HAL Id: jpa-00247180
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/jpa-00247180
Submitted on 1 Jan 1996
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Multiphase Coexistence and Non-linear Rheology of Colloidal. Dispersions as Observed in a Model Capillary
Viscosimeter
Thomas Palberg, Mathias Würth
To cite this version:
Thomas Palberg, Mathias Würth. Multiphase Coexistence and Non-linear Rheology of Colloidal.
Dispersions as Observed in a Model Capillary Viscosimeter. Journal de Physique I, EDP Sciences,
1996, 6 (2), pp.237-244. �10.1051/jp1:1996145�. �jpa-00247180�
Multiphase Coexistence and Non.linear Rheology of Colloidal.
Dispersions
asObserved in
aModel Capillary Viscosimeter
Thomas
Palberg (*)
and Mathias WürthUniversity
ofKonstanz, Faculty
ofPhysics,
Postfach 5560M675,
78434 Kontanz,Germany
(Received
13July
1995, revised 26 October 1995,accepted
6 November1995)
PACS.82.70.Dd Colloids
PACS.47.20.Ky Nonlinearity
PACS.64.60.-i General studies of
phase
transitionsAbstract.
Investigations
of the flow properties of colloidal substancesby viscometry
andrheometry
are a valuable trot inunderstanding
many transport processes ofimportance
in biol- ogy, medicine and industrial treatment of materials. Triestreaming
ofcytoplasm, blood,
micellarsolutions or crude ail emulsions are but some obvious
examples.
One of the mostintriguing
prop-erties of colloidal systems is their
ability
ofthinning
orthickening
under shear. TO characterise this non-Newtonian flow behaviour different visco- and rheometric experiments have been de-vised,
thecapillary
viscometerbeing
one of the classical instruments. Theuuderlying physical
mechanisms of non-linear
rheometry
are the shear-induced formation and destruction oflong
range
positional
and orientational order. Sinceonly
in rare casescomprehensive
structure andvelocity
information is accessible from inside a viscosimeter,generally, homogeneous samples
areassumed. However, there are indications of a geometry
dependent
evolution ofinhomogeneous phase
and flow behaviour from recent experiments on colloidal mortel systems, inparticular
for denser systems of
strongly iuteractiug partiales.
We here presentinvestigations performed
on a well characterised
suspension
ofspherical partiales interacting
ma a screened electrostaticpotential.
Wegive
a detailedstudy
of trie local structures and shear rates in anoptical
mortelcapillary
viscosimeter. As a function of the overall flux several different flow scenariosare ob-
served within the viscosimeter and the most
striking
feature is the simultaneous existence of up to four concentricallyarrangea phases
under conditions of stationary flow.For a Newtonian fluid the shear stress a within trie fluid is
proportional
to the shear rate i =du/dx
times trieviscosity
~: a = ~7. While this behaviour is observed for mostsimple fluids,
colloidaldispersions
often showsignificant
deviations from thissimple law,
and thisproperty
finds a number ofinteresting applications. Thixotropy
orshear-thinning,
for exam-ple,
is a welcome aid inpainting
without the formation of tears. This is due to trieparallel
arrangement
of thepigment platelets
under trieshearing
forces of trie brush. After termi- nation of shear triepartiales
agam becomeorientationally
disordered due to their Brownian motion. Such behaviour may be connected to aphase
transition under sheariii
Forexample,
recent
investigations
m a cone andplate
rheometer on wormlike micelles showed aplateau
value in the measured shear stress upon
increasmg
trie shear rate[2].
Itcorresponds
to a first order transition from trieisotropic
to trie nematicphase,
with thephase boundary shifting
(*)
Author forcorrespondence (e-mail: [email protected])
©
LesÉditions
de Physique 1996238 JOURNAL DE
PHYSIQUE
I N°2under
increasing
shear towards lower micellar concentrations. In order toexplain
the observed non-linearrheology
a nucleation andgro~vth
mechanism wasproposed leading
to a twophase
coexistence.
