• Aucun résultat trouvé

Answering French Questions in English by Exploiting Results from Several Sources of Information

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "Answering French Questions in English by Exploiting Results from Several Sources of Information"

Copied!
13
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)Answering French Questions in English by Exploiting Results from Several Sources of Information Brigitte Grau, Gabriel Illouz, Laura Monceaux, Isabelle Robba, Anne Vilnat, Guillaume Bourdil, Faïza Elkateb-Gara, Olivier Ferret, Benoît Mathieu. To cite this version: Brigitte Grau, Gabriel Illouz, Laura Monceaux, Isabelle Robba, Anne Vilnat, et al.. Answering French Questions in English by Exploiting Results from Several Sources of Information. 5th Workshop of the Cross-Language Evaluation Forum (CLEF 2004), 2005, Bath, United Kingdom. pp.470–481. �hal00444444�. HAL Id: hal-00444444 https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00444444 Submitted on 12 Jan 2020. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés..

(2) 

(3)     !#"$ % &('*) ",+-.% / 01&.%2&34  5 6798  :;%<67= 9>?3 @ 34=

(4) 5A:BC = FD EHGJIKGMLNLNO;PB]nEHmNQSQSRUZXTWO!VX\J\aPYO;QSo9Z[`KEHGJZ[O!Zf\^Q ]_T\J\aVf`SpR[bch[TdhfVfOreq Q4R[Ga\JE/hfQ Q4Lg.T `Shfi O!QSRkj[lcV PBR[Ga\a\aQSR[stO;Du`KR[E/vkGJ\wTWVfxXQ!yzab!Q {

(5) \a|cQcLHO Zk}nPYQ4E/Q~T!VU\aGa€~GaO ExfO EHENO LHYQ4hXv‚DFO hf`dƒzJLg„QcLH [GJO!Rf †t‡XˆŠ‰Œ‹ nŽW~f‘’‡fˆ_“*n”4¢«ªnˆŠ•—˜¬–&£ ˜F­r‰F¥W”[® ¯’‘S£ ™C­ršœ¥°F›2!± S­r‘k¢ ž4®›/²aŸW  W?¡un¢n£/¤t–&¥/¦K¥H§ ³ ‡fˆ_–´W“‚‘k–Cµ¶

(6) ¨d•Š‡X© ˆ_n”S¢«ªn·F˜¬‘’£ ™&­rš¹¥W® ¸S¯’‘~£!žd­r´!¥2´!°F¸Wº;©½/¥2»K£SŽW®© ²J¯c ªn¥/¯’£/¤4•Š£!S§S•¼‰ŽW¢_¥/¢ ¾ ‡XˆŠ˜¬¶ ‘~´ nK¥¦K¥¬n¢«±M£Bªn˜¬¿u£!¨dŽW­r© K¥!¢_®¢ ¯~© ¯ £!©Á­r¥HÀ n¥¥W°F‘k±™&¯’šÂ£4® žd~´!¯ ´! WÃ4•¼¯’‘’£ Ÿ!¯4ŸdªnW¥HW¢/´Y® ²J ˜¬£!¯cªn¥/¢u–&¥2¦S¥H§= ¨d© © ©ÅÄ nªÆ;·CÔK‰uÇ^¥µ&È/­rÉ/– ÊŽ!˒† ¯~‘^Ì!Ž!ÉWÕ

(7) ± © Í ¯KÔK‹W¡F¥H’nS¥ £ Y±kŽ!¢«Î K¤S©r¢«± ©ªn¯~Îk¥/‹!­Ö¥/’¢«ªB£!Õ ±Fn© ¥/ªnϬÔr¢_~¶ÐÕ

(8) ±ØªnÔ¢Y¢«¤K© ½×ÕC¢«Ôrªn¥N¥HnÕC­1¥t¥ŽWԒ“ ÎS£ ª×Ñ9Ä £ ¥

(9) ”K¯~–C’¥2£‡U¦._µÒª Õ

(10) © »&½ Ô~© ‘ ’¥H©£ ¯Ù¢;ªn¥/Õ&Î~¦ £!¥ ¢_© ¯Y¥2½/¦„Ž!ªn­BÔKŽW¥uߐS¯KϬn¥2¥ ¦¶FÄ4© ‡ÓŽ!ªnÔ~–u~¥¢ ‘ n½/¥/Ž!¢_±Å±MK¥H±Ø½Hªnª ¢rŽWŽ!¯²9²a¢_Ž!¥ Ä ¥H£!×¯K£!¢«±

(11) ÕC¢_¥H¥2n£¢/n‘X½NÔK£!¯~¥/¢/¦7®C¢_» ¥H©½/nŽW¢«¯~ª2‘&¦7ϬªnÔ~¶F¥ ‡Uܜ–$µÒ¢_¥2©™u£ ®[n½×ÜÔ~¥/¥B¦ÚÝW¥/£ÛKnª¬¥/ªn± © Ô £ Î~¢¬±Å¥Û¢«ª_×¦K£ Žc© ªn½H¥/~‹ ­r¤Û¥/²Þ¯cŽ!ª –Ô~C£!‡X¯’µ¦S»&±Å¥&‘K© ­Bn¥HKªnK±Øª n±¯ ¯~© ¯K‹!‹B’£ ª—Õ&± ªŠŽB¤nÎc~¤¬¯K¢/ª_×®~£ ˆŠ¯~¯=¢_ªn±M£ ÔKª ¥¬¯Kß~‹Fn¢«ªnª

(12) Ô~¥ÒŽW¯Kªn¥H¥Wn‘~­rÕ&¢ ¥9¦K­r¥HŽ4¯4¦ ª © ß~ߒ¥2¥/¦¦tϬ¯© ¶FªnÔ~‡U¥&–¹à4K¢_Ž;¥/¢«£!ª ¢ŽWªn¯fŽ ® ˆŠŽ!¯ÎKª×ªn£ Ô~¯K¥Y¥2¢_¦ ¥H½/ÎcŽW¤=¯~© ¦‚ßK© nn¢«~ª

(13) ¯fª_‘X×£!© Õ&¯~¥r¢_±M£½/ŽWª ­¯K‹YÎ © ªn¯~Ô~¥2¥¦Ûàc© ªn~Ô~¥H¥B¢«ª n¥HŽ!¢_¯X~‘S±Øªnªn¢Ô~¥/Ž ¯ ²© ªn£!Ô~K¥B~±Ø©ßK¤ n¯K¢«ª‹B© nªn~Ô~¯‚¥¬Õ²a~© ±Åªn±^ÔϬªn¶uÔK© ŽW‡Ó¢_– ¥ ¢«~ª_£ ×ª £ªnŽW© ¥/¯?‹!¤ ½/ŽW© ¯S® ¥!ß~®’n¢_­r¥2£¢Ònªn½NÔ~Ô ¥

(14) © ¯K²Á‹r£!½NÎkªCŽ!ªnªn© ԒÔ?£ªCªnÔ~ªn¥¬Ô~¥½/Ž!Îk±Å¥/±M¥H¢«½HªCª n©© ŽW¥/¯Û¢_K£!±Øªn¯~¢¦=£ nªn¥uÔ~¥uŽWÎKܜª×£ µ© ¯~™¥2®’¦;·CÎcÔK¤Y¥¬½/ߒŽ!¯’­B£ αX¥ ¯ Ä £ ¯K±Å‹ • © ©© ¦ ©Åá ¥N© n¥/¯cª

(15) ¢_ŽWKn½H¥/¢uŽ ² © ¯K²aŽ!n­;£ ª © Ž!¯X® â ã~äåkæ[ç9èé êUå[ënçä QO 4 h[GaìXsõIKO!GJh[hkGaOWm?}«v[mFLN`SLN`Ús* fQ4öfQ4L9hfGahîv÷ENO íLNì[R[ENR[EHOWO!h‚im×GÞLNm×ï9GaO`S fh[Q4`S}«hf\ap OBmNhfïFvkm×`kO ïFE/i m;O R[EHstLHGah[`ÚO I<h~ø~LHR[ð—m!íBO!ùkm×úÖpBLNGañ*`S [hXO GÞm7m?hGaQœLHhŒ [IKO!hXENmNQc`cOYLNï9RfO Gah[EHh[QSIKIò\uGJh[\ÞQ4OWQ4EHm9h[O!IKQ4QÂRf\Þm×`SQ4` ó;IKEHOSENOVOWLNm×R[RfOWh[ENQ4h\aE/GJ|Ki/m× ôOh[GamNì[ï9O!ìU [QSOEH`KL/i/mNm O V ISGJQShþGamr€~ï9PBGah[ [`’ItGÞ`Si/Q4IS ÷h\aO!ïF4Q4VÓhfOmNLNïu [QSENO!O!OûÙE!ùfm×Q4RkGasüÿÛh[OYi QcGJi/O!LY fhKì[QSLH\J\JEHûŒ\a`cO €~h[iGÞIK`SvkOh[Gah[öXGaI=h‚vkO ýnLNh~Rf [LWmnGÞmFLHù GMöU¬ öfi O fQc\ÞOvLHGJ`KQSi`Sì[hfhXì[mBm×EH`4GÞ`Kmnó¬QSL/mFi/vk ÷`kGJh‚iïuR[öfstOhfO vkvkh~GaO h[L/€KmItO \aE/`S`SQchfìULH\JO! [û*v÷O `KEBGJh[hÖLHOB fíBQ4QSh7hfp mNýne ïuRfO!mnLE V `SENO!R[\JEBGÞQ4stZ[Ga`S\aGMh[Lnû`K\JGa`4h[ó

(16) ISQ4RXh„Q4\CQS{

(17) hfmNh[ïuIKO!\JGÞEm× „Z’ûø~R[mHOWimn`KLHENGJGa`Kh[hÚI*QSGJLBhfm×QSïFi!iO `KEHGaEHh[vkI7Gah[mNI û’m×LNLN`ÛO!sLN [VUO=i |~`SGahfhfmNv.Gam×LH`SmóGa|~hÙhf`cO!ï9m×LN\JGaOWs*vkQcISLHOrGJh[`KI‚ELNLN f fOO |~Q4hGahfO v.hf`Svkó`KISì[O!ENh[`k`Si O!RfmHmCm9OWRfmnLHmNGJO!s*vQ4ówLN`SGaE`Sh GML/ï9m GMO!LH\a QSZXEH`KO!mNEHìUQ4LNO!Gai2`SLhLHù `BLN`c [ïFOO i €S`SO!\a\JE!OWVki2ïFLNGaOr`Sh ów`Kï¬R[hfQSmCvh[LH`S fLQcmNL RkìfÿÛEN`ci€’GaO GÞh~vkLWGJhfù IY¬ ’ýnRfRfmnm L V ³†Ôc·Cª_‰Fªn µ – 2Õ¥ Ä Õ£!Õ9±Å’® £‹!ª Žc© ŽWŽ!‹!¯~±M¢u¥!®£ ½HnŽW¥9­ ½2£ ­r’£ © ‹!¯~¢

(18) Ž!n‹W£!¯ © ¢_¥/¦tÎ4¤rªnÔK¥9˜Fˆ«”K· SÔcª_ªn  2ª_n¥/½W® ¯ © ¢«ª2® ‹WŽ Ä.

(19) wóïuiEN`SOB`KsthKvkLstO!LNi `S [GahÙvkOOWLNENv*`OWm×LHZUR[`=\J`4LHQ4LNm

(20) ìf Âì[ì[mNEN\Jût`S`cR[€’`KGÞE/R[vkiEFO!OWvm mNûk`cZ’mn€Kû LHO O ZXEBs `SR[LNh[`S 7h‚GÞøKmNRfQ4`Sh[R[O `SE/`KiLNh[OW [m O!O!ùSm!EuúÚVÓmNO `SOB€KR[O i/E/hÙ [iO`KGJmNó`SO¬óÒLHLN [|’ [Oth[O!`c\ah*Q4ï9L×LN\aLH`;O!O vkEYó¼QdIK f€SO`SQSGJRfv¹h7E`SQ‚ì[E/EN [vk`KO GJIKìXE Ú`~LNm×`tmHGJLNiiGa`K`S`SENhXh[OKm} ù O Duv[h[Q4OW`Khfi R[QSi ISû*Rf m×`4O V’óïFm×LHRXOB [i/OYi/ Ú fúÚ`KEHO!mNO!QKOZ‚m×LN`K\a fO!h[QKOBGJv*hfú¹I7LHO `?Q4Zì[öfìfQShXm¬\Jv‚GaO!mNmBQ=O!i ZU\J`S`SOhfLFL×v‚LH`SO óm×Er`KQ4GJR[hXóEHm×LHi ïF [OSO O*ù’E/g.m m×V’`K`SQSR[EHmFEHO i `cïFO!€KmOBO EW`4i!V4óQ4LHh|’ [h[Orm×O!`cvkOï9GJ€KGa\ahO!O v[E/ ISm×GJO=«LnVû*QS EN Q4Othf«v7vkV

(21) G EN UOWO!vkENQSR[O!hfh~hkv L} —ù. Í ’Í ·CÔ~¥9±M£ ¯~‹W~£!‹!¥/¢uŽ!¯ ªnÔ~¥uÜ¥/Î. 

