Strategic analysis of petty corruption with an intermediary

Texte intégral

(1)Strategic analysis of petty corruption with an intermediary Ariane Lambert-Mogiliansky, Mukul Majumdar, Radner Roy. To cite this version: Ariane Lambert-Mogiliansky, Mukul Majumdar, Radner Roy. Strategic analysis of petty corruption with an intermediary. 2007. �halshs-00587715�. HAL Id: halshs-00587715 https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-00587715 Preprint submitted on 26 Apr 2011. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés..

(2) WORKING PAPER N° 2007 - 38. Strategic analysis of petty corruption with an intermediary. Ariane Lambert-Mogiliansky Mukul Majumdar Roy Radner. JEL Codes: D73, C73, 017 Keywords: petty corruption, intermediaries, game theory. PARIS-JOURDAN SCIENCES ECONOMIQUES LABORATOIRE D’ECONOMIE APPLIQUÉE - INRA 48, BD JOURDAN – E.N.S. – 75014 PARIS TÉL. : 33(0) 1 43 13 63 00 – FAX : 33 (0) 1 43 13 63 10. www.pse.ens.fr. CENTRE NATIONAL DE LA RECHERCHE SCIENTIFIQUE – ÉCOLE DES HAUTES ÉTUDES EN SCIENCES SOCIALES ÉCOLE NATIONALE DES PONTS ET CHAUSSÉES – ÉCOLE NORMALE SUPÉRIEURE.

(3) Manuscript Click here to download Manuscript: sapci3.pdf. 'CA0C4682 =0;HB8B >5 %4CCH >AAD?C8>= F8C7 0= =C4A<4380AH A80=4 !0<14AC">68;80=B:H "D:D; "09D<30A 0=3 &>H &03=4A %' %0A8B '27>>; >5 2>=><82B 2>=><82B 4?0AC<4=C >A=4;; )=8E4AB8CH 'C4A= '27>>; >5 DB8=4BB #4F ,>A: )=8E4AB8CH D;H '(&( (78B =>C4 A4?>ACB ?0AC >5 0 ;0A64A BCD3H >5 M?4CCH 2>AAD?C8>=N 1H 6>E 4A=<4=C 1DA40D2A0CB 8= C74 ?A>24BB >5 0??A>E8=6 =4F 1DB8=4BB ?A>942CB 027 1DA40D2A0C <0H 34<0=3 0 1A814 0B 0 2>=38C8>= >5 0??A>E0; =CA4 ?A4=4DAB DB4 C74 B4AE824B >5 0= 8=C4A<4380AH F7> 5>A 0 544 D=34AC0:4B C> >1C08= 0;; >5 C74 A4@D8A43 0??A>E0;B = 0 3H=0<82 60<4 <>34; F4 8=E4BC8 60C4 C74 <D;C8?;828CH >5 4@D8;81A80 C74 4@D8;81A80 C70C 0A4 B>280;;H 4O284=C 0=3

(4) C74 4@D8;81A80 C70C <0G8<8I4 C74 C>C0; 4G?42C43 1DA40D 2A0CBL 1A814 8=2><4 +4 2><?0A4 C74B4 A4BD;CB F8C7 C7>B4 5>A C74 20B4 8= F7827 4=CA4?A4=4DAB 0??;H 38A42C;H C> C74 1DA40D2A0CB. . #(&$)($#. (78B =>C4 8B ?0AC >5 0= >=6>8=6 ?A>942C C> BCD3H 5A>< 0 60<4C74>A4C82 ?>8=C >5 E84F C74 ?74=><4=>= >5 *..3 ),,/*.#)( 1H 6>E4A=<4=C 1DA40D2A0CB CH?820; 4G0<?;4 8=E>;E4B C74 ?A>24BB >5 >1C08=8=6 6>E4A=<4=C 0??A>E0; >5 0 =4F 1DB8=4BB 02C8E8CH 20;;43 74A4 0 *,)$. C> <0:4 BDA4 C70C 8C 2><?;84B F8C7 C74 ;0FB >= F>A:4ABL B054CH B054 2>=BCAD2C8>= BC0=30A3B 4=E8A>=<4=C0; 70I0A3B 4C2 (74 4=CA4?A4=4DA >A60=8I8=6 C74 ?A>942C <DBC >1C08= C74 0??A>E0; >5 4027 >5 0 B4C >5 1DA40D2A0CB 20;;43 74A4 C74 .,% >5C4= 8= 0 ?A4B2A8143 >A34A 027 1DA40D2A0C <0H 34<0=3 0 1A814 0B 0 2>=38C8>= >5 0??A>E0; ;C7>D67 4027 >5 C74 1A814B <0H 14 B<0;; 74=24 C74 03942C8E4 ?4CCHL C74 C>C0; 0<>D=C >5 C74 1A814B <0H 14 B> ;0A64 C70C C74 ?A>942C 8B => ;>=64A ?A>JC01;4 = C78B 20B4 0 ?A>942C C70C F>D;3 >C74AF8B4 14 42>=><820;;H E801;4 F8;; =>C 14 D=34AC0:4= (7DB C74 BHBC4< >5 1A814B =>C >=;H CA0=B54AB <>=4H 5A>< C74 4=CA4?A4=4DAB C> C74 1DA40D2A0CB 1DC 0;B> A4BD;CB 8= 0 3403 F4867C ;>BB 2>AA4B?>=38=6 C> C74 C>C0; E0;D4 >5 C74 ?A>942CB C70C 0A4 =>C D=34AC0:4= >A <0=H 42>=><84B BD27 ;>BB4B 70E4 144= A42>6=8I43 0B BD1BC0=C80; >A 0= 4GC4=343 8=CA>3D2C8>= C>.

(5) C78B C>?82 0=3 A454A4=24B C> C74 A4;0C43 ;8C4A0CDA4 B44 !0<14AC">68;80=B:H "09D<30A 0=3 &03=4A 0 74A405C4A A454AA43 C> 0B !"&0 = >DA ?D1;8B743 F>A: C7DB 50A F4 70E4 5>2DB43 >= C74 20B4 8= F7827 C74 4=CA4?A4=4DAB 0??;H 38A42C;H C> C74 1DA402A0CB 5>A 0??A>E0; >5 C748A ?A>942C +4 2>=B834A 0 B8CD0C8>= 8= F7827 0 B4@D4=24 >5 4=CA4?A4DAB 70E4 C74 >??>ACD=8CH C> 0??;H 8= CDA= C> C74 CA02: 027 4=CA4?A4DALB ?A>942C 70B 0 E0;D4 C70C F8;; 14 A40;8I43 85 C74 ?A>942C 8B 0??A>E43 (78B E0;D4 8B :=>F= C> C74 4=CA4?A4DA 1DC =>C C> C74 1DA40D2A0CB 8= C74 CA02: =>A C> C74 >C74A 4=CA4?A4DAB +4 5>A<D;0C4 0 3H=0<82 60<4 C70C 20?CDA4B C74 <08= 540CDA4B >5 C78B B8CD0C8>= 0=3 8= C74 2>=C4GC >5 C78B 60<4 F4 8=E4BC860C4 C74 4G8BC4=24 >5 0= 4@D8;81A8D< >5 C74 60<4 C74 <D;C8?;828CH >5 4@D8;81A80

