حجيّة الدفاتر التجاريّة الإلكترونيّة في الإثبات
Texte intégral
(2) אא אא ) (4א 2012. . . 105. . l^fmý]»íéÞæ%ÓÖý]íè…^rjÖ]†i^Ê‚Ö]íéru . . . . ì‚Â^Š¹]çÛ¦‚·_K
(3) . . . '() * +א א &$ %א ! " #א א א א אכ א-./א2 ,א +א ) 3 4א א2א01א ,א א 9! :כא56 7 א)2א א ;2א< :3א + 0 @Aא ? 4א> א;= א2א# @ @!כא אEא>2 :א Dכ #@ Bא א א א אכ: @I 76-Jא 5H 2)@ ,א ; ' +א
(4) א 4 Gא %& F6א-6 א אK I& :א> Iכ +Lא
(5) 2א אM& :7א &% א? א6א0 5Jא GאכKא א.N 6 '() 7
(6) Sא א & Q RM %א! א$ Pא א א א @א אEא> א $א א א א א J I& :א &() #@ %א א 4 א א ($ =2א ,א Uא -Nא +$ T2א א א א א א . '() * ) X6א א Sא א-א!
(7) 2$ 9א )(א FVW 4 M @$ :א ! YD # $א #א) א א א א אכ @Dכא+א Z .אא כ(כ !א ! ,א א א א א א א א אכ Z .אNא א]א G)@ 4-אא\[ אJא ,א Gא+& 5Jא. אכ Z †ñ]ˆ¢]{ë]çÖ]íÃÚ^q{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{íé‰^éŠÖ]Ýç×ÃÖ]æÑçÏ£]íé×Ò.
(8) . 2012 ( א4) א
(9) אא אא. 106. ABSTRACT This study seeks to identify evidential cogency of electronic commercial books in view of their significant part in today's commercial disputes. The Jordanian legislator addressed this subject and inherent developments in context of both comparative legislations and court judgments. No doubt, electronic commercial books are important in the process of ongoing shift towards Internet-enabled e-commerce within the information technology environment. This study addresses argument with electronic vs. traditional commercial books and concluded that electronic commercial books have the same evidential power as do traditional commercial books. To achieve study goal, this subject is was dealt with by first describing electronic commercial books and kinds, conditions required for electronic commercial books to be cogent, and cases in which electronic commercial books will have cogency. The conclusion includes major results and recommendations.. א+$ א א אFא20<א א2 א א א א2)@ - ^\ א32
(10) א-
(11) I& :B)א א<א א3 FVW 4 :Kאא אL :-א62' א3S X. : אB_ `א7-N אX?א Z % 0
(12) S אא+2 א,אאT אG)@ א)א-0א$ כ א א א א2)< GL 9! : א א, א;
(13) אGL
(14) B 0 ab :K אאXא0 .1966 12 GS 3< אU א א#אS א+ @!כא3<; א2א 52
(15) אB$ T2 א9 6`א א0 5\א+ אc = א? א א4כ אT = כI 4אT I& :,א-./ ! א#א2\ א0 4 cא א UN >אK c( א:d אeא6 א+H 2 א
(16) אc א אG 6א %&
(17) א2 אU כfא6Jg$ א03 c( א< א:7/ א+H
(18) א2א 52
(19) א א+$ T2 א0 א-אכ2 א א א א4 K $ א_כ . א] א א א א א אכ%& BK א# כאV
(20) cא א א א,-0 אc א א# אא,_אh א א, א;
(21) א#@ א2$ ì‚Â^Š¹]çÛ¦‚·_J{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{l^fmý]»íéÞæ%ÓÖý]íè…^rjÖ]†i^Ê‚Ö]íéru.
(22) א
(23) אא אא ) (4א 2012. . 107. א א א א! Uא +& gא אא % 0 F`6 Kא-אא, א $
(24) 2אM& :Bא & '() 2)@ %א א א-./א #< :,א;2 א אW 0א JכאS 40 i ] 3א0 @?0@ VJא)א ! א-./אZ , א-./א ,א2א\ 5א. 2
(25) :.
(26) א[ )(' א א 4 3 0אD/כאא)N ,א Mא+ :96-א !א ! ,א א א א א; Yא 1Vא ! +א א-./א, !א ,א] א+א Q 0 ZJא! א+$ Pא @א אEא>I :כ . ?א kא ) אא #א< j
(27) $ :3א;
(28) א ,א2אj
(29) $ : @!כא אEא> Iא ,א` M2$א א FVW 4 :אK/א % 0 $א< l א N6-אא: .1א ) iSא ;2א< ! 4 3א א א א אכ א א+ $א א;
(30) א ,א2אn .2א ) א; Yא 1Vא ! א א א א אכ א-./אn, .3א ) !א ! ,א א א א אכn .4א ) Qא! א$ Pא א א א @א אEא>n
(31) :. '() * +א א &$ %א ! #א א א א אכ א-./א FVW 4 ,א:d .1א
(32) * % 0א א eאא א א א אכ "
(33) א Iכ 42Mא;
(34) א ,א<I 3א ,א` M2$א א א א+ $א 4א;
(35) א ,א2א. †ñ]ˆ¢]{ë]çÖ]íÃÚ^q{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{íé‰^éŠÖ]Ýç×ÃÖ]æÑçÏ£]íé×Ò.
(36) 108. א
(37) אא אא ) (4א 2012. . .2א
(38) * D@ % 0כא Fא א א א אכ א dא
(39) -2 ] 4Tא
(40) 2א '() 5N ,א א. .3א
(41) * ! " % 0א א א א אכ א-./א4 , RM FVWא6א ,א )Nא ! א א א א :כ(כ אd א$
(42) -2א! א$ Pא א א א @א אEא>.
