HAL Id: jpa-00225089
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/jpa-00225089
Submitted on 1 Jan 1985
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of
sci-entific research documents, whether they are
pub-lished or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés.
FRACTONS AND THE HOMOGENEOUS
LINEWIDTH OF THE 5D0 - 7F0 TRANSITION IN
Eu3+-DOPED GLASSES
G. Dixon, R. Powell, X. Gang
To cite this version:
JOURNAL DE PHYSIQUE
Colloque C7, supplbment au nOIO, Tome 46, octobre 1985 page C7-331
FRACTONS AND THE HOMOGENEOUS LINEWIDTH OF THE
5 ~ 0-
7 ~ 0TRANSITION
IN
EU~+-DOPED
GLASSES
G.S. Dixon, R.C. Powell and X. Gang
OkZahoma State University, StiZZwater, OK 74074, U. S.A.
Re'sume'
-
Les mesures du r6tr6cissement de la raie fluorescence r4sultant de--
la transition 5 ~ 0 - 7 ~ 0 dans plusieurs verres do$~ a 1'mopim et a ~ a n t des structures diff6rentes seront pr6sentGes. La largeur de raie hmog'ene suit une l oi de variation T~ entre 30 et 300K. I 1 a 6te' montre' que ce comporte- ment peut &re interprgtg a
I
'aide des proc6dBs Raman avec des irrdgularit6s dans les modes de vibration dues2
la structure fractale du verre.Abstract
-
F l uorescence I i ne narrowing measurements of t h e 5 ~ O - 7 ~ 0 transit ion--
in severa I structural 1 y di ss imi l ar Eu-doped g1 asses are presented. The homogeneous I inewidth exhibits a T~ dependence from 30 to 300 K. We show that this behavior can be accounted for by Raman processes with the anomalous
vibrational modes of the fractal structure of the glass.
I
-
INTRODUCTIONBy the use of high resol ution lasers, subsets of ions within the inhomoge- neous l y broadened spectra 1 prof i l e can be se l ect i ve l y excited in glasses so that their homogeneous linewidth can be measured. Hole-burning in absorption and fluore- scence linenarrowing (FLN) in emission make use of this technique. FLN experiments /1/ on E U ~ + ions in a si l icate glass have shown a homogeneous l inewidth at low temperatures substantially larger than seen in crystals and a quadratic temperature dependence that is unexpected for any known linebroadening mechanism in crystals.
In this paper we report FLN measurements on E U ~ + in three structural l y di ssimi-
1 ar g 1 asses at temperatures ranging from 10 to 300 K. A 'T dependence for the homogeneous 1 i new i dth i s observed in each of these l ending support to the notion that this is a uni versa1 property of glasses. To account for these results, a simple model based on the fracton concept of Alexander and Orbach /2/ is developed for Raman and direct process broadening. Both the quadratic dependence and the approximate magnitude of the broadening are consistent with this model.
I 1 - EXPERIMENTAL
Site sel ect ion was achieved with a nitrogen- 1 aser-pumped tunab 1 e dye 1 aser using coumarin dye. The 10 ns excitation pulse was narrowed to 0.15 cm-' by passing it through an extra-cavity etalon. The samples were mounted on the coldfinger of a c l osed-cyc l e he l ium cryostat permitting measurements between 10 and 300 K. The fluorescence was measured by a I-m monochromator with slits set for 0.08 A. A
shutter placed between the sample and the monochromator was opened 0.1 ms after the excitation, eliminating the possibl ity of contamination by scattered 1 ight. It has been shown elsewhere that energy transfer does not broaden the fluorescence on this time sca l e / 3 / .
The three europium doped glasses studied here had the following compositions in
C7-332 J O U R N A L D E PHYSIQUE
mole percent: l ithium si l icate glass (LS) 57.0 Si02, 27.5 Li20. 10.0 CaO, 2.5 A1 203, 3.0 Eu20j; sodium si l icate glass (NS) 72.0 Si02, 15.0 Na20, 5.0 BaO, 5.0 ZrO, 3.0 Eu203; and potassium germanate glass (KG) 65.3 Ge02. 17.0 K20. 17.0 BaO. 0.7 Eu203. The spectral properties of these glasses have been reported previously / 3 / .
For each glass excitation spectra were obtained at 577.5 nm and 580 nm on the high and low energy sides of the inhomogeneous prof i le of the 5 ~ 0 - 7 ~ 0 transition, respectively.
I 1 1 - HOMOGENEOUS INHO'MOGENEOUS_ BROADENING OF THE FLN LINEWIOTH
The temperature dependence of the FLN linewidth is shown in Fig. I. These data have been reduced using the approximation of Kushida and Takushi /4/ for a reson- antly excited transition,
where Av is the l inewidth of the transit ion, Avobs is the measured f 1 uorescence 1 inewidth, and Avres is the instrumental resol ution.
TEMPERATURE
(K)
Fig. I - FLN l inewidth on the high and low energy sides of the inhomogeneous prof i 1 e. A denotes excitation at 577.5 nm; 0, at 580 nm. The residual broadening at low temperatures is due to imperfect site selection as discussed in the text.