(6) C74 270A02C4A8I0C8>= >5 C74 4@D8;81A80 C70C 0A4 B>280;;H 4O284=C 8= 0 ?0AC82D;0A B4=B4 0=3 C74 270A02C4A8I0C8>= >5 C74 4@D8;81A80 C70C <0G8<8I4 C74 C>C0; 4G?42C43 1A814 8=2><4 >5 C74 1DA40D2A0CB >F4E4A 8C 8B >5C4= C74 20B4 C70C 4=CA4?A4=4DAB DB4 C74 B4AE824B >5 0= 8= C4A<4380AH F7> 5>A 0 544 D=34AC0:4B C> >1C08= 0;; >5 C74 A4@D8A43 0??A>E0;B = C78B =>C4 F4 2>=B834A 0 E0A80C8>= >5 C74 01>E4 0=0;HB8B 5>A 0 <>34; 8= F7827 4=CA4?A4DAB 0??;H 85 0C 0;; C7A>D67 0 B8=6;4 8=C4A<4380AH '42C8>= = '42 C8>=

(7) F4 2><?0A4 C74 A4BD;CB C> C7>B4 5>A C74 <>34; F8C7 => 8=C4A<4380AH = '42C8>= F4 ?A>E834 B><4 C7>D67CB 01>DC E0A8>DB 4GC4=B8>=B >5 C74 <>34; = ?0AC82D;0A >=4 8<?>AC0=C 4GC4=B8>= F>D;3 14 C> <>34; C74 4=5>A24<4=C >5 C74 0=C82>AAD?C8>= ;0FB 0=3 C74 ?>BB81;4 2>AAD?C8>= >5 C74 1DA40D2A0CBL BD?4AE8 B>AB (78B C>?82 8B A4;0C43 C> B><4 >5 C74 F>A: >5 !4> DAF82I B44 DAF82I.

(8) '42C8>= 2>=C08=B B><4 1A845 181;8>6A0?782 =>C4B 0=3 C74 ;8BC >5 A454A4=24B. . $&"! $!'. B =>C43 01>E4 C74 =4F C74>A4C820; A4BD;CB 8= C78B =>C4 2>=24A= 0 3H=0<82 60<4 8= F7827 0 B4@D4=24 >5 4=CA4?A4=4DAB 0??;H C7A>D67 0= 8=C4A<4380AH C> 0 CA02: >5 1DA40D2A0CB 5>A 0??A>E0; >5 C748A ?A>942CB >F4E4A C> ?DC C74 <>34; 8= C74 2>=C4GC >5 C74 1A>034A A4B40A27 064=30 F4 BC0AC 1H ?A4B4=C8=6 0 <>34; >5 0 >=4BC064 60<4 8= F7827 0 B8=6;4 4=CA4?A4=4DA 0??;84B 38A42C;H C> C74 CA02: >5 1DA402A0CB F8C7>DC 0=H 8=C4A<4380C8>= +4 B70;; 5>;;>F C70C F8C7 0 34B2A8?C8>= >5 C74 >=4BC064 60<4 F8C7 0= 8=C4A<4380AH 0=3 C74= 0= 0=0;HB8B >5 0 5D;;1;>F= 3H=0<82 60<4 F8C7 0= 8=C4A<4380AH -#>C4 (74 <0C4A80; >= C74 <>34; >5 C74 >=4BC064 60<4 F8C7>DC 0= 8=C4A <4380AH 8B C0:4= 5A>< !"&0.. . #( " *($)( # #(&"&+. (74 ?;0H4AB 8= C74 >=4BC064 60<4 2>=B8BC >5 0 B8=6;4 4=CA4?A4=4DA # 0=3 0 B8=6;4 .,% >5 1DA40D2A0CB )B F8C7 0AA0=643 8= 0 B?428J2 B4@D4=24 = >A34A C> 64C 74A ?A>942C 0??A>E43 # <DBC 0??;H C> 0=3 ).#( **,)0& ,)' " ) ." )B #( ." *,-,# ),, 84 ) JABC C74= ).

(9) 4C2 5 C74 ?A>942C 8B A4942C43 1H 0=H >=4 ) C74 60<4 4=3B 0=3 # 3>4B =>C ?A>2443 5DAC74A 8= C74 CA02: 4A4 8B C74 2><?;4C4 34B2A8?C8>= >5 C74 4GC4=B8E4 5>A< >5 C74 60<4 !4C 34=>C4 C74 ?A>942CLB ?>C4=C80; E0;D4 F7827 8B D=85>A<;H 38BCA81DC43 >= B><4 2;>B43 8=C4AE0; F7827 F4 <0H =>A<0;8I4 C> 14

(10) (74 ?A>1018;8CH 38BCA81 DC8>= >5 C74 M?A8>AN 8B 2><<>= :=>F;4364 1DC C74 A40;8I43 E0;D4 >5 8B :=>F= >=;H C> # 5 0=3 F74= # 0??;84B C> ) B74 8=2DAB 0 2>BC >A 2>=E4=84=24 >5 4G?>B8C8>= C78B 2>BC 8B 0BBD<43 C> 14 C74 B0<4 5>A 0;; )B (74 2>BC 8B :=>F= C> && C74 ?;0H4AB 5 # 0??;84B C> ) ;4C 34=>C4 C74 1A814 34<0=343 1H 78< (74 ?A>942C 8B 0??A>E43 85 0=3 >=;H 85 C74 1A814 8B ?083 (74 1A814 8B 34<0=343 >= 0 MC0:48C>A;40E48CN 10B8B B> C70C 85 # A45DB4B C> ?0H C74 1A814 C74 60<4 4=3B C 8B 0BBD<43 C70C C74 )B 3> =>C >1B4AE4 C74 1A814B 34<0=343 1H C74 >C74A )B !4C >A 022>A38=6 0B # 3>4B >A 3>4B =>C 0??;H C> ) 5 B74 3>4B 0??;H B74 8=2DAB C74 0??;820C8>= 2>BC 0=3 ."( ;40A=B C74 <06=8CD34 >5 C74 1A814 34<0=343 1H ) !4C >A 022>A38=6 0B # 3>4B >A 3>4B =>C ?0H C74 1A814 #>C4 C70C 85 >A C74= C74 60<4 8B >E4A (7DB 85 F4 70E4 0=3 85 C74= 5>A 0;; 0;; C74 ?0AC >5 C74 60<4 8= F7827 # 5024B ) C74 (." -.* (74 02C8>= C0:4= 1H # 8= BC4? 8B C74 ?08A (74 02C8>= C0:4= 1H ) 8= BC4? 8B >5 2>DAB4 >A ;4C 34=>C4 C74 78BC>AH >5 C74 60<4 C7A>D67 BC4? 84 C74 B4@D4=24 >5 02C8>=B C0:4= 1H 0;; ?;0H4AB C7A>D67 BC4? BCA0C46H 5>A # 8B 0 B4@D4=24 >5 5D=2C8>=B F7827 34C4A<8=4 #LB 02C8>=B 022>A38=6 C> . . 4A4 34=>C4B 0= 4G>64=>DB 2>=BC0=C C74 ?A478BC>AH >5 C74 60<4 '8=24 ) 3>4B =>C :=>F C74 <06=8CD34B >5 0=H ?A4E8>DB;H 34<0=343 1A814B 78B BCA0C46H 5>A C74 60<4 8B C74 <06=8CD34 >5 C74 1A814 74 34<0=3B (> 2><?;4C4 C74 34B2A8?C8>= >5 C74 60<4 F4 <DBC 34B2A814 C74 ?;0H4ABL ?0H>P 5D=2C8>=B (74 ?0H>P 5>A ) 8B C74 1A814 74 34<0=3B 85 8C 8B ?083 84 .

