le§fw]^`d\CrqoCmp`d_^¦q]a\SbgfwPSU5m~PS`cu~f~Umyfvlhif~PSuw`crS_aU T ]a\Cf~PSUTU fwhibduwhcS"P (' PS]aePC]jmv]^\H¥kleUCro f~PSU uwU mpf~uw]je§f~]a`c\<f~` SkSuwU¦cU u~f~U ·<U _^]aT]^\lhif~]a`c\n«vq]a\leU5f~PSU 4hiuw¯c`¦q]©fw³¥U bdu~U U`i´h0¦cU upfwU· ]jm¥oq\lhcT]ae hi_a_^o ePHhi\Sbd]^\SbQfwPSuw`ckSbdPS`ck¥f+f~PSU¤U _a]^T]a\lhfw]^`d\0Su~`¥e U mwmn]^fwme hi_jekl_ahif~]a`c\0]jmnuhf~PlU u+U ·¥HU \lmp]a¦cU¢ + W- £+Plh®¦q]^\lb ]a\±T]a\l f~PHhf<-U;]a_^_-Plh®¦dUf~`ºe`cTSkSf~U;]^fC\qkSTU u~`dklmf~]aTU mC¥kSuw]^\lb¨f~PSU:m~]^T<kS_ahif~U>hi\S\SUhi_a]^\lb hc_^bd`cuw]©fwPST:« `ifw]ae UgfwPlhf-f~PSU0e `cTSk¥fhf~]a`c\`infwPSU vkle_a]j¥U hc\¥]jmpfwhi\HeU[rHU fy¤U U \;fy-`<e ]©fw]^Um-]^\f~PSU O5StPl]aeP]am5lhiu~f`i ²sklhfw]^`d\º Vc£§Ãl]ame `cTlhiuhirl_^o;ePSUhin« .
(80) . . . . B(B ÒCEDGFGFGH.
(81) . 4
(82) $. ES = MAX(V_F,V_B); m = COST(ES);. CG: p > 0. min = m; mprev = m; logm = log(m); t = m / logm; il = (int) (p*(2*atan(1) - atan(p/30 - 1))); ilc = 0; ol = (int) (p*(2*atan(1) - atan(p/100))+50); olc=0;. accepted = 0; zeros = 0; olc++;. ilc++;. EST = RANDOM_CHANGE(ES); m = COST(ES);. 0. m == mprev ? 1. zeros++;. 0. METROP(m-mprev) ?. 1. ES = EST; accepted++; mprev = m;. 0. m < min ? 1. min = m; ESmin = ES;. 0. ilc == il ? 1 0. accepted > zeros ? 1. ESmin (min) olc == ol ? 1 0. t = m / (olc * logm);. »]abckSuwU A_²q]aT kS_jhfwU :5\S\lU hi_a]a\Sb5_abc`cuw]^f~PST. m Ð Bnm
(83) o.
(84) 76.
(85) . 687. . ' =' . . . »]abckSuwU 5m~PS`5m'PS`±f~PSU]aTS_^U TU \f~UCm~]aT kS_jhfwU Chi\S\SUhi_a]^\lbhc_^bd`cuw]©fwPST3-`cuw¯qm «n| fmpfwhcupfm%]^f~Phc\ a] \S]^f~]jhi_dU _a]^T]a\lhfw]^`d\m~U skSU \leU¢ q£LPS]aeP0-UvPlh®¦dU²ePS`dm~U \[f~`grHUvfwPSU²Th·¥]aT kST)`ckSfn`iq`cuw-hcuw[hi\H rHhce¯q-hcuw:¦dU u~f~U ·:U _^]aT]^\Hhf~]a`c\°T`qSU m¢]^\°f~U u~Tm[`i²fwPSUC\klT rLU u`iT<kS_^f~]aS_^]je hif~]a`c\lm¢uwU skS]au~U:`cu fwPSU¢hde e kST kS_jhfw]^`d\`if~PSU[e`dTCl_^U f~U[ªdhce `crS]jhi\+«%-ffwPSU5rLU bd]^\S\l]^\Sb<`if~PlUg`cSf~]aTC]a³ hif~]a`c\Suw`¥eU¥kSuwU -U¥`¢\S`if-hc\fnf~`¢rHUf~PSUQe`myf <`c ¢e_a`dm~Uvfw`5f~PlUT]^\l]^T<kST:«%|µ\0fwPS]jm%e hcm~U]^f%-`ckS_jrHUe`dTCU¤¦cU u~o _a]a¯cU _aof~PHhf-f~PSU0hi_abc`du~]^f~PlT myfw`clm-h fwU u'xyklmpf`c\SU[]©fwU uhfw]^`d\;]©fwPS`ckSfSU _a]^¦dU uw]^\Sbhi\qo]aTClu~`¦dU TU \f « {¢klu5mp]aT kS_jhfwU :hi\l\SU hc_^]a\Sbhi_abc`cuw]^f~PST e `c\lm~]jmyfmQ`i+fy-`Thi]a\ _^`q`cHm/ hc\N`dk¥f~U u_a``dÖe`dkS\f~U u_{ c£hi\H)hc\N]a\S\SU u¨_^`q`d ¡e`dkS\f~U u_ c£§«»S`du"rH`cf~P `i-f~PlU T¸-U;¥U 5l\SUkSSLU u rH`dkS\lSm `cufwPSU \qkST<rHU ug`iv]^f~U uwhif~]a`c\lmQfwPSU o:]a_^_%HU up`du~T ,{ ;hi\l £§«