(22)  . GJi h[`SI¹h~LH]_LHOh [j’O.FL!ùeúÚg.{O!`Kx÷Z$ENO!O ð¼`c€cGŠ€SQ4ù OSO!\aùRfE!VUQcGML/LHïumtGJ`KOtENhOWs=VkvkLHRfR[ [mnhfO;LYv[ì[L/QSQ4EHhf`S|SiZ[Otû[\añO GaVh~s LNGa`.mtGam9`KQSh[i!LN`Ûi\Jû÷`SQSRfvfO!hK ÓQ4LBO!ìkLNi2L fLHGJLHOt€K [Oó¼GÞmQSGJi2hômnLYLHEHLH{

(23) Q4 fh[LNQcO!IKLrIS\JGÞûÛLHmN [ Gah„O*V

(24) QSGJQth~m LHs?O ì[EHR[EHO!`c\Jm×LN€SLYGa\aOWGJGav[h[h¹l7IKRfRfZ’Q4mnû }\ xQSmBGaISm×RfOWENQ4O"E/i/S [ùGJhf¬ I*~RXLN [m VÓOtm×{

(25) OWQ4hfE/ISi/\a [GamNGa .h[I*úÚLN fO!ZO ù^xfx[EN`KO!E#hfi/F „eú¹{xôO ZÙO ïF€cQS`S\JRfRf\aQ4v.LNGahf`Sh`4LVUïFIKGJO=€KO=vkO!QK€SmO \amN`SGJIKìUh[O!GJvÙöXi g QShK$&LB%'ENFOWm×eRf{\ML/x m mRf×ð¼g.GÞm×mnGaL/h[R[m¬Ir\JLNGJhGaLH\a [GJQ4h[O!hXIKmNO9Q4Rf\aQ4LHû~\(EHb!QSGJ%’hfhfûkm×I?mn\ÞLHQcLHO LH [sO!Orv=x[ówLN`SEHO!O E)ENhfs*Fi/m

(26) eÒLN{ø~`?R[xmNO!ñBO!m×QSLNï9EHGa`Si/ [h GÞi/V~LN òLH fEHORfQSmNhfENO!O m×mYów\ÞO QcLnEHLHïFO GJhfhf`„I i O m×+NLNiGJE/h~`KQcLN\JLNO!\aO!O!ENISiOWGaLNmnO!GaLH`Sm!GJù*hhfI=¬ ùKg [ìfO*QS$&E×öX%fL/-mEHíB,fm×L;.p VkQ4YV`Shfh[~vÛO‚ï9LNi [ [`SGÞO!i/h[h } LNGaïFmE/QKQ4`Sm hfR[mNìUEu\aQ4`Ks?LNmHGam×R[h[Ga\JZ[ILN\aGaOLN\JGa [h[LNO9IK fRfø~QSR[Q4h[\XO!|km×sm LNGaLH`k`S0` vkh=RfFGJ\JhtOK{uVS{

(27) pów`Khfñ\JISVX\a`c\aLHGaï [mN ?O mChÒRfLNV fmNGaQ4Gah[mFì[Irmnì[LHQ \aEHû’Q4ì[GJhfLNEHO!I.`4ISówûSOWíBmNù/pmN¬ Ga`Se [hfO QSV^mN\KO!`S€KiRfO `KE/Ehfm×v*GaO `Sj’h;m×GÞLNm×`SE/LNQcóGah[LN%’O!I‚ûkISm×stû LNE/`KiQ4`Sh[hhX`Sm×\aðwGJGÞï9hfmnL/IS [m

(28) RfGÞi/GaQSh \ m×ûkm×LNO sVcGahfi\aRfvkGah[ILN [O¬ú¹O Z*mNO!Q4E/i/ ù¬ [OFöfE/mnLmnLHEHQ4LNO!ISûri`KENEHO!mNìX`Khfv[mÒLN`Y`SRfEöXEHm×L&EHR[hV ¾9Îk·CŽWÔ S© ¢

(29) n¯~ߒ¥ ‹WSSՍn¥ÕÕ9© ¢® ~¥H§4~ª_ÎK×± £!½N½N•Šªnk¥2¦=Ž!± ²a½Nn¤cŽ!®­ K¯ ªn­rÔK¥ ¥/±Å–&ÎX¥/® ¥2¯c¦Sª_Xn¥¬® £!²Þ1Ž 9¥/š‹!Ž ~Î~¥H± n© ½ ¯’£ šÓ¯~ŽW½/± ¥2© ½H ¤t’£ Ž k²^¥HªnnÔ~¢3 !¥!ÑF ¯ ”S©ÅÄÝ ¥H¦Kn¢­r© ª—Ž ¤?n¥WŽ!® ²[“¦S² ¥H±Å• © © © Ä ©.

(30) nLï9ïu [`tGJp9\aOtstóÁLNïu`SO!h[OtE‚`KvkGa\Jh~GaGÞh[v„LNIKEH`kRfLH [vkQ4OÛRf\ÓiEHmNGaO!O!h[mNiIœR[`K\MhfL/`Kmrv„R[E7ðwEHZ[R[QSEHhÚ`cì[ïì[ï9EHmNGMGJ`KLHh[QS ÚIti/ þLHZU [`4LHO*LH`œ ‚i`Ks?LHs? [R[O;Z[\JLNGaiGahf\a`KGJQch[\JLH\aIKO!GJ`KiRfLNhÙQ4Ga\a`SGÞ`Shm×ó

(31) sQ4LNVF [hfOtv7ïuO„s=LN fR[ìfOr\MENLHúÚOWGJ\am×GaO!O!h[hKZXISL7ñ2Rfù QSLN [\

(32) OÚQ4hfISvÙ\a`SLNZf fQSO \ LNQ4 [E/i/Or [s=GMLHR[O!i\MLHLNGJR[\aGaEHh[OrIS`4RfóQS\g st$4`k%'vkFR[eÒ\aOS{uù xîðŠg $&%XíB.p ÐQ4hfvÙíBpe ¬ñVUQShfvLN [O!hÙvkO LHQ4Ga\5g $&%fíB.p YV 6 7 & é 8_å[3ë 8Në×:ä 9<é ;.8×-ë =1>@?BA<Dë CFEGæ EÒäuIå HKJ&J æ[ç ;Cê L<E*= ]_¬ h.[íOÙR[öXOWEHmnm×LHLGJ`K`Khh[p OÚhfi mN`SïuhfO!mNENGÞmnGah[L/m‚IfVkGah,mNO €KRXO m×E/GaQ4h[\ÓIþm×`Kst\JRkQKLHi/GJ [`KGahfh[mFO„OLHjkEHGÞQSmnL¬hfm×ów\Þ`SQcELHGJv[`KO!hÖQ4\aówGa`Sh[E‚I=LNï9 fGJOÂLN ø~s=R[OWR[mn\MLHLHGJGJ`K\aGahh[ù¬ISRf]_h<QS\JGÞLHmN [sGam ù öfì[EH\JGam×O!Lv?i ï9QKm×GMLHOK [VK`SLHR[ [LCOrQSQSh~vkûB€cQSsthK`kL/Q4vkIKGMöUOi ówQc`SLHE¬GJ`KRfhm¬ù GÞ¬ mF[LNO XQcs*L9Q4`SýnR[`SE¬EÒìfstEN`S`KhfZ[`S\JO!\aGJs h[IKGaRfmQ4LN X\ÓQcmNû’L&m×QSLNRkO!LNs `Ks*s*QcQdLNûtGÞiLNLH [EHO!QSh‚hfmNZU\aQ4O;LNQ4Ga`Sì[h } vkQ4hf`’mNO!ïumuO!h[EN`4GaL9h[I vkO!mNûkQS\UmnLHi O `Ss*EHENm!OWùdi2gÙLH\JûQSi/ï9 [GaGMh[LH ‚OuLNvkE/GÞQ4mHQ4hfs?mN\aQ4ZfLNGJIKGa`SRfh;QcLHGÞmGJ`KLNh* [O9ì[ENmN`K`SZ[\aRk\aO LNGas*`Sh?m

(33) Gaïuh7O¬`KQSìXvkO!`Khkìk}«LNv[OW`Sv?s*QKQ4mGah7QZfø~R[QSmNO!GÞm×iLNGa\a`SGJhfh[O } ówì[`S\JE

(34) O LNLHO [i 4O `SF\a\JeOWi2{LHGJMx `Kh=N?`Só^i!v[Q4st`’i ìfR[Q4stGaISO hÒh~ùLHm!¬ ù4[]_O h mNLNO! fi Ga`Smuhfm×v*OWimN`S`ShX\aRkv LNi!Ga`SQShÛmNOSi Vd`SLHhf [mNO9GÞmnLNL/E/mQ4hXGJhÛm×\ÞLNQcE/LHQ4GJ`Khfh=mN\as*Q4LNQdGah[û;IYZULNO fISORfiGa`Kvks OWv } Z~GamBû LHLH f [QcOLYi LN`S fh~OtLNO i j~`SLW\a\JV~OWQSi2hfLHGJvt`Kh¹LH [mNOBGJb!mNO=ûkmnGÞLHmYO hÚs LNvkGas `’O!OWmumYh[GML/`4mYLFGJ fhfQdGM€SLHGaOQS\

(35) LN`?\JO!ZUh[OYI4LHi/ Ù fQ4ówh[`KEYIKO!hÚv^ù~\ÞQ4p<h[IKs*RfQcQ4ýnIK`KO!EuPm OUvkE/p Qdh[ï9`4ZfLHQK [i/O | E \avkð¼QKx[GMmnÿÛEHL9O i hXm×R[`Ki/\M ò\JLR[LNì[GJGahœEN`S`Kh7`KZ[R[GÞ\amuO E?s LNi!` QSGÞmNì[mOWEHìUñ2`’V&`Ki mNQ4O O!hfOWvv*v¹Z’LNLH`=ûÛ [O LNLHh f [OYO;LHQS`.GasthfLNQ4ìXE/\aQ4`~ûkhXmNm×mNGÞm×muGJ\ÞZfQc`4GJLH\aóOÛGMLnLHû7`S [h[OBLN\a`*û„ø~R[LHLHEHOW [QSmnO7LHhfGJmN`KGa\ahkh7Q4ówLN`KGaOBh7ENs*LNLH [ [QcO?OrLHGJï9`Km×`Kh [R[`Sì[E/\aOriENO `kúÚvk\ÞQ4RXO!hfiZQISO!OvÂRf¬ QSZ’fISû OO LN`S [h[O7\aû7QSLHhf [Q4O;\aûkLHm×O GÞEHm!s*ù]_m9hòLN XLN fQcGaLm=QSm×EN`KO?\JRki LH`SGJhf`KmNhGÞVvkO ïFEHO7O!vvk`„Gas hfìU`4`SL;ENLHLHQSENh~ûÚL LNZ’`„û7`KLHZk [LHO=QSGJQShòhfQ„Q4\aûki m×`SGÞstmì[Q4\aEHOOYLHO*LNE/LNQ4E/hXQ4m×hf\ÞQcmNLH\ÞQcO!LNv^Ga`SùXh*]«L R ówGam`S\aLN\J`c fï9O GamNh[`SIt\aRkìfLNQ4Ga`SE/Q4hÚIKïuEHQSO ì[ fQSvkm!V~`KQ4ìkóÁLNLNOWO!v.E9ówì[`KENEOWm×`KO!R[h~EYLNGas?h[I R[\JQSLNhGa\JGa`ch[€SIKO RfEHQ4€’\CGJO!stïÖ`k`4vkó&R[LN\aOS [VÓO;ï9g5 [$&GÞi/ Ù%'FïFeO={vkx÷O LHmNQ4ûkGamn\CLHGJO hÚsLNù fO æ 9ë #çYX"7[Z]\:^M_a`cb LNìX¬ Ga`~`S[mNh÷O;mNGJISZfQS\ahf\J`SOtQ4ZX\aQ4Q4ûkhf\Òm×mNGÞQSmrïFEHi/O st [E/m `kGJLNvkGaOWh¹R[i2LH\aO‚mNR[O ENQ4\aOrO!Gais*`SLNó