(11) . (74 ?0H>P 5>A # 8B C74 E0;D4 >5 C74 ?A>942C 85 C74 ?A>942C 8B 0??A>E43 ;4BB C74 BD< >5 C74 0??;820C8>= 2>BCB 0=3 1A814B ?083 F74C74A >A =>C C74 ?A>942C 8B 2><?;4C4;H 0??A>E43 (7DB #LB ?0H>P 8B .

(12).

(13) 8=0;;H F8C7>DC ;>BB >5 64=4A0;8CH 0BBD<4 . . $C74AF8B4 => ?A>942C F>D;3 14 ?A>JC01;4 C <0H 14 >5 8=C4A4BC C> @D>C4 74A4 B><4 A4BD;CB 01>DC 4@D8;81A80 >5 C78B 60<4 0;C7>D67 C74H F8;; =>C 14 DB43 8= F70C 5>;;>FB B DBD0; 0 0H4B #0B7 +/#&#,#/' >5 C74 60<4 8B 0 ?A>J;4 >5 BCA0C4684B BD27 C70C => ?;0H4A 20= 8=2A40B4 78B >A 74A 4G?42C43 ?0H>P 1H D=8;0C4A0;;H 270=68=6 78B >A 74A BCA0C46H BCA0C46H 8B F40:;H /()'#(. 85 C74A4 8B => >C74A BCA0C46H C70C H84;3B C74 ?;0H4A 0B 7867 0 ?0H>P 5>A 0;; BCA0C46H ?A>J;4B >5 C74 >C74A ?;0H4AB 0=3 0 BCA82C;H 78674A ?0H>P 5>A B><4 BCA0C46H ?A>J;4 >5 C74 >C74A ?;0H4AB >A >DA JABC A4BD;C F4 B70;; 2>=J=4 >DAB4;E4B C> 4@D8;81A80 8= D=3><8=0C43 BCA0C4684B (74 JABC A4BD;C 8B C70C .", #- () +/#&#,#/' #( /()'#(. -.,.!#- #( 1"#" ." *,)$. #- **,)0 1#." *)-#.#0 *,)#&#.3 '44 -!"&0. 0B F4;; 0B -!0<14AC "09D<30A 0=3 &03=4A 1. 74A405C4A A454AA43 C> 0B !"&1 +4 =>C4 C70C 5>A C74 C74>A4< 8B E0;83 4E4= F74= (74 B42>=3 A4BD;C 2>=24A=B 0 50<8;H >5 4@D8;81A80 8= F7827 () **&#.) ." 5,-.

(14) ( "( () *,)$. #- 0, **,)0 BCA0C46H ?A>J;4 8= C78B 50<8;H F8;; 14 20;;43 0 (/&& -.,.!3 *,)5& #'% ?0AC82D;0A #'% 8B 270A02C4A8I43 1H ?0A0<4C4AB (74 ?0A0<4C4A A4?A4B4=CB C74 1A814 C70C # 4G?42CB ) C> 34<0=3 0=3 8C 8B 0;B> C74 1A814 C70C ) ?;0=B C> 34<0=3 (74B4 ?0A0<4C4AB B0C8B5H C74 2>=38C8>=B . 5>A . . (74 L BCA0C46H 8B 5>A # 0??;84B C> ) >=;H 85 C74 E0;D4 >5 74A ?A>942C 8B 0B ;0A64 0B C74 BD< >5 C74 2*. 2>BC >5 2><?;4C8=6 C74 CA02: F74A40B B74 ?0HB C74 ./& 1A814 34<0=343 >=;H 85 C74 E0;D4 >5 74A ?A>942C 8B 0B ;0A64 0B C74 BD< >5 C78B 02CD0; 1A814 0=3 C74 2>BC >5 2><?;4C8=6 C74 CA02: 85 C74 A4<08=8=6 )B 34<0=3 C748A ?;0==43 1A814B (74 BCA0C46H >5 ) 8B 5 # 0??;84B C> 78< 34<0=3 C74 1A814 B 8B 2><<>= 8= 60<4C74>A4C82 0=0;HB4B F4 F8B7 C> 2>=J=4 0CC4=C8>= C> 4@D8;81A80 8= F7827 C74 BCA0C4684B 0A4 8= B><4 B4=B4 2A4381;4 F7827 8=E>;E4B 4G0<8=8=6 C74 1470E8>A >5 C74 BHBC4< >P C74 4@D8;81A8D< ?0C7 (> C78B 4=3 5>A C74 ?DA?>B4 >5 C74 5>;;>F8=6 C74>A4< F4 J=3 8C 2>=E4=84=C C> A4?;024 C74 A4@D8A4<4=C C70C BCA0C4684B 14 D=3><8=0C43 1H 0 2>=38C8>= C70C F4 20;; '#--##&#.3 F7827 8B 8= B><4 B4=B4 <>A4 34<0=38=6 1DC 0;B> B><4F70C <>A4 2><?;4G C> BC0C4 8ABC -.,.!3 ) #- '#--#& 85 C74 1A814 34<0=343 8B BCA82C;H 14CF44= I4A> 0=3 >=4

(15) ,# *,)5& #- '#--#& 85 4027 )LB BCA0C46H 8B 03<8BB81;4

(16) -.,.!3 ), #- '#--#& 85 8C 8B 0 14BC A4B?>=B4 C> -)' 03<8BB81;4 1A814 ?A>J;4 >A 0 ) F4 0;C4A B><4F70C C74 34J=8C8>= >5 D=3><8=0C43 BCA0C46H = 03<8BB81;4 BCA0C46H 5>A ) 8B +/-#/()'#(. 85 C74A4 8B => >C74A 03<8BB81;4.