Non-Newtonian behaviour is also found in sy.stems of
simpler partiale shape exhibiting
suf-ficiently strong
interaction between trieparticles.
Under these conditions shear may induce several different transitions to states of either lower orhigher viscosity.
Fluid states mai- first order under shear to formlayered
structures; above a critical shear rate,however,
extremedilatancy
is observed and attributed to cluster formation [3]. Otherexperiments
report trie structuralchanges
observableduring
trie transition from colloidalcrystals
toisotropic
fluidstates
il, 4-6].
Measurements with acapillary
viscosimeter revealed a many orders ofmagni-
tude decrease of the apparent
viscosity dunng
this shearmelting
processI?i. Although
shear inducedphase
transitions thus showpronounced
effects on trierheology
of colloidal suspen-sions, only
very few papers existgiving
detailed connections between triesuspension
structureand the colloidal flow
properties [3,
8.9].
Most studies on shearmelting
focused on structuralaspects
alone or discuss trieunderlying microscopic
mechanismslà, 8-11].
Some of theexperi-
ments
[12]
bave beensupported by computer
simulations andnon-equilibrium phase diagrams
bave been derived
[10,13].
In most studies
homogeneous stationary
states had to be assumed.Obviously
this will not hold forcomplicated
flowgeometries
oroscillatory
shear. Infact,
the formation of coexistentphases
has been observed in aTaylor-Couette
flow or inoscillatory capillary
flow. In both cases instabilities connected tophase
coexistence evolve due to triehydrodynamics
of triesystem [13].
First observations of two
phase
coexistence forsimple geometries
baveonly
veryrecently
beenreported
oncharge
stabilised silica [9] andpolystyrene spheres [14]
We here examine asimple
colloidalsystem
in asimple
flowgeometry. Charged
latexspheres
may be manufactured with well definedshape,
radius andcharge.
Suchmonodisperse suspensions
bavealready acquired
the state of model systems within the
heterogeneous
Mass of colloidaldispersions [15].
Dueto their
long ranged
interactionthey
show anequilibrium phase
transition from trie fluid to acrystalline
ordered state at micromolar concentrations ofscreening electrolyte
even atpacking
fractions well below one
percent.
Since then thetypical interparticle spacing
is on the order of the~vavelength
of visiblehght
triesystems
areoptically
accessibleby hght scattenng
ormicroscopy.
Triepartiales
underinvestigation
here and trieequihbrium
suspensionproperties
bave beencarefully
charactenzed in both trie fluid and trie solid state(Lot #
2011M9R, Seradyn, U.S.A.,
radius a= Si nui, bare
charge
Z=
620;
[16]).
The shear modulus of trie sohd formed at 4l= 0.0035 and under
completely
deionized conditions is on the order of G = 0ANm~~
Thesystem
therefore may be shear moltensimply by shaking
triesample.
Once
sheanng
is terminated triesystem mstantaneously
relaxes to a metastable state of fluidorder,
from which itcrystalhses
back to trie solid state on trie time scale of some seconds tominutes.
All these
investigations
wereperformed
at mechamcalequihbrium.
We heresubject
triesystem
to continuous flowthrough
ahonzontally
mounted modelcapillary
viscosimeter of 4.0 mm mner diameter and alength
of 50 cm. It flows under triehydrostatic
pressure diiferencebetween two reservoirs of fixed
height
difference. Aperistaltic
pump refills trie upper reservoirthrough
a closed Teflontubing
systemcontaining
an ionexchange
chamber and aconductivity
measurement to maintain and control conditions of
complete
deionisation at apacking
fraction fixed to 4l= 0.0035
[17]
In
Figure
la wepresent
trieadjusted height
difference between trie reservoirs Ah indepen-
dence on trie overall fluxV,
asintegrated
from triespatial velocity
distributionu(r).