(43) :. כ '() 2)@ 42א א כ ! #א א א א אכ א-./אK :,א> +Lא
(44) 2א אM& :7א & %א? א6א5J 0א GאכKא א 4 K +H :N 6א א B 0 X A@ UאG א א Uאכ 9! :כאI #כ 56א)2א ;0א א<=M$ 3 א -SoאF SאS 0א I U Kא$ J ,א] א א;-כ א
(45) כZ L -. א L 7_ 2א %& F6א א Uאכ I& :כא 7א & Jא. ;
(46) א GL ,א
(47) 2א ,Vאכ +אS :א #א
(48) 2א ,Vאכ א<( :2001 85 GS 3כ 3 #pאא )(' `" % 0 e ! א א אכ כ2 iכ 4א-0א)א U K $א-./א., :
(49) 2א-א! '() 9א א א [+2א _JאS 9! : 6א D@ 6$כא Fא א א א אכ א; Yא 1Vא ! א א א א אכ א-./א! ,א ! ,א א א א אכ א-./א Q ,א! א+$ Pא 2
(50) :א א % 0א
(51) 4א`2א+2)@ 5
(52) 3א א q` 4 3א;
(53) א ,א Aא א+ $א q` 4א;= א2א!@ j
(54) $ :#כא אEא> :כ(כ @Wא #pא א 5_r G &+אא ,א__h 4 Bא0 ,א @ ]``: Z ì‚Â^Š¹]çÛ¦‚·_J{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{l^fmý]»íéÞæ%ÓÖý]íè…^rjÖ]†i^Ê‚Ö]íéru.
(55) א
(56) אא אא ) (4א 2012. . 109. א j
(57) $ %& Kא2א =Sא/כ א-6$ ``]2א+א ` א Z .א s !g$א א)א ,א> א;
(58) @ אEא\ @ א_.+ I % 0כ '() 96-א א FVW 4א:d @ : Zא) א א א א אכ @Dכא+א .1א) א א א א אכ. D@ .2כא Fא א א א אכ . .אא ! YD :א א א א אכ Sא 0א!_א+$ tא. Z ! YD .1א א א א אכ. @ YD .אכא.$ YD .fא.=S YD .Pא.X. S .2א 0א!_א$ tא א א א .אNא ! :א ! ,א א א א אכ. Z ! .1א א א א 6 `2אא M Kא.K ! .2א א א א 6 `2אא u M Kאא.K ! .3א א א א א-./א M ,אא.K Q .4א! א$ Pא א א א א-./א., אא\[ אJא:, "!#$#%" &"'! ( #) '*#+ # : א א א א @) 2כ U-א-./א :,כ+א א א! U א +& gא אא % 0 F`6 Kא
(59) 2א ,א-אא'() 7$ 9! :, א א _ 56 A Uא -2א< 3@ 4$ %א-./א 0 :,א כא7. †ñ]ˆ¢]{ë]çÖ]íÃÚ^q{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{íé‰^éŠÖ]Ýç×ÃÖ]æÑçÏ£]íé×Ò.
(60) 110. א
(61) אא אא ) (4א 2012. . א;
(62) א
(63) ,א 5א א @ % 0 cא vא 3@ "S@ Bא-./א ,א 2כ #@ 4א-./ Mא ,אא 56
(64) Sא.(1)X6 כ +H 5H 4א6א eא dא א) ? 4 Bא\0 5אG א
(65) 2א ,א
(66) 2א 56 R-J@ 9! :,Vכא כ=2K U- א 2א I& :,אכ '() eא?_ Uא
(67) 2א +Hא\ 5כK 6כ '() Gא
(68) 2א+
(69) 2 ,א אTWא+א אKא+0א +אI& : @ '() % 0 X Aאא\ ) R ?` 5א6א eא/כ()( :(2כ >M )(' א?
(70) 2אT R-J@ ,א Zא @20@ -! G #א Fאא L 76 :Kא $ %2א א א א אכ( .כ * I 96-כ FVW 4 RMא) א א א א אכ @$ ZאD@ #כא Fא א א א אכ .אא.Z. .&"'! ( #) '*#+ # .1 אא =Sא ;2א< *
(71) G 3א א א א אכ R`$ y 6א א
(72) -א$ Uא2א = א א א א א :כ 4כא #א)2אZ J B. + BM
(73) $א g$כ 0 :=; 4 Nא + a`Wא אS 3א #א אU א< (21z16) 3א 7א
(74) $ iא א א א @א+0א) .(3כא7 אD/אE@ Uא & %א א א א אכ `S qא #א-כ א< %& 2000 28 GS 3א ,Vא62א ,א\ 5א-א# אכ).(4 @$א ;ככ $א-0א א א א א אכ N2$א6 $ אכ h I& :א Kא> B$א ;2א< 0 3א *0א 62אכ y _
(75) FVW 4א\ 5א
(76) 2אS 42M ,א #א
(77) 2א ,Vאכ ì‚Â^Š¹]çÛ¦‚·_J{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{l^fmý]»íéÞæ%ÓÖý]íè…^rjÖ]†i^Ê‚Ö]íéru.