(36) OWm=v„g Q4Lìf$&QKvk%'mNOWFmHvkQ4eRfIK{O!i m GJxŒh[QSIÚGahfm i/v.GJ f\a\aLHQ4Rf`E/mnQSLHENiEHO LNQ4ówO `SLNEHOWEHGÞs?vmnLHR[GaGJi!h„\ÞmrQcx&LHï9O=GaIS [ø~R[GÞR[i/EH œO!Oem×LNdks*GaùX`SQdxhXûÚmGaE/ [mnGahÚLWO!Vf\JìœQGJLHmBLNvk`„OWøKiRföX\ÞQ4O!hfENm×v }} QcQ4LNEHGaOr€SO=LN [ówO `SEHø~sR[O!vkm×LNOWGavk`SGÞhi QcówLH`kO!iv„RXm LNVX`LN [LN [O=Ots*ú¹Q4GaO h„Zò€SmNO!O!ENQ4Z„E/i/QS „hfv.O!h[m×ISû’Gah[h~LHOQKðŠi2PBLHGa`’i?`SENIKO!\J\aOdQ4ñ2LNùQGa`S¬ hf[m¬OWówm×`KOtE i/st fQ4`kE/vkQSGJöfiLNO O!E/ENm GÞùUmnLHú¹Gai!O m ówLN`’Ga`Si hRfùmNO!x[v„`K)E `KR[FEeLN{E/Q4]x hfmN\aN¹Q4LNGai `SQSh„s fO ìX UQ4`KGaISE×L/hmBV`Sïuh„OLHvk [O O!€KmNO O \a`SO ìU\aO O!stvœO QÚh~LHh[m!V^O ï QSm€KOO jkE/ì[m×\ÞGaQ4`SGahòh[O!`SvÙóGJLNhÙ fGaLNm [stO `kh[vkO j~R[L;\aO7mNO!ów`KiE} øKRfO!m×LNGa`ShfmGah7xfENO!hfi/ ù/¬ fO Q4hfQS\JûkmNGamCGÞm

(37) ZXQSmNO!vtj `S dht—ù[LH [xfO`SE9EHO!LHmN [R[O;\JLHQ4mhf`SQSóU\JûkLH [mNGaOm¬xf`SENóO!LHhf [i/OY *LN€SE/O!Q4EHhXmNm×Ga\Þ`SQch LHO!`4v ó g D] hCVkLH [OrEN`KZ[Rfm×L m×û’h~LHQKi2LHGaiBìfQSEHmNO E¬`4ó g O!EN`dM OLn øKû~€cRfìUQ4O!\aO*m×RfLNQcGaGÞ`Sm;LHhGJQ`KV~hÂïuhfQ4`4O stóFRfLNO!m× [Ov¹OÛ]nO!.x xfhK%iENLHO!GMhCLnhfûKV~i/ùÒQS òh[x[`4øK`KLHRfEY [O!LNO m× [EuLNOWGaEN`Sm×`Khò0O Z[Rf/Q4Phfm×LuQS\JmNø~ûkû~R[mNh~GaO!L/mYm×QSLNsti2GaLH`S`kGahfi vkm!R[ìfV^\aQ4EHO*E/O!mNi ówO `KQSE

(38) E;\J\`SøKGÞQó FmRfg O!jm×O /LNEHGak`d`SQj hf QSmrfhf—ï9ùSvÙúÚ fìf`KOBENmNOWOts*iGÞQSQSm×hfGavk`SmNO h¹ïuQSO!Gah mE jlk7ù m×OWQ4E/íi/ R[ùÓO EH]_GJhÚOWm;LH [Q4O*EHO*\ÞQSh[m×`SL?L;i LNQS [mNOOSVÓmNïFQSstO*OtRfmNówOt`SE;gÚLH4P [OÛm*ú¹ów`SO ErZ÷EHOmNLHO!ENQSGaO EH€’i/ òGah[I‚QShfìXv¹QSmHów`SmNQSErISLHO! [m!Ocù^x[F`KeE;{øKx$RfO iEH`Kû~\JGa\ah[O!IiLNLNGa`S fh O “ oþ²ÞŽ!¬“t£!¯~£!‹ © ¯Ka‹ o © ‹d£!Îc¤4ªn¥/¢

(39) Ôcª_ªn  2ÕÕÕ9® ½/¢/® ­BX® PŽ pW® £!i ­r‹ n ) S. TVUE GU 3EW.

(40) NLúÚ [O!OrZo9ú¹VkOïuO LHENZOBGaO i/EH€KO! [O!vk`’vrR[`KvkhXmNO`kv[iQ4LHRf`hfs i mNûÛO O!hfh~ïFv‚LH`Sm&Q?R[Q4\ÞEHhfv‚OO!QSLNQ4 [\JEHï¬\aO!û h?QdûkO ì[mFj[EHQSì[`ki2ENiLu`cOW€’mNów`SmNGÞO!vkEHv^s?OYù R[vk¬ \Þ`kQc[iLHO R[GJûr`Ksth7QSO EN`Sh~OuóL/ENm LNO ù [}—OYGahfQ4vkhXO m×j’ïFOWvYO E¬Z’QSûmHLHm× [RfOus ø~Gah[R[I?OWmnLNLH fGJ`KQ4h L LN|~O GahfEHs*v÷m`4QSóhfLHvO EHLHst [m=O GaEYów`K\JR[Gah[hfISvœRfGaGahœm×LNGÞLHi; [€cO Q4sEHGÞV

(41) Q4mNh~`ÚLHm!QKVfm;EHO LH`K`¹EHvkmNO!O EN\aO!OWiv.LtQSQ¹i!im×`SRfE/Zfvkm×GaO h[L It`SLNó9`‚LNLN [ fO!O?sh’Yù R[q s?Q4ZUstO EYOWvœQ4hXO v.h~LHLNGM fLnû O ENQ„OWiïF`SO IKGah[ISGJ ~LNLNGaGa`Sh[hIÚì[mHEHi/`’ [i O!O!s mHm×O7OWm `4óQSENLHOY [OLH [mNO O h¹h~LHQ4O ì[hfì[i \aO!GaO!m!v^VÒùów`K¬ \J\a[`cO?ïuOWQSvÂhfm×Z’ïFûÚO ELH [Oj’OLNQ4E/QShfimNLNïuGa`SO!h.E?O ì[j~EHLH`kEHiQKOWi2mNLHm9GJ`KEHhòO \aGaGMO!L/mm×O!`K\Mónh ù LNúÚi [`SOO!hXs m×Q4GÞmnì[L/\aì[O!m;\aQKû.GavkhŒGavkh[i

(42) G I. U`SO!stLNEN`ÙO!ìfhKQ4ì[LBEHENGa`Kì[h[ìXEHIf`’`~V^i m×ówO*O!`KmHE?ïFm×OWLHO m [GaISOÛQS ~i!LHLHiO!EH`KQSvòEHhfvkQ4mNGa\ah[hXQ4Itm×LNïFO!LHvòO `ÛE/m ø~LNù fR[O?x[OWmn`S|’LHE=GJGJ`KhX`Shfv.R[m!E VF`4ó

(43) m×ðŠQKOWO iñ«j’LH`KìU [hfO!O7v¹iLNEHENOWO!R[v„mNhÒR[Q4\JVÒLHhfLHm=mN [ïFGaOÛmHO mNEWöfR[V[hXO!O!v¹Q4QK\ui/ówm×EH .LN`SO!s`4ì ó LNð¼ [i!ñ

(44) OYLNi f`KO \J\aO!EHO!imNLNR[Ga`S\MhL/mV^GÞðwmHZUm×ñ«R[LNOW fvtOBówEHEHO!`SmNs R[\JLHLNmF [OBGÞmNmNs?R[R[O!\Jv*LNGaów\aENGJh[`KIKs RfQ4LN [\ÓOYmNû’ú¹m×LNO O!Z‚sQSV~hfQSv^hfvÛV~ów`Si`KEFstLH [ì[O RkLNLHGaEHh[QSI hfmNQY\aQ4öfLNhfO!v*QS\ULNmHO iEH`Ks*ENOKm Vù ]«ì[LHENm*`KìXì[`~EHm×GahfGJLNiGaGa`Sì[hX\aO.m V’ïFO €KQKO mthLNï9`òGJLNZU `’`KENm×O!L7\aQ4LNQ4GahրSO!Q4\Jû*hfmN\aïF`cïîO EtmHGMió;`KENQSOW\Jm \9ù LH [O„i/ fQSGJhfmÛEHQSh[|SOWv÷GJLÛGJhôLH [OLN`Krì . 2 lists of ranked answers (Collection). Collection. French Questions. Question analysis Answer type Focus Semantically linked words Syntactic relations Main verb Terms. English questions. Search engine. Document processing Reindexing and ranking Selection Names entity tagging. English Answers. Answer extraction Sentence weighting Answer extraction. English terms English Translation. Fusion. Web. Ranked answers (Web). Í [Í “ Ñ9”~–C‡Xµ»„£n½NÔ © ªn¥H½HªnKn¥. Ys Pt. ÷é Så[ë×çäyxÙæ[ç9êE*=1=’ë×ä:9 `4p Q4óFh÷m&ø~stQSR[RkO OWLNh~mn`KLHLNstGJGa`K`SQ4hfh[LNmBOWGÞvriÛLN XGaLHh=QcEHL?QSmNhfO!i i2mNQSLH\ahÚQ4GJ`KLNhz`SZUE;O*SówV!s*`SLnEïFQcL/`LNi/E/ [mNQ4`SO!hf\avÚmNRk\ÞLNQcï9GaLN`SGMGahfLHh[ òmIÙïFvkø~O `kR[EHiOWOR[mnLNstLHOWGJ`KmnO LHhfh~O!L/m?vrm ówù*ówEN`K¬ `KEs fZfO=R[xföXGJEN\ÞEHvkO!m×hfGaLrh[i/IY œ`Sh[QLHOt`ÚEHO s*ì[{Q4EHh[O!|KISmNO!O \amYGah~mNLHRf ÷Q4mNLNOtQSGahf`S`4vh ó LNi [`SO!hXhm×GÞV¬mnL/ìXmrO!E×Gahœów`KENQ4s*hfQSm*\Jû’LHb [GaOÂh[I.Q4hfø~QSR[\JO!ûkm×mNLNGaGam7`ShX`4mrórGJLNh fOÙLH [LHO7EHQSmNhf`Sm×R[\ÞE/QciLHOtO!vÖ\ÞQ4ø~h[R[IKOWRfmnQ4LHIKGJ`KOShfVm ï9(ù f¬ Gai/[ ÂO¹GÞm×m?OWx[i`SEHO hXhXv<i/ ¹m×`KGa\JhòR[LN`SGa`SRfh E i Q4QSEHOYmNOSi V[`SQShfhfmNv‚GÞvkLNO E/EHQ4O!hfv‚mNQS\ÞQcmFLNGaLNh[ fItOrGas h`~LNmn [LOYGastL/Q4ìXEHIS`KOE×L/L9Q4\Þh~Q4L9h[IK`SRfh[Q4OWIKm ùOSVkï9 [GÞi/ Gam {

(45) h[IK\JGÞm× ÒV’LN [`~m×OYLHO EHstm9LN fQ4L u. v <Ew=.