(17) BCA0C46H 5>A 78< C70C H84;3B 78< 0B 7867 0 ?0H>P 5>A 0;; 03<8BB81;4 BCA0C46H ?A>J;4B >5 C74 >C74A ?;0H4AB 0=3 0 BCA82C;H 78674A ?0H>P 5>A B><4 03<8BB81;4 BCA0C46H ?A>J;4 >5 C74 >C74A ?;0H4AB 8=0;;H ( +/#&#,#/' -.,.!3 *,)5& #- '#--#& 85 #LB BCA0C46H 8B 03 <8BB81;4 0=3 0=3 4027 )LB BCA0C46H 8B 03<8BB81;4 0=3 @D0B8D=3><8=0C43 $&" /**)- .". ), " ."( ." ),,-*)(#(! #- ( '#--#& +/#&#,#/' ( ), 0,3 0&/ ) )- (). **&3 .) = C74 <>34; >5 C74 3H=0<82 60<4 F8C7>DC 0= 8=C4A<4380AH F7827 F8;; =>C 14 34B2A8143 74A4 5>A<0;;H 0 ;0A64 2;0BB >5 4@D8;81A80 8=2;D38=6 B42>=314BC 4@D8;81A80 0A4 BDBC08=43 1H C7A40CB C> A4E4AC C> 0= #'% 4@D8;81A8D< 85 0=H ?;0H4A 34542CB #0B7 A4E4AB8>= (78B C>?82 F8;; 14 C0:4= D? 1A84KH 8= '42C8>=

(18) . . #( " *( # #(&"&+. = C74 >=4BC064 60<4 F8C7 0= 8=C4A<4380AH C74 # 3>4B =>C 0??;H 38A42C;H C> C74 CA02: >5 )B 1DC 8=BC403 B74 0??;84B 85 0C 0;; C7A>D67 0= 8=C4A<4380AH # F7> 270A64B 0 544 B0H # C74= 0??;84B C> C74 CA02: >5 )B ?;0H8=6 0 A>;4 0=0;06>DB C> C70C >5 # 8= C74 ?A4E8>DB BD1B42C8>= (74 8=C4A<4380AHLB 544 8B 02CD0;;H ?083 >=;H D?>= 0??A>E0; >5 C74 ?A>942C # :=>FB C74 544 145>A4 <0:8=6 C74 3428B8>= 5 # 3>4B =>C 0??;H C> # C74 60<4 8B >E4A 0=3 4E4AH ?;0H4ALB ?0H>P 8B I4A> 5 # 0??;84B C> # C74= # C74= 1468=B E8B8C8=6 4027 ) 8= C74 ?A4B2A8143 >A34A !4C >A 022>A38=6 0B # 3>4B >A 3>4B =>C 0??;H C> ) 5 74 3>4B 0??;H 74 8=2DAB 0 2>BC 0=3 C74= ;40A=B C74 <06=8CD34 >5 C74 1A814 34<0=343 1H ) 5 # ?0HB C74 1A814 C74 ?A>942C 8B 0??A>E43 1H ) 0=3 # 6>4B >= C> C74 =4GC ) 85 C74A4 C74A4 0A4 0=H A4<08=8=6 5 # 3>4B =>C ?0H C74 1A814 34<0=343 1H ) C74 60<4 4=3B 0=3 C74 ?0H>PB 0A4 0B 5>;;>FB >A ) 64CB 0 ?0H>P # ;>B4B C74 0??;820C8>= 2>BCB 0=3 1A814B 0;A403H 8=2DAA43 0=3 C74 >C74A ?;0H4AB 64C I4A> 5 C74 ?A>942C 8B 0??A>E43 1H 0;; C74 )B C74= 8C 8B 0??A>E43 1H C74 CA02: = C78B 20B4 #LB ?0H>P 8B C74 E0;D4 >5 C74 ?A>942C ;4BB #LB 544 #LB ?0H>P 8B C74 544 ;4BB C74 0??;820C8>= 544B 0=3 1A814B C70C 74 70B ?083 0=3 4027 )LB ?0H>P 8B C74 1A814 C70C 74 70B 144= ?083 608= 8C 8B 0BBD<43 C70C C74 )B 3> =>C >1B4AE4 C74 1A814B 34<0=343 1H C74 >C74A )B ">A4 5>A<0;;H +4 B70;; <0:4 0 2>AA4B?>=38=6 030?C0C8>= >5 C74 =>C0C8>= 5>A C74 ?;0H4ABL 02C8>=B !4C >A 022>A38=6 0B # 3>4B >A 3>4B =>C 0??;H C> # >A 022>A38=6 0B # 3>4B >A 3>4B =>C 0??;H C> ) 0=3 >A 022>A38=6 0B # 3>4B >A 3>4B =>C ?0H C74 1A814 34<0=343 1H ) A>< C74 01>E4 34B2A8?C8>= >5 C74 60<4 . . .

(19) . 5>A 0;; . . !4C #>C4 C70C C74 ?A>942C 8B 0??A>E43 85 0=3 >=;H 8= (74 ?0H>PB C> # # 0=3 ) 0A4 A4B?42C8E4;H .

(20)

(21) . . . . . . . . B =>C43 8= C74 ?A4E8>DB BD1B42C8>= 8= -!"&0 0=3 !"&1. C74 0=0;HB8B >5 C74 3H=0<82 60<4 F8C7 => 8=C4A<4380AH <0:4B DB4 >5 =D;;BCA0C46H?A>J;4 #'% 4@D;81A80 >5 C74 >=4BC064 60<4 >F4E4A 8= C74 0=0;HB8B C74 B4@D4=C8>=0; 60<4 F8C7 0= 8=C4A<4380AH 8= C74 5>;;>F8=6 BD1B42C8>= F4 3> =>C <0:4 DB4 >5 0=H 8=5>A<0C8>= 01>DC 4@D8;81A80 >5 C74 >=4BC064 60<4 0=3 B> F4 ><8C C70C 74A4. .