(86) { º]jm;fwPSUETh·¥]aThi_g\qkST<rHU u`c0]©fwU uhf~]a`c\HmE fwPSUºThi·¥]^Thi_ \klT rLU u+`cSU _a]^T]a\lhfw]^`d\ m~U skSU \HeU mnf~Plhifhcu~U²bdU \SU uwhif~U0hi\l0uwkS\H£ rHU `cuwU"f~PlU<hi_abc`du~]^f~PlT mpf~`dlm ÃLU ¦dU \]^²]^f[Plhdm5\S`cf[e `c\q¦cU u~bdU ´«5| f Th®oPlhilHU \:f~Plhifg`c\SU"hc\lf~PlU m~hcTU0U _a]^T]a\lhfw]^`d\mpUsdklU \le U0]am ePSU e¯dU ¢fy]ae U²`cu+U ¦cU \TC`du~Uv`c f~U \nÃihi_^f~PS`dkSbcP]^f+]jmn¦cU u~o¢kS\S_a]^¯dU _aoc« ¹°UThi¯dU[m~kSuwU5f~PHhf¤UbdUfh uwU m~kS_^f-]^f~PS]a\¨h uwU hdmp`d\lhirl_^Ufw]^TU mplhc\¨rqom~Uf~f~]a\Sb { hi\l l«| fwm[sklhi_a]©fyo:mpf~uw`c\Sbd_^o¥U LU \llmg`d\ f~PSU0lhcuwhcTUf~U uwm¤`if~PlU"mp]aT kS_jhfwU hi\S\lU hi_a]a\Sbhi_abc`cuw]^f~PST:« »]abckSuwU R m~PS`5m²fwPSU¥U ¦dU _a`cSTU \fQ`i Chi\Hf{ C¥U LU \lS]^\Sb `c\ f~PSU¨\qkST<rHU u `c0]^\f~U u~TU¥]ahif~U:¦hiuw]ahcrS_aU m]a\ f~PSUEe bduwhcSP NPC« `ifw]ae U<fwPlhf`du0`ckSu0hi_abc`du~]^f~PlT¤Uhi_aQh®oqm[hcmwm~kSTU<fwPlhf f~PSU u~U"]jm[hf¢_aU hdmyf¢`c\SU<¦cU u~f~U ·fw`;rLU<U _^]aT]^\lhif~U:u~`dT NP ´OQPSU Thi·¥]^Thi_¥\qkST<rHU u²`i´e`q`d_^]a\Sb0myfwU lm²_^]aU m²hc_^Qh®o¥mrHU fy¤U U \ 6ihi\H »]^bdkSu~U RO_ +`q`clm 6il« | f]a\le u~Uhcm~U m"uhil]a¥_ao `cum~Thi_a_¤¦hi_akSUm<`c ´ÃPSU u~Uhcm<]©f e`c\q¦dU uwbcU mgf~`>7 6i `cu"_jhiuwbcU ubcuhiSPlm «5\lhc_^`dbc`dklm Ã+¤U`drlmpU u~¦dU h:mpf~U U >hcmweU \df"]a\ºf~PSU 5Huwmpf"lhiu~f; q£¢`i-f~PSU;e kSuw¦cUC`cu l« 5bhi]a\nÃ+]^f m~Ufpfw_^Um`cu<h¦hc_^kSU hcu~`dkS\l ¨`cu<]^\HeuwU hcm~]a\Sb\qkST rLU um<`ig]a\f~U uwTU ¥]jhfwU ¦hiuw]jhirS_aU m « }¤PS`q`mp]a\SbrL`ifwPJ¦hi_akSU mChcm ¤U S]aºhcmwmpklu~UmgfwPlhffwPSU;hi_abc`du~]^f~PST]a_a_²hi_a-h®o¥m¢f~U u~T]a\lhfwUhi f~U u"h uwU hdmp`d\lhirS_aUhi\l°]^\ºT`dmpf"e hcm~U m m~ke3;e]aU \fuwkS\¥ f~]aTCUd« OQPSU §f~U TLU uhfwkSu~U ~>]jm_^`-U uwU ±]©fwPU ¦cU uwo ]©fwU uhfw]^`d\J`igf~PSU:`ckSf~U u_a`q`chc\l]©f]jm<¯dU ¥f e `c\lmpfwhc\f5PS]^_aU uwkS\S\l]^\Sb;f~PSuw`ckSbdPf~PSU<]^\S\lU ug_a`q`cn«¹ ]^f~Pl]^\¨fwPSU _jhf~f~U ug-U"uwhc\l¥`dTC_aoePHhi\SbdU0f~PSU