(78) א
(79) אא אא ) (4א 2012. . 111. א< :(5)3כ(כ Kא> Iא ,אאE@ #א $א % 0 aא 5אכ @ R ?` B 0 X Aא @ א
(80) @ א א
(81) 2א ,א ;& Gא)א @ &א+א @ +2א @ ]+Tא $א\ 5אכK .א> ,א2א U3אא4
(82) $ Iא ,אאh #כ א % 0 Bא
(83) 2א ,Vאכ )א ,V אכ( א =Sאכ @ cא
(84) א ,אכ).(6 @א Sא #אא Fא #g;$ KI2א א Uא/כ*0 : א א-אא2$ ,א B3אNא א_)@( +g$א" א
(85) 2א ,א ;& Gא)א @ &א+א @ א+Vא @ ]+Tא $א\ 5אכ @ $ @ \Mא\5 ;א2$ :B+$א Iכ 5- % 0אN2א Fא- `6א F3א-אא ,אכ: @ א -א/כ @ :א @ :k-א כ^ :א א.(7)"S- $א %& Lא '() 4א`S #@ qא #א
(86) 2א,V ?א$א `S qא #אא Fא#g;$ KI2 אכ א<K 3א> Z א א Uאכ 2+_
(87) FVW 4א א\ 5א
(88) 2אI %
(89) .,כ @# א א א א אכ ) -0א6 40 Uא @ ,א ,אכ G ]+Tא א6אS@ eK2$ eא G - J qא]א+Kא UT+K@ 4 א6א0/ :eאS U3א> Uא-אא ,א +T] Gא. &;& 20 #Iא> א א/כ ) N2$א;& $א> & 5כ $כא 0א() 42E I& :BAD 'Jא א 5א-אא ,אא eKא)א א א א א א )$ :(8א> I % 0כ #pא א א א א/כ ) -0א 40 Uא] א א א/כ _! 4א
(90) 2א,V א א א& ,V ) @ Kכ + #א אא Kכא ,VW b 'Tא2א4 : ]Kא
(91) ,א BVא א +\M % 0 3 6א כ b -א @ '() #אK]2א ,א-0 ) ,VW 2א3S 40 U א6 *
(92) 2א Z †ñ]ˆ¢]{ë]çÖ]íÃÚ^q{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{íé‰^éŠÖ]Ýç×ÃÖ]æÑçÏ£]íé×Ò.
(93) 112. א
(94) אא אא ) (4א 2012. . 6א -כ& #א א א3 $א\ @ #@ 4 Z $ : -א62אe. אכא).(9 '() 4 $א3 % 0 3א Kp$ Sא> א Z .&"'! ( #) '*#+ ,#% .2. @S Tא #א א Uא< 1966 12 GS 3אא.V. GL$ K @א 4א א א א) '() (10א א ) 3א J 3 אא\ 3 5א 3אT2א() % 0 X A@ I& :א א א " Gא א א א אT/א" #@ u :א ;2כ א KאM& 6א WQ 4א א &Iא I euכ :כא2$ R2 BH 7כ '() 5Nא א: @() % 0 X Aא א א" Gא א אWא").(11 כ +H
(95) $ 4א6א fא א) ? 4 Bא\0 5אG אכא ,א 56 (Wכא כ() U-א א
(96) ` א$ G
(97) _2אכKא: ! 56 5א<א 4T] 4 kא
(98) 2א ,א-אא ,כא<AD . א<Sא qאr2א Aא2כ ( :Gכ #pא *VWא?k. א _6 N 6א א א א &;א\+א [ @ +H B0א א א א א/כ +-א אא:Z @3 .א א U`$אr`2א ,א_ ) 2א א.(Ur`2 Gכ R ?` 4אr`2א ,א_ 2א] אא 56 Bא)2א J`Wא Tאא _ :B א 40;2אא@ :X$א אR-J@ #d Z Z GEWא UNאכ I& :Kא ;2א< S 3אJ *0א! $א א א א אכ D % 0כr` 5א+ ] B2 ,א א-כ
(99) א+Vא א " U`$ `2כ 5J@ 4 Z $ "Gא א א ,V אכ;א ,א.א\ Xא2אK :(12),Vא> '
(100) $א ;2א -א( cא20 ì‚Â^Š¹]çÛ¦‚·_J{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{l^fmý]»íéÞæ%ÓÖý]íè…^rjÖ]†i^Ê‚Ö]íéru.
(101) א
(102) אא אא ) (4א 2012. . 113. @Eא % 0א א Ur`2כ_! 5 -א tא;כא ,אh2א ,א א א`2א* $א)א א+Vא )uא 4א<א kא
(103) 2$ `2א+Vא א אI %
(104) .13כ @ #א א`-0 Urא 40 Uא\ 5אכ G +-K2$א ] 4Tא
(105) 2א+2 @ ,א @ כ2א @+ 0 X Aא j
(106) $א_+א> `? Rאr`2א ,א_ #I& .(14)(microfilms) 2אr`2א ,א_ 2 Dg$כא+א א % 0 _ ]2כW3& Uא Fא @ 62א Sא<%& J @+0 b UT+Kא +T] UJא ;$כR YrE @ r` 5 אKא+0א &0א-A U3א+0 ] 0א).(15 2$א @ #א;א Yא אT S cא א dא<I #p :UWכ כ# --א ; 3Kכ א #T]2א Sאא[ UM 40א!_אt Z א h2א א $א)א א+Vא א> א`א @ U3אא+ U3אI& :
(107) 4 ZV
(108) -א`
(109) $א ,א+א @א כ אh2א. ,. E2$אT 4Tא ! Gא 2א ,אא eKא!_א+$ tאM& :א &%. @ #א kא0 ]2א אכ _ 20 #@ 40 ZVE :אS e ? _6אZ כאא1 Zא i` Zא 2א ,אKא+0א &Iא א %ESא< G. 4 :כא# J`Wא כ א $ $ , % 0א-כ א;כא ,אh2א:, Z א #T]2אאכ +א E2$א_ #@ :4Tכ 20א א +KאTאU3 כאא א G ! U22א<I :iDכ 56 96$ B2 ! rE$ Z rJא $כ _ @@ 0 5Sכ -אKא א 2א :,כא 7א Z. א) Ur`2א2כ $ (Gא-0א)א
(110) א () X6א א.(16)r. _ &! " א אא ,א Sא+$ 7א א<א UIאD 1א 4- @ G ! #א #T]2א _ Sא\ -כ א Aא_ -. †ñ]ˆ¢]{ë]çÖ]íÃÚ^q{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{íé‰^éŠÖ]Ýç×ÃÖ]æÑçÏ£]íé×Ò.