Trie datapoints discontinuously approach
a hnearbehaviour,
i e. alimiting
Newtonian case. An apparent viscosity ~APP is deducedfollowmg
trieprocedures suggested by
Laun et ai. [3] ando o
~o
o
*
~o
o
a
~
o~
G'
*~
o
***~ ***~~
** *
o
~ ***
fl
o°o
~~o°
120 160 80
a)
v jmm~ sec~' b v 1mm~ sec-11O ~
OOO D *~ ~O
~ OO
~
° ~
COQ O
~~
*Ô
Î O
E ~*
~&~
'
O
E **
~
g ~
©
~
**~~ ~~~~~
~ O
~ Î
~
~~~~iÎ
~ ~ ©
é
~
p
~~************
=~~***~~~~~~ii~
~**~
D~**
~~~*
~~&~
~~~
& ~*
~O°~O~~~~
C) V lmm~""'1
d)
~ lmm~s~c~~iFig.
l. Evolution of several quantities measured in thestationary
state independence
on trie overall flux V, as measuredby integrating
trie observedvelocity profiles v(r)
and varied inequidistant
steps by increasing the speed of therefilling
pump. Trie suspension and shear parameters are: 4l= 0.0035,
c = o~Lmol
l~~,
a= 51 nm, Z
= 620. Trie measured quantities are:
a) Height
difference Ah between trie two reservoirsadjusted
toprovide
a constant flux.b) Apparent
viscosities ~App as deducedfollowing
the
procedures
of Laun et ai. [3]. Note the strong overalltendency
for shearthinning,
the saturation behaviour atlarge
fluxes and the threesteplike
increases.c)
Shear rates as deduced from localvelocity
measurements. Stars: HLI
showing registered sliding;
open circles: HL2showing
continuousshding;
open squares: fluid
phase. d)
Radial distribution of the respective phases. Stars denote theboundary
of the
polycrystalline
core to otherphases;
circles denote theboundary
of the HL2phase
to otherphases
andtriangles
theboundary
between HLI and fluidphase.
Note that for eachphase
trie shearrate increases
hnearly
withincreasing
flux until a furtherphase
is observed and the shear rate saturates.The fluid
phase
shows an onset of shearthinning
athighest
fluxes.assuming
trie relevant pressuredrop
tohappen along
triecapillary
tube. Thisviscosity
is pre- sented inFigure
16. Fourregions
of apparent shearthinning
areclearly
discernibleseparated by seemingly
discontinuous mcreases in ~APP. Forhigh
fluxes(completely
shear moltenstate)
a
hmiting viscosity
isapproached. Comparison
to measurements with pure water at 18 °C givean absolute value of ~F
# 1.05 cp. for the melt. Thus shear
thinning
of colloidal suspensionsas observed in a
capillary
rheometer may be acomplex multistep
process and aninterpretation
m terms of a
single
first orderphase
transition Will not suflice for itsexplanation.
We therefore
carefully analysed
trie structural evolution of trie suspensionalong
and across240 JOURNAL DE
PHYSIQUE
I N°2HL~ F HL, PC HL,F HL~
a)
~ ~ ~b)
Fig.
2.a)
Cuttrough
the mortelcapillary
viscosimeteralong
the direction of flowshowing
sketch of the structural evolutionalong
the cell at V= 128
mm~s~~.
Itwas drawn after visual observations and was
placed upright
forlayout
reasons. Thedrawing
exaggerates thelength
of theregion
ofnucleation and
growth
in order toclarify
the observablephenomena,
a stationary state usually is reachedalready
aftersome centimeters.
Throughout
the experiments the mortel viscosimeterwas
mounted horizontally. Trie cross hatched area denotes the
polycrystalhne
cote, the striped area denotes trie region ofhexagonal sliding layers,
the remaining part is of fluid order.b)
cutthrough
the cellperpendicular
to trie cellaxis. Note the concentric arrangement of trie
respective phases nicely reflecting
the instrumental geometry.
trie tube. We first
report
the observationsalready possible by
eye. If the tube is illuminated with ~v-fritelight
from aside andperpendicular
to trie flowdirection,
and looked at from apoint
on trie other side of trie tube but from
aboue,
the differentphases
are observed as iridescentareas of different
intensity,
colour and texture. Trie suspension enters triecapillary
in trie shearmolten state and relaxes into a
partly crystalline
flowpattern.