U _^]aT]^\Hhf~]a`c\¨m~U skSU \leU0klm~]a\Sbf~PSU"fy¤`8;F;M898HM=HB eOFKfFBDCv<¤m~kSbcbdU mpf~UhcrH`¦dUc«²¹ PlUf~PlU u5fwPS]jm5\SU 0ÃHm~` ¡hcu'f~U TCL`cuhiuwocÃ`duwSU u5 S£%]amvhde eU ¥f~U `duv\S`ifSU LU \lSm²`c\<f~PSU 4:U f~uw`cL`c_a]amve u~]^f~U u~]a`c\+«+| f²uwUf~klu~\lm hCrL`q`c_aU hi\:¦hiuw]jhirS_aUPS]aeP:]jm~m~kSUmh¦cU u¥]je§f5`d\PSU f~PSU uf~`;hde e U ¥fghuwU e `c4\ 5lbdkSuhf~]a`c\_^Uhc¥]a\SbCf~` hCePlhc\SbcU e| C]^\f~PlU0`cr¥xyUe§f~]a¦cU¢kS\lef~]a`c\1x «| ]a_^_%hi_a-h®o¥m¤rHU0hce eU ¥f~U´«v| f~PSU0hc\lmp-U u¤`i 5]a_^_´`d\S_aorHU[H`mp]^f~]a¦cU[]^f~PSu~`drlhirl]^_a]©fyo
(87) ~ «%gm-¤U[Plh®¦dU hc_^uwU hd¥o;L`c]a\f~U :`dk¥f ÃN~ ]jm5\S`cfgePlhi\lbcU ]^f~PS]a\:f~PlU"]^\l\SU u¢_^`q`c+« 05`-U ¦dU uÃ¥]©fwP¨U ¦dU uwo ]^f~U uhfw]^`d\ v{ c£Q`cvf~PSU<`ck¥fwU u[_^`q`d¨¤U<u~U ]^\S]^f~]jhi_a]a³ Uj~¨hcm~ { { q« `ifw]ae U"f~PHhfgfwPSU \lU 3¦hi_akSU `c ~¥U LU \llm5`c\f~PlU ekSuwuwU \f 4¨hiuw¯c`¦q]^f~³¥U bdu~U UcÃ¥] « Ud«²]©fgSU LU \lSmg`c\f~PSU<e`dmpf`if~PSU _ahdmyf5hce eU ¥f~U . . .
(88). 200.
Documents relatifs
It is obvious that the steel showed the plastic strain memory effects at each test temperature, in other words, in spite of the hardness of the steel cyclic stress,
Les cités et leur territoire d'influence sont administrées par de puissantes familles, celles de l'aristocratie terrienne et marchande, qui tirent leur légitimité de
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des
In this paper, we have defined the steady-state control problem for MDP, and shown that this question is decidable for (ergodic) MDP in polynomial time, and for labeled MDP
Trois autres échantillons du pool CHAT étaient également gardés au Center for Disease Control et ont été inclus dans cette analyse (CHAT pool 13, CHAT type 1 Wy4B-5, CHAT 1FL)..
Un habitat de La Tène moyenne et finale à Berry-au-Bac au lieu-dit “ Le Chemin de la Pêcherie ” (Aisne).. Jérôme Dubouloz, Michel Plateaux,
constat, unanime en Colombie, que la résolution des conflits par élimination de “l’opposant” est l’une des caractéristiques de la violence nationale. Première
Automatic test data generation, structural testing, constraint solving techniques, global constraints 1.. Structural testing techniques are widely used in unit or module testing