(46) {*|~}. "€* ‚ƒ „GP†ˆ‡"‰Š„G‹Œ ˆ„i †ˆ‚Ž‹r‚:z€w‘1ŒPP†~‚‹Œ. {*| Ÿ. ‰‘jŠƒ¡‰Š„G‹ŒP~„iP†~‚‹. ¬ øKRf~O!RXm×m LNVGa`SLNhf [m

(47) O‚QSöfhfE/vtmnL*vk`kmN`SiR[\aRkstLNGaO!`ShKhœL/mïFEHOÛO \aGJLHOWO!mm×LN`SOWh vòLNów f`SO EtQ4mNRk`SLH\a`S€~s*Gah[QcIÙLHGaLNiF [LHOEHQS\aQShfh[mN\aISQ4RXLNQ4Ga`SISh O7`4s ó^GÞøKmNRfstO!Q4m×LNLHGai/`S œhfm!ZUù4O]_Lnh*ïFO `SO!Rfh E GJi øKh~QSRfLNmNO!O!OSm×E×VLNó¼GaQKLN`Si [hfO

(48) GÞmm;ìf`4Q4ENó^`cR[€’LNLN fGÞ`SvkO#s*O!FvBQ4LNeZ’GÞiû“{xÚLN%kE/û’Q4O m×hf€cLNQ4mNE/\aQ4\aQ4RfhLNQc”cGaLH`SùPGJh¹q `Kh7` ïFQ4QSQKEHv[mYO9v[ìXh[GMLHO!`SGJE×`KLuówhf`K€SENQ4O!st\~ENûtvkOWGavÚii`KLNZ’Gast`SûÙhfì[QSLN\JO [ENjtûO"ïFów%1ENQK`K’“m^s%iRf9omNQ=O!m×v^p&û’ùWh~q p LHeÒmQKi2GJsth[LNGÞ|k`Ki m×m?QSLÒ\f`S`4ìUh[ó’`S\aLNGJGahf fh~OOL `4QSóCm¬€~EHO GaO \aGaï$QSZ[Q4\JhfOKV[vQSQKm¬v[Gavk\J\aEHRfO!m×mHLNmuE/QcIKLHO O!h[v‚O!EHZ~QSû‚\xm×RfGaISZkRfýnO!ENi#O LHm![V’ù LN [O!GJE9LHEHQShfmN\aQ4LNGa`Shfm¬i QSh`4óÁLNO!hZXO;i `ShfmNGav[O EHO!v  W W ! ! W WžBžB•&•ÜòÏF’ÔK£ ¥/¯’¯t¦?¦ ¥/¢«¦?ªuªn£!Ô~~¥9~µ£ nÎk=ŽW±Mk£ ŽWKn~±M£B¢

(49) S£!Kn¥/k­ ¥2£ ©Á¥HÀ

(50) n²a¥FŽ!²ÞŽ ªn© ¢uÔ~¥F±Å¥ ßKÄ4n©¢«nª~ª ¢­rµÒÎk¥2• Ž!±M£F• © Ä4© ©  S S›/›/¸W¸W¸B¸B•&•Üò¡ tÀ ÔK¥H¢_n¥¬¥ ª_n¢Ž! ¿FÄ £!¥F± ¿¬²Á££!§1± • © ²Á£§z• © © Ys PÍ –[Í µ§K£!­rK±Å¥/¢Ž!²½/Ž _n¥/½Hªuàc~¥/¢«ª © Ž!¯ ª_×£!¯K¢_±J£ª © ŽW¯ iGJ hfQ4m×h„LHQSmNhf`cO iO=ïFOKO GM<V LB€S+/O!GJíhÚE!V&RfxLHO EHGa\

(51) ISQSRfOWhfmnENmחLOe\Þ,QcNfLHmNGJù`K [¬ h÷`KfR[stO!\av¹mNGÞO?mnZUL/stQ4O*|SGaLNOWm×E/LHmtQ4QShXs*|Sm×OWQd\Þm9Qcû÷LHs*O!Q4v¹Qd\Þûm×`ÂQSi 0m `S`k+Nhfi úÖi i R[O [EHEth.`.ów`Sm×Gaû’E‚˜m ,.h~m×LHGaQ4Q4sthXjì[vÚRX\JGJO„hfh¹`4ø~ø~L?R[R[QSOWO!mnm m×LHLNGJ+×Ga`K`SúÖhfhVm! [V

(52) GÞi/lQS ÂmtówGaïF`K˜m ,OE GaQ4øKm¬hfRf`KvÂO!h[m×LNGa\JhœGaû*`Sh ìXø~Q4R[ENO!lLNm×GÞ‚LNQ4Ga\a`SQ4\JKhû*I~Q4LHPGaEHh™jQS(VkhfV^+×mNGE\aLHQ4O! [ž LNQSOÛO!\JGÞv'ì[mHœcQc fù[LNEHO!DFQKR[m×Rk—EšO L¬,tLN+/Ga [ímBOW*R LHm×EHOY› OWQSmnsthfLNm×}«Ga\Þi m×QcOÛLHLHQSO!øK|SvÚRfOWmFPO QS,[cmQSV\amN+×LN` EH fO!Q4stQSL?\JQdGab GaûÛm=O!˜E i m×,Û`SìUhfO!ï9i i [O GMöUEHGJ\ah‚itOÛmNLNQ4O `Ùh¹s*ø~Q4Q4R[hfh~OWmNLHmnïFGaLHi!GJO mf`KEYRkhfGaGam!h m V søKRf`KO!ENm×OFLNGa\a`SGJ|KhVO \aPûr™jLN*`YQ4ZU\ÞmNO¬`*ów`SGJ\aR[\JRXhfmnv=LHEHGJQ4óULNGJLO!mGam&LNLH [EHO=QShfì[m×EH\Þ`SQcZ[LH\aO!O v s>QS4m `4ó+Nv[LH [GJEHO?O!iR[LNhX`Si—E `S,st`K“E ì[\a+nOöfLH\aO s h[OWvkmNm GaENOW`4i2óLHvk`SGޗE i2,[LHùcGJ`Kx&hfGJhfQ4EHQSGa\JO!\aûSm!VV ówï9\aQ4`S [LNE O!GaQKi/v ŒiEHQK`SGam)mth’+×û’GaúrststìX Pm R.`~4mN+/mN,.BGaZ[Mg ð¼\JúÚO‚`KLN,.`ÂEN\Þð—vciGaÒEE/EHiIK/R[QSQ4s=vkhfO=Ga€SmHO Qch~LHEHGJL `KIKh‚QSówR[h[g.\aGa\Jb!ûœ`KQchfLHGaGJhŒvk`KGÞhXQ4QSñ2\ahŒO;VWýn`KvkRfìXR m×LO!uhkQK}_`Sm)vkst`S+/s*st4Q4&pO E/Ga:h÷iOdq&mNñ¬ûk,tm×mn [GaLHm¬`KO sR[LHEH\ÞQSVvhfO!ZXmNmN\aOrìXQ4OWLNLHiO!EHGÞQSvQ4hf\aQK\Jm×û m} +-q . p 4, Gah.øKRfO!m×LNGa`SMh fN/fù HLì[¢ Q4ENG

(53) GaO! Uh[€’O!OWGJENvÙ`KO!Rfh~Z’mL ûÚmNstO!Q7i2OLHLNLNGJ fE/`KQ4`’hhXvfV[m×m LH\ÞQc [i LHO;QSGJ`Kh.EHhÚO!ZXø~ZfO?R[QKGaRfENm×OWm×OWOWvv„vLN`K`’LNh¹`Û`S\ÞZfQKmGJi/\avk [GJhf`7GJO!ISh[€SRfOY`4QSL \LHO EH`SEHO!h~s QSLN\J`K\aû7LH\J`KEHQSO ISjkhfGaO!Gam×mPm×\ÞL Qc£XLHZ[GaGJh„`KR[hL?`Sù[ìUQSo9O mYhkOWst}_m×vkR[O `K\Jh~LHstLNm GaQS`Ss*GJhfhÒQdO!ùfû7vÚpZUGJsth¹O?`SLN`Shf fZ[IO } LNGJh [O;RfmN`SGJLNh[ [IrO!E¬QLNZ[E/GaQ4\JGahfh[mNIS\ÞRXQcLNQ4Ga\[`SvkhGÞi2ìULH`KGJ`KmHhfm×GaQ4Z[EHGaûY\JGJLNLNGa`BO!m!LNV[E/ïFQ4hXO;m×\ÞiQc`SLHhXOm×LHGÞvk [O OFEHLNO!O v7EHs*LN fm&O;ówENO!`KQKs m×GaO!LNm× fL9O¬`SmNh[`SOKRfV[EHï9i Ou [\ÞGÞQ4i/ h[IKi Rf`SQ4hfIKmNO

(54) GÞmnLHL/` m ¤uÜ¥¬Õ&ŽW~±M¦t± © Ýd¥9ªnŽYªnԒ£ ¯~Ý ”4¤S¢«ª_×£!¯ ²aŽ!uªnÔ~¥£!½H½/¥/¢_¢uªnÔK¥H¤=‹ ©ÅÄ ¥9ªnŽr~¢

(55) ªnŽBªnÔ © ¢¢_¥H Ä4© ½/¥ © ¯ ªnÔK¥ ½/ŽW¯cªn¥H§4ª

(56) Ž ²^ªnÔ~¥9¶u‡Ó“t¶ŒSnfŽ ¥—¥/½Hª2® ¦ ™¤7ªnÔ~¥BÕC£2¤c‘fªnÔ © ¢ŽWÎK¢_¥H Ä £ ª © ŽW¯.¢_ÔKŽÕ

(57) ¢9ªnÔ~£ ª£!¢²ÞŽ ~£ _ª_•¼Ž!²J•¼¢_k¥/¥/½×Ԫף!‹!‹W¥Hn¢Ž! ¢«¤S¯4ª×£ ½Hª © ½ ¢«£!¤S¯~¢«£!ªn±Ø¥/¤ ­rp/¥H¢Cn¢/Õ

(58) ‘cÔ àc© K±Å¥9¥/¢«ªnª Ô~© ŽW¥H¯~¤?¢£¢_nÔK¥ ŽW‹!~¥/±M¦ ¯~¥NÎk×¥£!±Å¢_±Ø¤k¥/¯K½ Ž!© ߒª2®½2£ ±Å±Å¤ª×£!Ýd¥H¯ © ¯cªnŽ¬£!½H½/ŽWK¯4ªÒÎc¤ ­;£!½×Ô © ¯~¥ª_×£!¯~¢_±M£ª © Ž!¯.

(59)  S S›2›2§W§Wºº•&•ÜòÏF~Ô ¥H±X½×Ô ¥/¢«ª¢

(60) ±Åªn¥¬Ô~¥F¥2¨ £ n¥/± © £!¢n±£ªnp/¥/¥HKuFŽ!²<¦K¥ª©—˜ ©Š˜ Ý © Ý ª×£f© ª×«£P• «a•  S S›/›/¸d¸dºº•&•ÜòÏF Ô~¬ ©£ ¥/¢«ªFª_¡9•¼©½/“*¥àc.– K• ¥¬ ± ¬ ¡9© “*­– • © ©  S S›H›HŸdŸdBB••Òˆ—µ¯?¯*Õ

(61) àcÔ ~¥/½×±ÅÔ ±Å¥¤c£!¥2¯K£¯¥/¨ ÕC¥9£!£®¢

(62) ¥H½H¨ ªn¥9¥2¨ £½Hªn¥/¥1¨ ¢¥/¨ ¥9˜¬± ¶Ò¬ ¡¬·

(63) ·ÓB¡ ¶• ˜¯• © Ys !Í °UÍ µ^§K£!­r~±Å¥/¢

(64) Ž ²^­ © ¢«ª×£!Ýd¥/¢ © ¯*àcK¥/¢«ª © ŽW¯=ª_×£ ¯~¢_±M£ ª © Ž!¯ LNZ[ [\JO OYLNL/` Q4EHvkISGJOEHL9O!i\ÞLNQ4\ah[û*IKvkRfGaQ4mHIKQ4OSs=Gù Z[¬ GaIS[RfGÞmQ4LNmNO9GJstLH [ì[O \aOr€cstQ4EHOGa`SLH [Rf`kmv‚s ìfOWENQ4OWh[m×GaO!h[hKI~L/m

(65) mF`4Lnó^ïuLH`Û [O v[EHïFQd`Sï9E/Zfv[QKm

(66) i/LN|k`;mfR~ZUGMO LLHGam9EHQSGahfstmNìX\aQ4`~LNmNO!mNvGJ} V Q4mnLHhfEHv QSGJLHh~ [LYO9GamBLnïF€S`;O!EN\aGJQSöfh[OWISvRXówQ4`SISEBOWmCLN fs?OtRfi m×`SLR[ZUìfO \JOt`SóÓ{