(111) 114. א
(112) אא אא ) (4א 2012. . 34.005כ
(113) ) :eא א vS G ! c1א` א;-$ +א^S : @ '() ,3א;2כ $א-כ & 4T] =2 ; #@ %א 2$ k "א-א % 0 :"#א! 26.5000כ
(114) 0 eא RM :1975א א Lא @Eא @ #א-כ !א2 =2 ; #@ %& Kא 5.כ ^2W 5א, Z א -$א .(17)%50 %& %10 4$ Tא G ! U3א #T]2אZ S. Kא> א e-א\ 4T]
(115) 40 96-א
(116) 2א= ,. @כ2 S -כ 4 4א
(117) 2אM& :,א & %א2א ] '() 4Tא
(118) 2א, 2$ B< :FA@ U 2אT 4Tא ! Gא 2א ,אא eKא!_אt Lא <+א @א $א א`
(119) :$ +$א 20 R-` G. 4 :א!_א$ tא<3 Z Z 6א %& Pכא(+ = #א אכ Gא 4 G]Eא 2א., .&"' ( #. '*#+/ 0#12 34
(120) #5 6'78 9 :(; .f 6א Sא #א -כ א<$ :3אD/א%& U Kא> אJ a Z ] 4Tא
(121) 2א- ,א #3 :UDא 0א3 3K$ 3א א @כ Iכ א ;2א<$ 3א_0& % 0 aא> א-כ א y 9! :- ] א6א eא 20 dא+א א2א אGL 4 `2 א א א א א + 0 aא Sא #א א Uא< 3א6א)I&.(18 אא$ Kא] א אכא $א;& 2Sא> !_ א א א א() :א
(122) -אכא $א ) 2Sאכא $א % 0 א] א אא\ 5א א jr$ N 6א 40 Lא 0א א ] +-Nא).(19 -כא &D #@ %כ א ,א א א א @א א ;2א_ B- Z 0א\א @א &W3א Fא
(123) 2א _6 א +
(124) M$א א6א 76-J@ S Z ì‚Â^Š¹]çÛ¦‚·_J{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{l^fmý]»íéÞæ%ÓÖý]íè…^rjÖ]†i^Ê‚Ö]íéru.
(125) א
(126) אא אא ) (4א 2012. . 115. '() 5Nא א א 2א 0 :,א א]( W3& 6 lK U?WאL Fא א א א א אכ א L2א אS 9! :א 30א5$ Jp$ 1983א אא 5
(127) #g;$ 83z353 GS #א2א 17 – 8 3אc () FVW 4 R2 96$ :א א
(128) W3p$ 5אL Fא א
(129) 2א א!V?Jא Z Kא ) "א ,Vא62א "-כ5 - א62אKg - Z R ?`2א " Gא א א א" '() eK2$ :א
(130) 4 R-J@ ,V א22כ '() 56 #@ 4א ,Vא62א 56 -א א א 0 : א א; Yא #@ :) $ ?2כ?$ Wh 2S U3 6 # 5+bא+& Kא).(20. iS Sא 3 ;2א/אא2 _S ,א() = .א א:M2. ! eK2$ S 9א2אS 4 38 U3א #א
(131) 2א ,Vא א &_0א> אאK א( 20 GL ] cא Bא א א6א eאUT+K@ 4 'u @ :d א א
(132) 2א, א א 4 N 6כ א א א א א Z -
(133) : א2א '() 4 Uא<)u @ UT+Kא 4א<א eאN2$ N 6א3 $א. א)M =M :(21א0 $א 20 GLא ,א] א+א $א 1 4 א`Sא 3א א 3 Uא/אא ,א
(134) $א.(22)U 62 & #Iא א א א א/כ -0א;& A s ! ? 40 Uא> ( א א 1אU 2
(135) U3K 7 !_ א א א א אb ,3 " lכ 4 U-א א 9! 42 :א3 7 #2E2א 2& :U Kא ) U K UJא א א 4T] 4 K f @b 5N2 א
(136) 2א % 0 :,א\& 5כ Iא
(137)
(138) YD , 6`$א #2E2$ ^ :B_ 62א א א א.. †ñ]ˆ¢]{ë]çÖ]íÃÚ^q{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{íé‰^éŠÖ]Ýç×ÃÖ]æÑçÏ£]íé×Ò.
(139) 116. א
(140) אא אא ) (4א 2012. . <.#= >#?@! A4B" &"'! ( #) '*#+ )@ C"'% :#&#. א() Fא א 96-2א; Yאא eKא)א $א א א א א/כ " א! א+$ Pא @א אEא> ) 4 5א22כ 4אא+א א-./א$ ,א א א '(+
(141) * :(23)nא; Yא 2א @)3א א;= א<S %&
(142) G. 4 :3א 0א!_א '(+$ tא א. .&"'! ( #) '*#+ )@ C"'% .1. 4א; Yאא eKא)א א א א א אכ ! %כ# +א א 6אכא א-./א ) :,אכא $א =Sא+- X.א אא.Z @ YD .אכא.(24)$. אא =Sא ;2א< 3 6 i
(143)
(144) G 3כא $אכ !א! Bא Fא e uא;
(145) א ,א
(146) $א$
(147) 2א א Uאכ$ :אNא>
(148) _א +א Sא #א =Sאכ אc`2 א ;2א c`2א(3@ c Z K :(25)2004 15 GSא> " Bאכא $אכ :כS@ @ *! 5א @ V0 c@ @ 1א03 % 0 7-N "W@ ,א אכ @ \M @ 2S @ @ @; "WאS 3 ?