(22) +#" " *( # #(&"&+. +4 =>F CDA= C> C74 <08= A4BD;CB >5 C78B =>C4 F7827 2>=24A= 0 3('# 60<4 F8C7 0= 8=C4A<4380AH = C78B 3H=0<82 60<4 C74A4 8B 0 B4@D4=24 >5 4=C4A?A4 =4DAB # #( 0 B8=6;4 8=C4A<4380AH # 0=3 0 B8=6;4 CA02: >5 1DA40D2A0CB ) ) =C4A?A4=4DA # 70B 0 ?A>942C F8C7 0 ?>C4=C80; E0;D4 027 >5 C74 4=CA4?A4=4DAB 8= BD224BB8>= ?;0HB C74 >=4BC064 60<4 34B2A8143 8= C74 ?A42438=6 BD1B42C8>= F8C7 C74 B0<4 8=C4A<4380AH 0=3 1DA40D 2A0CB +4 4GC4=3 C74 =>C0C8>= >5 C74 >=4BC064 60<4 C> C74 3H=0<82 60<4 8= C74 >1E8>DB F0H B> C70C C74 02C8>=B >5 C74 ?;0H4AB 8= C74 60<4 >5 BC064 0A4 0=3 F4 ;4C (74B4 02C8>=B <DBC B0C8B5H C74 2>=BCA08=CB 2>AA4B?>=38=6 C> (74 >=4BC064 ?0H>PB 2>AA4B?>=38=6 C> . 0A4 A4B?42C8E4;H (74 3H=0<8260<4 ?0H>P 5>A 8B 0=3 C74 3H=0<8260<4 ?0H>PB 5>A # 0=3 C74 )B 0A4 C748A A4B?42 C8E4 C>C0; 38B2>D=C43 >=4BC064 ?0H>PB F8C7 0 2><<>= 38B2>D=C 502C>A +4 0BBD<4 C70C 0A4 8=34?4=34=C;H 0=3 D=85>A<;H 38BCA81DC43 >=

(23) . .

(24) . (74 ;0BC 0BBD<?C8>= 8B =44343 C> :44? C74 60<4 5A>< 148=6 CA8E80; 8=0;;H C> 2><?;4C4 C74 34B2A8?C8>= >5 C74 3H=0<82 60<4 F4 =443 C> B?4285H C74 8=5>A<0C8>= 0E08;01;4 C> 4027 ?;0H4A 0C 4027 BC064 >5 C74 60<4 &420;; C70C F4 70E4 0BBD<43 C70C F8C78= 0=H >=4 BC064 C74 )B 3> =>C >1B4AE4 C74 1A814B 34<0=343 1H C74 >C74A )B &460A38=6 C74 8=5>A<0C8>= C70C ?;0H4AB 70E4 01>DC C74 78BC>AH >5 ?A4E8>DB BC064B F4 <0:4 C74 5>;;>F8=6 0BBD<?C8>= .

(25) '')"%($# " *&3,- #( (3 )( *,#) %()1 ()."#(! )/. ." "#- .),3 ) ." !' #( *,0#)/- *,#)- ).", ."( ." *,0#)/- "#-.),3 ) ." .,(- .#)(- #( 1"#" ."3 #,.&3 *,.##*. E4= F8C7 C78B 3A02>=80= 0BBD<?C8>= F4 B70;; B7>F C70C 1420DB4 >5 C74 ?A4B4=24 >5 C74 ;>=6;8E43 8=C4A<4380AH 85 C74 ?;0H4ABL 38B2>D=C 502C>A 8B 2;>B4 4=>D67 C> D=8CH C74= C74A4 8B 0 50<8;H >5 4@D8;81A80 5>A F7827 C74A4 8B 0 ?>B8C8E4 ?A>1018;8CH C70C 0= % F8;; 0??;H C> C74 8=C4A<4380AH F7> F8;; ?0H C74 1A814B 34<0=343 0=3 C74 4=CA4?A4=4DA 0=3 C74 8=C4A<4380AH F8;; 1>C7 A4C08= 0 ?>B8C8E4 BDA?;DB >F4E4A 8= 2>=CA0BC F8C7 C74 >;:(74>A4<;8:4 A4BD;C 5>A C74 60<4 F8C7>DC 0= 8=C4A<4380AH C74 4@D8;81A8D< B4C <0H 14 1>D=343 0F0H 5A>< B>280; 4O284=2H F74= C74 38B2>D=C 502C>A 0??A>0274B D=8CH '8=24 C74 4=CA4?A4=4DAB # 0A4 38P4A4=C 5>A 38P4A4=C BC064B C74 3H =0<82 60<4 C70C F4 70E4 9DBC 34B2A8143 8B =>C BCA82C;H B?40:8=6 0 A4?40C43 60<4 #4E4AC74;4BB 1420DB4 >5 C74 0BBD<?C8>= C70C C74 ?A>942C E0;D4B 0A4 8=34?4=34=C;H 0=3 834=C820;;H 38BCA81DC43 C74 <4C7>3 >5 0=0;H8B8B 0=3 C74 A4BD;CB F8;; 140A B><4 B8<8;0A8CH C> C7>B4 5>A A4?40C43 60<4B 4=24 F4 B70;; F8C7 B><4 01DB4 >5 C4A<8=>;>6H A454A C> C74 3H=0<82 60<4 0B C74 -/*,!' +4 B70;; =>F 34B2A814 0 ?0AC82D;0A 50<8;H >5 BCA0C46H ?A>J;4B >5 C74 BD ?4A60<4 (74 4@D8;81A80 8= C78B 50<8;H F8;; 14 8=34G43 1H 0 E42C>A >5 ?0A0<4C4AB . . = F70C 5>;;>FB 8= 4@D8;81A8D< F8;; 14 C74 544 270A643 1H # 0=3 F8;; 14 C74 1A814 34<0=343 1H ) 4J=4. . . . . (7DB 8B #LB C>C0; 2>BC 85 C74 ?A>942C 8B 0??A>E43 1H C74 4=C8A4 CA02: (74 E42C>A 8B A4@D8A43 C> B0C8B5H C74 2>=BCA08=CB . . = 0338C8>=. . . . . . . #>C4 C70C. . 8E4= C74 ?;0H4ABL BCA0C4684B 0A4 34C4A<8=43 0B 5>;;>FB # 0??;84B C> # 85 0=3 >=;H 85 C74 E0;D4 >5 74A ?A>942C 4G2443B #LB 544 84 . . # 0;F0HB 270A64B C74 B0<4 544 5>A 0;; . .