(67) OWh[ø~IKR[\JGJGހcmNŽ QS\J±cO!xfhKENLuO!\JhfO i/j’ GÞi VfQSïF\[O EHGaRfi/ [m×OWhfv„O!mHLHm [/ù GÞ%kmGJhfsti O OLNLH [ [`kGav^mQù \aQK`mn‚LFiIK`SGJ€Kh[O } Q4i`Sh¹EHì[GavkRfOWmYQ`S`44ó ó LH² [/O*‚Q4ø~s=R[Z[OWmnGJIKLHGJR[`KGJhfLNGamrO!mBGahÂïu{Oth[s*IS\aQdGÞû„m× ¹O!hf`4Bói`K9oR[h~LN{ O EYùGah¹p9Q„óÁLNO!íBE?p Q4hXiQ4`K\ah~û’LNmNOGÞm j’V^LWVUïFïFO*O*|SO!mnLHìkRfaL vkGaO!/vÚ‚LN f`4O ó LNl’ [ù /#O YGah7™/dú¹N `SïFE/vG`SqE/v[O mCL!Rfùi¬ mNO![v=OBGJh Oj’LHLN [EHGaO ms*iQ?`SEHïuì[RfO!ENm!Oeù ¬ =[ðwOO j[QdQ4€KstO E/ì[Q4\aISOOR`4³ŽóU´fµiLN [¶-·O9¸s·-h’¹R[ºˆs=»—¼ZX¸¼ñFO!EQ4`4hfóÓv"s OW7Q4ð¼h[OGaj[h[Q4I~stmCïFì[\aQKOm R ½ ¶-´—¼ ¾[ñ2ù[p EN`KR[hfvtLH [OYQd€SO E/Q4IKO9€cQ4\aR[OSV’ïFOów`SRfhfv7i `Sstst`ShÛïF`SE/v[mmNRfi/ QSY m ¿Ž¶2º

(68) À ´2Á ½ ¸

(69) · ·PÂÁ ·¶~¹j¼³º

(70) ÀP¼Ã~ºˆ·³f1ù O!hfiOKV4ïuOi `SR[\Þvth[`SLi`ShXm×GÞvkO E

(71) Qrv[GaiLNGa`ShfQSENû;IKGJ€’Gah[Ir`Shf\Jû=`Sh[O9stO!QSh[Gah[I ówGJh`SEu`SQ?RfEïuíB`KEHp$vV4i st`Sh~`SLNEHO O j’`cL!€Sù O!EïuOh[O OWvkO!v*LN`?vkO öfh[OBQ;stO!QKm×R[EHO`SóULH [O €cQS\JR[O`4óÒQYLHEHQShfmN\aQ4LNGa`Sh LNs [GaO h[úÖ`K`S\Jh[`KGMLH\aISGa òh[GÞøKO LNRf [v[OdOWDTGam×iÇ=OLNGa`K`SiE;hf`KQShfx[ENEHmnGaLHO O!EHPO m QSEGJð¼/h~mNQ4L/Rfhfm i/VmN Ú\aïuQ4QKLNOGamY`Smnh¹o9LHRfO THvk€KTGaO ñO!E/VÒvÂm×Q4`jhXLHÄd [v„VO%kLHû’v[ [m×GOÛLN ÓE/O vkQ4EHGÞhi2O LNÅ4h~GaVL `SPBhXv[Q4`’GaiEH`SLNGJISOWGa`Sm\aOPhfRfÆ4QSVhfEN¢vkGaO!O GÞm?E?i2LNïu“PGa`SO7huhfi hfe÷`SQ4R[Ga\aENGÞ\ÞivòOªO hXORfi mNO!OENm} R D`4uð¼mNLNR[Rf fLi/O 7EYLN [QS\JO!Gamustû=g„GMEHL/O!QcQ4mNLHIK`SGJGa\a`Ki€Sh¹È} Ou¢ï¬LNGÞ [i QSOT×m QSLH`Ss? [E O Z[$Gaó¼ISh[QSRfi2GÞvkGMLYLnGÞû i!LHñ fQ41ù Qchf¬ Lrv?fïFLNO [Ot`SO!i û=hf`S\J`KGaR[h[h[\ÞOvÚ\aû;v[h[ISGa`4iGaLrLN€SGaO¬`Ssthf`S`kQShfvkENO¬GaGMO!ówLNû„muE/Q4Q4LNhfEH [mNOOW\aQ4m×ISO*LNO!Gah[`SvkO h GÞi2E/ìXLHQ4GJ\aO!`K\JE

(72) û hfïFQ4iEH`K`SGJs E/OWv^m ìfV^ù4\JpQSO LNhfhkOSv } ù LN`4 fóQ4ENL¬OWø~ïFR[OBO!m× fLHQSm9vÛïFLNO;`ts*vkO!QdQSû‚\^QKï9vkGMEHLHO! ‚mHmmN`SQ4sthfvO LHLHO! [i/O= [hfQKGai i!i Q4O!\^mHmFi`KLNhfGas mnLHOKEHùQSGJuh~`KL/muhfimNO!RfENi/hf ‚GJh[QKItmuLHLN [ [O=OY\aP“GJsthuGJeœLNO!vkv‚GÞi2h’LNR[Ga`Ss?hXZUQ4O ENE} ó¼GJZ[OWQSGJm m×\aGaV^Lh[LHISQ4 [hfRfO v‚QSû¹\[ówvkQ4`KGÞEHEi2O*LNstGa`S`S`KZ’hXm׀’Q4LGJEH`K`4GJRfOWóm mNQ4ùc\Jû.\ap\ŠVf\astO!LNmH [`Km;O!h[û7IBi`KISLNst [Ga€SOì[O;\JP“O mNLNO hOK€KeVO Z[E/vkQ4RkGÞ\Ói2L;LHLHGJLHEH`K [QShfhfO Q4ûÂm×EH\ÞQcGai O!LHQSm!GJhÚ`KVWhfïFZUmFO¬OÛówi/`Sst [E`K`kQtmNvkOFENGJöfgÙOWøKO!Q4v^RfISO!VÒGÞm×i2LNL! [}_VfvkO!QKGÞûÚi4m9VdQSiZUEN\ÞO!QSOti mHQSm׀SGÞRfO!i ENmNQSû O \ `4ZXó

(73) O!GJGJh[LHmI?O GJh~€SLN`KO!\JISR[E/LNQcGa€~LHGJO!Lnv^û V4R[ï9LHO fEHGasti/ *mBGÞi mQSh[h„`SL

(74) ZULNO= [QSOvfi vkQSO!mNv.O¬ówZ’`Sû.E Q4$h’h[ûGÞvkRfGÞi4mNO ù~EWx[Vf`SZ[EuRkOLBj[LNQ4 fstO ì[û.\aO¬Q4EHLNO; fO €SO!ø~ENR[GJöfO EHOWû;vówZX`KO E

(75) ówLN`S fEHOO x[EHO hfi/ ïu`KEHvz¿'·¶2ÃÉ´rISGa€SOWmuLN [OYów`K\J\a`cï9GJhfI EHO!mNR[\JLHmrð¼ïuOr`Kh[\Jû7ISGa€SOYQ4hOj[iO!ENì[L/ñ2R Ê ìX`KE×LHOYZfQ4I~Q4ISOWmu}

(76) \JR[IKIKQSISO E/QSi/|ÓV~\JRfISIKQSISOEHQKi/| Ê ìX`KE×LHOriGaIKQ4EHOLNLNOB}iGaIKQSENO L×LHOB f`S\ÞvkO E Ê ìX`KE×LHOri\aOó¼m¬}

(77) |KO û~}—EHGah[I Ë Ôcª_ªn  2ª_×£!¯~¢_±M£ª © Ž!¯k´c® ~£ ×£ ± © ¯KÝ[® ½/Ž!­ ̬Ôcª_ªn  Β£!Îk¥H±w® £ ±Åª×£ Ä4© ¢«ª×£ 2ª_×£!¯~¢_±M£ªn¥W® ¦S¤S¯ †ˆ†_Î͆ÔcÔcÔcª_ª_ª_ªnªnªn  . 2  2ÕÕ‹!×ÕÕ£!¯~Õ9Õ9¦~®® ²J‹!¦ nŽc©¥/½NŽW¥Hª ‹!ª_© ×±MŽ!¥!£ ¯~®¯~½H¯~¢_ŽW£ ±M­a£ © nª ¥W ŽW±M® ½/£ ¯fŽW¯~® ­ ½/‹WŽW~­ £!‹!¥ ªnŽcŽ!±M¢ †Š³ Ôcª_ªn ­;£!‹ © ½H•Š¦ © ½!® ÔKŽW­r¥/K¯© © §[® ¯~¥Hª-.

(78) ìX`KE×LHOYì[\JRfs O;}ów`SR[h~LHQSGJhìUO h Ê ìX`KE×LHOYìfQ4EH`S\aOSVk\a`kiRkLHO R[E¬}umNìU`S|SOWm×s*QSh Ê ìX`KE×LHOB}uvk`’`SEWVkIKQ4LNO `4GMLóï9m×O!Ò`GJ€SLNt O!EHì[LNQSEH f\[O O?vk€KO GaPBih~LN`~L9Ga`S`KGMhfISL/m9\aQSOrENR[GavkhfO!GamCi i`SIKLNstGaGJ`S€Khfì[O!mQS\aOENZULNûKO!Où h[LNLNO!O!mHEm!VfEHO!Q4mNhfR[v‚\ML/ZUmCO!LNi XQSQ4RfhÛmNOrQYGMR[Lh[ fGÞø~QKR[m¬OZX`KO!O h[h.OSVKì[ïuEH`cO9€SGaOWh~v*LNO LHhX fv QcL9LN`;LH [O!h[OrENRfGÞi/mN O Ê. {*|ÐÏ. ‰FÑ‘ ÒӀÔ †ˆ~†ˆ‹Õ€„GYÒӂ*Öw€ˆ‘. Úú ×-Ø Oµ'ï9´f¸:Ga\J´2\¬Ù2GaÃÚ\J\aRk¸

(79) ´ LNE/³QcLH·O7ÛÜLH [ÂO.´mn¸

(80) LH¼®EHQ4¿LN¶2O!º IS³Žûò»fº ¿Gvk¼O¸

(81) öX´Vh[O!»—v÷·Û:GJhô¿G¼Pg¹³$&ºˆ´š%XíB¼(fp.Ý´ ¶2ºˆ´!³`S³Žh÷´šLN¼ [¸ O‚¸

(82) ´fÛ)ów`S¼\a\a³Ž`cÂ/ï9´iGJh[Þß2IÚV¬Oï9j[ [Q4GÞsti/ ôì[\aOGam R LNE/Q4hf¬ mN[\aQ4O*LNOWöfvrE/mnGJh=Lt{

(83) mnLHh[O IKìœ\JGÞGÞm×mr LH×P [àzO7á ìX¼Q4ÃQE/m׺ÐÙGah[à I„á ´B`Só9³Ž¼LNÛ) [O´:x[·3âEHO à hfá i/´( œÛªø~¼R[º ³OWmnLHã<GJ`K´!h¶2Û)LN¼ f³äQ4L=¼º ì[¶2EH¸åº `c³Ž€’´4Gavk»—OW·m?Û:Q.¿G¼\a³'GÞmnæL Þ`4ß2ó ù LNGJh [OLN fR[O;h[GJøK}ŠLHRfO O!EHm×stLNGam`ShQ4V[hfQSv*hfQSv\J\fO LN\a [GJstOGaZ[hfGMQc}—LNLHO!O!ENmFs*LN fmO;ðŠm×mnRXLH`Si/ ÛìQSïu&m `K¼/EHv[ÂÉçfm!´—Gù »f¬ Ã~º [è´ÉOYéZ[»—GJ·LNÛÚO!ENÛªs*·m³ QSEN³ŽOB·µiRf³ÓmNOñCówR[ï9\— fV[GaZUi/ *O!i ïFQSRfO mNEHOO LNO [j[O!Q4ûîstì[ðwGa\ahfOSvkVKGaLNEH [O!OYi2LHZ[\Jû[GJLNñtO!ENvks*GÞmHmBQ4s?ðwGah7ZfGJLHIK [RfO QcGaLHEFO\JO!Z’s ûœs*IKQ4GJ€’LNGaGab h[O!IòvÛQÖów`SEHð¼sÛmNs*ñQ4QS\aEN\Þñt/O Ri ¿`S¶2h~º LN³ŽO »fj~º Lt¿G¼LH¸w`œ»—·QÚÛ:ïF¿G`S¼P¹E/v^³ùºˆ´2]_Áêhô»—·`SÛÚRfE ë ¿G¼P¹³ºˆ´®¼(!Ý´ ¶2ºˆ´f³GÁ“¼(fÝ´ ¶2ºˆ´!³K¼¸ ¸

(84) ´fÛª¼³ŽÂ£&Q4hfvÚLH [O*R[h[GJLNO!ENs*Pm RY³Ž·ÛaÁ¿¶2º ³Ž»fº ¿G¼¸ìÁ“»—·Û:¿'¼f¹³'ºˆ´!Á ¼(fÝ´ ¶2ºˆ´!³'Á¼¸ ¸