(149) +$א3o $אכ" #I& .אכא $ 1א
(150) 40 -א_כ() G+ YD 4 ^ :א א
(151) #@ -
(152) " @ #כ# Z & Gא %& '3א :4
(153) c3א> @כאS k % 0 @ e;W % 0 #א3 1 5 % 0אכא( .(26)$כ אhא Fא() B_ ? cא )K 5 4$ kאכא $אכ אכא $א .n א" א ;2א_ א 4$אכא $אכ א 4 : !2+
(154) 2 9א $א 6א Uא-./א eK2$ :,אאz230 GS # 2000א`א 13 3א :2000 vא( cא,V
(155) B-K2$ 5W3 q` % 0אא #אI +H I& : 2כ א2א 4 3/1316 U3א4 ì‚Â^Š¹]çÛ¦‚·_J{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{l^fmý]»íéÞæ%ÓÖý]íè…^rjÖ]†i^Ê‚Ö]íéru.
(156) 117. . 2012 ( א4) א
(157) אא אא. א אכ0 א% 0 $ כא# כ#@ % 0 7` א_ א2א .(27)S א03 % 0 א+$ =2 א,א-./ אU_^ א " L'écrit sur support électronique a la même force probante que l'écrit sur support papier ". @א: א\ אכ5כD % 0 אכ$ אכא#@ (28)"@ 4 אכ+ * +$ 3א א<א+-א כ- )א3 א0& G ,א-.& 5\ א+ 3 א
(158) א,א א Z. 4
(159) 5כD Y; :אS , `א40 g; S אG+S! X. 4 א$ אכא40 i ] אכ$ אכא#@ )(א%
(160) :$(' אכא+ א$ אכא# כI& :$ )(' אכא526 c( אc3א2 א א9! U
(161) JאW UT+K@ FVW 4 G אכ$א @א אכאZ S. '(+ `א Z `W , 0b@ , !א% 0 rEא$ א2& : ] א$ $ אכא#כ FאW3& G 96$ !_ אJ 42Sא א2) :אאS@ @ Zא1 # כ:grא Z ,א2 כ%& אS< )(' א2K$ ' $ c( אeא6 א%& 1)(' א .(29)U> 5כD % 0 # אכ כ$ אכא#@ (30)Wd אj
(162) -א @" א2 4 א+KאW& ,אא- אFאW3& , א20 FVW 4 (_ 1אW ,3
(163) א ,
(164) א2(' א+$ 1א+ ( אr FVW 4 G א:eא6 אDאD FVW אK @ אR_א2 ! א- אFאW3/ א, ! אXA 40 .Tכ2
(165) א א2 אU ! T]2 א,
(166) א2א U3א2 אa א0 אכ$אכא$ (W אc\אT ; א2@א א 5 א;כ$אכא$ ,א-./ א-
(167) ":#@ % 0 (31) K 1 כ323 ) 4 כg &כא אY;$ :k א% 0 $אכא$ ,א-.pאכ כ 42E *H H_6 U
(168) # כ#@ )אJ@ c( אa]; א. †ñ]ˆ¢]{ë]çÖ]íÃÚ^q{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{íé‰^éŠÖ]Ýç×ÃÖ]æÑçÏ£]íé×Ò.
(169) 118. א
(170) אא אא ) (4א 2012. . +Vא"($ .כ כ #א S ;2א 20אכא++_2$ $א אא=#@ #3 : _ kא 4$אכא $א % 0א @ kאכא $אכ א Kא>4 , W UT+K@ FVWא U
(171) Jכ2א $א א$א.Z #@ ! 2.א ;2א< S 3א U$ Sא62א ,אכ y א-./א+
(172) G 96$ ,א @ )rא)2$ :(32א @ 4 Bא22כ56 4 א %& 1אכ K V :א ?0& 4 =2א> )(א א ! א א
(173) א c3א-./א$ I& :,א/כא #אאI % 0 vכ א? % 0 X-כא א62א ,א> כאI 3 :0 @ 2 7כ א Kא> B$ ,אe u א;
(174) א ,א
(175) 20 GL %& 7א-./א ,אא\ 5אכ ! = 5N2 U3 6 + 42Mא62א ,אכ &- % ! א62א ,א.(33)S אD/א #@ %& Uא2א 4 1/316 U3א 4א 2א_ S ! ,3א; Yאא eKא)א F-א 62אכ כ 5 א-./א US ^_$ B
(176) 2 ,א 62אI :Sכ $א % 0 aא
(177) B אכא כ 5א-./א+gD ,א #gDאכא% 0 $ Z $אכא $אD U(]2כZV 03א #@ Y;$ :Sכ #א/כא$ #א ) 6 UEא;]a א ;+
(178) -A 4 Yא @# א( '()
(179) #@ :B , J cאכא _6 $ Z +V 42Eא).(34. YD .fא.=S
(180) -א =Sכ@ 4א א-./א$ ,א-0א' @! א; Yא\ א 5אכאK %& $א eאכא $א 4 %Sאא! אא &- % א 5אכא 5א-./א :,א +$ [6 4 =S 526 Gא I _ :B 0כ @ #א ;2א Tא\ S cא U$ 0א =Sאכ a 42Mא2אU3 ì‚Â^Š¹]çÛ¦‚·_J{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{l^fmý]»íéÞæ%ÓÖý]íè…^rjÖ]†i^Ê‚Ö]íéru.