(26) '0H C70C # 8B )*( #( *,#) 85 8= ?4A8>3 74 0??;84B C> C74 )B >= 1470;5 >5 # F74= A4@D4BC43 >C74AF8B4 F4 B70;; B0H C70C # 8B &)- # 8B >?4= 8= ?4A8>3 '0H C70C ) .- 8= ?4A8>3 85 5 # 0??;84B C> ) 8= ?4A8>3 C74= 74 ?0HB C74 1A814 34<0=343 85 0=3 >=;H 85 ) 3>4B =>C 34542C +8C7 C74 B?428J20C8>= >5 C74 BCA0C46H ?A>J;4 68E4= C7DB 50A # F8;; 0? ?;H C> # 85 0=3 >=;H 85 5 # 3>4B 0??;H C74= # F8;; 0??;H C> 4027 ) 8= C74 CA02: ?0H C74 1A814B 0=3 C74 ?A>942C F8;; 14 0??A>E43 +4 B70;; 2><?;4C4 C74 B?428J20C8>= >5 C74 BCA0C4684B 1H 34B2A818=6 F70C 70??4=B 85 C74 01>E4 B?428J20C8>= 8B E8>;0C43 0C B><4 =>34 8= C74 60<4 CA44 '0H C70C 0 -")% >22DAB 8= ?4A8>3 0C ) 85 74 34542CB 8= ?4A8>3 0=3 # )- ?0H C74 1A814 34<0=343 +74= 0 B7>2: >22DAB 8= 0 ?4A8>3 C74= # A4<08=B >?4= 5>A C74 A4<08=34A >5 C70C ?4A8>3 1DC A4<08=B 2;>B43 5>A && BD224438=6 ?4A8>3B DAC74A<>A4 85 0 B7>2: >22DAB 8= 0 ?4A8>3 0C ) C74= 8= 0;; BD1B4@D4=C ?4 A8>3B C74 ;0CC4A F8;; 34<0=3 0 1A814 4@D0; C> F7827 F4 B70;; B?4285H 14;>F $C74AF8B4 ) 34<0=3B C74 1A814 B?428J43 8= C74 E42C>A D=C8; 78B =4GC 34542C8>= 85 0=H +4 B70;; 20;; C78B 4=C8A4 BCA0C46H ?A>J;4 C74 C A4<08=B C> B?4285H C74 .",. ,#- 0=3 5>A C78B F4 =443 B><4 0338C8>=0; =>C0C8>= >A 4027 34J=4

(27) . . . . . . (7DB 8B #LB C>C0; MBD=: 2>BC 8= C74 2DAA4=C ?4A8>3 ?A42438=6 78B 3428B8>= F74C74A C> ?0H C74 1A814 0=3 8B C74 2>BC >5 0??;H8=6 0=3 ?0H8=6 C74 1A814B C> C74 BD224438=6 )B 8= C74 CA02: #>C4 C70C . . (74 C7A40C 1A814 8B 34J=43 0B . . #>C4 C70C. . +74= C74 ?;0H4AB DB4 C74 #'% BCA0C46H ?A>J;4 85 # 0??;84B C> C74 CA02: >5 )B C74= 78B >=4?4A8>3 ?0H>P =4C A4E4=D4 4@D0;B . . #>C4 C70C 1H . . .

(28) &$%$'($# (,

(29) --/'*.#)( # . . . ."( -.,.!3 *,)5& -.#- 3#(! #- ( +/#&#,#/' &$$ C 8B 8<<4380C4 C70C #LB BCA0C46H 8B 0 14BC A4B?>=B4 C> C7>B4 >5 C74 >C74A ?;0H4AB 8E4= C74 BCA0C4684B >5 C74 >C74A ?;0H4AB 85 8= ?4A8>3 # 34<0=3B 0 544 4@D0; C> 78B 4G?42C43 =4C ?A>JC 8= C70C ?4A8>3 8B (78B 8B <0G8<8I43 F74= 0=3 C74 2>AA4B?>=38=6 =4C ?A>JC 8B . . . #>F BD??>B4 C70C ) 34542CB 8= ?4A8>3 F8C7>DC ;>BB >5 64=4A0;8CH F4 <0H C0:4 5 # 3>4B =>C ?0H C74 1A814 C74= 74 ;>B4B 8= ?4A8>3 1DC 78B 4G?42C43 C>C0; 38B2>D=C43 ?0H>P 8= C74 A4<08=8=6 ?4A8>3B 8B B> 78B =4C 4G?42C43 38B2>D=C43 ?0H>P 8B $= C74 >C74A 70=3 85 74 383 ?0H C74 1A814 C74= 78B ?0H>P 8= ?4A8>3 F>D;3 14 >F4E4A 8= 0;; BD224438=6 ?4A8>3B ) F>D;3 34<0=3 C74 1A814 0=3 #LB ?4A?4A8>3 C>C0; 2>BC >5 64CC8=6 C74 ?A>942C 0??A>E43 F>D;3 14 . . . . . . 74=24 8C F>D;3 14 >?C8<0; 5>A # =>C C> 0??;H 8= C74 BD224438=6 ?4A8>3B 0=3 78B ?0H>PB F>D;3 14 I4A> 4=24 8C 8B >?C8<0; 5>A # =>C C> ?0H C74 M34542C8>= 1A814 85 >A. . . .

(30) $1B4AE4 C70C. . .

(31) . F7827 E4A8J4B C74 8=4@D0;8CH 8= C74 (74>A4< = 0=H ?4A8>3 ) B7>D;3 =>C 34<0=3 BCA82C;H ;4BB C70= $= C74 >C74A 70=3 85 74 34<0=3B <>A4 C70= C74= 78B ?0H>P F8;; 14 I4A> 8= C70C ?4A8>3 F8C7>DC 0=H 5DCDA4 14=4JC 8=0;;H 8C 8B BCA0867C5>AF0A3 C> E4A85H C70C => BCA0C46H 8= 0 #'% BCA0C46H ?A>J;4 B0C8B5H8=6 8B 3><8=0C43 4E4= F40:;H >A C74 )B C78B 34?4=3B >= C74 1A814B 148=6 BCA82C;H ?>B8C8E4 (78B 2><?;4C4B C74 ?A>>5 >5 C74 (74>A4< "& = C78B 50<8;H >5 4@D8;81A80 #LB 544 8B 34C4A<8=43 1H C74 E42C>A >5 1A814B 0=3 C74 <D;C8?;828CH >5 C78B E42C>A 8B 2>=BCA08=43 1H B C74 38B2>D=C 502C>A 0??A>0274B D=8CH C74 <>BC 4O284=C 4@D8;81A80 8= C74 50<8;H 0??A>027 0= >DC2><4 F8C7 I4A> 1A814B 0=3 C74 B<0;;4BC 544 B44 '42C8>=

(32) 5>A 34J=8C8>=B 0=3 0 38B2DBB8>= >5 0;C4A=0C8E4 2>=24?CB >5 4O284=2H "& +8C7 78674A 1A814B # A4248E4B ;>F4A ?0H>PB 0=3 C74 )B A4248E4 78674A ?0H>PB D? C> 0 ?>8=C $=4 20= E4A85H C70C C74 C>C0; 4G?42C43 38B2>D=C43 ?0H>PB >5 0;; C74 )B C>64C74A 8B <0G8<8I43 F74= C74 C>C0; >5 C74 1A814B 8B .