InFigure
2a we sketch asample
at constant flux of V
= 80
mm~s~~
Afterentering
trie tube smallcrystallites
nucleate in triecentre and grow, until
they
form apolycrystalline
solid core(crosshatched
area, henceforthdenoted
PC)
Triecrystallite
size increases withincreasing
distance to the cell centre. This is consistent with thefindings
ofPalberg
et ai.[18]
whoreport
astrong
decrease in nucleationrates with
increasmg
shear rate. Bath on the outside of this core and on the quartz wall of thecapillary
tworegions
form and grow toroughly
one mm thickness. Theirlong ranged positional
order m trie
plane parallel
to trie wall is reflectedby
trie restriction of theirextremely bright
iridescence to a small
angular region opposite
and above theilluminating lamp. They
appear dark from other directions. Theseregions
are drawn as hatched areas and henceforth denotedHLI
andHL2.
As will be shown belowthey
are of similar structure butsignificantly
different flowproperties.
Trieremaining
regionstays
fluid(unmarked
area mFig.
2 and henceforthdenoted
F).
A
stationary
state is reached for most overall fluxes well before trie end of thecapillary.
Only
for thehighest
fluxes the tubelength
is too short to allow forcomplete
relaxation within the passage time. While the relative volume of eachregion
is astrong
function of the overallflux,
their radial sequence seems to be fixed.Figure
2b shows a cutthrough
the cell atthe
stationary
state reached inFigure
2a afteristat
# 30 cm. This was drawn after
Bragg- microscopic
measurements(see below) performed
at several different orientations of the tube.Note the concentric
arrangement
of therespective phases nicely reflecting
the instrumentalgeometry.
The structure of the individual
phases
was confirmedby
staticlight scattering
and we willreport
about details of thescattenng arrangement
and the observedscattering
patterns in aforthcoming
paper. A laser beam crosses the cellperpendicular
to the flow direction. We corrected for the distortions of thescattering pattern
causedby
thecapillary using
aspecially designed
indexmatching
bath. Thescattering pattern
is observed on a screenplaced
behind the bath with3% angular
resolution in latitudinal(8)
and azimuthal(çJ)
direction. Weobserve three different
scattering patterns.
The core(PC)
shows thetypical powder pattern
of the
body
centered cubicil10)
reflection ofrandomly
oriented smallcrystallites.
The fluidphase (F)
shows the unstructured smeared ring known from observations of Couette shearexperiments by
neutron orX-ray scattering.
Unlikethere,
the ring observed here does not showsignificant
distortions nor variations mintensity
which would indicate the formation of shear enforced orientational orpositional ordering.
However due to the restrictedprecision
of thisset-up,
we cannotcompletely
rule out thepossibility
of a shear-deformed fluid state.The
HL-regions
both show ahexagonal scattering pattern
atpractically
identicalangle
8as trie other two
phases.
The azimuthalangles
çJ between the maxima are consistent with 60degree
within the resolution of ourset-up.
For similarlight scattering
pattern fromequi-
librium b.c.c.crystals [19]
and neutronscattering pattern
fromequflibrium randomly
stacked f-c-c-crystals
both observed under Couetteflow,
thecorresponding
structure wasanalysed
to be ofhexagonal sliding layers.
Tounequivocally identify
the structure m ourexperiment,
bothhigher
order diffractionpatterns
and absolute intensities would be necessary[11]
Since how-ever our observations for both
regions
arecompatible
withhexagonal layers,
we will continueusing
the abbreviationsHLI
andHL2.
We then
performed
ananalysis
of the structural distribution and the local shear rates at thestationary
states (1 >istat
under variation of the overall flux. The local velocities are measuredby
LaserDoppler velocimetry using
a fibreoptic
detection scheme togain
asufliciently high spatial
resolution of10 ~m. From eachvelocity profile
the local shear rate isprecisely
deter-mined
by differentiating
with respect to r and the overall fluxby integration. Simultaneously
the distribution of individual
phases
is determinedusing high
resolutionBragg microscopy.