(85) ´fÛ)¼³ŽÂ4ù Z[ïuGMO!LHENO úÖOBEHs*LHGMQSLHm÷ Ú|SO!ðwLHhï9 [ fGaOÛh~O LNh [`ÛO!\JLNQKì fi O i`Sû$`KóuR[LHOh~ [jkL!OÛGaù[m×p L/g„ñ\JVQ4\ÒIKQSLNGa [hfiOYvî}«v[LHGaLNO it [EHstOŒvkGÞmi2R[LHïuh[GJ`KGJO!LNh[ENO OYhfEHs*Q4ISEHE/m ûSQ4ùV^stïFps*O*\a\?QcQcLHLHLNGa [i!LNOœO Q4st\a\Jì[ûÛìkEHLH`SLHO!Q4ìUv¹IK`KISmNLHOWO!`v^v,LNùkE/LN]«Q4E/óChfQ4QthfmN\amNZfQ4\ÞGMLNQc}—O LNLNGaO!`SLNEN fhXs Om GJi»˜h[`S·I RfÛ<\aLH¿'vÙ [¼fO;h[¹³'`4{

(86) LYæ—h[éŽZXIKÛªO*\JGÞ¼mNvk º ³íGaEHmNO!û’»—i2hK·LHÛ:L/\JûQc¿Gj^LH¼PùkEH¹QSx[³hf`KæmNE9Áª\aQ4`S¼LNR[º O!E9¶MvO VX»˜jk·GJLrQSÛ<stïF¿'ì[QK¼f¹\Jm OK³'VkEHæO!ïuÁzi OY`S¼st`Kº ¶®ZkìXLH`~¹/QSm×´fGJOW¶2h[vÛªOWvÛ¼ówEH³wów`S`K£9sE¬QSLNhfLN [ fvþOYO Z[ówRf`SGJLNE7h[O!GMENLHLNs*O [EHOÚmPs*R1R[m ¿Žh[VU¶2GJówº LN`S³O \a»!EH\a`cs*º ¿'לּmf} R¸ O³Žjk¼GaÛ)m׬ L´D[éGah7O!¼˜mN¿/LHOr¿G [´fLNO;O!¸ ¸

(87) ENvk¼s*GÞÃ~i2ºˆmLN·Ga³G`Sì[Á(hf\aRfhf¿ŽmQ4¶2EHº LH³ûS [»!VkO º ïFGa¿'Er¼OYi ¸ é|SQ4Û)O LNO O!¼IK캠`S³GGMEHL ÁaGJOWQK»—m;m¬·ðwÛ:GMIKL¿'GJ€Kï9¼fO ¹ [h.³'GJLNæZ’ fÁ<û`S¹/RkLN´fL [¶2OªÛªQSh~E¼ûÛ³fNO!ù&v[OaGaúÖQKQi [SEHO GMISLHhŒIKGaiSO Q.ùE2ñ¬ïuGJhX`KmnEHLHvÂO!QSvkv„`’OW`4m;óh[LN f`SOL `SmnLHEHO!GJIKQSGJvþhfQS`S\óïFLH`S [E/O.v[m`SEHïFGJIKO GJEHhXOrQ4LN\¬ fïuO h„`KEHIKvfGJm €KYù O ¬ h„[QSOm LHGJhfEHQSì[hfRkmNLB\aQ4LNLN`ÛGa`SLHhþ [O?s `S`kLNvk [RfO!E \JO„stvk`kGÞvþvkR[h[\aO!`4mL*`4LHóENû÷g LN$4`œ%fmNíB`S.p \a€SYVOULNGJ fhkO } R[R[Q4s?h[stGaZf`SO h~GJhÂIKL?R[`4m×GMóLnO!û7\JQ4OW\aZXi2\LHO LHGJLn`K [ïuhO*O!ù^O LN]«hE/ó¬Q4LNhXLN f [m×O;OÛ\ÞQcvkLHvkGJG

(88) G`K Ó ÓhfO O mYEHEHO O Q4h~h~hfLLYv¹LHLNEHO LHQSEH [hfs*OÛmNm;\avkQ4GÞQ4LNmNGaEHQS`SO*s?hfm×mPZ[û’R’Gah[LNIS [`KR[O;h’GÞmHû~gÚQcs*LNGaP m!`SVÓhÚEHìXO!LHO!ø~QSE×R[|SLHOWGJOWh[mnmrL9O!h~ì[GÞL?m\ÞQSs*vkiOÛ`kQSiv[v[R[OYR[stENówGaO ENh[`Kh~I.sL/m;vkLNQ4`k fEHi2OO } LNi [`SO! fh7O EHEHO Oh~LNLEHGaï9O €SGMLHOW [v*GJhtï9LHGJLN [ ‚OLNi [`KOWh~m×LNOYOj’m×LWû’V4h[ïu`KOh’û~mNs*R[ì[m!ìUV4`KLH fmNO9Q4h[GJLH|kmmuGaihLN`tîfR[Q;O!\ÞhfQ4iEHO9ISO!GÞmEuh[mNO!`SQSLEHm×i/R[ ÿ*ù~]«i óGJO!LHh~ [LOLNïF`r`SISE/O!v*h[O GÞmFE/QcGJhkLHO } h[`SGÞm×úÚOKù O.s*QSv[O„Q4hôO €cQ4\aRfQ4LNGa`Shþ`4óYLN [OLHEHQShfmN\aQ4LNGa`ShþISGa€SO hþZ’ûŒg $4%fí4$ p.Yù¬ [O5d/ øKQ4hfRfvO!m×LN/Ga/`Sd hfm¬LHO Gah.EHs*x[m=EHO ð¼hfR[i/h[ .GJ}ŠLHiO `KEHh~stLHQ4#m Gah[ï OWcv Z[GJl}ŠGLHO BEHs*ïu`KmHñ EHv[im!`SV[EHiEH`KO!ENmNEHìXO!`KmNhfìUvk`SGahfh[vkItGah[LN`I=LNfc` N/™PNt/GLNO!YEN{

(89) s*h[mIKGJ\Jh¹GÞmN ‚{

(90) h[ïFIK`S\JE/GÞm×v[ Òm!ùV %~LNRfv[û~Gah[ItLH [Gam9LNE/Q4hfmN\aQ4LNGa`ShV’ïFOY`SZfmNO EH€SOWv*LN XQcLPR Ê 1k$`4óXLN [OFLNE/Q4hXm×\ÞQcLHO!vrLHO EHs*mCïuO!ENO¬i`KENEHO!iL!VkðwZ[R[Lów`S( \a²jQ4k1LNGa`S`4hó¬s*LN [QdOtûÛLHZXEHQSOrhfO!mNh[\aQ4 fLNQSO!hfvÚiOWLHvfO EHñ stm;ïuO!ENO*i`KENEHO!iL!V^Z[R[L?Gav[E O h~ d[LNGÞV i ™/QSj\kîLN``4óXLHLN [O!O*ENs*LNO!m&ENs*LN fmrOuGaLHhÂEHQSLNhf fm×O } Ê m×`KR[E/iOY\aQSh[ISRXQ4ISO.

(91) `4ó&LN [OYLHEHQShfmN\aQ4LNO!vÛLNO!ENs*m9ïFO EHOGahfi `SEHENOWi2L úÚðwh[`.Ou]«ïuLHLuEH`KGÞQSR[m

(92) hf\a`SvYmNZ’\aQ4`K€’LNZkGaGa`SLH`SRfQSh¹GJmCh;`4LHQ¬ fóFQcIKLNLu [ENOWO7LNQc [xfLHOBO ENEÒvkO!hfGÞi i2`ci/LN €SGa`SO €SE^hXO!Q4Z’ENEHûYZcû=içfï¬`K·s QSµ'mìf´f¶h[\JO `4LNGJLuhòGah[i IGJ`SLHsts*m?ì[sQ4h’\aOOWRfLHQ4QSO h[\JGaO \ah[û hfIV`SLH [R[ÃÉOIK·Ú tst¿ówGÞ¸

(93) `SmN¼mNE

(94) æcGaVh[LH [ówI¬`SGÞLNmuE;E/i!Q4O Q4hfj[stmNQ4\ÞstìfQcLNQ4ì[GaGa`S\aISOWhXhÒñ2m ùù úÚO;pQSENh[Or`SLNQ4 [\ÞmNO!` EQKO!€dv[QSvk\JGaRXh[QcI LNGaLN`SE/hÚQ4hfimN`S\aQ4hXLNiGaO `SEHhfhfmFmZ’LNû7 [O EHO!Z[ø~GJR[LNO OWEHmns*L/mum LNVX`tLN XLN fQcLYO?ïuPBO=`~`Kì[ISEN\aOWOBm×O!LNh~E/Q4LNO!hfvÙmN\aQ4QSLNmGa`S€Kh‚O EHs û`kGJstvkRfìU\J`SOKENù } LHs Q4Gah~h[L=OWvœLN`ÚLH [v[OGamHQ4v[s=`’i Z[R[GJIKstRfO Qch~LHLtOÛówQ4ENs=OWø~Z[R[GJIKO hfR[i `SûÂRXm;`4ó R[h[OWGJQSLNi/O! œENs*LHm!EHQSùhf`mNÙ\aQ4QKLNGai `Sihœ`Kst`Sóì[\JLNGÞ [mN ÂOLNvk [

(95) G UGÞm?O!ENIKO!`Kh~QSLt\ŠVZfïuGMLHOO EHvkstOm LHO GaENh } LNLN [E/Q4FO hfFmN\aeÒQ4LN{uGa`Sxòhiù`SpEHì[i Rfi`Km!EHù~v[]«óGJh[LNIÚ [OLN`ÂówEHO!LHø~ [R[GÞm*O hXmniLHû*RfvkGÞmûSV [N1GaISl’ Òùì/VKk LH [O `Sh‚ó LNLH f [OO.Z[Z[GJGJLNLNO!O ENEHs s*mts*ïuQdûtO!ENZUO‚OBów`SQSRfh‚hfQSvþv[O!GJhþø~RfLNQc fLHOO LNii [`S`SO!EHEHì[ì[s RfRfm!mrów`SùSðw\ap LH\J`cQSh*ï9ENIKGJGah~Oh[LNL9I?O!\aENLNQSOW [h[mnO!ISLHGJGJRXEFhfQ4I;ówEHISO!Q4Odø~ì[ñ2R[ù ì[O EHhX`KiQKû*i/ ZUi `4`SLNR[ \ÞvGah‚ZXQ=OZ[LN`;GJ\aGa€ch[Q4IS\aRfGÞv[QSQc\^LHiO¬`SLNEH [ì[O9Rfm!LHVkEHQSQ4hfhfmNv7\aQ4GJLNhGa`SQ?hfm!stVc`KZ’h[û `SmH\aGJihf`KISENRfGah[QSI \ OLN!`ÛmNìXvkOWúÚO!i€SGÞOÛQ4O \a\aQS\J`Sû.\aì‚mN`.IKZ[O h[Ga`S\J`4GaIKh[LHEHISGaQSi RXì[O!Q4 [vÚ\GÞirLN\aGa Xm×hfQcLHQSmFL=s ówQS`KOWh¹E¬m VÓLNGast [`KOrENìXI~st`KQ4E×h[`~L/GamnQ4b!L9h~Q4L;LNówEHGa`SO!ïFh.ø~`SR[EHhfO!|„QShKs L9 fQSh[OWvÚmY`KR[Q4LHhf`„hfm!vÚùZXOÛQSiv[EH`S`Sh’h[û’OÛs*`Km hÂùXì[úÚENO`KìXLHO! [ErO h¹h[`Sh[RfO hfOWm v V Ê 1k. é ’ënçäçYX0\EUEÒæG;.8"\Fçé æfêE*=òçYX‚ãKä:XHçæ'>ñ;å[ë×çä Z~p íBû*mFp i GMeL9`S stï¬ìfQSmNmFO!Q4Q4EHmNGaE/QSh[i/GaIY [vÛGaLNh[GJ [hIEHm×O `SOWOhÚi2m×LHO LNGJ`K [LHmuhäO*`4‚ú¹óð¼EHO `cO!Zœ€SmNR[O!QSEN\MhfL/€’mfv„GaRSO ïôLNLH [ [O `4O*óöfLHg5E/ [mnGJ$&LFE/v¹Ga%'mFZ’ISû¹eGa€S{íBO xh*p ñ2Z’Vkeû*`KÐR[g EFmN$4O!mNQSO!%fEHi íBi/`S [hfp.GavÛh[YVIENSR[LH`Sh‚ [hÚOGamFLNmN [O!`KO"i Zk`SLHFhfQSevtGJh[{Z’OWx vû s?ENiO!`SRf\J\aO!\ai/O!€d i2QSLHh~\ÞGJQ4`KL