At high temperatures each linewidth has an approximately quadratic temperature dependence, but approaches a temperature-independent 1 lmlt at low temperatures. This l imi t i ng va l ue i s about an order of magnitude l arger than our exper irnenta 1
resolution. We interpret it as residual inhomogeneous broadening due to imperfect site selection. We note i n this regard that such a limiting value was not observed
Fig. 2
-
Homogeneous 1 inewidth after substraction of the residua1 inhomogeneous broadening. Symbol s are as in Fig. 1. A l 1 data are consistent with a 'T dependence as shown by the I ines.A1 I the homogeneous l inewidths are consistent with a
'
T
dependence over the entire temperature range. One notes, however, that the homogeneous l inewidth is sma 1 I er on the high energy side of the inhomogeneous profile than on the low energy side in the LS glass. This behavior differs from that seen in the NS and KG glasses and also from the results of Morgan, et al., for a variety of glasses at room tempera- ture /5/. This provides a clear indication that a quadratic temperature dependence may be a universal property of otherwise dissimilar glasses.I V - FRACTONS AND THE HOMOGENEOUS LINEWIDTH
The idea that systems with fractal structure might have an anoma lous v ibra- tional density of states was introduced by Stapl eton, et al. /6/ to explain the spin-lattice relaxation time seen in iron-containing proteins. This has led to the e l egant deve l opment of the "f racton" model of l oca l ized v i brat ions on f racta I struc- tures by Alexander and Orbach and co-workers / 2 , 7 / . They have shown that plane waves are a poor representation of the vibrational modes except at long wavelengths. They find a critical length scale L for the Debye approximation, on shorter scales. 1, the vibrations (now cat led fractons) are localized. The density of states for the vibrations is then
where IAD and aF are the f~equencies of the Debye phonons and fractons of charac- teristic length L; d, and d are the Euclidean and fracton dimensionalities.
C7-334 JOURNAL DE PHYSIQUE
and the R a m n broadening is
where tv': en: v> is a matrix element of the average local strain, <e'l V : e > is the electrostatic matrix element for the direct or Raman process and Aj is the splitting to the jth neighboring el ectronic state. These expressions give the conventional resu I ts for crystals when the Debye approximat'ion is used. They may be appl Led to the glass problem using the dispersion relation /2/ for the fracton w = I - ~ / ~ on a sel f-simi lar fractal of Hausdorff dimensional ity
a
and noting that the average local strain from a normal mode with amplitude Q and localization I should scale as Q/1. For a direct process the temperature dependence of the linewidth will be dominated by the thermal population of vibrational quanta with energy Aj as in crystals, but the magnitude will be changed in proportion to the density of states at that energy. For R a m n processes one haswhere the first integral is over the Debye-
-
1 i ke modes and the second is over the fractons. The exponent p = Zd(2/d +I)-4. For fractal structures in a 3 dimensional glass, one has 3>a>2.5, the value for a critically percolating cluster. Alexander and Orbach /2/ conjecture that is uni versa1 l y 4/3; the effective medium approxima-tion /7/ gives ;*I. The specific heat of epoxy can be fit /7/ above I K with
d
=1.3, eL=14 K and eD=29 K. Fig. 3 shows numerical results for the fracton contribu- t ion to the 1 inewidth. A 'T dependence is expected for the broadening throughout the range of our experiment if the 8's for our glasses are simi l ar to those for epoxy. The contribution from the Debye-l i ke modes is negl igibl e at these tempera- tures. Similarly, the parameter A that governs the magnitude of the Raman broad- ening can be estimated from the McCumber and Sturge /8/ a parameter for a crystal with the same average density and sound velocity as the glass. This equivalent a is given by
where BX is the Debye temperature of this equivalent crystal. In our glasses the homogeneous 1 inewidth is =Io-~T' cm-l, giving a-10' cm-' which is the same magnitude seen for rare earth transitions in crysta l s. Thus, the e 1 ectron-fracton Raman process accounts for both the magnitude and temperature dependence of the homo- geneous broadening in glasses. As the glass structure enters the model through
a,
Fig. 3 suggests on 1 y a weak structural dependence if the A l exander and Orbach conjecture ho l ds.It is also of interest to compare the magnitude o f t h e direct process broad- ening in glass tothat seen in crystals. Forthe same equivalent crystal usedto compare the Rarnan broadening, AvGl ass=Avxta for Aj/h<wL; AvG ass=AvXta +AvFracton
for o L <A J ./6<uD; and A v ~ ~ ~for A j > u ~ . Assuming the same coup1 ing ~ ~ = A v ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ strenght ;<e'lVD:e>l in both the glass and the crystal, the fracton contributuon to
the direct process broadening is AvFracton=AvXta (l/3)uD5uL-q(~j/h)q-5 where q=d(l+Z/a). Since the lowest l eve1 for a direct process is "250 cm-l above the ground state in EU~', no observab l e direct process contribution to the l inewidth is expected at the temperatures of these experiments.
This reseach was supported by Rome Air Development Center and the National Science Foundation under grant number DMR-82-16551.
REFERENCES
/1/ P. M. Selzer, D. L. Huber. D. 5. Hamilton. W. M. Yen, and M. J. Weber, Phys. Rev. Lett.
36.
813 (1976)./2/ S. A 1 exander and R. Orbach, J. Phys. (Paris) Lett. 43, L-625 ( 1982).
/3/ X. Gang and R. C. Powe l I, J. App I. Phys.
57,
1299 (1985); X. Gang, G. Bou l on, and R. C. Powel 1, J. Chem. Phys.28.
4374 (1983)./4/ T. Kushida and E. Takushi, Phys. Rev. 0 12, 824 (19751.
/5/ J. R. Morgan. E. P. Chock. W. D. Hopewel I, M. A. El-Sayed, and R. Orbach. J.
Phys. Chem.
85.
747 (1981)./6/ H. J. Stapl eton, J. P. A 1 l en, C. P. F l ynn. D. G. St inton. and S. R. Kurtz. Phys. Rev. Lett. 45. 1456 (1980).
/7/ S. Alexander, C. Laermans, R. Orbach, and H. M. Rosenberg, Phys. Rev. B a , 4615 (1983); P. Tua. 5. Putterman. R. Orbach, Phys. Lett.