A second laser beam crossing the
capillary
is observed with a video cameraequipped
with amacro lens. The camera is
placed
at theposition
of one of theBragg spots
of the HLphase
andoriented under the
scattering angle
8. The image of the laser beam then appears with differentbrightness,
since the static structure factor of the three(four)
regions differsignificantly
at thisparticular
choice of observationangles. HL-regions
appearextremely bright,
the fluid shows a much smallerintensity
and the core appearspractically dark,
sinceonly rarely
an individualcrystallite
fulfills the orientationalBragg
condition.As a function of the mcreasing overall flux we observe a very
complex
behaviourincluding
the formation of
coexisting
shear stabilisedphases.
For a flux of V= 80
mm~s~~
the radialintensity
distributions is shown inFigure
3together
with thelocally
measured velocities. This remarkable case of a fourphase
coexistencecorresponds
to the situation inFigure
2. The local shear rate shows astep-like
behaviourreflecting
the radialphase
distribution. The coreregion
remains unsheared and flows as a solid
plug.
The outerphases
each show different shear rates.The boundaries seem to be continuous
which, however,
is an effect of thelong integration
time242 JOURNAL DE
PHYSIQUE
I N°212 12
* * * * *
0 eM
- ~%
1 'à
O ~
fl 8
-f
E ~
~ ~
Î
~~ * C
à * * 3
à * * c
O * *
~ * *
> ~ ~
i 0
cell rQdiUS mmi
Fig.
3.Representative example
of the shear-inducedphenomena
observed in trie stationary statecorresponding
ta the situationin
Figure
2. Sofia fines show the radialprofiles
of the scatteredintensity
as measured
Bragg microscopy. High
intensitiescorrespond
tophases
ofhexagonal shding
layers.medium intensities to the fluid
phase
and lowintensity
to thepolycrystalline
core. Stars denote the local velocity as measuredby
laserDoppler velocimetry.
for the
velocity
measurements used to enhance thesignal/noise
ratio. With shortintegration times,
say of less than 10 s, we observe aSharp (<
50~m) boundary slowly moving
in andout~vard over a distance of Ar m 250 pm.
The HL
phases
do trot mergecompletely
butstay separated
into tworegions
of different flow behaviour. A remarkable result is the lmear decrease ofvelocity
with the radiusgiving
a shear rate
independent
of theposition.
The inner HL shows the lowergradient,
whichonly
very
slightly
increases with furtherincreasing flux,
while the HLadjacent
to the wall shows astrongly
fluxdependent velocity gradient.
At the same time the scatteredintensity
of the outer region is decreased. This is attributed to a transition from a state ofplanes registered
betweensingle shding
events to a star.e of continuonsgliding
assuggested by
several authors [5,7, iii.
As
expected
for aHagen-Poiseuflle flow,
thevelocity profile
within the fluidphase
isparabolic.
For small fluid
regions
it may beapproximated by
astraight
line and a constant shear rate may beassigned.
InFigure
3 it has aconsiderably
lower value than the shear rate in theHL-regions.
Theinteresting
conclusion is that at V= 80
mm~s~~
the fluidphase
is lubricatedon both sides
by
aphase
ofhigher
order and lowerviscosity.
To compare all the flow data collected in the
stationary
states independence
on the overallflux we
plot
the shear rates measured within the differentphases
inFigure
1c. The solidcore
representing
theequilibrium
stablephase
remained unsheared in allexperiments
and was lubricatedby
one or t~vo HLphases and/or
a fluidphase.
Note that for all fluxes at least twophases
coexist. lvhile thepossibility
of a coexistence bet~veen twophases
hasrecently
been confirmedexperimentally [9,14j,
this is the first demonstration of amultiphase
coexistence.lvithin all
phases
the shear rates increasenearly linearly
until a newphase
is observed. The saturation values areapproximately
6s~~
and 17s~~
for the two HLphases.