(181) א
(182) אא אא ) (4א 2012. . 119. TK 2/327א\$
(183) .....":#@ % 0 (35)cא =Sא/כ X א; Yא(2כ Uא2א 323 U3כ #< : " 'V0@ 1א -
(184) =Sא 3אA< 62א() :(36)Bא אא kא YDא ;2א<#@ 3 כK] #א ,א6א %! zfכ ! B #א א
(185) א c3א-./אz, Sא .(37)B0 J 42 @ #כ#
(186) Sא @ ` Z Z = א א א Uאכ :א] א א א ,א
(187) 3אכ א 7Mא =Sאכ א< א(
(188) ; 5W %& "3@ c '() GLא_2א) Gא 9! :N 6א Sאא #א F! KI2א אU אכ א`א 40 3אא #א א cא " א< GאU 62 $א Uא -Nא =Sאכ eK2$ 4אא 162/51 GS א :1996 /1/16כ(כ Sא #אא Fא #g;$ KI2א
(189) Sא, אכ :א( cא B 20אא #א א cא " א< GאU 62 +3א א $ 34א E@ a 5/7/2001א GL % 0א=S אכ א kא
(190) SVאI ,א ,א?א =$א א@ :cא אא #אcT / @W 6\ Jא =S Jא/כ T! 7 W3@ :א_א IאNא4 4א '()
(191) I& :2002 vא 6\Vא א BK $א`א 4 3א2-א# +Kא WQ א< =S $א/כ $א 1999/12/13א( cאS Z $א F! 2000/6/8א א Uאכ אgכ % 0א)2א $א
(192) 3 $א? kאכ).(38 אD/א #@ %& Uא =Sא/כ ) &כ 2כ4 E2$א)א ) 6א;] aא f2א = B& =Sא א #g$ B [ .Qא' אא 2 6 % 0א 5.א ]$ =Sא :א =Sכ2א Kא> B$. †ñ]ˆ¢]{ë]çÖ]íÃÚ^q{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{íé‰^éŠÖ]Ýç×ÃÖ]æÑçÏ£]íé×Ò.
(193) 120. א
(194) אא אא ) (4א 2012. . אW V0") j
(195) -א+
(196) E UT2 Jא א % 0 cg$ =S2 S/א'") 2)@ =K .(39א =Sא/כ$ :א ] א Bכא
(197) Sא@ 5N :א א =-א;א> :אS % 0 =Sא\G א
(198) א ,Vא ? e Z 3Kא = אE-א\= :א % 0 =Sא אD : Vא> (אכ א_: א ,Vא.(40)= -N2 YD .Pא.X. ! %כ #אכ א @ 6א 5א-./א#@ $ V , כ. #א I& :41Zכ 2)@ 42א X.אכ >Mא Kא> B$א;2 א<S 3א #א
(199) 2א ,Vאכ :א2אI& .f ": #@ % 0 f/32 U3א Gכ 4א 5אכ @ א =Sאכ .א ^ ! c@ B "($כ R2א ;2א< 3א 5אכ @I& ! cא Gכ4 Z.א :42כ($ #כ T@ Sכ-D FVW 4 *` cg$ a]D 5כ. א X. 7/א`* א( * +$ :G cא_6א k! % 0 tא
(200) 2א 4 4 -D FVWכ א c@ 4 7א 0א> @ 2 uא :G+ 0 vא J& #א @c 6אכ 4 $אא .(43)B.$ @א א ;2א a Sא_`S 4 (4)5א #א-2א ,3א אU אכ S 2
(201) ":#@ % 0אא !_ א .אכ כ2א
(202) _! 2 א .אכא T .$א _6$ 52א .אכ א;כ 5א 2 T B$א '() _6$ B& 52א .א;כ 5א(+2 cא %
(203) ."B$ Iכ @ #א ;2א א" 4$א .א$
(204) S2א =Sא c $א .א
(205) S2 2Sא).(44 Z !א
(206) 5א ;2א<
(207) $ 3א20א 3א 5אכ א Gכ4 Z ì‚Â^Š¹]çÛ¦‚·_J{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{l^fmý]»íéÞæ%ÓÖý]íè…^rjÖ]†i^Ê‚Ö]íéru.
(208) א
(209) אא אא ) (4א 2012. . 121. .א `S 9! :א 4 ;2א> Iכ !2א א
(210) א ,Vאכ א Z -D FVW 4 Gכ א :7א כ2 =2 !_ #א
(211) '() 5 א;-כ 2
(212) M0א ,א 5-S 4 Jא_lא ,א 22א0א א<20א Fא/כ2 I& :כ 4א '() 5N +Kא]2אFVW 4 & A X. % 0 52
(213) U 2
(214) +Kא 5א/כ_! :אZ Hא k! % 0. `א Rאh2א ,א<א 3א ] א 5א/כ).(45. !K& X6 %א>א ,א 0 :X.א כא #א+ rא א_6א% 0 t א א/כ 4א @ e0Vא #p :i6א< ? #@ eכ #כ אK/א>אI ,א_J ,א ,א eא X.א/כ2$ :א אc@ ^ B &Kא> Sא X. % 0 3א 5א/כ e)I :א ;2א<%& 3 M =Mא :
(215) $כא #א+ * +א א0א Uא *Lא 2
(216) $ ?62אX. א]א ?$ Jא
(217) SVא א).(46 I& B 0א K& X-? Gא>א - X. ,א Zא = א0א Uא*L א]אAg$ Jא* א
(218) 2א א+ 0 q`2א $א #א
(219) 2א ,Vאכ א< 3א$ 2א :Bכ #כ אK/א>א .@ ,א X. 50א 5 א/כ. `א 0א aא2אU3 () 42א א X ?2כא #א ;2א<Z ! 3 S 4 1/40א #א
(220) 2א ,Vא/כ J& UM % 0א ^ א1א> Lאא ] Jp$ aא +Dא3א ,א X.א +א6כ א ]a א<3 Z. ($כ א א אא+
(221) 3 eKא).(47. †ñ]ˆ¢]{ë]çÖ]íÃÚ^q{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{íé‰^éŠÖ]Ýç×ÃÖ]æÑçÏ£]íé×Ò.