(33) "& = C74 E4AB8>= >5 C74 #'% ?A4B4=C43 74A4 >=24 C74 # 8B 2;>B43 74 8B 2;>B43 ),0, (78B 2>AA4B?>=3B C> F70C D<0== 70B 20;;43 0 6A8< ?D8B7<4=C BCA0C46H ;C4A=0C8E4;H # 2>D;3 A4<08= 2;>B43 5>A B><4 ?A434C4A<8=43 =D<14A >5 ?4A8>3B 0 ?0A0<4C4A >5 #LB BCA0C46H 2>AA4B?>=38=6 C> F70C D<0== 70B 20;;43 0 A4;4=C8=6 ?D=8B7<4=C BCA0C46H >A C78B ;0CC4A :8=3 >5 BCA0C46H >=4 20= ?A>E4 A4BD;CB B8<8;0A C> C7>B4 ?A4B4=C43 74A4 ?A>E8343 C74 ?D=8B7<4=C ?4A8>3 8B ;>=6 4=>D67. . $"%&'$# *( ( ' $ $ #(&" &+. = !"&0 0=3 !"&1 F4 BCD3843 0 <>34; >5 0 3H=0<82 60<4 F8C7 => 8=C4A <4380AH 10B43 >= C74 >=4BC064 60<4 34B2A8143 8= '42C8>= +4 B70;; A454A C> C70C 0B C74 #># <>34; +4 B70;; =>C 34B2A814 C74 #># <>34; 8= 0=H 34C08; 1DC 9DBC 7867867C C74 <08= 38P4A4=24B 8= C74 0BBD<?C8>=B 0=3 A4BD;CB 2><?0A43 C> C74 <>34; >5 '42C8>=

(34) C74 # <>34; (74 <>BC 8<?>AC0=C 38P4A4=24 8= C74 0BBD<?C8>=B 0B834 5A>< C74 01B4=24 >5 0= 8=C4A<4380AH 2>=24A=B C74 8=5>A<0C8>= C70C ?;0H4AB 70E4 01>DC C74 78BC>AH >5 ?A4E8>DB BC064B >A C74 #># <>34; F4 <034 C74 5>;;>F8=6 0BBD<?C8>= '')"%($#

(35) . ." !#((#(! ) *,#) && ." /,,(. *&3,- %()1 ." "#-.),3 ) && .#)(- # (3 #( && *,#)- /* .) ( #(&/#(! *,#).

(36) ( #.#)( && *&3,- %()1 ." "#-.),3 ) ) ." .,(-.#)(- #( 1"#" ."3 #,.&3 *,.##*. $1B4AE4 C70C BBD<?C8>= # 8B A4;0C43 C> BBD<?C8>= 1H C74 0338C8>= >5 C74 JABC B4=C4=24 0=3 74=24 8B BCA82C;H BCA>=64A 'C4<<8=6 5A>< C78B 38P4A4=24 8= BBD<?C8>=B # 0=3 8B 0= 8<?>AC0=C 385 54A4=24 8= C74 A4BD;CB (> BC0C4 C74 A4;4E0=C A4BD;CB 5>A C74 #># <>34; F4 JABC 68E4 0 74DA8BC82 34B2A8?C8>= >5 0 .,#!!, -.,.!3 *,)5& ('% (74A4 8B 0 E42C>A >5 (),'& ,#- +4 B70;; B0H C70C ) .- 8= 0 ?0A C82D;0A ?4A8>3 85 8= C70C ?4A8>3 74 34<0=3B 0 1A814 C70C BCA82C;H 4G2443B 78B =>A<0; 1A814 5 0=3 F74= 0 34542C8>= C0:4B ?;024 C74= && *&3,- 1#&& *&3 ." (/&&-.,.!3*,)5& ) ." )(-.! !' - .#)( #( && -/-+/(. *,#)- H BBD<?C8>= # 85 0 34542C8>= >22DAB 0;; C74 ?;0H4AB ;40A= 01>DC 8C 0C C74 1468==8=6 >5 C74 =4GC ?4A8>3 4=24 >=24 0 34542C8>= >22DAB 0;; ?;0H4AB A4248E4 0 I4A> ?0H>P 8= 0;; BD1B4@D4=C ?4A8>3B 5 0 ('% 5>A<B 0= 4@D8;81A8D< >5 C74 #># 3H=0<82 60<4 F4 F4 B70;; 20;; 8C 0 +/#&#,#/' ('% = 0 ('% 4027 1DA40D2A0C 0;F0HB 34<0=3B 78B =>A<0; 1A814 0=3 4027 ?A>942C F8C7 0 ?>C4=C80; E0;D4 C70C 4G2443B C74 C>C0; 2>BCB >5 0??;820C8>= 0=3 =>AA<0; 1A814B 8B 0??A>E43 45>A4 BC0C8=6 C74 =4GC C74>A4< F4 34J=4 0 2>=24?C >C 42>=><82 4O284=2H >A 4O284=2H 5>A B7>AC &420;; C70C C74 2>BC >5 0??;820C8>= >5 4027 4=CA4?A4=4DA # C> 4027 1DA40D2A0C 8= C74 CA02: 8B +4 B70;; 20;; 0= >DC2><4 >5 C74 60<4 6#(. 85 4E4AH ?A>942C F7>B4 ?>C4=C80; E0;D4 4G2443B 8B 0??A>E43 = ?0AC82D;0A 8= 0=H 4@D8;81A8D< F7>B4 >DC2><4 8B 4O284=C C74 1A814B <DBC 14 I4A> $=4 20= ?A>E4 C70C F8C7 B><4 0338C8>=0; C427=820; 2>=38C8>=B &$%$'($# ." (),'& ,#- , -.,#.&3 *)-#.#0 ( -. #- 3 ." )(-.,#(.

(37) . ."( .", 2#-.- -/6#(.&3 &,! -/" .". ), && ." #- ( +/#&#,#/' ) ." -/*,!' /,.",'), - ." #-)/(. .), **,)"/(#.3 .", #- -+/( ) +/#&#,# 1")- )/.)'- **,)" 6#(3 (74 2>=2;DB8>= >5 C78B ;0BC C74>A4< 2>=CA0BCB F8C7 C70C >5 (74>A4< B8=24 8= 0=H #'% 4@D8;81A8D< C74 544 8B 1H 0=3 0C ;40BC F7827 1H 8B BCA82C;H 6A40C4A C70= 4=24 85 C74= C74 >DC2><4 >5 0= #'% 4@D8;81A8D< 8B =>C 4O284=C $= C74 >C74A 70=3 85 C74= 5>A BDO284=C;H 2;>B4 C> D=8CH C74A4 0A4 ('% 4@D8;81A80 C70C 0A4 4O284=C = >C74A F>A3B 85 # 20= 0??;H C> C74 CA02: 0C ;>F4A 2>BC C70= C74 #B 20= C74= C74 >DC2><4 >5 0= #'% 4@D8;81A8D< 20= 14 4O284=C 85 C74 544 0=3 C74 1A814B 0A4 =>C C> 7867 >F4E4A 85 F7827 F>D;3 B44< C> 14 C74 =>A<0; 20B4 8C 2>D;3 14 0A6D43 C70C 8= C74 34J=8C8>= >5 4O284=2H B7>D;3 14 A4?;0243 1H +88C7 C78B 34J=8C8>= >5 4O284=2H 4E4= 0B C74 >DC2><4 >5 #'% 4@D8;81A80 0A4 1>D=343 0F0H 5A>< 4O284=2H.