As shownm
Figure 1c,
for ourcapillary
viscosimeter thetypical
sequence ofphases
appeanng undermcreasing
shear isPC, HLI> HL2,
F. From intuitive considerations one would expect that smallest shear rates are found in the cell centre and increase towards the cell walls. The concentricarrangement
therefore should also reflect the above mentioned succession of non-equilibrium phases
withincreasing perturbation
of the mechanicalequilibrium. Clearly
thisis not the case. One may
speculate
that theunexpected
radialarrangement
ofphases
isdetermined
by
the kinetics ofheterogeneous
nucleation andgrowth
of the HLphases
on the wall and thepolycrystalline
core,respectively.
Figure
id shows thecorresponding
distributions ofphases
as observed in thestationary
state. With
increasing
flux theHLI phase
grows at the expense of the solid core, thenHL2
grows at the expense of the solid core, while the volume of
HLI stays nearly
constant. Between V m 80mm3s~~
and V m 120mm3s~~
the fluidphase
increases on expense of both the HL andabove V m 120
mm3s~~
on expense of the solid core. The observedstepwise melting
processtherefore seems to be a succession of first order transitions. A detailed
explanation
of the observedbehaviour, however,
remains achallenge.
In addition totltermodynamic
and kineticconsiderations it will have to include
geometrical influences,
too. To stress the latterpoint,
we note that a 150 ~m thickHL2 Phase
remams ratherunchanged
in thickness withincreasing
flux. Thisstability
of the wall basedHL2
is not understood.Layering
of colloidalpartiales
next to a ~vall has been observed but under mechanical
equilibrium
it does not exceed some ten ordered sheets[21].
We further note that a solid-fluid transition without the intermediateformation of HL was
recently
observed for a colloïdalcrystal flowing through
aparallel plate arrangement [13].
We
finally
compareFigures
1c and id to the non Ne1N.tonian behaviourdepicted
inFigures
la and 16 in order toexplain
both the overall shearthiitning
and theseemingly
discontinuousmcreases observed at fluxes of
approximately 40,
80 and 120mm3s~~
TheHLI phase
sho~vsa lower
viscosity
than theHL2 Phase.
Theviscosity
of fluidphase
is somewhatlarger
but still much smaller than for thepolycrystalline
solid. Therefore theregions
ofmonotonously decreasing
~APP may bemterpreted
as the mcrease in volume of lowviscosity phases
on expense of the solid core, while each increase m ~APP represents the stabilisation of afurther,
lessordered
phase
ofrelatively higher viscosity.
IiiHLI
thelong
rangepositional
order is still present for threedimensions,
smce theparticles
remaiuregistered
betweenshding
events, it is lost in radial direction upon the transition to thecontinuously shding
stateHL2.
It iscompletely
lost for the fluidphase.
The
system
understudy
was anexample
of a verysimple
colloidal suspension. Allparticles
were
spherical
and thesamples
maysafely
be consideredmonodisperse.
Thereforecomplica-
tions due to
polydispersity,
asthey
are often observed for technicalsamples,
were not addressed here.Furthermore,
the interaction between thepartiales
wassufliciently high
to allow for adescription
m terms of an effective Yukawapotential
while thepacking
fraction wassufliciently
low to
neglect hydrodynamic
interactions betweenparticles
m the bulkphases.
in addition the chosengeometry
was thesimplest
one of radialsymmetry.
On the other hand the observedbehaviour
already
was rathercomplex
and wehope
to havecaught
alarge
number of effectstypical
forsimple
colloidalsystems.