(96) EHhïFIS(ù O QdEu¬ ûrLN[LH X`?OÙQ4ihú¹`KLNhkO [öfZ<eO EHs ìfFENe`cmN`S{€’stGÞxŒvkO9O!im7`4`Só^\a`S\aGJO!R[LHi2EmuLHQ4GJm×`KhfûkhmNm×GùïuLNO!$ O!s EHmNmGah[ï9QSI*hfGJLNv=m× $RfLNi/`;Qœ .EHmN|’O `SGah[hkR[`cówE/ï9`KiEHOB\ai O!OFISvkGaIKGJ€SLHOÙOWmumum×i`KLN`K`*R[hkE/öX`SivkRfO.O!Ehf`Sm×iZ’ûkO€’m×GaLNmH`SO iRfs`KmNEN\JOKûQ ù `cïFO €SO!E!V4QSst`Sh[IBLN fO Q4hfmNïFO E/mìfEN`c€’GÞvkO!v Z’û;LH [Oú¹O Z*m×OWQ4E/i/ V4mN`SstOQ4EHO9h[`4Lów`KR[hfvtGah GJQ4h5h’®û F{eÒFQS{ueÒi/ Yxœ{u`Sxœiók`KvkLN\J [\a`kO!OuiiRfLNLNGa [s `SEHhO!O h~ùOuL!ENù OW%’m×Rf`X\MV[L/GJmÒLmNGaOm¬LHm&LH`ti`KZXh~O;LHQ4hfGa`4hfLNmGÞiów`SOWEÒvÛOWLHQS fi/Qc ?Lø~ú¹R[OWO mnZ„LHGJ`KQShfh;mNQ ïumNO!OEHL&mF`4s?ófRXQ4hXmnL9m×ïFZUO O;E/ì[m^EHï9O! [mNO GÞi/h~ L Q4vkEHG ÓOBO `KEHEHO v[h~O LCEHmnO!LHvO ìfQSmi i `4`SókE/LHvk [GaOuh[QSI?hfLHm×`7ïFQtO EiO`Kj’hkLNöXE/vkQSiO!LNhfGai`SO;hùWmHiDF`KOENówOK`SGù EHO¬ vk[OWGam mNi mNENi Ga`SZ[EHGah[OBI9GÞm9LH [R[OuìÓQSv[\JQ4IKLN`SO!EHv.GMLHQS [\Jsî\Q4ïF\a`SOh[ï9I EHLN`4 fLHOO ówLN`S`*EO!LHQK [i/O9 ‚öfi!hfQ4QShf\XvkmNGÞO v[\aQ4O!LNiO;LNGa`SQ4hhXm×VKïFïuO O9EWï9ù Ga\J\UvkO!mHiEHGaZXO¬LH [Oï¬Qdû;LN fO i`KhköXvkO!hfiO mHi`KENO¬GÞmQ4L×LNEHGaZ[RkLNOWv ð. b &=. ò|~}. "‹wŒPóa‘jŠzôí‘1†ˆÕŽÑP†~‹wÕ. NLLNp`Û [\aOB\IKLNQ4GJ€K fhfOrO;mNïuLNm× [O!O!hKO!E!s>LHVKO Q4hfhfQÛi v O!ïum9LHO! [ìfGJOIKEN K`cìUL€’`KGÞmHENvkm×OfO!GaîfZ[v‚O!Gai\JZ’GJLNLnûÛGaû?h[LNI*LH f fO?ZXQc`SLuvkLN`kLN . [iR[OLH [stm×O?ûkO!m×hKìULNL`KO smHì[mNENGJZ[`ki!Q4Gai \aO!htGMLnmHû‚m×\J`kGah[LNi! fIQcQ4LNïuOLO!LNLNEN [ fOrOBO=O Q4mNjkhfO QSh~mNstïuLNO!GJO!hfh[E

(97) iOWï9O?vGJi LNGJh`S [h~Ga`Sh*LHE/QSLNvkGJ fhXO!OEm O`Sm×O!j’Z’hKLN€’LHE/GJO QS`KhfiRfLNi mÛO!OSvŒ*ùQ4hX¬ ówm×EHfïF`SOÛs O E/im EHLNùuGM [LHO OÙEHRfGaø~Q7E‚R[LNOWQ4 fmnGaLHsQ4GJL?`KhmNïF [ù O `K¬ R[RX[\am×vôO.OWvÚEHZUO!O„ïFmNR[O LHEH\J fLNO*GaQch[L7iIœ\a`KLN [mNmNO O O¹\ah~û„LNm×O!R[\ahfGJZXh[im×|KO.OWO!øKv¹E/RfQ4O ï9h[h~|’GJLÛLNGah[ ÂstIœZf`’mNQSv[ [mNR[GÞ`Sit\JR[OWmÛ\ÞGJvþhków`S`Kh[órEN`4s*QSLÛhfQ4mNstLNïuGaGÞ`SO!mNh mE OQ4j’h*LNR[E/QSì[iìULNO Ga`SEFhtE/Q4Q4h[hf|tv=QSöfi!hfiQS`S\[E/Q4vkhfGah[mNIYïFO LN`=E

(98) mNQSO v[\aO!vki2OWLHvÛGJ`KmNh ìXOWQSiENGJO9öXQSi Z[i \JENOFGJLNLHO!`rENGÞEHQ[QSù GamN¬ O9fQO\a`ciEHïFGJLNO O EEHïFGÞQBO LNGaIS f ~Q4LNLuOWïFv=O QShfEHOm×LHïFQSO GJhfE&O!LHv` Q4EHOBZXQSmNO!v‚`Sh‚LN [OYów`K\J\a`cï9GJhfI=ówOWQcLHR[ENOWm¬ï9GMLH [Gah‚LH [O;i QShfvkGÞv[QcLHOrm×O!hKLHO hfi O!mPR.

(99) €Ê Oø~j[Q4R[EHQSO!Gaim×QSLNL9hKGa`SïuL/m¬h`K`4EH\JO!v[óCstmFøKRf`SstóO!QKm×LHLNm [GaVf`SO;ïuhø~O!R[\JGJO!IKO!s Km×LNLHs*GaO!`Sv‚QKhÂm Z’V ðwû*`Kh[LN\J [û‚O!GJGJEhm×LHìU [O!O0i GM+NöXQSi \JGM\ÓLnû‚O hfvkISO \aIKGamNEN 'O!, OdT׀SlcO!V EHmNGJ`KhXñ2V c Ê Ê s?RkLHRfQ4\i\a`KmNO h[OWmNmF`4ó&LN fO;øKRfO!m×LNGa`Shïu`KEHv[m!V Ê ì[EHO!mNO hfi OB`SóLH [OYOjkìUO!i2LHO!vhfQSs OWvO h~LNGJLnû*Lnû’ìXOKù øïuKRfO!O!GJIKxm×LN KGaGaE/L`Smnh„GÞL m\aïuEHO O Ost\ÞQcs*iLN`SGa€SQSstOKmùcì[`SúÚR[ELNOO‚€dQSmNQÙENR[GÞZfQ4ZfmNh~QSO!L/mNø~mGÞR[i*`4O!óïuh~LHLNO! [\aGJû=IKO! ~mNQSOL=vfv=\J`4O!ó9sQSLHhts* [QKOQKv[m=m×vkO!GJðwhKLNLNGa [LH`SO O?hfhfQSLni ïu\kOÛïu`7ZfO!QKöfGJIKm×EHOWm× ~vòLBL&i LH`SEN`YhòGJLNLNO! [LHEN [GÞGÞmOQKZfñì[ùQKEN¬ m×OWGÞ[i¬m×O!O ïFhfZfO iGaO7QKISm× ~`4GÞiLó ówh[`S`4E¬LO!ZUQKOri/ 7 [GaQSISv[ [v[O!GME¬LHGJLN`K fhfQSQ4h\^iQSEHZXGJLN`KO RkEHFL GÞQrPLN1 XkQcL¬`4Gaóm¬LNmH [QcOrLNGÞZfm×öfQKm×O!GÞv^iBùkïu{uO!QSGJi/IK 7 ~L!QKù v[vkGJLNGa`ShfQS\Ui ENGJLNO!ENGÞQ;ïFO GaIS ~L9i Q4h[} Lniû~`SìUEHEHOB¢ O!mNGaR[m¬ìXEH`KGaQ;h[hfhXIvÚQ4Q4stLNhf`.mNO!ïFv7LH [O O EO7h~O LNO j~GJj’LnLHûSìUEHV~QKO!LNi2i fLHLNGJOWO `KvÂh‚hmNLnLHû’O [\aìXGÞO!mOKiïFLNù OW`O v7Ga„ISQ4 ~`ShXLE/m×GavkïFmO!O ówErR[E/mENLNLN [QS [OENO!O EÒQ4LNEHhf [OmNOBöfïFh[ïuO OWE/`Kv^m EHVÒù vf]«5g m

(100) ó’LH`4$& [óÒ%'O

(101) LNF [OjkOYeìU{m×O!O!x$ih~LNLNO!iO vr`ShXstiQSOhfì[mNLNR[ïu fLNQ4O!O!LmE QSv[vkGJLNGa`ShXQ4\^ïFO GaIS ~LHmFL/Q4|’GJhfI Gah~LN`*QSi!i`KR[h~LPR Ê LN [OrìfENOWiGÞm×OY`SE9IKO h[O!ENGÞihfQ4stO!vO!hKLHGMLnûÛLnû~ìUOr`4ó&LN fO;Q4hfmNïuO!E!V Ê LN [O¬\a`ki QcLHGJ`Kh?`Só[LN [O¬ìU`4LHO h~LNGÞQ4\[QShfm×ïFO E&ï9GJLN ENO!IKQ4E/vYLH` LH [O9øKRfO!m×LNGa`Sh?ïF`SE/v[mï9GMLH [Gah LNLN [ [O;OrEHmNO O!h~v[LHR[O hfhfv[i QSOShfV iûÛ`SóLH [O;Q4hXm×ïFO E¬Gah‚LH [OYLN`Kì7LHO h.mNO h~LNO!hfiOWm ù Ê ìfQ4hfQcLNQSLNúÖ\JO ûkEHmN [hfO!O v=m!hŒù[Rf{LNm× [QKGah[i/OIB O LNi!j’ fQ4ìUO9hfO!vkOij’GÞLNv[OWLNE/Q4vŒQSLNOriQSLNhfm×Ga`SO!m×ïFh~h LNO ìfO E hXQcLNiLnLNû’OYO ìUEHì[Oh*EH`cGÞQS€~m mHGÞm×vkh[`kOW`4i v7LÛGaQ4Z’QÚLNO!û*v?hfLHQ4 [ï9stO;GMLHOWm× tv÷O!h~LNO! [LNhKO OLHhXø~GMiLnR[OrûKOWVm×mnO!ïuLH\JGJOWO`Ki2h?LHRfGJLnmN`Kû’Oh‚ìUOO¬stj’LNLN`k fE/vkQSQ4R[iL\aLNOr fGa`SQKGah mm ZXENO!O!ISO R[h.\ÞQ4vkEYOLHOO jkEHì[stEHO!GJh[mHmNOWGJv`KhfZ~mBûÛï9LN [GMLHO; Úø~LHR[ [OWOtmnLHówGJ`k`KihRfQSmYhfhfQ4`S\aûkR[m×hòGÞm QSùkmY{

(102) ìfj~GJLH€KEH`4QKL!i2ùLHGJg„`Kh7`SEHìfOtQ4L×v[LNOO!LHENQShXGJm\uQ4i EHQ4OBh¹i ZU`SOtstówìU`S`KR[mNhfO!v¹v‚Ga`4h ó l—ù Q4EHOBp9EHOóÁL/LNQ4O!E

(103) Gah[LHO! [v7OówO`Sj’E¬LHLHEH [QKi2OYLNöfGa`ShfhtQS\Q4hXm×O!v=\JOWïFi2LHO GJGa`KISh‚ ~LHstGJh[`kIrvkìfR[EN\a`kOSiù OWvkR[EHOSVcLH [O9öf€KO9ZXOWmnLuïuO!GJIK KLHO!vtQ4hXm×ïFO E/m Ê. ò| Ÿ. õB†~‹w„GBö*‘j~‘1‡P†~‚‹K"ˆÕŽ‚'Š†Ô Ñwƒ. !O¬ vkvkG[ ÓIKOO OSEHR[ùSO hXh~vkL9R[O EEHEHO!\Jiû’mN`KR[Gas h[\ML IìXmNQ4GÞOvkEHL/O!Gam mNQ`SV’Gah;LHmÒ ’QSLNRf` \Jm9\a`ci Q4ï`S\ast\JmÒ`cRXìfï9m&QSGah[ENLNO