(222) 122. א
(223) אא אא ) (4א 2012. . .&"'! ( #) '*#+ #0 >#?@! A4B .2 @ Tא ;2א< 3אא$ Kא!_א $ tא' א א
(224) $אWא+א U ;0אI %
(225) :(48),כ @ #אא3 G $ T Kא' FVWכ אU 2 () 4 5 6 :א אTא
(226) $א+א> כ אE@ a S :U 2א א;2 א Tא\ % 0 cא+_ U 2א 0 :א @ Tאא$ Kא!_א c $ tא א :3כ(כ א2א ,Vאא U3אא ,א^_ A +K2 א :(49)U 2כ2 5) 4כ 4א-0א )(' אZ 0 U 2א 4אא 3א2. j
(227) $ e)I :n @ k6א_ %& (50)Bא U #g$ Fא!_אt. $א א א א Z 0 7א 4אא 3א2& :k6 2א ) U )3 ! 1א א ;y 2א U 4$ 1V I& Kאא U 3א!_אt. $א א א א.. כ 5H 4א] א א6אI& fא 2א $א 1א] א אאK א א א אכ :א> ;$ @
(228) 3 ! 42Mכ$ V :X ? 5
(229) 4א U 2א % 0 eאא Kא!_א $ tא' א א2$ :א @# א א א א אכ ;כ G V $ 5אrא> 40 B$א א א '() 4 % 0 @A & ^ ? 3 ) #I& :א א :א )א & :4@ 4$א @ #כ %
(230) 2$ #אכ G :2אTא +$א $כ 5א B- Aא#@ @ (Microfilm) ?$ ,rJb G. 4 V`_ 2K ;2. אא Kא] -אW3& UDא Fא-אא+K %& ,א 1א6א eא@ :dא כא7 Aא T b 1 U 3K 4 $אא$ Kא!_א$ tא א. א א).(51. 2$א @S #א #א א Uא< %& k? G 3אא\ 5אכ א;/ N 6א> !_ א א א א #p :אhא Fא() B_ ? cא. ì‚Â^Š¹]çÛ¦‚·_J{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{l^fmý]»íéÞæ%ÓÖý]íè…^rjÖ]†i^Ê‚Ö]íéru.
(231) א
(232) אא אא ) (4א 2012. . 123. ) 5א U 2א T bאא Kא!_א$ tא א א א אכ ) _^. Uא!_א$ tא א א 0 .nא כ #א א א א D % 0כ5. `rא; @ N :B2 ,כ 6א U 2א _6 Tא אI& : ?+ 0 X-א @!כא א א א א א :כ+א @ VJא ,-0 א `q !כ+2א$ :אא U #pא!_א+$ tא כ ;0 #א, Z Sא #א א Uא<@ .3א א ;2א/אא U % 0 aא!_אt $א א א א ^2W U 2א0 :(52),אE@ S 3א 42Mא2א(32) U3 S 4א #א
(233) 2א ,Vאכ א/אאK@ 9! :א`2 1א* א;כא, @ אh2א ,א ` +$א Sא 1 4א`Sא 3א א _6 #@ :U U 2א(2כ Uא2א 43אא$ 4$א` Uא) Ur`2כ 'u @ G UT+K@ 4א א 5J@ 4 $ (N 6א א א.א\ Xא2א,V אS-א ,א_א )uא 4א 2א ,א20g$ `2א+א א2א: א א כ '(+ #א` ! א< 5Jא-./א.(53), כ 4א &Iא $א -א א - ,g;@bא+K % 0 UDא 1א6אf #@ #3כ+ #א @ 5Jא c3כ U 5) :fא!_א+$ tא ) _^ U א!_א$ tא א א Ko nאI % 0 $כ FVW 4אS %& Kא# א-כ א< :3א- ) a S Bכ @ U 2 _6 #א U2אא# ) Ur` U`$א2כ () 4 :(54)('u @ Gא א #@ !V aא;2 %?0@ Sא+_ U 2א _!Vא$ tא א א א אכ א ,Sb. א א ) ;0 Uא e! ,א Kא> S q`$א# א א Uא<. 3. †ñ]ˆ¢]{ë]çÖ]íÃÚ^q{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{íé‰^éŠÖ]Ýç×ÃÖ]æÑçÏ£]íé×Ò.
(234) 124. א
(235) אא אא ) (4א 2012. . <&"'D ( #) '*#+ )@ E!#@:#1# @ %?0א ;2א< 3א א א א ! א-./אS X ,א0 WאS 40 i ] Jא 0א-./א ,א % 0 :(55) 2א-0א @L #א א-./א, -Aא א 0א
(236) אS % 0 :א@ 4 0א2) :4א @ #א;]1 a Z. @( :B_ M ZV3 G % 0 - b :B_ ZV3 =?` #כ Bp 2כI 6 4כ FVW 4א ! " 96-א א א א 6 `2אא M Kא ! Z@ Kא א א א 6 `2אאM K. Wא * .אא ! א א א א MאאK uאאK .אNא @ Z Z Z.