The usefulness of colloïdal suspensions as models of con- densed matter hasalready
been demonstrated for a number ofequihbrium
situations. Thepresent expenments
under conditions far from mechanicalequilibrium, might
therefore havean
impact
also oninvestigations
of solidification of atomic or molecular material under shear.We have
presented
anexample
of thepossibilities
toquantitatively
characterize the flow behaviour of asuspension
of well defined colloidalspheres by
means of a combination oflight scattering
andmicroscopic
methods. In anoptical
modelcapfllary
viscosimeter the combinedevolution of the
sample's
local structure and shear rate was monitored undercarefully
controlled shear conditions. For the first time it waspossible
toassign
the observedstrongly
non-linearviscosity
behaviour to a succession ofnon-equilibrium phases,
which for themselves seem toobey
a Newtomanrheology. Up
to four differentphases
were observed to coexist 1&~hichstrongly
differ m their
degree
oflong
range order.244 JOURNAL DE
PHYSIQUE
I N°2The
emerging qualitatively
consistent picture demonstrates the value ofopto-rheometric
expenments and should stimulate enhanced
experimental
and theoretical efforts toquantify existing microscopic
models of bothphase
transitions under shear and theircorrespondence
tothe
complex
flow behaviour observed in colloidalsystems.
Acknowledgments
The authors like to thank G. Porte and P. Leiderer for critical discussions on the issue of non
equflibrium phase diagrams.
Financial supportby
the DeutscheForschungsgememschaft
isgratefully acknowledged.
References
iii
HoffmannR.L.,
Trans. Soc. Rheoi. 16(1972)155;
J. Coll.Interface
Sci. 46(1974) 491;
Adu. Coll.
Interface
Sci. 17(1982)
161.[2] Berret
J-F-,
Roux D.C- and PorteG.,
J.Phys.
Il France 4(1994)
1261.[3] Laun
H.M., Bung R.,
HessS.,
LooseW.,
HessO.,
HahnK.,
HàdickeE., Hingmann R.,
Schmidt F. and LindnerP.,
J. Rheoi. 36(1993)
1057.[4] Ackerson B.J. and Clark
N-A-, Phys.
Reu. Lett. 46(1981)
123.[Si Ackerson
B.J., Physica
A 128(1983)
221.[6] Ackerson
B.J., Hayter J-B-,
Clark N.A. and CotterL.,
J. Chem.Phys.
84(1986)
2344.[7] Chen L.B. and Zukoski
C.F., Phys.
Reu. Lett. 65(1990)
44.[8] Chen
L.B.,
ChowM.K.,
Ackerson B.J. and ZukoskiC.F., Langmitir10 (1994)
2817.[9] Imhoff
A.,
van Blaaderen A. and DhontJ.K.G., Langmitir10 (1994)
3477.[loi
StevensM.J-,
Robbins M.O. and BelakJ.F., Phys.
Reu. Lett. 66(1991)
3004.[Il]
Loose W. and AckersonB.J.,
J. Chem.Phgs.
101(1994)
7211.[12]
ChaikinP.M., dimeglio J.M.,
DozierW., Lindsay
H.M. and WeitzD.A.,
mPhysics
ofComplex
andSupramolecular Fluids,
S.A. Safran and N.A. Clark Eds.(N.Y., Wiley- Interscience, 1987)
pp.65; Lindsay
H.M. and ChaikinP.M.,
J.Phys. Coiioq.
France 46(1985)
C3-269.[13]
Lahin R. andRamaswamy S., Phys.
Reu. Lett. 73(1994)
1043.[14]
Palberg
T. and StreicherK.,
Natitre 367(1994)
Si.[15] Pusey P-N-,
mLiquids, freezing
andglass transition,
51st summer school in theoreticalphysics,
Les Houches(F) 1989,
J. P.Hansen,
D.Levesque
and J. Zinn-Justin Eds.(Else-
vier, Amsterdam
1991)
pp. 763.[16] Palberg T.,
WürthM.,
Simon R. and LeidererP., Prog.
Coiioid 8Poiym.
Sci. 96(1994)
62.
[17]
Palberg
T.. HàrtlW., Wittig U.,
VersmoldH.,
Würth M. and SimnacherE.,
J.Phys.
Chem. 96
(1992)
8180.[18]
Palberg T.,
SchwarzJ.,
Würth M. and LeidererP.,
J. Chem.Phys. accepted (1995).
[19] Ackerson B.J. and Clark
N.A., Phys.
Reu. A30(1984)
906.[20j
Versmold H. and LindnerP., Langmitir10 (1994)
3034.[21] Grier D. and