(104) `BItEHENQtO!O!mNGJm×R[hkGaISów\JLH`Kh[mÒEHGJi `SöXO

(105) Zki!Q4L/LH [Q4h~GaO9LFh[mNh’O!i vBR[`Ss=ówEHEHOZX`S`4sO!óUEQ4vk`4hfGaóC€SmNiO!ïu`KEHO!mNENEHO

(106) EHmO!m×iZU`KL¬O R[\aQSE/`Shfih[O!m×IKmïFGJ`4h[O ó[E/I m|’LNh[LN`B`*`cLNï9ZU f\JOO } LNLNQS`E/mHQ4m×LNhfGaIS [mNh[Or\aQ4OWø~LNvtOWR[v7LNOW fmnGaLHOh.GJ`KöX{

(107) hQEHh[m×R LFIK× \JE/÷ GÞQ4m׳Mhf |Uø!×Ðùiµ'þ &Q´f³5¸ 4¸

(108) ÿ´ÚZ[\aá ¼OÚ¼³'ÃB³FæPi Ý´ ´˜`S´®¼h~¶aù LHQSá ÂGJ·ºˆhfšÛ)mF¼ùQ4Ù#h‚á ·ú5OÛ)j[¼Q4¼³'stÙa³ì[ú ¼\aOBëɼÃ~³'ëÉ`4º ³ ó¸*LH·ÿ. [½ º O!ÃɳmN´!Or³à áµcm×´&O ¸

(109) LH´&ýem¬ûi· `K½¶2´fENºüÚEH¸O!ûýamNìX¶2· º

(110) `KÀ ½ hf´!´G¸BvkÞGaßÞh[ù ß2I V ówZX`SO!eE GJh[¬ 9oIÙ[ LNOF{ [LNO [EHwùQ4O hf¬ O9mNfmNïFOGamO LHE;m

(111) Q4`4ìU\aISóX`K`KEHmNENO!GMGJLHmNLNGJR[ [`K\Jhfs LHmm;QSOGahòENj[O¬QSLHsi [`KO Gas h[GaE=OWìXm;`cQ4ï9EHO!O!QKhœv?i/ òLnmNïuOiLW`B`SùRfZ’úÖì[û;\J fO¹LnO ïFhœð `ZURf`4mNGaLHh[ ÷IrQ4Q4NhfVhtmNïFQ4\aO ISE/`Sm;EHGJQ4LNEH [WOÛsÐñêV O!ï9ø~ºrRfEHQSQSGJhfL×\LNcv O!`Kh Eç GJ`4hfóYi LN\JRX [vkO¹O!v÷i`K`SR[h[ì[O‚\aOSêùGJhò¬ LHf [GaOm‚`4ZXLN`K fh’O RfEWmÛVÒLHGÞm7 [O‚i!Q4QS\Þ\JiIKR[`S\ÞEHQcGMLHLHO! [vÖsõQSQci!L×iLH`KENEHGavkZ[GaRkh[LHIÂO!m LH`œQ„ZXZU`S`SLNh’ <Rfm?ìULN`K`ÙmNGJLNLNGa [`SOhf5m ZXOWº mnLtQShfmNi šv `SEHç'O R ðDP ð ï ’ñ×ñ zP/[ùê¬ fOÚQSvfvkGMLHGJ`KhfQ4\ZX`Kh’Rfm7ï¬QSm‚i/ [`KmNO hÖGah<`KEHvkO!EÛLH`÷ì[\ÞQSi O„LN fO †¼¾½/·CŽWÔ~­r¥rK¢_Kkªn¥/¥2½ ¦;© ß~ŽW½ ¯t© ª—¤£B±M¦K£ ¥/n‹ ‹Wn¥¥/¥r½/Ž Ž!n²~K£ ¢/±Å® ¥/­r­;£ ¦S¥/k¥/¯’¦S¢9ŽW¯ªnÔK¥ © ¯ Ä ¥Hn¢_¥rŽ!² © ªn¢9n¥/±M£ª ©MÄ ¥;²Jn¥2àc~¥/¯K½H¤   

(112)   . . . . .

(113) KË Ç c’Í ¶¯~¢«ÕC¥Nu¢_¥Nªu¥N§~£ ­r~±Å¥ ¶u  ¯~¢«Õ&¥HϬ ¶u‡Ó– ŒÜ¥HÎ ”S½/Ž n¥ ¶  ¯~¢«“ ÕCѬ¥N ”~Ϭ¶Ò”S§W· ´4½/Ž › n¥ ¶u 

(114) ¯K¡F¢«Ï¬ÕC½H¶u¥HªnŽ!‡ÓÎk– ¥H֛W›Y–&‘fŽW±Å›2±Åž!¥/½Hž!ª Ÿ © Ž!ÔS¯ §!½/Ž à n¥ ›´ F W›2 Ãà ªn§WÔÛº•n1“t›/t žd£ ºWnº ½×Ô›2à §!ž žW›2 W W W 1º t ´› §W´4› ›   1t 1– W ¸ ! ¸ Ÿ ´ §!žWà ÃÃ!Ÿd§ ž§ Ÿ ¬´›/žW¸ Ÿ ¸!º!Ÿd¸S › Ÿ

(115) ¡F¯‚½Hªn›/Ž!ž Îk§ ž¥H›´?‘f›2ž!ž!Ÿ ¸W§! WžW¸ Ÿ © ¯‚›2ž! W © . . . . . *)+, -$. /. . 0. *)+, -$. /. 0. . *)+, -3$-. $# %#. "!. $&('. . 54)"+, -35-. '%2. 1# %# "! 4)"+,-$. /. . . . 5. im×O `SLYh[öf`SENóFstQSOWhfvŒm×ïFQSO hfEYm×iïF`KO R[E/ì[m=\aO!ZXmYO ów`K`SEHEHvkO‚O!ENLHOW [vÙO.QKR[i hfii `K`SEHhkv[öXGJh[ENstI7O!LN`vŒLN`S fhfO O!Gam!ErùYh[¬ O ï~RXmmNi LN`S [EHOSO„ùQS%’\JGJIKhX`SiEHO*GMLHGa [hVsõFZ[eR[{Ga\axôvfm*ïFQO f`4óFQSvÙQShfLNmN`„ïui O!`SEBstmNOìfL/Q4m EHO=ðwLN [LN [EHO EHO O O*LHGJmNstOLHO!mYm/ñ2`SVÓóFLHEH [O!O*mNR[Q4\JhfLHm!mNV^ïFïuO EO*öfQShfì[Q4ì[\a\a\aGJû„OWv„ENO LHLN [R[OÛEHh[Q4OW\av„IS`KZUENGJO LN\a [`Ss1h[I~m `KhÂLH`7O!QSLH [i/ ¹O*ii`K`KR[R[ì[ì[\a\aOO ï9 [Gai/ `KZkLHQSGJhfmFLH [OrZUO!m×L mNi `SEHOSù QZX4hf`K5vh~eRXº `’m ³ ùQ`S|’%’Ga`7h[I*LNd ['ù QcO*¬ &L Q4f&QhXOB4m×Z[i ïF`S\aO zO R[Eeì[Kº \aVf³OBïFï9O; [m×GaO!i/òOr `SLNQ4 fZ[ì[Q4LHìUQ4LO!GaLnhfQSïFEHm mu`7LNGa [h7v[OtQcZULHZU`SO!O!m\Þm×v*LQSówì[öX`SìUh~hfO!L¬Q4Q4\GJEch mHGJih&Q`S4EHLHO‚Z[ [\aOrð3aO PLHB/ [²/ENENdäOWO!O?iï O!mNGJ€KO/LHO!Pm m ~R*/ñ9º ³ Q4=hfQSvÙmFGaQ m LN [O!hEHOLHR[EHh[O!v^ù `SENOWh¹i2LNs¬ \aût[`KGaENZXmFO=O Q4LnLNïu\a XISO!Q4`KO hÚENh*GJLNLnLH fïu [s `Oï9LHm× [O [LHEHGÞm!O i/ùO 7qQSi hfO `S€KmNstïuO ENìfO!LNEuQ4 [EHO!mNO!O\JOWmuLHmNmuQ4m!hfïFVÓmNïu`SïFR[OtO \ÞEuvt`KZfmNISOm×GaL/O!€Sm

(116) ENOB€KLnvkO!ïFvG `; ÓO LHZ’ fEHû O Qch~L;LnLFïuQEN`?OWim×Ga`KmuR[s \JLNLH ’ìXm!RfùSQ4mu]_EHhXGaO!mNvkQK`SO m×h„OWû=vÛs*LN`s*QKvkQ4Q4O*ì[|’ìfGavkh[\JGMûI } LNQ4 [hfOtmNïuiO!`KEHs m¬ìXQSQ4ì[EHìXGamNOW`SQ4hfEHGJm9hfLnI=ïuGa`‚hZ~LN [ûOYLnïFLH [`fENVUO!O;ïuO m×O vkLHm!`ù h[`4LLHQ4|KO?Gah~LN`‚QKi i `SR[h~LGah„LH [O=mHQ4stO=ïFQdûLN fO 6$71897. :6$7<;5=. >6$7$87. ?. ’é nå. KE*= :8 G= @. Ë~Ç ätfÍ –&ŽW­r~£ ×£ ª ©ÅÄ ¥9¥ Ä £ ±M~£ ª © ŽW¯ Ž!²ÓªnÔK¥¦ ©Øá ¥Hn¥/¯cª

(117) ¢«ª_×£ ªn¥H‹ © ¥/¢ “ Ñ9”KϬ¶· –&ϬŽ!¶u±Å±M‡Ó¥H½H– ª ŽW¯ Ϭ¶F܇U¥/– Î ¼¡ r½ »~~£ ±X¢ © nŽW¥/¯ ¢_K±Åªn¢ © ”˜¬S¥HµÙ¯4ªn£!¥H¯K¯~¢«½/ÕC¥/¢¥Hn¢ ‰Fº £ ß~¯~n¢«Ý*ª› ×£ ¯~Ý4¢ º!!› ¸§ ¸W´ ¸º © ¸S´ Ÿ›   § Ÿd   ˜FŽ!¯ ˜Fµ¹£!¯K¢«ÕC¥Hn¢ ‰Fº º £ ß~ß~¯~nn¢«¢«Ý*ªª› ××£ £ ¯~¯~Ý4Ý4¢¢ W›§ ´ ·UŽ ª×£!± ‰Fº £ ß~¯~n¢«Ý*ª› ×£ ¯~Ý4¢ ´ Ÿ «ŸW›2Ÿ ´ ´!ž «›/Ÿdà ŸKº ® º ´ Ÿ «Ÿd›   ´ Wž «›/žS‘ º . A. . . B DC. FB. GH. IB. GH. 9B. GH. E. FB. GJ. ¬ [OQSO €cZ[Q4\J®O \aRfdQcLHì[GJ`KEHh÷O!mNO ï¬h~QSLHm m=s*Q„QSivk`KOs Z’ìXûœQ4E/QcQ4LNhôGa€SQ4O*RkO!LH€c`SQ4s*\aRfQcQcLHGaLHi‚GJ`Kì[hòEH`kZXiO O!LnmHïum=O!O LN fh÷Q4gL \a$4`’`S%f|kíB=m p.ów`SE Q4LNhX fv÷OíBQShfp mNeïuO!E ù.

Références

Documents relatifs

Our systems adhere to the classical architecture of a Question Answering system, with an emphasis on simplicity and real time answers: only shallow parsing was used

The basic architecture of our factoid system is standard in nature and comprises query type identification, query analysis and translation, retrieval query formulation, document

[r]

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des

The aim of the study is to compare the usages of additive coherence relation markers by speakers of the political speech genre in the two languages and to

We are de- scribing in this paper our participation to Task 3: Patient-Centered Information Retrieval which aims to evaluate the effectiveness of information retrieval sys- tems

In the preceding section, meta-knowledge concerned the relevance and the crudest form of lack of truthfulness of sources of information. However, in some applica- tions, the lack

checkEarlyTermination (Alg. To decide whether or not we have all information in hand to compute our Why-Not answer, checkEarlyTermination evaluates the position of the