(38) . $#!)# "& '. C F>D;3 14 34B8A01;4 C> 4GC4=3 C74 # <>34; 8= 0 =D<14A >5 38A42C8>=B C70C 0A4 14H>=3 B2>?4 >5 C78B =>C4 4A4 0A4 B><4 ?>BB81;4 0=3 8=C4A4BC8=6 4GC4=B8>=B. =2;D34 C74 >?C8>= 5>A C74 #B C> 0??;H 38A42C;H C> C74 CA02: >5 )B >F4E4A 85 C74 #B 383 =>C >1C08= 8=5>A<0C8>= 01>DC C74 1A814B 34<0=343 8= ?A4E8>DB ?4A8>3B 8C F>D;3 14 38O2D;C 5>A C74< C> BDBC08= A40B>=01;4 BD?4A60<4 4@D8;81A80 >= C748A >F= DAC74A<>A4 8C F>D;3 14 =0CDA0; C> 0BBD<4 C70C C74 #BL 0??;820C8>= 2>BC 8B 78674A C70= C70C >5 C74 # B> C70C 8C B44<B ;8:4;H C70C 0=H 4@D8;81A80 C70C 8=E>;E43 38A42C 0??;820C8>=B 1H C74 #B F>D;3 14 3><8=0C43 1H 4@D8;81A80 8= F7827 C74 # 383 C74 0??;H8=6 >=B834A <D;C8?;4 8=C4A<4380A84B 0=3 2><?4C8C8>= 0<>=6 C74< "D;C8?;4 8=C4A<4380A84B <867C 38P4A 8= C74 @D0;8CH >5 C74 B4AE824 C70C C74H ?A>E834 46 B?443 >5 0??A>E0; ?A>1018;8CH >5 34C42C8>= >5 1A814AH 4C2 =CA>3D24 B><4 BCAD2CDA4 >5 0=C82>AAD?C8>= 4=5>A24<4=C 8=2;D38=6 BD ?4AE8B>AB 0B ?;0H4AB

(39) *0AH C74 8=5>A<0C8>= BCAD2CDA4 2>=24A=8=6 C74 78BC>AH >5 C74 60<4 0=3 C74 E0;D4B >5 C74 ?A>942CB >=B834A <>A4 64=4A0; 38BCA81DC8>=B >5 ?A>942C E0;D4B 0=3 4E4= <>A4 64=4A0; ?A>24BB4B >5 4=CA4?A4=4DA 0AA8E0; =0;HI4 C74 4P42CB >5 E0A8>DB A45>A< ?A>?>B0;B &460A38=6 C74 ;0BC 4GC4=B8>= 8= C74 2>=C4GC >5 C74 #># <>34; B44 -!"&0 0=3 !"&1. #$*!"#(' (74 0DC7>AB 0A4 6A0C45D; C> %A0=01 0A370= A0=2>8B >DA6D86=>= %A098C DCC0 0=3 0H0=C0 &>H 5>A 74;?5D; 38B2DBB8>=B >= C74 BD1942C >5 C78B 4=C8A4 ?A>942C B DBD0; F4 0A4 B>;4;H A4B?>=B81;4 5>A 0=H 4AA>AB >A 103 8340B 8= C78B =>C4. . !$&% $(' # &#'. C7>A>D67 A4E84F >5 C74 ;8C4A0CDA4 >= C74 ?A4B4=C C>?82 8B 14H>=3 C74 B2>?4 >5 C78B =>C4 (74A4 0A4 >=;H 0 54F ?D1;8B743 60<4C74>A4C82 0=0;HB4B >5 8=C4A<4 380A84B 0=3 2>AAD?C8>= (74 <>BC A424=C 0??40AB C> 14 1H 0B:4A 0=3 $:C4= F7827 2>=C08=B A454A4=24B C> C74 ?A4E8>DB ;8C4A0CDA4 +4 0;B> =>C4 C74 ?0?4A 1H 0H0A =3443 F4 0A4 =>C 0F0A4 >5 0=H C74>A4C820; 0=0;HB4B >5 ?4CCH 2>AAD?C8>= F8C7 >A F8C7>DC 8=C4A<4380A84B DB8=6 0 3H=0<8260<4 <>34; >A A454A4=24B C> C74 <>A4 64=4A0; C>?82 >5 2>AAD?C8>= 0=3 C> 60<4C74>A4C82 0=0;HB4B 8= ?0AC82D;0A B44 !"&0 0=3 !0<1B3>AP >A 8=B867C5D; >1 B4AE0C8>=B >= C74 64=4A0; C>?82 >5 4=5>A24<4=C B44 DAF82I

(40) .

(41) &#' 0H0A (74 &>;4 >5 =C4A<4380A84B 8= >AAD?C8>= /&# ")#. 0B:4A 0=3 0=3 $:C4= =C4A<4380A84B 0=3 >AAD?C8>= C> 0??40A 8= ) )()'# "0#), ( ,!(#4.#)( DAF82I !

(42) <?;4<4=C0C8>= 0=3 =5>A24<4=C 8= =BC8CDC8>=0; ">3 4;8=6 8= + 0A=4CC 4C 0; 43B )&#.#& )()'3 (-.#./.#)(- )'*.# .#)( ( *,-(..#)( 0<1A8364 ) %A4BB 0<1A8364

(43) DAF82I ! DC +7> +8;; D0A3 C74 D0A380=B 2>=><82B 4?C ) >5 "8== "0H

(44) D=?D1;8B743 !0<14AC">68;80=B:H " "09D<30A 0=3 & &03=4A 0 M'CA0C4682 =0;HB8B >5 %4CCH >AAD?C8>= =CA4?A4=4DAB 0=3 DA40D2A0CBN ) 0&)* '(. )()'#-

(45)

(46)

(47) /////// 1M%4CCH >AAD?C8>= 0<4(74>A4C82 ??A>027N C> 0??40A 8= (.,(.#)(& ) )()'# "),3 !0<1B3>AP " (-.#./.#)(& )()'#- ) ),,/*.#)( ( ),' 0<1A8364 )=8E4AB8CH %A4BB 0<1A8364 ) .

(48).

(49)