(237) & Q %א! א$ Pא א א א א-./א, )(56. . 'F#* G 'F# H ( #) '*#+ )@ .1 אא 0א
(238) א א-./אZV3 =?` #@ a]; 1 B@ F , _ 6J % 0 B2`W M Bא :B0כa]D M 53 G 0 4 `]Dא ! %כ !V Z- #אB$ P
(239) #@ $ :4כB J S # Z. :(57)B 0כ 4אK@ ;2א 1א-א
(240) ,א-./א$ ,א? א א. א א :א> 6 `2אאK :' M @ Kא> Iכ א2א4 2/16 U3 Sא #א-א #א< 0 :3א @Kא 1א -
(241) #@ Mא א א א ! `א!+-א 2$א + 3א א
(242) 2א ,Vא]א $ Jא 0 :Bא כ #א]*V 4$ B$א WQ Kכא 7א א א א K 9! :(58)2Lא> )(א א-0א 2א BEא א 0 4 Uא\2א #א
(243) א 5א Fא א.U a FVW 4א2אS 4 16 U3א #א-א #א<3 #@ :3א אאK כ M ! #א WQ Kכ)3 ! YD 42M 4א א+ 2 ;2א א:d ì‚Â^Š¹]çÛ¦‚·_J{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{l^fmý]»íéÞæ%ÓÖý]íè…^rjÖ]†i^Ê‚Ö]íéru.
(244) א
(245) אא אא ) (4א 2012. . 125. @ #@ .כ #אTא 4$א.4K אKא2$ T :כ א א א א#@ : @ #@ cכ #אZ B 0 [62 כ #א`* א א 56אTא 3 B. ' S "K Sא' () 5+א אK/א> % 0אא Mא %& 5Jא4 6 א אy 9! :. K& FVWא> אE2א)א3 4$ Uא א א 56אTא א כ2+ 5א =. א 5K@ 4 :Wdא "03 ! %& FJאא 0 Kא! א $ BKא' M אא KאIp :(59)Wdא ?א 7$א א G6bאTא `א Rאא Kא:0 2. & &Iא א?א א0 7 -N WQ 53 G B 0 %0 2כ^ א 3. א @ :4א &Iא -א 7א3 (60)3א א]`6 42כ Gאא+$ Mא א-א #א
(246) 2אMא 4 e ? #א03 % 0 WQ ZV3 G 0 2א'. #@ .fכ 56 #אTא 520א.c `() % 0 7א א; Yא2אS 4 (2/16) U3א #א-א #א<% 0 3 @ #< R ` .2 ":#כ` ! #א!+-א א
(247) 2א ,Vא $ `]2אI& Bא כא 2L 7כא #א] 4$ B$ *VאI c ".Kכ @ #כ# אא $א a \TK 5 6$ :
(248) -א2א2/16 U3 אא @ B
(249) -?$ א
(250) 52 Z Z S 4א #א-א #א<K@ 3א ,1כ א2א #@ U3כ #א א א א ! `א!+-א א
(251) 2א ,Vא $ `]2א.B & '() #Iא2א #@ Y; G U3כ #א
(252) M 52אTא א Zא 4$ א? :4כ2א א "Dא! א א @.אZ .א 4 BT B
(253) MאWQ K. א $א -א Kאc;2
(254) א 5א Uא<.א() 5N #p :sא א
(255) Z 52. א Zא $א- -א\=($ :כ כ- #א\= T F`! 0א
(256) (+$ Xא א % 0 [6 #@ :M2א2$ Wdא Kא> 3א' א א :כ #א?4. †ñ]ˆ¢]{ë]çÖ]íÃÚ^q{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{íé‰^éŠÖ]Ýç×ÃÖ]æÑçÏ£]íé×Ò.
(257) 126. א
(258) אא אא ) (4א 2012. . אא 2$ 4Tכ א א א א).(61 Z א\-א
(259) $אDא BAא ) 4א @S #א #א-א #א< 3כאZ J # א
(260) 56 52אTא $א2 4? -כא 4א! א $ Pא)2א א א: $אא Vא= 3 EW 4א א א AאTא E2א)א*`$ U א _J 40 Lא
(261) 52כ2+ 5א. #@.Pכ #א א א2א 3א! א+$ Pא .2L S aא #א א Uא< 42M 3א2א #@ B (1718) 3כ# א א א א א2א 3א! א+$ Pא K S :2Lא> Sא 6כ2 א T2א< S #@" 3א #א א Uא
(262) 2Nא Tא-0א א א א א ! א c@ Kא-כ א Gכ e! S ` 2L 4א<I& FJא G א א YDא GLא` Xאא
(263) -א א 4 א %
Documents relatifs
There are many studies on children’s literature and children’s book publishing business, women writers of the eighteenth century and on paratextual elements in late
The definition of the hypertextbook page, as a visual unit of information, takes into account many different factors, among them the legibility and cognitive issues, which are related
A little while after watching the movie I found Between God and My People (1992) at a stall, a book containing some of Petre }u]ea’s in- terviews and writings, edited by
In the post task questionnaire, participants using the baseline interface were asked to indicate the usefulness of the book-bag in general while participants
The parity register controls the operation of thH parity circuits for all memory installed in the MICRO- MEMORY 7405.. Note: This enables the benefits of a parity
• A recent study at Memorial’s Health Sciences Library showed both growing use of electronic books and stable use of print books. • Libraries need of evidence-based
'Clip from The Verb: Andy McNab, Alex Horne, Bernadine Evaristo, Trevor Cox', The Verb, Andy McNab, Alex Horne, Bernadine Evaristo, Trevor Cox, 22:00 24/01/2014, BBC Radio 3,
Two of the most visible on-line book retailers are examined separately as a case study (Appendix 1) of the impact that the entry of a retailer with a significant presence in